Rushing to Judgment

There's no sense sugar coating the reality: Airline flying is essentially an unnatural act that requires blind trust and a complete surrender of control. That's why whenever something goes wrong, there's a collective shudder in the public consciousness and a very real need for rapid reassurance that whatever just happened will not happen to us when we fly!

Interestingly enough, long periods of perfectly safe operation in the airline industry just make this reaction worse, as we saw last week with the Toronto crash of an Air France Airbus A-340, or on Sunday with the crash of Helios Airways flight ZU522, an Boeing 737, north of Athens.

The basic facts of the Helios crash are still being worked out today. But we do know something about the Air France accident. By the time Flight 358 rocketed off the end of the runway and caught fire, nearly four years had elapsed since the last major airline accident in North America. The immediate aftermath of news reports and conflicting eyewitness accounts obscured not only the significance of 309 people surviving largely as a result of 30 years of cabin safety improvements, but it obscured the fact that tens of millions of passengers have flown unscathed since American 587 went down in New York City in 2001.

Of course we need to know what happened in Toronto, as well as in New York, and as rare as airline accidents are these days, we still need reassurance. The problem is, we're never going to get either reality or reassurance from oversimplification or premature conclusions.

Research and industry analysis long ago proved that there is never -- EVER -- a single cause to any major accident, whether aviation, rail, medical, nuclear or even corporate. Every accident, incident or near miss has a long chain of contributing causes that all came together -- we might say line up -- to reach from the beginning of a sequence to the end result.

And this reality is one of the most difficult things to convey in the first hours after an airline mishap, and Toronto is a classic example.

Initial Response and Search for Details

In the first few minutes after the Toronto accident last week, those of us in the media had only a few basic facts, including the information that an Airbus A-340 had exited the far end of the runway, broken into three pieces, been evacuated and caught fire.

It became quickly apparent that there had been a severe thunderstorm in progress over the field at the time, and further, that the Air France crew had already made one "missed approach" to the airport. We also discovered within minutes that the flight was inbound from Paris, and that there were reports of lightning striking near or around the aircraft as it made its approach to the runway.

Driving all these facts toward some sort of conclusion about cause was the usual combination of public pressure and curiosity combined with the natural media inertia toward getting the story out first. Even for aviation professionals, the almost vortex-like temptation was to say: Aha! The weather must be responsible. Maybe they were hit by lightning or they hydroplaned off the runway (the wheels were floating on a film of water rendering the brakes ineffective for too long) or shifting wind currents unique to thunderstorms somehow affected the flight path. In other words, if we just looked hard enough, the cause had to be apparent, and it had to center around weather.

Page
  • 1
  • |
  • 2
null
Join the Discussion
You are using an outdated version of Internet Explorer. Please click here to upgrade your browser in order to comment.
blog comments powered by Disqus
 
You Might Also Like...
See It, Share It
PHOTO: Cornealious Anderson, who was convicted of armed robbery in 2000, is shown in this undated file photo.
Missouri Department of Corrections/AP Photo
Find out how to avoid hunger-induced crankiness.
Altrendo/Getty Images
PHOTO: Robin Williams starred in the 1993 comedy Mrs. Doubtfire. According to The Hollywood Reporter, a sequel to the movie is in the works.
20th Century-Fox/Getty Images
Kate Middleton Rocks a Pattern Down Under
Brendon Thorne/Getty Images