Creative Consumer: Dirty Secrets of Joining a Gym

Jan. 7, 2008 — -- It's a new year and that means many Americans will resolve to get in shape and gym memberships will soar.

It's a great idea, but keep in mind that you join a gym to exercise your body, but if you want to quit, you may find it hard to exercise your rights. A brand new Better Business Bureau analysis found that consumer complaints about gyms are up more than 90 percent in the last five years.

If you're hoping for buns of steel, then you'll probably be asked to sign an ironclad contract. Don't accuse gym managers of being dumb jocks. Their contracts are long, involved and full of legalese. If you sign one without reading it, you're the dummy. A contract's a contract.

The BBB analysis found that 73 percent of customer complaints involved contract or billing disputes, including people who were upset that they were still being billed after they thought their contract was over.

One national chain holds customers to their contracts unless they are gravely ill, badly injured or move more than 50 miles from the nearest branch of the gym. Can you imagine driving 50 miles to work out? I have some exercise gear in my basement and I have a hard time summoning the willpower to use it.

Many gyms push three-year, five-year or lifetime memberships. Customers go for it, because the longer the contract, the cheaper the monthly rate. But is it really a savings if you are dissatisfied with the gym and never go? As with all future services contracts in which you make a long-term commitment and pay in advance, there are risks.

Some gyms have been known to sell memberships before they're open and then fail to open for months. Others have gone out of business, leaving prepaid members in the lurch. Once again, the BBB numbers are enlightening. A hefty 15 percent of complaints concerned gyms that went out of business soon after opening, leaving customers in the lurch who had paid expensive initiation fees.

Some states now require gyms to offer people the option of a brief introductory membership — typically 90 days. Unfortunately, when I investigated the health-club industry, none of the gym salespeople informed my undercover producer about the introductory membership option. Plus, when we went to cancel the various memberships we'd signed up for, some of the gyms put collection agents on us.