Timing is everything. Hit the website at the right time, and you get tickets to Bruce Springsteen and the E Street Band. Two seconds too late, and you're watching Bill and the Ankle Biters.
As far as we can tell — you never know what will happen next — the Standard & Poor's 500-stock index bottomed on March 9. It's up 34.1% since. You may feel you missed a chance to get the biggest bargains.
And you did. But you can still find plenty of bargains. The easiest to find are in closed-end mutual funds.
A closed-end fund is the earliest form of mutual fund and, frankly, they're relics of a bygone era. They have a structure that was first developed in the 1920s, and has long since been improved upon.
Like all mutual funds, closed-end funds are a professionally managed portfolio of stocks or bonds. And like exchange traded funds, you can buy and sell shares of closed-ends on the stock exchanges.
But unlike all other types of funds, closed-end funds issue a fixed number of shares. New closed-end funds raise money through an initial public offering and use that money to buy and sell stocks and bonds. In this sense, a closed-end fund is a bit like any company that's listed on the stock exchanges. One way to think of a closed-end fund is as a corporation whose business is buying and selling stocks.
What makes a closed-end fund peculiar is that its share price often doesn't reflect the value of its holdings.
Let's consider the Cohen & Steers Worldwide Realty fund, which trades under the ticker RWF. As of Wednesday, the assets in the fund's portfolio, minus expenses, were worth $4.48 a share. But the fund's shares sold that day for $3.38 — a 32.5% discount, in closed-end parlance. If the fund were liquidated that day, brand-new shareholders would get an instant profit of $1.10 a share.
Most closed-end funds sell at a discount, which has mystified academics for years. One theory is that closed-end funds don't liquidate very often. And if they were to sell all their holdings at once, they would have to do so at fire-sale prices.
But basically, closed-end funds sell at a discount because the fund's share price reflects what investors think of the fund's prospects, not its current value. Shareholders would be right to have a low opinion of Cohen & Steers Worldwide Realty fund. Its shares have plunged 76.9% in the previous 12 months, including reinvested dividends, according to Morningstar, the Chicago investment trackers.
Investors are often mistaken, though. As witness to this, a few funds sell for a premium — that is, for more than the value of their holdings. Pimco High Income, for example, sold at $8.59 a share Wednesday, even though the securities in its portfolio were valued at $4.74 a share, an 81.2% premium.
As you may have guessed, it's better to buy at a discount, not a premium. As proof, we looked at the entire universe of closed-end funds and ranked them by their premium or discount five years ago. We then created four groups — group one had the highest premium. Group four had the biggest discounts, and groups two and three were in the middle.
Group one sold for an average premium of 10.9%. The funds, which were a mix of stock and bond funds, lost an average 19.6% over five years. Group four, the cheapest funds, sold for an average discount of 8.3%. Average return: -4.1%.