Details surrounding the heist seem to defy logic, however.
Amadio said that because the two men had recently moved from Boston, they were in a "funny transition period" with their insurance. Although the works were insured in Boston, Amadio said he had yet to activate a policy in California.
And they claim they were not allowed to put a security system in the rental house.
Amadio said the thieves took "the back up provenance on the hard drive" which will likely make it even more difficult to prove the works' authenticity.
Detective Donald Hrycyk of the Los Angeles Police Department's art theft unit has been tracking art thefts for 15 years. "Unlike TV dramas, we usually have very little to identify who the crook is. We focus on trying to find the unique property and then work our way back," said Hrycyk.
He recently found two high-value pieces for sale at a N.Y. auction that had been stolen in 1989. Finding the property, led Hrycyk to the thieves some 20 years after the crime had been committed. But thefts involving more than a dozen works of art like the one reported in Pebble Beach are rare, said Hrycyk.
"Fine art and paintings tend to be bulky you have to pull up a van or a pick-up truck and load up these big objects. Still, any crook if he has the means will take anything he thinks is of value," he said.
Amadio said he never set out to be an art collector -- his previous business efforts included selling purebred puppies and an asset allocation company.
"I have always said I know nothing about art. I just have it around me," said Amadio.
But Ralph Kennaugh did know art, according to Amadio, and had been collecting for over 30 years. "Ralph's credibility gave us access to an exclusive market" where the two men would track "substantial pieces" and buy them at probate or divorce sales, said Amadio. "We just got very lucky in business."
But that luck may have now run out. The pair are offering a $1 million reward for the return of the art.