Cosmo's Beland believes "there's a lot to be said for dating your opposite, because it brings out a different side of you. So, there's a positive angle and a negative angle to a woman who changes when she's with a certain guy. A lot of women will date certain men because they want to experiment with that guy's lifestyle and play with a different side of themselves. When Jennifer Aniston was with John Mayer, it may have been because she actually wanted to be with a rock star. She wanted to be exposed to the parties and the concerts. It can be really fun, if you're trying to figure out what you want to do next and, to a degree, who you are. But, of course, the negative side is that when you're changing to please a guy, at some point in the relationship, you're going to come back to who you really are. Then he's going to be disappointed and confused, and you're going to be frustrated by that reaction. And that creates a real hot mess."
In the end, Titus said, "Jennifer Aniston is subconsciously still trying to replace Brad Pitt. To her, what they had was perfect. He completely fit Jennifer Aniston's desires in every way, sexually, socially. Brad Pitt was the perfect fit for her. And she's been trying to re-create that scenario with anybody. She's willing to sacrifice whatever she has to, even if that means playing groupie to John Mayer."