Did Kirstie Alley Lose the Battle of the Bulge?


Jim Foster, the editor of Diet-Blog.com, told ABCNEWS.com that the failure of a weight loss program's spokesperson is definitely a sign to fellow dieters that perhaps that plan isn't going to work, but added that the spokesperson for a brand is often not someone many people can identify with.

"Right or wrongly, many of us view celebrities as 'privileged' — the ones that can afford personal trainers and home-delivered meals," said Foster. "Because of this, we have a perception that psychical transformation must be easier for them."

"With that said, I'm not sure how many people honestly identify with a celebrity figure. We tend to put them in the 'unreal' category — a source of entertainment rather than inspiration," said Foster.

Carla Wolper, a nutritionist at the Obesity Research Center at St. Luke Hospital in New York, said she doubts the loss of a spokesperson will have much of an effect on anyone.

"Even if someone flunks at a diet, if they're doing well then they're not going to suddenly just quit," said Wolper. "If most people find a method that is successful and they're not having any trouble adhering to the method, it won't matter if the CEO and the spokesperson [leaves the company]."

Bad Dieter? Bad for Business

While dieters like Foster may not care very much about the spokesperson for a particular diet, nutritionists say companies put a great deal of thought into who they have representing their weight loss programs.

"Sometimes people really do care about the spokespeople [of a diet plan]," said Debbie Then, a clinical psychologist who specializes in women's appearance issues. "If they don't like the person to begin with, they may not pay attention to the diet."

"Companies pay a lot of attention to who they name a spokesperson," added Then, who said that her chief complaint with many diets is the lack of acknowledgement of some of the underlying reasons people over-eat and become obese, such as emotional problems.

"Dieters like role models and people who they emulate," said Then. "Initially companies pick people who a wide variety of people can identify with, and I do think it's hard to all of a sudden have that person gone."

There has never been a scientific study that compares the success of programs like Jenny Craig with and without a recognizable spokesperson, but Yale's Katz said spokespeople are undoubtedly a large investment for companies.

"We know that big companies with deep pockets routinely use celebrities to endorse," said Katz. "Clearly the value of a celebrity to represent your product is well established."

"But if you have a high-profile spokesperson on your diet plan and they're gaining weight, that's not good for business."

-- This embed didnt make it to copy for story id = 4316799. -- This embed didnt make it to copy for story id = 4316799.
  • 1
  • |
  • 2
Join the Discussion
You are using an outdated version of Internet Explorer. Please click here to upgrade your browser in order to comment.
blog comments powered by Disqus
You Might Also Like...