Hatch praised Geithner for trying to chart a "bipartisan course," and said his knowledge of economic policy from years at the Fed, the IMF and earlier at the Treasury Department, will allow him to "hit the ground running on day one and get the economy running again."
But Hatch also said his office got many calls from constituents, angry that the man who is being appointed to oversee the IRS is not "beyond reproach" with his own taxes.
The micro issue of Geithner's taxes was enough to make him unfit to address the country's macro economic issues, according to some Republicans and Democrats.
"How can Mr. Geithner speak with any credibility as the nation's chief tax collector? Would his admonition be do as I say, not as I do?" Sen. Tom Harkin, D-Iowa, asked before the vote.
Harkin criticized Geithner for his role in crafting the Wall Street bailout, and for not doing more to oversee Citigroup as head of the New York Fed. Geithner, said Harkin, is too close to Wall Street, when "I want a treasury secretary that is going to start banging some heads."
Most of the opposition, however, came from Republicans. Sen. Saxby Chambliss, R-Ga., who said he spent part of the weekend puzzling over his own taxes, said on the Senate floor, "Here we are making an exception to the rule and I, for one, think it's not the time to make an exception."
Sen. Susan Collins of Maine, a middle-of-the-road Republican who often sides with Democrats, opposed him.
In a speech prepared for the Senate floor, Collins said, "Throughout the state of Maine and, indeed, throughout the nation, millions of hard-working Americans pay their taxes on time and in full. Our taxation system is essentially an honor system that depends on self-assessment and honesty. When taxpayers make mistakes, they are expected to correct them promptly and completely. How can we tell the taxpayers that they are expected to comply fully with our tax laws, when these laws have been treated so cavalierly by the person who would lead the Treasury Department and, ultimately, the Internal Revenue Service, when he was applying them to himself?"
When he worked for the International Monetary Fund from 2001 - 2004, Geithner was given a monetary credit by the international organization to pay Social Security and Medicare taxes that would normally be withheld. While he signed a document promising to use the credit to pay his taxes -- more than $40,000 over those four years -- he did not pay half the taxes until an audit uncovered the mistake for two years and the other half shortly before he was nominated to run the Treasury Department. Geithner took responsibility for the mistake, declining to blame Turbo Tax, the software he used to prepare his taxes in 2001 and 2002, for missing the IMF-specific tax issue and told senators it was unintentional, but several Republicans have remained skeptical.
Others believe his failure to pay the taxes was unintentional, but cannot get over the symbolism of appointing a person with tax issues to head the Treasury Department, which includes the IRS.
Many Republicans who disagree with Geithner's economic world view said they would support the nomination to allow Obama to choose his own economic team.