Classic NYC: Everything old is new again

ByABC News
December 12, 2008, 1:48 PM

— -- As indicated by its name, "New" York is definitely not "Old" York. This constantly shifting city is often focused on the here and now, the spots that have opened the most recently and are getting the loudest buzz. But there are plenty of NYC hotspots that date not from the 21st century but from the early 20th or even the 19th century and are still going strong. Here's a look at a select group of places to eat, drink and shop that have lasted for around 100 years, give or take a decade or two.

Classic food: A century of good eats

From fine dining to casual delis, New Yorkers have been eating well for several generations. We start with more formal options below before looking at some everyday mealtime choices.

Oak Room and Oak Bar at the PlazaThe Edwardian-style Plaza Hotel, built in 1907 at the intersection of Central Park South and the shopping mecca of Fifth Avenue, is one of New York City's most recognizable landmarks. The soaring cathedral ceilings and abundant wood in the Plaza's elegant Oak Room (768 Fifth Ave.; 212-758-7777; fairmont.com/theplaza/GuestServices/Restaurants/OakRoom.htm), which just reopened to the public after an extensive renovation, also lend the restaurant a landmark-in-the-making feel, but one that's not at all stuffy. Atlanta star chef Joel Antunes serves up eclectic French-influenced food with a slant toward fish and meat dishes, and though the prices are aggressively modern (appetizers range from $18 for a beetroot gazpacho with horseradish ravioli to $38 for Jerusalem artichoke lasagna with fresh truffle, and entries from $32 for roasted winter vegetables to $74 for a charred grilled ribeye), the service is old-fashioned friendly. After dinner, join the lively crowd for a classic cocktail at the neighboring Oak Bar (fairmont.com/theplaza/GuestServices/Restaurants/OakBar.htm), where you can step back in time with drinks such as Carrols Cocktail, a tasty pre-Prohibition-style concoction of calvados, Benedictine liqueur, sweet vermouth and aromatics ($18).

'21' ClubFor one of the most atmospheric dining experiences in the city, you can't do much better than the former speakeasy and celebrity magnet the '21' Club (21 West 52nd St.; 212-582-7200; 21club.com), opened on the sly during Prohibition in 1929. As you enter down the stairs along with the long-time regulars, tourists and power lunchers, you'll pass brightly colored models of jockeys, many donated by horse breeders and owners starting in the 1930s; you'll end up in the Bar Room, a surreal dining space under a ceiling hung with footballs, model planes, trucks and other toys, all given to the restaurant by its storied clientele. But the '21' Club's real claim to fame is its secret wine cellar, hidden behind a door that looks like a brick wall; it can only be opened by a meat skewer inserted into a tiny crack in the door. Though police raided the Club during Prohibition, the cellar was never found but you can see it for yourself by asking for a private tour after dinner. As for the food, the menu is divided into modern vs. classic dishes. For a taste of the traditional, start with the iconic Pommes Soufflées, puffy hollow fried potatoes served with a spicy '21' cocktail sauce ($14), followed by the tangy Cold Senegalese Soup, thick with curry, chicken chunks and apples ($14); the Creamy Chicken Hash, with baby spinach ($36); or the famous '21' Burger ($30). Note that the '21' Club has a dress code, so jackets and ties are required for men and no jeans and sneakers are allowed for either gender.

Russian Tea RoomFounded in 1927 by former dancers from the Russian Imperial Ballet as a chocolate shop and tea emporium, The Russian Tea Room (150 W. 57th St.; 212-581-7100; russiantearoomnyc.com) has had its share of ups and downs in the years since. At one time a gathering place for the New York theater elite, aided by its location next door to Carnegie Hall, the Tea Room brought in a new chef in 2007 and refocused the menu more toward the classics borscht ($18), pelmeni (classic Russian oxtail dumplings, $22), chicken Kiev ($38), boeuf a la stroganoff ($39) as well as contemporary versions of traditional Russian cuisine, including goat cheese and wild mushroom blinchiki ($18). Go not only for the unusual-in-Manhattan food, but for the extravagant décor rich red booths facing into the restaurant for people-watching, dark green walls covered with replicas of Russian paintings, chandeliers hung with festive red Christmas balls year-round and a gilded gold ceiling. Splurge on the cheese and cherry blintzes for dessert ($18), or try some vodka flights ($18 for 3 ¾ oz tastes) or classic cocktails like the Moscow Mule, a blend of Stolichnaya and ginger juice ($18), at the well-stocked bar up front as you imagine that you're celebrating with the Russian cultural elite of yore. Tip: For a slightly more affordable indulgence, pre- and post-theater prix fixe menus are available for $55 for three courses, and there's a tasting of three vodkas for $14 from 5 to 7 p.m. Monday to Friday at the bar.