"Out of concern...Liza Huntington called Terry to tell him that her ex-husband and Tara were arranging play dates for their children so they could spend time with each other and that the affair was having an adverse impact on their children. Thereafter Terry confronted Tara, who admitted that she had been having an affair with Huntington," the lawsuit states.
Arthur Newmyer claims that Huntington sent sexually graphic emails from the school server to Tara Newmyer while he was meeting with students. He claims that Sidwell Friends acted inappropriately by not protecting his daughter once they were made aware of the affair.
Carol Anderson is a family friend of the Newmyer couple and said that they seemed like an ordinary couple until the affair. Anderson said that both Tara and Arthur Newmyer are committed to their children.
"She's a devoted mother. I think they both really care about their children and they just don't have the same views as how they should be raised," she said.
Tara Newmyer's attorney did not return messages for comment.