Pregnant T-Mobile Employee Clocked Out to Use Toilet

By Abby Ellin

May 1, 2013 6:01am
ht kristi rifkin family nt 130430 wblog Pregnant T Mobile Employee Clocked Out to Use Toilet

Image credit: Courtesy Kristi Rifkin

Kristi Rifkin had been working at T-Mobile Call Center in Nashville for four years when she got pregnant with her third child. She says she loved her job.

“I had a great run,” Rifkin, 40, told ABC News. “I was making bonus. T Mobile was good to me. I never had a problem getting a schedule I wanted. I enjoyed it. I had even left another company to work at T Mobile because they had great benefits.”

But her good will toward the company changed once she got pregnant.

According to Rifkin, the pregnancy–her second (she has one stepson)–was a difficult one, and she was going to the doctor twice a week, seeing both a regular obstetrician and a high-risk obstetrician. She was also required to drink “tons and tons” of water – which, in turn, resulted in frequent trips to the bathroom. This did not sit well with T-Mobile, she said.

“They give you two 15 minute breaks and a 30 minute lunch,” said Rifkin. “If you can’t take care of your biological needs in that time period,  you don’t go.”

Before her pregnancy, this wasn’t an issue. But as she explained in a blog post on Moms Rising.org, frequent jaunts to the bathroom would cut into what was known in the call center world as  ”adherence” — a metric that measures the degree to which employees meet their quota for being on the phone.

“You have different numbers you have to meet each month, and if you don’t meet them they can fire you,” she said. “The thinking is that if you’re off the phone and you’re not doing what you’re supposed to be doing, then there are customers waiting to talk to you.”

She tried to hold off on eating and drinking; she needed the health insurance the job provided. But the baby was suffering, Rifkin said, and she had to start drinking water again.

Finally, she said, her supervisor pulled her aside and told her to get a note from her doctor explaining that she needed to go the bathroom often.  ”At that point, I thought my head was going to launch off my shoulders,” said Rifkin. “‘Are you serious? I need to get a note from my doctor to go to the toilet?’ This is a basic biological need.’”

But Rifkin did as she was told; she got the doctor’s note and cleared it with Human Resources. She was told that she could use the rest room any time she needed to, she said, but that she would have to clock out. When she returned from that bathroom, she would have to clock back in. “This meant I was out of work for five minutes,” she said. She had to write the hours down and turn it into her supervisor, just to make sure she wasn’t taking advantage of the situation.

“I ended up using my vacation time to use the bathroom,” she said.

But she still wasn’t eating and drinking as she was supposed to. Her blood pressure skyrocketed. She was stressed and anxious.

She finally went on the Family Medical Leave Act, which requires employers to provide up to 12 weeks of unpaid, job-protected leave to eligible employees,  seven weeks before her son, Ian, was born, on May 14, 2010. A month and a half after she returned to work she was fired, she said.

The reason?  Rifkin says she was summarily fired after she failed to remove an extra-charge feature from a customer’s account, the commission for which was 12 cents. She says the rare error occurred when she either forgot to remove the charge or removed another charge instead.

She got no severance, she said, and now pays for medical expenses out of pocket.

Rifkin said she has no plans to sue the company; it’s too expensive, and Tennessee is an at-will employment state. “They can fire you for any reason,” she said

The US. Department of Labor reports that only eight states require paid rest periods and Tennessee is not among them.

“There is no specific legal requirement that requires employers to let their employees use the restroom,” Paula Brantner, the executive director of Workplace Fairness, which provides legal information about workers rights. However, “If a pregnant woman is the only employee being forced to clock out, and they don’t require males or non-pregnant females to do so, it would seem to me that would be pregnancy discrimination.”

In an email statement to ABC News, T-Mobile spokesperson Glenn A. Zaccara said that he could not comment on a specific individual. But “T-Mobile employees enjoy generous benefits including paid-time-off and short and long-term disability coverage,” he said. “The company has leave of absence policies in line with regulatory requirements.”

Rifkin was not impressed. “I’m done with T-Mobile,” she said. “I don’t want anything to do with them anymore.”

SHOWS:

User Comments

Now you know why unions are good. They can go to bat for you. What happens when you got those rich republcan godless ba-star-ds running this country enriching their pockets and h*** with little people. Little people are the fodder for making green bucks for my CEO mega bonuses.

Posted by: Just Sayin | May 1, 2013, 8:12 am 8:12 am

“According to Rifkin, the pregnancy–her second (she has one stepson)–was a difficult one…”

Wait, isn’t a stepson the son of her husband with a different mother?

Posted by: Phoenix Risen | May 1, 2013, 8:28 am 8:28 am

It states in the first paragraph that she became pregnant with her “3rd child”. As it was her 2nd pregnancy, they were explaining the 3rd child (stepson).

Posted by: giraffeh2o | May 1, 2013, 8:53 am 8:53 am

Kristi,
I wish you the best. I’m sure there are better things for you down the road….:))

Posted by: Bambino | May 1, 2013, 9:21 am 9:21 am

Better things did find me. Thank you for the interest in this article…And Unions have become an outdated notion from the past, however, I feel are becoming more relevant again due to situations like mine. Many people feel that Union workers are over paid, but perhaps the reality (in my opinion), is that non-union workers could be under-paid….

Posted by: Kristi Rifkin | May 1, 2013, 10:20 am 10:20 am

There is more to this story than was told here, you can bet on that. There must be a reason she isn’t suing.

Posted by: chatmandu002 | May 1, 2013, 11:02 am 11:02 am

This story convinces me to never, ever sign up with T-Mobile. I cannot support a company that is so cruel to it’s employees.

Posted by: Zenguy1213 | May 1, 2013, 12:10 pm 12:10 pm

If I’ve said it once, I’ve said it a zillion times: If men were the ones that had to get pregnant, none of these policies would even exist. Period!

Posted by: Debbie | May 1, 2013, 12:15 pm 12:15 pm

Chatmandu002…not everyone can find happiness at the end of a lawsuit. You make it sound like she is up to something. Bringing awareness to an unjust issue just may be payment enough for her. Good for you Kristi. Hold on to your values and pride!

Posted by: marsha | May 1, 2013, 12:28 pm 12:28 pm

I am tired of people whining & bringing lawsuits into things…Take a 15 minute lunch & turn your breaks into two 71/2 minute potty breaks…with lunch & 2 breaks, you were getting a full hour of paid time out of the work day…How much time do you WANT? If pregnancy makes it difficult to work, then A: don’t get pregnant or B: stay home…

Posted by: Suzi | May 1, 2013, 1:46 pm 1:46 pm

And, Suzi, most places, if not all, do NOT pay for people to eat lunch. I’ve been working for 45 years and never ONCE was I paid for my lunch period. Check yourself.

Posted by: greennnnnn | May 1, 2013, 3:03 pm 3:03 pm

suzi – do you have kids?? were you ever pregnant? NO pregnancy is the same. Your body reacts differently each time, so there is no way to predict what you will need. IT states that she was having a difficult pregnancy and had to see two doctors. This was wrong on several levels.

Posted by: pksk531 | May 1, 2013, 3:28 pm 3:28 pm

Georgia is a right to work state. Yes, you can be fired for anything without reason, but the Department of Labor in all states can and does award employees if they conclude that the termination was without merit. There is no fee to have a labor hearing. If she doesn’t sue she is a fool and she shouldn’t have made her story known to the public.

Posted by: B.A. | May 1, 2013, 3:52 pm 3:52 pm

Just Sayin: you should check your facts before you bath mouth American businesses. T-Mobile is a German company, and last I checked the Germans aren’t “running this country” as you put it.

Posted by: MadGuy1961 | May 1, 2013, 4:00 pm 4:00 pm

So foreign companies operating in the U.S. are free to act as they please? Why give break at all? “Just use it at your desk!” Shut up MADGUY1961.

Posted by: B.A. | May 1, 2013, 4:04 pm 4:04 pm

Suzi: Have you ever had a job? Most companies with defined break periods will not let you split your breaks up however you want. Call centers like those where she worked use heavily monitored call systems that track every call to the second and route calls to agents based on inbound call traffic volume. I’m surprised she enjoyed her work so much in the first place; it sounds like a sweatshop to me.

Posted by: MadGuy1961 | May 1, 2013, 4:05 pm 4:05 pm

She’s likely not suing because she does not stand to benefit much financially; therefore no steep contingency for an attorney. My company relocated and laid off the ones who could no move, me included. Surprise, they were all older with homes they couldn’t sell, parents to take care of, etc. People who had worked there 20-40 years. Good way to lay off those close to retirement and not have to deal with benefits or pension issues, plus keep the newbies who don’t make as much money. And don’t fool yourself. Unions can’t save you. Companies will relocate or just not hire because they can’t afford union pay benefits. There has to be a middle ground somewhere that will allow employees to be treated fairly and companies to thrive. But it sure isn’t anywhere where I live.

Posted by: CP | May 1, 2013, 4:33 pm 4:33 pm

Sadly this is all to true an occurance. My 17 daughter was born premature and needed cpr at birth. My employer at the time was a large corporate hospital. They would not let me have time off to see my OB doctor. I nearly killed myself and my daughter, by not going to any appointments. I was even written up for requesting the time off to see my doctor. My daughter has long lasting effects from being premature and loss of oxygen at birth. I filed an EEOC complaint and was told, I was in the wrong for asking for time off. I was deemed unreasonable and unnessasary. After my family leave, I quit without notice. I have found many employers over my years are very unreasonable, and most of my dealings were with working in hospitals.

Posted by: Jennifer | May 1, 2013, 4:40 pm 4:40 pm

Leave a Reply

Do you have more information about this topic? If so, please click here to contact the editors of ABC News.