May 23, 2008 11:43am

Review: Foxboro Hot Tubs’ “Stop Drop and Roll!!!”

  “American Idiot” stands as one of the most profoundly brilliant and poignant records of this decade.  No doubt, it is going to be a difficult record to follow-up since it was so monumental in its scope.  Leave it to Green Day to dodge that menacing task by disguising themselves as a sixties-influenced garage-rock band called the Foxboro Hot Tubs.  In many ways it’s a brilliant move.  “American Idiot” was a pretty heavy album, subject-wise.  It was the album where the lovable goofball, wiseguy pop-punks grew up and gave us something immense. This new guise helps them lighten their load and let loose again like old times.  It’s a 32 minute blast of retro sounds, simple riffs and good-time attitude.  In comparison to “American Idiot,” some may consider it a bizarre step backwards, but it’s really meant to be nothing more than a big, fun rock record for the ages.  It has no obvious message or political agenda; it’s just a fun, fully retro romp complete with simple production and a loving wink to the bands of the past.  Consider this disc Green Day’s submission for Rhino’s next “Nuggets” boxed-set.  It’s nice that the album’s title promotes good fire-safety techniques, and the title-track is a riff-tastic rocker. You can feel the steam coming off their amps as Billie Joe Armstrong’s voice mimics classic British Invasion harmonies over a punked-up, riff.  It’s obviously a Green Day cut, but it’s got a well-aged dingy sound not heard on their other records.  “Mother Mary” borrows Iggy Pop’s “Lust For Life” rhythm much like Jet did a few years back for “Are You Gonna Be My Girl?”  This song is much cheerier and happier sounding than both those tracks.  Green Day’s biggest strength has always been their ability to steal from others and change things around just ever-so-slightly so that the tracks sound a bit familiar but nevertheless original.  It’s their gift.  “Ruby Room” recalls their hit “Hitching a Ride,” with an addition of some sweet farfisa for good, authentic measure. The “Woo woo” background vocals are an intriguing addition.  “Red Tide” recalls the best of the Kinks.  Mainly the track sounds like an altered take on the formula for “Tired of Waiting,” which Green Day has previously covered.  The tone of the guitar is perfect to imitate the era, and Tre Cool’s drums swing with ease.  At 3:32, “Broadway” is the mammoth in comparison to the rest of the tracks.  It also sounds strikingly like a normal Green Day track with a beefier guitar riff, a bongo drum solo and more vocal harmonizing.  The dissatisfied references to “drinking gasoline” and the refrain of “it’s killing me” bring back memories of the edgy teen angst found on “Dookie.” “She’s a Saint Not a Celebrity” borrows its main riff liberally from both Eddie Cochran’s “Summertime Blues” and “A Little Bit o’ Soul” by the Music Explosion. It’s a formula which has been often been bitten, sliced and diced and repurposed.  The track also possesses a defining Ramones-like crunch.  “Sally” sounds like a more paisley-soaked answer the Monkees’ (I’m Not Your) Stepping Stone.”  The farfisa in combination with the mid-song rhythm-shifts, give the song weight and importance. “Alligator” returns to Kinks-ville.  It’s a funhouse mirror answer to “You Really Got Me.” “The Pedestrian” is typical, sunny Green Day pop-punk.  It should be a single.  It takes a bouncy riff and “whee-ohh-whee” background exclamations to arena-rock heights.  Again, there’s no doubt this is Green Day, and this track could have easily been an out-take from their “Nimrod” album.  “27th Ave. Shuffle” blends early Stones, Who, and Beatles techniques together in a pop-rock stew.  Even though everything seems borrowed and effortless, it has it’s own new style.  Think about all the bands that have poorly tried to emulate Green Day and failed miserably.  Their level of skill is both underestimated and undeniable.  “Dark Side of Night” is a nifty slightly reverb-drenched, softer number, recorded on an old-school analog 4-track.  The acoustic guitar strumming, Mike Dirnt’s steady bass, and Cool’s reverberating beat all resonate, but the real highlight of the track is the dynamite flute solo.  It embraces its retro-feel, but it sounds strangely authentic.  The album closes with “Pieces of Truth,” an all-out rave-up that sounds like something that would’ve made the kids on “Shindig” go nuts and scream and yell.  It’s like a revved up answer to the Beatles’ version of “Twist and Shout” mixed with touches of “I Saw Her Standing There.”  The lively saxophone solo brings it all up to a whole other level of frantic greatness.  Green Day aren’t the first band to hide behind another band-name.  In the mid eighties, XTC gave themselves a psychedelic makeover and briefly began recording as the Dukes of the Stratosphear.  This isn’t even the first time Green Day have done this, since they are also most likely 3/5 of the Devo-esque band The Network, who in 2003 released a wonderfully robotic album, “Money Money 2020.” “Stop Drop and Roll!!! doesn’t pack the punch of “American Idiot,” but it’s not meant to.  It’s meant to be a back-to-basics exercise and a fun attempt at rock-and-roll bait and switch.  It’s simply a fun, rousing record.  I think the Foxboro Hot Tubs just might go places!

User Comments

Hey Allan, review this: http://www.DeepRelease.com

Posted by: Deep Release | May 23, 2008, 12:09 pm 12:09 pm

I love music reviewers who take it all way too seriously. All anybody is trying to do is sell records. If they can embed their own political views into it, they will, but in the end, it’s a cash business. American Idiot was “monumental in scope” because it made the boys in the band quite rich and famous. No other reason. My kid likes the music and has NO CLUE what the story or the message is. But he spent a couple of bucks on a couple of songs. Mission accomplished.

Posted by: Zinglesloff | May 23, 2008, 12:29 pm 12:29 pm

Just my humble opinion, but “American Idiot” did not even come close to the greatness of “Dookie”, which is by far the more iconic and relevant album ever released by Green Day…still in my rotation after all these mosh-filled years…American Idiot was just a bunch of mostly unmemorable pop tracks…

Posted by: Jazz | May 23, 2008, 1:41 pm 1:41 pm

Hey Allan, a great review for the greatest rock band ever!
Boy some people are unfortunately very cynical. Why would a band of this stature go and play tiny clubs that hold 100 – 200 people and not market their album in the traditional ways if they were only in it for the money? The reason they do what they do is no doubt for themselves – they love to play music and have great aspirations to be the best at what they do. If fans come along for the ride – that’s great.

Posted by: melody | May 25, 2008, 11:21 am 11:21 am

I love people who comment on music reviews with a completely biased, ignorant view. The fact that they say its about the money couldn’t be any farther from the truth and shows compelte ignorance. And your humble opinion sucks and should not be shared. Great review and even better album.

Posted by: kgjsjkg | May 25, 2008, 3:41 pm 3:41 pm

Just because your kid is too thick to have ANY CLUE what “American Idiot” means does not change that it was deep, audacious, and intrepid. I do not believe for one second that the driving force behind “American Idiot” was to sell records. Anyone who spouts out ideas like that has a very superficial knowledge of the band. They were trying to demolish mediocrity and raise the bar. And guess what: mission accomplished.
Cheers kgjsjkg

Posted by: rory | May 25, 2008, 7:47 pm 7:47 pm

Dookie is still the best album Green Day’s ever released…

Posted by: Jazz | May 26, 2008, 12:04 pm 12:04 pm

“American Idiot” is one of the greatest albums ever…and not in my top three favorite Green Day albums. They are musical geniuses pure and simple. And to say they’re in it for the money? My god, man, are you even slightly aware of the state of the music industry, where EVERYONE else IS in it for the money, and make very little bones about it?
I’m going to get Stop, Drop… consider it a Green Day album… and hope it cracks my top 3.

Posted by: Christian | September 12, 2008, 12:01 pm 12:01 pm

Leave a Reply

Do you have more information about this topic? If so, please click here to contact the editors of ABC News.