Review: Jet’s “Shaka Rock”
Jet’s 2003 album, “Get Born,” did have a few minor bits of excitement, but it’s time to face the fact that Jet have very little to offer. They want to be an amalgam of AC/DC and the Beatles but they lack the potency, backbone and fortitude of both. Their 2006 follow-up, “Shine On” felt like a less impressive retread of their first record. In retrospect, maybe “Get Born” wasn’t that great an album after all and merely coasted by, winning its audience with shrewd marketing maneuvers. Their break-out hit, “Are You Gonna Be My Girl?” seemed to borrow a little too liberally (perhaps accidently) from Iggy Pop’s classic, “Lust For Life,” and “Look What You’ve Done,” the album’s best song (and the group’s best song to date) sounds like a second rate Beatles ballad. The closing track on “Get Born,” “Timothy,” wasn’t a single, but it should have been. This slow tale of an alien trying to find his spaceship served as the only thought-provoking track on the record. This brings up the point that the members of Jet only show any true hint of any kind of lasting potential on their slower songs. When they rock out on asinine hits like “Put Your Money Where Your Mouth Is” or (even worse) “Cold Hard Bitch,” they become brainless, aimless puppets trying to bring the “Rawk!” It doesn’t work for bands like Buckcherry. It definitely doesn’t work for Jet.
So, how are Jet in 2009? For starters, “Shaka Rock” may be the worst album title of the year this side of Sugar Ray calling their new album “Music For Cougars.” It doesn’t help that this album makes “Shine On” seem like a masterpiece and “Get Born” seem like the Holy Grail. (At this rate, their fourth album should be frightening!)
“K.I.A. (Killed In Action) starts the record, and it begins with a false glimmer of hope. “I live in the middle of a combat zone. / And I’m too scared to pick up the phone,” Nic Cester sings. His brother Chris keeps a swaggering drumbeat in back just for a moment so you think this might be interesting. Then it all goes down the drain quickly with the “uh-huh, uh-huh, uh, huh” chorus and the “This ain’t fair / I ain’t scared,” refrain. This song is beyond lyrically ridiculous and the music is derivative, exhibiting numerous hard and classic rock clichés. The band simply doesn’t have the skill to pull this off convincingly. Perhaps around the time of “Get Born,” they could have, but now they seem to be six years further down into the abyss. What kind of line is, “Let’s get into a coma, just like the stars?” It’s a hacky line! Whereas Jet used to possess a vague hint of power, they have now wandered into the all too unintentionally hilarious world of self-parody.
“Beat On Repeat” apes the Clash’s style so horribly that Joe Strummer should be rolling over in his grave. In fact, one gets the idea that the members of Jet want this to be their answer to “Rock The Casbah.” The truth is that this song is so laughably ready to be mocked that it shouldn’t have even been let out of the studio doors. Comparing it to the Clash in any way shape or form actually is probably an insult to that band’s stellar legacy. By putting this track on an album, Jet have insulted us all.
“She’s a Genius” takes a basic bass-line and mirrors it with a guitar. Nic Cester sings about his “girl” and how “she only listens to the radio to see who’s alive.” The song is full of ham-fisted lines like this. If one line doesn’t make sense, another is just serving up more clichés like “she really blows my mind.” This song makes a glammed-up, trashy band like Louis XIV sound innovative in comparison.
“Hearts On Fire” mines similar classic-rock mockery, but it seems to have an ever-so-slight danceable sheen. This track also wants to be their answer to “Dirty Deeds (Done Dirt Cheap)” but it just falls flat.
“Seventeen” benefits from the use of piano during the verses, but once again, its weak lyrics and its reliance on “oh-oh-oh” chorus call-outs don’t do it any favors. It’s not that great a song, but it just might be the best song here. Would it kill Jet to try to be an innovative band?
The acoustic strumming on “La Di Da” makes it sound like an awful mix of Heart’s “Crazy On You” and the Beatles’ “The Continuing Story Of Bungalow Bill.” It’s pointless. The beat switches during the chorus and the song takes a brighter turn for a second, but it’s too late and unsalvageable.
“Goodbye Hollywood” tries to be one of those arrogant tales of decadence lost and actually goes as far as to recycle yet another clichéd line, “Life can build you up just to knock you down.” To their benefit, there are a few surprises in the arrangement when nearly all the instruments pull back leaving just an organ and vocals for a period. It ends up sounding like a less intricate answer to E.LO. The track still isn’t quite a winner, but it is nice to hear a surprise or two. Jet are a by-the-numbers band. Nothing groundbreaking is expected here, so any hint of thought is considered relatively golden. They’ve set the bar so low that even small victories are celebrated.
“Walk” may be better than “Seventeen,” with its piano riff and its thrusting beat. The “yeah yeah yeah,” chorus nearly kills it, however. (This is a band badly in need of a lyricist!!!)
“Times Like This” is built around a belching guitar line, repeating the same note over and over again. The note changes from time to time but the pattern stays the same. It’s not necessary. It aims to be a unifying party song. (“From the Hollywood hills down to Ecuador / Everyone’s the same when they hit the floor. / They feel the way they want to feel.”) This is an unflattering stereotype of a rock record. The lyrics make little sense, full of empty platitudes and contradictory sentiments. My guess is that the band is trying to say we should all stick together because in “times like this, you’re on your own.”
“Let Me Out” is a tenth rate attempt at a Replacements-style song. It has some lift, but it’s nothing we haven’t already heard.
“Start The Show” is a rock stereotype with no substance. It’s all lobotomized testosterone and might. It even goes as far as to put a cow bell at its center for a bit. (Seriously? A cow bell? Didn’t they see the Christopher Walken SNL skit?) Again, this track is needless.
“She Holds A Grudge” is a ballad. Considering that on their other two records, the band shined most on their ballads, you’d think this song would fare better. It’s the album’s closer. After everything we have heard, it just sounds like more shape-shifting and recycling, even as the tempo changes.
“Shaka Rock is not a worthy record. It isn’t the album Jet should have released. They should’ve put their naysayers to rest by delivering something truly dynamic. Instead, they issued their most vacant album to date. On “Get Born,” there were hints of potential. Maybe that potential isn’t as dead as it seems. Maybe their next record will be outstanding and prove me wrong. I am rooting for them to succeed, but I’m not counting on it. This record is so recycled, it feels like instant garbage. Time will probably only make this problem worse. This is just plain awful! There’s no sugar-coating it. There’s no getting around it.
Email
Pray Away the Gay?
Cover It Up 



RSS
Twitter
Facebook
I somewhat doubt the crediblility of your review. You think “timothy” is an alien. Huh, how many times did you listen to each album. And were you looking for deep thought and lyrical geniuses when you went out of your way to listen to these albums. Cos if you did, im sorry for you. I guess rock n’ roll isn’t your thing. You should try sensitive coffehouse acoustic bands.
Posted by: Jake | August 27, 2009, 4:43 pm 4:43 pm
I hate your passive aggressive attitude towards JET. How can you honestly expect us to believe you hate all 3 of their albums, but you’re “rooting for them to succeed”? Give me a break. You don’t like them, you don’t like this kind of music, and you are therefore not qualified to review this album. Shaka Rock is their best album to date. All of the songs are solid and the band was able to sound fresh without straying from their roots. It’s a shame you couldn’t get over your pre-existing anti-JET bias and give Shaka Rock an objective review.
Posted by: Anthony | August 27, 2009, 6:49 pm 6:49 pm
As someone pointed out earlier, Timothy is not about an alien, but the guitarist’s, Cameron Muncey, dead brother. That alone disqualifies you from any reviews of that album or really any album, although that may be a bit draconian, like your review. And you mocked them for mirroring bass and guitar lines when bands like Led Zeppelin did the same, and if Led Zeppelin did it, well it must be good. And as far as The Clash comment you made goes, I think the Clash would appreciate the fact that JET are garage rockers who are just playing what they want and, no offense to The Clash, probably have more instrumental talent as well. Their lyrics could use work on some songs, but their fine and applicable, a truth is a truth. Your lyrics accusation is similar to ones people made Led Zeppelin also, that they just took common lyrics and used them, and again, if Led Zeppelin did it… People also made accusations that Oasis has terrible lyrics, but their still amazing. Jet is just rock and roll, plain and simple, and there and not to many bands like that left.
Posted by: Adam | August 29, 2009, 10:41 pm 10:41 pm
who is this guy and what is he doing reviewing a rock album??
Posted by: dust | August 30, 2009, 10:50 am 10:50 am
I’m 55 years old, I grew up with the best Rock & roll bands in the world from the 60,70,80, Jet has a Rock and roll soul, this might be hard for someone like this guy to understand un-like today mindless three cord wonders. Next time you want to hear good lead guitar lead pop in the Police CD and hear them Rip it up ha ha. Jet puts fun back into rock and roll…START THE SHOW….
Posted by: BubblePuppy | September 1, 2009, 3:42 pm 3:42 pm
I thought this was an awesome album for Jet, it was very fresh and I’ve been waiting for what feels like forever since “Shine On”… I made the mistake of reading this so called “review” before listening to the CD, and I mean, dude what kind of critic are you? You obviously have something against this band, did they blow you off for an autograph or something? You put way to much effort into comparing every song here to a classic, why would you do that? You literally describe the songs like you are describing music to a deaf person and then you attack every good thing like its a bad thing, I’m hurt that when I google a review for this album this terrible biased review even pops up…
Posted by: Evan | September 4, 2009, 2:38 am 2:38 am
The real job of a critic is to be honest, and you’re definity not. I can understand you don’t like their style but to hate everything it’s not fair. Their last album ”Shaka Rock” is not my favorite but there’s a lot of great songs in this album. I prefer the album ”Shine On” but this one is not bad too. The next time let someone else make the critic…please mister right !
Posted by: Andy Bernard | September 6, 2009, 12:57 am 12:57 am
Ignore the critics’ “reviews at face value”; they are nothing but boring denunciation which shows that they only listened to the first fifteen seconds of each song. Anyone with a real objective idea of what constitutes a good album will review Shaka Rock and review it highly, there is nothing to be said for people who have only bad things to say — They are wrong.
Jet’s third album, Shaka Rock, delivers solid, catchy, relatable(?) and fun musical mastery. The bands tunes in Shaka Rock are free of the over-produced feel of the last album, Shine On, with a new producer ‘Frenchie’ Smith, and the beat has come back up to cheer us up like Get Born did, such a long time ago.
If there is any real criticism to be made of this band, it is that there is too long a gap between albums. Reviewers expect three years’ work to be compiled into one album — Or the culmination of any gap of time with one album and another. The truth is, however, like a disorganised student studying at the last minute, Jet come together at the last second after being placed apart all over the globe and rely on their pure talent to pull them through. And, boy it does! Without classical training and with independant production, the boys from Melbourne have pulled off something that most who boast the exact opposite cannot — An eye catching album cover, inspired music, confidence in vocals and soul that makes the music acceptable on many demographics.
Good one, Jet
Posted by: Tony Marcerole | September 6, 2009, 2:34 am 2:34 am
I don’t think Shaka Rock is as good as their first two, but it has been growing on me. It’s very different in some ways from their previous efforts but still good. This review is total crap IMHO. I wish their opinion was more humble and respectful. It’s hard to make great music.
Posted by: Grady Truchelut | September 8, 2009, 2:30 pm 2:30 pm
This album is the farthest thing from “musical mastery” that a group can get. I feel this critic shows us a WIDE variety in what he reviews. “What’s he doing reviewing rock albums?”… well none of you took the time to comment on his spot on Dinosaur Jr. review, probably because you chose to listen to this crap instead of a true rock record like Farm. Just cause this band of joke musicians turns it up to 11 and plays distorted guitars, doesn’t make this a rock album, or even a decent one at that. It just makes all of you gullible to cookie cutter pop rock. There’s so much more out there that deserves a better chance at the spotlight than this “band”… good job, critic.
Posted by: Richard | September 10, 2009, 12:54 pm 12:54 pm
I think shaka rock is just as good as some of there previous albums, if not better. The tracks from She’s a Genius down to La di da are amazing (seventeen and black hearts) I think this review was very unfair on this album
Posted by: LIam | September 24, 2009, 5:23 am 5:23 am
What did Jet do to critics????? Honestly, maybe no autographs…. Clean yours ears out, this is a great album, geez.
Posted by: Rock86 | September 29, 2009, 11:50 pm 11:50 pm
Is this guy serious? What are you on about… Analysing the album like it’s a grade 10 English essay. Awesome album from an awesome band. Black Hearts and KIA are the best.
Posted by: Will | October 1, 2009, 2:08 am 2:08 am
this is the worst review ever written. the author sounds like someone who could is still bitter for never making anything of himself…perhaps in the music industry himself, so all that’s left is to criticise those who have.
Posted by: jess | October 14, 2009, 9:00 pm 9:00 pm
If that’s what you call “making it” then you can “keep it”. This album is not even worthy to be my dogs new chew toy.
Posted by: Mamspone | October 16, 2009, 3:18 pm 3:18 pm
JET ROCKS! one of the best rock and roll bands today, we need more of these bands and less freakin atreyu and emo rock. lets go back to good rock! and this guy has no idea what hes talking about.
Posted by: Jimmy Jo | October 26, 2009, 11:37 am 11:37 am
I will not sway your opinion on JET, Allan Raible. But I do want to sway your vote on the worst album of the year, it’s Britney Spears – Circus. If you are too focus on the lyric, you may want to try Country music, those lyrics are sweet, yo understance?
Posted by: squirrelonfire | November 19, 2009, 8:26 pm 8:26 pm
Are You mad?
This album is insane classic Rock n’Roll!
My favourites are:
Seventeen
She’s a Genius
Times Like This
Start the Show
This guy does not know the meaning of Rock n’ Roll!
I don’t really know about Get Born and Shine On but this is classy!
Posted by: James Winckley | November 30, 2009, 8:46 am 8:46 am
I agree with the comments on this guys critical review of Jet’s newest album. He’s obviously against this ‘back to the roots’ rock that I think has a great appeal. I’m not saying that Jet’s lyrics don’t need work but you have to take them for what they are; “A classic rock garage band”. People want to find some deep hidden meaning in this kind of music. It doesn’t sound totally original because it’s not meant to. People want to still hear music as close to the origins of rock as possible. This critic stick to reviewing bands he doesn’t appreciate for what they are. It’s like him bring critical of the experimental metal band Tool for not being ‘up beat’ because he love pop music.
Posted by: Bill Ter Burgh | October 9, 2010, 10:08 pm 10:08 pm
ignore this article ive just bought shaka rock and ive listened to the first 5 tracks, possibly the best album i have purchased this year and its the 31st of december. I also loved the Shine On album, especially the song Rip it Up. Their music sounds much more clever on this new album, every song sounds different and the album runs smoothly. They do sound kind of Beatles-seque but not in such a way that they are copying or immitating anything :/
Posted by: kerr | December 31, 2010, 3:51 pm 3:51 pm
Lol this guy is a looser; he has no idea on what he’s talking about. This is a great album, with many great songs.
Guessing by the comments I think you should have a hard think about your review. JET are one of the best bands out. Just because you don’t like this classic style of music doesn’t mean you should write a misleading review.
My favourites:
Black Hearts
Seventeen
La di da
Goodbye Hollywood
Start the Show
Rock ‘n’ Roll <3
Posted by: Sam | February 15, 2011, 12:28 am 12:28 am