Justin Bieber’s Baby Drama Escalates

Mariah Yeater's 2006 yearbook photo.
More details are coming out about the woman who claims to be the mother of Justin Bieber‘s baby.
Lawyers for Mariah Yeater, 20, appeared on HLN’s “Dr. Drew” show Thursday urging the pop star to “step up and take” a paternity test.
Lawyers Matt Pare and Lance Rogers were asked what they would do if the paternity test came back proving that Bieber, 17, is not the father of Yeater’s 3-month-old son. If that happens, they might face a lawsuit from Bieber’s team, who has called the lawsuit “malicious,” “defamatory” and “demonstrably false.”
“We think that’s highly unlikely based on the evidence we have, not all of which has been released to the media,” Pare said. “There’s credible evidence that supports he is the father.”
There’s also potential for the paternity suit to backfire. The LAPD may look into whether Yeater, who was 19 when she claimed she had sex with the then 16-year-old Bieber backstage at one of his Los Angeles concerts, could be charged with statutory rape. Asked whether Yeater’s paternity suit is an admission of statutory rape, Pare said, “not technically.” He added that even if she is found guilty of statutory rape, “that has no bearing whatsoever on the right for child support.”
Meanwhile, photos of the California girl and self-avowed Bieber fan have emerged online. In many, she shows off her prolific piercings and tattoos. Yeater displays the nonchalance of an immature teenager, throwing up her middle finger at the camera in one photo and posing with saran wrap over her face in others.
Bieber is trying to distance himself from the controversy.
“Never met the woman,” he said on NBC’s “Today” show this morning. ”I’d just like to say, basically, that none of those allegations are true.”
But say a judge ordered Bieber to submit to a paternity test (which could happen if the “credible evidence” Yeater’s lawyers referenced holds up in court) that revealed he is the father of Yeater’s child. How much would he have to cough up for child support?
“He is a very high income earner, but in the case of child support, it’s about finding a reasonable amount that is required to raise the child by the standards of the parent who will have custody,” said family law specialist Debra Opri. “If she thinks she’s going to get $500,000 a month, she’s wrong. $5,000 to $10,000 a month is more likely.”
If Bieber were Opri’s client, she’d put off that paternity test as long as possible.
“I wouldn’t volunteer a paternity test, I wouldn’t make it easy for her whatsoever,” she said. “I would make her life miserable.”

Email
Celebrities with 'Sole'
Robin Thicke's Advice for Aspiring Musicians 




RSS
Twitter
Facebook
Something tells me that with all of the women Beiber could choose from, he wouldn’t choose her. She seems a long ways away from his current girlfriend.
Posted by: Sarah | November 4, 2011, 11:42 am 11:42 am
If he has had sex yet it was likely NOT with a female.
Posted by: bob | November 4, 2011, 11:51 am 11:51 am
It’s pretty simple to solve, take the paternity test. If he “knows” this is not his child then he has nothing to fear…unless he just likes the publicity and has something to hide
Posted by: samhiguchi | November 4, 2011, 11:59 am 11:59 am
I admit this chick is a dog, and I wouldn’t touch her with a 10 foot pole, but Bieber can easily supply a little DNA and get this over and done with. It’s very simple thing to do… unless you are lying or you enjoy the extra publicity. For me, I’m not a Bieber fan could care less about his music. If he ain’t country, I don’t care, just get him out of the news.
Posted by: sage59 | November 4, 2011, 12:03 pm 12:03 pm
Who cares about this CREEP. He dogged America 4 or 5 months ago and he is down here making a good paycheck. Kick his a– back to Canada. My grandkids think he is a creep
Posted by: Jim Rod | November 4, 2011, 12:14 pm 12:14 pm
The last lawyer is a real piece of work. If this child is B’s then he should man-up and pay for the child’s care. This “mom” may not even have a cent to care for the child. Take the test you spoiled brat and then everyone will know.
Posted by: jagray | November 4, 2011, 12:31 pm 12:31 pm
would anyone really be surprised if this story was true?? With all of the girls throwing themselves at hi, why wouldn’t he partake????????
Posted by: dontheking | November 4, 2011, 12:37 pm 12:37 pm
I think its his. He’s ignoring it? Take the Paternity test and get it over…I think he’s lying…after all the kids mentor is USHER lol…and we all know what happened with usher and his baby mama drama LOL apple doesn’t fall far from the tree and apparently his apples fell early LOL
Posted by: totallyawsome4ever | November 4, 2011, 1:02 pm 1:02 pm
I couldn’t pick Justin Bieber out of a lineup and if I’ve ever heard anything from him it’s been as elevator muzak… but having said that this could only happen in America. A minor is being sued by their molester for child support? Really? The police shouldn’t be standing on the sideline giggling like schoolgirls. Arrest her charge her with child molestation and put her away for a very long time.
Posted by: glacia | November 4, 2011, 1:03 pm 1:03 pm
I thought Beiber was a closet gay. Who did you say the “father” of his child was?
Posted by: Me | November 4, 2011, 1:08 pm 1:08 pm
I think it would be hilarious if it turns out she was a little high during the concert and didn’t realize that the father of her child was a backup singer/dancer.
Posted by: Crow T. Robot | November 4, 2011, 1:11 pm 1:11 pm
I think she’s telling the truth. The 30 second remark seals it for me.
Posted by: Jim Bob jr. | November 4, 2011, 1:22 pm 1:22 pm
To me this seems pretty straightforward. Take the test and if it proves to be false sue for defamation of character using this girl as an example that any future false paternity claims will be taken seriously. Plain and simple end of story. Why let this continue on unless there is something to hide or he likes all the attention this is generating.
Posted by: just get it over with | November 4, 2011, 1:25 pm 1:25 pm
Calling a 16 yr old male who wants to get laid a minor … priceless. As well as clueless. Only from a woman.
Posted by: Bryan | November 4, 2011, 1:26 pm 1:26 pm
I think it is funny, the comment from one of the woman’s lawyers….”She wants him to take the test so that she will know who the father of her baby is…” I think that says it all. LOL
Posted by: Elles | November 4, 2011, 1:29 pm 1:29 pm
What’s with the headline…”$10,000 and Call it a Day”? I didn’t see anything about that in the article.
Posted by: Lee | November 4, 2011, 1:51 pm 1:51 pm
Take the test little boy. Time to man up. And let’s not forget there is a baby to be concerned about. I could give a crap about Bieber or this woman. But the baby deserves to know who his father is. Justin may not like it, but he should of kept his zipper shut. And for Opri that says she would make her life miserable … what about the baby? You can sleep at night doing that just to protect Justin’s bank account, when he may in fact be the father? Take the test, get this taken care of.
Posted by: Lori | November 4, 2011, 1:54 pm 1:54 pm
So if a woman rapes a boy along the statutory guidelines, he is required to pay child support? explain how that makes sense?
Posted by: c | November 4, 2011, 1:55 pm 1:55 pm
If the child is his, I’d say that he used his popularity power to rape her. In this situation, he was the instigator, he had power over her, and he would have chosen to seduce her. Somethings wrong in a nation where a kid like him could have sex with a woman and she’s the one that gets charged for rape.
Posted by: Richard | November 4, 2011, 2:12 pm 2:12 pm
Okay – this is an easy on… Bieber, take the test. If you are the daddy, arrest her for rape, Bieber gets custody of the baby, no child support for Bieber!!!
Posted by: Smurfette | November 4, 2011, 2:13 pm 2:13 pm
He SHOULDN’T submit to the test. If he submits too quickly to the DNA test to prove he’s not the dad, he’s made himself an easy target. How long before dozens of other women come out for her 15 minutes and attempted pay day? I would advise him to avoid the test and make it difficult so the next woman thinks long and hard before accusing him of being the daddy.
Posted by: M | November 4, 2011, 2:26 pm 2:26 pm
Sorry, I don’t believe this story is true for one second. I have researched Justin Bieber thoroughly because my children love him and I want to know who my children are idolizing. Let me ask you this… If you are a huge fan of any star and are asked backstage after a concert… what is the first thing you are going to do… you are gonna snap pictures like crazy with your cell phone. She has countless pictures that they have pulled from her facebook profile and she doesn’t have a single picture up from the concert? Also, Justin Bieber’s staff is like a close nit family and he has always expressed the urge to live life like a child and never turn into one of those child stars that go wrong. He has a beautiful girlfriend that he has even adopted a dog with. Celebrity or not he is a 16 year old boy and what 16 year old boy, who has a gorgeous gf, is going to lose his virginity in a bathroom with a random, unattractive stranger. I mean out of all the girls in the audience… he is gonna pick her? I wouldn’t take a paternity test if I were him… I would not give this woman the time of day until court ordered me to do it. I would say it wasn’t true at all and then move on with my life and ignore it… which is what Justin is doing.
And if this is at all true, I think the woman may have bit off more than she could chew… because whose to say that she would even get custody of the child. She has a hard time holding down a job and is living off government assistance and would have had random sex with a minor. Justin, being raised with little interaction with his father is probably not going to walk down that same road and will most likely want custody of his child. But I really don’t believe that there is any truth to this woman’s claims….
Posted by: April | November 4, 2011, 2:27 pm 2:27 pm
this is total crap! rape a minor then you go to court for payment? that woman is tooo agry in the first plan
Posted by: nancyamos | November 4, 2011, 2:27 pm 2:27 pm
how could this b true she is saying that she has no money and waent to a justin bieber concert FRONT ROW not the back but the front. and she keeps on changing the story cuz i c different stuff on different websites and sources so i cant believe her and from alll the girls i knoe he wouldnt choose a girl with piercings eveywhere and tattoes!! umm hello and she should b going 2 jail cuz she was over and he was younger IF THIS EVEN HAPPENED!
Posted by: Isabelle | November 4, 2011, 2:30 pm 2:30 pm
“Justin Bieber said he’s never met the woman who claims to be the father of his baby.”
….did anyone else notice that? “…the woman who claims to be the father…”
Posted by: Jackie | November 4, 2011, 2:43 pm 2:43 pm
I don’t believe it, but if he was bent over in a stall with a guy, I’d be more inclined too.
Posted by: jmiccey | November 4, 2011, 2:45 pm 2:45 pm
Wow what a babe. I can see how Bieber could fall victim to her charms.
Posted by: Atilathehun101 | November 4, 2011, 2:57 pm 2:57 pm
Bieber’s asked his lawyer if he needs a tutor to help him study for the DNA test.
Posted by: Atilathehun101 | November 4, 2011, 3:00 pm 3:00 pm
Why is $5000 to $10000 a month considered an appropriate amount used to raise a child? My husband and I raise 5 kids on far less than that. Our kids are well-fed and have plenty of clothes, are involved in lots of activities and it does not cost even half that amount for all of them.
Posted by: Lease | November 4, 2011, 3:01 pm 3:01 pm
Maybe if B threatened to charge her for rape before agreeing to taking a test she’ll forget about trying to get money from him. Because honestly if it is his then she did illegally have sex with him. So It’s justin’s then she raped him. It’s not justin’s then she lied. It’s a lose lose situation. She obviously wasn’t the sharpest tool in the box!
Posted by: Mellisa | November 4, 2011, 3:19 pm 3:19 pm
I wish I had $5,000 to $10,000 per month to raise my child. This woman is NOT looking for child support she is looking for the fame that will come with having the baby of a star. She is looking for a lavish lifestyle. He should do the test, and do the right thing if the child is his. By the right thing I mean a small amount to pay for the expense of the child NOT the mothers expenses.
Posted by: Donna | November 4, 2011, 3:31 pm 3:31 pm
Fact of the matter is if he slept with her he needs to man up to his fault. Regaurdless if her intensions were to get pregnant by him or not he stupidly slept with a random fan without a condom not knowing her true intensions. There for he just needs to be a man about this and take care of his wrong doing. The back and forth crap is not needed. Take a dna test and that will settle everything. Sycho women nowadays will do anything for money as you can see this individual is living proof. But as a role model for young teens justin needs to handle this like a man. He was a man when he had sex with her now he needs to man up to wether hes the daddy or not. His bbaby momma is nothing to speak of concidering her desprite attempt to trap a pop star or milk him for his money.
Posted by: Becka | November 4, 2011, 3:43 pm 3:43 pm
The biebster is so stupid he thinks a DNA test is a pop quiz on explosives
Posted by: beebster | November 4, 2011, 3:48 pm 3:48 pm
LOL! This is cuh-razee! Go on Maury with this one! Justin…..YOU ARE……NOT THE FATHER!! He can dance around on the stage, and she can run off crying down the back hall and collapse into a sobbing whorish mess on the floor. Then Maury can put his arms around her shoulders and walk her back on the stage for a little more public humiliation and ask her if she knows who the father is…she will commence to say yes, then come back and have like, 6 more guys tested and neither one will be the daddy, and she will say its ok, because my baby will be alright. LMAO!!!!!!
Posted by: Thoughtyouknew | November 4, 2011, 3:51 pm 3:51 pm
….MAURY IM A HUNDRED, THOUSAND, TRILLION PERCENT SURE, JUSTIN IS THE FATHER!! maury: how can you be sure? baby mama: AT THAT CONCERT AND ME AND JUSTINS EYES LOCKED RIGHT? SO THEN HE ASKS ME TO COME BACK STAGE, AND I WENT, YOU THINK IM CRAZY MAURY? maury; So you didnt have sex with anyone else around the time you “had sex with justin?” BABY MAMA;Beuse i havent been with anyone ..lets see…like 3 days before I was with Justin…that’s how I know it’s his.
Posted by: Thoughtyouknew | November 4, 2011, 3:56 pm 3:56 pm
IT’S NOT MY BABY, BABY, BABY NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!! *im having just a little to much fun here…sorry” LOL!
Posted by: Thoughtyouknew | November 4, 2011, 3:57 pm 3:57 pm
“I wouldn’t volunteer a paternity test, I wouldn’t make it easy for her whatsoever,” she said. “I would make her life miserable.”…said the attorney ABC News spoke to. Oh, no doubt about that. But, other than for her own selfish reasons and because drawing the situation out means more $$$ for the lawyers, why? Why do this to a child that is potentially his? If he is the father, and the baby is being raised on welfare, why would anyone wish that on a child who can’t support himself? (I mean the baby, not Bieber). If he has nothing to hide, then take the test and prove her wrong, end of story. If the woman is lying, then that’s the time to “draw it out” in court. But not now. In my eyes, if he’s so sure of himself, he’d step up and take the test.
Posted by: Mobalajee | November 4, 2011, 3:58 pm 3:58 pm
If NOT true then take the paternity test. Nothing to hide, then clear this up and make her look like a moron. If they don’t, then it must be true. Simple as that.
Posted by: Steve | November 4, 2011, 3:58 pm 3:58 pm
Wow, for a woman who claimed to be on food stamps and welfare (according to the lawsuit) she sure can afford, not only one, but two attorneys??
Posted by: Marie | November 4, 2011, 3:59 pm 3:59 pm
If Bieber were Opri’s client, she’d put off that paternity test as long as possible.
“I wouldn’t volunteer a paternity test, I wouldn’t make it easy for her whatsoever,” she said. “I would make her life miserable.”
Maybe that’s his lawyers plan.
Posted by: Meli | November 4, 2011, 4:00 pm 4:00 pm
Yeater – Are you in yet?
Bieber – I finshed 2 minutes ago!
Posted by: Rick | November 4, 2011, 4:00 pm 4:00 pm
SARAH -Based on his current girlfriend?! YOU DON”T KNOW MEN! There always looking something different. Just ask Hugh Grant, Arnold Schwarzenegger, etc
Posted by: Im having his baby 2 | November 4, 2011, 4:08 pm 4:08 pm
I giggle with glee over the remarks by the people who still think Bieber’s a virgin. He told this girl he didn’t want to use a condom because it was his “first time”. BS! Have you seen the pictures of him and Selena online damn near molesting each other on the beach? And he’s got thousands (if not millions) of girls tossing their goodies in his face every damned day. What 16 year old boy could resist that? And what 16 year old boy doesn’t want to hump everything willing? Because of that, I think the statutory rape thing is a joke! Yes, she did wrong. But 16 is old enought to know right from wrong and being the fruit that he is, he did hold some weird power over here, I’m sure. If it were a few years later and he was 20 and she was 23, who’d complain about the age difference then? No one, except for a few Biebernuts. I think they’re both at fault. Take the damned test already!
Posted by: ladybugtoos | November 4, 2011, 4:09 pm 4:09 pm
First of all he probably is guilty, or she could be lying. The messed up part to this story is she can get arrested for statutory rape, hello selena gomez is 20good an d you can’t say they never had sex
Posted by: heated | November 4, 2011, 4:13 pm 4:13 pm
Make her life a living hell??????? What? If he didn’t do it than why not prove her and the world wrong and get the test done!!! Why would you want to make her life a living hell for??? Because he is guilty??? She needs to support him obviously! Man, these people are idiots! Rape??? with his body guards I would not at all think anyone could even get that close to him!!! Stupid!!! If he stuck it in her, then he needs to pay!!!
Posted by: ME | November 4, 2011, 4:13 pm 4:13 pm
I understand that you all think this woman is incredible because of the way she looks. However, none of us really know who or why Justin would sleep with somebody.
Think about this; if he gives them a blood sample and they are lying, these lawyers and Mariah would be at risk of a perjury suit. This means that they would be risking jail and their entire careers with this. Not to mention the fact that Mariah will be scorned and attacked by Bieber fans everywhere if it doesn’t come out truthful.
With the power of Justin Bieber, you know that he would definitely take legal action if it was a lie. All of the parties (including Mariah) have been notified of the possible punishment. Why would they do this just to “get back at” Justin Bieber? It would ruin their lives more than anyone else’s.
Not only that, but if they DID have sex, there is something called “legal age of consent”. By California law (where the incident “took place”), someone at age 16 is legally able to have sex with someone up to age 19 as long as they are consenting. Ergo, this boy would have zero “statutory rape” suit against her.
Posted by: Amanda | November 4, 2011, 4:14 pm 4:14 pm
To the mother “M” who commented, hoping that this guy is a squeaky clean teenager, there actually are pictures from her Facebook of her and Justin.
They most definitely met. Go to Facebook and type in “Mariah Yeates” and you will see a whole page of different photos and comments.
Posted by: Amanda | November 4, 2011, 4:23 pm 4:23 pm
First off I would like to say this info isn’t so u can disrespect the kid. If u think he is a creep keep it to urself maybe someone thinks ur a creep how u gonna feel if they wrote tht somewhere a lot of ppl can see it! U wouldn’t like it much now would u. I think I made my point but anyway I think he should take the test and just get it over with if it ain’t his he got nothing to worry about and if it is his they’re gonna find out one way or another
Posted by: Mee | November 4, 2011, 4:30 pm 4:30 pm
Who cares about this CREEP. He dogged America 4 or 5 months ago and he is down here making a good paycheck. Kick his a– back to Canada. My grandkids think he is a creep. He can’t sing or dance, my grandkids don’t like him either. Where the heck did he come from to make his fans go crazy. He’s a little boy with a swollen head. He won’t last long…….I hope. I’ve seen better on American Idol and they get kicked off. This has gone to his head bigtime. He’s probably a virgin anyway.
Posted by: Gibby | November 4, 2011, 4:32 pm 4:32 pm
I don’t believe what so ever that he could be the father of her child.Sure she might have been lucky enough to get up on stage and chill with Bieber but for him to have sex with a complete stranger doesnt seem likely.He is way to good of a person to do that and has so much respect for his fans.Either way he needs to take the test as soon as possible instead of waiting until Dec. Always a fan nomatter what happens.I love J. D .B!!!
Savanna
Posted by: savanna | November 4, 2011, 4:33 pm 4:33 pm
Okay first off, This is just another helpless desperate chick that wants money&attention! I hate how all of the celeb’s out there she goes after justin bieber . Second shes acusing herself for something she didnt do like shes basically saying she raped him . Thats pretty stupied of her! Im a true belieber and i will NEVER believe any rumors that go around about him or anyone bc, those are just a bunch of crap . Done with this convo//subject . Move on with ur freakin lives.
Byee
xx-Ava(:
Posted by: Ava | November 4, 2011, 4:37 pm 4:37 pm
if he really isnt the father of this three month old baby, why should he be embarrassed to take the paternity test?
Posted by: Jasmine | November 4, 2011, 4:37 pm 4:37 pm
@Savanna kiddo, you have a lot to learn about the real world.
Just because you saw “Never Say Never” and have watched his interviews does not, by any means, entail that you actually know that he is “to (too) good of a person to do that”.
Do you realize that Justin will, never once, take time out of his schedule to personally thank you for doing this?
Tell me, what happens if the baby IS his?
Posted by: Amanda | November 4, 2011, 4:43 pm 4:43 pm
Am I the only one who thinks that if you’re convicted of “rape” you shouldn’t be allowed to collect child support from your victim? Furthermore, is a convicted rapist really fit to raise a child? Should Philip Garrido be allowed to raise the children he fathered with Jacee Lee Dugard? If this is all true I hope that the baby is taken away from this rapist.
Posted by: Carl | November 4, 2011, 4:46 pm 4:46 pm
I can’t express how sickening the idea that someone accused of something has ‘Nothing to fear’ by allowing and assisting an investigation if they are innocent. Bull! Until we have perfect cops (no, not even close) and perfect courts (not by any stretch of the imagination!) everyone has something to fear. He’s supposed to be Innocent Until Proven Guilty, right? So why should someone be forced to assist their accusers if they are innocent? Why should an innocent person be forced to do ANYTHING? The fact that some of you think he should submit to this invasion of privacy indicates that you don’t understand the concept.
And no, I don’t listen to or support this kids music. Hell, I don’t think I’ve even heard one of his songs, and don’t lament the lack.
Posted by: Flonkbob | November 4, 2011, 4:52 pm 4:52 pm
@Carl the state of California, as well as many other states, have something called “legal age of consent”. Not only that, but statutory rape only applies to people more than 3 years older than the minor.
Since the legal age of consent is 16 and Mariah was 19 at the time (just within the legal range), then there is zero chance of a “rape” case.
Posted by: NonBelieber | November 4, 2011, 4:53 pm 4:53 pm
Justin I no it’s not yours see just wunts the $ so she is making her life a living hell for her self. You guys out there hateing on Justin are wrong it’s not his #1fan
Posted by: Sam | November 4, 2011, 5:00 pm 5:00 pm
Honestly though, do you guys really believe that Bieber could be the father? Like he said, he goes straight from the stage to his car after a concert. He also has his bodyguard around him at all times. Do you really think his security guard would leave him alone with some random girl from the audience? I don’t think so. She just sounds like a lunatic who obviously did not think this through.
Posted by: April | November 4, 2011, 5:00 pm 5:00 pm
My god, I didn’t even think he hit puberty yet, but in any case, Bieber should take the test, unless this is a publicity stunt or if he is afraid of being the father. Better he support the child if he is, than the taxpayers. I doubt this woman works for a living.
Posted by: moffet | November 4, 2011, 5:03 pm 5:03 pm
I don’t think a rapist should collect child support. That may be legal – but there’s also the issue of trying to raise a child from a jail cell. Bieber should go for custody, and the rapist can pay him child support – it’s also a legal, and plausible outcome.
Of course he’s saying he didn’t do it – which is unbelievable, frankly. She won’t get any money unless he truly is the father.
Posted by: RoboBobo | November 4, 2011, 5:07 pm 5:07 pm
Either way you look at it – this woman is nothing but trashy to say the least. I couldn’t help but to wonder does the recent baby Lisa missing case as something to do with this trashy woman’s claim – you know, one’s trying to get media attention no matter what?! If I were Justin then I’ll submit my DNA for the paternity test. If the result shows that I’m the father then I’ll ask the court to grant me sole custody of the baby; otherwise I’ll file law-suit to put the trashy woman behind bars!
Posted by: Get_Down | November 4, 2011, 5:11 pm 5:11 pm
He can’t sue her if he had sexual intercourse with this girl….
Posted by: really? | November 4, 2011, 5:20 pm 5:20 pm
The ‘Bieberspiel’ continues.I think Miss Yeater is the real ‘beaver-cheater’.Ha,ha.
Posted by: MagickalMerlin777 | November 4, 2011, 5:27 pm 5:27 pm
That is so stupid for Opri to talk about torturing the woman by not making Bieber take the paternity test. It’s the BABY everyone needs to worry about. If Justin has nothing to hide, he needs to take the test. THAT, and ONLY that, will make a statement to any other girls seeking to make a quick buck by saying he’s the father of their children. When you make a web of lies, you get caught in them. But trying to stall taking the test is just dumb. Makes him look like he IS the father. And even if he is, it’s not like he doesn’t have the money for child support. He needs to quit being a baby and take care of his.
Posted by: Lisa | November 4, 2011, 5:33 pm 5:33 pm
Two words…. TIGER WOODS! Things aren’t always what they seem to be.
Posted by: Barry Badrinath | November 4, 2011, 5:40 pm 5:40 pm
No one in their right mind would say something like this if it weren’t true plain and simple.
Posted by: 887 | November 4, 2011, 5:42 pm 5:42 pm
First, age of consent is 18 in California. If the two parties are “close in age” (that is, less than three years), it is a misdemeanor instead of a felony, but the age limit of 18 is a hard set rule. With that, since she was 19 and he was 16, she would indeed be able to be charged with statutory rape and depending on when their birthdays fall (if they’re over or under three years apart) it could be considered either a misdemeanor (if under 3 years) or a felony (if over 3 years). Since by law he would be considered a victim of statutory rape (even if he agreed to having sex) because of his age, I doubt he could be forced to pay child support. If she’s telling the truth and the baby is his, then even if he’s not legally required to pay, he should out of moral obligation to the child. Anyways, no use in speculating though since nothing’s proven.
Posted by: Chris | November 4, 2011, 5:46 pm 5:46 pm
I’m really not a Bieber fan, but this woman is incredibly stupid.
If the test comes back negative, she will get sued for slander.
If it comes back positive, it proves she had sex with a minor (under retarded christian-puritan-fanatics American age-of-consent laws), landing her in prison for up to a year, which will actually lose her the custody for the child, so she will be the one paying child support (assuming she will ever have an income, she looks like some one who would live on the street).
Posted by: Anonymous | November 4, 2011, 5:49 pm 5:49 pm
I think he is not the dad!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I dont believe in it
Posted by: carissa | November 4, 2011, 5:55 pm 5:55 pm
Let’s see, he is 17 and she is 20. She could be charged with child molestation or some sex crime. He is a minor.
Posted by: THOMAS | November 4, 2011, 5:56 pm 5:56 pm
Who is she?
Nobody – that’s the problem. There are a lot of useless people trying to get attention by piggy-backing on celebrity names. If I were his lawyers, I’d let her run with her story, disprove it, then sue her into the ground to make an example of her.
Posted by: Cassandra | November 4, 2011, 5:58 pm 5:58 pm
Shes so stupid, If he is the daddy then shes going to jail for statutory rape of a minor he was 16 she 19, 18 years in california is year of consent. If hes not the daddy she’ll go to jail for perjury. I hope this is worth the quick buck. Bieber is going to sue her and her lawyers into the stone age.
Posted by: rich | November 4, 2011, 5:59 pm 5:59 pm
Re: “No one in their right mind would say something like this if it weren’t true plain and simple.” You’ve seen her photos – and you still think she’s in her right mind?
I think she believed he’d pay her off to make her go away and that she may not know who the father really is.
Posted by: Cassandra | November 4, 2011, 6:02 pm 6:02 pm
I’m starting to think it’s all of his fans that are crazy. This is truly a simple matter to settle. This boy should take the test and call it a day. If he knows he did nothing wrong, he’s got nothing to worry about. If he delays taking the paternity test, he appears worried about what the results are despite the fact that he supposedly never met the woman. I would be anxious to take the test so I could laugh in that person’s face sooner. It’s possible she’s just looking for publicity but very few people would deliberately make their first move one that would draw the ire of millions of people. He might not be the father but I believe she has good reason to suspect he is and that’s why she’s filed suit.
Posted by: Christina | November 4, 2011, 6:23 pm 6:23 pm
If its true, he should pay child support! He didn’t get raped! He hit that willingly! He knew what he was doing, and he damn well enjoyed it until the end didnt he? (If its true)
Posted by: devin | November 4, 2011, 6:28 pm 6:28 pm
The girl is HIDEOUS. He could have pretty much any teen girl he wanted and he’s gonna pick THAT one???? NO, no way. Hope he sues.
Posted by: Splum | November 4, 2011, 6:33 pm 6:33 pm
This is just dumb, I mean a women out of nowhere tells you that you’re the baby of her father? Wth, I doubt that he would do that I mean look at her and he’s not dumb enough. This is obviously for publicity and she probably wants money.
Posted by: Nguyen | November 4, 2011, 6:43 pm 6:43 pm
i find it interesting that he isnt willing to take the paternity test and has hired a crisis management firm. why do either of those things if you have nothing to hide? now on the flip side i could also see this as a situation where they are trying to protect his supposedly squeaky clean image. i actually dont think he hooked up with this girl but i do think he has hooked up with others. if they allow her to get the paternity test, i would bet that there will be more than a few others who come out of the wood works. while he likely didnt impregnate this girl, he has surely hooked up with another who could more credibly claim that he got her pregnant. that is what explains all the crisis management and lack of willingness to give the paternity test. they dont want to open the floodgates. this guy is most certainly not a virgin regardless of what he says about his religious beliefs. he’s too young, too famous and too desired for that. i think the saintly act is part of his mass appeal to a particular demographic. his handlers most certainly want to protect that, as that element of his persona is a big part of his ability to make big dollars. so in other words, this is likely just the beginning of the various scandals and what not that slowly but surely changer this guy’s image. i say scandal loosely though because for bieber, anything non squeaky clean would be a scandal but in reality, they is 17 years old so what would people expect. it should be interesting.
Posted by: A | November 4, 2011, 6:44 pm 6:44 pm
Let’s put this on Maury!
Posted by: Lysia | November 4, 2011, 7:26 pm 7:26 pm
She’s not hideous, Splum. She may not be drop dead gorgeous, but she looks like a lot of people out there. I think people are judging pictures of Mariah Yeates with a post pregnancy body. Hate to break it to you, but the reality of having kids is that moms put on a bit of weight after having a baby. Not everyone is lucky enough to have personal trainers and look fabulous a week later, like the media loves to portray.
Posted by: Aquia | November 4, 2011, 7:38 pm 7:38 pm
She is another crazed fan who will do anything to get within 50 feet of Justin. I mean I am sure he would pull someone out of the crowd, but not her. She is unattractive. I do not believe that child is his. If he did have sex with her, send her to jail for sex with a minor.
Posted by: Alexis | November 4, 2011, 7:53 pm 7:53 pm
Hello!!! If she was 19 and he was 16, then this woman is claiming she is a child molester and rapist. Is she crazy?
Posted by: Jean | November 4, 2011, 7:54 pm 7:54 pm
wow, IF THAT’s TRUE, what a shame for Bieber, being idolized by millions of little girls. that’s disgusting really. poor boy
Posted by: Ralph | November 4, 2011, 7:58 pm 7:58 pm
First off, Sam. You need to learn how to spell correctly. Reading some of these comments just sicken and disappoint me. For the most part, non of you even know what you guys are talking about. Bieber could very well be the father, but if this girl is found of statutory rape, he definitely should NOT have to pay child support. I’m sure most of you have NO idea what statutory rape is either, without going alooking it up on the internet. I know at least one person will want to reply to my comment, which is fine by me! But send it to my email, since I won’t be looking at these comments anymore. Thanks!
-Nikki
Posted by: Nikki | November 4, 2011, 8:10 pm 8:10 pm
I dont know someone commented on this and I wonder too, the article said that if he is the father and the matter of rape comes up it has no barrings on child support…. I think that lawyer or team of lawyers are an idiot, if the charges of rape came up and she was found guilty Bieber would be the first to be able to take the child and then no child support would be awarded to anyone!
Personally its all gossip and I think this girl is a nutcase. I dont care either way but my daughter is 8 and adores Bieber and I am not to sure if this is a role model I would want for her anymore. It would definitely hurt his image with parents whom monitor what their kids listen too.
Posted by: guin | November 4, 2011, 8:18 pm 8:18 pm
I agree with both Nikki and Guin. I mean it will hurt his career, but seriously this is a publicity stunt pulled by Mariah Yeater. There is a chance that he is lying, he probably is about never seeing her before. My friend, Jessica, thinks Mariah is a physco. I do think it might be his, because if it wasn’t why go through the trouble of filing a lawsuit? It isn’t fair because most of us do not know this chick, we are judging off what we think of Justin Bieber, and post-prego pics. It would be rape, but if he knocked this women up, and agreed to having sex with her then no she shouldn’t get rape charge.
Selena Gomez was 18 when he got with her, so the women had just turned 19. She was only 3 years older… my point is if it his, he needs to the manly thing and take the test, if its his pay for the little boy, if it isn’t blow the whole thing of.
Posted by: Paige | November 4, 2011, 9:26 pm 9:26 pm
Any Baby DA who would consider filing statutiry rape cahrges against a 19 year old for having sex in a restroom with a 16 year old rock star is obviously considering the benefits likely to flow his way from the rock stars supporters and is not considering social policies of the last 1000 years or so, or routine application of the law.
Posted by: LiliQ | November 4, 2011, 10:16 pm 10:16 pm
Its funny that its been a year and this girl is just now saying this? She didnt have friends she leaked it to who leaked it to thers? This should have been more public earlier i would think. Where does she get the # for his rep’s? I would like the # to Iggy Pops rep if anyone has readily available access to it. Its a joke and a con like the whole thing with Kutcher and that gir. This girl thought she could make a buck and its back firing. What credible evidence does she have? Either way he has to submit a paternity test. Theres no support till then and theres no way to get around the test. And yes, I would think they would have found someone MUCH better looking!
Posted by: hahahaha | November 4, 2011, 10:24 pm 10:24 pm
It is obvious this lady just needs money. And what better way to do that than to make up rumors about a global pop star. First of all she is pleading guilty to rape since Justin would have been 16 at the time and come she is all of the sudden coming out with this when the baby is now 3 months old! How come she didnt come out with this when she was pregnant or when the baby was born. This is completely false and I think this lady should spend her time looking for a job and taking care of her baby instead of accusing this innocent teenager of being a dad. So pathetic.
Posted by: Nic | November 4, 2011, 10:25 pm 10:25 pm
justin bieber if ur not the father prove it by taking a test… if u r the father step and be a dad… it isnt her fault that she MIGHT be ur 1st baby mamma….. Ohhh and im ur biggest fan…. with love LeoHoward & Justinbieber lover…..
Posted by: LeoHowardLover | November 4, 2011, 11:46 pm 11:46 pm
If he knows he’s not the father why drag it out? If he is then he needs to step up. I’m still shocked he’s not gay?!
Posted by: jessica | November 5, 2011, 12:23 am 12:23 am
People you wrong to think if Justin is innocent he should take the DNA test and get it over with, that would only encourage every nut case to pull the same stunt to get their 5 minutes of fame. If it was me I would blow these silly allegations off until I was ordered by court. If it was true, I wouldn’t take a DNA test I would come out and say I was a kid but I wanna take responsibility and I seeking full custody of my son, because obviously she raped a minor. If it was a 19 year old boy and a 16 year old girl he wouldn’t dare do this B.S. stunt, tell me I’m wrong. For the record I don’t care for the kid but the situation and how sick America has become.
Posted by: jack murray | November 5, 2011, 12:26 am 12:26 am
I think that it is close minded of everyone to assume that just because he is technically underage that he is a victim. please ppl get a grip. havent we learned already that fame is a totally different ballgame then real life??? slamming someones pic from almost 6 years ago is wrong, Look at a pic of yourself from 6 years ago and c how much u have changed. Also if it turns out that he is the dad then he should man up. if ur gonna make your bed then lay in it. dont completely blame the woman. if u were faced with someone u idiolized u dont know the decisions u would make right or wrong. so dont assume if u dont know. damn atleast she wasnt 40 years old. if anyone recalls thier earlier days. a few years is not a big deal just a technicallity. if ur gonna post a comment maybe ppl should think it through a bit so they dont sound like complete morons. ppl who r posting such hateful, judgmental, or just plain dumb comments should atleast take the time to read what they are posting before they hit the submit button.
Posted by: carita wood | November 5, 2011, 12:45 am 12:45 am
also what about the kid, say he drags this out for a year and he is the dad well gee who hurts from his being stubborn, uh duh the kid. get it taken care of for one, to clear ur name, and for two if that is not the case then atleast give the kid a chance. in 15 years he will be just as popular as justin is now. just think of arnolds love child. he could have any movie part he wanted right now.
Posted by: carita wood | November 5, 2011, 12:53 am 12:53 am
This is so fake! That little biyotch is, like, totally desperate. I mean, not that I like Justin Bieber, but she is so freaking retarded for saying she’s got HIS baby. Why not someone totally hot like Taylor Lautner? I mean, not that i want that to happen to him (since I totally like him), but why is that ugly chick so stupid and retarded? And the kid probably is some random dude’s child. I say Bieber is innocent.
Posted by: Mia | November 5, 2011, 1:48 am 1:48 am
She’s just a crazed Beiber fan who wants to scandal him into her life. Prettyboy will probably see this again. As much as I hate to admit it, the dude’s morally correct. I am not a Beiber fan, but I’ll defend the side I see fit.
Posted by: Obviousness | November 5, 2011, 2:14 am 2:14 am
mia, i am assuming you are under the age of 15, because if not you obviously need to attend some language courses, but regardless if she is crazy or not there is still a kid involved, who cares who wants what or what is better for who, the kid should be the main priority.
Posted by: carita | November 5, 2011, 2:56 am 2:56 am
The lawyers for the woman are not stupid, and wouldn’t thrust themselves into this mess if they didn’t sincerely believe he is the father.
What will Bieber say if the paternity test comes back saying he’s the father, and he was all, like, I NEVER met her, I NEVER had sex with her?
Posted by: John Hoff | November 5, 2011, 6:08 am 6:08 am
she is lieing i new justin bieber mii whole lfe that is mii brother he was with me that night it was me and selena and him we went on vaction that night she dont know nothin she needs to back off with her stupid ass and her ass is probley lieing to with her dumb ass
Posted by: dnaue | November 5, 2011, 9:07 am 9:07 am
i highly doubt that justin had sex…ever. this woman is probably going through a rough time with the world and no having a newborn. she wants money and what better way than to accuse a 17 year old pop star that makes millions every year. weather or not justin takes the test or not it’s none of our buisness and it’s sad that our “entertainment” is this. that women should just go away and find someone that will actually support her.
Posted by: Maggie | November 5, 2011, 9:44 am 9:44 am
I can see why Bieber should not easily take that DNA test; this woman is clearly crazy, it’s highly unlikely that she even got near JB (i..e. if she did, why wouldn’t she have a photo of her and him, like he takes with his other fans). She should have to prove there is reasonable evidence that they had sex before he gives up that blood sample. Why? Because if he does this for her without making her fight for it, then there will be 100 other crazies lining up behind her to accuse him of the same thing. Should he have to go and get poked with a needle every time some greedy skunk makes up lies about him? I think not!!!
Posted by: Stacy | November 5, 2011, 11:16 am 11:16 am
Something tells me this girl is more than slightly unhinged.
Posted by: VA_Jill | November 5, 2011, 11:37 am 11:37 am
Justin Bieber, One lie leads to a million lies! Let just watch his demeanor as he answers this question again and again. The truth will be in his eyes and behavior there after.
Posted by: Donna | November 5, 2011, 12:36 pm 12:36 pm
take the dna test.
Posted by: dusmop | November 5, 2011, 1:04 pm 1:04 pm
Put this rapist in prison just like you would a man.
Posted by: Things Are Bad | November 5, 2011, 2:34 pm 2:34 pm
I think it is possible.. and I think to even think charging her with rape would be riduclous. What always upsets me is the fact that their is a child invovled..lets think about what is best for the child…Take the test..Like another person said if you have nothing to hide..SO WHAT..She will just look like a pathetic girl looking for fame. BUT if it is his son…lets not make the child grow up like Justin..without his father. Who know..getr custody and raise him right. Maybe he will be a prodigy as well. I will be waiting for the results!!!
Posted by: Connie Robinson | November 5, 2011, 5:02 pm 5:02 pm
Let me begin by saying I’m not a Justin beiber fan. Never was, never will be. But there’s no way he’s the dad. What is the likelihood that a 16 year old guy with millions of admirerors would randomly hav intercourse with a strnge girl with peircings and Insist on not using a condom. He’s sixteen, he’s not stupid. And she’s even blamed the baby on her ex previously! in his position I’d never submit to a paternity test because 1.I’d want to make her suffer 2. That’s admitting there’s a possibility he was the father (it’s a pride and publicity thing). 3. It’s destroying his reputation! He wants to ignore it as much as possible and I would too.
Posted by: This is stupid | November 5, 2011, 6:07 pm 6:07 pm
Sounds like a episode of The Murray Show. If this is true….they should both be held accountable. She should be charged for statutory rape, and he should pay child support it’s simple. The law needs to look at both parties equally, and judge them accordingly! But we also need to look at any 16 year old boy especially one with an ego, it’s not impossible for a boy to rape a woman of any age.
Posted by: Hannah | November 5, 2011, 8:01 pm 8:01 pm
God just leave him alone I don’t believe it for a sec he was only 16 and she raped him member because she was 19 and he should take the test but first tell her he is gonna charge her for rape
Posted by: Hannah | November 5, 2011, 8:25 pm 8:25 pm
I think that if she was lying, then she would not be encouraging a paternity test. I mean, if he is for sure not the father, then she would be afraid that it was going to come back negative, which it would, if that were the case.
Either way, I think she at least BELIEVES he is the father, not saying he has to be.
Posted by: ugh | November 5, 2011, 10:10 pm 10:10 pm
Omg I can’t believe all this publicity I mean just get over it like who cares, we all knew this was going to happen and anyways why can’t he just take the test like if it’s not his how come he won’t take the test I mean if it isn’t his what is he hiding or why does it matter if he has to take the test
Posted by: Tjcimmarrusti | November 5, 2011, 11:23 pm 11:23 pm
“I wouldn’t volunteer a paternity test, I wouldn’t make it easy for her whatsoever,” she said. “I would make her life miserable.”
Sorry Debra Opri, but you ooze sleaze.
Let’s say that Bieber is the father, you’re not just making the mother’s life miserable, you’re denying the child support from its father and that is disgusting. Yet another reason why people hate lawyers. If he isn’t the father, give the DNA and be done with it!
Posted by: Kelly | November 6, 2011, 12:03 am 12:03 am
I can assure you that statutory rape, in this case, will never hold up in court. This is what’s called the “Romeo and Juliet” law which serves to reduce or eliminate the penalty of the crime in cases where the couple’s age difference is minor and the sexual contact is only considered rape because of the lack of legally recognized consent. If Justin is not the father, and he wants to pursue her legally, she would be charged with a misdemeanor at best! So, she got her 15 minutes of fame and picks up litter off the highway for a month.
Posted by: Rob Paulson | November 6, 2011, 12:13 am 12:13 am
All this mumbo jumbo about why would he pick her. OK why wouldn’t He. A 16 year old boy who has the world at his finger tips… and a million girls…? A boy will take anything willing to drop her panties for him. Protection? Virginity? Eh who cares… his money will take care of everything is this kids mindset. I don’t doubt that He would partake… who knows who is telling the truth. I would never say that Bieber is more credible than her. Maybe she does want fame. Or maybe she just wants what most single parents want. A jerk to step up, pull his head out of his butt and man up to his careless actions…
Posted by: holly | November 6, 2011, 12:31 am 12:31 am
Personally I think she is a nut but we can judge based on opinion can we. Looking at this from a realistic stand point I think the jury is out; there are several good comments on the form here that make a good point like don’t take the test or else 100 nuts will take her place to say in bluntly or take the test and prove her wrong and gain your rep back. also something most people haven’t thought about is some of these company who sell he merchandising probley want him to take the test because let’s face in his rep is now damaged by 1% or more until this is over and even if it is confirmed that he is not the father the it will probley take a year for his reputation to recover somewhat. Okay that was off topic any way I have to admit there is a chance we might have a tiger woods’ case here I mean before he was found out he was a role model and nobody thought he would sink so low. We could also have a case where the woman is lying and is hopeing they will pay her to shut up. and to end my comment I must add and admit that there is a chance he is the father I mean we have all seen shows about 16 year old parent and if he is the father he should pay up but I also hope if this scenario were the case that both parent would raze the kid. last I must make it very very clear I am not a Justin B fan and also people another reason to hope he is not the father is because he is a role model so many of the of our nation youth and if he were well…….it wouldn’t set a good example P.S. I am a republican Highschooler from W.A. state Yes there are republicans in W.A. Down with occupy wall street.
Posted by: captain rex | November 6, 2011, 3:12 am 3:12 am
(Edit we cant is what i ment to say in my last post. auto correct word is not aways helpful) Personally I think she is a nut but we can’t judge based on opinion can we. Looking at this from a realistic stand point I think the jury is out; there are several good comments on the form here that make a good point like don’t take the test or else 100 nuts will take her place to say in bluntly or take the test and prove her wrong and gain your rep back. also something most people haven’t thought about is some of these company who sell he merchandising probley want him to take the test because let’s face in his rep is now damaged by 1% or more until this is over and even if it is confirmed that he is not the father the it will probley take a year for his reputation to recover somewhat. Okay that was off topic any way I have to admit there is a chance we might have a tiger woods’ case here I mean before he was found out he was a role model and nobody thought he would sink so low. We could also have a case where the woman is lying and is hopeing they will pay her to shut up. and to end my comment I must add and admit that there is a chance he is the father I mean we have all seen shows about 16 year old parent and if he is the father he should pay up but I also hope if this scenario were the case that both parent would raze the kid. last I must make it very very clear I am not a Justin B fan and also people another reason to hope he is not the father is because he is a role model so many of the of our nation youth and if he were well…….it wouldn’t set a good example P.S. I am a republican Highschooler from W.A. state Yes there are republicans in W.A. Down with occupy wall street.
Posted by: captain rex | November 6, 2011, 3:18 am 3:18 am
Ewww, she’s so gross!! And if this is true, what a damn shame. His image is RUINED!
Posted by: Jennifer | November 6, 2011, 7:41 am 7:41 am
I can’t believe this, just leave it alone I mean why is everyone so interested and concerned about all Justin bieber’s drama. If it’s not his it’s not his. And if it is his who cares, it’s not that shocking i mean almost every star is doing it. I mean I love his music and I think he is totally cute but i think he’s really stupid to like Selena gomez I think she’s pretty and I like her music but seriously she’s almost 2years older than him
Posted by: Tjcimmarrusti | November 6, 2011, 11:18 am 11:18 am
I think that the only one that is going to suffer threw all of this is that little baby. Everyone needs to support there children no matter who is poor or wealthy, I think it is a sad world for someone to deny there own flesh and blood but I guess this is how people are. If he is lying then what does that teach his fans and for what reason why, because of selina? Please grow up and be a man. If the girl is lying then she needs some serious counseling to find out where all this is coming from. I just feel bad for the child and whomever is going to support that baby with honor, now that is the one who will be rich in heart.
Posted by: christi | November 6, 2011, 12:12 pm 12:12 pm
HEATED said: “First of all he probably is guilty, or she could be lying.”
Yeah, that makes sense.
Posted by: Aaron Ververs | November 6, 2011, 12:58 pm 12:58 pm
I believe him because there is no evidence at all i know this because my sister has been to every single one of his concerts and have watched him have no time to see a girl and his security was there and every thing one the bus was his mother father gaurd driver and one more person dont know who but it was a guy. She says.
Posted by: Conner | November 6, 2011, 2:34 pm 2:34 pm
Here is a news flash for all of you. There is a real world out there lol why on earth give this no talent punk anymore attention than he deserves, his 15 were up long long ago. And to all the young fans commenting, learn to spell like we do in the real world, someone might take you seriously sooner or later that way.
Posted by: onlyanegg | November 6, 2011, 2:54 pm 2:54 pm
omg why would this problem pop up out of nowhere?this woman is a joke!if he was the father this word would have been out. i think she just set this up for attention. im not suprized this happed.. she needs to get it together sheis 20 acting like a11year old…(may god be with this problem)
Posted by: ren'ee | November 6, 2011, 3:06 pm 3:06 pm
if he is the father isnt that rape since he is a minor and shes 20
Posted by: amanda | November 6, 2011, 3:53 pm 3:53 pm
Roses are red,
Orchids are great.
Two words, Mariah.
Statuatory. Rape.
Posted by: Kairi Rose | November 6, 2011, 8:40 pm 8:40 pm
I love how some people actually think it might be his child.
Do you really think Bieber would go for her?
Posted by: windrixx | November 7, 2011, 12:26 am 12:26 am
I hope the testing is certified , supervised and unbiased; A supervisor should validate the results. Bieber is worth 85 million and can pay off any lab to say the child is not his. I hope the attorneys know this… and are not naive enough to think that it could not happen. America loves this kid and noone is going to allow his reputation to be sullied. Now if it was Will Smith’s son– that’s a different story.
Posted by: 1voice | November 7, 2011, 3:40 am 3:40 am
what I don’t understand is all of a sudden they mention “statutory rape” because the female was 19 at the time and JB was 16…. Hellllooo, JB and Selena Gomez have dated some time now and no one has said anything about that age difference? They going to charge Selena Gomez with Statutory Rape!!!?
Posted by: KLflocco | November 7, 2011, 8:15 am 8:15 am
She should be arrested for statutory rape
Posted by: Debra | November 7, 2011, 9:27 am 9:27 am
Knowing both Justin and his bodyguard personally….there is NO way this is true. His bodyguard doesn’t let anyone get near him, much less some strange girl. The idea that Justin would go off with some potential stalker/killer/weirdo and have sex with her is ridiculous. 1) He’s not that kind of guy. 2) He’s SURROUNDED constantly by a bunch of people who wouldn’t let him do that. 3). Chick is a dog. Justin loves girls – PRETTY girls. 4) Justin is very aware of his public image, and wouldn’t do anything to damage it.
Posted by: Kristin | November 7, 2011, 9:57 am 9:57 am
You know that she can be arrested for rape even though technically Bieber supposedly had sex with her. Whatever, just have Justin take the paternity test and get this over with. Then we’ll see. I mean, either way, somebody is probably going to go to court or get sued.
Posted by: Aud | November 7, 2011, 12:45 pm 12:45 pm
isnt that sagitory rape…shes ugly she looks 30
Posted by: Amber | November 7, 2011, 12:50 pm 12:50 pm
I also think that these guys that go out and bring girls backstage after the show should be held accountable as well. What did he bring her back FOR? Exactly, and that is WHY she went.
Posted by: babs | November 7, 2011, 2:49 pm 2:49 pm
Don’t bother comparing her to his current girlfriend. This is sex for a 16 year old. Nothing more. And remember, he is just a kid. He’ll have lots of girlfriends, and lots of non-girlfriend sex. He’s a baby.
Posted by: bobo | November 7, 2011, 2:51 pm 2:51 pm
I want to know what the “credible evidence” is. Is it a shirt that she wore to the concert that has his “fluid” on it? If her lawyers are talking that “it’s VERY unlikely that he is not the father,” I hope he’s gettin ready to pay up!! This is getting ugly — he definitely will lose his younger fan base if this turns out to be true. This is turning into another Chris Brown situation — his squeaky clean image is diminishing. Why in the world would she lie to risk getting sued for defamation of character and/or false claims? Why would someone her age even be at a concert for teeny boppers I will never understand this…..
Posted by: T | November 7, 2011, 3:02 pm 3:02 pm
Sounds like somebody who’s just after money and doesn’t know how to make it herself. And why in the world would somebody need $10,000/month to raise a child!! That’s $120,000/year!! That’s more than most of the people in America make. Doesn’t she realize that people see right through her stupidity? What idiot takes legal action about something that is obviously false? While I’m not a huge Bieber fan I don’t think he’s dumb enough to do something like this. At least Selena hasn’t broken up with him, I think that says she believes him. Why would he do anything to ruin that relationship or his career for that matter… I feel for him, I’m sure it’s a lot of stress and hassle to deal with something so crazy..
Posted by: Christy | November 7, 2011, 3:22 pm 3:22 pm
The baby has his hair… I wouldn’t be surprised if he already has three kids.
Posted by: Ray | November 7, 2011, 3:42 pm 3:42 pm
A sixteen year old boy could overpower a nineteen year old girl easily, even if we are talking about Justin Bieber…
You cannot rape the willing.
Posted by: Ray | November 7, 2011, 3:47 pm 3:47 pm
People in this country are in denial about kids and Sex I don’t think the woman should be brought up on any charges. I am sure Justin was likely having Sex way before people especillly parents need to wake up about thier kids and Sex.
Posted by: Angelina | November 7, 2011, 5:20 pm 5:20 pm
I think that she is a fool too. One thing look at her age and his age. If he did father a child with her there is one thing she needs to know. That is a thing called statutory rape. He was under age when it happened. If that were my son I would talk to a lawyer about that. I think the law covers boys as well as girls. She can go to jail for that.
Posted by: Diana Hinzman | November 7, 2011, 5:49 pm 5:49 pm
I looked up the statutory rape law for California. She can still be in trouble for statutory rape.
Posted by: Diana Hinzman | November 7, 2011, 6:01 pm 6:01 pm
ok idiots…. CA. age of consent is 18, not 16. The 3-year difference is another thing but still, 1 day shy of 18 still make you a ‘minor’ in the state of California. and how does a ‘girl’ living on food stamps etc. get the $$$ for a concert ticket?? and front row?? I think I’m working too hard for too little because I couldn’t afford front row tickets for my GRANDDAUGHTER and I make a h3ll of a lot more than food stamps etc.
Posted by: grandma | November 7, 2011, 6:49 pm 6:49 pm
O.k look, I am a fan of his. I will happily admit that. But say the child is his? What then? I mean people look at both sides of this. I will not be happy if it his but then what fan of his would be? We are looking at post-pregnancy photos of her. Y’all need to look at both sides of this. If it is his, oh well man up and take care of the child, and she would be put in jail for rape, if it isn’t, dismiss her as another crazed fan. Simple as that.
Posted by: Alexis | November 7, 2011, 9:47 pm 9:47 pm
If that is B’s baby thats messed up to make that baby and his mother miserable and wait for a perternity test. man up and step up. your just proving yourself to be a worthless man. What a money hungry SOB!
Posted by: Christina H | November 7, 2011, 9:51 pm 9:51 pm
JUSTIN BIEBER IS AN ENTERTAINER WHO HAS NO RESPONSIBILITY TO THOSE FANS THAT THINK HE DID SOMETHING TO THEM. HE HAS ALSO SAID THAT HE WILL TAKE THE DNA TEST WHEN HE RETURNS TO THE STATES. THIS WOMAN WAS ARRESTED FOR FIGHTING AN 18 YEAR OLD AFTER ACCUSING HIM OF FATHERING HER CHILD. THIS WAS IN DECEMBER ,2010. LOOK IT UP. SHE IS DESPARATE TO FIND THE FATHER OF HER CHILD. SHE MAY HAVE SOME KIND OF MENTAL DISORDER THAT MAKES HER THINK THIS ENCOUNTER REALLY HAPPENED. FOR THOSE WHO THINK SHE SHOULD NOT BE CHARGED WITH RAPE ….IS IT BECAUSE THE VICTIM IS MALE. IF IT WAS REVERSED, EVERYONE WOULD BE CALLING FOR THE MAXIMUM PUNISHMENT FOR HIM. KNOCK THE GREEN HEADED MONSTERS OFF. HE WAS FORTUNATE ENOUGH TO GET INTO THE BUSINESS AND EARN A LOT OF MONEY AT AN EARLY AGE. SHE NEEDS A JOB TOO.
Posted by: marie k | November 8, 2011, 2:16 am 2:16 am
What makes this whole situation extremly hilarious. Is that this girl could have met up with a Justin look alike and had unprotected sex with a complete stranger. And now wants to point the finger at this kid. And states she wants to know who her child’s father is. What if its not his now you have thousands of possible suspects to try to figure out whose kid it is. Then she’s screwed. I’m not saying I believe Justin either. I just find it hilarious that a 20 year old still doesn’t know to have protected sex.
Posted by: me | November 8, 2011, 12:17 pm 12:17 pm
It’s wild that so many folks have opinions on this. To me it could go either way. Since the people involved are human, no telling what actually happened. I’ve heard that girls get stood up by guys who get em pregnant all the time. Hopefully, JB has the balls to truly stand up for what’s right if need be. Obviously, image is important to him and to the people who benefit from his image. Yea.. in the end it’s up to him to act like a true man, even tho he’s only a boy right now. Sometimes ppl do things that make em have to grow up too soon. Good luck whatever happened!
Posted by: Mike B | November 8, 2011, 6:42 pm 6:42 pm
this was pre-meditated on her part…
Posted by: BabyDaddy | November 9, 2011, 6:38 pm 6:38 pm
Bieber has brown eyes (when he doesn`t use coloured lenses)….the baby has what?
I don`t believe her story yet.
Posted by: so what | November 10, 2011, 12:45 pm 12:45 pm
so why did it take her so long to come out
Posted by: memememe | November 12, 2011, 1:20 am 1:20 am
For all of you saying “Bieber wouldn’t choose a girl like this for his first time!”,well it’s like this, 1, There’s no way it would have been his first time. 2, when you wanna do a grimey ho in the bathroom, you usually pick a grimey ho that will do you in the bathroom. 3. After long forgeting about the grimey ho you did in the washroom, it poops out your kid and files a lawsuit that the whole world will see, you do everything you possibly can to distance yourself and discredit her… when that all fails, the truth comes out… Sry Bieb’s but The Truth is gonna come out.
Posted by: The Truth | November 13, 2011, 8:05 am 8:05 am
If Bieber were Opri’s client, she’d put off that paternity test as long as possible.
“I wouldn’t volunteer a paternity test, I wouldn’t make it easy for her whatsoever,” she said. “I would make her life miserable.”
And by doing that you make the child’s life miserable, way to go. What if the kid really is his?
Posted by: Jo F. | November 14, 2011, 4:52 am 4:52 am
IN RESPONSE TO:
And by doing that you make the child’s life miserable, way to go. What if the kid really is his?
How is that making the kids life miserable? I mean really. Isnt the MOTHER doing that all on her own? And yes… I would do the same especially if I knew that I was not the father. Why give her a break if she is just trying to jump on the gravy train? I would pull to get that child taken away from her to be honest because I wouldn’t want another child growing up in a home that acts like that.
And yeah if he IS the father…step up AFTER it is proven. And in my opinion…5k to 10k a month? are you NUTS! I don’t care how much you make. THATS why people drag celebs through hell with false paternity suits/
Posted by: justanother guy | November 14, 2011, 5:59 am 5:59 am
First: Given the mother has admitted to the offense of child molestation (or sexual contact with a minor), California Child Welfare should take the child for it’s own safety.
Second: The mother should be remanded to the custody of a mental institution, until it can determined if she is a threat to herself, her baby or other children.
Third: Justin should hold off as long as possible, but he could make arrangements via third parties to offer assistance to the child, pending the outcome of a paternity test. If it comes back negative, then he should be able to sue her for that money back, as well as for his damaged reputation.
Fourth: IF Justin knows he ‘may be’ the ‘baby daddy’, then he should man up, take the test and then sue for custody of the child, which shouldn’t be that hard, since the mother is an ADMITTED COLD MOLESTER, especially when the evidence is readily available (the paternity test).
Posted by: ForestRJ | November 14, 2011, 7:14 am 7:14 am
“If Bieber were Opri’s client, she’d put off that paternity test as long as possible.
“I wouldn’t volunteer a paternity test, I wouldn’t make it easy for her whatsoever,” she said. “I would make her life miserable.”
Yeah…. way to show responsibility…
Posted by: Emma | November 14, 2011, 12:35 pm 12:35 pm
Make her life miserable, are you kidding me? IF Justin is the father, why wouldn’t they want to know so he can know his child? IF he’s not the father, then all the better to make this go away. Keanu Reeves stepped up and insisted on a paternity test. I’m not saying this is Justin’s baby, oh baby, but I am not doubting this girl’s story either and they’re vilifying her without proof. Seriously, this kid has enough money in his pocket to get a paternity test, just do it if he’s so positive this is not true? Something stinks here.
Posted by: Layla | November 14, 2011, 1:03 pm 1:03 pm
This girl is only 3 yrs. older than him. Both teenagers… and 16 is the age of consent of sex. I could see if she wass way older or something. Charging her with stag rape is just insane. LOL. Just take the damn test and move on already…..
Posted by: Virtue | November 14, 2011, 3:45 pm 3:45 pm
What do you know? Ho Ho HO and Baby Baby Baby keep it zipped
Posted by: Diane | November 14, 2011, 8:49 pm 8:49 pm
I don’t think its his. And even if they did have sex then she should have thought “Well I don’t have any money to take care of a baby so I shouldn’t be doing this”. I don’t believe in the caught in the moment crap. If two people have sex the have the power to choose not too.
Posted by: Timothy Smitley | November 14, 2011, 10:51 pm 10:51 pm
To Virtue: That maybe the case but the age of consent means he has to ask his parents to have sex and if they say no and he went ahead and did it then let the Sat charges roll.
Posted by: Timothy Smitley | November 14, 2011, 10:54 pm 10:54 pm
Heres my take on this. I see people on here saying “why now” for the claims. I believe this girl thought the baby was her ex’s but when the test came back negative for him she realized it most likely was from her 1 night stand with Justin. Do i think this girl has reason to believe its Justins? Yes. I dont think she or her lawyers would be going through all this and risking so much if not. As far as doing this for the money she obviously knows theres a huge chance of her being sued for all shes made off this already and then some.. so why keep doing interviews? Shes going to lose it all anyway if shes lying. Not to mention the rape charges. As far as how shes paying for the lawyers… theyre most likely doing it pro bono knowing how high profile of a case it is and i do believe they feel they are going to get positive media attention from it in the end. Do i think justins as “clean” as he says he is? Absolutely not and I do have reason to say so as a good friend of mine toured with him for a while on his first tour I cant imagine how he is now with double the fame. Not saying my friend ever saw him bring a girl anywhere privately but hes def. not the sweet little boy him and his team make him out to be. He really is a normal teenage boy in that sense. As far as “why her” why does anyone do anything? No one can say why he did or didnt do anything because there could be 1000s of reasons.Theres many attractive highly famous stars who have been with less than attractive women in the past and there will be plenty more to follow. I think the “rape” charges are pretty ridiculous since I think he knew exactly what he was doing and was most likely the aggressor but the law is the law and the statute of limitations for a minor to press charges is until the age of 18 or 23 depending on the state so well see how that goes. All in all i do believe this girl has reason to believe the child is his and i think him hiding from the test is just making it worse. People need to think of this baby.. not the fame. And about the “theyre making it draw out so they can sue her like crazy” comments… she doesnt have much to sue for.. why draw it out? I think theyre getting ready for it to be his or for others to come forward if this child is not his. I dont believe shes the only one hes had sex with and they know it too.
Posted by: Hmm | November 15, 2011, 3:47 am 3:47 am
FOR THOSE who keep saying that selena gomez is 20 and the girl is 20 this is the difference. the claim is she says Justin is the father and fathered the baby when he was 16 while she was 20. He is now 17 and selena gomez is 20. HENCE CALIFORNIA LAW
(b) Any person who engages in an act of unlawful sexual
intercourse with a minor who is not more than three years
older or three years younger than the perpetrator, is
guilty of a misdemeanor.
Posted by: read the law | November 15, 2011, 7:42 am 7:42 am
If Bieber were Opri’s client, she’d put off that paternity test as long as possible.
“I wouldn’t volunteer a paternity test, I wouldn’t make it easy for her whatsoever,” she said. “I would make her life miserable.”
i don’t care whether or not he’s the father.. but this comment shows why our legal system is screwed…. lets make the person bringing the suit suffer for doing it….
Posted by: Shadow8088 | November 15, 2011, 5:53 pm 5:53 pm
She should be put in jail, really?! I mean… yeah, she’s guilty by law, but do you guys really think that Justin was a victim here? If it really happened, I think he had WAY more influence and power over her than her over him. What is wrong with this country?! Everyone can carry a gun but two teens can’t sleep together?!?! She was 19 (or 20, I don’t care) not 34!!!
If JB was to charge her with statutory rape, for me, it would more of a scandal than if he was the father of the kid. THAT WOULD BE SO LOW!!!!!!
Posted by: Marilyne | November 15, 2011, 7:04 pm 7:04 pm
Some people ask if this wasn’t true, why is she demanding a test, and why she would just come out and say this? Simple. She’s thinking he’s just going to pay her a big lump sum of money to get her to shut up and go away before his image is damaged. However, if he “KNOWS” he’s not this child’s father, and that he’s never met her, etc., then why not just take the test and get it over and done with so this can just go away?! I mean seriously?! Something sounds fishy that he’s trying to “make it hard for her to get this test”. Why would you do that? I don’t know what to think and all honesty, I won’t pass judgement until it’s officially PROVEN he’s NOT this child’s father. Where’s Maury when you need him?! LOL P.S. If this was the other way around (the guy being 19 and the girl being 16 when it happened) you can bet your @$$ he’d be in jail for statutory rape and have to register as a sex offender. BTW he should still have to take care of this child IF it’s his. If he fathered this child regardless of age, should have to take care of it!!
Posted by: cRazEEEEEE People MaN | November 15, 2011, 9:43 pm 9:43 pm
I’m appalled that most peoples’ initial reaction to this story is that this girl is “ugly.” Who are you to judge her physical appearance? I’m not going to defend what she’s doing, but saying that Bieber couldn’t have slept with her because a bunch of random internet strangers find her unattractive is preposterous. Bottom line- he should clear his name and then all pertinent parties need to decide on the best course of action for the baby’s well-being. A lot of people here have missed that point.
Posted by: RAS | November 16, 2011, 2:31 am 2:31 am
There are places all over the world where he could get the testing started. I think it’s probably at least possible that this is his baby or he’d have already had his cheek swabbed. You can order a test kit having it delivered by Fed Ex, get it administered by a professional who will protect the chain of evidence, Fed Ex it back and be done. Simple and fast. The complication is by choice. Any man who says “I”m not the dad, I’m not taking a stupid test.” knows it might be his. This kids break out hit was “Baby”. Karma is such a ….
Posted by: Mitchy | November 16, 2011, 9:00 pm 9:00 pm
ok. i think that there is a really good chance that heis the father. justin is not a child! he is a american teenager. and what do most teens do? have sex! im not saying that every teen does it, but lets face it, its america. most children are born to teens. so what makes justin any different? nothing.justin can pick anyone to do it with, and shes probably not the first. just because shes not as atrractive as the celebs dosnt mean he wont choose her for a one night stand. and rape is when someone is having sex with someone else angainst that persons will. do you really think justin would say no to that. and why sue mariah for rape? just because shes the older one dosent mean snything. in most cases youll find the ‘minour’ chose to do it with the ‘adult’.and lieing is so easy everyone does it. youve lied atleast a bunch of times in your life. teens especially lie a lot. shes not crazy just because she stepped up to say justin is her babys father. you are only thinking based off of the fact that you are justins fan or think when it comes to cases invovling a celeb and a normal person, the celeb is always pure and that theother person is lieing and their wrong and should go to jail.dont judge a book by its cover goes a long way, you know. dont judge mariah by wha she looks like and thats she”crazy”. and dont judge justin because hes famous, supposedly pure, and mainly becausehes famous. everyone has adirty little secret in their life,and no on eis perfect. we all make baad choices, and dont think about the consequences. so if its his baby, he needs to admit his mistakes, apolagize to mariah for this mess, and pay the child support. if its not his,then she shouls apolagize to justin and find out who the the father is. but she shouldnt be arrested for either outcome. oh, and i doubt anyof you are better looking than mariah.there post pregnancy pictures andyou shouldnt judge her based on only the pictures. remember, no one is who you think they are. we all hide things from everyone.
Posted by: mjb | November 20, 2011, 3:18 pm 3:18 pm
Just check the birth certificate! Isnt that easy and the drama will be over with!
Posted by: Chloe | November 27, 2011, 11:49 am 11:49 am
Justin Bieber is super awesome!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Posted by: ? | March 20, 2012, 2:02 pm 2:02 pm