Debt Collectors Take Advantage of Intimidated Consumers
With a record number of Americans in debt, consumers are also reporting a record number of abusive phone calls from debt collectors. Many of those harassed, however, are unaware of their rights under the law, according to former debt collector Mike Flannagan. Flannagan, who quit the industry in disgust, said, "The debtors’ ignorance is the best weapon we’ll have in collections." The federal Fair Debt Collections Practice Act protects consumers from harassment and contains specific regulations that debt collectors must follow. For example, under the FDCPA, a debt collector cannot call a consumer at inconvenient times or places and cannot threaten violence or use profane language.
Listen to actual calls and read the transcripts of debt collectors ignoring the rules. (Audio recordings are courtesy of John Fugate) Collectors also cannot threaten consumers that they will be arrested if they do not pay their debt. Collectors cannot report a person’s debt to outside parties. Click Here for Full Blotter Coverage.
Consumers can stop a debt collector from contacting them by sending a cease and desist letter to the collector. Experts say such letters should always be sent by certified mail. After that the debt collector is only allowed to contact a consumer if a specific action, like a lawsuit, is being taken against the consumer. If a consumer disputes whether the debt is even owed, the collection agency can only resume collection activities, including telephone calls, if it provides valid proof that the consumer does actually owe the debt. Consumers have the right to sue debt collectors for damages in state or federal court if they believe the law was violated. Click here for a list of debt collector do’s and don’ts. Ultimately, Michael Flannagan says the best defense against an abusive collector is to secretly tape your phone calls if it is legal to do so in your state. Otherwise, Flannagan says simply telling a collector that you plan to tape the call is often enough to stop the abuse. "If I know that I’m being recorded," said Flannagan, "an intelligent collector will continue the conversation, but with a lot more ‘pleases’ and ‘thank you’s’ and no implied threats." Rozanne Andersen of ACA International, the trade group for the collection industry, says abusive collectors are rare and that most follow the law . According to Anderson, "A debt collector is not the enemy of the consumer. His or her job is to help find a solution and help the person figure out a way to pay the debt." The above picture is an industry photo.
Email




RSS
Twitter
Facebook
I was called and told I’d be sued for fraud by being behind on my credit card bill that legal action was building on me and that if I didn’t pay at least 1/2 of the bill by this date my “butt” (not in those words) would be in court. I had made payments but was still behind, and I was getting calls on my cell phone at 11 pm and sometimes at 4 in the morning!!
Posted by: Scott | January 19, 2007, 6:05 pm 6:05 pm
Where do you think all the bullies from High School went after graduation. The mean ones are in prison and the really mean ones are bill and debt collectors.
Posted by: Mike Jones | January 19, 2007, 6:32 pm 6:32 pm
I think ABC is doing a disservice by not stressing more what consumers can do to STOP the harassment and the calls entirely. First, when they call, tell them that under the Fair Debt Collections Practices Act, you DISPUTE the debt and they are further prohibited from contacting you anymore except as provided by law. Second, you MUST send this same message in writing to the collection agency, to whatever addresses are on their collection letter(s) to you. Send this certified mail, return receipt requested. That way, if they call you or send you letters after the date you know from the receipt that they received your letter, it is evidence for a lawsuit against them. Always try to record the conversations or at least immediately write it down – everything that was said, word for word, if possible. While it’ll be your word against theirs, if you have organized, dated notes with the times of the calls and the name of the person to whom you spoke, it shows much more on your side that you are believable. Finally, try to do this within the first 30 days after receiving the letters or phone calls. They MUST send you a letter in writing, if they only call you they are breaking the law. And YOU MUST reply in writing. If it has gone beyond the 30 days, they can report you to a credit bureau. But if that happens and you follow the above instructions, if you challenge the credit report, they generally cannot verify the debt and it will disappear from your credit report. While they try to claim most follow the law, it is the exact opposite and it is because people do NOT know their own rights. YOU HAVE THE RIGHT TO TELL THEM TO BUZZ OFF, YOU CAN EVEN ABUSE THEM IF YOU WANT. There is no law prohibiting YOU from abusing the collector, only laws preventing them from abusing YOU.
Posted by: Mauro Montoya | January 19, 2007, 7:00 pm 7:00 pm
Somehow our society has made a disappointed turn to “how to beat a debt” in comparison to “how to not be abused by debt collectors”. It is very disconcerting to me the “free” advice that has been plastered on these comments on the internet as a whole. There seems to not be a deliberate assessment of whether one owes the bill or not, merely how to avoid the debt. Debt collection has become a cat and mouse game, which should have never been the objective. As a 15 year veteran of the collection industry, allow me to make some comments.
First, I am a successful, educated, happy person much to the dismay of many of you, I did not pick this career path to “get out my aggressions”. I chose this path because I believe debt collection is a valuable service to our community. Many individuals will never fully comprehend the financial impact that the industry has had on consumers. It has become a necessary part of our culture. One of the reasons consumers pay more for everyday needs are due to the fact that there are those out there not paying at all. Not because they “can’t” because they “choose” not to. There are citizens of our country that truly need help…. their debts should be waived when possible. It is our duty to help those less privileged. It is NOT our duty to help those who choose to pay on luxuries only. Despite your opinions there are several manipulative people in the world in some circumstances. Abuses of any debtor are inconceivable. However, in many cases debtors have become to believe that the mere request to pay a bill is a violation of their rights.
Secondly, never in my 15 years have I heard conversations like the ones in this show. I am not discounting them, some are absolutely awful and those collectors should pick another line of work. However, I know many, many good collectors who work with people and help them budget money to avoid pitfalls. At my office we allow individuals to pay $5.00 a month if that is all their budget will allow, as long as it is consistent. That is all we ask. It is not the cruel world tactics I have read about in these comments. I have had debtors who have become clients over the years. I have had people “bless” me for helping them. I have also had them “damn” me to hell for asking them to take responsibility. I think extreme caution should be taken when you use God to defend accountability. Lastly, in 15 years I can count on my hand the number of truly innocent debtors, true accounting mistakes or client error. Maybe I have good clients, maybe we are cautious in whom we purse……all I know is that the portrayal of innocence that I have read today is somewhat hard to imagine. Just remember, there are a lot of inmates whom claim they are innocent. There are always two sides which is why all conversations should be taped, to weed out the good and bad on BOTH sides. I do want to conclude with stating that it is easy to stop communicating with a collector as many of you have so graciously shared to your fellow consumer.
Posted by: Deborah | January 19, 2007, 8:13 pm 8:13 pm
One problem the article misses is how many of these calls go to the wrong households, and how absolutely impossible it is to stop them. We constantly get calls for people we’ve never heard of, and since we’ve had this number for several years, if this ever was a correct contact number, it’s seriously out of date and the collection people must know how old their contact info is. They keep calling though, and no amount of politely telling them they are calling the wrong number will get rid of most of them. Ninety-five percent will call back over and over again, sometimes several times a day. They refuse to identify themselves (illegal) and sometimes tell all about the debt without any indication they are speaking to the person who supposedly owes it (also illegal). We have an unlisted phone number, so obviously cannot be sending cease-and-desist letters giving them our true name and phone number — that would completely defeat the purpose of being unlisted.
I can’t stand these people, and from the research I did when we first started getting these calls, it’s likely that very few of the “debts” they are pursuing are even legitimate.
I have taken to trying to make them miserable and crazy when they call back, since I have no sympathy for them. I hope others will do the same — the more we waste their time, the higher their costs and the less incentive they have to bother innocent people.
Posted by: Irina | January 19, 2007, 8:44 pm 8:44 pm
bush and the ftc wont enforce the law against these clowns. they allow the companies to act irresponsible in the pushing of credit pay day loans etc then make it impossible for these people to get out by changing the bankruptcy laws. business has a responsibility to not extend credit to unworthy customers so the rest of us end up paying.
Posted by: jack | January 19, 2007, 8:57 pm 8:57 pm
Though I absolutely agree with recording your calls if the debt collector is in fact “out of line”, I do not however, agree with abusing the collectors; obviously if you, yourself, are being abused, there is some sort of retaliation that every person automatically gives out.
I myself have experienced greatness in debt collectors. Some companies actually purchased the “bad” debt from original creditors. They will work with you on payment plans and settlements. You may not have to pay the entire balance, not that you shouldn’t, but because they purchased the debt and own it, they are at liberty to offer you a discounted settlement. Now that’s what I call helping people.
I completely agree with the collection industry (those that follow the laws). Why is it that someone can charge up a credit card or buy a vehicle and not pay for it. Don’t misunderstand me, I know that there are people out there who have in fact been victims of fraud, or have had some sort of life altering issue arise that does keep them from being able to pay their bills. I’m talking about those people who are not under the poverty line, who do have some sort of savings, yet won’t take the collectors calls. They won’t even make small monthly payments in good faith. In today’s world, credit is everything. Some people can’t even get approved for a simple cell phone plan because of their lack of credit.
Posted by: JC | January 19, 2007, 8:58 pm 8:58 pm
I would reward anyone with a self-awarded pat- on-the back for giving those GREEDY,BULLY natured companies/Individuals a dose of their own PIG-HEADED ways of demanding money from “clients” of illegal money collecting practices.
Fingerhut/RIPOFFS actually took me for $100.00 in “late fees” over a balance dispute of 90-some dollar balance.Problem? New Management/took charge over the old contract and decided to collect money that was unethically claimed in their practice. You can sue over unfair/illegal business practices,but prepare for a BIG money lawyer to File unheard of claims against the uneducated victims. BY MY experience..TERRY
Posted by: TERRY Turman | January 19, 2007, 9:04 pm 9:04 pm
This story is so correct. We had almost a BILLION dollars of Collection Accounts and simply walked away.
Now, we are traveling the world teaching Collection Agencies HOW to legally collect and also helping Consumers who are Under attack from illegal collectors. Why do we do this? Because we REALLY CARE!
Thanks ABC News!
Robert Paisola
Posted by: Robert Paisola | January 19, 2007, 9:14 pm 9:14 pm
AFSA- I used to have a student loan from them until I was told that I could refinance through the federal government…when trying to make payment arrangements I had AFSA threaten, challenge and ask for my retirement, my parents retirement, they put me in tears…my mother has cancer, has no insurance and no retirement…how dare them!!!
Posted by: susan carroll | January 19, 2007, 11:04 pm 11:04 pm
These people should have lived with-in their means to begin with. They really do deserve the harassament they receive. Only 20% of debt from these people is ever collected. They increase the price and interest rate all the honost responsible people pay.
Posted by: David Roth | January 19, 2007, 11:23 pm 11:23 pm
Thank you for this story.
I just recieved a harrasment call from a debt collector which I knew they where in the wrong for. I have been trying to pull from memory of 6 years ago what I could do to fight them back. I aprieciate your link to F.T.C. for my rights.
Posted by: julia | January 19, 2007, 11:26 pm 11:26 pm
If anything, I wish that debt collectors could record all the abusive language and profanity spewed at them by ignorant individuals. I understand that these debtors are probably just frustrated by the debt they’ve created for themselves, but they need to deal with the issue like adults.
Posted by: Matthew | January 20, 2007, 12:43 am 12:43 am
What Mr. Montoya said is correct! You should request verification of what you are being told is owed? Who money is owed to? When? How much? and yes you can tell collection agencies to “buzz off!” But what people fail to understand is that the ABC report only showed two sides of the whole Rubik’s Cube. Yes those calls presented were abusive and illegal. Yes, some of those calls were to people that at the end didn’t even owe money. Yes, once a collection agency is told not to call a certain phone number or a job site, they are required to honor that request and do as they are told! What the story failed to present was the side of the collection Industry that actually does the job correctly and not only gets results in the forms of payments and debts being resolved, but also maintains good repor and relationship with their clients. Oh and by the way, a person who owes money is called a debtor. A debtor is not a Client!!!!! Get it straight! The “Client” is the company that that has hired the agency to do the collect and retain the balance that is owed. You, as a debtor and me, as a collector, its not my job or responsibility to inform you of your rights. IT IS my responsibility to know what your rights as a consumer/debtor are and what my boundaries are and how not to break them or abuse them. One more thing, if you owe the bill and you know you owe the bill pay them darn thing, and that friend of a friend that told you that certain bills that are placed on your credit bureau report won’t hurt your credit rating is an idiot! Don’t listen to them and ALL negative marks on your credit report hurt you one way or another. Just a little FYI!
Posted by: Collector I | January 20, 2007, 1:12 am 1:12 am
I have a problem with creditors calling about a person who must have had my phone number before I did. I tell them that I am not this person, but they keep calling me several times a day from 8 a.m. to 9 p.m. When I complain it stops for a month or so, and then starts up again. This has been going on for nearly four years. How can I get this to stop?
Posted by: Chrisitne Riley | January 20, 2007, 1:22 am 1:22 am
long story, sorta short. i recieved a letter from a collection agency from the state of IL. that i owed over $6,400.00 to my X in back child support, i called them and was told i also owed another women over $29,000.00 in back support. first i said i dont know the $29,000.00+ women and i am not behind in support to my X. they said they wanted proof, i said how do i prove i dont know somebody? then they said well what about the other, i told them to do the leg work as i am not behind. i was told that till i sent proof to them it would be on my record(remember im not behind). so my X mailed all the papers. she called a part of the “system” and they varified i was over(paid more) on my support but the fax # she was given was wrong(now how can they have all the info but nobody else?). they gave her the right number to send it to. so i get a call this morning from the collection people…rude and ready for battle, but admit they talked to my X about the whole problem, and still said till they get the info they will keep calling and acting this way. so i call the state of IL., after 30 min. on hold i get a man that really works with me. he has no case of me even oweing my X anything. so after time he figures it out…they have my wrong S.S.# with my name( i have never changed it). he tells me to write a letter and copy my S.S.# card and mail it in to get it straight(like i should prove who i am). then he says i should call back the collection agency (that they hired to come after me) for proof of the women that i owe $29,000.00+ to. when i call them back i am told that it was a mistake and has been fixed(but they could not call me with good news). my point is when i asked the state of IL. to stop the collection harrassment i was told it had to run the course…might be a month or better till it is stopped…so even tho i was treated like i was guilty from the first call…with the proof open, even the state of IL. cant stop them.
Posted by: jeff | January 20, 2007, 2:36 am 2:36 am
I have only one thing to say: in the event of a global catastrophe cockroaches and bill collectors will survive.
I wish I knew this information when I had a bill collector calling me at all hours of the day and when I stopped answering the phone they called my wife’s parents house, told them I was in collections and would they please call me to tell me to answer my phone.
Posted by: Nick I | January 20, 2007, 2:42 am 2:42 am
This is not new! In 1985 my sister called me in tears because a bill collector called her regarding an outstanding student loan. He was very abuse on the phone and told her that she better get a job or start “hooking”. She now has 2 wonderful well behaved boys, is graduating with her degree after a long time of working and going to school in between marriage and work. She also has a specialty license in health care management requiring a certified case management license and has worked as a psyche nurse, a triage nurse, a public health nurse. I still to this day remember her tears at hearing her describe this loser bill collector encouraging someone to engage in illegal activity (ie sexual favors for money) in order to become a legitimate citizen! Kudos to her for being shocked, but at the same time, 23 years ago didn’t know how to handle this kind of bullying and dispicable behavior!
Posted by: Erin | January 20, 2007, 2:59 am 2:59 am
sent the mean debt collector who is breaking the law to the big house. and thank you card’s to the nice one’s who is helping you to get out of debt
Posted by: karl Ahlf | January 20, 2007, 3:04 am 3:04 am
The best thing for anyone to do is educate yourself. A debtors’s ignorance is the collector’s best weapon.
Posted by: Flannagan | January 20, 2007, 3:18 am 3:18 am
Hi, I watched the segmment on tv last night and I just this week did some reseach on the Fair Debt Collection Act, as I had just received two letters in the mail this week regarding two debts that I believe that I don’t owe. I immediately wrote a letter to each collection agency stating I dispute this debt and unless the collection agency was going to sue me that they should stop contacting me regarding this debt. I had also researched the statue of limitations for my state (IL) and found out that for open accounts that time frame was 5 years. This collection accounts were not on my credit report, but noticed that one of them had accessed my crediti report. I had just checked my credit report in May and November 2006. I did send the letters signature confirmation from my local post office, so that I know that they received my letter. Thank you for airing the story last night for consumers such as myself.
Posted by: CB | January 20, 2007, 8:14 am 8:14 am
I don’t get it. If consumers don’t have debts and are called by collection agencies BY MISTAKE, then explain it, document it, etc. But find out WHY your credit history was misattributed to the debt. DO NOT blame the agency hired by a vendor whom the consumer thinks has wrong information. Don’t Kill The Messenger; solve your problem without blaming the wrong person! And, keep breathing; stress kills!
Posted by: bob | January 20, 2007, 8:59 am 8:59 am
Your article on the web does not contain the lawyers names who worked in behalf of the consumer.
Posted by: Jackie | January 20, 2007, 12:18 pm 12:18 pm
I am a bill collector. However the company I work for goes above & beyond the FDCPA. I do not agree with abuse tatics, it doesn’t work and it’s just down right mean. In my office abuse towards debtors is not tolerated, collectors will be fired & every call is recorded. The abuse that you hear on these reports are just a few out of several thousand collectors nationwide. About 4 million dollars in unpaid debts are sent to my office each month. Just my office alone! I can’t speak for every agency when I say this but we do not purchase these debts, our clients don’t get paid until the debtor pays the bill, and all we collect is the money owed to our client, no added fees. Our clients are losing money when they are forced to use a collection agency.
Ok, I guess our clients are not losing money they just increase charges for the consumers that do pay their bills. For anyone that disputes a bill, put it in writing and prove your case! I’m sure you’ll ask, why should you do the work if it’s not even your bill? Because we use your social security number to find you, & if we have your social tied with a bill that’s not yours then more than likely it’s identity theft. Why wouldn’t you want to protect yourself & report this crime?? If you claim to have paid it, computer errors do occur so please show me proof you paid. Correct me if I’m wrong, but that’s why consumers are given reciepts or use your checking account so you have proof of payment. There are several open accounts that can all be zeroed out if the debtor just got the needed paperwork.
But I guess it is easier to just yell into the phone. If you honestly can’t pay the bill, then set up payments! Most collectors will want to work with you on payments verses no money at all. We may ask you several questions that you don’t want to answer, maybe because your worried about being sued..if the specific account allows, we can do that anyway without your answers, it just shows us if you have intent on paying the bill or not. It also shows us if you do have means to pay the balance, this is because a lot of consumers choose to blow their money instead of paying bills. If you honestly need payments, you will get them! Anytime a report airs of this nature, it makes my job more difficult for several weeks. Debtors now believe they are invincible and don’t have to pay their bills.
Posted by: Mary | January 20, 2007, 2:38 pm 2:38 pm
I have been harrassed now for nearly 4 months by debt collectors trying to collect money on my college loans. They started calling me after attemps I made to make payments to them. I have offered to send them a check every month of a reasonable amount that is still with in my current student budget. They are have been unwilling to take any amount if it is not the amount that they are in search of, nearly $400 dollars a months. I told them I am able to send them about half. They refuse my money. How can I pay the debt if they won’t allow it but still they persue it. I have been sending the checks directly to Sallie Mae for the past months and still they ( the bill collectors) keep on. They tell me all kinds of things and have even resorted to calling me names and insulting my intellegence. They asked me if I was a vegetable, if I was able to work. I stopped answering the phone or even trying to call them back because they leave me swearing, and in tears each time. I am just trying to clear it up and it seems that all they are interested in doing is making trouble not collecting a debt or helping me at all. They have called me to ask me why I had sworn at a collector and sometimes I feel like they are holding themselves back from laughter as if it’s a prank phone call and they just want to get a rise out of me. So four months have gone by and as many times as we have talked, NOTHING has been resolved!
I have had the thought to record them. I’ll try it and see how it goes.
Posted by: Elle | January 20, 2007, 5:25 pm 5:25 pm
I remember after i filed bkrupcy they still tried to contact me about the debt. I just discovered they had me down as twice on the credit report so i will have to get them to fix it. It was only one but it makes me out to be bad
Posted by: LDS | January 20, 2007, 11:37 pm 11:37 pm
I did record a very very racial/hate message left on my phone at work, caller I.D. gave us the number and name of the Company where the call came from. I contacted my jobs police department and they took a report. I would like to know how to proceed and find legal help with this type of thing. It has put me on guard wondering what this person may know about me, two days later my ATM was shut down by my bank. I’m nervous but don’t know what to do. My voicemail (use) to say my name and what department and company I work at. I feel like a sitting duck that would make me pretty easy to find. AND IT’S NOT MY DEBT. Anybody have any suggestions.
Posted by: Pam | January 21, 2007, 10:29 am 10:29 am
my personal experience comes from a vindictive and manipulative ex-wife, who after running up thousands in credit card debits 5 years after we divorced had the debt collectors contacting me for payment, not believing that we were no longer together. this was not one agency but 3, each time insinuating that I was a dead beat and that I was lying to avoid “our” debt. Again these credit card debts were in her name only and was created well after our divorce was finalized. Only after sending these idiots a copy of the divorce papers did they tone down the threats and accusations and tried to find the actual debtor, my ex.
Fortunately I can say I don’t both know or care where she is now, but I do wish them luck in finding her.
Posted by: Carl | January 21, 2007, 3:15 pm 3:15 pm
I have been a debt collector for almost two years.
I don’t try and bully people…but people are idiots and lazy.
Besides medical bills…every situation can be avoided.
I get sick of all the excuses…this is a great and competitive country. Quit your crying.
Posted by: Frank | January 21, 2007, 4:56 pm 4:56 pm
One thing you learn by growing up in the middle east is that debts are bad! Yes, every body please repeat after me! Debts are bad! Debts are bad! Debts are bad!
You don’t buy what you cannot afford, and if you are so poor that you cannot afford to provide for the necessities of life, what you do is NOT to load your credit cards.
You join the peace corp, you travel the world for free, and you help other people all over the world who are far worst than you. During the time you do that, food and shelter will be provided for you, and you do this until your mind begins to understand why you should live your life WITHIN your means.
Posted by: Ahmed | January 21, 2007, 5:30 pm 5:30 pm
This is not entirely related, but recently I’ve been receiving calls from a specific debt collector using an automated dialer. They are in violation of several FCC Telecommunications Privacy Act laws by calling my cell phone in such a manner, they leave voice mail in the form of an automated message but do not identify themselves, do not provide an opt out number, and whats more is they block caller ID on the line from their auto-dialer. Their message simply asks me to call them back for an “Important business offer”, which I have not done. I only found out that they were a debt collection agency by doing a web search on the phone number they leave. Whats worse is I have no debts, so whoever they are looking for I am not it. I reported them to the FCC for the 4 telecommunications violations and if the calls do not stop soon I will take legal action against them.
Posted by: Kevin | January 22, 2007, 12:20 am 12:20 am
I’ve been in the Debt Collection business for 15 years – never, at any of the 5 companies I have worked for, is this type of behavior tolerated. That being said, people need to step up and take responsibility for what they do….I have people who say, “I can’t pay that because I’m on disability….” However, THEY WERE ON DISABILITY WHEN THEY OPENED AND RAN UP THE ACCOUNT TO BBEGIN WITH……we live in a society were excuses are supposed to take the place of responsibility. It’s sad – and now that this story has ran, we, a company that does things right -will have thousands of people who are trying to DODGE their obligations use this story as yet another excuse.
Posted by: Bradley Shropshire | January 22, 2007, 9:39 am 9:39 am
I am currently a trainer for large collection corporation. I was very upset with the tactics of the debt collectors you showed. Not all of us are like that. We spend 3 weeks grooming our perspective new hires on the FDCPA and also the proper phone and communication skills. These agencies should be shut down if they continue these practices.
Posted by: Lisa Conley | January 22, 2007, 3:53 pm 3:53 pm
We have a few collectors calling our house for the people that used to live here years ago, though we’ve had our phone number for ten years. We get automated messages that say we are not allowed to listen to them if we are not the person they are calling for, even though they’ve been told they don’t live here.
When my husband lost his job due to layoff 9 years ago, we fell behind. I had a collector all but come right out and say I should abort my unborn child “Maybe you should go ‘take care of that’” since we couldn’t pay a $500. debt. A debt we agreed to pay in full when we recieved our tax return and offered to pay on monthly until then – which wasn’t good enough, she wanted it all NOW or ELSE. Nice huh. I still remember her name and voice to this day.
Posted by: Amy | January 22, 2007, 3:53 pm 3:53 pm
Pay your bills on time and you will not have a problem. If you have circumstances where you will be late, contact the lender and advise them.
Posted by: Bill Boomer | January 22, 2007, 4:58 pm 4:58 pm
I have just recently made a career change to become a collector. Throughout the course of my training, we were educated constantly on the FDCPA (Fair Debt Collection Practices Act). I am honestly in SHOCK that some collectors choose not to follow this, and that their employers turn a blind eye. There are serious monetary fines for both the company and the collector for breaking the laws of the FDCPA. Consumers need to know that they have rights… and that there is legal action to be taken. True, if you have a debt, you have to take responsibility for it, but you should not be made to feel inferior because you have hit hard times or tried to live beyond your means. Most of us have been there – I know I certainly have been, and I have dodged calls from collectors in the past myself. I suppose what I am trying to say to the average person out there is that the majority of collectors play by the rules. Educate yourself on the laws governing fair collecting, and know how to protect yourself from abuse. On the other hand, if you know that you have an outstanding debt, don’t avoid the calls. Like I said, most of us are truly nice people with years of customer service experience who want to offer a solution, not create another problem.
Posted by: Lee | January 22, 2007, 8:37 pm 8:37 pm
Woow……I am just blown away from some of the violations that is recorded on this show. I am a collections manager for a law firm and we go strictly by the book. I have repremended, suspended and fired collectors the FDCPA violations. Most of my day is spend monitoring calls and making sure my collectors are following both company and federal guidelines. So all I can say is it is up to the owner/management to make sure that the agency is following the guidelines of the law and the rules of being a good human being.
Posted by: Peter | January 23, 2007, 1:37 am 1:37 am
All these collectors seem to be under the impression that they can violate the consumer’s rights just because they BELIEVE the consumer owes money. Here’s a news flash for you all. If you can’t prove it, you don’t collect. Simple as that. Try going to court against a savy consumer and show up with a printout from your computer saying I owe you money. It won’t fly. The ONLY time you can win a suit is when you serve the consumer at a known old address and get a default judgment.
Posted by: pryan67 | January 23, 2007, 5:20 pm 5:20 pm
Approximately 6 months ago, I received a threatening letter from a collection agency with a toll free number to call. I called the number to find out it was for a debt owed to a health center in St Louis, which I probably live 70 miles from. The debtor had the same first and last name as mine with no middle initial. After speaking with the rep, and asking questions, I discovered there was not even a SSN associated with the name. It appears they just grabbed a handfull of people with the same first and last name as mine in hopes of finding the right person. The rep apologized for the confusion and let me go.
I had a similar incident 15 years ago when I purchsed a bedroom suit on a 6 months same as cash promotion. I had the money to pay for it, but thought what the heck. When I filled out the credit paperwork, took delivery of the furniture and paid for it before the money was due less than 6 months later. A couple of months later I received a call from a collector demanding I pay for the bedroom suit, or he would damage my credit. Well…………he pushed my button and I educated him and informed him that if he does damage my credit, I would personally see that he ends up standing in a soup line. I contacted the company I bought the furniture from, who verified I had paid them. They also said they would investigate. Come to find out; when I paid for the furniture, the credit was placed to another account. Folks…..for your information, the creditor was ITT Financial (put that in your memory banks). A few months later, I received an offer in the mail from ITT Financial for a loan. I called the toll free number on the offer and informed them I was not interested and why. I also advised the rep to escalate it to management.
Posted by: Dave | January 23, 2007, 11:32 pm 11:32 pm
After seeing the show, looking over the online article, and reading the previous posts, I realize there are some very strong feelings on all sides of this issue. There are so many people (debtors AND collectors) with very negative remarks, and I have no doubt many of the stories are factual and reliable. But when we read these posts maybe we should consider many of them represent the extremes. People who’ve not had serious problems with these issues seldom take the time to post replies, so we are missing a vast number of stories about good collectors and good debtors. There are good people and there are bad people in all types of jobs and situations. There are collectors who break the laws and abuse those they call; and there are debtors who misuse credit with no intention of paying the bills they owe. Has this country gotten so bad, though, that we can not truly believe the majority of people are not out to hurt, cheat and abuse? Not all collectors are trying to emotionally and mentally abuse you with threats, innuendos and repulsive actions. There are plenty who are just doing their job, offering those behind in their bills a way to resolve an issue that helps all concerned, and providing a valuable service in the business world. Just as not all debtors are deadbeats who are trying to get by without paying. Emergencies and unexpected events happen all the time and can throw honest, hard-working people into a temporary, but none-the-less difficult, situation where they are not able to meet their bills in full. With the changes in our economy and the further division of our classes, debt in our society is becoming more and more of a concern. It doesn’t take much nowadays for a family who has always been fiscally responsible to find themselves suddenly in a financial disaster.
It is not my intention to sound like I’m “above” all this because I’m not. I’ve had my previous experiences with bad and good collectors; and the fear, anger, and uncertainty of dealing with all that. Some of the collection attempts were not valid, but others were. Currently I’m in the process of building up a good credit record after having my previous credit report ruined for many years. This came about for two reasons. One reason was a rough divorce from years ago and an ex that did not pay the portion of bills he agreed, and court ordered, to pay. The other reason is because I did not pay all of the bills I had agreed, and court, ordered to pay. After the divorce, I went through the proverbial financial problems. A single mom of three children, child support not being paid, the loss of a second income (the hubby) and low wages were some of the challenges I had to face. But I used those as an excuse for not paying my debts when the real truth is I continued using some of the money I made to pay for the lifestyle I’d gotten used to when having credit and a husband’s income besides mine. Don’t get me wrong. My kids were always well cared for but any “extra” money I had was spent on “stuff” instead of paying my debts. That was immature and irresponsible on my part and as a result my credit was completely destroyed. It has taken years to gradually repair the damage done, going without and working hard so I could pay the debts I owed. My mistakes also affected my kids because they spent years being teased and ridiculed for being “poor.” They always had food to eat, clothes to wear and medical needs met, but “extras” and frivolous things were seldom an option because we made sure the bills got paid first. Now that my kids are grown I’ve discovered this was a blessing in disguise because they understand and appreciate money and understand how credit can be a double-edged sword. I also learned some tough lessons during that time. First, many people are spoiled and feel they are entitled to have everything they want “right now” so they go into debt to have those things. That was how I used to feel. Now I know there are NEEDS and there are WANTS and we need to learn to distinguish between the two. I also learned credit is a very important and worthwhile thing. A previous post stated, “Besides medical bills…every situation can be avoided.” Well I guess on paper that might be true but in a real world that is hogwash. After all, most Americans would not be able to own a home, auto, or business without using credit. But credit needs to be used wisely and responsibly.
I will climb down off my soapbox now, but please let me finish by saying…
If we spent as much time trying to come up with workable and honorable solutions to our problems as we do finding faults and badmouthing others, maybe some of the animosity and anger could be avoided.
Thanks for taking the time to read this and I wish the best to all of you.
Posted by: RW | January 24, 2007, 1:32 am 1:32 am
I have seen both sides of the collection agency. I belong to a 12-step program called Debtors Anonymous to help people learn to pay off their debts, to take responsibility, and to learn to live within their means.
I have certainly had some past due bills, and am working to get everything cleared up. With loss of income due to employers and changing job markets, though I have not been unemployed my income has dropped considerably – about 30% – but the expenses have not.
However, DA will give someone who is willing to use the tools the help they need to get out of debt and stay out of debt.
Lately I have had several calls from several collection agencies. They correctly identify themselves, and then ask someone to call them back – at certain person at a certain number at a certain company. However, the person they are asking for is not at this phone number (it is my cell number), and I have had it for 5+ years. The gentleman that I spoke with told me that obviously these people had given them a false phone number – which is very difficult to get, because I don’t give it to anyone (it is, however, a very easy number to remember, so maybe they made it up) – and I hope I do not receive any more phone calls from this company. However, they were most courteous (as many have not been in the past), and said I would not hear from them again, as they have made the appropriate notifications on their bill. It made me angry that someone would knowingly give them false information.
Posted by: mja | January 24, 2007, 9:39 am 9:39 am
Bill B.-
Not every creditor is willing to work with you. This was the one that was just not interested. They wanted the money now, all of it and the collection agency they used represented that well. She was the only one we had such a problem with.
“Pay your bills on time.” Now why didn’t I think of that? If only it were so easy. That was the year we went from making 26,000 one year to supporting a family of four, with two children under two, on 11,000 the next. We did not join the welfare rolls nor file for bancrupcy, we struggled everyday. Do you know how hard it is to get hired when you’re seven months pregnant? Hah! Sometimes getting out of the finicial hole you’re in means aquiring more education, which takes time.When you’re barely bringing in enough money to feed yourself and keep a roof over your head working 16 hours a day then what do you do?
We now have our own home and a clean credit record and earned it and there’s an education to fall back on. Circumstances can put anyone in a world of fiscal pain. Look at what Katrina did. Millions of Americans live paycheck to paycheck, even the very well paid ones.
Posted by: Amy | January 24, 2007, 12:03 pm 12:03 pm
Let me give you first hand information on the collection industry. I worked for many years a consumer collector of credit cards, mostly first and second placements. I took the job because the company I worked for went out of business and I was getting married in two months (I do not work in that field any more, thank G*D).
The agency I worked for was one of the largest in NJ employing roughly 200 full time employees. When I first started I and three other people were given copies of the FDCPA and had to watch several movies then we were asked questions on what we saw and read. The next day we went to the training room and the floor supervisor and the company manger came in and made us sign a piece of paper stating we would follow the law etc etc. After that we were flat out told if you want to make any money here you do what you have to do but remember we wont protect you if you break the law. I remember sitting there thinking this is a joke right.
One of the people I was training with told me the same thing went on at two other agencies he worked at. That they encourage you to break the law because that’s the only way to get the debtors to pay and the fines are so small it doesn’t really matter, plus all collectors are expendable (we had a 20% turn around every month). Once that was done I was given a fake name (yes every collector you speak with is using a fake name) a cubicle, phone and a computer loaded with accounts to call on, I could run Credit reports on these people when ever I wanted. Yes collecting money on delinquent accounts does aid the economy and is a tool that needs to be done. With that said the people doing the collecting, can get away with just about anything because the majority of people in collections don’t know their rights.
Posted by: jeff | January 24, 2007, 1:06 pm 1:06 pm
this is the continuation of above
I would stress to every one I spoke with to get a copy of the FDCPA (of course my boss’s didn’t like that but hey I needed my job and was a top collector). If people would just educate them selves a little bit the industry would have to change. Also the collectors on this site saying that the majority in their field are law abiding are lying to them selves, it’s more like 20% follow the law and 80% do what they want to. Ask yourself this question if you have an unpublished number and they get it, or they call you on your cell phone how are they getting it.
Ill let you in on a secret of how, if you have cable TV / Satellite, they call the provider pretending they are you and say I was left several massages from your company. Then when the cable company says what number are you calling from the collector will ask them what number do you have. 9 out of 10 times they just give you the number. This also works with electric companies, water co, gas etc.
They will call neighbors looking for your number stating they are an international operator with an urgent call, when the neighbor says leave me the message they say unfortunately because of the nature of the call I can only leave it for them, well your neighbor some nice old woman gives out your number. As you can see they will do anything to get your number. Please make sure to call people who have your number not to give it out no matter what, this is for companies, work, friends and family.
Posted by: jeff | January 24, 2007, 1:51 pm 1:51 pm
Again continued from above (sorry)
would also say to any one in deep collections get rid of you home phone and go to a pay as you go cell phone. Another thing make sure who ever calls you to get it in writing and ask for the original bill, if it’s a credit card you want to see the charges including signatures. Credit card companies have all the records readily available. Get the persons name, the company they are calling from and if possible record your call with them. Don’t get mad at them just tell them when you see the bill, you will call them back (though they will keep calling). Also if they are calling often and they are belligerent (most are) with you, again don’t get mad, since most of them thrive on it, write a letter to them not to call you , send it return receipt proving they got it. If the calls keep happening send a letter to your states Attorney Generals office cc the agency again send it return receipt. Also do not fall for it when they say they are going to send the sheriff to arrest you it’s a lie, we do not have debtor prisons, also if you don’t own a home its very unlikely they will try and sue you or garnish your salary, your debt will just go back in a pool and on to the next agency.
If you don’t owe the bill and the CA is trying to collect it get you credit report and make sure it’s not on there, then find the original creditor and deal with them. One of the biggest scams are collectors calling on debts that are paid off but not removed from your credit report. If this does not work, get an attorney and go after the agency. Also if you have settled on a debit for less then full amount make sure the agency sends a letter stating that the debt is satisfied, this way it cant end up in some other CA and they are demanding payment for it. Also make sure you get letters when you pay off your bills.
Just remember, record all calls they make to you, if you have the money pay the bill, and get proof of the debt.
Posted by: jeff | January 24, 2007, 3:41 pm 3:41 pm
Boring show. Calls were probably faked by actors.
Posted by: Bob | January 24, 2007, 10:28 pm 10:28 pm
Am I missing something?
Why did you not just hang up?
Duh!
Posted by: Cindy | January 24, 2007, 10:29 pm 10:29 pm
Since this report came out one of my creditors actitud changed I was late on my car payment for 10 days I was reciving 5 to 7 calls daily and usually kind of rude. No one investigated creditors actitud before some times any one can be late on payments for many reasons – Creditors just do your job PROFESSIONAL and monitor all the calls get rid of all unethical personnel try to find some solutions I am sure you will get more people to pay-
it works!
Posted by: Nena | January 25, 2007, 10:40 am 10:40 am
Cindy:
They call right back and the abuse continues.
Save your “duhs” for someone who deserves it.
Posted by: Heather | January 26, 2007, 12:26 pm 12:26 pm
My experience with debt collectors is rather mixed. We had 5-credit cards that we could not continue paying on (thanks to newborn and medical/ auto expenditures within the same year). We opted to try to continue to pay on those cards but a smaller amount and went with a third party Credit Negotiator (youve seen the adds) who stated they could cut the amounts in half if not more.
One of the things they keep quiet about is that they only negotiate with bill collectors not the Card companies themselves so they request that you don’t make any payments till the collectors call. We were told once they started that it could get ugly -which it did at times. We were also informed to jot down and keep track of what time, where they called (work/home), and any statements made. After a While we had a notebook full.
Needless to say, we were told repeatedly by the collectors that they did not deal with 3rd. party or Negotiating firm and they only dealt with us. The calls continued, got nastier and the frustration grew.
Posted by: Ed | January 26, 2007, 1:22 pm 1:22 pm
Read all these whining comments from deadbeats who take out loans with no intention of repaying them, then trying to blame debt collectors for the end result of calculated thievery. What do you expect? Stop whining. If you deadbeats would pay your bills you wouldn’t be getting calls from collectors. But that would require you to accept responsibility for your actions and do the right thing, wouldnt it? You are incapable of doing the right thing because your parents never whipped your butts and made you do the right thing, right? So now you can blame your parents too, eh? Blame everybody but yourselves. It has become the American way.
Posted by: Fred | January 27, 2007, 8:37 am 8:37 am
Fred, my what big assumptions you have with your blanket statements. If you’re looking for calculated thievery, look to your government.
Posted by: Amy | January 27, 2007, 7:55 pm 7:55 pm
For truly unlawful and illegal collection tactics no company or business can rival State courts and officials. I recently sent the following communication to some of these “fine” State officials.
I wanted to make sure I
wrote your office,certainly it does not matter whether
“Phil” sees his shadow in PA,because the shadow of
wrongful & unlawful acts by your CSRU & will never eclipse.
I have included a narrative documenting the world as
you & your forces would like to see it,in your continuing campaign against America’s Fathers.
I have just read that a State is considering curfews
for men concerning the child support issue. The
tactics of the “State” have all been accomplished
before as referenced in the following excerpts of
articles and information:
Ref 1: “Canceled citizenship and instituted the
restrictions that forbid them to work for the government,to be bankers,teachers and students and the number to work in professions was limited.”
Ref 2: “Took prisoners,confiscated property and imposed heavy financial punishments…and on the rest were cast economic restrictions.”
Ref 3: “The… laws deprived them of their rights of
citizenship,giving them the status of subjects.”
Ref 4: The leader “became an official tasked with
infiltrating and reporting to his superiors on their
activities.”
Ref 5: The leader wrote a book,denouncing the ‘the
enemies of the State’ as “parasites and laying the
foundation for conquest.” Through the use of propaganda the ‘State’ became immensely popular with
the people.
Ref 6: They used their propaganda machine not only to
‘acquire acquiescence but to convince citizens of
their purity” and demonize the targeted group.
Ref 7: “Through a series of show trials,the defendants
were sentenced.” Often using extreme tactics to
extract confessions and agreeing on lenient sentences
for a confession on false charges in the court,the
court would turn on their word and exact the most
severe level of punishment.
Ref 8: The enemies of the State were “forbidden to
operate retail stores,mail order houses,or sales
agencies,or to practice a craft.” “They cannot offer
for sale goods or services,to advertise these or to
accept orders at markets,fairs or exhibitions of all
sorts.”
Ref 9: “They were forbidden to ride streetcars,go to
the theater,play sports,go to parks,practice
medicine,law or farming,and can only walk on certain
streets.” They were forbidden to leave their homes
except for a few hours each day.
They were forced to deposit all their money in
banks,then forbidden to taker the money out. The money
was confiscated by the State.” “Telephones were taken
away,and eventually,they could not have pets,attend
school of any kind,and had to give up extra
clothing.”
Ref 10: “The life,the survival against the odds,the
fixed viewpoint…the terror,that tightening noose,and
the endless mounting chicanery of the State.” He was
there day in,and day out with unwavering determination
against the evil of the State.
Ref 11: In the early seventies I visited a museum in Claremore,OK. The museum contained a lamp which had a lamp shade made from the skin of an American solider
by the nazis.
The nazis tanned the soldiers skin and hide to make a lampshade and other items. I am sure these tactics would be very popular at CSRU. If a person died & owed
child support you could get a court order for the body
and make products from the corpse of the debtor. I am
sure your offices could come up with a clever State
marketing scheme for such products.
These measures were indeed tried by governments in the
past. The irony is that these are the same procedural
tactics used by the ‘State’ against Fathers in this
country. I am certain there are many State officials
who think these things would be just fine.
The above references originate from the following
sources which I am sure are the guideline for all
workers of the S.S.(Social Services)
REF 1 & 2: Vichy law, Nazi Germany
REF 3: Nuremberg Race Laws,Germany,1935
REF 4-7: Hitler & Stalin in review
REF 8-10: Source: FAQfarm,Life in Nazi Germany
REF 11: Source: Museum,Claremore,OK
Posted by: Joe | February 3, 2007, 10:19 am 10:19 am
You know, sometimes extinuating circumstances come along and throw you a curve ball…
From personal experience – I had perfect credit. I had paid off over 80,000.00 in unsecured credit and was continuing to do so when something unexpected happened… my sister in law lost her son to the state and I stepped in to take guardianship over him.
He was troubled and special-needs, so I shortly had to quit my job to take care of him. I continued to pay, although struggling, and soon after – had a 3rd back surgery – making me permanently disabled.
I had credit protection on ALL of my cards… an insurance that was to pay the bills should I be unable to. I enacted these “insurance services” and one of the companies conveniently uses an outside agency to handle it. THEY NEVER PAID IT! Now, 5 YEARS LATER, they CONTINUE to call and harrass me relentlessly. I have NO ss payments, NO welfare and my husband – a Police Officer – stuggles to pay for a family of 4 to survive.
So… sometimes, it isn’t that we are “low-lives” or “worthless” or “living beyond our means” ad leaving our bills to be paid by you… Sometimes, life throws you a curve ball and unscrupulous credit card companies take money for protection they don’t intend to extend to you.
They need to be stopped.
Posted by: TRISHA | February 22, 2007, 12:19 pm 12:19 pm
My husband and I are normal working class people who have fallen behind on our credit card payments due to a few unforeseen reasons.We have made every effort to make payment arrangements but the credit card company tells us it’s all or nothing.They will not accept anything less than what they decide the payment should be. Usually these amounts are astronomical.I acknowledge our responsiblity to pay the debt owed but I don;t have the resources to pay them what they want. Is it an “urban myth” that you can make good faith payments?
If not,where do I find where it is written that I can say “I can only afford…..” and they have to accept it.
Just this morning I was told by a debt collector that I should stop paying my mortage and pay him. He also said I had 24 hours to come up with 7,000.00 or they “might” take my house. I have read all of the Fair Debt Collection Law,and yes this is harrassment but at this point it is mute. I just want to be able to have them agree to take a certain amount each month out of my checking account. They continue to refuse,saying that they don’t trust me.
I wonder how many suicides are caused by people being oevrwhelmed by debt collectors who push them to the edge.
Posted by: Tracie | February 23, 2007, 10:14 am 10:14 am
I have been getting harassing phone calls from a company asking for a girl named Stephanie. I keep telling them they have the wrong number and they keep calling 3-4 times a day from 8 am to 9 pm at night! I have never purchased anything from them and they just wont stop calling. its always a different person I talk to, dont they keep notes on this stuff in their computers??? Is there anything I can do to stop this with out having to change my telephone number?
Posted by: Nancy B | July 4, 2007, 10:25 am 10:25 am
I can relate to the story of debt collectors. I agree that one should pay their debts. However, I don’t tollerate any of their nasty behavior. I am quick to turn them in to the Better Business Bureau, FTC, the Attorney General or any factions that deal with these clowns. Yes, clowns! Not all debt collectors are bad and they are trying to earn a living too. There is never an excuse for acting nasty. “Be not deceived; God is not mocked: for whatsoever a man soweth, that shall he also reap.”(Galatians 6:7). Why do I quote the Word of God, because many don’t realize why their personal lives are so jacked up! So if you act nasty, then that same spirit will be returned to you sevenfold.
Posted by: Jenny M | July 7, 2007, 12:13 am 12:13 am
Get a hold of the District Attorney in your state.. Let them know what is going on with the debt collector is doing. Then the BBB. You have the right to complain bout the way they work. I have been through it so many times that I know how to work them back. even though they try to threatn me with jail time. lmao I love to see them try that one. These debt collector what you to think you know nothing bout the law. I am sooo dang glad that this was on.. Its nice to know that I am not the only one out there.
Posted by: Kris | July 7, 2007, 12:15 am 12:15 am
my situation is that I;am currantly in a credit counseling and pay this company a certain amount of money each month to pay off our debt I now have this collections company calling me and telling me there have been no payments made on this account I explain the situation an told them they needed to speak with ccc and that they deal with the orginal creditor HSBC in this case they told me that was my promblem and I proceeded to call CCC and explain this call and also called HSBC after I listen to her tell me that they sold this debt in May 07 I was with CCC april 30 07 and that I needed to call this company she did say they had gotten a payment in May , June for 25.00 I do believe proposl are sent to each of these creditors agreeing to payment amounts now I have leading Edge recovery calling me telling me they dont work with CCC and the payments are to small ,I called all my crediters after I lost my job last year and explain my family situation I sent letters to everyone stating this issue I even went as far as to tell them not to call me to call CCC now they have a Lawyer messaged recording being left on my phone, And Im trying to make good and Im still being harrassed.
Posted by: Rhonda | July 7, 2007, 6:41 pm 6:41 pm
What about companies that are in multiple illegal situations? In my case, I’m dealing with a private company who is not associated with the BBB and has their own collections dept. My situation is one bill–I’m not what most people would call “in debt”. I simply refused to pay said bill due to the fact that their equipment failed and then I discovered that I was dealing with a company that scams people with fraudulent contracts with illegal terms.
But that doesn’t stop them from calling me up to 20 times a day. When I specifically asked them to stop, I was told (in these exact words), “No. We will not stop calling you. You will have to get a new number in order for that to happen–but even then, we’ll find you. We’ll get your new number and keep calling you.” This was said after numerous times of representatives hanging up on me (simply because I asked them to stop interrupting me while I explained why I wasn’t paying), they have inadvertently threatened me claiming legal action (but they do nothing but call because they know they have no leg to stand on legally w/ their “case”). I have reported this company to the BBB (they will mediate with companies that are not associated with them), the FCC for their behavior and their “abandoned calls” (automated dialing that hangs up on the consumer), and New York’s Attorney General–because it turns out that HUNDREDS of people in this country are suffering the same abuse from this same company in both the fraudulent contract and their abusive calls. And other states’ attorney generals are filing class action suits.
I have told them that their behavior is harassment to which they snicker and raise their voice a few notches for the rest of their conversation. What is my resolution when I find out this company isn’t covered under the FDCPA’s regulations? They certainly don’t seem to care about anything other than harassing me. Much less their jobs. The company is altogether sketchy. There doesn’t appear to be a manager or supervisor of any kind that works there, because I’m never able to talk to him/her. And by the way, as far as the advice about your state attorney general–their office told me there must be many more complaints from other state residents about a certain company before they’d investigate it. I found the others’ complaints online; and it was there I was told to contact the company’s state’s Att. Gen. I hope to those out there that are being harassed that this editorial has educated you to your rights, and to the collectors that choose to follow the rules and are upset at ABC’s show–just know an ounce of negative news interests a lot more than a ton of positive–so it wasn’t personal. And to those collectors who don’t follow the rules, good luck on the lawsuits that may be coming your way.
Posted by: rob | July 7, 2007, 8:18 pm 8:18 pm
I work in the collections industry and I was very disappointed by the story because it only portrayed collectors in a negative context. The organization for which I work requires participation in an extensive 3 wk training program which covers the Fair Credit Practices within the 50 states and surrounding territories; before we make calls. Our training is an ongoing process throughout out tenure. We are told that our job is to help the debtor to work out the best possible arrangements. We DO NOT THREATEN DEBTORS for payments! It’s not neccesary and, we face immediate termination for unprofessional behavior. On the other hand, it is difficult to do our job when we call a debtor and they assume that we will be rude. The collectors profiled in your story make it difficult for the many professional collectors who provide good customer service.
Posted by: Angela | July 18, 2007, 8:37 am 8:37 am
Funny how most of the people who are collectors that are posting a message here are trying to be just as intimidating and arrogant as they would be if they were calling your homes and jobs and cell phones, etc… I really feel sorry for people who do this as a JOB. Get a life.
Posted by: danielle | August 14, 2007, 3:28 pm 3:28 pm
Is there such a thing as a “good faith payment”? I purchased a car, kept up payments for 4 yrs, never late, and car was totalled. The payoff didn’t cover the loan on the car. The bank that financed car wouldn’t finance me again and I had to go to another finance co. to get another car. I had to have transportation for work. I got behind in my bills and had $25.00 taken out of my checking account every month to the finance co. I was getting calls 8 -12 times daily from this co. I finally spoke with a supervisor, which he was rude and told me that wasn’t acceptable, they wanted their money. They were also charging me late fees and fees for not paying the full amount. I had a bill collector call me tonite and tell me they were going to sue me for fraud. I don’t have anyone to borry money from, Do they have to accept this payment or am I just going to be sued?
Posted by: judy | September 6, 2007, 9:01 pm 9:01 pm
Not all debt is from being an irresponsible person. To say these debtors deserve the harassment is sick!
I have no credit card bills, no car payments, etc….in other words no extravagant living above my means debt.
I have medical bill debts from having no insurance or welfare to help pay for it. I can’t make payments to each collector, I would have no money for food left.
They call 12 times a day, 7 days a week. I suppose I just have to learn to ignore it until I can pay.
Posted by: Amanda | November 11, 2007, 1:27 pm 1:27 pm
My daughter (21) has some debt run up by a manipulating ex-con boyfriend. Debt collectors have been calling me incessantly asking for her. I explained that she has not lived with me for 2 years, and have given them the only phone numbers and addresses I have ever had for her. They continue to call me still asking to talk to her, saying that the phone number is ‘fraudulent’. This is the phone number she calls me from and I call her–not a ‘fraudulent’ number. I’ve even tried the approch of saying that I have no idea who they are looking for. The most recent call, they told me that they KNOW she lives here, and they also had information that included the FIRST AND MIDDLE NAMES of my other children (one a minor). They don’t imply that I owe them money, but they call several times a day (thank God I work days and often don’t have to talk to them–just phone messages) asking to talk to my daughter. They will not disclose the name or address of their organization to me ‘because of privacy issues’ so I cannot send them a certified letter to stop their calls. They have told me that I can be arrested for ‘obstruction of justice’–total BS, I know that. WHAT CAN I DO TO STOP THEM? I cannot afford a lawyer right now, but if I can’t get their name or address that wouldn’t help me anyway.
Posted by: Terry | March 20, 2008, 4:25 pm 4:25 pm
As a former legal debt collector for a large collection agency, I can not stress enough that the company I worked for tried very hard to abide by the law and ensure collectors were not violating laws. Were all employees perfect all the time? No but most were day in and day out because they had to. Collection agencies do not want to get sued for violations or have a suit dismissed for improper conduct – trust me.
I encourage citizens to understand not only their rights but debt collectors rights as well because otherwise what you “think you know” may be wrong. I can not count the number of times debtors would accuse me of harassment simply for calling them to inform them of their debt and that we were suing them and that I could help them work out a settlement and have the suit dismissed. Obviously that is not harassment but in their mind it was and instead of telling me not to contact them anymore, which I would abide by, they would say I was harassing and hang up. That did the debtor no good because then it was permittable to continue to contact them.
Bottom line is try to take responsibility for your debt and don’t get mad at a debt collector who is doing their job and trying to get the debt paid off. If you honestly can not or chose not to pay and you request to have communication ceased then the agency must do so; however understand the debt will not go away and you may suffer legal ramifications, poor credit rating, etc.
It’s a very difficult economy right now and most collection agencies understand this and will try to work with debtors who legitimately and consistently make efforts to pay off their debt so keep that in mind. Doing something is better than nothing.
Posted by: Jennifer | April 4, 2008, 5:05 pm 5:05 pm
Just came off the phone to someone calling for my husband. she sounded really sinister and kept asking if he was there when I said he was at work.
She had the CHEEK to ask me if I was disguising my voice. I am appalled.I asked her what she was calling about and she got funny repeating her name so I said well what company do you work for?.She told me. I am so angry at how she spoke to me,I am stay at home mom and I have no financial income and my hubby deals with it all.NOw I have to unplug home phone as my hubby can not afford caller ID any more. This economy is so bad my hubby works long hours and after we pay rent utilty we have very little left.The days before payday my fridge and freezer are bare.WE do not drink or smoke or go out. so no one can say we are living out of our means. The clothes I have worn this year are my friend’s worn cast offs.
Sorry to moan but the lady was so rude it upset me as I have no control over the situation.
Posted by: carly | September 25, 2008, 9:51 am 9:51 am
I had previously ordered some Oreck XL products, but what I ran in2 $$$ trouble, I had 2 try 2 reduce my debts by returning Oreck’s products. this was the right thing, because I was getting in over my head. needless 2 say, HSBC Retail Services keeps sending me a bill 4 the costs/L8 fees of the products I no longer have, & I have PROOF that I DID indeed return the stuff. I no longer owe this company, & surely there must B some 1 out there who can help in this situation, as I’m on fixt income.
Posted by: anonymous | October 12, 2008, 1:22 am 1:22 am
It is an awesome post with deep insight of the issue.
=====================================
Jacob
Posted by: debt consolidation | October 15, 2009, 5:05 am 5:05 am