Apr 11, 2007 10:45am

A Couch Don Imus Should Avoid

While all of America may be talking about  the slurs of radio shock jock Don Imus, Canada is dealing with its own outrageous race scandal.  But unlike Imus, no one’s taken responsibility for the Canadian fiasco, which introduced a young girl to the "N" word that she had been lucky enough never to have heard before. ABC News spoke to Doris  and Douglas Moore of Toronto about what happened when they purchased a set of dark brown couches for $1300 and were told the couches were high-quality imports from Italy. But when they arrived, her 7-year-old daughter made a startling discovery. On the shipping label, next to "color," it read: Ni**er-Brown. Doris Moore says she was in the kitchen when her daughter called out, "Mommy, what’s ni**er brown?"  Doris, who is originally from Ghana, says she didn’t believe her daughter at first and went to look at the label herself to confirm. When her daughter asked her the meaning of the word again, she was forced to explain a painful word that she had hoped to shield her daughter from as long as possible.  She says her daughter "had never heard the word before. Never," not even in schoolyard taunts. Click Here for Full Blotter Coverage. So far, no one has wanted to take responsibility for the slur.   Moore immediately called the furniture store,  Vanaik, from where she and her husband purchased the couches, but received no response. So she contacted a local television station, Toronto’s City News,  who tracked down the store manager. He told a reporter from the station he was sorry for the label but blamed the supplier, Paul Kumar of Toronto-based Cosmos Furniture, who also ships furniture to the United States. In media reports, Kumar said that the label was placed by the manufacturer, located in China, not Italy.  Kumar told ABC News that he spoke to the manufacturer and that the mistake was made "out of innocence."  The slur was a translation problem with the labeling software, he said, but he declined to name the software used. He also said he didn’t know how many other pieces of furniture his company may have sold with the racial epithet on the label. Doris Moore has filed a formal complaint with the Ontario Human Rights Commission and the family is considering suing both the store and the supplier. If the OHRC finds the stores guilty of violating the Moore’s civil rights, they could face fines.  Doris Moore says that despite the public apologies, neither the store owner or the supplier have contacted them to offer a refund or even a personal apology, something her husband, Douglass finds completely unacceptable. "People have to be made accountable for this," he says.  He sees a parallel in his family’s situation and the fallout from the Don Imus racial controversy here in the U.S. "In this day in age, when is this going to end?" he asks. "It’s 2007."

User Comments

I’d be willing to bet that “slur” was put there by Ms. Brown herself.

Posted by: arlan | April 11, 2007, 12:23 pm 12:23 pm

I too have a bi-racial (black and native american) adopted 8 yr old daughter and definately feel for this family. We live in a small Northern Ontario town which is predominately white (as am I) and “isms” of all kinds are alive and well here. What breaks my heart is that her generation should never have to hear that word or worry about the color of their skin but here we are. As her father said its 2007.

Posted by: Duana Bos | April 11, 2007, 12:36 pm 12:36 pm

I demand AL SHARPTON GET ON THE COUCH
He is a bigger racist then Kramer, Mel Gibson, and Don Imus all put together.
The whole world knows it, but the MSM denies it.
I WILL NOT ACCEPT his fake sense of morality, and neither should any other free-thinking american.
His racism is chains. He enslaves his own community through hatred, fear, and veiled threats.

Posted by: JelloBiafra | April 11, 2007, 12:42 pm 12:42 pm

It’s more amazing that this young girl never heard the “n” word before via rap music or in a random street conversation among other black youths. There are those that consider this word completely taboo in some contexts and allowable in others.
Here is an instance where it likely cannot even be proved who left this comment or why and these people are looking for some sort of personal apology, refund, gain, etc…. If I got a pair of shoes that arrived with the label “honky white,” I doubt a) that I’d really care, b) get any help finding the source and c) obtaining some kind of recourse.
If someone is genuinely oppressed via racism, we should fight with all our might against it. A single word on a couch label that may or may not be intentional, that doesn’t have any real consequence? Let’s move on, people.

Posted by: Tighe | April 11, 2007, 12:48 pm 12:48 pm

Having worked in China as an English teacher, we had a list of hilarious translations made by either translation software or incompetent Chinese/English translators. This was not a deliberate attempt to pick on people of colour. Let it go already.

Posted by: Justin Kase | April 11, 2007, 12:56 pm 12:56 pm

I think this article is going to cause the next big scandal. I hope the authoer is ready to apologzie to the millions of Canadians offended by the first sentence. “All of America…” is concerned by the Imus Scandal. Canada, on the other hand has its own issue…

Posted by: Mark | April 11, 2007, 12:58 pm 12:58 pm

HAHAHAHAHAHAHA

Posted by: T | April 11, 2007, 1:02 pm 1:02 pm

I am a 30 year old African American women with very high standards. I can understand why people may get mad over the talk show host comments because they were directed directly to that group of young ladies. But why should any African American get mad over the word.

Posted by: torian scott | April 11, 2007, 1:03 pm 1:03 pm

Why is she going to sue. For what, pain and suffering? So take the couch back but this wasn’t targeted at her. It was a translation error.

Posted by: amanda | April 11, 2007, 1:08 pm 1:08 pm

Why would the Daughter even question the word if she had never heard it before. GET OVER IT!
We all have to walk around scared to be sued over anything and everything.
The American dream (now)is someone will make a MISTAKE so that we can sue them and be rich or get something for free. ITS HORRIABLE

Posted by: Wendy | April 11, 2007, 1:10 pm 1:10 pm

Wow. Very non-pc. BUT, a free sofa out of the deal? Come on! What does getting offended have to do with getting a $1300 couch for $0.

Posted by: jason | April 11, 2007, 1:14 pm 1:14 pm

I am a porcelain skinned American who feels sick to her stommach when I hear or read that word. You don’t have to be a person of color to be offended by this. I feel very sad that there are people in this world who enjoy trying to take another individual’s power away from them by devaluing them. My only word of hope for this family is that they teach their daughter that a rose by any other name would smell as sweet. You are beautiful no matter what another individual says or writes… believe in yourself and retain your power. I hope that they find out who did this and moreover I hope that the individual is remorseful and can learn from this nasty act.

Posted by: annonymous | April 11, 2007, 1:15 pm 1:15 pm

Personally, I’m sick of hearing about it. Those of African descent call each other by this so-called slur but let anyone else do it and the fur flys. Maybe they should lead by example instead of publicity and litigation.

Posted by: Mike | April 11, 2007, 1:15 pm 1:15 pm

Are you kidding me? Who do these people think they are? Ni**er brown? That’s sad. Look, this isn’t 1860, we’re talking 2000′s! SUE THEM!!!!!

Posted by: Are You Kidding Me? | April 11, 2007, 1:15 pm 1:15 pm

That’s sadly hilarious.
racial slurs and other terms rooted in Hate will be the last to be removed from the ‘database’.

Posted by: Brenda | April 11, 2007, 1:15 pm 1:15 pm

I think that racis people are messed up. I think that the government should try to do something about it!! Thats just messed the heck up!

Posted by: Stefanie Maddalozzo | April 11, 2007, 1:16 pm 1:16 pm

Excuse me, isn’t the insult spelled with two Ns? One N is a country is Africa.

Posted by: voiceofreason | April 11, 2007, 1:18 pm 1:18 pm

Outside of America, it’s not commonly known that “***” is such a politically charged word. I’m sure the manufacturers did simply made a translation mistake and did not intentionally mean any slight to African-American’s by this.

Posted by: Tim | April 11, 2007, 1:18 pm 1:18 pm

Seriously ABC News. did you have to blot out the “N” word on the photo? What are you afraid of? You’re supposed to report the news, not censor it. This is 2007.

Posted by: johnny b | April 11, 2007, 1:19 pm 1:19 pm

Isn’t it possible the word was used in a translation error? The dreaded “N” word was originally “negro,” which means “black”, and is NOT insulting. The ONLY reason the so-called “N”-word is insulting is because we ALLOW it to be.
I have English background, but the term “Limey” doesn’t bother me. Why are black people so hung-up over a word? It’s ATTITUDE that matters!
Another “tempest in a teapot”.

Posted by: rmberryman | April 11, 2007, 1:22 pm 1:22 pm

For God sake. Just in USA that word is an offense: in Spanish you say Niegro, in Portuguese you say Negro, in French you say Noir, no problem at all. Means Black that’s the collor of the Sofa, you dont have problems, you create problems

Posted by: Margarida | April 11, 2007, 1:22 pm 1:22 pm

If people would stop screaming racism at every little thing – this “racial profiling” wouldn’t exist. If you say “Negro” its now racist – but it’s also Spanish for black!

Posted by: Jessica | April 11, 2007, 1:27 pm 1:27 pm

IMO Imus crossed the line and this lady wants a free couch.

Posted by: RealityBites | April 11, 2007, 1:28 pm 1:28 pm

accident? come on man, and there are only a few of these pieces that are like this. im only 22 years old but im not stupid. either that was a badly soured prank by an employee or this company new that these pieces were leaving out like this. If they didnt know, well then they should pay better attention because these are million dollar errors.

Posted by: anthony mitchell | April 11, 2007, 1:29 pm 1:29 pm

Maybe the people who are up in arms and screaming racism, hate, etc. should stop using these words to describe each other first. You cant own words within your race or “culture” and forbid others to use them. Change starts within your own communities.

Posted by: Miguel | April 11, 2007, 1:30 pm 1:30 pm

Maybe the people who are up in arms and screaming racism, hate, etc. should stop using these words to describe each other first. You cant own words within your race or “culture” and forbid others to use them. Change starts within your own communities.

Posted by: Miguel | April 11, 2007, 1:31 pm 1:31 pm

Well of course if this lady doesn’t like the term *** brown she could always go back to Ghana. Of course the idea of making some money out of little work wouldn’t be clouding this lady’s feelings just a little.
As I understand it a certain ewthnic group use the *** word quite regularly, and they are not white anglo saxon. Usually you can find their origins in Africa, and I bet she isn’t going to sue them.

Posted by: Chris | April 11, 2007, 1:31 pm 1:31 pm

It was just a label. Nothing had shown that racism had been related to it. This is the America, people should be able to say anything they want to say as they have the constitutional right for “Freedom of Speech”. I think most of the people are sick and tired of being “Politically Correct” !!! At least I am !!!

Posted by: Mike | April 11, 2007, 1:31 pm 1:31 pm

WOW. Sounds like it was an honest mistake, but someone needs to step up and make this right with the family and get a recall of all other such labeled furniture.
However, I do think it would not be right for this family to sue for profit. Make them accountable, but don’t try to get rich from this!
God help humanity…

Posted by: Randy James | April 11, 2007, 1:32 pm 1:32 pm

yes, its 2007. i had a 12th grade civic social problems teather in 1959 tell the class that it will only stop when there is a complete amalgamation of the races. i happen to be 66 now & we have things that are politically corect to say, but that really changes nothing.

Posted by: barnes | April 11, 2007, 1:33 pm 1:33 pm

Racists all deserve to be punished. This is just not something to shrug at.

Posted by: kim | April 11, 2007, 1:35 pm 1:35 pm

cry me a river a mile wide & a mile deep it’s just a word, doesn’t anybody remember the old saying…sticks & stone may break my bones but names will never hurt me, GET OVER IT!!!!

Posted by: DAVE | April 11, 2007, 1:36 pm 1:36 pm

This sounds like an innocent mistake that someone is making an issue out of, probably looking for money.

Posted by: Seah Haggerty | April 11, 2007, 1:37 pm 1:37 pm

Why does everyone have to be so mortally offended these days.
Being one who has their sexual orientation constantly degraged, I can understand the hurt, but, get over yourselves.
You must always know that those who do these things have the problem, not you. Rise above their level, hold up your head, and quit whining.

Posted by: Todd | April 11, 2007, 1:39 pm 1:39 pm

It may be an intentional racial slur, but I am not sure. After all, there is a country in Africa called “Niger,” which means “black” in Latin. So the offensive term could be a misspelling of the original Latin term meaning “black,” rather than a racial slur. It depends on the context.

Posted by: George | April 11, 2007, 1:41 pm 1:41 pm

Refund????? Give me a break. Is the sofa what they wanted? Remove the tag and move on. This is just plain cashing in on the Imus hype…they should be ashamed of themselves.

Posted by: Tom | April 11, 2007, 1:43 pm 1:43 pm

Here we go again! Yet still nothing being said about the black lady calling the banker on Deal or No Deal a cracker on Monday night. Outrageous!

Posted by: Jeff | April 11, 2007, 1:46 pm 1:46 pm

Why should the store be held resposible for something they did not put in place and probably never saw? Why does someone have to be held accountable for hurting your feelings? Some things just happen, and not everyone is out to get you.

Posted by: Get over it | April 11, 2007, 1:59 pm 1:59 pm

I can see where this could be a glitch of some sort. Wasn’t there a crayola crayon years ago ‘niger brown’?

Posted by: debi | April 11, 2007, 2:00 pm 2:00 pm

Unfortunately, it is a fact of life that somewhere in this young girl’s life she will either hear or at least know the heritage of the word, including the way modern black society is allowed to use the “word” but heaven forbid anyone ELSE in the rest of the world use it.

Posted by: Equality should prevail | April 11, 2007, 2:01 pm 2:01 pm

The false advertising alone should be enough to justify damages. You’re told it’s fine Italian furniture and find out that it’s thrown togather in China. Be interesting to know if the racial wording on the tag was intentional, or an innocent mistake made by someone not aware of the racial slur.

Posted by: Dave | April 11, 2007, 2:01 pm 2:01 pm

isn’t niger in spanish the color black? When working with other countries color translation can be mistranslated. What civil rights have taken away from this family. Now they want the couch for free. There were no burning cross’s or windows broken.

Posted by: jj | April 11, 2007, 2:04 pm 2:04 pm

A personal apology, an explanation of how this happened, and what has been done to prevent it from happening again? Yes, I would agree they deserve this. A refund for the purchase price of the furniture? I don’t think that is appropriate unless they are returning the furniture.

Posted by: Mike | April 11, 2007, 2:05 pm 2:05 pm

The use of the term is despicable!
But maybe the salesman, cashier, and deliverymen should also be sued. Oh yeah, how about the customs guy?

Posted by: MB | April 11, 2007, 2:06 pm 2:06 pm

They were not calling her the n word. Get on with you life. and Tell your daughter the trueth. The word is an old slange word for black person. Get on with your life. Stop trying to make money off of something that happened too many years ago.

Posted by: Lorraine | April 11, 2007, 2:06 pm 2:06 pm

I am sorry to say that racism will always exist in some way, shape or form. Rather it is color, gender or ceed. Even though slavery ended, people have mostly remained seperated and living around “people of their own kind”. We really need to pray and try to get to know others for who they are. We will never be able to change how someone feels, yet the more try to understand the better thing may become. I am sorry that things are this way ,but we can remain strong and work our way through these situations.

Posted by: kay | April 11, 2007, 2:08 pm 2:08 pm

Perhaps we should be more worried about REAL harms, instead of just the use of words.

Posted by: Bryan | April 11, 2007, 2:11 pm 2:11 pm

I do believe the maker should indeed apologize for such stupidness that word should have not been used at all. I feel awful that the 7 year old little girl had to find that written on the tag.

Posted by: Iris | April 11, 2007, 2:12 pm 2:12 pm

I have seen numerous translation mistakes like this in China. I think that no one should be sued but just issue an apology. These days everyone needs to sue someone for a mistake, it doesnt even sound like it was racially motivated anyways.

Posted by: Alex | April 11, 2007, 2:12 pm 2:12 pm

Seriously this is so lame!!!!!
First: Typical dishonesty/misrepresentation by some businesspeople. The couches were from supposedly from Italy (aka China)!!!
Second:It was an “innocent mistake” made by somebody else in China and left to stand (i.e., not corrected by the Business when they receive the couches)but the guy had to hide until he was tracked a radio station?!! He could not fix this seemingly “minor innocent” mistake before it was blown into the public arena by the media???

Posted by: Tim | April 11, 2007, 2:13 pm 2:13 pm

I am sorry to say that racism will always exist in some way, shape or form. Rather it is color, gender or creed. Even though slavery ended, people have mostly remained seperated and living around “people of their own kind”. We really need to pray and try to get to know others for who they are. We will never be able to change how someone feels, but people should always have respect for each other. I am sorry that things are this way ,but we can remain strong and work our way through these situations.

Posted by: kay | April 11, 2007, 2:14 pm 2:14 pm

Yes – there are no excuses for this sort of “mistake”.
NO – this is not a case whereby someone NEEDS to waste our courts time and incure taxpayer expenses just so someone can take advantage and make big money!!! This is 2007, when will this type of profiteering stop.

Posted by: Cheryl | April 11, 2007, 2:15 pm 2:15 pm

Really…is this serious? Enjoy the free couch, cause that’s what really matters to that family. I think the fact that her daughter had never heard the “n” word is proof positive that racism is almost gone except for those who belly-ache and just want free hand outs or publicity.

Posted by: Andrew Bigham | April 11, 2007, 2:21 pm 2:21 pm

In order to ban the N word, the black community and its leaders should address the black “entertainer” first. Those are the people who glorify the N word and use in every single sentence. Why is it OK for them to use the N word, but not others? This is worst than double standard, it is reverse racism.

Posted by: Honest Opinion | April 11, 2007, 2:22 pm 2:22 pm

Maybe she should hold all rap artists accountable,too.

Posted by: Rich | April 11, 2007, 2:24 pm 2:24 pm

Black in spanish is actually negro.

Posted by: liza | April 11, 2007, 2:28 pm 2:28 pm

No harm intended, just a translation error..Yes, other countries use as the color black. Yes, and alot of black youth use the word so its common in those circles. Just heard it the other day while passing a phone booth. Come up with something that is truth instead of pure speculation.

Posted by: Alley | April 11, 2007, 2:28 pm 2:28 pm

They were simply wanted to buy a couch and they got insulted instead.
{if that violated laws in Canada, then it will be dealt with that} The Business manager dodged them over some “innocent mistake.” Afterall. racism in its insidious form is “simple innocent mistake.”
In spanish there is a word for brown to not just black. So if some apologist is trying to claim that the label was a spanish translation , we would have expected the entire label to be in Spanish.
If you have the strength ignore the racial slights that some people endure frequently, thank God for giving superior inner strength. But the dismissiveness with which some react to these incidents does not help people move on.
The label could have very well been an honest mistake made by some factory people who are not aware of the Market they were selling to. What is really annoying is the behavior of Vanaik prior to being outed in the media!

Posted by: Tim | April 11, 2007, 2:29 pm 2:29 pm

Get over it. It was obviously a translation error. As a previous writer said if something came in honky white, would I care?
The word nig**r is denegrating, but why isn’t there any outrage when blacks call whites, honky, crackers, etc. Even if a person was a racist, so be it. You can’t change people’s opinions and this constant whining about every little thing certainly doesn’t help the situation.

Posted by: Barbara T. | April 11, 2007, 2:29 pm 2:29 pm

How wonderful that the child has never heard the word. As for the rest, these people need to get a life. As for a lawsuit, on what grounds?

Posted by: sgb | April 11, 2007, 2:31 pm 2:31 pm

For the record, the Spanish word for black is Negro, ya’ll. See how confusion gets started?
So the couch cost $1300.00, but that doesn’t mean it was leather. At the risk of dating mayself, maybe it was “Naugahyde”, which, I suppose, could have been mis-translated:)
I am black and I am proud, and the sooner people begin educating their kids about ethnicities, whatever they want to classify their children as, the better for the children. I never liked having these conversations with my own offspring, but better from Dad/Grandfather than from the ignorant and ill-informed of the world — black and white.
Richard S

Posted by: richard | April 11, 2007, 2:31 pm 2:31 pm

She wants to sue over a translation mistake? Give me a break.

Posted by: Dusty | April 11, 2007, 2:34 pm 2:34 pm

The color of the couch is brown not black. And negro is the spanish word for black not niger you idiot.

Posted by: slick | April 11, 2007, 2:34 pm 2:34 pm

I think that we tend to take things to seriously here in America when something offends us. The most proper thing to do was to call the manufacture and explain that the translation of the word was offensive and move on. If her daughter wanted to know what the word meant it would have bee easier to let her know it was the other name for a color and not use it as a rascist term

Posted by: SLM | April 11, 2007, 2:35 pm 2:35 pm

This is ridiculous!!!! Money or an apology will not solve their personal problems or fill their voids in life!!! Only generally unhappy people make big deals about these sort of things. Just because someone calls you a name on “the playground of life,” and so-calls….disrespects you…doesn’t mean you have to have a public apology!!!!!!! Its not like you would not then spend your life trying to sew someone anywhere anyway. You will look stupid in the process, by the way! Move on people and grow up! Find some kind of self satisfaction in life or a hobby and don’t let every single episode in life blow your fuses or ruffle those little feathers of your!!!!

Posted by: Get over yourselves!!! | April 11, 2007, 2:35 pm 2:35 pm

I have to say that while this isn’t an acceptable description of the color of the couch, I think it’s ridiculous for this family to be causing such a mess over it. The family was not personally attacked and therefore should not in turn personally attack the store owner.

Posted by: karin | April 11, 2007, 2:35 pm 2:35 pm

The New American Dream —
Getting something for Nothing
Thank you libs. Thank you S.F. You make the Nothings proud.

Posted by: JelloBiafra | April 11, 2007, 2:36 pm 2:36 pm

No, Niger is not spanish for black, it’s actually negro (same spelling different pronounciation). However I do agree that this was quite obviously a very embarrassing software translation error and getting a free couch or taking legal action is a bit over the top. Like everyone else has said ‘Get Over It!’, they got apologies and no one was scarred for life so move on.

Posted by: mc | April 11, 2007, 2:37 pm 2:37 pm

Get over it allready, Probably just mad that she paid too much for the couch and no return policy. Take it to the pawn shop and get a life in exchange. People are just looking for anyway and every way to either get something free or sue someone. Who cares….Im goina go home tonight and pull the tags off my leather couch.

Posted by: Kara | April 11, 2007, 2:38 pm 2:38 pm

Does anyone else think it’s silly that the article won’t even use the word at issue?

Posted by: Eddie | April 11, 2007, 2:41 pm 2:41 pm

Negro is the spanish word for black. There is no way there was a legitimate translation error. This was either someone’s overt or lazy racism coming through. Someone entered that into the software and meant to leave it in or forgot to take it out.
There should be some amends made if the actual responsible party can be found, but otherwise, move on.
Racism is horrible, but feeding it like we do keeps it alive.

Posted by: eric | April 11, 2007, 2:42 pm 2:42 pm

Oh please! Why is it ok for some young “person of color” to drive down the road with his stereo turned up full blast shouting all kinds of racist words for all the world to hear, but let someone else speak those words and it’s like the world is going to come to an end. GET OVER IT!!! Niger also refers to a type of thistle seed fed to finches. It is a dark brown/black colored seed. DUH!!!!

Posted by: Sandy | April 11, 2007, 2:42 pm 2:42 pm

Sue, sue, sue… Give me a break. Get over it already. What if the couch was labeled “honky white”? You wouldn’t see white people suing over that – guaranteed! Oh wait, here comes Al Sharpton in 3…2…1…

Posted by: Dave | April 11, 2007, 2:42 pm 2:42 pm

It’s just a (very) unfortunate translation error. No need to summon the Authorities.
What they meant is that the couch is black-brown. And if that’s it behind the Offended Party, the label is accurate.
Apologies should be made an accepted. Nothing racist is happening here. Unlike Imus, who is clearly a racist and has been for many years. Why are people suddenly surprised?

Posted by: BiafraJello | April 11, 2007, 2:43 pm 2:43 pm

Maybe the couch was actually labeled in Nigeria!!??? and they shortened the name????
Get over it.

Posted by: Ines | April 11, 2007, 2:45 pm 2:45 pm

No jj the word for black in spainish is negro, nice try though. As for all of the “get over it comments” Why in the heck should the “get over it”? These people paid good money for an item that turns out to contain something that attacks the very notion that they are human, and espouses the idea that they are not human and are less than human. How would you feel if you spent 1200 bucks on something only to have your 6 year old find a picture on said item depicting gay anal sex? Would you just get over that? Those who made comments like “get over it” need to “get over” the idea that these kinds of incidents are still acceptable and to be overlooked, and that those who cause them will not be held accoutable as the law requires.

Posted by: notsofast | April 11, 2007, 2:46 pm 2:46 pm

Are you serious? the “N” word is totally ok when a rapper uses it in his/her “art” and young people of color use it on a daily basis to each other and because the store is not owned by people of color then it’s taken as an afront to this entire family. I say send the couches back get your money and but a ticket on the next space shuttle to a perfect world. That would be the only way to shield your family from the dreaded “N” word. what’s that old ryme sticks & stones……..

Posted by: Tim | April 11, 2007, 2:46 pm 2:46 pm

It is a shame that african americans don’t get mad at their own color for using the “N” word, but God forbid anyone else. Start holding your own color accountable for using that word any ANY fashion. It’s a double standard.

Posted by: Dave | April 11, 2007, 2:47 pm 2:47 pm

If you look at clothing ads from newspapers in the early 20th century (around the 1920s) you will see dresses advertised as n**** brown. Once it was an acceptable term. This was a silly translation error, not intended as a pejorative or hate crime. As the couch was made in Italy, chances are the translator was using a very old dictionary. Oh, and to arlan, the woman’s name was Moore, not Brown. Did you actually read the article?

Posted by: Marla | April 11, 2007, 2:48 pm 2:48 pm

Is there evidence that the store or supplier added the label? I believe the mistake was made at the manufacturer in China. The software used to make the label probably is to blame. Maybe the Chinese meant to describe the color of the couch as black-brown, but mistakenly used the word *** for black.

Posted by: Ted | April 11, 2007, 2:50 pm 2:50 pm

What ever happen to: “Sticks and stones may break my bones, but names will never hurt me?” What the heck is going on in this country anymore? Someone calls you a name and you can’t deal with it? Get a life people and move on.

Posted by: Bozo | April 11, 2007, 2:50 pm 2:50 pm

OMG! PEople will try to get paid for any thing. It was not directed towards her or her family or their race. I swear there are those in this world who think everyone is out to get them. Yes, there are a few that are racist but racisim comes from every race, but you don;t hear them hooting and hollering about it. grow up – those time are over. Computer error- Human error who cares no one is perfect. Just like the imus situation – Yeah he was a jerk for saying what he said, but he did not say the blacks were “nappy headed hos” He mad a general comment about them all, but it all of a sudden is a race thing. I am so tired of hearing its about race. All it is, is someone is out in hopes to make money of the smallest thing. and have A FREAKING PITY PARTY. BOO HOO. GET OVER YOURSELF!

Posted by: Leslie | April 11, 2007, 2:51 pm 2:51 pm

I completely believe that this is just a mis-translation at the Chinese supplier. There are several examples of mis-translated verbiage from Chinese to English. Many of them are just as weird as this.

Posted by: MIKE | April 11, 2007, 2:53 pm 2:53 pm

OMG! People will try to get paid for anything. It was not directed towards her or her family or their race. I swear there are those in this world who think everyone is out to get them. Yes, there are a few that are racist but racisim comes from every race, but you don’t hear them hooting and hollering about it. Always seems to be one in particular. Grow up – those time are over. Computer error,Human error, who cares no one is perfect. Just like the Imus situation – Yeah he was a jerk for saying what he said, but he did not say to any particular race. He made a general comment about the whole team (isn’t that freedom of speech – it is his opinion. What happened to sticks and stones may break my bones but WORDS may never hurt me – yeah an old childhood saying but so true – unless you let it hurt you), but it all of a sudden is a race thing. I am so tired of hearing its about race. All it is, is someone is out in hopes to make money of the smallest thing and have a FREAKING PITY PARTY. BOO HOO. GET OVER YOURSELF!

Posted by: Leslie | April 11, 2007, 2:56 pm 2:56 pm

OK I can understand these people being a bit “shocked” at what was found yet I don’t believe that Doris had to explain so much to her 7 year old! If this label was applied in China there may very well have been some kind of mistake so how would the store have known about it? Are all stores required to look at every single label on every item that comes through their store? My God they would have to hire someone just to do that, how unreal is that? The one thing that bothered me most wasn’t even the fact that the “N” word was used it is that these people are actually thinking about what kind of fincial gain they can make from this even after getting a PUBLIC apology. *Shakes Head* I guess it isn’t just the USA that is sue happy….

Posted by: Tehya | April 11, 2007, 2:57 pm 2:57 pm

If we got rid of all the ignorant people and the people who have said or done something stupid in their lives, there would be nobody left. We’ve ALL stuck our foot in our mouths or unintentionally offended or hurt someone at one point or another. Is anyone out there really going to say they haven’t?

Posted by: Catherine | April 11, 2007, 2:57 pm 2:57 pm

OK notsofast… The “n” word is far from being the same as a picture of gay anal sex. However, if in another country they used a picture of gay anal sex to describe the word “white”, I would think it would be ok to get upset but if I was truly offended I doubt I would hold the blurred picture up for a camera. I’d probably contact someone with the manufacturing company and request that it be changed. Compare apples to apples… Besides if the tag read “cracker white” I would have to get a new couch because I would have laughed so hard I peed on it!! People are looking for a reason to complain and they are the ones that are keeping racism alive in this country. You don’t want to be sterotyped, don’t act like the sterotype that’s been created!

Posted by: karin | April 11, 2007, 2:58 pm 2:58 pm

Interesting, the word *** is removed from all of our comments and replaced with stars. It’s not a curse word like **, so why is it censored? And none of the comments use the word in a disparaging way, we’re merely talking about the word. So why censor it? I wonder if a computer is reading our comments and censoring them or an actual person is.

Posted by: Ted | April 11, 2007, 2:59 pm 2:59 pm

Stick and stones…Too many are wiling to jump on the hyper-sentitive bandwagon. Send in Sharpton and Jesse to clean up this “lost in tranlation”

Posted by: Bill | April 11, 2007, 3:02 pm 3:02 pm

Doesn’t anyone remember the old saying sticks & stones may break my bones but names will never hurt me? I’m sure a couple of trillon dollars will put thier little babies mind at ease though.
I know when someone calls me a dumb ** it take at least two or three years for me to get over it.

Posted by: DAVE | April 11, 2007, 3:02 pm 3:02 pm

It must be a person reading our comments. Greetings moderator!

Posted by: Ted | April 11, 2007, 3:04 pm 3:04 pm

I do believe that the comment may have been translated with no harm intended. However, to state that there is no offense by the use of the word in any context (however innocent) is to be blind and to want to stay blind of the fact that, historically, the very word “***” was created to humiliate and oppressed all people of color.
It is a fact that ever since the 1800′s, all colonial powers promulgated the word (in various translation)among their culture to humiliate and oppresse people of color during the height of the global enslavement of the African.
This was done, of course, without regard to the damage such an offense does to a people, overtime. In short, it is important that this word be wiped out from the world’s vocabular and those who choose to use it (White, black, asian etc). Sometimes the only way individuals stop the spread of an injustice, whether or not they are cognizant of the injustice, is when it stricts them in their pocket–$$$.
So the moral is–if you chose to use the offensive (and evil word) you do it at your own risk. You never know who is watching or listening and will decide to give you a just lesson on how evil and offensive the word is to many around the world. Hopefully, the right choice or, for some the economical choice, is to just not use the word.

Posted by: Offended by some who posted comments | April 11, 2007, 3:05 pm 3:05 pm

. . .Sales of this couch have sky-rocketed across the south . . .

Posted by: joseph | April 11, 2007, 3:06 pm 3:06 pm

Did the people in China know that the furniture was intended for a couple that is from Ghana and now living in Toronto Canada or did they simply “fill an order”? You must respect the couple for not wanting to subject their family to such language but at the same time they must know they were not purposely targeted. This is only my opinion.

Posted by: VO | April 11, 2007, 3:06 pm 3:06 pm

Did anyone actually read the article? There was no mention of suing anyone. There was no mention of getting a free couch. It mentioned refunding her money or apologizing. The fact that the store would not respond to her lead her to contacting a TV station. Had the store been responsible to the customer none of this would have blown up in its face.
By the way, this happened in Canada not the U.S. Please read the story.

Posted by: Bob Gilmore | April 11, 2007, 3:06 pm 3:06 pm

OK I can understand these people being a bit “shocked” at what was found yet I don’t believe that Doris had to explain so much to her 7 year old! If this label was applied in China there may very well have been some kind of mistake so how would the store have known about it? Are all stores required to look at every single label on every item that comes through their store? My God they would have to hire someone just to do that, how unreal is that? The one thing that bothered me most wasn’t even the fact that the “N” word was used it is that these people are actually thinking about what kind of fincial gain they can make from this even after getting a PUBLIC apology. *Shakes Head* I guess it isn’t just the USA that is sue happy…. Oh and one more comment: This hsppened in CANADA people not in the USA… *ggls* see there are greedy people in other countries too!!!

Posted by: Tehya | April 11, 2007, 3:09 pm 3:09 pm

Who is Don Imus?

Posted by: Ted2 | April 11, 2007, 3:09 pm 3:09 pm

Um, Isn’t nigro spanish for brown?
Duh!

Posted by: shannon | April 11, 2007, 3:10 pm 3:10 pm

Oh I get it! We are now on a bandwagon where we have become hyper sensitive to any type of “racial” comment and then bam (!) file a lawsuit and recoop some big $$$$. This has become a sue happy country and it is truly annoying. Maybe the ones who should sue are our wounded soldiers coming back from war and not receiving the decent treatment they deserve. Now that would be deserving!

Posted by: Renee | April 11, 2007, 3:13 pm 3:13 pm

*** brown is an old term used by some Australians to describe dark brown. I can see how someone in Asia may have used this old tanslation.
The person also was not African American. They were African and on top of that from Ghana the country the capture and sold the slaves.
Family of Kuraseni

Posted by: rick | April 11, 2007, 3:14 pm 3:14 pm

I am outraged that crackers are called crackers…It offends me, they should be called saltines – I think I’ll sue

Posted by: JEN | April 11, 2007, 3:19 pm 3:19 pm

Bob Gilmore:
There IS talk of suing the store that sold her the sofa…
“Doris Moore has filed a formal complaint with the Ontario Human Rights Commission and the family is considering suing both the store and the supplier.”
I think this is ludicrous and makes me think she’s just out to make a buck–this is not about her civil rights supposedly being violated. If she were concerned about that she’d sue the millions of people who use it every day including many blacks.
You need to read the story.

Posted by: Ted | April 11, 2007, 3:21 pm 3:21 pm

Bob
You didn’t read the article carefully enough…
1. They did not get a public or private apology (hence why they took it to the news)
2. They never said they would sue. Even if they did, any attorney worth a dime, would tell you suit doesn’t necessarily mean monetary awards. It simply means finding a way to remedy the party that has been harm or wrong. For example, if there were a suit, the settlement may simply be to order the company to change the label on the furniture etc.
It sad how ones tendency to see ill of people of color drives them to interpret this story negatively against the family. SAD…VERY SAD

Posted by: Take your time to read | April 11, 2007, 3:23 pm 3:23 pm

My sister lives in Norway, she and her kids, 12 and 15 y.o. called the Blacks as ni..r without any malice.
They thought that the word ni..r is not offensive to the Blacks.

Posted by: Leah | April 11, 2007, 3:24 pm 3:24 pm

Yesterday, I was called a fat ho. Who can I sue?

Posted by: Jacki | April 11, 2007, 3:28 pm 3:28 pm

NOT RACIST ! Oh really.. how come it was FOUND on a DARK couch; and NOT on a white or pink or red couch; had that been the case then I might be incline to buy into error. P>S Whats the IQ of the people that work at these places to not see something so blatant.

Posted by: sweetINSANITY | April 11, 2007, 3:34 pm 3:34 pm

Racism is obviously a word this woman is teaching her child now and how to cash in on it. It can definately be assumed that the origin of the word is latin or spanish and not the racial slur she was so quick to jump to. She definately has a legitimate claim regarding the origin of the couch since they told her it from Italy and is actually manufactured in China. Move on with the racial slur hubbub. Teach your child a much better lession like not letting someone(or a couch) define you and maybe some morals while your at it.

Posted by: JERSEY | April 11, 2007, 3:34 pm 3:34 pm

It saddens me that she’s willing to sue. She’s been given a tremendous opportunity by being allowed to live in Canada. Lord knows what her life would be like if she were still in her home country. I think she has been affected by our sue-happy culture and is only out to make a buck.

Posted by: Ted | April 11, 2007, 3:35 pm 3:35 pm

Niger is a country and a river, also refers to the color of a brown that is dark and close to black, if you look at the picture you can see how dark the sofa is–It was most likely a blasted typo.
Whites have also been called white bread.

Posted by: zee | April 11, 2007, 3:35 pm 3:35 pm

i’d like to reply to the very first comment on here
it says the lady’s last name is moore
not brown
do better

Posted by: dmetrius | April 11, 2007, 3:36 pm 3:36 pm

Please stop saying that this word is accepted in the black community because it is not. I nor anyone in my immediate or extended family use this word. Yet all you see on TV or those who do use this word and all of sudden everyone thinks that every black person in the world is represented by the handful of black youths that are shown on TV using this word. In the majority of the black community this word is not acceptable. And she does deserve an apology and a goodwill offer to pay for the couch is more than justified. $1,300 is just enough to cover the cost of having to explain such a horrible situation to an innocent 7 year old child.

Posted by: Bo | April 11, 2007, 3:38 pm 3:38 pm

In the words of Rodney King, “Why can’t we all just get along?” We live in the greatest country in the world but we are rapidly creating our own demise with bigotry and hatred. Any racial slurs against any race of people should not be allowed or tolerated whether it’s on the air waves, a furniture label or in everyday speech.

Posted by: DJD | April 11, 2007, 3:44 pm 3:44 pm

After reading some more of these comments, I think I’ll start reading all the labels I can find around my home.
Being that I’m hispanic (Cuban/American) maybe I’ll find a label that reads something like “spik n’ span” – hey, I wouldn’t mind a new washer and dryer!!!
We’ve all been there and heard it!!! Please!!!

Posted by: Ines | April 11, 2007, 3:45 pm 3:45 pm

This is all ridiculous!
I am a white female – from the south. Who has many black friends AND family members. And none of them can believe that everyone is making such a big deal about either big headline this week!
Most of my black family members/friends are all college grads with really good paying jobs and are so tired of watching/hearing Al and Jesse – THIS IS LIFE PEOPLE -
Between the Imus remarks and the Couch label – this is getting crazy!
The label – however the label got there did someone know the black family would be buying it???? No, so it was not meant for them much less about them.
And Imus – who cares what he says? Does anybody base their morals on what he says or does not say?
There are Black only colleges, scholarships, internships – and the white people are not protesting – I mean if that is what you want – do it. But let someone have an ALL WHITE COLLEGE, ETC., then here comes Jesse and Al!!! And then ALL THE WHITE PEOPLE ARE RACIST and the NAACP would be all over it demanding to allow black people in.

Posted by: wen | April 11, 2007, 3:46 pm 3:46 pm

I heard a bad word in a rap song yesterday. Is it legal to sue in the US?

Posted by: c12k | April 11, 2007, 3:48 pm 3:48 pm

Give me a break, another gold digger.

Posted by: Christie | April 11, 2007, 3:48 pm 3:48 pm

Hey, I got an idea! If people can sue for something absurd as an ENGRISH translation!
Every white American should sue CRACKER BARREL restaraunt for blatantly displaying the word CRACKER on every highway and city in America!
ROFL!!!

Posted by: Mr Twister | April 11, 2007, 3:52 pm 3:52 pm

Myself, my husband, and child are all caucasian. We live in a predominately black area and hear “the word” spoken frequently by our neighbors and their children. Do you think I ever wanted my child to know that word either? Of course not, but it is still apart of the culture, but it is no longer seen as derogatory- unless spoken by someone who is not of African decent. Children are going to be exposed to these words and many more, tell them the truth. Hoping your child never hears a hurtful word does not protect them; explaining these terms to them so they understand is much more valuable.
This term was not used purposfully. It is a label on an item of furniture that came from overseas. If you are that offended by it, take the furniture back and purchase furniture made by a local manufacturer. Everyone benefits: you have furniture you wanted (that is probably of a better quality), you have help your local economy and you have let the manufacturer know that you will not tolerate their practices, even if it was just an error in a computer program.
Remember, just because you were offended by a word does not entitle you to special treatment.

Posted by: JC | April 11, 2007, 4:03 pm 4:03 pm

I believe that racism will always be with us. There are ignorant people from EVERY race! If the family would like their money back for the sofa…I agree…they should return it and get their money back. It SHOULD NOT be free!!! No need to reward someone for a mistake. It was not a personel attack. I don’t see how that word can be a personel attack when people within the community use it in rap songs and everyday slang. If it is truely to be stricken from the language, thene there should be NO double standard. NO ONE should be able to use the word!
I HATE racism….it just shows the ignorance in people and how narrow-sighted they actually are. Try to get to know someone instead of judging by race!

Posted by: Johnnyd | April 11, 2007, 4:04 pm 4:04 pm

Who cares? Its a typo. And why is it that black people are the only people on earth that can be scarred for life by a word?????

Posted by: Brian | April 11, 2007, 4:05 pm 4:05 pm

This is for all the ignorant WP out there and on this board who think that it is ok in ‘Black society’ to use the N word. For those of you who think this you must be listening to too much Rap music or watching too many videos. I have never used the word or had any BP refer to me in this manner. I have also never heard any of my Black friends, family, etc. call someone the N word. Your problem is you generalize too much and try to lump the entire black community into one category. I assure you that 90% of all BP do not condone this, so don’t act like you know what every BP thinks and does. See it is the other 10% that you attempt to group every BP with. That is the Gangsta Rappers and the uneducated. You seem to also think that Al Sharpton and Jesse Jackson speaks for all BP. Again, this is called ignorance. In reference to IMUS. If he were black I would be just as offended and would want his @#% fired. You can say what you want because you are white and this wasn’t your wife, mother, daugther, or niece being refered to as a HO or jiggaboo. There is something called self-esteem. Don’t try to use excuses as to why it is okay for you or anyone else to say or do what you want to. Your excuse: If they ‘BP’ do it, then it should be okay. I think you refer to it as double-standards. A lot of you must be uneducated and problably not intimately know any person of color. If you did, you would know this and stop spreading lies to justify your ignorance and actions. I don’t think you teach your kids to take whatever comes there way, especially if it does them harm. For all you racist out there you really need to remember that it is 2007. I really hope you don’t think you are going to get the same results from BP as you did 100+ years ago. Back then it was the white sheets and now you hide behind your kitchen tables and your emails.

Posted by: tj | April 11, 2007, 4:07 pm 4:07 pm

The 7 year old girl had never heard the N word??? WHAT? are you kidding me? Black youth use this word after every other word. Not to mention the rappers. Give me a break. Get a life woman, you are obviously after some free cash. If you are so offended by the N word, maybe you should start suing the millions of blacks that use it every day. You should be ashamed of yourself to expose your little girl to such a huge deal out of nothing. All you needed to do is tell her that was a mistake in the label and explain to her why this word is offensive. One other thing, if the little girl have never heard of the word before why would she question it?… I smell something fishy.

Posted by: Ed | April 11, 2007, 4:18 pm 4:18 pm

It is troubling to see how many people are ignorant on why the company’s lack of awareness is troublesome. It reaffirms my need to become a lot more active with fighting racism in US and across the world.
To the person who stated that she has all these black friends and they told her that they don’t see the issue. Is telling of one of two realities:
1. Who are stretching the truth of the number of “black” friend you indeed have to bolster your point or;
2. You, indeed, have these friends who lack an understanding of the harm this word has done to people of color (latina, African, west indian etc.)and wont realize it until they make an effort to learn about the effects of *** to demonize them and their children…

Posted by: Wow....every blog who demonizes this family is wrong | April 11, 2007, 4:19 pm 4:19 pm

White people just don’t get the point of racist comments because they have never had to experience racism like other minority groups have in the country and around the world. They have absolutely no clue what the “N” word means to people of color and it’s negative, demeaning, degrading origin which goes back more than 200 years. They have never had to sit at the back of a bus or be forced to give up their seat to a white person. They never had to sit in the back of a theater or eat in the kitchen instead of the main dining areas or be refused service because of the color of your skin. They have never had to drink out a drinking fountain labled for “Blacks only”. Many black people including myself have experienced these things. Our experiences are much different than theirs. Caucasians can afford to take the attitude “so what’s the big deal” because they have been given a pass on a lot of these issues and simply cannot relate. It doesn’t matter what race uses the “N” word because it’s demeaning and why do they want to use it anyway!
sticks and stones may break your bones and yes, words can hurt your spirit and heart and soul. We all need to respect each other and act like human beings regardless of race, color, sex, religion etc….

Posted by: Faye Mitchell | April 11, 2007, 4:19 pm 4:19 pm

to tj
know and have been around lots of BP and the n word is used – you must be in a very protected area most of the time the n word is not used in a derogatory manner(?)like hey n– whas up? It depends on who is using it and how it is used.

Posted by: zee | April 11, 2007, 4:22 pm 4:22 pm

People have to see the bigger picture about the ‘N’ word and it is associated along with it. In this case, who ever wrote the was labeling the colors used the ‘N’ word because he associated it black or brown colors. That is the bigger problem. What people associate people of color with. Why not associate people of color with the word ‘person’ or ‘human’. This has to be deal with but people don’t like to deal with problems for some reason.
And to JelloBiafra, quit forging your own reality and then commenting about it. Because lying to yourself just doesn’t help, and having facts as you want them to be, that contradicts reality as it is makes everything you say invalid and would like to NOT see you write anything again because of it.

Posted by: JD | April 11, 2007, 4:24 pm 4:24 pm

Finally someone who is setting the record straight.

Posted by: Brian--I APPLAUD YOU | April 11, 2007, 4:25 pm 4:25 pm

Karin, it IS the same thing as a picture of gay anal sex, it is horridly offensive to some, inappropriate on a item bought with out teh consuers knowledge, and not appropriate for a young child. It is appels to appels, its the same thing to these people and that is the point. No one is loking for an excuse to keep racism alive, most of us are sick to death of it, but we WILL NOT pretend its not around and just “get over” the fact that it is still very much around and your comments highlight that fact. You do not see the people in this story laughing, and as you admitted you would not be laughing over gay porn. You get over the idea that racism is not around because it is.

Posted by: notsofast | April 11, 2007, 4:33 pm 4:33 pm

Too many comments to read to see if anyone thinks like I do. Many Chinese tags are mispelled. Did anyone think it should have been “Niger Brown”. This could be a very simple mistake.

Posted by: Marilyn | April 11, 2007, 4:47 pm 4:47 pm

The black people who say, “90% of black people don’t use that word” – really, you know 90% of the black population? Wow. The white people who say, “rappers use the word all the time” are quoting an inarguable fact. Turn on a radio station – bam, there it is. Myself, I have personally heard more than 1, 2 or 3 black people speak the word. The point is, if this incident – where there are at least three solid non-racist-related reasons as to how that word got on there, is so unequivocally wrong to you, why aren’t those rap songs? Those even isolated personally-witnessed utterances?

Posted by: Tighe | April 11, 2007, 4:51 pm 4:51 pm

I think the couch should be made to stand in the corner for hurling racial epithets at its owners.

Posted by: Hmmm | April 11, 2007, 4:52 pm 4:52 pm

notsofast-
For CRYIN’ out loud!! INTENT matters? You tell me how a picture of gay anal sex could get on a couch label by sheer accident, and THEN we’ll talk. This is NOT a nebulous discussion of, oh, is the ‘n’ word as offensive as anal sex? It’s about whether THIS occurrence of it is ACTUALLY an offensive use of the word. The FACT is, the ‘n’ word IS used by black people – let’s forget prevalence, suffice it to say it’s not rare or uncommon – without ramification, so clearly not EVERY single appearance of the ‘n’ word is cause for action.
Question: what if we found out a ‘person of color’ (god, that term is even dumber than ‘African American’ – why does NO caucasian race go by “X-American”??) was the last one in the processing plant before this got shipped??

Posted by: Tighe | April 11, 2007, 4:55 pm 4:55 pm

I think I will submit this to Crayola for a new crayon color

Posted by: Oilguzzler | April 11, 2007, 4:58 pm 4:58 pm

I think the couch should stand in the corner for hurling racial epithets at its owners

Posted by: Hmm | April 11, 2007, 5:02 pm 5:02 pm

I could give a flying crap about political correctness or retaliation. It is sad that most of the blogs are for the family or for the furniture store. To me it is simple… Fear equals hatred and forgiveness equals love. It is sad that the folks at the furniture store didn’t appologize out of “fear” of retaliation and it is sad that the family felt “hatred” instead of “forgiveness”. We as a society are all to blame for not looking at ourselves first. We attack each other. Anger and sarcasm are born from fear. If anybody had compassion for the other side and let go of their fears nobody would be discussing this right now. I’ve done it and everyone writing here has done it. If we all worked on ourselves more and forgive those who live in fear and hatred we’d probably be a better society. We might experience a more fulfilling, abundant life. I forgive myself for my mistakes and I forgive those who have wronged me. But sadly, we humans usually get angry first before we come to this stage. Be nice?!

Posted by: annonymous | April 11, 2007, 5:12 pm 5:12 pm

From one hyphenated american to another — when my grandparents came here from Italy they were met with discrimination. It has been that way for virtually every ethnic group that ever came here. Black people got it worse — a lot worse — than most. There might be some hypersensitivity involved, but then this county was downright ugly to black americans for a long long time and it’s going to take some — and trying — to heal.

Posted by: Hmm | April 11, 2007, 5:18 pm 5:18 pm

Does intent matter, maybe, maybe not, nobody knows what the intent was in this case, and nobody who might be able to shed light on it is willing to step up. That is part of the problem. If I run you over with my car and kill you, is your family going to be any less upset because I say “Oops sorry I did not mean to”? With or with out intent, you are still dead, and your family is still (iam assuming that they would actually miss you, which might be a false assumption)be upset over your untimly demise. Should they be denied the right to sue me for killing you because I did not mean to run you over? Of course not, such a result would be stupid at face value. As for whether its offensive in this case, as you put it, it sure is to the people invovled, so you really have answered your own question with a big fat yes. As for the idea that some blacks use this word, so what? Apparently the people in this story don’t use that word. Alot of people speed alot of people use drugs, a lot of people commit murder and rob, all of which is still wrong. One persons wrong does not excuse another’s. Wrong is wrong is wrong. Saying that guy did it too is not a defense. Grow up. Finally, as to your question as to what if the last person in the factory was a “person of color” … that would also show nothing, the tag could have been put on at any time of the day, and frankly that is an unsophisticated “argument” but again, I guess your assumption would just be to go ahead and blame the black guy anyway. Figures.

Posted by: notsofast | April 11, 2007, 5:34 pm 5:34 pm

After reading the comments left behind by bloggers I can see that we still have a long way to go as far as race relations in this day and age. I am really shocked by the number of people trying to minimized the issue at hand. I also think that people are missing the point. If the Manager of the furniture store had taken the time to address the issue( exchanging the sofa and apologizing TO THE FAMILY))instead of dismissing them, the whole matter probably would have ended there, but now the family is angry and is taking a stand ON PRINCIPLE. Does anyone find it odd that the store didn’t see fit to return the CUSTOMERS call but apoligized ONLY when the media got involved????

Posted by: Monee Wells | April 11, 2007, 5:40 pm 5:40 pm

i honestly dont think its that big of a deal and they definately shouldnt be trying to sue. but i dont blame the family for getting the media involved b/c the mananger didnt return her phone calls and as far as im concerned i would’ve have done the same (but not for a free couch or anything like that, i would have done it to call the store out on their mistake)
(P.S for those who say why would the 7yr-old question the N word if she didnt know it…um when you dont know something dont question it..cuz i know i do)

Posted by: AW | April 11, 2007, 5:42 pm 5:42 pm

I think that people are getting too worked up over a stupid word. Im 14 years old and have been taught the old “sticks n stones” by many adults. Yet when something like this comes up everyone has to make a huge fuss over it. Please someone listen to any rap. This stuff is everywhere, but no one seems to care much. But then “OH NO! my couch has the N word on it” this gets more publicity then the entire american youth being exposed to these words daily by people like 50 cent and Ludicras. So please, either get angry at every time someone uses the N word, or don’t get mad at all. Geez.

Posted by: Stairwayth | April 11, 2007, 5:53 pm 5:53 pm

Seriously,
Am I the only one who thinks that this “innocent mistake was poorly handled by the Business that sold the couch to the point of it becoming news?
“Moore immediately called the furniture store, Vanaik, from where she and her husband purchased the couches, but received no response. So she contacted a local television station, Toronto’s City News, who tracked down the store manager.”
Some racism apologists are not even bothered by the bait-and-switch tactics that were used by the business (i.e. Italy=China)!!!

Posted by: Tim | April 11, 2007, 5:57 pm 5:57 pm

*** is a made up word, so what translation software would have mistranslated this word unless it was first programmed to do so.
Get Real!!

Posted by: KL | April 11, 2007, 6:24 pm 6:24 pm

This could be better than winning the lottery, getting too-hot coffee from McDonalds, or not knowing that Ambien has a “may cause drowsieness” side effect. Get the lawyers! Get Hillary warmed up for a photo op! Get Real!

Posted by: MatthewG | April 11, 2007, 6:36 pm 6:36 pm

Tighe–
This is America. My ancestors were stolen from Africa. I am however, proud to be an African American.
Black is a color, were not black.
The Chinese live in China. The Japanese live in Japan. The Italians live in Italy. The British live in Britain. Due to ignorance, greed, status & power, America has chosen to place emphasis on race. This is why America will NEVER reach its full potential.

Posted by: KL | April 11, 2007, 6:55 pm 6:55 pm

The “emotional” reaction that some feel upon hearing this word is a perfect example of how many people’s attitudes are shaped by gut-level reaction as opposed to logic. Although I understand the severity of the uproar, it makes little logical sense, and I worry that those who “feel the pain” may be no more sensible than those who may unknowingly inflict it.

Posted by: C Shaffer | April 11, 2007, 6:58 pm 6:58 pm

How did the discussion of the color of the ssofa as identified by thr manufacturer turn into a discussion about Al Sharton? After reading most of the comments on this site, I got a real feel for the number of racists there are left in the world. It is a sorry thing that there are stil so many ill-informed people who think they are better because of the color of their skins. As long as there are ignorant racists, the mother will not be able to protect her daughter from the word **

Posted by: Gloria P | April 11, 2007, 7:08 pm 7:08 pm

I briefly scanned through the comments and got tired of people who are NOT African Americans say “Get over it”. Please tell me how when society is constantly bombarded by things like this. Some of you say it was an innocent mistake (translation error) – well let’s do something to correct it. Some of you said ‘blacks say it among themselves and nobody says anything’. You call your mom, “mom” and your sister, “sister” and your lover “sweetheart’ or whatever. What would you think if I took the same liberty? Don’t minimize something that you could NEVER begin to understand unless it has happened to you. Can any of you claim that your ancestors were enslaved, that your culture and heritage were stripped away and that you were not considered a human being. When you can, then perhaps you have a right to tell African Americans to ‘just get over it.”

Posted by: Joyce | April 11, 2007, 7:18 pm 7:18 pm

Man. I should print myself a label that says Honky White and sue everyone and go to the news and demand apologies from Richard Pryor’s estate and Eddie Murphy and all other Black comedians who have insulted white people. Im insulted and I want a cookie because Im entitled. What a nation of whimps and whiners.
I guess racial slurs are completely wrong except in rap music which absolutely denigrates women and destroys the black community.
Is it just me or Do Rev. Sharpton and Jackson just move from place to place wanting ‘Sorries’ all the time?
Si vis pacem, para bellum.

Posted by: napolean | April 11, 2007, 7:27 pm 7:27 pm

As a young black male, living in New Jersey I can accept the apology that Don Imus made, but the whole outlandish marches and backlash is for the birds. Rappers and black comedians get off scott free when referring to blacks as ho’s, ***s, bitches and anything else deemed degrading. One of the hottest songs on the radio right now is “Make it rain” by Fat Joe (a hispanic rapper) mind you that I bet some of those girls from RU basketball team have jammed out to the song but if anyone listens to it’s referring to ejacuating on women or hoes as the song says. Another thing Imus said the other day during his incounter with the “rev.” al sharpton, the dreeded “you people” , hey “my people” how many times do “we” say “our community or our people” so when this old white guy says is we get all bent out of shape?? i dont get it, lets stop the double standard stuff!

Posted by: NJGUY | April 11, 2007, 7:28 pm 7:28 pm

All of this is besides the point. What matters is whether the distributor’s arguement carries any weight. I can’t imagine any software which would translate any color into n*****. In other languages, negre, noire, are all words for black, but that’s not what the label says. In to language is n***** an actual word that software would accidentally use in a translation

Posted by: Jon | April 11, 2007, 7:34 pm 7:34 pm

“Niger
Niger, black”
If anyone actually used their brains they’d know it was a translation error. It happens all the time.
Thistle seed also comes in a “Niger” variety, and I can see a possibility for translation errors there too.
-D

Posted by: Damon | April 11, 2007, 7:45 pm 7:45 pm

What a scam! This Lady is trying to get something for nothing, and feels good about it, bacause its white/asian people she is trying to extort money out of.
Why are we not talking about her racisim, and using her own child
in the commision of what most consider a crime?

Posted by: Jac_Gas | April 11, 2007, 7:46 pm 7:46 pm

I think that is hilarious! I always wondered what shade was considered **** color.

Posted by: Don | April 11, 2007, 7:46 pm 7:46 pm

Thanks Kay, Bryan for your intelect and empathy regarding this situation. Thanks also Bob Gilmore for clarifying to these people who obviously did not read or understood the artlce being referenced. Well said Slick, Faye Mitchell, Eric. I have one comment to those of you who’s forefathers enslaved and created this derogative name(****)to taunt and degrade a race of people for your own interest have NO RIGHT to tell someone to “Get over ANYTHING”. The best you can do is to be empathetic to these people who have experienced this insult. Do not critizize them or tell them how they should feel or tell anyone how BP use the N-word amongst each other until you have fully understood the devastating impact SLAVERY/RACISM has on a society, otherwise make no comment!

Posted by: The Truth Hurts | April 11, 2007, 8:09 pm 8:09 pm

For the lady who made a comment about black colleges and scholarships for blacks only. Anyone can go to any historically black college you do not have to be black to go there, if you are turned down it will more than likely be because of your GPA than your race, just not a whole lot of whites apply or attend Historically Black Colleges.
As for scholarships for blacks only, well there are scholarships that are only for Hispanics and Native Americans and yes even Whites. Back in the mid to late 90′s Alabama State had scholarships just for Whites to help desegregate the school, blacks applied for the scholarships and were turned down because of their race. The State soon had to change the scholarships to mix race but still blacks could not apply and be awarded those scholarships. When it comes to scholarships there are many out there that are awarded on any reason. You have a certain last name, your parents or grandparents went to a certain university, etc…

Posted by: Lisa Brooks | April 11, 2007, 8:09 pm 8:09 pm

This is my first and probably last visit to the so called “forum”. I should be amazed (but I am not)at the raw ignorance displayed in these E-mails. Fortunately, I do not believe this is representative of maany Whites I have known over the years. Thousands worked for me and they all had the ability to structure a simple sentence or correctly spell a one syllable word. However, racism is alive and well and its adherents find refuge and aanonymity in Imus, Lim baugh, and forums such as these. Ironically, I bet many of you go to segregated churches on Sunday with lofty expectations. Disappointment will surely follow. The use of racist words is emblematic of the powerful versus the powerless. If a Black person calls a White person a name, it has very little consequence since (1) there are no really hurtful words to use, (2) very few Blacks have any economic control over Whites. Do you really believe that a white who choses to use these words and have power over Blacks are going to play fair? This the real crux of the issue.

Posted by: James | April 11, 2007, 8:10 pm 8:10 pm

what you people seem not to understand is that we, as African American people have been oppressed for ages..we were slaves people, do you all understand that! we were made to enter thru the back doors..sit at the back of the bus..giving the leftovers from everyone else..what do u not understand..i know that our people need to work together and change things within our own community..Come on people! it’s not ok..we do not need to get over it..this type of behavior is not ok from anyone..please..wake up.

Posted by: jenell | April 11, 2007, 10:51 pm 10:51 pm

After reading comments this afternoon, I searched for the word on the internet:
_________________________________
Used in combinations (e.g. nigger-brown, nigger-head, nigger-toe) since 1840s for various dark brown or black hues or objects; euphemistic substitutions (e.g. Zulu) began to appear in these senses c.1917.
_________________________________
It is not a pretty word, for sure, however, it stands to reason that it was used as a color description, only–
Other countries many times use words or phrases that in interpretation, are at best awkward, and depending on what any particular person is sensitive about–could be construed as hurtful. This was not a personally directed insult.
I am fat,and have been called purposefully hurtful names many times in my life; but I sure hope I don’t start getting insulted every time I hear or see any “fatty” word.

Posted by: linda | April 12, 2007, 12:37 am 12:37 am

I really doubt that the store owner was even aware what was on the tag. How many pieces of furniture pass through his store? How many tags does he personally inspect? The story did say that the item came from Italy. Do we know enough about the Itallian culture and slang to know this was meant to be a insulting? Hopfully this has all been a painful misunderstanding.

Posted by: DON | April 12, 2007, 2:37 am 2:37 am

Etymology: alteration of earlier neger, from Middle French negre, from Spanish or Portuguese negro, from negro black, from Latin niger.
Some people need to get over their paranoia!
Why do you get so upset over being called ‘negroid’,black, which only denotes your origins, but you want to be called ‘AFRICAN-AMERICAN’, which you are not!
Most of you (black & white) would have trouble finding Africa on a map and you have surely never been there.
Drop the ‘AFRICAN’ and just be an American. I think you will find that people will have fewer problems with you. Claiming to be something that you are not just irritates people.

Posted by: P RAY | April 12, 2007, 3:39 am 3:39 am

jenell, many Europeans also came to America as ‘slaves’(indentured servants) and were treated the same as the blacks, but you don’t hear them crying about it all the time, the way the blacks do.
Besides, don’t blame the whites for all your past problems, your own ‘race?’ captured people from neighboring tribes and sold them to Arab slave traders, who in turn, sold them to America.
So, if you wish to place blame, look to Africa!!!
As a Native American, I probably have as much right to whine as you do, but I accept it as just being part of history. So should you.

Posted by: P RAY | April 12, 2007, 4:59 am 4:59 am

PRAY,
Once again the problem against was not so much SLAVERY as it WAS and IS RACISM!!!!!There were never any seperate cars or barriers imposed on those “European slaves” onces they were{or had} free themselves of their indenturedness. However, even the returning military Blacks who had the served the US overseas in World War II were being made to give their seats for captured NAZI POWs?!!!!! This was LONG after Slavery had been Outlawed in the USA. If you feel as Native American who has more right to whine but has chosen, you can go ahead and congratulate yourself on your “high/Superior” morality but do not expect those who see “RACISM to pretend they do not see any!!

Posted by: Tim | April 12, 2007, 9:44 am 9:44 am

I am an importer and recognise this simply and likely very unintentionally as an oversight by the sofa importer …not a translation error. In fact, throughout Europe one can find items called N…..referring to only color black. A candy item from Scandinavia is very popular and called N…..Kisses! It is chocolate covered marshmallow. This is all just an oversight on part of importer who ought to have erased or snipped the sofa tag to avoid offending hypersensitive people in N.America.

Posted by: RegH | April 12, 2007, 10:30 am 10:30 am

So Don Imus has been raked across the coals for making inappropriate comments. I get that. But who is Al Sharpton to complain, when he appeared in a Saturday Night Live skit, (as the REVEREND Al Sharpton) called Al’s Chicken Shack?
Pardon me, Mr. Sharpton, but aren’t you propogating the very stereotype you’re slamming Don Imus for?
Though I’m not defending him, worse comments have been aired that what Imus said.

Posted by: Doug | April 12, 2007, 11:28 am 11:28 am

Just one more example of the ultra high standards of Chinese quallity control.

Posted by: American QC | April 12, 2007, 1:47 pm 1:47 pm

Two words:
Tawana Brawley
Google it, then talk to me about apologies.

Posted by: nicole | April 12, 2007, 3:22 pm 3:22 pm

LOTS of GUILTY conscious here trying to MINIMIZE the ISSUE in order not to SHOW the UGLINESS of what their ancestors perpetrated in the past . e.g someone said Richard pryor and eddie murphy make fun of whites.One problem here.. there is NOTHING a person of colour can say to a white person that can offend them; last time I check BLACK NEVER HAD WHITES AS SLAVES; so EXCUSE US when something RACIST IS SAID or WRIITEN .. to go ballistic.Some WHITES here have no business giving an OPINION.. they are NOT on a receiving end of these SLURS; So what the heck do they KNOW.

Posted by: R taylor | April 12, 2007, 3:55 pm 3:55 pm

As a gay man, I can say I’ve experienced slurs similar to those of black Americans. So telling me I can’t voice my opinion because I’m white makes me a little angry. Anyone has a right to voice their opinion on any issue, but minorities especially on this issue.
Think about it: Would this be that big of a deal if I got a piece of furniture whose color was *** Blue? I don’t think so.

Posted by: GMan | April 12, 2007, 4:21 pm 4:21 pm

R Taylor
So what is your opinion about American Indians and their treatment? Just because you are black does not give you a free pass to use the race card for every situation for the rest of time. I do not throw around my ethnic background to gain notoriaty, fame, free merchandise everytime someone says Indian giver, or any other ridiculious comment. If you don’t let go of the past, the future will never happen. Make up your mind if you want equally or if you want to hold onto your anger until the end of time. The color of you skin does not pay your bills even if you are white, it doesn’t put food on the table for your kids. Every race struggles and to think your struggles are worse than anyone elses is sheer narrowmindedness, oh, and racist. Be careful who you call racist, because you maybe one yourself.

Posted by: Jersey | April 12, 2007, 4:27 pm 4:27 pm

this is just dumb. everywhere in the world (except usa and canada) the N word just refers to the color, has nothing to do with racial slur.
its a translation issue that needs to be worked out and is not a big deal at all.

Posted by: chris | April 12, 2007, 4:46 pm 4:46 pm

I think that this lady just wants a free couch while Imus did actually go too far. two very different stories, unrelated at all.

Posted by: chris | April 12, 2007, 4:47 pm 4:47 pm

To R. Taylor et al.
First off, none of the blacks writing in here has ever been held as a slave here in America, so stop whining. Second, whites have been held as slaves by blacks in Africa, usually when white sailors wrecked off the coast of Africa made it to land and were taken as slaves by the locals, so stop the self righteousness. And anyone can be the subject of slurs regardless of their race or position in society, it is just a matter of what the slur is about e.g. it could be a slur about gays, or Italians, or Packer fans. Secondly whites in America are enslaved in a way by blacks in the form of the vast amounts of taxes collected to support what is largely a black population of welfare receiptients. Every time a single unemployed black woman chooses to have unprotected sex and then has a child with no means of her own or the baby’s daddy to support it she further enslaves the general tax paying population, mostly whites, by putting it on their financial resources to provide for said child. Also many white communities in American cities are enslaved in that their freedom of movement is restricted by the constant threat of unpredictable and senseless violence coming from the black communties.

Posted by: Barry G | April 12, 2007, 5:14 pm 5:14 pm

To Barry G
FIRST off! before you post anything in the future you better GET with the FACTS; your line of ‘whites get burden with taxes to support blacks who are on welfare”…ROFL. That would be all well and nice… ONE PROBLEM! MORE WHITES ARE ON WELFARE THAN BLACKS; Its common sense you are the MAJORITY; So run along and try something else;..—>SIGH.

Posted by: R Taylor | April 13, 2007, 2:00 am 2:00 am

If all you have to say is “get over it,” obviously you think this is acceptable. And the point about “black people using the word” is irrelevant
simply because she said her daughter has never heard it. I don’t know why it is that some of you people feel the need to trivialize something like this. Oh wait — I remember; it’s because it doesn’t offend you. It’s because you don’t know the meaning behind the word. It’s because you don’t know the history of the way it was used. IT IS because YOUR ancestors were not subjected to the hatred behind the word for 400 years.
I get it. It’s because you don’t understand. If I got a couch or anything for that matter with a hateful word labeled on it I would be offended. I would then hold whatever company the product came from responsible. It’s like if someone calls in for customer service somewhere and JOHN DOE (the rep) calls him/her (the customer) something offensive. JOHN DOE represents the company and one would then hold the company responsible even though the CEO might not even know who the hell JOHN DOE is. You guys amaze me more and more eveyday– and I hope that doesn’t offend you too much.

Posted by: gr | April 13, 2007, 9:03 am 9:03 am

yeah should of checked the labeling just lost a $1300 and more

Posted by: Whoyou thinkyouare | April 13, 2007, 10:29 am 10:29 am

white people are smart… you all say the right things to try and keep my people down..WHY? because you all are scared that African americans will one day very soom be better off than every biggot in the world… And white people are also jealous.. why do you all tan and get lip injections because yall want to be black! I dont know what they do in other countries so i cant say if that comment was a mistake or not but i do know that world can hurt… No now black people are not slaves but that is a very derogatory term that is just bad to use… I know that there are black people who use the n word and i think that is very bad mabey worst then when a white person says it but lets say there is a name just your friends or family call you Like FAT BOY it may be okay for them to say it but when someone you dont know says it

Posted by: DANIEL | April 13, 2007, 10:53 am 10:53 am

Yeah, Ron more whites total may be on welfare given that blacks are only about 14% of the total pop. but a vastly higher PERCENTAGE of blacks are collecting.

Posted by: Barry G | April 13, 2007, 11:21 am 11:21 am

I am glad that some of you find the n-word offensive when it is being directed at a person of color.
And, yes, the word is still being used in our community and it is an issue that we African-Americans have to deal with by applying heat to the African-American entertainers as well.
Perhaps, in a few more generations this word will only mean “black” in spanish, as one of you mentioned earlier. But for now, whether you can understand it or not the word remains hurtful to many.
Also, just because the Reverends Jackson and Sharpton stepped to the fore on this issue doesn’t mean they speak for the entire group.
As far as Mr. Imus’s comments are concerned, AA’s have always had to endure jokes and ill-humor. Recall the days of Stepin Fetchit and the minstrel shows that blatantly made fun of African-Americans.
Get over it? I don’t so.

Posted by: Cburn | April 13, 2007, 12:42 pm 12:42 pm

Come on! Find one more sofa with this label and I’ll believe this lady. Don’t find another and she’s the racist by stirring the pot.

Posted by: R. Phelps | April 13, 2007, 2:01 pm 2:01 pm

That couch would look great in my living room.

Posted by: Scott | April 13, 2007, 2:16 pm 2:16 pm

He made a mistake, he learned his lesson, why does he have to be fired. Racism will never go away until all races let it. Even when a commit is made not in hate, people make more of it. African-Americans, anglo, hisp, ect are all equal and made from the same love. In order for racism to end you have to be able to let it. To some that is all that keeps them going.

Posted by: tammie | April 13, 2007, 2:28 pm 2:28 pm

barry g
JUST STOP! you are sinking further in your ignorance; Show me the RAW DATA from a reputable national census site… that SHOW the amount of BLACKS on WELFARE and the total amount of BLACKS in AMERICA; And lets see if your stereotype assumtion that the majority is on welfare.

Posted by: R Taylor | April 13, 2007, 2:51 pm 2:51 pm

Can any of you claim that your ancestors were enslaved, that your culture and heritage were stripped away and that you were not considered a human being. When you can, then perhaps you have a right to tell African Americans to ‘just get over it.”
Posted by: Joyce | Apr 11, 2007 7:18:41 PM
=================================
How about the people held in concentration camps like Dachau and Auschwitz and also the peoples of eastern Europe who were imprisoned until just recent history.

Posted by: zee | April 13, 2007, 3:37 pm 3:37 pm

I am very sure that this was a translation error. The Chineese don’t even have such words in the language. We all know that niger is another word for black or sometimes dark, so the label said niger-brown meaning dark brown the mistake is clearly seen here. I believe that the complaintant is just looking for the payoff!!! Come on this is not the store owners fault. Also I doubt very seriously that the daughter has never heard this word. Listen to the radio or BET and you here it all day.

Posted by: Mark | April 13, 2007, 5:05 pm 5:05 pm

Did the white race not hollar about their being a problem in the world because they are now the minority instead of the majority. Yes this family has a right to be very upset, and when did you ask your white anglo skin-heads to pipe down,or the kkk to stop lynching,or the millions of other offenses your race has committed against other races. simple mistake, maybe, but the family is justified in their feelings toward the word *****

Posted by: dee | April 13, 2007, 5:53 pm 5:53 pm

Thats right we should punish people for things they didn’t do just because the don’t like a word that was translated wrong by a person who has no clue what that word means. This is all about the money and you know it!!!!

Posted by: Mark | April 14, 2007, 11:02 am 11:02 am

People in China don’t even use English. To them, it is just different marks on paper, so how can they understand that in these two countries, out of the entire world, that this term is offensive? I just saw the movie ‘Bamboozled,’ and all I could think of, all the way through it, was, “And they fired Imus?” Ms. Moore should watch Spike Lee’s brilliant representation of upper-level black humor (ha ha). I had a black man once tell me all whites were racist, because we had owned slaves. I informed him I have never owned another human being, and for that matter, neither had any of my ancestors, as the original member of my family who came to the colonies came as an indentured servant, which was not that far removed from slavery. As a kidm I was called four-eyes, in my professional life, I was subjected to a number of slang terms for cop, and since I became disabled, I have been called a crip and worse. Hmmmm, where’s my lawyer, I could double or triple my SSDI. Oh, also, as part Native American, you people who are so offended by words, GET OVER IT, ALREADY!

Posted by: Allen | April 15, 2007, 4:33 am 4:33 am

Amen Brother!!! I am part Native American my self. Where is my retribution??? This crap of saying we were slaves is nonsense. Most blacks in this country never had a ancestor that was in-slaved, that’s a racial misrepresented get something free card. You all should be ashamed to even claim something like that!! For those who were in-slaved, they would surely not approve of your actions!! I don’t think hurtful words should be used at all!! Tell all those so called rap artist to stop using them!!! Tell them to stop singing about killing cops and whites!! Talk about a hypocrite!!!!

Posted by: Mark | April 15, 2007, 10:22 am 10:22 am

It’s now like looking for a prize in the cereal box. “Where can I find something that I can say offends me and there are enough people with misplaced guilt or so full of fear that they won’t question me?” Comrade Stalin, welcome to North America!

Posted by: ricardo max | April 17, 2007, 6:59 am 6:59 am

You guys don’t get it. This is not about Imus or rap artists. The woman did not say that she ever used the N word. If her daughter did not know about the word then it’s obvious that she is not in the habbit of saying it. If she is uncomfortable with this couch she should return it. Depending on how they handle the situation she may need to sue. Don’t be so blazay with the N word because it does not personally offend YOU!

Posted by: 911insidejob | April 17, 2007, 10:26 pm 10:26 pm

wow this artical got freeped, huge conservative response with very consistant ideology coming from small percentage of people, to skew public opinion towards drudge savage limbough hannity etc. they will do all to distract from the devastation a small group in power who are criminals not conservatives to devastate this country in 5 years. A foolish arrogant war started on a lie thinking it would ensure gop majoritys and oil company profits for years

Posted by: DAN | April 19, 2007, 8:04 am 8:04 am

What are you talking about? This has absolutly nothing to do with Bush and the Iraq war. Talk about a SPIN!!! WOW is right!!!

Posted by: Mark | April 19, 2007, 5:55 pm 5:55 pm

I say, get over it !! Seems everything is about money and suing to me. I hear more African American’s use the N word than any other race combined. So, why don’t you sue them!! Get a grip, if you can’t sit on the sofa, return it and by a white one!

Posted by: Barbara | April 19, 2007, 10:04 pm 10:04 pm

Does this really require a lawsuit? This is a joke. This woman needs some real hardship in her life. Some people just love to be the victim.

Posted by: JOe | April 19, 2007, 11:54 pm 11:54 pm

It’s been almost two weeks since the ‘discovery’ yet she still has the sofa. She contends it was offensive, yet it is still in her home – as was discussed on a local talk radio station.
The longer she holds on to this offensive ‘thing’ the less I am inclined to believe that her moral outrage is genuine.
It is most curious that she would not immediately get rid of something that caused so much anguish.

Posted by: Torontonian | April 20, 2007, 9:27 pm 9:27 pm

Leave a Reply

Do you have more information about this topic? If so, please click here to contact the editors of ABC News.