By Thomas Nagorski

Dec 29, 2008 1:18pm

Middle East Muddle: Gaza, Obama & “All-Out War”

For much of the campaign it was accepted wisdom — or at least it was presented as such by the GOP: Barack Obama was not the stalwart friend of Israel that George W. Bush and other U.S. presidents have been. The moniker "candidate of change" did not sit well with staunch supporters of Israel, who have found the status quo just fine when it comes to U.S.-Israeli relations. Rightly or wrongly, Obama the candidate was tarred by association with Pastor Jeremiah Wright, whose anti-Israel comments were well-documented. And Obama is still seen by many in the region to be — on the scale of U.S. politicians at least — more supportive than most when it comes to the rights of Palestinians. At any rate, sooner than he might have expected, Barack Obama will have to face these questions as a practical rather than theoretical matter. It is hard to imagine that within three weeks the situation in Gaza will have calmed much — and easy to imagine the opposite. More than three hundred people have died and another fourteen hundred been wounded in the Israeli operation thus far; and the Israeli government is calling this an "all-out war" on Hamas. President Obama will in rapid fashion be forced to fill in the nearly blank slate that is his record on the Israeli-Palestinian question. Soon it won’t suffice to say, as he does now, "there’s one president at a time"; soon that one president will be Barack Obama himself.

User Comments

Obama won’t be president for 3 more weeks. Give it a rest already.

Posted by: Cameron | December 29, 2008, 1:31 pm 1:31 pm

Israel has no greater friend, no greater ally, in the war on terror as they have in just about anyone else apart from President Elect Barack Obama. Hillary – please help him.

Posted by: C | December 29, 2008, 1:40 pm 1:40 pm

Huuummmmm . . . . . . .
I wonder if NoBo says just the right things in a nice way he can get Hamas to stop launching mortars into Israel.

Posted by: Noz | December 29, 2008, 1:41 pm 1:41 pm

==Hillary – please help him. ==
Saudi Arabia, for example, has given her bubby hubby millions. What will she have to give them as pay-back?

Posted by: Mr. Incredible | December 29, 2008, 1:48 pm 1:48 pm

==I wonder if NoBo says just the right things in a nice way he can get Hamas to stop launching mortars into Israel.==
Maybe he will invite them to tea and cookies.

Posted by: Mr. Incredible | December 29, 2008, 1:49 pm 1:49 pm

Hopefully BO can look at this situation more objectively than previous US presidents. Time will tell. As for the he won’t be pres for three more weeks comment…don’t worry, they will still be fighting in one capacity or another…he will have more than his shot at the problem.

Posted by: samhiguchi | December 29, 2008, 1:51 pm 1:51 pm

Obama will certainly do better than Bush; Bush having done nothing in 8 years.
Israel politics have been a problem for all sitting Presidents since it’s beginning. Why would anyone expect anything different from Obama?

Posted by: Thinking | December 29, 2008, 2:11 pm 2:11 pm

Barack what did the children and the elderly of Gaza do to deserve to die??? I guess it doesn’t matter to you as long as you and Joe get to cash the checks from the Israelis, huh? Utter disgrace, you and your friend George W. are a traitor to humanity.

Posted by: please! | December 29, 2008, 2:31 pm 2:31 pm

Let’s hope he is an honest broker. To have peace all settlements in the West Bank and the checkpoints associated with them need to go away. It is unreasonable for us to expect that the Palestinians will accept being caged and fenced in little areas and enjoy it. This latest Hamas rocket firing and Israeli escalation is not at the heart of the problem. The heart of the problem is the occupation of Israelis within the territories. This is a completely separate argument from the one about Israel’s right to exist.

Posted by: Ben Straub | December 29, 2008, 2:33 pm 2:33 pm

As usual, the neo-cons are busy trying to blame events on Obama even though he isn’t president. If you want to throw mud, try throwing at Bush and Rice, Israel slaughtering the Palestinians is their work not Obama’s.

Posted by: JR | December 29, 2008, 2:37 pm 2:37 pm

“Israel politics have been a problem for all sitting Presidents since it’s beginning. Why would anyone expect anything different from Obama?” – Thinking
Good point Thinking.
That’s why I’m not expecting any Change regarding this issue and that may be why someone like Sarah Silverman felt safe voting for BHO.

Posted by: Noz | December 29, 2008, 2:37 pm 2:37 pm

Let’s give Obama his chance. Bush has been a failure, McCain would have been disastrous, and Obama probably will not be that great, but he deserves a chance to prove himself. US foreign policy needs to change drastically. I foresee the coming economic collapse as a blessing in disguise, at least with regards to foreign policy.

Posted by: Ben Straub | December 29, 2008, 2:44 pm 2:44 pm

“The heart of the problem is the occupation of Israelis within the territories. This is a completely separate argument from the one about Israel’s right to exist.” – Ben Straub
Ben buddy, the heart of the problem lies north, in Tehran.

Posted by: Noz | December 29, 2008, 2:44 pm 2:44 pm

Noz – Thanks for the perspective. Of course you are not completely correct. Let’s remember the US (the only country to use nukes on population centers and the country that invades a new country about every other year) is telling Iran (a country that has not attacked anyone preemptively in 250 years) that they Iran can not have nukes in order to protect the country Israel ( a country that keeps millions of Palestinians locked up via checkpoints, and continues to land grab for illegal settlements). Given this perspective the problem lies in DC and Tel Aviv. I am no fan of Iran’s leadership, but I sympathize with the Palestinian plight. The Israelis are guilty of grave humanitarian crimes, and this latest bombing campaign is another. I encourage you to take a look at the map of the West Bank and note the 1000 or so settlements carving up the place. If you still feel that Israel is in the right then we won’t make any headway.

Posted by: Ben Straub | December 29, 2008, 2:51 pm 2:51 pm

Israel citizens living in illegal settlements.
1966 0
1972 10,608
1983 106,595
1993 281,800
2004 441,165
2006 484,562
I encourage everyone to go to wilkipedia and look at the settlement locations. It is no wonder why the Palestinians have lost hope and resorted to violence.

Posted by: Ben Straub | December 29, 2008, 2:54 pm 2:54 pm

==Obama will certainly do better than Bush; Bush having done nothing in 8 years.==
Really??? “Nothing”???
==Let’s give Obama his chance.==
Yeah, the kinda chance Libs gave Bush in 2000.
== Bush has been a failure…==
That’s the Lib Pr, anyway.
==US foreign policy needs to change drastically.==
Translation: “More in line with the Lib philosophy of tea and cookies for terrorists.”
== I foresee the coming economic collapse as a blessing in disguise, at least with regards to foreign policy.==
Translation: “I’ve been hoping and waiting for the other shoe to drop on America, and I’m glad it is doing just that.”

Posted by: Mr. Incredible | December 29, 2008, 2:58 pm 2:58 pm

Thinking….you aren’t thinking. Hamas is a fully funded arm of the Iranian government;a government hell bent on the death of Israel but also a governemt that tried to muck things up in Iraq. While Our sitting President called them for what they are the one to be President wants to have a chat with them….maybe it will work, maybe it won’t but one thing for is for sure and that is that the current President has created a climate to where now Iranian refuges are pouring into of all places….Iraq.

Posted by: david | December 29, 2008, 3:03 pm 3:03 pm

==The heart of the problem is the occupation of Israelis within the territories.==
and
==Israel slaughtering the Palestinians…==
not to mention
==The Israelis are guilty of grave humanitarian crimes, and this latest bombing campaign is another. ==
and still
==It is no wonder why the Palestinians have lost hope and resorted to violence.==
Nothing in any of that to indicate that Hamas announced, recently, the end of the truce with Israel.
Nothing to indicate that it is Hamas that started up the violence again by lobbing rockets into Israel, threatening and jeopardizing the lives of women and children.
According to those posters, it’s the victim’s fault. Blame the victim for the crime.

Posted by: Mr. Incredible | December 29, 2008, 3:05 pm 3:05 pm

Mr. Incredible – There are reports out of other news outlets in Europe and the Middle East that says that Israel killed around 20 Palestinians during the truce. They also flew over Gaza militarily during the truce and conducted a couple of assasinations. It would be nice if our media would emphasize these things too in concert with the recent rocket attacks that killed an Israeli.

Posted by: Ben Straub | December 29, 2008, 3:11 pm 3:11 pm

==You always have to ask what a terrorist’s motivations are.==
I’d buy a ticket to see the look on your family’s faces when you tell them that, if they die at the hand of a terrorist, they must consider the terrorist’s motivations.
== If you have policies in place that result in their loved ones being killed, you should expect reprisals.==
And that’s why Israel attacks them anew, after Hamas attacked Israel with rockets. Get the chronology correct, at least.
== The Golden Rule really does hold water.==
So, why doesn’t Hamas comply with it?
== The economic collapse is of our own doing.==
Not my doing and not Republicans’ doing. Republicans wanted regulation of the housing finance industry; Dems like Frank wanted everybody to have a house, and, so, they opposed regulation.
== We consume and borrow too much.==
Garbage.
== We do not save or produce enough.==
Plenty of people do just that.
== Our children worship Lohan and Spears rather than James Clerk Maxwell and the like.==
Whose fault is THAT? Not mine.
== The food we eat is nutrient-free, gmo, processed to the hilt garbage.==
And, yet, you people buy it.
== And you wonder why the healthcare system is collapsing.==
And, yet, it’s not. It doesn’t work well in Canada.
== Yes an economic collapse will be a much needed lesson on all fronts, especially foreign policy.==
Uh, not really. Our foreign policy won’t change cuz it doesn’t have to change.
Economic policy of individuals is changing the oil landscape, though. OPEC finds that it is not stopping the price drop by cutting production cuz drivers continue to consume less.
== You are just another neocon that is contributing to our downward spiral.==
That’s the Lib PR, anyway.
== Thanks for supporting this trillion dollar war and the next one that comes along. ==
You’re welcomed. Glad I can help a neighbor get back on his feet.

Posted by: Mr. Incredible | December 29, 2008, 3:14 pm 3:14 pm

==There are reports out of other news outlets in Europe and the Middle East that says that Israel killed around 20 Palestinians during the truce.==
“Reports.”
Israel would not take that chance to be blamed. If they killed anybody, it was cuz they were attacked. Israel has been remarkably reluctant to fight back.
==They also flew over Gaza militarily during the truce and conducted a couple of assasinations.==
Not without provocation.
== It would be nice if our media would emphasize these things too…==
Translation: “It would be nice if our media would align itself with world media that are anti-America.”
Aren’t they already?

Posted by: Mr. Incredible | December 29, 2008, 3:17 pm 3:17 pm

Mr. Incredible – Let’s look at numbers:
US sponsored sanctions on Iraq during the 90 killed 500,000. Albright on national news said these deaths were worth it. Our latest intervention has created an environment where another 200,000-500,000 have been killed. 2 million Iraqis are now refugees, and the Christians have been purged from Iraq. Surely motivations exists?
During this truce Israel hasn’t been all peaches and cream…see my previous post.
We don’t consume too much? Ok you are delusional.
We produce plenty….maybe gas after eating an obese enabling meal.
I do not buy this food. I grow my own and go organic.
PR Lib eh?

Posted by: Ben Straub | December 29, 2008, 3:20 pm 3:20 pm

It’s always America and Israel’s fault. It’s never Hamas’, nor Hezbollah’s, fault; they’re just innocent bystanders.

Posted by: Mr. Incredible | December 29, 2008, 3:22 pm 3:22 pm

Mr. Incredible – You just keep convincing yourself that Israel is so high and mighty. Again go and look and the map of the settlements. If you still think Israel is in the right than you are an impediment to so called world peace.

Posted by: Ben Straub | December 29, 2008, 3:22 pm 3:22 pm

==Mr. Incredible – You just keep convincing yourself that Israel is so high and mighty.==
Nobody is high and mighty. Israel is merely defending herself, having resisted, against practical and Moral self-interest, defending herself.
== Again go and look and the map of the settlements.==
If you think that settlements equals the Right to drop rockets into Israel, then YOU are an impediment to world peace.

Posted by: Mr. Incredible | December 29, 2008, 3:25 pm 3:25 pm

Mr. Incredible – Now you are getting desperate. I do not like violence per say, so I do not condone the acts of Hezbollah and Hamas. This includes their propaganda and using civilians as shields, but I also do not condone Israel or the US militaristic adventures either. If you look at numbers dead, Israel and the US kill orders of magnitudes more civilians. Someone like you might say that this occurs because the US and Israel are so awesome and powerful. To the powerful go the spoils I suppose. However, as a Christian US taxpayer, I must voice my dissaproval at US weapons being used on civilians expecially in light of the minimal damage done to Israel and the setllement and land demaracation issue in the occupied territories.

Posted by: Ben Straub | December 29, 2008, 3:28 pm 3:28 pm

Ben Straub,
Care to completely rewrite history while your at it? Before being critical of our use of the atomic bomb, you should actually talk to some WWII vets who fought in the Pacific. You will learn a lot more than trying to read someones ideas of what they think was going to happen back then. those men expereinced first hand what an invasion of Japan would result in.
Im so tired of bleeding heart liberals who think wars can be executed with kind of high level moralistic code. That crap only goes on in the movies. If your enemy is willing to kill himself in an attempt to kill you, there are no rules! Ask anyone who was on a WWII ship that got hit by a kamikazie attack. Or those who had to deal walk into villages in Veitnam not knowing if the kids running up to you was glad to see you, or ready to kill you. Today in Iraq, Afganistan and other places, the same scenario.
For allyou Obamabots….in a few days, you get stop whining about Bush ….oh…let me guess, if Obama fails…its still Bush’s fault…right?

Posted by: Mike_C | December 29, 2008, 3:28 pm 3:28 pm

Mr. Incredible – Maybe you are right. The Palestinians should accept there situation in which Israel controls the power, water, and food transport into Gaza. Maybe the Palestinians should accept being fenced into small areas in the West Bank. The Palestinains should go Gandi and MLK with peaceful protests. Surely Israel will dissolve all of these settlements. Surely.

Posted by: Ben Straub | December 29, 2008, 3:30 pm 3:30 pm

Straub,
I have a wonderful idea, since you obviously have all the answers to all the problems. Why don’t you go to Gaza and live amongst Hamas for a while. By the way, make sure you tell them your an American & that you are their to help them!
I’m sure they will greet you with open arms and agree to whatever terms you propose!

Posted by: Mike_C | December 29, 2008, 3:32 pm 3:32 pm

What actions by the President would you liberals like him or Obama to take. Short of invading another country to stop this conflict, talking will not get the job done. Lets go for change and let them solve their own problems. We could do more in Africa to save millions but when less than 500 people die we get all up in arms. Many of your are just good old American bigots when it comes to the Jewish population of the world.

Posted by: William | December 29, 2008, 3:32 pm 3:32 pm

Mike_C – Ironically I support the use of the bomb on Japan. It is justified in light of the preemptive strike against us and the lives saved from a Japanese invasion. I am not a liberal. In fact I am a paleoconservative. I bring up the bomb to emphasize our bullying mentality on countries such as Iran.

Posted by: Ben Straub | December 29, 2008, 3:33 pm 3:33 pm

Mike_C – I don’t want to live there. Israel has pretty much made living there too painful.

Posted by: Ben Straub | December 29, 2008, 3:36 pm 3:36 pm

William – I propose worrying about the problems at home. We can’t solve the world’s problems. In the middle east though, we give overwhelming aid to Israel in light of the settlements and land demarcations. I am saying that this is not a good idea. Stop all foreign aid. We are broke.

Posted by: Ben Straub | December 29, 2008, 3:38 pm 3:38 pm

==Mr. Incredible – Now you are getting desperate.==
“Desperate,” huh. Hardly.
== I do not like violence per say, so I do not condone the acts of Hezbollah and Hamas.==
And, yet, you give them latitude.
==This includes their propaganda and using civilians as shields, but I also do not condone Israel or the US militaristic adventures either.==
Sooooo, you don’t see the difference between terrorists and America/Israel policies. Wow! Your self-imposed inablility to see the difference is the problem.
== If you look at numbers dead, Israel and the US kill orders of magnitudes more civilians.==
And, when a street gang performs, a much bigger police force reacts. So what???
When an intruder faces off with you, you wanna have a bigger weapon than he has. So what???
== Someone like you might say that this occurs because the US and Israel are so awesome and powerful.==
It’s nice to know we have capability.
== To the powerful go the spoils I suppose.==
We’re not talking about winning over somebody just cuz we want their riches and resources. We’re talking about stopping people whose stated aim is to kill us and our friends and neighbors.
== However, as a Christian US taxpayer, I must voice my dissaproval at US weapons being used on civilians expecially in light of the minimal damage done to Israel and the setllement and land demaracation issue in the occupied territories.==
But you had no problem with Dresden, we guess.
In war, civilians get in the way. The enemy depends on it.
The solution is for the civilians to tell their government to stop its shennanigans.

Posted by: Mr. Incredible | December 29, 2008, 3:39 pm 3:39 pm

==Mr. Incredible – Maybe you are right. The Palestinians should accept there situation in which Israel controls the power, water, and food transport into Gaza. Maybe the Palestinians should accept being fenced into small areas in the West Bank. The Palestinains should go Gandi and MLK with peaceful protests. Surely Israel will dissolve all of these settlements. Surely.==
Surely settlements = rockets. Surely.

Posted by: Mr. Incredible | December 29, 2008, 3:40 pm 3:40 pm

==Stop all foreign aid. We are broke.==
Let China, North Korea, Cuba, Iran and Syria and the growing Russia into a new Soviet Union court with foreign aid. Yeah, THAT’s the answer.

Posted by: Mr. Incredible | December 29, 2008, 3:42 pm 3:42 pm

Ben S,
So you support the idea of allowing more & more nations to have the nuclear option ?
Not me, and as far as the whole who is to blame for what in the middle east…PLEASE….the arguements on BOTH sides can go back hundreds of years!
Hamas & the palestinians have put themselves in this position do you think for one minute that if Iran had a viable nuke, that it would not fnd its way into Hamas’ hands and endup getting lobbed into Israel ? Then what happens?
Id you want to seriously talk about why anyones cares about this, its OIL! This same issue came up in Bosnia under clinton. He drew line after line after line in the sand and people kept crossing them. Most of the world did not give a damn, because there was not strategic reason to care. Middle eastern Oil is the only reason people care about the middle east.
It is also why we need to get moving on drilling more here because eventually that powered keg is going to ignite again …and we will be looking at extreme oil prices again.

Posted by: Mike_C | December 29, 2008, 3:43 pm 3:43 pm

Bush promised to solve the problem before he leaves the office. Has he left already or he is just playing with Barney!

Posted by: Rita | December 29, 2008, 3:44 pm 3:44 pm

==Bush promised to solve the problem before he leaves the office.==
We’ll bet that you have promised a lotta people a lotta things and have yet to fulfill all of them cuz there’s so much and so many people and things involved, and they all change from minute to minute. Things over which you have no control. Now you can understand the president’s difficulty with keeping that promise. Or, maybe, you still can’t.

Posted by: Mr. Incredible | December 29, 2008, 3:47 pm 3:47 pm

Mike_C – Iran will eventually get the nuke. If Israel keeps the Palestinians quartered between checkpoints in squalor, it wouldn’t suprise me if a nuclear weapon was passed from Tehran to Hamas. Policies need to change on the ground that reduce tensions and make this an extremely remote possibility. Right now Hamas has every reason to resist. I know I would kick in the 2nd amendment here if I was under similar distress.

Posted by: BenStraub | December 29, 2008, 3:48 pm 3:48 pm

“Let China, North Korea, Cuba, Iran and Syria and the growing Russia into a new Soviet Union court with foreign aid. Yeah, THAT’s the answer.”
Say what. Nothing you do will change this geopolitical realignment. Doesn’t really matter what we do with our dollars. Need to change policies with Cuba. Should be some beach front condos by now.

Posted by: BenStraub | December 29, 2008, 3:51 pm 3:51 pm

Mr. Incredible – Gotta go take care of the kiddos. It has been fun disagreeing with you. I will look for you again later in another blog. Later.

Posted by: Ben Straub | December 29, 2008, 3:56 pm 3:56 pm

“I am not a liberal. In fact I am a paleoconservative.” – Ben Straub
I’m a pedestrian, glad to meet you.

Posted by: Noz | December 29, 2008, 4:38 pm 4:38 pm

The events of recent days are just a continuation of a religious-political war that has raged for 2000 years. More precisely, I was born the year Israel became a nation and they have been at war all my life. None of the parties are without fault. “Moral equivalency” means nothing to a grieving family. Please excuse me, but I’m just very sick and tired of this. It’s too bad we just can build an impenetrable fence around this region to contain the spread of violence, and then LEAVE.

Posted by: B. Bear | December 29, 2008, 4:39 pm 4:39 pm

==The events of recent days are just a continuation of a religious-political war that has raged for 2000 years.==
Whose fault is THAT?
==…I was born the year Israel became a nation and they have been at war all my life.==
Who’s been at war? Israel, all by herself?
== None of the parties are [sic] without fault.==
Sooo, in your view, Israel is at fault for defending herself. Uh huh.
== “Moral equivalency” means nothing to a grieving family.==
The grieving family that voted for a terrorist organization like Hamas to govern their community must take responsibility as accomplices in making happen what Hamas has made happen.
== …I’m just very sick and tired of this.==
Then quit encouraging Hamas.
== It’s too bad we just can build an impenetrable fence around this region to contain the spread of violence, and then LEAVE.==
Well, we can’t, and,. so, we must deal with it. In order to deal with it, we must come to terms with who threw the first punch. To that end, I am prepared to say, relying on accurate news reports, that Hamas started it by declaring the truce at an end and by firing hundreds of rockets into Israel. Israel told them to stop it while it was still up to them. They did not. It’s now up to Israel.

Posted by: Mr. Incredible | December 30, 2008, 3:19 am 3:19 am

Leave a Reply

Do you have more information about this topic? If so, please click here to contact the editors of ABC News.