Closing Arguments: So, Does Satan Exist?
There has been no shortage of opinion about tonight’s Face-off debate. Now, you have heard both sides of our panel sound off on the matter. Perhaps you had an opinion to begin with. Maybe one of the panelists has changed your mind. Maybe not. But now we want you to know what you think: Does Satan exist? And follow "Nightline" on Twitter: http://twitter.com/Nightline
Email




RSS
Twitter
Facebook
YES!!
Only on Earth, he uses the name Cheney.
Posted by: R Mutt | March 26, 2009, 11:39 pm 11:39 pm
He was our president for the past eight years.
Posted by: Treacy Lambert | March 27, 2009, 12:04 am 12:04 am
Unfortunately for all of us, satan does exist.
Posted by: Cormac | March 27, 2009, 12:05 am 12:05 am
there is no satan, it is hard to understand how so many people still believe in such nonsense
Posted by: becky | March 27, 2009, 12:05 am 12:05 am
Looking in the eyes of Charles Manson, Adolf Hitler, and others who torture, kill and destroy and still ask that ?
Posted by: D. William | March 27, 2009, 12:05 am 12:05 am
You bet Satan exists! I committed suicide and got a dose of hell and Satan that I will never forget. To this day I still smell the sulphur and bmstone of hell. To those who do not…are fools!
By the way God Does exist..I saw Him to when I had a NDE!
Posted by: Leslie Trombly | March 27, 2009, 12:06 am 12:06 am
Satan exists and has deceived the world into thinking that he does not exist.
Preparing the world to accept this lie and welcome in the AntiChrist.
Posted by: Raphael | March 27, 2009, 12:06 am 12:06 am
You bet Satan exists! I committed suicide and got a dose of hell and Satan that I will never forget. To this day I still smell the sulphur and brimstone of hell. To those who do not…are fools!
By the way God Does exist..I saw Him too when I had a NDE!
Posted by: Leslie Trombly | March 27, 2009, 12:07 am 12:07 am
No. For some reason, otherwise reasonable, educated adults persist in ancient superstitions. We can’t seem to grow up enough to take responsibility for our own actions. Deepak Chopra is the voice of reason.
Posted by: Beverly | March 27, 2009, 12:08 am 12:08 am
God exists and so does Satan.
Because one does not believe this does not make their existence any less real.
Posted by: dally | March 27, 2009, 12:08 am 12:08 am
Leslie, you had two near death experiences and saw hell one time and heaven the next. thats really amusing.
Posted by: becky | March 27, 2009, 12:08 am 12:08 am
Go to any childrens hospital! room after room and floor after floor of undeserved pain!
Posted by: Michael Martin | March 27, 2009, 12:08 am 12:08 am
God is real. Satan is real. And weather you believe in them they belive in you.
Posted by: Stefanie | March 27, 2009, 12:09 am 12:09 am
Faith is a gift from the Father, that no man may boast. For people to believe in Jesus, they must receive the gift from the Father. Those that believe in Jesus, believe in His Word. Therefore, they know that Satan exists. You may deny belief that a chair exists but that doesn’t make it disappear. You may deny that Satan or God exist, but that doesn’t make them disappear either.
Posted by: Fr. Michael | March 27, 2009, 12:09 am 12:09 am
Satan was Jesus way of describing “free will gone wrong”. there is no heaven or hell, we aren’t better than any other animal, just able to communicate better. Religion has been the cause of more heartbreak than any other thing.
Posted by: belezebub | March 27, 2009, 12:09 am 12:09 am
Satan did not exist in scripture untill the 12th or 13th century, so how can Moses or Abraham been a believer in God since they clearly did not believe in Satan. The fact of the mater is that Satan was created by the church to help rule by fear. Why is Satan never mentioned once in the Old Testament???
Posted by: recovery | March 27, 2009, 12:10 am 12:10 am
honestly,is theretruth differendesebetweenevui
>i believe tht Gog gave gave us thright to decidE S0.WE AS AN INFORMED SOCIE
think possible canada is th best
cananda
==\\
HATE
Posted by: richardo | March 27, 2009, 12:10 am 12:10 am
No.
I never considered Satan didn’t exist, until hearing this debate. Deepak is right that sick people use the “Satan made me do it” excuse to blame someone/something else for what they did. Take responsibility for the good and evil in yourself. I don’t need to believe in the white male god and the red horned devil to be spiritual.
Posted by: Caitlinny | March 27, 2009, 12:11 am 12:11 am
It really comes down to the question..”Do you believe the Bible is true?” If you believe that the Bible is the “Word of God”, then you must believe that Satan exists. If you choose to not accept the Bible as the “Word of God”, then let the debate begin.
Posted by: kevin | March 27, 2009, 12:11 am 12:11 am
He surely does and anyone who doesnt know has fallen into his trap. God has a plan and some people are not going to like it if they dont believe. a scary time is near.
Posted by: Ben Rosser | March 27, 2009, 12:11 am 12:11 am
if you want a good argument about if satan is real or not, talk to
RAVI ZACHARIAS. he will provide the most logical and idealistic answer to the existence of satan.
Posted by: jerin | March 27, 2009, 12:12 am 12:12 am
Hmmmm, recovery, seems that you have never even read the Old Testament!!! He is mentioned in the very first book of the Bible. And the Jews called him Ha Satan. It’s amazing how many people make comments which have no basis in truth.
Posted by: Michael | March 27, 2009, 12:13 am 12:13 am
Satan does exist and every evil influence is from him. God has provided for us a way of escape, by believing in Jesus Christ and what He accomplished for all mankind on the Cross. He has given us authority over the devil. He does exist but he only has the power we allow him to have.
Posted by: Liliana | March 27, 2009, 12:13 am 12:13 am
Yes, Satan is real and we are told this by God and Jesus many times. Anyone who sits there and says they only want to believe in God but that what God tells us in the Bible about Satan is not true is a FOOL and will get to spend their eternal time in hell with Satan. Don’t fall to the lies that Satan tries to lead you to. God help you fools!
Posted by: Monica | March 27, 2009, 12:13 am 12:13 am
I have to laugh at the stupidity of man sometimes. Only in a country like this one – so rich in resources and sensuality and egotism – would we devote a news broadcast to address the question of Satan’s existence.
Ask the people in Darfur of Satan’s existence. Ask the people in Rwanda. Ask the people in Bosnia. Ask the Holocaust survivors.
The Bible says (of Satan) that He comes to kill, steal and destroy. In other words, he plays for keeps!
It is almost laughable that in a nation that turns its head in apathy to the genocide going on RIGHT NOW IN DARFUR, that we have actually convinced ourselves that we are actually moral beings, we are each of us essentially good, we are the ones who are able to judge what is evil and what is not, what is “enlightened” and what is “primitive.”
All the while we are lovers of ourselves, care little for our fellow man, call ourselves Christian because we buy books that tell us how to have “Your Best Life Now!” while all the while there are people dying of starvation, dying by the tens of thousands…
Just the fact that we can sit back and take our little coffee-table discussion about spirituality so seriously… is evidence that Satan is very much alive and kicking!
Posted by: Jon | March 27, 2009, 12:15 am 12:15 am
Actually Michael, he was originally a serpant, and the church changed him into Satan in the 12th century,
Posted by: Recovery | March 27, 2009, 12:15 am 12:15 am
Absolutely not! The devil was created by man as a way to enable uneducated people to conceptualize evil. The image of the devil that we all know was not prevalent until Dante’s Inferno gave the concept an image. But if some people today need the devil to understand the concept of good vs. evil, then that’s OK. Just quit trying to ram your superstitions down my throat. I really truly don’t want to be saved by you.
Posted by: AnOldFool | March 27, 2009, 12:15 am 12:15 am
The Bush family are Satan. They put our country in this mess. But they had other little devils with the Republican majority to get us in this mess. May they all burn in hell with there leader the devil. And this includes some Democrats that voted with them. They will all spend the nights in the same place. God Pray for us, we need you.
Posted by: Michael | March 27, 2009, 12:16 am 12:16 am
Yes, Satan does exist and apparently he’s doing a good job of deceiving thousands of people. The Bible says that to those who think themselves wise, the truth is foolishness.
Posted by: Deb | March 27, 2009, 12:16 am 12:16 am
We are all cooked. Keep on marking off the plagues as they come. er.. weather..quakes..volcanos..er stock brokers..laywers..more laywers…even more laywers..
Posted by: Courier2001 | March 27, 2009, 12:17 am 12:17 am
Satan does exist but we cannot blame our sins on the him because although he tempts us we are ultimately responsible for our own actions. Let us also keep in mind that Satan is sexless. To call Satan a “him” is to put human-like qualities on spiritual being for our own understanding and lack of language. Same goes for God.
Posted by: John | March 27, 2009, 12:18 am 12:18 am
The very idea of Satan was created in the minds of people too weak to take responsibility fot their own actions . How could a God create a being , form his mind , control every aspect of his environment , create his very personality and perception , then not take credit for his actions ? What kind of cowardly buck-passing God do Christians worship ? Satan = lame excuse .
Posted by: mateo | March 27, 2009, 12:18 am 12:18 am
When you look around you see evil all around the wlord, how can you deny satans presens when you see his evil actions afecting the people in this world. If there is no satan where does evil come from?
Posted by: Godbeliver | March 27, 2009, 12:18 am 12:18 am
The truth in my opion is that in life if we seem to struggle it is only for the choices we make in our past. It is are job to learn right from wrong. We need to have faith in our selfs. No matter what your belief most of us seem to begiveing answers rather then seek for our selfs. Like some leader we follow. We act like Spritel belivers with the characteristics of a lost dog. In a state of apathy stumbleing between lies and truth! mindlessly performing task that result in little or no consequence. How can you absolutely guarantee life afterdeath? I dont think we can but all in the same we need to understand that this life is hard and it is up to us to seek a path of independents emotionally and mentally and do the best we can. I think that well lead us to truth.
Posted by: Justin | March 27, 2009, 12:19 am 12:19 am
the idea of satan is just that an idea a mental construct it exists only
in mans mind.man can do good or evil
its his choice alone to make
thanks
john
Posted by: john matthes | March 27, 2009, 12:21 am 12:21 am
Satan exist because it is an evil, human suppressing, earth destroying, lustful, greedy, gluttony force that humans have to have virtue to control because we are FLESH; Just as God (or our creator, whether you believe scientific or spiritual)created us without supernatural powers so that we must practice virtue and self-control—– so does “satan” have power over humans because we are not capable of maintaining our earthly control unless we practice control of our flesh with a conscience and virtue.
Posted by: Lisa | March 27, 2009, 12:23 am 12:23 am
You know if I have learned anything over all these many years of my life it is to stay away from a debate on religion or politics. Very rarely is anyone’s opinion changed. What really irritates me is the one individual who stated you could pick and choose what you believed in the Bible.
Posted by: larry | March 27, 2009, 12:24 am 12:24 am
How do you pick and choose parts of the Bible? Look at the prophecies in the Old Testament that Jesus fulfilled which told of where he was born and how he died. If we only believe in parts why not throw out the whole thing. You may have to laugh all the way to Hell when you die.
Posted by: Realbeliever | March 27, 2009, 12:27 am 12:27 am
If God is all powerful, why hasn’t he kicked Satan’s ass by now? You talk of Rowanda and Hitler and undeserved pain in childrens’ hospitals in your posts. If God is all powerful and lets these things happen, what does that say about god? If god lets these horrors happen, isn’t he evil? Evil exists in our hearts and is not some being other than ourselves.
Just because you believe, doesn’t mean Satan exists.
Posted by: Kelly | March 27, 2009, 12:29 am 12:29 am
The thing that I cant stand about die hard Christians is that, in the same breath, they will say that God is the judge and then they will condem someone to Hell for not believing in him/her!
Posted by: recovery | March 27, 2009, 12:30 am 12:30 am
I wonder why our forefathers who wrote up the constitution, all over our federal buildings have: IN GOD WE TRUST,GOD BLESS AMERICA.
DEPAK IS LOSING HIS MARBLES.
THERE IS A GOD, AND HE SENT HIS BELOVED SON TO DIE ON THE CROSS. lucifer-satan
was cast out of the Kingdon of HEAVEN!
That is why there is so much evil stealing, raping, incest, murders, and thieves. The non-believers God have mercy on their souls. DOUBTING THOMAS’
IS ALL OVER OUR WORLD. LOVE GOES A LOT FARTHER THAN HATE. I JUST RENOUNCE SATAN AND ALL HIS WORKS AND POMPS.
MAY GOD BLESS YOU ALL, WE WILL ALL FIND OUT ON JUDGMENT DAY, NO LAWYERS, JUST YOU STANDING “HEAVEN, PURGATORY, OR HELL” I judge no one they have their own free wills, EVIL=SATAN WINS, LOVE, FORGIVENESS, AND THE TEN COMMANDMENTS=GOD…MAY HE REMAIN IN EVERYONES HEART, AND WE APPROACH THE RESURECTION OF JESUS INTO HEAVEN,EASTER.
JOY,PEACE,PRAYER. GOD BLESS AMERICA.
jj
Posted by: JJ | March 27, 2009, 12:30 am 12:30 am
That was a very interesting debate how about a debate on the existence of a
god as is referred by the so called bible.
Posted by: eros | March 27, 2009, 12:31 am 12:31 am
Deepak Chopra wrote a book about a “new Jesus” and he quotes SOME of what Jesus said (as recorded in the Four Gospels), but… he falls prey to the same practice that Wayne Dyer, Eckhart Tolle, and other New Age-rs do — selective scripture reading! They love to say that Jesus was all about peace, that he taught and spoke about peace, that was his thing. Yet scripture clearly quotes Jesus as saying “Don’t think I came to bring peace. I did not come to bring peace, but a sword.”
Also… Chopra wrote an entire book about Jesus (or at least this “new Jesus” guy) and somehow he missed the part where Jesus talks about Satan. He says quite directly to the pharisees “if God were your father, you would love me… but you are of [your] father the devil, and the lusts of your father you will do. He was a murderer from the beginning, and did not abide in the truth, because there is no truth in him. When he speaks a lie, he speaks of his own: for he is a liar, and the father of lies.”
It is enough for me that Jesus said it pretty plainly. He also said “I am the the Way, the Truth and the Life; no one comes unto the Father except through ME.”
For all those people who think that Christians are close-minded to other faiths, please try to understand… we believe the words of Jesus. He said He is the ONLY WAY. If you have a problem with that, your problem is not with me. Your problem is with Christ.
Posted by: Jon | March 27, 2009, 12:32 am 12:32 am
We have a current Satan today in the form of Osama bin Laden, don’t you think?
Posted by: larry | March 27, 2009, 12:34 am 12:34 am
The Bible is the Word of God, It still is the best seller every year, outselling all other spiritual books. It gives us the truth about satan and his work of stealing, killing and destroying. He is also the master at deception. Jesus overcame him at the cross and all who put their faith in Christ may overcome him too.
Posted by: Jake | March 27, 2009, 12:35 am 12:35 am
This is a ridiculous argument, one can’t argue with someone’s faith because by definition it has no basis. One commentor said “visit a children’s hospital and see the pain caused by the devil” how can that reconcile with the belief of a loving god? where is he/she/it for the children. grow up people.
Posted by: Brian | March 27, 2009, 12:35 am 12:35 am
The truth in my opion is that in life if we seem to struggle it is only for the choices we make in our past. It is are job to learn right from wrong. We need to have faith in our selfs. No matter what your belief most of us seem to begiveing answers rather then seek for our selfs. Like some leader we follow. We act like Spritel belivers with the characteristics of a lost dog. In a state of apathy stumbleing between lies and truth! mindlessly performing task that result in little or no consequence. How can you absolutely guarantee life afterdeath? I dont think we can but all in the same we need to understand that this life is hard and it is up to us to seek a path of independents emotionally and mentally and do the best we can. I think that well lead us to truth.
Thanks
Justin
Posted by: Justin Brightwell | March 27, 2009, 12:38 am 12:38 am
The church used to believe the Earth was the center of the universe….They were wrong. Just because the chirch told you something your whole life doesn’t mean that it is true.
Posted by: recovery | March 27, 2009, 12:41 am 12:41 am
Yes, Satin exist,he is a lier and deceiver. God is a God of Love. Our creator gave us a choice. There is not Love with out Choice. Jesus died for us to spend Eternity with Him! Satin will
not be there, with Belivers in Our Lord and Savitor Jesus Christ.
He died so you would not have to spend eternity with Satin. Satin know’s
Father,Son and Holy Spirit, and Scripture. Read John in the Bible, the Love Chapter. Satin is real, dont be deceived!
Posted by: pat carasick | March 27, 2009, 12:43 am 12:43 am
Satan sure does exist. He delights in taking over a person’s mind and soul to do his own bidding, ie, sexual predators, school assassins, child porn addicts, children who murder their parents, etc., etc. Don’t be afraid to ask God to reveal himself to you and teach you about Jesus and Eternal Life. He never preaches, He just teaches. God bless all who read this.
Posted by: Vicki | March 27, 2009, 12:43 am 12:43 am
The mere fact the question is asked proves that there is “something”, rather you call it inside you or outside you. We can believe it exist now, or not. The only time it will really matter is when we die. You do believe in death, don’t you? I had to ask because people can’t even come to a conclusion as to when life begins. Conception! I pray that we all have the right answer for both at the time of death.
Posted by: Mustardseed faith! | March 27, 2009, 12:44 am 12:44 am
I doubt Satan is one being or one form — but if he is he would likely take the form of someone like Bernie Madoff.
Posted by: WestCoastMessenger | March 27, 2009, 12:48 am 12:48 am
Satan is alive and well seeking and searching whom he can devour. So be for warned the time in now.
For I can not to call the righteous but Sinners to repentance Luke 5:32
for the son of man is come to seek and to save that which is lost Luke19:10
i will pray for all of the lost souls for they are blinded by satan himself
Posted by: Kathleen | March 27, 2009, 12:48 am 12:48 am
To those that think believing in Satan is only for those who can’t take responsibility for themselves and their actions, I say this. It is exactly those who are taking responsibility in believing that they could have done wrong and need forgiveness from God. Just as Satan (aka the fallen angel, Lucifer)would like you to believe he does not exist and therefore you will never have to pay the ultimate price for your errors. Dorothy Sayers’ “The Devil to Pay” has a character named Mephistopheles who says it most accurately. “Lies? What lies have I ever told? I have no need of lying seeing as mankind are such fools! Why, tell them the truth and they will mislead themselves by their own vanities and save me the trouble of invention.” For those who can relate, this is Satan’s modus operandi to a “t”.
Posted by: Liz | March 27, 2009, 12:49 am 12:49 am
First of all, to understand spiritual matters, you have to seek spiritual sources. Many people are spiritually dead, and do not have the capacity to understand spiritual matters. So they conclude that one has to be uneducated, and or ignorant to believe that Satan is real.
These same intelligent people who make these statements, live in a world that is a complete mystery to us all, yet these intelligent people who say its foolish to believe in Satan, don’t have enough intelligence to understand that they are not authorities on the subject either.
So which of these is more ignorant. To say Satan is not real, and those who believe he is are uneducated, mis-informed, mis-guided people and whatever else you can say to make their belief seem too ridiculous to believe, or to say the bible that has been around longer than any of us tells us that Satan is real?
The fact is, no one can answer this question unless they have been around long enough to know whether Satan is real or not.
The Son of God, better known as Jesus to english speaking folks, Yoshua to others, said Satan is real. No one else has seen God, according to Jesus, so he would be the one who knows if Satan is real. By the way, he is also the creator of all things.
Now, whether you choose to believe there is no God, or believe that God is a cow, or believe that people are God, or some may even believ nature is God, this one thing is true. We all will find out very soon who is right, and who is wrong, and if my beliefs are correct, those who have refused to believe the report of the Lord will be in grave danger, and will face the wrath of the Most High God, and eternal damnation.
Now the Bible is true. If you dont’ believe it, look at the prophecy of the book that have come true. However, if you are spiritually dead to the God, The Most High God, you would not be able to understand what you read.
So, be not deceived, The Most High God will solve this question soon and very soon, so what ever you believe, keep on believing it, and we will see who is right.
Posted by: dennis | March 27, 2009, 12:49 am 12:49 am
Man is always trying exert an excusable reason to permenatly defer judgement. If there is no God or Jesus or Satan….hen there is no standard by which one can be judged in this life or any possible afterlife. Life is just an series of random events with no cause, reason, or purpose. I have then No reason to live life with the hope that anything exists after this…It’s just 65 years of work, etirement and then death…The scriptures say that the Fool has said in his heart that there is no GOD…Our very design and all CREATION proves the existence of someone with wisdom so Infinite that our Finite minds will never, no matter how much we try, be able to fathom the what, whys and hows of this exsistence…It is mans deepinig search for the one thing that He’ll never have and that’s control!Which of the theolgy that we do have in the Christian community is one of the priciple motives that led to his fall…he sought to have total control above that which GOD gave him…and this will ultimately lead to the overall destruction of man Himself…God, in his infinte love and mercy has given us the grace to make a decision simply to belive and defer judgement and not make excuses…Which when you stand before a Judge….excuses dont matter just evidence! And the holy scriptures declare that Faith is the substance of things hoped for and the EVIDENCE of things not seen. It is sad to see such bold debates such as this in a country that claims to be the greatest Christian nation….But these things must be so that the times may be fulfilled.
Posted by: John Williams | March 27, 2009, 12:52 am 12:52 am
What is the matter with all of you? How can you wake up every morning and not believe God woke you up. I know as a fact that Jesus is real and that proves
that God is real. They don’t exist, they are existence. You can belive what you want to believe,but when you meet satan face to face, it will be to late to believe in God. All good is from God and evil is from satan. I know of some who have fought with satan and called on God for help and he sent Michael the
Archangel to lift them up a flight of sstairs. I know of healings from God.
All I can say is wouldn’t you rather
believe and there be no God, than not to believe only to find out that He is
real. I pray for all of you. Love is the answer. If you love one another there is no place for hate or satan.
Posted by: Ruby | March 27, 2009, 1:00 am 1:00 am
Evil exist in the physical world so that we may experiance life as we know it.If it did not exist we could not experiance the physical world.In the physical world if only good and love existed then we would not have anything to compare it to we could only know of love and not experiance it.In the spirtiual world where God is there is nothing but love.God lets our sprits come into the phyisal world so we may experiance the drama and the love of not only knowing but experianceing love. God does not punish anybody,only loves them for taking the role that you are here to play,wherther that role is good or bad.Love one another,do not judge one another.
Posted by: Windell Leach | March 27, 2009, 1:03 am 1:03 am
This debate is stated as a sign of the times in prophesy. Time and time again sciences has been trying to prove the bible wrong however, when it does so it opens up more about the truth of Jesus or God in the old testament and New thru Geological, historic, forensic and other present time evidence. how did they know the age of the big bang? Sounds great ! his guess is as good as yours and mine.
Posted by: Tim | March 27, 2009, 1:05 am 1:05 am
People! read your bible God exist and satan exist, people always pointing fingers at God concerning things that is happing on this earth. Satan cause sickness,death,sin,murder, God love us. God would not have sent Jesus to destroy the works of satan only to pick them back up to use on those He loves. Everyone who do not believe in God or Jesus, will one day come face to face with satan. I am not trying to sent no one to hell they are doing a good job by them self. Love Ya
Posted by: Cal | March 27, 2009, 1:08 am 1:08 am
We believe what we have been told to believe, that is how belief systems work. There are an estimated 4400 different religions in the world today, and this is not including beliefs of past mythology. Of this 4400 90% of religious people today are the same faith as their parents. This is no coincidence and this is no different than 80% of Americans being of the same political beliefs (democrat vs. republican) as their parents. Do we make conscious decisions- Hell No(by the way I’m referring to hell as a a figure of speech not a destination for those “believers” about to jump at any opportunity to attack my religious stand! We are given a set of belief systems as kids that become close to impossible to shake, think; even the fact there is no Santa Clause is tough for a kid to accept when he first hears. Those that believe in God and Jesus would be the first to believe in Vishnu & Shiva if they were born in India or Buddha if they were born in Tibet or the fact the mountains have mystical powers if born in Nepal. The Church of England finally apologized to Darwin in Sept. of 2008 for dissing his theory of evolution yet you get dumbass actors like Kirk Cameron still in ’08 trying to rationalize evolution by saying things like if it really existed there would be artifacts of things like a duck-o-gator or a frog-o-potomous. It’s a sloooow evolution process Kirk (kinda like yourself). Gotta say Kirk, I lost all credibility for you as an evolved thinking human after that show never mind an actor (rolling my eyes) Evolution happens slooowwwly. People, it is time to start asking ourselves what we believe in, and where did those beliefs come from. Even IQ is now proven to be established by belief, and those with higher IQ’s are proven to be nonreligious (sound untrue-google it It’s not because they are born that way it’s because people with higher IQ’s are the same people who question their beliefs) If we believe we are stupid…guess what people. Start being responsible for your reality. You are in charge! I grew up in a super religious family, my Uncle is over in Brazil preaching to hundreds at this moment, my Great Grandfather was a pastor that dedicated his life to the church as well as my Grandfather and Dad. I had to seriously look a bit deeper and traveled the world in “seek” mode. It almost killed me to change beliefs after 30 years and made me anxious for a year. Now I question everything
Posted by: Dave | March 27, 2009, 1:09 am 1:09 am
Yes, YES, YES!!! Satan does exist.
Posted by: Karen | March 27, 2009, 1:11 am 1:11 am
For everything in our world there is certainly a direct and equal opposite. Though I find myself, that Like Deepak Chopra I see things in terms of our own individual experience, with each being uniquely our own.
Again, and maybe like Chopra too, I only see the need to focus more closely and entirely on God in my life, and probably not harboring any guilt or shame either, as being among the best ways to be rid of satan and the devil,
Posted by: John DiStefano | March 27, 2009, 1:13 am 1:13 am
Contact at: jwxxjw@aol.com or phone: 573-301-6347 cell phone only.
part two…continuation of part one…
The Religious Answer: A Virtual-Infinite Universe
by Larry Oliver Williams, M.Ed., Copyright 12/25/08 – All Rights Reserved
Infinite Spirits created by God are Godly thereby; without exception, Holy!
True infinite Spirits have God’s authority. Religious organizations do not, and cannot adjudicate; as if God. No man can assume the functions of God.
No specific “faith” is more dominant than any other. None are compulsory.
Jesus Christ, for example, was/is a Godly Spirit transformed into the body of a man to sense our finite Universe. Physically, I have sensed Christ just as I sense myself, and, other people, animals, and all living and non-living things in my own finite Universe. That is my “pure-belief”; Jesus Christ is GOD!
I have a blind-faith belief that Jesus Christ is a Godly Spirit; no doubt, God.
Jesus Christ has the authority of God as a Godly Spirit. All Holy Spirits do!
All religious “books” are sacred here also; to site them reveals your “intent”.
The Bible, for example, is a Holy Book; however tainted, or not, it is Holy.
All religious “faiths” created in God’s purpose, regardless of its Holy iconic name, has sacred value in your desire to know and love the one true God. Your intent is foremost at adjudication. God knows my “true earnestness”.
No matter how you might try to appear sincere, or seek a condolence from your peers, God always knows the truth of your intent; your sincere desire.
Intent has only two directions; either you intend to, or, you do not. Which?
You will not become immortal until you are sincere in your intent to “know” and love the one true God. A man (any) can believe in his own actions even if his actions are not “good”; if his actions are sincere. Intent reigns! This is not God’s mercy, but God’s indulgence. “Intent” reigns over “actions”. It is certain that God is not daunted by our actions; but, by our (free will) intent.
What effect can any act have upon God; except to reveal our intent foremost.
Even if we intend to know and love God, our actions may not be deliberate.
If we do not truly intend to know and love God, then, we will never “know”.
By our “free will” we eventually “know” God; giving credence to our being.
While we seek immortality, with God, we can’t even imagine God’s “mind”.
You are not learning to “know about God” (an impossibility), but, to know “as” God knows. Godly wisdom is a different level of knowledge than the knowledge of “things” in our finite arena. It is more of an “understanding”, or feeling, rather than an account of things. When you finally (if you ever) “know” God, you will feel an understanding of his creation. Although you are “implicit”, you are a real witness to understand and appreciate God’s true virtual-infinite creation. Imagine feeling “bliss” forever, and forever, and…
God’s has created all to benefit all; not as a selfish vent. Your “bliss” is for your enjoyment eternally; for knowing God’s “power”. Knowing is joyous!
You will finally know (feel) God’s presence as you come into God’s “light”. It is an immortal level of knowledge that takes you away from your previous state into the realm of infinite bliss. The things (concerns) from your finite arena are gone forever. Your “wisdom” has come from pain, and from joy.
You will not go to a “Heaven” (an Earthlike paradise) or a “Hell” (a furnace of fire and brimstone), and you do not retain anything from your “life”; not family, relationships, or your body. All of that is intentional propaganda that has been created by men trying to control you in a materialistic vein that has no Godly purpose, and is indeed, unholy. Do not be manipulated by anyone.
This unique universal religious theory is not an attempt to manipulate or to control anyone. It is just a reasonable supposition of our purpose; inspired!
Everything in “history” is within God’s infinite Universe, created in perfect detail; but all virtual in God’s mind. It is so detailed and perfect that it “is” real to us. It does not, however, have a physical beginning or end; “virtual”.
It is truly infinite and can not be traced to conception; God’s virtual creation.
We learn as finite beings in a finite Universe; possibly many times over, but, since we only perceive our finite Universe with our five senses, it only exists to us while we are alive. When we die we transfer into our Soul, (maybe for liability), then, we may transfer to a “new” body and/or arena; reincarnation?
Many reputed religions believe in “reincarnation”; it is herein, “reasonable”.
God’s lessons may continue for us, mercifully, until we do, at last, “know”.
It is impractical that you only live once and then die and simply disintegrate.
You can trust in the fact that your “mind” (Soul) will not ever “disintegrate”.
Your “mortality” mandates your “immortality”; a semantic-paradox at least!
It is also impractical that you will never “know” God; like being on a dismal endless journey in which you wistfully learn in various forms and/or arenas.
In either case God’s creation would be futile and indifferent to any purpose.
You can trust in the fact that your “mind” (Soul) is on a practical “journey”.
We are “here” to witness God’s creation; not to simply bear life as “beings”.
We are God’s children, mortally and immortally; created for His “purpose”!
You can trust in the fact that God has not imprisoned you in a never-ending journey of successive bodies and/or arenas. You are here to learn and you will truthfully, “know” God, immortally. You are a child of God, eternally!
Nobody fully knows what God’s virtual-infinite Universe “is” or “how” you exist. It is impossible for you to ever completely “know” God (even as His Godly Spirits “know”), however, you can surely always know your “intent to know”, (an equivalent to “knowing” God). You can at last rejoice; now!
I can not tell you the framework of your life, but, I can tell you to trust in the fact that your life has purpose and direction from God. That “trust” has to come from your own “free will”, however, to give your witness credibility.
It isn’t the purpose of this religious theory to tell you what will happen; but, to help you to know that God is directing your journey, regardless. What happens is simply what happens; its God’s virtual creation. We are here as students to know God; and, we can trust God. Trusting in God inherently is to “love” God. Begin now to love God (and all things); then, you can know.
We “are” to know and love God “mortally” before we know and love God “immortally”. We are created purposefully within God’s virtual Universe; to be God’s “witness”. It is not our prerogative to grasp God’s “creation” or the state of our being. We are created to witness God; and God’s creations. Trust in God, and relax with an inner peace. Your purpose is being fulfilled.
It is difficult to overcome our innate desire for a life that centers upon our physical nutrients. Our purpose is not to adorn ourselves with our accolades, but to fulfill God’s purpose of our learning. We learn from diverse sources, however. God indulges our actions according to our “intent” to know God.
Do not adjudicate anyone’s deeds; even your own. God is the “adjudicator”.
Our finite Body has no relevance in our afterlife. When God’s lessons are over, we “know” God, or we do not; but, for all eternity? God’s purpose is to have us be divinely knowledgeable and loving. Ironically, “true-intent” is what reigns in our seeking to know God; mercy, an intentional “quagmire”.
Our body perceives our temporary Universe with our senses: sight, sound, touch, taste, and smell. We are born, have life, and die. We are in our finite arena to learn to become God’s virtual-witness to a virtual-infinite Universe.
The Universe is finite in our mind. All is “virtually-infinite” in God’s mind.
Our concepts of time, space, and matter are true while we are “alive” and sensing our finite Universe. Time, space, and matter are finite concepts in God’s infinite virtual scheme; a dilemma for our limited human vocabulary.
After our death, it is unnecessary to sense time, space, or matter, so, our mental “Id” is transferred to our Soul where it continues without our body. Our finite body is no longer necessary to perceive our new virtual-infinite Universe. Our true intent to know God is accounted for and our passage is left to God; regardless of any vain misgivings we had prior to our “death”.
Implicitly, this unique theory, or supposition, of how we exists gives each body it’s own finite Universe that is completely separate, although perfectly coordinated, with all other finite Universes ongoing simultaneously. God is a magnificent infinite God, limitless in His power to create; God is infinite!
It is possible that there are completely separate Universes other than our finite Universe. That would display the creative magnificence of GOD.
There may be infinite types of Universes and an infinite variety of “Body” types too. Anything is possible for God; including infinite finite Universes!
It is like a television station broadcasting one channel to all viewers. Each viewer is “seeing” their picture (their own finite Universe) as an individual action; but, all are on the same channel seeing the same picture. There may be other channels (other finite Universe types) to “tune-in to” also; strange!
Each Body senses the Universe simultaneously with a unique perspective. Although the “picture” is the same for everyone, everyone has a different perspective. Each Body senses a finite Universe from a unique viewpoint.
That would mean that infinite-finite Universes are ongoing, all right now! “Infinite” is humanly inconceivable, so, we can only sense our finite arena.
It’s a vast and difficult theory to comprehend. It is a religious theory that accommodates all Laws of Physics. It also accommodates all of God’s true spiritual icons, (Godly Spirits bestowed with a body that sense as we do in our finite arena). For instance, Christ definitely lived as a man on the Earth.
Religious faiths can rejoice in their authority from the “one” God; Holiness!
Looking for a religious answer to our being should start with the idea of God (at the top) and it should not claim indefinite facts. All that we know is that our Body perceives a finite Universe with our bodily senses during our life.
All else is purely imagined; blind-faith! We should not claim anything that is beyond our finite knowledge. This theory is just an imagined “answer”.
Traditional religions that are founded in uncertain claims should be set aside. If they were organized to fulfill vain purposes of dire men, they are unholy. Any religious theory seeking to know God is good if it is scientifically true and subdues death, but, it must be maintained without using fear tactics or controlling devices. It must be true to God’s purpose, and not man’s vain purposes. It is invariably difficult to detect what is of God and not just man.
There are infinite Spirits, but only one God. There are infinite Souls, and possibly infinite Universes, but only one God; the infinite Spirits are Godly Spirits uniquely. Everything is within the one God; virtual creations therein.
Many different religions exist in our World; all of them are “true”. Every religious faith is “true”, because each is created by the one God; in that regard, all are united! All things, (including all religious icons) are God’s.
Priests/preachers/teachers, churches, and all religious texts or doctrines, such as the Christian Bible or the Muslim Koran, are purposeful; they are the will of God. Within our finite “Universe” they are separate and vain, but God created them, thus, they each have Godly purpose. Each is a Holy creation!
Do not condemn any of them, but, merrily put them aside for the moment.
Do not condemn any so-called doctrine of God; the Bible, the Koran, or any.
They are all Holy doctrines (however inspired), but, they are written by men and cannot be interpreted to be God’s word. They all give insight into God, but cannot be used to interpret Man’s actions since they are spoiled by Man. In the beginning, God created them Holy; then Man tainted their godliness.
Your sole intent will lead you past all preconceptions. You do not need any religious doctrines to guide you through your life; not even this supposition.
You will know right and wrong when you must decide; always intend right.
Excessive focus upon a traditional faith is debilitating, and it does not serve God, or man. It is the nature of God’s method to create a “paradox”; so, to have a changing Universe. As a paradox changes its polarity, so we evolve!
In order to “know” God, we must learn God’s lessons; no matter the spring.
God created our finite Universe to provide a “stage” for our learning. God’s infinite purpose is to have answerable Souls; credible virtual Holy witnesses.
It doesn’t matter by what faith our finite mind seeks God, but, it does matter if our mind knows God when we leave our finite state; to know as a witness.
Our finite Universe acts like a pendulum that God has swung. It moves first one way, then the other, until it comes to rest in the center. Ultimately, all will “center”! As our paradox reaches polarity, it will reverse for the sake of continuance within. God’s lessons are unveiled within our learning arena.
By this, we learn to know and love God as the Creator; our purpose fulfilled.
Every person’s faith or belief is respected and true in this Infinite Universe Theory; it accommodates everyone with respect and love. It is hypocritical to subscribe to any specific religious belief without respecting all of them.
A Soul should seek God sincerely; regardless of a particular religious faith.
Using a finite language to pray to an infinite God is a contradiction. Prayers are subsequently unnecessary and do not serve God particularly. Pretending to talk to God or feeling God’s presence is an enigma; it satisfies only our mind. Our Soul is always with God; a paradox of seeking and finding God. It is unnecessary to pray; since we are always within God’s mind; virtually.
How do we live, day to day, hour to hour, minute to minute, second to second? We must sustain ourselves within God’s finite arena; if only to be able to live on. God’s lessons come in many forms, including intricate trials. You may know what is good or what is not good; intend always to be good.
Seek the avenues that help you to learn, and thereby, to finally “know” God.
It doesn’t matter at what age a person dies. Every life is unique to God and each has an “era” to live and to die. Our finite perimeters are not significant.
At our birth God has created us Godly; from there, we “are” to “know” God.
Race and nationality have no value in this religious theory. God does not value us by any human set we may rely upon otherwise. Earthly groupings do not give us “power” in God’s name; even religious affiliations. To God, it is unimportant whether you are African-American or Irish-Catholic, Hell’s Angel or Baptist, male or female, black or white, or what “team” you are on.
You may have affiliations in your finite life; just know your inner purpose.
Affiliations can be detrimental to learning the truth of our Godly purpose.
Many Earthly affiliations claim “power” that is not issued by God. Ignore them all and focus upon knowing and loving the one true God; as a student.
Although we live together, we are alone in God’s mind. We are in our finite learning arena to learn God’s lessons; not Man’s. War between any factions is destructive and negative within God’s mind. Whoever is at fault surely does not intend to know and love God. Unfortunately, we have become so wrongfully affiliated that wars and killing seem common to us; they are not!
If Man was not in such affiliations, wars would cease, and all could learn God’s lessons without physical pain and mental anguish. It is ironic that Mankind promotes affiliation among peers, rather than to live in harmony as individuals; group mentality creates negative obstacles that work against God’s intention. Affiliate to learn God’s lessons without “evil” intentions.
This theory can only take you to a higher plane than your traditional (or non-traditional) religious faith has already taken you. It is not intended to cause confusion or to demise your previous religious values (all faiths). It purely hopes to bring a new understanding of your “being”, and to bring all people in this finite learning arena “together”. We may diminish physical pain and mental anguish if more people live to “know” and to love the one true God.
Many traditional ideas in your old religious faith will seem less reasonable and they will have less value in your life. Exaggerated stories, fables, and tales of “miracles” in religious documents may only be false accounts that were written or spoken by men to manipulate political veins; not from God.
It is up to you, and you alone, to decide what was/is true historically in your search to know God. This unique conjecture is merely a possibility; and not certain. It is, surely, worthy of consideration; an investment in your “finite” being. Unravel the knots in your old family beliefs and practices; “reason”.
Family relationships are not significant in your efforts to know the one God. You will not benefit from the empowerments of being a family leader, nor a family member. Do not rely upon “family support” to increase your position with God regarding your intent to know and love Him. Many people believe that having strong “family support” enhances their life, which it may; it does not, however, enhance one’s knowledge of God, necessarily. Treat everyone as though you are a family peer; not only the family in which you were born.
“Blood is thicker than water” is a false premise. It has caused much sorrow.
Each of God’s children will know God alone and without affiliation. Intent is an individual issue that cannot be stipulated by affiliation or manipulation.
Having a “free will” is a sacred attribute for choosing your true Godly intent.
Live your life for your ideal end; that you will truly know the one true God.
All of your family, (all relatives, friends, and acquaintances, and even your enemies), are only temporary. You can disregard them all; then, stand alone.
Do not allow yourself to be subjected by mankind. Live by notwithstanding!
You will be challenged by Earthly deterrents; a “lesson” in wanting and in needing. You may want what is acceptable to your peers, but you need what is necessary to have infinite joy (immortality). Only do what is necessary to know and love God; not what is compelling “as advertised” by manipulators.
Even those you do not know of can manipulate your positive will to “know”.
In this supposition you will see wisdom and love, not manipulation. This is sent, not to direct or control you, but, to give you “light”; subjective content.
You must decide your “intent”; and what is your purpose? This, an answer!
Everyone’s life is unique and timely in this finite arena where we live alone.
It may seem unreasonable for you to know, or love, God, when your lessons feel too painful (or too harsh); but, never stop intending, for that is how you will know (and love) God. Persistence, tenacity, and confidence will carry you out. Learn unto the end; that you will know (and love) “your” Creator.
Religious holidays and celebrations can be good; to show sincerity in your intend to know God, regardless to which “faith” it is attached. Enjoy God’s holidays in the spirit of loving God’s creation. It is merely impossible to pursue knowledge (of God) without feeling great joy in your learning. Do not, however, let celebrations become clouded with vain misgivings. Dire materialistic bliss often poses as pious undertaking; God knows which path you are on and what your true intent is. Every thought can be joyful if it is unselfish. Celebrate God each day, hour, minute, and second in your “life”!
An eternal subjection (such as in Hell) is neither Godly, nor practical. Only our human mind fears a Hell; and plainly to know God is “Heaven”. “Hell” is a probable creation of political tactics. Hell was created by men to play upon our human condition; a political device to instill fear and control. God has no need for an eternal Hell in this theory, and the reward for our learning (Heaven) is intrinsic, eternal joy! The true outcome of learning is to know.
There may be accountability for our Soul’s intent; it is not possible to know or understand, or calculate. Some things are better left to God. Our “mind” cannot create its own eternal fatality; a finite vocabulary cannot define an infinite Universe. Language was created by humans, and so it is limited to the finite perimeters of our “Universe”. God designed a learning arena in which we cannot be both, the teacher and the student. We are the student!
Imagine Christianity without a Priest/Preacher, a Church, or a Bible. Pure Christianity is based upon a belief in Jesus Christ as God. Jesus Christ is a Godly Spirit with all of the features of God; therefore, God. The irony here is that there can be only one GOD; one God who created this virtual cosmos.
Consider any religious faith and how it centers upon a supernatural figure in Bodily form; a “Spiritual” figure. All faiths (religions) are social in nature and have the purpose of making life and death, meaningful and good. This theory (the Virtual-Infinite Universe Theory) postulates God represented by Holy Spirits. We may have separate viewpoints or personal opinions from which we account for our being, but there is no benefit in rivalry “faiths”.
We each live in (sense) a unique finite Universe. Each Body is completely separate in its accountability for its intentions. A Body’s infinite Soul is virtually alone. While we feel each other’s presence, we are alone to God.
Do not fear death. Let yourself, your Soul, experience this most universal and reasonable theory as a way to understand “life” and to dissolve your fear of “death”. We were not created to fear God, or life, or our imminent death.
Consider the Lilies of the Field…, our “Universe” is only a “stage” for our Soul to learn the nature of God. We can learn without fear; our lessons are in God’s control. How could a loving God create these dreadful situations? Dire physical pain and mental anguish are simply God’s intentional lessons.
Use what happens in your life as a lesson to help you to learn to know God.
It isn’t easy to clearly unveil the Infinite Universe Theory and its potential philosophical issues. This Virtual-Infinite Universe Theory is an attempt to discern the real “Universe” objectively by extracting the apparent non-truths from the reasonable truths. It is also a very serious attempt to present a new universal religious theory that can accommodate all current religions while abiding by the Scientific Laws of Physics that regulate our finite Universe.
This theory uniquely provides a structure that allows Science to agree with all religious faiths. Specific issues for differing “faiths” may not seem to be congruent within this theory (faith), and scientific viewpoints may state very differing facts and opinions for what is “infinite” and what is “finite”. Each person must decide what is true or not true according to their own thinking.
The Body herein, is divided into two unique regions: an internal Body, and an external Body. The internal Body resides with the Soul (mind), and the external Body lives in the physical Universe. When our physical Body dies and no longer has energy, our internal mind subtly shifts into our Soul; an endless state. Our Soul and our internal Body share our Id (mind), which is connected to the Ego and the Super Ego. Our Id supervises our Ego and our Super Ego. Our Id is the final decision-maker and it remembers our Earthly “lifetime” after we die. Then, our mind can know and love God; immortally.
The external Body is made up of our sensual mechanics and the physics of the electro-chemical Body. We can not sense with the internal Body (mind) because it is a state of mental energy. We only sense with our external Body in a physical manner. We can recognize other external Bodies and we can communicate physically. It is very difficult to focus on anything except our external presence. Our Soul communicates with our body emotionally as we realize internally the things we sense externally. The process of sensing the “Universe” is necessarily vague. We mistakenly desire Earthly possessions.
What matters is not what we externally feel matters; a true “paradox”. What is important in this theory is the belief that we “sense” our finite Universe in order to learn. We are in the process of sharing ourselves with God, and hopefully, knowing God, sincerely. Our Soul is responsible to God, but only for our intentions. Our true “intent” is what matters to God; to our fortuity.
Peace of mind (Soul) is the goal of this new theory. All religions can learn the lessons of God in paradoxes. Our Soul is responsible for our “actions”.
Paradoxical issues are purposeful challenges in our lives (to love or hate, be good or bad, be nice or hateful, and etc…). This Virtual-Infinite Universe Theory is a complex belief that God created “all” to have witnesses thereto.
In the Infinite Universe Theory, there is no “sin”, and therefore, no actual “punishment” for sin; to our relief! Our purpose herein is to learn about God; “forgiveness” is sensible, regardless. We progress based upon “intent”.
We feel joy in sensations as we learn to know God. Sexual sensations begin very young and lead us to generosity, sharing, and reliance upon each other. It can seem fulfilling to “love” each other in our learning arena; love is trust.
No matter what a person’s bearing is, he (she) can feel a great joy in their sexual sensations (inner feeling); imagine too, how great the joy is in your love for God. As God has created you in His image, so also will you create.
Procreation is God’s way of creating Bodies. You who have procreated can rejoice in your association with God’s creating. Adults and children have an equal standing with God; we are all God’s “children”. Treat everyone in your life equally; regardless of their age. No person is above you, or below.
Everyone is equal at their birth; all are God’s children. That is always true.
Any form of loving is good if it leads you to God; your caring reveals intent.
It doesn’t matter in what milieu you feel love (trust), if it is felt “sincerely”.
Trust (love) can evoke sexual sensations innately; joyful when your trust is shared. It can be evocative as such, propagation (nurture) and “self”. The true sincerity of your intent is the “key” to knowing God, regardless of any sexual sensations you may feel as a man (or woman). Sex (love) is “trust”; invariably concise when it is a selfish act. Sex, trust, and joy are inherently related, naturally; as are envy, selfishness, and hate. Paradoxical lessons, all.
God purposefully linked them to create anticipation in our drive to “know”.
Neither of them are “sins”, as their sense credits “intent”; by this, you can love “hate” or hate “love”, as well, and you can hate “hate” or love “love”. Nothing in your journey is as concrete as you would like to assume; thorny!
“Love” is synonymous with confusing sexual sensation and one’s trust; that doesn’t mean that you can’t be trusting (loving) by any means. It just means that you must be vigilant in your journey to “know”; regardless of any peril!
As we age our mind matures, but, our ability to love is always within reason.
God has created us to love each other; and God. Love for each other reveals our intent to love God; to know God. Sexual sensations can be confused for trust, however, and can become a paradoxical lesson in our journey to know God. When our sexual sensations (joy) become confused with trust, we are experiencing a polarization effect upon us in God’s paradoxical finite arena.
This can cause conflict and difficulty in our propagation and in our learning.
There are numerous ways that polarization affects us as we move through our life. Love (trust) can surely become hate (distrust). Our life can plainly become indifferent as to our intent to love God; we become confused about our intentions and the intentions of others in order to seek a satisfying poise.
We may commit “criminal” acts, regardless, in order to have “satisfaction”.
It is God’s lesson that separates our vain intention from our Godly intention.
God may send us on many unique journeys until God’s purpose is fulfilled.
All men are criminals to learn God’s lessons; punishment can have an actual influence upon future behaviors. Man punishes crimes (sins) overtly without Godly authority, but, in order to stop other crimes; a dicey sociological idea.
Crime in any form is subjective according to one’s viewpoint. Do not try to adjudicate crime, whatever its degree. God will know the true intent of any man; regardless of his actions. When anyone commits a crime against any person, or animal, their intent to know God suffers by default. It is wrong to harm any of God’s finite creatures (intentionally commit any crime) as it undoubtedly goes against one’s intent to know and to love the one true God.
God, however, will determine whether we “know” Him, or not. Crime and sin are man’s terminology and have little influence upon God’s adjudication.
Man struggles with “love” and “hate” in many areas; an expense of free will.
Our Godly purpose requires us to have a “free will” regarding our intentions, no matter which path we take; so the end result will be “true” in God’s mind.
It may take many journeys until we reach the end; ironically, the beginning!
We can learn to know God as the criminal or the victim; both teach lessons.
Crimes are not valued by God for one’s acts committed; but by one’s intent.
That doesn’t mean it is alright to commit dire crimes (sins); by any rationale.
Crimes will be punished in the finite arena as God sees therein a true lesson.
As far as our (human) ability to control our (human) behaviors (considered sins), it is dependant upon one’s viewpoint whether a crime (sin) has really been committed. It doesn’t matter to God what any man tries to adjudicate; the weight of a man’s intent is far greater than any perceived terrible crime.
There are many crimes (sins) that are committed with good intent. Man has constructed a harmful system to adjudicate crimes, and many suffer through wrongful punishment. Should any man be caged for years and years for any reason (crime)? Victims suffer regardless of any finite human punishments.
Man adjudicating crimes (sins) is in itself a crime (sin) as it clearly goes against God; the true prosecutor of wrongful intent. Many acts that are considered crimes (sins) are prosecuted by men with tainted selfish goals.
Men who adjudicate other men will be adjudicated by God for their intent.
Society needs to control crime, even though it can be an underlying event.
Crimes are committed that are never adjudicated in our finite justice system; adjudicated by God without fail, however, a “just” intercession for “intent”.
You will never “get away with” any crime (sin) in the end; your real intent.
Unfortunately, we are merely at the mercy of our own sociological demise.
Man simply cannot prosecute crimes (sins) perfectly, and should not engage in that vein. What about victims and bystanders who suffer from the crimes (sins) of another? Victims do suffer the actions (sins) of a dire wanton man.
A victim’s path is left to God’s pity and God’s power to reimburse; or to not.
Both, the criminal and the victim can learn therein, to know and love God as it is intended. Our lessons come in sadness and in joy; a continuous course.
God will fairly prosecute all by “intent”. It is critical in this learning arena to trust also that God will attend to all fairly; even the victim can learn when a crime is committed against him (or her). Lastly, it is a lesson for patience.
Trusting in God to provide us with true lessons and a true knowledge in the end is our pathway to immortal joy. Trust by observation, or with a blind-faith, as your “free will” leads you to learn the wisdom of our one true God.
As you learn to know God, you learn to know yourself, and your purpose.
So-called criminals routinely re-commit their crime because they have lost all hope in their fate within man’s finite parameters. They are “outsiders” who are left to believe that a life of crime is their only logical investment.
Do not give-up on any criminal as he is always a child of God; regardless.
Even the worst crimes may have originated from good intent; let God say.
Everyone has a criminal potential depending upon how their life unfolds.
God will always monitor our progress and adjust our finite learning arena.
It is truly all about trusting in God, and learning to “know” God; sincerely.
God’s mercy is a mandate for us to continue learning until we “know” God.
There is no reason for God to value our “sins”; God is unaffected thereby.
If we truly intend to know and love God in our life, we surely do not “sin”. Our so-called “sins” simply show our probable intent to truly “know” God.
It is God’s assessment of our true intent that makes us immortal; not “sins”.
It is God’s intent, ironically, that men desire to prosecute men (a thirst for power) in the name of Godliness. We all seek power in our learning arena.
The power of prosecution and adjudication belong to God; and only God.
Our Id, Ego, or Super Ego may experience suffering because of our Body’s actions; “lessons” in our life. Suffering is very real, and this religious theory does not dispel suffering; anguish or pain. That we are “forgivable” does not mean that we are free of suffering during our lessons. God is our “teacher”.
We are “students” of God’s persistent lessons; we fight to appreciate peace, we hate to understand love, we cry to know laughter, and on and on we go…
Rich or poor alike suffer the lessons of God’s Infinite Universe. Every Body has an independent Soul; God’s lessons are independent as well. Only our “intent” to learn about God is of value to God; our social position has none.
Your intent to know God can be your greatest “asset” in this human arena.
Rich and poor, all races, all religions, and even all levels of “intelligence” are responsible for their own intentions. We are all alone in our “intent” to know God, even as we desire companionship. Even if two married people die at the same time, they are each “alone” in death. Life is all about death. Earthly happiness generated by materialistic greed is but a fleeting illusion.
When we learn God’s lessons, we begin to know God. It may take more than one “lifetime” to learn the lesson(s) of God; “reincarnation”. Many true religions believe in “reincarnation”; here it is only a possibility. God has created our learning arena to accommodate any vessel; or any combinations.
We are going against God’s purpose for our creation when we desire to control our “Universe”. Although we may have an innate desire to control our surroundings (our “Universe”), we can not be God. Our lessons in life are to learn (about God) as a being with good intentions, and to become one with our Soul. God may then have us become Godly Spirits as well; lastly.
Our focus upon our “Universe” blinds us to the original purpose for our being created. We tend to focus upon ourselves (Id, Ego, and Super Ego). Many want to be powerful. Self-indulgence can be a vain obstacle to our learning. Our desire for power can become a paradoxical lesson from God.
“Power” in our finite life is a paradoxical lesson. No matter what the vein of power is, (money, fame, skill, intelligence, strength, or etc.), it can easily be seductive and debilitating in your journey to know God. A “rich” man can truly intend to please God by his efforts to reduce pain or anguish wherever, but still not trust in God for his own sake. Utter wealth can be a dire lesson.
Many forms of “power” induce “lessons”; God teaches in paradoxical ways.
Possession and Power are persuasive obstacles that may keep you from knowing God, and loving Him as your true Creator. While “ownership” plainly feels powerful, it is simply a false security that can misdirect you away from God’s intentional purpose. You did not create the finite arena you are in, and you cannot “own” anything in it. God possesses all things in the virtual-infinite Universe, including all apparent finite materials, and all beings. Sacrifice your desire to own (control) your lessons. Do not become allured by shiny trinkets, or pretty things that your peers may crave, or have, or anything that makes you feel so powerful that you forget your purpose; to know and love the one true God. You will be secure in God’s true wisdom.
Only when “ownership” runs parallel to your intent to know and love God is it reasonable, and then it is fleeting necessarily. God does not detest your joy in “ownership” if it is indeed for enhancing your desire to know God. A sincere generosity in God’s purpose will produce true joy; impeccably so!
Paradoxically, you cannot possibly “have your cake and eat it too”. Which?
Ironically, your greatest joy will come in knowing; wisdom exceeds control.
You can never control your environment or your fate; except to have intent.
Sacrifice your Earthly possessions and trust God to satisfy your inner being.
If you have an overt abundance of assets, real estate, cash, savings, financial investments, or etc. (wealth), then, you are intentionally committing at least two errors. First, you are not trusting God to uphold you in your finite arena (as God will do), and secondly, you are not using (all of) your power for the sake of “seeding God’s flowers”; giving your whole “wealth” to help others.
“Seeding” one’s wealth means to use it intentionally to provide others with an opportunity to learn (know) God’s wisdom. It shows one’s sincere intent.
Sincerity is an absolute in the “seeding” of one’s wealth; no acts of “vanity”.
Trust and intent (true trust and true intent) will lead you to a true wisdom.
Many wealthy people believe they can achieve immortality without “trust”.
Using only some of your “power” for God’s sake shows you do not “trust”.
We live in our finite arena until we know God; only then can we know God.
“Power” in our infinite afterlife is unnecessary. There will be no exclusive advantages in the presence of God. All who know God “are” in God’s light.
This theory is an inspiration (from God); not just another pious conjecture.
God has inspired this unique theory to benefit your journey. It is up to you to focus upon God’s message. Consider your life and what your intent is. Then, decide what you can do to further your true intent; hopefully to know.
This subjective theory can never explain God’s creation or God’s plan fully. It can only reach the limits of Man’s limited vocabulary. It is honest to say that it is “inspired” as it seems; however, I cannot calculate God’s Creation.
I sincerely believe that this “inspired” theory has reason and it can unite all.
Science and Religion unite! All faiths unite! Male and female, black and white, brown and yellow, rich and poor can unite herein. Set aside your old religious documents and affiliations. Unite as individuals (not affiliations) to see the light of God that leads all to know; finally all will know one God.
Decide to know your purpose! Decide to stop pain and anguish! Unite in a singular focus; to know God. Learn to know God together, as “individuals”, not as an organized faction that has a collective purpose; politically aligned.
You will know God by your individual lessons and format. Do not be led by affiliations that obstruct your true purpose. You are born alone, you will die alone, and you will witness God as one. Unite to share, but, not to empower.
When you focus upon this new theory, you will find peace; and no longer fear “death”. This theory condemns nothing, and, it can truly enlighten you.
This unique religious theory does not condemn any religious organization; it only sets them aside so that everyone can learn together without affiliations.
If you do affiliate, do it to with judgment and restraint; maintain self-control.
All faiths are “righteous” in this unique supposition. Your religious faith may appear in a different light, but it is equivalent in its “holiness” herein.
You do not need to end your allegiance or suffer indifference here; you will only learn to know God (and yourself) with more confidence and humility.
Simply set your old faith, your old leaders, and your old documents aside, and think about this new concept that allows all faiths and Science to agree.
Our finite Universe evolves as God polarizes our finite lessons. Reversing the polarity of our finite lessons causes our evolution. We live within an evolving virtual finite creation. You were created by an infinite (unlimited) loving God for the purpose of “knowing”. Your purpose is to “know” GOD.
This is truly an inspiration from God that has reason and gives hope to all who feel confused and separated from knowing their true purpose in “life”.
If your “free will” has led you to this supposition and you find what is here to be reasonable, and you are inspired by its religious content, and you truly believe it is God’s inspiration (without error), then, and only then, will you be able to see this loving message as a principle theory for your whole being.
Go forth and learn God’s lessons (all) with an open heart and mind, even in difficult circumstances (or in joy) you can see God’s light leading your path.
It is never God’s purpose to create you and then to let you suffer your death without purpose or reason. You are a final witness to God’s creation; freely!
First be at peace with yourself, then all others, then with God; a free witness.
You were created with a free will to choose which path to take as you travel.
It is imperative that you are learning herein by you own “free will” and not because of any manipulation or control from any venue. You are alone here.
It is also imperative that you truly feel God’s hand in this message; inspired!
I sincerely believe that we were created purposefully by one God; virtually, to be witness to His Creation, (a virtual-infinite cosmos without limitations).
I also sincerely believe that God is represented by Godly Spirits who have at some time in history visited our finite Universe and presented themselves as Godly Spirits, yet humans, whom we have adorned as religious icons in our various Earthly religions (faiths); all are God (all represent God’s authority or have a Holy authority in documents and tales). We can acclaim them all.
If everyone can agree to accept all of the apparent religious icons (faiths) as having one purpose, to please God, without indifference to any of them, and all having Godly purpose (as true Godly Spirits), then, we will have a more joyous and more peaceful World to live in. This is my unqualified opinion.
It will not offend our true creator if we are sincerely aimed toward knowing and loving the one true God; while setting aside our beloved “Godly icons”, and previous religious documents, and all otherwise religious organizations.
We can set aside all religious leaders/preachers, churches/institutions, and all “religious books”, regardless of their historic influence, to clear up our mind.
NOTHING IS BEING DESTROYED, DEMINISHED, OR CONDEMNED.
The Religious Answer: A Virtual-Infinite Universe is an inspired “theory” that can unite “believers” with a cogent supposition that will make our dire finite Universe more meaningful as it avows one infinite “Creator”; our God.
Posted by: Larry O. Williams, M.Ed. | March 27, 2009, 1:16 am 1:16 am
Bad, evil, the growing number of visious acts are indicative of the works of satan. Evil did not evolve from itself, it had to come from some kind of being, and that would be satan. We can’t see winds, but we do see what it does. Just like we can’t see satanic forces, but we do see what they can yeild. We can’t see, hear, touch, or smell gravity, yet we know without any doubt, not to jump off the roof of a skyscraper.
Posted by: Janice Selden | March 27, 2009, 1:17 am 1:17 am
Well said Dave!
Posted by: recovery | March 27, 2009, 1:17 am 1:17 am
I do not believe in Satan, but I do believe in God. The question of whether or not Satan exists is one of APOLOGETICS….if you believe in Christianity, Islam, or Judaism, you believe in Satan, because those religions teach that Satan exists….if you don’t follow one of those three religions, you probably don’t believe in a personal devil. So the question becomes one of WHAT IS THE TRUTH? I believe in Eastern religions and “New Age” spirituality, and I’d like to explain why. One of the main problems that New Agers have with Christianity is the idea of HELL. How could a loving God make a person suffer for all eternity? It doesn’t make sense….and the idea that eternal (and therefore infinite) suffering is a JUST punishment of what must be a FINITE amount of evil is nonsensical. Another argument is that the PHYSICAL SCIENCES, particularly physics, support Eastern and New Age philosophy. New Agers, Buddhists and Hindus believe that everything is joined together in an inseparable ONENESS (the idea that “all is one”). Physicists are beginning to see this too. They have discovered that there is something called the “Unified Field,” which is the underlying absolute reality to all phenomenon, it connects all things together in oneness. Still more evidence is the fact that just as many answered prayers and “miracles” have occurred in the lives of New Agers as have occurred in the lives of Christians…..this means to me that ALL religions and approaches to God are valid, but Christianity claims to be the ONLY path to God. Another thing is Near-Death Experiences (NDE’s). Many people have come close to death and met a loving being, such as Jesus or an angel, and have been told that it DOESN’T MATTER what religion you belong to, but that what matters is what’s in your HEART…..yet Christians say that you have to believe in Jesus. One final thing is that there have been many people who could remember their past lives (reincarnation), and often these people know things that they couldn’t possibly know had they not truly been remembering a previous lifetime, such as private events that happened between them and other people from their past life. Well, those are just a few of the reasons why I believe in New Age…..and believing in New Age, I do not believe in a personal devil.
Posted by: David | March 27, 2009, 1:23 am 1:23 am
Whether you believe in God or the Devil or you do not… it is your choice. We all have to find our own truth as individuals. There is not just one truth for everyone. It is my belief that what each of us as individuals has to find a belief in most of all is in ourselves. I believe we all have to find the answers within ourselves and not outside of ourselves. If we trust and believe in ourselves we will find peace and understanding, and in the end isn’t that what most of humanity is looking for!
Posted by: PAL | March 27, 2009, 1:25 am 1:25 am
Janice,
The wind can be explained in the physical world. It is the movement in air due to the warming and cooling of the atmosphere. Not a good analogy for an abstract idea like Satan or God
Posted by: recovery | March 27, 2009, 1:26 am 1:26 am
Janice,
The wind can be explained in the physical world. It is the movement in air due to the warming and cooling of the atmosphere. Not a good analogy for an abstract idea like Satan or God
Posted by: recovery | March 27, 2009, 1:26 am 1:26 am
I have not believed in the devil or hell since I was 7yrs old. I was raised in the Catholic church and schools until 8th grade. In second grade catechism class, we were taught that God is “all powerful, all knowing and everywhere”(omnipotent, omniscient and omnipresent). In the next breath, we were told God lived in heaven and the devil lived in hell. I raised my hand and asked: “If God is everywhere, how can there be a place called hell? God is either everywhere or He isn’t.”
The nun’s response was momentary silence. When she regained her composure, she said “Hold out your hand, knuckles up” whereupon they were hit several times with her ruler (this was 1953 when it was allowed).
Throughout my 8 years of parochial school, I asked other questions when something the nuns and/or priests were trying to shove into my brain didn’t make sense. All I got for my honest inquisitiveness was punishment and/or penance.
Even as a 7yr old, I chose to think for myself and not follow any kind of religion blindly. My father encouraged my independent thinking but it took me until age 30 to discover teachings which showed me the philosophy by which I’d lived my life. I just never had a name for it until then.
I am neither atheist nor agnostic because I do believe in a power greater than I am. I choose to call that power “All That Is”.
Posted by: K Lee Abraham | March 27, 2009, 1:28 am 1:28 am
Satan is within us, daily, on our dirty minds, on our selfish behaviour, on our weak minds. Satan is what you call it when you knowingly do something that wasn’t nice … period. Evil doesn’t make you an evil person, our evilish behaviour creates the evil circumstances that are viewed as Satan’s work. So, BE NICE.
Posted by: We The People | March 27, 2009, 1:34 am 1:34 am
Anyone who does not believe that Satan and his byproduct of evil in the world, is obviously in denial of what is going on around them.
The good news is that Jesus defeated Satan on the cross and is waiting with open arms to love anyone that will come to Him and accept His salvation.
Posted by: Gary Jag | March 27, 2009, 1:35 am 1:35 am
Yes Satan do exist. The person who say he is not in the Old Testament. Read Genesis chapter 3:1-15, then 1 Chronicles 21 verse 1. Jesus is Lord and you can only come in by him. I remember when there were no rain across the south in some states I belive a year ago. The drinking water was short. When they prayed to the Lord Jesus Christ then it rain. You tell me who is in control. He only have to withhold something you really need and you will acknowledge him.
Posted by: Kenny | March 27, 2009, 1:35 am 1:35 am
Yes Satan does exist read your bible
He have you to believe that he does’nt exist. At 2 Corinthians 11:14 Satan himself keeps transforming himself into an angel of light. As far as creation God didn’t created Satan He created him as beauiful angel. He made himself a Devil. Think in this way when a child is brought up by his parent by raising him to do what’s right. And when child get older and he become a thief.
Would you say that his parent raise him to be thief of course not. He made himself to be a thief. So it the same thing with Satan God did’nt made him that way Satan made himself that way. Now as for created.
God created all things at Genesis1:1
He created the Heaven and Earth.
God is spirit and Satan is a spirit creater Satan is the cause of the wickeness in this world at 1 John 5:19 said the whole world is lying in the power of the wicked one that Satan the Devil. Revelation 12:7-9 A war broke out of heaven Satan hurled down to the earth misleading the entire earth along with the demons and earth filled wickeness There is hope there will be a time very soon God will due away all the wickeness in the world.Read Revelation 21:1-4 Remember Draw close to God and he will Draw close to you John 4:8
Posted by: Eveyn | March 27, 2009, 1:46 am 1:46 am
It is “primitive” to believe that the world revolves around me. That’s how children think. Informed, mature and wise people realize that their life is about more than themselves and that there are greater forces that are impacting their lives. I am a Christian who agrees that many people blame Satan for things that God actually did. I believe that “The Earth is the Lord’s and the fullness thereof.” I compare it to a child who throws a rock and breaks a window. You blame the child if they do it on their own. You blame the parent if the child asked the parent if they could do it and the parent said “yes”. The Bible states that the Devil goes to God every day and asks His permission to do things. So God does allow “bad” things to happen and in Romans 8:28 it says that ALL things work together for good for those who love Him and are called for His purpose. So stop thinking that because bad things happen there is no God. Stop thinking that all bad things are Satan’s fault. Know that God has a greater plan for your life, have faith that He will get you through good and bad times. Be Blessed!
Posted by: TGG (To God's Glory) | March 27, 2009, 1:47 am 1:47 am
No. Neither “God” nor “Satan” exists except in people’s minds. Evil people (Manson, Hitler, etc) are evil because thier brains disfuntional, not because some fictional evil spirit made them kill people, If you want to believe in whatever “God” you want, then more power to you, but they are called religious beliefs for one simple reason; they can’t be called religious facts.
Posted by: Carl | March 27, 2009, 2:14 am 2:14 am
Dave,
One may be born into a belief system, but one is not born into being Saved, which means that at death we will be with Jesus in Heaven. As said above, I say that if I am wrong in my belief, we just die and that is it. But if I am correct, I live on with Jesus in Heaven and you live on with Satan/The Deceiver of Old in the place of torment which was made for Satan and his followers.
I especially commend the wonderful people who described their belief in God and Jesus in so many ways. Thanks to God
Posted by: euphoniey | March 27, 2009, 3:10 am 3:10 am
Read Mary Baxter’s books:
The Devine Revelation of Hell &
The Devine Revelation of Spiritual Warfare.
Christ appeared to Mary in 1974 and told her He was to take her thru Hell to show its true existence–then He ordered her to write a book for all of humanity to warn us–this place really exists. Christ told Mary we are running out of time and many souls are in danger of going to hell. The Hell book is horrifying-violently shook my soul.
You either believe all of Scripture or you do not believe it. To randomly select is to call God a liar–
God created the Angels–Lucifer being the greatest , most beautiful and magnificent-stood in a class by himself.
God gave them, like us, a test to prove their worthiness. God showed the angels Christ (as a man) that all were to serve Him. Pride swelled in Lucifer and rebelled and defiantly stated, “I rather reign in hell then serve in Heaven”–and he fell and being a very powerful angel–he dragged one third of all the angels–such was his persuasion.
A rebellion took place–angels fighting with angels–St. Michael led the obedient and faithful of God–and Lucifer was thrown out of Heaven with one third. If Lucifer can convince one third of all the angels– this should give you an idea the power of our enemy in this world–we are no match agains’t Satan–his raging hate and envy agains’t humanity comes from the fact that they lost their chance to be w/ God-and we now have a chance. Satan’s mission is to destroy our soul and take us to hell.
Look at the state of affairs in the world, -the profound evil that exists all around us. God stated in Scripture-only a remnant of humanity will be saved–very frightening statement. It will be by our own free will that we will choose God and win Salvation—or reject God and forever be dammed to hell.
We not only have to believe in Christ–we have to live the life He lived.
Posted by: Glori | March 27, 2009, 3:11 am 3:11 am
Superstitious bumpkins have held us back as a race for centuries. Time to take off the blinders and see the Universe for what it is instead of wailing to gods and devils and all other forms of superstition. Religion poisons everything.
Posted by: Toby2957 | March 27, 2009, 3:12 am 3:12 am
Top Ten Signs You Are A Fundamentalist Christian
10 – You vigorously deny the existence of thousands of gods claimed by other religions, but feel outraged when someone denies the existence of yours.
9 – You feel insulted and “dehumanized” when scientists say that people evolved from other life forms, but you have no problem with the Biblical claim that we were created from dirt.
8 – You laugh at polytheists, but you have no problem believing in a Triune God.
7 – Your face turns purple when you hear of the “atrocities” attributed to Allah, but you don’t even flinch when hearing about how God/Jehovah slaughtered all the babies of Egypt in “Exodus” and ordered the elimination of entire ethnic groups in “Joshua” including women, children, and trees!
6 – You laugh at Hindu beliefs that deify humans, and Greek claims about gods sleeping with women, but you have no problem believing that the Holy Spirit impregnated Mary, who then gave birth to a man-god who got killed, came back to life and then ascended into the sky.
Posted by: Toby2957 | March 27, 2009, 3:14 am 3:14 am
Top Ten Signs You Are A Fundamentalist Christian
5 – You are willing to spend your life looking for little loopholes in the scientifically established age of Earth (few billion years), but you find nothing wrong with believing dates recorded by Bronze Age tribesmen sitting in their tents and guessing that Earth is a few generations old.
4 – You believe that the entire population of this planet with the exception of those who share your beliefs — though excluding those in all rival sects – will spend Eternity in an infinite Hell of Suffering. And yet consider your religion the most “tolerant” and “loving.”
3 – While modern science, history, geology, biology, and physics have failed to convince you otherwise, some idiot rolling around on the floor speaking in “tongues” may be all the evidence you need to “prove” Christianity.
2 – You define 0.01% as a “high success rate” when it comes to answered prayers. You consider that to be evidence that prayer works. And you think that the remaining 99.99% FAILURE was simply the will of God.
1 – You actually know a lot less than many atheists and agnostics do about the Bible, Christianity, and church history – but still call yourself a Christian.
Posted by: Toby2957 | March 27, 2009, 3:14 am 3:14 am
No, God is all powerful and defeats Satan. There is no satan or hell it is just scare tactics. A loving God would not let such things happen.
Posted by: Jo | March 27, 2009, 3:16 am 3:16 am
No, God is all powerful and defeats Satan. There is no satan or hell it is just scare tactics. A loving God would not let such things happen.
Posted by: Jo | March 27, 2009, 3:16 am 3:16 am
Each side says the other sides’ view is dangerous and yet what is REALLY dangerous is the argument about it. That’s what has started so many so-called holy wars.
I have to say, I was surprised to see Depak Chopra become so intense about it.
Posted by: Carol | March 27, 2009, 3:16 am 3:16 am
Why hold a debate at a church? Maybe next time at the American Atheists visitors center? Nah…that would make the debate biased… : )
Posted by: Dave S | March 27, 2009, 3:16 am 3:16 am
There are balances in life and nature, such as flood and drought, heat and cold, day and night, love and hate, sickness and health, sorrow and joy. There is land & water, valley & mountain, and day & night.
There must be God and Satan. No need to even consider our simple, shallow beliefs in science or evolution (we once swore the earth was flat remember – how embarrassing now!)
I believe God is too bright to see, but is the shape and purpose of love & healing. Satan takes on any form, especially that which will tempt each person most, but with a goal of destruction.
Isn’t it nice though, that one little lit match can help lighten even the darkest void? I guess we know then that love and life win out over hate and death. It won out the moment the curtain tore in two – from top to bottom.
Posted by: Devoted2 | March 27, 2009, 3:29 am 3:29 am
There’s far too much pain, grief, and suffering around us all today in this world, and in what may be percieved to be seen as a “living hell” existing here and now on this earth, so the existence of Satan and the Devil may probably fit in well with this whole perception here.
There is, however, a great shift in conscioussness now taking place in many people all across the globe today, and may hold out much real hope and promise for a new and far Better World on the horizon.
Posted by: John DiStefano | March 27, 2009, 3:40 am 3:40 am
Often times it seems that we only have two choices in the debate of Satan’s existence. Either he is a supernatural being or he’s a fiction. I believe Satan to be is a creature that is not human, whose natural abilities are far superior to our own. There is nothing supernatural about him he is only a being who has seemingly magical powers only because we lack either the technology or the intelligence (probably both) to see him and his fallen angels.
Posted by: LetsjustsayRavin | March 27, 2009, 3:47 am 3:47 am
This debate is a moot point. One side is trying to prove a point from a Biblical perspective while the rebuttal is from another source. The outcome will never arrive to the real truth, but we are all left to choose the better “opinion.” If they really wanted to make their debate meaningful, then start with proving the validity and authority of the Bible and if it’s proven to be a fake and totally nonsense, then all else fail with the Christian belief, but if it speaks wisdom and truth, then Depak Chopra and all mockers must concede.
EC
Posted by: Ener | March 27, 2009, 4:33 am 4:33 am
Satan no more exists than your imaginary god exists. It was a stupid question to waste even 20 minutes of time on it as you did on 3/26/09.
Not one of the panel members used anything close to a logical argument. Completely laughable.
Posted by: Nick | March 27, 2009, 5:03 am 5:03 am
Satan, GOD, JESUS, SPIRITS, ANGELS, DEMONS…
What do most (almost all) beliefs have in common? Is it not someone, or something claiming power from being someone or somewhere?
I personally came from a Baptist type of background, but have had since some ‘rather-interesting’ experiences from being in Iraq where I’ve seen some spirits, I’d say some good, some bad. With what some would say a ‘loonatic’ “information” received when told.
All this has to do with one main key thing, have you ever seen a ‘ghost’, ‘demon’, ‘spirit’, ‘angel’, or ‘unknown-being’? Have you ever known anyone with a near-death experience? (near-death experiences have quite similiar similarities no matter what religion the people have to believe.) How do you know that the Mormans haven’t been ‘Created’ by GOD due to the Muslims to create a ‘Path’ to GOD from the past? How do you know that what so many different ‘RPG’ (Role Playing Games) I.E. Runescape, World of Warcraft, etc… any-type of 3-Dimensional game involving ‘Evil’ things to be taken down with certain weapons? How do we know that those games weren’t ‘inspired’ and given form and creation from another ‘thing’ either ‘good or bad’ to create an awareness of the real-truth that is out there that some accept and some rather look at as a mere joke of reality? I know some people who choose to consider living in WOW (Just playing the game) as their own reality and this actual ‘flesh world’ as nothing more than a hindrance to what they want to be at and doing?
I just think bottom line that, There is a GOD, there is a Satan, but I also am open to the consideration that there’s other beliefs being present with ‘power’ but since no one believes, or practices that belief that religious figure (I.E. god-head power) has no power because no one believes in it.
Can you consider what would happen if no one believed in Christianity *A being capable of Love, Compassion, Caring, Judgement, anything good*
And instead of just believing in Satan? *A being known or accused of taking, stealing, killing, hurting, possessing, injuring, and anything bad*
If someone stopped beleiving (in beings) then at worste when something came and actually presented it to you *whoever* that is a ‘super-natural’ or possibly presenting itself to you in a ‘human-form’ with ‘supernatural-powers’ (I.E. possibly Anti-Christ)then the one presenting itself would have Supreme Capabilities to be understood and accepted as their ‘ruler’ or ‘conquerer’ for whatever good, or bad it may be.
I’m not annotating that Humans are ‘beings’ but I’m not annotating that ‘beings’ cannot be in a disguise to be amused and entertained by mere humans.
Like the song from Michael W. Smith (Angel Trilogy) Where the key words are “Maybe we are entertaining angels unaware…” *which I personally enjoy very much his songs but that’s a side note* And yes, that is a Christian Singer, but I’m also entertained at the songs that other Singers and Artists use in their lyrics too talking about the Bad, or the Songs that have words like, “Molly are you okay, Molly are you okay now,” words, and actions being done and said in songs really create a symbolic message behind the media’s image which literally has a ‘subliminal message’ if someone was to be doing the digging and searching in both the ‘neutral, good, and bad sides’ of the forms and creations…
To not pay attention to things is to show ignorance, but to see, and understand it then claim ignorance is stubbornness.
If you want to have a e-mail conversation I am fair game for response, just please give me time to respond for I am not always at the computer checking e-mail… at waterscalming@gmail.com
Posted by: waterscalming | March 27, 2009, 5:25 am 5:25 am
People, people, people!!! This is the 21st **bleeping** Century! Educate yourselves…so much of it is right at your fingertips through reputable research you can find online, if you don’t want to head to the library. Please, please, please, dig deeper and find out the real truths of our universe, evolutionary history, life, and the human pursuit to understand things around us and how things REALLY work…including the historical & societal influences on culture and religion (things WE created). If you’re not going to read, let me recommend some must see’s for your Netflix list: “The Universe” (series by History Channel – 4th disk is a good primer if you tuned out science classes or were just programmed to believe that because something is called a “theory” makes it not credible), “Evolution” (series by PBS, fantastic and eye opening), “Origins: Battle for the Planet” (shows the true beginnings of life) “From Ape to Man” (again from H.C.- excellent- showing bridge to current humanity), “Journey of Man” (phenomenal!!!- 50K years ago how humans spread around the earth), “Joseph Campbell: The Power of Myth” (the advent of peoples spiritual beliefs- around the world with common elements of myth), “The God Who Wasn’t There” (not very good production value and yes it’s incendiary, but there are great insights in the main feature and also definitely in the bonus features as well…the bible isn’t the infallible word of god you think it to be) That’s just a starter, but there’s so much more…so much truth finally out there. REAL knowledge. I dare you to dig deeper. Ask questions. And don’t be afraid to accept that as a culture we have been surrounded by myth, “spirituality” and superstition. But as people capable of thinking, learning, discovering and understanding we can finally put aside that which isn’t real. I no longer praise or fear God or Satan, BOTH were created by man. “There are none so blind as those who refuse to see.” Please open your eyes…and mind.
Posted by: Chris | March 27, 2009, 6:29 am 6:29 am
Yes, Satan exists. She is not a demon or some other symbol that may be used to represent her. She is collectively the evil in the world. She is the reason we have totally failed government at the national, state, and local levels. Failed government is, in turn, the source of all other evil in the world. We the People can do good in our lives by starting to pressure the useless dung that now fills the government jobs to start doing their jobs–or yield those jobs to some of us, who will actually do something useful in those positions. Satan is failed government and all of its consequences.
Posted by: Jack of SB | March 27, 2009, 6:38 am 6:38 am
YES, SATAN IS REAL… HE’S CURRENTLY IN THE OVAL OFFICE….
Posted by: AsianGOP | March 27, 2009, 7:05 am 7:05 am
YES, SATAN IS REAL… HE’S CURRENTLY IN THE OVAL OFFICE….
Posted by: AsianGOP | March 27, 2009, 7:05 am 7:05 am
Qoute: “Why is Satan never mentioned once in the Old Testament???” Posted by: recovery
If you read the Old Testament you will fiind that Satan is mentioned through out the OT. For example: 1 Chronicles 21:1 (Whole Chapter)
And Satan stood up against Israel, and provoked David to number Israel.
Job 1:6 (Whole Chapter)
Now there was a day when the sons of God came to present themselves before the LORD, and Satan came also among them.
Job 1:7 (Whole Chapter)
And the LORD said unto Satan, Whence comest thou? Then Satan answered the LORD, and said, From going to and fro in the earth, and from walking up and down in it.
Job 1:8 (Whole Chapter)
And the LORD said unto Satan, Hast thou considered my servant Job, that there is none like him in the earth, a perfect and an upright man, one that feareth God, and escheweth evil?
Job 1:9 (Whole Chapter)
Then Satan answered the LORD, and said, Doth Job fear God for nought?
Job 1:12 (Whole Chapter)
And the LORD said unto Satan, Behold, all that he hath is in thy power; only upon himself put not forth thine hand. So Satan went forth from the presence of the LORD.
Job 2:1 (Whole Chapter)
Again there was a day when the sons of God came to present themselves before the LORD, and Satan came also among them to present himself before the LORD.
Job 2:2 (Whole Chapter)
And the LORD said unto Satan, From whence comest thou? And Satan answered the LORD, and said, From going to and fro in the earth, and from walking up and down in it.
Job 2:3 (Whole Chapter)
And the LORD said unto Satan, Hast thou considered my servant Job, that there is none like him in the earth, a perfect and an upright man, one that feareth God, and escheweth evil? and still he holdeth fast his integrity, although thou movedst me against him, to destroy him without cause.
Job 2:4 (Whole Chapter)
And Satan answered the LORD, and said, Skin for skin, yea, all that a man hath will he give for his life.
Job 2:6 (Whole Chapter)
And the LORD said unto Satan, Behold, he is in thine hand; but save his life.
Job 2:7 (Whole Chapter)
So went Satan forth from the presence of the LORD, and smote Job with sore boils from the sole of his foot unto his crown.
Psalm 109:6 (Whole Chapter)
Set thou a wicked man over him: and let Satan stand at his right hand.
Zechariah 3:1 (Whole Chapter)
And he shewed me Joshua the high priest standing before the angel of the LORD, and Satan standing at his right hand to resist him.
Zechariah 3:2 (Whole Chapter)
And the LORD said unto Satan, The LORD rebuke thee, O Satan; even the LORD that hath chosen Jerusalem rebuke thee: is not this a brand plucked out of the fire?
Matthew 4:10 (Whole Chapter)
Then saith Jesus unto him, Get thee hence, Satan: for it is written, Thou shalt worship the Lord thy God, and him only shalt thou serve.
Matthew 12:26 (Whole Chapter)
And if Satan cast out Satan, he is divided against himself; how shall then his kingdom stand?
Matthew 16:23 (Whole Chapter)
But he turned, and said unto Peter, Get thee behind me, Satan: thou art an offence unto me: for thou savourest not the things that be of God, but those that be of men.
Mark 1:13 (Whole Chapter)
And he was there in the wilderness forty days, tempted of Satan; and was with the wild beasts; and the angels ministered unto him.
Mark 3:23 (Whole Chapter)
And he called them unto him, and said unto them in parables, How can Satan cast out Satan?
Mark 3:26 (Whole Chapter)
And if Satan rise up against himself, and be divided, he cannot stand, but hath an end.
Mark 4:15 (Whole Chapter)
And these are they by the way side, where the word is sown; but when they have heard, Satan cometh immediately, and taketh away the word that was sown in their hearts.
Mark 8:33 (Whole Chapter)
But when he had turned about and looked on his disciples, he rebuked Peter, saying, Get thee behind me, Satan: for thou savourest not the things that be of God, but the things that be of men.
Luke 4:8 (Whole Chapter)
And Jesus answered and said unto him, Get thee behind me, Satan: for it is written, Thou shalt worship the Lord thy God, and him only shalt thou serve.
Luke 10:18 (Whole Chapter)
And he said unto them, I beheld Satan as lightning fall from heaven.
Do you believe “the word of God?”
Posted by: seeker-of-truth | March 27, 2009, 7:43 am 7:43 am
A belief in God would certainly seem to make Satan a part of that belief… since all things were created in pairs, in duality, positive/negative, male/female, good/evil, hot/cold, life/death, Democrat/Republican etc. (just kidding on the last set ;)!
The original meaning of Satan, was an obstacle on one’s path,
Astrologically, Saturn, is the planet that constricts, limits and puts obstacles before us…in this life.
It is is the taskmaster, teaching us what we must learn in the flesh to progress as spiritual beings….
Personally, it is my belief, that if there indeed be a Satan, then Satan works “with” the Creator for the betterment of humankind.
For it is when we overcome obstacles, when we overcome hardships or “evils” that we have learned the most about ourselves and others…overcoming such evil is where we become wise and find true strength. It is when we have gone through great trials in life that we come to see the simple beauty that surrounds us constantly.
There is good and “evil” in all people and in all things that pertain to people like governments, religions, or organizations and such.
And then there is the freedom of choice, even God, it seems is prochoice, we have that freedom to choose to make good decisions or not…
even to our deaths…
good decisions or not, are the seeds that we plant, so that as we sow we shall truly reap, is the purest of truths. I have seen this reality of cause and effect many times and know that it is very real.
Though I quote the Bible, I do not believe in it, as it has become in these days… yet small quips of wisdom lay within it’s pages still, undisturbed by the constant reinterpretations by man.
A belief in Anything gives it strength and makes it real. As all thoughts have energy, those energies should not dwell upon Satan as some evil entity but, rather as an energy that we must overcome to find what is right and good in the world, to find our true selves as spiritual beings and not these fleshy bodies that we become so attached to that we fear death…
Posted by: theafalcon200 | March 27, 2009, 7:46 am 7:46 am
The Bible is not the work of god, it is the work of man. Saying god inspired them is just wishful thinking, hardly proof at all. Man wrote it, amended it, and “sanctified” it so he could rule over the fearful and ignorant. This business about “Jesus said” is totally withoput foundation. Nobody was there with a videocam, and Bible scholars agree that nothing was written down for at least 60 years, passed on by flawed and embellished oral history. Your doctor doesn’t refer to 2000 year old medical texts, does he?, and you need to stop running your lives according to a 2000 year old book of popular myths !!!
Posted by: fuzzy | March 27, 2009, 7:57 am 7:57 am
I think we can all agree that good and evil exist, but the question was whether a very specific evil god named Satan exists.
To put this in context, the remaining programs in this series will debate the existence of Thor, Dionysus, Ba’al, Zeus, Jehovah, Mithridates, Loki, and the FSM. There will also be several short segments on the actual honest-to-god reality of Hercules, Macbeth, Tom Sawyer, and the Ferengi named Quark.
Posted by: James | March 27, 2009, 8:00 am 8:00 am
Belief has nothing to do with facts! One can believe that there is no gravitational force yet a fall will bring enlightenment.
The facts remain that no humans witnessed the beginning of the universe, though one believes that it sprang from nothing based on faith in the teacher’s of evolution which states that they know what happened billions of years before there were humans.
It is said that life came from non-life
and this also produced intelligent beings from a non-intelligent source.
This they say is the most intelligent way to think????
Posted by: go20009 | March 27, 2009, 10:08 am 10:08 am
1. Then was Jesus led up of the Spirit into the wilderness to be tempted of the devil.
2. And when he had fasted forty days and forty nights, he was afterward an hungred.
3. And when the tempter came to him, he said, If thou be the Son of God, command that these stones be made bread.
4. But he answered and said, It is written, Man shall not live by bread alone, but by every word that proceedeth out of the mouth of God.
5. Then the devil taketh him up into the holy city, and setteth him on a pinnacle of the temple,
6. And saith unto him, If thou be the Son of God, cast thyself down: for it is written, He shall give his angels charge concerning thee: and in their hands they shall bear thee up, lest at any time thou dash thy foot against a stone.
7. Jesus said unto him, It is written again, Thou shalt not tempt the Lord thy God.
8. Again, the devil taketh him up into an exceeding high mountain, and sheweth him all the kingdoms of the world, and the glory of them;
9. And saith unto him, All these things will I give thee, if thou wilt fall down and worship me.
10. Then saith Jesus unto him, Get thee hence, Satan: for it is written, Thou shalt worship the Lord thy God, and him only shalt thou serve.
11. Then the devil leaveth him, and, behold, angels came and ministered unto him.
12. Now when Jesus had heard that John was cast into prison, he departed into Galilee;
As we see from this passage in the Bible, Satan is the god of this world (for now). He has power and is the root cause of Sin.
Posted by: Mike | March 27, 2009, 10:42 am 10:42 am
Does the devil exist. Does GOD exist. Does it it really matter. The fact of the matter is this. There are those who will forever believe that Satan exists. There are those who believe that God exists. As for Me, I believe That Jesus Christ is the Son of God and that HE is GOD therefore Satan Exists.
But my main concern with the debate was this. On one side you have two people that believe that the devil does not exist. On the other side, you have two people that believe that the devil does exist.
There were no other religions there on the believe side except for Christians. No other religions at all. Now you could argue that well, we as Christians, are the most believing in Satan. Now one could argue that Christianity is the best religion to pick on cause well, a man that willingly died to save mankind…preposterous. But I don’t particularly believe that. I believe that Christians are chosen cause well….they all think that we are saps that believe in a guy that was born of a virgin and worship a guy that died for us and that he did it willingly and that he did it because he loved us so much.
Or maybe it was just because it was only Christians that had the grapefruits to sit up there and be paraded around as freaks.
Deepak wants us to believe that Satan doesn’t exist and that we can live in a world that is all rainbows and butterflies. Wish it were true but alas it isn’t. It must be nice to live in a fantasy world and not have any strife or worries of anything of that kind. But life isn’t all roses and wine. Life is brutal and life is filled with stress and strife. And it doesn’t matter if you are a christian or not. You live on this earth you have strife. You can’t wash it away with rainbows.
Vishnu, there is no recorded historical text that shows that he/she existed. No literature to back that up at all. BUT there is actual historical text to prove that Jesus Christ did exist. Far to many to mention here.
Ladies and Gents, it all comes down to “believing without seeing” Faith. Not rainbows and butterflies. It is up to you to decide. If there is a heaven then there is a hell. If there is a god then there is a devil.
Nuff said
Posted by: PastorOfMuppets | March 27, 2009, 10:43 am 10:43 am
whether one believes in satan’s existence or not, how would it change the way you live your life? should we not all be living our lives as the greatest spiritual beings have taught and following their examples? the best way to battle “evil” is with love, kindness, goodness, forgiveness. if you are striving to create a world filled with love, and if you want to reference the bible there are numerous suggestions on how to do this, there is really no need for this argument. the parties on both sides of this discussion can hold their beliefs and respect one another for them, where is the harm in this?
Posted by: onelove | March 27, 2009, 10:51 am 10:51 am
God didn’t create Satan cuz God didn’t create darkness. God spoke Light into the darkness, and the darkness comprehended it not.
==there is no satan==
You refuse to see him.
== it is hard to understand how so many people still believe in such nonsense==
We don’t believe IN Satan. We know he exists.
==Faith is a gift from the Father==
Righteousness is the gift. Faith is OUR response to His Offer of Reconciliation through Christ.
==we aren’t better than any other animal…==
You must be one-a those homosexuals who look to the animals for sex tips.
God gave Man dominion over the animals.
==Satan does exist but we cannot blame our sins on the him because although he tempts us we are ultimately responsible for our own actions.==
That’s correct! He has no authority to impose, except the authority a person gives to him, as did Adam and Eve.
==We all have to find our own truth as individuals.==
One person’s truth is to beat his kids. Another’s is to take your money.
== There is not just one truth for everyone.==
Jesus said there is. You callin’ Him a “liar”?
== It is my belief that what each of us as individuals has to find a belief in most of all is in ourselves.==
However, people oppose themselves.
== I believe we all have to find the answers within ourselves and not outside of ourselves.==
John 8:32
== If we trust and believe in ourselves we will find peace and understanding…==
How’s that workin’, so far? Not very well, is it?
==A loving God would not let such things happen.==
A person who loves God would not turn his back on Him.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 27, 2009, 11:13 am 11:13 am
==Belief has nothing to do with facts! ==
(Heb 11:1) Now faith is the substance of things hoped for, the evidence of things not seen.
Substance and evidence. Facts.
(2Co 4:18) While we look not at the things which are seen, but at the things which are not seen: for the things which are seen are temporal; but the things which are not seen are eternal.
(Heb 11:3) Through faith we understand that the worlds were framed by the word of God, so that things which are seen were not made of things which do appear.
(Rom 1:20) For the invisible things of him from the creation of the world are clearly seen, being understood by the things that are made, even his eternal power and Godhead; so that they are without excuse…
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 27, 2009, 11:31 am 11:31 am
Yes Satan does exist, but Satan is Risen, Reborn, In Christ and a New Creation; just like the rest of so called Christians. How Do I know? Well I dont think Satan is dumb and I think Satan agreed to accept that free gift of salvation offered all at calvary’s cross. The three in agreement with this Master plan were GOD, Jesus Christ, Her only begotten Son, and Satan, GOD’s only begotten Daughter. Satan is the help Meet inside of Jesus Christ, just as Eve was inside of Adam from the start. So then “It is for this cause the man is to leave his father and his mother to cleave unto his wife; and the twain shall be one flesh; aint no mystery no more and thats why Jesus Christ is called the Bridegroom to come. .
Posted by: MrsChrist12 | March 27, 2009, 11:46 am 11:46 am
Oh..One more think; Just picture this;
Satan comes forth, risen, reborn and a new creation in the Flesh of a woman. She goes before the US Supreme Court and throws the BOOK at the Judges; or back into Court; claiming Breach of Contract, Honor, Oaths and promises that were sworn on the bible by All US presidents and public officials. Satan contends that the word “NO” in the first AMENdment is a Tort. “Congress shall make No law respecting an establishment of religion”. So Satan or She claims since women didnt get the vote, choice, or decent respect of being asked about their religion convictions; the word No should be removed. Then Satan quotes the Deeclaration of Independence; asking for Separation and Throw Off of the body of government men who denied Her hand Her kind the same laws of nature and nature’s GOD those sons of guns were allowed to use and enjoy.
The constitution does not require they swear an oath on the bible; but the Courts allowed its use as a instrument of law and fully legal and binding contract that was passed down to US all under the wills of our forefathers i.e., Abraham, Lincoln and Red Cloud.
Peace out
Posted by: MrsChrist12 | March 27, 2009, 11:55 am 11:55 am
Matthew 24:
1. And Jesus went out, and departed from the temple: and his disciples came to him for to shew him the buildings of the temple.
2. And Jesus said unto them, See ye not all these things? verily I say unto you, There shall not be left here one stone upon another, that shall not be thrown down.
3. And as he sat upon the mount of Olives, the disciples came unto him privately, saying, Tell us, when shall these things be? and what shall be the sign of thy coming, and of the end of the world?
4. And Jesus answered and said unto them, Take heed that no man deceive you.
5. For many shall come in my name, saying, I am Christ; and shall deceive many.
6. And ye shall hear of wars and rumours of wars: see that ye be not troubled: for all these things must come to pass, but the end is not yet.
7. For nation shall rise against nation, and kingdom against kingdom: and there shall be famines, and pestilences, and earthquakes, in divers places.
8. All these are the beginning of sorrows.
9. Then shall they deliver you up to be afflicted, and shall kill you: and ye shall be hated of all nations for my name’s sake.
10. And then shall many be offended, and shall betray one another, and shall hate one another.
11. And many false prophets shall rise, and shall deceive many.
12. And because iniquity shall abound, the love of many shall wax cold.
13. But he that shall endure unto the end, the same shall be saved.
14. And this gospel of the kingdom shall be preached in all the world for a witness unto all nations; and then shall the end come.
15. When ye therefore shall see the abomination of desolation, spoken of by Daniel the prophet, stand in the holy place, (whoso readeth, let him understand:)
16. Then let them which be in Judaea flee into the mountains:
17. Let him which is on the housetop not come down to take any thing out of his house:
18. Neither let him which is in the field return back to take his clothes.
19. And woe unto them that are with child, and to them that give suck in those days!
20. But pray ye that your flight be not in the winter, neither on the sabbath day:
21. For then shall be great tribulation, such as was not since the beginning of the world to this time, no, nor ever shall be.
22. And except those days should be shortened, there should no flesh be saved: but for the elect’s sake those days shall be shortened.
23. Then if any man shall say unto you, Lo, here is Christ, or there; believe it not.
24. For there shall arise false Christs, and false prophets, and shall shew great signs and wonders; insomuch that, if it were possible, they shall deceive the very elect.
25. Behold, I have told you before.
26. Wherefore if they shall say unto you, Behold, he is in the desert; go not forth: behold, he is in the secret chambers; believe it not.
27. For as the lightning cometh out of the east, and shineth even unto the west; so shall also the coming of the Son of man be.
28. For wheresoever the carcase is, there will the eagles be gathered together.
29. Immediately after the tribulation of those days shall the sun be darkened, and the moon shall not give her light, and the stars shall fall from heaven, and the powers of the heavens shall be shaken:
30. And then shall appear the sign of the Son of man in heaven: and then shall all the tribes of the earth mourn, and they shall see the Son of man coming in the clouds of heaven with power and great glory.
31. And he shall send his angels with a great sound of a trumpet, and they shall gather together his elect from the four winds, from one end of heaven to the other.
32. Now learn a parable of the fig tree; When his branch is yet tender, and putteth forth leaves, ye know that summer is nigh:
33. So likewise ye, when ye shall see all these things, know that it is near, even at the doors.
34. Verily I say unto you, This generation shall not pass, till all these things be fulfilled.
35. Heaven and earth shall pass away, but my words shall not pass away.
36. But of that day and hour knoweth no man , no, not the angels of heaven, but my Father only.
37. But as the days of Noe were , so shall also the coming of the Son of man be.
38. For as in the days that were before the flood they were eating and drinking, marrying and giving in marriage, until the day that Noe entered into the ark,
39. And knew not until the flood came, and took them all away; so shall also the coming of the Son of man be.
40. Then shall two be in the field; the one shall be taken, and the other left.
41. Two women shall be grinding at the mill; the one shall be taken, and the other left.
42. Watch therefore: for ye know not what hour your Lord doth come.
43. But know this, that if the goodman of the house had known in what watch the thief would come, he would have watched, and would not have suffered his house to be broken up.
44. Therefore be ye also ready: for in such an hour as ye think not the Son of man cometh.
45. Who then is a faithful and wise servant, whom his lord hath made ruler over his household, to give them meat in due season?
46. Blessed is that servant, whom his lord when he cometh shall find so doing.
47. Verily I say unto you, That he shall make him ruler over all his goods.
48. But and if that evil servant shall say in his heart, My lord delayeth his coming;
49. And shall begin to smite his fellowservants, and to eat and drink with the drunken;
50. The lord of that servant shall come in a day when he looketh not for him , and in an hour that he is not aware of,
51. And shall cut him asunder, and appoint him his portion with the hypocrites: there shall be weeping and gnashing of teeth.
Posted by: MB | March 27, 2009, 12:08 pm 12:08 pm
MB,
You’re gonna have to explain that to the unbeliever who probalby STILL won’t understand it.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 27, 2009, 12:15 pm 12:15 pm
==…Satan agreed to accept that free gift of salvation offered all at calvary’s cross.==
Where is THAT in the Word of God?
== The three in agreement with this Master plan were GOD, Jesus Christ, Her only begotten Son, and Satan, GOD’s only begotten Daughter.==
Care to point to the place in the Word of God where that is said?
== Satan is the help Meet inside of Jesus Christ…==
That’s what the Devil’s PR sheet says.
==… just as Eve was inside of Adam from the start.==
No, she wasn’t. God made her from Man. God did not draw her from Man, like removing an appendix. Although, at the start, “Man” — not A man — included the spirits of male and female, just as “Man,” today, is made up of male and female, but A man isn’t.
However, God created the woman externally, from a piece of the man. That doesn’t mean that he was part female, any more than I am part monkey just cuz my fingernails are made of the same stuff the monkey’s fingernails are made of.
== So then “It is for this cause the man is to leave his father and his mother to cleave unto his wife; and the twain shall be one flesh; aint no mystery no more and thats why Jesus Christ is called the Bridegroom to come. . ==
I hadn’t thought about THAT point, that the creation of physical female from a piece of the man, and the command for the two to cleave into one flesh, simulates — is a type and shadow of — the coming of Christ, that this union is also to produce Godly children [Mal 2:15 AMP].
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 27, 2009, 12:40 pm 12:40 pm
As a matter of fact, the statement
== So then “It is for this cause the man is to leave his father and his mother to cleave unto his wife; and the twain shall be one flesh; aint no mystery no more and thats why Jesus Christ is called the Bridegroom to come. . ==
and my reply
“I hadn’t thought about THAT point, that the creation of physical female from a piece of the man, and the command for the two to cleave into one flesh, simulates — is a type and shadow of — the coming of Christ, that this union is also to produce Godly children [Mal 2:15 AMP]”
are the kinds of mysteries of God that you can’t get by reading the Word as you do a newspaper, or textbook.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 27, 2009, 12:46 pm 12:46 pm
==there is no satan==
You refuse to see him. You can’t see anything in the darkness.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 27, 2009, 1:05 pm 1:05 pm
==…Satan agreed to accept that free gift of salvation offered all at calvary’s cross.==
WHERE is this “agreement”?
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 27, 2009, 1:07 pm 1:07 pm
Don’t we have more impotent things to think about?
Posted by: Mortimer Snerd | March 27, 2009, 3:11 pm 3:11 pm
Why sure he does. God in all of His loving kindness toward his us, ‘His creations,’ built into us a sinful nature, so that when we fall short he can consign us to an eternity of torture and unending agony. He loves us too much to forgive and forget so he gives us over to Satan if we aren’t good enough. With love like that, you wonder what happens to those of His creations that he hates.
Actually, no there is no Satan. God wouldn’t allow it. The Bible authors added it because they felt people would abuse God’s infinate mercy.
Posted by: Ted Cox | March 27, 2009, 3:12 pm 3:12 pm
Of course satan exists. It is ridiculous to think he doesn’t. But God is still in control. Read Job and you will find that satan had to get permission from God before he could take Job’s wealth and his children but God said “You cannot touch his life”.
God will only allow satan to go so far in this world. God is still in control.
Posted by: Jean Heckart | March 27, 2009, 3:13 pm 3:13 pm
Without exception, every religion that ever existed has been an exercise in do-it-yourself hypnosis. That’s the whole point of their function — to calm and control the frightened beast.
Posted by: William F. Brabenec | March 27, 2009, 3:51 pm 3:51 pm
==Don’t we have more impotent things to think about?==
More important than Salvation??? Uhhh, no.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 27, 2009, 4:52 pm 4:52 pm
==Actually, no there is no Satan.==
Actuall, yes there is.
== God wouldn’t allow it.==
He doesn’t. We do.
After all, Jesus defeated the works of the Devil. He showed us how not to give authority to the Devil. Some of us take Him seriously. Those who don’t live in denial.
== The Bible authors added it because they felt people would abuse God’s infinate mercy. ==
Garbage.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 27, 2009, 4:55 pm 4:55 pm
There is only one God. There is not a god of good and a god of evil. Satan is simply a way of conceptualizing remoteness from God, the essence of selfishness, materialism, jealousy, hatred, and fear. One of our purposes in life is to learn how to recognize and overcome our “dark side” and develop our ability to love, have compassion, be honest, truthful, selfless and just. Externalizing our negative qualities and blaming them on Satan or demons does not really get us there.
Posted by: Sara | March 27, 2009, 5:08 pm 5:08 pm
Satan exist because it is an evil, human suppressing, earth destroying, lustful, greedy, gluttony force that humans have to have virtue to control because we are FLESH; Just as God (or our creator, whether you believe scientific or spiritual)created us without supernatural powers so that we must practice virtue and self-control—– so does “satan” have power over humans because we are not capable of maintaining our earthly control unless we practice control of our flesh with a conscience and virtue.
Humans were created as a paradox. We live this way every day. It is unavoidable. Satan exist because we are in a constant struggle with what we should be and become. From childhood till death, each human struggles on a journey (and hopefully, progressive journey)for self-fulfillment, gratification, enlightenment, joy, love; At the same time this requires one be cognizant of the “self” and thoughts. To be fully cognizant is in itself a paradox and a balancing act. It means you need to know what thoughts to filter in and what thoughts to filter out and at exactly the right time. Thus, you must balance your desires of the FLESH and needs. This is where “satan” forces exist because one can’t ALWAYS be cognizant and know what is pure desire and what’s really necessary for the preservation and growth of the “self”.
Posted by: Lisa | March 27, 2009, 5:19 pm 5:19 pm
SATAN EXISTS IN OUR NEW PRESIDENT STANDING AGAINST LIFE AND EMBRACING DEATH OF OUR MOST INNOCENT CITIZENS, THE UNBORN, AND EXPORTING ABORTION TO OTHER COUNTRIES, BEGINNING WITH MEXICO ON HIS FIRST FEW DAYS IN OFFICE. WE ALL NEED TO PRAY FOR HIS CONVERSION. AND FOR ALL THOSE AMERICAN CITIZENS THAT ALSO SUPPORT THIS LOVE FOR KILLING INNOCENT UNBORN CHILDREN, AND NOW EVEN EMBRYOS—GOD HELP OUR COUNTRY!!! COMMUNISM AND SOCIALISM IS ONLY A STEP AWAY—–PRAY, PRAY, PRAY!!!!!!
Posted by: MARY | March 27, 2009, 5:54 pm 5:54 pm
Only in the hearts of men!!!!!!!!!!!!!! God is a positive light force and only light and love can be there. Therefore, if God is love and light and he created all things he would not have created negative force or evil. That, my friends is the work of humans. Amen.
Posted by: patricia | March 27, 2009, 6:18 pm 6:18 pm
Religion is a product of man’s inability to explain how nature works. Nature has no feelings. Things that happen are neither rewards nor punishments.
It is a difficult realization to believe that we are alone in this solar system, maybe the galaxy and maybe the whole universe. People need to have a “parent” in charge of them, to depend on and to talk to. Therefore God, by whatever name is given, exists.
Spiritual rewards and punishments are designed to help keep people in line with what those in power wanted the people to believe so that “they” could keep the power.
Religion is the opiate of the masses. It is a very powerful weapon in the wrong hands. Look to history for examples, the christian crusades, the jewish pograms, the islamic jihads, etc.
Posted by: Sarah | March 27, 2009, 6:37 pm 6:37 pm
Yes he exixts and delights in the fact that people deny his existence. The greatest strategy he has is in the diversions we are all preoccupied with.
Posted by: Bob | March 27, 2009, 6:48 pm 6:48 pm
This entire debate is nothing more than PR for the devil. I suggest they follow this with a “Does God exist?” debate. Believe me, people goodness exists, too. God is love and love conquers all.
Posted by: drjules900 | March 27, 2009, 7:20 pm 7:20 pm
I know you’ve been brought up or ushered into the belief that the bible is the infallible word of God, (I used to truly believe the same) but seriously, it’s pathetic.
Stop quoting verses from what others here have aptly and correctly described as a Bronze Age book of popular myths.
Do some research. Don’t put your abiding faith and trust (and whole LIFE) in what MAN wrote and the churches rewrote and mandated from !!thousands!! of years ago.
Think about it, do we still believe chanting makes it rain?!? You’re not being lead astray by the devil if you use your brain and think and ask questions. That’s why we understand the way things work now. That’s how the human race has been able to grow, learn, discover and create all that we have in the course of our brief existence on this planet. (50,000 years as modern humans…and hundreds of thousands of years as tool making beings.)
Dig a little deeper and don’t be afraid to find the truth that you’ve been buying into myth and lies.
Sure it seems scary to think that everything you’ve been taught is B.S. and that everything you’ve “interpreted” as spiritual moments in your own life are just a result of the way our brains work (especially in tandem with societal influences)…but why live in a delusion?
Sure it’s more comforting to call on blind faith, a loving God and a malevolent Satan, but take some responsibility and step into the 21st century and learn something!!! This backwards view of God and Satan is just pathetically uninformed given what the human race now KNOWS.
See my post from 6:29am above for some good resources if you want to discover the real TRUTH. It’s right there at your fingertips if you have the intelligence to seek it out and the independence to stop being spoon fed from your same old sources.
And I’m sorry to burst your bubble, but the Bible and every other religious text out there can NOT be taken literally or seriously. Please…seek truth.
Posted by: Chris | March 27, 2009, 8:28 pm 8:28 pm
There are no evil beings, but persons doing evil. And it follows that experiencing demonic attacks does not a devil make, since man himself makes mayhem. But if Satan must be taken as “real”, think of Paul’s approach that Satan acts as God’s agent not to corrupt but to test. The idea is to repent and change, not avoid hell.
Posted by: Doug | March 27, 2009, 8:38 pm 8:38 pm
==Stop quoting verses …==
No.
What’s the matter, they burning your eyes?
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 27, 2009, 11:06 pm 11:06 pm
I am a young physician, biology major,philosophy minor, grew up in a Buddhist home but my parents have always taught me to find my own path so I went to a Christian church, read the bible, went to a Seven Day Adventist University nearly got Baptized, went back to study Hindu and the Gita and currently reading the Koran. I still find knowledge in all the religion. In regards to the question I think there is fallacy is even asking the question. Whether Satan exist or not it doesn’t matter. If we (as humans) know we all have to head north, a compass pointing north is all we need. The compass is a metaphor of any world religion. All religion, in its purest essense, guides us “north”. Thank you.
Posted by: Dong | March 27, 2009, 11:09 pm 11:09 pm
I was very disappointed last night with your show. Your quality dropped from its normal high. It was a fight between non equals. One side was uneducated while the other has vast knowledge and it just fell flat and had no depth.
Could you do this again with real qualified theologians? This topic is just to important to just throw in the wind. With viewers all over the world, you should keep the edge sharp.
Posted by: Bill | March 27, 2009, 11:23 pm 11:23 pm
Jesus said that He is the ONLY Way to the Father.
Letsee a show of hands — posts — of and by those who say that Jesus is the “liar.” God would just like to have that for the record, for future reference.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 27, 2009, 11:36 pm 11:36 pm
Satan is just a way for people like that wh*re to blame something besides themselves for the stupid things they’ve done. The bible is a buncha crap, it wasn’t written by Jesus, it was edited by the stupid catholics because they wanted to control everyone with fear. And whaddyaknow it worked!!! For THOUSANDS of years it’s still working. Sad sad sad….
Posted by: Kathie | March 28, 2009, 1:03 am 1:03 am
I admire Deepak Chopra for expressing his beliefs among those that already have all the answers and are no longer asking questions but instead are following the easy path of putting their faith in some deity instead of in themselves. It is ironic that the messages of all religions rests somewhere near the concept of the ‘Golden Rule’, and yet more people have died in the eternal battle among religions for the right to declare their deity as the true God than for any other true conflict. I believe that Deepak was saying that we should concentrate on the ‘message’ and not the messenger. It is not possible for every religion to have the right concept of ‘God’, and there is the fundamental problem with who is going to make that decision. Why can’t we accept that a ‘God’ or life-force permeates everybody and every thing, and take responsibility for our own actions instead of depending on a mythical being to take over the responsibility for our own thoughts and actions? I do not profess to have the answer to who or what ‘God’ is, and it does not bother me in the least because the ‘message’ is the important concept, not the messenger. I am a seeker of truth and knowledge because I believe that truth comes from within by learning who we are instead of depending on an external power to define who we are.
Posted by: Bruce M. Cohen | March 28, 2009, 1:25 am 1:25 am
To Dave who’s Uncle is in Brazil preaching to hundreds.
You might better change that to thousands. If your Uncle is who I think he is, he doesn’t just preach, he teaches. The one I’m talking about just got back from Brazil.Furthermore, by the power of the Holy Spirit, he heals. He is one of the greatest teachers of the Bible on earth today. I saw him in Atlanta,Ga, I saw glory on the faces of people there. I saw people healed, I saw demons cast out just like when Jesus cast out demons from the man who had so many they called themselves legend. You have had the chance that others may never have, to have learned from such great teachers in your family. You should be ashamed because you must surely KNOW that satan exists, he must be trying to get into your mind.DON’T LET him IN. I watch your Uncle on the TBN network channel 52 in central Florida. By the way I am not the same religion as my parents or of the same political party. I am my own person I’ve researched and listened and let the Holy Spirit guild me to the truth, He can only speak the truth and the truth will set you free. I am a true BELIEVER. I have experienced God, Jesus, the Holy Spirit and yes satan and no one will ever change the way I believe. May God have mercy and bless us, and forgive our sins.
Love to all. Ruby
Posted by: Ruby | March 28, 2009, 3:12 am 3:12 am
If the promise of Heaven and or the fear of Hell are your only motivation for being a good person then nothing you do is ever simply to glorify God but to selfishly gain some eternal reward. What ever happend to living with integrety. For those of you who don’t know the word, it’s the willingness to do the right thing in the absense of supervision (God) or reward (Heaven). Integrety, self respect and respect for others are the principals that guide my life. No one will ever be able to say 100% if God or Satan exists, that is the foundation of faith, but if they do Satan seems to be showing up more and more in the pews and pulpits of the worlds religious institutions spewing hatred and intolerance in the name of God. This practice is so diviously alluring because it feeds on peoples fear of the other or the unknown. If you are using the words God and hates together, maybe you need to take a second look at the path your following in your spiritual life.
Posted by: Eric | March 28, 2009, 10:52 am 10:52 am
==No one will ever be able to say 100% if God or Satan exists…==
(Heb 11:1) Now faith is the substance of things hoped for, the evidence of things not seen.
Substance. Evidence. Facts.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 28, 2009, 12:44 pm 12:44 pm
Little air time was spent discussing the issue. It seemed more like they were debating other issues related to the Bible & Christianity.
Point is, if they are ready to believe in a god that represents good why are they reluctant to accept the existence of something that would represent evil?
Posted by: Ray | March 28, 2009, 3:09 pm 3:09 pm
==If the promise of Heaven and or the fear of Hell are your only motivation for being a good person then nothing you do is ever simply to glorify God but to selfishly gain some eternal reward. ==
In other words, to YOU, in YOUR world, God is an Object from Whom to take and take and take. Is THAT the way you treat people, too?
We love Him, not just to get prizes. We love Him cuz He loved us first and performed His promises, and we wanna take Him up on His promise to give us eternal life.
(1Co 2:9) But as it is written, Eye hath not seen, nor ear heard, neither have entered into the heart of man, the things which God hath prepared for them that love him.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 28, 2009, 3:11 pm 3:11 pm
==…if they are ready to believe in a god that represents good why are they reluctant to accept the existence of something that would represent evil?==
Cuz they think — wrongly — that, if they ignore the Devil, he’ll go away and/or, if they think the Devil into non-existence, then, to THEIR way of thinking, he doesn’t exist. It’s a used car salesman’s trick.
The Devil likes no resistence, and the best way to get that is to suggest to them, in their own word-thoughts [inner thoughts] that he doesn’t exist.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 28, 2009, 3:19 pm 3:19 pm
resistence —> resistance
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 28, 2009, 3:20 pm 3:20 pm
I form the light and create darkness: I make peace and create “EVIL”: I the Lord do all these things.Isaiah 45:7
Also: I created the waster (Satan) to destroy.Isaiah 54:16…It was necessary for God to create evil and follow it with the creation of satan who carries out evil. This was done for one reason only….”to teach mankind the difference.Example: if we were born and raised in the sun, we would not know the sun is shining until the darkness comes.Now that we have spent 6000 years in darkness, when the “SON” arrives, all shall know and appreciate.
Posted by: The Evangelist | March 28, 2009, 3:27 pm 3:27 pm
==If the promise of Heaven and or the fear of Hell are your only motivation for being a good person…==
Define “good person”? What is “good” enough?
==… then nothing you do is ever simply to glorify God but to selfishly gain some eternal reward.==
That’s the Muslim way, not the Christ way.
== What ever happend to living with integrety [sic].==
Whose?
== For those of you who don’t know the word, it’s the willingness to do the right thing in the absense [sic] of supervision (God) or reward (Heaven).==
“Separation from God” is the definition of “sin.” Absence from God would be separation from Him.
Separate from Him, it is impossible to do the “right” thing.
==Integrety [[sic], self respect and respect for others are the principals [sic] that guide my life.==
So, you get to make it all up as you go along. How convenient. No judge other than yourself. So, do I also get to be the judge of what I do, or must I submit my wishes to you first?
== Satan seems to be showing up more and more in the pews and pulpits of the worlds religious institutions spewing hatred and intolerance in the name of God.==
Translation: “Anything that is said that is not in line with what I think, in my own made-up integrity and goodness, is hatred.”
==If you are using the words God and hates together, maybe you need to take a second look at the path your following in your spiritual life.==
Sooo, YOU get to judge, according to YOUR agenda, whether, when we use the Word of God, we are communicating hate, huh?
Well, I don’t submit to you, twinkletoes. I submit to God and let the chips fall where they may.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 28, 2009, 3:32 pm 3:32 pm
==”I form the light and create darkness…”==
That is NATURAL light and darkness.
God, here, commands His Sovereignty over both.
==”…: I make peace and create ‘EVIL’…”==
“create evil — not moral evil (Jam_1:13), but in contrast to “peace” in the parallel clause, war, disaster (compare Psa_65:7; Amo_3:6).” — Jamieson, Fausset and Brown Commentary
“creates evil, not the evil of sin, but the evil of punishment. He is the Author of all that is true, holy, good, or happy; and evil, error, and misery, came into the world by his permission, through the wilful apostacy of his creatures, but are restrained and overruled to his righteous purpose.” — Matthew Henry Concise Commentary
==Also: “I created the waster (Satan) to destroy.” Isaiah 54:16==
“I have created the waster to destroy – I have formed every man who is engaged in spreading desolation by wars, and I have every such man under my control (see the notes at Isa_10:5-7; Isa_37:26-27; Isa_46:1-6). The sense here is, that as God had all such conquerors under his control, they could accomplish no more than he permitted them to do. — Matthew Barnes’ Notes on the Bible
“and I have created the waster to destroy; military men, soldiers that use the above weapons of destruction for that purpose; these are God’s creatures, and he can destroy or disappoint them, so that their hands cannot perform their enterprise. — John Gill’s Exposition on the Entire Bible
==…It was necessary for God to create evil and follow it with the creation of satan who carries out evil.==
As explained, that is not true.
== This was done for one reason only….”to teach mankind the difference.==
God’s response to Evil that came from Lucifer’s choice to bolt and get Man to drift is His teaching, not the other way around.
==Example: if we were born and raised in the sun, we would not know the sun is shining until the darkness comes.==
Not scriptural.
==Now that we have spent 6000 years in darkness, when the “SON” arrives, all shall know and appreciate.==
The Son — that is, the Word — is here now, and, by Him, we can know and appreciate. He says, “Follow Me” now, not later. Later is too late.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 28, 2009, 3:47 pm 3:47 pm
That man who is call the “Father of lies,The god( little G) of this world, the deceiver, according to the bible would deceive many,even elect,” is real.
According to the Bible,Satan comes to steal,kill and destroy. The only way he
can fulfilled his work,is by dening
his existance and allowing his to do whatever he wants in our lives.Conclusion; when we do so,he will invade with no mercy.
Posted by: Arlene | March 28, 2009, 3:48 pm 3:48 pm
To clear this up…
==Example: if we were born and raised in the sun, we would not know the sun is shining until the darkness comes.==
Not scriptural, except that there are times when the sinner has to be give up to Satan that the sinner learns and knows.
In the Garden, Man knew not the darkness. He walked in the Light of God without having compared it to darkness. It was only AFTER temptation and acting on that temptation that Man compared it to darkness and jumped into the darkness.
Thus, now, we need adversity, not darkness, to see that we need the Light and not to be in the darkness. So, in the end, we don’t need darkness. Darkness shows us nothing; it’s what happens to us in the darkness that’s the trouble, and, if we’re of a changed heart, we see the Light that leads us outta the darkness.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 28, 2009, 3:55 pm 3:55 pm
Watching the entire uncut version of the Satan debate was great. I don’t agree with any of the panelists, who were all either Christian or at least spiritual. Being an atheist, I think there are no external spiritual forces of any kind, good OR evil, and that when humans do evil things, it comes entirely from within them. Some of these people can be rehabilitated, but some cannot.
I do believe that believing in mythical or spiritual beings IS the cause of most historical wars and cultural hatreds, because it allows people to think in terms of ME versus THEM, as Deepak Chopra pointed out. I believe that because human beings are social animals and must live with one another, laws have to be created by society so that people do not harm one another, and that because we can never totally get rid of people who will chose to do evil, we must either lock these people away from others or rehabilitate them.
All evil comes from within. But so does all good.
Posted by: Pam Minch | March 28, 2009, 3:56 pm 3:56 pm
It’s not the darkness that we need, rather to realize our condition before God before we can know that we need God’s Mercy.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 28, 2009, 3:57 pm 3:57 pm
==…believing in mythical or spiritual beings IS the cause of most historical wars and cultural hatreds, because it allows people to think in terms of ME versus THEM…==
Except that the Godless killed more than anybody in the past hundred years.
==…because human beings are social animals and must live with one another, laws have to be created by society so that people do not harm one another, and that because we can never totally get rid of people who will chose to do evil, we must either lock these people away from others or rehabilitate them.==
How do we know what’s good and what’s bad? Who makes THAt decision for all of us, based on what standard?
==All evil comes from within. But so does all good.
==
How do I know, then, which is which?
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 28, 2009, 4:01 pm 4:01 pm
Question is:
Does God represent Man’s “good,” what men think is “good,” or is Man supposed to represent God’s Good?
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 28, 2009, 4:04 pm 4:04 pm
If God created all that is good, then He couldn’t have created what is bad. He cannot be dualminded and expect us to follow His Good if He also created bad cuz many would go bad and justify it by saying that He created bad, too.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 28, 2009, 4:06 pm 4:06 pm
==…there are no external spiritual forces of any kind, good OR evil, and that when humans do evil things, it comes entirely from within them. ==
Sooo, you know, for a fact, that there is no spiritual dimension parallel to this dimension? How do you know this if you don’t know anywhere near all there is to know? Cuz you’d have to know all there is to know in order to know and say, conclusively, that there are no external spiritual forces.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 28, 2009, 4:11 pm 4:11 pm
So, is the Evangelist, up there at 3:27, saying that God has an evil side, that, if God is love, love must also be evil?
If THAT’s God’s Message, how do we know what to do?
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 28, 2009, 4:14 pm 4:14 pm
If God created Good and evil, is the Devil good? Why, then, did Jesus, in the wilderness, resist the Devil with Scripture? Wy didn’t Jesus embrace the Devil?
If God created evil, and God is love, and I am evil, do I love, biblically?
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 28, 2009, 4:21 pm 4:21 pm
(Rom 1:22) Professing themselves to be wise, they became fools,
(Rom 1:23) And changed the glory of the uncorruptible God into an image made like to corruptible man, and to birds, and fourfooted beasts, and creeping things.
(Rom 1:24) Wherefore God also gave them up to uncleanness through the lusts of their own hearts, to dishonour their own bodies between themselves:
(Rom 1:25) Who changed the truth of God into a lie, and worshipped and served the creature more than the Creator, who is blessed for ever. Amen.
(Rom 1:26) For this cause God gave them up unto vile affections: for even their women did change the natural use into that which is against nature:
(Rom 1:27) And likewise also the men, leaving the natural use of the woman, burned in their lust one toward another; men with men working that which is unseemly, and receiving in themselves that recompence of their error which was meet.
(Rom 1:28) And even as they did not like to retain God in their knowledge, God gave them over to a reprobate mind, to do those things which are not convenient;
(Rom 1:29) Being filled with all unrighteousness, fornication, wickedness, covetousness, maliciousness; full of envy, murder, debate, deceit, malignity; whisperers,
(Rom 1:30) Backbiters, haters of God, despiteful, proud, boasters, inventors of evil things, disobedient to parents,
(Rom 1:31) Without understanding, covenantbreakers, without natural affection, implacable, unmerciful:
(Rom 1:32) Who knowing the judgment of God, that they which commit such things are worthy of death, not only do the same, but have pleasure in them that do them.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 28, 2009, 4:27 pm 4:27 pm
Are Godly and ungodly the same, if God created evil?
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 28, 2009, 4:28 pm 4:28 pm
Sooo many questions and sooo many professing to know and without answers, even though the answers are readily available in His Word to those who are dilegent seekers of the Truth.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 28, 2009, 4:30 pm 4:30 pm
dilegent—>diligent
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 28, 2009, 4:39 pm 4:39 pm
So, to some, God created Good and evil.
So, what’s with the mixed messages, then, if He wants to save us?
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 28, 2009, 4:52 pm 4:52 pm
Yes Satan exists because God exist. Man that says in his heart that there is no God is a fool. As Satan is filled with pride and vanity so is the fool. As Satan wanted to ascend to the mountain of God and become God so does the fool. He thinks he has the wisdom of God and therefore he thinks by saying that Satan and God does not exists that he makes it true by his very word. God says that the wisdom of man is foolishness to God and the wisdom of God is foolishness to man. We cannot not understand God unless we enter the mind of God which is only possible by taking on the mind of Christ and we accomplish this by first believing that God exist and that he is a rewarder of them that diligently seek him.
Christ knew Satan from the beginning of Creation. He says through the Prophet Isaiah, “how art thou fallen from heaven, O Lucifer, son of the morning, how art thou cut down to the ground, which didst weaken the nations! For thou has said in thine heart, I will ascend into heaven; I will sit also upon the mount of the congregation, in the sides of the north: I will ascend above the heights of the clouds; I will be like the most High. Yet thou shalt be brought down to hell, to the side of the pit. They that see thee shall narrowly look upon thee, and consider thee, saying, is this the man that made the earth to tremble, that did shake kingdoms; That made the world as a wilderness, and destroyed the cities thereof; that opened not the house of his prisoners? All the kings of the nations, even all of them, lie in glory, every one in his own house. But thou art cast out of the grave like an abominable branch, and as raiment of those that are slain, thrust through with a sword, that go down to the sides of the pit; as a carcass trodden under feet. Thou shalt not be joined with them in burial, because thou has destroyed the land and slain thy people; the seed of evildoers shall never be renowned. Prepare slaughter for his children for the iniquity of their fathers; that they do not rise, nor possess the land, nor fill the face of the world with cities.
God was so concerned about people going to hell that he told his prophets that they must warn the wicked that they were going to hell if they did not repent of their sins and if they did not take the warning seriously and did not repent then the blood of their soul was on their own souls but if on the other hand the prophet did not warn the wicked then the blood of the souls of the wicked was on the prophet’s soul. This is why that it is important to warn people of the consequences of not believing in the only way that can save them from living throughout all eternity in the pit of hell. It is not a place of good times like some misinformed people like to convey but a place where you will be alive with pain fluctuating throughout your body with unrelenting hunger and thirst, while feeling hot and cold simultaneously and with all sorts of viral, bacterial, and fungus diseases devouring your body continuously. At the same time people will be closed up in individual holes in the side of the pit cursing each other and saying why did I listen to your lies? And they will say, yea, well, why did you? And then it will be too late and it will be all over but the screaming and cursing.
Discerning Spirit
Posted by: Discerning Spirit | March 28, 2009, 6:37 pm 6:37 pm
Jesus states in the Holy Bible that in John 3:16 “For God so loves the world that He gave his only begotten son that whoesover believes in Him shall not PERISH, that is, go to Hell, but have everlasting life, here on earth and in heaven. In John 10:10 Jesus also said that he gives life abundantly. However, Satan kills, steals, and destroys. Just remember the Bible is the Truth and it is Fact. Sally Finegold
Posted by: Sally R. Finegold | March 28, 2009, 7:07 pm 7:07 pm
God gave us the freedom to choose, he didn’t create evil
Posted by: Izzo | March 28, 2009, 7:58 pm 7:58 pm
Mr Incredible all of your logic is faulty because a FACT cannot be gleened from an unproven BELIEF and all of your so called facts stem from your belief that the Bible is the word of God. Even if you could prove that to be true, you also believe that anything that is filtered through man is tainted and since God did not sit down at a desk and write out the Bible Himself it cannot be a purely untarnished document no matter how devinly inspired it’s iterpretation has been influenced by the subjectivity and limitations of mans understanding of the infinite.
Posted by: Eric | March 29, 2009, 2:07 am 2:07 am
==Mr Incredible all of your logic is faulty because a FACT cannot be gleened from an unproven [sic] BELIEF…==
Except that’s not true.
==… and all of your so called facts stem from your belief that the Bible is the word of God.==
Which He is.
==Even if you could prove that to be true, you also believe that anything that is filtered through man is tainted…==
Thanks to Adam and Eve, we ARE imperfect through them.
==… and since God did not sit down at a desk and write out the Bible Himself it cannot be a purely untarnished document no matter how devinly inspired it’s [sic] iterpretation [sic] has been influenced by the subjectivity and limitations of mans [sic] understanding of the infinite. ==
Who wrote The Ten Commandments on a mountain’s stone? A man didn’t.
The fact is that it has been proved by the experience of great, great, great multitudes of multitudes of hundreds and thousands of multitudes that the Word of God is true, that God has performed as He said He would. I am one of those multitudes.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 29, 2009, 3:09 am 3:09 am
Again Mr. Incredible all of your argument stems from a documet that only holds water under your willingness to beieve in it there is no real fact in that only your faith. Facts hold a CONSISTENTLY OBSERVEABLE TRUTH, wether or not you believe it, that connot be attributed to any other cause. The story of the Ten Commandments is just that. There is no real proof that they came to us in the way stated in the Bible. You and many more choose to BELEIVE it’s true but that does not make it fact.
Posted by: Eric | March 29, 2009, 9:56 am 9:56 am
I had my own personal learning experience with God, when I’d finally given up on learning “why” for everything & then found myself one with eternal peace & in that eternal moment, was shown/knew we are all one, eternity & peace. “God” is the eternal peace we all truly are. “Satan” is our human self that thinks there’s something to fear in this physical world of the finite & strife-ridden where all seems separate from one another. Our experience of being human here on earth is to have amnesia about who we truly are, so being here is to be in “school” where we learn so much more about who we truly are. We think there’s something to fear about dying because we don’t remember eternity – so, we hold onto the life we know here for dear life; therefore, things like war take place. We even hold onto our opinions for dear life; therefore, arguments take place. However, our fear isn’t wrong or bad – it’s simply what is when being human here on earth. In fact, it’s our fear that teaches us more about who we truly are. As we move through the always present challenges here on earth, we are provided opportunities for glimpsing the eternal peace that is us. To learn about who we truly are in the midst of who we truly aren’t is to expand who we truly are in a unique & powerful way. There are no sides here (it only seems that way to our human selves). There’s only our fearful human selves & our divine reality working together to ever-deepen our realization of our oneness, of eternity, of peace: of who we truly are. P.S. You won’t find the peace of God that passes all understanding “out there” in a religious leader, group, doctrine, book etc – it’s something that comes to you when you alone go deep inside your own heart.
Posted by: Michelle Sullivan | March 29, 2009, 12:41 pm 12:41 pm
Yes, Satan exists. And he knows how to make a quick $100 million.
http://michaelfury.wordpress.com/2008/08/20/the-ghost-in-the-machines-the-mystery-of-the-wtc-hard-drive-recoveries/
Posted by: ghost | March 29, 2009, 12:49 pm 12:49 pm
==Again Mr. Incredible all of your argument stems from a documet that only holds water under your willingness to beieve in it there is no real fact in that only your faith.==
Except, again, that that’s not true.
Great, great, great, great multitudes of thousands of multitudes of multitudes of multitudes have experienced what I have, and these experiences prove that God has perfomed what He promised to perform and that, therefore, the Word of God is true and correct. That YOU don’t receive Him doesn’t make Him otherwise.
== Facts hold a CONSISTENTLY OBSERVEABLE TRUTH…==
That’s true and that applies to what I explained above. Others’ and my experience validate God’s performance through His Word.
==The story of the Ten Commandments is just that.==
Excdept that there was one witness, on scene. He says it happened as he says it happened.
Now, where is YOUR witness, on scene, who says otherwise?
== There is no real proof that they came to us in the way stated in the Bible.==
Where is your witness, on scene, who disputes Moses who WAS there?
== You and many more choose to BELEIVE it’s true but that does not make it fact. ==
That is correct that I don’t say something is fact before I know it to be fact. It is fact first, and I recognize it, and then I report that fact, and I have here. So, my saying it’s fact doesn’t compel it to be so, rather the other way that the fact that it’s fact compels ME.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 29, 2009, 1:08 pm 1:08 pm
==Facts hold a CONSISTENTLY OBSERVEABLE TRUTH…==
God’s promised performance, through His Word, has been consistently observed by me and others throughout the Ages. We say that we were not seeing and hearing things. You say we were, and, yet you have no proof other than to say that YOU didn’t see them, nor hear them. All THAT means is that you didn’t receive what was there and we did and do.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 29, 2009, 1:15 pm 1:15 pm
==Again Mr. Incredible all of your argument stems from a documet that only holds water under your willingness to beieve in it there is no real fact in that only your faith.==
To clarify:
It’s true that my mere saying it doesn’t make it true. It’s true, independent of my saying it, that the fact of it’s Truth compels me to say it.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 29, 2009, 1:23 pm 1:23 pm
==Facts hold a CONSISTENTLY OBSERVEABLE TRUTH…==
Of course, first, we have to find out WHOSE “facts” you’re talking about.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 29, 2009, 1:40 pm 1:40 pm
Of course, YOU’ll say, “Facts are facts!” and, then, you’ll continue to dismiss the facts WE know. So, even to YOU, facts are not always facts.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 29, 2009, 1:42 pm 1:42 pm
What I did there I call a “prebuttal.”
“Prebuttal” anticipates an argument and shoots that outta the air before the other person can make it.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 29, 2009, 1:45 pm 1:45 pm
==Facts hold a CONSISTENTLY OBSERVEABLE TRUTH…==
The facts of God’s performance of His promises hold a CONSISTENTLY OBSERVABLE TRUTH witnessed by the multitudes I told you about.
Now, when you say, “observable,” what are you talking about? What kinda observation? Seeing with the natural eyes, for instance? Well, if THAT’s the standard, then, since you cannot see “love,” nor “beauty,” they must not be facts, by YOUR standard, that is.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 29, 2009, 2:00 pm 2:00 pm
==Jesus states in the Holy Bible that in John 3:16 “For God so loves the world that He gave his only begotten son …==
God, in Genesis 1:3, spoke Light into the darkness, not darkness into light. He did not create the darkness so that He could speak Light into it cuz, when He first created, all was dark and void already, just like so many hearts, thanks to Adam and Eve.
Jesus was the True Light God spoke into existence. He came by — took the path of [least resistance?] — Grace and Truth.
Therefore, when you speak “Light be!” into the darkness of the world, you are doing what God did, speaking Grace and Truth into and to the world of darkness. It is a creative act.
God did not create evil, and, so, He does not tell you to speak evil into and to the world of darkness cuz it’s already there! He tells you to speak the Light of Grace and Truth, not dark, and He tells you the difference in Proverbs 18:21.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 29, 2009, 2:35 pm 2:35 pm
Gods CONSISTANTLY OBSERVABLE TRUTH is most often not cosistant but sparatic (your prayers will not always be answered) and could generally be explained in some other way, therefore you cannot factually say that God was the cause only that, through your faith, you believe him to be the cause. Try as you may but God and faith cannot intersect with fact. If Gods existance could be proven there would be no need for faith. You don’t have to put faith in the exisitance of a tree because you can see and feel it to prove its there. And you are right, love and beauty are not facts either so you do have to have faith that someone loves you when they say they do. You can’t prove that they really do, you just choose to believe it or not.
Posted by: Eric | March 29, 2009, 3:07 pm 3:07 pm
==Gods [sic] CONSISTANTLY OBSERVABLE TRUTH is most often not cosistant but sparatic…==
God’s truth is observable and consistent all the time. Others and I are witnesses to that fact.
==… (your prayers will not always be answered)…==
The prayers of His Children — that is, those who are born again — are always answered.
They aren’t always what we want. Sometimes, we hinder the answer. Sometime, we pray amiss. If the desire aligns with the Word of God, it is always answered. Actually, even if it does not align with the Word of God, it is answered — in the negative.
==… you cannot factually say that God was the cause…==
Either God is the cause, or He allowed the cause for His purposes. All things happen for the good for those who love Him. He may allow the disobedient to get away with something, not for the benefit of the disobedient person, rather for the benefit of the obedient person.
==… only that, through your faith, you believe him to be the cause.==
The First Cause — that is, God — happens whether I believe that He exists, or not, or whether I trust Him, or not. He will as He Wills. He didn’t wait for me in order to create the world.
== Try as you may but God and faith cannot intersect with fact.==
That, essentially, is what the Devil told Eve, in the Garden. Eve of course, was enticed by that argument, and she went on to entice Adam, and it continues today.
== If Gods [sic] existance [sic] could be proven [sic] there would be no need for faith.==
God exists apart from my faith. I didn’t just make Him up.
== You don’t have to put faith in the exisitance [sic] of a tree because you can see and feel it to prove its there.==
However, you must put faith in the existence of “love” and “beauty” cuz you can’t see them. So, you make my argument for me.
== And you are right, love and beauty are not facts either so you do have to have faith that someone loves you when they say they do. You can’t prove that they really do, you just choose to believe it or not. ==
Thanks for making my argument for me. You just defeated your own argument.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 29, 2009, 3:43 pm 3:43 pm
I believe 21st century Americans, while much more advanced than they were several thousands, and even hundreds of years ago, are still extremely primitive in the knowledge of the great universe and what exists beyond our little piece of grass here in the U.S. Unfortunately, most people in this conversation do not have a clue about what goes in the universe. People like Chopra I would have thought had had a little more experience in life even on this planet than he exhibits. People who have never seen evil have had a very sheltered existence in life and are extremely arrogant in the idea that there is no evil or supernatural beings who influence men and women at times. I don’t doubt that a lot of people don’t recognize Satan or his demons, that is his goal. They will perhaps when he is unleashed on them…
Satan seeks to kill and destroy, and he will take our children and try to destroy their very lives with drugs and sexual diseases or activities that will lock them away for the rest of their life or even literally destroy their body. He will cause a person to do something they could have never conceived of, like drowning their own children… yes, mental disease does exist, but there is also a spiritual influence that can take over and cause someone to act totally out of their character.
I do not for one bit believe we are the only beings in this great universe..OR that we are so smart that we know what exists and doesn’t, by our own thinking.
The beginning of wisdom is the knowledge of God.. and God confounds the wise so they don’t even comprehend or believe …. Be careful if you think you are wise.
Posted by: 4hopesoon | March 29, 2009, 3:54 pm 3:54 pm
== And you are right, love and beauty are not facts either so you do have to have faith that someone loves you when they say they do. You can’t prove that they really do, you just choose to believe it or not. ==
“Love” and “beauty” DO exist. They exist in the spiritual dimension. They manifest themselves in the physical in many ways, according to private interpretation. That private interpretation may correspond with reality, or not. It depends on experience. It is not Science. It is life. It is not subject to scientific tests and proof. That doesn’t mean they aren’t any less real.
Faith gives you access to that reality. Faith gives you access to the reality of God, too. So, God is not subject to scientific proof, rather to the proof of life experience, just as “love” and “beauty” are not subject to scientific proof, rather to the proof of life experience.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 29, 2009, 3:55 pm 3:55 pm
If God created evil, then He must be pleased with evil. How can that be? Is He directing us to Good, or to evil? Did He bring those who are born again out of darkness, or out of Light?
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 29, 2009, 4:00 pm 4:00 pm
(Heb 4:2) For unto us was the gospel preached, as well as unto them: but the word preached did not profit them, not being mixed with faith in them that heard it.
(Heb 11:1) Now faith is the substance of things hoped for, the evidence of things not seen.
There are facts accessible only by faith.
However,
(Joh 1:10) He was in the world, and the world was made by him, and the world knew him not.
(Joh 1:12) But as many as received him, to them gave he power to become the sons of God, even to them that believe on his name…
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 29, 2009, 4:32 pm 4:32 pm
The scoffers are chokin’ on this.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 29, 2009, 4:52 pm 4:52 pm
I guess the Word of God is right: Mouths are stopped.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 29, 2009, 6:20 pm 6:20 pm
well all i can say is that i will be praying for you people that dont beleive but if you beleive in one you got to beleive in the other.it like this i rether live live my life beleiving there is a God and die and find out theres not. than to live my life like there is not a God an to die and find out that there is.so think about that for awhile because when you die it is to late.
Posted by: jessie | March 29, 2009, 10:21 pm 10:21 pm
Those who know the least are usually the ones that shout the loudest…BC
Posted by: Bruce | March 29, 2009, 11:36 pm 11:36 pm
I say thank you Mr Incredible for proving my original point which was that your faith nor the faith of the multitudes PROVES the existance of God any more than the lack of faith proves that he dosen’t exist. Faith is personal and for Christians to say that only their faith is real is arrogant and unrepresentative of a true loving God.
Posted by: Eric | March 30, 2009, 9:11 am 9:11 am
There are an estimated 6.4 billion people on the planet with 6.4 billion separate beliefs, perceptions, experiences and interpretations. Each Major Religion has its groups of denomintions or sects that have its own interpretation of each “Holy Book”. The Bible, the Quran, etc. If you trace the origins of each religious book back as far as you can go their is no proof of authenticity or who the original writers. People have been born into families and communitotes that expouse certain beliefs. Those beliefs provide a basic I am from a small town in Georgia where yoi have hundreds of Christian Denominations where they disagree of ther interpretation of the bible. So there is no proof, there is a poltical history and motivation from the Emperor Constantine to create the Bible, and all the Christian Denomionations can’t agree on a unified interpretation. So does Satan exist? I don’t belive he does. But Can I prove that he doesn’t no. So I will take the most honest approach and say I don’t know but based on all the information provided. Belief is an assumption. Knowing something can only be gained through personal experience. Turn your belief systems into known systems. Do I know that my awareness survives without the body? Yes How do I know? I had several Out of Body experiences with validation. Did i ever see Satan? no Did I see others who were family memebers? Back to my point is people need to reseach what they believe and critically analyze it from every angle before they can impose their view onto another person before they can say another is wrong. Religious abuse can be one of the worst forms of abuse. it has lead to psychological disfunction, arguments, murder, and wars. Love, kindness, cooperation, giving, and compassion are subjective experiences in my own awareness that i know to be expression of the source of my life. So if believing in Satan is what you chose that is yoru choice. if you choose not to belive in Satain that is your choice. Most Christians use Circular reasoning to say that Satan exists by referencing the Bible. Now if Satan showed up on national Television and demostrated his power infront of billions or myself I may strongly consider his existence. Thank you ;)
Posted by: Shaye | March 30, 2009, 11:04 am 11:04 am
There are an estimated 6.4 billion people on the planet with 6.4 billion separate beliefs, perceptions, experiences and interpretations. Each Major Religion has its groups of denomintions or sects that have its own interpretation of each “Holy Book”. The Bible, the Quran, etc. If you trace the origins of each religious book back as far as you can go their is no proof of authenticity or who the original writers. People have been born into families and communitotes that expouse certain beliefs. Those beliefs provide a basic I am from a small town in Georgia where yoi have hundreds of Christian Denominations where they disagree of ther interpretation of the bible. So there is no proof, there is a poltical history and motivation from the Emperor Constantine to create the Bible, and all the Christian Denomionations can’t agree on a unified interpretation. So does Satan exist? I don’t belive he does. But Can I prove that he doesn’t no. So I will take the most honest approach and say I don’t know but based on all the information provided. Belief is an assumption. Knowing something can only be gained through personal experience. Turn your belief systems into known systems. Do I know that my awareness survives without the body? Yes How do I know? I had several Out of Body experiences with validation. Did i ever see Satan? no Did I see others who were family memebers? Back to my point is people need to reseach what they believe and critically analyze it from every angle before they can impose their view onto another person before they can say another is wrong. Religious abuse can be one of the worst forms of abuse. it has lead to psychological disfunction, arguments, murder, and wars. Love, kindness, cooperation, giving, and compassion are subjective experiences in my own awareness that i know to be expression of the source of my life. So if believing in Satan is what you chose that is yoru choice. if you choose not to belive in Satain that is your choice. Most Christians use Circular reasoning to say that Satan exists by referencing the Bible. Now if Satan showed up on national Television and demostrated his power infront of billions or myself I may strongly consider his existence. Thank you ;)
Posted by: Shaye | March 30, 2009, 11:04 am 11:04 am
==There are an estimated 6.4 billion people on the planet with 6.4 billion separate beliefs, perceptions, experiences and interpretations.==
The Devil is so pleased, too.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 30, 2009, 2:07 pm 2:07 pm
==..your faith nor the faith of the multitudes PROVES the existance of God any more than the lack of faith proves that he dosen’t exist.==
But, according to witnesses, it does.
== Faith is personal and for Christians to say that only their faith is real is arrogant…==
We say only what our Father says and do only what our Father does.
Jesus said that He is the ONLY Way to the Father.
==… and unrepresentative of a true loving God. ==
The true, loving God says that He is the ONLY Way to Salvation. We report what He says. You don’t believe it. So what?
Thanks for proving my point.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 30, 2009, 2:10 pm 2:10 pm
==… and unrepresentative of a true loving God. ==
Tell us what “love” is, according to God. After all, you must know, if you make that statement. Don’t tell us what the love does. Tell us what it IS.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 30, 2009, 2:12 pm 2:12 pm
==..your faith nor the faith of the multitudes PROVES the existance of God any more than the lack of faith proves that he dosen’t exist.==
But, according to witnesses, it does — that is, faith proves He exists cuz, according to that faith, He has performed. It’s just that those who have no such faith can’t see what He has performed. They are blind.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 30, 2009, 2:14 pm 2:14 pm
==Most Christians use Circular reasoning to say that Satan exists by referencing the Bible.==
It’s not circular reasoning. It’s just that your head is spinning.
== Now if Satan showed up on national Television and demostrated his power infront of billions or myself I may strongly consider his existence.==
So, seeing is believing, to YOU.
That means that “love” and “beauty,” to YOU, don’t exist cuz you can’t see them. We get it.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 30, 2009, 2:19 pm 2:19 pm
==So if believing in Satan is what you chose that is yoru choice.==
We don’t believe IN Satan. That is, we don’t trust in Satan.
[We don't give him authority, license, to act. Adam and Eve gave him permission to act. Having been born again, with the Power of God -- that is, the Word -- I took that permission back.]
We know THAT he exists.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 30, 2009, 2:22 pm 2:22 pm
==well all i can say is that i will be praying for you people that dont beleive but if you beleive in one you got to beleive in the other.it like this i rether live live my life beleiving there is a God and die and find out theres not. than to live my life like there is not a God an to die and find out that there is.so think about that for awhile because when you die it is to late.== — jessie
Thank you, jessie!
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 30, 2009, 2:25 pm 2:25 pm
==…for Christians to say that only their faith is real is arrogant and unrepresentative of a true loving God.==
To YOU, “loving” means “permission to do whatever you want.” However, to GOD, it doesn’t mean that.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 30, 2009, 2:35 pm 2:35 pm
==Most Christians use Circular reasoning to say that Satan exists by referencing the Bible.==
We reference our own pre-born-again lives and experiences to prove that Satan exists. We also know that he attacks us every minute of every day, to no avail, of course, in those who are strong in the LORD. Then, we point to the Word of God Which warned us of Satan’s MO and devices.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 30, 2009, 2:50 pm 2:50 pm
==…your faith nor the faith of the multitudes PROVES the existance of God…==
There are facts accessible only by faith:
(Heb 11:1) Now faith is the substance of things hoped for, the evidence of things not seen.
Faith is substance and evidence.
However:
(1Co 2:14) But the natural man receiveth not the things of the Spirit of God: for they are foolishness unto him: neither can he know them, because they are spiritually discerned.
So, there are facts that scoffers, mockers and scorners — the unfaithful — cannot perceive. Then, they use this blindness to “prove,” in their minds, that God doesn’t exist. How convenient.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 30, 2009, 3:05 pm 3:05 pm
Come on people…Mr. Incredible must be putting us on…nobody could possibly be that big a self-righteous, sanctimonious, narrow-minded idiot.
Posted by: Bruce | March 30, 2009, 3:24 pm 3:24 pm
==Come on people…Mr. Incredible must be putting us on…nobody could possibly be that big a self-righteous…==
No, CHRIST Righteous!
==… sanctimonious…==
I’m one-a God’s sheep, separated from the goats.
==… narrow-minded idiot.==
We have the Mind of Christ, having been born again. For the record He keeps — for future reference, mind you — you callin’ Christ an “idiot”?
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 30, 2009, 4:12 pm 4:12 pm
==Mr. Incredible must be putting us on…==
If I am putting you on, then the Word of God must be putting you on.
If the Word of God is not putting you on, then I am not putting you on.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 30, 2009, 4:15 pm 4:15 pm
==…nobody could possibly be that big a self-righteous, sanctimonious, narrow-minded idiot. ==
“Nobody” must include me. Gee, thanks!
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 30, 2009, 4:16 pm 4:16 pm
==…nobody could possibly be that big a self-righteous…==
The Pharisees said the same thing about Jesus, and Jesus told them the same thing I will tell you:
I haven’t lifted myself up, rather I have lifted God, through Christ, up.
I don’t speak of and for myself, rather of and for Him and what God tells me to speak. I speak what I hear Him speak, through His Word, and do what I see Him do.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 30, 2009, 4:20 pm 4:20 pm
It is a lie to deny the fact of God and His performance of what He promised.
Therefore, I will not deny that God is fact and so is His performance of what He promised, cuz I have lived it and am a witness to it.
Just cuz YOU haven’t lived it doesn’t mean I haven’t, nor that God doesn’t exist, nor that He didn’t perform.
Just cuz He’s invisible doesn’t translate into no-existence.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 30, 2009, 4:33 pm 4:33 pm
==Mr. Incredible must be putting us on…nobody could possibly be that big a self-righteous, sanctimonious, narrow-minded idiot. ==
Romans 8:1 [KJV]
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 30, 2009, 4:35 pm 4:35 pm
I rest my case..
Posted by: Bruce | March 30, 2009, 9:36 pm 9:36 pm
==I rest my case..==
What case?
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 30, 2009, 9:38 pm 9:38 pm
Mr. Incredible is actually just Mr. Very Annoying.
This thread has turned from a forum to a revival tent.
Posted by: carlton f. | March 31, 2009, 12:08 am 12:08 am
We used to believe in Zeus, Hercules, Venus, and their kin. Very real, very true at one time. Belief is powerful. Everyone’s ideas about God and the devil are changing and will do so for a long time. One day we’ll look back on these beliefs that we’ve created about God and a devil and call them our “Christian mythology.”
Posted by: Robin | March 31, 2009, 12:13 am 12:13 am
==Mr. Incredible is actually just Mr. Very Annoying.==
Things are tough all over.
==This thread has turned from a forum to a revival tent.==
This thread asks the question, “Does Satan exist?”
Are you trying to say that we aren’t allowed to answer that question?
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 31, 2009, 12:14 am 12:14 am
RE: “daily” (COMMENT #10 from the top):
God does not exist and neither does Satan.
Just because one believes this does not make their existence any more real.
[See? Your logic works just as well in reverse... Actually, better.]
Posted by: chuck in AK | March 31, 2009, 12:16 am 12:16 am
==We used to believe in Zeus, Hercules, Venus, and their kin.==
You did. I didn’t.
==Very real, very true at one time.==
I’m sorry to see that you were afflicted.
== Belief is powerful.==
When Jesus said, “Out of the abundance of the heart, the mouth speaks,” and where Psalm 18:21 says, “Death and life are in the power of the tongue…” it is clear that whatever is in the heart will be spoken.
== Everyone’s ideas about God and the devil are changing…==
That’s because they are weak.
== And will do so for a long time.==
The Devil is pleased about that.
== One day we’ll look back on these beliefs that we’ve created about God and a devil and call them our “Christian mythology.” ==
(1Ti 4:1) Now the Spirit speaketh expressly, that in the latter times some shall depart from the faith, giving heed to seducing spirits, and doctrines of devils;
(1Ti 4:2) Speaking lies in hypocrisy; having their conscience seared with a hot iron…
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 31, 2009, 12:18 am 12:18 am
==God does not exist…==
For YOU, He doesn’t.
==… and neither does Satan.==
You think that just because you can say that Satan doesn’t exist that he doesn’t. Satan likes that. He gets to do his work without resistance.
==Just because one believes this does not make their existence any more real. ==
That’s true. The fact is that we believe it CUZ is true.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 31, 2009, 12:21 am 12:21 am
==Mr. Incredible is actually just Mr. Very Annoying.==
Y’know, there are doctors who can help you with that intolerance.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 31, 2009, 12:25 am 12:25 am
Is it irony that Mr. Incredible picked his username so well?
Incredible:
“So implausible as to elicit disbelief”
He truly IS.
Posted by: bend 'or | March 31, 2009, 12:42 am 12:42 am
Yes Satan exists and he is living in the White House now!!!!
Posted by: larry | March 31, 2009, 8:18 am 8:18 am
==Is it irony that Mr. Incredible picked his username so well?
Incredible:
“So implausible as to elicit disbelief”==
Or “extraordinary; astonishing”
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 31, 2009, 9:38 am 9:38 am
==Is it irony that Mr. Incredible picked his username so well? ==
Soooo, that’s more important than the issues I raise. We see.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 31, 2009, 9:40 am 9:40 am
This is my comment:
There are an estimated 6.4 billion people on the planet with 6.4 billion separate beliefs, perceptions, experiences and interpretations.==
This is Mr. incredibles comment”
“The Devil is so pleased, too”.
So Mr incredible-How do you know he(Satan) is pleased? Do you know this 1st, 2nd, or third person account? This is a belief once again. You do not know. :)
Posted by: shaye | March 31, 2009, 9:59 am 9:59 am
Thsi is my comment:
==Most Christians use Circular reasoning to say that Satan exists by referencing the Bible.==
This is Mr. incredibles comment
“It’s not circular reasoning. It’s just that your head is spinning.”
Mr. Incredible you have lowerd yourself out of a respectful discussion to make childlike comment. You can’t refute the circular reasoning that “Satan” exists beacuse the bible said so”
My comment:
== Now if Satan showed up on national Television and demostrated his power infront of billions or myself I may strongly consider his existence.==
Mr. Incredible’s Comment:
So, seeing is believing, to YOU.
That means that “love” and “beauty,” to YOU, don’t exist cuz you can’t see them. We get it.
My Response to MR. Incredible. If you see an 18 wheeler pull out in front of you or in your direction. You may put on the brakes. Why beacause you believe It may hit you. So seeing is beleiving.
You make assumtion that love and beauty canniot be seen. Love can bee seen in the holding of a child. Beauty can be seen (The sunset or sunrise on a beach). Have you ever been to an Art Gallery? There is objective beauty and subjective experience of it.
Posted by: Shaye | March 31, 2009, 10:12 am 10:12 am
==So if believing in Satan is what you chose that is yoru choice.==
We don’t believe IN Satan. That is, we don’t trust in Satan.
[We don't give him authority, license, to act. Adam and Eve gave him permission to act. Having been born again, with the Power of God -- that is, the Word -- I took that permission back.]
We know THAT he exists.
My Reponse to Mr. Incredible: Once again you cannot Know what you have not experienced. you believe that satan exists beacuse the bible said so. you reference stories from the bible above. that is circular reasoning. Show me some scientific or even a subjective person converstaion with this satan? you cant.
Posted by: Shaye | March 31, 2009, 10:17 am 10:17 am
I used to be a Christian Fundamentalist. I grew up in the Southern Baptist Convention. I felt the religious abuse of those in the Church. They make me believe that I was not good enough for God. And on top of it that God allowed this Satan Character to influence me. I emotionally out of my own self shame to get emotionally and was “saved”. I have been baptized three times. I know according to fundamentalists the blood of Christ should be powerful enough to erase my sins. I abused another with this type of mentality. Something in me felt that this was not right. I went to Theological seminary and learned the history of Christianity, the bible, and different theology. I sat in a classroom with 30 different Christians and we all had different interpretations for one line of scripture. So the “truth” was relative at best. I was freed from almost thirty years of limited Christian belief systems. I ask you Mr. incredible to examine your beliefs, examine the history of the bible, and examine the psychological abuse you have been subjected to and are subjecting to others. I had to heal myself from this Satanic like religious abuse. I know through my own subjective experience and objective reasoning that unconditional love or compassion is the highest trait that we can express as human beings. The source that I “believe” in is the source of all life (that is something you’re subjectively and objectively experience-we all know. Fill yourself with that kind of love and be that example. You recite all these words. Words are just signposts. You found a signpost in your bible. That says God this way. You have obsessively clung to the signpost thinking you have found “God. You yell at other to come and embrace the signpost/billboard. If they don’t come to the signpost of believe your interpretation of the signpost or billboard then you are wrong or this mythological Satan is influencing you. You recite the words (which are not proven) and hold others to a measure you cannot live yourself. “Live what you believe or you will be a fraud within yourself”. I feel that I have been freed to live without judging others from a religious perspective and I have a much more open mind and capacity to love others. In that process I LEARNED TO LOVE MYSELF AND IN TURN LOVE OTHERS MORE FULLY.
Posted by: Shaye | March 31, 2009, 10:44 am 10:44 am
==My Reponse to Mr. Incredible: Once again you cannot Know what you have not experienced.==
And YOU can’t tell me what I’ve experienced.
== you believe that satan exists beacuse the bible said so.==
No, my experience says so. The Word of God tells me what I’ve experienced.
== you reference stories from the bible above. that is circular reasoning.==
What you call “circular reasoning” is actually your head spinning.
== Show me some scientific or even a subjective person converstaion with this satan? you cant.==
In Matthew 4:1-11, Jesus shows us how NOT to have a conversation with the Devil. That’s cuz the Devil lays traps in conversation. Conversations with the Devil are referred to, by the Word of God, as “filthy conversations.” There is a reason for that.
So, you won’t find any person who is born again conversing with the Devil. You will find references to Satan’s temptations, suggestions.
At the same time, the Devil comes to a person in a person’s own voice, in inner conversation, making the person think that it’s all his own thinking. If that thinking doesn’t align with the Word of God, it’s the Devil. This kind of “filthy conversation” the Devil finds the easiest in and with those who deny his existence; there’s nothing to stop him.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 31, 2009, 11:59 am 11:59 am
==/==There are an estimated 6.4 billion people on the planet with 6.4 billion separate beliefs, perceptions, experiences and interpretations.==
This is Mr. incredibles comment”
“The Devil is so pleased, too”.
So Mr incredible-How do you know he(Satan) is pleased? Do you know this 1st, 2nd, or third person account? This is a belief once again. You do not know.==
Yes, I DO know. That’s cuz, first of all, I trust God Who tells me. Second of all, Satan wants to defeat God. So, anything he can do to that end pleases him. Just like I know it pleases you to think that you are defeating me.
==/==Most Christians use Circular reasoning to say that Satan exists by referencing the Bible.==
This is Mr. incredibles comment
“It’s not circular reasoning. It’s just that your head is spinning.”
Mr. Incredible you have lowerd yourself out of a respectful discussion to make childlike comment.==
Well, if it’s not a circular argument, the only reason you can be seeing what you say is a “circular argument” is that your head is spinning.
== You can’t refute the circular reasoning that “Satan” exists beacuse the bible said so” ==
I’m not making the argument that Satan exists just cuz the Word of God tells me so. I have first-hand knowledge of the attacks of the Devil, and I compare this to what the Word of God says about the Devil’s devices. The Word of God knows what He’s talking about.
==/== Now if Satan showed up on national Television and demostrated his power infront of billions or myself I may strongly consider his existence.==
Mr. Incredible’s Comment:
So, seeing is believing, to YOU.
That means that “love” and “beauty,” to YOU, don’t exist cuz you can’t see them. We get it.
If you see an 18 wheeler pull out in front of you or in your direction. You may put on the brakes. Why beacause you believe It may hit you. So seeing is beleiving.==
However, you cannot see “love,” nor, “beauty.” So, according to YOUR standard, they don’t exist.
==You make assumtion that love and beauty canniot be seen.==
It’s not an assumption. I recognize the fact.
== Love can bee seen in the holding of a child.==
What you see there is the result of what you believe is “love.” It is not “love,” the thing. What you see is an indirect indication of it. You cannot see it directly. You assume it’s “love.”
== Beauty can be seen (The sunset or sunrise on a beach).==
Again, you attach “beauty” to it. You do not see “beauty” directly.
== Have you ever been to an Art Gallery? There is objective beauty…==
No, there isn’t. What YOU do there is attach what you believe to be “beauty” to the object. You do not see “beauty” directly.
==… and subjective experience of it.==
Ahhh, “subjective.” That means that you don’t see it directly.
==I used to be a Christian Fundamentalist. ==
No, you aren’t. You tried to act like one.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 31, 2009, 12:13 pm 12:13 pm
==/==There are an estimated 6.4 billion people on the planet with 6.4 billion separate beliefs, perceptions, experiences and interpretations.==
This is Mr. incredibles comment”
“The Devil is so pleased, too”.
So Mr incredible-How do you know he(Satan) is pleased? ==
In the Garden, the Devil gave Eve his first, revised version of the Word of God. He’s been distributing revised versions ever since.
The Devil is the father of lies and of confusion. Therefore, the more separate beliefs, perceptions, experiences and interpretations, the better he likes it. That’s cuz he wants to take people away from the Word of God, not draw them to Him. The best way to do that is to make them believe that there are many ways to the Father, not just One. So, he is pleased that his lies and confusions have worked.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 31, 2009, 12:18 pm 12:18 pm
CORRECTION
==I used to be a Christian Fundamentalist. ==
No, you weren’t. You tried to act like one. If you loed God through Christ, you would not have lost that love. So, it must not have been as strong a love as you wanted to think.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 31, 2009, 12:20 pm 12:20 pm
== Have you ever been to an Art Gallery? There is objective beauty…==
Do you suppose that each person on Earth will agree with you? If you find at least one person who disagrees with you, then you cannot say that there IS “beauty” in that art gallery because, if there were, that person would be able to see it, too.
No, what you are glorying in is your own interpretation. You’re groovin’ on the fumes of your own interpretation of “beauty” and saying that “beauty” IS there, in front of your eyes and not in back of your eyes.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 31, 2009, 1:00 pm 1:00 pm
Now, as I say, there ARE facts accessible only by faith. “Love” and “beauty” are accessible not by Science, rather by the faith that comes with life’s experience. They are not objects to be beheld by the natural eyes.
And, yet, you say that you believe only things that you can see, and you cannot see “love” and “beauty.”
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 31, 2009, 1:04 pm 1:04 pm
Now im glad I got you to see that you can’t use circular reasoning to prove that Satan exists. You say that you have experienced the being Satan first hand. Please explain your subjective experience with Satan. The world wants to know. Be honest :)
Posted by: Shaye | March 31, 2009, 2:37 pm 2:37 pm
Oh and on the subject of beauty and love. Beauty and love are words with many meanings. The individual give the word the meaning. Life is what you make it. Once agin my point in why words are so versatile with so many meanings. Im sure If i googled Satan I would have counless christian arguing over what that world in scripture really meant.
Posted by: Shaye | March 31, 2009, 2:40 pm 2:40 pm
==/==There are an estimated 6.4 billion people on the planet with 6.4 billion separate beliefs, perceptions, experiences and interpretations.==
This is Mr. incredibles comment”
“The Devil is so pleased, too”.
So Mr incredible-How do you know he(Satan) is pleased? Do you know this 1st, 2nd, or third person account? This is a belief once again. You do not know.==
Yes, I DO know. That’s cuz, first of all, I trust God Who tells me. Second of all, Satan wants to defeat God. So, anything he can do to that end pleases him. Just like I know it pleases you to think that you are defeating me.
My comment: So God told you? How did GOD tell you? by phone, email, the bible or in person? You are referencing the Bible for this answer and onece again you do you do noty know- you merely beleive.
Posted by: Shaye | March 31, 2009, 2:44 pm 2:44 pm
== Have you ever been to an Art Gallery? There is objective beauty…==
Do you suppose that each person on Earth will agree with you? If you find at least one person who disagrees with you, then you cannot say that there IS “beauty” in that art gallery because, if there were, that person would be able to see it, too.
No, what you are glorying in is your own interpretation. You’re groovin’ on the fumes of your own interpretation of “beauty” and saying that “beauty” IS there, in front of your eyes and not in back of your eyes.
MY RESPONSE: MY looking at art is my subjecting and objective experience and therefore my reality. What I experice, define or believe about the art is only mine. I dont have to get anyone to aree with me nor have need to. Just like religion. No two Christians even in the same denomination has the exact same interpetations. Therefore religion is subjective to the interpreter.
Posted by: Shaye | March 31, 2009, 2:49 pm 2:49 pm
==My Reponse to Mr. Incredible: Once again you cannot Know what you have not experienced.==
And YOU can’t tell me what I’ve experienced.
== you believe that satan exists beacuse the bible said so.==
No, my experience says so. The Word of God tells me what I’ve experienced.
== you reference stories from the bible above. that is circular reasoning.==
What you call “circular reasoning” is actually your head spinning.
== Show me some scientific or even a subjective person converstaion with this satan? you cant.==
In Matthew 4:1-11, Jesus shows us how NOT to have a conversation with the Devil. That’s cuz the Devil lays traps in conversation. Conversations with the Devil are referred to, by the Word of God, as “filthy conversations.” There is a reason for that.
So, you won’t find any person who is born again conversing with the Devil. You will find references to Satan’s temptations, suggestions.
At the same time, the Devil comes to a person in a person’s own voice, in inner conversation, making the person think that it’s all his own thinking. If that thinking doesn’t align with the Word of God, it’s the Devil. This kind of “filthy conversation” the Devil finds the easiest in and with those who deny his existence; there’s nothing to stop him.
MY RESPONSE: You said that Satan was pleased with this. How do you know? Once gain your interpretation, assumption on what please the mythilogical idea of Satan. You (Mr. incredible said the “At the same time, the Devil comes to a person in a person’s own voice, in inner conversation, making the person think that it’s all his own thinking.” Okay so whos to say that Satan isnt doing that to you?
Posted by: Shaye | March 31, 2009, 2:56 pm 2:56 pm
Mr Incredible-Your believe is strong in Satan. I have not a subjective or Objective experience of Satan. So therefore He doesnot exsist in my personal reality or affects me.
Posted by: Shaye | March 31, 2009, 3:02 pm 3:02 pm
Mr. Incredible. the bottom line is the Word Satan is a word that creates a subjective idea in your mind. Its just an idea. Give me the proof subjective or objectinve that Satan is a living sentient being. You cant. This debate is moot.
Posted by: Shaye | March 31, 2009, 3:07 pm 3:07 pm
You cant prove that Stan exists. You are just explaining why you believe he exists. people in the past coundt see Cancer and the cause from radiation but they blamed it on Satan. There are alot of things in this universe that cannot be seen by the naked eye that can impact you negatively but there are other natural explainations that have noting to do with an single being out to get you. Now when I say radiation- what comes to mind? This can be measured by devices and there is a physical cause and effect. Once again,the bottom line is the Word Satan is a word that creates a subjective idea in your mind. Its just an idea. Give me the proof subjective or objectinve that Satan is a living sentient being. You cant. This debate is moot.
Posted by: Shaye | March 31, 2009, 3:55 pm 3:55 pm
My only sin here is my spelling. Please forgive me! I was typing too fast. lol
Posted by: Shaye | March 31, 2009, 3:57 pm 3:57 pm
You cant prove that Satan exists. You are just explaining why you believe he exists. People in the past couldn’t see Cancer or Radiation but they blamed it on Satan. There are alot of things in this universe that cannot be seen by the naked eye that can impact you negatively but there are other natural explainations that have noting to do with an single being out to get you. Now when I say “radiation” what comes to mind? This can be measured by devices and there is a physical cause and effect. Once again,the bottom line is the Word Satan is a word that creates a subjective idea in your mind. Its just an idea. Give me the proof subjective or objectinve that Satan is a living sentient being(accoring to your interpretation in your bible). You cant. This debate is moot.
Posted by: Shaye | March 31, 2009, 4:00 pm 4:00 pm
Let me clarify my position. If you had a spiritual encounter or experience of Satan or a family member who passed away. Its not my call to say to anyone that they didit have that experience or try to define it for them. That is your subjective experience and I honor that. I can’t say that experience was not true for another. I honor everyone’s diverse internal subjective experience. So I have to take someone elses beliefs or experiences to be my own? NO Can I alow others to own their subjective experience and beliefs? YES
Posted by: Shaye | March 31, 2009, 4:13 pm 4:13 pm
Circular Reasoning or beggin the Question
Description of Begging the Question
Begging the Question is a fallacy in which the premises include the claim that the conclusion is true or (directly or indirectly) assume that the conclusion is true. This sort of “reasoning” typically has the following form.
Premises in which the truth of the conclusion is claimed or the truth of the conclusion is assumed (either directly or indirectly).
Claim C (the conclusion) is true.
This sort of “reasoning” is fallacious because simply assuming that the conclusion is true (directly or indirectly) in the premises does not constitute evidence for that conclusion. Obviously, simply assuming a claim is true does not serve as evidence for that claim. This is especially clear in particularly blatant cases: “X is true. The evidence for this claim is that X is true.”
Some cases of question begging are fairly blatant, while others can be extremely subtle.
Examples of Begging the Question
Mr Incredible: “Satan must exist.”
Shaye: “How do you know.”
Mr Incredible: “Because the Bible says so.”
Shaye: “Why should I believe the Bible?”
Mr Incredible: “Because the Bible was written by God.”
I saw Mr. Incredibles repetitive response above so I thought I would clarify for him what circular reasoning actually is. I hope this helps.
Posted by: Shaye | March 31, 2009, 4:50 pm 4:50 pm
==Now im glad I got you to see that you can’t use circular reasoning to prove that Satan exists.==
I didn’t say I can’t. I don’t.
== You say that you have experienced the being Satan first hand.==
Yes.
== Please explain your subjective experience with Satan.==
I already have. The Word of God explains it exactly as it is.
== The world wants to know.==
No, it doesn’t. That’s the point.
== Be honest ==
I have been.
==Oh and on the subject of beauty and love. Beauty and love are words with many meanings.==
I’ve been clear. Now you’re trying to fog things up.
==The individual give the word the meaning.==
Again, I’ve been clear.
== Life is what you make it.==
God gave you choice. He put before you blessing and curse. The Day of Accountability is here.
== Once agin my point in why words are so versatile with so many meanings.==
So what?
== Im sure If i googled Satan I would have counless christian arguing over what that world in scripture really meant.==
The Devil likes that confusion.
==So God told you?==
Just as He told me He would.
== How did GOD tell you? by phone, email, the bible or in person?==
In person, through the Word of God, just as He told me.
== You are referencing the Bible for this answer and onece again you do you do noty know- you merely beleive.==
God, through His Word, told me that I would know. It turned out exactly as He says. I believe cuz my experience matches what He says it would be.
==MY looking at art is my subjecting and objective experience and therefore my reality.==
But not REAL reality.
== What I experice, define or believe about the art is only mine.==
That’s what an insane person says.
== I dont have to get anyone to aree with me nor have need to. ==
If you want somebody to believe you, you do.
== Just like religion. No two Christians even in the same denomination has the exact same interpetations.==
That’s of their interpretations are private interpretations. The Word of God says that we are to guard against this. We are to let the Holy Spirit do the interpreting.
== Therefore religion is subjective to the interpreter.==
You have to believe that an honor to disregard God.
==You said that Satan was pleased with this.==
He is pleased with the confusion you display.
== How do you know?==
Satan is trying to defeat God. Anything he does is geared toward that mission. So, anything that is not aligned with the Word of God comes from Satan. Therefore, the confusion you display is authored by Satan. He must be pleased with this.
== Once gain your interpretation, assumption…==
My realization of fact.
==… on what please the mythilogical idea of Satan. ==
God says that Satan is real. My experience matches what He says.
== You (Mr. incredible said the “At the same time, the Devil comes to a person in a person’s own voice, in inner conversation, making the person think that it’s all his own thinking.” Okay so whos to say that Satan isnt doing that to you? ==
The Word of God. What I am saying aligns with the Word of God. Therefore, what I say is not from Satan cuz Satan cannot uplift God.==
==Your believe is strong in Satan.==
To “believe in” is to trust. I don’t trust Satan. I trust God because God has performed what He has promised.
== I have not a subjective or Objective experience of Satan.==
That cuz you refuse to believe that he exists. That’s the best environment, the most fertile ground, for his work. No resistance.
== So therefore He doesnot exsist in my personal reality or affects me. ==
Ahhh, just to wish it away and POOF!
==You cant prove that Satan exists. ==
I already have proved it. God has proved it. Satan, himself, has proved it.
== You are just explaining why you believe he exists.==
You asked for an explanation, and I explained.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 31, 2009, 6:11 pm 6:11 pm
== People in the past couldn’t see Cancer or Radiation but they blamed it on Satan.==
I blame nothing on Satan, except his attacks of suggestion. The blame is squarely on individuals who give him authority.
== There are alot of things in this universe that cannot be seen by the naked eye that can impact you negatively…==
Like Satan.
==… but there are other natural explainations that have noting to do with an single being out to get you.==
However, Satan is explained by the statement just before that.
== Now when I say “radiation” what comes to mind? This can be measured by devices and there is a physical cause and effect.==
But you can’t see it directly.
== Once again,the bottom line is the Word Satan is a word that creates a subjective idea in your mind.==
The word refers to a reality. The definition of the name, “Satan,” is the reality, not what appears in my mind.
== Its just an idea.==
It’s more than that, as explained.
== Give me the proof subjective or objectinve that Satan is a living sentient being(accoring to your interpretation in your bible).==
Already done.
== You cant.==
You preclude your self from knowing. Some Science, huh.
== This debate is moot.==
That’s cuz you choose to want to ignore the reality. That’s the responsible.
== If you had a spiritual encounter or experience of Satan or a family member who passed away. Its not my call to say to anyone that they didit have that experience or try to define it for them. That is your subjective experience…==
My experience of an objective reality.
==Examples of Begging the Question
Mr Incredible: “Satan must exist.”
Shaye: “How do you know.”
Mr Incredible: “Because the Bible says so.” …==
Now you resort to misrepresenting what I wrote.
==… Shaye: “Why should I believe the Bible?”
Mr Incredible: “Because the Bible was written by God.” ==
Not only that, but He has performed what He promised to perform.
==I saw Mr. Incredibles repetitive response above so I thought I would clarify for him what circular reasoning actually is.==
It’s not what I write that is circular reasoning, rather that your head is spinning.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 31, 2009, 6:11 pm 6:11 pm
==My only sin here is my spelling.==
So, YOU get to be the judge of your own self. How convenient.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | March 31, 2009, 6:14 pm 6:14 pm
Mr Incredible It very simple. You have not proved to me that Satan the evil sentient being exists. Your crutch is referring back to a book. I want proof and you cant give me any. I’m sorry man but I need more than you quoting scripture and your circular reasoning. its not my head spinning its an actually term. Google it yourself :)
Posted by: shaye | March 31, 2009, 7:37 pm 7:37 pm
I don’t judge myself. I fully love and accept myself.;-)
Posted by: shaye | March 31, 2009, 7:41 pm 7:41 pm
Can i help you out Mr. Incredible? Let me help you make your case. Go Buy Norman Geisler’s Handbook for Christian Apologetics. He will help you defend you position. You can also gather hellish Near Death Accounts. Go to http://www.near-death.com. You gotta give us some supporting evidence. Research some Catholic Exorcisms if you are not to Protestant to not judge the Catholic Church. Make your case. Please bring something man. I love this kind of thing. This is getting boring. Im sure you and I would become friends and debate at Starbucks till the cows came home. Lets take it up a couple of notches. :-)
Posted by: Shaye | March 31, 2009, 7:54 pm 7:54 pm
Let me go over what “The Bible Actually Says about “Satan”. I studied Hebrew and Greek in Seminary and researched this regarding “satan”. The Hebrew name Satan (pronounced sa-tan) actually means “adversary,” and most often in the Hebrew Bible it is prefaced by the direct object, meaning “the adversary” rather than a distinct personal name. Satan’s role grows more developed both in scope and magnitude through time, and, thus, in the earlier writings of the Hebrew Bible, Satan exists not so much as an individual character but as an adversarial position occupied by both humans and angels.
For example, the word satan is used for a human potential adversary in the Philistine army (1 Samuel 29:4), and two kings God raises to be Solomon’s adversaries (1 Kings 11:14, 23). An angel of the LORD is called satan when he blocks the path of Balaam (Numbers 22:22, 32). Satan becomes more developed as a character in later writings of the Hebrew Bible, though he only appears a few times. He at times causes humans to do bad things, as he incites King David to conduct a census (1 Chronicles 21:1).
Satan also acts as a heavenly prosecuting attorney, bringing charges against sinners before God’s heavenly court. For example, in Psalm 109:6 the author asks Satan to bring an enemy to trial. Also in Zechariah 3:1-2, Satan stands at the right hand of an angel to bring charges against the High Priest. Satan has a similar role in the opening chapter of Job, where he appears in the heavenly court with the sons of God to bring charges against Job.
In the New Testament, Satan plays a much larger role. Here Satan, also frequently called the Devil (from Greek diabolos, also meaning “adversary”) is a proper name for the one who opposes God. Satan is also identified in the New Testament with the deceitful serpent in Eden, as well as many other names including Belial, the evil one, the ruler of the demons, the enemy, the ruler of this world, and Beelzebul (Beelzebub, meaning “Lord of the flies,” is a pun on the name Beelzebul, meaning “Prince Baal”).
Many scholars attribute Satan’s development from an adversary to the archenemy of God to the influence of the Persian religion Zoroastrianism. This religion is a lot like Star Wars, in which two opposing forces, one good and the other evil, struggle for control of the universe. Yet, the New Testament preserves the Hebrew Bible’s notion of Satan as far inferior to God and needing to get God’s permission before “raising hell” on earth (see, for example, Luke 22:31). Following the biblical period, Medieval theologians reinterpreted passages such as Isaiah 14 and Ezekiel 28, in which Babylonian and Phoenician kings are condemned for pride, as descriptions about Satan. In fact, the name Lucifer comes from a Latin translation of Isaiah 14:12, in which the Babylonian king is linked to a fallen Morning Star, called in Latin lucern ferre (“bearer of light”). I want to end my thesis to say that this is no way is proof that Satan exists. If anything it clarifies the meaning of the word “satan” and it explains the origins and use of the word. This is great research in to the biblical accounts of Satan but doesn’t prove anything. Mr. Incredible I know my stuff. You have to come with something stronger. Satan does not exist.
Posted by: shaye | March 31, 2009, 8:08 pm 8:08 pm
Mr Incredible
So you don’t forget about my earlier request and I don’t want to get bogged down in theology I will repost the earlier post…..
Can i help you out Mr. Incredible? Let me help you make your case. Go Buy Norman Geisler’s Handbook for Christian Apologetics. He will help you defend your position. You can also gather hellish Near Death Accounts. Go to http://www.near-death.com. You gotta give us some supporting evidence. Research some Catholic Exorcisms if you are not to Protestant to not judge the Catholic Church. Make your case. Please bring something man. I love this kind of thing. This is getting boring. I’m sure you and I would become friends and debate at Starbucks till the cows came home. Lets take it up a couple of notches. :-)
Posted by: shaye | March 31, 2009, 8:14 pm 8:14 pm
For you new people on the Blog. Mr. Incredible has yet to prove to me that Satan exists. I’m trying to help him with theological research, hellish near-death experiences, exorcisms, first hand accounts just to get him out of the starting gate to begin to make sense. ;)
Posted by: shaye | March 31, 2009, 8:19 pm 8:19 pm
Anybody want to help Mr. Incredible. Its more like “Mr. Because the Bible Tells me So”. Yes I remember singing that song in Baptist Church as a kid. :) Lets have a good adult theological dialogue here and make a good case for Satan’s existence.:)
Posted by: shaye | March 31, 2009, 9:28 pm 9:28 pm
Mr. Incredibles proof that Stan exists:
My realization of fact.
==… on what please the mythological idea of Satan. ==
God says that Satan is real. My experience matches what He says.
My response: Once again, God did not tell you. You believed what man wrote about his understanding of Satan. It is like God showed up and told you like George Burns in O GOD. I don’t think so. You say that your experience matches what “He” says. You once again use circular reasoning to justify your position that Satan exists. Well who wrote what GOD says and which book? When was it written? Who was the audience? Where was it found? How is it valid? You can’t answer those questions. You have homework to do. First you have to prove the documents you read are valid. Then tell me which translitteration from Aramai to Hebrew, to Greek to Latin, to German to the King James Version to the New International Version. Who is to say the writers in their mostly 3rd person account were accurate? To much room for error my friend. you cant get past the validity of the document that the word Satan is written on much less prove that Satan is a real being off that paper. You have provided no other evidence other than you belief in the documents.
Posted by: shaye | March 31, 2009, 10:18 pm 10:18 pm
==You have not proved to me that Satan the evil sentient being exists.==
There’s no doubt that I haven’t proved it to YOU. That doesn’t mean I haven’t proved it.
== Your crutch is referring back to a book.==
No, I don’t. However, my experience squares with the Word of God.
==I want proof… ==
I gave it to you already.
==… and you cant give me any.==
None that you’ll believe, anyway.
== I’m sorry man but I need more than you quoting scripture…==
The Word of God is good enough for me. He knows more than I do.
==… and your circular reasoning.==
It has nothing to do with what you say you believe is my circular reasoning. It has more to do with your head spinning.
== Its not my head spinning its an actually term. ==
I argument is not circular reasoning. As I say, you see it is circular reasoning because your head is spinning.
==I don’t judge myself.==
Who does? You.
== I fully love and accept myself.==
So does Charles Manson.
==You gotta give us some supporting evidence. ==
You have precluded yourself from accepting my evidence. I can’t help that.
==This is getting boring.==
Translation: “This is boring because I can’t get Mr. Incredible to agree with me.”
==I know my stuff.==
So do I, Praise the Lord!
== You have to come with something stronger.==
You’ve precluded yourself from my evidence. It has nothing to do with me.
== Satan does not exist.==
Yes, he does.
==For you new people on the Blog. Mr. Incredible has yet to prove to me that Satan exists.==
Notice the language there: “has yet to prove to me.” “To me.”
That’s code for, “I won’t accept anything he says because I’ve rejected the idea that Satan exists.”
== I’m trying to help him with theological research, hellish near-death experiences, exorcisms, first hand accounts just to get him out of the starting gate to begin to make sense.==
Translation: “Somebody help me get Mr. Incredible over here, to the dark side.”
==Mr. Incredibles proof that Stan exists:
My realization of fact.==
Again, you misrepresent what I wrote. My proof is more than that.
==Once again, God did not tell you.==
Satan told you that. Of course, it isn’t true. Got DID tell me.
== You believed what man wrote about his understanding of Satan.==
I believe what they wrote in their hand because God told them and they experienced it for themselves. My experience tracks theirs.
==It is like God showed up and told you like George Burns in O GOD. I don’t think so.==
And YOU say you went to seminary??? And you didn’t learn that God speaks through His Word???
== You say that your experience matches what “He” says. You once again use circular reasoning to justify your position that Satan exists.==
It’s not that I use circular reasoning as much as your head is spinning, and that’s why you see it as circular reasoning.
== Well who wrote what GOD says…==
Men took His dictation.
==… and which book?==
All of them.
== When was it written?==
Irrelevant. The Word of God is timeless. It’s as relevant now as it was then.
== Who was the audience? ==
The lessons on Satan are relevant to Man.
== Where was it found?==
Irrelevant.
== How is it valid?==
The Word of God provides lessons from God to Man on how to take advantage of His Offer of Reconciliation so that Men may be saved.
== You can’t answer those questions.==
I did, even though they are foolish questions.
== You have homework to do.==
Done and done.
== First you have to prove the documents you read are valid.==
Again, you have precluded yourself from any such evidence.
== Then tell me which translitteration from Aramai to Hebrew, to Greek to Latin, to German to the King James Version to the New International Version.==
You’re confused.
== Who is to say the writers in their mostly 3rd person account were accurate?==
They either witnessed what was said and done, or talked to witnesses who were on scene and heard what was said and saw what was done.
== To much room for error my friend. ==
The Word of God, regarding the spiritual journey, is without error.
== you cant get past the validity of the document that the word Satan is written on much less prove that Satan is a real being off that paper.==
Satan is real.
== You have provided no other evidence other than you belief in the documents. ==
I’ve said it a bazillion times already, that what the Word of God says tracks my experience, and vice versa. God knows what He’s talking about.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | April 1, 2009, 4:31 am 4:31 am
If God cares nothing for things of the flesh, why would he feel the need to punish the eternal spirit for what the flesh has done? If I throw out a pair of old jeans that I care nothing about, I don’t feel the need to punish you if you dig them out of the trash and burn them. You may say that he punishes the spirit because you do not believe, but your thoughts and beliefs are simply by products of the brains (which is flesh) interpretation of this flesh driven life. When the brain dies all thoughts and beliefs die with it and all that is left is the life energy or spirit if you will. That sprit is neither good or bad, honest or dishonest it just is. The eternal spirit is simply the energy that fuels our lives and to punish it for what the brain or flesh has done is like punishing the gas of a car because the driver ran over someone.
Posted by: Eric | April 1, 2009, 10:04 am 10:04 am
Mr. Incredible
You said that the formulation of the Bible is “irrelavant*(which man wrote each of the sixty six books, when it was written, the specific sudience of that day) of the Bible is irrelevant? it seems you have no knowledge of this. Well it is very relevant when determining its authenticity and most Christains make sure they know the history of their Holy Book. You have shared no information regarding these questions and this may demostrated your lack of knowledge regarding these matters. if you know please educate us. The idea of Satan came from the documents of this book. You also speak for God and for Satan(knowing their likes and dislikes) numerous times above. This tells me your belief has psychologically affected you in some way.
Posted by: Shaye | April 1, 2009, 11:12 am 11:12 am
Shaye:
== Your crutch is referring back to a book.==
Mr, Incredible
No, I don’t. However, my experience squares with the Word of God.
Shaye:
==I want proof… ==
Mr. Incredible
I gave it to you already.
==… and you cant give me any.==
None that you’ll believe, anyway.
Shaye
== I’m sorry man but I need more than you quoting scripture…==
Mr. Incredible
The Word of God is good enough for me. He knows more than I do.
Shaye
==… and your circular reasoning.==
It has nothing to do with what you say you believe is my circular reasoning. It has more to do with your head spinning.
(THIS IS A COP OUT BECAUSE HE KNOWS THIS IS WHAT HE IS DOING)
== Its not my head spinning its an actually term. ==
I argument is not circular reasoning. As I say, you see it is circular reasoning because your head is spinning.
==I don’t judge myself.==
Who does? You.
(YOU ANSWER FOR GOD SATAN, AND NOW ME?
== I fully love and accept myself.==
So does Charles Manson.
(SO DOES MY MOTHER AND FATHER)
==You gotta give us some supporting evidence. ==
You have precluded yourself from accepting my evidence. I can’t help that.
(YOU CAN HELP IT)
==This is getting boring.==
Translation: “This is boring because I can’t get Mr. Incredible to agree with me.”
(ONCE AGAIN YOUR SPEAK FOR GOD SATAN AND NOW ME)
==I know my stuff.==
So do I, Praise the Lord!
== You have to come with something stronger.==
You’ve precluded yourself from my evidence. It has nothing to do with me.
== Satan does not exist.==
Yes, he does.
(THE ONUS IS ON YOU TO PROVE THAT HE EXISTS AND YOUI HAVE NOT DONE THAT)
==For you new people on the Blog. Mr. Incredible has yet to prove to me that Satan exists.==
Notice the language there: “has yet to prove to me.” “To me.”
That’s code for, “I won’t accept anything he says because I’ve rejected the idea that Satan exists.”
== I’m trying to help him with theological research, hellish near-death experiences, exorcisms, first hand accounts just to get him out of the starting gate to begin to make sense.==
Translation: “Somebody help me get Mr. Incredible over here, to the dark side.”
(NO THAT MEANS YOU HAVE NO CIRCUMSTANTYIAL EVIDENCE OUTSIDE OF YOUR CIRCULAR REASONING)
==Mr. Incredibles proof that Stan exists:
My realization of fact.==
Again, you misrepresent what I wrote. My proof is more than that.
==Once again, God did not tell you.==
Satan told you that. Of course, it isn’t true. Got DID tell me.
(OKAY SO YOU ARE NOW RESORTING TO BELIEVING THAT SATAN TOLD ME TO SAY THAT. ARE YOU SERIOUS? IF YOU ARE THEN YOU MAY NEED SOME PSYCHOLICAL HELP. YOU NOT ONLY HEAR GODS AND SATSN THOUGHTS BUY YOU HEAR SATAN TALKING TO ME?
== You believed what man wrote about his understanding of Satan.==
I believe what they wrote in their hand because God told them and they experienced it for themselves. My experience tracks theirs.
(ONE AGAIN YOU WERE THERE WHEN GOD TOLD THEM? WHO WERE THE WRITERS-NAMES? WHAT YEAR WAS IT? PLEASE ANSWER)
==It is like God showed up and told you like George Burns in O GOD. I don’t think so.==
And YOU say you went to seminary??? And you didn’t learn that God speaks through His Word???
(I DEMOSTRATED SOME OF MY KNOLEDGE WITH SCRIPTURES REGARDING SATAN(READ ABOVE). SOMETHING YOU DID NOT DO)
== You say that your experience matches what “He” says. You once again use circular reasoning to justify your position that Satan exists.==
It’s not that I use circular reasoning as much as your head is spinning, and that’s why you see it as circular reasoning.
(NICE DEFENSE-SARCASM-NOT GOOD ENOUGH)
== Well who wrote what GOD says…==
Men took His dictation.
(WHO WERE THE WRITERS-NAMES? WHAT YEAR WAS IT? PLEASE ANSWER)
==… and which book?==
All of them.
DOES THAT INCLUDE THE BOOK OF REVELTIONS BEACUSE NOT ALL CHRISTINSA CONSIDER IT DOCTORINE LIKE THE LUTHERANS)?
== When was it written?==
Irrelevant. The Word of God is timeless. It’s as relevant now as it was then.
(YOU HAVE NOT DEMOSTRATED THAT YOU KNOW THE ANSWER TO THIS QUESTION. IT IS VERY RELEVANT)
== Who was the audience? ==
The lessons on Satan are relevant to Man.
(REFER BACK TO MY PREVIOUS BLOG)
== Where was it found?==
Irrelevant.
(REFER BACK TO MY PREVIOUS BLOG. SOME WOULD SAY THIS TO AVOID THE AUTHENTICITY DEBATE :)
== How is it valid?==
The Word of God provides lessons from God to Man on how to take advantage of His Offer of Reconciliation so that Men may be saved.
(THIS DOES NOT EXPLAIN HOW VALIDATION OF THE BIBLE)
== You can’t answer those questions.==
I did, even though they are foolish questions.
(YOU RESORT TO CALLING THEM FOOOLISH> MANY PEOPLE DO THIS BECAUSE THEY DONT KNOW THE ANSEER OR THEY FEAR THE ANSER MIGHT DISRUPT THIER BELEIF SYSTEMS.
== You have homework to do.==
Done and done.
== First you have to prove the documents you read are valid.==
Again, you have precluded yourself from any such evidence.
(I AM WAITING ON THE EVIDENCE. START WITH THE HISTORY OF THE BIBLE AND LINK IT OT OUTSIDE HISTORY, ARCHEOLOGY, Etc.
== Then tell me which translitteration from Aramai to Hebrew, to Greek to Latin, to German to the King James Version to the New International Version.==
You’re confused.
IM CONFUSED? I JUST SHOWE YOU I KNOW THE DIFFERENT LANGUAGES AND PROGRESSION OF THE BIBLES TRANSLITTERATION.) ONCE AGAIN YOU ARE IN MY HEAD? I AM VERY CLEAR ON WHAT I AM COMMUNICATION. MY FRIEND YOU ANSWER IS NOT APPLICABLE.
== Who is to say the writers in their mostly 3rd person account were accurate?==
They either witnessed what was said and done, or talked to witnesses who were on scene and heard what was said and saw what was done.
ONCE AGAIN WHO IS THEY? WHAT WERE THEIR NAMES?
== To much room for error my friend. ==
The Word of God, regarding the spiritual journey, is without error.
REALLY CHECK THESE OUT:
CONTRADICION #1
2 Kings 8:26 says “Two and twenty years old was Ahaziah when he began to reign…
” 2 Chronicles 22:2 says “Forty and two years old was Ahaziah when he began to reign…”
CONTRADICION #2
2 Samuel 6:23 says “Therefore Michal the daughter of Saul had no child unto the day of her death”
2 Samuel 21:8 says “But the king took…the five sons of Michal the daughter of Saul”
CONTRADICTION #3
2 Samuel 8:3-4 says “David smote also Hadadezer…and took from him…seven hundred horsemen…”
1 Chronicles 18:3-4 says “David smote Hadarezer…and took from him…seven thousand horsemen…”
CONTRADITION #4
1 Kings 4:26 says “And Solomon had forty thousand stalls of horses for his chariots…”
2 Chronicles 9:25 says “And Solomon had four thousand stalls for horses and chariots…”
CONTRADICTION #5
2 Kings 25:8 says “And in the fifth month, on the seventh day of the month…Nebuzaradan…came…unto Jerusalem”
Jeremiah 52:12 says “…in the fifth month, in the tenth day of the month…came Nebuzaradan…into Jerusalem”
CONTRADICTION #6
1 Samuel 31:4-6 says “…Saul took a sword and fell upon it. And when his armourbearer saw that Saul was dead and…died with him. So Saul died…”
2 Samuel 21:12 says “…the Philistines had slain Saul in Gilboa.”
CONTRADICTION # 7
Gen 2:17 says “But of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil, thou shalt not eat of it: for in the day thou eastest thereof thou shalt surely die
Gen 5:5 says “And all the days that Adam lived were nine hundred and thirty years: and he died.”
CONTRADICTION #8
Matt 1:16 says, “And Jacob begat Joseph the husband of Mary, of whom was born Jesus…”
Luke 3:23 says “And Jesus…the son of Joseph, which was the son of Heli”
CONTRADICTION #10
James 1:13 says “..for God cannot be tempted with evil, neither tempteth he any man.”
Gen 22:1 says “And it came to pass after these things, that God did tempt Abraham…”
CONTRADICTION #11
Gen 6:20 says “Of fowls after their kind and of cattle [etc.]…two of every sort shall come unto thee…”
Gen 7:2,3 says “Of every clean beast thou shall take to thee by sevens…Of fowls also of the air by sevens…”
CONTRADICTION #11
Gen 32:30 states “…for I have seen God face to face, and my life is preserved.”
John 1:18 states, “No man hath seen God at any time…”
== you cant get past the validity of the document that the word Satan is written on much less prove that Satan is a real being off that paper.==
Satan is real.
== You have provided no other evidence other than you belief in the documents. ==
I’ve said it a bazillion times already, that what the Word of God says tracks my experience, and vice versa. God knows what He’s talking about.
ONCE GAIN HOW DID YOU KNWO THAT GOD SAID THESE THINGS? WHERE YOU THERE WHEN MAN WROTE THIS?
I am well intentioned that I really want you to examine your beliefs.
Posted by: Shaye | April 1, 2009, 12:00 pm 12:00 pm
Sorry folks I really need to use spell check but my time is limited lol
Posted by: Shaye | April 1, 2009, 12:02 pm 12:02 pm
==I rest my case..==
What case?
Ask and ye shall receive…first let me define a few of the terms, including my own, that have been used to describe you.
Self-righteous…sure of the moral superiority of personal beliefs and actions, usually to an irritating degree.
Sanctimonious…making an exaggerated show of holiness or moral superiority
Bigot…somebody with strong opinions, especially on politics, religion, or ethnicity, who refuses to accept different views.
Arrogant…feeling or showing self-importance and contempt or disregard for others.
Narrow-minded…having or showing a limited and often prejudiced or intolerant outlook.
Let me preface what I am about to say with a few words. I believe that everyone has the right to believe whatever they want so long as it does not hurt others or intrude upon the rights of others. Therefore every religion has a right to believe or not believe in the god of their choice. The majority of most religious people have a deep faith in what they believe, and yet are tolerant to others’ beliefs even when they do not understand them. Unfortunately there are fanatic fundamentalists like you that believe they have cornered the market in truth, and have no tolerance for the beliefs of others. You demonstrated this with the following statement.
==If the promise of Heaven and or the fear of Hell are your only motivation for being a good person…==
“Define “good person”? What is “good” enough?”
==… then nothing you do is ever simply to glorify God but to selfishly gain some eternal reward.==
“That’s the Muslim way, not the Christ way. “
(Your words…let’s see…that statement alone covers self-righteous, sanctimonious, bigot, arrogant, and narrow-minded) You say you speak the word of Christ….is Christ this intolerant of others, or does he show love to everyone even when he is not loved by them? Doesn’t sound very tolerant or Christian to me…and as a ‘prebutal’…a term and strategy you used in one of your arguments, allow me to quote you again…
“I don’t speak of and for myself, rather of and for Him and what God tells me to speak. I speak what I hear Him speak, through His Word, and do what I see Him do.”
Another one of your statements…
==we aren’t better than any other animal…==
“You must be one-a those homosexuals who look to the animals for sex tips.”
(Your words…I doubt seriously whether Christ would have made such an obscene and crass comment…but…and I quote—
-“ I’m not making the argument that Satan exists just cuz the Word of God tells me so. I have first-hand knowledge of the attacks of the Devil, and I compare this to what the Word of God says about the Devil’s devices. The Word of God knows what He’s talking about.” So tell me, was that comment one of your examples of having first-hand knowledge of the attacks of the Devil, or is God really that crude? And is being homo-phobic one of your more tolerant traits?
I do not profess to be perfect…far from it, but I try to understand or at least be tolerant of other people’s choices regarding religion and sexual orientation. The only thing that I am totally intolerant to is narrow-minded bigoted people like you.
You sir, are the epitome of what is wrong with religion today. It is not religion itself, but the fanatical fringe elements like you that have warped and distorted the message of peace, love, and tolerance that mainstream religion focuses on.
You speak for no one but yourself! And if you think that I am going to hell, I’m sure you’ll be there to greet me…that would be my hell.
Posted by: Bruce | April 1, 2009, 12:10 pm 12:10 pm
I will leave on a positive note. I enjoyed this debate. Thank you Mr. Incredible for the dialogue. He is probably a very good man who brings alot of good to himself, his church and the world. I like to challenge people (including myself) on belief systems. But in the end I will never tell people that they are wrong (if it appear like that in my debate I want you to know that was not my intention). Each person has the freedom to believe what they want to believe, and give their own meaning to their inner psychological experience of this outer physical world. I have a respect for all religions because there is something to be learned from each one. Humans are capable of expressing the compassion, love, joy, kindness, cooperation, patience, and other positive qualities in this world. I feel that if we all focus on expressing these qualities more fully then the objective outer world would reflect a more of those qualities from our inner subjective world. We can bring more love to the world. What matters to me is that you are who you are and it is a beautiful creation. Who we are in each moment to each other is what really matters. Lets all meet where we know and that’s our love for one another. With Love-Shaye
Posted by: Shaye | April 1, 2009, 12:32 pm 12:32 pm
Y’think there’s NO Satan, no Devil?
“Ay, think so still — till experience change thy mind!” — Mephostophillis
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | April 1, 2009, 3:11 pm 3:11 pm
Of course
I can conjure Satan if I’m in the mood for a little nastiness.
And I can conjure God if I’m feeling loving.
Some times I do both, if I’m feeling good and naughty all at once. That’s when it really gets good. Enjoy!
Posted by: Joe | April 2, 2009, 12:06 am 12:06 am
==You said that the formulation of the Bible is “irrelavant*==
No, I didn’t.
The formulation of over 5600 manuscripts into the KJV, complete with accuracy in the upper 90 percentile, is not irrelevant.
==… (which man wrote each of the sixty six books…==
Irrelevant.
==… when it was written…==
Irrelevant.
==… the specific sudience of that day) of the Bible is irrelevant?==
Yes.
==… it seems you have no knowledge of this. ==
Translation: “You don’t have MY knowledge.”
== Well it is very relevant when determining its authenticity…==
That has already been done.
==… and most Christains make sure they know the history of their Holy Book.==
Except that we don’t have to go over and over and over it again and again and again and again.
==You have shared no information regarding these questions…==
I can’t do better than what has already been done a those who know more than I do.
==… and this may demostrated your lack of knowledge regarding these matters.==
I know the Word of God. I know to whom He is speaking at a given place in the Word of God, whether he is speaking to the Jews, or Jewish priests, or Man.
==The idea of Satan came from the documents of this book.==
No, it came from God Who reported to those who actually penned the Word of God, then to me through the Word of God.
== You also speak for God …==
Those who are born again represent God.
==… and for Satan (knowing their likes and dislikes)…==
We know God’s mission and His method.
We know Satan’s mission and his devices. He set this in motion in the Garden.
==This tells me your belief has psychologically affected you in some way. ==
Knowledge of God through Christ most certainly has. As Martha Stewart would say, “It’s a good thing.”
==Shaye ==… and your circular reasoning.==
“It has nothing to do with what you say you believe is my circular reasoning. It has more to do with your head spinning.”
(THIS IS A COP OUT BECAUSE HE KNOWS THIS IS WHAT HE IS DOING)==
I know I’m doing, and it ain’t circular reasoning.
==/==I don’t judge myself.==
“Who does? You.”
(YOU ANSWER FOR GOD SATAN, AND NOW ME?==
That’s funny, just above that, you think you speak for me.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | April 2, 2009, 12:10 am 12:10 am
==/==This is getting boring.==
“Translation: ‘This is boring because I can’t get Mr. Incredible to agree with me.’”
(ONCE AGAIN YOUR SPEAK FOR GOD SATAN AND NOW ME)==
I’m just characterizing what you write.
==/==I know my stuff.==
“So do I, Praise the Lord!”
== You have to come with something stronger.==
“You’ve precluded yourself from my evidence. It has nothing to do with me.”
== Satan does not exist.==
“Yes, he does.”
(THE ONUS IS ON YOU TO PROVE THAT HE EXISTS…==
I have assumed that responsibility.
==… AND YOUI HAVE NOT DONE THAT)==
Yes, I have. It’s just that you missed it.
==/==For you new people on the Blog. Mr. Incredible has yet to prove to me that Satan exists.==
“Notice the language there: ‘has yet to prove to me.’ ‘To me.’
That’s code for, ‘I won’t accept anything he says because I’ve rejected the idea that Satan exists.’
== I’m trying to help him with theological research, hellish near-death experiences, exorcisms, first hand accounts just to get him out of the starting gate to begin to make sense.==
“Translation: ‘Somebody help me get Mr. Incredible over here, to the dark side.’
(NO THAT MEANS YOU HAVE NO CIRCUMSTANTYIAL EVIDENCE OUTSIDE OF YOUR CIRCULAR REASONING)==
It’s not circular reasoning that you see, it’s just that your head is spinning.
==Mr. Incredibles proof that Stan exists:
My realization of fact.==
“Again, you misrepresent what I wrote. My proof is more than that. ”
==Once again, God did not tell you.==
Satan told you that. Of course, it isn’t true. Got DID tell me.
(OKAY SO YOU ARE NOW RESORTING TO BELIEVING THAT SATAN TOLD ME TO SAY THAT.==
That’s the way the Devil works. I merely report that fact.
== ARE YOU SERIOUS? ==
GOD is serious.
==IF YOU ARE THEN YOU MAY NEED SOME PSYCHOLICAL HELP.==
Translation: “If you disagree with me, you need psychological help.”
==YOU NOT ONLY HEAR GODS AND SATSN THOUGHTS BUY YOU HEAR SATAN TALKING TO ME?==
I don’t hear Satan talking to you. Given that I am aware of Satan his devices, that he tries to defeat the Word of God, I can tell when someone is not lifting up the Word of God.
==/== You believed what man wrote about his understanding of Satan.==
“I believe what they wrote in their hand because God told them and they experienced it for themselves. My experience tracks theirs. ”
(ONE AGAIN YOU WERE THERE WHEN GOD TOLD THEM?==
I didn’t have to be there. I have their Deposition.
== WHO WERE THE WRITERS-NAMES? ==
They are listed in the Word of God.
== WHAT YEAR WAS IT?==
Irrelevant.
== PLEASE ANSWER)==
Already done, where it is relevant to the spiritual journey.
==/==It is like God showed up and told you like George Burns in O GOD. I don’t think so.==
“And YOU say you went to seminary??? And you didn’t learn that God speaks through His Word???”
(I DEMOSTRATED SOME OF MY KNOLEDGE WITH SCRIPTURES REGARDING SATAN(READ ABOVE). SOMETHING YOU DID NOT DO)==
You’ve provided no Scripture. And, in an interesting note, Satan cannot quote Scripture, either. However, he misquotes Him cuz, to quote Him would be to lift Him up.
==/== You say that your experience matches what “He” says. You once again use circular reasoning to justify your position that Satan exists.==
“It’s not that I use circular reasoning as much as your head is spinning, and that’s why you see it as circular reasoning.”
(NICE DEFENSE-SARCASM-NOT GOOD ENOUGH)==
It accurately explains why you see circular reasoning in my posts.
==/== Well who wrote what GOD says…==
“Men took His dictation.”
(WHO WERE THE WRITERS-NAMES?
The names appear in the Word of God.
== WHAT YEAR WAS IT?==
Irrelevant.
== PLEASE ANSWER)==
Already done, where it is relevant to the spiritual journey.
==/==… and which book?==
“All of them.”
DOES THAT INCLUDE THE BOOK OF REVELTIONS BEACUSE NOT ALL CHRISTINSA CONSIDER IT DOCTORINE LIKE THE LUTHERANS)? ==
There is no Book in the Word of God called “Revelations.” It may be an YOUR version that CLAIMS to be the Word of God.
==/== When was it written?==
“Irrelevant. The Word of God is timeless. It’s as relevant now as it was then.”
(YOU HAVE NOT DEMOSTRATED THAT YOU KNOW THE ANSWER TO THIS QUESTION.==
Irrelevant.
== IT IS VERY RELEVANT)==
It is irrelevant to the spiritual journey.
==/== Who was the audience? ==
“The lessons on Satan are relevant to Man.”
(REFER BACK TO MY PREVIOUS BLOG)==
The lessons on Satan are relevant to all Mankind. So, the audience is MANKIND.
==/== Where was it found?==
“Irrelevant.”
(REFER BACK TO MY PREVIOUS BLOG.==
No. Answer it here. I’m not going to traipse all around the Internet.
== SOME WOULD SAY THIS ["irrelevant"] TO AVOID THE AUTHENTICITY DEBATE ==
Some would. I don’t.
==/== How is it valid?==
“The Word of God provides lessons from God to Man on how to take advantage of His Offer of Reconciliation so that Men may be saved.”
(THIS DOES NOT EXPLAIN HOW VALIDATION OF THE BIBLE)==
Yes, it does. Apparently, it’s over your head.
==/== You can’t answer those questions.==
“I did, even though they are foolish questions.”
(YOU RESORT TO CALLING THEM FOOOLISH>==
The WORD OF GOD does.
== MANY PEOPLE DO THIS BECAUSE THEY DONT KNOW THE ANSEER…==
The answer you want is irrelevant.
==… OR THEY FEAR THE ANSER MIGHT DISRUPT THIER BELEIF SYSTEMS.==
I’m strong in the Lord. God did not give me the spirit of fear. I’m not afraid.
==/== You have homework to do.==
“Done and done.”
== First you have to prove the documents you read are valid.==
“Again, you have precluded yourself from any such evidence.”
(I AM WAITING ON THE EVIDENCE.==
I gave you the relevant evidence. You must have missed it.
== START WITH THE HISTORY OF THE BIBLE…==
Irrelevant.
==… AND LINK IT OT OUTSIDE HISTORY, ARCHEOLOGY, Etc.==
No need to. It’s irrelevant to the spiritual journey.
==/== Then tell me which translitteration from Aramai to Hebrew, to Greek to Latin, to German to the King James Version to the New International Version.==
“You’re confused.”
IM CONFUSED?==
Yes, YOU’RE confused. Of course, you don’t know it.
== I JUST SHOWE YOU I KNOW THE DIFFERENT LANGUAGES AND PROGRESSION OF THE BIBLES TRANSLITTERATION.) ==
You went through the trouble for nothing because it is irrelevant to the spiritual journey.
== I AM VERY CLEAR ON WHAT I AM COMMUNICATION.==
I’m sure that you think you are. I don’t dispute the fact that you think you are clear on what you say you think you are communicating.
== MY FRIEND YOU ANSWER IS NOT APPLICABLE.==
Translation: “I dismiss any answer that doesn’t agree with mine.”
==/== Who is to say the writers in their mostly 3rd person account were accurate?==
“They either witnessed what was said and done, or talked to witnesses who were on scene and heard what was said and saw what was done.”
ONCE AGAIN WHO IS THEY?==
Those who penned the Word of God.
== WHAT WERE THEIR NAMES?==
Their names are in the Word of God.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | April 2, 2009, 12:11 am 12:11 am
==/== To much room for error my friend. ==
“The Word of God, regarding the spiritual journey, is without error.”
REALLY CHECK THESE OUT:
CONTRADICION #1
2 Kings 8:26 says “Two and twenty years old was Ahaziah when he began to reign…
” 2 Chronicles 22:2 says “Forty and two years old was Ahaziah when he began to reign…” ==
Irrelevant to the spiritual journey.
==CONTRADICION #2
2 Samuel 6:23 says “Therefore Michal the daughter of Saul had no child unto the day of her death”
2 Samuel 21:8 says “But the king took…the five sons of Michal the daughter of Saul” Q1
Irrelevant to the spiritual journey.
==CONTRADICTION #3
2 Samuel 8:3-4 says “David smote also Hadadezer…and took from him…seven hundred horsemen…”
1 Chronicles 18:3-4 says “David smote Hadarezer…and took from him…seven thousand horsemen…” ==
Irrelevant to the spiritual journey.
==CONTRADITION #4
1 Kings 4:26 says “And Solomon had forty thousand stalls of horses for his chariots…”
2 Chronicles 9:25 says “And Solomon had four thousand stalls for horses and chariots…” ==
Irrelevant to the spiritual journey.
==CONTRADICTION #5
2 Kings 25:8 says “And in the fifth month, on the seventh day of the month…Nebuzaradan…came…unto Jerusalem”
Jeremiah 52:12 says “…in the fifth month, in the tenth day of the month…came Nebuzaradan…into Jerusalem” ==
Irrelevant to the spiritual journey.
==CONTRADICTION #6
1 Samuel 31:4-6 says “…Saul took a sword and fell upon it. And when his armourbearer saw that Saul was dead and…died with him. So Saul died…”
2 Samuel 21:12 says “…the Philistines had slain Saul in Gilboa.” ==
Irrelevant to the spiritual journey
==CONTRADICTION # 7
Gen 2:17 says “But of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil, thou shalt not eat of it: for in the day thou eastest thereof thou shalt surely die
Gen 5:5 says “And all the days that Adam lived were nine hundred and thirty years: and he died.”
Yes, he died spiritually on the day he ate. Separation from God is death.
==CONTRADICTION #8
Matt 1:16 says, “And Jacob begat Joseph the husband of Mary, of whom was born Jesus…”
Luke 3:23 says “And Jesus…the son of Joseph, which was the son of Heli”
”…Joseph, son of Jacob, according to St. Matthew, was son-in-law of Heli, according to St. Luke.” — Matthew Clark’s Commentary on the Bible
Which was the son of Eli; meaning, not that Joseph was the son of Eli; for he was the son of Jacob, according to Mat_1:16, but Jesus was the son of Eli; and which must be understood, and carried through the whole genealogy, as thus; Jesus the son of Matthat, Jesus the son of Levi, Jesus the son of Melchi, &c. till you come to Jesus the son of Adam, and Jesus the Son of God; though it is true indeed that Joseph was the son of Eli, having married his daughter; Mary was the daughter of Eli: and so the Jews speak of one Mary, the daughter of Eli, by whom they seem to design the mother of our Lord: for they tell (b) us of one,
“that saw, מרים בת עלי, “Mary the daughter of Eli” in the shades, hanging by the fibres of her breasts; and there are that say, the gate, or, as elsewhere (c), the bar of the gate of hell is fixed to her ear.”
By the horrible malice, in the words, you may know who is meant: however, this we gain by it, that by their own confession, Mary is the daughter of Eli; which accords with this genealogy of the evangelist, who traces it from Mary, under her husband Joseph; though she is not mentioned, because of a rule with the Jews (d), that
“the family of the mother is not called a family.” — John Gill’s Exposition of the Entire Bible
==CONTRADICTION #10
James 1:13 says “..for God cannot be tempted with evil, neither tempteth he any man.”
Gen 22:1 says “And it came to pass after these things, that God did tempt Abraham…” ==
neither tempteth he any man; that is, to sin; he tempted Abraham, to try his faith, love, and obedience to him; he tempted the Israelites in the wilderness, to try them and humble them, and prove what was in their hearts; and he tempted Job, and tried his faith and patience; and so he tempts and tries all his righteous ones, by afflictions, more or less: but he never tempts or solicits them to sin; temptations to sin come from another quarter, as follows. — John Gill’s Exposition of the Entire Bible
Neither tempteth he any man – That is, he places nothing before any human being with a view to induce him to do wrong. This is one of the most positive and unambiguous of all the declarations in the Bible, and one of the most important.
God does not place inducements before us with a view that we should sin, or in order to lead us into sin. None of his decrees, or his arrangements, or his desires, are based on that, but all have some other purpose and end. The real force of temptation is to be traced to some other source – to ourselves, and not to God. — Albert Barnes’ Notes on the Bible
In any case, you forgot James 1:14 –
(Jas 1:14) But every man is tempted, when he is drawn away of his own lust, and enticed.
That explains a lot that you wish hadn’t been explained.
==CONTRADICTION #11
Gen 6:20 says “Of fowls after their kind and of cattle [etc.]…two of every sort shall come unto thee…”
Gen 7:2,3 says “Of every clean beast thou shall take to thee by sevens…Of fowls also of the air by sevens…” ==
Irrelevant to the spiritual journey.
==CONTRADICTION #11
Gen 32:30 states “…for I have seen God face to face, and my life is preserved.” ==
Corrupt translation. The correct translation is
(Gen 32:20) And say ye moreover, Behold, thy servant Jacob is behind us. For he said, I will appease him with the present that goeth before me, and afterward I will see his face; peradventure he will accept of me.
Anywho…
In the Old Testament, in unrighteousness, no man COULD see the face of God.
==John 1:18 states, “No man hath seen God at any time…” ==
The same is true here. Except, now, the Righteous man sees God because he is begotten of God.
==/== you cant get past the validity of the document that the word Satan is written on much less prove that Satan is a real being off that paper.==
“Satan is real.”
== You have provided no other evidence other than you belief in the documents. ==
“I’ve said it a bazillion times already, that what the Word of God says tracks my experience, and vice versa. God knows what He’s talking about.”
ONCE GAIN HOW DID YOU KNWO THAT GOD SAID THESE THINGS?==
Cuz God has performed what He promised to perform. I’m witness to this.
== WHERE YOU THERE WHEN MAN WROTE THIS?==
No, but many, many, many, many, many, great, great, great, great, multitudes of men were, and they testify of the same things.
==I am well intentioned that I really want you to examine your beliefs.==
God has examined me, and I pass. 100%. I’m not subject to the examination of men.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | April 2, 2009, 12:12 am 12:12 am
==Satan does not exist.==
Faustus: “I think Hell’s a fable.”
Mephostophilis: “Ay, thinks so still — till experience change thy mind!”
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | April 2, 2009, 12:18 am 12:18 am
thinks so still —-> think so still
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | April 2, 2009, 12:19 am 12:19 am
my concern is with the existence of God. I prefer to ‘accentuate the positive’. If i align myself with the All that is Good i have nothing else to worry about.
Posted by: teopa | April 2, 2009, 12:19 am 12:19 am
By the way, what you say are “contradictions” in the Word of God are really only contradictions in your mind.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | April 2, 2009, 12:20 am 12:20 am
==If i align myself with the All that is Good i have nothing else to worry about.==
Define “good.”
Is it YOUR definition? The world’s definition? What’s God’s definition?
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | April 2, 2009, 12:58 am 12:58 am
people tend to be too centered around themselves.
when looking at the word of God, you cannot adjust what you read to your lifestyle..you must adjust your lifestyle to what you read.
may God bless all of you.
it irritates me how easily Satan tricks people..
he may be winning now, but thank God i already know God has the victory..
can’t wait til the end!
Posted by: jyoonie | April 2, 2009, 3:16 am 3:16 am
It’s not just me. The number of women and children being attacked and killed in their own homes IS increasing, a lot.
A 37% increase in Florida. In all of 2008, 14,000 women sought shelter from violence in Florida. Already, in the first three months of 2009, 8,000 women have fled their homes, usually with their children. If the rate continues, the one year increase will be from 14,000 to 32,000. Stunning.
In New York state local police are noting a “string of violent attacks on women in Niagra County.” Some local women and women politicians (Vote FOR Women!) are doing something about it.
In Chula Vista, California the calls to help lines from terrorized women and children have doubled over the 2008 rate. Elsewhere in Southern California police departments are bracing for increases in attacks and murders.
In Chicago, where men kill a woman in their family an average of once a week, in a state where the police recorded more than 95,000 wife-attacks in a single year, and where the city’s police officers arrested 13,000 men in one year for attacking their wives or girlfriends, the state’s domestic violence website hasn’t been updated in two years.
In Michigan, Genesee County (which includes Flint) has the highest per capita rate of woman-lynching of any county. The rate of felonious attacks increased 50% from 2006 to 2007 with another similar increase in 2008.
Nationwide, there has been an increase of at least 21% in attacks reported to the National Domestic Violence Hotline.
RESOURCES
National Domestic Violence Hotline
Posted by: OH YEAH | April 2, 2009, 6:30 am 6:30 am
Mr. Incredible
You who claim the Bible as the cornerstone of your faith, the instruction manual that you would impose on you and me and everyone else — YOU CAN’T READ IT. Reading a translation isn’t the same thing. Not even close. With the Bible, you’ve got speeches that Jesus made to crowds of people in a long-dead vernacular Hebrew called Aramaic, written down years later in classical Greek with varying degrees of competence (Luke’s Greek is elegant; Mark’s is wretched), then translated into English sometime between 1600 and now (depending on which English version you carry).
Posted by: Shaye | April 2, 2009, 11:18 am 11:18 am
Mr. Incredible,
You say that these contraditions are irrelevant? Well if the Bible is “inerrant” word of God as you and many “Christian Fundamantalists” believe then there should be no errors (litteral contradictions). So if there are litteral contradictions(errors) it is not the “litteral and inerrant” word of God. Please explain why there are litteral contradictions(errors) below. One of the verses has to be right so that means that the other is wrong.
Thank you
Mr. Incredible Wrote
“The Word of God, regarding the spiritual journey, is without error.”
REALLY CHECK THESE OUT:
CONTRADICION #1
2 Kings 8:26 says “Two and twenty years old was Ahaziah when he began to reign…
” 2 Chronicles 22:2 says “Forty and two years old was Ahaziah when he began to reign…” ==
Mr. Incredible said:
Irrelevant to the spiritual journey.
==CONTRADICION #2
2 Samuel 6:23 says “Therefore Michal the daughter of Saul had no child unto the day of her death”
2 Samuel 21:8 says “But the king took…the five sons of Michal the daughter of Saul” Q1
Mr. Incredible said:
Irrelevant to the spiritual journey.
==CONTRADICTION #3
2 Samuel 8:3-4 says “David smote also Hadadezer…and took from him…seven hundred horsemen…”
1 Chronicles 18:3-4 says “David smote Hadarezer…and took from him…seven thousand horsemen…” ==
Mr. Incredible said:
Irrelevant to the spiritual journey.
==CONTRADITION #4
1 Kings 4:26 says “And Solomon had forty thousand stalls of horses for his chariots…”
2 Chronicles 9:25 says “And Solomon had four thousand stalls for horses and chariots…” ==
Mr. Incredible said:
Irrelevant to the spiritual journey.
==CONTRADICTION #5
2 Kings 25:8 says “And in the fifth month, on the seventh day of the month…Nebuzaradan…came…unto Jerusalem”
Jeremiah 52:12 says “…in the fifth month, in the tenth day of the month…came Nebuzaradan…into Jerusalem” ==
Mr. Incredible said:
Irrelevant to the spiritual journey.
==CONTRADICTION #6
1 Samuel 31:4-6 says “…Saul took a sword and fell upon it. And when his armourbearer saw that Saul was dead and…died with him. So Saul died…”
2 Samuel 21:12 says “…the Philistines had slain Saul in Gilboa.” ==
Mr. Incredible said:
Irrelevant to the spiritual journey
==CONTRADICTION # 7
Gen 2:17 says “But of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil, thou shalt not eat of it: for in the day thou eastest thereof thou shalt surely die
Gen 5:5 says “And all the days that Adam lived were nine hundred and thirty years: and he died.”
Yes, he died spiritually on the day he ate. Separation from God is death.(The TEXT SAYS NOTHING ABOUT HIM DYING SPIRITUALLY)
Posted by: Shaye | April 2, 2009, 1:58 pm 1:58 pm
Mr. Incredible
As you already know Biblical writings were first written in Aramaic. Hebrew is a later dialect of Aramaic. The first five books of the Bible, the Pentateuch or Torah, were not written down until the time of the Babylonian Captivity, 500-600 B.C. and they were written in Aramaic, later translated to Hebrew. Moses was also NOT the author of them, he was already dead by the time they were written down. In the 3rd century B.C. the scriptures were translated into Greek because the Alexandrian Jews could not understand Aramaic. When this was done, many of the meanings of the idioms were lost.
Idioms are a problem for the student of any foreign language. We have a lot of idioms in English that give foreign students trouble. Ones like “He’s in a pickle” or “He’s in a jam” or other such phrases whose meanings are not literal. Aramaic, like most languages, has many idioms. When the translation was made from Aramaic to Greek, those who spoke Greek did not understand the idioms and their meanings were lost or misinterpreted.
In James 1:4, it says “But let patience have her perfect work, that ye may be perfect and entire, wanting nothing.”
(In this verse, patience is given a personality. It is referred to as a she. Now no one would believe that this verse in any way is implying that patience is an actual person, divine or otherwise. It is just a figure of speech, giving personality to a concept or set of ideas).
Another example is Proverbs 1:23. “Wisdom crieth without; she uttereth her voice in the streets.” (Here wisdom is given a personality, a female one, and it is even implied that she is given movement and a voice).
This tradition of giving personality to a concept or idea is often used in Eastern writing. You forget that Christianity and The Bible are EASTERN in origin and influence. Christians pride themselves with Christianity being “WESTERN”. You need to realize that Christianity is AN EASTERN RELIGION. The Western church has, in many instances, changed Christianity into something that does not even resemble the original.
Now, I have given the two examples above to show you how figures of speech can be used in a way that is not literal, and give personality to a concept. In the original Aramaic language, which the person Jesus spoke and understood, and which was commonly spoken at the time of Christ, the word Satan was considered a figure of speech, a personality that was given to a concept, the concept of evil intent or opposition. SATAN WAS NOT CONSIDERED TO BE A REAL BEING. For instance, Luke 10:18 in which Jesus says “I beheld Satan as lightening fall from heaven,” the Aramaic idioms would translate the concept of Satan falling from heaven as “evil destroyed.” The word Satan itself means “to slide, to mislead, to slip; to miss the mark.” In other words, Jesus was saying that his coming has destroyed the concept of sin and evil. The Aramaic interpretation for Satan is “crazy thinking”.
Posted by: Shaye | April 2, 2009, 2:22 pm 2:22 pm
Mr. Incredible
The Bible consists of a collection of sixty-six separate books. These books were chosen, after a bit of haggling, by the Catholic Council of Carthage in 397 A.D.–more than three hundred years after the time of Jesus. This collection is broken into two major sections: The Old Testament, which consists of thirty-nine books, and The New Testament, which consists of twenty-seven books. (Catholic Bibles include additional books known as the Apocrypha.)
The Old Testament is concerned with the Hebrew God, Yahweh, and purports to be a history of the early Israelites. The New Testament is the work of early Christians and reflects their beliefs about Jesus; it purports to be a history of what Jesus taught and did.
The composition of the various books is thought to have begun around 1000 B.C., and to have continued for about 1,100 years. Much oral material was included. This was repeated from father to son, revised over and over again, and then put into written form by various editors. These editors often worked in different locales and in different time periods and were often unaware of each other. Their work was primarily intended for local use and it is unlikely that any author foresaw that his work would be included in a “Bible.”
No original manuscripts exist. There is probably not one book which survives in anything like its original form. There are hundreds of differences between the oldest manuscripts of any one book. These differences indicate that numerous additions and alterations, some accidental and some purposeful, were made to the originals by various authors, editors, and copyists.
Many biblical authors are unknown. Where an author has been named, that name has sometimes been selected by pious believers rather than given by the author himself. The four Gospels, Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John, are examples of books which did not carry the names of their actual authors. The present names were assigned long after these four books were written. And–in spite of what the Gospel authors say–biblical scholars are now almost unanimously agreed that none of the Gospel authors was either an actual disciple of Jesus or even an eyewitness to his ministry.
Although some books of the Bible are traditionally attributed to a single author, many are actually the work of multiple authors. Genesis and John are two examples of books which reflect multiple authorship.
Many biblical books have the earmarks of fiction. For example, private conversations are often related when no reporter was present. Conversations between God and various individuals are recorded. Prehistoric events are given in great detail. When a story is told by more than one author, there are usually significant differences. Many stories–stories which in their original context are considered even by Christians to be fictional–were borrowed by the biblical authors, adapted for their own purposes, given a historical setting, and then declared to be fact.
The Flood story is an example of this kind of adaptation. Its migration from the earliest known occurrence in Sumeria, around 1600 B.C., from place to place and eventually to the Bible, can be traced historically. Each time the story was used again, it was altered to speak of local gods and heroes.
——————————————————————————–
But is the Bible, nevertheless, the work of God? Is it a valid guidebook? How can we know?
If the Bible were really the work of a perfect, all-powerful, and loving God, one would reasonably expect it to be obviously superlative in every respect–accurate, clear, concise, and consistent throughout–as compared to anything that could possibly be conceived by human intellect alone.
Fundamentalists, in fact, hold this to be true. Using a circular argument, they say that because the Bible is without error or inconsistency, it must be the work of God, and because it is the work of God, it must be without error or inconsistency. It seems not to matter which proposition comes first, the other is thought to follow.
Notwithstanding the fundamentalist viewpoint, however, the Bible does contain a number of real problems. And some of these problems are absolutely fatal to its credibility.
Many passages relate God-ordained atrocities; such passages are unworthy of the Christian God. Some biblical precepts are both unreasonable and unlikely since they are in obvious disagreement with common sense as well as the qualities of character which are attributed to God. Some biblical statements are absurd in that they represent very primitive beliefs. The believability of many biblical stories–stories that are crucial to Christianity–are discredited by numerous inconsistencies. The picture is further complicated by the many different and conflicting interpretations that are often given to a specific passage by sincere, well-intentioned believers.
While Biblicists are capable of offering some sort of explanation for nearly any biblical problem that can be uncovered, such explanations should be unnecessary. The point is not whether some explanation can be conceived, but rather that a perfect, all-powerful, and loving God certainly could, should, and would do a much better job of it were he to have anything to do with the writing of a book.
The evidence which follows, taken from the Bible itself, is but a small portion of that which exists. This evidence demonstrates that the Bible cannot be the literal, complete, inerrant and perfect work of a perfect, all-powerful, and loving God. It also demonstrates that the Bible is not especially useful even as a guidebook. In addition, because the Bible reflects every important belief of traditional Christianity–the foundation of Christianity itself rests on shaky ground.
Posted by: Shaye | April 2, 2009, 2:57 pm 2:57 pm
Awaiting your response Mr. Incredible:)
Posted by: Shaye | April 2, 2009, 4:13 pm 4:13 pm
Awaiting your response Mr. Incredible:)
Posted by: Shaye | April 2, 2009, 4:13 pm 4:13 pm
To elaborate further on my comment above.
“No original manuscripts exist. There is probably not one book which survives in anything like its original form. There are hundreds of differences between the oldest manuscripts of any one book. These differences indicate that numerous additions and alterations, some accidental and some purposeful, were made to the originals by various authors, editors, and copyists.
Many biblical authors are unknown. Where an author has been named, that name has sometimes been selected by pious believers rather than given by the author himself. The four Gospels, Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John, are examples of books which did not carry the names of their actual authors. The present names were assigned long after these four books were written. And–in spite of what the Gospel authors say–biblical scholars are now almost unanimously agreed that none of the Gospel authors was either an actual disciple of Jesus or even an eyewitness to his ministry”.
Take a look at this historical list of dates and meetings where numreous men who have had their hands in creating the Bible. It is the governing body of the church (Much like the US Congress) passing laws and making decisions over hundreds of years. Who were these men? What were their interpretations that threw some books out and kept others?
Here is the timeline of manipulation by men:
AD 51-125: The New Testament books are written.
AD 140: Marcion, a businessman in Rome, taught that there were two Gods:
Yahweh, the cruel God of the Old Testament, and Abba, the kind father of the New Testament. Marcion eliminated the Old Testament as Scriptures and, since he was anti-Semitic, kept from the New Testament only 10 letters of Paul and 2/3 of Luke’s gospel (he deleted references to Jesus’s Jewishness). Marcion’s “New Testament”, the first to be compiled, forced the mainstream Church to decide on a core canon: the four Gospels and Letters of Paul.
AD 200: The periphery of the canon is not yet determined. According to one list, compiled at Rome c. AD 200 (the Muratorian Canon), the NT consists of the 4 gospels; Acts; 13 letters of Paul (Hebrews is not included); 3 of the 7 General Epistles (1-2 John and Jude); and also the Apocalypse of Peter.
AD 367: The earliest extant list of the books of the NT, in exactly the number and order in which we presently have them, is written by Athanasius, Bishop of Alexandria, in his Festal letter # 39 of 367 A.D..
382 –Council of Rome (whereby Pope Damasus started the ball rolling for the defining of a universal canon for all city-churches). Listed the New Testament books in their present number and order.
393 A.D. –the Council of Hippo, which began “arguing it out.” Canon proposed by Bishop Athanasius.
AD 397: The Council of Carthage, which refined the canon for the Western Church, sending it back to Pope Innocent for ratification. In the East, the canonical process was hampered by a number of schisms (esp. within the Church of Antioch). However, this changed by …
787 A.D. The Ecumenical Council of Nicaea II, which adopted the canon of Carthage. At this point, both the Latin West and the Greek / Byzantine East had the same canon. However, … The non-Greek, Monophysite and Nestorian Churches of the East (the Copts, the Ethiopians, the Syrians, the Armenians, the Syro-Malankars, the Chaldeans, and the Malabars) were still left out. But these Churches came together in agreement, in 1442A.D., in Florence.
AD 1442: At the Council of Florence, the entire Church recognized the 27 books. This council confirmed the Roman Catholic Canon of the Bible which Pope Damasus I had published a thousand years earlier. So, by 1439, all orthodox branches of the Church were legally bound to the same canon. This is 100 years before the Reformation.
AD 1536: In his translation of the Bible from Greek into German, Luther removed 4 N.T. books (Hebrews, James, Jude, and Revelation) and placed them in an appendix saying they were less than canonical.
AD 1546: At the Council of Trent, the Catholic Church reaffirmed once and for all the full list of 27 books. The council also confirmed the inclusion of the Deuterocanonical books which had been a part of the Bible canon since the early Church and was confirmed at the councils of 393 AD, 373, 787 and 1442 AD. At Trent Rome actually dogmatized the canon, making it more than a matter of canon law, which had been the case up to that point, closing it for good.
This bible has a long history of being manipilated and there is no way to prove its authenticity. This evidence demonstrates that the Bible cannot be the literal, complete, inerrant and perfect work of a perfect, all-powerful, and loving God. It also demonstrates that the Bible is not especially useful even as a guidebook. In addition, because the Bible reflects every important belief of traditional Christianity–the foundation of Christianity itself rests on shaky ground.
Posted by: Shaye | April 2, 2009, 4:27 pm 4:27 pm
I have shared the timeline is just for the Catholic Church. I have not even gotten to the Protestant Reformation with Martin Luther. I can also get us up to date with the arguments between the Southern Baptist Convention and the Coopertave Baptist Fellowship? There are group of men throughout history and today making decisions and interpreting and arguing over the meanings, doctorine and cannon of the Bible.
Posted by: Shaye | April 2, 2009, 4:36 pm 4:36 pm
You who claim the Bible as the cornerstone of your faith, the instruction manual that you would impose on you and me and everyone else ..
I, Mr. I, say: we have no interest in imposing it on you, nor anyone else. The essence of biblical love is unselfish concern for the Salvation of others. All we want to do is give you people the Instrument of that Salvation.
– YOU CAN’T READ IT.
I, Mr. I, say: [BUZZER SOUND!] Wrong again!
Reading a translation isn’t the same thing.
I, Mr. I, say: It’s close enough.
With the Bible, you’ve got speeches that Jesus made to crowds of people in a long-dead vernacular Hebrew called Aramaic, written down years later in classical Greek with varying degrees of competence (Luke’s Greek is elegant; Mark’s is wretched), then translated into English sometime between 1600 and now (depending on which English version you carry).
I, Mr. I, say: Nevertheless, accuracy made it down to us.
You say that these contraditions are irrelevant?
I, Mr. I, say: Yes. Some of them are irrelevant to the spiritual journey.
Well if the Bible is “inerrant” word of God as you and many “Christian Fundamantalists” believe then there should be no errors (litteral contradictions).
I, Mr. I, say: There aren’t any contradictions in the Word of God that matter to the spiritual journey, nor any ones that haven’t been explained. We can’t help it that you reject the explanations.
So if there are litteral contradictions(errors) it is not the “litteral and inerrant” word of God.
I, Mr. I, say: Not every statement in the Word of God is a of God. For example, statements by the Devil are not statements by God.
Please explain why there are litteral contradictions(errors) below. One of the verses has to be right so that means that the other is wrong.
I, Mr. I, say: I’ve already explained them.
The TEXT SAYS NOTHING ABOUT HIM DYING SPIRITUALLY
Irrelevant. The text is about the spiritual journey. That God said that he would die the day he ate, and, then, he went on to live physically, is not a contradiction. He died — that is, he was separated from God. God explains this after he ate.
As you already know Biblical writings were first written in Aramaic. Hebrew is a later dialect of Aramaic. The first five books of the Bible, the Pentateuch or Torah, were not written down until the time of the Babylonian Captivity, 500-600 B.C. and they were written in Aramaic, later translated to Hebrew. Moses was also NOT the author of them, he was already dead by the time they were written down. In the 3rd century B.C. the scriptures were translated into Greek because the Alexandrian Jews could not understand Aramaic. When this was done, many of the meanings of the idioms were lost.
I, Mr. I, say: However, for example, The King James Version is in the upper 90s percentile accurate with Texas Receptus Greek. TR is in the upper 90s percentile accurate with over 5600 manuscripts. This is not the case with the Wescott-Hort Greek. The WH is corrupt, and so are the modern translations which are based on the WH Greek.
In James 1:4, it says “But let patience have her perfect work, that ye may be perfect and entire, wanting nothing.”
(In this verse, patience is given a personality. It is referred to as a she. Now no one would believe that this verse in any way is implying that patience is an actual person, divine or otherwise. It is just a figure of speech, giving personality to a concept or set of ideas).
Another example is Proverbs 1:23. “Wisdom crieth without; she uttereth her voice in the streets.” (Here wisdom is given a personality, a female one, and it is even implied that she is given movement and a voice).
I, Mr. I, say: So what? Just as they needed parable, they needed figures of speech that combined with their experiences in order to understand what was being said. Those who listen to Jesus told Him that what He was saying are “hard sayings.” So, in so many cases, He responded with parable so they could grasp His concepts.
You forget that Christianity and The Bible are EASTERN in origin and influence. Christians pride themselves with Christianity being “WESTERN”.
I, Mr. I, say: I care only whether Christianity is true. I find that it is. Great, great, great, great, great, great, great, great, great multitudes throughout the ages agree with me.
You need to realize that Christianity is AN EASTERN RELIGION.
I, Mr. I, say: I have no such need. That’s cuz it’s irrelevant.
The Western church has, in many instances, changed Christianity into something that does not even resemble the original.
I, Mr. I, say: Maybe God, through the ages, intended to clarify over time.
Now, I have given the two examples above to show you how figures of speech can be used in a way that is not literal…
I, Mr. I, say: Figures of speech, by definition, are not literal. However, the things to which they refer ARE literal. They are literally true. That’s cuz the connections between two dissimilar things, made linguistically, MUST be true. There must be a truth between them for them to work.
In the original Aramaic language, which the person Jesus spoke and understood, and which was commonly spoken at the time of Christ, the word Satan was considered a figure of speech…
I, Mr. I, say: Even so, however, the concept is true. A rose by any other name…
SATAN WAS NOT CONSIDERED TO BE A REAL BEING.
I, Mr. I, say: Jesus considered Satan to be a real being. Otherwise, He was talking to Himself in the wilderness, in Matthew 4:1-11. As a matter of fact, in a manner of speaking, He WAS talking to Himself cuz he did not engage in “filthy conversation” with the Devil. In response to the Devil, He recited Scripture in order to guide and guard His mind against the attacks of the Devil. He taught us.
For instance, Luke 10:18 in which Jesus says “I beheld Satan as lightening fall from heaven,” the Aramaic idioms would translate the concept of Satan falling from heaven as “evil destroyed.” The word Satan itself means “to slide, to mislead, to slip; to miss the mark.” In other words, Jesus was saying that his coming has destroyed the concept of sin and evil. The Aramaic interpretation for Satan is “crazy thinking”.
I, Mr. I, say: And, yet, those who spoke Aramaic, for instance, assigned figures for real things, like Satan.
The Old Testament is concerned with the Hebrew God, Yahweh, and purports to be a history of the early Israelites.
I, Mr. I, say: In the Old Testament, God is concealed.
The New Testament is the work of early Christians and reflects their beliefs about Jesus; it purports to be a history of what Jesus taught and did.
I, Mr. I, say: In the New Testament, God is revealed.
No original manuscripts exist.
Irrelevant. The King James Version is in the upper 90 percentiles accurate with Texas Receptus. Texas Receptus is in the upper 90 percentile accurate with over 5600 manuscripts. The Wescott-Hort Greek is corrupt. Modern versions are based on the WH Greek. They are corrupt through WH Greek misinterpretations and copyist mistakes.
There is probably not one book which survives in anything like its original form.
I, Mr. I, say: Irrelevant, as I explained.
There are hundreds of differences between the oldest manuscripts of any one book. These differences indicate that numerous additions and alterations, some accidental and some purposeful, were made to the originals by various authors, editors, and copyists.
I, Mr. I, say: That’s true for the WH Greek. It is nowhere near as true for the TR Greek.
The four Gospels, Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John, are examples of books which did not carry the names of their actual authors.
I, Mr. I, say: Scoffer BS.
The present names were assigned long after these four books were written. And–in spite of what the Gospel authors say–biblical scholars…
I, Mr. I, say: Your cherry-picked “scholars”?
… are now almost unanimously agreed that none of the Gospel authors was either an actual disciple of Jesus or even an eyewitness to his ministry.
I, Mr. I, say: How about John, the Revelator?
Although some books of the Bible are traditionally attributed to a single author, many are actually the work of multiple authors. Genesis and John are two examples of books which reflect multiple authorship.
I, Mr. I, say: More scoffer BS.
Many biblical books have the earmarks of fiction.
I, Mr. I, say: PRIVATE INTERPRETATION ALERT — PRIVATE INTERPRETATION ALERT — PRIVATE INTERPRETATION ALERT
The Flood story is an example of this kind of adaptation. Its migration from the earliest known occurrence in Sumeria, around 1600 B.C., from place to place and eventually to the Bible, can be traced historically. Each time the story was used again, it was altered to speak of local gods and heroes.
I, Mr. I, say: Scoffer BS.
But is the Bible, nevertheless, the work of God?
I, Mr. I, say: Yes!
Is it a valid guidebook?
I, Mr. I, say: Yes!
How can we know?
I, Mr. I, say: Hebrews 4:2 [KJV]
If the Bible were really the work of a perfect, all-powerful, and loving God, one would reasonably expect it to be obviously superlative in every respect–accurate, clear, concise, and consistent throughout–as compared to anything that could possibly be conceived by human intellect alone.
I, Mr. I, say: He is!
Using a circular argument…
I, Mr. I, say: We aren’t engaged in so-called “circular argument.” It’s just that your head is spinning.
… they say that because the Bible is without error or inconsistency, it must be the work of God, and because it is the work of God, it must be without error or inconsistency.
I, Mr. I, say: Regarding the spiritual journey, He is without error and without inconsistency.
Notwithstanding the fundamentalist viewpoint, however, the Bible does contain a number of real problems. And some of these problems are absolutely fatal to its credibility.
I, Mr. I, say: The so-called “problems” you say you see are figments of your imagination. You have a darkened heart cuz-a those vain imaginations cuz you don’t thank God cuz you don’t glorify God.
Many passages relate God-ordained atrocities…
I, Mr. I, say: That’s the Old Testament and the God of wrath. Its what He was willing to do cuz-a the evil in the world. It’s not as though, however, that He didn’t warn anybody.
…; such passages are unworthy of the Christian God.
I, Mr. I, say: He is unworthy of YOU?? YOU put God on trial and convict Him?? He would like to know, just for future reference, if you take my meaning. He would like you to declare yourself on this, so there will be no mistake “later on.”
Some biblical precepts are both unreasonable and unlikely since they are in obvious disagreement with common sense…
I, Mr. I, say: So, you match wits with God?
… as well as the qualities of character which are attributed to God.
I, Mr. I, say: Not all the characters in the Word of God are Godly.
Some biblical statements are absurd in that they represent very primitive beliefs.
I, Mr. I, say: Not all of the statements in the Word of God are Godly. In some cases, God is reporting what others have said, so that He can make a point.
The believability of many biblical stories–stories that are crucial to Christianity–are discredited…
I, Mr. I, say: Discrediting dreamt up by YOU.
By numerous inconsistencies.
I, Mr. I, say: The inconsistencies are in your head.
The picture is further complicated by the many different and conflicting interpretations that are often given to a specific passage by sincere, well-intentioned believers.
I, Mr. I, say: The Devil is pleased that so many people believe so many different things. After all, the Devil is the father of confusion, not only lies.
While Biblicists are capable of offering some sort of explanation for nearly any biblical problem that can be uncovered…
I, Mr. I, say: I JUST GOOGLED THAT STATEMENT, AND I FOUND THAT STATEMENT TO BELONG TO SOMEBODY ELSE. THUS, YOU ARE PLAGIARIZING. YOU ARE NOT ATTRIBUTING SOMEBODY ELSE’S STATEMENTS TO THEM, RATHER POSTING THEM AS YOUR OWN.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | April 2, 2009, 5:42 pm 5:42 pm
I want to stress that Shaye, the poster, in his posts, has plagiarized. Of course, this is nothing new from scoffers. They can’t think for themselves. They must rob somebody else’s material and masquerade it as their own so that they can appear to be intellectual.
In order to see this, all you need to do is do what I did — just google the statement he posted without attribution, “While Biblicists are capable of offering some sort of explanation for nearly any biblical problem that can be uncovered.” You’ll see that it’s not his.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | April 2, 2009, 5:46 pm 5:46 pm
I just also googled the statement in Shaye’s post, “Some biblical statements are absurd in that they represent very primitive beliefs.” It is, also, plagiarized.
Now, I didn’t discover this until late in replying to his long post with all the plagiarism. That is when I decided, just for kicks, to google the first statement, just to see what happens cuz, suddenly, reading his material — or, should I say, what he portrayed as his material — it sounded like an article, not a poster’s writing. Had I done this earlier, I would have pointed it out earlier, and wouldn’t have wasted my time. However, now that I come to think of it, it wasn’t really a waste of time because I did a pretty good job of answering the concerns he outlined in his plagiarism.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | April 2, 2009, 5:52 pm 5:52 pm
I have just now also googled, “If the Bible were really the work of a perfect, all-powerful, and loving God, one would reasonably expect it to be obviously superlative in every respect,” another statement in a shaye post. THAT IS ALSO PLAGIARIZED.
So, you now a sampling of the statements Shaye made, without attribution, that he paraded as his own, but, in actuality, are somebody else’s statements. That’s illegal.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | April 2, 2009, 5:58 pm 5:58 pm
Very, very, very dishonest, Shaye, and it’s no surprise, then, that you couldn’t stand Christianity.
You can’t claim that it’s Christianity’s fault. The love of God, through Christ, is NOT in you, never was.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | April 2, 2009, 6:01 pm 6:01 pm
MY Comment:
The TEXT SAYS NOTHING ABOUT HIM DYING SPIRITUALLY
Irrelevant. The text is about the spiritual journey. That God said that he would die the day he ate, and, then, he went on to live physically, is not a contradiction. He died — that is, he was separated from God. God explains this after he ate.
(Where does it say in the Bible specifically that that scripture is about the spiritual journey-that is your interprestaion of that scripture)
I, Mr. I, say: However, for example, The King James Version is in the upper 90s percentile accurate with Texas Receptus Greek. TR is in the upper 90s percentile accurate with over 5600 manuscripts. This is not the case with the Wescott-Hort Greek. The WH is corrupt, and so are the modern translations which are based on the WH Greek.
You admit by you own opinon that it is not 100% accurate aka error free. its only 90% and that is debatable. Im sure Airline has planes designed 90% accurate manuals you would want to travel in that plane. I bet you would run to travel with your family on that one).
– YOU CAN’T READ IT.
I, Mr. I, say: [BUZZER SOUND!] Wrong again! So you can Translate Aramaic to English? I don’t believe so(see your next response.
Reading a translation isn’t the same thing.
I, Mr. I, say: It’s close enough.
(When you and other fundamentalists claim in that something is the ineerrant “Close enough doesn’t suffice. Close is only good enough in horse shoes).
With the Bible, you’ve got speeches that Jesus made to crowds of people in a long-dead vernacular Hebrew called Aramaic, written down years later in classical Greek with varying degrees of competence (Luke’s Greek is elegant; Mark’s is wretched), then translated into English sometime between 1600 and now (depending on which English version you carry).
I, Mr. I, say: Nevertheless, accuracy made it down to us.
(MANS ERRORS BY YOUR OWN WORDS ABOVE)
You say that these contraditions are irrelevant?
I, Mr. I, say: Yes. Some of them are irrelevant to the spiritual journey.
(THESE CONTRADTIONS ARE RELAVENT TO PROVE THAT THE BIBLE HAS ERRORS)
Well if the Bible is “inerrant” word of God as you and many “Christian Fundamantalists” believe then there should be no errors (litteral contradictions).
I, Mr. I, say: There aren’t any contradictions in the Word of God that matter to the spiritual journey, nor any ones that haven’t been explained. We can’t help it that you reject the explanations.
(YOU HAVE NOT EXPLAINED THE LITTERAL CONTRADITIONS OR ERRORS)
So if there are litteral contradictions(errors) it is not the “litteral and inerrant” word of God.
I, Mr. I, say: Not every statement in the Word of God is a of God. For example, statements by the Devil are not statements by God.
(THAT IS NOT WHAT WERE ARE TALKING ABOUT-WERE TALKING ABOUT THE BIBLE BEING ERROR FREE)
Please explain why there are litteral contradictions(errors) below. One of the verses has to be right so that means that the other is wrong.
I, Mr. I, say: I’ve already explained them.
(YOU HAVE NOT)
The TEXT SAYS NOTHING ABOUT HIM DYING SPIRITUALLY
Irrelevant. The text is about the spiritual journey. That God said that he would die the day he ate, and, then, he went on to live physically, is not a contradiction. He died — that is, he was separated from God. God explains this after he ate.
(YOU MEANT TO SAY I READ IN THE 90% ACCURATE ACCORDING TO ME BIBILE THAT GOD SAID)
Posted by: Shaye | April 2, 2009, 6:17 pm 6:17 pm
See you resort to attacking me and bringing the references That I used which are still words that have meaning which you cannot refute. I can provide those refereces if needed. So back to the point.
Posted by: Shaye | April 2, 2009, 6:21 pm 6:21 pm
MY Comment:
The TEXT SAYS NOTHING ABOUT HIM DYING SPIRITUALLY
Irrelevant. The text is about the spiritual journey. That God said that he would die the day he ate, and, then, he went on to live physically, is not a contradiction. He died — that is, he was separated from God. God explains this after he ate.
(Where does it say in the Bible specifically that that scripture is about the spiritual journey-that is your interprestaion of that scripture)
I, Mr. I, say: However, for example, The King James Version is in the upper 90s percentile accurate with Texas Receptus Greek. TR is in the upper 90s percentile accurate with over 5600 manuscripts. This is not the case with the Wescott-Hort Greek. The WH is corrupt, and so are the modern translations which are based on the WH Greek.
You admit by you own opinon that it is not 100% accurate aka error free. its only 90% and that is debatable. Im sure Airline has planes designed 90% accurate manuals you would want to travel in that plane. I bet you would run to travel with your family on that one).
– YOU CAN’T READ IT.
I, Mr. I, say: [BUZZER SOUND!] Wrong again! So you can Translate Aramaic to English? I don’t believe so(see your next response.
Reading a translation isn’t the same thing.
I, Mr. I, say: It’s close enough.
(When you and other fundamentalists claim in that something is the ineerrant “Close enough doesn’t suffice. Close is only good enough in horse shoes).
With the Bible, you’ve got speeches that Jesus made to crowds of people in a long-dead vernacular Hebrew called Aramaic, written down years later in classical Greek with varying degrees of competence (Luke’s Greek is elegant; Mark’s is wretched), then translated into English sometime between 1600 and now (depending on which English version you carry).
I, Mr. I, say: Nevertheless, accuracy made it down to us.
(MANS ERRORS BY YOUR OWN WORDS ABOVE)
You say that these contraditions are irrelevant?
I, Mr. I, say: Yes. Some of them are irrelevant to the spiritual journey.
(THESE CONTRADTIONS ARE RELAVENT TO PROVE THAT THE BIBLE HAS ERRORS)
Well if the Bible is “inerrant” word of God as you and many “Christian Fundamantalists” believe then there should be no errors (litteral contradictions).
I, Mr. I, say: There aren’t any contradictions in the Word of God that matter to the spiritual journey, nor any ones that haven’t been explained. We can’t help it that you reject the explanations.
(YOU HAVE NOT EXPLAINED THE LITTERAL CONTRADITIONS OR ERRORS)
So if there are litteral contradictions(errors) it is not the “litteral and inerrant” word of God.
I, Mr. I, say: Not every statement in the Word of God is a of God. For example, statements by the Devil are not statements by God.
(THAT IS NOT WHAT WERE ARE TALKING ABOUT-WERE TALKING ABOUT THE BIBLE BEING ERROR FREE)
Please explain why there are litteral contradictions(errors) below. One of the verses has to be right so that means that the other is wrong.
I, Mr. I, say: I’ve already explained them.
(YOU HAVE NOT)
The TEXT SAYS NOTHING ABOUT HIM DYING SPIRITUALLY
Irrelevant. The text is about the spiritual journey. That God said that he would die the day he ate, and, then, he went on to live physically, is not a contradiction. He died — that is, he was separated from God. God explains this after he ate.
(YOU MEANT TO SAY I READ IN THE 90% ACCURATE ACCORDING TO ME BIBILE THAT GOD SAID)
Posted by: Shaye | April 2, 2009, 6:23 pm 6:23 pm
==You admit by you own opinon that it is not 100% accurate aka error free.==
I did nothing of the kind, plagiarist.
== its only 90% …==
100%.
== And that is debatable.==
It is not.
== Im sure Airline has planes designed 90% accurate manuals you would want to travel in that plane. I bet you would run to travel with your family on that one).==
Irrelevant. Non sequitur.
==(When you and other fundamentalists claim in that something is the ineerrant “Close enough doesn’t suffice. Close is only good enough in horse shoes).==
The language, itself, is close enough to the accuracy of the spiritual journey God intends.
==With the Bible, you’ve got speeches that Jesus made to crowds of people in a long-dead vernacular Hebrew called Aramaic, written down years later in classical Greek with varying degrees of competence (Luke’s Greek is elegant; Mark’s is wretched), then translated into English sometime between 1600 and now (depending on which English version you carry).==
Irrelevant. The ideas get across.
==(THESE CONTRADTIONS ARE RELAVENT TO PROVE THAT THE BIBLE HAS ERRORS)==
Any contradictions you say you find in the Word of God are really in your head.
==(YOU HAVE NOT EXPLAINED THE LITTERAL CONTRADITIONS OR ERRORS)==
I have, but you miss them cuz you have precluded yourself from receiving them.
==I, Mr. I, say: Not every statement in the Word of God is a of God. For example, statements by the Devil are not statements by God.
(THAT IS NOT WHAT WERE ARE TALKING ABOUT-WERE TALKING ABOUT THE BIBLE BEING ERROR FREE)==
It IS what we’re talking about. You can’t blame God for saying something that He didn’t say.
==(YOU MEANT TO SAY I READ IN THE 90% ACCURATE ACCORDING TO ME BIBILE THAT GOD SAID)==
You don’t get to say what I meant.
==See you resort to attacking me…==
YOU’RE responsible for your arguments.
==… and bringing the references That I used which are still words that have meaning which you cannot refute.==
Words have no meaning. People have meaning.
== I can provide those refereces if needed.==
More plagiarism?
==(Where does it say in the Bible specifically that that scripture is about the spiritual journey…==
The entire Word of God is about a spiritual journey. You can’t appreciate that concept by reading the Word of God as you do a newspaper. Reading the Word of God as a newspaper, or a textbook, rather than as He was intended, is a favorite technique of scoffers who are trying to defeat God and His Word. It’s not working.
==…-that is your interprestaion of that scripture)==
The Word of God is of no private interpretation. I take that seriously. It is a Holy Spirit interpretation. I take that seriously.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | April 2, 2009, 6:41 pm 6:41 pm
Here are my references for some of this blog exchange. Please read them when you have time. I have persoanlly agree with these references.
http://www.infidels.org/library/modern/donald_morgan/intro.html
http://www.etymonline.com/columns/fallacy.htm
Eveyone on this blog should read them(Copy the links and share them with people and have discussions)
Posted by: Shaye | April 2, 2009, 6:43 pm 6:43 pm
I, Mr. I, say: However, for example, The King James Version is in the upper 90s percentile accurate with Texas Receptus Greek. TR is in the upper 90s percentile accurate with over 5600 manuscripts. This is not the case with the Wescott-Hort Greek. The WH is corrupt, and so are the modern translations which are based on the WH Greek.
What does this mean? Exactly? Upper 90% that is not 100%. Logic
Posted by: Shaye | April 2, 2009, 6:48 pm 6:48 pm
==…-that is your interprestaion of that scripture)==
The Word of God is of no private interpretation. I take that seriously. It is a Holy Spirit interpretation. I take that seriously.
(Okay then when is the Holy Spirit interpresting and your mind interpreting?)
There are thousands of Christian Denominations aka intepretations. Did the Holy Spirit interpret them differently.
Posted by: Shaye | April 2, 2009, 6:52 pm 6:52 pm
2 Kings 8:26 says “Two and twenty years old was Ahaziah when he began to reign…
” 2 Chronicles 22:2 says “Forty and two years old was Ahaziah when he began to reign…” ==
If you take a look above then you will see the Age of Ahaziah 22 and in the second 42. There is twenty year difference in age. So Which one is it?
Posted by: Shaye | April 2, 2009, 6:56 pm 6:56 pm
== And that is debatable.==
It is not.
== Im sure Airline has planes designed 90% accurate manuals you would want to travel in that plane. I bet you would run to travel with your family on that one).==
Irrelevant. Non sequitur.
(THIS IS A SPIRITUAL LIFE AND DEATH SITUATION LIKE AN INDIVIDUAL LIFE AND DEATH SITUATION WITH THE EXAMPLE ABOVE. WOULD YOU HAVE YOUR FAMILY RIDE THAT PLANE?)
==(When you and other fundamentalists claim in that something is the ineerrant “Close enough doesn’t suffice. Close is only good enough in horse shoes).==
The language, itself, is close enough to the accuracy of the spiritual journey God intends.
(HOW DO YOU KNOW GOD INTENDS IT TO BE CLOSE ENOUGH? WERE YOU IN HIS MIND WHEN HE SET THAT INTENTION? OH YEAH YOU READ IT :)
==With the Bible, you’ve got speeches that Jesus made to crowds of people in a long-dead vernacular Hebrew called Aramaic, written down years later in classical Greek with varying degrees of competence (Luke’s Greek is elegant; Mark’s is wretched), then translated into English sometime between 1600 and now (depending on which English version you carry).==
Irrelevant. The ideas get across.
(PLAY THE MESSAGE GAME WHERE MESSAGES GET PASSED AROUND AND IN THE ENED THE MESSAGE IS COMPLETELY DIFFERENT)
==(THESE CONTRADTIONS ARE RELAVENT TO PROVE THAT THE BIBLE HAS ERRORS)==
Any contradictions you say you find in the Word of God are really in your head.
(UM NO THEY ARE IN YOUR BIBLE-Was Ahaziah or 22 years old or 42? when he took his reign?)
Posted by: Shaye | April 2, 2009, 7:04 pm 7:04 pm
Mr. I’s Words:
Words have no meaning. People have meaning.
(So then words in your bible have no meaning. People have meaning.
I REST MY CASE YOU AND I ARE 100% in agreement:)
Posted by: Shaye | April 2, 2009, 7:09 pm 7:09 pm
==(So then words in your bible have no meaning. People have meaning. ==
God has meaning. He means something specific by His Words.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | April 2, 2009, 7:17 pm 7:17 pm
Play the message game with 5 different languages over 1000+ years :)
Posted by: Shaye | April 2, 2009, 7:17 pm 7:17 pm
Hey Mr. I
I just want you to know im not an Athiest by the way. I just disagree with a Fundamentalist Viewpoint of the Bible. I have a theological question. I have been saved and baptised 3 times and redidicated my life to Christ. The baptisim is an outward sign of inward grace which I honestly believe in Jesus and the Creator aka GOD. Am I saved?
Posted by: Shaye | April 2, 2009, 7:23 pm 7:23 pm
==(So then words in your bible have no meaning. People have meaning. ==
God has meaning. He means something specific by His Words.
So how does God have meaning? Specifically. How did he get the meaning? Did we give him the meaning. Since by your words People have meaning. Is that meaning what we attach to the word God? What does the word GOD mean to you?
Posted by: Shaye | April 2, 2009, 7:32 pm 7:32 pm
==Here are my references for some of this blog exchange. Please read them when you have time.==
No.
== I have persoanlly agree with these references.==
That’s why.
==I, Mr. I, say: However, for example, The King James Version is in the upper 90s percentile accurate with Texas Receptus Greek. TR is in the upper 90s percentile accurate with over 5600 manuscripts. This is not the case with the Wescott-Hort Greek. The WH is corrupt, and so are the modern translations which are based on the WH Greek.
What does this mean? Exactly? Upper 90% that is not 100%. Logic==
What it means is that the words in the Word of God are accurate enough to get across the concept of the spiritual journey. They are as accurate to the originals as they are going to get, and that’s pretty accurate. They don’t have to be 100%.
==(Okay then when is the Holy Spirit interpresting and your mind interpreting?==
When what I think and say align with the Word of God, it must have been the Holy Spirit. It can be nothing else.
When I privately interpret, the interpretation will wander from alignment with the Word of God. My mind will argue with me. I will entertain filthy conversations. That’s a sure way to get it wrong.
==There are thousands of Christian Denominations aka intepretations.==
The Devil likes it that way. Confusion. More chance for lies.
== Did the Holy Spirit interpret them differently. ==
The Holy Spirit cannot be telling one person one thing and telling me another.
==2 Kings 8:26 says “Two and twenty years old was Ahaziah when he began to reign…
” 2 Chronicles 22:2 says “Forty and two years old was Ahaziah when he began to reign…” ==
If you take a look above then you will see the Age of Ahaziah 22 and in the second 42. There is twenty year difference in age. So Which one is it?==
It’s irrelevant to the spiritual journey.
==(THIS IS A SPIRITUAL LIFE AND DEATH SITUATION LIKE AN INDIVIDUAL LIFE AND DEATH SITUATION WITH THE EXAMPLE ABOVE. WOULD YOU HAVE YOUR FAMILY RIDE THAT PLANE?)==
Non sequitur.
However, on the question of aviation, a worldly question, having nothing to do with the Word of God, I’ll say that I’m a pilot. And no small time one, at that.
Airplanes are not 100% 100% of the time. Pilots are not 100% 100% of the time. There are shortcuts, and nothing is 100% of the time according to the manual. Sticking to the manual and to the law 100% of the time would make flying impossible.
However, sticking to the Word of God, as in hand as He is, does NOT make life impossible. He makes life possible.
==(HOW DO YOU KNOW GOD INTENDS IT TO BE CLOSE ENOUGH?==
Cuz THAT’S the Message of the Word of God.
==WERE YOU IN HIS MIND WHEN HE SET THAT INTENTION?==
He knew me before I was born.
==(PLAY THE MESSAGE GAME WHERE MESSAGES GET PASSED AROUND AND IN THE ENED THE MESSAGE IS COMPLETELY DIFFERENT)==
You’re trying to give God human attributes. It doesn’t work that way.
== “Any contradictions you say you find in the Word of God are really in your head.”
(UM NO THEY ARE IN YOUR BIBLE…==
There are no contradictions in the Word of God that are relevant to the spiritual journey. What scoffers try to do is take grammar, for instance, and try to say that it’s an error in the instructions for the spiritual journey. They are two different things.
==…-Was Ahaziah or 22 years old or 42? when he took his reign?) ==
I don’t care. It’s irrelevant to the spiritual journey.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | April 2, 2009, 7:33 pm 7:33 pm
==Play the message game with 5 different languages over 1000+ years ==
Human reasoning. Not God reasoning.
==I just want you to know im not an Athiest by the way. ==
What do YOU call it?
== I just disagree with a Fundamentalist Viewpoint of the Bible. ==
Oh, and you want a substitute YOUR viewpoint for it.
== I have been saved and baptised 3 times and redidicated my life to Christ. The baptisim is an outward sign of inward grace which I honestly believe in Jesus and the Creator aka GOD. ==
Why isn’t it, “God, a.k.a. Creator”? Interesting frame of mind your wording betrays.
Anyway, if all that is true, you wouldn’t be saying the things you’re saying. Death and life are in the power of the tongue. If you’re speaking death, that list of things cannot apply to you. You would, then, be a false teacher.
==Am I saved?==
If you’re speaking death, no.
==So how does God have meaning? Specifically.==
To whom?
== How did he get the meaning?==
He had it from the beginning.
== Did we give him the meaning.==
He gives us meaning.
== Since by your words People have meaning. Is that meaning what we attach to the word God?==
No. The Word of God has meaning all His own. It’s up to us to discover Him. If we are attacking our own meaning to Him, we are privately interpreting Him.
== What does the word GOD mean to you?==
He means what He means to all. It’s a matter of who receives Him, and who doesn’t. Those who receive Him receive an interpretation from the Holy Spirit that is different from those who do not receive Him who make up their own interpretation.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | April 2, 2009, 8:02 pm 8:02 pm
==I, Mr. I, say: However, for example, The King James Version is in the upper 90s percentile accurate with Texas Receptus Greek. TR is in the upper 90s percentile accurate with over 5600 manuscripts. This is not the case with the Wescott-Hort Greek. The WH is corrupt, and so are the modern translations which are based on the WH Greek.
What does this mean? Exactly? Upper 90% that is not 100%. Logic==
What it means is that the words in the Word of God are accurate enough to get across the concept of the spiritual journey. They are as accurate to the originals as they are going to get, and that’s pretty accurate. They don’t have to be 100%.
Okay so you are a fundamentalist that will admint there are some minor man made errors. That seems more real than the document being perfect gramatically and historically in every way. I will accept that. No argument here.
==(Okay then when is the Holy Spirit interpresting and your mind interpreting?==
When what I think and say align with the Word of God, it must have been the Holy Spirit. It can be nothing else.
When I privately interpret, the interpretation will wander from alignment with the Word of God. My mind will argue with me. I will entertain filthy conversations. That’s a sure way to get it wrong.
(So basically you thouths and actions have to kine with scripture litterally) Thoughts outside the bible are not of God)?
==There are thousands of Christian Denominations aka intepretations.==
The Devil likes it that way. Confusion. More chance for lies.
SO which denomination is the correct one?) Which one do you most closely align with)?
== Did the Holy Spirit interpret them differently. ==
The Holy Spirit cannot be telling one person one thing and telling me another.
(I agree)
==2 Kings 8:26 says “Two and twenty years old was Ahaziah when he began to reign…
” 2 Chronicles 22:2 says “Forty and two years old was Ahaziah when he began to reign…” ==
If you take a look above then you will see the Age of Ahaziah 22 and in the second 42. There is twenty year difference in age. So Which one is it?==
It’s irrelevant to the spiritual journey.
(You are correct it has no real impact on my spiritual journey or yours-this issue-Agreed)
==(THIS IS A SPIRITUAL LIFE AND DEATH SITUATION LIKE AN INDIVIDUAL LIFE AND DEATH SITUATION WITH THE EXAMPLE ABOVE. WOULD YOU HAVE YOUR FAMILY RIDE THAT PLANE?)==
Non sequitur.
However, on the question of aviation, a worldly question, having nothing to do with the Word of God, I’ll say that I’m a pilot. And no small time one, at that.
Airplanes are not 100% 100% of the time. Pilots are not 100% 100% of the time. There are shortcuts, and nothing is 100% of the time according to the manual. Sticking to the manual and to the law 100% of the time would make flying impossible.
However, sticking to the Word of God, as in hand as He is, does NOT make life impossible. He makes life possible.
(Now are you personally able to follow the word of God 100% of the time)?
==(HOW DO YOU KNOW GOD INTENDS IT TO BE CLOSE ENOUGH?==
Cuz THAT’S the Message of the Word of God.
(Can you share that specific Scripture with me?)
==WERE YOU IN HIS MIND WHEN HE SET THAT INTENTION?==
He knew me before I was born.
(How do you “know” that he knew you before you were born. I feel a more accurate and honest statement would be “I believe based on what I have read that God knew me before I was born.:)
==(PLAY THE MESSAGE GAME WHERE MESSAGES GET PASSED AROUND AND IN THE ENED THE MESSAGE IS COMPLETELY DIFFERENT)==
You’re trying to give God human attributes. It doesn’t work that way.
(Im not talking about God. Im talking about the people who dictated “Gods” message, translitterated the words, chose which books to become cannon,from Moses time all the way from AD 51 to year 2009. It is the most grand message game ever played.
Posted by: Shaye | April 2, 2009, 8:04 pm 8:04 pm
==I, Mr. I, say: However, for example, The King James Version is in the upper 90s percentile accurate with Texas Receptus Greek. TR is in the upper 90s percentile accurate with over 5600 manuscripts. This is not the case with the Wescott-Hort Greek. The WH is corrupt, and so are the modern translations which are based on the WH Greek.
What does this mean? Exactly? Upper 90% that is not 100%. Logic==
What it means is that the words in the Word of God are accurate enough to get across the concept of the spiritual journey. They are as accurate to the originals as they are going to get, and that’s pretty accurate. They don’t have to be 100%.
Okay so you are a fundamentalist that will admint there are some minor man made errors. That seems more real than the document being perfect gramatically and historically in every way. I will accept that. No argument here.
==(Okay then when is the Holy Spirit interpresting and your mind interpreting?==
When what I think and say align with the Word of God, it must have been the Holy Spirit. It can be nothing else.
When I privately interpret, the interpretation will wander from alignment with the Word of God. My mind will argue with me. I will entertain filthy conversations. That’s a sure way to get it wrong.
(So basically you thouths and actions have to kine with scripture litterally) Thoughts outside the bible are not of God)?
==There are thousands of Christian Denominations aka intepretations.==
The Devil likes it that way. Confusion. More chance for lies.
SO which denomination is the correct one?) Which one do you most closely align with)?
== Did the Holy Spirit interpret them differently. ==
The Holy Spirit cannot be telling one person one thing and telling me another.
(I agree)
==2 Kings 8:26 says “Two and twenty years old was Ahaziah when he began to reign…
” 2 Chronicles 22:2 says “Forty and two years old was Ahaziah when he began to reign…” ==
If you take a look above then you will see the Age of Ahaziah 22 and in the second 42. There is twenty year difference in age. So Which one is it?==
It’s irrelevant to the spiritual journey.
(You are correct it has no real impact on my spiritual journey or yours-this issue-Agreed)
==(THIS IS A SPIRITUAL LIFE AND DEATH SITUATION LIKE AN INDIVIDUAL LIFE AND DEATH SITUATION WITH THE EXAMPLE ABOVE. WOULD YOU HAVE YOUR FAMILY RIDE THAT PLANE?)==
Non sequitur.
However, on the question of aviation, a worldly question, having nothing to do with the Word of God, I’ll say that I’m a pilot. And no small time one, at that.
Airplanes are not 100% 100% of the time. Pilots are not 100% 100% of the time. There are shortcuts, and nothing is 100% of the time according to the manual. Sticking to the manual and to the law 100% of the time would make flying impossible.
However, sticking to the Word of God, as in hand as He is, does NOT make life impossible. He makes life possible.
(Now are you personally able to follow the word of God 100% of the time)?
==(HOW DO YOU KNOW GOD INTENDS IT TO BE CLOSE ENOUGH?==
Cuz THAT’S the Message of the Word of God.
(Can you share that specific Scripture with me?)
==WERE YOU IN HIS MIND WHEN HE SET THAT INTENTION?==
He knew me before I was born.
(How do you “know” that he knew you before you were born. I feel a more accurate and honest statement would be “I believe based on what I have read that God knew me before I was born.:)
==(PLAY THE MESSAGE GAME WHERE MESSAGES GET PASSED AROUND AND IN THE ENED THE MESSAGE IS COMPLETELY DIFFERENT)==
You’re trying to give God human attributes. It doesn’t work that way.
(Im not talking about God. Im talking about the people who dictated “Gods” message, translitterated the words, chose which books to become cannon,from Moses time all the way from AD 51 to year 2009. It is the most grand message game ever played.
Posted by: Shaye | April 2, 2009, 8:04 pm 8:04 pm
The Word of God calls what Shaye is trying to engage me in as, “filthy conversation.” It is also called, “foolish questions.”
It is all designed as the Devil design his mission in the wilderness, with Jesus. The Devil tries to disengage the Believer from God. Throw him off track. They can stumble, then say, “See! He stumbled!”
Shaye and all others can plainly see that it isn’t working on me just as it didn’t work on Jesus.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | April 2, 2009, 8:07 pm 8:07 pm
They can stumble—> make him stumble
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | April 2, 2009, 8:08 pm 8:08 pm
I am just having a dialoge here. lol
Posted by: Shaye | April 2, 2009, 8:17 pm 8:17 pm
Hey M. Incredible I respect that you have your beliefs.
John 3:15-18
The Son of Man must be lifted up, that everyone who believes in him may have eternal life. For God so loved the world that he gave his one and only Son, that whoever believes in him shall not perish but have eternal life. For God did not send his Son into the world to condemn the world, but to save the world through him. Whoever believes in him is not condemned, but whoever does not believe stands condemned already because he has not believed in the name of God’s one and only Son.”
Salvation in Christ is not temporary, it is eternal.
Sorry Mr. Incredible. I believe in Jesus and not in your interpretation of the bible. I am Saved. Salvation in Christ is not temporary, it is eternal.
Posted by: Shaye | April 2, 2009, 8:22 pm 8:22 pm
Oh yeah what is your Christian Denomniation? What is the denomination of the Church you attend?
Typing words are debating is easy. Our lives will be the true test. “Your life is your spirituality demonstrated” Faith wihout deeds is dead. ;)
Posted by: Shaye | April 2, 2009, 8:43 pm 8:43 pm
I ask everyone to ask themselves. So does your life match up with your words? Live what you believe or you will be a fraud within yourself.
Posted by: Shaye | April 2, 2009, 8:46 pm 8:46 pm
I pray that everyone will follow the path of love. Now thats a solid theology(I can hear Mr incredibles thinking-lol) What is you definition of love? lol Have a great night everyone!
Posted by: Shaye | April 2, 2009, 8:50 pm 8:50 pm
Mr. Incredible. I thank you for being a good debater with me. You have helped me grow in that area. You have fine tuned my skills and opned up some theological questions for me to investigate. I hope the exchange between you and I has increased your faith and understanding. I enjoyed this.
Posted by: Shaye | April 2, 2009, 8:56 pm 8:56 pm
==I believe in Jesus and not in your interpretation of the bible.==
The Holy Spirit can be telling you one thing and me another.
== Faith wihout deeds is dead.==
What kinda deeds?
==I pray that everyone will follow the path of love.==
Define “love.”
==Mr. Incredible. I thank you for being a good debater with me. You have helped me grow in that area. You have fine tuned my skills and opned up some theological questions for me to investigate. I hope the exchange between you and I has increased your faith and understanding. I enjoyed this.==
Thank you. Me too.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | April 3, 2009, 2:10 am 2:10 am
== Faith wihout deeds is dead.==
What kinda deeds?
Loving deeds
Define “love.”
“Love is patient, love is kind. It does not envy, it does not boast, it is not proud. It is not rude, it is not self-seeking, it is not easily angered, it keeps no record of wrongs. Love does not delight in evil but rejoices with the truth. It always protects, always trusts, always hopes, always preserves.”
– 1 Corinthians 13:4-
Posted by: Shaye | April 3, 2009, 11:09 am 11:09 am
The Holy Spirit can be telling you one thing and me another.
(Lets investigate this)
I want your opinion on this practical spiritual application in daily life:
“Do unto others as you would have them do unto you” is the golden rule correct? The “golden rule can apply to each and every circumstance and situation. Can the Holy Sprit give unique advice in those unique situations? The “Holy Spirit” can give advice depending on the context of the situation. So a good way to tell if you are following the more spiritual path is to be mindful in situations and apply the golden rule based on the definition of love above. This is the best defense against lets say negative selfish thinking and Satan if he exists? We are in essence are being more aware of our own thinking and external circumstances and applying this spiritual love. Since our beliefs affect our thoughts, our thoughts affect your emotions, and our emotions affect our behavior. And its our behavior that is the end result of “missing the mark” in relation to the definition of love above. So we will in essence create a natural spiritual defense against negative (non loving) personal thinking, other human , social, cultural, political, and religious influences. Now if our “Spiritual Star Trek shields or “helmet” are up then the extra outside being Satan cannot break through the “helmet” and affect our thoughts? If the being Satan can’t do that then belief that he is exists is not necessarily needed because we already have the natural piritual defense up. Correct?
Posted by: Shaye | April 3, 2009, 12:43 pm 12:43 pm
Its simple like in Marital arts. Where head goes, the body goes. Keep your head focused on love(Love is patient, love is kind, do unto others, etc) and that focus block out any negative mind chatter or possible outside of your mind. This takes focus and discipline to create a spirutally positive mind patterns.
Posted by: Shaye | April 3, 2009, 4:19 pm 4:19 pm
If we can focus our own thoughts then no external being ranging from your aggravating brother, to the woman at work who wants to get you fired, the ghose in your grandmas house, to the Satan that some people believe exists. You have to do the work! No one else can accept responsibiliy but you and if someone influences you so what you free choice and its your responsibility.
Posted by: Shaye | April 3, 2009, 4:25 pm 4:25 pm
If we can focus our own thoughts then no external being ranging from your aggravating brother, to the woman at work who wants to get you fired, the ghost in your grandmas house, to the Satan that some people believe exists can make you do anything. You have to do the work! No one else but you can accept responsibility for yout life. So what if someone influences you. you experience influences all the time. At the end of the day it your choice and its your responsibility to create your life situation.
Posted by: Shaye | April 3, 2009, 4:29 pm 4:29 pm
What does the law of physics say?
How does the balance sheet in bookkeeping … work?
For every action there is an equal and opposite reaction!!!!
I am a fundamental Christian. I believe in God thereby I need to also believe in Lucifer, a/k/a the devil, a/k/a satin.
However my beliefs neither accept nor reject the bible as it was written and modified by mankind, though it was inspired by god. Like all truly religiously oriented people I possess a personal relationship and passion for my faith, work, family and knowledge.
Posted by: John | April 7, 2009, 3:21 am 3:21 am
The ‘War in Heaven’ continues on Earth – YES absolutely, the battle rages on for your soul – every single minute of every single day. Have you ever asked yourself if we ‘evolved’ from apes why are there still apes? Instead of asking the typical question, reverse it: can you prove God does not exist? Didn’t think so. If you are on Earth it is only because you chose Jesus Christ/the freedom to choose vs. Lucifer/no choice during the War in Heaven – where you came from. Your time on Earth is but a moment in eternity. It is what you do with the gift of life given you on Earth that determines where you spend eternity… Ask: What do you have to lose by living a Godly life vs. what do you have to lose by ignoring Him?
Posted by: sprowlindak | April 7, 2009, 5:22 pm 5:22 pm
Ruby,
I rest my case. Even someone like you that doesn’t even know who I am says “shame on you for not believing in what your uncle believes” -my point exactly
I’ll chose my beliefs thanks.
Posted by: Dave | April 8, 2009, 12:07 am 12:07 am
The truth is no one in this dialogue proved or disprove that Satan (the singular being)exists. We cannot use circular reasoning that a religious text says he exists so there fore he exists. You can believe what you have read but that does not substantiate proof. The only way you can know something is through personal experience. Now some want to blame Satan as the reason why they lost their job, cheated on their wife, or for their Bipolar disorder. That is the an easy way to escape responsibility. No matter what influence that exists you have a choice and it your and yours only. I am not arrogant to say he exists or doesn’t exist. I have not experienced this being and it will take more than ink from me to know 100%. If you want to believe or not believe either way is fine with me and I honor your choice as a sentient human being.
Posted by: shaye | April 12, 2009, 4:23 pm 4:23 pm
==/== Faith wihout deeds is dead.==
“What kinda deeds?”
Loving deeds
“Define ‘love.’”
‘Love is patient, love is kind. It does not envy, it does not boast, it is not proud. It is not rude, it is not self-seeking, it is not easily angered, it keeps no record of wrongs. Love does not delight in evil but rejoices with the truth. It always protects, always trusts, always hopes, always preserves.’
– 1 Corinthians 13:4-==
You tell us what “love” does, not what it is, biblically.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | April 13, 2009, 3:43 pm 3:43 pm
==Its [sic] simple like in Marital arts. Where head goes, the body goes.==
In martial arts, basketball, football and hockey, you don’t lookit the head, rather the chest area cuz the direction of the chest is where the body is going.
== Keep your head focused on love(Love is patient, love is kind, do unto others, etc)…==
YOu say what “love” does, not what it is, biblically.
The way YOU describe it, “love” can be a worldly love, and worldly “love” ain’t what Christ is all about.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | April 13, 2009, 3:49 pm 3:49 pm
==I am not arrogant to say he exists or doesn’t exist.==
It’s not arrogant to believe God when He says the Devil — Satan — exists. Unless, of course, you say that God is arrogant.
== I have not experienced this being…==
Yes, you have. You’re just not conscious of it. That you are unconscious doesn’t mean that he doesn’t exist.
==… and it will take more than ink from me to know 100%.==
God tells you 100% sure. You choose not to believe Him.
Can I know that Man’s heart is wicked? Yes, cuz God tells me so, and I believe Him cuz He knows.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | April 13, 2009, 3:52 pm 3:52 pm
==What is you definition of love?==
My definition of “love,” in my unrighteous self, conforms to the world’s definition which changes from second to second and person to person; one never knows what it is in the world. The world’s definition, thankfully, is not God’s definition, though.
However, in my Righteous self — thanks to Christ! — the definition follows the biblical example: Unselfish concern for the Salvation of others. Thus, I follow His example.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | April 13, 2009, 3:56 pm 3:56 pm
==Where head goes, the body goes.==
As we learn in sport, the head fake has left many a player in the dust.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | April 13, 2009, 3:58 pm 3:58 pm
==“Do unto others as you would have them do unto you” is the golden rule correct?==
How are we to do unto others, biblically? Preach and teach the Word of Salvation! I give them what they need for eternity cuz I want them to give me what I need for eternity. THAT is the love of God!
== The “golden rule can apply to each and every circumstance and situation.==
Depends. In the worldly sense, one who holds the Truth in unrighteousness can apply it to mean that he wants another to “do” to him what he wants to “do” to another.
The Righteous definition of the “rule” is something else again.
== Can the Holy Sprit give unique advice in those unique situations? ==
Whatever advice He gives must adhere to and align with the Word of God, and, since those who are born again must all be on the same page and have the same Message, the Holy Spirit cannot tell you one thing and me another, regarding the same issue.
==The “Holy Spirit” can give advice depending on the context of the situation. ==
However, if we are in the same situation, His advice must be the same in the Word of God cuz He cannot and will not change, even from one person to the next, even from one second to the next.
==So a good way to tell if you are following the more spiritual path…==
Is there a “path” other than Christ???
==… is to be mindful in situations and apply the golden rule based on the definition of love above.==
Oh, you mean, like, your worldly definition.
==… being more aware of our own thinking…==
Rather than God’s??
==… and external circumstances and applying this spiritual love.==
Your definition again.
== Since our beliefs affect our thoughts, our thoughts affect your emotions, and our emotions affect our behavior.==
Not true.
Our words make up our thoughts and our thoughts make up our beliefs. Except that the born again individual incorporates God’s Thoughts, and God says Satan exists. I believe Him cuz God cannot lie AND I am persuaded by His performance of His Promise. He has proved by performance, by work. His work is a work of love, faith, Grace and Truth.
== And its our behavior that is the end result of “missing the mark” in relation to the definition of love above.==
The worldly definition.
== So we will in essence create a natural spiritual defense…==
Based on the worldly definition of “love.”
==… against negative (non loving) personal thinking, other human , social, cultural, political, and religious influences.==
Nice way to talk yourself into jusitfying anything you want, like believing that Satan doesn’t exist.
== Now if our “Spiritual Star Trek shields or “helmet” are up then the extra outside being Satan cannot break through the “helmet” and affect our thoughts?==
What are those “shields”? What is that “helmet”?
== If the being Satan can’t do that then belief that he is exists is not necessarily needed…==
God says that Satan exists and attacks all the time, just as he is trying to do here; but the prince of this world has nothing in me.
==… because we already have the natural piritual defense up. Correct?==
No. The unrighteous have no such defense against the Devil.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | April 13, 2009, 4:17 pm 4:17 pm
Mr. Incredible
Good to see you back! I was getting lonely.I’m glad you have your beliefs. :)
Posted by: shaye | April 13, 2009, 7:33 pm 7:33 pm
MY COMMENTS WILL BE IN ( )
==/== Faith wihout deeds is dead.==
“What kinda deeds?”
Loving deeds
“Define ‘love.’”
‘Love is patient, love is kind. It does not envy, it does not boast, it is not proud. It is not rude, it is not self-seeking, it is not easily angered, it keeps no record of wrongs. Love does not delight in evil but rejoices with the truth. It always protects, always trusts, always hopes, always preserves.’
– 1 Corinthians 13:4-==
You tell us what “love” does, not what it is, biblical.
( WELL SINCE WE ARE HUMAN WE LIKE TO HAVE HUMAN EXAMPLES. WHAT IS YOUR DEFINITION OF LOVE MR INCREDIBLE)?
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | Apr 13, 2009 3:43:19 PM
==Its [sic] simple like in Marital arts. Where head goes, the body goes.==
In martial arts, basketball, football and hockey, you don’t lookit the head, rather the chest area cuz the direction of the chest is where the body is going.
(OK OBVIOUSLY IM TALKING ABOUT GRABBING THE HEAD NOT STARING AT IT. YOU ARE MISTAKEN AGAIN LOL)
== Keep your head focused on love(Love is patient, love is kind, do unto others, etc)…==
YOu say what “love” does, not what it is, biblically.
(WHAT IS YOUR INTERPRETATION OF WHAT YOU READ IN THE BIBLE AND ITS DEFINITION & WHICH VERSION)
The way YOU describe it, “love” can be a worldly love, and worldly “love” ain’t what Christ is all about.
I USED IT RIGHT FROM THE BIBLE. I’M SURE YOU HAVE HEARD OF IT) LOL
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | Apr 13, 2009 3:49:00 PM
==I am not arrogant to say he exists or doesn’t exist.==
It’s not arrogant to believe God when He says the Devil — Satan — exists. Unless, of course, you say that God is arrogant.
ONCE AGAIN WE ALL KNOW THAT GOD READY DIDN’T SAY THIS TO YOU LIKE GEORGE BURNS DID IN OH GOD. YOU READ WORDS AND BELIEVED THEM FROM THE BIBLE. DO YOU EVER QUESTION ANYTHING YOU READ SO WHY IS THE BIBLE SPECIAL? BECAUSE IT SAID IT WAS “GOD BREATHED” LOL YOUR CIRCULAR REASONING AND YOUR HEAD IS SPINNING LOL YOU SHOW YOUR ARRNGANCE BY SPEAKING ABOUT THINGS YOU “KNOW” NOTHING ABOUT.
== I have not experienced this being…==
Yes, you have. You’re just not conscious of it. That you are unconscious doesn’t mean that he doesn’t exist.
(HOW DO YOU KNOW WHAT I HAVE EXPERIENCED? I HAVE NOT COMMUNICATE ALL OF MY LIFE EXPERIENCE. HAVE YOU BEEN IN MY MIND BODY AND SPIRIT. I HOPE NOT. I WOULD HAVE TO CALL 911) LOL SO PLEASE REFRAIN FROM SAYING I AM NOT CONSCIOUS OF IT. ONCE AGAIN TALKING ABOUT THINGS YOU DO NOT KNOW –THANK YOU)
==… and it will take more than ink from me to know 100%.==
God tells you 100% sure. You choose not to believe Him.
(IF GOD COMES AND TELLS ME PERSONALLY I WILL TAKE IT INTO CONSIDERATION. I WOULD NOT TAKE IT FROM YOU BECAUSE YOU ARE NOT GOOD WITNESS FOR THAT KIND OF MESSAGE THAT IS MY EXPERIENCE):)
Can I know that Man’s heart is wicked? Yes, cuz God tells me so, and I believe Him cuz He knows.
(HOW DI HE TELL YOU AGAIN. I THOUGHT YOU READ THIS IN ONE OF THE MANY VERSIONS AND TRANSLITTERATIONS OF THE BIBILE. PLEASE LET ME KNOW WHICH VERSION (KJV, NIV, LIVING BIBILE)
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | Apr 13, 2009 3:52:48 PM
==What is you definition of love?==
My definition of “love,” in my unrighteous self, conforms to the world’s definition which changes from second to second and person to person; one never knows what it is in the world. The world’s definition, thankfully, is not God’s definition, though.
(WHAT IS YOUR DEFINITION OF LOVE AGAIN? HOW DID YOU GET IT? PLEASE REFERENCE IT FOR ME AND THE REST OF THE WORLD)
However, in my Righteous self — thanks to Christ! — the definition follows the biblical example: Unselfish concern for the Salvation of others. Thus, I follow His example.
(DID YOU SHARE THIS UNSELFISH CONCERN WITH EVERYONE IN YOUR PATH TODAY)? AT WORK ON THE STREET? WITH EVERY FAMILY AND FRIEND?)
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | Apr 13, 2009 3:56:53 PM
==Where head goes, the body goes.==
As we learn in sport, the head fake has left many a player in the dust.
(UM YOU ARE STILL MISTAKEN WITH MY EXAMPLEWHEN SONE GRABS YOUR HEAD THE BODY FOLLOWS)
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | Apr 13, 2009 3:58:18 PM
==“Do unto others as you would have them do unto you” is the golden rule correct?==
How are we to do unto others, biblically? Preach and teach the Word of Salvation! I give them what they need for eternity cuz I want them to give me what I need for eternity. THAT is the love of God!
IT SAYS DO UNTO OTHERS AND YOU WOULD HAVE THEM DO UNTO YOU. I LOOKED and you have added “”"”Preach and teach the Word of Salvation! I give them what they need for eternity cuz I want them to give me what I need for eternity. THAT is the love of God!”"”"that to that verse. I’m sorry that your intertpretation and adding to the words written in the bibile. insnt there a verse that talks about that and you are DOING THAT! Mr. INCREDIBLE
== The “golden rule can apply to each and every circumstance and situation.==
Depends. In the worldly sense, one who holds the Truth in unrighteousness can apply it to mean that he wants another to “do” to him what he wants to “do” to another.
THERE IS NO DEPENDS THE GOLEN RULE APPLIES OR IT DOESN’T. YOU ARE ADDING YOUR OWN WORDS TO THE BIBILE AGAIN!
The Righteous definition of the “rule” is something else again.
== Can the Holy Sprit give unique advice in those unique situations? ==
Whatever advice He gives must adhere to and align with the Word of God, and, since those who are born again must all be on the same page and have the same Message, the Holy Spirit cannot tell you one thing and me another, regarding the same issue.
(NOW YOU ARE TELLING THE HOLY SPIRIT WHAT IT CAN AND CANNOT DO!!!!WOW YOU REALLY HAVE GONE TOO FAR WITH THAT ITS SUPPOSED TO BE FATHER SON AND HOLY SPIRIT NOT FATHER SON HOLY SPIRIT AND MR INCREDIBLE. YOU GONE TOO FAR WITH YOUR PRIVATE INTEPRETATION.
==The “Holy Spirit” can give advice depending on the context of the situation. ==
However, if we are in the same situation, His advice must be the same in the Word of God cuz He cannot and will not change, even from one person to the next, even from one second to the next.
(NOW YOU ARE TELLING THE HOLY SPIRIT WHAT IT CAN AND CANNOT DO!!!!WOW YOU REALLY HAVE GONE TOO FAR WITH THAT ITS SUPPOSED TO BE FATHER SON AND HOLY SPIRIT NOT FATHER SON HOLY SPIRIT AND MR INCREDIBLE. YOU GONE TOO FAR WITH YOUR PRIVATE INTEPRETATION.
==So a good way to tell if you are following the more spiritual path…==
Is there a “path” other than Christ???
WHAT DOES THAT MEAN? THRRE ARE THOUSANDS OF DENIOMONATIONS THAT ARGUE OVER WHAT THAT LOOKS LIKE. WHAT IS YOUR DENOMINATION MR INCREDIBLE?
==… is to be mindful in situations and apply the golden rule based on the definition of love above.==
Oh, you mean, like, your worldly definition.
I USED THE BIBILE UNLIKE YOU ADDING WORDS AND PRIVATE INTERPRETATION D TELLING THE HOLY SPIRIT WHAT IT CAN AND CANNOT DO.
==… being more aware of our own thinking…==
Rather than God’s??
(OKAY SO NOW YOU CAN READ GOD MIND> YOU ARE POWERFUL)
==… and external circumstances and applying this spiritual love.==
Your definition again.
(I USED A REFERENCE FROM THE BIBLE YOU REFER TO SO MUCH)
== Since our beliefs affect our thoughts, our thoughts affect your emotions, and our emotions affect our behavior.==
Not true.
Our words make up our thoughts and our thoughts make up our beliefs. Except that the born again individual incorporates God’s Thoughts, and God says Satan exists. I believe Him cuz God cannot lie AND I am persuaded by His performance of His Promise. He has proved by performance, by work. His work is a work of love, faith, Grace and Truth.
(OBVIOUSLY IN ORDER TO SPEAK WE HAVE TO THINK IT FIRST SO YOU MISTAKEN IN YOUR ORDER. LOL ALL THE ABOVE IS YOUR PERSONAL INTERPRETATION ONCE AGAIN.
== And its our behavior that is the end result of “missing the mark” in relation to the definition of love above.==
The worldly definition.
(SO WHAT IS THE BIBLES DEFINITION OF MISSION THE MARK? YOU HAVE GIVEN US NOTHING BUT YOUR OWN INTEPRATIONS, KNOWING GODS THOUGHTS, TELLING THE HOLY SPIIRT WHAT IT CAN AND CANNOT DO And EVEN KNOWING WHAT IN MY CONSCIOUSNESS. YOU ARE SOME KIND OF SUPER BEING???
== So we will in essence create a natural spiritual defense…==
Based on the worldly definition of “love.”
==… against negative (non loving) personal thinking, other human , social, cultural, political, and religious influences.==
Nice way to talk yourself into jusitfying anything you want, like believing that Satan doesn’t exist.
(I DONT HAVE TO TALK MYSEF INTO ANYTHING. ONCE AGAIN YOU THINK YOU KNOW AND YOU ASSUME THINGS IN MY HEAD. YOU KNOW HAT HAPPENS WHEN YOU ASSUME MR INCREDIBLE? :)
== Now if our “Spiritual Star Trek shields or “helmet” are up then the extra outside being Satan cannot break through the “helmet” and affect our thoughts?==
What are those “shields”? What is that “helmet”?
THE HELMET OF SALVATION have you read that onein YOUR BIBILE??? :)
== If the being Satan can’t do that then belief that he is exists is not necessarily needed…==
God says that Satan exists and attacks all the time, just as he is trying to do here; but the prince of this world has nothing in me.
(I WANT YOU TO SHOW ME WHERE THE BIBILE SAYS THAT. YOUR PRIVATE INTERPRETATION IS RUNNING RAMPANT TONIGHT.
==… because we already have the natural Spiritual defense up. Correct?==
No. The unrighteous have no such defense against the Devil.
(HOW DO YOU KNOW THAT THERE IS A DEVIL AND HOW DO YOU KNOW WHO IS UNRIGHTEOUS. PLEASE PROVIDE ANOTHER SCRIPTURE. YOUR PRIVATE INTERPRETATION IS RUNNING RAMPANT AGAIN!
GOD BLESS YOU MR. INCREDIBLE
Posted by: shaye | April 13, 2009, 8:16 pm 8:16 pm
MY COMMENTS WILL BE IN ( )
==/== Faith wihout deeds is dead.==
“What kinda deeds?”
Loving deeds
“Define ‘love.’”
‘Love is patient, love is kind. It does not envy, it does not boast, it is not proud. It is not rude, it is not self-seeking, it is not easily angered, it keeps no record of wrongs. Love does not delight in evil but rejoices with the truth. It always protects, always trusts, always hopes, always preserves.’
– 1 Corinthians 13:4-==
You tell us what “love” does, not what it is, biblical.
( WELL SINCE WE ARE HUMAN WE LIKE TO HAVE HUMAN EXAMPLES. WHAT IS YOUR DEFINITION OF LOVE MR INCREDIBLE)?
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | Apr 13, 2009 3:43:19 PM
==Its [sic] simple like in Marital arts. Where head goes, the body goes.==
In martial arts, basketball, football and hockey, you don’t lookit the head, rather the chest area cuz the direction of the chest is where the body is going.
(OK OBVIOUSLY IM TALKING ABOUT GRABBING THE HEAD NOT STARING AT IT. YOU ARE MISTAKEN AGAIN LOL)
== Keep your head focused on love(Love is patient, love is kind, do unto others, etc)…==
YOu say what “love” does, not what it is, biblically.
(WHAT IS YOUR INTERPRETATION OF WHAT YOU READ IN THE BIBLE AND ITS DEFINITION & WHICH VERSION)
The way YOU describe it, “love” can be a worldly love, and worldly “love” ain’t what Christ is all about.
I USED IT RIGHT FROM THE BIBLE. I’M SURE YOU HAVE HEARD OF IT) LOL
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | Apr 13, 2009 3:49:00 PM
==I am not arrogant to say he exists or doesn’t exist.==
It’s not arrogant to believe God when He says the Devil — Satan — exists. Unless, of course, you say that God is arrogant.
ONCE AGAIN WE ALL KNOW THAT GOD READY DIDN’T SAY THIS TO YOU LIKE GEORGE BURNS DID IN OH GOD. YOU READ WORDS AND BELIEVED THEM FROM THE BIBLE. DO YOU EVER QUESTION ANYTHING YOU READ SO WHY IS THE BIBLE SPECIAL? BECAUSE IT SAID IT WAS “GOD BREATHED” LOL YOUR CIRCULAR REASONING AND YOUR HEAD IS SPINNING LOL YOU SHOW YOUR ARRNGANCE BY SPEAKING ABOUT THINGS YOU “KNOW” NOTHING ABOUT.
== I have not experienced this being…==
Yes, you have. You’re just not conscious of it. That you are unconscious doesn’t mean that he doesn’t exist.
(HOW DO YOU KNOW WHAT I HAVE EXPERIENCED? I HAVE NOT COMMUNICATE ALL OF MY LIFE EXPERIENCE. HAVE YOU BEEN IN MY MIND BODY AND SPIRIT. I HOPE NOT. I WOULD HAVE TO CALL 911) LOL SO PLEASE REFRAIN FROM SAYING I AM NOT CONSCIOUS OF IT. ONCE AGAIN TALKING ABOUT THINGS YOU DO NOT KNOW –THANK YOU)
==… and it will take more than ink from me to know 100%.==
God tells you 100% sure. You choose not to believe Him.
(IF GOD COMES AND TELLS ME PERSONALLY I WILL TAKE IT INTO CONSIDERATION. I WOULD NOT TAKE IT FROM YOU BECAUSE YOU ARE NOT GOOD WITNESS FOR THAT KIND OF MESSAGE THAT IS MY EXPERIENCE):)
Can I know that Man’s heart is wicked? Yes, cuz God tells me so, and I believe Him cuz He knows.
(HOW DI HE TELL YOU AGAIN. I THOUGHT YOU READ THIS IN ONE OF THE MANY VERSIONS AND TRANSLITTERATIONS OF THE BIBILE. PLEASE LET ME KNOW WHICH VERSION (KJV, NIV, LIVING BIBILE)
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | Apr 13, 2009 3:52:48 PM
==What is you definition of love?==
My definition of “love,” in my unrighteous self, conforms to the world’s definition which changes from second to second and person to person; one never knows what it is in the world. The world’s definition, thankfully, is not God’s definition, though.
(WHAT IS YOUR DEFINITION OF LOVE AGAIN? HOW DID YOU GET IT? PLEASE REFERENCE IT FOR ME AND THE REST OF THE WORLD)
However, in my Righteous self — thanks to Christ! — the definition follows the biblical example: Unselfish concern for the Salvation of others. Thus, I follow His example.
(DID YOU SHARE THIS UNSELFISH CONCERN WITH EVERYONE IN YOUR PATH TODAY)? AT WORK ON THE STREET? WITH EVERY FAMILY AND FRIEND?)
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | Apr 13, 2009 3:56:53 PM
==Where head goes, the body goes.==
As we learn in sport, the head fake has left many a player in the dust.
(UM YOU ARE STILL MISTAKEN WITH MY EXAMPLEWHEN SONE GRABS YOUR HEAD THE BODY FOLLOWS)
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | Apr 13, 2009 3:58:18 PM
==“Do unto others as you would have them do unto you” is the golden rule correct?==
How are we to do unto others, biblically? Preach and teach the Word of Salvation! I give them what they need for eternity cuz I want them to give me what I need for eternity. THAT is the love of God!
IT SAYS DO UNTO OTHERS AND YOU WOULD HAVE THEM DO UNTO YOU. I LOOKED and you have added “”"”Preach and teach the Word of Salvation! I give them what they need for eternity cuz I want them to give me what I need for eternity. THAT is the love of God!”"”"that to that verse. I’m sorry that your intertpretation and adding to the words written in the bibile. insnt there a verse that talks about that and you are DOING THAT! Mr. INCREDIBLE
== The “golden rule can apply to each and every circumstance and situation.==
Depends. In the worldly sense, one who holds the Truth in unrighteousness can apply it to mean that he wants another to “do” to him what he wants to “do” to another.
THERE IS NO DEPENDS THE GOLEN RULE APPLIES OR IT DOESN’T. YOU ARE ADDING YOUR OWN WORDS TO THE BIBILE AGAIN!
The Righteous definition of the “rule” is something else again.
== Can the Holy Sprit give unique advice in those unique situations? ==
Whatever advice He gives must adhere to and align with the Word of God, and, since those who are born again must all be on the same page and have the same Message, the Holy Spirit cannot tell you one thing and me another, regarding the same issue.
(NOW YOU ARE TELLING THE HOLY SPIRIT WHAT IT CAN AND CANNOT DO!!!!WOW YOU REALLY HAVE GONE TOO FAR WITH THAT ITS SUPPOSED TO BE FATHER SON AND HOLY SPIRIT NOT FATHER SON HOLY SPIRIT AND MR INCREDIBLE. YOU GONE TOO FAR WITH YOUR PRIVATE INTEPRETATION.
==The “Holy Spirit” can give advice depending on the context of the situation. ==
However, if we are in the same situation, His advice must be the same in the Word of God cuz He cannot and will not change, even from one person to the next, even from one second to the next.
(NOW YOU ARE TELLING THE HOLY SPIRIT WHAT IT CAN AND CANNOT DO!!!!WOW YOU REALLY HAVE GONE TOO FAR WITH THAT ITS SUPPOSED TO BE FATHER SON AND HOLY SPIRIT NOT FATHER SON HOLY SPIRIT AND MR INCREDIBLE. YOU GONE TOO FAR WITH YOUR PRIVATE INTEPRETATION.
==So a good way to tell if you are following the more spiritual path…==
Is there a “path” other than Christ???
WHAT DOES THAT MEAN? THRRE ARE THOUSANDS OF DENIOMONATIONS THAT ARGUE OVER WHAT THAT LOOKS LIKE. WHAT IS YOUR DENOMINATION MR INCREDIBLE?
==… is to be mindful in situations and apply the golden rule based on the definition of love above.==
Oh, you mean, like, your worldly definition.
I USED THE BIBILE UNLIKE YOU ADDING WORDS AND PRIVATE INTERPRETATION D TELLING THE HOLY SPIRIT WHAT IT CAN AND CANNOT DO.
==… being more aware of our own thinking…==
Rather than God’s??
(OKAY SO NOW YOU CAN READ GOD MIND> YOU ARE POWERFUL)
==… and external circumstances and applying this spiritual love.==
Your definition again.
(I USED A REFERENCE FROM THE BIBLE YOU REFER TO SO MUCH)
== Since our beliefs affect our thoughts, our thoughts affect your emotions, and our emotions affect our behavior.==
Not true.
Our words make up our thoughts and our thoughts make up our beliefs. Except that the born again individual incorporates God’s Thoughts, and God says Satan exists. I believe Him cuz God cannot lie AND I am persuaded by His performance of His Promise. He has proved by performance, by work. His work is a work of love, faith, Grace and Truth.
(OBVIOUSLY IN ORDER TO SPEAK WE HAVE TO THINK IT FIRST SO YOU MISTAKEN IN YOUR ORDER. LOL ALL THE ABOVE IS YOUR PERSONAL INTERPRETATION ONCE AGAIN.
== And its our behavior that is the end result of “missing the mark” in relation to the definition of love above.==
The worldly definition.
(SO WHAT IS THE BIBLES DEFINITION OF MISSION THE MARK? YOU HAVE GIVEN US NOTHING BUT YOUR OWN INTEPRATIONS, KNOWING GODS THOUGHTS, TELLING THE HOLY SPIIRT WHAT IT CAN AND CANNOT DO And EVEN KNOWING WHAT IN MY CONSCIOUSNESS. YOU ARE SOME KIND OF SUPER BEING???
== So we will in essence create a natural spiritual defense…==
Based on the worldly definition of “love.”
==… against negative (non loving) personal thinking, other human , social, cultural, political, and religious influences.==
Nice way to talk yourself into jusitfying anything you want, like believing that Satan doesn’t exist.
(I DONT HAVE TO TALK MYSEF INTO ANYTHING. ONCE AGAIN YOU THINK YOU KNOW AND YOU ASSUME THINGS IN MY HEAD. YOU KNOW HAT HAPPENS WHEN YOU ASSUME MR INCREDIBLE? :)
== Now if our “Spiritual Star Trek shields or “helmet” are up then the extra outside being Satan cannot break through the “helmet” and affect our thoughts?==
What are those “shields”? What is that “helmet”?
THE HELMET OF SALVATION have you read that onein YOUR BIBILE??? :)
== If the being Satan can’t do that then belief that he is exists is not necessarily needed…==
God says that Satan exists and attacks all the time, just as he is trying to do here; but the prince of this world has nothing in me.
(I WANT YOU TO SHOW ME WHERE THE BIBILE SAYS THAT. YOUR PRIVATE INTERPRETATION IS RUNNING RAMPANT TONIGHT.
==… because we already have the natural Spiritual defense up. Correct?==
No. The unrighteous have no such defense against the Devil.
(HOW DO YOU KNOW THAT THERE IS A DEVIL AND HOW DO YOU KNOW WHO IS UNRIGHTEOUS. PLEASE PROVIDE ANOTHER SCRIPTURE. YOUR PRIVATE INTERPRETATION IS RUNNING RAMPANT AGAIN!
GOD BLESS YOU MR. INCREDIBLE
Posted by: shaye | April 13, 2009, 8:16 pm 8:16 pm
I just want to say I’m not yelling in caps. I am just separating our dialogue. My tone is very conversational and not confrontational. I am making points with emphasis. I really having these discuassion with you. I find it very good to debate our positions. God bless your brother.
Posted by: shaye | April 14, 2009, 2:38 am 2:38 am
What doe righteous mean? I am already saved then I am righteous and I have a defense against this Satan according to the bible an interpretation you provide. So I have nothing to worry about. Now there are other who aren’t “saved” and I believe they have a defense against this “Satan” as well. :)
Posted by: shaye | April 14, 2009, 8:32 am 8:32 am
Mr. Incredible you should really be concerned about your own personal relationship with God and not talking about things you only read and believe and do not know. God is bigger than your Bible and your interpretation of it. If you believe those are his words which are really the words of man that could only possibly be inspired by God and can’t be proven and is not perfect. Stop worshiping a book(The Bible) which the term is called Bibidolatry. An all powerful God doesn’t need your belief in the words for him to exist. Belive in God and stop this bibidolatry.
Posted by: shaye | April 14, 2009, 8:40 am 8:40 am
Mr. Incredible I will reference the definiltion from Wikipedia.
Bibliolatry (from the Greek biblion “book” + latria “worship”) is the worship of a particular book.
In the case of Christianity, the term bibliolatry is used in a derogatory sense toward those who either have an extreme devotion to the Bible, or hold to a high view of biblical inerrancy [1]. However Historic Christianity has never endorsed worship of the Bible itself, as worship is explicitly reserved only for God Himself. The groups to whom the term is most often applied are Protestants of a fundamentalist and evangelical background who hold to Biblical inerrancy and Scripture as the only divine authority. So most of those who level the charge either reject Biblical inerrancy (such as Liberal Christians) or uphold divine authority that includes Apostolic Tradition in concert with Scripture rather than Scripture alone (Catholic Christians).
Posted by: Shaye | April 14, 2009, 11:49 am 11:49 am
Mr. incredible:So well From our earlier conversations you admit that the Bible is only 90% accurate. So your extreme devotion to the Bible is to really just 90% of it? so Are you are you in agreement with the Protestant Evangelicals, the Liberal Christians(Seems you are closer to them based on what you have written) or the Catholic Chriatians? Also which denomination is correct?
Posted by: Shaye | April 14, 2009, 11:54 am 11:54 am
I can neither confrim nor deny that Satan exists. All beliefs are your your choice and I honor that. Thanks! Shaye
Posted by: Shaye | April 14, 2009, 11:57 am 11:57 am
Oh and if the bibile has errors. Who is to say that they got the Satan translitteration incorrect? just beacuse you ass a sentence from a later book added to the collection of books of the bibile that says “All scripure it God breathed” dent correct all the errors. Mr. Incredible what if that part of the Bible that mentions “Satan” is in cluded in you 10% that is not accurate accrding to you and many others?
Posted by: Shaye | April 14, 2009, 12:00 pm 12:00 pm
I should really spell check. I write type too fast. :)
Oh and if the “Bible” has errors. Who is to say that the translators and Catholic meetings got the Satan translitteration correct?Just because you add a sentence from a later written book and added to the collection of books at the Council of Nicea that says “All scripure it God breathed” doesnt correct all the errors. Mr. Incredible what if that part of the Bible that mentions “Satan” is in cluded in you 10% that say is not accurate according to you and many others?
Posted by: Shaye | April 14, 2009, 12:05 pm 12:05 pm
==WHAT IS YOUR DEFINITION OF LOVE MR INCREDIBLE)?==
God is not concerned with MY definition. MY definition would be an unrighteous definition. A worldly definition.
However, taking the line of scriptural thought, “love,” biblically, is unselfish concern for the Salvation of others, as much concern for others’ Salvation as one has for his own.
So, then, the ultimate expression of biblical “love” is to do what God did — that is, send the Word of God into the world.
==Posted by: Mr. Incredible | Apr 13, 2009 3:43:19 PM
==Its [sic] simple like in Marital arts. Where head goes, the body goes.==
In martial arts, basketball, football and hockey, you don’t lookit the head, rather the chest area cuz the direction of the chest is where the body is going.
(OK OBVIOUSLY IM TALKING ABOUT GRABBING THE HEAD NOT STARING AT IT. YOU ARE MISTAKEN AGAIN LOL)==
No, obviously I’m not.
==/== Keep your head focused on love(Love is patient, love is kind, do unto others, etc)…==
YOu say what “love” does, not what it is, biblically.
(WHAT IS YOUR INTERPRETATION OF WHAT YOU READ IN THE BIBLE AND ITS DEFINITION & WHICH VERSION)==
Irrelevant. The line of scriptural thought, in the most accurate version we have, shows that the love of God is the Word of God.
==The way YOU describe it, “love” can be a worldly love, and worldly “love” ain’t what Christ is all about.
I USED IT RIGHT FROM THE BIBLE.==
No, you didn’t. The definition of “love” is not in the Word of God. You picked out a part of the Word of God that describes what biblical love does, not what it is.
==Posted by: Mr. Incredible | Apr 13, 2009 3:49:00 PM
==I am not arrogant to say he exists or doesn’t exist.==
It’s not arrogant to believe God when He says the Devil — Satan — exists. Unless, of course, you say that God is arrogant.
ONCE AGAIN WE ALL KNOW THAT GOD READY DIDN’T SAY THIS…==
Once again, we all know that God really did say that. Not only does He say that Satan exists, He talks to Satan.
==YOU READ WORDS AND BELIEVED THEM FROM THE BIBLE.==
That’s cuz I trust God.
== DO YOU EVER QUESTION ANYTHING YOU READ…==
I question what men, of their own power, write.
== SO WHY IS THE BIBLE SPECIAL?==
Cuz He is the Word of God.
==… BECAUSE IT SAID IT WAS “GOD BREATHED” ==
No, cuz He IS God-breathed.
==YOUR CIRCULAR REASONING AND YOUR HEAD IS SPINNING ==
It’s circular reasoning to you because YOUR head is spinning. My head spins around God.
==YOU SHOW YOUR ARRNGANCE BY SPEAKING ABOUT THINGS YOU “KNOW” NOTHING ABOUT.==
According to the world, that’s true. It’s not true, according to God. I’ll go with Him.
==/== I have not experienced this being…==
Yes, you have. You’re just not conscious of it. That you are unconscious doesn’t mean that he doesn’t exist.
(HOW DO YOU KNOW WHAT I HAVE EXPERIENCED?==
Cuz Satan touches everyone who is not protected by the Word of God. Those who are not protected and who deny that Satan exists, are most vulnerable to him. No resistance.
== I HAVE NOT COMMUNICATE ALL OF MY LIFE EXPERIENCE.==
Irrelevant.
== HAVE YOU BEEN IN MY MIND BODY AND SPIRIT.==
Irrelevant.
==… PLEASE REFRAIN FROM SAYING I AM NOT CONSCIOUS OF IT. ==
The truth is that you are not conscious of the effect of Satan on you. That’s clear from what you write.
==ONCE AGAIN TALKING ABOUT THINGS YOU DO NOT KNOW…==
According to the world, yes. Not according to God, though.
==/ ==… and it will take more than ink from me to know 100%.==
God tells you 100% sure. You choose not to believe Him.
(IF GOD COMES AND TELLS ME PERSONALLY I WILL TAKE IT INTO CONSIDERATION.==
And, still, you wouldn’t believe it.
In any case, He already did tell you. You reject it. You turn your back on Him. And YOU expect Him to come to you and reiterate what He has already said???
== I WOULD NOT TAKE IT FROM YOU BECAUSE YOU ARE NOT GOOD WITNESS FOR THAT KIND OF MESSAGE THAT IS MY EXPERIENCE):)==
God tells us what is in men’s hearts. He says it is wickedness. I believe Him. Therefore, I know.
==Can I know that Man’s heart is wicked? Yes, cuz God tells me so, and I believe Him cuz He knows.
(HOW DI HE TELL YOU AGAIN.==
Through His Word, just as He promised.
== I THOUGHT YOU READ THIS IN ONE OF THE MANY VERSIONS AND TRANSLITTERATIONS OF THE BIBILE. PLEASE LET ME KNOW WHICH VERSION (KJV, NIV, LIVING BIBILE)==
The King James Version Which compares favorably with over 5600 manuscripts we have. The King James Version is the Word of God preserved in English.
==Posted by: Mr. Incredible | Apr 13, 2009 3:52:48 PM
==What is you definition of love?==
My definition of “love,” in my unrighteous self, conforms to the world’s definition which changes from second to second and person to person; one never knows what it is in the world. The world’s definition, thankfully, is not God’s definition, though.
(WHAT IS YOUR DEFINITION OF LOVE AGAIN?==
I already told you above.
== HOW DID YOU GET IT? PLEASE REFERENCE IT FOR ME AND THE REST OF THE WORLD)==
The line of scriptural thought.
==However, in my Righteous self — thanks to Christ! — the definition follows the biblical example: Unselfish concern for the Salvation of others. Thus, I follow His example.
(DID YOU SHARE THIS UNSELFISH CONCERN WITH EVERYONE IN YOUR PATH TODAY)? AT WORK ON THE STREET? WITH EVERY FAMILY AND FRIEND?) ==
The Word of God says that we must do this, as we have occasion. I try to make sure every day that I have the occasion. I go out of my way to manipulate conversations, as a matter of fact.
==Posted by: Mr. Incredible | Apr 13, 2009 3:56:53 PM
==Where head goes, the body goes.==
As we learn in sport, the head fake has left many a player in the dust.
(UM YOU ARE STILL MISTAKEN WITH MY EXAMPLEWHEN SONE GRABS YOUR HEAD THE BODY FOLLOWS)==
No, I’m not mistaken. He said nothing about grabbing.
==Posted by: Mr. Incredible | Apr 13, 2009 3:58:18 PM
==“Do unto others as you would have them do unto you” is the golden rule correct?==
How are we to do unto others, biblically? Preach and teach the Word of Salvation! I give them what they need for eternity cuz I want them to give me what I need for eternity. THAT is the love of God!
IT SAYS DO UNTO OTHERS AND YOU WOULD HAVE THEM DO UNTO YOU.==
He means what I say He means. What I say He means conforms to the line of scriptural thought.
==I LOOKED and you have added “”"”Preach and teach the Word of Salvation! I give them what they need for eternity cuz I want them to give me what I need for eternity. THAT is the love of God!”"”"that to that verse.==
I add nothing. What I said conforms to the line of scriptural thought.
== I’m sorry that your intertpretation and adding to the words written in the bibile.==
I add nothing. What I said conforms to the line of scriptural thought.
== insnt there a verse that talks about that and you are DOING THAT!==
No, I’m not.
==/== The “golden rule can apply to each and every circumstance and situation.==
Depends. In the worldly sense, one who holds the Truth in unrighteousness can apply it to mean that he wants another to “do” to him what he wants to “do” to another.
THERE IS NO DEPENDS THE GOLEN RULE APPLIES OR IT DOESN’T.==
Yes, there is a “depends.” You don’t distinguish between unrighteous and Righteous situations.
I am to give others the Word of God because I would have them give me the Word of God.
== YOU ARE ADDING YOUR OWN WORDS TO THE BIBILE AGAIN!==
Then, by your own standard, YOU must be adding to the Word of God, too.
==/== Can the Holy Sprit give unique advice in those unique situations? ==
Whatever advice He gives must adhere to and align with the Word of God, and, since those who are born again must all be on the same page and have the same Message, the Holy Spirit cannot tell you one thing and me another, regarding the same issue.
(NOW YOU ARE TELLING THE HOLY SPIRIT WHAT IT CAN AND CANNOT DO!!!!==
No, I’m recognizing what the Holy Spirit can do and reporting it to you. You don’t believe the report. That’s too bad.
== However, YOU GONE TOO FAR WITH YOUR PRIVATE INTEPRETATION.==
I don’t subscribe to private interpretation. I go with Holy Spirit interpretation, and the Holy Spirit can’t be telling you one thing and me another. All interpretation must align with the Word of God. Otherwise, it is not a Godly interpretation.
==/==So a good way to tell if you are following the more spiritual path…==
Is there a “path” other than Christ???
WHAT DOES THAT MEAN?==
You don’t KNOW??
==THRRE ARE THOUSANDS OF DENIOMONATIONS…==
The Devil is pleased.
==… THAT ARGUE OVER WHAT THAT LOOKS LIKE. ==
The Devil is pleased with all the arguing.
== WHAT IS YOUR DENOMINATION MR INCREDIBLE?==
I am born again. That’s all that’s necessary.
==/==… is to be mindful in situations and apply the golden rule based on the definition of love above.==
Oh, you mean, like, your worldly definition.
I USED THE BIBILE …==
To try to defeat the Word of God, yes.
== UNLIKE YOU ADDING WORDS…==
I added nothing.
==… AND PRIVATE INTERPRETATION…==
I don’t privately interpret the Word of God. I let the Holy Spirit do the interpreting.
==… D TELLING THE HOLY SPIRIT WHAT IT CAN AND CANNOT DO. ==
I only report what the Holy Spirit does. You don’t receive it. So what? That you don’t receive it does not impact my Salvation.
==/==… being more aware of our own thinking…==
Rather than God’s??
(OKAY SO NOW YOU CAN READ GOD MIND> YOU ARE POWERFUL)==
The Word of God says that God declared to Man His thoughts. Got also said that His people are destroyed for lack of knowledge. So, then, how can He threaten us with His wrath and eternal damnation if we can’t know what He says we must know??? It looks as though you haven’t thought this all the way through.
==/==… and external circumstances and applying this spiritual love.==
Your definition again.
(I USED A REFERENCE FROM THE BIBLE YOU REFER TO SO MUCH)==
You used a verse that describes what love does, not what it is, biblically.
==/== Since our beliefs affect our thoughts, our thoughts affect your emotions, and our emotions affect our behavior.==
Not true.
Our words make up our thoughts and our thoughts make up our beliefs. Except that the born again individual incorporates God’s Thoughts, and God says Satan exists. I believe Him cuz God cannot lie AND I am persuaded by His performance of His Promise. He has proved by performance, by work. His work is a work of love, faith, Grace and Truth.
(OBVIOUSLY IN ORDER TO SPEAK WE HAVE TO THINK IT FIRST==
We think in words. The word comes first.
== SO YOU MISTAKEN IN YOUR ORDER.==
No, I’m not.
==ALL THE ABOVE IS YOUR PERSONAL INTERPRETATION ONCE AGAIN.==
No, it isn’t. It’s Holy Spirit interpretation. It’s just that you don’t receive it. That’s your choice. That you don’t receive it doesn’t impact my Salvation.
==/== And its our behavior that is the end result of “missing the mark” in relation to the definition of love above.==
The worldly definition.
(SO WHAT IS THE BIBLES DEFINITION OF MISSION THE MARK?==
Not staying on course with God.
== YOU HAVE GIVEN US NOTHING BUT YOUR OWN INTEPRATIONS… Q1
I’ve given Holy Spirit interpretation, not my own interpretation.
==… KNOWING GODS THOUGHTS…==
He tells us through His Word. If He didn’t tell us, how could He hold us responsible for knowing what He didn’t tell us???
==… TELLING THE HOLY SPIIRT WHAT IT CAN AND CANNOT DO…==
I never did that. I merely reported what the Word of God says the Holy Spirit can do. You don’t receive it. Just cuz you don’t receive it doesn’t impact my Salvation.
==… And EVEN KNOWING WHAT IN MY CONSCIOUSNESS. ==
If you write things that try to defeat the Word of God, that, in itself, tips me off. It should tipoff anyone who is born again.
==YOU ARE SOME KIND OF SUPER BEING??? ==
God makes me super in Christ! HALLELUJAH!
==/== So we will in essence create a natural spiritual defense…==
Based on the worldly definition of “love.”
==… against negative (non loving) personal thinking, other human , social, cultural, political, and religious influences.==
Nice way to talk yourself into jusitfying anything you want, like believing that Satan doesn’t exist.
(I DONT HAVE TO TALK MYSEF INTO ANYTHING.==
And, yet, you have, and you don’t even know it!
== ONCE AGAIN YOU THINK YOU KNOW…==
I can compare what you write with the Word of God, and I can see that the two of you are at opposite ends of the spectrum.
==… AND YOU ASSUME THINGS IN MY HEAD. ==
So, the things you write are not in your head???
== YOU KNOW HAT HAPPENS WHEN YOU ASSUME MR INCREDIBLE? :)==
I know what happens when I assume, and that’s why I am not assuming.
==/== Now if our “Spiritual Star Trek shields or “helmet” are up then the extra outside being Satan cannot break through the “helmet” and affect our thoughts?==
What are those “shields”? What is that “helmet”?
THE HELMET OF SALVATION have you read that onein YOUR BIBILE??? :)==
However, unless you wear that helmet, Satan can get through. Wearing the helmet means declaring the Word of God in speech.
==/== If the being Satan can’t do that then belief that he is exists is not necessarily needed…==
God says that Satan exists and attacks all the time, just as he is trying to do here; but the prince of this world has nothing in me.
(I WANT YOU TO SHOW ME WHERE THE BIBILE SAYS THAT. ==
You don’t know???
(1Pe 5:8) Be sober, be vigilant; because your adversary the devil, as a roaring lion, walketh about, seeking whom he may devour:
(Joh 14:30) …the prince of this world cometh, and hath nothing in me.
== YOUR PRIVATE INTERPRETATION IS RUNNING RAMPANT TONIGHT.==
I not engaged in private interpretation rather Holy Spirit interpretation.
==/==… because we already have the natural Spiritual defense up. Correct?==
No. The unrighteous have no such defense against the Devil.
(HOW DO YOU KNOW THAT THERE IS A DEVIL…==
First, God says so. I trust Him.
Second, I have experienced the attacks that God has said would come. Of course, I do what Jesus did in the wilderness [Matthew 4:1-11] — that is, I give it to God, I resist the Devil and the Devil flees [James 4:7]. No problem.
== AND HOW DO YOU KNOW WHO IS UNRIGHTEOUS. ==
I compare what they say and do with what the word of God says. If they don’t align, the Word of God, of course, is Righteous, and they aren’t.
== PLEASE PROVIDE ANOTHER SCRIPTURE.==
I’m not going to republish the Word of God here. It’s available for you to find.
== YOUR PRIVATE INTERPRETATION IS RUNNING RAMPANT AGAIN!==
The Devil says that to me all the time. Just remember Romans 8:1 KJV
==What doe righteous mean?==
It’s a gift of faith.
== I am already saved then==
Not necessarily. The Word of God says that you must CONTINUE in the faith.
== I am righteous…==
Not unless you CONTINUE in the faith. That means doing what Christ tells you to do.
==… and I have a defense against this Satan according to the bible an interpretation you provide.==
We’ll see on Judgment Day, won’t we.
== So I have nothing to worry about. ==
If you think you have nothing to worry about, feel free not to make your election sure.
== Now there are other who aren’t “saved” and I believe they have a defense against this “Satan” as well. :)==
Not scriptural. Remember Romans 1:18 KJV.
==… you should really be concerned about your own personal relationship with God… Q1
I can be concerned with mine and yours and everybody else’s. I can multitask, thanks to God, through Christ.
==… and not talking about things you only read and believe and do not know.==
God tells us to read and believe and know. That’s cuz He told us.
== God is bigger than your Bible…==
Moses: “He revealed his Word to my mind, and the Word was God.” — from the film, “The Ten Commandments”
==… and your interpretation of it.==
My interpretation, based on Holy Spirit interpretation, is correct.
== If you believe those are his words which are really the words of man…==
If you believe that, you wind saved. You have backslidden. You have not continued in the faith.
==… that could only possibly be inspired by God and can’t be proven and is not perfect.==
What the Word of God reports is 100% accurate.
== Stop worshiping a book…==
The physical book is the shadow of the Real Thing. The physical book tells us what the Real Thing is. I don’t worship the physical book. I worship the Real Thing.
==… which the term is called Bibidolatry. ==
Absurd.
== An all powerful God doesn’t need your belief in the words for him to exist.==
(Hos 4:6) My people are destroyed for lack of knowledge…
(Rom 10:17) So then faith cometh by hearing, and hearing by the word of God.
(Heb 4:2) For unto us was the gospel preached, as well as unto them: but the word preached did not profit them, not being mixed with faith in them that heard it.
So, yes, He needs for us to know, to understand and to comprehend His Word:
(Joh 8:32) And ye shall know the truth, and the truth shall make you free.
(Joh 1:17) For the law was given by Moses, but grace and truth came by Jesus Christ.
== Belive in God…==
I believe in God, through Christ.
==… and stop this bibidolatry.==
I don’t worship the physical book. I read the Word of God so that I can understand what God tells me.
==Mr. Incredible I will reference the definiltion from Wikipedia.==
Corrupt on its face. Written by men, not by God.
==… So well From our earlier conversations you admit that the Bible is only 90% accurate.==
No, I didn’t.
== So your extreme devotion to the Bible is to really just 90% of it? ==
My devotion is 100%.
==… so Are you are you in agreement with the Protestant Evangelicals, the Liberal Christians(Seems you are closer to them based on what you have written) or the Catholic Chriatians?==
I am in agreement with God [Amos 3:3].
== Also which denomination is correct?==
I’m not concerned with denominations. Neither is God.
==I can neither confrim nor deny that Satan exists. ==
So, you don’t trust what God says. We get it. So does He.
== All beliefs are your your choice…==
I choose, outta honesty with and love for God, to believe the Truth.
==Who is to say that the translators and Catholic meetings got the Satan translitteration correct?==
We can tell from the line of scriptural thought.
== Just because you add a sentence from a later written book and added to the collection of books at the Council of Nicea that says “All scripure it God breathed” doesnt correct all the errors.==
The error is in your own mind. You’re hallucinating.
== Mr. Incredible what if that part of the Bible that mentions “Satan” is in cluded in you 10% that say is not accurate according to you and many others?==
I never said that the Word of God is not accurate.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | April 15, 2009, 5:21 am 5:21 am
Thanks for your responses Mr. Incredible. Let’s further discuss your communication with the “Holy Spirit” and the only way for you to tell that the what the Holy Spirit is is that it lines up with the Bible.
Mr. I, say: However, for example, The King James Version is in the upper 90s percentile accurate with Texas Receptus Greek. TR is in the upper 90s percentile accurate with over 5600 manuscripts. This is not the case with the Wescott-Hort Greek. The WH is corrupt, and so are the modern translations which are based on the WH Greek.
Shaye: What does this mean? Exactly? Upper 90% that is not 100%. Logic==
Mr I: What it means is that the words in the Word of God are accurate enough to get across the concept of the spiritual journey. They are as accurate to the originals as they are going to get, and that’s pretty accurate. They don’t have to be 100%.
SHAYE: Okay so you are a fundamentalist that will admint there are some minor man made errors. That seems more real than the document being perfect gramatically and historically in every way. I will accept that. No argument here.
==(Okay then when is the Holy Spirit interpresting and your mind interpreting?==
When what I think and say align with the Word of God, it must have been the Holy Spirit. It can be nothing else.
SHAYE: So MR. I your documents(The Bible) you use as a reference for these “Interpretations” or thoughts you have from the Holy Spirit are not 100% accurate. How can you say that you know that the Holy Spirit is accurate when the document is not accurate.
And if ther are 2 billion different Christian who have divided themselves up into thousands of denominations and sects all claim that they hear from the Holy Spirit and their views are different from one another and probably yours. So how do you know yours is correct over the 1000s of other Christions interpretations from the Holy Spiirt that contradict yours?? The answer is obvious either you are right and ther is 1,999,999 other Christians wrong, or the Word is not what you beleive it is, or humans make errors in their reciving of these thoughts from the “Holy Spirit”. Over a billion errors. Im glad Im speaking to 1 in 2 billion (Mr. Incredible) :)
Posted by: Shaye | April 15, 2009, 11:51 am 11:51 am
Sorry I left out a few numbers:
1,999,999,999 Christians. :)
Posted by: Shaye | April 15, 2009, 11:53 am 11:53 am
Here are the Facts:
1) The Bible has errors
2) The Bibile was Translitterated from (Aramaic to Hebrew to Greek, to German to the Kings English)
3) The Bible was created at the Council OF Nicea(By Emperor Constantine).
3) No one person has cornered the market on the (correct interpretation)with proof.
4) People can worship “God” without any Bible.
5) Satan canno be proven to exist by mere belief in the document. Anyone can read a national Enquirer and they could have an article on Satan and people could say My experience matches up with the National Enquirer. That doen not make it a Holy Book or validate the existence of Satan.
6) One can believe that the “Holy Spirit” told them something but not know for sure beacuse the documents are not accurate and may have lost meanings through the translitteration process.
7)There are and estimated 2 billion Christins with thousands of denominations, use different bibiles, and not all of the same cannion. All claim that they have the correct interpretation by the Holy Spirit or the most accurate Bible or Theology.
8) Mr. Incredible believes that the “Holy Spirit” talk to him and he can somehow interpret the same innacurate document used to back up his converstations with the “Holy Spirit” and even alter the meanings of the same Bible that he has to use to justify his understandings from the “Holy Spirit”. You then change the mensings of your reference guide. This is pretty funny-possibly insane.
Posted by: Shaye | April 15, 2009, 12:18 pm 12:18 pm
Its all a matter of belief. I rest my case.
Posted by: Shaye | April 15, 2009, 12:20 pm 12:20 pm
Mr. incredible will prbably blame Satan for the other 2billion Christians who are confused and he probably attacked the printer on the King James printing press who changed the words and meanings which caused the litteral and circumstantial errors in the current bible and that Satan has attaced ever other Chritian who beleives differently from him. This could be a very unhealthy psycholgial condition.
Posted by: Shaye | April 15, 2009, 12:29 pm 12:29 pm
==Its [sic] all a matter of belief.==
Belief must be based on correct perception of things and situations.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | April 15, 2009, 12:59 pm 12:59 pm
==Upper 90% that is not 100%. ==
The errors you say you think you find in the physical book are harmless when it comes to the spiritual Message Which is 100%.
For instance, where the book says that God said, “Let there be light,” it doesn’t matter that the Hebrew says He said, “Light be!” The spiritual Message is the same.
What DOES matter is when the modern versions change “virgin” to “maid.” God said “virgin.”
What matters is when, in modern versions, men take out half of Romans 8:1 when God said all of that verse, not half of it.
==so you are a fundamentalist that will admint there are some minor man made errors.==
However, God made no errors in the Word.
==your documents(The Bible)…==
God’s Document, not mine.
==… you use as a reference for these “Interpretations” or thoughts you have from the Holy Spirit are not 100% accurate.==
Yes, they are.
== How can you say that you know that the Holy Spirit is accurate when the document is not accurate. ==
Cuz the Holy Spirit must align with the Word of God.
==And if ther are 2 billion different Christian who have divided themselves up into thousands of denominations and sects all claim that they hear from the Holy Spirit and their views are different from one another and probably yours.==
Then, we’ll all see on Judgment Day, won’t we.
== So how do you know yours is correct over the 1000s of other Christions interpretations from the Holy Spiirt that contradict yours??==
Revelation from God through His Word.
== The answer is obvious either you are right and ther is 1,999,999 other Christians wrong, or the Word is not what you beleive it is, or humans make errors in their reciving of these thoughts from the “Holy Spirit”.==
I AM correct.
== Over a billion errors.==
Men make mistakes and they are mistaken.
==1) The Bible has errors==
Not spiritual errors. God’s Message is 100% intact.
==2) The Bibile was Translitterated from (Aramaic to Hebrew to Greek, to German to the Kings English) ==
Irrelevant. KJV is God’s Word, preserved in English, and He gets the Message across.
=3) The Bible was created at the Council OF Nicea(By Emperor Constantine).==
God created the Word and God created Man; but Man did not create God, nor His Word.
==3) No one person has cornered the market on the (correct interpretation)with proof.==
That’s what the Devil says, too. Keeps that doubt going. That’s why God will save only a remnant, that only a few find the gate.
==4) People can worship “God” without any Bible.==
That’s basically what the Church of England said to the settlers.
Anywho…
Hebrews 4:2 tells you otherwise.
==5) Satan canno be proven to exist by mere belief in the document.==
That’s true, but we don’t bellieve in a mere document, rather in God, through the Person of the Word.
==Anyone can read a national Enquirer and they could have an article on Satan and people could say My experience matches up with the National Enquirer. That doen not make it a Holy Book or validate the existence of Satan.==
That’s true. However, The National Enquirer is men-made.
==6) One can believe that the “Holy Spirit” told them something but not know for sure…==
Yes, they can. You are trying to sow doubt. It’s not working on me, though.
==… beacuse the documents are not accurate…==
The Word of God is spiritually accurate by 100%.
==… and may have lost meanings through the translitteration process.==
The Word of God has lost meaning for YOU, thanks to the Devil.
==7)There are and estimated 2 billion Christins with thousands of denominations, use different bibiles, and not all of the same cannion. All claim that they have the correct interpretation by the Holy Spirit or the most accurate Bible or Theology.==
The Devil likes it that way.
==8) Mr. Incredible believes that the “Holy Spirit” talk to him…==
That’s the promise of God through Christ. So, it is not just some belief. It is a recognition of fact.
==… and he can somehow interpret the same innacurate document used to back up his converstations with the “Holy Spirit”…==
The Word of God says that kinda conversation is “good conversation.”
==…and even alter the meanings of the same Bible that he has to use to justify his understandings from the “Holy Spirit”.==
I justify nothing. God does the justifying through His Word.
== You then change the mensings of your reference guide.==
No, I recognize the meaning of the “reference guide.”
== This is pretty funny-possibly insane. ==
Romans 8:1 KJV.
==Mr. incredible will prbably blame Satan for the other 2billion Christians who are confused…==
The DEvil is tghe author of confusion, yes.
==… and he probably attacked the printer on the King James printing press who changed the words and meanings …==
Textus Receptus, regarding the New Testament, is 100% accurate spiritually when compared to ancient manuscripts cuz the copyists and printers were meticulous, as opposed to the Westcott-Hort Greek copyists who inserted comments and other meanings, etc. Modern versions of the Word are based on WH and, thus, corrupt.
==…which caused the litteral and circumstantial errors in the current bible…==
There are no spiritual errors in the Word of God.
==… and that Satan has attaced ever other Chritian who beleives differently from him.==
Satan attacks everybody. Those armed with the Word of God survive the attacks with distinction.
== This could be a very unhealthy psycholgial condition.==
According to the world, of course, and you who are a worldling.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | April 15, 2009, 1:32 pm 1:32 pm
JUST TO KEEP THE DIALOGUE GOING:
Thanks for your responses Mr. Incredible. Let’s further discuss your communication with the “Holy Spirit” and the only way for you to tell that the what the Holy Spirit is is that it lines up with the Bible.
Mr. I, say: However, for example, The King James Version is in the upper 90s percentile accurate with Texas Receptus Greek. TR is in the upper 90s percentile accurate with over 5600 manuscripts. This is not the case with the Wescott-Hort Greek. The WH is corrupt, and so are the modern translations which are based on the WH Greek.
Shaye: What does this mean? Exactly? Upper 90% that is not 100%. Logic==
Mr I: What it means is that the words in the Word of God are accurate enough to get across the concept of the spiritual journey. They are as accurate to the originals as they are going to get, and that’s pretty accurate. They don’t have to be 100%.
SHAYE: Okay so you are a fundamentalist that will admint there are some minor man made errors. That seems more real than the document being perfect gramatically and historically in every way. I will accept that. No argument here.
==(Okay then when is the Holy Spirit interpresting and your mind interpreting?==
When what I think and say align with the Word of God, it must have been the Holy Spirit. It can be nothing else.
SHAYE: So MR. I your documents(The Bible) you use as a reference for these “Interpretations” or thoughts you have from the Holy Spirit are not 100% accurate. How can you say that you know that the Holy Spirit is accurate when the document is not accurate.
And if ther are 2 billion different Christian who have divided themselves up into thousands of denominations and sects all claim that they hear from the Holy Spirit and their views are different from one another and probably yours. So how do you know yours is correct over the 1000s of other Christions interpretations from the Holy Spiirt that contradict yours?? The answer is obvious either you are right and ther is 1,999,999 other Christians wrong, or the Word is not what you beleive it is, or humans make errors in their reciving of these thoughts from the “Holy Spirit”. Over a billion errors. Im glad Im speaking to 1 in 2 billion (Mr. Incredible) :)
Posted by: Shaye | April 15, 2009, 1:35 pm 1:35 pm
(Joh 3:12) If I have told you earthly things, and ye believe not, how shall ye believe, if I tell you of heavenly things?
(Gal 1:6) I marvel that ye are so soon removed from him that called you into the grace of Christ unto another gospel:
(Gal 1:7) Which is not another; but there be some that trouble you, and would pervert the gospel of Christ.
(Gal 1:8) But though we, or an angel from heaven, preach any other gospel unto you than that which we have preached unto you, let him be accursed.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | April 15, 2009, 1:56 pm 1:56 pm
==Upper 90% that is not 100%. ==
The errors you say you think you find in the physical book are harmless when it comes to the spiritual Message Which is 100%.
For instance, where the book says that God said, “Let there be light,” it doesn’t matter that the Hebrew says He said, “Light be!” The spiritual Message is the same.
What DOES matter is when the modern versions change “virgin” to “maid.” God said “virgin.”
What matters is when, in modern versions, men take out half of Romans 8:1 when God said all of that verse, not half of it.
(ONCE AGAIN YOU SHOW EVIDENCE THAT THE BIBLE HAS ERRORS ADMIT THE BIBILE IS NOT 100% ACCRUATE)
==so you are a fundamentalist that will admint there are some minor man made errors.==
However, God made no errors in the Word.
ONCE AGAIN YOU ADMIT THE BIBILE IS NOT 100% ACCRUATE. You SAY GOD MADE NO ERRORS. HOW DO YOU THAT GOD DID ANYTHING? YOU DONT)
==your documents(The Bible)…==
(YOU BELIEVE THAT WHAT WAS TRANSLATED MADE BY KING JAMES IS GOD DOCUMENT)
God’s Document, not mine.
==… you use as a reference for these “Interpretations” or thoughts you have from the Holy Spirit are not 100% accurate.==
Yes, they are.
(THAT IS DEBATEABLE WITH OTHER CHRISTIANS)
== How can you say that you know that the Holy Spirit is accurate when the document is not accurate. ==
Cuz the Holy Spirit must align with the Word of God.
(SO YOU ARE SAYING THE YOU KNOW THAT THE HOLY SPIRT MUST ALING WITH AN INACCURATE KING JAMES BIBLE FROM YOUR OWN ADMISSION)
==And if ther are 2 billion different Christian who have divided themselves up into thousands of denominations and sects all claim that they hear from the Holy Spirit and their views are different from one another and probably yours.==
Then, we’ll all see on Judgment Day, won’t we.
(THATS ABOUT THE BEST ANSWER YOU HAVE GIVEN YET) LOL
== So how do you know yours is correct over the 1000s of other Christions interpretations from the Holy Spiirt that contradict yours??==
Revelation from God through His Word.
(YOU BELIEVE THAT YOUR REVELATIONS ARE CORRECT OVER THE OTHER 2 BILLION CHRISTIANS-THAT IS ARROGANCE)
== The answer is obvious either you are right and ther is 1,999,999 other Christians wrong, or the Word is not what you beleive it is, or humans make errors in their reciving of these thoughts from the “Holy Spirit”.==
I AM correct.
(I UNDERSTAND YOU ARE TRYING TO HIND BEHIND THE “I AM” IN THE BIBILE(NICE TRY). HOW IS THE REVALATIONS FROM THE “I AM” aka GOD aka HOLY SPIRIT PROVEN MORE ACCURATE THAN THE OTHER 2 BILLION CHRISTION WHO READ “The Word” and worship GOD?
== Over a billion errors.==
Men make mistakes and they are mistaken.
(SO YOU ARE INERRANT? DO YOU MAKE MISTAKES?)
==1) The Bible has errors==
Not spiritual errors. God’s Message is 100% intact.
(THAT IS WHAT YOU BELIEVE)
==2) The Bibile was Translitterated from (Aramaic to Hebrew to Greek, to German to the Kings English) ==
Irrelevant. KJV is God’s Word, preserved in English, and He gets the Message across.
(IT IS RELEVANT BECAUSE IT SHOWS THE MEANINGS OF WORDS GET LOST IN TRANSLATION)
=3) The Bible was created at the Council OF Nicea(By Emperor Constantine).==
God created the Word and God created Man; but Man did not create God, nor His Word.
(THE COUNCIL OF NICEA IN ROME CREATED THE FIRST BIBLE. SO THE COUNCIL WAS GOD? SO GOD IN MANY HUMAN PERSONS NOW?)
==3) No one person has cornered the market on the (correct interpretation)with proof.==
That’s what the Devil says, too. Keeps that doubt going. That’s why God will save only a remnant, that only a few find the gate.
(NOW YOU ARE HAVING ILLUSORY CONCERSATIONS WITH THE DEVIL? THIS IS ANOTHER ONE OF YOUR BELIEFS)
==4) People can worship “God” without any Bible.==
That’s basically what the Church of England said to the settlers.
(ITS TRUE YOU CAN WORSHIP WITHOUT A BIBLE)
Anywho…
Hebrews 4:2 tells you otherwise.
==5) Satan canno be proven to exist by mere belief in the document.==
That’s true, but we don’t bellieve in a mere document, rather in God, through the Person of the Word.
(BELIVE IN GOD THEN. THE BIBILE IS THE DOCUMENT WHICH HAS THE WORDS IN IT)
==Anyone can read a national Enquirer and they could have an article on Satan and people could say My experience matches up with the National Enquirer. That doen not make it a Holy Book or validate the existence of Satan.==
That’s true. However, The National Enquirer is men-made.
(THE BIBLE IS MAN MADE REMEBER THE COUNCIL OF NICEA AND EMPEROR CONSTANTINE)
==6) One can believe that the “Holy Spirit” told them something but not know for sure…==
Yes, they can. You are trying to sow doubt. It’s not working on me, though.
(IM NOT TRYING TO SOW DOUBT. I AM ASKING QUESTIONS AND YOU MY FIRND ANRE NOT BEYOND ASKING QUESTIONS)
==… beacuse the documents are not accurate…==
The Word of God is spiritually accurate by 100%.
(THE BIBILE IS NOT 100% ACCURATE. DO YOU HAVE SOME OTHER DOCUMENT THAT YOU WANT TO SHARE called the “Word of God” Please tell me that we are taking about the same KJV BiBLE-Which has errors)
==… and may have lost meanings through the translitteration process.==
The Word of God has lost meaning for YOU, thanks to the Devil.
(THR BIBILE IS A WONDWERFUL BOOK. I FIND MEANING IN IT. AND TO BLAME A DEVIL CANT GET YOU OUT OF THESE QUESTIONS)
==7)There are and estimated 2 billion Christins with thousands of denominations, use different bibiles, and not all of the same cannion. All claim that they have the correct interpretation by the Holy Spirit or the most accurate Bible or Theology.==
The Devil likes it that way.
(YOU CANT ANSWER THIS QUESTION WITHOUT BLAMING ONE OF THE CHARACTERS IN THE BIBLE-NOT A VERY GOOD ANSWER AND QUITE SAD)
==8) Mr. Incredible believes that the “Holy Spirit” talk to him…==
That’s the promise of God through Christ. So, it is not just some belief. It is a recognition of fact.
(SO YOUR BELIEFS ARE NOW FACTS. THEY ARE NOT FACTS THEY ARE YOUR BELIEFS)
==… and he can somehow interpret the same innacurate document used to back up his converstations with the “Holy Spirit”…==
The Word of God says that kinda conversation is “good conversation.”
(WELL YOU CANNT BE KINDA WRONG AND KINDA PREGNANT.)
==…and even alter the meanings of the same Bible that he has to use to justify his understandings from the “Holy Spirit”.==
I justify nothing. God does the justifying through His Word.
YOU DO THE JUSTIFYING BASED ON YOUR BEIF IN THE BIBILE)
== You then change the mensings of your reference guide.==
No, I recognize the meaning of the “reference guide.”
(YOU CHANGE THE MEANINGS TO FIT YOU OWN BELIEFS JUST LIKE ALL THER OTHER DENOMINATIONS. YOU ARE THE SAME)
== This is pretty funny-possibly insane. ==
Romans 8:1 KJV.
==Mr. incredible will prbably blame Satan for the other 2billion Christians who are confused…==
The DEvil is tghe author of confusion, yes.
(THIS IS THE MOST ARROGANT THING YOU AHVE SAID. IMPLYING THAT YOU ARE RIGHT AND 2 billion people got it wrong. This is hilarous).
==… and he probably attacked the printer on the King James printing press who changed the words and meanings …==
Textus Receptus, regarding the New Testament, is 100% accurate spiritually when compared to ancient manuscripts cuz the copyists and printers were meticulous, as opposed to the Westcott-Hort Greek copyists who inserted comments and other meanings, etc. Modern versions of the Word are based on WH and, thus, corrupt.
(THAT DOENSNT MEAN ITS TRUE EVEN IF THEY GOT IT 92% Translated)
==…which caused the litteral and circumstantial errors in the current bible…==
There are no spiritual errors in the Word of God.
(SO NOW THERE ARE NO SPIRITUAL ERRORS PLEASE EXPLAIN THE DIFFERNECE BETWEEN THE LITTTERAL AND SPIRITUAL ERRORS)
==… and that Satan has attaced ever other Chritian who beleives differently from him.==
Satan attacks everybody. Those armed with the Word of God survive the attacks with distinction.
(THIS IS A BELIEF ONCE AGAIN)
== This could be a very unhealthy psycholgial condition.==
According to the world, of course, and you who are a worldling.
(ALL THE ABOVE MAKES MY POINT)
Posted by: Shaye | April 15, 2009, 2:07 pm 2:07 pm
I am trying to get you to see MR. Incredible the difference between believing and knowing. :)
Posted by: Shaye | April 15, 2009, 2:12 pm 2:12 pm
==And if ther are 2 billion different Christian who have divided themselves up into thousands of denominations and sects all claim that they hear from the Holy Spirit and their views are different from one another and probably yours.==
Then, we’ll all see on Judgment Day, won’t we.
== So how do you know yours is correct over the 1000s of other Christions interpretations from the Holy Spiirt that contradict yours??==
Revelation from God through His Word.
== The answer is obvious either you are right and ther is 1,999,999 other Christians wrong, or the Word is not what you beleive it is, or humans make errors in their reciving of these thoughts from the “Holy Spirit”.==
I AM correct.
== Over a billion errors.==
Men make mistakes and they are mistaken.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | April 15, 2009, 2:21 pm 2:21 pm
==I am trying to get you to see MR. Incredible the difference between believing and knowing. ==
Pretty much what the Devil tried to do and succeeded in the Garden and in the wilderness.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | April 15, 2009, 2:22 pm 2:22 pm
==/==Upper 90% that is not 100%. ==
The errors you say you think you find in the physical book are harmless when it comes to the spiritual Message Which is 100%.
For instance, where the book says that God said, “Let there be light,” it doesn’t matter that the Hebrew says He said, “Light be!” The spiritual Message is the same.
What DOES matter is when the modern versions change “virgin” to “maid.” God said “virgin.”
What matters is when, in modern versions, men take out half of Romans 8:1 when God said all of that verse, not half of it.
(ONCE AGAIN YOU SHOW EVIDENCE THAT THE BIBLE HAS ERRORS ADMIT THE BIBILE IS NOT 100% ACCRUATE) ==
Once again, no, I didn’t.
==/==so you are a fundamentalist that will admint there are some minor man made errors.==
However, God made no errors in the Word.
ONCE AGAIN YOU ADMIT THE BIBILE IS NOT 100% ACCRUATE.==
No, I don’t.
== You SAY GOD MADE NO ERRORS.==
I did not and doesn’t err, and it doesn’t have anything to do with whether I say so, or not. He doesn’t need my permission.
== HOW DO YOU THAT GOD DID ANYTHING?==
(Rom 1:20) For the invisible things of him from the creation of the world are clearly seen, being understood by the things that are made, even his eternal power and Godhead; so that they are without excuse:
== YOU DONT) ==
Yes, I do. YOU don’t.
==/==your documents(The Bible)…==
(YOU BELIEVE THAT WHAT WAS TRANSLATED MADE BY KING JAMES IS GOD DOCUMENT)==
The physical book is a shadow of the Real Thing.
==/==God’s Document, not mine.
==… you use as a reference for these “Interpretations” or thoughts you have from the Holy Spirit are not 100% accurate.==
Yes, they are.
(THAT IS DEBATEABLE WITH OTHER CHRISTIANS)==
And, as He says, few will find the gate.
==/== How can you say that you know that the Holy Spirit is accurate when the document is not accurate. ==
Cuz the Holy Spirit must align with the Word of God.
(SO YOU ARE SAYING THE YOU KNOW THAT THE HOLY SPIRT MUST ALING WITH AN INACCURATE KING JAMES BIBLE FROM YOUR OWN ADMISSION)==
Quit misrepresenting my argument. I said nothing of the kind.
==/==And if ther are 2 billion different Christian who have divided themselves up into thousands of denominations and sects all claim that they hear from the Holy Spirit and their views are different from one another and probably yours.==
Then, we’ll all see on Judgment Day, won’t we.
(THATS ABOUT THE BEST ANSWER YOU HAVE GIVEN YET) ==
I’m not interested in pleasing you. I don’t care whether you think my answers are good, or not.
==/== So how do you know yours is correct over the 1000s of other Christions interpretations from the Holy Spiirt that contradict yours??==
Revelation from God through His Word.
(YOU BELIEVE THAT YOUR REVELATIONS ARE CORRECT OVER THE OTHER 2 BILLION CHRISTIANS-THAT IS ARROGANCE)==
That’s your human “reasoning.” The Pharisees thought Jesus was arrogant, too. I’m in Good Company. HALLELUJAH!
==/== The answer is obvious either you are right and ther is 1,999,999 other Christians wrong, or the Word is not what you beleive it is, or humans make errors in their reciving of these thoughts from the “Holy Spirit”.==
I AM correct.
(I UNDERSTAND YOU ARE TRYING TO HIND BEHIND THE “I AM” IN THE BIBILE(NICE TRY).==
God, through Christ, is my Protector.
== HOW IS THE REVALATIONS FROM THE “I AM” aka GOD aka HOLY SPIRIT PROVEN MORE ACCURATE THAN THE OTHER 2 BILLION CHRISTION WHO READ “The Word” and worship GOD?==
They read amiss.
==/== Over a billion errors.==
Men make mistakes and they are mistaken.
(SO YOU ARE INERRANT?==
No. The Word of God is inerrant.
== DO YOU MAKE MISTAKES?)==
Since I am not God, I make mistakes in unrighteousness. However, Christ makes me Righteous. In Righteousness, I let the Holy Spirit do the interpreting of the Word of God. The Holy Spirit is 100% accurate.
==/==1) The Bible has errors==
Not spiritual errors. God’s Message is 100% intact.
(THAT IS WHAT YOU BELIEVE)==
Uhhh, yeah-uh.
==/==2) The Bibile was Translitterated from (Aramaic to Hebrew to Greek, to German to the Kings English) ==
Irrelevant. KJV is God’s Word, preserved in English, and He gets the Message across.
(IT IS RELEVANT BECAUSE IT SHOWS THE MEANINGS OF WORDS GET LOST IN TRANSLATION)==
The meanings not lost in the areas where they count.
==/=3) The Bible was created at the Council OF Nicea(By Emperor Constantine).==
God created the Word and God created Man; but Man did not create God, nor His Word.
(THE COUNCIL OF NICEA IN ROME CREATED THE FIRST BIBLE. ==
They may have created the first book. The Word of God was created in the beginning.
== SO THE COUNCIL WAS GOD?==
The Word is God.
== SO GOD IN MANY HUMAN PERSONS NOW?)==
Amos 3:3 [KJV]
==/==3) No one person has cornered the market on the (correct interpretation)with proof.==
That’s what the Devil says, too. Keeps that doubt going. That’s why God will save only a remnant, that only a few find the gate.
(NOW YOU ARE HAVING ILLUSORY CONCERSATIONS WITH THE DEVIL? ==
No more than Jesus had in the wilderness. He did not have filthy conversations with the Devil.
== THIS IS ANOTHER ONE OF YOUR BELIEFS)==
Satan is a fact.
==/==4) People can worship “God” without any Bible.==
That’s basically what the Church of England said to the settlers.
(ITS TRUE YOU CAN WORSHIP WITHOUT A BIBLE)
Hebrews 4:2 KJV
==/==5) Satan canno be proven to exist by mere belief in the document.==
That’s true, but we don’t bellieve in a mere document, rather in God, through the Person of the Word.
(BELIVE IN GOD THEN. THE BIBILE IS THE DOCUMENT WHICH HAS THE WORDS IN IT)==
The physical book is the shadow of the Real Thing. The physical book is NOT the Real Thing.
==/==Anyone can read a national Enquirer and they could have an article on Satan and people could say My experience matches up with the National Enquirer. That doen not make it a Holy Book or validate the existence of Satan.==
That’s true. However, The National Enquirer is men-made.
(THE BIBLE IS MAN MADE==
The Word of God is 100% spiritually accurate.
== REMEBER THE COUNCIL OF NICEA AND EMPEROR CONSTANTINE)==
They put together the book — the physical book — that is a shadow of a Real Thing. The book is not the Real Thing.
==/==6) One can believe that the “Holy Spirit” told them something but not know for sure…==
Yes, they can. You are trying to sow doubt. It’s not working on me, though.
(IM NOT TRYING TO SOW DOUBT.==
Yes, you are.
== I AM ASKING QUESTIONS…==
The Word of God calls them “foolish questions.”
== AND YOU MY FIRND ANRE NOT BEYOND ASKING QUESTIONS)==
Ask away. And I will answer according to the method Jesus used in the wilderness.
==/==… beacuse the documents are not accurate…==
The Word of God is spiritually accurate by 100%.
(THE BIBILE IS NOT 100% ACCURATE.==
The Word of God is 100% spiritually accurate.
== DO YOU HAVE SOME OTHER DOCUMENT THAT YOU WANT TO SHARE called the “Word of God” ==
(Gal 1:6) I marvel that ye are so soon removed from him that called you into the grace of Christ unto another gospel:
(Gal 1:7) Which is not another; but there be some that trouble you, and would pervert the gospel of Christ.
(Gal 1:8) But though we, or an angel from heaven, preach any other gospel unto you than that which we have preached unto you, let him be accursed.
==Please tell me that we are taking about the same KJV BiBLE-Which has errors)==
The Word of God is 100% spiritually accurate. The “errors” are in your head.
==/==… and may have lost meanings through the translitteration process.==
The Word of God has lost meaning for YOU, thanks to the Devil.
(THR BIBILE IS A WONDWERFUL BOOK. I FIND MEANING IN IT.==
You warp Him to fit YOUR ideas.
== AND TO BLAME A DEVIL…==
I’m not blaming the Devil. I blame people who listen to the Devil and, then, act on what they hear, then, say that they thought of it all by themselves.
==… CANT GET YOU OUT OF THESE QUESTIONS)==
I’m not trying to get out of any questions.
==/==7)There are and estimated 2 billion Christins with thousands of denominations, use different bibiles, and not all of the same cannion. All claim that they have the correct interpretation by the Holy Spirit or the most accurate Bible or Theology.==
The Devil likes it that way.
(YOU CANT ANSWER THIS QUESTION WITHOUT BLAMING ONE OF THE CHARACTERS IN THE BIBLE…==
I’m not blaming the Devil. I’m saying only that he likes your questions. He likes the fact that you choose to sow doubt.
==…-NOT A VERY GOOD ANSWER AND QUITE SAD)==
Translation: “Any answer the does not agree with me is not a very good answer and quite sad.”
==/==8) Mr. Incredible believes that the “Holy Spirit” talk to him…==
That’s the promise of God through Christ. So, it is not just some belief. It is a recognition of fact.
(SO YOUR BELIEFS ARE NOW FACTS.==
My belief is based on the fact of God and His Word and Their performance.
== THEY ARE NOT FACTS THEY ARE YOUR BELIEFS)==
They are my beliefs based on the facts.
==/==… and he can somehow interpret the same innacurate document used to back up his converstations with the “Holy Spirit”…==
The Word of God says that kinda conversation is “good conversation.”
(WELL YOU CANNT BE KINDA WRONG AND KINDA PREGNANT.)
The Word of God refers to good conversation and filthy conversation. Conversation with the Devil is filthy conversation, with the you believe that the Devil exists, or not.
==/==…and even alter the meanings of the same Bible that he has to use to justify his understandings from the “Holy Spirit”.==
I justify nothing. God does the justifying through His Word.
YOU DO THE JUSTIFYING BASED ON YOUR BEIF IN THE BIBILE)==
God, through Christ, justifies me. I don’t justify me.
==/== You then change the mensings of your reference guide.==
No, I recognize the meaning of the “reference guide.”
(YOU CHANGE THE MEANINGS TO FIT YOU OWN BELIEFS==
I changed nothing.
==… JUST LIKE ALL THER OTHER DENOMINATIONS.==
That’s why they are not saved.
==… YOU ARE THE SAME)==
No, I am not the same as they are.
==/== This is pretty funny-possibly insane. ==
Romans 8:1 KJV.
==Mr. incredible will prbably blame Satan for the other 2billion Christians who are confused…==
The DEvil is tghe author of confusion, yes.
(THIS IS THE MOST ARROGANT THING YOU AHVE SAID. ==
Yours is worldly thinking. After all, you are a worldling. I am in the world, not OF it. I am born of God, not of the world.
== IMPLYING THAT YOU ARE RIGHT AND 2 billion people got it wrong.==
It’s not up for a vote.
== This is hilarous).==
The Devil left to Jesus in the wilderness, too. Did it stop Jesus? NO!
==/==… and he probably attacked the printer on the King James printing press who changed the words and meanings …==
Textus Receptus, regarding the New Testament, is 100% accurate spiritually when compared to ancient manuscripts cuz the copyists and printers were meticulous, as opposed to the Westcott-Hort Greek copyists who inserted comments and other meanings, etc. Modern versions of the Word are based on WH and, thus, corrupt.
(THAT DOENSNT MEAN ITS TRUE EVEN IF THEY GOT IT 92% Translated)==
The Word of God is not true for YOU. The natural man doesn’t get it.
==/==…which caused the litteral and circumstantial errors in the current bible…==
There are no spiritual errors in the Word of God.
(SO NOW THERE ARE NO SPIRITUAL ERRORS==
That’s what I said. Duh.
== PLEASE EXPLAIN THE DIFFERNECE BETWEEN THE LITTTERAL AND SPIRITUAL ERRORS)==
The natural man doesn’t understand spiritual things. So, it will do no good for me to explain it to you cuz you are blocked from understanding it.
==/==… and that Satan has attaced ever other Chritian who beleives differently from him.==
Satan attacks everybody. Those armed with the Word of God survive the attacks with distinction.
(THIS IS A BELIEF ONCE AGAIN)==
Belief based on facts.
==/== This could be a very unhealthy psycholgial condition.==
According to the world, of course, and you who are a worldling.
(ALL THE ABOVE MAKES MY POINT)==
A wrong point.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | April 15, 2009, 2:55 pm 2:55 pm
==I am trying to get you to see MR. Incredible the difference between believing and knowing.==
The Devil had great success on that with Eve.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | April 15, 2009, 2:57 pm 2:57 pm
The physical book is the shadow of the Real Thing. The physical book is NOT the Real Thing.
(1Co 2:9) But as it is written, Eye hath not seen, nor ear heard, neither have entered into the heart of man, the things which God hath prepared for them that love him.
(1Co 2:10) But God hath revealed them unto us by his Spirit: for the Spirit searcheth all things, yea, the deep things of God.
(Rom 1:19) Because that which may be known of God is manifest in them; for God hath shewed it unto them.
(Rom 1:20) For the invisible things of him from the creation of the world are clearly seen, being understood by the things that are made, even his eternal power and Godhead; so that they are without excuse:
(1Co 2:11) For what man knoweth the things of a man, save the spirit of man which is in him? even so the things of God knoweth no man, but the Spirit of God.
(1Co 2:12) Now we have received, not the spirit of the world, but the spirit which is of God; that we might know the things that are freely given to us of God.
(1Co 2:13) Which things also we speak, not in the words which man’s wisdom teacheth, but which the Holy Ghost teacheth; comparing spiritual things with spiritual.
(1Co 2:14) But the natural man receiveth not the things of the Spirit of God: for they are foolishness unto him: neither can he know them, because they are spiritually discerned.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | April 15, 2009, 3:18 pm 3:18 pm
You use your circular reasoning with the Bible to justify your beliefs and in fact your own head is spinning. Your beliefs are your beliefs. :)
Posted by: Shaye | April 15, 2009, 3:57 pm 3:57 pm
==/==Anyone can read a national Enquirer and they could have an article on Satan and people could say My experience matches up with the National Enquirer. That doen not make it a Holy Book or validate the existence of Satan.
That’s true. However, The National Enquirer is men-made.
(THE BIBLE IS MAN MADE==
The Word of God is 100% spiritually accurate.
== REMEBER THE COUNCIL OF NICEA AND EMPEROR CONSTANTINE THEY CREATED THE BIBILE)==
Posted by: Shaye | April 15, 2009, 4:08 pm 4:08 pm
The physical book is a shadow of the Real Thing.
(SO YOU HAVENT SEEN THE REAL THING. IF YOU SEE SHADOWS WHILE IN A CAVE LOOKING OUR YOU DONT REALLY KNOW WHAT YOU SEE)
==/==God’s Document, not mine.
==… you use as a reference for these “Interpretations” or thoughts you have from the Holy Spirit are not 100% accurate.==
Yes, they are.
(THAT IS DEBATEABLE WITH OTHER CHRISTIANS)==
And, as He says, few will find the gate.
(WHO IS HE? WHERE DOE HE SAY THIS? AND HOW DO YOU KNOW YOU WILL BE AT THAT GATE? YOU BELIEVE YOU WILL GO TO THE GATE.)
Posted by: Shaye | April 15, 2009, 4:09 pm 4:09 pm
How can you say that you know that the Holy Spirit is accurate when the document is not accurate. ==
Cuz the Holy Spirit must align with the Word of God.
(SO YOU ARE SAYING FROM YOUR OWN ADMISSION)==
Quit misrepresenting my argument. I said nothing of the kind.
(SO ANSWER THE QUESTION HOW CAN YOU KNOW THAT YOUR INTERPRESTAION FO A PERCIVED MESSAGE FROM THE HOLY SPIRIT IS CORRECT WHEN YOU CANT REFER BACK TO A CORRECT BIBLE???? YOU CANT
==/==And if ther are 2 billion different Christian who have divided themselves up into thousands of denominations and sects all claim that they hear from the Holy Spirit and their views are different from one another and probably yours.==
Then, we’ll all see on Judgment Day, won’t we.
(THATS ABOUT THE BEST ANSWER YOU HAVE GIVEN YET) ==
I’m not interested in pleasing you. I don’t care whether you think my answers are good, or not.
(WE WILL SEE ON JUDEGEMENT DAY) :)
Posted by: Shaye | April 15, 2009, 4:10 pm 4:10 pm
==You use your circular reasoning…==
It’s not circular reasoning. What you see as “circular reasoning” is actually your head spinning.
===.. with the Bible to justify your beliefs…==
I don’t justify. God justifies ME through Christ, just as he promised.
==… and in fact your own head is spinning.==
Not with God it isn’t!
== Your beliefs are your beliefs.==
Yes, they are based on facts to which you have no access.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | April 15, 2009, 4:11 pm 4:11 pm
I AM DEBATIN MR INCREDIBLE MY ANSWERS ARE IN ALL CAPS.
So how do you know yours is correct over the 1000s of other Christions interpretations from the Holy Spiirt that contradict yours??==
Revelation from God through His Word.
(YOU BELIEVE THAT YOUR REVELATIONS ARE CORRECT OVER THE OTHER 2 BILLION CHRISTIANS-THAT IS ARROGANCE)==
That’s your human “reasoning.” The Pharisees thought Jesus was arrogant, too. I’m in Good Company. HALLELUJAH!
(REMBER THE DEBATE BETWEEN DAN QUALE AND BENTSEN-YOU ARE NO JFK TO DAN QUALE. IN THIS CASE YOU ARE NO JESUS. TO DRAW A COMPARISON BETWEEN YOU AND JESUS IS NOT EVEN A COMPARISON.
Posted by: Shaye | April 15, 2009, 4:12 pm 4:12 pm
HOW IS THE REVALATIONS FROM THE “I AM” aka GOD aka HOLY SPIRIT (TO YOU)PROVEN MORE ACCURATE THAN THE OTHER 2 BILLION CHRISTION WHO READ “The Word” and worship GOD?==
They read amiss.
WOW ARE YOU SERIOUS. I AM GLAD I HAVE MET THE ONE CHRISTIAN PERSON(MR INCREDIBLE) ON THE PLANET WHO DID NOT READ AMISS)
==/== Over a billion errors.==
Men make mistakes and they are mistaken.
(SO YOU ARE INERRANT?==
No. The Word of God is inerrant.
(BUT YOU CAN ERROR THAT IS A FACT)
== DO YOU MAKE MISTAKES?)==
Since I am not God, I make mistakes in unrighteousness. However, Christ makes me Righteous. In Righteousness, I let the Holy Spirit do the interpreting of the Word of God. The Holy Spirit is 100% accurate.
(SO YOU CAN ERROR IN YOUR MISTAKES AND THAT INCLUDES YOUR PERCEPTION OF EVENTS)ANY EVENT)
Posted by: Shaye | April 15, 2009, 4:13 pm 4:13 pm
The Bibile was Translitterated from (Aramaic to Hebrew to Greek, to German to the Kings English) ==
Irrelevant. KJV is God’s Word, preserved in English, and He gets the Message across.
(IT IS RELEVANT BECAUSE IT SHOWS THE MEANINGS OF WORDS GET LOST IN TRANSLATION)==
The meanings not lost in the areas where they count.
(WHERE THEY COUNT) SO WHERE DID YOU GET THE POWER TO DETERMIN WHAT COUNTS? ARE YOU THE POPE? ARE YOU THE HEAD OF THE SBC? ARE YOU JESUS OR GOD HIMSELF. I THINK NOT)
Posted by: Shaye | April 15, 2009, 4:15 pm 4:15 pm
The Bible was created at the Council OF Nicea(By Emperor Constantine).==
God created the Word and God created Man; but Man did not create God, nor His Word.
(THE COUNCIL OF NICEA IN ROME CREATED THE FIRST BIBLE. ==
They may have created the first book. The Word of God was created in the beginning.
(THAT IS A BELIEF BASED ON A SCRIPTURE WITHIN THE BOOK THAT WAS MADE BY MAN)
== SO THE COUNCIL WAS GOD?==
The Word is God.
(THATIS A REFERNCE TO THE BIBILE WHICH WAS CREATED BY THE COUNCIL OF NICEA)
Posted by: Shaye | April 15, 2009, 4:16 pm 4:16 pm
No one person has cornered the market on the (correct interpretation)with proof.==
That’s what the Devil says, too. Keeps that doubt going. That’s why God will save only a remnant, that only a few find the gate.
(NOW YOU ARE HAVING ILLUSORY CONCERSATIONS WITH THE DEVIL? ==
No more than Jesus had in the wilderness. He did not have filthy conversations with the Devil.
(Well You COMPARE YOURSELF WITH JESUS AND HAVE CONVERSATIONS WITH SATAN)
== THIS IS ANOTHER ONE OF YOUR BELIEFS)==
Satan is a fact.
(PROVE YOUR FACT)
Posted by: Shaye | April 15, 2009, 4:16 pm 4:16 pm
REMEBER THE COUNCIL OF NICEA AND EMPEROR CONSTANTINE)==
They put together the book — the physical book — that is a shadow of a Real Thing. The book is not the Real Thing.
(YOU HAVE NEVER SEEN OR EXPERIENCED THE REAL THING)
Posted by: Shaye | April 15, 2009, 4:19 pm 4:19 pm
==/==How can you say that you know that the Holy Spirit is accurate when the document is not accurate. ==
Cuz the Holy Spirit must align with the Word of God.
(SO YOU ARE SAYING FROM YOUR OWN ADMISSION)==
The Word of God is 100% spiritually accurate. The Holy Spirit must align with the Word of God.
==/==Quit misrepresenting my argument. I said nothing of the kind.
(SO ANSWER THE QUESTION HOW CAN YOU KNOW THAT YOUR INTERPRESTAION FO A PERCIVED MESSAGE FROM THE HOLY SPIRIT IS CORRECT WHEN YOU CANT REFER BACK TO A CORRECT BIBLE???? YOU CANT==
So, YOUR method is to ask a question of me, then answer it so you don’t have to accept the answer that I give. We see.
==/==/==And if ther are 2 billion different Christian who have divided themselves up into thousands of denominations and sects all claim that they hear from the Holy Spirit and their views are different from one another and probably yours.==
Then, we’ll all see on Judgment Day, won’t we.
(THATS ABOUT THE BEST ANSWER YOU HAVE GIVEN YET) ==
I’m not interested in pleasing you. I don’t care whether you think my answers are good, or not.
(WE WILL SEE ON JUDEGEMENT DAY) :) ==
I go boldly and confidently to the Throne of God. No problem.
==/==The physical book is a shadow of the Real Thing.
(SO YOU HAVENT SEEN THE REAL THING. ==
Yes, I have.
== IF YOU SEE SHADOWS WHILE IN A CAVE LOOKING OUR YOU DONT REALLY KNOW WHAT YOU SEE)==
As God says, the natural man cannot understand. And, so, you don’t.
==/==/==God’s Document, not mine.
==… you use as a reference for these “Interpretations” or thoughts you have from the Holy Spirit are not 100% accurate.==
Yes, they are.
(THAT IS DEBATEABLE WITH OTHER CHRISTIANS)==
And, as He says, few will find the gate.
(WHO IS HE?==
Gosh, you don’t know. You STILL don’t know.
== WHERE DOE HE SAY THIS?==
In the Word of God.
== AND HOW DO YOU KNOW YOU WILL BE AT THAT GATE? ==
Cuz I have made sure, and I continue to make sure, that my election is sure.
== YOU BELIEVE YOU WILL GO TO THE GATE.)==
No. I will go THROUGH the gate.
== REMEBER THE COUNCIL OF NICEA AND EMPEROR CONSTANTINE THEY CREATED THE BIBILE)==
They didn’t create the Word of God.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | April 15, 2009, 4:21 pm 4:21 pm
You then change the mensings of your reference guide.==
No, I recognize the meaning of the “reference guide.”
(YOU CHANGE THE MEANINGS TO FIT YOU OWN BELIEFS==
I changed nothing.
(YOU HAVE DONE THIS NUMEROUS TIMES ABOVE AND CLAIN THE HOLY SPIRIT GAVE YOU INTERPRETATION)
==… JUST LIKE ALL THER OTHER DENOMINATIONS.==
That’s why they are not saved.
(NOW YOU KNOW THAT THEY ARENT SAVED? HOW DI YOU GET THIS KNWOING> DID GOD ALLOW YOU TO LOOK INTO THE HEARTS OF MEN AND GIVE YOU SPECIAL INFORMATION_I THINK NOT)
Posted by: Shaye | April 15, 2009, 4:22 pm 4:22 pm
SO YOU COMPARE YOURSELF WITH JESUS< YOU "KNOW" OTHER DENOMINATIONS ARE NOT "SAVED", YOU CHANGED THE MEANINGS OF THE BIBILE BASED ON YOUR BELIEF OF A HOLY SPIRIT MEASSAGE. WOW! LOL
Posted by: Shaye | April 15, 2009, 4:24 pm 4:24 pm
So which Christians are not saved? Since you have this knowing power(Which you really only believe) ;-) DIdnt the BIBLE say tha Jesus didnt know the hour? Youre ridiculous Mr. Incredible
Posted by: Shaye | April 15, 2009, 4:32 pm 4:32 pm
==So how do you know yours is correct over the 1000s of other Christions interpretations from the Holy Spiirt that contradict yours??==
Revelation from God through His Word.
(YOU BELIEVE THAT YOUR REVELATIONS ARE CORRECT OVER THE OTHER 2 BILLION CHRISTIANS-THAT IS ARROGANCE)==
That’s your human “reasoning.” The Pharisees thought Jesus was arrogant, too. I’m in Good Company. HALLELUJAH!
(REMBER THE DEBATE BETWEEN DAN QUALE AND BENTSEN-YOU ARE NO JFK TO DAN QUALE. ==
That’s what the Devil says to me, too. However, Romans 8:1 [KJV]
== IN THIS CASE YOU ARE NO JESUS. ==
I don’t have to be. I am a son of God, just as Christ promised.
== TO DRAW A COMPARISON BETWEEN YOU AND JESUS IS NOT EVEN A COMPARISON.==
We ARE to compare ourselves to Christ. He is our Measure.
==/==HOW IS THE REVALATIONS FROM THE “I AM” aka GOD aka HOLY SPIRIT (TO YOU)PROVEN MORE ACCURATE THAN THE OTHER 2 BILLION CHRISTION WHO READ “The Word” and worship GOD?==
They read amiss.
WOW ARE YOU SERIOUS. ==
WOW! I AM.
==I AM GLAD I HAVE MET THE ONE CHRISTIAN PERSON(MR INCREDIBLE) ON THE PLANET WHO DID NOT READ AMISS)==
Exciting, isn’t it?
==/==/== Over a billion errors.==
Men make mistakes and they are mistaken.
(SO YOU ARE INERRANT?==
No. The Word of God is inerrant.
(BUT YOU CAN ERROR THAT IS A FACT)==
However, the Word of God cannot err, and I can read and get Holy Spirit interpretation. That’s all that’s important.
==/== DO YOU MAKE MISTAKES?)==
Since I am not God, I make mistakes in unrighteousness. However, Christ makes me Righteous. In Righteousness, I let the Holy Spirit do the interpreting of the Word of God. The Holy Spirit is 100% accurate.
(SO YOU CAN ERROR IN YOUR MISTAKES AND THAT INCLUDES YOUR PERCEPTION OF EVENTS)ANY EVENT)==
All those who are unrighteous err in the Word of God. However, those who are born again were made Righteous by the words of Christ. So, in Righteousness, with Holy Spirit interpretation, there are no mistakes.
==/==The Bibile was Translitterated from (Aramaic to Hebrew to Greek, to German to the Kings English) ==
Irrelevant. KJV is God’s Word, preserved in English, and He gets the Message across.
(IT IS RELEVANT BECAUSE IT SHOWS THE MEANINGS OF WORDS GET LOST IN TRANSLATION)==
The meanings not lost in the areas where they count.
(WHERE THEY COUNT) SO WHERE DID YOU GET THE POWER TO DETERMIN WHAT COUNTS?==
From the Holy Spirit.
== ARE YOU THE POPE?==
I don’t have to be. God gives those who are born again access to His Mysteries.
== ARE YOU THE HEAD OF THE SBC?==
I don’t have to be. God gives those who are born again access to His Mysteries.
== ARE YOU JESUS OR GOD HIMSELF.==
I don’t have to be. God gives those were born again access to His Mysteries.
== I THINK NOT)==
That’s the first true thing you’ve said.
==/==The Bible was created at the Council OF Nicea(By Emperor Constantine).==
God created the Word and God created Man; but Man did not create God, nor His Word.
(THE COUNCIL OF NICEA IN ROME CREATED THE FIRST BIBLE. ==
They may have created the first book. The Word of God was created in the beginning.
(THAT IS A BELIEF BASED ON A SCRIPTURE WITHIN THE BOOK THAT WAS MADE BY MAN)==
It’s a belief based on fact that the Word of God was with God in the beginning and created by God. The physical book was created by man. The book gets the spiritual stuff 100% accurate.
==/== SO THE COUNCIL WAS GOD?==
The Word is God.
(THATIS A REFERNCE TO THE BIBILE WHICH WAS CREATED BY THE COUNCIL OF NICEA)==
They created the physical book. The physical book is only the shadow of the Real Thing. The Word of God is the Real Thing.
==/==No one person has cornered the market on the (correct interpretation)with proof.==
That’s what the Devil says, too. Keeps that doubt going. That’s why God will save only a remnant, that only a few find the gate.
(NOW YOU ARE HAVING ILLUSORY CONCERSATIONS WITH THE DEVIL? ==
No more than Jesus had in the wilderness. He did not have filthy conversations with the Devil.
(Well You COMPARE YOURSELF WITH JESUS…==
He is my Measure.
==… AND HAVE CONVERSATIONS WITH SATAN)==
No, I don’t. That would be a filthy conversation.
Jesus did not converse with the Devil. He responded to the Devil with Scripture in order to guard His gate.
==/== THIS IS ANOTHER ONE OF YOUR BELIEFS)==
Satan is a fact.
(PROVE YOUR FACT)==
God already proved it.
==REMEBER THE COUNCIL OF NICEA AND EMPEROR CONSTANTINE)==
They put together the book — the physical book — that is a shadow of a Real Thing. The book is not the Real Thing.
(YOU HAVE NEVER SEEN OR EXPERIENCED THE REAL THING)==
Yes, I have.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | April 15, 2009, 4:33 pm 4:33 pm
==/==You then change the mensings of your reference guide.==
No, I recognize the meaning of the “reference guide.”
(YOU CHANGE THE MEANINGS TO FIT YOU OWN BELIEFS
I changed nothing.
(YOU HAVE DONE THIS NUMEROUS TIMES ABOVE AND CLAIN THE HOLY SPIRIT GAVE YOU INTERPRETATION)==
That’s the way YOU choose to see it so that you can try to justify, in your own, spinning mind, your erroneous views.
==/==… JUST LIKE ALL THER OTHER DENOMINATIONS.==
That’s why they are not saved.
(NOW YOU KNOW THAT THEY ARENT SAVED?==
The Word of God tells us. I believe the Word. The Lord is my Shepherd, not you.
== HOW DI YOU GET THIS KNWOING> ==
By reading, knowing, understanding and comprehending the Word of God, thanks to the Holy Spirit.
== DID GOD ALLOW YOU TO LOOK INTO THE HEARTS OF MEN AND GIVE YOU SPECIAL INFORMATION_…==
No information that He doesn’t give anybody.
God tells us that the hearts of men are wicked. I believe Him.
== I THINK NOT)==
Thank you for admitting that.
==SO YOU COMPARE YOURSELF WITH JESUS…==
He is my Measure.
== < YOU "KNOW" OTHER DENOMINATIONS ARE NOT "SAVED"…==
Those who do not align themselves with the Word of God are not saved.
==… YOU CHANGED THE MEANINGS OF THE BIBILE BASED ON YOUR BELIEF OF A HOLY SPIRIT MEASSAGE. WOW! LOL==
All Scripture is the Inspiration of God. I believe Him. The Lord is my Shepherd, not you.
==So which Christians are not saved?==
Those who do not align themselves with the Word of God.
== Since you have this knowing power…==
God promised us this Power. It comes through the Word of God.
==… (Which you really only believe)==
My belief is based on facts to which you have no access.
== DIdnt the BIBLE say tha Jesus didnt know the hour?==
So?
== Youre ridiculous Mr. Incredible==
The Devil tells me that, too. However, Romans 8:1 [KJV] .
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | April 15, 2009, 4:42 pm 4:42 pm
==YOU CHANGE THE MEANINGS TO FIT YOU OWN BELIEFS==
I recognize the meaning, thanks to the Holy Spirit, and tailor my beliefs to fit the meaning of the Word of God.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | April 15, 2009, 4:44 pm 4:44 pm
== DIdnt the BIBLE say tha Jesus didnt know the hour?==
The hour of what?
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | April 15, 2009, 5:02 pm 5:02 pm
MY RESPONSE IS IN ALL CAPS:
Mr Incredible IS THE ONLY CHRIATISN WHO HAS INTEPRETED THE BIBILE CORRECTLY AND GOD HAS GIVEN HIM THE MYSTICAL POWER TO KNOW WHICH OTHER CHRISTIANS ARE GOING TO HELL. THIS IS OUTRAGEOUS>
==/==HOW IS THE REVALATIONS FROM THE “I AM” aka GOD aka HOLY SPIRIT (TO YOU)PROVEN MORE ACCURATE THAN THE OTHER 2 BILLION CHRISTION WHO READ “The Word” and worship GOD?==
They read amiss.
WOW ARE YOU SERIOUS. ==
WOW! I AM.
==I AM GLAD I HAVE MET THE ONE CHRISTIAN PERSON(MR INCREDIBLE) ON THE PLANET WHO DID NOT READ AMISS)==
Exciting, isn’t it?
==/==/== Over a billion errors.==
Men make mistakes and they are mistaken.
(SO YOU ARE INERRANT?==
No. The Word of God is inerrant.
(BUT YOU CAN ERROR THAT IS A FACT)==
However, the Word of God cannot err, and I can read and get Holy Spirit interpretation. That’s all that’s important.
==/== DO YOU MAKE MISTAKES?)==
Since I am not God, I make mistakes in unrighteousness. However, Christ makes me Righteous. In Righteousness, I let the Holy Spirit do the interpreting of the Word of God. The Holy Spirit is 100% accurate.
(SO YOU CAN ERROR IN YOUR MISTAKES AND THAT INCLUDES YOUR PERCEPTION OF EVENTS)ANY EVENT)==
(YOU YOU CAN MAKE A MISTAKE ON DETERNIMING WHAT WAS A MESSAGE FROM THE HOLY SPIRIT AND WHAT WAS YOUR OWN MIND> IT IS POSSIBLE FOR YOU TO MAKE THAT ERROR) BESIDES YOUR REFERNECE BOOK THAT WAS MADE BY MAN HAS ERRORS)
==So which Christians are not saved?==
Those who do not align themselves with the Word of God.(HOW DO YOU KNOW HWO HANST ALIGNED THEMSELVES. THE BIBILE SAY THAT FOR GO SO LOVED THE WORLD THAT HE GAVE HIS ONLY BEGOTTEN SON THAT WHOSOEVER BEIVES IN HIM SHAT NOT PERISH BUT HAVE EVERLASTING LIFE JOHN 3:16. IT SAYS NOTHING ABOUT CHRISTINAS ALIGNIN THEM SELVES WITH THE BIBILE. TAT ID YOUR INTERPRETATION AGAIN.
NOW YOU CLAIM SPECIAL MYSTICAL POWERS:
== Since you have this knowing power…==
God promised us this Power. It comes through the Word of God.
==… (Which you really only believe)==
My belief is based on facts to which you have no access.
FACTS YOU CANT PROVE AND YOU BELIEVE IN AND YOU BELIEVE I CANT ACCESS.) :)
Posted by: Shaye | April 15, 2009, 5:20 pm 5:20 pm
Mr. Incredible you gave a good debate in the begining but now youre in Marvel Comics. Youre Mr. Incredible LOL
Posted by: Shaye | April 15, 2009, 5:22 pm 5:22 pm
MArvel Comics could produce a movie bigger than Iron Man. with all of your powers. Call it the Mr. Incredible!! He has the super power to know if you are going to Hell and to tell 2billion Christains they are wrong. His sidekeck is the Holy Spirit and he makes no miskaes when determining his mind or the Holy Spirits. He has one weakness. He fights in Circles. His head is alaways spinnning from his circular reasonging and he fights an invisible opponent he cant see. Up up and awayyyyyy!! MR. Incredible LOL
Posted by: Shaye | April 15, 2009, 5:27 pm 5:27 pm
==Mr Incredible IS THE ONLY CHRIATISN WHO HAS INTEPRETED THE BIBILE CORRECTLY…==
Not the only one.
== AND GOD HAS GIVEN HIM THE MYSTICAL POWER TO KNOW WHICH OTHER CHRISTIANS ARE GOING TO HELL.==
I never said that God gave me the mystical power to know which other Christians are going to hell. I know only what the Word of God says, that those who are not aligned with God, through Christ, are not saved.
== THIS IS OUTRAGEOUS>==
The Devil think so, too.
==/==/== DO YOU MAKE MISTAKES?)==
Since I am not God, I make mistakes in unrighteousness. However, Christ makes me Righteous. In Righteousness, I let the Holy Spirit do the interpreting of the Word of God. The Holy Spirit is 100% accurate.
(SO YOU CAN ERROR IN YOUR MISTAKES AND THAT INCLUDES YOUR PERCEPTION OF EVENTS)ANY EVENT)==
(YOU YOU CAN MAKE A MISTAKE ON DETERNIMING WHAT WAS A MESSAGE FROM THE HOLY SPIRIT AND WHAT WAS YOUR OWN MIND>==
That would be true in my unrighteous self. In my Righteous self, it is not true.
== IT IS POSSIBLE FOR YOU TO MAKE THAT ERROR)==
That would be true in my unrighteous self. In my Righteous self, it is not true.
== BESIDES YOUR REFERNECE BOOK THAT WAS MADE BY MAN HAS ERRORS)==
The Word of God has no errors.
==/==So which Christians are not saved?==
Those who do not align themselves with the Word of God.(HOW DO YOU KNOW HWO HANST ALIGNED THEMSELVES.==
(1Jn 4:1) Beloved, believe not every spirit, but try the spirits whether they are of God: because many false prophets are gone out into the world.
== THE BIBILE SAY THAT FOR GO SO LOVED THE WORLD THAT HE GAVE HIS ONLY BEGOTTEN SON THAT WHOSOEVER BEIVES IN HIM SHAT NOT PERISH BUT HAVE EVERLASTING LIFE JOHN 3:16. IT SAYS NOTHING ABOUT CHRISTINAS ALIGNIN THEM SELVES WITH THE BIBILE.==
Yes, He does.
== TAT ID YOUR INTERPRETATION AGAIN.==
No, it’s God’s interpretation.
==NOW YOU CLAIM SPECIAL MYSTICAL POWERS…==
I claim what God, through Christ, has promised me.
==/==…: Since you have this knowing power…==
God promised us this Power. It comes through the Word of God.
==… (Which you really only believe)==
My belief is based on facts to which you have no access.
FACTS YOU CANT PROVE…==
I provided proof. It’s just that you won’t receive.
==… YOU BELIEVE I CANT ACCESS.) :)==
God tells me that people like you don’t have access to His Mysteries.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | April 15, 2009, 5:32 pm 5:32 pm
==Mr. Incredible you gave a good debate in the begining but now youre in Marvel Comics.==
I’m sorry to see that you think the Word of God is comparable to a comic book. God will make note of it, for future reference.
== Youre Mr. Incredible==
Duh.
==MArvel Comics could produce a movie bigger than Iron Man. with all of your powers. Call it the Mr. Incredible!! He has the super power to know if you are going to Hell and to tell 2billion Christains they are wrong. His sidekeck is the Holy Spirit and he makes no miskaes when determining his mind or the Holy Spirits. He has one weakness. He fights in Circles. His head is alaways spinnning from his circular reasonging…==
Y’know, I already used that. Can’t you come up with your own original stuff??
Anywho…
==… and he fights an invisible opponent he cant see.==
God sees him, and that’s enough.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | April 15, 2009, 5:36 pm 5:36 pm
Mr Incredible
I want to Share with you. If you are still not in your comic book. I referenced a Christian Ministers Near Death Experience from http://www.near-death.com
A minister named Ken Martin who had a near-death experience. Upon his return from his experience, he discovered that everything he had previously known – his ministry, his calling, everything – was insignificant in comparison to his experience with the afterlife.
“Heaven is not about religious beliefs, but about spiritual actions. It is not true, as some people believe, that we get to heaven by giving verbal assent to belief in God. It is love, not religious doctrines, that creates spiritual growth. Religions are cultural institutions but love is universal. Those religions which claim superiority over other religions or exclude people for various reasons, go against God’s law to love others as we love ourselves. Although religion, in itself, is not important to God, all religions are necessary because there are people who need what they teach. For this reason, all religions are precious in the sight of God. All religions refer to the same God. All religions are different ways of trying to describe the same God. After death, if you insist upon searching for an old man on a throne as God, you will do this for awhile until you get the idea that you are following an illusion”.
Posted by: Shaye | April 15, 2009, 5:39 pm 5:39 pm
Christian Miniset Ken Martin “Knows” what he is talking about beacause of his personal experience when he died.
Posted by: Shaye | April 15, 2009, 5:42 pm 5:42 pm
I love to read thsese storeis of Near Death experiences on http://www.near-death.com. Please read a few and use the “Gift” of spiritual dicernment sn tell me what the “Holy Spirit” tells you. Please read Embraced by the Light by Christian Betty J. Eadie. You can read it on her website http://www.embracedbythelight.com. I really want your opinion.
Thank you!
Posted by: Shaye | April 15, 2009, 5:53 pm 5:53 pm
==If you are still not in your comic book.==
That’s YOUR gospel.
== I referenced a Christian Ministers Near Death Experience from http://www.near-death.com==
Another gospel.
==A minister named Ken Martin who had a near-death experience. Upon his return from his experience, he discovered that everything he had previously known – his ministry, his calling, everything – was insignificant in comparison to his experience with the afterlife.==
If he wasn’t dead, then he didn’t experience any “afterlife.”
==”Heaven is not about religious beliefs, but about spiritual actions.” ==
Except that, without the Word, there is no faith in God.
==”It is not true, as some people believe, that we get to heaven by giving verbal assent to belief in God.”==
So, Jesus is a “liar”????
==” It is love…”==
Worldly love?
==”… not religious doctrines…”==
Except that Jesus said that we must follow His doctrines.
==”… that creates spiritual growth.”==
Garbage gospel.
==” Religions are cultural institutions but love is universal.”==
Then, it oughta be abundant. Where is it?? How’s it doin’? Not very well, huh.
==” Those religions which claim superiority over other religions or exclude people for various reasons, go against God’s law to love others as we love ourselves.”==
No, they don’t, IF they do what Christ tells them to do: that is, to give the world the Message of God’s Reconciliation.
==” Although religion, in itself, is not important to God, all religions are necessary because there are people who need what they teach.”==
The teaching of Isalm is not important to me.
==” For this reason, all religions are precious in the sight of God.”==
No, they aren’t. Jesus, as God on Earth, said that He is the ONLY Way to the Father.
==” All religions refer to the same God.”==
Not scriptural. False teaching.
==” All religions are different ways of trying to describe the same God.”==
Not what Christ says.
==” After death, if you insist upon searching for an old man on a throne as God, you will do this for awhile until you get the idea that you are following an illusion”.==
False teaching.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | April 15, 2009, 6:00 pm 6:00 pm
First you say:
==I referenced a Christian Ministers Near Death Experience from http://www.near-death.com
A minister named Ken Martin who had a near-death experience. ==
Then, you say:
==Christian Miniset Ken Martin “Knows” what he is talking about beacause of his personal experience when he died.
==
Which is it?
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | April 15, 2009, 6:02 pm 6:02 pm
First you say:
==I referenced a Christian Ministers Near Death Experience from http://www.near-death.com
A minister named Ken Martin who had a near-death experience. ==
Then, you say:
==Christian Miniset Ken Martin “Knows” what he is talking about beacause of his personal experience when he died.
==
Which is it?
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | April 15, 2009, 6:02 pm 6:02 pm
==I love to read thsese storeis of Near Death experiences on http://www.near-death.com. ==
Of course you do. Anything to get you to stay away from the Word of God. The Devil is very pleased!
==Please read a few and use the “Gift” of spiritual dicernment sn tell me what the “Holy Spirit” tells you.==
The Holy Spirit tells me that it’s all c r a p.
== Please read Embraced by the Light by Christian Betty J. Eadie.==
No.
==I really want your opinion.==
My opinion coincides with the Word of God.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | April 15, 2009, 6:05 pm 6:05 pm
I tell you a little secret Mr Incredible I have been to the spirit world and back through Out of Body experiences. I know that there is God and it not the “old man” on the throne and we dont have the capacity to comprehend what that word really means. This is what I know through personal experience. We all survive the death of the physical body, we are all immortal spiritual beings. There are spiritual beings and many call them Angels. My feeling is that Jesus is the Christ and he came to show us how to love unconditionally. The lesson in life is unconditional love. I enjoy having these debates with you Mr. Incredible. I do know that God gives us the gifts of spiritual discernment and the reference point is unconditional love. I really just like to debate and I honor your beliefs. Nothing worng with asking a few questions to se where somebody is coming from :)
Posted by: Shaye | April 15, 2009, 6:09 pm 6:09 pm
Your reliance on the bible has somehwat blinded your possibity of a personal experience of the spirit world and of God. I believe in my personal experience in the Unconditiona love of GOD and Christ over your religious doctorines. The certainty of my experience outrules you belief and interpretation of my experience.
Posted by: Shaye | April 15, 2009, 6:14 pm 6:14 pm
==I am Saved. ==
(Joh 8:31) Then said Jesus to those Jews which believed on him, If ye continue in my word, then are ye my disciples indeed;
(Joh 15:9) As the Father hath loved me, so have I loved you: continue ye in my love.
[So, to contiue in His Word is to continue in His Love.]
(Rom 11:22) Behold therefore the goodness and severity of God: on them which fell, severity; but toward thee, goodness, if thou continue in his goodness: otherwise thou also shalt be cut off.
(1Ti 4:16) Take heed unto thyself, and unto the doctrine; continue in them: for in doing this thou shalt both save thyself, and them that hear thee.
(2Ti 3:14) But continue thou in the things which thou hast learned and hast been assured of, knowing of whom thou hast learned them;
(1Jn 2:24) Let that therefore abide in you, which ye have heard from the beginning. If that which ye have heard from the beginning shall remain in you, ye also shall continue in the Son, and in the Father.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | April 15, 2009, 6:14 pm 6:14 pm
You only have Religious belief system not a “spiritual” known system through experience. Have some and then we can talk. :)
Posted by: Shaye | April 15, 2009, 6:18 pm 6:18 pm
==I have been to the spirit world and back through Out of Body experiences.==
Garbage.
== I know that there is God…==
He is known ONLY through His Word, Christ.
==… and it not the “old man” on the throne and we dont have the capacity to comprehend what that word really means.==
He says that we do. I believe Him.
== This is what I know through personal experience.==
What you THINK is experience.
== We all survive the death of the physical body, we are all immortal spiritual beings.==
Not what God says. It’s what the Devil says. The Devil promises eternal life, regardless of what you believe. That is his message in the Garden, to Eve.
== There are spiritual beings and many call them Angels.==
There are angels of darkness, yes. They aren’t mine, though. They may be yours, and you’ll have the chance to explain that when you appear before God’s Judgment Bar.
== My feeling is that Jesus is the Christ and he came to show us how to love unconditionally.==
What IS that “love”? He says it’s the Message, His Words.
== The lesson in life is unconditional love.==
Whose “love”?
==I do know that God gives us the gifts of spiritual discernment…==
Accessible only throught the Word.
==… and the reference point is unconditional love.==
Does God love evil? Is that unconditional, too? Did Jesus love the Devil in the wilderness, or anywhere else?
(Rom 1:18) For the wrath of God is revealed from heaven against all ungodliness and unrighteousness of men, who hold the truth in unrighteousness;
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | April 15, 2009, 6:22 pm 6:22 pm
==You only have Religious belief system not a “spiritual” known system through experience. Have some and then we can talk…==
I’m not interesrted in another gospel.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | April 15, 2009, 6:22 pm 6:22 pm
==Your reliance on the bible has somehwat blinded your possibity of a personal experience of the spirit world and of God.==
The Word of God has opened my eyes! I WAS blind, and now I see!
== I believe in my personal experience in the Unconditiona love of GOD and Christ over your religious doctorines.==
I have no “religious ” principles since “religion,” like Islam, is a tradition of men. It is performance and external. Christianity is internal and not performance-based.
== The certainty of my experience…==
The “certainty” of which you persuaded yourself.
==… outrules you belief…==
God says, “No, it doesn’t!”
==… and interpretation of my experience. ==
So, it’s “interpretation” of what you say is your experience, not your experience. I wish you’d make up your mind.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | April 15, 2009, 6:27 pm 6:27 pm
“The certainty of my experience outweights your belief” So no matter what verses you use with your circular reasoning with the Bibile, and your personal beliefs aka opinions which are not experiential knowns carry little or no weight. Its been fun Mr. Incredible.
Posted by: Shaye | April 15, 2009, 6:27 pm 6:27 pm
Again…
First you say:
==I referenced a Christian Ministers Near Death Experience from http://www.near-death.com
A minister named Ken Martin who had a near-death experience. ==
Then, you say:
==Christian Miniset Ken Martin “Knows” what he is talking about beacause of his personal experience when he died.
==
Which is it? Was it near-death, or death?
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | April 15, 2009, 6:28 pm 6:28 pm
==”The certainty of my experience outweights your belief”
So no matter what verses you use with your circular reasoning …==
Mine is not circular reasoning. Your head is just spinning…outta control, too.
==…with the Bibile…==
God confirms that I am on the right track, not you.
==… and your personal beliefs aka opinions which are not experiential …==
But they ARE!
==…knowns carry little or no weight. ==
That’s cuz, in order to justify your “beliefs” to yourself, you gotta deny the Power of God. It’s a mind trick suggested by the Devil.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | April 15, 2009, 6:31 pm 6:31 pm
Im not expecting you or trying to make you believe me. I could care less. I know what I know and you believe what you believe. Just know that I have a love for you that goes beyond this deabte. I love you beacuse you exist, you are a sentient human being. It doens’t matter what you do in the shor lifetime or what you believe nothing could ever make me want to punish you much less send you to hell. My love would not allow that. Its unconditional.
Posted by: Shaye | April 15, 2009, 6:32 pm 6:32 pm
You have a form of godliness:
(2Ti 3:5) Having a form of godliness, but denying the power thereof: from such turn away.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | April 15, 2009, 6:32 pm 6:32 pm
I love you Mr. Incredible.
Posted by: Shaye | April 15, 2009, 6:33 pm 6:33 pm
I pray that the love of God and Christ will fill every ounce of your being and bless you and your family 1000 fold. In the name of Jesus Christ.
Posted by: Shaye | April 15, 2009, 6:35 pm 6:35 pm
==Im not expecting you or trying to make you believe me. I could care less.==
You mean, “I couldn’t care less.”
== I know what I know…==
You say you think you know what you choose to imagein that you choose to think you know.
==…and you believe what you believe. ==
My beliefs are based on the facts of God through Christ.
==Just know that I have a love for you that goes beyond this deabte. I love you beacuse you exist, you are a sentient human being.==
Did you dream that love up? Did you create it? What Morality created that love?
== It doens’t matter what you do in the shor lifetime or what you believe nothing could ever make me want to punish you much less send you to hell. ==
You don’t have that power anyway.
==My love would not allow that. Its unconditional.==
Do you love the Devil? Did Jesus love the Devil?
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | April 15, 2009, 6:36 pm 6:36 pm
==I love you Mr. Incredible.==
It’s not a Godly love.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | April 15, 2009, 6:36 pm 6:36 pm
==I pray that the love of God and Christ will fill every ounce of your being and bless you and your family 1000 fold. In the name of Jesus Christ.==
Already done.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | April 15, 2009, 6:37 pm 6:37 pm
Man if you had any personal issues broken down, needed some extra help, or a place to stay(temporararily), needed help to find a job(I am a Recruiter)you call me in a minute. If you needed someone to have a fun deabte with I am the person. Do I deny your experince no. Do I give you a hard time about your beliefs yes. in the end man is the love you give yourself, your family and your friends that matters. You can share your bliefs and even bring them to your church but dont forget to love them. Thank you, Mr Incredible
Posted by: Shaye | April 15, 2009, 6:39 pm 6:39 pm
If I speak in the tongues of mortals and of angels, but do not have love, I am a noisy gong or a clanging cymbal. And if I have prophetic powers, and understand all mysteries and all knowledge, and if I have all faith, so as to remove mountains, but do not have love, I am nothing. (1 Cor. 13:1-2, NRSV)
Posted by: Shaye | April 15, 2009, 6:41 pm 6:41 pm
1 Peter 4:8
Above all, love each other deeply, because love covers over a multitude of sins. (NIV)
1 John 3:16
This is how we know what love is: Jesus Christ laid down his life for us. And we ought to lay down our lives for our brothers. (NIV)
1 John 3:18
Dear children, let us not love with words or tongue but with actions and in truth. (NIV)
1 John 4:8
Whoever does not love does not know God, because God is love. (NIV)
1 John 4:18
There is no fear in love. But perfect love drives out fear, because fear has to do with punishment. The one who fears is not made perfect in love
And so there remain Faith, Hope, Love–these three; and of these the greatest is Love.
Posted by: Shaye | April 15, 2009, 6:45 pm 6:45 pm
I have faith in the love of GOD and Christ.
Posted by: Shaye | April 15, 2009, 6:47 pm 6:47 pm
God is love. We experience God’s love and we share God love through our loving actions.
Posted by: Shaye | April 15, 2009, 6:52 pm 6:52 pm
==God is love.==
Without the Word, how do you know?
== We experience God’s love…==
How do you know it’s God’s love if you don’t have the Word of God Who He sent?
==… and we share God love through our loving actions.==
Which are…?
Are these “loving actions” based on OUR ideas of “love,” or His ideas of “love”?
the “love” you’ve advocated here isn’t biblical love, rather worldly love, cuz you have said that you reject the Word.
God so loved the world THAT — THAT — He gave His only, begotten Son; and we know that His Son is Jesus and He is the Word in the flesh.
So, God loved the world so much THAT He gave the world His Word — Christ [read also Genesis 1:3, John 1:9 and 1 John 2:8]. The Word is Christ, and, so, when we love, we give Light, Christ — that is, the Word Which is the true Light, God’s Love.
So, one day a few years ago, I was in a Bible study and people were talking about “love” and not defining it, and this became a problem for me cuz I knew that it couldn’t be worldly love, what we, in unrighteousness, think is love cuz that love changes from second to second and person to person. So, I thought that it had to be something else, a higher standard.
I looked in a paperback book sized Bible dictionary for “love,” just to get started, and it says, “unselfish concern.” “Unselfish concern” for what, I asked myself rhetorically. Then, I connected the Message of God, through Christ, and I came up with “unselfish concern for the Salvation of others, as much concern for their Salvation as I have for my own [love your neighbor as yourself, and do unto others as you would have them...].” That fits the Christ Message and what He wants us to do. He wants us to send God’s Love — the Word and true Light — into the world cuz God loves it so much and so do we. His Love has nothing to do with worldly, unrighteous love.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | April 16, 2009, 3:31 am 3:31 am
==in the end man is the love you give yourself, your family and your friends that matters.==
And, yet, you still fail to define “love,” as God and Christ understand it. Above, I’ve given a working definition that fits with Christ.
== You can share your bliefs…==
What, about another gospel like “near-death” experiences?
==…and even bring them to your church but dont forget to love them.==
Love them by understanding that “love” is defined, biblically, how, and by doing what, biblically?
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | April 16, 2009, 3:36 am 3:36 am
==I have faith in the love of GOD and Christ.==
Not without the Word. Heb 4:2 KJV
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | April 16, 2009, 3:37 am 3:37 am
==If I speak in the tongues of mortals and of angels, but do not have love, I am a noisy gong or a clanging cymbal. And if I have prophetic powers, and understand all mysteries and all knowledge, and if I have all faith, so as to remove mountains, but do not have love, I am nothing. (1 Cor. 13:1-2, NRSV) ==
This along with the following post gives us not one peek into a definition of “love.” All you give is verses that talk ABOUT “love,” not what it IS. The Holy Spirit gives insight, and it is this insight that would go beyond mere quoting to summarizing and telling us what biblical “love” is. A summarization, as that which I gave, would show that you hve a knowledge of the Word that goes beyond mere memorization of the Word, or the ability to go grab a verse here and there and post it, thinking that that is all it takes. It takes more than mere words on a page, rather the mystery of God hidden therein, and only those born again have access to those mysteries.
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | April 16, 2009, 3:47 am 3:47 am
==God is love.==
Without the Word, how do you know?
(I HAVE PERSONALLY EXPERIENCED GODS LOVE)
== We experience God’s love…==
How do you know it’s God’s love if you don’t have the Word of God Who He sent?
(I HAVE SEEN THE BIBILE AND IT DOES HAVE REFERENCES TO GODS LOVE)
==… and we share God love through our loving actions.==
Which are…?
(LOVING YOUR NEIGHBOR AS YOURSELF)
Are these “loving actions” based on OUR ideas of “love,” or His ideas of “love”?
(IS BASED ON THE LOVE OF GOD THAT ONE EXPERINCES WITHIN HIS BEING)
the “love” you’ve advocated here isn’t biblical love, rather worldly love, cuz you have said that you reject the Word.
(I NEVER SAID I REJECT THE WORLD OF GOD. I REJECT YOUR INTERPREATION OF THE BIBILE)
God so loved the world THAT — THAT — He gave His only, begotten Son; and we know that His Son is Jesus and He is the Word in the flesh.
(I BELIVE THAT AND I AM SAVED)
So, God loved the world so much THAT He gave the world His Word — Christ [read also Genesis 1:3, John 1:9 and 1 John 2:8]. The Word is Christ, and, so, when we love, we give Light, Christ — that is, the Word Which is the true Light, God’s Love.
(MY SALVATION IS NOT DEPENDENT ON HEARING ANYTHING ELSE OR BELIVEING ANYTHING ELSE OTHER THAN JOHN 3:16)
So, one day a few years ago, I was in a Bible study and people were talking about “love” and not defining it, and this became a problem for me cuz I knew that it couldn’t be worldly love, what we, in unrighteousness, think is love cuz that love changes from second to second and person to person. So, I thought that it had to be something else, a higher standard.
I looked in a paperback book sized Bible dictionary for “love,” just to get started, and it says, “unselfish concern.” “Unselfish concern” for what, I asked myself rhetorically. Then, I connected the Message of God, through Christ, and I came up with “unselfish concern for the Salvation of others, as much concern for their Salvation as I have for my own [love your neighbor as yourself, and do unto others as you would have them...].” That fits the Christ Message and what He wants us to do. He wants us to send God’s Love — the Word and true Light — into the world cuz God loves it so much and so do we. His Love has nothing to do with worldly, unrighteous love.
(I AGREE AND I HAVE AN UNSELFISH CONCERN AND I DO MY BEST TO LOVE MY NEIGHBOR AS MYSELF-NO ARGUMENT HERE)
Posted by: Mr. Incredible | Apr 16, 2009 3:31:15 AM
==in the end man is the love you give yourself, your family and your friends that matters.==
And, yet, you still fail to define “love,” as God and Christ understand it. Above, I’ve given a working definition that fits with Christ.
(I AGREE AND I HAVE AN UNSELFISH CONCERN AND I DO MY BEST TO LOVE MY NEIGHBOR AS MYSELF-NO ARGUMENT HERE)
== You can share your bliefs…==
What, about another gospel like “near-death” experiences?
(NEAR DEATH EXPERICNES ARE OTHER PEOPLES NEAR DEATH EXPERIENCES NOT A “GOSPEL” SPAEKIN OF DO YOU KNOW WHO WROTE THE GOSPELS?
==…and even bring them to your church but dont forget to love them.==
Love them by understanding that “love” is defined, biblically, how, and by doing what, biblically?
AN UNSELFISH CONCERN AND I DO MY BEST TO LOVE MY NEIGHBOR AS MYSELF-NO ARGUMENT HERE.)
I GUESS WE AGREE ON WHATS GODS LOVE. AN UNSELFISH CONCERN AND LOVEING YOUR NEIGHBORS AS YOURSELF.
I STILL DISAGREE WITH YOUR PRIVATE PERCIEDE INTERPETATION FO THE BIBILE THAT WS CREATED BY MAN.
I AGREE WITH YOU ON THE LOVE OF GOD.
Posted by: Shaye | April 16, 2009, 9:43 am 9:43 am
I DISAGREE WITH YOU AND I KNOW THAT THE BIBILE HASS ERRORS, YOU ARE A FALLIABLE HUMAN SO YOU CAN MISINTERPRET YOUR OWN PRIVATE NTERPRETATION AND EVEN YOUR BELIEF THAT THE HOLY SPIRIT ALLOWS YOU TO INTEPRET AND CHANGE THE MEANINGS OF THE BIBILE TO FIT YOUR OWN BELIEFS. SO YOUR TRUTH CAN BE ABOUT AS FLUID AS YOU CAN COME UP WITH MEANINGS OF THE WORDS WHICH IS RELATIVISISM. IM NOT BUYING YOUR BELIFS THAT YOU GAINED FROM THE KJV or BOOK.
Posted by: Shaye | April 16, 2009, 9:48 am 9:48 am
==If I speak in the tongues of mortals and of angels, but do not have love, I am a noisy gong or a clanging cymbal. And if I have prophetic powers, and understand all mysteries and all knowledge, and if I have all faith, so as to remove mountains, but do not have love, I am nothing. (1 Cor. 13:1-2, NRSV) ==
This along with the following post gives us not one peek into a definition of “love.” All you give is verses that talk ABOUT “love,” not what it IS. The Holy Spirit gives insight, and it is this insight that would go beyond mere quoting to summarizing and telling us what biblical “love” is. A summarization, as that which I gave, would show that you hve a knowledge of the Word that goes beyond mere memorization of the Word, or the ability to go grab a verse here and there and post it, thinking that that is all it takes. It takes more than mere words on a page, rather the mystery of God hidden therein, and only those born again have access to those mysteries.
(THIS IS YOUR ANALYSIS PRESUMTIVE BELEIFS)
Posted by: Shaye | April 16, 2009, 9:50 am 9:50 am
I looked in a paperback book sized Bible dictionary for “love,” just to get started, and it says, “unselfish concern.” “Unselfish concern” for what, I asked myself rhetorically. Then, I connected the Message of God, through Christ, and I came up with “unselfish concern for the Salvation of others, as much concern for their Salvation as I have for my own [love your neighbor as yourself, and do unto others as you would have them...].” That fits the Christ Message and what He wants us to do. He wants us to send God’s Love — the Word and true Light — into the world cuz God loves it so much and so do we. His Love has nothing to do with worldly, unrighteous love.
I HAVE AN UNSELFHS CONCERN FOR OTHERS SALVATION. I JUST DISAGREE WITH YOUR PRIVATE INTERPRETATION OF HOW ONE GETS SAVED. ITS CLEAR IN JOHN 3:16. WHO EVER BELEIVES IN HIM NOT WHO BELIEVS IN THE KJV BIBILE. JESUS EXISTED BEFORE THE BIBILE> THERE WERE THOS WHO BELIEVED IN HIM BEFORE THE BIBILE SO THEREFORE ONE CAN BE SAVED WITHOUT THE BIBILE. ONCE AN WORSHIP WITHOUT THE BIBILE AND ONE COULD WATCH AN HISTORY CHANNNELD DOCUMANTARY ON THE LIFE OF JESUS OR HAVE A PERSONAL ENCOUNTER LIKE THE APOSTLE PAUL AND BELIEVE IN JESUS CHRIST.
Posted by: Shaye | April 16, 2009, 9:54 am 9:54 am
SO YOUR BIBILIODOLATRY MR INCREDIBLE is BECOMING VERY APPARENT.
Posted by: Shaye | April 16, 2009, 9:56 am 9:56 am
I CHOSE TO HAVE AN UNSELFISH CONCERN AND TO DO UNTO OTHERS AND I WOULD DO UNTO MYSLEF. YOU SIT IN THE THONE OF GOD AND JUDGE PEOPLE BASED ON YOUR BELIIEFS. YOU SAY YOU “KNOW” WHO WILL BE SAVED AND WHO WILL NOT. THATIS BETWEEN GOD AND THE INDIVIDUAL. YOU SAY THAT 2 BILLIONS CHRISTIANS ARE WRONG AND YOU ARE THE ONLY ONE TO GET IT RIGHT. I THINK YOU WILL HAVE SOME ANSWERING TO DO WITH GOD.
Posted by: Shaye | April 16, 2009, 10:03 am 10:03 am
THE BIBILE WAS CREATED AT THE COUNCIL OF NICEA AROUND 325 AD. HISTORIANS SAY JESUS LIVES HUNDRED OF YEARS BEFORE THAT. PEOPLE WHO HEARD AND HAD FAITH IN JESUS SAVING POWER BEFORE THE BIBILE I BELIEVE ARE SAVED. THERE IS NO REQUIREMENT TO BELEIVE IN OR THE LETTERS IN A BIBILE. THATS RELIGION.
Posted by: Shaye | April 16, 2009, 10:06 am 10:06 am
YOU BELIVE LOVE IS PRESENTING RELIGIOUS PERSONAL PRESUMTPIVE BELIEFS AND GETTING OTHERS TO AGREE WITH YOUR PERSONAL PRESUMTIVE BELIEFS. I DONT BELEIVE THAT IS LOVE. THAT IS EGO.
Posted by: Shaye | April 16, 2009, 10:09 am 10:09 am
SO SATAN IS a PART OF A BELIEF SYSTEM.
Posted by: shaye | April 16, 2009, 6:22 pm 6:22 pm
IT IS A MATTER OF BELIEF AND I HONOR EVERYONE’S BELIEFS.
Posted by: shaye | April 16, 2009, 6:24 pm 6:24 pm
MEANING I DONT CARE YOU IF YOU BELIEVE EITHER WAY.
Posted by: shaye | April 16, 2009, 6:25 pm 6:25 pm
My love would not allow that. Its unconditional.==
Do you love the Devil? Did Jesus love the Devil?
(FIRST OF ALL HOW CAN I UNCONDITIONALLY LOVE SOMETHING LIKE THE DEVIL THAT I DON’T BELIEVE EXISTS. I CANT. DO LOVE THE TOOTH FAIRY? LOL HOW CAN YOU KNOW WHATS WAS INSIDE OF JESUS’ MIND-YOU CAN’T-YOU ARE NOT JESUS AND THERE IS NO PERSONAL MANUSCRIPT THAT EXISTS(THAT ANYONE KNOWS OF)WHERE JESUS WROTE DOWN EVERY SINGLE ONE OF HIS THOUGHTS AND THE KJV or any BIBLE DOESN’T HAVE ANY OF HIS (JESUS) OWN PERSONAL WRITINGS SO YOU HAVE NO PROOF YOU MERELY BELIEVE THAT WHAT YOU BELIEVE WITHOUT EVIDENCE AND YOU CAN BELIEVE WHAT YOU WANT MR. INCREDIBLE.
Posted by: shaye | April 17, 2009, 4:49 am 4:49 am
WHY DO YOU BELIEVE SO MUCH IN THE BIBLE?
Posted by: shaye | April 18, 2009, 5:06 pm 5:06 pm
Someone on this blog said that Satan wasn’t mentioned once in the Old Testament. Try the book of Job, chapter 1 verses 6 thru 12 for starters. Since you have to admit your were wrong on this, you must acknowlege that you could be wrong about the origins and reality of Satan. I don’t mean to seem combative. That won’t solve anything. But I don’t mind gently challenging your world view, and if you commit yourself to the study of the bible, then if it doesn’t change your position, at least you will be better informed when arriving at your conclusions. May God help you.
Posted by: George | June 19, 2009, 12:35 am 12:35 am
Dear Ladies and Gentlemen, there is no Heaven or Hell. When we die we will go to sleep and we will sleep for eternity. Your body goes back to the dust. When God drove Adam and Eve out of the Garden of Eden he told them, from dust you came and dust you shall return. In 1915 the world’s population was just 1.8 Billion people. In 2009 the world’s population is 6.8 Billion people. In the past 94 years the world’s population has increased by 5 Billion people. That’s only one lifetime. In 500 years that will be 25 Billion people. If there is poverty, starvation, global warming and a hole in the ozone layer now, what do you think it will be like in 500 years? Man is literally destroying the earth and himself by over populating. Save your generations from suffering a miserable and horrible end. Stop creating and if you have children tell them when they grow up not to create. Please help spread this message to the entire world.
Posted by: Jesus Christ | August 30, 2009, 1:24 pm 1:24 pm
I saw a dog with a bible and I asked said “hey dog, where are you going?”
Dog responded, “to church my friend. I would not like to go to hell you know.”
So then at that moment I started to believed in god and the devil…..and at the same time christ appeared before me and said Santa Claus would be coming to my home with gifts…
Posted by: esmith | September 18, 2009, 10:09 pm 10:09 pm
==========================
Jesus made it very clear – Satan does exist
==========================
And for all those who dabble in contacting the dead, ghosts or spirit guides, there is a universal experience – when you become a Christian, all these spiritual entities reveal themselves to be demonic.
Posted by: N Waff | April 5, 2010, 8:09 pm 8:09 pm