By David Schoetz

Mar 17, 2009 10:58pm

Closing Arguments: Risking YOUR Own AIG

From taxing those big bonuses to simply taking them back, the race is to find a way to punish AIG executives who have needed billions from taxpayers just to stay afloat. But some financial experts are waving a yellow flag of caution — reminding the public that an attack on AIG is an attack on a company they own 80 percent of. So tonight, we ask you: Would you like to see the bonuses recouped at any cost? Even if it renders AIG incapable of paying back their bailout? Tell us what you think. And follow "Nightline" on Twitter: http://twitter.com/Nightline

User Comments

How to stop AIG’s bonuses. Will this work?
“How to Stop AIG’s Bonuses”
http://accuracy.org/newsrelease.php?articleId=1949

Posted by: Konstantin | March 17, 2009, 11:14 pm 11:14 pm

I think the American people are starting to wake up. It’s not just the AIG bonuses, they are starting to understand that they’ve been had, that’s why the cover up. That all this bailout money has been going out of the country to pay off AIG claims. That they have been lied to, and that there is no end in sight. AIG owes trillions in claims out of the country.That the American tax payer is paying off on high risk bets that other countries made and AIG insured those bets.These bailouts have to stop NOW !!! Next Washington will sound like a gambler who won’t stop when he’s loseing, they will say they can’t stop, they need to win there money back. And we all know how that doesn’t work.
Ex Republican

Posted by: RGeier | March 17, 2009, 11:24 pm 11:24 pm

How sad that the people receiving the bonuses aren’t willing to step forward and refuse the money during such an economic crisis. Isn’t that what community is about, taking care of each other in time of need. Carolyn Shawgo

Posted by: Carolyn Shawgo | March 17, 2009, 11:28 pm 11:28 pm

I am choked up with anger here.
– President Obama,
========
Phony.
It’s your own yet another boneheaded mistake, now that you pretend choking up. Who the hell gave them the bailout to begin with? Did not your House just claimed you are confident you knew where the AIG bailout money went?
Did not you read what you signed off that AIG contracts will be honored? Now you pretend to be choked up. Perhaps you should follow Grassley’s model and do the right thing – apologize and resign. Joe Biden won’t make your inexperienced incompetent boneheaded mistakes.

Posted by: white flags | March 17, 2009, 11:46 pm 11:46 pm

I don’t want the bonuses recouped at any cost until someone shows me a real live person with a real name and a real contract who didn’t do what he agreed to do for the money he was offered. It’s fine to assume that each of these bonus recipients personally wrote the CDS contract that ate Cleveland, but that’s because assuming beats the heck out of thinking.
Barney Frank says the American taxpayers should start acting like owners. Only owners decide who they need and pay them bonuses to sign on and stay in rough times. At least that’s what smart owners do, but Barney didn’t say we had to behave like smart owners. He and Sen. Dodd and that idiot Grassley – we’re talking bipartisan cluelessness here – want to scuttle their ship so that the captain won’t get paid. Smart. Real smart.
It’s nice that ABC news has figured out that the government may be shooting itself in the foot. That was, of course, obvious yesterday, but yesterday the “news” was that people were angry. Today, the news is that angry people do dumb things. Where would we be without our journalists? Maybe tomorrow you folks will figure out that a retroactive 100% income tax is more properly called a “fine,” and ought, one would think, to follow a trial for commission of a crime.
The Constitution has this nonsense about ex post facto laws and bills of attainder, but it’s in Latin and archaic English, so we can probably ignore it. I mean, any stick is good enough to beat these dogs, right?

Posted by: Lawrence J Kramer | March 17, 2009, 11:49 pm 11:49 pm

How sad and dispicable that the people who ensured that the AIG bonuses were “protected” in the Stimulus Package (elected representatives each one) aren’t willing to be honest with the American People and admit what they did. Instead, like hypocrits, they are SCREAMING about AIG and its execs.
Let’s see: Dodd inserted the provision in the Stimulus Bill that allowed AIG to provide the bonuses. Dodd was also the #1 beneficiary of AIG political donations in 2008. I’d like to recover every penny AIG gave to Dodd from Dodd’s personal wealth. Also want him to rebate his Senator’s salary for 2008-09.
President Obama rushed to sign the Stimulus Bill into law with the Dodd AIG bonus provision. In 2008, then Sen. Obama was the #2 or #3 biggest beneficiary of AIG political contributions. The taxpayer should get back every penny of the AIG donations paid to Pres. Obama. Pres Obama should also pay a 100% personal income tax for 2009.
No More Bailouts Designed by our Crooked Elected Reps!!!

Posted by: Voter2Be | March 17, 2009, 11:55 pm 11:55 pm

I feel if bonuses are to be given, they should come out of money that the COMPANY earns, not get their million dollar bonuses from our taxpayer money! When my employees get bonuses, it comes out of MY pocket!

Posted by: Robin Mattson | March 17, 2009, 11:58 pm 11:58 pm

Sure!! I say give AIG the money and let them toss it out anyway they want-like last time!!

Posted by: Suzannaquanashawn | March 18, 2009, 12:03 am 12:03 am

Let the IRS go after them. That way AIG can “honor its contracts”, the government doesn’t tell a company what to do and the greedy employees can give back to the taxpayers. Funny how the company had to pay bonuses to keep the best talent…some of whom have now left after getting their money. Greed is disgusting, and we are all guilty. The difference is having a conscience — or the lack of it.
– Houston, TX

Posted by: ocay | March 18, 2009, 12:11 am 12:11 am

“So tonight, we ask you: Would you like to see the bonuses recouped at any cost? Even if it renders AIG incapable of paying back their bailout?”
Who are you trying to fool? AIG probably won’t be able to “pay back their bailout” and if we don’t have to sink another $50 billion to keep it afloat long enough to break it up and sell it off, I’ll be shocked.
http://moronmeter.com

Posted by: I'm With Stupid | March 18, 2009, 12:14 am 12:14 am

I am very surprise with the Republican’s response. Republicans are equally responsible when AIG tricked America. Nobody from Republicans approached Mr. Geithner before the damage was done. Any body can scream after the damages is done.

Posted by: JS | March 18, 2009, 12:14 am 12:14 am

That Joe Cassano that you quoted and showed his picture as a financial advisor of AIG in 2007, who was saying there was no reason to belive they would lose even $1, was then and still is being paid $1 Million a month by AIG!! t\This is equally as bad as the $165 million in bonuses and you need to publicize it.

Posted by: Jack Hudson | March 18, 2009, 12:16 am 12:16 am

This makes me so angry! I can’t believe after the 1st bailout money was sent to AIG and they spent it on a lavish party that they are receiving more money. There are so many people out there loosing jobs, homes etc and these people well what can one say? When is the american public going to get mad enough, when are we going to say enough is enough? we are expected to cut back on basic necessities, watch our spending, pay our bills but i do not see these big companies going on a budget unless it involves cutting jobs, why not cut these big salaried jobs and make the CEO answer his own phone, get his own coffee and type his own memos? We have our insurance with AIG and I can tell you this they WILL NOT be receiving our premium payment for April 09, if i have to send the the government more tax money for their foolish spending ways i am going to make a mature decision regarding my budget something has to go i will not support them anylonger voluntarily anyway, I have had enough, i am cancelling them and finding someone else.

Posted by: T.Jones | March 18, 2009, 12:21 am 12:21 am

I also think that AIG should take care of themselves now at least further bleeding will be stopped. If the recovering is costing more than the cost of company that do not create jobs and use bailout money is used to pay the creditors who are sacking people every month.

Posted by: JS | March 18, 2009, 12:23 am 12:23 am

If the people in our government does take back the bonuses then watch out they will come after everyone’s else. This is a slippery slope that will come back to haunt the rest for the public and businessses. Just think of the exorbite profit tax they want to put on companies. What next? The people in congerss several years back should have to pay back this because they were the main reason for all of this mess.

Posted by: Charles Parker | March 18, 2009, 12:27 am 12:27 am

Thanks to Nightline for again not reporting the “meat” of the story, but simply presenting fodder for anger without cause, or moreso without “digging into” the story beyone the surface. Ever heard of a politician named Dodd? Why doesn’t anyone mention Obama as having known anything about this? Isn’t he the smartest man in the room?

Posted by: BJH | March 18, 2009, 12:47 am 12:47 am

Sounds like more lies, just to keep everyone off AIG’s back…
Get the money back and let them dig themselves out of the hole they dug … we don’t need to bail anymore CEO’s, big businesses or wallstreet any more…
There is alot more to this story that is not being told… maybe the government has something to do with this… but there is more to this
And AIG should not get that 30 Billion dollars that was committed to them… they ruined it when they gave out those bonuses.

Posted by: lm | March 18, 2009, 12:52 am 12:52 am

Something just isn’t right! Why do the big whigs get rewarded for their wrong doing ? This is putting us all back to slavery ! Think about it, They’re giving them a bailout, now they are hoarding it. You can’t even get a loan even in your hometown. We had to go 1 state south to get one. Pitiful!

Posted by: Vicki | March 18, 2009, 12:55 am 12:55 am

Don’t blame the execs of AIG…Hell, if they offered me the bonus I’d surely take it…Put the ONUS where it belongs…a clueless President controlled by the IDIOTS he has for advisors…and the FOOLS in congress, which unfortunately, we citizens put in office. Once there they have a habit of forgetting that they were ELECTED and whom they are supposed to SERVE !!!
Many years ago an infamous statesman made a profound statement that unfortunately rings as true today as it did then, And I might add, under equally as dire circumstances.
” It is fortunate for governments and politicians that the people do not think.” Adolph Hitler 1939
WAKE UP AMERICA…It’s your money, how much of this crap are you going to take?
contact your representatives and let them know how you feel…this type of thinking permeates all branches of government from the city hall to the white house…WE ARE DIMINISHED.

Posted by: The Pro from Dover | March 18, 2009, 12:55 am 12:55 am

I think we should find out how they intended to pay the bonus without the bailout.

Posted by: Bernie | March 18, 2009, 1:11 am 1:11 am

AIG is not the problem………… The problem is incompetents and arrogant in our government. What group of idiots gave our money to this corrupt company without safeguards. It’s like giving a drug addict money for food and expecting him to buy food instead of drugs. It is your elected representatives in Washington, wake up. The “news media” has died at the wheel.

Posted by: Jim | March 18, 2009, 1:18 am 1:18 am

Those execs who did actually wrong should be punished to the maximum extent of the law.
Those who were merely incompetent should be fired and required to return their bonuses.
Those who merely did their jobs should probably return their bonuses as well, but can be allowed to keep their jobs.
Those who went above and beyond, probably should be allowed to keep their bonuses.

Posted by: RR | March 18, 2009, 1:23 am 1:23 am

I would think the bonuses could be recalled by claiming; Eminent Domain

Posted by: Tom | March 18, 2009, 1:39 am 1:39 am

YES! I would like to see the bonuses recouped at any cost, even if it renders AIG incapable of paying back their bailout. MOREOVER … I would like to see each and everyone of the “executives” running the company FIRED! and perhaps replace them with some honest grease monkey MBA rookies that are up for the challenge to rebuid the company with a lot of help from a lot of people.
Same for the auto industry, the AWU created a system with unsustainable overhead, most USA workers do not have the perks available to auto workers. The PIGS running the auto industry only care about their yearly bonus. FRAUD!
These companies should have been allowed to fail and go bankrupt in the first place, but now that WE THE PEOPLE own the company, no way no how this fraud should take place one more day.
Make sure to get the bonuses from the people that quit after getting the cash.
OH … and make sure to get every penney from Berney Maddof, his momma, his wife, his kids, his grandkids, his close relatives, his distant relatives, his barber, his colonostopy doctor, his gold teeth, his pacemaker, and his gay lover.

Posted by: Fire_AIG_executives | March 18, 2009, 1:52 am 1:52 am

A contract can be broken. It happens everyday in the “real world”. AIG execs you should be ashamed of yourselves. No one should get a bonus, reward or compensation for something bad that you helped create. Be men or women and step up you made mistakes you definately DO NOT deserve my tax dollars for your blunders. I would hope that President Obama can resind the last bail out check. Then you can rely on your “execs” to figure out how you can save your own shareholders and clients. Then tell us you still gave them the bonuses. SHAME SHAME SHAME on all of you. The American people may not be cpa’s or financial advisers but we sure know when we are being taken.

Posted by: MAB | March 18, 2009, 2:05 am 2:05 am

Claw back the money from the executives, whatever the cost.
Enough is enough.

Posted by: gaz | March 18, 2009, 2:15 am 2:15 am

Paulson designed this ‘Ponzi’ scheme (TARP). We understand everyone wanting us to buy more stock in order to keep the market up…fix the system…then we’ll have ‘confidence’ to invest.
And that FIX is simple and oblivious, but everyone seems not to be addressing it directly…
- it’s ‘Corruption-Corruption-Corruption’.
ie. special interest groups, earmarks, lobbyist, elimination of rules and regulations, the financial sector having contributed over $5.2B to political campaigns, same people who got us in this mess are now tying to get us out (humanly impossible…they will, and have instead spent most of the time & money trying to cover-up the industry’s underlining behavior).
Corruption is the ‘root’ problem here…as it is everywhere. Until that gets fixed first…everything else is redundant…we’re just pouring $$$ into the abyss! Wall Street has always been Ponzi Street, and the Golden Rule always applies; ‘never invest $$$ you can’t afford to lose’.
Fix the ‘corruption’ – then we’ll have ‘confidence’.
The solution – ‘Transparency-Transparency-Transparency’.
How? Start now Restructuring (nationalize, fix, resell) all the zombie banks – the FIDC does this every day.

Posted by: vanron100 | March 18, 2009, 2:50 am 2:50 am

AIG is in the same league as ENRON now, except we can’t let this one fail… and that’s too bad, they deserve to fail…

Posted by: Maria | March 18, 2009, 3:11 am 3:11 am

They have to be hanged from their offices for this heinous crime that they have committed. There has to be no pardon. The common man has been taken for a ride and if no action is taken, they will be taken for rides even by others who have got the taxpayer’s money.

Posted by: Shashikiran Srinivasa | March 18, 2009, 3:20 am 3:20 am

At some point, we have to face up to the fact that we’re dumping billions of bailout dollars into a corrupt organization that is unsalvageable. If possible, get the money back that was paid out in bonuses, stop all payments to the company, and shut it down.

Posted by: Kelly | March 18, 2009, 3:31 am 3:31 am

Oh, C’mon, how can someone suggest “Risking YOUR Own AIG”? Let’s take all the money that we’ve given them and strip them down and rebuild. AIG really needs a blood transfusion – there’s been too much bad blood. Don’t be afraid to act now, else there’s no end to this mess – just wait and see what criminals these people really are. If we can’t get the money back now, let’s seize their properties, take away their passports, freeze their assets, etc. Trace where they’re trying to hide their new millions. These have been done to suspected white-collar criminals in the past, what’s wrong with using them now? If we’re afraid of prosecuting them in error, let them sue the people at a later time. I don’t agree with taxing them – it just takes too long. Let’s recover the money asap. For what American’s have lost, I think it’s not far from hitting rock bottom any ways, therefore we just could be pulling through better than if we continue to enable criminal deeds that are so obvious.

Posted by: Monkey Wrench | March 18, 2009, 3:32 am 3:32 am

There was a time in our great country when the words “Political Integrity and Responsible Business Practices” meant something!!! To violate these principles was viewed as a “Hanging offense”by the general populace. Maybe we should reinstate some of these old feelings and methods……Oh Hell, that wouldn’t work. There isn’t enough room left in Arlington Cemetery to bury all the BASTARDS involved.
Give the next bailout to the people and try some “TRICKLE UP ECONOMICS” for a change. It would be far more beneficial.
Get the bonuses back? By all means, at any cost!!!

Posted by: nachtwischen | March 18, 2009, 3:43 am 3:43 am

Yes, the bonuses should be recouped at any cost. This outrageous case can be used as an example to aid in fixing a number of major problems in this country.
AIG’s managers who received these bonuses are total incompetents who destroyed AIG and brought the world financial system to the brink of collapse. They have totally destroyed the lives of millions of people. It is totally ludicrous for them to claim that the bonuses are necessary for their retention. Why would a feeble company want to retain feeble, incompetent managers? It is time to throw them out and bring in some real talent and without outrageous salaries and bonuses.
This mess illustrates that the whole concept of paying for performance via bonuses is totally flawed. It has created a loophole that crooked managers, like those at AIG, can use to feather their own nests and give nothing to rank and file employees. My company started this bonus nonsense about 20 years ago. Us peons in the trenches get laughable peanut bonuses or nothing at all, and we are worked 80 hour weeks and get no vacations, while the top managers take all the cream and contribute very little if anything. It is time to make compensation via bonuses illegal, and start paying honest salaries for honest work again. Once again, our would-be government has failed to act on behalf of the people in this area, as in all other areas.
Finally, the crooked AIG managers and their kind elsewhere should be prosecuted and get sentenced to either life imprisonment or lethal injection (the death penalty). Come on would-be government, let’s start to do your job.

Posted by: Jack | March 18, 2009, 5:19 am 5:19 am

So tonight, we ask you: Would you like to see the bonuses recouped at any cost? Even if it renders AIG incapable of paying back their bailout?
****************************************
The indispensable employee defense. BS since when? If there is one thing I learned in life it is that there is no indespensable anything.

Posted by: Thinking | March 18, 2009, 6:33 am 6:33 am

js wrote:”I am very surprise with the Republican’s response. Republicans are equally responsible when AIG tricked America”.
Republicans and GW Bush never met a CEO they didn’t love. This B.S. started the moment Bush took office. The truth is about to come out in the next couple of months and the top NeoCons will be headed outta the country leaving their pitiful followers to face the wraith.

Posted by: Trent | March 18, 2009, 7:57 am 7:57 am

What these executives, these elite talents, the smartest guys in any room have done amounts to murder. They have killed the populace’s confidence in this ” best of all systems.” They have snuffed the dreams of countless individuals. They have ruined the hopes of a stable ” American dream ” in the future. They have jeapordized the psychological & physical health of each of us, an entire nation.
I’ve read a columnist suggest the bonus payments proceed for the sake of the sanctity of contracts. Bullsh, these business “leaders” broke all their contracts thru their mismanagement & subterfuge by proposing their complicated “investment instruments.” They’re so used to playing their game & fixing the rules as they go that they believe they really deserve all they can get by any means because they’ve worked so hard & applied all their “talents” on their schemes. I can just imagine them thinking: Greed is good & I’m really good.” They have no conscience like psycopaths.
I wish all their lucre could be confiscated, & they be banned from any further practice in any positions of such responsibility & authority. But they’ll probably walk away unscathed & continue to practice their “talents.” Justice is only brought down on the plodding workers who make mistakes.

Posted by: rorbeck | March 18, 2009, 9:13 am 9:13 am

This is outrages. America needs a little communist revolution on the crooked rich and powerful now. Post the names and addresses of those shameless AIG executives and the Wall Street crooks on the internet and let us, the little people who have become victims for being law-abiding citizens, take care of them.
—————— (Don’t know why. The ABC News has blocked my ids from posting comments on its site. They also deleted some of my comments. And they refuse to tell me why. I can only post in this blog section now. Guess the freedom of speech is no longer in ABC News’ vocabulary.)

Posted by: cbs_bull | March 18, 2009, 10:18 am 10:18 am

Aren’t we all just sick of this? I’m ready for the second coming of Christ. Man has sure screwed things up! When will the dispicable acts of the greedy end?!

Posted by: Trish | March 18, 2009, 12:01 pm 12:01 pm

Things are done by people- either accomplished or destroyed- something. A society has to send out right message for people to trust each other.
Worried and wondering why we are in such a huge hole… Then, one page of Wall Street Watch answered a lot of questions. We taxpayers should read it so we can make sure the future system will be good. The 250-page study is on that website,too.
http://www.wallstreetwatch.org
However, the summary page is good enough to understand why we are here today.

Posted by: Elise Y.-outraged & worried | March 18, 2009, 4:22 pm 4:22 pm

Anybody interested & wants to read this page to understand why :
http://www.wallstreetwatch.org

Posted by: Elise Y.-outraged & worried | March 18, 2009, 4:31 pm 4:31 pm

It seems to me that AIG is holding itself hostage by claiming that if they fail, it would be catastrophic to our economy. (keep in mind that is a very Subjective statement, coming from AIG) Therefore, with this threat, the government rushes in with a ransom (aka ‘bailout’) And now, they have us in a catch 22; because taxpayers own 80% of AIG, we Definitely don’t want it to fail! A vicious cycle now ensues.

Posted by: wizardlisa | March 18, 2009, 5:20 pm 5:20 pm

This GREED of AIG (and some other companies) is just like a CANCER, eating America from inside. This is ECONOMIC TERRORISM. It is these people who took the bonus who led this economic mess. This kind of problem is worse than to fight againt terrorism in foreing countries.
Oh, another thing is that AIG CEO was appointed by Republican. Republican is criticizing Obama, but they are responsible for this mess!

Posted by: mo | March 19, 2009, 2:06 am 2:06 am

AIG is just one more fine example of our congress and senate racing around like the RATS they are trying to put out the fire they started. The democratic senate allowed and voted for the loopholes ,requested by the democratic treasury, which was then voted on by a democratic house, a bill signed by the democratic President. When will these people think before they act. Now they are passing a tax bill which is illeagle and will tie-up the court system for years at tax payer expense. When will the false taking of responsibility end? When will change begin? When will those poor girls ever get the dog>

Posted by: kvolovick | March 20, 2009, 1:14 am 1:14 am

It appears as if our elected officials may be the one’s that are enriching themselves at the expense of taxpayers. In 2007 Obama’s net worth had increased from 700k to 4.7 million dollars and he now has a $400k a year salary and all of his expenses paid. Sen. Hillary Clinton’s average net worth, adjusted for inflation, grew from negative $6 million to $30.7 million between 2000 and 2006. Sen. John McCain of Arizona reported a $27.6 million surge in his average net worth from 1995 to 2006. Senator Dodd’s net worth was $101,000 in 1967 and in 2007 was 1.5 million but is now over $3.5 million. Our congress expressed such outrage and distain for a measly $165 million dollars in bonuses to executives (many of which agreed to a salary of $1 for the year) when Congress’s collective net worth is around 3.6 billion dollars.

Posted by: Matthew Council | April 1, 2009, 9:32 am 9:32 am

Leave a Reply

Do you have more information about this topic? If so, please click here to contact the editors of ABC News.