By David Schoetz

May 19, 2009 11:10pm

Closing Argument: Internet’s Impact on Love and Sex

As you’ve seen tonight, the Internet is a powerful force for satisfying sexual desires — often at the cost of a monogamous relationship.

But we also know that many go online in search of true love — and often find it.

So tonight, we ask, quite simply: Has the Internet done more to improve courtship and intimacy or to tear it apart?

Tell us what you think.

And you can follow "Nightline" anytime on Twitter: http://twitter.com/Nightline.   

User Comments

The internet has done more to tear apart courtship and intimacy and nothing to improve it. By their very nature, courtship and intimacy cannot be done over the internet.
As the internet celebrates its 40th birthday this year, it is a sad statement on what has happened to it that such a question as yours is being asked. The internet was created 40 years ago with much nobler purposes in mind–like educational uses, rather than being a cheap media for peddling sex and other uses by cheap charlatans.

Posted by: Proud Native American and Independent Voter | May 19, 2009, 11:33 pm 11:33 pm

When a long-term love breaks up with you via email, then you’ll know the answer to this question. And, yes, it did happen to me.

Posted by: Jennifer | May 20, 2009, 12:08 am 12:08 am

I have to disagree strongly with the poster who said “The internet has done more to tear apart courtship and intimacy and nothing to improve it. By their very nature, courtship and intimacy cannot be done over the internet.”
I met my wife on the internet, over 10 years ago. We became friends and it progressed from there. I lived in Toronto, she lived near Philadelphia. Without the internet we would have never met. We did meet, and now we are coming upon our 11th anniversary of marriage. Only the weak and / or desperate would fall prey to home wreckers on the internet.

Posted by: A Canadian Guy Married in the US | May 20, 2009, 12:11 am 12:11 am

Committment is now an old fashioned word but it is where true intimacy and growth happen. Living a shallow, bumper sticker life is easier with the glitz of the iternet connections. Reality comes when someone blows up their family for the easy button. In my case it started in the workplace business gathering in a vacation spot but it was reinforced with the ease of email. Now I will never know how the internet played a part of his life. But it the easy connection makes relationships a series of teen connections which are particularly unattractive in an adult.

Posted by: Carole Ferguson | May 20, 2009, 12:12 am 12:12 am

Facebook, Myspace an all the other sites that im not familiar with have done way more bad than good. People go seeking out ways to be unfaithful. Relationships these days are a big joke with all the surveys and facts saying that people wont last after they get married or how soon they will get divorced cmon already why get married. When people make the other sign a prenumpt! you know yourself its going to happen! Im only 23 years old and i know this.

Posted by: Louie | May 20, 2009, 12:15 am 12:15 am

Internet dating presents itself as the perfect solution for the lonely and those who’ve lost love – romantic partners are just a click away. But Internet dating creates a mindset of a kid in a candy store – no one wants to focus on one person or accept anyone with flaws. Why should they? ‘Better’ options are just a click away. It’s a real shame and a sad reflection on our society today.

Posted by: Aggie | May 20, 2009, 12:19 am 12:19 am

I found my soulmate on an internet dating site and am totally in love. It is the way to go for many divorced middle-aged individuals who no longer want to go to bars to be ‘picked up’. It is a sign of our times! Courtship can definitely be done over the internet and moves forward from there. Happy to say I met the love of my life on the internet.

Posted by: Myrna | May 20, 2009, 12:21 am 12:21 am

Personally, I would have to say that the internet has done more to improve courtship, especially if that is your ultimate goal, and not just one night stands.
In this day and age, it is unsafe and usually unsatisfying to find a mate in a bar, as used to happen. As a busy professional, I had a hard time, first, going out to public places to find intelligent life forms for a potential mate, and second, finding time to go out to such places; therefore, I turned to the internet.
I met my husband through Match.com. The first night I met him, I knew he was the one, which I thought was a myth made up by romantics and older relatives. Our first date lasted 5 hours and consisted of us both ignoring the waitress multiple times as we had a genuine and amazing discussion. Our relationship only got better from there. It was clear to all of our family and friends that we belonged together and we were engaged within 6 months and married within a year and a half and are still going strong. When people hear our story, I am told they get chills.
I am not saying that you don’t have to kiss a lot of frogs before you find the prince, but if you are honest about what you are looking for, the internet is a way to put you in touch with a potential mate who may not live in your immediate area and run in your circles. In our pre-cana class, two other couples had met the same way we did, and you know what, they have become our closest friends. All couples are now happily married and going strong; meanwhile, many of my friends who met through the “normal” channels of chance meetings/bars/set-ups are now divorced.
Without the internet as a matchmaker, I may never have found the most loving and wonderful man I am now married to. He is truly my knight in shining armour.

Posted by: atrouty | May 20, 2009, 12:21 am 12:21 am

It has made all of the single’s lives mini “soundbites”, if they don’t see something exactly as they want it, on to the next profile. It has made people become “serial daters”. Makes for millions of lonely people

Posted by: Kim | May 20, 2009, 12:23 am 12:23 am

I think it just depends on the person. The internet is not for everyone. for instance: I was bored of going out to a bar or to a party and trying to pick up guys who were obviously not right. with the internet you can read up on a profile..you know we have all seen e-harmony commercials and you have to go through a very substantial list of questions to actually put a profile on the site. so its easy to read and they match you up the people who are compatible with. long story short. I am now engaged to my fiance who i met on a dating website..and we are happy. it just depends on your lifestyle and how it fits to you.

Posted by: Heather Hebert | May 20, 2009, 12:30 am 12:30 am

I agree with “a Canadian Guy Married in the US”. My husband and I met 6 years ago through an internet dating service and will be celebrating our 4th wedding anniversary this October. I never would have met him if it wasn’t for the internet as he lived more than an hour north of me.
I think blaming the internet is just another convenient way for people NOT to take responsibilty for their actions. OH the big bad internet made it EASY for me to cheat. BOGUS!!!!!! If you really want to cheat, you’ll find a way with or without it. Come on people… Take some responsability for your actions.

Posted by: Cheryl Lynn | May 20, 2009, 12:31 am 12:31 am

The internet didn’t help my first marriage nor the second.
It’s easier to track down long lost loves when life gets tough and resilience is required.
Also easier to share w/strangers when No Strings are attached. Someone can be whoever they want to be instead of who they are and the person on the receiving end of the internet interaction has NO clue who they really are.
For my money the internet and relationships do not go together a serious toxic reaction occurs!!

Posted by: Lovin Fools w/technology | May 20, 2009, 12:35 am 12:35 am

How long are we going to continue to blame exogenous factors for our own dysfunction! The internet is NOT the problem! We CHOOSE to use the modalities available to us to pursue what we want; the internet simply makes it easier. The internet also makes it easier to find a bargain, to find a map to somewhere, to communicate in a healthy manner. I’m SO sick of hearing people blame everything but themselves for the ills of society! I met my spouse on the internet and we’ve been in a monogamous relationship for ten years…you get what you put into it. Had I wanted to cheat, I would have used the internet for that as well. We act as if these outside things have some power over us so we don’t have to be responsible for our actions…COME ON!! PLEASE do not foster this ridiculous attitude that we aren’t responsible for our behavior because some technology makes our already screwed up behavior more simple to pursue!

Posted by: Val | May 20, 2009, 12:37 am 12:37 am

It’s more complicated than just the internet. Women from Philippines and other third world countries are looking for American men to get to America. They don’t care if they are married, old, sick or dying. They will do anything. These gals are 18 and up. There are Philippine “clusters” around the country where these gals bring their families here once they get here. One is in Oak Ridge, TN. The fathers come here, work a few years and go home to retire on our social security.Gal relatives do what they do best and try to snag a man here. Wouldn’t think American men would be smarter? Apparently not, my brother-in-law has been married two times to mail-order brides from the Philippines. I would like to see Nightline address this issue.

Posted by: Linda | May 20, 2009, 12:40 am 12:40 am

Women without God in there lives have created a chaotic, confused, and troublesome state in this world today.
Society changes when the home changes.
No morals in the home no morals in society. No peace in the home, no peace in society. No love in the home, no love in society. No respect in the home, no respect in society, No God in the home, no God in society.
…Broad is the way, that leadeth to destruction, and many there be which go in thereat: Matthew 7:13

Posted by: AssistantMother | May 20, 2009, 12:43 am 12:43 am

The internet has become a place for married people to find someone to have an affair with. You never know who you’re talking to. I think it’s true if you are honestly looking for someone and tell the truth, it can be a great resource for busy professionals to find that special someone. It can also be a place for an unhappy spouse to find someone to commit adultry with instead of using those efforts to repair a relationship they already have. If like mine, they’ll find out they made a big mistake by finding someone that was just surfing for “mates” not a commitment and lost the family they once had because of it.

Posted by: kyle | May 20, 2009, 12:51 am 12:51 am

I met a special match online for the first time last year.Howver the internet was a simple way of him getting sexual pictures from his exwife.He also refused to cancel or minimize the solicitations of friends on the same site we met..he kept solcitating half naked women on there..Being that I am beautiful and confident I know I will find a special someone but now opting not online..I don’t blame the internet for his actions..He definitely had a problem..Thank God its not mine anymore..

Posted by: miss A | May 20, 2009, 1:03 am 1:03 am

Where are the checks and balances for the Internet? Why aren’t more of us standing up? The First Amendment is being abused and the First Amendment does not protect obscenity. Why isn’t the Supreme Court ruling on these now constantly more graphically obscene and xxx “gonzo” and “barely legal” sites with rape simulations and connected to live calls with local prostitutes – they call them escorts, but this is just semantics – these are young boys and girls for sale everywhere on millions of Internet Servers and Internet Service Providers and sites like Craigslist- why is this legal? Is it legal to provide a venue for illicit trafficking? Is it legal to provide a venue for prostitution/escorting; whatever you to call it, this rose wil never smell as sweet….????
“We all deserve better than a porn culture.” -Gail Dines PhD
Human trafficking is a crime against humanity.

Posted by: LeChat | May 20, 2009, 1:51 am 1:51 am

I joined e harmony in january of this year..One of my matches has become a very close and dear friend and now she has met a wonderful man as I have met a wonderful Lady. If one is honest and forthright about who they are and what type of relationship they want it is a great way to meet members of the opposite sex…We learn each other from the inside out…a far different approach from the “game” that goes on in clubs, etc.
As usual, only the “bad” sites make a program such as yours, however, i daresay look at the many happy people that some online services have created. you’ll find many more of those than the losers you portrayed.

Posted by: Vegas guy | May 20, 2009, 3:14 am 3:14 am

Absolutely the Internet has demoralized the whole concept of Intimacy and furthermore “Love”. It’s become 99% of American’s wives threat to fulfilling our dreams, because of the neverending competition of the contenders in the internet throwing themselves merciles at our Husbands, who are already vulnerable by nature to the dangling things they’re told they “can have”. How about including the vast amount they will lose and the innocent children’s perfect lives that they destroy. There’s absolute medical evidence now specifically directed therapy to internet harm related mental illnesses. My marriage almost perished to this “technology”. I’m one of few willing to fight back, but feel devastated by its thousands of daily victims, both spouses and children, There’s nothing intimate about a human-computer relationship. In fact it’s unnatural. God Give strentgh to both sides victimized by this Monster.

Posted by: Chica | May 20, 2009, 3:49 am 3:49 am

There is way too many infidelities that goes on in the internet. I check my e-mail and there are girls just dancing around in bikini tops advertising for some site. It just takes 1 click and your watching and fantasising other people, I was truely shocked to find out about a site (there were actually dosens of them) about exposed pictures of ex-girlfriends and wifes that men sent to the site for exposure to feel some kind of payback or revenge. Literally, nude pics that the females sent to their lovers. There are so many sickening websites. Its just unbelievable. I wish there was laws for the internet and police monitering the websites. Todays world, its a million times harder to trust someone where theres so much sex exposed, children are hit with it and there needs to be more control.

Posted by: C | May 20, 2009, 4:01 am 4:01 am

I found tonight’s episode on modern sex very interesting. We often find ourselves in trouble, and then trying to find out why. The Internet is a technological tool that has virtually eliminated our protective barrier of distance from each other. God separated us long ago for a good reason. The Internet has brought us back togther. Our destructive nature never changes. We continue to develop new technology, often with good intentions, that is misused and abused. It’s what we do. Whether you believe in God or not, I challenge you to study the Bible, and study history. You will find that the only way for us to live happy, meaningful, and productive lives, is to follow God’s plan. There is an infinite number of things we do not understand about ourselves, our world, and our universe. Doesn’t it make sense to listen to God, the all knowing Creator? We are like the defiant child who refuses to listen to their loving parent, and gets into trouble.

Posted by: Don | May 20, 2009, 4:17 am 4:17 am

Internet influence on sex and love is multi-dimensional.
FIRST: The user will make a choice between positive/negative use of it.
(Good versus evil)
SECOND:Internet pornography negative effect as a sex tool is; The more it is used by the user,the attraction for their spouse diminishes as the spouse
“Can not meet the expectations” of the Internet. (This may also lead to sexual aberration of the user), As their demands for sexual activity becomes unacceptable to their spouse.
Third:Love yourself first,or you will never experience love. The Internets impact on love is simple. Love fulfillment will either be remorsefully self-centered, or emotionally and mutually beneficial to both individuals.
A Creator who allows us free choice is a wonderful thing….for now?

Posted by: crackmeupp | May 20, 2009, 5:22 am 5:22 am

I just viewed the posted piece that Nightline aired last night. Martin did a good job of pressing the three main characters on the realities of what they are doing. They were clearly a pimp, a common prostitute, and a john. They all had developed their own little lies to create a sphere of self-denial about what they are doing and to try and hide it. The interviewed psychologist cut right to the chase on what they are doing.
I wish I made the salary that the john does and had the free time he does. I make a small fraction of what he does and have no free time, due to the long hours that I work. If I were him, I would be saving and investing the money for retirement, rather than totally wasting it on a common prostitute.
It is tragic to see what has happened to the internet, as it celebrates its 40th birthday, and to compare it to the noble purposes for which it was created. It just goes to show that, if you make something good available to the mindless masses, they do mindless things with it, rather than use it for good.
Hopefully, the authorities with take action to shut down this prostitution business, now that you have exposed it.

Posted by: Proud Native American and Independent Voter | May 20, 2009, 10:55 am 10:55 am

Any tool can be used for good or ill, but that doesn’t mean that it’s totally neutral in terms of its effect, or that the good cancels out the bad. Technology in general has made porn more available and prostitution easier and more profitable– first it was phone sex services, then porn videos. And in both those cases, easy access and anonymizing the transaction DEFINITELY meant more porn users and heavier use by those users. People too lazy or too worried to go to a strip club or a theater that showed X films were perfectly comfortable buying videos.
Now you don’t even have to rouse yourself to order a video, just use the same computer you use at work, and access a world of totally interactive sexual opportunities! Without even leaving your desk.
The same is true of internet dating or hookups. Sure there are some great people out there, I met the love of my life on the internet– on craigslist of all places. But I also met married guys trawling for casual sex, often posing as looking for a long-term relationship. Sure, without the internet they might have hung out in bars and clubs and hit on people at work. But not nearly as much or as often, and they would have to actually go somewhere, and take some action to do so. But with the internet, they can do this virtually 24/7, while pretending to work either at the office or at home. And they can tell themselves that this is “normal” behavior, because just look at craigslist–everyone is doing it, there are zillions of ads, every day.
One guy I met (he had posted for a LTR) started crying when he talked about his marriage and how he had ruined it (end of our conversation, didn’t even finish the coffee) BUT he was back posting again, multiple posts, that afternoon.
I love the internet– I love email, google searches, the availability of music and video, ebay and other shopping. I love the availability of info… I love the fact that I met my soulmate (who I never would have otherwise come in contact with) on the internet.
And I hate the internet, because that easy, anonymous access makes people who are lying, lazy, cheating scuzzbags even more so. Hey, the internet is like junk food and no-interest low-doc mortgages and easy credit: it’s like crack to those with no ethics and no self-discipline. And they can tell themselves that what they are doing is normal, and that if they eventually admit to a problem, it is always the fault of someone or something else.

Posted by: anonycat | May 20, 2009, 11:12 am 11:12 am

I fear that pretty soon it will be hard to just keep GOD in our homes as everything else and everyone else seems to forget that he exists…so I totally don’t agree with internet relationships. You must look at a person in the eye to read them as you would when you have them face to face and if you can’t even see them as they type type how do you know they are being honest. You are just setting yourself up for more pain and failure.

Posted by: Vickie Murillo | May 20, 2009, 11:42 am 11:42 am

As to the first story in last night’s show and whether it constitutes prostitution, that’s a tough one. At a minimum, the parties involved are “shallow” to say the least!! The particular men are mainly/only interested in the woman’s “attractiveness”, and she’s mainly/only interested in his wallet. And the woman who runs that website is really a sad person.
But as to prostitution, whether explicit or not, doesn’t EVERY relationship involve some sort of give and take…some bargaining? Isn’t everybody considering what they are getting out of the relationship vs. what they themselves contribute to the equation? Actually, I think outright prostitution (where both parties are completely honest about what is going on) is MUCH more noble than what was depicted last night…where the men act like they’re not be used, and the women act like they’re not using the men. Please.
As to the internet and its affect on romance and dating, I think overall it HAS done more harm than good. Sure, some people have met via the internet and gone on to marry. But I wonder what percentage of internet meetings resulted in actual relationships? I agree with others that for far too many people, many internet dating sites are more like “catalogs”, where you can browse and see what you like, and if that one doesn’t work, then you can click on the next hot profile you see, and IM them!
Also, with the advent of internet dating, many people have never learned, or else forgot, how to COMMUNICATE in the real world. They’ve hidden behind their computers, afraid to speak to members of the opposite sex…to try and talk someone up in a bar or at a museum, etc. NOTHING can compare to first meeting someone in person and seeing if there is chemistry. The problem with internet dating is that 9 times out of 10 the chemistry doesn’t work. So then you go back to your apartment, fire up the computer, and try again, browsing for other “hot” guys/women. There’s something very sad, unnatural and alienating about the whole process.
For those who say that, if it werent’ for the internet, they never would have met their current partner: you know what? If you hadn’t met them, you would have met someone else at some point! Do people seriously think there is only ONE person for them in the world?
As to the internet making cheating more common, if someone is going to cheat, they are going to cheat. A man or woman that has NO desire to cheat, is not going to suddenly change their thoughts about this, because of browsing on the internet. If someone cheats after meeting someone on the internet, then the desire/intention/lack of happiness in their current relationship HAD to have already been there to some degree.

Posted by: yip | May 20, 2009, 12:06 pm 12:06 pm

Leave a Reply

Do you have more information about this topic? If so, please click here to contact the editors of ABC News.