By Sadie Bass

Nov 23, 2009 11:00am

Another Vampire Blockbuster? Why?

The Twilight Saga: New Moon is doing gangbusters at the box office.  A huge opening weekend – in fact one of the biggest – for a movie and THE biggest for a movie premiering outside the big summer season.  Which brings us to a central question: why?  Reviewers did not like it.  Okay, quality reviews are by no means a prerequisite for success.  Is it the vampire premise?  Is it the love story?  If you are a tween or the parent of one, please chime in.

User Comments

Maybe the vampire represents the bad boy for the tweens.

Posted by: ddg | November 23, 2009, 12:25 pm 12:25 pm

Obviously, people today, have a really distorted view of what is entertaining.

Posted by: Rick McDaniel | November 23, 2009, 1:10 pm 1:10 pm

it’s for kids mostly

Posted by: ddg | November 23, 2009, 1:20 pm 1:20 pm

My psychologist friend explains it this way. We are all in search of perfection in life, but never get it. Our friends disappoint us, our family disappoints us, our husbands, kids and schoolmates also disappoint us. The main character in Twilight (E. Cullen) represents that perfection we are searching for – everything about him is perfect.

Posted by: D. Coran | November 23, 2009, 2:34 pm 2:34 pm

My entire family went to see this movie and that’s all they talked about all weekend, I think us older folks don’t spend enough time with these young kids and that is why we are so far apart, myself I cannot imagine being away from my grandchildren any more than a day or two at the most my daughters the same, we are a very close family so when they clued me in about this series i was ready to listen, and they loved it, they buy all the hats,books t-shirts,sweatshirts the marketing in incredible…so find out what the kids are into and get in there with them, trust me it will keep you young and happy…One Happy Grandmother.

Posted by: janet ramsos | November 23, 2009, 2:36 pm 2:36 pm

Usually when the critics say it’s not good, that means the movie is going to be a good one to see. I saw it with my kids and nieces, we all enjoyed it!

Posted by: CeCe | November 23, 2009, 2:47 pm 2:47 pm

I haven’t seen the movies yet, but I read the books after my 50-something sister recommended them. I can understand the teen and tween infatuation with them; Edward (vampire) would do anything for Bella, the all-too-flawed (at least in her own eyes) human heroine. Jacob is not just the best friend a girl could ever hope to have, he’s just as sexy as Edward — and warm, too. He may not be as “perfect” as the vampire, but in some ways that makes him better for Bella, and he adores her too. The girls whe read and watch seem to divide into “camp Edward” and “camp Jacob,” hoping that one or the other will end up with Bella. The boys who read it, and some really do, probably want to BE Edward or Jacob. And if you read the books carefully, the underlying theme is that pre-marital sex will kill you — literally. What else would you expect from a writer who’s both Mormon and a mother of girls? I don’t know if the teens see that theme, but if parents read it, they should. My clever niece, the mother of a toddler, described the writing as a “literary trainwreck” but it didn’t stop her from reading all four books. I agreed — but I read them all too.

Posted by: L. Scott | November 23, 2009, 2:53 pm 2:53 pm

in this real world, most love comes with conditions – even parental love might seem to a child like the parent will only love you IF: if you behave, if you do well in school, if you love them back, etc., etc. In this story, the vampire character loves the girl without condition, without expectation; he loves her because she exists. That is what appeals to me about the story, and I’ll bet that’s what appeals to the pre-teen and teen girls who make up the bulk of the audience – love without condition – not “if you sleep with me I’ll love you”, as I am sure many of these girls have heard from the boys in their lives, but just pure, simple, unconditional lasting love. The fact that he has the special powers of a vampire is just icing on the cake, and makes the story more action packed and dramatic, that’s all.

Posted by: m | November 23, 2009, 3:02 pm 3:02 pm

The media vampire phenomenon is such because teens – thru late 20′s are in need pyschological escape. Some clinicians think this may be due to artificial sweeteners / preservatives being introduced more and more over the past 2 decades in the food supply of western countries, accounting for the increased diagnoses of hyperactivity in adolescent males and bipolar syndrome in females. Vampire fantasies – and addiction to networked online video / computer games like World of Warcraft – offer releif from the chemically-induced mental turmoil that modern American teens, and their subset tweens, have become unable to endure.

Posted by: Bob W. | November 23, 2009, 5:46 pm 5:46 pm

It’s romance..and a very well written one at that.

Posted by: Turtlehen | November 23, 2009, 6:49 pm 6:49 pm

I didn’t like the books that much. In fact, I could barely finish NEW MOON without gagging. However, I give kudos to the film crews for Twilight and New Moon because they’ve managed to turn out a couple of entertaining films from poorly written material.

Posted by: cmhuante | November 23, 2009, 8:48 pm 8:48 pm

Is it just a case of sore losers? I have seen many films, some adored by the critics, I am amazed at how terrible they are. I thought movies were suppose to be entertainment, an escape. I went to watch New Moon, and I read that it was the really awful, a waste of time,imagine my surprise, it’s a good movie, a solid B,
the acting was great, not wooden, the story moved well, and the action was exciting. Not once in the two hours did I roll my eyes, look at my watch, or fall asleep.
It’s a good movie, give it rest critics, or should I give us break, we really want to be entertained.

Posted by: Lisa | November 23, 2009, 10:02 pm 10:02 pm

I remember what it was like to be a teen girl with your first serious crush. When every look from him sent your heart to your throat, when simple innocent touches meant you felt weak and dizzy. A kiss could stop your world. This is the essence of Bella and the biggest appeal of Twilight. Being young and so breathlessly, recklessly in love. Twilight Moms, perhaps, have fallen in love with the books and movies because it’s a fun, romantic, perfect escape. Who wants to talk about the economy and household chores and bills? Not me. I’d rather daydream a bit too, about sexy vampires or smokin’ hot werewolves. The appeal for the teen girls is simple. They long for a love like Bella’s, something real and lasting. In this fast world, it’s an awesome pg-rated escape for them too. Taylor and Robert don’t hurt, of course.

Posted by: angelabdreaming | November 23, 2009, 10:45 pm 10:45 pm

Twilight is bad for women. The main character is a spineless sap. Her only desire is to give up everything (her family, friends and her humanity) for a man. She risks her life just for the chance to seeing him. She is the lamest female character to come along in a long, long time. And the whole no sex before marriage thing? Seriously? You think getting married right out of high school is better than having sex before you’re married? Is that what we want to teach young girls? Stephanie Meyers should be ashamed of herself.
The books were awful, boring and pathetic. I’m not surprised the movie’s were bashed by the critics.

Posted by: Emily | November 24, 2009, 2:43 pm 2:43 pm

I saw the movie with a friend and we both really liked it. Leave it to critics to hate popular movies. I remember in the 80s the critics didn’t like Grease II, I thought it was good but not as good as the original w/ John Travolta and Olivia Newton-John. “Edward” and “Jacob” were both handsome devils I wouldn’t have minded meeting and I’m not a tween, far from it. Maybe it’s because of the war times that everyone needs to fixate on something else other than the government and their problems.

Posted by: Steph | November 25, 2009, 12:31 am 12:31 am

I am a lot like others .. if there is a review that says the movie is no good .. that is Definitely the one i will go see .. cause it is the one i probably will like the most …. critics just give an opinion .. and if they are not into the genre they are not going to like it … for instance .. if i had to be a critic for comedies .. most would come up short as i don’t find many of them very funny .. so reviews would be thumbs down .. lOl .. so .. each to their own .. don’t let critics stop you from going to a movie .. if you feel you want to go see one .. go … and make your own opinion … *smile*

Posted by: tigerladyinwi | November 25, 2009, 9:12 am 9:12 am

Leave a Reply

Do you have more information about this topic? If so, please click here to contact the editors of ABC News.