North vs. South: Can Two Koreas Reunite?
EmailABC's Joohee Cho reports from South Korea: When the Berlin Wall fell, South Koreans were high in hopes that the wall dividing North and South Korea might also come down ‘in the near future’. Since then 20 years have gone by and now many South Koreans, especially the younger generation, are feeling that the last Cold War frontier collapsing may not be such a good idea after all. Discussing unification to any Korean – both North and South – can be a very touchy subject. First of all, the politically correct term to use is ‘reunification’, not ‘unification’. Koreans say that is because the Cold War and the great powers ‘slashed their country into half’ along the 38th parallel; against the Korean people’s wishes. So when you ask anyone on the streets of Seoul or Pyongyang whether they want reunification, even a five year-old will say ‘yes, our wish is reunification’. That ‘Our-Wish-Is-Reunification’ is a long-time catchphrase and a title of the song that Korean kids learn at elementary school. It is also the favorite song to sing – holding hands and often in tears – when North and South Korean civilians get together for example at occasional family reunions But if you ask the next question, ‘when and how’ they want reunification, the answers will come back very mixed. North Koreans trained and educated to shout the text book answer would respond, ‘we shall rescue our southern brothers from the imperialist Americans by military force to reunite as soon as possible.’ But down South where national income is 17 times higher than the North, people have been in doubt and calculating how much it would cost if the Demilitarized Zone (DMZ) was dismantled. According to a recent study from the Korean Institute of Public Finance, more than 8 percent of a united Korea’s GDP would have to be spent to guarantee South Korean-standard minimum social welfare to the North Koreans The study also forecasted that the gap between North and South would still exist even long after 20 years. Experts say the cost of Korean reunification will be 2.5 times more than what the Germans have spent. That means starting from the day North collapses, South Koreans would have to donate at least 10 percent of their GDP for an unspecified time. Most South Koreans – under the age of 59 – were born after the Korean War (1950-1953). Throughout their lives there has been no communication or travel to the North. They have been living under daily threat of North Korean military force and its nuclear programs. They are content and proud of their nation’s economic performance ranking Asia’s 4th and world’s 14th largest economy. Perhaps that is why these days more South Koreans respond to the last question of when and how, ‘sometime in the future… gradually.’
RSS
Twitter
Facebook
They’re never going to reunite. Their political positions are mutually exclusive, and the Korean War has left them permanently scarred.
Posted by: Dave | November 9, 2009, 2:28 pm 2:28 pm
Anything is possible, but NK is a dynasty, being handed down to sons, and is a little different situation than with Germany.
Posted by: Rick McDaniel | November 9, 2009, 5:20 pm 5:20 pm
They will reunite and anybody who thinks they will not are enemies of peace.
Posted by: United We Stand | November 9, 2009, 5:47 pm 5:47 pm
As long a China wants a buffer between a strongly Westernized society (S. Korea), N. Korea will remain intact.
When China decides it no longer needs it, N. Korea will collapse – there’s so little holding it together other than China now.
Posted by: The_Mick | November 10, 2009, 2:00 am 2:00 am
Why is there nothing about the skirmish between the NK and SK battleships today?
Posted by: ElleSTL | November 10, 2009, 9:52 am 9:52 am
The problem is that Germany benefitted from Egon Krenz realizing that the old-line Ulbricht-Honnecker style of rule was not going to hold, particularly after the news of the velvet revolutions sweeping across Europe and the Tiananmen Square massacre became public knowledge in the DDR stirring up defiance from the people. That, and the ease of defection from East Germany (through Hungary and other Eastern Bloc nations that were opening their borders to the West — and being returned to East Germany in an attempt was not a death-penalty offense) in the final days before the Wall’s fall were the major factors in the border collapse and the reunification of Germany.
North Korea has no Egon Krenz, there are no velvet revolutions occuring in its neighbors, and even if they were, the excruciatingly-controlled North Korean media would not note them. And it is atrociously difficult to leave North Korea — you can’t just hop a train to the “socialist neighbor” China and then hole up in the South Korean embassy … and if you had, you would be returned to North Korea and shot as a traitor. Sadly, there are no hopeful historical paralells between 1989 Germany and 2009 Korea. All we can hope for is that whoever succeeds the obviously dying Kim Jong-il is much saner than he.
Posted by: Pat | November 11, 2009, 2:59 pm 2:59 pm
YES THEY WILL REAUNITE AND IT WILL HAPPEN!
Posted by: Blood Rose | November 11, 2009, 7:39 pm 7:39 pm
Adherence to Principles of National Reunification Called for
Pyongyang, October 14 (KCNA) — The three principles of national reunification set forth by the Workers’ Party of Korea– independence, peaceful reunification and great national unity–are the most just and patriotic principles, says Rodong Sinmun Thursday in a signed article.
It is the invariable stand of the WPK to achieve the country’s reunification on the principle of national independence, the article says, and goes on:
The June 15 joint declaration and the October 4 declaration correctly reflect the desire and demand of all Koreans for rejecting foreign forces and realizing the independent reunification by the united efforts of the nation. The adoption of these declarations, a reunification program common to the nation, and the admirable success made in the inter-Korean relations after it are a vivid demonstration of the validity and vitality of the WPK’s principle of independent reunification.
It is the consistent principle of the WPK to reunify the country in a peaceful way.
The WPK has waged a dynamic struggle for national reunification under the banner of peaceful reunification over the past 60 years. The proposal for founding the Democratic Federal Republic of Koryo advanced by President Kim Il Sung at the 6th Congress of the WPK is the most patriotic and just proposal which embodied the principle of peaceful reunification. Nothing is better than the federation proposal in realizing national reunification. All Koreans at home and abroad are now making a vigorous struggle to materialize the federation proposal clarified in the historic June 15 joint declaration, zealously supporting it. This goes to prove the validity of the WPK’s principle of peaceful reunification.
It is the fundamental principle of national reunification advocated by the WPK to realize the country’s reunification by pooling efforts of all Koreans.
The WPK regarded patriotism and the spirit of national independence as basis for national unity. The 10-point programme of great unity of the whole nation advanced by Kim Il Sung and the five-point policy for great national unity set forth by General Secretary Kim Jong Il on the sacred road for national unity have served as the banner of national reconciliation and unity and as the guidelines of action.
“By our nation itself”, the idea of national unity, became a steadfast idea common to the nation and solidarity and alliance among the Koreans of different strata at home and abroad for national reunification have grown stronger than ever before on a nationwide scale. This is a shining fruition of the WPK’s energetic efforts for achieving the country’s reunification through the concerted efforts of the nation.
Posted by: Mohammed AL-Saedi | October 15, 2010, 8:58 am 8:58 am