Phoebe Prince & Bullying in Small-town USA
By now, you've likely seen the tragic story of Phoebe Prince and her suicide's combustible aftermath. The plan for tonight is a report from Andrea Canning about the case. She's in Massachusetts today as three of the nine suspects charged last week in connection with Prince's bullying death were scheduled for arraignment (though no court appearance is required). It all went down at South Hadley High School in a quiet part of Western Massachusetts were the culture of teen bullying became so bad for Prince, an Irish immigrant new to school dating an older boy, that she took her own life. While the case has reignited the conversation about bullying in America's schools, particularly in the digital age, it has also raised questions and criticisms about the vigilance of the educators and parents nearest the situation. Click HERE for the March 29 ABCNews.com report, the day the nine teenagers were indicted — charges that generated quite a controversy. Embedded below is a Yunji de Nies "GMA" report from January 25, when the small-town case was just starting to draw national attention — a story that could happen too easily in so many similar communities.
Email




RSS
Twitter
Facebook
The nine should really all be tried as adults. Period. The nine should all have bail amounts set to help prevent them for fleeing. The parents of all of the charged nine should be thoroughly investiged and if evidence found, charge them. The superintendent and principal should also be charged for their failure to act when notified. All school administrators and teachers that knew the bullying was going on should be charged. We Americans need to apologize to Ireland for failing to take care of one of their precious children. We need to make America and our schools ALL ZERO TOLERANCE for bullying. I pray the Prince family can find some peace in their fond memories of Phoebe.
Posted by: Lin McKay | April 6, 2010, 2:22 pm 2:22 pm
My heart goes out for Phoebe and her family, as well as to all the kids who are tormented every day and feel like they can’t take it anymore. Judging by the pics of the girls, it’s no wonder they were jealous of how pretty Phoebe was. I wonder how the bullies like it to be so hated and reviled now? I think the school (who knew and didn’t do anything), the bullies and their pathetic parents should be held accountable in every way possible. Rest in peace Phoebe.
Posted by: Laura A | April 6, 2010, 3:04 pm 3:04 pm
Lin and Laura, I agree with you 100%. This tragedy could have been avoided if the correct action had been taken. Since it wasn’t, then all involved should share in the punishment. I can’t even imagine what Miss Prince was feeling at the time of her death.
Posted by: jas | April 6, 2010, 4:04 pm 4:04 pm
This story is heartbreaking! Here you have a beautiful girl, new to our country, and this was how she was treated. Every community should have a zero tolerance policy. These teenagers should not be offered any protection just because they are in public school; the law still applies–even to teenagers. If I threw a drink at someone on the street, I would (and should) be charged with assault. These teenagers are disgusting, and I hope they get the sentences they deserve. I also have no patience for the school administrators. They stood by and did nothing. They all have blood on their hands. May God be with the Prince family.
Posted by: Katie | April 6, 2010, 4:18 pm 4:18 pm
why did she get bullied she is so pretty
Posted by: bernie | April 6, 2010, 8:02 pm 8:02 pm
I teach middle school and deal with bullying EVERY day. Cell phones are not allowed at school and bullying is one reason for this rule. Teachers cannot control everything students do in the restrooms, on their cell phones, on facebook after school, in the hall between classes and on the bus. All the while teachers are “held accountable” for test scores with little or no money for paper, field trips, or technology. We are vigilant, but I have 128 students! Parents of students who bully enable their students and are themselves abusive to faculty and staff when their students get into trouble at school. They are the first parents to call or show up at school being abusive and beligerant toward faculty and staff following any earned consequence. KEY ISSUES – (1) popularity has become the primary goal at school (2) socializing takes priority over everything else (3) parents object to the even the smallest consequence earned by a student (4) parents treat faculty and staff with extreme disrespect and abuse (5) parents and students MUST take responsibility for their education and their behavior. The total shift of responsibility from parents and students to schools for food, health, morality, social development, and general well-being reaches a crescendo with this case. The parent/student ratio is approximately 1/1. The teacher student ration is approximately 1/128-150. Until parents support faculty and staff, and pay attention to what their own students are doing… this is going to get worse.
Posted by: Judy | April 6, 2010, 8:05 pm 8:05 pm
What Judy said. Also, it seems that the reason Phoebe was bullied by female classmates is that she dated a popular boy and they didn’t feel she had the “right” to date him. There are girls like that in the school where I work. You can call it jealousy I suppose, but it’s mainly the desire to have power over someone else’s life. You have to wonder why so many girls feel so powerless.
Posted by: Jill | April 6, 2010, 8:34 pm 8:34 pm
I hope a Phoebe Alert will come out of this horrific event that will help save many others as the Amber Alert does. Regarding the perpetrators: they’ll meet real bullies in prison. I hope then these amateurs will go on the lecture circuit to describe how terrorizing in hs leads to imprisonment and being terrorized.
IMHO, it’s mostly the parents’ fault. Bullies are very monkey-see, monkey-do. Teachers have it rough. But writing up a student terrorizing another student surely can’t add all that much paperwork.
We’re all responsible as a society, too, so long as we don’t crack down on violent behavior early on.
Posted by: CeeCee | April 6, 2010, 9:16 pm 9:16 pm
I’m not a teacher or an educator and it’s a little weird to me that so many well-intentioned people are putting the blame on the school.
So far, there has been no facts to definitively prove that the school knew the bullying had been going on for 3 months and the school staff knew about Ms. Prince’s allegedly ongoing, long-term torment.
According to the Times, Ms. Prince was seen crying at the nurse’s office once. And there could have been many other reasons besides bullying that she was crying. Also, maybe whatever the issues were, the nurse had to keep them confidential so the principal wasn’t informed.
And for all those calling for the heads to roll at the school, ask yourself this: If the principal, teachers, staff, et al. are supposed to be omniscient then what about the parents? How could the senior boys’ parents not know that their sons were having sex with a 15 y.o. thus committing statutory rape which could lead to jail time? Did the victim’s parent know that their daughter “immediately got this horribly bad reputation” (as a sophomore told the Times)? Why didn’t the mean girls’ parents know their daughters are ganging up on a freshmen girl from another country who apparently didn’t know the unwritten rules of their queendom?
If the parents are clueless, how is the teacher who is teaching and watching over hundreds of kids supposed to know?
Posted by: em | April 7, 2010, 12:27 am 12:27 am
I think several people share the blame in this case.
Several articles I read said multiple teachers witnessed the bullying of Phoebe Prince on the day she died. They didn’t report it until after the fact. Why didn’t they intervene?
When I was in high school, I had a person bullying me over the fact that my dad had lost his job. We were in history, and a teacher overheard the comments directed at me. She halted class, called the bully up, and said, “Apologize or don’t come back to class.” The bully apologized and never said another word. It’s a tough job being a teacher, but there are ways they can help. A teacher helped me…
The parents of the bullies are also at fault. Why these people don’t talk to their children about the importance of being kind to others is beyond me. The bullies in this case have long lives ahead, and they will have to live with what they have done for a very long time.
Posted by: Amy | April 7, 2010, 9:47 am 9:47 am
This is a very sad case. Just think of how alone the poor girl felt when no one in the whole school would reach out to her in friendship. Students and facalty alike. I hope they have a hard time sleeping or looking in the mirror.
Posted by: Paul | April 7, 2010, 6:50 pm 6:50 pm
I think that the teenagers need to be tried as adults. They knew what they were doing, and need to take responsibility. I do not, however, believe that the parents should be held accountable. You can teach your children how to be perfect role models, how to be upstanding citizens, but when the cat’s away, the mice will play. The only ones that are responsible for their actions, are the teenagers. Bullies have low self-esteem. They pick on others to make themselves look better. Bullies need to get what they deserve.
Posted by: Jennifer | April 8, 2010, 3:24 pm 3:24 pm
These nine suspects were obviously raised with no core values or respect for human life! The parents should be charged with a lack of enagement in developing their children’s manners, and common decency. These nine suspects actions are appalling and disgusting.
Posted by: Richard Dover | April 9, 2010, 11:47 pm 11:47 pm
Bullies, you are totally and 100% responsible for the tragedy that led to the end of a precious life. Parents of these bullies, you are totally and 100% responsible for the tragedy that led to the end of a precious life. School Administrators, you are totally and 100% responsible for the tragedy that led to the end of a precious life. You are all totally and equally responsible for your actions, and inactions. Those of you that cannot recognize this, have obviously missed something. What makes this even more tragic, for me, is the way we were treated last year on our first trip to Ireland. I have never met such hospitable, friendly, and helpful people anywhere else I have traveled. One kind lady on the street, who noticed we looked lost, gave us directions to the restaurant we were looking for. Apparently, minutes later, she realized she gave us a wrong turn and actually chased us down for 5 or 6 blocks to APOLOGIZE and point us in the right direction. This is only a small example of the genuine kindness and hospitality we received. I can only imagine how Phoebe must have felt being treated so inconceivably horrible. Ireland, I apoligize for the actions of such vile, evil people. We are all not of the same mind, or heart. God be with you all as you deal with this loss, but also with the evil that would allow such treatment of one of God’s children.
Posted by: Jan | April 11, 2010, 6:47 pm 6:47 pm
THIS TO PHOEBE PRINCE,A BEAUTIFUL GIRL
WHO CAME FROM SOUTH HADLEY
WHO TOOK HER OWN LIFE,BECAUSE HER SO CALLED FRIEND TREATED HER BADLY
I CAN ONLY IMAGINE HOW DEEP WERE HER FEARS
I HOPE WE’RE ALL PRAYING DAILY AND ITS GOD DRYING TEARS
HER LIFE WAS CUT SHORT,ONE ALL WOULD HAVE HOPES SHE WOULD LIVE FULLY
BUT NOW HER LOVED ONES WON’T KNOW BECAUSE OF SOME INSUCURE BULLYS
SO I SAY TO YOU ALL ,KEEP PHOEBE UP FRONT IN YOUR MIND
YOU’LL NEVER KNOW HOW YOUR WORDS ARE BEING TAKEN,SO PLEASE MAKE SURE THERE KIND……PHOEBE PRINCE REST IN PEACE…DICO
Posted by: Dico | April 12, 2010, 12:24 am 12:24 am
The so called mean girls and the wannabe football player are just a waste of human flesh,REALLY!!! are they really needed in society? Nice welcome to America they gave Phoebe.
Posted by: ru kidding | April 13, 2010, 5:28 pm 5:28 pm
I too was an outcast in high school. 2 things worked against me: I was, more or less, new to the area and I was a small, skinny, “late bloomer”. I’m not sure how I made it through but I do know that I completely withdrew socially in school and tried to stay away from the others in my school and in the long run I found others from other schools that became my friends.
I basically turned my back on the school I attended and somehow made it thru to graduate though I had and wanted nothing to do with the high school I attended. No one will ever remember me cause after my freshman picture I simply refused to have my picture taken for the yearbook after that. When I was contacted for the school reunion I called the number on the letter and said that “he” (meaning me) was deceased and not send anymore invites.
Something occurred in my high school years happened it tells you a LOT of what high school did TO me. Like I said I was a “late bloomer” so i didn’t reach adolescence until the summer between my sophmore and junior years. I went from probably 5′something to, I’m presuming, my present 6’1″. Something happened in my junior year that I didn’t understand/comprehend: a whole lot of the “popular”/”stuck up” BUT HOT (and all senior) girls SUDDENLY started being real nice to me and being REAL friendly to me . For be, browbeaten as I was, saw the mean/popular girls as just carrying on the “being mean” to me…….. I just shrugged off their attempts to talk to me cause I figured why set myself up to be taunted and picked on right?……. It wasn’t till many, MANY years later that something dawned on me…….. those “stuck up” “popular” girls were NOT being mean to me….. they meant it when they came on to me. But all those years/times before my senior year I was so beaten down that I just couldn’t comprehend it. But in my late teens/20s I NEVER had problems meeting women and women were ALWAYS throwing themselves at me AND NO I’M NOT SAYING THIS TO TALK MYSELF UP but rather I NEVER thought about, let alone realized those “mean”/”popular” “stuck up” girls were hitting on me till many years later because it shows the bitterness and anger I suppressed over my high school years.
It’s terrible being a teen as IF YOU SURVIVE IT you’ll find out that it’s such a miniscule part of your overall life.
Posted by: RW | April 13, 2010, 7:39 pm 7:39 pm
The South Hadley Six are toast.
Everybody who has ever been bullied or mobbed knows the reason was simply being in the wrong place at the wrong time. You were relatively powerless, with weak or no ethical authority figures to maintain order. It has nothing to do with victims deserving the attacks and everything to do with the bullies cravings for power and control.
And then they mocked Phoebe’s death, not caring who witnessed. Now every bulling victim in the world (probably numbering in the billions), wants justice, vindication and revenge.
Their only hope is the government starts some kind of bully protection program.
Posted by: Lieutenant Dan | April 15, 2010, 7:39 pm 7:39 pm
So, lemme get this straight… teachers shouldn’t be held accountable FOR THEIR STUDENTS ACTIONS WHILE IN SCHOOL? Am I hearing this correctly? So you will allow another student to harass and pick on another student in front of your face and keep your mouth shut? test scores and no resources aside, the safety of these kids between the hours of 8-3 IS your responsibility. I am not saying that teachers don’t have a lot on their plate I just find it odd that you want to type out a laundry list of OTHER responsibilities that you have when first and foremost your commitment is to your students. Secondly, If I had gone to administration and voiced a concern regarding a problem I knew had occurred and might occur in the future and then that very thing happens, it is called neglect, I am sorry but I have BEEN to high school and I currently work with kids.. ADULTS always know your business… it’s just a matter of who takes it seriously. it’s 2010 people WAKE THE HELL UP. Blame the parents.. I agree I work with at risk youth and if you can blame the parents for those souls then you can blame them for raising obnoxious teenagers who think the world revolves around them. All 9 should face jail time and they should BE AT EVERY COURT appearance. As for school administration.. I wouldn’t worry about them THIS will happen again there because they clearly do not care what is going on there.
Posted by: Sick of it ALL | April 19, 2010, 3:28 am 3:28 am
I agree 100% with the previous post. I too was bullied an inordinate amount in school.
Once I was attacked in a stairwell before going onto stage for a chorus concert in front of half the class (20 people). The teacher was no where in site during the incident and did nothing once she learned of it. In fact another girl that same night was attacked by the same person that attacked me.
All that was done was the teacher wrote both the attacker and myself up. The administration tried to tell me that “I couldn’t be let go scott free without punishment”, even though I never technically attacked back and had no previous history of fighting and this was my senior year of high school.
If I hadn’t have stood up and called the school on their b.s. This incident would’ve been swept under the rug as well. I was the one who suggested that more faculty members be assigned to the next Chorus concert the following night (the only adult present was an 8 month pregnant teacher) and remind them that although I didn’t fight back the law states that if you feel you’re life is in danger you can defend yourself and their rules of no fighting period rule goes against the law.
Something needs to be done about bullying by the government. Laws need to be better reinforced that it’s the duty of the school and each teacher to first PROTECT their students and then teach. How would they feel if this were their child this happened to and no one did anything to stop it at their child’s school.
Posted by: W | April 20, 2010, 4:32 pm 4:32 pm