By David Schoetz

May 26, 2010 12:20pm

Graphic Video: More Dairy Farm Animal Abuse?

Some very disturbing undercover footage of cows being beaten at an Ohio dairy farm has been released to the public. According to the Chicago-based animal welfare group Mercy For Animals, which advocates a vegan diet in the name of farm animal protection, the footage was taken at Conklin Dairy Farms in Plain City, Ohio, during a recent month-long, hidden-camera investigation. A warning, the video embedded below is graphic in nature and was produced by Mercy For Animals. Animals are shown being stomped, beaten with a tire iron, and jabbed with a pitchfork. The group is pushing for criminal prosecution of the workers featured in the violent film.  Conklin Dairy Farms has not yet made a statement about the video, according to the AP. That probably won't last long. Brian Ross and the investigative unit worked with Mercy For Animals in January on an investigation into animal abuses at a large New York dairy farm.  In that case, the investigation, focused more on controversial industry practices — such as how cows are dehorned, pictured above, and tail-docking. An employee caught on tape striking a cow was eventually suspended. This previous blog on the topic remains an active comment thread filled with outrage but also several reminders from those in the agriculture community of the old adage, "one bad apple doesn't spoil the bunch." And here is the Brian Ross "Nightline" report, "The Ugly Side of Milk."   UPDATE: Dairy farm worker Billy Joe Gregg Jr., 25, has been charged with 12 counts of cruelty to animals after the release of the video, the AP is now reporting. Gregg, pictured in his mugshot below, was also fired. He is being held pending his arraignment Thursday, according to the local prosecutor. Meanwhile, the fourth-generation Conklin Dairy Farms released a statement condemning the violent treatment of animals. "We will not condone animal abuse on our farm," the statement reads. "We have launched our own internal investigation into this matter and will be conducting interviews with everyone on our farm who works with animals." The police investigation is also ongoing.

User Comments

I can’t believe these savages. They deserve to be treated exactly the same with their customers providing the treatment they gave the animals. I have no doubt that anyone to uses the products that cattle provide us would feel that this type of treatment is in any way acceptable.

Posted by: Mike | May 26, 2010, 12:53 pm 12:53 pm

I’ve been through a lot of dairys… worked for a few and know plenty of farmers. I’ve never seen treatment like that. Lock the sicko’s up and throw away the key.

Posted by: Chad | May 26, 2010, 12:58 pm 12:58 pm

There are many undercover investigations that show animal cruelty and abuse is rampant throughout animal agriculture operations. The industry is largely self-regulated, and the repeated investigations revealing this sickening cruelty shows a dire need for regulation by federal and state authorities.

Posted by: Mark | May 26, 2010, 1:05 pm 1:05 pm

These dairy farmers obviously have mental problems. Anyone twisted enough to brutalize an innocent animal is not beyond doing the same to a human being. Please tell me they are being prosecuted and will have some sort of criminal record based on these tapes.
Another concern would be are these idiots tainting the milk we drink?

Posted by: rhida | May 26, 2010, 1:29 pm 1:29 pm

Conklin Dairy needs to be shut down and fined. The sickos who treated these animals the way that they did and ENJOYED it need to be prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law and put UNDER the prison. They are obviously a bunch of sick people and I would be willing to bet that they knew that these practices have been going on for a long time and the only reason that the owner is so “outraged” is because he and his cronies got caught! Sick, sick, sick and disgusting. Conklin Dairy — if your company is an example of the industry standards, I’m going with soy milk! Shame on you.

Posted by: Allison | May 26, 2010, 1:31 pm 1:31 pm

Why?????????????

Posted by: Ina | May 26, 2010, 1:39 pm 1:39 pm

These guys are going to be taken to the cleaners by CNN’s Jane Velez Mitchell tonight on her show “Issues.” Watch and enjoy the payback!!!!

Posted by: JVMFan | May 26, 2010, 1:42 pm 1:42 pm

Okay so what can we do besides become vegans, and donate money. These videos really make me sick. So sad..

Posted by: Meghan | May 26, 2010, 1:52 pm 1:52 pm

“Graphic Video: More Dairy Farm Animal Abuse?” — Why is there a question mark on that? Does anyone anywhere NOT think that is animal abuse? There are people on this planet who should be locked away & never released — but is that enough? Guilty beyond a shadow of a doubt (multiple accounts on video, no less), they get NO SYMPATHY from me.

Posted by: Richard the Big Bunny | May 26, 2010, 1:55 pm 1:55 pm

what kind of human they are? these workers should be isolate from every kind of living animal forever.

Posted by: Tuncay Demirtepe | May 26, 2010, 2:03 pm 2:03 pm

Has anyone considered these abhorrent actions to be a staged event by an anti-animal group. With the excellent camera actions present, it appears that it takes two to tango. Both individuals, regardless of affiliation, are guilty of animal abuse and should be prosecuted to the extent of the law.

Posted by: Steve | May 26, 2010, 2:08 pm 2:08 pm

If and Hopefully when these sickos get put in prison,the’d better put them in solitary because they will beat other inmates just because theres nothing else to beat on. They need Deep psyco therapy. Or they will turn out to be mass murders.

Posted by: violet lynch | May 26, 2010, 2:18 pm 2:18 pm

This video staged? Right. Mercy for Animals must have hired the Avatar special effects team for that. The cameraman did it? Do you hear the cameraman egging anyone on? I don’t. This is abuse clear and simple, and the bastards need to be locked up for life. I am tired of all the excuses and obfuscations. If I were a dairy farmer, I wouldn’t be shooting the messenger. I’d be putting this place out of business.

Posted by: amyk | May 26, 2010, 2:53 pm 2:53 pm

Does anyone believe dairy farmers do what they do for any other reason than because they have a passion for it and they LIKE cows??? Do you think they do it because there is so much money in it? Do you KNOW what milk prices are like? They are up and down, and right now they are WAY DOWN. Do you think they do it because they want one of the hardest lifestyles possible?
There are a few wackjobs who are getting caught on video. These are not owners, they are employees who are idiots. And to me, this video looks quite staged – like this guy knew there was a camera. These people are not the norm in animal agriculture – they are the exception.
Keep in mind that the people making these videos are dishonest and shiesty. They are driven by a goal to ruin animal agriculture and they will do anything to get there.
Please, please PLEASE educate yourself on both sidse of the story. And DO NOT believe everything you see – and certainly do not believe it is the norm.

Posted by: Jaye | May 26, 2010, 3:04 pm 3:04 pm

Also – kicking udders, stabbing with pitchforks and such leads to illness’s which lead to no milk being sold which leads to no profit. Thus NO ONE who has a stake in whether the farm does does this crap!!!

Posted by: Jaye | May 26, 2010, 3:08 pm 3:08 pm

What happened in this video is horrible and should not happen and is not a true representation of the Dairy Industry or of Conklin Farms. The video appears to be staged, and the same person or persons doing the abusing. It is reprehensible and wrong. They appeared to be showing off for the cameras rather than actually doing anything else. And they (the ones doing the acts) are not farmers when they do something like. Farmers are good people. Naturally the leader of any business or farm or organization ultimately takes the blame and should, but be careful who you’re sticking with that fork. Mr. Conklin is a good man and a good dairy farmer, and clearly he made some poor hiring choices.

Posted by: Concerned Farmer | May 26, 2010, 3:25 pm 3:25 pm

To those who think this is staged- there is no way to stage abhorrent abuse. You think that MFA is trying to ruin agriculture, NO- they are trying to open everyone’s eyes to the lack of control, morals and overall greed the industry operates as. Educate yourself about the fact that your meat, eggs and dairy all come from factory farms where the abuse and filth is widespread and not isolated. Unless you are watching a farmer kill the animal, picking the eggs yourself, or milking a cow THEN it is humane. This is NOT humane and is meant to open your ignorant eyes. Why are you having someone do this dirty work for you? Because everyone who consumes animal products doesn’t want to face the ugly truth and would rather have scum like in these videos kill these animals for them. Open your eyes everyone, the ag industry has major issues. Support your local farmers or kill the animals yourself, but DO NOT support this disgusting industry of scumbags.

Posted by: AD | May 26, 2010, 3:43 pm 3:43 pm

I condemn Conklin Farms and its apologists, you must be stopped before you hurt human beings, you need serious therapy and serious punishment.

Posted by: Orion Hughes | May 26, 2010, 3:50 pm 3:50 pm

Dear Concerned Farmer, if your post is correct why is Mr. Conklin seen hurting a cow? If you are in fact a concerned farmer why don’t you police your own instead of making excuses for them? I think we need a nationwide BOYCOTT of MILK maybe then you will get our message. Abuse will NOT be tolerated and if you cannot police your own then we will! My grandfater was a dairy farmer and NEVER did he ever hurt one of his herd. I hope they put both those men in JAIL. Mr. Conklin needs to be shoveling poo and not dairy farming as he obviously does not keep watch as to what is happening at his farm he should be held accountable!
We are watching all of you and will not hesitate to report ANY of you!

Posted by: Tonya | May 26, 2010, 3:57 pm 3:57 pm

To “Concerned Farmer” who was defending Conklin: Aparently you did not even watch the video of Conklin himself kicking a cow in the head. The comment that one bad apple should not spoil the barrel makes a prefect statement backing Mercy For Animals position. Prosecute these individuals to the fullest since they are “outside” the norm and bad apples right. Therefore stiff sentencing of people like this should offend no one right Mr Concerned Farmer.

Posted by: Concerned Consumer | May 26, 2010, 4:01 pm 4:01 pm

If Mr Conklin in the upstanding man and dairy farmer Concerned Farmer suggests he is, perhaps he will take center stage and ask for stiffer laws and penalties for individuals such as the “poor choices” he made when hiring and training these people. (How you can explain Conklin himself kicking a cow is beyond me), but I will give you, Mr Concerned Farmer, the benefit of the doubt regarding your comment.

Posted by: Concerned Consumer | May 26, 2010, 4:05 pm 4:05 pm

Re: Jaye
Staged video…really? Your position is quite laughable really. What do you think it is, computer generated graphics showing Conklin and his employees abusing animals for no apparent reason. These people should spend 6 months in jail and be fined an amount suffecient to cause them to reconsider their behavior in the future. Or perhaps you would suggest a stern talking to by their mothers.

Posted by: Concerned Consumer | May 26, 2010, 4:14 pm 4:14 pm

I have never seen such horrible cruelity, wht the hell is this dairy stil doing in business? These men should hve the same treatment done to them, I hope and pray that they are prosecuted to the extent….. these are very sick people those poor cattle and calfs, I was raised on a farm, and this just makes me sick……. and Mr Conklin you are a maniac. you all belong in prison, probaly cant fight your way out of a paper bag, so you take it out on defensive animals you dam cowards.

Posted by: karol martin | May 26, 2010, 4:21 pm 4:21 pm

Why are we to assume this abuse is common practice on dairy farms?
I cannot for a minute imagine my family or any one of the farmers I’ve met kicking or smacking an animal in the head for what appears to be pure enjoyment. That is just ridiculous. Shame on anyone who believes the honest, hardworking farm families of this country would be so evil.
As a country we are alienated from agriculture. Most of us have no idea how our food is produced. We are not however alienated from people. Would you suspect your neighbor, co-worker, or the checker at the grocery store of animal cruelty? Why are we so easily lead to believe it of people who have committed their entire lives to the care of the land and their animals?

Posted by: I'm a farmer. | May 26, 2010, 4:22 pm 4:22 pm

Re: I’m a Farmer. I for one do not assume abuse is common. I do wonder why even the farmers are not standing up and saying this is wrong. I read a lot of defense but no disgust on your part. Just as was said earlier, if Mr Gary Conklin who owns this farm is such an upstanding dairy man, why is he not cheerleading the prosecution of these rouge workers? Why are you not asking for that. Fair enough question right!?!?

Posted by: Concerned Consumer | May 26, 2010, 4:35 pm 4:35 pm

Growing up on a small dairy farm I’ve learned to work and respect cattle. They are large animals that are very strong and can be dangerous at times, but what this man in Ohio did is unacceptable. No animals deserve to be treated in that way. Working with cattle can be frustrating at times but there is no reason for him treating his cows in that way. The health and well being of the cows are the most important thing for dairy farmers so why would you harm and harass your cows? He gives dairy farmers a bad reputation that they don’t deserve. This guy should be locked up for life. Also about the news do a story for once about a good dairy? There maybe a handful of this type of dairies but I know there’s a whole lot more better and caring dairy farms than this guys.

Posted by: matt | May 26, 2010, 4:47 pm 4:47 pm

I am a high school student raising my own dairy cattle as well as working on a dairy farm there is no way that this would ever take place on a dairy farm. How can this not be staged?(same man same farm every time? and if this did take place then take the farm from him. Not every farmer is to blame for this this is one out of a million farmers how can you blame a whole industry for one mans doing. The animals are what makes things run on the farm so all of the cattle are treat well to make there lives as easy as possible, our goal is to have our cattle healthy so they can have the best production through out there life. each calve that is born receives the proper care when delivered because they are an important part of the farm. Dairy farmers have nutritionist to make sure that all of the cattle have a suitable diet for there body to keep them healthy, i don’t even have that to in my life. Tale docking is a practice many farmers do not do anymore and is very out dated. So here is the facts from a dairy person the cows are what i live for i want them to be happy and health at all times, manure is cleaned out every time the cattle are milk i walk in the pens all the time they are milked and pens are not manure filled ever. I show my cattle at different expos and would like to say they are pampered the cows bedding is fluffed all the time the are bathed and clipped just like you going to the beauty salon. Just want to let everyone know that i love my cows and all the cows at work i make sure that every time i care for the animals i make sure they have every thing they need to stay happy and health. The cows are my life and i love all of them. Please think about the real dairy farmers in America before you say that all are bad. Fancy is my best friend and i love her. Thanks :)

Posted by: Fancy my cow is the love of my life | May 26, 2010, 4:52 pm 4:52 pm

How can this man call himself a human being…He is a animal!!! Treating these cows with such abuse!!!!!!!!!
The baby cow was tortured FOR what??????? HE IS A Very sick man and needs to go to a mental institution as he is a danger to our society!! And there he needs to get educated on animals and their ability to feel pain and emotions!!!! ALso he needs to be publically humilated till he seeks forgivenss and sincere rehabilitaiton!!!
Crying for the human race and how ignorant it still is!!!
He is a v

Posted by: suzie hayes | May 26, 2010, 5:04 pm 5:04 pm

Matt and Fancy, So glad to see others outraged by this behavior. If Mercy For Animals staged this video they would be liable for any and all damages to Mr Conklin. Do you really think they would sacrifice their careers in some kind of vendetta against anyone? No, they would not. The only thing many of us want are laws so that people like this go to jail and do not get “suspended”. This kind of blatent lack of compassion for life is easily transferred into abusive behavior towards humans. (Not my words, do some research on serial killers and how most start out abusing animals). If this is such outlandish behavior by everyone’s standards, then prosecution of these folks should be NO PROBLEM. All of us should be demanding they go to jail right???

Posted by: Concerned Consumer | May 26, 2010, 5:07 pm 5:07 pm

I’m filled with disgust. It’s animal abuse at its worst. And it must be stopped.
However, I do not believe there are many of these people but the whole industry will pay the price for their actions.
Prosecuting to the full extent of the law is the answer. Zero tolerance. Lock them up. Throw away the key. Let the livestock industry take the lead in making an example of them. We—as an industry and as individuals—must be out front in making it known that these actions will not be tolerated. Animal abuse is wrong. And it must be stopped.
That’s how I feel. There is no excuse for this kind of behavior.

Posted by: I'm a farmer. | May 26, 2010, 5:12 pm 5:12 pm

Re I’m a farmer: Not that my two cents will make of break your day, but I am very happy to see that my request for disgust from all whether in farming or not be voiced was heard by you. KUDOS!!!
We, as a civilized society, need to see that there are laws in place to ensure this behavior is discouraged very strongly. Firing them, a $50 fine will not stop this; but 6 months in jail and a $2,500 fine might make them think twice next time ya know what I mean. :)

Posted by: Concerned Consumer | May 26, 2010, 5:24 pm 5:24 pm

These guys need to be punched and poked just as they did and then put behind bars never to see daylight again. EVIL PURE EVIL.
P.S. Abuse of animals almost always seems to predict abuse of humans. Jeffrey Dahlmer????

Posted by: Kim | May 26, 2010, 5:27 pm 5:27 pm

I am absolutely disgusted by this. Conklin farms should be shut down and everyone involved should face criminal charges – others must have seen and been aware of what transpired. This is terrible and beyond comprehension. Conklin himself should be also held accountable, he was shown in the video. He should be fined, jailed and shut down! DISGUSTING!!!!! I would like to boycott their products, this is a shame that these animals had to endure this.

Posted by: ABSOLUTELY DISGUSTING | May 26, 2010, 5:45 pm 5:45 pm

I and my family are dairy farmers in PA and we do not and have never treated cows or any other animals like in that video. But, the animal rights people thrive on something like this and it furthers their cause. Most of the farmers I know care for their cows as humanely as possible. The workers in the video would have left at first signs of treatment like this. Shame, shame on Conklin Dairy for allowing this to happen.

Posted by: Joann Keenan | May 26, 2010, 5:54 pm 5:54 pm

if you hate your job then freaking quit!!!!!!!!! these guys are sick perverts and deserve to be treated exactly how they treated those poor innocent animals!! FREAKING SAVAGES!!!!!!!!!!

Posted by: Student | May 26, 2010, 6:16 pm 6:16 pm

THAT IS SO SAD A PUNK CRAZY ANIMAL BEATS ON HELPLESS ANIMALS AND PEOPLE WHAT WAS THE POINT I DON’T GET IT

Posted by: BARBARA | May 26, 2010, 6:20 pm 6:20 pm

The dairy industry is just that….complete exploitation of cows. How is that good? How is that justifiable? This is absolutely disgusting behavior. The ONLY solution is to NOT SUPPORT IT!!

Posted by: Nate | May 26, 2010, 6:35 pm 6:35 pm

I do not believe that the owners could not be aware of what was happening to their cows. Pitchforks and tire irons leave marks. Anyone who is a real farmer would notice immediately if their animals were as damaged as these cows were. Conklin Dairy should be shut down.

Posted by: LA | May 26, 2010, 7:43 pm 7:43 pm

my aunt and uncle had a dairy farm and there is no need to abuse those animals like that. those cows are in a routine everyday and know what to do without punishment. i cannot believe someone could be so cruel. and for you people thinking that is staged apparently you have never heard a animal in pain. those men should be cruelly punished.

Posted by: lisa | May 26, 2010, 9:30 pm 9:30 pm

Also most dairy farmers are not exactly millionaires from selling milk. If they killed all their calves, beat the crap out of their cows, stabbed them, beat them with crow bars, etcc…it would stress the cow so bad that she would not produce milk….if you kill the calves you have no up and coming stock. That stupid kid they show over and over in the videos is by no means a farmer. He’s some sick idiot who needs a therapist and lots of jail time!

Posted by: Jennifer | May 26, 2010, 11:01 pm 11:01 pm

Boycotting milk and punishing all of the hard working people who care about their animals and their way of life is not the answer. Tougher laws on animal abuse is a better start. That kid will end up with a fine and maybe minimal jail time. that is the sick part. How does boycotting milk fix that??? IT DOESN’T!!!!

Posted by: Jennifer | May 26, 2010, 11:01 pm 11:01 pm

Educate yourself and take the time to get to know your farmer neighbors. Don’t let the media be the one to educate you!! Get involved, learn from the people who have spent generations doing what they do and loving what they do. These people are very passionate and caring towards their animals.. how many of you have sat up all night with a sick … See Moreanimal or got up every hour in the middle of a blizzard to go check on a cow ready to calve? How many of you have given CPR to a calf or foal trying like hell to save its life? How many of you have stayed up all night trying to nurse one back to health? These are the stories you will never see on CNN or Nightline. These are the stories that the general public never gets to hear and really get to understand the passion behind the people who farm and raise livestock.

Posted by: Jennifer | May 26, 2010, 11:02 pm 11:02 pm

this video is horrible, disturbing….
i have worked on alot of dairy farms, and the cows are treated very well, so this definately is not a portrayal of what a dairy farm is like.
They got a roof over there head, a comfy mat to sleep on, fans to keep them cool in the summer, heated water bowls in the winter, and an electric cow brush mounted on … See Morethe wall that they line up for, so they can get there back scratched. All these things are very standard on a dairy farm.
This farmer is an exception to the norm and should be punished…

Posted by: Steve | May 26, 2010, 11:14 pm 11:14 pm

This “farmer” must be banned from owning animals forever. And, people who did this should go to jail for at least a decade. How horrible beyond imagine!
Unless all businesses wake up and agree to strict regulatory practices complete with regular spot inspections they are going to put themselves out of business.
How terrible.

Posted by: Disgusted | May 26, 2010, 11:25 pm 11:25 pm

I agree no reason to defend Conklin or his farm. They need to be prosecuted to the fullest extent possible.

Posted by: LB | May 26, 2010, 11:49 pm 11:49 pm

We all have a right to be here and to a life without unnecessary pain.

Posted by: Katey | May 27, 2010, 2:13 am 2:13 am

“this sickening cruelty shows a dire need for regulation by federal and state authorities.”
There’s already cruelty to animals regulations; the trouble is these are all self-watched and rarely enforced. FDA couldn’t care less. FBI only cares if animals are rescued from these places.
Only the grassroots can truly expose this. And only a boycott of all animal products can strike this evil in the root. Soy milk, almond milk, rice milk, hemp seed milk instead and dark leafy vegetables for calcium. Show some courage and stand up to this evil.

Posted by: blakmira | May 27, 2010, 2:14 am 2:14 am

To ALL IDIOTS!
I love animals and I abhor abuse. What happened to those cows is reprehensible. However, all of you need to become more educated. Mercy for Animals also has an agenda to fulfill as does the HUmane Society. They want that new bill passed. I think the whole thing is staged as my husband and his family have known the Conklin family for about 40 years and all would say that they don’t abuse their animals. If a farmer abuses his animals, he loses money. Also, the NEW BILL that the Humane Society is trying to get into law needs REVISED! There is a section that states that all animals should have free movement at all times. You can not milk a 1200 pound animal on a tether. It will either seriously injure itself and/or kill the farmer. How do I know? Because there was a vet in the last few years that tethered a cow too lose and it jumped and wrapped the rope around his waist. He died instantly. Are you people seriously going to pass something that could injure animals and farmers because their is a few whackjobs out there?

Posted by: Alida | May 27, 2010, 7:28 am 7:28 am

Consumers should boycott this Conklin Farms and any product produced by the company. Regardless of number of people employed by Conklin Farms, the Federal funding should be pulled and the farm will hopefully shut down. It appears that many individuals participated and endorsed the actions of this Farm. Therefore, they should all pay a price. I sincerely hope this puts Conklin out of business.

Posted by: Jacksonville Resident | May 27, 2010, 7:35 am 7:35 am

I think it is interesting that everyone has jumped on the media bandwagon. I thought news was supposed to be unbiased? If Mercy for Animals does not have an agenda and this was just news, we must ask ourselves why they chose to place a pro-vegan tagline at the end of their video?

Posted by: Alida | May 27, 2010, 7:45 am 7:45 am

Blakmira,
Boycotting all milk doesn’t solve any problems. What that will do is shut down all farms (the good ones with the bad). Then, all of our products will come from overseas where there is much more abuse that occurs and then there is nothing that can be done about it. Not only that, products overseas have been known to contain toxins, such as the toys sent from China with high lead and Cadmiuim levels. If this what you want? Get real. Get educated. And don’t let the media and those in power fool you into shutting down local farmers.

Posted by: Alida | May 27, 2010, 7:53 am 7:53 am

This is certainly not the norm. I agree that there are really bad things going on in this video. Growing up on a dairy farm, I can tell you that this is not the way 99.9% farmers operate. The stuff shown in this video sicked me. Even on a basic business decision, this would be stupid. The cows are a dairy farmers life and blood and treating them like this would cause a farmer to go out of business with the loss of milk production.
Equating this to every dairy farmer is like saying that all child day care centers should be closed because one day care center hired employees that sexually assaulted kids.
Mercy for Animals did a “recent month-long, hidden-camera investigation.” It took them that long to realize that things were going on that they should report it? As soon as they had the first day’s information recorded, they should have turned it over then to get the people criminally prosecuted. They are just as guilty for allowing it to go on, and not stop in and stop it.
Again, allowing someone to sexually assualt kids, is just as guilty as the person doing it.
Mercy for Animals has a motive different than the humane treatment of animals. Even according to this article, they want “vegan diet in the name of farm animal protection.”
Again the majority of farmers raise and treat their cattle like they are part of the family.

Posted by: Del | May 27, 2010, 9:27 am 9:27 am

Del is absolutely correct. I think it’s terrible that Mercy for Animals let it go this far. Abuse is abuse. It shouldn’e matter how many instances of it can be found over a 30-day period of time. Also, I think that ALL the FARMERS in OHIO should sue Mercy and all the news stations for Libel and Slander as they are making headlines about Ohio Dairy Farm Abuse and putting it as if it happens on all farms, which I know for a fact, is not the case. And, the person doing to cruelty is not a farmer, but a hired hand, which are not easy to come by because not many in this country actually want to work hard and do a good job. Finding hired help is not easy. So, I can easily see how perhaps the Conklins were either unaware or needed the help.

Posted by: Alida | May 27, 2010, 10:14 am 10:14 am

While there is absolutely no defense for the actions on this video, this should not be seen as how the entire dairy industry operates. Growing up around dairy farms, and currently raising buffalo for meat, I fully support throwing the book at such animals as these that abuse livestock this way. I also agree with “Concerned Farmer” who if I read his posting correctly is not supporting or defending Conklin. No humane farmer could ever support such treatment. I also think what “Concerned Farmer” is getting at is that the consumer is so far removed from the raising, care and slaughter of animals that the economics of large scale animal production open the door to this kind of abhorrent abuse. These animals in such a situation are not valued as “sentient beings” but as “units”.
But raise, care for and slaughter them yourself, and maybe this kind of disconnect will not be so common. We all have impacts on the earth and other beings, be it eating meet or digging up the earth, cutting down trees and destroying another animals wild habitat to grow vegetables to eat.

Posted by: NaShook | May 27, 2010, 12:12 pm 12:12 pm

I could not believe what I was seeing. The people in this video should be prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law. No suspended sentences, no reduced sentences. I would love to see these scumbags in jail for a long time. They are a threat to anyone around them. I would bet that if this video was shown to the fellow inmates of these individuals, some old fashioned prison justice would happen, which I think that these psychopaths truly deserve.

Posted by: JB | May 27, 2010, 1:00 pm 1:00 pm

To Alida (the real idiot):
You want to defend the Conklin family since you’ve known them so long. YOU need to educate yourself on who you keep company with. Conklin was shown in the video kicking a defenseless animal. What education do we need to be able to understand HIS actions? The camera did not lie.. Conklin and workers are TRASH!

Posted by: Jen | May 27, 2010, 1:14 pm 1:14 pm

In the video the sadist Billy Joe was shown bragging about beating a cow so bad her face was horrifically swollen before sent to slaughter. Does this abuse not affect the quality of the meat product? It is known that the answer if YES! The product from this farm should be boycotted!! This ignorant animal that has worked along with such a monster should pay $$!!!

Posted by: Jen | May 27, 2010, 1:32 pm 1:32 pm

This a deeply depressing statement on human nature and its propensity to inflict suffering. Stories like this undermine my faith in humanity and in a society that would allow such suffering to take place. Unfortunately this is one of many undercover investigations at large farming operations where there is a sense of chaos and confusion for workers and animals. This form of farming is wrong for workers, animals, the environment and human health. I beleive we will ultimately be forced to develop better farms in the future.

Posted by: Robert | May 27, 2010, 1:44 pm 1:44 pm

This People that are miss treating the cows should just come and tell me wath kind of calaber do they want in their head. These peolpe are just garbage.

Posted by: george | May 27, 2010, 2:00 pm 2:00 pm

I am a livestock auctioneer by trade and also a farmer.I was angered by this tape but not surprised . I can pick out the small farm dairy cows from the large farm dairy cows by the animals condition. We lost alot of caring and tradition when factory farming took off.It never ceases to amaze me when a old dairy cow enters the auction ring and I am told by the SMALL farmer she is 15 years old. It would be hard pressed to find one that old at a large dairy farm. The small farmer is saddened by his loss of a an old friend,and really is there to say good bye as I auction her off for beef. I to have seen those happy cow ads knowing that monster factory farms are in California and most of these girls never have seen a blade of grass. Well America, wake up! Happy cows come from the good ol small farmer who knows his cow by an name not a number.

Posted by: patrick | May 27, 2010, 2:13 pm 2:13 pm

OMG that poor baby calf.
I could only watch a few seconds of this…This is horrible :-(
:’-(

Posted by: Angel | May 27, 2010, 2:16 pm 2:16 pm

This is horrible! This people are criminals and should be behind bars. Someone who can do this to a helpless defenseless animal can do it to a human too given the opportunity. I condem Conklin farms, there are no excuses for behavior like this.

Posted by: Isabel | May 27, 2010, 2:18 pm 2:18 pm

Dear concerened farmer I applaud you!!!!! Why would you look straight in to the camera if you dont know it is there!!! I believe this was staged!!

Posted by: Close by | May 27, 2010, 3:00 pm 3:00 pm

Funny how people react more vividly to cow cruelty than stories about domestic violence.
These guys are messed up and totally
desensitized by working around live stock.
I agree, they should be punished for that.
I am not ready to say it’s the norm. Far from it.

Posted by: Whocares | May 27, 2010, 3:23 pm 3:23 pm

I am a farmer, my husbands family comes from a long line of dairy farmers that goes back over 150 years. This video is sick, disgusting and very upsetting. This isn’t something that happens in every day farm life. To blame it on all dairy farmers and boycott milk is for a person with a one track mind. This is people livelyhood, there income! Farmers put there life into their business and too blame all dairy farmers for this one bad egg, doesn’t mean all farmers are like that. We love our animals tremedously. We don’t have dairy cows, we have horses, beef,chickens, fruit and vegetables. This action made me almost loose my lunch. Farmers struggle as it is. Where would you people all be if it wasn’t for farmers putting in long hours, 7 days a week, 365 days a year to put food on your table. What do you just think it grows in boxes, bottles, jars etc. Where do you think fresh vegetables and fruit come from.

Posted by: Debbie | May 27, 2010, 4:11 pm 4:11 pm

I agree with Tuncay 100%. One time seeing this would have made me sick and turned the person in. They watched the place for weeks!!!! Give me a break, you are just as much at fault. Support your local farmers, local farm markets. Most farmers couldn’t afford to abuse animals and loose them. Like Concerned Farmer said, “they are factory farms”.

Posted by: Debbie | May 27, 2010, 4:18 pm 4:18 pm

I have nevert ssen anything like this in my life this has really torn me up i couldn’t watch the video iam really relieved this is out because they need to be severly punished for their actions these laws of animal abuse must be changed those cows should have turned on them and kicked them to where they could not walk to court i pray they rot in prison do not let them out abuse must stop now get these people don’t allow them to do it again i can’t comphrend what makes people do such cruel things to humans and to animals please stop the cruelty

Posted by: ramona | May 27, 2010, 6:13 pm 6:13 pm

This is so sick and heart-wrenching. The person in this video is seriously ill and needs to be locked up and treated. This abuse will not stop at animals, check out the people in this persons life and you will find other abuse. Generally farmers work hard and long hours. They are decent people who are trying to make a life for themselves and their family like any other family. You can be sure that the farmers are outraged by this as much or more than anyone. Not only is this heinous but it also makes no sense economically, you need your animals healthy to make a profit, not beaten and broken.

Posted by: Jim | May 27, 2010, 6:55 pm 6:55 pm

Gary Conklin should definately be held accountable and this business should be shut down. Did Gary Conklin know of the abuse? Well being that he himself, the owner of the company, was shown in the video abusing an animal I would say he not only knew but condoned these acts. I am not an animal activist but this unrelenting torture of the animals that are providing us substanence. Why has Conklin or any of the other workers besides Gregg not been arrested and charged? Insanity!

Posted by: Chris | May 27, 2010, 7:08 pm 7:08 pm

Death penalty.

Posted by: Jeff | May 27, 2010, 8:48 pm 8:48 pm

I would like 5 minutes with this guy thats all it would take with this punk

Posted by: Hermit | May 27, 2010, 9:23 pm 9:23 pm

I hope that sorry son of a burns in hell for doing that to them animals and anyone else that thinks he did nothing wrong you can burn too. Maybe he’ll come back in his next life as a animal that someone would do the same thing to. The world should be rid of people like that, besides a slap on the wrist. I have never hated someone so much that could do something to a defenceless animal. Just goes to show animal cruelty laws arent strongenough. my family owned a very large dairy farm and none of its animals were ever treated like that. Our cows and other animals were treated with nothing and i do mean nothing but COMPLETE RESPECT AND HUMANITY for our animals. Theres no excuse for that treatment at ALL OR EVER. And I give complete props to the individuals that brought these images to the u.s attention. Thank you

Posted by: stephanie | May 27, 2010, 9:33 pm 9:33 pm

How can anyone think it’s acceptable to beat a defenseless animal of any kind whether they know there’s a camera on them or not? Would they hurt them a little less if noone was around? Don’t be ridiculous and get your head out of your ass. I do believe that the ‘norm’ by a lot of the farms is the humane treatment and care of any farm animal whether it’s a cow or a chicken, and anything in between. These guys should have the maximum sentence and fines and maybe a little like treatment while they’re at it. They can show what a big man they are with a metal hook in their nose and getting a few bones broken with a crowbar. I think there’s probably a few people that would be willing to help out. As far as the farm owner not knowing what’s going on is a crock. He’s not a very good businessman if he doesn’t know what’s happening in his own business. How can you hide the blood from the injuries they have inflicted, or the swollen faces, limping or other problems that would arise? I think he knew about what these morons were doing and is just sorry about getting caught and is now acting righteous about the situation. I would never buy any product related to this farm.

Posted by: Pamela | May 27, 2010, 10:30 pm 10:30 pm

I think this is one of the most outrageous videos I have seen, as an animal control officer I’ve seen alot of abuse and if the county agency lets these people back on the street they are just as guilty….I think these people should never be allowed to own or operate a farm anywhere…..they need to impose the same abuse to them. The animals had no defense unless laws are imposed to punish to the full extent….would you do this to a child and get away with it…..God I hope they pay dearly…..

Posted by: jj | May 27, 2010, 11:58 pm 11:58 pm

I would love 5 minutes with a tire iron and that guy.

Posted by: Toni | May 28, 2010, 2:16 am 2:16 am

Maybe I could raise some money online and promise it to whoever is 1st to hospitalise that guy.
If every concerned person put in $10 I’m sure we could raise enough to stop him ever doing that again.

Posted by: ben | May 28, 2010, 9:25 am 9:25 am

I am totally outraged over this animal abuse. I have asked our Governor, Ted Strickland, to shut down Conklin Dairy Farm. This is the tip of the iceberg. I’m sure this has been going on for years and yet the owner, Gary Conklin, says that his cows and calves are treated humanely. The video doesn’t lie. Thanks to Mercy For Animals for the undercover investigation.
Mary Johnson
Gahanna, OH

Posted by: Mary Johnson | May 28, 2010, 11:04 am 11:04 am

wow. that got my blood pressure up. sweats and all. whoever was filming all of the cruelty should be charged with accessory to the crime also. i don’t disagree with some forcible prodding with beligerant animals honestly. but yanking on its eyeballs, stabbing with a pitchfork, clubbing with a tire iron and stuff like that is pretty damned horrible.

Posted by: merd | May 28, 2010, 11:05 am 11:05 am

We would be insane to believe that this company was ignorant to the goings on within their own dairy farm. Were there no managers, supervisor, or owners anywhere on the premises the entire time this horror was going on? The owners of Conklin Dairy Farm need to fess up to their responsibility and show they are truly remorseful and as horrified as the rest of the world about this, and install video cameras as well as make a sizeable donation to the Humane Society. Otherwise, it’s all yada yada BS and we all know it. It’s up to US to make sure that we police dishonest, greedy companies such as this, and we fully intend to do so. The state of Ohio needs to step up too and do their part once and for all. Stiff penalties for this company and changes in the abuse laws of Ohio…NC is doing it, so no excuses, please. We’ll be watching without a doubt. We won’t be going away.

Posted by: Betsy | May 28, 2010, 12:24 pm 12:24 pm

Im so glad that he was caught and I can just imagine what types of things he hasnt been caught doing yet that is so sad….

Posted by: angela huerta | May 28, 2010, 2:49 pm 2:49 pm

Conklin Dairy Farms in Plain City owner)s) and workers are guilty for this barbaric actions. They are responsible and must pay under the law for this horror. The controls in all U.S must be scrutinized at all times. The consumers should know what is behind the products they buy and boycott those tat promote cruelty

Posted by: Ari | May 28, 2010, 5:51 pm 5:51 pm

that is so bad i never seen nothing like it and the in ohio is one sick man to beat alittle baby caff like that and the mother. u wonder what he does when hes not there and no one should by the milk or the meat or nothing from thoughs companys .tears in my heart…….

Posted by: nora | May 28, 2010, 7:14 pm 7:14 pm

You’ve got to just love those who want to pin it on animal activists! WHAT? STAGED?? HELLO! Yes, they were FILMING THEMSELVES because they find themselves so damn entertaining! Have you lived in the 21st century? Have you not heard of all the Whackos and sadists who film themselves and post it (until it’s removed) on Youtube? Some boys who tortured a street dog in Mexico recently did that and thankfully it, like this, created an uproar.
ANIMAL ABUSE, like ANY ABUSE – IS INTOLERABLE, INEXCUSABLE and DANGEROUS, as it leads to increasing violence – PERIOD.
I echo those who’ve pointed out that CONKLIN, HIMSELF is seen abusing his cows. CALVES, no less!!! SHAME ON THEM and SHAME ON YOU FOR MAKING EXCUSES for them, STEVE, JAYE, CONCERNED FARMER! The fact that you are not as sickened by seeing this as most humans are, speaks directly to what’s in YOUR heart and mind. I still can’t breathe after having watched it and as a longtime animal AND human rights advocate, I’ve seen some horrendous things in my time. These ‘men’ have no right sharing this planet.

Posted by: C. | May 28, 2010, 7:27 pm 7:27 pm

Thanks to Nightline for bringing attention to the issue. I will watch the program more regularly after seeing this news coverage. I am not a vegetarian, and drink milk pretty much daily. So I thought the dairy industry’s stance would be to feel just as outraged as any average, reasonable person would feel before animal abuse, especially in their industry. So to see a defensive stance is quite disturbing. By doing so, they pretty much though out the baby with the bathwater, and lose consumers who don’t want to risk funding the wrong people. Consumers like me.

Posted by: Consumer in Chicago | May 28, 2010, 7:37 pm 7:37 pm

Thanking you ABC for continuing to broadcast stories such as this, bringing it to the public eye. Please continue to do follow up with any leads.

Posted by: Harry Hmura | May 29, 2010, 2:06 am 2:06 am

if this guy got chained up and fed to lions it would be more than he deserves.

Posted by: william lambier | May 29, 2010, 12:36 pm 12:36 pm

thank you for posting this for everyone to see! these sort of farms should not remain behind the curtain. people need to see where their food comes from and how it’s made.
someone said “one bad apple doesn’t spoil the bunch.” well this bunch is mostly spoiled. find me a dairy farm where calves aren’t taken from their mothers, where the mothers don’t go through this process of losing their child over and over again, where cows are free ranging on grass, and where the spent cows aren’t sent to slaughter after years of being used.

Posted by: beaut | May 29, 2010, 4:52 pm 4:52 pm

I could not stop crying when I watched this video and I asked myself over and over: What’s wrong with people? Animals are like little babies so depending on us, that we feed them, care for them, love them. I just hope that justice is served in this case and many other.

Posted by: Giovanna | May 29, 2010, 9:37 pm 9:37 pm

This incident makes me sick. I grew up on a dairy farm and we would have never even imagined treating our animals the way they were treated in this video. The health and welfare of our family and our finances were based on the health of the cows. All of the research out there shows that the more relaxed and comfortable the cows are, the more and higher quality milk they produce.
I hope these barbarians are legally taken to the cleaners, they deserve it.

Posted by: Joe J. | May 30, 2010, 12:32 am 12:32 am

Sadness and sorrow for these poor poor animals. Disgust and revulsion for the other animals in the video who perpetrated such vile acts. How can anybody do this to such a placid creature? Is it not enough that these animals are bred for meat and milk? At least they should be respected and treated humanely. The farm should be closed down immediately and these workers, together with Mr Conklin,should be locked away for a long long time.
And a message to everybody, please do not forget and if possible, cut down on the consumption of meat. It will be better for you and for the animals too.

Posted by: anna ballerini | May 30, 2010, 8:23 am 8:23 am

We alrleady have too many federal regulations. You cannot dictate morals to people no matter how many regulations there are. Cruel people will do cruel things – its been that way since time began. This video is exceptionally graphic. There are some times when you have to prod a cow to get it up (as the owner was shown doing in the video). If you can’t get it up, it could die. But the employee in this video goes way beyond that. His treatment of the animals is cruel and he seemed to enjoy it. Most owners try to take good care of their animals since they represent their livlihoods. I am very much against cruelty but I am equally against the government taking more control of our lives.

Posted by: mary | May 30, 2010, 11:57 am 11:57 am

ALL THAT DID THESE HORRIBLE CRUEL ACTS TO THESE POOR DEFENSELESS ANIMALS SHOULD BE CONVICTED AND ALL THAT KNEW THIS WAS GOING ON SHOULD BE CONVICTED. THIS SHOULD BE A FELONY CHARGE AND THEY ALL SHOULD ROT IN HELL!!!!!

Posted by: Pam McConnell | May 30, 2010, 4:38 pm 4:38 pm

I can barely articulate how deeply this video upset me. I’ve already gone to Soy Milk and plan to move from meats altogether. I am an avid animal advocate and seeing what happened at the Conklin Farm makes me want to get myself a crowbar and show those ignorant and dangerous men what it feels like to be beat in the head mercilessly. How can the owner (pictured in the video abusing a cow himself) stand up and say to the public that he had no idea this was happening on his farm?! I know that this behavior doesn’t portray the actions of every dairy farmer in the world. I know that. Having said that and knowing this is an isolated circumstance, I feel that all persons involved in these actions need only to have every count of cruelty they’ve ever committed on an animal done back to them. They may not make it through it, but I’m guessing that many of the cows and other animals they abused in their life times didn’t make it either. I have no sympathy anyone who abuses defenseless creatures. I hope desperately that this man gets more than just 3 years in jail and $9000 in fines. If they give him the maximum, that’s all he’ll get. And if he gets the 2 for 1 deal that they give convicts in Indiana, he’ll be out again in 18 months. It’s just not right. Disgusting, vile, immoral, reprehensible and wrong. That place needs shut down and burnt to the ground.

Posted by: Ashley B | May 30, 2010, 6:49 pm 6:49 pm

What 90 days in jail and a $750.00 fine. Wow can I do the same to him as what he did to this poor cows and get the same sentence. I personally would like to do this to him. What kind of system do we have please we need to have more strict laws and protect our voiceless animals.

Posted by: Lopez | May 31, 2010, 10:54 am 10:54 am

Personally, i would love to take these farm workers and jab them with pitchforks in front of their families.

Posted by: Geo | May 31, 2010, 12:38 pm 12:38 pm

drop him off in a tigers cage or around bulls dressed in red

Posted by: Adam | May 31, 2010, 1:08 pm 1:08 pm

I never understood why people who hate animals, get into the animal business. This is why when my family and I buy milk, we only buy local. There is no need to rush production, for poor treatment. If we wanted to, we could go to the farm and buy direct. In PA, raw milk is legal to buy, and that is all my family drinks. Please support local farmers, know where you are buying from, and put people like this out of business!

Posted by: Sal | May 31, 2010, 1:14 pm 1:14 pm

This guy deserves death. People like this really deserve death. I feel a bit of a hypocrite now since I often say no one has the right to cast judgement on another but after watching something like this… well I have a limit!

Posted by: Bruno | May 31, 2010, 2:24 pm 2:24 pm

well it is plan to see that they don’t love their jobs or they wouldn’t do that to their charges imagine if they were working in aged cared or for the mentally impaired wow we would lock them up for many years for the abuse, which they have done to defensive animals chained up and cant runaway from them. that is my only problem with this type of farming is the people want PROFIT over welfare not only for animals the employees (re:pay peanuts get monkeys). so why use this media to punish a few losers, so then use the media to look at the social issues as a whole why do we blame a few losers for abuse and the whole problem is society as a whole get it right and take responsibility for your own crap and fix the problem not the symptoms as always if they can make profit they will do it or not stop blaming and fix it for every one not just the few who can afford it

Posted by: trevor | May 31, 2010, 7:54 pm 7:54 pm

animals will be animals.

Posted by: Person | May 31, 2010, 10:03 pm 10:03 pm

this is disgusting. i hope he dies.

Posted by: WOW | June 1, 2010, 1:40 am 1:40 am

If you think this video is bad, check out the other documentary narrated by alec baldwin called “meet your meat”. it shows tons of abuses that ware way worse than the ones seen in this video, but that are considered acceptable by the factory farm industry, such as chicken beak mutilation, kosher slaughtering practices, etc etc.

Posted by: john doe | June 1, 2010, 2:21 am 2:21 am

Thanks to ABC News and Mercy for Animals for reporting on this story. Let’s hope that the horror of this crime isn’t pardoned by default when another unconscionable news story shuffles it to the bottom of the pile. This farm needs to be burned to the ground, its owner and workers beaten with crow bars and pitch forks themselves before being made to live in the stench and slop of their own feces. The animals should be given a new home at Farm Sanctuary.
How as a society have we continued to protect the worst behaviors for profit?
Is there no hope for us to act honorably? Are we destined to ignore evil for the sake of convenience?

Posted by: Sarah | June 1, 2010, 11:22 am 11:22 am

I disagree, these workers should be set free immediately. Only thing is, thier release date, time and location should be made public so anyone who wants to have ‘a word’ with them, can.

Posted by: uhm | June 1, 2010, 11:58 am 11:58 am

Obviously these are not California cows, California cows are happy cows :D

Posted by: Zilla | June 1, 2010, 3:32 pm 3:32 pm

Reading all of these comments made me think of an article about Columbine that I read the other day. How many of us fully trust in the news? If you believe this completly then you must believe absolutly everything you see on the news. As far as the comments towards it being staged goes…. I immediately thought it was staged. But, why would these morons condem theirselves unless it was to become famous. We will never know what was going through their minds. The personal interview with that guy just doesn’t seem right though. Also, if he was “struggling” with tending to the animals……wouldn’t the guy holding the camera have stepped in to “assist”. Am I the only one who finds that a little odd that the guy never moved to help. Would you not find it odd if you were struggling to move something and a person you knew just stood there silent? Just an observation take it as you will.

Posted by: cattle rancher | June 1, 2010, 4:16 pm 4:16 pm

We run a large scale cattle ranch. I know that ranches are not the same as dairy farms but they can be similar. We have never in our lives mistreated our animals.
The men that you just witnessed in that video are ones that you will see abusing people and or killing them. I highly doubt that they grew up on a ranch/farm. If they did they need to be taken out back and shot.
As with any industry you will always have your “Culls” who spit in your food, cut corners or just half-ass their work. Think about how many people you know/work with that really don’t care about what they are doing. The sad thing is that they are the ones that PETA and other animal rights groups always manage to find and film.
Please do not judge our industry as a whole based on these morons. For those of you who think we are all rich….You should really look at a balance sheet of a rancher/farmer. It is a commodities market. When the price of cattle is down, hay prices/grain prices are up. The reason that we do it…..we love it. Every aspect of it. There is nothing more exciting than seeing a baby calf born that you planned out over a year ago. Or watching your kids raise a bummer calf from a bottle and then take it to the county fair and win their first ribbon. Do you really think they are going to mistreat bessy?
Please believe me when I say that this does not happen often and that ALL of the parties involved (including the camera man) should be prosecuted. When two men break into a house and only one murders someone they are both guilty of murder. Same should go here. The guy with the camera is out of his mind and equally as guilty for not reporting his findings to local police.
The sad thing is that he was so contented about the video that he did absolutely nothing to stop it. What does that say about his organization if they are not willing to step up to the plate and stop this when it is right in front of their eyes? They allowed animals to be brutally beaten for at least a month before they did anything. Does that sound like someone who really cares about animals? They should have turned them in to the police like anyone with half a brain would have done.
If your kid went over to someone’s house with a video camera and witnessed a father raping a girl and did nothing but video tape it for an entire month, would he be as heroic as the activist holding this camera? Now that it is shone in a different light do you see what I am getting at?
PETA and the rest of these organizations do have an agenda, and they will do what they can to accomplish it. I believe that the organizations were founded for the right reasons, but are now over-run with extremists.
When you donate to the humane society you are NOT donating to help animals. You are, however, donating to pay for lawyers. If you donate anything give it to your local shelter. It will go directly to the animals and their care.
What I am trying to accomplish with this lengthy post is that I want you to see all views. I do not condone any of this and I believe that the farmer should also be punished. I am sorry but it is bogus to think he didn’t know. When those men lifted their hands the animals flinched. He had to have noticed that.
Please do not boycott milk because some liberal extremist believes it will put dairy farmers out of business. And to the liberal extremist, if you put them out of business where do you think the cows would go? Mcdonalds? Or some plush pasture paid for by the government.
Take this as you will it is just my viewpoint and some actual facts about the humane society that sarah mcgloughlin, jenny mccartney (sp…who cares) forget to tell you about.

Posted by: cattle rancher | June 1, 2010, 4:53 pm 4:53 pm

Aww, I can’t believe they abuse animals like that.
———————————

Posted by: Bruce Lee | June 1, 2010, 9:55 pm 9:55 pm

This is outrageous. I am sick to my stomach after watching this. I just can’t believe that someone could be so heartless. The entire farming industry needs to be reevaluated and new standards need to be defined… and clearly, Conklin Dairy Farms needs to be shut down.

Posted by: El Chuey | June 2, 2010, 12:12 am 12:12 am

For whatever reason this has happened and until an investigation occurs the truth will not be known. There is not a lot of money to be had in milk farming, so the owners may not be aware that the people they hire are commiting this kind of atrocity. Yes, perhaps they should have been aware, but we must remember that in this economy that our own mouths to feed and care for are first priority and some things tend to be overlooked no matter how disgusting.

Posted by: Beth | June 2, 2010, 1:53 am 1:53 am

As a young woman, currently working on my degree in agriculture, I have spent countless hours working on a dairy farm back home, not to mention all of the hours I have spent working with a beef cattle operation at school, I have a hard time watching this video. There is nothing acceptable about the violence taking place at this farm. Even as a STRONG supporter of American farmers and American agriculture, I see no reason to keep this farm in operation. Episodes such as this one are what give those of us in Agriculture a bad rep. Get rid of farmers who choose to take part in inhumane practices, and leave the real farming to those of us who truly care.

Posted by: Sweet Soft Southern Thrill | June 2, 2010, 12:29 pm 12:29 pm

*herbicide, not pesticide that is included in innoculations

Posted by: cattle rancher | June 2, 2010, 3:02 pm 3:02 pm

To all of you whom think ranchers/farmers are millionaires (beth);
Before you just jump to conclusions lets remember expenses. Innoculating livestock costs approximately $30/head a year ($3000 for 100) this does not include palpating them.
You bitched and whined when gas was at an all time high, imagine running tractors all summer to harvest hay/grain/other forages, and then continuing to run them throughout the winter. Let’s pretend there is a hay shortage (2006) and the ground won’t defrost. One ton of hay (One big round bale) is going to cost around $200. We feed 5 to 50 head every three days. Imagine what it costs to insure a farm, equipment, cattle, people who work on it. Imagine the power bills from the parlor, irrigation and other misc. equipment. Not to mention control of obnoxious weeds. Some weeds you have to spray with a helicopter because whiny people like you are no longer allowing controlled burns. That alone is around $20,000 vs maybe $100 from field burning, one top of another $20,000 to put on fertilizer. Those pivots you see in the field, they start at $75,000. The hand irrigation, every link is $60+. So before you all start jumping to conclusions about what is in our pocket, try using your head. It is very expensive to run a farm/ranch.

Posted by: cattle rancher | June 2, 2010, 3:13 pm 3:13 pm

Staged or not…the guy in the video needs to be punished. I would skip jail and go straight to breaking fingers, stomping on his head and hitting him with a crowbar. What a piece of trash.

Posted by: NoJailForThisOne | June 2, 2010, 8:45 pm 8:45 pm

Don’t send those bastards to one of our plush, humane prisons! Send them to Iran with CIA documentation and no weapons. Thats the only way they’ll get the treatment they deserve!

Posted by: Greg Epps | June 2, 2010, 10:22 pm 10:22 pm

Thank you amyk! Dairy farmers do not make very much money and they make less when their animals are stressed, sick, or injured because these animals can no longer produce as much milk. In addition to not making very much money they wake up at the crack of dawn to start their work and don’t end until the day is over. They do this because they are passionate about their animals and because they love the industry. I do not know if this is a staged video, but just take a closer look at it. It does appear that Billy is looking right into the video and all of the pictures of Billy are very close up. You can see a definite change in the quality of picture when Gary Conklin is being videotaped. This picture is from far away and is very blurry. This one appears to actually be a hidden camera. I also think it is ironic that Billy and the MFA undercover were hired at the same time, and this was the time when the videos began to be taped. I also think it is ironic that Billy tried to get a job at Select Sires before he went to Conklin Farms and they would not hire him, when Select Sires is right across the street from them. I also think it is ironic that this video came out right when animal rights activists were in desperate need of petition votes so that they could get their initiatives on the ballot in November. Now I don’t know if this was coincidence or if this was a scam. No one does except for the two people involved, but I would like for everyone to look at every angle of the story and remember that only 2% of the population feeds the rest of our 6 billion people. Don’t take this for granite because food is not a right it is a privilege.

Posted by: DJM2013 | June 3, 2010, 11:28 am 11:28 am

amen

Posted by: cattle rancher | June 3, 2010, 2:37 pm 2:37 pm

Just to let whoever made these videos or even had anything to do with them are sick. Is this what you want your children watching? Or better yet would you ever do this to anybody? Im a firm believer in stopping abuse and animal abuse. People, this is wrong and you know it. This isnt fair. To the people of the viewing or better yet, THE ANIMALS. Why cant we milk our cows the “natural” or “american” way? Using pure utter and elbow grease. Not machines. To anybody who agrees, you can fight with me to stop this horrible “trend”. I am disgusted with this kind of behavior.

Posted by: Kellie Hartwick | June 3, 2010, 2:46 pm 2:46 pm

Thank you for sharing this information. Absolutely horrifying treatment. I’m appalled and disgusted. These men have major power trips and anger issues and deserve to be punished for this abuse. Please continue to bring these situations to light so that innocent animals who give so much to us, can have a decent life.

Posted by: twig | June 3, 2010, 3:21 pm 3:21 pm

Seeing that video makes me really angry there is nothing in this world that makes me more angry than animal abuse. Give me 5 minutes with that dude and ill show him some animal abuse he’ll never forget.

Posted by: Matt | June 4, 2010, 4:12 am 4:12 am

Kellie,
How many cows have you milked in your lifetime? To call you on your bs, describe the process, from squeeze chute to filteration. And exotics do not count, they had better be dairy or certain english x breds, or continentals. Or at least a mw epd of the equivelancy to the aaa’s +32. Oh and btw, it is spelt Udders not utters. That fits into “you are utterly ridiculous if you think you are going to win this round.”

Posted by: cattle rancher | June 4, 2010, 4:39 pm 4:39 pm

We need more investigations into the abuse of production animals. It’s doubtful this is an isolated incident.
Just because it’s on the grocery shelves doesn’t mean it’s ‘ok’ to eat….mindless overweight American drones. No wonder Americans are ignorant fat cows. Milk isn’t even good for you, look it up, ignorant.

Posted by: Jen | June 4, 2010, 6:46 pm 6:46 pm

They are only bastards! The same treatment should be used on them!

Posted by: delfy | June 5, 2010, 3:52 am 3:52 am

I think we need a nationwide BOYCOTT of MILK maybe then you will get our message. Abuse will NOT be tolerated and if you cannot police your own then we will! My grandfater was a dairy farmer and NEVER did he ever hurt one of his herd. I hope they put both those men in JAIL. Mr. Conklin needs to be shoveling poo and not dairy farming as he obviously does not keep watch as to what is happening at his farm he should be held accountable

Posted by: Qasim11876 | June 6, 2010, 4:00 am 4:00 am

I’m soo having steak for dinner

Posted by: wooo | June 6, 2010, 4:03 am 4:03 am

think i’m gonna go out and buy a ton of milk, sombody gotta stop all the hardworking people from losing their jobs

Posted by: wooo | June 6, 2010, 4:45 am 4:45 am

Where do you think the cows will go qasim if you put the industry out of business? It is a large industry and it is very hard to “police” it. I am willing to bet grandad had no more than 20 acres with 10 cows on it. You have no clue what you are talking about, stick to big city living and let people who know more give their input on this.

Posted by: cattle rancher | June 8, 2010, 12:22 pm 12:22 pm

These are the punishment which people give to the animals and pet,its not fair.animals deserve rights of their saftey.

Posted by: gesundes Hundefutter | June 20, 2010, 4:58 am 4:58 am

The same happen next to my house. A man who has a dog; never give a bath to this dog. The dog is 17 years old. He looks like a sheep; he never cut its hair. He left the dos outside during the whole winter and we can heard the dog crying everyday.

Posted by: Patty | June 20, 2010, 9:46 pm 9:46 pm

I am a veterinary student and eventually would like to work with primarily dairy cows. When I saw this video it broke my heart and I would never support any of those behaviors. However, what consumers must realize is that this is one worker on one farm and that the majority of farmers do what they do because they love animals and they treat them with kindness. I have been on many dairy farms during my training and while not all the workers have the same passion and love for the animals they still have all treated them with kindness and respect. It is extremely unfortunate that people like this man in the video get away with these actions and it is equally as heart wrenching that the person video taping did not step in and stop him. Also if as a consumer you feel as though you can’t trust farmers, reach out to your local farms, I know in my community they have a lot of community events at farms for the public to learn and even tour a farm. Be informed and realize that this man is not a representative of all of animal agriculture.

Posted by: Karen | November 13, 2010, 1:27 pm 1:27 pm

I don’t drink much milk but am going to boycott all animal products coming out of Ohio. This state has an ever deepening cess pool of abuse.
Many of the surrounding states have shut down their dog auctions–but not Ohio. Hey, a way to make money off the backs of these dependent animals.
I used to think the amish were a uniquely sensitive group choosing to live life outside the mainstream. Their total disregard for the animals in
their filthy hovels. disgusting!

Posted by: myrna | January 6, 2011, 11:47 am 11:47 am

Omg.. wow. To be fully honest, I wannted to stop watching this video from the very begining. This is HORRIBLE and so wrong… wow. This hurt my soul….

Posted by: Edgar Galindo | March 9, 2011, 10:32 pm 10:32 pm

Thank you Mercy For Animals for doing your part in our world

Posted by: Edgar Galindo | March 9, 2011, 10:33 pm 10:33 pm

I cannot believe how angry this made me. Those men should die for what they were doing. I wanted to reach into my computer screen and help the poor cows.

Posted by: Kenzie | March 13, 2011, 2:46 pm 2:46 pm

This is the most horrific thing I have ever seen! What kind of person could actually do this do another living being! I am completely sickened!!! Poor animals!!!!!

Posted by: Jonna Pierce | April 22, 2011, 9:41 am 9:41 am

We need to start making better choices, remember we have choices but ,those poor animals don’t. … :( those poor animals deserve to be freeeee!!!!

Posted by: Maria | May 24, 2011, 10:25 pm 10:25 pm

very sad and unacceptable, heart breaking.

Posted by: dev | July 9, 2011, 1:29 am 1:29 am

This just shows you that you never really know what you’re paying for and i hope this video makes people turn to an alternative life style of not being ignorant, just because theirs happy cow on the cover of the building doesn’t mean it’s going to be peaches and cream

Posted by: Eric | November 7, 2011, 8:42 am 8:42 am

Leave a Reply

Do you have more information about this topic? If so, please click here to contact the editors of ABC News.