Rebecca Zahau’s Boyfriend Warns He Might Sue Her Family’s Lawyer

Medicis CEO Jonah Shacknai is pictured with Rebecca Zahau in this exclusive picture obtained by ABC News.
A lawyer for pharmaceutical mogul Jonah Shacknai has sent an email to the lawyer representing the family of his dead girlfriend, whose body was found at his historic mansion, threatening to sue if her family’s lawyer doesn’t stop insinuating that Shacknai influenced the probe into her death.
The body of Shacknai’s girlfriend Rebecca Zahau, 32, was found on the grounds of his Spreckels Mansion in Coronado, Calif., July 13. She died two days after Shacknai’s young son fell down the stairs of the mansion, suffering fatal head injuries.
A police investigation determined Zahau’s death was a suicide, but her family has hired lawyer Anne Bremner who has raised questions about the death and has pressed police to reopen the case.
ABCNews.com has obtained an email lawyer Dan K. Webb of the law firm Winston & Strawn LLP sent to Bremner Tuesday morning warning that “your false public statements constitute defamation, per se, and under law, entitle Mr. Shacknai to recover from you, and your law firm, substantial damages.”
“What is most concerning are recent false public statements you have made that Mr. Shacknai, because of his business success, has somehow improperly influenced the investigations… You have further made public comments that these agencies have applied a different standard in conducting their investigations because of Mr. Shacknai’s wealth,” the letter said.
Webb called Bremner’s statements “highly insensitive on a human level. Mr. Shacknai and his family have suffered two tragic losses under the harsh and unkind glare of a national media frenzy you have now helped sustain.”
Bremner responded to the allegations Thursday night, telling ABCNews.com, “I haven’t said anything about his wealth nor have I said anything that could be considered false or defamatory … We are simply seeking the truth and justice.”
In the email, Webb emphasized that he was not advocating that Bremner’s clients accept the results of the police investigation. “They are, of course, entitled to their point of view regarding this matter,” he wrote.
The email concludes with, “You must cease and desist from making any further false public statements about Mr. Shacknai.”
A spokesman for Shacknai, Terry Fahn, declined to comment.
In July when police arrived at Shacknai’s mansion they found Zahau on the back lawn, her hands tied behind her back and her feet bound. Her body had been cut down by her boyfriend’s brother, Adam Shacknai, who was staying at the home. A message in black paint on a bedroom near where Zahau was found hanging said, “She saved him can you save her?”
The autopsy report also states there were hemorrhages under Zahau’s scalp, tape residue and blood on her legs, and a T-shirt that was wrapped around Zahau’s neck had been partially stuffed in her mouth.
Email




RSS
Twitter
Facebook
I hope he sues them. He’s grieving the loss of his little boy due to their relative’s neglect of the child (or something even more sinister). He doesn’t need this grief from her golddigging family.
Posted by: ECH | September 8, 2011, 5:23 pm 5:23 pm
I dont ever remember Anne Bremner indicating Shacknai’s business success had somehow improperly influenced the investigations. Every one was already thinking this without her talking about it. What a selfish and self centered man.
Posted by: Jane | September 8, 2011, 5:29 pm 5:29 pm
The autopsy report also states there were hemorrhages under Zahau’s scalp, tape residue and blood on her legs, and a T-shirt that was wrapped around Zahau’s neck had been partially stuffed in her mouth. Her hands were tied behind her back and her legs were tied together
How in the world can any sane person accept this as a suicide. And as for the message – the is errie – She saved him, can you save her – does not sound like a suicide note – sounds like a homicide note to me.
I personally believe it was murder and it was covered up due to his wealth and notoriety.
Posted by: Kate Olsen | September 8, 2011, 5:40 pm 5:40 pm
@Kate Olsen: Suicide notes have been written in the third person before. Not only that, but Rebecca’s note makes sense in the light of Asian beliefs, that suicide deaths free the spirits of those they’ve injured. So perhaps her note meant that her suicide was “payment” for injuring Max, and that perhaps he could return the favour to her by getting well so that she wouldn’t have his death on her hands.
Posted by: ECH | September 8, 2011, 5:56 pm 5:56 pm
It is my hope that the Federal Bureau of Investigation look at this mystery as a potential violation of the poor woman’s civil rights by unknown or unidentified person or persons. Even if only half the things reported are true concerning how this poor woman was found, something is not right. ‘Nuf said.
Posted by: David Pawlowski | September 8, 2011, 6:11 pm 6:11 pm
@ECH: Just FYI. Max is deceased.
Posted by: FD in Seattle | September 8, 2011, 6:12 pm 6:12 pm
Rebecca did not kill Max, she was using the restroom (Damn her for having a bladder)
Step-parents don’t kill themselves for the children (show me one), when she was killed the boy was still alive. Women do not kill themselves hanging naked outside. (show me one) She was Asian not a Japanese kamakazi.
There was no proof she could tie those complex knots.
She received a voice mail but there is no proof to what it said.
She was hit in the head 4 times!!
Women seldom write in block letters, men write in block letters.
She was 32 not an 15 emotional schoolgirl, she was upset about Max but that does not prove in any way she was suicidal.
Why is her BF not want the case open? If someone possibly killed the women I loved I would not stop until I knew for sure and I would hunt down the killer.. Unless it was me..
Posted by: Wally | September 8, 2011, 6:22 pm 6:22 pm
He killed her!! No boyfriend sues his dead girlfriends family just because they want to know how she died.
Posted by: Andrew | September 8, 2011, 6:23 pm 6:23 pm
This woman’s autopsy reports show clear signs of strangulation. So how does San Diego law enforcement state suicide then close the case? Mr Shacknai should be welcoming anything that will shed light on his beloved GF’s death, certainly not be lawyering up against her family! Very fishy.
Posted by: Paul | September 8, 2011, 6:26 pm 6:26 pm
To Kare Olsen: Rebecca’s note makes sense in the light of Asian beliefs, that suicide deaths free the spirits of those they’ve injured.
What Asian belief are you talking about? There is no such a belief that suicide frees the injured’s spirit. Plus, is there any evidence that Rebecca injured Max?
Posted by: Karen | September 8, 2011, 6:27 pm 6:27 pm
Perhaps it is time for law enforcement to step aside and the FBI step in and take over this investigation.
Posted by: NewUnion | September 8, 2011, 6:28 pm 6:28 pm
I never read from anywhere that Anne Bremner implied Shacknai’s wealth had improperly influenced the investigations. Most people on the web made that implications themselves based on a number of facts. What probably irked Mr. Shacknai was that Anne Bremner released information such as the painted message on the door, Rebecca’s hemorrhages under the scalp, etc. These information fueled the public’s rage over the case and put a lot of pressure on the San Diego sheriff’s department and made possible a reopening of the case.
Posted by: Karen | September 8, 2011, 6:34 pm 6:34 pm
Open the case send them to jail!! Who do I call to make it happen?
Posted by: Becky | September 8, 2011, 6:36 pm 6:36 pm
The BF is Guilty as HELL!!
Posted by: Sarah | September 8, 2011, 6:37 pm 6:37 pm
The family has every right to question the circumstances regarding her death BUT they don’t have the right to make accusatory statements regarding Mr. Shacknai. THAT is why he is threatening to sue, and I don’t blame him. Do the circumstances sound suspicious…heck yeah they do but that doesn’t mean he was involved. We are so quick to convict in the media, it’s beyond ridiculous! Last I heard, one is innocent until proven guilty in a court of law. Has that changed?
Posted by: KC2CHI | September 8, 2011, 7:15 pm 7:15 pm
He’s going to sue! LOLOLOL. If anybody should sue, it’s Rebecca’s family for killing her. Doesn’t this guy even care that she has been murdered? WOW.
Posted by: bb | September 8, 2011, 7:20 pm 7:20 pm
I think it’s his exwife, who had someone kill her or this guy’s brother who flew in the night she was killed, from Memphis, but I still lean toward the exwife. By the way, this woman was gagged and beat up.
Posted by: bb | September 8, 2011, 7:23 pm 7:23 pm
Maybe the house is haunted?
Posted by: Jose | September 8, 2011, 7:31 pm 7:31 pm
This fool is just trying to bully ther family. Im rich and your not. This was no suicide, unless this woman was Houdini!! I personally find this disgusting that he would stoop to this level. Anyone who believes he didnt do it or have it done, is really misinformed. He should have been arrested immediately. I hope the family fights him on this. 2 people have lost their lives in this………….and both cannot speak up and defend themselves on who did this crime. ‘nough said………
Posted by: bob | September 8, 2011, 7:34 pm 7:34 pm
I am also leaning toward the ex wife involved in this. She wanted to shame Rebecca as much as possible hence the naked hanging. Also agree women don’t write in block letters. It’s a contract killing.
Posted by: tj | September 8, 2011, 8:14 pm 8:14 pm
Everyone on here is correct – NO One would kill themselves in this way – this BF and his Brother should both be investigated in this supposed suicide. How convenient that his brother found her and cut her down – heck if she is already dead let her hang until the Police arrive and do their job. If you don’t want accusations made then don’t tamper with the crime scene. I am going to bet that this little boy’s “accident” may need to be investigated as well. What if he saw something he sould not have seen and was going to tell his father – which set off this entire set of tragic events.
Posted by: Mercedes | September 8, 2011, 9:24 pm 9:24 pm
Dan K. Webb? I believe he was a former US Attorney (from Chicago ?). Boy, this CEO sure has money to throw around getting the best legal help. Now, it’s more certain that there is really, really something to hide. Yessir! Americans, is there justice in America? I sure hope so.
Posted by: Mei Om Law | September 8, 2011, 9:28 pm 9:28 pm
He only values all of his friends and relatives and that poor girlfriend means absolutely nothing to him. It seems any harm to him or any one of them is unacceptable to him.
Good enough reason to use money power to accomplish it and sue.
Posted by: Paul setra | September 8, 2011, 9:39 pm 9:39 pm
Ok, so this expensive lawyer writes a letter that says “my client is going to use his money to destroy you if you don’t stop insinuating that he uses his money to threaten people and get the outcome that he wants”. Interesting, very interesting.
Posted by: Missy | September 8, 2011, 9:41 pm 9:41 pm
People in the construction or architectural field write in block letters.
Posted by: Jane | September 8, 2011, 9:45 pm 9:45 pm
I don’t believe it was a suicide either. Why would she refer to herself as “she” in her own suicide note? Let alone binding and gagging herself. I also don’t think the boy’s death was an accident either. At the time of the hanging, the girlfriend had previously saved the boy by performing CPR and gotten him help. He was still alive in the hospital when the woman was hung. The note on the door read “she saved him. can you save her” Somebody was out to get this guy through his loved ones.
Posted by: Missy | September 8, 2011, 9:46 pm 9:46 pm
I agree with u bb….maybe the ex have some involmemt..
Posted by: lulu | September 8, 2011, 9:50 pm 9:50 pm
The more I find out about this case the more I suspect it was not a suicide. I think a private investigation is in order here.
Posted by: JMPOV | September 8, 2011, 10:14 pm 10:14 pm
He just revealed himself as the killer and the brother was his hit man. He’s going to sue the victim’s sister and Mother for wanting a thorough investigation? Blood Simple.
Posted by: Detective_X | September 8, 2011, 10:18 pm 10:18 pm
I really don’t understand how ANYONE could believe this is a suicide. Really guys? Either investigators are bat sh- dumb or they’ve been paid to sway the public. My bet’s on the latter.
Not saying he killed anyone, but this is no suicide. You don’t have to be a detective to figure that one out.
Posted by: anon | September 8, 2011, 10:19 pm 10:19 pm
The visiting Brother probably had a thing for the deceased… snuck around her room and ran into the child. He attempted to scare the child into silence and mortally injured the child. Fearing that the deceased woman might have figured things out, he them fabs a story to the boyfriend that the girlfriend was responsible. The boyfriend in grieving turns a blind eye to the Brother’s perversion and let’s him kill the girlfriend in vendetta. The Brother is a tugboat crewman which explains that nautical knots used o the body. He cut the body down to attempt to correct a mistake… maybe the duct taping of the legs. They are both guilty as sin, and their actions at deception bear it out. The SDPD is also implicated in trying to protect the reputation of the Millionaire and the City of SD from this lurid case. Give it to a Grand Jury. As phone calls, txting were involved and clear human rights violation and obvious local malfeasance, where is the FBI?
Posted by: Detective_X | September 8, 2011, 10:27 pm 10:27 pm
@FD in Seattle – Max wasn’t dead when Rebecca killed herself. She probably hoped that her death would atone for her injuring Max, whether intentional or not. And to the people who asked about the Asian belief that suicide gives the dead person power to help living relatives. that’s pretty common. That’s why suicide is so common in Asian countries.
Posted by: ECH | September 8, 2011, 10:39 pm 10:39 pm
I think the note on the door is the saving grace for Mr. Shacknai. I think everyone needs to be further investigated as those that did the investigation, as it was stated from the beginning, were not real good at it???? I think Dina needs to be investigated thouroughly!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! And maybe someone will come forth if they were hired to do the job.
Posted by: Barbara | September 8, 2011, 10:41 pm 10:41 pm
@Wally – You’d be surprised how many people kill themselves in the nude.
Posted by: ECH | September 8, 2011, 10:41 pm 10:41 pm
Let’s imagine I am a CEO. My girl friend mysteriously gets killed, what would I do? Hire a PR firm, a bunch of lawyers, and make sure the story goes away. I would avoid commenting on it. After all, what a PR nightmare! How about my sales and shareholder value?
Sadly these are the priorities of the times we live in. That’s why this case is drawing so much attention. It really hit me like a hammer.
Posted by: PI Rockford | September 8, 2011, 10:44 pm 10:44 pm
@ ECH: Are you Dina in disguise? As an Asian American myself, I’ve never heard about your Asian belief. Please stop spreading the rumors and try to be helpful to seek for justice.
Posted by: JeanG | September 8, 2011, 11:40 pm 11:40 pm
I wonder who this ECH person is. Are you the ex-wife??
Posted by: Jojo | September 8, 2011, 11:50 pm 11:50 pm
Critically think about every post on every website. I realize this describes me too, but there are a lot of new posters everywhere this story is written and many of them attack the victim, even though after reading everything–including the leaked ME report–its incomprehensible to consider this a suicide. I don’t think her boyfriend was involved but he did hire a PRE firm and posting attacks on the family would match that job….
Posted by: car guy | September 9, 2011, 1:44 am 1:44 am
It does not take a genius to figure out that money and influence had a lot to do with the outcome of this investigation. If Ms. Zahau was found dead in an average Joe’s house under the same suspicious nature, I’m sure there would have been a murder investigation from day one and those closest to the case would have been identified at least as “persons of interests” if not as “suspects”. Polygraph tests would have been given and both the course and outcome of the investigation would have been very different from the one we have now.
Mr. Shacknai is proving here that money intimidates to say the least.
Posted by: CuriousObserver | September 9, 2011, 1:47 am 1:47 am
if shacknai and his team can sue to shut america up, he would. he has enough money to do so. if so, oj smpson shd sue nicole’s family for suing him. why dont he sue everyone on twitter and facebook and news comments too??? if my gf is found dead tied up gagged and humiliated, i will be using my money to find the killer, unless it were me, what a self deluded guilty as hell a-hole. Wally thank you- you said it right, no woman, asian or not, kill themselves naked with expert knots tying their limbs behind their back then hop over the balcony 3 feet tall?? will those who rule this a suicide demonstrate how rebecca turned houdini and threw herself off a balcony, after being hit 4 tmes on the head, duct taped and bloodied. ECH – you sound like shacknai team with made belief asian beliefs, spirts do not save the living nor the dead, do you know of any woman, asian or not, who killed herself, if a STEPchild was injured. no blood ties, no suicide, and this whole thing how money is trying to INTIMIDATE just makes america sick. FBI / GRAND JURY – WHERE ARE YOU? do america some justice
Posted by: Free Speech | September 9, 2011, 1:52 am 1:52 am
The SDPD refuse to release info about the painted message on the door, Rebecca’s hemorrhages under the scalp, These alone they should reopen the case. I been following the story and the lawyer never said anything about the wealth. Well, maybe I’ve said it.
Posted by: dugudr | September 9, 2011, 3:12 am 3:12 am
This is getting mighty interesting! Dateline, 48 hours where are you.
Posted by: dugudr | September 9, 2011, 3:19 am 3:19 am
could the hemorrhage be from her head possibly hitting the ground from being cut down by the brother? i know it looks suspicious, but maybe she felt guilty that the little boy got hurt on her watch. If not she probably was dead before she was thrown, but then again they say she asphyxiated no? meaning it could have came from the hanging.
Posted by: IDKoK | September 9, 2011, 7:02 am 7:02 am
“She saved him,can you save her”.
This almost appears to be a riddle. The reports indicate that she was a religious/spiritual individual.She did not believe in suicide because in the hereafter one goes to hell.
Whoever painted the message on the wall may have been mocking her religious beliefs.
t… One can hypothesize that she was a “christian”. The statement tells a story, she may have shared with him her faith in Jesus and he accepted Jesus into his heart=”saved”.Maybe the people in his immediate circle did not like his conversion. The other half of the message “can YOU SAVE her” is directed towards God. Can He “save” her from her impending death.
This whole case is very creepy and indeed twisted.
Posted by: Jen | September 9, 2011, 8:15 am 8:15 am
It wouldn’t be in tune with the American spirit to accuse Mr Shacknai of any involvement. He is grieving and our thoughts and prayers are with him. The case is drawing a lot of publicity, and managing public opinion is very difficult, so it is understandable that he hired professionals to assist him. The case is inconclusive, but it’s not fair to declare anyone guilty until it is proven. I am sure Ms Zahau’s family has shared its suspicions (“Rebecca was killed and we think we know did it”) with the authorities. It is now up to them to investigate further. I also don’t think anybody was paid off to rush the investigation. The rush is more of this strange but common behavior in the US where everybody caters to the money class even if most of us aren’t part of it. See the tea party’s policies, too. Why would most of the tea party members so vehemently defend the rich and care about the money class’ tax rate. Somehow America likes to watch how the rich live, and will defend those who achieved the ultimate American dream (which is wealth). That’s what happened in this case; although I presume the tycoon’s innocence, the investigation was pushed to a premature conclusion in order to prevent any damage to the firm. I hope the case will soon be solved to everybody’s benefit.
Posted by: PI Rockford | September 9, 2011, 9:51 am 9:51 am
There is no Asian belief that suicide will give the dead person power to help their living relatives. Stop spreading the false information. Being an Asian myself, not Asian growing up in America but Asian growing up in Asia, I am amazed how people like ECH can make up something like this. You are taking advantage of the fact that most Americans don’t know much about Asian culture. You can post your statement in Asian forums and see how many people will tell you that is total BS.
Posted by: Karen | September 9, 2011, 10:39 am 10:39 am
I would advise Mr. Shacknai to fund the Zachau Family investigation. The expense would be nothing to him and his support would demonstrate his compassion and innocence.
Posted by: PatRedstone | September 9, 2011, 12:05 pm 12:05 pm
Death Before Dishonor…
She mustve had something to do w/ it,
and that is all ASIAN culture.
Posted by: Theorists | September 9, 2011, 1:02 pm 1:02 pm
Karen is right. Showing some public feelings may be a good thing.
Posted by: PI Rockford | September 9, 2011, 1:04 pm 1:04 pm
My research shows that it is not uncommon for people to ties their hands (maybe feet too) before comitting suicide so as to avoid the reflex to fight. Tongue would hang out of the mouth upon hanging, so maybe put the shirt in her mouth to avoid this…Not sure why she was naked…Could have hit her head on her way down (or swinging). If one were to PAINT letters on a door it would prob be easier to use block letters. Sounds kind of normal for a suicide note to try to be poetic. Hasn’t this man been through enough…If she were murdered and the perp were trying to make it look like a suicide, why make it look like a murder (tying the hands, message, etc)
Posted by: sherry | September 9, 2011, 1:11 pm 1:11 pm
If this same situation had happened at your average middle class household, there would be a charge of murder and a full investigation.
The suicide does NOT pass the smell test.
Reminds of the snarky joke about blacks found hanging from trees in the south, riddled with bullet holes, only to have the town sheriff state it was the worst case of suicide he’d ever seen.
Suicide?
Don’t think so.
Posted by: jon | September 9, 2011, 1:42 pm 1:42 pm
Do you mean to tell me that the brother found her, cut her down so she would fall one story, break a table it seems with her fall, and THEN call 911? I don’t get it. Is there any evidence that he went and checked her after he cut her down? Seems like she was left there naked to humiliate her even more. Very suspicious…all of it.
Posted by: Mary-Frances Reilly | September 9, 2011, 1:43 pm 1:43 pm
I think what the public finds startling is that there seems to be very little expression of compassion for the Zahau family from the boyfriend’s family. All that is reported is the infamous cease and desist order. Possible that the compassion was kept private and now the lack of such PR is backfiring. Strategically paying for the private Zahau investigation may have been better than paying for lawyers, private security and a PR firm.
Somehow what the public thinks spiraled out of control…and there’s no closure in sight in the court of public opinion.
Posted by: PI Rockford | September 9, 2011, 2:08 pm 2:08 pm
Agree totally with Pi Rockford. Mr Shacknai attacking the Zahau family reeks of guilt at most and knowledge of who murdered Rebecca at least. That he has not shown the least of compassion from the moment she was found, coupled with the extremely biased shoddy police investigation, has created this case spiraling out of control.
Posted by: Paul | September 9, 2011, 2:53 pm 2:53 pm
Interesting that the Zahau family have not expressed one iota of grief for little Max’s death. Interesting, too, that they loved Jonah Shacknai and denied he had any wrongdoing in Rebecca’s death, until the money ran out.
Posted by: TC | September 9, 2011, 3:04 pm 3:04 pm
By the way, as soon as Max was taken to the hospital with life threatening injuries, Rebecca and her sister went shopping. That’s right. They spend the child’s father’s money, then planned a party for a few days later. Sounds like odd behavior from someone who allegedly loved little Max like her own son.
Posted by: TC | September 9, 2011, 3:06 pm 3:06 pm
yes to everyone above who is logical and not lost in some jackie chan film.
Remember, she was deeply religious and would not have killed herself, not to mention she’s a beautiful, intelligent female who would have rather been sleeping instead of making a list of supplies needed from home depot to take her own life at 3 am.
let’s ask any female posting here.
If your boyfriend was the owner of a pharmaceutical company and you REALLY wanted to commit suicide.
would you
a. take some (readily available) pills and slowly fade out
or
b. write an obscure message on a wall with black paint (remember we are females who know how to communicate our feelings very clearly)
mark our bodies with black paint, bang ourselves on the head in 3 places, strip naked, make a noose with a complicated military slip knot, bind our feet, find a tee shirt to jam in our mouth (check), as we are standing with bound feet and gagging we will then bind our hands and jump to our death. did I leave anything out? Oh yeah, the fact that this was NOT a suicide.
Posted by: fancydrew | September 9, 2011, 4:42 pm 4:42 pm
Interesting comments TC. Don’t recall reading anything about Rebecca and her sister going shopping nor that her family benefited in any way from Jonah Shacknai’s money. Why are you bashing the victim here? Two lives were tragically taken. I question your agenda.
Posted by: Paul | September 9, 2011, 4:44 pm 4:44 pm
@ Fancy Drew – She couldn’t have been too religious since she was caught shoplifting $1,000.00 worth of jewellery from Macy’s and had a criminal record. As far as women hanging themselves go, it’s the most common way of females committing suicide in Asian countries. Remember, Rebecca wasn’t born here.
@Paul- Rebecca’s sister made the comments about Rebecca going shopping immediately after Max was fatally injured. This was her “proof” that Rebecca wasn’t suicidal over Max’s death. Same with the wild party Rebecca threw. Both those tidbits come from the mouths of Rebecca’s family.
Posted by: TC | September 9, 2011, 5:01 pm 5:01 pm
@TC when did she shoplift, how many years ago was that? Does that mean that because a person shoplifts they can not be religious or make changes in their lives? should I conclude that shoplifting leads to suicide from your logic? Since you seem to know so much about Rebecca please do tell what pr firm are you working for exactly?
Posted by: fancydrew | September 9, 2011, 5:12 pm 5:12 pm
@ Fancy Drew – The shoplifting charges were in 2009 or 2010. They were not long ago, nor was she a small child when she committed the crime. She was a mature woman in her 30′s. Religious people don’t steal because it’s, oh I don’t know, kind of like breaking a major commandment. My point is that this woman was not a stellar member of the community nor some nun like her opportunistic family is trying to make her out to be. She was after money and they’re after money plain and simple. She shopped while a child lay dying. She threw a wild party while a child lay dying. Perhaps when she learned her meal ticket was drying up she decided to end it. Or maybe she was afraid evidence would tie her to Max’s death and land her in jail.
Posted by: TC | September 9, 2011, 5:37 pm 5:37 pm
@ Paul – A person with “serious problems” is one who browbeats a grieving mother and father and tries to ruin their livelihood because he/she/they want his money.
No one has said Rebecca deserved to die, whether it was by her own hand or not, but it’s odd that you and so many others here are not sad in the least that little Max is dead. You gloss over the child’s death. So if you want to talk about someone who didn’t get a life, it’s a little 6 year old boy who died under far more suspicious circumstances than some golddigging shoplifter.
Posted by: TC | September 9, 2011, 6:38 pm 6:38 pm
And by the way, Paul, the Zahau family and Rebecca’s ex-husband (who also has a criminal past) are trying to get the public to fund their “investigation” (code for “civil suit” because there’s already been ONE investigation that taxpayers have already paid for). Hope you’ve donated.
Posted by: TC | September 9, 2011, 6:40 pm 6:40 pm
Rebecca’s shoplifting has nothing to do with her murder. Justice has been perverted in the investigation of her death. That’s why people are outraged. The six years old died and it was a tragedy. But there is no sign of coverup in that death. I personally believe Rebecca was a gold digger. However, she’s no worse than other rich men’s young wives and she certainly does not deserve to die. I don’t believe her family is asking for donation to pursue the civil suit. They can open a civil suit at any time. And there will be plenty of lawyers jump on that case to work for free (and get their paycheck as a percentage of the final payout). The family needs money to hire private investigators to keep the criminal investigation going and hopefully new evidence will eventually make the police department reopen the criminal case. No private investigators/researchers will work for free because criminal cases won’t carry a big payout. It does not matter whether Rebecca shoplifted and had DUI on her record. The family deserves justice.
Posted by: Karen | September 9, 2011, 7:29 pm 7:29 pm
In the same case, the rich man just can get away from it whie common folks can not. Police just buy what the rich man says without any doubt.
Posted by: newman | September 9, 2011, 7:49 pm 7:49 pm
@ Karen – Rebecca’s criminal past definitely DOES have something to do with establishing her as an unstable person. Unstable people are more likely to commit suicide, a fact which is something her family wants denied. They also, along with her criminal-past ex-husband, are asking for donations under the GUISE of pursuing a private investigation, but they really want it for a criminal lawsuit. You see, an investigation has already been carried out at taxpayer’s expense, but they want to bleed everyone else dry so they can profit financially. That’s not what moral people do.
Posted by: TC | September 9, 2011, 8:46 pm 8:46 pm
Give it a rest TC. I am just having a tough time figuring out why your are so angry and defensive. Re-opening the case and having an independent investigation would put all this speculation to rest. That would be a good thing for all involved. I cannot imagine anyone could disagree, especially Jonah Shacknai and his family.
Posted by: Paul | September 9, 2011, 8:54 pm 8:54 pm
@Paul – Not only am I not angry nor defensive, but whenever someone projects something onto you that you’re not feeling, chances are they are the ones feeling it themselves. In other words, you’re awfully angry and defensive about the death of someone you presumably don’t know. Unless you’re hinting that you’re the criminal ex-husband or something. Hmmmm.
Anyway, no one is arguing about the family’s right to a private investigation, but they should be the ones to pay for it. The public has already paid for one investigation into Rebecca’s death. The family doesn’t like it, so they want another one. Fine. Let them cough up the money. Rebecca had parents, sisters, in-laws, friends, and ex-husband. Don’t they care enough to come up with the cash?
The point of this article isn’t whether or not the family has the right to an investigation. It’s about whether or not they have the right to slur innocent victims, including a dead childm in the press because they’re angry their cash cow is dead and her ex-boyfriend won’t line their pockets with more money. That’s the crux of the matter.
RIP, little Max.
Posted by: TC | September 9, 2011, 9:12 pm 9:12 pm
What a smart tactic.. Hire expensive high end lawyers to force and bully other people into not saying he uses his money and influence to get what he wants. I am going to remain quite and not say anything by saying something. Jonah, everyone knows you paid your brother Adam to kill Rebecca because you and your wife blame Rebecca for your son’s death. Everyone that knows the both of you knows you are both terrible parent and bad people. Max is better off than having to live in your madness. Max loved the relationship he and Rebecca had and he talked about her all the time. Jonah and Dina were too busy being selfish in their petty lives. Surprised Max died in Rebecca’s care, he was always in her care. Jonah was always golfing and Dina was always shopping. All three of you Adam, Jonah, Dina need to go to jail for Rebecca’s death. Jonah staged it, the house was full and even the guest house had renters. The day after Max fell Jonah sent everyone away even the dog. At the same time he sent for his loser brother who lived in a dump despite his millionaire brother. Adam works on a tugboat and is a pro at tying KNOTS.. That night Rebecca is killed, with rope, using knots.. Re-Open this case, do not let his money buy you..
Posted by: Wesson | September 10, 2011, 4:11 am 4:11 am
Shacknai is guilty of murder and he wants to use his money to make it go away. That sounds bad, but what is worse is everyone that is taking his money. You have to be an idiot to think he had nothing to do with this woman’s murder. Since he hasn’t even been named a suspect then he must have paid off or scared the right people. I am giving the family money, I want to see this creep fry!!
Posted by: People | September 10, 2011, 4:41 am 4:41 am
The brother Adam killed Rebecca and Jonah set it up. The house was full of people and even the guest house had renters until the day Max fell. Jonah sent everyone “including the dog” away and brought his brother who works as a crewman on a tugboat in the next day. That night she dies.. He had the motive of the parents anger because they blamed Rebecca for Max’s fall, and he will have the payout which I am sure will come soon. Jonah and his brother aren’t even close, yet he flew him in over all the other family and friends to choose from. Look at those knots and tell me who can make those better, a 32yo Asian woman with no knot tying experience or a crewman on a tugboat. As far as scaring her into being quiet and maybe even helping at times.. What about the second knife people? One to cut, one to threaten.. The excuse that it was suicide because Rebecca was guilty or distraught is horrible. There is no proof that she was anything other than concerned like any other person would be if you boyfriend’s child was in the hospital. There is NO proof or witness that she felt any guilt for his accident.. DOn’t LET THIS STORY DIE.. PLEASE RE-OPEN CASE.
Posted by: TC4 | September 10, 2011, 5:00 am 5:00 am
Yes, bring in the FBI; the police department has been bribed.
Even an 8 year old can tell this is not suicide; only fools believe it is.
Posted by: Ann | September 10, 2011, 7:13 am 7:13 am
@Bob7: You are essentially calling Rebecca’s family liars, because they are the ones who maintain she went shopping with her sister immediately after emergency workers took Max away in the ambulance. Rebecca’s family say she threw a party the night before she died. They offer these as proof that she wasn’t depressed. Others could say it looks more like she was callous and uncaring. Kind of like Casey Anthony.
@Ackers – I’m well and familiar with suicide statistics. You obviously are not. Rebecca’s family have claimed she was a happy, well adjusted person who never did anything wrong to anyone, when facts show otherwise. She had a criminal record and a little boy, under her care, is dead. People who are happy and well adjusted don’t commit crimes. They don’t mar their bodies with extensive plastic surgeries so they are almost unrecognizable. They don’t send email messages to their sisters, complaining about their boyfriend’s children while maintaining publicly that they love said children more than their own mothers. Rebecca Zahau was a troubled soul and her poor decisions caught up with her.
Many of you hate Jonah Shacknai because in this age of recession, he represents what you envy: weath. You write hateful words on the internet because you wish you had just a smidgen of the wealth that this grieving father does. Well I’ll tell you what: this grieving father would probably give his entire wealth away if it would bring little Maxie back. Think about that next time you hug your kid.
Posted by: TC | September 10, 2011, 8:21 am 8:21 am
Everything is possible: Tying hands and feet, putting a noose around your neck, stuffing a T-shirt in your mouth, but hanging yourself naked for all to see, no, I don’t believe a woman would ever do that.
Posted by: Gabrielle Moore | September 10, 2011, 1:00 pm 1:00 pm
So tell me TC…..was she so unaffected and unconcerned by the boy’s condition that she shopped and partied, or was she so devastated and distraught that she committed suicide?
Posted by: AtlGa | September 10, 2011, 9:17 pm 9:17 pm
God, this is obviously a murder, NOT a suicide!! Who on earth would go through all this trouble (and naked, of all things) to die?!
By the way, TC, you sound damn suspicious and it’s creeping everyone out. Of course everyone’s grieving the little boy’s death too, why are you so against Rebecca..? And no one said they hate Jonah Shacknai…..people are pointing fingers at the case, not at him especially.
Posted by: Lena | September 11, 2011, 7:15 am 7:15 am
All Rebecca did was be at the wrong place at the wrong time. She became the scapegoat for the Shacknai family. It is always very suspicious when the victim’s image is being tarnished. It is the guilty party’s way of convincing the public that she deserved to dye.
Posted by: TC9 | September 11, 2011, 8:56 am 8:56 am
It’s sad to think that Rebecca Zahau thought that Jonas Shacknoi loved her when in fact it appears he loves himself more and is willing to do about anything to shut her family up and try to sweep this under the rug. If he really loved Rebecca Zahau, he would at all cost try to really find out what happened to her, perhaps he knows. But his actions show that he trully has something to hide. You do not sue her family to keep them quiet and threaten leagal action. Something is totally amiss here and I smell a dirty weathy rat.
Posted by: Kim | September 11, 2011, 2:00 pm 2:00 pm
Rebecca was hit in the head 4 times and knocked unconscious. Maybe she did that to herself? She was also gagged, hands bound behind her back. C;mon now. The person who killed her tried to makeit like a suicide first then came up with the wall writing idea to confuse the scene. The writing was not in her handwriting either. Note that the bf Jonah Shacknai had a domestic violence history and hsi alibi seems full of holes , the multi millionaire says he was in the ronald mcdonald house …doing what ? at 3 AM ? He has hired some PR people now so that his company stock doesnt tank and he doesnt have to resign. He has paid off everybody. The bf Jonah Shacknai is a millionaire and knows how to grease palms. Now his PR people are spinning and lying. Shame on the cops , they should be fired. The truth will come out eventually.
Posted by: RyanW | September 11, 2011, 6:13 pm 6:13 pm
Interestingly “OJ” are the first two letters in JOnah Shacknai’s name. Just sayin.
Posted by: sensing sarcasm | September 12, 2011, 2:50 am 2:50 am
Yes, Rebecca was a gold digger; so was Dina and Shacknai’s first wife…….c’mon, besides money, what could have attracted women to this ugly fella, whose twin sister happens to be Jocelyn Widenstein.
Posted by: Ann | September 12, 2011, 1:07 pm 1:07 pm
It really amazes me how uninformed people are regarding suicide. Suicide among Asians are the lowest and being Asian I have never heard of some ot these ridiculous theories, perhaps in a made up Charlie Chan movie in the 1950′s. Statistics show that women rarely choose the method of hanging as suicide and even rarer in the nude. There was a poll taken and approximatel 88% of the public believes this was murder and not suicide. On one of the investigative channels, they had an expert forensic saying he believed she was strangled based on the condition of the body and the murderer made it try to look like suicide. The victim and family needs justice but it will not in the Billionare Jonas Shacknai or others that he has in his very deep pockets. Very sad and disappointing situation
Posted by: Kim | September 12, 2011, 4:07 pm 4:07 pm
@TC I think you revealed yourself with your last comment (below) and I am sorry for your agonizing loss and pain if that is the case. – Referring to Max as “Maxie” is familiar and only something you do when you know a person well. Justice will be served for Rebecca and her family- I hope that your family finds peace~ may God Bless you.
“Many of you hate Jonah Shacknai because in this age of recession, he represents what you envy: weath. You write hateful words on the internet because you wish you had just a smidgen of the wealth that this grieving father does. Well I’ll tell you what: this grieving father would probably give his entire wealth away if it would bring little Maxie back. Think about that next time you hug your kid.”
POSTED BY: TC | SEPTEMBER 10, 2011, 8:21 AM 8:21 AM
Posted by: fancydrew | September 12, 2011, 6:56 pm 6:56 pm
Who is this TC with so much “insider” info about what money changes hands between Shacknai and Rebecca’s relatives – including her “criminal ex-husband”? WTH? TC are you bought off to do the devil’s PR work and easily sold your soul for pittance during this recession?
People are discussing discrepancies between publicized & withheld evidence, and the police presentation. You’re the only one emotionalizing the guilt, trauma etc like some deeply personal offense – reserved for one of two deaths ONLY. As supposedly an unconnected member of public, your neutrality is laughable.
Posted by: marv | September 12, 2011, 9:40 pm 9:40 pm
Fancy Drew, you are sadly mistaken if you think that Jonah Shacknai is being persecuted because he is weathier than most and that people are envious. People are not envious but ourtraged that this situation is called a “suicide” when evidence cannot conclude it so quickly. If Jonah Shacknai was the average Joe, he and his family members would be hauled into court so quickly and held. However, not in this siutation, the actions of the people involved is very questionable. This is not the actions of someone that loved this victim or was going to marry him. As Wally said, you would do everything in your means and power to get to the truth unless you have something to hide
Rebecca and was planning to marry her, this is not the actions of
Posted by: Josie | September 13, 2011, 12:53 am 12:53 am
I think TC is either closely related to Jonah or is Jonah himself. Also, ECH and TC are the same person. The comments from both ECH and TC bore the same characteristics, formatting, conversation style, etc.
Anyway, TC revealed some insider infomation. The media did not mention Rebecca went to shopping and partying after Max was hospitalized. If Rebecca’s sister said that, the media did not show that conversation to the public. TC also mentioned that Rebecca was using Jonah’s money doing this shopping and partying after Max’s tragedy. How do you know that if you are not close to Jonah or are Jonah himself? TC knew about Rebecca’s shoplifting one or two years ago. He knew about Rebecca’s ex husband’s criminal record. He also knew that Rebecca complained about Max in her email to her sister although she claimed that she loved Max more than her own. He said that Rebecca had extensive plastic surgery done that she resembled nothing like her old self. He indicated that Rebecca’s family received money from Jonah. None of these were ever revealed by the media. That’s why I am saying TC/ECH must be close to Jonah or is Jonah himself. Otherwise, he won’t have this information.
I also doubt TC/ECH is the hired PR staff. His messages were way too emotional to be someone who was not part of the family. The PR people would have posted more calm, less emotional messages, as overzealous posts would only hurt their agenda. In TC’s last statement, he said, “this grieving father would probably give his entire wealth away if it would bring little Maxie back”. As FancyDrew said, “referring to Max as “Maxie” is familiar and only something you do when you know a person well.” I have to say I felt his agony and pain after reading this. If there was evidence Rebecca killed the child intentionally, I would not sympathize her at all. However, I just don’t see any proof that Max’s death was a murder committed by Rebecca. For one thing, why would a golddigger kill her boyfriend’s son before she’s even married? Even if she was not put in jail, the mere fact the kid died in her care would probably got her kicked out of the perspective of a marriage.
Whoever TC/ECH is, I think one thing is clear from all his posts. He blames Rebecca for Max’s death. TC/ECH mourned little Max with deep grief in his posts. He indicated again and again that Rebecca was responsible for Max’s death (see the examples below):
- “perhaps her note meant that her suicide was “payment” for injuring Max”
- “She probably hoped that her death would atone for her injuring Max”
- “Interesting that the Zahau family have not expressed one iota of grief for little Max’s death”
- “Or maybe she was afraid evidence would tie her to Max’s death and land her in jail.”
-” it’s odd that you and so many others here are not sad in the least that little Max is dead. You gloss over the child’s death. So if you want to talk about someone who didn’t get a life, it’s a little 6 year old boy who died under far more suspicious circumstances than some golddigging shoplifter.”
TC/ECH’s messages are also conflicting. On one hand, he stated Rebecca was probably the cause of Max’s death and she was shopping and partying after Max’s tragic death, “callous and uncaring Kind of like Casey Anthony”. On the other hand, he was saying Rebecca’s suicide did not look suspicious. He said it was normal for suicide notes to be written in the third person. “Not only that, but Rebecca’s note makes sense in the light of Asian beliefs”. He also said that “you’d be surprised how many people kill themselves in the nude.” to justify the naked scene. But his two sides of the statements do not make any sense because a callous and uncaring golddigger will not commit suicide over a future step child out of guilt, especially if she injured the kid intentionally.
Posted by: My2Cents | September 13, 2011, 4:12 pm 4:12 pm
Nobody has answered the question of how these two met. How did Rebecca meet this multi-millionaire?
Posted by: SK | September 13, 2011, 5:33 pm 5:33 pm
@Josie – You make very astute points about TC/ECH and anyone else attacking Rebecca. On one hand, she is a gold-digger. On the other hand, she intentionally hurt Max, thereby risking her future earnings before she was married and had legal claim over Jonah Shacknai’s money. Then, on the other hand, she felt very guilty about Max’s serious condition and decided to kill herself in the most humiliating way possible. Oh, and she must have learned how to tie knots in ropes in her spare time of shopping, partying and going to the gym.
Seriously, that is just so ridiculous! There is no logical reason that the SDPD would just close the case so quickly unless they were “encouraged” to do so, particularly when they spent so much of their investigation time trying to prove that it was physically possible to bind yourself and hang yourself. It’s physically possible to do a lot of things…that doesn’t mean it logically makes sense. There are too many unanswered questions here and if anything, by closing this investigation, the SDPD are making themselves and Jonah Shacknai seem far more suspicious than if they took the time to do a thorough investigation.
Posted by: SS | September 15, 2011, 12:53 am 12:53 am
@AtlGa – She committed suicide over the fact that she was going to lose her multi-millionaire lifestyle and possibly go to jail for the death of little Max. I believe his death was manslaughter.
Posted by: TC | September 15, 2011, 4:47 pm 4:47 pm
@ My2Cents – Rebecca’s sisters are the ones who said, to the press, that Rebecca took their younger sister shopping after Max was fatally injured.
Posted by: TC | September 15, 2011, 4:49 pm 4:49 pm
@TC – Max was hospitalized for several days. When someone you know got injured, do you just sit and mourn until they get release? Not very productive!
You also call Rebecca an unstable person and a criminal. What crime did she commit? Shoplifting? Did you know that according the National Association for Shoplifting Prevention, there are approximately 27 million shoplifters (or 1 in 11 people) in our nation today? According to you, 1/11 Americans today are unstable.
Let me tell you a little bit more about these corrupted SNPD just in case if you don’t live in San Diego like I do. When an attorney that I knew had a case against some wealty resident, she was threatend by a man with mask to give away her files on hand in the parking lot. This poor attorney could not walk to her parking with peace for 3months while the case was still in process. Who is behind this incident? Who would want to destroy the files? It was so obvious yet $$ still won the case.
Posted by: JL | September 15, 2011, 9:47 pm 9:47 pm
FYI: TC is AESOP on radar online. Everyone knows it’s probably Dina trolling these threads.
According to TC or AESOP, Either Rebecca was a hard partying ,carefree,unaffected person or she was depressed and suicidal. Pick one please.
Posted by: TCisAESOP | September 18, 2011, 2:38 pm 2:38 pm
Hi there —–I don’t nderstand —-why is Mr. shacknaii threatenning the Lowyer of Rebecca’s Family…..???? What is He afraid of…..And —-He’s using a third party to relate this ——tel Me ——-where I the Authenticity here………….She never said anything Unbecomming…about shacknaii ——-It Is the People ! We are in Support of the Truth here….@ not necessarily some “storries” the authorities are giving…….People are figuring this Out themselves…..@ ain’t got nothing to do with The Respected Attorny. Mr. shacknaii can try @ Intimidate —-But, alll that Is Reflected Out of that ——–Is His Fear. If He has nothing to Fear ( in this case ) then why worry………..we respect e. one !…..
Posted by: hana M | October 13, 2011, 5:27 pm 5:27 pm
This Is the most rediculous thing” I have witnessed”….Involving a wealthy Guy @ a Beautifull woman…..I don’t know where to begin. Why on earth —would mr.shacknaii…threaten the attorney of Rebecca’s family…..are they not almost all women ?? the attorney Is —-where Is the Gentlemany Behaviour from shaciknaii Here ? Why —-while ‘Hiding” behind “all the president’s Men” — Is Jonah :throwig a “bom”……On the fragile Family……This —I wish for mr. shacknai to Understand —–Is Just deepenning thou Holl”…….Becouse It’s a statement ! You are “stating.” that You wouldn’t “tolerate”……………..what ? the Truth comming to Light ?? And we thought You were Interested ——–Isn’t that why He appealed for It to be Investigated again ?? So….It’s confusing”…..Usuallly —–when someone has somethig to Hide —would they Do that : threaten ! This Is a Giveaway. It shows the colours He (Jonah) tried to hide previosly…………Mr. shacknai…..shold Know —that We are the 99%…@ we are Not stupid…We can See……..It has Nothing to do with the kind / Hardworking…..Inteligent Attorny……But It does have to do with “emotional Intellligence”……I mean –2 days after the Unfortunate situation with Little Max……..And one can tell me that It’s noe Revange ??……The “Giveaway’ are a Lot in the comments……the subtle Blaming It on Rebecca……How Inconsiderate…How Insensitive…..How —Mismanagement of Our Emotions…..Blame. ….It’s nwilling to take responsibility…for what is happening ( dou to pain)…..to Us ——So…I will Just Point the finger to the next person….How Unbrave.@ Immature…….WE are Here to learn to take responsibility to things —–Not do Wrong to the Person we think might have Hurt our family memmber…………By Inflicting Pain to another ?? that Only double the Pain of e. one Involved…….It Is Not Inteligent………
Posted by: Jasminrose | October 21, 2011, 4:31 am 4:31 am