Reservation Child’s Wish: Fresh Water, Bubble Gum and a Backpack
By ELISSA STOHLER
When ABC News first met little Tashina Iron Horse, she was 5 years old, a chatty and vivacious kindergartener. Now she’s 6, in the first grade, and she tells us she wants Justin Bieber to be her boyfriend. If she could, she’d ask President Obama for “Fresh water…and bubble gum…and a backpack.” She wants to grow up to be a police officer, a career choice inspired by her mother Bobbie, who works long hours as a security guard.
Get Involved: How to Help the Children of the Plains
Tashina lives on the Pine Ridge Indian Reservation, where most of the 30,000 to 40,000 residents identify as Oglala Lakota Sioux and boast of a rich cultural history and deep-seeded spirituality. Located in the southwest corner of South Dakota, Pine Ridge is one of the 565 federally recognized Indian Nations in the United States. It is also one of the poorest.

Young Tashina Iron Horse is a competitive pow wow dancer. (credit: Elissa Stohler/ABC News)
Pine Ridge residents live amid poverty that rivals that of the third world. Forty-seven percent of the Pine Ridge population lives below the federal poverty level, 65 percent to 80 percent of the adults are unemployed, and rampant alcoholism and an obesity epidemic combine with underfunded schools to make it a rough place to grow up. Tashina lives in government housing in Manderson, 30 minutes north of downtown Pine Ridge. She lives with her grandmother, parents, siblings and uncles – sometimes up to 19 people live in the three-bedroom house, which has seen better days.
In the decades following President John F. Kennedy’s pledge to fund public housing projects on American Indian reservations, a construction boom began in Pine Ridge. Today, most of these units built in the 1970s and 1980s are in varying degrees of disrepair – a result, critics say, of steep cuts to the Housing and Urban Development budget made by President Ronald Reagan in the 1980s. Public housing dollars today are largely spent battling black mold in reservation housing rather than constructing new homes.
Amid the despair, there are youth across the reservation — like Tashina — who are breaking through the hopelessness with huge dreams and powerful stories.
So that she can be a competitive dancer at the pow wows, Tashina sports beautifully hand-crafted outfits made by her Uncle Matthew. Matthew is a senior in high school who lovingly hand-sews and beads Tashina’s pow wow regalia: shawls, moccasins, hair pieces, and dresses. At the pow wows, Matthew is constantly at Tashina’s side: practicing with her and helping her get dressed.
Learn more about Tashina and the challenges she and other Pine Ridge children face Friday at 10 p.m. ET on “Hidden America: Children of the Plains,” a 20/20 special and check out a sneak peek — Tashina teaches Diane Sawyer some of her moves.
More from “Children of the Plains”:
Reservation Kids: First Drink at Age 5?
Facing Hunger, Mom’s Addiction, Lakota Sioux Girl ‘Stands Against the Wind’
Boy’s Dream: Build a Better Playground, Become First Native American President
A Better Future: High School Pregnancy Means New Worries But Same Big Dreams
Email




RSS
Twitter
Facebook
Pow-wow outfits are not costumes (this isn’t Halloween). Please be mindful.
Posted by: ksam | October 11, 2011, 5:51 pm 5:51 pm
Amazing how such simple things that others take for granted can be so important to children. This year we provided over 800 backpacks stuffed with school supplies to several villages on Pine Ridge Reservation. We do this every year and our hope it to provide as many backpacks as possible to the children there.
Posted by: Amber | October 12, 2011, 1:55 pm 1:55 pm
It’s about time America remembers Native Americans, not Christopher Columbus. Columbus Day should be abolished. And this is coming from a Native American. Apache, Comanche, Seminole, and Chickasaw. 100 % Native. We feel forgotten.
Posted by: Shannon | October 12, 2011, 2:28 pm 2:28 pm
I would think after a year of taping this show on the rez, you would have been informed that our Powwow outfits are NOT costumes,but regalia or outfits,that are very special to us,with items being passed down from many generations, and we are offended by the use of the word “costume”, u might want to think about changing the wordage.
Posted by: nativeveteran | October 12, 2011, 2:58 pm 2:58 pm
While the Government gives Billions in foreign aid to our enemies we allow Native A mericans to suffer.Uncociounable shame on the Congress.
Posted by: Walter Jones | October 12, 2011, 4:40 pm 4:40 pm
I am blessed to be born in Pine Ridge to a Native American mother and adopted by a white couple who had no children and came to the rez to adopt children….why don’t we help the Native Americans? I went back home 2007 and was shocked at the local parks condition…I watched a little boy have his bike stolen from Shell station….I drove by and gave him money to buy a bike in Rapid City…..WE need to do what we can to take our people, the Native Americans, out of these horrific living conditions….there’s no HOPE! There’s no HOPE!!! We need to provide decent housing, boys and girls clubs, donate clothing, money anything to help the REZ people….I am blessed to have gotten adopted by an educated white couple but am PROUD of my Heritage and my name Standing Bear!!!! The Native Americans have been abused, continue to suffer in so many ways…if the land has gold…push the rez line back…if there’s ore…push the rez boundary back….from proud warriors to a people with little hope and little to look forward too….How can the Government give back what they have taken away??? Get them houses with windows and indoor plumbing…people feel sorry for ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS but the Native Americans had this whole country….and still have to get commodity foods and live akin to 3rd world countries!!!!!…..LET’S HELP OUR OWN….
Posted by: Debbie Anderson (M.Standing Bear | October 12, 2011, 6:58 pm 6:58 pm
I find this story on the verge of laughable, but with children involved, I won’t even snicker. The American Indians have and still are holding white America hostage to deeds done years and years ago by our forefathers. Deeds, by the way, that have led the way to a better place for all of us to live, American Indians and the white man. I would wonder however why all the tax breaks the AI get from the U.S. Government why such a poor tribe of Indians in South Dakota? Don’t ALL states have to give their AI these privileges?
Posted by: kathy | October 12, 2011, 11:14 pm 11:14 pm
“Kathy,” I can’t even begin to tell you how little you THINK you know about what you speak of. I am non-Native but have worked in Native American schools with tribal children and their families for several years. The “better place for all of us to live” that you speak of must be nice…for YOU. But for Native Americans, the impact of white civilization throughout history has had lasting and devastating effects, despite what you seem to think of as generous “tax breaks.” Not that a tax break does much good for someone who doesn’t have an income. It’s true that many Native Americans find themselves dependent on government aid, and it’s true that some could better their own situation – but it’s just not that simple. Oppression takes many forms, and I truly believe govt. aid is a form of oppression. BUT the availability of good jobs, or any jobs for that matter, on reservations is what is “laughable,” not this story. I dare you to visit a reservation and come away claiming that NATIVES are somehow holding WHITES hostage for anything. You get as much respect as you give, and it’s one thing to acknowledge that you are not responsible for the deeds of your forefathers, but it’s a different thing entirely to acknowledge it with such DISRESPECT and IGNORANCE. People like you get your panties in a bunch when your ancestors catch a bad rap, so much that you would love to turn the tables and somehow be a victim of profiling. You have no idea what you’re talking about. GET REAL.
Posted by: Emily | October 13, 2011, 12:01 am 12:01 am
Oh get ready for this.. Does one really know how much HUD funds the Pine Ridge Reservation for one year for their Indian Housing Block Grant (IHBG)? One posting a comment states ” While the Government gives Billions in foreign aid to enemies we allow Native Americans to suffer.” WELL… I will tell you. Pine Ridge Reservation was just allocated 11,712,526.00 for the new fiscal year of 2012 for their housing program. YES PEOPLE.. one year over eleven million to just one tribe! The government funds over 545 Tribes. HUD has been funding this Indian Reservation with approx. this much each year for the past 15 years! Go figure… that would make the Government giving this one tribe $175,687,890.00… that’s over one hundred seventy-five million! Let’s figure again, they say they have 40,000 people and one home had 19 of them living together, we won’t use 19, instead we will say 5 people to a home that makes 8000 homes, that makes that the Goverment gave them $21,960.99 per home over the last 15 years. Now that’s pretty damn good, wish someone would give me $$$ to fix up my home!. I’m no Indian, I’m one of those who gives part of my check everytime to cover those “we owe them people”. The given figures represent only one tribe, here’s a fact for ya, the total package under the IHBG for the fiscal year 2012 (only one year) comes to a whooping $697,038,824.00 that’s pretty close to that Billion that that one wrote of that we give as foreign aid! But wait just a minute.. this is only ONE program that the Government funds tribes, for their is Aid to Tribal Government (ATTG), EPA $, HUD- Indian Community Development Block Grants (BIG MONEY), Indian Health Service (IHS), Bureau of Indian Affairs $$ to fix their roads, man their fire teams, grants after grants after grants (it’s all public knowledge, just ask your state Representative he/she will let you know of theTRILLIONS we give and give over to the American Indian’s of USA… overall the Government provides for Native American Indians (population 2,180,162) every aspect of their life as if they were our own children. No wonder our Government is BROKE. Our/my pockets just don’t go deep enough to cover all of our dependants in the USA, Can I claim one (or a few) of them on my income tax!
Posted by: Juana | October 13, 2011, 1:35 am 1:35 am
@ NATIVEVETERAN | OCTOBER 12, 2011, 2:58 PM 2:58 PM
While the Government gives Billions in foreign aid to our enemies we allow Native A mericans to suffer.Uncociounable shame on the Congress. I Could not have said it any better!!!
Posted by: cris | October 13, 2011, 2:29 am 2:29 am
@ NATIVEVETERAN | OCTOBER 12, 2011, 2:58 PM 2:58 PM
While the Government gives Billions in foreign aid to our enemies we allow Native A mericans to suffer.Uncociounable shame on the Congress. I Could not have said it any better!!! ok i copied wrong but can’t find this written at . i take bak what i wrote after of just reading this !! Oh get ready for this.. Does one really know how much HUD funds the Pine Ridge Reservation for one year for their Indian Housing Block Grant (IHBG)? One posting a comment states ” While the Government gives Billions in foreign aid to enemies we allow Native Americans to suffer.” WELL… I will tell you. Pine Ridge Reservation was just allocated 11,712,526.00 for the new fiscal year of 2012 for their housing program. YES PEOPLE.. one year over eleven million to just one tribe! The government funds over 545 Tribes. HUD has been funding this Indian Reservation with approx. this much each year for the past 15 years! Go figure… that would make the Government giving this one tribe $175,687,890.00… that’s over one hundred seventy-five million! Let’s figure again, they say they have 40,000 people and one home had 19 of them living together, we won’t use 19, instead we will say 5 people to a home that makes 8000 homes, that makes that the Goverment gave them $21,960.99 per home over the last 15 years. Now that’s pretty damn good, wish someone would give me $$$ to fix up my home!. I’m no Indian, I’m one of those who gives part of my check everytime to cover those “we owe them people”. The given figures represent only one tribe, here’s a fact for ya, the total package under the IHBG for the fiscal year 2012 (only one year) comes to a whooping $697,038,824.00 that’s pretty close to that Billion that that one wrote of that we give as foreign aid! But wait just a minute.. this is only ONE program that the Government funds tribes, for their is Aid to Tribal Government (ATTG), EPA $, HUD- Indian Community Development Block Grants (BIG MONEY), Indian Health Service (IHS), Bureau of Indian Affairs $$ to fix their roads, man their fire teams, grants after grants after grants (it’s all public knowledge, just ask your state Representative he/she will let you know of theTRILLIONS we give and give over to the American Indian’s of USA… overall the Government provides for Native American Indians (population 2,180,162) every aspect of their life as if they were our own children. No wonder our Government is BROKE. Our/my pockets just don’t go deep enough to cover all of our dependants in the USA, Can I claim one (or a few) of them on my income tax!
Posted by: cris | October 13, 2011, 2:36 am 2:36 am
Powwow regalia are not “costumes”. We spend thousands of hours on our outfits to make them beautiful. The basic necessities most take for granted in our own US is a hot commodity to those on reservations. We were put on reservations by our Government, and they gave us commodities that most in the New World wouldn’t even touch let alone eat. They sent our ancestors to boarding schools to cleanse the “Indian” right out of them. I’m so glad we are in a new age where we are allowed to express our culture, language, and history to those that want to know it. I’ve traveled to Pine Ridge, and if you’ve never been there then you really don’t know what poverty is. It’s unfortunate there is still prejudice and racism even today in 2011. Bless you guys for showing others how it truly is on a reservation.
Posted by: Jessica | October 13, 2011, 1:01 pm 1:01 pm
Racism & stupidity is very much alive. Just look at some of these comments….. Especially, Kathy’s and Cris’s. These 2 aren’t even descendants of any Native American tribe, yet they still wanna criticize and justify their own disgusting behavior. It just angers me when I see stupid comments like these! Anybody can say money is going to a certain place, but is it really?! How does Cris really know? Oh yeah cause some “state Representative” told her/him then that means its true! Yeah, right…. Think people like Kathy & Cris need to volunteer HANDS ON in Pine Ridge or any reservation in the country. Live on the rez, see what its like…. Experience it, let them see if that money is really going to where their “state Representative” says its going to. Pine Ridge is not the reason why the United States is in debt!!! We’ve been in a “war on terror” for about 10 years. War is expensive….
Posted by: Pasaasi | October 13, 2011, 1:29 pm 1:29 pm
On my comment above: I meant Juana, not Cris. Sorry. Got so angry I guess I didn’t realize my error.
Posted by: Pasaasi | October 13, 2011, 1:32 pm 1:32 pm
I’m guardian for a 15 year old boy who is 1/8 Lakota, but can’t be “enrolled” in the tribe. The figures you get sometimes are only the enrolled members. There are a LOT more AI out “there”. My boy has asked me “why” they don’t just move? I told him it costs money to move: transportation (many do not have cars), closest “big” city is Rapid City, rent, deposits, need a job (but you need to live nearby to get one), traditions, and most importantly that’s their home and where their families are. Some have managed to move off because of the military or to go to college and have resettled. But even to get that far you need a hs diploma. Check out the Okini project and help out there. Check out Friends of Pine River Reservation and help there. Call Shannon School District in South Dakota and see what they need or would like. EVERYONE pitching in Can make a difference by showing the kids growing up now that we do care. I’ve watched over the years how AI in our area were treated by “original families” – who moved here in the 1800′s – treated them like dirt – wouldn’t help them at the business I was working at & this was only 15 years ago- old prejudices die hard still. Those who still live on the reservations can make a difference in their communities by setting an example for the children or setting the children up to learn, not just survive the situation. The situations that exist on the reservations: crime, theft, poverty, poor housing, drugs, health issues go on everywhere else, but are exacerbated on the reservation when there’s no easy way out (move, change jobs, transportation). When there’s no real economic structure with a lot of businesses providing jobs, thus money to buy more things, life stagnates. Parents can only hope their children have a better life and education is a way to get there.
Posted by: TyzAnika | October 13, 2011, 3:51 pm 3:51 pm
Please, people. Don’t be fooled. This is a big messy web and the ones stuck in the middle are the Natives who are living on the Reservations. There is so much corruption and confusion involved in the politics it is shameful. Just because the numbers are on paper doesn’t mean it ever reaches the Reservations. There is so much hidden, so much false information out there. Please don’t assume that our Government is telling you the whole story, when it comes to funding the reservations, they’re not. The most difficult aspect of being Native is not the poverty, it’s the ignorance and as a result the hatred and anger that people have towards them. If you really want to get a grasp of what is happening….you must go to the reservations and talk with the people yourself. Something must be done….they are stuck in a broken system created 150 years ago. It was broken then, it is broken now. It IS the governments responsibility to pull their heads out of the sand, take some time and talk with the Tribal Governments. They need help.
Posted by: Cindy Butow | October 13, 2011, 5:23 pm 5:23 pm
We have non-natives coming to the reservation all the time looking for a sad story to tell and then take it off the reservation and get raves for it, nominations and notoriety. Then what do we get? nothing, We got non-profits claiming to help us and raise millions of dollars and what do we get? 1% the rest of it goes into their pockets. I think that should all be stopped, They should be escorted off the reservation. We are not here for your gain.
Posted by: Gloria Eastman | October 13, 2011, 5:54 pm 5:54 pm
FINALLY! Thanks Diane for a program that focuses on the aboriginals of this land. A few years ago the Survivor show said that they had a cast that represented America. Did anyone but us notice that there wasn’t an aboriginal in the group?
It is long past due that the media include the original inhabitants of this land in its coverage of American issues and not limit that coverage to the Hispanic, Black and white races. We are here, we have ALWAYS been here.
Posted by: Brian | October 13, 2011, 8:52 pm 8:52 pm
I am actually one of Robert’s (the boy in the documentary) teacher. I am proud of him and the other girls who allowed their lives to be filmed. I’m not going to get into the politics of it all, but just wanted to say that these are wonderful, terrific kids who deserve the best! Robert is now our school’s class president and is well on his way to becoming an excellent leader in the future as well! Don’t let the conditions of the reservation weaken your perceptions of the people. I am non-native and have nothing but love and compassion for my students! So proud of them all! :) I hope you all are able to gain a better understanding of “child” life on the reservation from this documentary. Thank you!
Posted by: YourTeacher | October 13, 2011, 11:07 pm 11:07 pm
EXCUSE ME….
But WHERE have the media been in regarding to the Plains Indians plight??
While everyone was coming to the aid of Haiti hand over fist, these folks were dealing with a winter that found them without fuel, electric and even running water. Where was the help and concern for them then?
Lets take care of our own FIRST. After all, they are the TRUE Americans!
Posted by: clara murzynski | October 14, 2011, 12:07 am 12:07 am
hi this is for diane sawyer. i saw part of your report on the little girl at pine ridge . is there any way i can help. ie. a back pack gum coats ect. please let me know
Posted by: dana glick | October 14, 2011, 2:50 am 2:50 am
While I’m proud of Tashina and her family for sharing their lives, I don’t want anyone taking pity. Yes life is rough out there. I grew up there myself and that area will always be my home. I have many wonderful memories despite not having a lot of things. I loved riding the mustangs, making dreamcatchers, hearing the creation stories, taking part in the dances, and just simply having a great time with my friends. I’ve lost count of how many Lakota have invited me into their homes and I’ve felt welcomed. These are good people with a wonderful culture and sadly most of the people that will watch this documentry will never experience it. As for bubblegum. I’ll gladly share my bubblegum with Tashina anytime as a friend.
Mitakuye oyasin na anpetu was’te.
Posted by: Sungmanitu | October 14, 2011, 7:34 am 7:34 am
Selfish people of the United States. Everyone is so about themselves. They have no compassion for others, regardless of the facts. Let someone come into this country now and force us all out of our homes into shacks on infertile soil, take our heritage away from us, force us to follow their laws, rape our women, kill our husbands, torture our children, then leave us to live in implorable conditions and forget about us. Yes, then you may think before you speak. Although I am not a full-blooded Native American, My great-grandmother was full blooded Sioux. The other great-grandmother was Sioux and Choctaw. I have seen the way they lived. They were hard-working, strong women, something that is hard to come by in todays society. We would rather sit in our nice homes, with our heat, water, modern appliances, etc., etc., etc. As it has always been, the rich get richer, more greedy, more self-indulgent, and leave the less fortunate behind without a glance. Wake up America….this country will never recognize the plight of the Native American or any poverty ridden citizen, we are too selfish. Tanisha, you will be receiving a gift from me. Keep dancing, sweetheart. Tell your story, be brave, make your people proud!
Posted by: Rhonda | October 14, 2011, 9:40 am 9:40 am
I would like to send Tanisha some gifts can someone please post an address to send it to, its a shame we live in America and our own people have to live this way as we send money abroad.
Posted by: niki | October 14, 2011, 10:15 am 10:15 am
It is easy for the non-natives to make judgements on the Native Americans because they think they are supposedly paying us back for what their forefathers did. Sad to say, but it wasn’t their forefathers but their grandfathers. My grandparents were forced to go to boarding school to “get educated”. They cut their hair, and scrubbed their mouths out when they spoke their language. In today’s society it would be called child abuse, and one really never gets over it, so it is carried onto the next generation, and then the next. Doesn’t all the psychologists say that it is a vicious cycle? So, please, before you make any judgements on Native Americans, please take the time, and educate yourself about thier plight!!!!
Posted by: Native American Woman | October 14, 2011, 10:48 am 10:48 am
I would love to send this beautiful little girl a backpack and bubble gum. Where can I can mail her the items?
Thank you :)
Elsa
Posted by: Elsa | October 14, 2011, 10:56 am 10:56 am
Thank you for making this documentry. For years we haue been telling people there were deep needs at Pine Ridge and Wounded Knee. People don’t seem to want to hear the truth about how bad things are on the reserations. For years we shipped semi-truck loads of goods from the Pensacola, Florida area up using a Methodist Church in Gulf Breeze, Florida but then the interest fell away and now nothing goes up.
So, anytime we hear that someone is talking about this subject we get excited. Hope A B C news will do more in the future. H F
Posted by: Hawks Flight | October 14, 2011, 11:08 am 11:08 am
I’d like to send this little girl water, a backpack and gum. Please let me know what address to mail it to. Thank you.
Posted by: GentleStorm67 | October 14, 2011, 11:14 am 11:14 am
FINALLY! Thank you 20/20 and Diane Sawyer for this report! FINALLY…..lets help our own peoples! AMEN to 20/20 AMEN!
Posted by: ANEMOKWE | October 14, 2011, 12:06 pm 12:06 pm
Where can donations be sent?
Posted by: Gabe | October 14, 2011, 12:12 pm 12:12 pm
post her address and i’ll send her a packback full of gum,its a shame that such a trivial thing could make a child that happy.cant help with the water but i could send enough gum and packbacks to make a few kids happy,not backpacks for school but backpacks just for play because every child deserves a few moments of sheer delight and fun without worry.
Posted by: norm420 | October 14, 2011, 12:27 pm 12:27 pm
You must feel for the children of a story like this. I see no adverse comments in these posts, but children live what they learn. I see no mention of the deep seeded corruption on Pine Ridge today. The politics of Dick Wilson have only transmuted into an ‘all for one”social mindset where ex-tribal cops turn politician use their so called traditional status to rip off the government and the public through pleas of pity. You only focused on one pathetic parental situation, where it is more the norm there, as the Sweetgrass- anti youth suicide program clearly reveals.
The rampant selling of ceremonies, drunken lifestyle, lawbreaking and human and animal rights violations on Pine Right
DOES NOT constitute ancient lakota cultural traditions or any deep spirituality, as you purport. .When traditional leaders of tiospayes can school his grandchildren on the proper ways of theft and other anti social behavior as a way of life, you must ask where the problem lies. Would we feel all this undo sympathy in a place where horse thieves are not honored as heros? Pathetic !
Posted by: truthseeker | October 14, 2011, 12:52 pm 12:52 pm
It is so interesting to read the comments which have been posted, Most are positive witth a few negative comments. To grow up iin poverty is difficult and the potholes are great and difficult to avoid and/ or recover from. Because someone is in poverty does not necessarily mean that they are totally dysfunctional. Remember that native americans did not request their plight, their plight was forced upon them because they lost the war against America and forced unto reservations. Know your history people and recognize what this country has done to its own inhabitants. Cuddles to Diane for showing the many faces of poverty. I look forward to the special tonight.
Posted by: Renee | October 14, 2011, 2:05 pm 2:05 pm
I feel the need to set the record straight regarding the HUD funding and grants given to the tribes for housing. The money doesn’t go to a native who owns his/her own home. The money goes to fix up the rental units owned by the government. Like any landlord they are required to provide upkeep on the houses/apartments that they provide to renters. As anyone can see from the documentary the government isn’t the best landlord. I live on a reservation in northeast South Dakota with my husband who is Dakota (not Sioux but that’s another story) and although this “rez” isn’t as impoverished as Pine Ridge, the housing units are substandard and in need of repair not to mention the black mold problem that never ceases. There are several units and the money runs out before all repairs can be made. As far as natives getting tax breaks, I would like to know about this because I would love to not pay taxes. The only taxes that natives are exempt from in South Dakota that I am aware of are the 3% state sales tax on purchased vehicles and property taxes. In both cases the native must live on tribal land. But any property that is owned by a native that is on trust land has no value or equity to the “outside” world. With that being said, what is really important here is the children. Looking at all of these stories my heart breaks for these kids and all the ugly things they deal with every day. They live in a place most people would call hell and yet they are survivors. Wakan Tanka bless all these children and give them hope and guide us on how we can help make life better for them.
Posted by: Kristelynn | October 14, 2011, 2:10 pm 2:10 pm
I would love to buy this little girl a backpack and some bubble gum and mail it to her. I’m not sure exactly how but if you have any idea please let me know…
Posted by: Lacey | October 14, 2011, 2:32 pm 2:32 pm
Juana you are just plain stupid. Where did you get these figures? I also like the “one posting a comment states…” That is laughable. Where exactly is the argument here? What you state is a false premise which makes the rest of it just plain ignorance. I will tell you what you can do reach a little deeper into those pockets and find a heart. What happened to the tribes here is somethings that will NEVER be forgotten. Turn your head and look at the real problem with our government and not the tribes here. Chew this up and swallow it Juana “While the Government gives Billions in foreign aid to our enemies we allow Native A mericans to suffer.Uncociounable shame on the Congress.” Ever think about that? Billions and Billions and you are complaining about a few million that is for aid.
Posted by: Evan | October 14, 2011, 2:35 pm 2:35 pm
The post by Juana | October 13, 2011, 1:35 am 1:35 am does not say WHO is spending the money given to the native americans, IF that is the amount that they are getting from the goverment. That a big IF!!!!!!!
The United States has broken every tready with all the Native American tribes execpt one, that is the only tribe that DID NOT SIGN A TREADY WITH THE U.S. govenerment. Go smoke that people!!!!!!
A hint: they are native to Florida.
It is a SHAME that a little girl is asking for CLEAN WATER. Shame on the U.S. goverment and the American people. If you all want to send iligale alians back to where the belong, start with everyone whose familly did come to North Amercian from Europe and everywhere else.
Posted by: Linda Johns | October 14, 2011, 2:59 pm 2:59 pm
You know backpacks and gum are nice, but look at the bigger picture people, how about sending winter coats, clothing for our elders, school supplies,all these things are needed on our rez’s !!!!!
winter is damn cold in South Dakota, there are elders with no heat or water,trying to stay warm. We have elders on the Navajo rez, being put out of their homes in which they have lived for many many years to make way for the mines, this is not just about gum.
Posted by: nativeveteran | October 14, 2011, 3:04 pm 3:04 pm
Plesse excuse my spelling, I have ADD and an 80% permiant short term memory lost. I am not uneducated, I have 73 semister hours of collage and I served in the United States Air Force and am a Viet Nam vet.. I cannot prove it but my mother told me that there was Checrokee indian on her side of the family (which makes no different to me). I always treat people like I want to be treated.
The U.S. goverment has broken EVERY tready with the Native American except one. The only tribe they have not broken a tready with is the Semonose Indians of Florida, that is because the indians NEVER signed a tready with the U.S. goverment. Small wonder!!
If people want to get rid of all the ileagle alians, then everyone who is not Native American should go back to where their familys came from, Europe and any other country not in North or South American. Let them put that in their pipe and smoke it.
Posted by: Linda Moore Johns | October 14, 2011, 3:16 pm 3:16 pm
How many in that house have a job?
Posted by: Michael | October 14, 2011, 3:46 pm 3:46 pm
there a very few jobs in Pine Ridge. go look at youtube, punch in White Clay Nebraska , now this should outrage you !After you look at some of the video, let me know what u think about it.
Posted by: nativeveteran | October 14, 2011, 3:58 pm 3:58 pm
WOW! did ABC miss the real store. Look at what over a 100 years of welfare has done to these people. Is this not a prefect example of how being supported by the government will destroy your spirit? Destroy your ability to see your real self worth? Destroy your desire to reach for your best potential. Drain out your life and lead you into Alcohol and food abuse. Sure Hope those guys can break away from the death that they have been fed by our government. It pains me to see how welfare destroys everything it touches. Sure it’s OK for a help for a short period but the government does not want you to ever get out of there evil clutches. God help us all. jim jim
Posted by: jim jim | October 14, 2011, 4:39 pm 4:39 pm
I’m a 100% Native American from Oklahoma and some of these comments made me just angry. People are complaining about honoring the treaties their ancestors made. Come on now. If the white people never came and took our land over, we wouldn’t be in this situation. Talk about IMMIGRATION REFORM. Why don’t we just SEND all the ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS back to where they came from -EUROPE.!! They are the real ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS !!!!!!!!!!!!
Posted by: Shannon Lusty | October 14, 2011, 6:46 pm 6:46 pm
I’m with you Shannon, send ‘em all back!!!!!
Posted by: nativeveteran | October 14, 2011, 7:06 pm 7:06 pm
If all we Euro-Americans could leave this continent tomorrow and miraculously restore this Turtle Island to what it was before we exploited it, magically restore the culture of all our Indigenous People to it’s purest state, and say a huge “We are sorry we stole your land, raped and murdered 60,000,000 of your people, destroyed the future of your children, killed your food supply, spread disease…..” It would not be enough to pay these people for what has been done to them. If there are any Indigenous Children out there who decide to go to Dartmouth College or VT Law school please contact me for free room and board in commuting distance with use of car. Pray for restoration and restitution-
Posted by: Joanna Hamlin | October 14, 2011, 7:48 pm 7:48 pm
I must correct myself, the future of these children has not been destroyed, they will rise up and prove that the human spirit is stronger than the evil that exists in racist hearts…
Posted by: Joanna Hamlin | October 14, 2011, 8:18 pm 8:18 pm
True, Diane made a mistake and called regalia a “costume” – if she had been corrected for making that statement, I’m sure she would have regretted any disrespect that people felt, and she would probably never make the same mistake twice! She can’t be expected to know much about Native culture because it’s never accurately taught in the schools in white America. Welalin, Diane, at least you’re trying…
Posted by: Wolf Spirit | October 14, 2011, 9:41 pm 9:41 pm
According to her commentary, her staff has been going to Pine Ridge for the last year and a half. Now she herself arrives and pretends to interveiw. How much money is she making using the cutesy interviews? How much money does the network charge per 30 sec ad space using the pubic interest draw of the cutesy custesy interviews and with Diane on the running horse? How much of a percentage of a 30 sec ad spot would provide clean water to all of Pine Ridge? What were here staff doing at Pine Ridge for the last yeer and a half? Sure not doing any free housing.
Posted by: Frannkk | October 14, 2011, 10:07 pm 10:07 pm
Truly a hertwrenching story, how we can ignore the poverty, need, and despair that our own citizens, Native American citizens are going through and yet help other countries???? No way! Our people, the American people need that help first. Illegal immigrants? send them back to wherever they came from and start helping out the Americans at home first. I who proudly admit to being cherokee/choctaw descent am truly embarassed that people here in the United states needs aid yet do not get it.
Posted by: Victor | October 14, 2011, 10:08 pm 10:08 pm
how can i help
Posted by: bobby | October 14, 2011, 10:17 pm 10:17 pm
TASHINA IRONHORSE & THE IRONHORSE BABYS ARE VERY STRONG & WE ALL PRAY FOR YOU GUYS!! TASHINA YOU MAKE YOUR DAD VERY PROUD & YOU KNOW THAT HE IS IN HEAVEN WATCHING OVER YOU!!!
Posted by: Lisa | October 14, 2011, 10:28 pm 10:28 pm
As a nation, we should be ashamed for helping other nations when our own people are living like this.
Posted by: Nancy | October 14, 2011, 11:11 pm 11:11 pm
WOW. A LOT of IGNORANT comments by a LOT of IGNORANT Americans. Again, I’m ashamed to be counted among said “Americans”. This land was STOLEN from the Native American people, and the STILL IGNORANT of today continue to persecute them….AND WITH WORDS SPELLED WRONG, NO LESS!! Look what our proud country is producing. If all the “LOUD-MOUTHED” ignorant fools would have shut up briefly and actually LISTENED to the program, they would have UNDERSTOOD that the Native American people are TIRED of the government hand-outs and desire the opportunity to ADVANCE on THEIR OWN….to MAKE THEIR OWN WAY…possibly OWN their own business. All those making negative, ignorant, racist comments need to SHUT up and THANK GOD for their obviously undeserved blessings in this “LAND OF THE FREE”, where it’s “WITH LIBERTY AND JUSTICE FOR ALL”. (Bunch of bull.)
Posted by: Marie | October 14, 2011, 11:16 pm 11:16 pm
who why where when. doesnt matter, the children matter, its not their fault. I nned to know where to send them things pls
Posted by: Krista | October 14, 2011, 11:17 pm 11:17 pm
Standing Against The Wind – “growing stronger in the storm” <3
Posted by: Charity | October 14, 2011, 11:22 pm 11:22 pm
Tribal Buffalo ranching , Badlands Solar power fields selling on the grid, a government water line established from an out side source, after all Vegas and Hollywood were established off of fresh piped water.There needs to be hope, and men need to be leaders in order for a people to survive , Pineridge needs an state of the art vocational School that teaches in what is indigenous and will benefit only the local area to live and remain………the people need to stop hating and move on with life or the children will continue to suffer their parents and grandparents ignorance and way of viewing life, complaining does no one good , it drives through life with the emergency brake half on. There are many options but people need to understand that all and everyone live in the 21 century and live and deal with 21st century problems and joys of life, living as the elders and the ancestors is the same as a 21st century Norwegian living as a nomad or a Viking and little harvest comes in life , the ways can be respected but people who are walking alive must also live in the present in order to flourish in this life. No matter the opinion, at the beginning of the day until the sun goes behind the hill each man is responsible for himself and the moral choices he makes throughout his journey.
Posted by: NewUnion | October 14, 2011, 11:28 pm 11:28 pm
Tribal Buffalo ranching , Badlands Solar power fields selling on the grid, a government water line established from an out side source, after all Vegas and Hollywood were established off of fresh piped water.There needs to be hope, and men need to be leaders in order for a people to survive , Pineridge needs an state of the art vocational School that teaches in what is indigenous and will benefit only the local area to live and remain………the people need to stop hating and move on with life or the children will continue to suffer their parents and grandparents ignorance and way of viewing life, complaining does no one good , it drives through life with the emergency brake half on. There are many options but people need to understand that all and everyone live in the 21 century and live and deal with 21st century problems and joys of life, living as the elders and the ancestors is the same as a 21st century Norwegian living as a nomad or a Viking and little harvest comes in life , the ways can be respected but people who are walking alive must also live in the present in order to flourish in this life. No matter the opinion, at the beginning of the day until the sun goes behind the hills each man is responsible for himself and the moral choices he makes throughout his journey.
Posted by: NewUnion | October 14, 2011, 11:31 pm 11:31 pm
Out of curiosity, how many young Native American men and women join the military? It appears as if it would be an excellent career path for many young people growing up in a stagnant community such as the reservation featured this evening.
Posted by: Hilary | October 14, 2011, 11:31 pm 11:31 pm
Can you please send me the school information along with the Pricipals name? Thank you
Posted by: Rose Torres | October 14, 2011, 11:37 pm 11:37 pm
NASA is asking $35 Billion dollars to build a rocket to fly to mars, a single long range rocket that no one will ever see again, i smell a story into what exactly all those costs are truly covering , children need to eat this morning, not 20 light years away.
Posted by: NewUnion | October 14, 2011, 11:43 pm 11:43 pm
I was not able to watch this tonight, as I have no television. I do wonder, however, if there was any discussion as to why Tashina might be in need of fresh water? Local ground water polluted by unregulated mining of uranium and other precious metals? Why, when there are many, many (virtually all white) people who are doing very well economically in those areas, no economic benefit from it seems to work its way into the actual native communities? I will say one thing to the individuals who pay hundreds or even thousands of dollars in taxes, probably a tiny fraction of which goes into payments for the BIA, who complain about it as if there are people on the rez mismanaging those funds. The BIA structure has historically been a very mixed bag, but primarily a way for white american companies to extract funds from the government, under the guise of “helping” the native people. While I do acknowledge that there undoubtedly have been individuals who’ve sought to make good use of those funds (ON BEHALF of the natives) over the last 130+ years, on the whole the approach has been to try to make white people out of them.
When you take people who are happy doing what they are doing, living free and in connection with the spiritual world around them and try to make them live in a box, they will not like it. They will fight it, they will resist it, they will become depressed and they will die. There are some who say that this was the actual intention of the BIA all along, including turning the children over to puritanical boarding schools they wouldn’t in a hundred years send their own kids to.
I don’t know, I wasn’t there.
All I ask, is that before anyone makes a judgement, they seek to understand the history, from the point of these people. Read the interviews with the Lakota who survived the wars in the late 19th century. Try to understand it from their perspective. Got to YouTube and watch some of the clips of John Trudell or Russell Means. Ask questions. Why did the 7th cavalry kill 300 virtually unarmed old men, women and children (as well as a number of their own troops) and get rewarded with multiple Congressional Medals of Honor?
The Lakota did not live easy lives, by our standards, but they were singularly and uniquely free – a condition which the dominant culture has sought to replace with its own version thereof.
Posted by: A. M. Relations | October 15, 2011, 12:17 am 12:17 am
Hilary, there are many Native Americans joining the military and sacrificing their lives for this country that has done their ancestors wrong. They want to fight like warriors and sacrifice their lives for this country that continues to turn a blind eye to them and their families. They join the military in high hopes of providing a better life for their people and their families. I’m 100% Native American and have cousins in the service as well as my Father and Grandfathers that have given themselves up to the Military.
Posted by: Pasaasi | October 15, 2011, 12:28 am 12:28 am
I have seen pine ridge.and mission. I have seen the housing, the drunk people in the streets. The goverment housing miles from a store, or even gas station, several don’t even have a car to get to a store, so they walk miles along the highway to go get food I know I have seen them. I am not native. but it has bothered me for years, its almost as if “we ” want them to fail? How can any one say any thing negative? alcohol is destroying lives, can’t we all just help one person ? 1 child? Make a difference and change a life? it may just make us all better people……
Posted by: jill | October 15, 2011, 12:30 am 12:30 am
who what where when, doesnt matter, the children matter, where can we send things
Posted by: krista | October 15, 2011, 12:40 am 12:40 am
A. M. Relations………the 7th cavalry kill 300 virtually unarmed old men, women and children (as well as a number of their own troops) and get rewarded with multiple Congressional Medals of Honor?…….what could this possibly even have to do with feeding a hungry child on Friday October 14 , 20011, there either must truly be something in the drinking water or in the continual teaching of bitterness and hatred……whatever happened is done, finished and over with, never to be seen again, reclaiming the Black Hills is more important than feeding a hungry tummy? What gives? What is more important to you? Arguing and whining about the past or blessing the present and the future? I had a very nice bicycle stolen from me when i was a boy, i will never own that bicycle ever again, however i have a very nice car sitting out on the driveway of my present and my future home………………………………..All I ask, is that before anyone makes a judgment, they seek to understand the history, from the point of these people……………..Why?………..why not do something right now in 2011 and send representatives to congress to bring in a fresh water line from an outside source which would create many native jobs and many native paychecks to benefit all people, why not put in a facsimile to a base exchange that has a constant supply of fresh food and baked bread, that no matter what, there will always be groceries, military people eat for free everyday……well nourished people have strong thinking minds as well as happy content children……………………..CHILDREN………..empty minds taught to be bitter?……….Why?
Posted by: NewUnion | October 15, 2011, 12:52 am 12:52 am
omgsh that made me tear up that they showed tashinas dad david in this video =( tashina lost her dad 7 months ago due to a car accident & it is so bad there in manderson there hospital is closed! if only the hospital were open he would still be alive today! tashina your daddy loves you & is so proud of you babygirl!
Posted by: Kourtney | October 15, 2011, 1:34 am 1:34 am
I spent a number of years in government & catholic Indian boarding schools. Eventually moved to
the Pacific Northwest near Seattle, washington. My daughter has a Masters in Education and
has lived on & near the Pine Ridge Reservation. It appears to have worsen since my years
living there. Please do a special on alcolol and its affect on all of us as a society.
Posted by: Arlene Pettie | October 15, 2011, 2:48 am 2:48 am
I grew up next to several Reservations. Saw the destruction to the homes, buildings and properties by the native americans. My best friend who is full blood Modoc left the rez because of the disrepect and violence on the rez, she was afraid for her family! She said that it was a common belief that if you destroy everything the gov’t just built for you, you would be getting back at the gov’t, so they destroyed their new homes, gyms, schools and properties. Why can’t people respect what they have and treat it with care? I know hunger and cold, I grew up very poor. I also am 1/2 cherokee and apache, never asked for or recieved gov’t aid. I support 2 native children and have supported one on this rez. I will continue too also. I wish I had a answer to the mess, may God help us all to respect each other and what we have. learn to help ourselves and reach out to our neighbors. It was a interesting program but left me with mixed emotions. I feel for the children, think the parents need to clean up their act so they will be a good example for their children, make their homes a clean safe place to live,(pick up the trash) take care of what you have…. Please understand that I care! I grew up with 6 sibblings in a two room house, hand me down cloths, food was picked out of the dump, gleaned orchards after the harvest. slept 5 to a bed (double). Life was NOT easy but we took care of what we had and appreciated what little we had. BE proud of what you have and take care of it! Teach your children how to respect what you have and you will be choosing a better path. Pray for our Nation and our people!
Posted by: Rebecca | October 15, 2011, 2:58 am 2:58 am
I found it a very well done story overall. It brought to light the situation of many Native Americans in this country, those living both on and off the rez. I thought it was interesting though that when Dian Sawyer said the quote “kill the Indian, save the man” she said it wrong, the true quote is “kill the savage, save the man” and it was said during the beginning of the boarding school era. While I feel as though 20/20 did a good job for a first try I think they should dive deeper and have Native Americans as lead writers or better.
Posted by: Yokut Girl | October 15, 2011, 3:50 am 3:50 am
I am Native American, Alaskan Native my mother was taken from her home her hair was chopped off and she was forced to speak only English and was punished for speaking her own language. This law was only changed in the 70′s. We are no different than any other people we deserve the same opportunities as anyone but, because we live on the reservation we are looked down on. People are making comments about things they know nothing about. Sitting in your high rise homes and making your uninformed comment to make yourselves feel better. God Bless those children we saw on this special they didn’t ask for their situations and must be given the same opportunities as any other American child to an education and the tools and knowledge to make their lives better. Given the chance they will.
Posted by: Barbara | October 15, 2011, 10:02 am 10:02 am
Well, if tax money went to something as ridiculous as clean water for citizens instead of a bunch of new gigantic autonomous robot trucks for the military, with, I kid you not, an Xbox-like controller, then maybe the Pine Ridge Reservation could at the very least get a little healthy. Someone should start a campaign: TerraMax Trucks versus kids getting clean water! lol
Like someone else pointed out about the gardening problem, I knew the land (and weather) wasn’t suited for your typical vegetable garden, so I was happy to hear another commenter say people are getting tips from the Amish, many of which also live in colder climates. It seemed the biggest problem with the food/weight was the distance to get to a store, and of course a lack of transportation. So you’re like JUST relying on government carbs! Of course people are going to be overweight.
It’s terrible that people aren’t able (?) to open businesses easily. It’s almost as if the government set the reservations up to drive people out of them so they could just take the land. I visited the Pine Ridge reservation in 1992 from Atlanta as part of Native American history class and I remember seeing an old building (I think a restaurant) that was JUST outside the reservation. Painted on the building in big letters was “NO INDIANS ALLOWED” except someone had halfassed-ly tried to fade out the “NO” but it was still extremely obvious. Terrible.
Posted by: Clarissa | October 15, 2011, 10:14 am 10:14 am
Thank-you for allowing this story to happen. This type of story can take place on almost any reservation across the nation. I am thankful that they took the time to air it to show the life many live in this country throughout the country. It is reality and SHOULDN”T matter how or why it is that way. The question that should be asked is how can we all come together to help fix what is happening in our own country. Not judge or question why isn’t the government subsidies enough and they should be able to handle their own. They right questions need to be asked such as: Why is it that a school IN AMERICA be allowed to be open with asbestos? How many presidents have visited the Lakota people and still there is not change for the better? I am a Native American from the Warm Springs Reservation in Oregon. This is a story that easily could have happened here. It is reality, it is happening here in across America and it needs to be revealed to show we are not perfect and we as a country need to focus on us BEFORE spending trillions upon trillions on others.
Posted by: NativeOregonian | October 15, 2011, 11:49 am 11:49 am
I’m chuckling at the “billions in foreign aid” comment. The inability to pay back the aid is the reason they get no aid. Natives claim “Sovereign Nation” every chance they get. So, be a sovereign nation.
Posted by: SouthDakotan | October 15, 2011, 1:00 pm 1:00 pm
Nativeoregonian said it well, all the same problems shown in Pine Ridge, happens on reservations across the country, I am also native living in Oregon,and as Nativeoregonian stated,this could have been Warm Springs, the Navajo Nation, or the Seminole Nation in Florida. Help is needed on all reservations,not just Pine RIdge.
I am glad that the show did a segment on Whiteclay Nb. I have been complaining about Whiteclay for years, that town is only there to profit and propagate from the sickness our people have,and the town only exist to make money and line the pockets of store and bar owners.
i did notice that the segment where Diane was looking at Tashinas regalia, saying what a pretty costume, was cut out,thats good.
So ABC how about doing stories on some other reservations, maybe from the 4 directions,but dont forget our brothers and sisters to the north in Canada, maybe you could do something on how Native land was used for the Olympics without permission, or how the cops arrested all the Natives living in the streets right before the start of the Olympics and held them in jail till the Olympics were over, so that the tourists didnt see the problems Vancouver has with Native alcoholism and homelessness……just a thought
Posted by: nativeveteran | October 15, 2011, 1:06 pm 1:06 pm
The 20/20 report was a good OUTLINE of Indian Country and the complex issues involved. History and current conditions are a continuing interaction showing us reality. Seeds produce plants reflecting the DNA planted. Many try to instill a get over it senerio (SP) yet their spouting off does not go under the surface to understand the roots of the current harvest of domination thrust upon First Nation’s people of the Americas. The men changed at the door of the PUSHERS/TRADERS who carry on the historic concept loosen them up with “spirits” to gain advantage in trade. This “trade” continues today how much money crossed the counter the reporter leaned over? Those protectors providers nurturers are enslaved to the same “spirits” their fathers and elders were “fed” to take away their land their identity. the women – widows and orphans are ghettoized. Points can be made concerning corruption greed and so on, however, culture striped from one leaves the one striped having to put on the covering of the stripper. Read history with truth seeking instead of coverup and truth tells us that the generations of elders learned corruption well from Indian agents and other BIA and Church officials mentoring them. This is the root of the harvest presented! The only way to get weeds out of a garden is to cut out the root. The correction is to complicated for this format but this truth remains the Native learned well from their domanaters how to take.
Posted by: Arthur Brokop II | October 15, 2011, 2:32 pm 2:32 pm
Diane: I have admired you for so long…..last night I was so moved by your report! Wonder, without undermining the social urgencies in other poor countries, but….why not to look inside the needs of these wonderful people, why to go so far away when so close our Native American brother & sisters are in so great need. These are true Americans that need help with their housing, to end their addictions, to build new schools and hospitals, to access to college and university education, to develop their communities. why, why, why!!
Posted by: Susana Vivares | October 15, 2011, 5:05 pm 5:05 pm
I sat with tears running down my face while watching “Children of the Plains”. This is so shameful and disgraceful to our government who has created this travisty with their “charity” by taking away these wonderful peoples incentive to be self sufficient. When our present president was elected, I sent him an e-mail urging him to remember our Native Americans and help ease their plight. Obviously that plea fell on deaf ears. These children are worth saving and shame on any who feels differently.
Posted by: Peggy Gotlibowski | October 15, 2011, 7:14 pm 7:14 pm
Diane: I will try to find the mailing address of Tashina Iron Horse so I can mail her bubble gum and a new backpack. Iwould like to know what else she or her classmates need in the way of school supplies. I wish I could get her the clean water she and all the rest deserve. For the uninformed people’s comments on here, the Native Americans did not ask to have these living conditions. Yes, some of them can help themselves haver a better life. Before you start casting your stones at the Native Americans, think about how many white americans who live on state aid and who have government housing; a nice apartment or house. Can’t they do the same that you are asking of the Native Americans. Can’t they do better for themselves too. Why is it they can receive state aid, (food stamps, insurance, housing, WIC, etc), have clean running water and a roof over their heads that doesn’t leak or have black mold in it? If you watched this show, your heart should have compelled you to feel disgusted at their living conditions. I, as an adult and educator, could not stomp on a child’s dream to have a better life. With the vicious comments I have seen on here, it made me sad to be a human.
Posted by: Patty | October 15, 2011, 10:47 pm 10:47 pm
After watching the program with my daughter, I asked her what she thought. She said frank and flatly “We are American’s, we are selfish, we get what we want the easiest way we can, basically we stole America” This is the same child that got detention because she said something similar in History class.
Never have I been so ashamed to be called an American. I do not know if words can describe how humiliating and devastating what we the American’s have allowed our government to do to the true American. I would wager there are very few among us born Americans that can actually tell of a 100% heritage. Myself, at best I am a mutt; a mixture of so many nationalities that I do not know where I come from. We Americans can not teach our heritage because we do not know it. I can only imagine the joy and pride that would come from knowing exactly where we came from and not blindly following what a website says. Can you imagine knowing that the past of your ancestors were such strong, brave and kind souls. How would it feel to make your own ceremonial outfits that mirror your ancestors. We have no idea, but the Native American does. Native America history should be included in every history class and I agree down with Columbus Day, isn’t Columbus day just a way that the blue collars can have a 3 day weekend? Ask someone on the street I bet they do not know what Columbus day is.
Ok so we can not change the past. It really does us no good to sit here and go back and fourth saying this one is right this one is wrong. Blah blah Complete waste of time. I challenge each and everyone to put yourself in the same place as anyone on a reservation. How would you feel? What would you change? How do we change it? So how do we make the future brighter? In the report I did not see one clinic or health facility. Yes it is unmentionable for 19 people to live in 3 bedrooms but what about their health? Why is there no AA on the reservation? Why not give incentive or a bonus for anyone who stops drinking and seeks help? If there is no Alcohol allowed then who is policing the reservation? I say put the young and healthy in a position to destroy the contraband; fine or incarcerate the violators. Why have rules if no one is following them?
The housing is deplorable; why not give the young warriors the tools, material and the skills to rebuild what is there. How bout an “EXTREME RESIVATION MAKEOVER” Where is Ty Pinnyton when we need him? Everyone knows when you have put your own work into something it means so much more. If the land is so barren that no vegetables can grow, why not have community greenhouses where each family can have an area to grow fresh vegetables. It was unreal to hear an elderly woman say she has not had a fresh cucumber in 8 years! Come on people, wake up! When is the last time you waited 8 seconds, 8 minutes, 8 hours, 8 days, 8 months for something anything you wanted, less alone 8 years! I do not have the answers but I am just one person who is willing to help make a change. I admit I am completely ignorant about the Native American culture but I am willing to learn. We need to aid in empowering these true Americans so that they can have the pride in everything they do. One way is to teach, educate and just care. The old saying feed them for a day or teach them to feed themselves for a lifetime. (I am sure someone will correct that saying for me)
Posted by: ashamed | October 15, 2011, 11:15 pm 11:15 pm
Yes people you may help Tashina. Please contact her mother via facebook to help. Her name is bobbie gibbons.
Posted by: KOURTNEY | October 16, 2011, 3:13 am 3:13 am
None of us can do anything to change the past, but we can build a better future for our young people. Growing up in a city with a university, I had opportunities that kids on the reservation here we live today have never had. Before anyone judges & says “why don’t they just leave” ask yourself where you would live if you wanted to go to a city for jobs, but had no money, credit cards, car or place to stay. It’s VERY difficult to rise from such crushing poverty without assistance. I got Pell Grants & Guaranteed Student Loans, which my high school counselor wouldn’t even tell me about. And we STILL face discrimination!!! It’s crushing when people treat you bad for no reason, even for a battle-hardened 53 yr-old mixed-blood corporate veteran & college-educated woman! We are as smart and ambitious as anyone else, give us just a little bit of help & you’ll be amazed what we can do!
Posted by: Janet Littlecrow | October 17, 2011, 7:07 pm 7:07 pm
that was the most compelling story ive seen, i feel for the children how can i help and know it will really get to them, there must be some way to help them get better housing,, there has to be a way I’m still crying two days later,,, really want to help
Posted by: carol delaquintana | October 17, 2011, 7:29 pm 7:29 pm
As of all of Diane’s documentaries on Hidden in America, her team does a wonderful job of highlighting the challenges this population faces without making them pitiful. Can you imagine the resiliance and pride this culture has. We could all learn to have some of the same. My church is doing Operation Christmas Child AGAIN this year, and I have requested that we do something more local, if it’s for the res, for kids in Appalachia, for people living in Detroit or Denver. It doesn’t matter. Despite the politics and the numbers, and the false information, we owe it to all the kids in America to take care of them before we give away all our riches to other countries.
Posted by: Bridget | October 17, 2011, 10:00 pm 10:00 pm
1 month ago I took in a 10 yr old Lakota girl from Pine Ridge Indian Reservation. I already had 4 kids of my own, but I too saw her living conditions and I could not say no to her mother in taking care of her. Being in the city she wants to learn more and do more. Hip Hop, music, singing, and more. She wants to take violin lessons and school but the school she attends has no more violin loaners. I am so grateful that she is eager to learn. She left Pine Ridge with a backpack of clothes.
If you want to help, I would be so thankful to you. I cannot afford much now with 5 kids. If you can help sponsor I will share with you her growth and talents. I get no financial help from no one but blessings from the creator. God Bless.
Posted by: lopez | October 18, 2011, 4:10 pm 4:10 pm
Please send donations to Wounded Knee School District, any help to the Lakota immersion department would be great. School supplies, kids clothes, any type of donation for the kids at this school in Manderson S.Dakota. Thank you.
Posted by: Lisa | October 19, 2011, 1:23 am 1:23 am
These people just don’t know how to handle the aid they are given. I have been on this reservation and the people are like vultures. Most of them think that work is an option and the world owes them something.
Posted by: kelly | October 29, 2011, 1:11 pm 1:11 pm
We would like to know where we could send money for tighing to this reservation and the needs of the children
Posted by: Valerie Pape | December 31, 2011, 11:46 pm 11:46 pm