By Nancy Ramsey

Jul 29, 2010 6:33pm

Shirley Sherrod’s Lessons to Young Journalists

 ABC News on Campus reporter Wesley Lowery blogs:
Less than two weeks after losing her job over remarks she made to the NAACP, Shirley Sherrod took the stage in San Diego at the National Association of Black Journalists’ annual convention -and implored young journalists to not let aspirations of fame drive them into sensational reporting, and to take lessons from history. Sherrod’s 8:00 a.m. appearance on the panel, “Context and Consequences: A Conversation with Shirley Sherrod,” focused on the media scandal surrounding the two-minute clip that was circulated by conservative blogger Andrew Breitbart. About a quarter of the hundreds in attendance were students. “I think it is great that she is here to speak with us,” said Georgia Dawkins, a graduate student at Florida A&M University and NABJ’s student representative to the board. “As student journalists there is a lot we can learn from this unfortunate situation.” When one audience member asked how she felt about the media coverage of the event, Sherrod said the ordeal has given her a new perspective. “I never asked for the limelight,” said Sherrod. “I’ve gone from the point where I saw the worst, and now I’ve seen how media can work and should work.” During the panel, Sherrod said she plans to sue Breitbart, news that made headlines within minutes. She also said that if President Obama were more informed about the tense racial history of the South, he may have handled the situation better. “He needs a history lesson.” The panel featured CNN anchor Don Lemon, media critic Eric Deggans and Mara Schiavocampo of NBC. “It’s really exciting,” said Marissa Evans, a student at Marquette University and founder of the school’s NABJ chapter. “As an up-and-coming reporter, I want to make sure I don’t fall into some of the same dangers shown throughout this ordeal.” Evans added that the primary caution she’s received from the way mainstream outlets handled the Sherrod clip is to always make sure you’ve got the full picture before attributing controversial statements to someone. Sherrod made interacting with students a focal point of her time at the convention – setting up an interview for about five student reporters after the panel. After witnessing her father’s murder at the hands of a white farmer, Sherrod devoted her life to improving race relations in the South. For decades she has served as an advocate for black farmers and in 2009 was named the Georgia Department of Agriculture’s first black director of rural development. Her husband, Charles Sherrod, also attended the interview and asked the students to not lose sight of their journalistic values when faced with the opportunity to make a name for themselves through sensational coverage. Charles Sherrod was active in the Civil Rights Movement, serving as an organizer of the Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee, an influential student coalition that organized sit-ins and freedom rides during the 1960s. “There is such a thing as being moral,” Charles said. “Be moral. There are some stories that don’t need to be told.” Wayne State University student Corrine Lyons said interviewing Sherrod held significance to her as both an aspiring journalist and as a black woman. “She’s a really big deal, especially down in the South with all of the work she’s done there for years.” Lyons said. “When you look at the history….it’s important to recognize the people who got you where you are.”
 

User Comments

One last thing,
Sherrod had a good thing going, and could have quit while she was ahead, but she appeared on Anderson Cooper 360 and said “I think that he [Breitbart] would like to get us stuck back in the times of slavery. That’s where I think he would like to see all black people end up again.”
Anderson Cooper then said to her “You think he’s racist.”
Sherrod: “I do.”
The full 4 minute clip of Anderson Cooper’s interview of Shirley Sherrod is available at YouTube.
Her lawsuit will most likely be negated if he does a counter lawsuit against her with this clip, or both lawsuits will be thrown out, given that her lawsuit would require loss of reputation, and her reputation was quickly restored.
If what is in that clip isn’t defamatory against Breitbart, then I don’t think that I, nor anyone else, does knows what is defamatory.
Breitbart was wrong, but Sherrod doesn’t sound any better than he.
Breitbart screwed up, Sherrod screwed up, Vilsack screwed up, and the White House screwed up.

Posted by: Ray | July 29, 2010, 7:45 pm 7:45 pm

As an upcoming journalist this should be a lesson for young reporters. On the other hand, I hope that journalists who have already been through college or any type of journalism education have already learned not to make the mistake that the reporter in this situation made. Plus, reporters still in college now probably are not surprised by this because journalism professors today are often using the Fox News station as an example of what not to do. It is a joke at this point.
Based on what I have been taught in my law and reporting classes, Sherrod has an excellent slander case against the stations that made the false reports.

Posted by: Richardson S. | July 29, 2010, 8:36 pm 8:36 pm

Wow, Ray, saying “I think he’s a racist” is as defamatory as broadcasting an edited videotape to give a misleading impression that SS is a black racist? You’re goofy. (Go ahead, sue me now — I’ve “defamed” you.)

Posted by: Tom | July 29, 2010, 8:40 pm 8:40 pm

Shirley Sherrod should sue Breitbart for no reason other than the simple fact that his pompous behind refuses to own up to what he did and apologize. Filing a lawsuit is the only way Shirley can hope to force Breitbart to admit he was wrong.

Posted by: Nikki | July 29, 2010, 10:57 pm 10:57 pm

I hope Shirley Sherrod and all the future journalists at today’s convention in San Diego found time to look at Page B1 of today’s San Diego, Union-Tribune. Surely some of the journalists were fair minded enough to look to the right of the white farmer pictured (a no-no no doubt for someone who named their kid Russia) to see the article on Don Yoon’s very legitimate and non-frivolous lawsuit against the Federal government, Titled “Suit filed in jet crash that killed 4 in house” written by Gretel C. Kovach. Obama was quick to apologize to this race-baiter for being shown as who she was rather than as the commie sympathizer she has evolved into, but Obama and the Navy’s JAG staff couldn’t be bothered to make amends to Mr yoon or comment on Yoon’s family being burned alive in their own home. Memo to Barack O’Carter: Come on Now You Blame everything Else on George W ush so let’s get that part of it over with and Pay Don Yoon. Memo to Shirley Sherrod-I think the pilot who ejected is WHITE-so maybe you should read that article even though Mr Yoon isn’t and his family weren’t BLACK.

Posted by: Hans | July 30, 2010, 12:10 am 12:10 am

What’s the lesson coming from JournoList? Any? No comment?
Don’t pass PR-pieces off as journalism and don’t secretly work to get people elected to office when working as a journalist – that’s the end of the lesson.

Posted by: Tom | July 30, 2010, 10:49 am 10:49 am

How about covering the fake and highly-edited Alvin Greene video tape that was posted on mainstream media sites within a day of it being received and without any vetting whatsoever (apparently). That video was posted within a week of the Sherrod tape and had the possibility of impacting a U.S. Senate race (a quite serious matter). So if any lessons were learned regarding the Sherrod tape, for some reason they weren’t applied in the same week on another tape.

Posted by: Jim | July 30, 2010, 10:56 am 10:56 am

Leave a Reply

Do you have more information about this topic? If so, please click here to contact the editors of ABC News.