Pelosi Wavering on Armenian Resolution
ABC News’ George Stephanopoulos Reports: According to Congressional and Bush administration sources, House Speaker Nancy Pelosi is now unlikely to bring a resolution which would label the deaths of Armenians in a conflict more than 90 years ago as "genocide".
Pelosi, as recently as Sunday on "This Week", has repeatedly said she would call the controversial but nonbinding resolution for a vote despite the opposition of the Bush administration and warnings that it could damage U.S. relations with Turkey.
President Bush called Speaker Pelosi on Monday night and asked her to pull the bill. But Congressional sources say that Pelosi is telling House members that she will not bring the bill to the floor without majority support.
At least seven House members have withdrawn as co-sponsors of the bill and several more are expected to follow. Key Pelosi ally Rep. John Murtha, D-Penn., is also lobbying against a vote.
Key House members continue to canvass members but don’t expect a vote this year.
Email
Rick Santorum Sweeps 3 States
Pentagon to Open Additional Jobs to Women
We have seen this show before when the Congress tries to engage in foreign policy:
This resolution was kicked around the House for years, and was almost voted on in 2000–until President Clinton-D pressed Speaker Hastert-R to postpone a vote, out of concern for the effect on the relationship between the United States and Turkey. In a hearing before the House International Relations Committee that year, the former Turkish Ambassador warned “But above all, our cooperation on Iraq will inevitably suffer. The support for American policy in northern Iraq, already slim, will dwindle immediately…”
Bad idea trying to chastise a reluctant ally for a crime committed almost a century ago by an ancient empire (Ottoman) which ended with World War One. And don’t forget our own dark history with native tribes in the 19th century.
This is different from dealing with a government (China) which TODAY is brutally suppressing religious and press freedoms (Tibet and Falun Gong), and enabling ongoing genocide in another nation (Sudan).
Posted by: carl | October 16, 2007, 6:05 pm 6:05 pm
Good. Another Pelosi surreneder. Wise choice.
Posted by: Gary | October 16, 2007, 6:11 pm 6:11 pm
This sounds as ridiculous and worthless as what the Republicans usually do. Good thing she’s dumping it. Best to NEVER do anything as stupid as the Republicans would. I hope she’s learned her lesson.
Posted by: wilder5121 | October 16, 2007, 6:20 pm 6:20 pm
Pelosi is pushing this resolution so she can hamstring the war effort and hasten America’s defeat and ultimate destruction. Now, she’s getting cold feet. Ahmadinajad and Assad must have told her to cool it. One can only speculate as to why.
Posted by: lonesomecharlie | October 16, 2007, 6:29 pm 6:29 pm
This should have never been brought up in the first place, Turkey has been a loyal friend of the U.S. at a time when we need all the friends we can get. I also think it was a political move on Pelosi”s part to fulfill her promises to get the U.S out of Iraq.
Posted by: BTL musings | October 16, 2007, 6:44 pm 6:44 pm
No moral compass left in Congress either.
Posted by: Princess Amidala | October 16, 2007, 6:47 pm 6:47 pm
By the Way,
President Reagan briefly acknowledged the Armenian genocide in a proclamation on the Holocaust in 1981, so it isn’t as though the US officially denies that it happened.
Posted by: carl | October 16, 2007, 6:52 pm 6:52 pm
I hope she has come to her senses…this kind of domestic pandering is what gets us into all kinds of unintended consequences on the world stage. Let’s lets have one Secretary of State at a time.
Posted by: John Davey | October 16, 2007, 6:54 pm 6:54 pm
How happy would we Americans be if other countries around the world started officially declaring the treatment of American Indians as genocide? Turkey is now a successful secular democracy with a pretty good civil rights record, not the medieval Ottoman Empire it was when the horrible events with the Armenians occurred.
Posted by: Doc | October 16, 2007, 6:56 pm 6:56 pm
Maybe Nancy is afraid of getting the Ottomon Empire mad at us. Congress is right on top of things!
james
Posted by: james everett | October 16, 2007, 6:58 pm 6:58 pm
It is about time!! I am not against the Armenian’s but wouldn’t it be good enought to have it put in history books?
Posted by: Leslie Bloss | October 16, 2007, 7:01 pm 7:01 pm
Another Dem smoke screen perpetrated by the Pelosistos. We know it’s happened and our sympathies go out for all involved. But what are these clowns in Washington doing wasting time and money (Oh! that’s what they do for a living) digging up dead issues while American public policies and interests languish or are held hostage by foreign dicates and dictators.
Posted by: jontro | October 16, 2007, 7:03 pm 7:03 pm
What the heck is wrong with this woman?? What possible good can come of this WWI-related matter today in Oct 2007? It’s VERY irresponsible to undermine our relations with Turkey at this time, and for what?? We need Turkey, as a moderate muslim state and ally, to work with us to ensure a stablized and peaceful Iraq.
Is Pelosi purposely trying to undermine the mission in Iraq? She needs to stop with these unhelpful, unneccessary distractions to our foriegn policy. Does she think she’s Sec. of State or something. The timing of this move is mischievious at best, catastrophic at worst.
Posted by: Chris S | October 16, 2007, 7:24 pm 7:24 pm
Well, “Truth Seeker” my great grandmother was scalped by the Indians, but I don’t carry a grudge about it. My immigrant father was discriminated against and called ethnic slur names, but I don’t cry about it. Pelosi is folding because this resolution will do no good and plenty of bad, like raising oil prices by raising tensions between Turkey and Iraq. The only consolation is: Pelosi and the Democrats could be busy doing real harm, but fortunately they have stayed occupied with silliness, meaningless resolutions and toothless hearings.
-Mark Twain
Posted by: Steve-o | October 16, 2007, 7:28 pm 7:28 pm
If you read today’s news with any intelligence, you will see that Turkey was backing down as well. Turkey has been very good to the U.S. … but the U.S. has been tremendously more good to Turkey.
Posted by: Hank | October 16, 2007, 7:31 pm 7:31 pm
Where will Congress and Pelosi stop? What’s next..condeming Greece for something that happened in the Peloponnesian War??!!
Posted by: Dave | October 16, 2007, 7:31 pm 7:31 pm
Well whoop-de-do, the damage has already been done; with oil going over $88 and heading rapidly for $100.
Pelosi’s sheer stupidity might just criple the US economy for the foreseeable future.
there’s a reason why US citizens are not allowed to engage in foreign policy.
Posted by: Seafang | October 16, 2007, 7:31 pm 7:31 pm
What, you mean Pelosi is not playing the same partisan game the GOP are so known for? You mean she is acting according to how she is supposed to act, and govern democratically with a majority consensus? GASP!
Posted by: RW | October 16, 2007, 7:40 pm 7:40 pm
I’m all for a resolution condemning the genocide practiced by the Roman Empire against my Germanic and Britannic ancestors. I’m sure Nancy Pelosi (no doubt a descendant of some slave-holding Roman nobleman) wouldn’t have a problem with this–simple justice demands it! ;)
Posted by: MarkJ | October 16, 2007, 7:43 pm 7:43 pm
Turkey should shut up on this issue: it was not even under the same government then. This all happened long before the founding of the Turkish Republic under Ataturk, and represents a failed policy of a failed government. Modern Turkey should actually favor this resolution.
Posted by: Jordan | October 16, 2007, 7:53 pm 7:53 pm
Trying to pass this resolution now, why? Because it’s another way to make the war harder for our troops, when they are making progress, trying to snatch defeat from the jaws of victory? There can be no other reason to re-hash a decades old issue now. And this is the latest example of why Democrats cannot be trusted with anything beyond those blunt scissors you used in kindergarten.
Posted by: Retired_subsailor | October 16, 2007, 7:57 pm 7:57 pm
She didn’t get cold feet – she got caught. In any sane world, in other words, one where Dems could actually do something despicable enough that the media would not give them a pass on it, this would be the end of the Democrats’ chances for the next election.
In today’s America, run by the media for the convenience of Democrats, it will be quickly “forgotten”.
Posted by: sherlock | October 16, 2007, 7:57 pm 7:57 pm
All of you would feel differently if it was your relatives – like mine – that died brutally at the hands of the Turks. Should we just forget the Holocaust too? The U.S. has every right to denounce it and make Turkey acknowledge exactly what it was – genocide.
Pelosi just gave in to political pressure. Shame on her and Bush.
Posted by: gridironchick | October 16, 2007, 8:15 pm 8:15 pm
Oh, this is got to hurt. She was probably sure that she could finally defeat the US in Iraq if she could only take out our supply line. It’s a fairly effective tactic to destroy your enemy. She almost had defeated the US. If she doesn’t capitulate, she still might be able to.
Posted by: TexBork | October 16, 2007, 8:18 pm 8:18 pm
Ms. Nancy (AIPAC) Pelosi is nothing but
incompetent house speaker and a loser.
Wish she would resign. She is worthless.
Posted by: Joe | October 16, 2007, 8:52 pm 8:52 pm
Idiotic move. She knew what Turkey’s and her allies’ responses will be. So what was she trying to accomplish?
Posted by: Aldel | October 16, 2007, 9:20 pm 9:20 pm
She attempted to negotiate a treaty with a foreign power which is a constitutional violation, now this. Pelosi is a loose cannon and getting very scary. I think she’s throwing authority around just for the heck of it. Even authority she doesn’t have!
Posted by: Royce | October 16, 2007, 9:40 pm 9:40 pm
pelosi is a grade a nitwit. I guess that 4 year degree in government from the little college was not quite enough. She better call her stooges and ask if it’s okay to not trash the global oil market and middle east relations this week. What a moron.
Posted by: cheesetoppings69 | October 16, 2007, 10:07 pm 10:07 pm
Mama Pelosi has figured out that we would be jeopardizing our troops if she pushed a resolution condeming an action that happened 90 years ago by a country that no longer exists. How brilliant of her. I guess that just goes to show what kind of leader a woman can be.
Posted by: strangelove | October 16, 2007, 10:13 pm 10:13 pm
It seems Ms. Pelosi didn’t have enough votes for blatant, open sedition and the sabotage of U.S. relations with our allies from the house floor. Who’d a’ thunk a woman from San Francisco would become the pulse of America….
So the democrats will have to work to obtain more house and senate seats before they can adequately undermine us under the rule of law. No problem…their immigration program insures a democrat majority for at least a generation. Then they can rot the American soul most effectively. Man, these people suck.
Posted by: JDWjr | October 16, 2007, 10:14 pm 10:14 pm
Pelosi should decide not to continue with this issue. It is not important and is causing problems for Iraq Kurds. Otherwise, who would give a darn about what happened so long ago. There are too many more important matters to take care of – like undoing anything and everything Bush and republicans have done in the years they have screwed up the country.
Posted by: Vicki | October 16, 2007, 10:25 pm 10:25 pm
you tell ‘em gridironchick…point well taken, although to be honest there is enough hate and bitterness to go around aplenty already so i cant really sanction or approve of your attitude or approach as i dont see how it ( placing official blame for a genocide/crime committed long ago) will make the world a better safer place today, in the long or short term. your way of thinking didnt help matters much after cambodia or rwanda or wounded knee either. the big problem is that your (and i suppose many others’ as well) attitude really does nothing to heal and everything to keep sore wounds open.
anyone who would attempt to do even superficial research on the ottoman /armenian incident would come to the truth eventually anyhow, no matter who “officially” acknowledges or disavows what really did happen then, or if it even ever did happen for that matter.
i think holding grudges about things they cant undo/change is the human condition unfortunately . i guess its just our evolved nature to be wary and mindful of past bad/hurtful experiences but to even TRY to forgive and forget is a wonderfully uplifting and angst releasing alternative ,try it before you knock it.
and lastly for all you dem/pelosi haters , well ive got extra good news for you ,and you might want to make a note of this for your financial consultant(s) and tax advisor(s)…
GET READY FOR HILLARY (AND NANCY) TO RAISE YOUR RICH FATCAT TAX RATES TO THE #$#@$# TROPOSPHERE FOR THE NEXT 8 YEARS OR SO!! ;}
Posted by: bah | October 16, 2007, 11:02 pm 11:02 pm
Are we not supposed to mention moveon org – the laughable web site that your President stomped over when we, the AMERICAN VOTERS elected him? Did they thank you for all the money you sent in? ..wonder how much of that was spend on swimming pools and SUV’s? LOL
Posted by: cheesetoppings69 | October 16, 2007, 11:56 pm 11:56 pm
and btw,for all of you that still dont understand how american politics really work,let me enlighten you.
this whole turkey issue is totally bipartisan with ms pelosi and the white house in unison ,albeit a very covert unison. but why is it happening just now,about 100 yrs later, you query?
ever hear of the “good cop” “bad cop” scenario?
its a ploy/method used to coerce and/or psychologically dominate someone (in this case a sovereign country), generally in order to get details/information or,in this case in particular, acquiescence.
theres also the “carrot” and “stick” approach where either incentives (carrot) or deterrences (stick) are offered to obtain the desired results/scenario.
see if that resolution/bill goes through and passes then turkey as a nation isnt shown in its best light internationally for the rest of “official” history, which they REALLY dont want (aka stick), thats nancys role here, the “bad cop” . BUT…if bushy and his peanut gallery(the good cops in this scenario) “appear” to stop said resolution (aka carrot), it then gives this administration much more sway with the turkish government , which is desperately needed right now with the pkk apparently carrying out separatist/terrorist ops against turkey from within iraq and the usa asking for and needing turkish military restraint.
this way turkey knows there is indeed a price to pay for any military incursions into iraq , (ie; binding house resolution on ww1 turkish genocide//aka stick) as opposed to the carrot approach (aka we give them lots of military/economic aid =$$) which is evidently much more palatable for them…
this “resolution” was and is going nowhere,(as planned) that is as long as turkey is our appreciative and helpful ally.
Posted by: bah | October 17, 2007, 12:11 am 12:11 am
Are you kidding me?? Who are we going to punish?? Those “responsible” have been dead for a couple of three GENERATIONS! If we are to “punish” Turkey, then why not go after the Japanese for their genocide of Chinese from 1937-1945; the Cambodians for the Killing Fields in the mid 1970’s; the Chinese for their many “reforms” where thousands were executed for their education or status in society (after 1948 when Mao was in power)?? Or, the Russians for Stalins’s many Purges from the 1930’s through his death in 1953?? Goodness, are we now proclaiming ourselves not only the world’s conscience but also the world’s Court?? And, how is this a punishment?? The only ones we will punish is our own servicemen (yes, the ones that put their trust in our government for a loose promise that if they risk their life, our government will support them!)
And, if Time is not a factor, why not go after the Catholics for Crusades? or the French, just because they are French! (couldn’t resist that one!) There is nobody alive today with living memory of what happened let alone eyewitnesses. It is definitely a shame it happened! We might have done more, but, we were heavily preoccupied in the Great War, a.k.a. WW1, where we experienced DIRECT consequences (i.e. Luistania). Hell, we are not even doing much for current genocide situations, i.e. Darfur.)
Please tell me how this will prevent future genocides!!
Posted by: mpreston | October 17, 2007, 12:26 am 12:26 am
Pretty disgusting if Pelosi abandons ship. Most of the neanderthals on this blog don’t realize that the Armenian genocide is the only one that American officials dare not speak. You have to wonder why. Is it because genocide by ally is no genocide at all?
Congrats, liberals and progressives, you helped kill a genocide denial bill and have given free reign to the deniers.
Don’t complain even once if Turkey commits atrocities against the Kurds in the coming years, because Turkey certainly has gotten the message tonight about what it means to be an ally.
Posted by: Dan Asta | October 17, 2007, 1:30 am 1:30 am
“Congrats, liberals and progressives, you helped kill a genocide denial bill and have given free reign to the deniers.”
Really?? a “genocide denial bill”? Perhaps you should read (or re-read) HR106.
And, “deniers”?? I don’t think that the people here are denying that the event happened. But, what is the benefit of passing this bill?? Really, is there one positive thing that will come out of it? But, there is definitely negative consequences…and servicemen will be the ones paying that immediate price. So, you who calls names (“Neanderthals”), you want to put our men in potential harms way? You would sacrifice those that have done nothing wrong? For what? The recognition that already exists from UN and Turkey (among others)? What does the US have to do with it?
This way of thinking that you espouse shows the nativity shared by Pelosi and others on the far Left. You show that you want something to the extent that you would harm our own people for.
Posted by: mpreston | October 17, 2007, 3:23 am 3:23 am
All Pelosi ever does is talk a big game to get her face on TV and then backdown like the wimp she is. The Dems need to get rid of the witch and put someone in power that has the “cookies” to do their job. It’s evident Nasty Nancy doesn’t.
Posted by: DK | October 17, 2007, 4:07 am 4:07 am
Pelosi, what are you trying to do, fix it so our troops can’t get the supplys they need. Shame on you, surely you can do better then that.
Posted by: cpman1946 | October 17, 2007, 5:07 am 5:07 am
So should we all forget the jewish holycust.That it never happened.Turkey is just like a baby. Bush should be ashame.The oil prices up and unemployment high.I think americans should leave Iraq.
Posted by: mary | October 17, 2007, 5:55 am 5:55 am
I don’t think that Nancy Pelosi should be ashamed or feel bullied into shelving this vote for the time being. The vote is over an incident that happened over 100 years ago. For those who say it can’t wait, I don’t know where you have been for the last 100 years. Turkey is a US Ally. The US should not look to offend them in any way. That being said, Turkey is being way too sensitive on this resolution. The resolution names the Ottoman Empire as the perpetrators of the genocide. Turkey is not the Ottoman Empire. They should not feel offended. This resolution should pass, but some time and diplomacy is needed first.
Posted by: Sean O'Brien | October 17, 2007, 7:27 am 7:27 am
Pelosi needs to just shut up and they need to do some real business on the hill. I do not agree with most that goes on currently from Bush and Co., but that does not mean I agree with this either. Our government is a joke. All of them.
Posted by: Sandra | October 17, 2007, 8:10 am 8:10 am
So that’s it? The Turks get away with murdering all those Armenians? Wow! I guess now the Turks will go into Iraq and murder some Kurds and Iraqis – those pesky little terrorists.
Posted by: Bob | October 17, 2007, 8:22 am 8:22 am
How about that another Pelosi BLUNDER. She and Harry are so inept. Looks like even her favorite DEMs are abandoning here in droves. Looks like her back door attempt to slow the war failed. Try again you pinko. Go Cindy! beat this over the hill con artist.
Posted by: Dean O | October 17, 2007, 8:27 am 8:27 am
American slave-trading was no less genocide than anything we could accuse the Turks of, so we shouldn’t be throwing stones in the first place. Millions also died during the “middle-passage.” Even so, the timing of the vote for condemning the Turks could not have been more, uh, untimely. With the Turks now wondering if their back-stabbing ally can be trusted, events in northern Iraq will bear watching. The fun is just beginning, and Pelosi is now simply a sideshow.
Posted by: rbsingleton2008 | October 17, 2007, 10:00 am 10:00 am
Hey Nanny-Pants, I’ll make you a deal. Ms Pelosi, I’ll support your resolution to defeat the US in Iraq by condemning Turkey for what they did in 1915, if you’ll publically work on a resolution to condemn Canada for it’s holocaust of the native people of Canada. Fair enough? Then we’ll condemn the Brits, the French, the Africans, the Spanish, Cuba, Italy, Chinese, Japanese… You wanna throw the US in there too? Why not? Blame America firstis the progressive thing to do. Should we do this alphabetically or by time? No, maybe we should do it in order of what could be most damaging for us first to least or is there some other reason you want to pick the one that would help you defeat the US in Iraq? I think that’s all her agenda is on this. Cutting off the cupply routes to your enemy is a very effective tactic and I know she’s promised our defeat in Iraq. Ever since Osama Bin Laden as voiced his displeasure in the democrats not living up to their promises to deliver our defeat, she’s really needed to step up her efforts to keep that base of support.
Posted by: TexBork | October 17, 2007, 10:28 am 10:28 am
My heart breaks for Turkey.
I had hoped that Congress wouldn’t let Turkey dictate the foreign policy of the United States, but alas, I appear to have been wrong: Support Wanes in House for Genocide Vote And rumor has it that, at his upcoming press
Posted by: inquire within | October 17, 2007, 11:16 am 11:16 am
Looking back over the many comments on this site it’s easy to see why Congress’ approval rating is in the toilet where it belongs, thanx to the total incompetence of Pelosi & Reed. Their obsessive hatred of Bush leads them down any dark path and keeps them from doing what used to be called “the people’s business.” As bad as Bush may be, these clowns are determined to outdo him. THROW THE BUMS OUT!
Posted by: Boiko | October 17, 2007, 11:59 am 11:59 am
I see this as another victory for our powerless President. Seems odd how he comes out on the right side of these issues, my guess he will prevail on the SChips as well. With Pelosi and Reid leading the Demos, is it any wonder why their poll numbers are so low. According to Zogby Poll, there could be another house cleaning come election time.
Posted by: homjett | October 17, 2007, 1:31 pm 1:31 pm
homjett dont get your hopes up. even if pelosi and reid get voted out you can be SURE some other democrat will take their place. the overwhelming majority of the american people have definitely had just about enough of your heros’ “victories” .yeah , thats all we need more, republican “victories” like the ones this nation has had to suffer/endure for the last 8 yrs.
you ,my friend, need to start reading the newspapers.
theres gonna be a female democrat president soon ,(with her husband in the navigator position) to ally with pelosi and reid …and watch how fast things start to happen then
rich folks, just get ready for your upcoming long term huge tax increase ok?? and yes you will soon be the ones largely paying for my health insurance,thanks… ;]
Posted by: bah | October 17, 2007, 1:49 pm 1:49 pm
why do we have to get involve with these people. leave them settle their own differences.
Posted by: marc | October 17, 2007, 1:56 pm 1:56 pm
the honest truth is that the republican party and their money grubbing ethics (or more correctly, their blatant lack of any real mainstream american core ethics/values) are a nasty festering pustule on the skin of this great nation.
the whole movement/party is corrupt , septic and should be lanced, drained and cleaned with a suitable strong disinfectant, until this country is healthy again. they are indeed the internal parasitic enemy of a healthy well balanced nation.
i hope (and am rather sure) nancy , hillary (& bill) and the rest of the democrats will do just that in the next 4-8 yrs.
Posted by: bah | October 17, 2007, 2:26 pm 2:26 pm
As an American, I feel very strongly that our government has failed us on every level imaginable. Where are the riots, the rallies, the leaders? Why are we all casting our votes on “polls” and not out on the streets of Washington with signs that express how we feel? Are we really going to let this government do this to us? I guess so. Nancy, you and Bush both suck. And so do both of your “party’s”.
Posted by: John | October 17, 2007, 3:14 pm 3:14 pm
Pelosi is a moron.
She needs to resign.
Posted by: Bob | October 17, 2007, 3:41 pm 3:41 pm
gj john,another well thought out remark,made possible in large part due to our wonderful education system!
john listen, the avg joe is too busy trying to make ends meet to even have time to read this ok? he doesnt have time to riot,and get thrown in jail, and lose his job etc etc ,or protest either.
he doesnt have time to do anything except work ,alot, longer and longer hours to make up for the myriad republican mistakes over the past 30 yrs, the s&l fiasco of the ’80s and now the housing/financial market standing out painful plain for any intelligent person to see. and the current immigration mess started long ago with ron reagan/republican giving several million california illegal immigrants amnesty (to make some of his wine grower buddies/republican party $$ donators richer) and now look where we are…yeah thanks republicans for looking out for the common legal citizen trying to make a decent living. right…
how anyone with even a room temp iq
cannot see how badly the republicans are doing for the majority of the populace is beyond belief, they either are 1)just stupid or 2)just dont want to see reality ,OR (most likely) 3)they are benefiting from the republican “tax the poor to give to the rich” strategy.
given a choice, i would always choose the lesser of 2 evils and ,in general, the democrats,as a whole, are more preferable and useful to the avg voter in almost every way vs almost any republican/republican ideal. true dems arent perfect ,but they are much MUCH better for the avg voter than the alternative…
Posted by: bah | October 17, 2007, 3:47 pm 3:47 pm
in my last post above where i typed ” myriad republican mistakes over the past 30 yrs”
that should read ” myriad republican money grabbing schemes disguised as bumbling mistakes over the past 30 yrs “
Posted by: bah | October 17, 2007, 4:00 pm 4:00 pm
We must commend and not condemn Nancy Pelosi, and all those who support this resolution, for taking a just and moral stance on this issue. Both the U.S. AND Turkey need to call it what it is, and move on. There’s no denying it. It’s no secret. It’s documented in U.S. records. Former President Ronald Reagon referred to it accurately – as genocide. Even Ataturk, the “father of modern Turkey” acknowledge it!
One wonders how the Jews would have reacted had Germany not acknowledged the Holocaust. Would they simply have let the subject go? Would they have not continued the GLOBAL fight for justice (in the name of their parents and grandparents)? Why has the U.S. accepted the Holocaust as a factual historical event and given it the respect it deserves? If we do it for one county and one people, then it is our duty to treat all equally. By doing so, it will reinforce the moral authority of the United States as a beacon of freedom and democracy.
Posted by: Ani | October 17, 2007, 5:56 pm 5:56 pm
Hey Ani, what history book did you read that states the Turks have committed ‘genocide’. Why do you think this issue has not been resolved for the last 91 years. Nancy Pelosi should be deported from the country, let alone be commended (what a joke). Here is the “So-Called Genocide of Armenians for Dummies”:
1.) The 20th Century started (WWI) with bloodshed. The massacre started by the Ottoman Empire started with the slaughtering of Muslims.
2.) The West (U.S. included), who called themselves Christans turned their face the other way.
3.) Whatever happened to the Armenians of 1915 was the miscalculations of their people.
4.) When the Americans hear the word “genocide” they immediately think the Holocaust. They think of killing all the people of one group. This did not happen with Armenians, because most of them survived, majority of Armenians deported/relocated by the Ottoman Turks to Syria and Iraq lived on, they could have been killed by the Turks, they were not killed, the Turkish people and government actually fed and tended to these people.
Here is what happened, 29 Jan 1915,
(Preserved Russian Nationalist Communist Party Central Committee) discovered recently in the classified archives, tells the actions of Armenian Rebels:
“The reports received by the First Caucasian Army Commander reveals that some Armenian rebels active in the region, have gone into cities and settlements and established themselves at Turkish households there. Instigated by the French and supported by the Russians, they refuse to abide by orders and started killing innocent Turkish civilians.
The Ottoman Empire would not have lasted for 623 years by suppressing or bullying people of other ethnic groups without being noticed. The Turks claim about 300,000 Armenians were killed due to an uprising by the Armenians, or a majority died from famine. The Armenian’s claim about 1.5 million Armenian’s were slaughtered by the Turks, first of all, if you read the c. 1915 there were about 650,000 to 800,000 Armenians in Turkey. In order for the Turks to kill 1.5 million people, the dead would have to awake and be killed again by the Turks.
The Turks were very tolerant of there people residing within the empire. Have you ever wandered why Turkish is not spoken anymore in the Balkans, Northern Africa, or Caucasia where the Turks ruled for over 6 centuries. Greek, Serbian, Slovak, Arabic, as well as Italian languages were freely spoken in the Turkish Empire.
The Armenians are no little innocent angels either, they killed many Turkish and Kurdish civilians during the uprising. The Turks had a law, an administration regulated provisional law this is known as the “Relocation law” it comprises four articles, the First Article stipulates: TO RETURN FORCE, AND DESTROY IN CASE OF OPPOSITION TO STATE FORCES, AND DISRUPTION OF ESTABLISHED PUBLIC ORDER AND ARMED ASSAULT AND/OR RESISTANCE.
My friends, you cannot start a fight and once you get beaten up claim genocide. I’m sorry it doesn’t work this way. The reasons for the enactment of the Relocation Law was because of terror committed by the Armenians to the local people, those who allege genocide were actually committing genocide themselves.
Unless you have a time machine in your garage, history should not be twisted (like Ani) because you would be doing more harm for the future. If you go to Turkey today you may research all archives on this issue, if you go to Armenia today, it is all closed, and also unlike in Turkey, there is no freedom of religion in Armenia.
It is funny how the Armenians compare there allegations with the Jewish Genocide, how does that fit into International Law. The Jews in Germany died systematically for no crime except that they were Jewish, and of the 6 million people who died over 1.5 million were children under 12 years of age, there has been nothing like it in history.
Today Armenians who try to blend their situation with Jews, seem to forget the murders conducted by their ancestors against the Jews, Armenians who served as Nazi officers in Hitler’s army in Caucasia. Hitler’s famous quote “who today remembers the Armenians” he remembers the Armenians for fighting for him.
Posted by: Breal | October 18, 2007, 12:28 am 12:28 am
Ottoman empire was in war in 1915(WWI) with Russia, France and Britain, those countries provocated Armenians in Ottoman Territory to rebel against the Ottomans(who were loyal to Turkish gov for 3-400 years even today food, music even names of Armenians are pretty much Turkish oriented even in USA), and many armenians helped the invaders, especially the ones in Eastern Turkey backed by Russia.
Ottoman gov hanged many of those armenian tribes who started to kill turkish civilians and forced those armenians in eastern Turkey to move to Syria and Lebanon, they even provided soldiers on the road to protect their armenian citizens’ lives.
Many died on the road. Thats the brief story of so-called genocide . If Ottomans would want to destroy whole nation they wouldnt wait for a chaotic time when they are not powerful , if Armenians would have problems in Ottoman country, you couldn’t see all kinda Turkish food in armenian restaurants today, and if there was a genocide you wouldnt see millions of armenians keeping their Turkish lastname , Americans should learn first what history is before trying to correct the world, also you should work on issues like racism and related crime in USA, you should never try to accuse outside before looking at your own issues
Posted by: oguz | October 18, 2007, 12:48 am 12:48 am
I don’t know what kind of book you guys reading or maybe being blindly brainwashde..
What Happened to the Armenians in (Western Armenia) now occupied by Turkey was a indeed a Genocide, and this is proven by manny manny historians, reasrchers and scholars, and even by the US ambassador in Istanbul (Constantinople). The US resolution about the Armenian Genocide is a moral issue in the name of justice and human rights and values, whitch so many people in Turkey still those not have. Also I am not sure if those who are against recognizing any Genocide has any moral human values and dignity ?..
Also What Happened to centuries old Armenian towns, villages, Churches, Schools, and Monasteries in Anatolia ?.. why they are all been distroyed by the Turkish army ?..
What Happened to the Armenian Historical and ancestral lands and territory ?..
How many archives with evidences of genocide did the Turkish authorities distroyed ?..
Why Turkey has so many problems with it’s neighboring countries ?.. even with Arabs ?.. I am not suprised that most European citizens are against Turkish accession in the EU, and would NOT like to see Turkey in the European Union.. hmmm… I wonder Why ?..
get your facts right first, read the real history..
Posted by: Sako | October 18, 2007, 1:57 am 1:57 am
Nancy Pelosi? What did you expect from a San Francisco democrat? Moderation? This woman is a danger to our republic and democratic values. She is a dictator in waiting. She wants our troops to be defeated and our country humiliated. Are you ready for the “Hell” we will endure if Hillary gets elected? These two will seek ways to stay in power until their deaths. Watch for a constitutional amendment to repeal the 22nd Amendment (Presidential term limits) if Hillary and the Democrats take control of all three branches. Anyone remember how Bill Clinton fumed because he couldn’t run again? Thought the 22nd was a good thing that went bad for him. With all the insane spending proposed by Hillary, the country will be insolvent in 10 years—-and so will democracy. Remember what Alexis de Tocqueville wrote in “Democracy in America” and I quote, “Democracy in America will cease to exist when the citizenry learns to feed at the public trough.” Politicians will financially break this country in order to retain power. It’s already happening but Nancy and Hillary will make it happen faster. Once the country is bankrupt, the dictatorship will commence. Do I ever hate politicians. I rate them about two notches below a child molester.
Posted by: Dobutsu | October 18, 2007, 2:22 am 2:22 am
‘many’ historians, scientists, researchers, scholars, (Justin McCarthy), court of law (Samuel Weems-R) have proved that the so-called genocide did not occur. Usually when a genocide does occur, you have an end-result of a thing called mass graves, when historians and scholars have been reviewing, researching this so-called genocide before you were even born, no such thing has been discovered. The claim of 1.5 million dead would have provided many bones and skulls. The majority of Armenian graves (they were actually given proper barely) are those that died from famine and from war. Many died from other condition such as Turkish tribesmen killing or hanging some of the Armenian rebels, these were localized incidents that the Turkish government does not condone.
I have posted a long response to this before, and I will not waist my time for cry baby Armenian-Americans to back up my claims.
I will now systematically destroy your false claims.
1.) You state that “The US resolution about the Armenian Genocide is a moral issue in the name of justice and human rights and values, which so many people in Turkey still those not have.”
A). The Republic of Turkey, Turkish citizens and other nationals of Turkey, enjoy freedoms everyday. The only strict rule the government applies is insulting the country that you reside in. Can you please explain why to this day freedom of religion does not exists in present day Armenia?
2.) Also I am not sure if those who are against recognizing any Genocide has any moral human values and dignity?–Sako
A.) No one here is against recognition of genocide, we are only for proper recognition meaning as defined by Article II of the 1948 United Nations Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide, the Armenians with their propaganda and motives clearly do not fall in this category.
3.) Also What Happened to centuries old Armenian towns, villages, Churches, Schools, and Monasteries in Anatolia ?.. why they are all been destroyed by the Turkish army ?..
What Happened to the Armenian Historical and ancestral lands and territory ?..–Sako
A.) What happened in 1997 with Nagorno-Karabakh when everyone was focused in the Bosnian conflict?
While you protect Armenian cultural heritage, you seem to consciously omit the fact that it was the Armenian side that demolished and looted more than 700 Azerbaijani settlements, destroying a total of 4366 objects of social infrastructure, 1145 nurseries and kindergartens, 1831 cinemas, 982 libraries, 693 secondary schools, 652 medical units and hospitals, 44 temples and 31 mosques.
Q.) How many archives with evidences of genocide did the Turkish authorities distroyed ?–Sako
A.) Many archives were burned in fires started from war between the two groups, and remaining papers are open to the public and scholars in Turkey, you just have to ask. Why is the same not provided in Armenia? Why have many pages been taken out in the so called “blue book” (THE TREATMENT OF ARMENIANS IN THE OTTOMAN EMPIRE, 1915-1916).
Why Turkey has so many problems with it’s neighboring countries ?.. even with Arabs ? I am not suprised that most European citizens are against Turkish accession in the EU, and would NOT like to see Turkey in the European Union.. hmmm… I wonder Why ?..–Sako
A.) Turkey sits in a very complex geographical location, she boarders 13 countries and four bodies of seas. It is the cross roads to east and west. The Turks have more Greek/Italian history in Turkey then those countries have in there lands. Most EU countries including but not limited to the sissy Franch indiscriminately will not allow Turks into Europe. Some of the reasons are very ridiculous but since you manage to change the subject from genocide to Turks in general I will have to speak for the Turks. France claims Turkey, due to it’s location and close proximity to the Middle East cannot be considered European, but then again Cyprus which is even closer to Syria has been accessed. Oh and also Constantinople which is present day Istanbul, was the capitol of Europe not long ago.
“get your facts right first, read the real history..”–Sako
I think we have our facts straight and while you manage to write a few sentences hoping that one or two might stick in the Americans minds, a Turks job is harder, they have to backup those claims with an entire paragraph or more.
The American people are not stupid, it just takes time for us to do the research and get back to you. Once we figure out your motives, like branding the modern-day Turkish people with genocide in 2007, and hoping to take Turkish lands (which will never happen), breaking the US/Turkish 50+ years alliance, we will turn you down and move on with our daily lives, unlike some Armenian-Americans.
“You have not won the debate until you have refuted your opponent’s strongest arguments”–John Stuart Mill
Posted by: Breal | October 18, 2007, 6:03 am 6:03 am
dobutsu, you have reason to be worried.
can you say ” huge long term tax increase upcoming for the rich spoiled republican brats “?
i personally hope hillary (& bill) and nancy will put long term tax increases in place to drain the rotten purses and wallets of all the money grubbers,(ie;republicans) who have been sucking this country dry for the last 8 yrs or so…
GO DEMS !! TAX ‘EM HARD ,MAYBE THEYLL MOVE TO PANAMA!!
Posted by: bah | October 18, 2007, 8:45 pm 8:45 pm
It is sad to see your partisan remarks regarding the murder of two million people.
1. United States supports Turkey plenty, why should Turkey bully the US in this way?
2. Nancy Pelosi probably needed for George Bush to owe her one – now he does thanks to the Armenians. The US probably wanted to show Turkey a big stick as the Turks gather around the Iraq border. Well now Turkey has seen the stick. Turkey if you don’t behave, we’ll pass the Armenian Genocide bill – again thanks to the Armenians.
3. George Bush couldn’t argue the facts in the bill because he knows better – that would give Turkey too much freedom – whereas the timing argument is still a good deterrant in case Turkey acts up in the future.
etc. etc. etc.
Many of you are too naive with your comments to realize some of the huge issues at stake here, but then again, you’re probably too naive to think that going into Iraq was making US safe, or that Muslims can be democratic.
Wake up America and realize that people manipulate your opinions. Wake up and realize that voting on a genocide bill is healthy for your own health. Wake up and realize that Turkey is not your friend. In fact, there are no friends out there.
Posted by: Eshi Poch | October 20, 2007, 8:22 am 8:22 am
When Iranian president Mahmoud Ahmadinejad denied the Jewish Holocaust a few months ago, all the American politicians were shocked and in an uproar. However, George Bush is doing the exact same thing with the Armenian Holocaust by not supporting the resolution. There are more than 20 western countries (including Canada, France, Germany, Russia and Argentina) that have acknowledged the Armenian Genocide. It’s embarrassing that a country like the United States of America who proclaims to be a big supporter of human and civil rights, truth and “justice for all” can be unsupportive of such an atrocious act of inhumanity.
Posted by: jack | October 21, 2007, 3:37 pm 3:37 pm
Today Armenians who try to blend their situation with Jews, seem to forget the murders conducted by their ancestors against the Jews, Armenians who served as Nazi officers in Hitler’s army in Caucasia. Hitler’s famous quote “who today remembers the Armenians” he remembers the Armenians for fighting for him. – breal
As for that, Hitler’s quote was not to acknowledge any Armenian for service but rather to justify his atrocities against the Jews. The genocide in Armenia went totally unnoticed, so too could the genocide of the Jews, so he thought. My question is simply this, how would America feel if the world turned around and said no one died at the World Trade Center on September 11th, 2001? Those that have suffered deserve the proper respect that has been given to others.
Posted by: Karl | November 17, 2007, 1:54 am 1:54 am