By Jacqueline Klingebiel

Jan 29, 2008 4:24pm

Stimulus, Gagging And Your Tax Rebate Check

ABC’s Z. Byron Wolf reports: If you needed some idea of how muddled ideas for the stimulus plan have gotten in the Senate, Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid today told reporters that one provision in a stimulus proposal offered by a fellow Democrat made him want to gag.

Democratic Sen. Max Baucus offered his plan yesterday as an alternative to the bipartisan stimulus hashed out between House Speaker Nancy Pelosi and President Bush. It would do away with an income cap that Pelosi and House Minority Leader John Boehner had agreed on ($75,000 for individuals and $150,000 for couples).

Baucus argues that seniors on fixed incomes are excluded in the House bill and they should get some stimulus too.

But along with including seniors, Baucus’s plan would give checks to people making hundreds and even millions of dollars each year.

Reid, while he said yesterday in a statement that he "strongly supported" Baucus’s attempts to find a bipartisan solution, today said the idea of sending Warren Buffett a tax rebate check is "causing me to want to gag."

Regardless of whether he’ll lose his lunch, Reid said he will continue to support Democrats in the Senate who want to tinker with the delicate balance reached in the House.

"There are 51 democratic senators, without exception, who think this package should be made better. That means we need to find 9 Republicans who think this package needs to be made better," he said, alluding to the fact that Democrats need 60 votes to get anything done in the Senate.

Reid said he has received letters from 15 Senators, including some Republicans, asking for additional funding to be put in the stimulus package.

There have been requests for everything from food banks and food stamps to infratsructure development and housing bonds.

"We have some really difficult decisions here to make," Reid said. "Its clear to me where all 15 letters I received from senators. Every one of them is a good idea. When you lump them all together, it becomes a pretty big package."

Republicans in the Senate, however, were talking about "the need for speed."

"This is not a time to get into some kind of testing of wills between the two congressional bodies. This is a time to show that we can rise above partisanship, do something important, and do it quickly," argued Sen. Mitch McConnell.

For their part, Reid and Baucus agree that speed is essential and they think that Senate tinkering with the stimulus package is not going to slow things down. They still hope to have a bill passed before President’s Day.

User Comments

On thid tax rebate I do believe that consideration has to be given to the senior citizen and the disabled. It is not our fault if we can no longer be part of the working public, but we would also like to feel like a working factor in our country’s economy. I feel like we should receive the same amount that any blue collar working adult will receive.

Posted by: Ann Clift | January 29, 2008, 4:47 pm 4:47 pm

I agree. I’m disabled and live on Social Security. It is hard on what it pays and a little more from the rebate would really help.

Posted by: Don | January 29, 2008, 4:58 pm 4:58 pm

This rebate is a joke and shouldn’t even be given out. It won’t save us from this so called recession either. I know I’ll get flak for this, but people, have a large percentage of jobs been lost? No. They’ve been created, and are still being created. The Stocks are going down, yes, but have been up and down last year, and previous years too. This rebate won’t do anything. But it looks like I’ll be getting one anyway. So instead of spending it, like the gov’t wants, it’ll go straight into my savings account, never to be seen again. Thanks for the loan gov’t.

Posted by: Lawrence | January 29, 2008, 5:03 pm 5:03 pm

these loans against next years taxes are not a solution. this $150 billion would be better spent installing fuelcell stacks in 2 million homes to provide power for the next 30 years, and converting 2 million cars to hydrogen powerplants and electric motors and get those people off gasoline. That will save money, and put people to work as well as make fuel cells cheaper. The hydrogen can be made on site as needed with water and an aluminum/gallium alloy pellet. (It absorbs the oxygen from the water and releases the hydrogen)

Posted by: Louis | January 29, 2008, 5:53 pm 5:53 pm

These punks actually have it in the bill that everybody (yes, even Bill Gates) gets $500 rebate. Why are they voting to give Bill Gates a REBATE!!! These jerks are doing more harm just trying to look like they’re doing something. If you really want change, just vote out ALL the incumbents, NOT one excluded. Otherwise, stop complaining!!! These losers are stealing your wealth and trying to bribe you with pocket change. Don’t buy it and WAKE UP!!!!

Posted by: wake up! | January 29, 2008, 6:50 pm 6:50 pm

This “stimulus package” will have an effect similar to putting a band-aid on a bullet hole. The dollar is tanking and the economy is struggling because of excessive government regulation, taxation and overseas spending.

Posted by: Timothy Logsdon | January 30, 2008, 12:39 pm 12:39 pm

Senator Baucas’ hearts in the right place but This is No time to be playing
games. Rebates for Millionaires is
stupid and wrong. The rich in this country don’t pay their fair share as it
is. Anything that holds up getting cash
to the middle class should be scrapped and fought over later.

Posted by: blackie | January 30, 2008, 1:19 pm 1:19 pm

I have thought a lot about this. I am on disability. I am taking out loans to go to nursing school. I want to get off of SSD. My dad died before he got his first retirement check. My mother is definitely not well off. They worked and helped build this country. Retired as well as disabled are some of the country’s most in need and to not be included is a joke. There are the working poor, but to hand out money to people making 100,000 is a joke. Most seniors and disabled make less than 20,000. Who do you think needs it most. There are the most medical bills also. They need it to eat as well.
Wake up people.

Posted by: Sal | February 2, 2008, 9:52 am 9:52 am

OK to all you people…you are all right. Think about the last time these checks were given out, remember 9/11 and the economic stimulus package that let all you Idiots(metaphoricly) buy new houses and great big suv’s etc, that you could not afford then and now that the interest has come you can’t afford to pay, well howdy doo. were screwed and circling the drain and the bureacrats know this for fact and the only solution we have is a “band-aid” fix. Put the band-aid on call it good and slap each other on the back for doing “good”. let the next gen figure it out. Peace in the Revolution…

Posted by: Ghost | February 8, 2008, 9:06 pm 9:06 pm

Leave a Reply

Do you have more information about this topic? If so, please click here to contact the editors of ABC News.