Feb 29, 2008 7:11pm

John McCain Enters the Autism Wars

At a town hall meeting Friday in Texas, Sen. John McCain, R-Ariz., declared that "there’s strong evidence" that thimerosal, a mercury-based preservative that was once in many childhood vaccines, is responsible for the increased diagnoses of autism in the U.S. — a position in stark contrast with the view of the medical establishment.

McCain was responding to a question from the mother of a boy with autism, who asked about a recent story that the U.S. Court of Federal Claims and the National Vaccine Injury Compensation Program had issued a judgment in favor of an unnamed child whose family claimed regressive encephalopathy and symptoms of autism were caused by thimerosal.

"We’ve been waiting for years for kind of a responsible answer to this question, and are hoping that you can help us out there," the woman said.

McCain said, per ABC News’ Bret Hovell, that "It’s indisputable that (autism) is on the rise amongst children, the question is what’s causing it. And we go back and forth and there’s strong evidence that indicates that it’s got to do with a preservative in vaccines."

McCain said there’s "divided scientific opinion" on the matter, with "many on the other side that are credible scientists that are saying that’s not the cause of it."

The established medical community is not as divided as McCain made it sound, however. Overwhelmingly the "credible scientists," at least as the government and the medical establishment so ordain them, side against McCain’s view.

Moreover, those scientists and organizations fear that powerful people lending credence to the thimerosal theory could dissuade parents from getting their children immunized — which in their view would lead to a very real health crisis.

The Centers for Disease Control says "There is no convincing scientific evidence of harm caused by the low doses of thimerosal in vaccines, except for minor reactions like redness and swelling at the injection site."

The American Academy of Pediatrics says"No scientific data link thimerosal used as a preservative in vaccines with any pediatric neurologic disorder, including autism."

The Food and Drug Administration conducted a review in 1999 — the year thimerosal was ordered to be removed from most vaccines — and said that it "found no evidence of harm from the use of thimerosal as a vaccine preservative, other than local hypersensitivity reactions."

The Institute of Medicine’s Immunization Safety Review Committee concluded "that the body of epidemiological evidence favors rejection of a causal relationship between thimerosal-containing vaccines and autism."

And a study of California Department of Developmental Services data published last month indicated that there was "an increase in autism in California despite the removal of thimerosal from most vaccines."

Yet there is a vocal, determined, passionate group — including some medical researchers and organizations — who vehemently dispute what the established medical community says about this wrenching issue. One of the questions they ask is why would the thimerosal have been removed from the vaccines if there was no real harm?

(The answer according to the Public Health Service, the American Academy of Pediatrics, and vaccine manufacturers was "because any potential risk is of concern.")

In any case, here we have a major political figure, the presumptive Republican nominee, who stated that he at the very least isn’t as sure about thimerosal as the medical establishment is.

Moreover, he made it sound as if the thimerosal is still in vaccines — though as I understand it, thimerosal is all but gone in almost every childhood vaccine now, and has been for years.

This could be quite controversial.

- jpt

User Comments

I would like to know when McCain received a medical degree and from where? Just what medical research does this old man base his “there’s strong evidence” statement on?
You are right Jake about thimerosal no longer being used. And yet, diagnoses of autistic spectrum diseases are still increasing among children. If this “politician” scares parents enough to keep them from immunizing children, I fear for the consequences of those kids having to deal with devastating illnesses like measles.
I am a nurse and someone needs to set the man straight about practicing medicine without a license!!

Posted by: kate, tx | February 29, 2008, 8:01 pm 8:01 pm

No, they you aren’t right about thimerosal not being used anymore. The recall was voluntary, and did not require vaccines be destroyed. The “ban” was simply on creating any more vaccines with a mercury preservative, not on actually preventing mercury from being injected into children.
Furthermore, there is overwhelming evidence that increases in autism cannot be explained by genetics alone. The strongest evidence that there is an environmental component is NEW JERSEY!!! where in one school, in Room 5, 9 babies were born to pregnant teachers who had autism.
There are hot spots near polluted industrial sites of autism all over this country. Texas scientifically linked mercury pollution in the environment with increased rates of autism very recently. (Google mercury and autism)
Whatever the real role of vaccines, whether the issue be mercury or simply overloading vulnerable immune systems with too many vaccines, there is a strong and real environmental component that the many people want you to deny and ignore.

Posted by: Julie | February 29, 2008, 8:24 pm 8:24 pm

Many parents with autistic kids feel just the opposite, I guess it is just their imagination ageofautism.com.

Posted by: unatutor | February 29, 2008, 8:26 pm 8:26 pm

Hear, hear! 3 Cheers for John McCain! While others choose to “listen” only to so called experts (note how they ALL have conflicts of interest) McCain has listened to the parents and doctors and researchers who also listened to parents who have witnessed drastic changes in their children after receiving vaccines.

Posted by: LizB | February 29, 2008, 8:36 pm 8:36 pm

Kate,
You are wrong, thimerosal is still being used in the flu vaccine which is recommened for children 6mo.-18yrs of age and for pregnant women as well. Also, it is not just the thimerosal, but it the gigantic increase in required vaccinations over the years. Our children’s immune system cannot handle this! Every organization that does feel vaccinations contribute to autism does NOT tell you not to vaccinete your child, however, they tell you to do it at a slower pace, separtate the vaccines instead of giving four at a time, do not get the flu vaccine that still contains mercury and so on. If you had a child that was affected by vaccines you would be right on board, trust me!!! John McCain is being responsible. It is about time someone stood up to the CDC, the AAP, the drug companies for not only poisoning our children, but also covering it up.

Posted by: sarah | February 29, 2008, 8:52 pm 8:52 pm

Thimerosal is still in the majority of flu shots in this country (about 80%, I believe), at the same dosages it always has been. These shots are now recommended annually starting at 6 months of age. It is also in other vaccines in “trace” amounts which are never monitored by the FDA, only by the drug companies themselves. Many vaccines also contain Aluminum, another known neurotoxin, which has replaced the thimerosal. The CDC would love for everyone to believe vaccines are safe; they are not. Problems with HepB shots (which are given to infants here starting at birth) have led to lawsuits in France and Japan. Several girls and young women have died from the Gardasil shot. ProQuad has a high incidence of causing seizures. This federal case is just the tip of the iceberg.

Posted by: Garbo | February 29, 2008, 8:53 pm 8:53 pm

kate,tx, when you go in to work on Monday, look at the package inserts for your flu shots. They’ll tell you all you need to know about the thimerosal in those vials.

Posted by: Garbo | February 29, 2008, 8:57 pm 8:57 pm

I don’t know if posting links is against the rules. I tried to post links but my post was deleted.
But you can go to the FDA Thimerosal web pages and see that it is still in vaccines. The highest concentrations are in the flu shot and generic tetanus shot.
CA passed legislation banning it in vaccines for pregnant women and children in 2001 but it was still given in vaccines to pregnant women and children through 2006. We won’t see reductions in ASD cases until 5-6 years after all traces of it are removed from vaccinations.
David Kirby has details of the recent govt. conceded vaccine/autism case at Huffington Post and Autism Radio has a great interview with Mr. Kirby and Dr. David Geier about the case on their site as well.

Posted by: biomedmom | February 29, 2008, 8:57 pm 8:57 pm

Nobody wants to see the diseases of the past but the US has become the US of Autism, ADHD, Asthma and Allergies. With the increasing rate of autism in 1990 came the increasing no. of vaccines mandated by the CDC and AAP(their cash cow).
Thimerosal is still being used in the manufacturing process of vaccines. There is no govt FDA/CDC whomever oversight as to how much mercury is left in these vaccines. The mercury ban in CA went into effect December 2006. In 2002 pregnant women and children 6 months to 5 years of age were recommended to have flu shots. To this day roughly 85% of US flu shot supply contains thimerisol. i.e. the mercury has not been removed.
Vaccines should be safe and effective. Today’s vaccine schedule calls for 30 some doses of vaccine before a child enters Kindergarten. Adverse effects are ignored becuase the CDC promotes universal immunization -NOT Safety.
The only way to settle this austism debate is a vaccinated and never-vaccinated study which the CDC won’t do. I wonder why.

Posted by: Holly | February 29, 2008, 8:58 pm 8:58 pm

There’s very little evidence to show that autism is linked to mercury. Who is John McCain, a politician, to make a judgement?
This reminds me of Bill Frist and the Republicans in the Terry Schiavo case – people without knowledge making statements and policies simply for political gain.

Posted by: RJ | February 29, 2008, 9:00 pm 9:00 pm

You are both wrong about thimerosal not being used in vaccines. The current “preservative” level mercury in multi-dose flu, meningococcal and tetanus vaccines is 50,000 parts per billion, a level of mercury 250 times higher than what the EPA classifies as hazardous waste. This can be confirmed by simply analyzing the multi-dose vaccine vials. Autism rates are still going up due to earlier intervention and change in diagnostic criteria. What does McCain know about thimerosal? He has helped Gulf War veterans recover from the same injuries caused by these vaccines as children.

Posted by: Mark | February 29, 2008, 9:03 pm 9:03 pm

Holly,
Autism rates have increased because the criteria doctors use to diagnose autism have become broader as we have learned more about the disease. There is no real correlation between vaccination rates and autism.

Posted by: RJ | February 29, 2008, 9:03 pm 9:03 pm

RJ, the govt. recently conceded causation in a vaccine/autism case. I posted the info below.
Frist actually tried to pass legislation protecting the pharmaceutical companies from Thimerosal lawsuits in the Homeland Security Bill years ago.

Posted by: biomedmom | February 29, 2008, 9:04 pm 9:04 pm

I am a parent of a child with autism. Having said that, she was fine until bombarded with vaccine after vaccine. Then I lost her. I am gaining her back now, slowly, through the use of biomedical treatments and lots of therapy. I applaud McCain for this. As I do Clinton for starting the free and appropriate education act long ago, and the combating autism act of 2007. There is nothing anyone can tell me to convince me of any other reason for my daughter to have autism. It is not in my family at all. There are some cases that are genetic, but not many. And isn’t it interesting that Amish people have very low cases of autism? Check out the National Autism Association website. What people don’t understand is that if we don’t find a cure, we are looking at one or two generations of people who will be on disability. Not to mention the child that has to pay the price.

Posted by: Catmacdee | February 29, 2008, 9:12 pm 9:12 pm

RJ, Autism rates have increased because more kids have autism. One way to tell for certain is the profound increase in public school district budgets for special education and services for all of these kids. Schools are strapped for cash and don’t want to pay a dime more than they absolutely have to; the fact that the percentages in spending have increased so markedly for special needs, special foods, special aides, etc. indicates that there’s been a huge increase in children who actually need help. Schools won’t “pay” based on a diagnosis, they “pay” based on the actual educational needs of the child. So regardless of broadened diagnostic criteria, there’s a tidal wave of autistic kids that need help. Don’t you think it would be in our society’s best interest to investigate the underlying cause of this profound increase in special needs children?

Posted by: Garbo | February 29, 2008, 9:16 pm 9:16 pm

Three cheers for John McCain! His comments made me cry tears of joy. My son is vaccine injured. My son has autism. Its true.

Posted by: Lisa | February 29, 2008, 9:18 pm 9:18 pm

Garbo,
It is true that there are more kids with autism today than 10 years ago. This is due to broadened description criteria.
And, this is NOT a bad thing. 10 years ago, there were more kids with autism who were not diagnosed with it, which meant they couldn’t get the help they needed. Broadening the criteria has allowed us to get help to more children – this is a GOOD thing.
People are investigating the underlying cause of autism. Catmacdee, I feel your pain, but I think we should leave it up to trained researchers to make the decisions about autism, not politicians. There is not a single gene for autism, just as there is not a single gene for almost all neural diseases out there. The lack of a single gene link or autism in a family tree does not eliminate the possibility of many multiple genes acting together to express autism newly in a family.

Posted by: RJ | February 29, 2008, 9:21 pm 9:21 pm

Well, I’m a Democrat but McCain has my interest here as I have a daughter who regressed into autism after numerous thimerosal vaccines. And, a big “no” to you, Jake, on your thinking that thimerosal is all gone. It is in close to 80% or more of the current flu vacines this season, shots that are given to pregnant women, infants, toddlers, and as of Tues, being recommended to ALL children up to age 18.
This debate has been going on for years as it is “conflict of interest” companies and government agencies vs parents and professionals who have seen the children change and become ill with immune issues; severe gastrointestinal disease; labs showing huge amounts of bacteria, yeast, and viruses; loss of speech or echoing the speech they hear; tics; ocd; anxiety; hyperacoustic hearing; pain and frustration that leads to aggression. The crazy thing too is that most cannot excrete metals that are in their environment, such as lead, aluminum, arsenic and the controversial thimerosal/mercury.
I am glad you referenced ARI and NAA as they are on a mission to heal these kids and get the word out that autism is a treatable medical issue. There are many more organizations, researchers, universities, doctors, and now, presidential hopefuls it appears, who have read the real research, attended conferences, looked at the data, but most importantly, examined the children. There is where you will see the damage done.
Teresa
Chicago

Posted by: Teresa | February 29, 2008, 9:24 pm 9:24 pm

A nurse is no more a doctor then Sen. John McCain.

Posted by: Sara | February 29, 2008, 9:48 pm 9:48 pm

Thimerosal has a skull and crossbones on the label. Why would any poison be safe to inject into our kids? It is not just the mercury it is the aluminum , formaldehyde and other toxins contained in the shots. There are too many vaccines too soon. Add that to chemicals in our food and environmental exposures and that is why our children are so sick. You don’t inject , ingest and expose a child to so many toxins and not expect anything to happen. Until this country changes the vaccination schedule we will never see a decrease in autism.
I am a nurse and I don’t understand why mainstream medicine is clueless about this epidemic!

Posted by: SCR | February 29, 2008, 10:01 pm 10:01 pm

RJ, I get what you are saying, but if there were just as many autistic children 10 or 20 years ago as there are today, where are they now? Where are all these severely autistic teenagers and young adults? The kids we are talking about have severe medical issues, not just behavioral or psychological ones. Did we suddenly broaden the criteria for diagnosing asthma and life-threatening food allergies too? Or for severe gastrointestinal disease? Because they’ve all increased and many of our kids have them.

Posted by: Garbo | February 29, 2008, 10:08 pm 10:08 pm

It is not about who is right and who is wrong. It is about the rights of parents to choose how best to raise their kids. Too many times the government and the medical establishment use threats to force us to subject our kids, our families, to do these kind of things. We are treated like idiots when we question their research and motives.
This used to be a free country.

Posted by: Chuck | February 29, 2008, 10:15 pm 10:15 pm

Senator McCain:
Autism is a horrible condition. My heart aches for those children and their parents.
However the constant unproven accusations and blame on vaccines will ultimately cause immunization rates to fall, disease epidemic to rise and lives will be lost or destroyed.
Time and time again research shows there is no link between vaccine and autism. Just this month ABC news aired a study that Suggests Autism Causes Are Genetic.
Sir, I mean this with no disrespect but you are old enough to remember those days before vaccine. One simply has to walk around and old cemetery to understand the value of vaccines. For me I just have to open my eyes everyday and face another day without my precious son.
In 1998 I lost my only child, Ryan, to meningococcal meningitis. My perfectly healthy son went from just that to blood coming from every orifice of his body in 14 hours and he died. All of this was vaccine preventable.
The last words Ryan heard were “Daddy loves you baby boy.” The last words he said were,”I know.”
With him went the words we would never hear again like mom and dad, the honor to be parents at his wedding, the joy of holding a grand child or having his comfort in our old age.
The public needs to know/see what happens when kids aren’t vaccinated, do not have access to vaccines or the worst, parents chose not to vaccinate. I believe if children were given the opportunity between loss of life or a sever disability caused by a vaccine preventable disease, they would choose vaccine.
Since Ryan’s death, I have dedicated my life to educating kids, teens, parents and the general public on communicable diseases and the prevention which includes vaccine.
Each day new families across this country, like me lose their children.
Many have children that are so severely debilitated that they require care 24 hours a day 7 days a week. They suffer from a wide variety of disabilities including brain damage, kidney failure along with other organ damage, blindness, deafness, migraine headaches, digestive, muscular and neurological disorders.
Many suffer severe anemia, learning disabilities, limb amputations, paralysis, seizure disorders so sever they have brain surgery to remove pieces of their little brains, mental illness and yes even autism.
Many families end in financial ruin because of the never ending medical bills, become social outcast and many end in family breakup. A few even suicide.
There are also parents who have lost children to pertussis, cervical cancer, chicken pox, influenza and more.
WE CAN PROVE that a vaccine preventable disease did this to our children, to our family, to our lives.
Vaccines are the greatest discovery of the last century. The lives saved are immeasurable.
It is time to STOP laying unproven blame on vaccines.
Mom to a child that shoul not have died.

Posted by: Frankie | February 29, 2008, 10:22 pm 10:22 pm

Let me make this clear – vaccines do NOT cause autism. Repeat that over and over. I’m a physician, but I’m also the father of an autistic daughter. Ignore all of the hysterical silliness and conspiracy theories. Vaccines do NOT cause autism. We need to get away from this nonsense if we’re to make progress in treatment and understanding of this condition.
Jake, you’re right on. Keep up the good work.

Posted by: pathdoc | February 29, 2008, 10:26 pm 10:26 pm

Anyone who claims thimerosal (mercury) has been removed from vaccines is just plain wrong and totally uninformed on the issue. Here is the web page that lists the current vaccines that do and do not contain thimerosal.
Even the vaccines listed as only containing trace amounts of mercury still contain 0.3mcg of mercury, which is a lot of mercury.

Posted by: Dan, tx | February 29, 2008, 10:31 pm 10:31 pm

Frankie, I am so sorry for the loss of your son. The terrible tragedy of all of this is that the CDC and FDA, by failing to ensure the safety of vaccines and by loading the vaccine schedule with too many shots in too short a time, have themselves jeopardized the vaccine program as a whole and the benefits of “herd immunity”. Most autism parents are not anti-vaccine; they are anti-UNSAFE vaccine. This is a big distinction. I feel I must address your premise that parents would choose disability from vaccines. Autism parents face this question every day when they must decide whether to vaccinate their subsequent children after seeing their first child slip into autism. I vaccinated my daughter even after my son was diagnosed, right up until last year when she began stuttering right after her last round of DTaP and chicken pox shots. No more. Never again. But don’t blame me. Blame the CDC, FDA, and AAP. I do.

Posted by: Garbo | February 29, 2008, 10:33 pm 10:33 pm

John McCain has now cemented my vote for him. Thank you Mr McCain, the vaccine damage is out of control…36 vacs before 5 yrs of age is INSANE !!!
Most of the comments here pro vacs are from Doctors and their wives who are slaves to the Pharma companies. They wouldn’t trade their free vacations to save children. Sad but 100% true.

Posted by: Thomas Mollo | February 29, 2008, 10:36 pm 10:36 pm

***Most of the comments here pro vacs are from Doctors and their wives who are slaves to the Pharma companies. They wouldn’t trade their free vacations to save children. Sad but 100% true.***
I’m a pathologist. How much am I dependent on “Big Pharma”? Less than zero. Honesty is my only excuse. I repeat: vaccines do NOT cause autism.

Posted by: pathdoc | February 29, 2008, 10:44 pm 10:44 pm

To Frankie-
I am deeply sorry for the loss of your child. Your comment here-”Many families end in financial ruin because of the never ending medical bills, become social outcast and many end in family breakup. A few even suicide. ”
This is the world of autism and the families that live there. We experience all of these too. The numbers are increasing as well. It is time to question vaccines and preservatives that can harm. Vaccines have been a powerful tool to keep illness away but we cannot close our eyes to pollution out of smokestacks, mercury in fish, or vaccines that cause immune,gastrointestinal,and neurological disorders as we are afraid what we may find. To blindly stay on that path will destroy more lives and the entire vaccination program.
Teresa
Chicago

Posted by: Teresa | February 29, 2008, 10:52 pm 10:52 pm

I was diagnosed (as an adult) with aspergers. Before that, I was just that weird kid in the back of the class. But in no way, shape, or form was it caused by vaccinations, I was born before the thimerosol.
If I decided to have my own child, I would still have them undergo vaccination. Why? Because even if there was a *documented* risk that a vaccine material could cause Autism, it is my responsibility to society to make sure my child doesn’t infect everyone around them with mumps, measels, etc.
I think it’s far more likely that children are autistic for genetic reasons (my whole family has a variation of disorders, which is why I plan to adopt instead). I also think a ‘mild case’ could be aggravated by other factors such as pollution – there’s probably far more than mercury lying around in our food supply- or just all the environmental garbage that you have to filter out every day, like neon signs, flashing television screens, and plain mind-numbing noise.
So many studies have been made, and no definitive link has been established.
We’re far better off using the money to look at some *other* source, whether it be genetic, or some environmental trigger, than wasting time on a possibility that has been exhaustively researched.
We have to decide if we want to find blame, or find a solution. It’s harder to rail at the environment, than it is to point a finger at some particular company and say “YOU DID IT!”. It’s perhaps even harder to look at yourselves and think – this came from us.
Do we really want to go back to rooms full of kids in iron lungs?

Posted by: Aspergergirl | February 29, 2008, 11:02 pm 11:02 pm

Hey pathdoc, apparently the National Vaccine Injury Compensation Program does not agree with you.
Since you can’t tell us what does cause autism how can you be so sure?

Posted by: Dan, tx | February 29, 2008, 11:05 pm 11:05 pm

Aspergirl, thimerosal has been around and used in vaxs since the 1930s, so in all likelihood if you got shots, you got some. The difference is, when you were growing up there were only a few shots. Even as recently as 1983 there were about ten. Now there are about forty. Forty.

Posted by: Garbo | February 29, 2008, 11:22 pm 11:22 pm

For some this is just a debate, something to argue for or aginst. For others, such as my son and I, this is real life. My son has autism (and no, it doesn’t run in my family). I used to scoff at biomedical approaches to autism. I thought they were desperate people who were in denial. I come from a family full of mathmaticians and scientists, and logic still reigns supreme in my house. The facts are evident to any who actually live with autism and don’t just chit chat about it on the web:
There is no such thing as a genetic epidemic
The diagnostic criteria has not expanded (giving way to the increased number of autistic children). There is simply more autistic children to be diagnosed.
Most autistic children share the same physical illnesses. Dysbiosis of the gut, yeast and bacterial infecions, viral infections, heavy metal toxicity, and mitochondrial disorders.
Get educated. And, unless you have autism, love or care for someone with autism, or are willing to help find the solution to autism….keep your uninformed opinions to yourself.

Posted by: rebelmom | February 29, 2008, 11:32 pm 11:32 pm

It seems like McCain is more like Bush all of the time, “the hell with science.” It is disgusting that they play into people’s tragedies and fears. McCain is not a doctor, nor is he a man of science and for him to tell someone what they want to hear is sinful.

Posted by: The Unshrub | February 29, 2008, 11:46 pm 11:46 pm

For sake of argument, lets say it is in a vaccine – but if there was only *some* vaccines with *some* mercury in my day – then why is it that my aspergers no different than any other child with aspergers born 20 years after me?
Wouldn’t more mercury exposure in vaccines lead to more severe cases of autism? Growing up I had mercury batteries, mercury thermometers in my mouth, and mercury in electronics. All in far greater concentrations than in vaccines.
The diagnostic criteria *has* increased – only because Autism was considered a form of mental retardation for several decades. You had to have had it *bad* in a Forrest Gump sort of way. Aspergers didn’t even enter the diagnostic lexicon until 1993, and by then, I was already 20 years old!
I have no problem with the idea that mercury, among *many* other pollutants, could be the cause of *genetic mutation* leading to more autism cases -but stuff from landfills and in our water supply is far more dangerous than what may or may not be in a vaccine delivery vial.
Look at some news reports recently of little kids having plastic compounds in their bodies. And we have *no* idea what effect that may have.

Posted by: Aspergergirl | March 1, 2008, 12:03 am 12:03 am

Aspergergirl,
The fact is that some people can excrete metal and toxins better than others. Perhaps your immune system is stronger and your glutithione levels are higher, giving you the ability to detoxify. This is the issue we have with vaccines. What’s wrong with wanting the vaccines to be given when the child is healthy and able to handle them? What’s wrong with testing for mitochondrial defects before vaccination? Do you know why they put thermerisol and other preservatives in vaccines? To save 52 cents an injection. What’s wrong with vaccines that contain no preservatives. I’m more than happy to pay 52 cents to keep my son free of thermerisol, aluminum, animal cells and tissue, and formaldahde. I appreciate you have probably had some struggles in your life….is it so wrong that we want to stop this from happening to other kids?

Posted by: rebelmom | March 1, 2008, 12:30 am 12:30 am

Exactly. Nobody knows what causes it. So let’s start with what we do know. One, mercury is highly neurotoxic. Two, it’s in vaccines, and dental amalgam, and fish, and the air we breathe, and on and on. Three, scientists have connected environmental mercury levels in Houston with increases in autism levels. Four, why is there even discussion of mercury in vaccines? We shouldn’t even be having a discussion about getting mercury out of vaccines and dental amalgams. It should be gone. There is no reason for it to be there, and every reason for it not to be.

Posted by: Garbo | March 1, 2008, 12:32 am 12:32 am

Thimerosal is not out of the vaccines. I appreciate your article but, you should check your facts. It is very easy to find out the current ingredients list on any of the vaccines in use today.

Posted by: Mo | March 1, 2008, 12:35 am 12:35 am

You are so right, rebelmom. My son was diagnosed at age 3; if I had listened to all the people who told me to just accept it I shudder to think where we’d be now. After almost 4 years of biomed he’s nearly whole. He tested high for mercury, lead, and a host of other nasties. He had zero good bacteria in his gut thanks to antibiotics for an ear infection, and loads of measles virus. Post-chelation he’s at the top of his class and nobody at his school is even aware he was ever diagnosed. All us parents want is for everyone else to know how to prevent this from happening in the first place, and if it does how it might be fixed. Some of the research I’ve read has suggested that Asperger’s people do not have the same high levels of heavy metals as other spectrum kids, so there may be a different underlying pathology.

Posted by: Garbo | March 1, 2008, 12:50 am 12:50 am

Garbo,
These autistic kids of 10 years ago who were never diagnosed are now poorly performing adults, who have most likely now been diagnosed with autism due to the broadened criteria. Because of those criteria, these adults can have better care, as can children who might have missed the previous criteria.
Also, there is reason for mercury to be present in our vaccines. Thimerosal is a potent preservative that prevents bacterial contamination of the vaccines. Indeed, while there is a mountain of evidence against the thimerosal-autism connection, there is no doubt a very high likelihood of bacterial contamination if it was taken out.
But, I’m going to be realistic here. There are surely other preservatives that could be used, but this would increase the price of the vaccines greatly and require years of revisionary research. In the end, those costs would be pushed onto the patient, and less people get vaccinations even if they’re required.
Vaccinations are important as a public health service. We’ve been able to wipe out things like Polio, Hep B rates are falling significantly, and MMR is way down too. These infections kill children.
And it’s not as if we can vaccinate only the people who want the vaccinations. These are infectious diseases that spread from person to person. If we leave children unvaccinated, they have the potential to infect and kill people with deficient immune systems – people with cancer, their own grandparents in their old age, and immunocompromised children. Vaccines are extremely important to the health of our country, and we should be asking Pharma companies why they are signficantly *decreasing* funding for vaccine development, not attacking them for things for which there’s no scientific proof.

Posted by: RJ | March 1, 2008, 12:52 am 12:52 am

“I appreciate you have probably had some struggles in your life….is it so wrong that we want to stop this from happening to other kids?”
Because the health risks to other adults and children are so high if we *don’t* vaccinate. Look at what’s going on in Switzerland. People didn’t vaccinate their kids – they’ve had over 1400 cases of measels in the last year. A child went there on vacation earlier in Feburary, and when they returned, infected other kids in San Diego, and one of THOSE kids went to Hawaii and now there are cases there.
What if your refusal to vaccinate, leads to the death of 10 kids in your child’s class? What if it leads to an epidemic in your town, with hundreds of people ill?
If there are other preservatives that work, then funding given to autism research should have an earmark to develop the new materials, and then *hand* it to the drug companies for free. Then all they need to do is mix it, OR a company can be found that will produce the vaccine with a safer mix, and we’ll all buy from them.
But that *still* won’t remove all the other junk in the environment, nor will it cure the cases that are most definitely genetic. I believe ABC news had a story about a family with 6 autistic kids within the last few weeks.

Posted by: Aspergergirl | March 1, 2008, 1:05 am 1:05 am

RJ, your own comments belie the truth. This is about money, and the fact is that having to reformulate the vaccines would eat into Pharma companies’ astronomical profits. Does every child in the U.S. need to be vaccinated for Rotavirus? No. It’s primary benefit is in third world countries, but the World Health Organization won’t buy it if it isn’t in the U.S. schedule. So guess what vaccine the FDA is thinking about approving now?
Measles, polio, and the other diseases you are talking about had already started dropping off with better sanitation, before vaccines were even introduced. Herd immunity is good in theory, but in practice it is impossible to achieve. There is always going to be someone who dies from a disease, and someone else who doesn’t gain immunity from the vaccine. Immune compromised people are more vulnerable. Guess what? My child is immune compromised because of vaccines. What you are talking about is trading one epidemic for another, and calling autism the lesser of two evils. Is it really my job as a parent to protect old lady Smith down the block from measles? And if so, then shouldn’t that cut both ways — isn’t it also old lady Smith’s responsibility to protect my child from autism?

Posted by: Garbo | March 1, 2008, 1:06 am 1:06 am

RJ,
What care are you speaking of when referring to adults or children with autism? Just try getting services that are recommended for chidren with autism (ABA therapy). If you can afford it it will run hundreds to thousands of dollars a week. If not, you can wait for the state or school district to hlp and believe me, that’s a fight I don’t wish upon anyone else. Are you seriously tryig to say to moms like Garbo and myself that our childrens autism is neccessary result of cost-effectiveness?!? Sell that one to someone else. You are not listening. We are not anti-vaccine!!!!!!! We are for clean vaccines. Tell you what, I’ll happily pay for the increase in health care costs if it means no more children are exposed to toxins through their friendly doctor at well baby check ups.
Congrats on your child’s progress Garbo…my son is making gains through chelation as well.
Here’s a thought: If the flu shot caused erectile dysfunction and baldness in 1 out of 150 men and they even suspected it was due to preservatives…..it would be cleaned up FAST!!!

Posted by: rebelmom | March 1, 2008, 1:19 am 1:19 am

Don’t you understand – NO disease, in this day and age, is limited to a geographic area.
God forbid someone comes home from a trip to Zimbabwe or something, and has Ebola. We have *no* way to stop that.
So *yes*, I do feel that autism is the lesser of two evils. Most definitely. While I may not be considered ‘normal’, at least I won’t be a biological threat to anyone.
Who am I to think that my child is worth more than anyone else’s? Little Old Lady Smith takes responsibility for your child by not speeding down the road while they are trying to cross, or paying taxes to the state to make sure schools are funded. We all play our part as a *society* to ensure that we don’t descend into some machete wielding mob everytime something goes wrong.
I’m sure Old Lady Smith also feels compassionate enough that if you said “Please give $10 of your money to fund safer vaccines for children” she’d do it.

Posted by: AspergerGirl | March 1, 2008, 1:20 am 1:20 am

Oh, and for McCain….being that he is what started the discussion.
I don’t think this would be close to affecting his chances in the election at all. I mean, if he came out and said that he didn’t believe in evolution, or that we were all children of Xenu and that we need to prepare for the battle of Thetans – then *maybe* people might think twice about letting him near the Red Button.
His heart is in the right place, even if what he is saying hasn’t been proven by science. But being that his wife has run medical missions to Southeast Asia, I’d love to know what she thinks of his comment.

Posted by: Aspergergirl | March 1, 2008, 1:29 am 1:29 am

That’s my candidate!! Thank God someone has the integrity to stand up and tell the truth! No more needs to be said.

Posted by: Brandonsmom | March 1, 2008, 1:31 am 1:31 am

Unshrub~
Your comment is presumptuous and it shows. Allow the truth from a politically active, autism mom to shed some light and open your mind (and hopefully your heart). First, President Bush did quite the opposite of what Senator McCain has and is. President Bush pandered and gave plenty of lip-service to the autism community. He made us promises, was elected and left us high and dry. President Bush also NEVER had the courage to take on this particular issue pertaining to the autism crisis; although, he promised us he would. Second, Senator McCain has an entire health staff working on this issue within his U.S. Senate offices. He and his staff are looking at, in scrupulous detail, ALL of the science and research, from ALL sides, not just from the financially tied and/or vested interested party’s side. He’s earnestly listening to the concerns of hundreds of thousands of parents. He has taken it upon himself to actually be fair, all the while knowing he will become a target of enormous, corporate powers and many, many members of Congress. Senator McCain is well aware of the controversy, as well as, the upheaval which will follow by taking on our plea. He is, nonetheless, an honorable man who is choosing to find the truth rather than cave to industry, special interests, and corruption. Lastly, he also chose to put a full-time health staffer in his campaign on this subject due to the numerous requests of parents and loved ones of those with autism from all across the nation. YOU ARE GRAVELY MISTAKEN. HE IS VERY WELL INFORMED AND EDUCATED ON THIS ISSUE! Senator McCain has chosen to give us a voice and a chance!! Take it from a mom, an advocate and a political activist who has had her feet pounding the pavement from ground zero, all Senator McCain is guilty of is listening to us and taking our concerns seriously. I applaud and commend you, Senator McCain, for having the courage to proceed where few others have. Sincerely, THANK YOU!!!

Posted by: oneproudMAMA | March 1, 2008, 2:05 am 2:05 am

I’ll use this entry to come out as a parent of an autistic child. My two year old was just diagnosed last month.
And yes, this is a very controversial issue. I’m stunned that McCain would come down on the same side as the alternative biomed community. I appreciate that he phrased his view diplomatically, but still he gives credence to a group of people who are, in essence, clinging to an unsupported conspiracy theory.
Does this change the way I feel about McCain? No.

Posted by: cordelia525 | March 1, 2008, 8:28 am 8:28 am

Many children are born with high levels of mercury that are passed from mom and dad from their mercury amalgam “silver” fillings. Boyd Haley and other doctors have researched this as a causative factor in autism and also in ad. The vaccinations are what push them over the edge.
Do I believe in vaccinations? Absolutley NOT. What protects us from disease is our immune systems. How can tearing down our immunity with toxic chemicals and a heavy metal make it stronger? Our immune systems can be built up through a proper diet. Unfortunatly the FDA does not look out for us it looks out for the drug companies.
For the person who thinks thimerasol is so wonderful and is needed in vaccinations, maybe you are mercury poisoned and your judgement is off.

Posted by: mercuryfree | March 1, 2008, 8:50 am 8:50 am

I am very grateful to John McCain for having the courage to question the safety of vaccines today! There is certainly plenty of scientific evidence that vaccines do cause autism, allergies, asthma and other serious neurological disorders.
Main stream media keeps NOT reporting study after study from reputable institutions, like Harvard, that there is definetly a link.
McCain has the courage and he has the power of truth behind him!

Posted by: Susan Fund | March 1, 2008, 8:57 am 8:57 am

Awww, that’s cute. ABC News thinks there’s no thimerasol in vaccines.

Posted by: Anne | March 1, 2008, 9:08 am 9:08 am

There are a whole lotta self-proclaimed experts on this thread saying the FDA, CDC, IOM, and AAP are wrong. Smarter than all of them put together, are you?
Give it up, mercury moms. The train has left the station. All your picket signs and lawsuits can’t change scientific fact, and your continued railing against vaccines places children in harm’s way.
I am disappointed to realize McCain lacks the sophistication to either (a) analyze a scientific question according to what science has actually found or (b) know when to consult an expert instead of relying on what some yahoo tells him. It shows a troubling lack of judgment.
For the record, the only thimerosal-containing vaccines licensed and marketed in the United States today at more than trace levels (a trace is a microgram or less per dose) are these:
* One diphtheria-tetanus and one tetanus-only vaccine, both of which are largely obsolete
* One tetanus-diphtheria booster, the need for which is also greatly diminished, and not given to kids anyway
* Some influenza vaccines
* Japanese encephalitis vaccine, not part of the standard vaccine schedule
* One meningococcal vaccine, mainly given at college age
The amount of ethylmercury in a child’s flu shot is less than the amount of methylmercury (which is more potent) in the average can of tuna.

Posted by: isles | March 1, 2008, 9:31 am 9:31 am

the necessity for thimerosal is because of MULTI-DOSE vaccine vials. You DO NOT need any mercury if each dose of vaccine is packaged separately. So insist your doctor use individually packaged vaccines and you do not have to worry about thimerosal!
Unfortunately I do not believe this will take away all vaccine -related autism cases, because how and when vaccines are delivered is a critical key that the govt/cdc/aap/etc does not even address. In fact the thimerasol issue has made it easy to hide that giving newborns/infants monthly assaults on their STILL DEVELOPING neurological systems has far more implications for autism and other neurological disorders than the mercury itself.
We even “swallow” their arguments about how little thimerasol there is in “A” vaccine. When is the last time your newborn/infant went for a “well-visit” and ONLY got “A” (as in 1) vaccine. Our babies get multiple vaccines each time…the case recently reported said the child had received 9 vaccines in one visit.
We need to stop allowing the govt to randomly assault our babies with whatever they discover. Why do babies need to be vaccinated for sexually transmitted diseases? Why can’t this wait until the child is older….because the medical community thinks parents are too irresponsible to bring their children to the doctor….they want to bombard the babies, early, so they know it is done. This is an insult to parents.
As someone who grew up when we only had polio, smallpox and dpt shots…..everyone had measles, mumps, chicken-pox and german measles….no one in my NYC public school died from any of those illnesses and everyone had to take their turn being out for the 10-14 days it took to recuperate …..maybe that is what the govt is trying to control….sick days! :-p
It is time to make the govt rethink when babies need to be vaccinated and to limit how many are given at a time…that would lower any thimerasol exposure from multi-dose vials too….

Posted by: Elyse | March 1, 2008, 9:39 am 9:39 am

Mercury IS poison; period and here we have individuals defending the usage in products that are either injected or placed within fillings inside our mouths. Now that’s insanity. Mercury is a cumulative poison that causes kidney and brain damage which is extremely difficult for detoxification. If anyone’s ever heard of the phrase “Mad as a Hatter” it refers to the neurological damage the hat makers experienced from mercury vapors breathed in while finishing hats. It doesn’t take someone with a degree in medicine to know there is severe reactions to mercury poisoning and McCain is rightfully stating reality unlike those in this thread and in the FDA, etc. which are denying the truth and subjecting society with passing off this poison as somehow safe. Anyone in the medical community who ought to know better and still supports the usage of mercury ought to be banned from the profession because they’re dangerous.

Posted by: Dan | March 1, 2008, 9:50 am 9:50 am

Hello Elyse, when you’re commenting on a blog, it’s good manners to at least take a glance at the comments that are already there, in case your point has already been made or addressed. See my post immediately preceding yours, which negates your concerns about multiple doses of thimerosal in one day.

Posted by: isles | March 1, 2008, 9:51 am 9:51 am

John McCain and “strong evidence”. Now where have I heard that one before? Something about “weapons of mass destruction” and “al Qaeda” connections. Can someone help me out here?

Posted by: Heraldblog | March 1, 2008, 9:57 am 9:57 am

Dan, the first principle of toxicology is usually stated for brevity as “the dose makes the poison.”
Everything is “poison” in the right (wrong?) quantity. People have died from drinking too much water. The fact that mercury can be toxic doesn’t mean that enough is present in thimerosal to make an effect on health.
In fact, in one of the few known cases of ethylmercury overdose (ethylmercury is the form in thimerosal), someone attempted to commit suicide by drinking a large quantity of straight thimerosal. His blood reached an astronomical mercury concentration – and he survived with no lingering neurological deficits (other than whatever made him crazy enough to attempt suicide via thimerosal in the first place!).

Posted by: isles | March 1, 2008, 9:57 am 9:57 am

let us cut the chase – republicans are the party most in bed with big pharma – and they have allowed for years for MERCURY to be in vaccines because it saved bog pharma $0.50 per shot over a non toxic preservative. now we are supposed to be thankful to mccain because he recognizes the possible link – or does he recognize that 1 in 150 children suffer from autism and to NOW act like an adviocare of this community might just get him the votes he needs in november – please. note: this is my nice version – my from the heart version is filled with expletives. Jim K

Posted by: jim | March 1, 2008, 10:09 am 10:09 am

One more thing. Some of the comments below reference anti-vaccine organizations’ claims that the government has conceded in a court case that a vaccine caused autism in the plaintiff.
Not. The finding was that the plaintiff had experienced an aggravation in her encephalopathy accompanying a mitochondrial disorder. Some of the symptoms of mitochondrial disorders mimic autism, but they are not autism. There are many things that could have been the cause of the worsening of the encephalopathy, but since vaccines were one plausible cause, compensation was judged appropriate under the lenient guidelines of the Vaccine Injury Compensation Program. In no way was it shown that “vaccines cause autism.”

Posted by: isles | March 1, 2008, 10:12 am 10:12 am

Jim K ~ PLEASE!! You don’t think the Dems are in bed with “Big Pharma”?!? I sincerely wish people cared enough to responsibly take a look for themselves. Look up their contributions history online. It is readily accessible and easy enough to do. Just requires some initiative. Hillary was the top recipient of pharma funding, but Senator Obama recently blew by her. Go figure?!? But, they’re not in bed with “Big Pharma”. Oh no; I’m certain it is all innocent and well. Here, I’ll even help you out. Do a search for, “Drug Money: Bets on Obama, So Far,” and “The best President that Big Pharma money can buy!” Please educate yourself before making such claims!!
1’Asperge~
You’ve nothing better to do than attack someone for a typo?!? Great indication of your maturity level, for sure. Perhaps the science, research, and EVIDENCE is too complex and a bit above your head.

Posted by: oneproudMAMA | March 1, 2008, 10:50 am 10:50 am

Vaccines do NOT cause autism.
There is a scientific consensus that vaccines do not cause autism, and there is no scientific controversy surrounding vaccines and autism.
This scientific consensus is backed by a very large body of legitimate scientific research — nearly 30 studies on thimerosal as well as the MMR vaccine, which never contained thimerosal — that found no correlation (which is not even close to causality) between vaccines and autism.
The divisions and debates have nothing to do with science, they are purely political.
The likely reason why so many folks showed up here to post anti-vaccination screeds is because this story is linked in blog posts on anti-vaccination activist group web sites.
Whenever there is a news story that contains the search terms “vaccines” and “autism,” anti-vaccination activists are urged to post multiple comments in order to make it appear that there are more anti-vaccination people than there actually are.
Anti-vaccination activism is a one-percenter issue, so Mr. McCain’s remarks will likely carry very little weight one way or the other with voters.
However, isles, in the comment posted Mar 1, 2008 9:31:04 AM, made an excellent observation that should be taken into serious consideration with regard to the wider range of issues:
“I am disappointed to realize McCain lacks the sophistication to either (a) analyze a scientific question according to what science has actually found or (b) know when to consult an expert instead of relying on what some yahoo tells him. It shows a troubling lack of judgment.”
Indeed, a most troubling lack of judgment. Now, I do not expect a presidential candidate to have a scientific background, but what sort of scientific advisors does Mr. McCain employ?
Once again, vaccines do NOT cause autism.

Posted by: Margaret Romao Toigo | March 1, 2008, 10:55 am 10:55 am

The invective written is amazing. The issue is what vaccines do to the human nervous system and immune system. A newborn does not need something hyperstimulating the systems the day he/she is born. What we received in 12 years is now being injected into children over 3 years. There will be an effect. Just yesterday there were reports released of convulsions in children as a result of a combo vaccine. The hatred espoused needs to stop. If something works to help 1 child reverse the impact of something our government has mandated, leave that parent alone. If people want to inject their babies, so be it. Those who want to delay the vaccines, let them be. It is hard enough to raise children without the venom written here. I don’t want my child to have measels. But, I won’t sacrifice his future by giving him poison before he can even walk.

Posted by: margaret | March 1, 2008, 11:13 am 11:13 am

In 1999, it was recommended that mercury be removed from vaccines. We’re almost ten years later now, and it’s still there. There has been more than enough time to figure out alternative formulations. Until the government mandates it, or growing numbers of vaccine refusals force it, the mercury will continue to be there. It’s sad that we are still fighting the same fight. For those who doubt the link between vaccines and autism, do some more research. Look at the Burbacher et al study that suggests ethyl mercury (thimerosal) may be even more neurotoxic than methyl mercury at smaller doses, because it crosses the blood-brain barrier and lodges in the brain. Children who get annual flu shots based on the current recommendations would be getting 150 mcg by age 5, just from that one vaccine alone. More than enough to cause damage, not even taking into account the viral components and other toxins like aluminum and formaldehyde found in vaccines. Even the FDA’s own website denotes a schizophrenic approach; formaldehyde is designated as unsafe for internal use, yet there it is on the approved vaccine ingredient list.

Posted by: Garbo | March 1, 2008, 11:25 am 11:25 am

Thank you John McCain… You will get votes from standing up for vaccine injured kids. Parents will vote!
All the hysterical parents are saying is Green our vaccines. Look at the facts:
1983: Autism rate 1 in 10,000
Vaccine schedule 10 shots
2008: Autism rate in boys 1 in 70
Vaccine schedule 36
My sons last words:
“My name is Tanner. My name is Tanner.”
The week of his shots for school…
Show me any other campaign for disinformation as wound up as this one by the medical(vaccine maker) community. Remove the Mecury, Aluminum, formaldehyde, ether, antifreeze. Reevaluate the schedule. What was the death rate from these deadly diseases in 1983 that we had to add 26shots? If there are side effects to the vaccinations all we asking for is support for therapy, respite, and recovery.

Posted by: Tim Welsh | March 1, 2008, 11:44 am 11:44 am

I am so happy that there is candidate running that is willing to have an opinion against the medical establishment when there are controversies such as this one. I want a president who would stand up for what is right and not take the side of what is popular and good for business. Someone has to look out for people of this country, especially our future generations. What we must realize is should Thimerisol turn out to be part of the cause of autism it will not only impact the drug companies, it will impact the American Academy of Pediatrics, The American Medical Association, the CDC and anyone else that had anything to do with the vaccines and the vaccine schedule. I think that this is very scary. However, the autism epidemic is even more scary. What is going to happen when all of these children become adults? Who is going to pay for their care? The Thimerisol issue is definitely controversial and scientists are divided on this issue. As far as I am aware it is not a dead issue and that more study is needed. We cannot take statements such “there is no evidence” as an absolute truth that Thimerisol does not cause autism. It may be part of a perfect storm of multiple causes that scientists have not been able to identify yet. We also need to look at some of the other ingredients of the adjuvants such as aluminum in our vaccines that may be contributing to autism as well. Adjuvants in vaccines are used to cause an immune response. Perhaps some people’s immune systems overreact to them. Epidemiology studies can have their flaws and do not address the biochemical processes involved. Many studies that are done on vaccines only address reactions that occur soon after the vaccine is given and do not study long term effects. The vaccines may also not be studied well enough in combination with the other vaccinations that children are given at the same time. We should not have blind faith in our policy makers who are pressured from the drug companies and physicians to put a new vaccine on the market and mandate it’s use. They can only make decisions based on the evidence presented to them which is usually from the drug companies themselves. Just this past week the advisory committee made a decision to recommend flu vaccines to all children up to 18 years old because flu cases are up. The only problem with this is that the current vaccine does not contain the strains that are causing the flu this year and needs to be changed. Flu vaccines are not totally safe (and most still contain thimerisol) and we should not be recommending them just because flu cases are up and we have it available. Most children can recover from the flu without complications. The benefits must outweigh the risk. I can understand the very young and the very old needing them but I am wondering why they suddenly want the older children vaccinated. I hope they are not doing this to financially support the drug companies so that they can change the strains in the vaccine. That would be bad policy. We need to recommend vaccines because of medical need, not for economic need and availability. I think that our vaccine program needs to be shaken up a little bit and we need to do some good research with a control groups of children who do not have vaccines. That would be impossible if we mandate them for all and put parents in jail for not having their children vaccinated. The public needs to be aware of what is going on and our politicians need to get their head out of the sand. John McCain is my man! He supports more research.

Posted by: Diane | March 1, 2008, 12:01 pm 12:01 pm

For those of you who DO NOT have a child on the autism spectrum, please forgive me, but you have NO idea what it’s like to see your child disappear into an abyss after vaccines. You can say all you want about the “studies” but until you see YOUR child go from a happy, healthy, smiling 2 year old to a child who screams high pitched shrills in the middle of the night for hours, bangs his head against walls until he’s bruised, has a body full of rashes from toxins trying to get out, and wears a towel because his stools are so loose that he had feces pouring out of him non- stop and his bottom is RAW, THEN we’ll see how many “studies” you quote. This all happened to my son within a month of his shots! Within 30 days, the soul was gone from his eyes he was and he stopped answering to his name. When you watch your child go through these things, then maybe you’ll open your mind to the possibility that the toxins that are in vaccines, (antifreeze, formaldahyde, aluminum, animal DNA as well as thimerosol) are responsible for the nerological damage of these precious kids. My son is one of the lucky ones. I didn’t listen to the mainstream medicine. I took him to a biomedical specialist (DAN! doctor, defeat autism now) and for the last 3 years he has gone through treaments to detox his little body from those chemicals. I saw the test results, he dumped MERCURY and ALUMINUM out of his stools and urine through chelation. How’s that for “science”? Now that he isn’t toxic anymore, he is in regular school and on his way to kindergarten next year. Of course he is still in PT, OT, speech and social skills classes, some paid for by insurance, mostly paid for by us! The detox from the junk in the vaccines caused us much financial hardship since no insurance company will touch this “alternative” therapy. But, there was no way on this earth that I could sit back and watch my son in such pain.
I hope this gives you a look into my “science”, because I don’t trust an FDA that both researches and promotes vaccines.
Francesca, mom to Daniel

Posted by: Francesca | March 1, 2008, 12:12 pm 12:12 pm

The Vaccine Injury Court has hearings that you can listen to online and it is apparent from listening to these hearings that the evidence,science and testimony of world famous Doctors and researchers overwhelmingly support a mercury/vaccine autism connection.Listen for yourself no need to take my word for it.

Posted by: Richard | March 1, 2008, 12:52 pm 12:52 pm

So John McCain is a science expert is he? I think not – from what I know of John McCain, I wouldn’t trust him to tie his own shoelaces. Hardly a major victory for the anti-vaxers!

Posted by: Rich Scopie | March 1, 2008, 12:56 pm 12:56 pm

Thank you Mr. McCain for having the courage to question the druglords

Posted by: Earl | March 1, 2008, 1:13 pm 1:13 pm

For those that fear the “devastating” consequences of measles, Autism is much worse. How many of us got measles and went on to live productive lives? The same can’t be said for all the kids today who are autistic and many will deal (and their family) it for the rest of their lives.
McCain may not be a scientist but he may have access to knowledge and information to lead him to answer the questions the way he did.

Posted by: Debbie | March 1, 2008, 1:19 pm 1:19 pm

He also has access to records of the many soldiers who have been devastated by vaccine injury. Anthrax vax + depleted uranium found in ammunition= Gulf War Syndrome. And the rise in ALS (Lou Gehrig’s) amongst military pilots. Mercury switches in the cockpit? Who knows. Shouldn’t we find out, though?

Posted by: Garbo | March 1, 2008, 1:37 pm 1:37 pm

Dan wrote:
“Mercury IS poison; period…”
That’s either dishonest, ignorant, or both. Like sodium and chlorine, mercury’s toxicity is completely dependent upon its form. Methylmercury is incredibly toxic, while ethylmercury is nontoxic. Again, anyone trying to pretend that ethylmercury (the form in thimoseral) is the same thing as methylmercury is misinformed, lying, or both.
Elemental sodium and chlorine are both explosive and toxic to humans. Combined as ions, they are table salt.
I know it must hurt for the parents of autistic children to watch their children suffer, but that in no way justifies their complete failure to understand the toxicology of mercury. If you think there’s a huge problem, you have a MORAL duty to delve into the technical details, and I have yet to encounter an antivaccination activist who has the integrity to do so.
“… Mercury is a cumulative poison that causes kidney and brain damage which is extremely difficult for detoxification.”
No, that would be methylmercury. Ethylmercury is very different, and it is dishonest and/or ignorant for you and McBush to lump them together.
“If anyone’s ever heard of the phrase “Mad as a Hatter” it refers to the neurological damage the hat makers experienced from mercury vapors breathed in while finishing hats.”
And that damage is caused by methylmercury, not ethylmercury.
“It doesn’t take someone with a degree in medicine to know there is severe reactions to mercury poisoning.”
It doesn’t take someone with a degree in medicine to admit that there’s a huge difference between methyl- and ethylmercury in terms of toxicity, so that it is dishonest to scare people away from ethylmercury with stories about methylmercury, pretending that there’s no difference and lumping them together.
That’s just plain dishonest and immoral.
So is pretending that the presence of thimoseral remaining in a minority of vaccines somehow keeps your hypothesis alive. The amount of thimoseral to which children are exposed has been dramatically reduced, but there has been no reduction in autism diagnoses. Case closed.

Posted by: John | March 1, 2008, 1:42 pm 1:42 pm

Hello, conspiracy theorists!
As Bill Nye would say, consider the following:
1. Total thimerosal exposure for U.S. children has declined to near zero since 1999.
2. Autism is at an all-time high.
Possible conclusions:
1. Autism and thimerosal are unrelated.
2. The federal government, which can’t find its butt with both hands, has managed to orchestrate a massive conspiracy with vaccine makers to make it look like thimerosal has been removed from vaccines while still slipping it in there undisclosed, in higher and higher doses over time to match the steady rise in autism prevalence, all the while hiding this activity from insurers, who would LOVE to know what was driving all these claims for the various therapies that autistic kids get.
If you think #2 is more plausible, you may have your tinfoil hat on a little too tight.

Posted by: isles | March 1, 2008, 1:53 pm 1:53 pm

For evidence to be statistically relevant in medical studies, one has to show a near 100% increase between the (in this case) toxin group and the control group. What that means is…for there to be a clear relationship between vaccines and autism, you would need to take a random group of at least 1,000 children and not give them any vaccines. then measure autism rates. You’d then have to take another group of at least 1,000 kids and give them all the vaccines recommended. If 10 kids are diagnosed with some level of autism from the NON VACCINE group…to prove relationship without question, at least 20 kids would need to be diagnosed from the VACCINE group. To my knowledge, no relationship such as this has been proven. Until such a study is done, I’ll continue to advocate for vaccines…why? Because 100s of similar studies have been done world-wide proving relationship between childhood exposure/infection/death and NOT GETTING VACCINATED.

Posted by: Dan | March 1, 2008, 2:20 pm 2:20 pm

Are you seriously so wrapped up in your own opinions that you have forgotten the fine art of actually listening to what others say, JOHN AND ISLES? I think perhaps you need to take your superior and belittling attitude down a few notches.
I do not believe there is a conspiracy to give our children autism….get it straight. You want to negate my point by calling it “crazy” or calling moms like me “conspiracy theorists”. If you do not have the intellect to argue a point in scientific manner, don’t try. What we are saying is that our children have underlying medical conditions that predispose them to negative reactions to ANY toxins,be it preservatives in vaccines, exposure to mom’s amalgram fillings in utero, or industrial pollutants. When a child is born with a weakened immune system due to genetics or pre-natal exposure, or if a chld is born with mitochondrial disorders that are not apparent and tested for, they are at risk for vaccine reactions. Every day children are given vaccines and don’t develop autism, and every day children are given vaccines and develop autistic symptoms soon after. I find it amazing that the world’s leading doctors argue this point, but some random person on the internet thinks they know the final answer….guess we can close the case on this one folks, John and Isles have spoken!
There is science on both sides of this issue, but you want to know what made me a believer? I ACTUALLY HAVE A MERCURY POISONED CHILD!!! That’s right! I’m not just sitting around talking about something I have no first hand knowledge in. I have been chelating my son and guess what? He is starting to talk, lost many autistic symptoms, and is improving at a drastic pace. So, when you want to dismiss us all as lunatics you’re really showing how scared you are of what might be the truth for some kids. Let me ask you something…..do you have a child that needs vaccines soon? Planing on having any babies in the near future? You blow hard on this blog, but I have a feeling you’d have some second thoughts when someone wanted to stick a needle in your 1 day old child that may or may not cause them to become autistic.

Posted by: rebelmom | March 1, 2008, 2:32 pm 2:32 pm

Isn’t mercury the stuff in the new energy saving light bulbs that is going to stop global warming?

Posted by: Paul | March 1, 2008, 3:06 pm 3:06 pm

Rebelmom:
And your child has been diagnosed with what underlying condition that makes him or her unable to receive vaccines…?
Yeah, didn’t think so. There are a few known conditions that contraindicate vaccination – and it is precisely because some can’t be vaccinated that it’s so important that everyone who can be, is. To do otherwise heightens the risk for kids who are already extra-vulnerable. Mercury moms like to say their kids have “mercury efflux disorder” or somesuch, but that’s just something they and a few crackpot professors made up.
Your child would be doing what he or she is doing with or without the chelation (provided, of course, it doesn’t kill him like that boy in Pennsylvania a couple years ago). You can stop patting yourself on the back for oh-so-bravely bucking the medical establishment, and give your kid a little credit.
No need to trust some random person on the internet. Check out the Institute of Medicine, World Health Organization, American Academy of Pediatrics, etc., etc., etc., etc.

Posted by: isles | March 1, 2008, 3:08 pm 3:08 pm

The flu shot has 26 micrograms of thimerosal in one shot and they give this to children unless the child is an infant then the infant gets the special order shot that is more expensive to manufacture.
I am not a doctor just a parent who is educating before I say yes to every shot and now its up to about 30 shots in the first 2 years of life. Thats why alot of children have messed up immune systems.
The post from the nurse shows she needs to go back to school since she is not aware that the flu shot has thimersal in it and they are also a few other vacinations with trace amounts still.
McCain has a medical person on his staff doing the research.

Posted by: veronica hippensteel | March 1, 2008, 3:12 pm 3:12 pm

John — We parents are all too aware of the differences between methyl and ethyl mercury. Methyl mercury stays in the body longer than ethyl mercury, but because of its molecular configuration ethyl mercury (thimerosal) crosses the blood-brain barrier whereas methyl mercury does not. The study by Dr. Burbacher et al which I referenced below, published in the journal Environmental Health Perspectives April 2005, discovered that ethyl mercury lodges in the brain tissue, and therefore may be even more neurotoxic than methylmercury at the same or lower dosages despite the shorter time it remains in the body. Another study, found in Toxicology & Applied Pharmacology April 2005, details the fact that in comparison to methyl mercury, ethyl mercury (Thimerosal) leads to second-tier immunosuppressive effects in certain populations. So please spare me the “Ethyl mercury is perfectly safe” argument. It may be even more dangerous in general, and especially dangerous for people with certain pre-existing markers.

Posted by: Garbo | March 1, 2008, 3:23 pm 3:23 pm

a brief clarification to Isles….
your comment was not there prior to my writing mine….
and my comments were about multiple vaccines in one doctor visit as being too systemically overwhelming for an infant….the thimerasol, if it is in the vaccines, is a bonus reason to not give multiple shots in one visit.

Posted by: Elyse | March 1, 2008, 3:35 pm 3:35 pm

Again you have the smug attitude that only the ignorant indulge in.
My son was born with a condition that causes oxaltes to accumulate in his cells. He was also born with almost no glutathione production ability. He had no chance against any toxin, much less one injected into him. Funny thing, they don’t test for things like this before sticking him with the Hep B vacc a few hours after he was born.
And as for thinking my son would be getting better without chelation, well, I again refer to my comment about the indulgence of ignorance. In October of 07 I was told he needed either to be heavily medicated or put in an institution (he is 4 years old, btw). This was said to me by a prominant neurologist at UCLA. It is now March of 08 and my son is now going to be put in a regular Kindergarten class next year. He is exceeding every goal we had set for him months ahead of schedule.
Give my son credit? You petty little fool, my son gets ALL the credit!!He is a fighter, an angel, a gift from God and I am grateful every day of my life for him. My son did not ask to be put in this position, yet he faces it on a daily basis with more dignity and class than you could ever dream to have. I suppose you would be content to lock an entire generation of children in institutions instead of digging a little further into the truth.
Also, why has no one responded to my post regarding the fact that autistic children often have the same physical illnesses? Guess that one must have been too hard for you to answer, so you ignored it. I don’t have that luxury.

Posted by: rebelmom | March 1, 2008, 3:44 pm 3:44 pm

Exactly my thoughts. We have no control over the mercury polluting our water and air, but we do have control — in most states — over injecting mercury into our children. Why are people still even trying to defend this practice? It’s a no-brainer — don’t inject babies with toxic substances. It might harm them. What happened to erring on the side of safety? What happened to “first do no harm”?

Posted by: Garbo | March 1, 2008, 5:17 pm 5:17 pm

McCain is right – it may be a preservative, but it is more likely the glutamate that they add to the vaccines as a preservative for the virus than it is the mercury. Currently the newest drugs on the market for neurodegenerative diseases are all glutamate blockers, but they still add glutamate to vaccines for children. Here is how it is related to mercury: glutamate interferes with the metabolism of cysteine – which is used to make glutathione in the body. Glutathione is the body’s natural means of getting rid of mercury FROM ANY SOURCE. So, modern vaccines will REDUCE a child’s ability to handle mercury from the air, from their tuna sandwiches, from the water – from ANYWHERE. Thimerosol doesn’t even need to be IN the vaccines for a vaccinated child to be harmed by the vaccines and consequently – mercury. There is enough mercury in the environment now that simply destroying a child’s ability to naturally get rid of mercury by shooting them full of glutamate – which, BTW when injected into mice makes them obese, and destroys brain cells, may cause damage in children with certain genetic predispositions. We took MSG out of baby food but we are injecting into our kids instead.
Why on earth are we injecting babies with glutamate while we are prescribing the following glutamate blockers: Lyrica, NBQX, Memantine, Topiramate, Baclofen, Riluzole,Tramadol, Tizanodine, and even Ibuprofen to their parents and grandparents who have diseases like Alzheimer’s and A.L.S. ????? Topiramate – BTW is a glutamate blocker used to treat epilepsy – which over 20% of autistic children suffer from. Coincidence? Not when the largest genome study in the world found in February of LAST YEAR that the genes involved in autism contain the instructions for wiring the nervous system – specifically the nerve synapses for GLUTAMATE neurotransmission. And the “Experts” still don’t know what causes autism??? Please. If they told us what caused it they wouldn’t be able to soak the parents for $$$$ to treat autism. Like a closet arsonist firefighter – Big Medica is GIVING these kids autism so they can treat it later.
Kudos to Senator McCain for speaking up – the cause IS a preservative STILL IN ALL vaccines – glutamate.

Posted by: Carol Hoernlein | March 1, 2008, 7:13 pm 7:13 pm

McCains wife has a masters degree in special education and has worked with severely disabled children. (I would assume some would have autism)
“Cindy participated in pilot programs testing Movement Therapy, which is now a widely accepted standard for working with severely disabled children. After receiving her degrees from USC, she began her teaching career at Agua Fria High School in Arizona where she continued her work with disabled children.”
I’m sure McCains wife has seen children that have been vaccine injured, as a matter of fact, My sons special education teacher knew that the children that are vaccine injured have the most severe seizures she has ever seen in any of her disabled kids.

Posted by: Donna | March 1, 2008, 11:17 pm 11:17 pm

There are several facts that have been mentioned by previous posters. Some are true, some some are slanted.
Vaccinating is a core belief. We are taught all of our lives that it is the right thing to do. It is like abortion and war. People are going to have strong beliefs.
But as a society we need to examine the bigger issue. Vaccinating goes beyond Kantian and Utilitarian ethics; it is a civil rights issue.
If vaccines were 100% safe, 100% of the time, well then that would be a first for the FDA to approve.
Someone needs to figure out why despite all of the wonderful vaccines, this generation of children is the FIRST to be sicker than the predecessor in a century.
Oh, and if you truly believe that the government is up front and honest (including the GOVERNMENT FUNDED medical studies), I guess you still believe we should keep looking for Weapons of Mass Destruction.

Posted by: Concerned parent | March 1, 2008, 11:34 pm 11:34 pm

Isles
Once again I ask the question that nobody answers… Why do we need 26 more shots today than we did in 1983?
What was the infant mortality rate then vs. now?
If for once the medical establishment would give honest straight forward answers… We would all get along.
We are not anti-vaccine. We just would like some support for therapy, respite, technology and recovery.
Admitting one size fits all is not true, does not take away the effectiveness of vaccines. It actually gives parents more confidence knowing doctors are honest that some are injured but when they get injured society supports those that get hurt.
All the hysterical parents are saying is Green our vaccines. Look at the facts:
1983: Autism rate 1 in 10,000
Vaccine schedule 10 shots
2008: Autism rate in boys 1 in 70
Vaccine schedule 36
My sons last words:
“My name is Tanner. My name is Tanner.”
The week of his shots for school…
Show me any other campaign for disinformation as wound up as this one by the medical(vaccine maker) community. Remove the Mecury, Aluminum, formaldehyde, ether, antifreeze. Reevaluate the schedule. What was the death rate from these deadly diseases in 1983 that we had to add 26shots? If there are side effects to the vaccinations all we asking for is support for therapy, respite, and recovery.

Posted by: Tanner's Dad | March 2, 2008, 1:02 am 1:02 am

It’s a virtual “Best of the Anti-Vaccine Movement!” Break out the disco ball!
@ Concerned Parent:
Here’s how it works. Not everyone can be or will be vaccinated. Some children have medical contraindications. Others have parents too disorganized or too sucked-in by the anti-vaccine movement to protect them via vaccination. Still others will be in the small percentage who do not become immune from a vaccination. (All vaccine experts readily admit this is true.) People in these categories need everyone around them to be immunized so that vaccine-preventable diseases can’t circulate in the community and reach them.
My concern is not solely or even primarily for the safety of myself or anyone in my family. I think of others. I wish anti-vaccine activists would do the same.
@ Rebelmom:
So you’re not contesting the fact that autism has nothing to do with oxalates and your little hypothesis about the causation of your son’s autism is just something you and your mercury mom friends made up. Now we’re getting somewhere!
On the subject of PubMed, I’m not sure if you’re suggesting that medical researchers ought to go back to the days of card catalogs or what. How odd.
Aluminum is an adjuvant (not a preservative) which is safe at the levels used in vaccines. (Ever eat anything made with baking powder? Uh oh!) Formaldehyde is present in trace trace amounts in vaccines, much less than the amount the human body naturally produces every day. (Oh, but it sounded so scary!) Ether is not a vaccine ingredient. Ethylmercury (mercury moms never make the important distinction between the different forms of mercury) is safe in the tiny amounts used in vaccines.
My offer to answer your questions was in reference to your objecting to my general advice to see the web sites of organizations like the American Academy of Pediatrics or the World Health Organization for more information. It was not an offer to share personal information which would be irrelevant to the scientific issue at hand. If you are proposing that being a mercury mom makes one a more authoritative analyst of the science, I would chucklingly beg to differ.
I am still waiting for that evidence that autism is associated with gut dysbiosis, yeast infections, bacterial infections, viral infections, heavy metal toxicity, and mitochondrial disorders. (This would need to be in the form of randomized cohort or case-control studies.) So you used some direct-to-consumer lab to give you some test results – do you know how inaccurate and misleading those places are? And that an anecdote is not the same as data?
It is common for mercury moms to say their kids got better after they started using alt-med treatments. Of course they want to see improvement. They paid good money for those pills and lotions and don’t want to think it was wasted! It’s getting tiresome, but I’ll say it again: Correlation does not equal causation.
Finally, your biggest blooper: The recent Vaccine Court case which was removed from the Autism Omnibus was removed precisely *because* the finding was that the injury in that case was NOT autism. It was an encephalopathy which may have been aggravated by a vaccine (but could have been aggravated by any fever-producing illness or just by the natural course of the condition; it’s only because of the generous nature of the Vaccine Injury Compensation Program that they give out money on a “just in case” basis). The child in question did become autistic eventually, but the fact that her encephalopathy and her autism shared some characteristics did not mean that vaccination was causally related to her autism.
If you feel like this isn’t enough answers for you, just keep on asking. I’ll be around.

Posted by: isles | March 2, 2008, 9:48 am 9:48 am

Thanks for blogging this Jake.
Most everyone else seems strangely silent on McCain’s comments.

Posted by: anna | March 2, 2008, 10:21 am 10:21 am

Give praise to John McCain for his courage in speaking out. Myself and the autism community are so grateful for his intelligence and honesty. There is science on our side. the only problem is that the media won’t report it because their hands are tied by the drug companies and the government’s desire not to bring the truth in the open.

Posted by: mogrammy | March 2, 2008, 10:22 am 10:22 am

Yep, mogrammy, it’s that durned media-government-industry conspiracy of silence again! Never mind that there’d be a Pulitzer waiting for any reporter who could show that it existed!

Posted by: isles | March 2, 2008, 10:30 am 10:30 am

Can we stop and look at the question that was asked of McCain that started this discussion?
The mom asked him about revelation this week that the US Government conceded that vaccines triggered “Eve’s” autism in the first autism case to be decided (of the 5000) in the vaccine court. This little AUTISTIC girl will now be paid damages from the VACCINE Injury Compensation Fund.
The case was supposed to go to a hearing in May, but the Government just admitted that her injury was caused by her vaccines and paid her with out even going to trial!
Yet over and over we keep hearing that there is no link between vaccines and Autism???
She was a normally developing child, was vaccinated and then regressed into autism.
THE GOVERNMENT HAS JUST ADMITTED THAT THERE WAS A BIG FAT CAUSAL LINK FOR THIS LITTLE GIRL!!!
And this is only the first of the 5000 cases to get a decision.
This is huge freaking news, and not one major news organization in the US (beyond the cursory mention of this mom’s question in this article) has reported on it since it was revealed this past week. Talk about burying the lead!
So how many of these 5000 cases are going to have to be decided in favor of the autistic plaintiffs before the main stream will start saying that there is a link between vaccines and autism.
One should be enough.

Posted by: Ginger Taylor | March 2, 2008, 10:49 am 10:49 am

Isle(s) of Wrong,
Can you point is in the direction of all the un-vaccinated Omish children with Autsim. I’d like to meet just one.
BR,
Steve

Posted by: Steve, Md | March 2, 2008, 10:54 am 10:54 am

If we only gave 1 vaccine at a time with 1 month between shots it would take 6 years with the current required vaccines and somebody thinks that 34 vaccines in 12 months/ starting on the day you are born is safe and does no harm?????we put all these viruses into babies less than 10 to 30 lbs.!!!!this is many to soon.

Posted by: grandmom of 5 | March 2, 2008, 11:09 am 11:09 am

The point is being missed! Even if the Mercury is no longer in vac’s parents can req that thier child receive non mercury based inmunizations and to have them spred out. what I want is redemption for our children that did receive mercury based imunizations and the damage has already been don. If parents relized they can request this then thare should be no fear of children not getting vacsinated. This is an excuse to not admit what they have done wrong. Using our childrn like ginnie pigs whith out our permission just in case we go to war. Well now our children have Autism becouse these kidos can not pass certain toxins. Its in the long run going to
cost the system even more. Not to mention the families heart break and to top it off insurance will not cover any of the dier treatment these kidos need to be succesful. These children are intelagiant beyond belief and are trapped in these shells of a body unable to express whats realy going on in thier heads. Imagine you had a stroke and could complettly hear and think for your self but could not speek and express you littlest needs how trapped you would feel! This is torture and abusive. And the government is the abuser and should be punnished! Shame on you!

Posted by: Jennifer Meyer | March 2, 2008, 11:39 am 11:39 am

Those who have not had it happen to their child are probably going to remain as the man rocking on his porch, petting his dogs. He hears the wolves off in the distance and thinks he has nothing to worry about. He goes inside and goes to sleep, only to wake up and find that his dogs have been torn apart by the wolves and they are coming in to get him next. But by that time, it will be too late to help.
I walked into a doctor’s office on 03/07/01 with a perfectly healthy child and vehemently stated that my child was not to get thimerosal containing vaccines. They lied, gave them to him anyway.
I walked out with a child who could no longer talk, sufferred excruciating abdominal pain, and has ever since had a damged immune system. He suffers from chronic lung problems, ASD, OCD, SID, and APD.
All of this because of the greater good?
I think not. I think it is profit driven, and we have a society now where their profit means more than our children.
You think we can eradicate disease? How stupid! Basic biology teahces us that life will always find a way –and tht includes bacteria and viruses. If we do not strengthen our immune systems by catching and surviving these more minor illnesses (benign compared to some really bad things out there), then our immune systems will not be preprared to handle them. Vaccinating against things like chilcken pox is positively assinine and due to nothing more than profit.
This has happened because we didn’t think to put the same checks and balances betwenn the government and medicine and medicine and pharmacology that we put between the branches of government.
They are afraid that vaccination rates will get too low? I don’t even put it past THEM to CAUSE the next epidemic. –they will do anything to deny what they have done, and to protect the profit projections.
WE are learning our lesson regarding the overuse of antibiotics. How long will it takes for them to admit the fallout due to the overuse of vaccines?
When will enough be enough? Now it’s thirty-six vaccines. When will they stop? AT fifty? At 100?
I say let them make their vaccines, but I think it it an inherent civil right to decline vaccines in the absence of a clear and present danger. (But then again they would create the danger), so I thnk it shoudl be a consitutional right to decline. I certainly view it as cruel and unusual punishment.
I read the scare tactic in the article about the boy who died after contracitng measles. Did ihe actually die of the measles? Was his immune system all ready comprimised before contracting the measles? They leave off vital information in order to invoke fear. He probably had AIDS or cancer to begin wtih. –not to dtract from that chld’s loss or his parents’ grief, but I think throwing away 1 out of 150 children to ASD becasue one child could catch such and such and die. This is not the purpose of governemnt. This is the parents decision and should remain such.
I sat by my brother’s bedside when he had the measles and I never caught it. i shred a room with my sister who caught the mumps. I never caught that.
I had the flu about four times in my life. It was no fun, but I survived.
I finally took a flu shot in 1987 and a few short hours later I was admitted to an emergency room. I nearly died. I won’t ever take a vaccine again and regret that I allowed them to vaccinate my son.
Here’s fear for you: one out of eighty infant boys who get fully vaccianted today on the present childhood schedule will wind up with an ASD disorder. This will be due to the synergistic effects beteent he mercury that still exists, the aluminum and the synergy that occurs when so many vaccines are given at the same time and combination vaccines that are given. As long as the “wolves” devour someone else’s children, they don’t care.
Also I am so sick of hearing that “they took thimerosal out.” They never ordered a recall of thimerosal- containing vaccines and there are plenty still out there.
My son got them AFTER they said it was out.
Also, thimerosal is still in some vaccines. I’m not concerned about the thimerosal, per se. I am concerned witht the mercury therein.
All vaccines that are not live virus vaccines are still MADE USING THIMEROSAL. They are telling the public that they then extract it out. Mercury binds to protein. All vacicnes use some form of animal protein. Therefore, the mercury binds to the protein, and it would be next to impossible to get it out. So, they get to dupe the public and say, “Hey kids are still winding up with autism and we took it out.”
I’m not falling for it. My son was diagnosed with “Heavy Metal Intoxication” at a major metropolitan children’s hospital. It was all very hush hush as this hospital has it’s lips so connected to the butt of the pharmeceutical industry. They wanted me to secretly let them admit my son and begin chelation. It was evident to me they didn’t know what the hell they were doing.
The lead pediatric neurologist said to my husband and me, “Gee, I’m sorry, but you’ve just got to understand, by mass vaccianting we are saving so many, but there are going o be losses. Your child is one of them and you just need to go home and accept it.”
What a load of crap is that?
Then after listening to them telling us how it’s hopeless and he will never talk, or be potty trained etc… We did what DR. Amy HOlmes told us to do, and I am happy to report he talks and is potty trained. But his immune system is still screwed up! His body chemistry is still screwed up!
Genetic? There is not autism in either of our families.
I walked into that doctor’s office with a perfectly healthy child. Four vaccines later I have a child who is chrocially ill and has been for the last six and half years! And they think they will EVER convince me it was mere coincidence?
I will NEVER stop warning parents about this. It is time for mandates to end, and we need the checks and balances between the drug companies, the FDA, and the CDC.
It needs to become illegal for doctors to recieve any perks from drug reps, and prescription advertising on television needs to be banned as it is in most other countries (Has New Zealand banned it yet?)
Sincerely,
One Mad Mom

Posted by: Rene | March 2, 2008, 11:48 am 11:48 am

Seriously, WHY THE RISE IN AUTISM?!
In the 60′s it was like 1 in 4,000, in the 80′s 1 in 2,000, in 1997 it was 1 in 600.
NOW it is 1 in 150! (per the US national average number from CDC) And depending on the US state your from it could be much higher like here in Oregon it is 1 in 88!
I don’t think anyone is really going to get off their butts and put “two + two” together until the numbers reach 1 in 10! And that’s the sad part of it all.
From the CDC web site:
Mercury and Vaccines (Thimerosal)
Thimerosal is a mercury-containing preservative used in some vaccines and other products since the 1930s. There is no convincing scientific evidence of harm caused by the low doses of thimerosal in vaccines, except for minor reactions like redness and swelling at the injection site. However, in July 1999, the Public Health Service agencies, the American Academy of Pediatrics, and vaccine manufacturers agreed that thimerosal should be reduced or eliminated in vaccines as a precautionary measure.
Since 2001, with the exception of some influenza (flu) vaccines, thimerosal is not used as a preservative in routinely recommended childhood vaccines.
source:
**Speaking of Flu Vaccine,read this bit of news**
In the 2009 vaccine recommendation, the CDC’s Advisory Committee for Immunization Practices (ACIP) is pushing for MANDATORY flu vaccine for children and teens. To keep parental choice in flu vaccine write today to:
Dr. Larry Pickering
Senior Advisor
NCIRD/CDC
and by email:
Also contact your Senators and Congressmen to keep parental choice in the flu vaccines!
ENOUGH IS ENOUGH!!!
How WE learned about Autism called:
You’re Not Alone

Posted by: Cindy | March 2, 2008, 11:56 am 11:56 am

Thimerosal was only RECOMMENDED to be removed in 1999. There was no mandatory recall. Manufacturers finally got around to “phasing it out” (reducing the levels to “trace amounts”) in 2001. The thimerosal containing vaccines in clinics didn’t expire until 2003-2004, and many clinics across the country continued to use these vaccines. In 2004, the flu chot was recommended for pregnant women and children 6 months and older, with 25 mcg of mercury.
Pregnant women and children continue to be poisoned to this day. I am so sick of reading and seeing reports that thimerosal has been out of vaccines for years. This is a lie. Go to the FDA website and see for yourselves.

Posted by: Heather K | March 2, 2008, 12:28 pm 12:28 pm

I have read every comment on this thread and I am sad to see that so many people are attacking parents of autistic children.
For a long time I personally didn’t believe in the autism/vaccine link. I thought a lot of people were spouting crazy conspiracy theories.
Then my daughter was diagnosed with Autism. I don’t know if her autism was caused by a vaccine or not because she was showing some autistic traits from early on. She wasn’t one who developed normally for 18 months and all of a sudden totally regress. I don’t know how it would feel to see my typical child suddenly transform into a whole other child overnight. I can imagine how horrific it would be though.
Because of my daughters autism, I have come into contact with COUNTLESS parents who had typical children until a certain vaccine was administered. They swear up and down that their children where healthy, happy, talkative, playful, loving, and fun. Then that all changed–literally overnight. All these parents say the change happened within days of certain vaccines.
All you have to do is meet these people, talk to them, meet their children and you will know that they are telling the truth about the sudden transformation that occurred in their children. These people aren’t crazy. These people aren’t ignorant. These people are normal, educated parents that lost their normal, healthy children to a hideous epidemic.
Yes, there is a genetic link. But there is something else, something that is pushing normal, typical children over the edge into the abyss of autism. These children may just have a predisposition for autism but perhaps autism wouldn’t have manifested itself if something hadn’t compromised their systems, opening the floodgate.
I tend to believe that whatever it is, is in the vaccines (whether it be mercury or something else) or other environmental toxins. Heck, possibly both.
I guess what I am trying to say is, unless you’ve lost a child to this horrible epidemic, you cannot possibly know how it feels. Until you’ve spent time with these people and their children–actually heard their stories and seen proof that their child WAS developing typically until a vaccine was administered–you have no room to be judging them and calling them crazy conspiracy theorists.
These parents saw the transformation in their children FIRST HAND! Give them a break! You think RIPPING these people to shreds over the internet will change what they witnessed? All of a sudden their stories will change because YOU say they are crazy and have NO IDEA what they are talking about?
Until you’ve lost your typical child autism, you have no room to be bullying these parents around.

Posted by: Penny | March 2, 2008, 1:02 pm 1:02 pm

Once upon a time, the tobacco companies said that smoking didn’t cause cancer and everyone believed them. They had all kinds of scientific studies performed by their own scientists to back themselves up, and they were able to use their power and money to suppress evidence to the contrary. Until one day the evidence was just too overwhelming — it was too clear — and now everyone knows and accepts that smoking causes cancer. And we know that the tobacco companies actually knew that all along. They lied to protect their profits.
We are now in that same place with autism and vaccines. There are now too many diseased children to effectively ignore any longer. The truth is starting to come out, the dam is starting to break, and once the flood happens people are going to be walking around saying, “oh, of course there’s a link between vaccines and autism, everyone knows that!”
People like to call autism parents crazy, but really it’s like Plato’s allegory of the cave: We’ve escaped the cave and seen the light and the truth of the world, but how do you explain sunshine and trees to people who’ve only ever lived in shadows chained to the wall of a cave? They’re not evolved enough to understand, they can only repeat what they’ve been told. It’s not their fault.

Posted by: Garbo | March 2, 2008, 1:55 pm 1:55 pm

Mercury has not been removed. My son received mercury in the womb with my flu shot, then his infant flu shots, my fillings, my seafood consumption, and pollution. Aside from this there is much more to be addressed with vaccine safety. I’m concerned with aluminum, nd live virus. AND I’m deeply concerned that we do not have knowledge of the TH1 TH2 balance of the immune system.
I’m not antivaccine, but I am pro safety and this has not been demonstated.
Mercury should not get the spot light. Even if a vaccine was toxin free. We need thorough studies of safety determining how an immature immune system is responding. Our children are individuals and we need to develop safer schedules based on individuality.
Pediatricians need to have basic understanding of how the body works. It is not acceptable to me that my son was constipated up to 10 days and when I asked my pediatrician in the 4th largest city in the US, I was told he’ll move when he’s ready.
To have to work this hard to hold my family together and save my son is ridiculous when you consider the true breakdown that is happening.
A child who is not eliminating properly clearly should be red flagged before we continue to insult their system.
I’m sick of the lies. Our children are at risk. We need to demand studies for all of our children with chronic ear infections, asthma,allergies, obesity, diabetes, learning problems, autism, and adhd. Problems we barely heard of when I was growing up.
Shannon Ruhe

Posted by: Shannon Ruhe | March 2, 2008, 1:56 pm 1:56 pm

Amen, sistah! My son had the same symptoms (I’m sure I don’t have to relate the gory details) and our pediatrician in a blue-chip Beverly Hills practice told us to give him prune juice. Never suggested a single test to see if there might be some kind of problem. First visit to a DAN! doctor tests were done and it turned out he had ZERO good bacteria in his gut; they had all been killed off by antibiotics for an ear infection at 4 months. Thus began the cascade to autism. 4 years later, we are nearly recovered. Anyone reading this recognize symptoms in your child? Stop vaccinating now, and get yourself to a DAN doctor pronto.

Posted by: Garbo | March 2, 2008, 2:11 pm 2:11 pm

To Isles-
Obviously you are pro-vaccine and pro-thimerosal. You do not use your real name and try your best to use sarcasm, smugness and arrogance to counter parental concerns. You are really a coward and maybe well paid to spend so much time and effort hanging on this blog trying to muddy the waters. Try as you might, science and honesty will win. Your attempts here are almost becoming comical.
Teresa
Chicago

Posted by: Teresa Conrick | March 2, 2008, 2:38 pm 2:38 pm

Isles — why the venom? How exactly does it hurt you that people want to make sure the vaccines their children get are safe? Do you work in sales for a Pharma company? As to thimerosal being safe, guess again. Even when it was first put in use in the 1930s, there were warnings. And if you’d bother to look at the studies I cited below (Burbacher et al, in the journal Environmental Health Perspectives 2005 August; Toxicology & Applied Pharmacology 2005 April) you would see that there is ample evidence that Thimerosal is harmful, may be even more neurotoxic than methyl mercury because of its molecular configuration, and leads to secondary immunosuppressive effects like those evinced in autism.
It’s stunning to me that people can go into a tizzy over lead paint on toys but sit idly by as mercury, which is even more toxic, is routinely injected into babies.

Posted by: Garbo | March 2, 2008, 2:41 pm 2:41 pm

Simply google ‘thimerosal content vaccines fda’ and you will find the FDA website which shows that flu vaccines, now advised by doctors for pregnant women and babies, contain twenty five micrograms of thimerosal (which is half mercury). This is the same toxic level of mercury that pushed a generation of children into autism. Only a little more effort will reveal that the vast majority of flu shots contain this ingredient at toxic levels. This is nothing less than genocide.

Posted by: Robin Nemeth | March 2, 2008, 2:51 pm 2:51 pm

@Isles,
Contrary to what you may believe, the only documented Amish study of Autism that I’ve come across revealed that there were only 3 cases of Autism in an Amish community that should have had as many as 200 cases statistically at the time. The first was a girl brought over from China, adopted by one family only to be given up after becoming overwhelmed by her autism. The second child had received a vaccination and developed autism shortly thereafter. The vaccination status of the third child wasn’t attainable at the time of the study. Neither case was born to an Amish couple. I find this study of the opposite affect astonishing to say the least. After reading a number of your responses to this news article, your ignorance on this whole subject precedes you.
BR,
Steve

Posted by: Steve, Md | March 2, 2008, 4:17 pm 4:17 pm

<<<<<<<<>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
WHY IS THIS ARTICLE NOT FRONT PAGE NEWS?
It has been around the world a couple
times on blog after blog but no major
news agency has picked it up… WHY NOT?
Talk to your producers… You deserve an Emmy Oscar and Nobel Prize if this is the truth.
Reason 1… McCain takes Anti-Establishment stance????
Reason 2 Gov. concedes case and covers it up… THIS IS THIS CENTURIES WATERGATE!!!!!
PLEASE SOMEONE ANSWER MY QUESTIONS!!!!!

Posted by: Tim Welsh | March 2, 2008, 6:15 pm 6:15 pm

Don’t be fooled by McCain’s efforts to win your votes! McCain, Huckabee, Obama, & Clinton are all members of the Council on Foreign Relations, which wants a one world govt – a vote for any of these candidates is a vote for Bush! RON PAUL IS THE ONLY PRESIDENTIAL CANDIDATE WHO IS NOT CFR. RON PAUL is an OBGYN, who is HOLISTIC, who’s been in CONGRESS for 10 TERMS representing Texans, who LOVE him! PAUL OPPOSES MANDATORY VAX legislation. Become a delegate to the National Republican Convention to cast your vote for the Love of America, for Freedom – Vote PRINCIPLE over party – VOTE FOR RON PAUL! Restore America to its founding Constitutional Principles!
h ttp://www.cfr.org/
h ttp://www.ronpaul2008.com/
h ttp://www.ronpaul2008.com/issues/health-freedom/
h ttp://www.rpv.org/?q=faq
h ttp://www.gopconvention2008.com/Default.aspx
h ttp://www.constitutioncenter.org/

Posted by: LoveFreedom | March 2, 2008, 8:38 pm 8:38 pm

GO, JOHNNY, GO!!

Posted by: oneproudMAMA | March 2, 2008, 8:56 pm 8:56 pm

I hear he’s also pretty suspicious about this whole rural electrification project. Causes brain tumors.

Posted by: Sam Nelson | March 3, 2008, 12:29 pm 12:29 pm

I think you should check again. Many vaccines have DECREASED but not eliminated thimerosol. They have also increased other metals, which may increase the overall effect, not decrease it. Some common vaccines, such as the flu vaccine currently being pushed, still have quite a lot of mercury.

Posted by: MS | March 3, 2008, 2:27 pm 2:27 pm

To those who insist that vaccines have not, are not and will no be linked in any way to ASD. That hundreds upon hundreds of stories about children regressing into autism, or developing other autoinmune disorders shortly after a round of vaccination are just the product of fertile imaginations. That thimerosal was taken out of the vaccines in 2001. That the CDC, AAP and FDA have no other interest than the health of our kids. That they are and always will be transparent. That they are not financially supported by vaccine makers. That they have no ties whatsoever with the pharmaceutical industry. That every study ever published discrediting the link between thimerosal or the MMR jab with autism has been unbiased, not manipulated, flawless, definitive, and that the researchers and authors of these studies never had or have any special interests, never received any funding or had any link with the CDC or pharmaceutical companies, and that they were never related in any way shape or form with the pharmaceutical industry. That the media is fair and balanced in reporting both sides of the story; that they do their homework before they report anything, and that they do not respond to any special interests. That every parent who tries to do “unproven” alternative therapies is an irresponsible whacko even if the kids get better. If the kids get better this way is probably just the natural progression of their autism, or they were never in the spectrum in the first place. That every parent should only try ST, OT or ABA with their kids as if these therapies were free, affordable, or even accesible to everyone.
I cannot force everyone to be objective and really do their homework, as I’m sure I don’t have the time to do it for them.
As Kim Staglano puts it “you cannot expect 100% of the vaccines to be 100% safe, 100% of the time to 100% of the children” Yet the CDC thinks so.
My son was diagnosed with PDD-NOS last a year ago, and he is the only peer reviewed double blind placebo controlled study that I need.
No developmental pediatrician, neurologist, psychologist or therapists have been able to explain to me why his metabolism is so messed up, or why he suffers frequent episodes of unexplained diarrhea, or why he has yeast and atypical bacteria overgrowth in his GI tract, or why he suffers from colitis, or why he is proven mercury and lead toxic. Furthermore, they have not been able to explain why so many kids in the spectrum have similar clinical problems as my son does, or why my son’s behaviors and symptoms have markedly improved with “voodoo” therapies, and treating his clinical issues.
If thimerosal was removed in 2001 one , then why in feb. 2007 we found thimerosal in 3 out of 4 vaccines that my then 4 months old daughter was going to receive just to have her ears pierced (I still have the vaccine inserts, and by the way this happened in Houston, TX and not in Uganda or wherever).
I read somewhere that you “don’t need a study to know that sh.. stinks”, I guess if enough people can agre on that, then thousands of anecdotal stories cannot or should not be ignored and considered worthless.
Also, I don’t want to say that the CDC or the AAP are corrupted and are profoundly interested in protecting their contributors and sources of funding (If I’m just making this up, just go their web pages and find out for yourselves), yet no one who has in all honestly reviewed the famous Denmark studies (form the statistical flaws to the researchers involved, as well as to the funding sources and vested interests), or the manipulation given to the original Verstraten data presented at Simpsonwood could in their right mind say that institutions like the above mentioned are transparent, and that they only have our children best interests in mind. The IOM, and the FDA are also just eating from the same plate.
The ignorance, or better said, lack of information that the mainstream medical community has is due in large part to their trust of the official federal institutions that I refered to. Your son/daughter pediatrician cannot be directly blamed for not knowing, but for not researching.
A study is published today (reputable or not)that allegedly destroys the thimerosal or MMR theories as causes of autism, and for the next three weeks you will find it on the web, in newspapers, television news, radio, magazines, and every form of media ever created. If such study (reputable or not) supported the idea that thimerosal or the MMR is related to autism causation you will be lucky if you get to read about it in the classifieds section of a God forsaken newspaper. And the scientific evidence that supports a connection is vast. For starters it is universally known that if I was mass murderer I would inject my victims with mercury. It wouldn’t take much to kill them, and only very minimal dosis would cause serious neurological damage. It is toxic and that is a fact
Apparently everybody has an agenda, and the parents are left to find answers on their own.
Unfortunatelly the answers that thousands of parents have found on their own are against everything that is oficially being fed to the masses. Therefore, we can only swim against the current, and work relentlessly with our kids and to see them improve day in and day out with forbidden therapies and traditional therapies as well, and in some cases even recover. All on our own.

Posted by: Francisco | March 3, 2008, 2:54 pm 2:54 pm

I am an Anti-vaccine mom, however I am for informed choice. I am not a McCain fan at all. I encourage people to look at all sides. Many people speaking here only see one side. It is the others that have done the research ( on both sides) for themselves that know the differences.
Consider the motives and motivation from both sides of the issue. The common thread is that each side wants to protect the health of our children. The mainstream side is not even entertaining the thought that the vaccines and amount we give our children is an issue. This is a grave mistake. Our doctors and government steer the way the CDC and other organizations tell them with out a second thought. The problem is that vaccines have become a big business and like all big businesses they want to increase profits. How do they do that? They make more vaccines and create an ambush of a vaccination schedule that is highly toxic and damages the immune system, and from birth begins antibiotic resistance.
The FDA and CDC are corrupt and getting hand outs from Big Pharma. Some that work at the CDC use to work for Big Pharma. It’s not about getting rid if diseases, most of them are already gone. It’s about increasing profits. We need to first, DO NO HARM.
You can check out some informative links at
The facts speak for themselves.

Posted by: sunshine | March 3, 2008, 3:16 pm 3:16 pm

John McCain just lost this physician’s vote for good.

Posted by: Mike | March 3, 2008, 7:38 pm 7:38 pm

Sorry, but why does anyone care what McCain has to say about this? It’s not like the President writes for medical journals. So people say he’s wrong. And?
You think he won’t have more pressing issues to contend with as President of the United States and Commander in Chief?
Do you all really want the President to get involved in stuff like this, regardless of his or her point of view?
This is beyond silly.
As a side note, some of y’all are being incredibly disrespectful toward the families of children with autism. Furthermore, people aren’t going to be “scared” out of vaccinating their children because John McCain said this–it’s NOT like it’s the first time someone has said there could be a link. I’ve heard about it for years, but I still got vaccinations for my daughter and she’s fine. That’s not the case with everyone, though, and they deserve to try to find out the cause of their childrens’ autism.
I can’t believe how irrational some people are because he said this, especially Mike at 7:38pm. I suspect McCain never had his vote to begin with. As a physician, you should know the President isn’t going to ban vaccinations (or whatever you’re imagining). Good grief.

Posted by: Beth | March 3, 2008, 8:03 pm 8:03 pm

There is NO, NO, No evidence of a link between autism and mercury and/or vaccines.

Posted by: Jose | March 3, 2008, 8:52 pm 8:52 pm

Follow the Money’
Research follows the money,
Goverment follows the money,
Academia follows the money.
There’s no money for research to prove the point.

Posted by: Dr Jim | March 3, 2008, 8:56 pm 8:56 pm

Though there is no doubt in my own mind that any mercury whatsoever is unhealthful to a growing human child, I admit that I do not know if thimerosol or mercury is at the root of autism. It could very well be that the vaccines themselves are completely toxic and harmful to some individuals and could very well be what is causing autism in so many. Now that the vaccination schedule is up to 36 various shots per child, God only knows which of the vaccines could be causing it. But quite obviously, it is most indeed seeming to have something to do with the vaccines.
Modern man has decided that 36 freaking various childhood vaccinations are necessary to protect our children from ever feeling ill or ever possibly dying young?
Has our society completely devolved into a bunch of neurotically spasmodically paranoid delusionals?

Posted by: Michael | March 3, 2008, 9:05 pm 9:05 pm

This Autistic will most certainly not be voting for McCain. Rest assured, you have lost the vast majority of the adult Autistic vote.

Posted by: NL | March 4, 2008, 6:15 am 6:15 am

That John McCain has joined the fray of psuedoscience experts is not so surprising. It does, however, raise the danger level of what has become an extremely frightening trend of misunderstanding the scientific concept of “evidence”. The evidence is overwhelming that thimerosal does not cause autism, and that the MMR vaccine (which never contained thimerosal) does not cause autism. Of course, science can never “prove” a negative, which is another concept the public does not understand. There is no scientific controversy about this subject. Only a media-enabled fear-spreading campaign to scapegoat vaccines yet again. The public needs to be reminded about the devastating nature of the diseases we prevent through immunizations. More importantly, we need to bring science to the forefront of our educational system, to prevent us from slipping even further back into the dark ages.

Posted by: John Snyder, M.D. | March 4, 2008, 9:24 am 9:24 am

1.) Touching personal stories from parents dealing with autistic children do not constitute scientific evidence of a casual link between autism and ethylmercury. Correlation does not mean causation.
2.) There are different types of mercury. Ethylmercury is one of the metabolites of thiomersal; it is not the same compound as Methylmercury, which is a toxin. Lumping the two together is like saying carbon dioxide and carbon monoxide are both carbon oxides and are equally dangerous to humans.
3.) The idea of a conspiracy of thousands of doctors and scientists and drug company executives many of which are parents themselves is an extraordinary claim, and it should be backed up with extraordinary evidence, not vague insinuations. If anyone has copies of e-mails, power-points, memos, documents, or whitewater type recordings that provide such evidence, I would love to see them.

Posted by: James | March 4, 2008, 10:30 am 10:30 am

Why is it so much to ask for two things…
1)Support and help for our kids
2)A non-biased study comparing the vaccinated population to a non-vacinated population.
???????????????????????????????????
Why do you need “copies of e-mails, power-points, memos, documents, or whitewater type recordings that provide such evidence”
All the hysterical parents are saying is Green our vaccines. Look at the facts:
1983: Autism rate 1 in 10,000
Vaccine schedule 10 shots
2008: Autism rate in boys 1 in 70
Vaccine schedule 36
My sons last words:
“My name is Tanner. My name is Tanner.”
The week of his shots for school…
Show me any other campaign for disinformation as wound up as this one by the medical(vaccine maker) community. Remove the Mecury, Aluminum, formaldehyde, ether, antifreeze. Reevaluate the schedule. What was the death rate from these deadly diseases in 1983 that we had to add 26shots? If there are side effects to the vaccinations all we asking for is support for therapy, respite, and recovery.

Posted by: Tim Welsh | March 4, 2008, 11:13 am 11:13 am

To the person who said that vaccines have decreased but not eliminated thimerosol: Perhaps you should check your facts, as you are almost 100% wrong. The FACTS are that NO childhood vaccine has contained thimerosol since 2001, with the exception of some (but not all) flu vaccines. We need to be careful about spreading this kind of misinformation as there IS evidence from other countries showing that people stop giving children vaccines when they believe vaccines are not safe…and what happens? Outbreaks of disease where thousands of children sicken and many are permanently disabled or killed. It may seem that we are getting paranoid about kids ever getting sick, but that is only the view of people who were not alive to see how many children died every year from measles, diphtheria and other diseases. My heart goes out to parents of children with autism…but it also goes out to the parents whose children have died of the flu or who have lost their hands and feet to meningitis and are permanently disabled. There is good evidence that NOT giving vaccines causes children immense harm…so why are so many people trying to scare parents with misinformation?

Posted by: Megan | March 4, 2008, 4:33 pm 4:33 pm

You’re right that we need to be careful about spreading misinformation, but wrong about your facts. 80% of the flu vaccine in this country still contains full-dose of mercury, and the CDC has expanded the flu vaccine recommendations significantly, despite the fact that this year’s vaccine doesn’t protect against the flu. Kids who start getting flu shots at 6 month will get 85 mcg by age 5, more than enough to cause harm just from flu vax alone. Most other vaccines still contain “trace” amounts of mercury which are only measured by the pharmaceutical companies, not the FDA, because mercury’s removal was “recommended” but never mandated. In many vaccines, the thimerosal has been replaced by aluminum, which is equally neurotoxic. If parents are afraid of vaccines’ safety, blame the CDC for never doing the proper studies to prove safety. No study comparing vaccinated with unvaccinated populations. No study to prove safety of different virus-containing vaccinations in combination. No study of the neurotoxic effects of the combined vaccine schedule. Don’t blame the parents who are trying to protect their children from harm. Blame the CDC, FDA and Pharma for putting profits ahead of safety.

Posted by: Garbo | March 4, 2008, 4:45 pm 4:45 pm

There have been good studies looking at incidence of autism in populations identical other than one group with full vaccines and one group with no vaccines and incidence of autism is identical in each. temporal association does not indicate causation. Incidence of autism is 4-6 per thousand in both groups. There may be slight increase in past few decades but there are numerous other possible explanations. Don’t forget how bad these diseases are and the “adverse effects” of the illness prevented by the vaccines.

Posted by: Jesse Parr | March 4, 2008, 5:41 pm 5:41 pm

Tim,
I fully support our kids against credible threats to their health and safety such as the diseases we vaccinate them against. The fact that autism rates have increased and the number of vaccines given to child is correlation, and it does not prove a casual relationship between the two.
There have been studies done on vaccines and autism, and the burden of proof is on you to prove they are biased. Here’s an alternative hypothesis why autism rates have increased: the consensus of what symptoms indicate autism have changed over the past 25 years and now more children are labeled autistic than would have been before.

Posted by: James | March 4, 2008, 8:21 pm 8:21 pm

Senator McCain lost my vote with such irresponsible and unscientific comments on vaccine and autism. Vaccines are responsible for saving millions of lives. The science supports it! The sad stories of parents with autistic children are very touching but their stories are not evidence or science. As an educated society, we need to focus on the science, not emotion.

Posted by: L | March 4, 2008, 8:28 pm 8:28 pm

Adapted response:
Vaccination is a sensitive topic. I suggest you review the vaccine ingredients; analyze the results of available safety and efficacy studies (and lack thereof); compare the risks of the vaccines against the diseases; and explore alternative methods to boost immunity, versus vaccines.
I have to admit, though, it was my friends very outspoken sister in law who got me to pay attention to the issues surrounding vaccines. At lunch, She turned to me and asked me outright if I was vaccinating my daughter. When I said “of course,” she looked at me in horror. I was dumbfounded because I thought everyone vaccinated. She then asked me if I would allow my daughter to “drink” aluminum, mercury, formaldehyde or monkey blood? When I said, “of course not,” she said, then you need to do your homework, because you are allowing doctors to inject these very substances into her bloodstream. I was completely confused, shocked and frightened…and, in my usual style, spent countless hours over the next few months (then years) researching vaccines, attending seminars, watching DVDs, you name it. Then, it was actually Dr. Tenpenny’s DVD that finally convinced my husband and me that we had made our vaccine decisions based on misinformation…basically no information, and we had made a poor decision.
I have become more outspoken over the years…I guess because I’m more concerned about the increase in the number of mandated vaccines, as well as the increase in childhood diseases, like autism. In NJ, 1 in 60 boys has autism.
Thank God, a few days ago, the court finally conceded that vaccines were linked to a child’s autism and awarded the family damages toward a lifetime of medical expenses.
“The reality, as documented by the American Medical Association’s own journal (JAMA) in the January 1999 issue, is that there is no connection between death from infectious diseases and vaccinations; that’s right, “none”.
If you like to gamble go ahead.

Posted by: sunshine | March 4, 2008, 9:45 pm 9:45 pm

John McCain is dead on, if he wasn’t the Feds wouldn’t have just concluded that vaccines are the cause. And Kate, if you are a nurse just do a little digging about autism, instead of basing you comment on outdated info. Google mitochondrial disease, impaired oxidative phosphorylation and vaccines. What do you come up with? Autism! Wow who would have thought!

Posted by: mary | March 5, 2008, 3:39 am 3:39 am

Autistic persons are genetically predisposed to be unable to detoxify from heavy metals and other toxins. So, it’s very likely that back in the days when childhood vaccines contained these substances, it was the vaccines that often triggered the autistic symptoms. Children not predisposed to autism could clear the toxins, but those unable to detoxify wound up with autism.
The fact that thimerosal has been removed from vaccines (except for some flu vaccines) yet autism continues to increase only shows how people are being exposed to more autism-triggering toxins overall. It needn’t be from vaccines only.

Posted by: Julia | March 5, 2008, 10:35 am 10:35 am

James
Thank you for your well written direct response. Your hypothesis is equally as valid as mine. I do disagree that a parent who is up all night, having to change diapers of a 10 year old, and worry every minute he will open a door or break a window and run down the middle of the street should be the one to do the research to find answers to these questions.
We all agree AUTISM is a real issue today. We all agree given current diagnosis criteria that we are looking at 1 in 150
Why is there no HELP…
For Therapy
For Respite
For Supplements
From Insurance
From Government
From Autism Society of America
From Autism Speaks
From Doctors ( AAP )
I know of story after story where parents have deserted each other and their child. I know of stories where the mothers have killed their child.
Time to wake UP… The system is broke…The sky is falling
And it is almost communist state like that this story is not headline news…
It is a headline that Hillary changed her hair, Britney went to a happier place, and Paris went to another party..
But you place the job back on the parents to research this????????
If no conspiracy then we must have apathetic uncaring idiots!!!!

Posted by: Tim Welsh | March 5, 2008, 10:52 am 10:52 am

Most Americans are aware of the courageous service John provided as a naval aviator and POW . But few can fully appreciate how bad the egregious hospitality of the Hanoi Hilton was .His main concerns were for other POWs’ life threatening conditions and how he could assist their problems.
To this day John’s truthfulness, dedication and what he believes in is demonstrated by his sincere actions and service as a Senator of the United States of America. We could do a whole lot worse than vote for John Mc Cain.

Posted by: Johns Son | March 5, 2008, 3:54 pm 3:54 pm

Yet more pandering from John McCain.

Posted by: Crust | March 5, 2008, 4:42 pm 4:42 pm

Tim,
I will say you are entitled to your hypothesis, but that it is not supported by the available evidence, and you are not entitled to your own facts. The National Academy of Sciences review in 2004 is just one of the many studies that rejects your hypothesis.
I am truly sorry for your son’s condition, and will not even pretend to know what it is like to care for an autistic child.
However, you use it in the context of this debate as an appeal to emotion in an attempt to shift the burden of proof . If you are going to make a claim, the burden of proof is by necessary on you to prove it correct, not anyone else to prove it incorrect.
I do agree with your final thought, and would say never assume malice on the part of people or the government when stupidity and apathy will suffice.

Posted by: James | March 5, 2008, 6:03 pm 6:03 pm

After we get through 4800 cases on this subject in the Vaccine court, I am sure we will be closer to a definitive answer.
Let me again say I am not Anti-Vaccine. I am pro-vaccine.
I just do not see a one size fits all. I think If government mandates shots for all, then government should be responsible for the results and injuries.
We will find out more in the morning…
PRESS CONFERENCE: VACCINE AUTISM LEGAL CONCESSION ON MARCH 6
Landmark Federal Court concession that local child from Atlanta developed autism from vaccines. Child joins parents in press conference about this historic result at Atlanta Federal Court House tomorrow.
The press conference will be held Thursday, March 6, 2008 at 11:30am on the steps of the US Federal Courthouse at 75 Spring Street, in Atlanta, GA.
I am amazed that there is not a middle ground on this topic. Why can’t we all take a deep breath and deal with the facts…
We have hurt kids
We can make them better
More research needs to be done now.
I will never claim to be a Doctor or Scientist.
My only job is to kick, yell, and Scream to help my son. If people like the John McCain make statements like he did last week… I will fight to get them on the front page. If the government concedes a Autism-Vaccine case (As they did on NOV. 9th 2007) I will fight to get it on the front page.

Posted by: Tim Welsh | March 5, 2008, 6:40 pm 6:40 pm

I am a pediatric RN. Thimerisol IS still in vaccines! I beilive it is dangerous. Of course the government says it is safe, they are making money off the pharmecutical companys!!

Posted by: Kate | March 6, 2008, 2:40 pm 2:40 pm

To correct all:
The people putting out the evidence against thimerosal as a cause of autism is not the government, it is university scientists.
And any regression following two years of normal development is called Childhood Disintegrative Disorder, which is not autism. (DSM-IV-TR, 2000)
Those who use their notariety to make fools of desperate parents in desperate situations should be ashamed of themselves. Dolphin therapy, hippotherapy, diets and vitamins; the only “cure” is through behavioral interventions.

Posted by: autism professional | March 6, 2008, 5:37 pm 5:37 pm

McCain is right. My son changed froma perfectly normal toddler into a bot ruled by autism within 3 days of his MMR vaccine. I have video proof.
The government does not want to admit it because they said it was safe to use Thimerisol in shots. They are to blame, as are the huge lobbyists in the pharmaceutical and health care industries. Why else do you think Congress keeps exempting them from autism lawsuits in the name of national security?
The link I provided is of a case where the vaccine fund actually paid out for an autism case. I hope they go more public and start a class action too. It’s sickening to think that Congress started up a vaccine fund which has unilaterally turned away thousands of parents of autistic children and still maintains their lobbyist’s position that autism increased exponentially within a year of the vaccine being required in four states through other means than the vaccines.
In my case, my son stopped talking within 2 hours of the shot, stopped looking at us within 24 hours, lost his potty training within 24 hours and started banging his head on the hallway tiles within 3 days, yelling and screaming when he did not get what he wanted. And it took 4 years more before we even got him to use one single verbal word.

Posted by: joe | March 7, 2008, 10:00 am 10:00 am

Kate RN, you must not know your stuff. I’m a pediatric clinic nurse specialist. Thimerosal HAS BEEN REMOVED FROM ALL VACCINES almost 5 years ago, with the exception of flu vaccine. SOME vaccines have a “trace” amount, it is removed during the manufacturing process. Since there is a chance that a trace amount could be present, they have to label it as trace. Any RN who is opposed to the benefits of vaccines should really consider a career change. Vaccines prevent MILLIONS of dealth world wide. Why don’t you go to Africa and tell them that they can’t have polio vaccine during an outbreak because it may cause autism and they will tell you that you’re crazy.

Posted by: jeneile | March 7, 2008, 3:19 pm 3:19 pm

Any type of medication prescribed or medical proceedure HAS A RISK. Penicillin kills people because of allergic reaction. People have died during surgery. There is a SMALL risk, perhpas 1 in 10 million that you may have a reaction to a vaccine. The benefits outweight the risks. The recent study in California proves beyond a doubt that this epidemic is likley a combination of a DNA anomaly and environmental. The study collecteed data about the numbers of autism diagnosis now (after thimerosal has been removed) and the numbers from when thimerosal was used. There are more diagnosis of autism now, even AFTER thimerosal has been removed. SOMETHING is causing this, but we don’t know what.

Posted by: jeneile | March 7, 2008, 3:27 pm 3:27 pm

jeneile, the vaccines are. Ask the parents whose child changed immediately after the vaccine, like mine. All you do by sporting your pharmaceutical funded trials is belittle and put down as wrong the parents, like me, who saw it happen.
Vaccines ARE causing autism in America. They are doing it today. And the risks are not acceptable for a mistaken benefit. Who cares if a kid gets chicken pox, flu or mumps? Odds are that kid will live and suffer absolutely no lasting side affects, other than an immunity the vaccine does not offer completely in the case of all but the flu.
My son changed the same day he got the shot. He lost potty training, ability and desire to speak, eye contact and all forms of normal interpersonal interaction, becoming a disease rather than a person BECAUSE of the vaccine. It happened to a now friend of mine last November.
The evidence that parents have outweighs the unbalanced, lying studies. That’s why the autism fund now paid out for a little girl your vaccines turned autistic. And I hold the medical providers, the states which require the vaccines, people like you who tow their line, and the politicians and pharmaceuticals who own them for it.

Posted by: joe | March 7, 2008, 3:39 pm 3:39 pm

Joe,
I’m REALLY sorry to hear about your child. I have to inform you that you’ve made an error in your thinking. The MMR vaccine does not and never had contained thimerosal.
MMR has never contained mercury in any form. There are multiple sources for this information. The FDA/CBER has a full report on Thimerosal in Vaccines. The report details the history and use of the mercury-based preservative thiomersal/thimerosal in vaccines with an overview of the reasons for its introduction and the studies on its safety.
I truly wish you the best of luck with your child and I sincerely hope that we find a prevention or cure for autism. But we must not be too quick to jump to conclusions.

Posted by: jeneile | March 7, 2008, 3:39 pm 3:39 pm

I’m glad John McCain is so concerned about the harmful effects of mercury. I hope his concerns lead him to propose and vote for legislation that puts strict limits on the mercury that can be released into the environment by factories and power plants.

Posted by: AC | March 7, 2008, 4:03 pm 4:03 pm

If McCain cares so much about the toxic effects of mercury, why did he support “Clean air Mercury Rule,” in 2005 that allowed power plants to be exempt from mercury emissions limits?
(the rule was found to be illegal on Feb 8 2008)
*****************
A federal appeals court ruled this morning that a rulemaking by the Environmental Protection Agency violates the Clean Air Act by evading mandatory cuts in toxic mercury pollution from coal- and oil-fired power plants. The decision invalidates the agency’s so-called “Clean Air Mercury Rule,” which would have allowed dangerously high levels of mercury pollution to persist under a weak cap-and-trade program that would not have taken full effect until well beyond 2020.

Posted by: David | March 7, 2008, 4:11 pm 4:11 pm

Joe,
Again, I have to really question this as a medical professional:
“My son changed the same day he got the shot. He lost potty training, ability and desire to speak, eye contact and all forms of normal interpersonal interaction, becoming a disease rather than a person BECAUSE of the vaccine”
Something is going on here, I don’t dispute that. You blame it on a vaccine. However, you do not know that is fact, It is your opinion. It is unfortunate, and I understand that you’re devastated by it. BTW- most of these studies are done by universities, not by vaccine companies.

Posted by: jeneile | March 7, 2008, 4:29 pm 4:29 pm

McCain is doing this as a political stunt for votes. He never gave a crap about this before. There is a HUGE differnce between ethyl mercury (the kind once used in vaccines), and methyl mercury (environmental type). Studies have shown that ethyl mercury is broken down and excreted from the body, but the methyl mercury (in our drinking water, in fish, etc) is not broken down as easily and accumulates in the body and may cause neurological damage. Why isn’t anyone concerned about all of the environmental toxins? There is as much methyl mercury in a can of tuna fish as there is in an adult flu shot with ethyl mercury (25 micrograms). Why isn’t this being attacked? People are still feeding there kids tuna fish and don’t accuse those companies of poisoning their children.

Posted by: jeneile | March 7, 2008, 4:42 pm 4:42 pm

If the anti-vaccine groups had their way, vaccines would be removed from clinic shelves–that is until a major outbreak of a vaccine preventable disease cost the lives and/or livelihood of thousands of children. Suddenly, the demand for vaccines would sky-rocket. Gee, let’s think back on the days when our country was stricken with childhood disease outbreaks–do measles or polio ring a bell?

Posted by: Hawkeye | March 7, 2008, 5:24 pm 5:24 pm

“That’s why the autism fund now paid out for a little girl your vaccines turned autistic” This is actually not correct. There is not an AUTISM FUND. You couldn’t be more wrong. It is a fund that pays out if there is an injury caused by a vaccine. There are very rare side effects such as brachial neuritis or anaphylactic allergy, and others that can be caused by certain components of certain vaccines, and the family can be compendated for this. This in NO WAY “proves” an autism/ vaccine link. This was ONE case in which the girl had an underlying medical condition, a mitochondrial DNA disorder, in which a vaccine aggravated her already present condition. This is RARE. VERY RARE. This is NOT the case for all children with autism. Autism is accuring in children who were NEVER vaccinated at all. Like I said before, any medication or medical proceedure carries risks.

Posted by: jeneile | March 7, 2008, 7:04 pm 7:04 pm

” John’s truthfulness, dedication and what he believes in is demonstrated by his sincere actions and service as a Senator of the United States of America. We could do a whole lot worse than vote for John Mc Cain”
Are you kidding me?
McCain was opposing the war until he found out that supporting it could get him a vote for president. I won’t be voting for him. Any ally of Bush is an enemy of mine.

Posted by: jeneile | March 7, 2008, 7:12 pm 7:12 pm

“I have to admit, though, it was my friends very outspoken sister in law who got me to pay attention to the issues surrounding vaccines. At lunch, She turned to me and asked me outright if I was vaccinating my daughter. When I said “of course,” she looked at me in horror.”
Ask a parent who lost their 18 year old college student to meningococcal meningitis the same question. I lost my sister to meningitis. It could have been prevented. She never got vaccinated.

Posted by: KATYRN | March 7, 2008, 7:17 pm 7:17 pm

The goverment and Pharm. companies are hand in hand with this. There is a major cover -up. Vaccines are NOT completely free of thermisol. It is a percentage less than what the FDA allows a pharm. comp. to label as “Free”
It is still present , but at a lower dose. As far as “Do vaccines cause autism?” I just rather leave that question alone.

Posted by: Nina | March 7, 2008, 8:08 pm 8:08 pm

“There is a major cover -up”
Wow. Now there is a conspiracy because SOME (not all) vaccines have a TRACE of thimerosal? Come on. Nothing is good enough. Pretty soon a vial of sterile water will cause cancer.

Posted by: Rick | March 7, 2008, 8:21 pm 8:21 pm

There is a HUGE difference between a trace <1 mcg and 25-500 mcg per vaccine. LESS THAN ONE MICROGRAM of ethyl Hg is NOT considered neurotoxic. Why don't people focus on some realistic causes such as environmental contaminants, as well as household toxins (vinyl flooring and siding is toxic, fame retardants in furniture, beds, etc is toxic, stain retardants in carpet are toxic, the list goes on and on. No one seems to be concerned about that.

Posted by: jeneile | March 7, 2008, 8:30 pm 8:30 pm

“What protects us from disease is our immune systems”
I would LOVE to see how the poster:Mercuryfree’s immune system holds up against measles or hepatitis b. Our immune system cannot protect us against everything. Be realistic.

Posted by: KATYRN | March 7, 2008, 8:45 pm 8:45 pm

Tim, how do you explain all of the current cases of autism? There are just as many, if not more than prior to 2001 when thimerosal was removed. There are children who have only recieved vaccines like MMR, Varicella, and polio which have never been produced using thimerosal and those children have autism. There are unvaccinated children with autism. What is your explanation from that? Time to start looking at environmental factors.

Posted by: KATYRN | March 9, 2008, 11:37 am 11:37 am

This does not represent anything other than a very special situation,” said Dr. Julie Gerberding, head of the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
Who are you going to believe the Boss doing the spin or the Judge that slipped?
The case may not be a first, said Gary Golkiewicz, chief special master for the U.S. Court of Federal Claims. He oversees the special “vaccine court” which rules on requests for payments from the vaccine injury fund.
“Years ago, actually, I had a case, before we understood or knew the implications of autism, that the vaccine injured the child’s brain caused an encephalopathy,” he said. And the symptoms that come with that “fall within the broad rubric of autism.”
And there are other somewhat similar cases, Golkiewicz says, that were decided before autism and its symptoms were more clearly defined

Posted by: Tim, IL | March 9, 2008, 10:53 pm 10:53 pm

It will take serious studies done in 2010 and beyond to figure out the damage done by the perservatives and other additives. It has been shown there was mercury in the vaccine pool in 2003 and beyond. Flu shots alone could skew the data.
All the hysterical parents are saying is Green our vaccines. Look at the facts:
1983: Autism rate 1 in 10,000
Vaccine schedule 10 shots
2008: Autism rate in boys 1 in 70
Vaccine schedule 36
My sons last words:
“My name is Tanner. My name is Tanner.”
The week of his shots for school…
Show me any other campaign for disinformation as wound up as this one by the medical(vaccine maker) community. Remove the Mecury, Aluminum, formaldehyde, ether, antifreeze. Reevaluate the schedule. What was the death rate from these deadly diseases in 1983 that we had to add 26shots? If there are side effects to the vaccinations all we asking for is support for therapy, respite, and recovery.

Posted by: Tim, IL | March 9, 2008, 10:57 pm 10:57 pm

Vaccines such as HIB and pneumococcal have saved many lives. They are “newly required” vaccines. Do the research. Meningococcal has as well. Do some reading on these. More research is being done on vaccine preventable disease,a nd we are finding more ways to prevent death. Children die from pneumoccocal disease and HIB meningitis. The ingredients such as thimerosal were used to keep the vaccines from becoming contaminated with bacteria. They were used to keep vaccines safe. Autism is more “prevalent” now becuause it is diagnosed sooner and we are now calling things “autism” that never used to be categorized as such. I am looking forward to more studies being done so we can move on from this situation.

Posted by: Tim | March 10, 2008, 12:07 am 12:07 am

It is amazing that no one seems to know or care that there is more mercury in our food and drinking water than there EVER has been in vaccines. And it is the “bad” kind of mercury that your body doesn’t get rid of. But yet, we’ll sit and blame vaccines. Never mind the fact that we’re immersed in a toxic environment.

Posted by: KATYRN | March 10, 2008, 12:25 am 12:25 am

Why if everyone is so confident that there are no side effects to vaccines do we need double speak and dishonesty?
The parents are not stupid… We know vaccines do great things for the general population.
We also believe we need to get the bad things out of our environment.
I guess when you have a son who could talk and use his body one day… Then he gets shots and does not talk and function… You tend to discount just about anything anybody says.
None of you have answered my questions.
How can parents tolerate Gerberding’s Lies? This is not the only case. Admit it. Give help to those that need it… And let’s move on.
We need Therapy, respite, and Recovery now!

Posted by: Tim, IL | March 10, 2008, 9:34 am 9:34 am

A vaccine is not going to cause an instantaneous neuroligical deconditioning of a child. It is merely a coincidence. These kids are born with genetic anomalies that manifest themselves at different times and different ways. Parents want someone and something to blame. That is understandable. But it isn’t the government’s responsibility to pay for therapy for autistic children. It is the parent’s responsibility.

Posted by: neurodoc | March 10, 2008, 12:36 pm 12:36 pm

A coincidence does not happen over and over again…
If the law mandates the vaccination then the Government is responsible for therapy, respite, recovery, and remediation.
So far all the parents get is smoke screens, lies, deflection, lies, delay, lies, and portral as the bad guys.
Creditablility is built on honesty and trust… One cannot say there is no link and then concede. It is not either/or… There is no such thing as Autism like… We already have a spectrum… Therefore the vacinations are involved in causing Autism. Double speak all you want.
The over 4800 cases are just the families of the Doctors and lawyers… Eventually the families of the non-professionals will have their day…

Posted by: Tim, IL | March 10, 2008, 6:12 pm 6:12 pm

On March 7, 2008, the Virginia Department of Health (VDH) received notification of a 15-month-old unvaccinated child with laboratory-confirmed measles (IgM-positive, IgG-negative, serum collected on February 27). The child is a resident of northern Virginia and returned to the United States after a 2.5-week visit to India on February 22. On the return flight (February 21–22) from New Delhi to Newark, New Jersey, the child developed fever and cold-like symptoms.
This child ended up becoming very ill with measles. Whe the HECK are people thinking? Taking an unvaccinated child to India? Since they purposely did not vaccinate this child, and did something idiotic, their health insurance should deny the claims to treat this child for this preventable disease.

Posted by: Rick | March 11, 2008, 11:41 am 11:41 am

I also look forward to more studies that refute the autism/ vaccine link and bring to light an environmental/ DNA link.
WASHINGTON (Reuters) – Scientists revealed the most extensive findings to date on the genetics of autism on Sunday, pinpointing two new genetic links that may predispose children to develop the complex brain disorder.
The five-year study, led by an international consortium of researchers from 19 nations, indicated autism had numerous genetic origins rather than a single or a few primary causes.
The researchers scoured DNA samples from 1,168 families with two or more children with autism, and used “gene chip” technology to detect genetic similarities. They also looked for tiny insertions and deletions of genetic material that could play a role in autism.
The scientists hope that nailing down the genetics of autism will lead to better ways to diagnose it and focus efforts on developing drugs to treat it. They announced they are launching a new phase in the research to map genes responsible for autism.
The study incriminated a gene called neurexin 1 involved with glutamate, a brain chemical previously implicated in autism that plays a role in early brain development, as a possible susceptibility gene for autism. A previously unidentified region of chromosome 11 also was implicated.
Autism is a spectrum of disorders apparently stemming from genetic and environmental causes. Geneticist Stephen Scherer of the University of Toronto and the Hospital for Sick Children in Toronto said 90 percent of autism may have a genetic basis.
“What we have now that we didn’t really have before is a pretty decent understanding of what the genetic architecture is looking like in the autism genome,” said Scherer, who worked on the study published in the journal Nature Genetics.

Posted by: Rick | March 11, 2008, 11:48 am 11:48 am

Tim, from IL-
Coincidences do happen over and over again.
Consider this. Over the past century, the number of storks has diminished in all industrialized countries, and so have birth rates. Today, in countries where storks are abundant, for instance in Africa where they stay in winter, birth rates are also high. There is a clear, highly significant positive correlation between the frequencies of storks and babies. There is also a theory about storks bringing children. Do storks cause births? Or do babies bring storks?
Most people would say no and no. Simply because there may be an apparent correlation between vaccines and autism does not mean that one causes the other. Furthermore, unvaccinated children acquire autism, too. So, at the very least, vaccines are not the only cause, if they are a cause at all (for which there is almost no evidence), of autism. Probably a variety of genetic and environmental causes contribute to the development of autism.
Thank you, Rick, for posting the new connections between autism and genetics. Once the mechanism behind autism is clearer, research can be done to determine possible treatments.
While I have no personal experience with autism, I truly feel for people who have. I just don’t feel that attacking vaccines and the people who make them is productive. Instead, we should focus on researching more tangible causes (like genetics and environmental factors), so we can in turn provide the treatments that people are so badly seeking. At heart, I feel this is a funding issue. For whatever reason, not enough money is available to fund unbiased research about many diseases, let alone autism. I feel it is too much of a generalization to claim it is basically a government conspiracy.

Posted by: Heather, student pharmacist | March 11, 2008, 6:59 pm 6:59 pm

None of you have answered my questions.
None of you have answered my questions.
How can parents tolerate Gerberding’s Lies?
Why if everyone is so confident that there are no side effects to vaccines do we need double speak and dishonesty?
The parents are not stupid… We know vaccines do great things for the general population.
We also believe we need to get the bad things out of our environment.
I guess when you have a son who could talk and use his body one day… Then he gets shots and does not talk and function… You tend to discount just about anything anybody says.
None of you have answered my questions.
How can parents tolerate Gerberding’s Lies? This is not the only case. Admit it. Give help to those that need it… And let’s move on.
We need Therapy, respite, and Recovery now!

Posted by: Tim, IL | March 12, 2008, 6:46 pm 6:46 pm

What’s next in line of conspiracy theories gaining mainstream acceptance-the rigging of the 2004 presidential election in Ohio, the NAFTA superhighway, or AIDS not being a disease?

Posted by: dbrett | March 25, 2008, 4:49 pm 4:49 pm

Hi,
I’m a student at a college in New England majoring in Psychology. For my Research Methods class I need to do a study and I chose to do Mercury causing Autism. I have a few questions that I would be very greatful if anyone would answer them and maybe give me an idea of how you feel about the subject. Thank you for taking the time.
1. Do you personally know anyone that has Autism?
2. Do you know a lot of information about Autism? Would you consider yourself an expert?
3. Do you believe mercury causes Autism?
4. Do you believe that thimerosal has made Autism increase?
5. Why do you think that the rate of Autism is at 1 out of 150 children?
6. Why do you believe that that number varies from state to state?
Is it the environment?
The mercury in the environment?
7. Do you believe that testing childrens’ hair is an accurate test of mercury causing Autism?

Posted by: Ashley | March 25, 2008, 8:33 pm 8:33 pm

1. Do you personally know anyone that has Autism?
Yes… My son’s last words after his shots for school were “My name is Tanner. My name is Tanner” He is low functioning non-verbal autistic.
2. Do you know a lot of information about Autism?
I have been imersed in the subject for more than 5 years.
Would you consider yourself an expert?
I am comfortable that I know more about ASD than 99% + of the general public.
3. Do you believe mercury causes Autism?
Mercury is one environmental factor that impacts Autism.
4. Do you believe that thimerosal has made Autism increase?
Yes I have yet to see what I consider a study that does not have bias or mistakes that can eliminate it as a factor in the rise of ASD.
5. Why do you think that the rate of Autism is at 1 out of 150 children?
Environmental stress (Mercury and other things we put into our children). Also better diagnosis plays a part.
6. Why do you believe that that number varies from state to state?
Again environmental impact, reporting, and support. I have experienced treatment programs in 7 states.
Is it the environment?
Part of the issue is the environment.
The mercury in the environment?
I believe this is part of the issue.
7. Do you believe that testing childrens’ hair is an accurate test of mercury causing Autism?
NO… The mercury deposits are found in other organs throughout the body. Part of the issue is this subgroup can not excrete the mercury like the majority.

Posted by: Tanners Dad | March 27, 2008, 9:03 pm 9:03 pm

Thank you so much Tanner’s Dad you really helped me!

Posted by: Ashley | March 27, 2008, 10:25 pm 10:25 pm

Thank you so much Tanner’s Dad you really helped me!

Posted by: Ashley | March 27, 2008, 10:25 pm 10:25 pm

I’m the father of an autistic son, and I have always found those who vilify vaccinations to be an unnecessary sidetrack on the path to assisting and understanding those with autism. Science has never backed that view, and all the money spent to repeatedly disprove it could be channeled into special education programs where the dollars could actually do some good.
No surprise, however, that the Republican candidate has to straddle the fence between science and any wacko idea out there, as his base includes creationists, flat-earthers, and global warming deniers.

Posted by: theron | March 31, 2008, 2:27 pm 2:27 pm

I have a normal healthy child who is supposed to get her MMR shot in 2 months. Recently, I decided to return to university at age 30. Since I could not prove that I had received the MMR within a ten year period of time I had to have the shot in order to register for classes. I had the vaccination and the next day I had a grand mal seizure…I have never had seizures in my life and was very happy and healthy. It continually got worse and doctors told me it had nothing to do with the MMR, “it was just coincidence”. After a long hospital stay, difficulty concentrating, walking, taking care of my daughter…I have been diagnosed with Brain Injury and Epilepsy. It changed my whole life (driver license taken away, etc) and no one seems to believe me. My daughter will NOT receive the shot, no way, no how. Children cannot not always speak for themselves, but as an adult I know my life changed the moment I had the MMR.

Posted by: Alisha | March 31, 2008, 4:05 pm 4:05 pm

I think anyone who doesn’t get their child vaccinated should be arrested for medical neglect and thrown in jail for endangering the public. We have seen countless times, horrible disease make their return to communities take reject immunizations. Very rarely people can get Guillian Barre and some other immune mediated affects but autism has been disproven to be a complication and People definately don’t get seizures from immunizations. As per what people are responding with to this article is a great indication that what McCain says is ignorant and dangerous. I thought for once we had an intelligent republican candadate. These comments he made completely turns me off to him.

Posted by: Keith | April 4, 2008, 4:22 pm 4:22 pm

Autism is now being diagnosed in the US at a rate of 1 in 150. The numbers fair worse in England and a bit better in other developed countries, but regardless there is no doubt we are dealing with a global epidemic.
It is impossible to have a ‘genetic epidemic.’ To blame the rise of Autism, Aspergers, PDD-NOS, ADHD/ADD, language delays, and other neurological disorders on genes alone is disingenous at best.
In 1999 the pharmaceutical companies began to PHASE OUT thimerosol (a mercury preservative) from most infant vaccines. Some say the phasing out has been completed, others disagree. I recommend reading the manufacturer’s insert.
For example, I know that to this day, the Hep-B shot (which is administered at the hospital before discharge, then again at 3 mo., and 6 mo.) still contains thimerosol. If you read the manufacturer’s package insert, it clearly states there are “traces of thimerosol” in the Hep-B shot.
For anyone wanting to know more read: “Evidence of Harm” by David Kirby (who contributed to the health and science section of The New York Times for eight years before writing this book).
Also visit: w w w . generationrescue . org
and Google Dr. Sears February 2008 article on vaccines.

Posted by: SilenceDoGood | April 6, 2008, 1:53 pm 1:53 pm

What a joke — of COURSE it is vaccines making our kids sick. What else do kids have in common all over the world besides vaccines? All their environments/genetics are different, but the are all getting shot full of a variety of chemical cocktails that are bypassing every defense their body has and going straight into the blood stream. Yes, mercury may be in the environment, but your skin and gastric juices offer you some defense — it doesn’t go straight into your blood stream!
For the poster who said unvaccinated kids are getting autism, I challenge him to go find 20. Just 20. I read that scientists were going to study autism in the Amish (because they don’t vaccinate) and they COULDN’T FIND ANY TEST SUBJECTS TO STUDY! None of my kids are vaxed and never will be — I saw my own nephew go from a shiny, bright child to a kid who can now never live on his own thanks to autism. My kids are healthier than ANY kids I know — my 12yo and 4yo have never had any illness, have never seen a doctor in their life. My 9yo has been ONCE for pinkeye. HOW MANY vaxed kids have that kind of health record — if it is not learning disorders, it’s asthma or other things, and nobody seems to know why. I’d much rather my kid get measles or mumps (which I was vaccinated for both and got BOTH anyway, and they were no big deal) than risk the chemical stew that is in vaccines. There is much controversy about shots for pets, and those shots causing cancers, seizures and other maladies. I can only hope some will connect the dots to see that there are also issues with shots for humans too.

Posted by: nonvaxmom | April 6, 2008, 4:14 pm 4:14 pm

Please, Everyone, it is important not to lie in order to make out points of view heard or believed. The MMR vaccine did not cause any adult epilepsy and you know it.
I am a pediatrician in Chicago and I must say that the vaccines-cause-autism crowd are convincing DESPITE the essential component of PROOF. I think it is easier for them to get their point across than any pediatrician could because all we physicians have is the need and imperative to show why we come to a particular conclusion. They say, “I’m a parent and that is how I feel” and that seems to be good enought to convince othr parents that these people have a legitimate point of view. Would anyone please tell me where the controversy is? You have the medical authorities who are supposedly experts in healthcare saying unwaveringly that there is no relationship. On the other side, there is a group of hacks of whatever backgrounds saying that they remember something being some way before something else happened so we should risk the health of the public at large based on that. Please understand that I concur that autism is a devastating condition for families and that it requires a lot in terms of care. My position is regarding causation and what to do about whatever the cause might be. When they do put out some thinly-veiled and poorly-conducted, likely made-up study, they claim suppression of information after it gets shot down. This whole conversation is easier than Roswell & UFOs. People can shout as loud from the hilltops as loudly as they want about how real or surreal their experiences were, it really does not matter to me. They have no evidence and that is quite clear. When they start putting the health of children at risk, I feel that I need to speak up also. Please continue to seek truth and not just some paranoid suspicions.

Posted by: docdus | April 12, 2008, 1:04 pm 1:04 pm

Joe wrote:
“My son changed froma perfectly normal toddler into a bot ruled by autism within 3 days of his MMR vaccine…. The government does not want to admit it because they said it was safe to use Thimerisol in shots.”
The MMR vaccine never contained thimerosal. You’re confusing two unrelated autism theories.

Posted by: John F. | April 15, 2008, 12:15 pm 12:15 pm

All the information that is posted is very interesting but show me some proof!
For instance websites or articles
thanks

Posted by: kylee | April 17, 2008, 4:16 pm 4:16 pm

I have two sons with high functioning autism. One is 8 the other is 4 years old. After they had their last shots around August 2007 we saw a big differance in their behavior. They became more defiant with more screaming.
The shots do effect children!

Posted by: Daniel | April 21, 2008, 2:43 pm 2:43 pm

I am a nurse and a mother of a child with Autism. I WAS a mother of a perfectly healthy, advanced-language for his age son until he got his 1 year old shots. We have him on video singing and talking before his shots. Within 1 week…nonverbal. I dare you to ask to see the packet inserts for the vaccinations before you let them give them to you kids! I bet you anything thimerisol is still in there….just not enough for them to have to tell you there is! Look at the “ingredient list” on the packet insert! Kind of like diet pops can claim they are calorie free when they aren’t….just not enough to have to say they are.

Posted by: Kari in Iowa | September 6, 2008, 12:06 pm 12:06 pm

hi i am justing wanting to say that you rock mccain!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Posted by: amy | September 30, 2008, 10:24 pm 10:24 pm

I have a 6 year old son with autism and we will NOT be supporting McCain no matter how many special needs children Pailn may have. Mc Cain is all about keeping the wars going which that and the economy which he helped the Republicans deregulate, will suck up all the money needed for research and new therapies for autism. The very latest debate between Obama and McCain also revealed a very scary detail– he is out of touch even with autism and what it is, connecting Sarah Palin’s down syndrome baby with autism. They are two very different disorders and the research for one has nothing to do with the research for the other. This showed me that he is not just out of touch with the economy but with other important matters that affect us. I’m sure Sarah Palin’s children will be taken care of just fine during a McCain/Palin administration while the rest of us get our programs axed.

Posted by: Phyllis Lorenzo | October 17, 2008, 8:50 am 8:50 am

I am so tired of hearing them LIE about thimerosol!!! I just read it off the label of dtap 3 months ago!!! Don’t believe me? GO LOOK! They didn’t remove it in 1999. It was in every one of my autistic daughters first shots in 2001/2002!! EVERY DAMN ONE. I pointed it out and was told “oh no its harmless”. My kid started staring into space after being alert and normal. She never talked,she hit all milestones before shots early, after shots, everything was different, shes 7 and can’t talk at all! STOP LYING about the preservative being removed I know for a fact it was not.

Posted by: rhonda | October 22, 2008, 3:56 am 3:56 am

wanted to add I’m voting for OBAMA, because McCain/Palin doesn’t give a crap about anyones kids.

Posted by: rhonda | October 22, 2008, 3:58 am 3:58 am

As for when thimerosal was removed… It was never totally removed.
The flu shot (which did and still does contain the full amount of thimerosal) was first recommended for pregnant women in 1997.
In 1999, congress decided that childhood vaccines should be made with little to no thimerosal, but the prenatal vaccine was STILL recommended and always has been since 1997.
Then in 2001 vaccines started being manufactured with the reduced amounts of thimerosal. However, existing vaccine stocks with the full amount of thimerosal were NOT recalled because this removal was considered to just be precautionary.
Based on the SV40 virus example below, the childhood vaccines that contained the full amount of thimerosal were probably still in circulation until at least 2003.
In 1961, the SV40 virus that was found in the polio vaccine was found to cause tumors in rodents. So they declared that future stocks should be free of the SV40 virus as a precautionary measure. “However existing stocks were remained in circulation until 1963.” Now traces of this virus have been found in certain types of lymphoma. This information was on the CDC’s website at this link: http://www2a.cdc.gov/nip/Redirects/Test1.asp?spath=http://www.cdc.gov/nip/vacsafe/concerns/Cancer/default.htm
But the page is no longer available. I had just accessed this page a week ago, and now it seems to be gone… You can find the link by googling “CDC polio vaccine SV40″ but it won’t display that page anymore.
So if the full-level thimerosal vaccines were still in circulation until 2003, and then in 2004 the full-thimerosal flu shot was added to the childhood vaccination schedule for children 6 months and older, there would have been a time period of only about 1 year where the childhood immunization schedule only included the “trace” amounts of thimerosal. And don’t forget, that even during that one-year time period the full-thimerosal prenatal flu shot was STLL being recommended even though thimerosal was removed for children. Why was it still recommended for developing children (who are much more susceptible) when congress decided it wasn’t safe for children to receive thimerosal?
Also, the CDC’s thimerosal study found that “increased prenatal exposure” caused “poorer executive functioning” in males only. That fit’s into the higher ratio of boys to girls with autism.
And another less frequently discussed problem is the aluminum. Aluminum levels were limited to 25 mcg in injectable medical solutions because the FDA, I’ll say that again, the FDA found that aluminum was causing neurological delays in preemies (and dementia in kidney dialysis patients aka post dialysis encephalopathy) due to reduced renal function.
Now the 250 mcg hep B vaccine is given to newborns, INCLUDING PREEMIES, the day they are born. Other studies have found that “Low birth weight and preterm birth increase the risk of autism in infants by about twofold”. Hep B is a STD, and the FDA already acknowledged that preemies have an increased risk of aluminum toxicity so shouldn’t this 250 mcg vaccine NOT be given to preemies unless the baby’s mother is Hep B positive???????
The CDC says that large amounts of aluminum have been found to cause neurological and skeletal delays in young and developing animals. Autism obviously includes neurological delays, AND the CDC also cites a study that found that children with autism have thinner bones than the controls.
Also, the NNii concedes that children’s aluminum levels do temporarily exceed the minimal risk level after being vaccinated, but that 50-70 percent is filtered out the next day so they’re not worried about it. Sure if it was only one shot, but we’re talking about 13 aluminum-containg vaccines by the time a child is 6 months old (For those of you who are curious, there were only 3 aluminum-containing vaccine doses by 6 months of age back in 1983). They haven’t done any further studies to determine what happens to the remaining 50-30 percent. Is the remaining aluminum removed by the body, or is it deposited in these children’s brain and skeletal tissue? 50-70 percent is a big difference, so obviously some children’s bodies are more efficient at filtering aluminum that others. Certain factors, such as elevated circulating parathyroid hormone increase aluminum absorption. Also, mercury and aluminum are synergistic, and studies have found that children’s risk of autism directly correlates to how close they live to power plants (this is believed to be due to the higher levels of environmental mercury due to pollution). Children with autism have had tests that show they have both high levels of mercury and aluminum.
And before anyone brings up the issue of how much aluminum is in soy baby formula, ingested aluminum and injected aluminum are two very different things.
The toxic dose of aluminum for an adult is 350 mcg or .350 mg. Extra strength antacid tablets contain 160 mg of aluminum hydroxide in each tablet, and the directions say to take 2-4 tablets up to four times a day. So there HAS to be a difference between ingested and injected aluminum or else a single antacid tablet would be toxic. (Remember, the FDA limited the injectable aluminum-containing solutions to 25 mcg. That’s .025 mg and the antacid tablet contains 160 mg)
Everything has a toxic limit

Posted by: CM | October 23, 2008, 11:11 pm 11:11 pm

Hi Rhonda,
The reason McCain said that Sarah Palin understands autism is that her sister’s 13 year-old son has autism.
Also, since you, just like me, are very concerned about the safety of vaccines, I think it’s important to let you know that Obama has stated on more than one occasion that he does NOT support selective vaccination, and when asked about the issue of Vaccine Choice on an A-Champ survey, he completely dodged the question by talking about “health screenings”.
On the other hand, here’s McCain’s stance:
1) Vaccine safety is a concern. He “will work with all agencies to take all necessary steps in an expedient manner to ensure safe vaccines for every American family.” This will include continuing work to reduce and eliminate thimerosal (containing the known neurotoxin mercury) from vaccines.
2) Parental choice is paramount. “The key to health care reform is to restore control to the patients themselves.”
Also, look at the comparison of campaign contributions:
“Obama $181,000 in Big Pharma donations through Jan. 31, compared with Clinton’s $174,000. As for McCain, his total was only $44,000.”
Who do you think is more likely to be on our side?
Also, Obama has never said anything about the safety of vaccines, but read this about McCain:
“McCain, along with Joe Lieberman, has asked the Senate health committee to look into environmental causes, vaccine additives and biomed treatments. Obama is on that committee and has not picked up the torch to make it happen.”
As for Sarah Palin,
“Barbara Angaiak, president of the state affiliate of the National Education Association… credited Ms. Palin for having backed a legislative proposal, which became law this year, that overhauled the state’s school funding system. That plan brought more money to the state’s many rural and remote school districts and raised spending for students with special needs. (“Alaska Legislators Overhaul Funding,” April 30, 2008.)
****The measure raised per-pupil funding by $100, to $5,480, and brought the state’s total K-12 budget to $1.2 billion.***
“She understands many of the issues that are important to educators in Alaska,” Ms. Angaiak said. ”
And
“If you look at the 2007 budget … the budget for the school year was $8,265,300 and this number included the Alaskan Challenged Youth Academy.
If you look at the 2008 budget …(page 13)
the budget is $3,156,000, but the Alaskan Challenged Youth Academy is a seperate line item. It’s budget is $5,709,000 for a grand total of $8,865,000.
This is a 6.25% increase, not a decrease!
If you look at the 2009 budget …(page 13)
Again if you add the two numbers together you get a total of $9,214,900 and this year it is a 3.94% increase.”
So I’m voting for McCain/Palin, (First and foremost because I want Vaccine Choice) and I sincerely hope you will too. If you want references to any of this info, I’d be happy to post all of them for you.

Posted by: CM | October 24, 2008, 12:04 am 12:04 am

I am originally from somalia and children born in minnesota to somali parents are being diagnosed with autism at a higher rate than the rest of the population. some of the parents including myself state that our children were fine before the mmr shot, but other parents in our community are saying that their child had the symptoms of autism before the mmr shot.
Is it possible for the medical community to do a specific study in our community and really find out the real cause of this disorder which will lead us to the cure and prevention. I think our light at the end of the tunnel is the cure for our kids. Right??

Posted by: idil | December 13, 2008, 1:18 am 1:18 am

Some of these comments are really offensive. I have autism and I do not like some of these comments at all

Posted by: 0112358 | July 9, 2010, 9:01 pm 9:01 pm

Some people say that their children get autism from the shots, what really happens is: You are born with autism, as you become older you gain symptoms and the symptoms get stronger, they get noticeable around the child’s first vaccination. The only reason that symptoms are noticed on the day of the vaccination is that AUTISTIC CHILDREN ARE HYPERSENSITIVE, IF YOU WERE TORTURED WOULD YOU BE EXPECTED TO BE HAPPY FOR THE REST OF THE DAY? There is something called aftershock, that is when the child feels so bad it get really quiet and don’t seem to remember things. Since I am autistic I get it. THERE IS NO AUTISM BOOM! THE INTERNET BOOM MAKES INFORMATION EASIER TO MAKE AND SHARE, IT IS ALSO THE PERFECT HABITAT FOR FRAUD.
☹☹☹☹☹☹☹☹☹☹☹☹☹☹☹☹☹☹☹☹☹☹☹☹☹☹☹☹☹☹☹☹☹☹☹☹☹☹☹☹☹☹☹☹☹☹☹☹

Posted by: 0112358 | July 9, 2010, 9:12 pm 9:12 pm

As my 3 children were born, I was finishing 8 years biology/chemistry/math, MS magna-cum-laude, three years graduate research using advanced statistical designs used for all academic areas requiring statistical inference. My third child was squarely autistic but all family members had severe ASD symptoms. The 20 year vaccine / amalgam record fits into a standard ANOVA and proves at a p(F) level of 1/247,000 that vaccines and amalgams both cause autism, provided symptoms are consistent with metal poisoning, which they are, not just mercury, but aluminum and copper. Placental transfer of amalgam mercury is also a likely agent.

Posted by: Alan Foos | December 26, 2010, 9:38 pm 9:38 pm

I should make another comment- the MMR caused the most severe effects of the vaccines in my children. To correct Jeniele among others, the MMR may have no Thimerosal, and the FDA says that it contains zero mercury, but the FDA is lying. It contains “trace” levels, which are definitely toxic, and it has far larger amounts of aluminum which in combination with the trace mercury will inflict a bigger punch and definitely causes autism. The point is that the vaccines cause autism, not only due to mercury, but to the overall combination of toxins in this clearly deadly brew. You’d have to be blind not to see that vaccines cause autism, and proving it scientifically is not at all difficult.

Posted by: Alan Foos | December 26, 2010, 9:45 pm 9:45 pm

////

Posted by: JenniferRN | August 17, 2011, 3:41 pm 3:41 pm

The idiot’s comment above, and those like you, who make statements that parents should be arrested for not vaccinating should be given a straight shot of mercury, to pass through your blood-brain barrier, and nullifies that thing between your ears!
It isn’t your business ever, if parents want reassurance that their child’s brain could not be damaged because of these multi-dose preservatives in the vaccines, that’s their/our business! Besides, since you are herding your kids in like cattle, even with this controversy going on, that you don’t even care to check out the pharmaceutical claims telling you what to do about vaccinating your kids, despite any clear answer of the CAUSE effecting our children… is only an action by responsible parents!
And what the hell do you care about other kids getting the mumps?! Your kids are “safe”, remember?? So shut-up! The rest of us as parents prefer to take a breather here, break out of the cattle line, use our independent brain, and investigate on behalf of a child that can’t make this decision and that we are responsible for.

Posted by: JenniferRN | August 17, 2011, 5:14 pm 5:14 pm

Leave a Reply

Do you have more information about this topic? If so, please click here to contact the editors of ABC News.