By Saira Anees

Apr 8, 2008 12:17pm

The Nuanced Truth About Hillary Clinton’s Hospital Story

The tragic story Sen. Hillary Clinton, D-NY, has been maligned for sharing about Trina Larae Bachtel, 35 — who lost her son and her own life — has some truth to it.

But it is also not as starkly illustrative of the problems with the U.S. health care system as Clinton has relayed to audiences on the stump.

This does not make the loss of Trina Bachtel and her stillborn son Tray Dean Hutton any less tragic. Nor does it take away from the fundamental issue — that tens of millions of Americans lack health insurance and this often has disastrous consequences.

But here are the facts of the case.

It’s a conclusion that is neither a dismissal of the story altogether, as some in the media have done following the remarks of one hospital administrator in the New York Times Saturday, nor is it a declaration that the story, as Clinton told it, was true, as the Clinton campaign would want it.

**

Clinton was first told the sad story of Trina Bachtel by an Meigs County Ohio sheriff’s deputy, Bryan Holman.

The moment Holman shared the anecdote with Clinton was captured on video, and you can watch it HERE.

“I’d like to tell you the story of a young woman I know that didn’t have health insurance," Holman said. "She worked in a little pizza place around here and she was pregnant, worked for minimum wage. She went to the hospital. And the hospital told her she needed $100 up front, which she didn’t have of course didn’t make a lot of money . So they had billed her a couple of times for it. And uh, after getting pregnant she went back, like I say, she went back again, they told her she needed $100 she didn’t have. So they refused to see her because she had a bill and stuff and been there before."

"So she went to another local hospital," he says. "And they seen her and stopped her labor and told her to come back in two days. Well, before she got back within those two days her baby died. So they life-flighted her to Co – to a hospital in Columbus and within 15 days she died. And they come to find out that they had misdiagnosed what the problem was. And it was a smaller hospital, didn’t have the needs to take care of what she needed at that time."

The larger point, says Holman to Clinton: "her family and them think that if she’d had good insurance and stuff and she was taken care of at the first hospital of course that had the medical means to take care of her that her and her baby of course would still be here. Its just you know the health insurance thing really needs to be addressed for people who you know work for minimum wage and different things.”

Said Clinton: "I hear so many stories like that. People without insurance are more likely to be die than people with insurance."

**

Clinton immediately began telling the story to make an argument for universal health care. Her campaign did not try to check its accuracy before she did so.

In Terre Haute, Indiana, Clinton said that in Ohio “a deputy sheriff told me about a young woman who worked at the pizza parlor there and she worked for minimum wage, she didn’t have any insurance. She got pregnant, went to the hospital — and I don’t blame the hospital. The hospital said, ‘We can’t take any more charity care. You have to give us $100 before we can examine you.’ She didn’t have $100. Went back another time, they told her the same thing.”

When Bachtel went back to the hospital, Clinton said, she did so “in an ambulance. And they worked hard to stabilize her, and she lost her baby. Then they airlifted her to Columbus to the medical center, and for 15 days they tried to save her life, and she died.”

Clinton in telling the story shared with her by Holman conflated the first hospital where Bachtel was denied here, with the second, where she lost her child, which was O’Bleness Memorial Hospital in Athens, Ohio.

O’Bleness Memorial Hospital took issue with the story, since she’d been making it sound as if the hospital where Bachtel died was the same one where she’d allegedly been denied care.

With that factual error noted in the New York Times, some in the media portrayed the story in such a way as to imply that none of it was true.

Some of it was accurate. The tragic death of Trina Bachtel and her son. The fears of a poor pregnant woman and her lack of immediate access to quality health care because she didn’t have health insurance.

But some of the story Clinton shared was not accurate.

**

In addition to Clinton conflating the first and second hospitals, Holman — who heard Bachtel’s story second-hand — got some key details wrong.

First, years ago, Bachtel was told she needed to pay $100 before she would be seen by a doctor not because they wanted the money up front, but because she owed the clinic money.

Second, this did not happen at a hospital, but at a private physicians’ clinic. Specifically, Holzer Clinic in Gallipolis, Ohio. Hospitals are legally not permitted to deny care to anyone. The rules are quite different for clinics.

Holzer Clinics Inc. is a private series of clinics (not to be confused with Holzer Hospitals). Holzer Clinic Inc. has nine offices throughout southeastern Ohio and West Virginia. They take in about 500,000 patient visits a year, including more than 100,000 Medicaid patients a year and maybe 25,000 patients with no insurance.

Holzer Clinics Inc. tries to work with patients who accrue medical debts. But there are times when a patient mounts up debts and the clinic system believes he or she needs to make more of an effort.

When that happens, the patient enters an "advanced payment status." Before the doctor will see the patient at this private clinic, he or she is asked to pay $100. If the patient says he cannot pay, he or she is counseled to go to a hospital emergency room.

This is what happened to Trina Bachtel, who at the time had no health insurance.

There are exceptions. Doctors at Holzer Clinics Inc will see patients in "advanced payment status" if, for instance, they have been referred out of an emergency room, if they’ve since gone onto Medicaid, or if they’re receiving workers compensation. Cancer patients in chemotherapy, and pregnant patients will be seen whether or not they pat the $100.

**

Which brings us to the third point: when Bachtel was told she needed to pay the $100 before the visit — and court records show that she’d owed thousands of dollars to the Holzer System — she was not pregnant.

Bachtel got pregnant and in 2007 suffered through a difficult pregnancy, suffering from preeclampsia, characterized by high blood pressure and the presence of protein in the urine, effecting 5-8% of all pregnancies.

At that time she had health insurance.

For whatever reason, she thought that she would need to pay Holzer Clinics Inc. $100 and she did not go to the clinic.

"She was told she had to have $100 upfront and that’s why she never went there when she got pregnant," one of her family members told me.

Later she went to O’Bleness Memorial Hospital when it was an emergency.

Her son was stillborn there on August 1, 2007. She was airlifted to OSU Medical Center in Columbus, where she died two weeks later.

**

It is all sad. It is all tragic. The family is grieving, and the renewed scrutiny of it all by the media — prompted by Sen. Clinton using the ancedote — is bringing them back to those dark days last August.

Those are the facts. A
young woman lost her life and the life of her child. But no hospital or clinic denied her coverage as a pregnant woman. She had insurance when she died.

What are we to learn from the tragic story of Trina Bachtel?

- jpt

User Comments

That we need a better healthcare system because she was not taken care of because of $100!

Posted by: John | April 8, 2008, 12:25 pm 12:25 pm

Jake Tapper,
Thanks for the balance. Hillary relayed a story that had been told to her. As it turns out there were some minor errors in the story from its source. This story has been discarded from the campaign speeches as a result, as soon as this was discovered.
Your reporting has clarified this further, and there is still sufficient basis to having discarded it.
Now watch as the band of Obama pirates begin to pour over the sides and say things like “she’s a witch, she’s a monster, she lies through her eyes”, and so on, and so on – shoobie doobie doobie.
=======================================
Please, have a field day my friends!
=======================================

Posted by: WestCoastMessenger | April 8, 2008, 12:36 pm 12:36 pm

What have we learned? We’ve learned that Clinton will say anything. After the Bosnia story was proven so false, she should have had her campaign vetting her other stories. Hillary will say anything to get elected.

Posted by: Kathleen | April 8, 2008, 12:37 pm 12:37 pm

Tuesday April 08, 2008. The Washington Post. By Anne E. Kornblut.
But so is Clinton’s claim that Bechtel did not get care at another hospital that wanted a $100 pre-payment before seeing her, according to the young woman’s aunt, Lisa Casto. “It’s a true story,” said Casto, 53.
Casto added some details that were not part — or differed from — the Clinton anecdote: She said her niece had previously been in debt to a local hospital that later sent her a letter informing her that she could only be treated there in the future if she gave them a $100 deposit. At the time she went into debt to that hospital, Casto said, Bechtel was uninsured, though she later obtained health insurance and was insured at the time of her death.
Casto said she did not want to give the name of the offending hospital because the flood of calls over the incident has overwhelmed her and Meigs County deputy sheriff Bryan Holman, a friend of hers who retold the story to Clinton when she campaigned in southern Ohio.

Posted by: Dogsoldier | April 8, 2008, 12:40 pm 12:40 pm

And Kathleen would be the first pirate on board. Welcome aboard Kathleen, make sure you don’t get trampled by the scurry of little feet behind you.
=======================================
Obama has a piece of eight, Hillary must have nine.
=======================================

Posted by: WestCoastMessenger | April 8, 2008, 12:40 pm 12:40 pm

I guess Obama will be last to ask questions about Iraq today so he has some direction from Hillary .

Posted by: Bishop | April 8, 2008, 12:41 pm 12:41 pm

Ok, I can’t vote for Hillary, because I would have an even worse feeling that the truth is either hidden, stretched, minimized or needs to be requested through an attorney.
I’m sorry, but after all these years of the Bush administrations “misstatements” about weapons of mass destruction, etc. – I will not support a candidate who is this far separated from the truth.

Posted by: Angela | April 8, 2008, 12:50 pm 12:50 pm

That people must found out all information before relying on and repeating and also adding our point of view into it. But that said Hillary should have been more diligent to vet the story before stumping it. She is only responsible for what comes out of her Mouth. Not what comes out of others. She has hundreds if not thousand who support her and would help her vet these things.

Posted by: Lauren | April 8, 2008, 12:50 pm 12:50 pm

What are we to learn from this? We learn that no CLINIC or hospital or doctor in this WEALTHY country should EVER deny a sick patient coverage for any reason whatsoever….whether she is pregnant or not. We also learn much about the health care system in this country and the GREED of doctors, clinics and hospitals. What’s more important? A sick young lady or whether the doctor of a clinic will be able to afford another Mercedes Benz? The entire system is broken. Money $$$$$$$ rules the day, not the sick people in this country. Something is seriously wrong here.
Hippocratic Oath:
1. To teach medicine to the sons of my teacher. In the past, medical schools would give preferential consideration to the children of physicians.
2. To practice and prescribe to the best of my ability for the good of my patients, and to try to avoid harming them. This beneficial intention is the purpose of the physician. However, this item is still invoked in the modern discussions of euthanasia.
3. Never to do deliberate harm to anyone for anyone else’s interest. Physician organizations in most countries have strongly denounced physician participation in legal executions. However, in a small number of cases, most notably Oregon[3] and the Netherlands[4], a doctor can perform euthanasia, by both his and the patient’s consent.
4. To avoid violating the morals of my community. Many licensing agencies will revoke a physician’s license for offending the morals of the community (“moral turpitude”).
5. To avoid attempting to do things that other specialists can do better. The “stones” referred to are kidney stones or bladder stones, removal of which was judged too menial for physicians, and therefore was left for barbers (the forerunners of modern surgeons). Surgery was not recognized as a specialty at that time. This sentence is now interpreted as acknowledging that it is impossible for any single physician to maintain expertise in all areas. It also highlights the different historical origins of the surgeon and the physician.
6. To keep the good of the patient as the highest priority. There may be other conflicting ‘good purposes,’ such as community welfare, conserving economic resources, supporting the criminal justice system, or simply making money for the physician or his employer that provide recurring challenges to physicians.
7. To avoid sexual relationships or other inappropriate entanglements with patients and families. The value of avoiding conflicts of interest, and the misuse of the superior position of the physician for self gratification, are not often questioned.

Posted by: Vickie | April 8, 2008, 12:51 pm 12:51 pm

That Clinton never named the woman or violated her privacy and simply relayed a story, with some variations (as it happens when stories are repeated), making the larger point that the health care system is broken and needs to be fixed.
Instead of trying to smear Clinton, we should focus on the issues.

Posted by: Joan | April 8, 2008, 12:54 pm 12:54 pm

Lauren,
At least you are consistent. Hillary was the villain when Obama was “twisting the truth” in the last column, and she is till the villain here. You always remain true to the Obama code. Arrrrrrr!
========================================
Arrrrrrr!!
=======================================

Posted by: WestCoastMessenger | April 8, 2008, 12:54 pm 12:54 pm

Angela,
You are an innocent my child. You obviously made up your mind, just now, having read the atrocious facts. This election is a horror isn’t it. You can’t trust Hillary because she told a story about the messed up health care system, and we know its not messed up. It’s perfect.
========================================
The health care system is perfect! Arrr!
Perfect for a pirate! Arrrr!
========================================

Posted by: WestCoastMessenger | April 8, 2008, 12:57 pm 12:57 pm

This is a lesson to Hillary.
People just don’t trust anything she says any more. Even when she tries to say the truth, people still doubt her.
She has built a reputation for lies which will take her some time to change.

Posted by: Geldo | April 8, 2008, 1:01 pm 1:01 pm

WCM
You got to admit that if Hillary did not lie about Bosnia for 1 she would not be called a liar.
Once again lets blame Obama for Hillary untruths.
Furthermore it was not just Obama supporters calling Hillary a Liar …But as they Say If The Shoe Fits Wear It.
She Must Take Responsibility For What Comes Out Of Her Mouth and for What she does and votes on.

Posted by: Lauren | April 8, 2008, 1:02 pm 1:02 pm

No Hillary is not a liar the media has painted her as one for thier own gain they have singled her out it could be a gender thing I think they would not dare say that about a male running for President.

Posted by: Bishop | April 8, 2008, 1:04 pm 1:04 pm

This is a lesson to Hillary.
People just don’t trust anything she says any more. Even when she tries to say the truth, people still doubt her.
She has built a reputation for lies which will take her some time to change.

Posted by: Geldo | April 8, 2008, 1:05 pm 1:05 pm

Geldo,
Imagine yourself running for office, and having hundreds of thousands of people tearing away at every nuance of everything you say. Then there are people re-interpreting your statements and hundreds of thousands of people tearing away at the re-intepretations. Do we really know what any politician has said. Jake is pointing to an original source here, finally, and you can make up your own mind if you go to that source. That fact that Hillary’s name was sullied on this story has nothing to do with Hillary, it’s more about the American people and the fact that they like a good fight.
=======================================
Arrrrrgggghhhhhh! Cat fight!
=======================================

Posted by: WestCoastMessenger | April 8, 2008, 1:05 pm 1:05 pm

Before you shoot off your mouth, get your facts staight? That would be a good lesson. And one that Dogsoldier and Westcoastmess could also benefit from!
Obama 2008 — Yes, WE CAN!!!

Posted by: Jackt51 | April 8, 2008, 1:06 pm 1:06 pm

@ Lauren
You’re totally right.
She should have done a background check on the deceased.
A sheriff’s deputy isn’t a trustworthy source!
You’re a genius.

Posted by: John | April 8, 2008, 1:08 pm 1:08 pm

Jackt51,
Dogsoldier and I would definitely benefit from people getting their facts straight before shooting their mouth off here. It makes our job harder to have to correct you first before engaging in our spin on it.
=======================================
Just the facts, Jack.
Arrrrrrggggggggggggghhhhhhhh!
=======================================

Posted by: WestCoastMessenger | April 8, 2008, 1:08 pm 1:08 pm

I want to say one thing to the American people. Everybody does it & I want you to listen to me. I did not have sexual relations with that woman, Miss Lewinsky. never. These allegations are false. And I need to go back to work for the American people. Thank you.

Posted by: B-1 | April 8, 2008, 1:09 pm 1:09 pm

Bishop
Duck and run to awaiting cars sniper fire ? Not a Liar?I was always not for NAFTA well in public when her Hubby passed it we did not hear her say in the Media I AM NOT FOR NAFTA. Not until she was running for Office was she publicly against NAFTA.

Posted by: Lauren | April 8, 2008, 1:09 pm 1:09 pm

Media scrutiny? This poor family and friends have been bothered endlessly by the media just so the could find something new to attack Hillary with. Hunting down children in campaign commercials, a aunt that lost to family members, who’s next. Could we save time and just have the media repeat 24 hours a day “We hate Hillary!We hate Hillary”and we all can take a rest till it’s time to vote.

Posted by: Kenny from CT. | April 8, 2008, 1:09 pm 1:09 pm

@ Jackt51
Give Obama that advice because a vacation to Pakistan doesn’t count as experience!

Posted by: John | April 8, 2008, 1:11 pm 1:11 pm

B1
You forgot It is the VAST right wing who is out to get Bill.
She is a stalker , mentally unbalanced.
Never can say i was wrong.
It was sleep deprivation.

Posted by: Lauren | April 8, 2008, 1:12 pm 1:12 pm

So if she wins the Presidency, is she or Obama going to lie to get what they want – YES of course, a Lib lies when ever their mouth opens!
Vickie Good reading of the oath but too bad it does not apply to this since she was not denied care – Also keep that #3 in mind when it comes to abortion, since by that they should never give abortions.

Posted by: spock | April 8, 2008, 1:14 pm 1:14 pm

Thanks – Dogsoldier. I feel badly that you that you glean all of your information for voting from newspapers and pundits. I’m fairly certain you can get the voting records online now. =-)
If you enjoy reading this much – maybe take a peak at the Starr report, congressional records, the White Water issue, the records that were found at the White House residence that were “missing” for 3 years after investigators supeaoned them.
You might also want to check out the banking records for the Cayman Island bank accounts the Clinton’s maintain and also their investments in foreign governements. While you are at it, you might want to check out the Clinton Library donor listing. Oh wait, the Clintons are having a “hard time” getting that together. You could also check out the source of the 5 million “loan” to the campaign – oh wait, they need 3 extra years to file that.
See the pattern? I don’t know how old you are, but if you went through the 90′s with the Clinton’s, you would not trust them either. Evidently over 50% of Americans don’t.
It’s sad to see someone have so much faith in the Clintons when their history of deception, lies and “misstatements” is so well recorded in court transcripts, legal record, voting records, etc. I think they underestimated the easy availability of their history to the American public, hence the hard time they are having selling the notion that they are “on our side”.

Posted by: Angela | April 8, 2008, 1:14 pm 1:14 pm

Who don’t think Obama is not a Liar??
He is just exactly the same…

Posted by: True Truth | April 8, 2008, 1:15 pm 1:15 pm

Lauren,
What is your candidate’s position on NAFTA? What is your candidate’s position on anything? I think it’s fair for you to take issue with Hillary’s authentic positions, but you should not repeat what you heard in these blogs
as the source of those positions. You’ve adopted a hate all things Hillary posture, you disregard the topic of this blog, and you launch into diatribes about Hillary. For what purpose, to make Obama look better?
=======================================
Hillary stands up for all voters!
=======================================

Posted by: WestCoastMessenger | April 8, 2008, 1:16 pm 1:16 pm

John
Thank You
Its to bad i can not say the same.

Posted by: Lauren | April 8, 2008, 1:16 pm 1:16 pm

You know I’m sure it was very dangerous no matter what they say . Every time I saw my loved ones off when they went to a war zone I always believed it was dangerous.

Posted by: Bishop | April 8, 2008, 1:16 pm 1:16 pm

Is being a first lady the experience one needs to be president?
What decisions was Hillary making as first lady?
Being married to a lawyer doesn’t make you one. Being married to a comedian doesn’t make you to be funny.

Posted by: Geldo | April 8, 2008, 1:17 pm 1:17 pm

I guess she sat under a rock and being as bright as she is took nothing in.

Posted by: Bishop | April 8, 2008, 1:18 pm 1:18 pm

Angela,
Are you serious? Take a look at the Starr report? Remind me of what party that Ken Starr belongs to? How much did we spend on his failure?
=======================================
Ken Starr (only cost us $millions)
=======================================

Posted by: WestCoastMessenger | April 8, 2008, 1:19 pm 1:19 pm

Angela – So you do faint at Obama speeches? Thought so.

Posted by: Dogsoldier | April 8, 2008, 1:21 pm 1:21 pm

Jack51
Havent you learned yet ? The facts are what team Hillary wants them to be.
Only Hillary matters. Its not about all of our rights. Its only about Hillary winning.
So i guess that means we are supposed to shut up and say yes my queen ..yes my queen.

Posted by: Lauren | April 8, 2008, 1:22 pm 1:22 pm

Hillary was for universal healthcare when it wasn’t cool. She has been beaten down by the media, the left wing and the right wing for every minor infraction both real and imagined. We will one day look back on this election and feel sadness for how unjustly Hillary has been treated. We will realize what a horrible mistake we have made just as we did after Gore lost in 2000. In a few years many will come to this realization, many of us know today.

Posted by: Firefighter | April 8, 2008, 1:23 pm 1:23 pm

We would invite all former first ladies and family members to run for presidency because they were all in the whitehouse with the president.
So they all have experience.

Posted by: Geldo | April 8, 2008, 1:23 pm 1:23 pm

Lauren,
The candidate’s sexuality has nothing to do with this. I’ve heard stories about Obama but I don’t engage in that drivel.
=======================================
Evaluate the candidate, not their sex!
=======================================

Posted by: WestCoastMessenger | April 8, 2008, 1:27 pm 1:27 pm

@Geldo
Ther are more than a few that could hold thier own I have great faith in the females that have been our first lady’s

Posted by: Bishop | April 8, 2008, 1:27 pm 1:27 pm

Geldo – Experience and Obama. Isn’t that an oxymoron? Of course Obama NOW claims to have more foreign policy experience than either McCain or Clinton. If you visit Kenya and dress up as an Muslim and go to Muslim school in Indonesia is the sum total of Obama’s “foreign” policy “experience.” Like I said, oxymoron.

Posted by: Dogsoldier | April 8, 2008, 1:29 pm 1:29 pm

This is such a nonstory. All the candidates spout anecdotes they have picked up on the campaign trail. In fact, Obama does it over and over. I take all of them with a grain of salt as to whether or not they are “accurate.” They remind me of the parables-teaching tools, not historically based, but nevertheless a vehicle for making a point.

Posted by: countallthevotes | April 8, 2008, 1:30 pm 1:30 pm

Lauren – So Obama is not in this to “win” either?

Posted by: Dogsoldier | April 8, 2008, 1:30 pm 1:30 pm

Geldo,
So am I to understand from your viewpoint that spouses (who happen to be attorneys, who have worked on the Watergate investigation, who have worked on the Children’s Defense Fund, who have been long term advocates of Health Care) are just basically incapable of understanding the working environment in which they are exposed to?
=======================================
Arrrrrghhhhh!
=======================================

Posted by: WestCoastMessenger | April 8, 2008, 1:30 pm 1:30 pm

Geldo posted:
“Is being a first lady the experience one needs to be president?
What decisions was Hillary making as first lady?
Being married to a lawyer doesn’t make you one. Being married to a comedian doesn’t make you to be funny.”
—————-
You are right… However, being married to a lawyer will give you opportunity to look at what the law pratice is… being married to a comedian will give your opportunity to know how a comedian make a life…
Being a first lady will let you know how the country will be managed if you worked hard to learn…
Being a first lady is a golden opportunity if you do care the country and how the country is run and what is inside the whole world…
So being a first lay will be a very unique experience to learn how to run the country if you want…
It will be much better than someone who has zero experience and doesn’t know what is extractly needed to run this country…

Posted by: True Truth | April 8, 2008, 1:31 pm 1:31 pm

Firefighter: to correct you a little.
Hillary tried to work on a health care plan for the nation, but was unsuccessful. She held closed door meetings (of course), failed to build consensus, lead others, etc. Her try at universal health care failed and she did not revisit that issue until now, coincidently now that she’s running an election.
Her current healthcare “solution” will require all to carry it whether they need it or not. For those who already have health insurance, we won’t want a mandate and penalty for not subscribing to her plan. Barack Obama’s plan is for people who are underinsured or uninsured, not a mandate for all people.

Posted by: Angela | April 8, 2008, 1:31 pm 1:31 pm

Can we just get off this story already. The media drags it on with their little spin to still make Hillary look like she made the story different. I read that the Aunt of the woman said it was true and she said she voted for Hillary and was glad she did. By the way, the heading was in very small letters and placed underneath a bigger story as an afterthought. I also just read that Obama claimed in a speech the other day that he has more foreign policy experience than both Hillary and McCain. Hillary responded that she was speechless he would say that but hopefully the voters will know better and look at his past record.

Posted by: Bon53 | April 8, 2008, 1:33 pm 1:33 pm

I read this last night and i think we all could use a laugh.
Proud vet if you see this thank you !!
An airplane was about to crash; there were 5 passengers on board, but had only 4 parachutes.The first passenger said, “I am Kobe Bryant, the best NBA basketball player; the Laker’s need me, I can’t afford to die.” So he took the first pack and left the plane.The second passenger, Hillary Clinton said, “I am the wife of the former U.S. President, a Senator from New York , and a potential future president. I am the smartest woman in American history, so America ‘s people don’t want me to die.” She took the second pack and jumped out of the plane.The third passenger, John Kerry, said, “I’m the Senator from the great state of Massachusetts “. I was my party’s last nominee for President. So he grabbed the pack next to him and jumped.The fourth passenger, President George W. Bush, said to the fifth passenger, a10-year-old schoolgirl, “I have lived a full life, and served my country well, I will sacrifice my life and let you have the last parachute.”The girl said, “That’s okay There’s a parachute left for you. America ‘s smartest woman took my schoolbag.”
Posted by:
Proud Vet

Posted by: Lauren | April 8, 2008, 1:36 pm 1:36 pm

Bishop ====== There is more to the presidency than meeting people around the world.
Qualities like – good management skills, good leadership skills, self control, ability to make quick decisions, negotiating skills etc.
You don’t acquire these abilities by being a first lady.

Posted by: Geldo | April 8, 2008, 1:36 pm 1:36 pm

Universal health plan has been widely implemented in Canada and the most civilized european countries..
Everyone has health insurance is the ultimate goal of civilization…
John Edwards also highly promoted it..

Posted by: True Truth | April 8, 2008, 1:36 pm 1:36 pm

The mainstream media will do ANYTHING they can to ensure Obama wins the presidency.
They’re not even trying to hide it anymore. I just read a Martha Raddatz piece about how supposedly the troops are all for Obama. That’s what they want you to think. They must think Obama needs so much help to win. Why is that? Because he’s a weak candidate, and they know it.
And the media wonders why they have approval ratings in the teens.

Posted by: Jo | April 8, 2008, 1:39 pm 1:39 pm

Jo === if Obama was weak, he wouldn’t be able to bias the media in his favour.
The media is made up of intelligent and knowledgeable human beings, not robots.

Posted by: Geldo | April 8, 2008, 1:43 pm 1:43 pm

Lauren – Wright. Joke? Obama sits in Wright’s church for twenty years and never heard a thing. Then Obama defended Wright by throwing grandma under the bus because she was a “typical white person”. However, grandma was still moving so Obama backed up the bus and ran over grandma again. Why? Who cares, she was still moving wasn’t she?

Posted by: Dogsoldier | April 8, 2008, 1:43 pm 1:43 pm

No one has any experience to start with…
However, the difference is taht someone can grap every opportunity to learn and build up his/her experience and accomplishment…
Being a firt lady is a golden opportunity to get to know what is exactly needed to lead the country… Some one missed this chance to learn.. some one took this chance to equip herself…
That is extractly every leader should have: don’t miss every chance to learn and equip yourself for better…

Posted by: True Truth | April 8, 2008, 1:44 pm 1:44 pm

Geldo – Do you get a shiver up your leg like Chris Matthews at MSNBC?

Posted by: Dogsoldier | April 8, 2008, 1:45 pm 1:45 pm

Jo
Do you Know why you use the Kool-aid is it because when you were growing up your parents could afford real juice?
When others (who aren’t millionaires)could not afford it. Keep putting down the poor. If that what you think that makes you BETTER than the rest for the working class poor. I wonder If Hillary approves of you bashing the Middle Class that she is supposedly representing.
I hope you and the others that use that term are sooooo proud that they were born RICH.
So keep on using that term and watch the WORKING CLASS not vote for the Millionaire who through you is obvious doesn’t understand as a Parent you buy what you can afford to get at least a little vitamin c.

Posted by: Lauren | April 8, 2008, 1:47 pm 1:47 pm

Jo,
That caring is only one-sided, they ignore the fact that Obama admitted cocaine usage, they ignore the fact that Obama admitted that he had a “boneheaded” relationship with Rezko (although he gained $250,000 in value out of it), they ignore the fact that he has been in a relationship with a hate-spewing reverend for 20 years, and he makes light of the guy, that he’s like an old uncle (the crazy uncle defense?), and they ignore the fact that he takes money from oil company executives.
=======================================
Obama helps us see!
Before Obama we were blind!
=======================================

Posted by: WestCoastMessenger | April 8, 2008, 1:48 pm 1:48 pm

I am really looking forward to the debate. This will go down in history as the best battle since Spartacus met Marcus Crassus.
So much fun. Here is a quote from one of those post baby boomer geniuses who give him money, Marc Andressen:
“We then asked, well, what about foreign policy — should we be concerned that you just don’t have much experience there?
He said, directly, two things.
First, he said, I’m on the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, where I serve with a number of Senators who are widely regarded as leading experts on foreign policy — and I can tell you that I know as much about foreign policy at this point as most of them.
Being a fan of blunt answers, I liked that one. But then he made what I think is the really good point.
He said — and I’m going to paraphrase a little here: think about who I am — my father was Kenyan; I have close relatives in a small rural village in Kenya to this day; and I spent several years of my childhood living in Jakarta, Indonesia. Think about what it’s going to mean in many parts of the world — parts of the world that we really care about — when I show up as the President of the United States. I’ll be fundamentally changing the world’s perception of what the United States is all about.
He’s got my vote.”
I’ll bet he does and he has your money.

Posted by: len | April 8, 2008, 1:49 pm 1:49 pm

WestCoastMessanger, russel, Jo, Jay, Jgaw, et al, HillLovers, you have to understand that presidency is not a sexually transmitted disease, so you cannot catch it or be able to exercise it by sleeping with someone who is a president. Being a gracious first lady is a ceremonial function, it is not a professional,political or administrative function. Period. Re the hospital story, Hill the Bosnian General has missed it again, she mispoke again. That is the important point here. Hill the Bosnian General should not force anybody to buy a health insurance. Even Castro will not do that to his people. Obama’s plan is the best plan because lowering the cost is most significant than pushing people to buy what they camnnot afford as Hill’s plan is imposing. In Mass. plan similar to HillaryCare have been assessed as dysfunctional and non affordable. God bless America and God bless Obama. OBAMA08.

Posted by: BKMC | April 8, 2008, 1:49 pm 1:49 pm

Unforrunately, Obama was not be able to be given the opportunity to be “the first lady”…
He was given the opportunity to be a street lawyer to learn his experience…
There is nothing wrong about it…it is just different experience, which most people can learn as well..

Posted by: True Truth | April 8, 2008, 1:50 pm 1:50 pm

True Truth – The president and 1st lady are not inseparable. Most of the time they are away on their own schedules (refer to Lewinsky matter as the to scheduling). She has misrepresented so much about her “35 years” now, that all of it is questionable.
About healthcare:
Words vs. Solutions
Hillary SAYS health care is a vital issue.
Hillary DOES:
Campaign finance records also reveal that Clinton, a champion of universal health care, was late paying nearly $300,000 in health care premiums for her campaign staff.
She can’t even effectively fire Penn.
Obama 08

Posted by: Angela | April 8, 2008, 1:51 pm 1:51 pm

@Lauren
Did you ever hear of Jim Jones and kool-aid that is why we are using it not because are parents were poor.

Posted by: Bishop | April 8, 2008, 1:52 pm 1:52 pm

The story is true. A hospital refused her treatment for lack of $100. She was turned away went to another hospital where her baby died. Then she died later.
True story!
Much more true than Obama saying his parents met at a civil rights march when he was already 4 years old for example.

Posted by: s.b. | April 8, 2008, 1:59 pm 1:59 pm

Bishop
could you please tell me about it
Because to me it its a put down to all those who could not afford to buy real juice. Poor whites and Blacks.
I would appreciate it.

Posted by: Lauren | April 8, 2008, 2:01 pm 2:01 pm

Angela,
First lady is NOT president for sure…
However, like I pointed, it is an given opportunity to know how a president to run the country…
Most first ladies don’t care how their husband to run the country but a few do…Hillary is one of a few who has desire to lead this country…How much has she learned and equiped herself will be up to American voters to judge…
But never understimate your fellow woman the desire to learn and try to lead the country for better…
BTW, please don’t do personal attack to your fellows..It is a committed SIN under the God’s name…

Posted by: True Truth | April 8, 2008, 2:03 pm 2:03 pm

American are so great!
not only import foreign goods, but also import president from Kenya and Insonesia.
It looks like everything from foreign country is better than oreginated in America.

Posted by: joke | April 8, 2008, 2:07 pm 2:07 pm

well then i guess it would be befitting
to use it against Hillary followers. Like they say what is good for the goose is good for the gander.
But I personally will not use it because as i stated above, there are thousands of children in this Country who do not get real juice because the Parents can not afford it. I also believe people are using it to put down African Americans and those who want Barack Obama as a put down.

Posted by: Lauren | April 8, 2008, 2:24 pm 2:24 pm

True truth – no personal attacks from me. These are well documented historical facts about the Clintons – not misstatements.
I don’t think being 1st lady is any more experience, probably less, than a cabinet member would have. Essentially, they are both senators. One traveled more.

Posted by: Angela | April 8, 2008, 2:25 pm 2:25 pm

I don’t know what you are geting at I just know that it is an expression that has been used when you see people who follow after some one and mainly since it was reported in the media that the JIm Jone cult leaders gave thier followers kool-aid laced with poison

Posted by: Bishop | April 8, 2008, 2:27 pm 2:27 pm

Lauren
I don’t use it but if I did I am not putting anyone down we drank out of a hose if we wanted a drink. unless it was meal time then it was milk or kool-aid . Most of the kids in our working class s nighberhood drank kool-aid cost 5cents a pack and 2cups of sugar.

Posted by: Bishop | April 8, 2008, 2:35 pm 2:35 pm

Angela,
One correction:
Yes, they are both Senators NOW:
Obama- 3 years
Hillary – 7 years;
More than twice of Senator experience..

Posted by: True Truth | April 8, 2008, 2:36 pm 2:36 pm

Please interview the deceased woman’s Aunt and discover that the reason why she could not seek treatment is because the hospital had informed her in correspondence that they would not treat her without $100.00. So Clinton told the truth and we still don’t have a retraction from the media.
At that point I hope you spend as much due diligence in vetting Obama’s stories about not having ever seen a survey with his handwriting on it or denying his surrogates met with Canada about NAFTA when they clearly did.

Posted by: Jackie | April 8, 2008, 2:40 pm 2:40 pm

Bishop
It is meant as a derogatory statement against blacks because they buy it.
They drink it all the time. According to some. They have been using it since the begiining when it first became available because it had vitamin c in it. It was popular in the homes ( white and black ) were buying juice real juice
was something you could not afford.

Posted by: Lauren | April 8, 2008, 2:40 pm 2:40 pm

Spock:
She WAS denied care at the clinic. She was told to fork over $100 or forget about any more care. THAT is why she went to the other hospital where she was cared for and died.

Posted by: Vickie | April 8, 2008, 2:41 pm 2:41 pm

Since the media will not allow Clinton to ask….where are the records of Obama’s state Senate terms….Does the media really believe the Obama stories of “there were none” and/or “they are lost”.

Posted by: Jackie | April 8, 2008, 2:42 pm 2:42 pm

Bishop
My appology if I offended you it was not meant to offend anyone . It does Offend me thou when others use it.
I guess even thou we dont agree politically we have a lot in common.
We are and have been from the working poor.
I hope you accept my apology.

Posted by: Lauren | April 8, 2008, 2:45 pm 2:45 pm

the truth of the matter is that Hillary saw a story that fit perfectly into her agenda, especially if she altered it a little… but in all honesty what candidate can we trust? Media’s opinion of the president changed when Nixon came around for the second time, but when 9-11 happened, the US fell back in love with their leaders. Unfortunately, the tides are turning once again, truths are being twisted and the political race is dancing around the more specific and important issues we need to be focusing on.

Posted by: Megan G | April 8, 2008, 2:58 pm 2:58 pm

I’m really getting tired of the media spending so much time tearing apart these stories. It is amazing that they have such attention to detail to the stories/examples that Hillary states and ignore others. The point is that our medical/insurance system needs some serious attention. Pay attention to the bigger picture!

Posted by: sarnorton | April 8, 2008, 3:00 pm 3:00 pm

Hilsry did not lie about the story. She got the information from the sheriff deputy. People are trying to find every little bit that they can find wrong with what Clintion did.
Look at the moral of Clintion’s sorty: the health care system is messed up and needs to be fixed. Why are people so against health care? No one will complain when they are going to the emergency room with no money to pay for it.
And “NEWSFLASH”: under Clinton’s plan, your health care pay wwill go accordingly to your income. So, if you make $0.00 guess what? Your health care costs will be $0.00. And if your make a substantial amount of money, it will go according to the money you make. You will not miss the money spent on your coverage when you realize how your debt would build should you not have health care coverage.
Are some people so anti-Hillary that they could care less about their own well-being? I don’t support Obama but I like his ideas for college students. I just have a stronger support for Hillary.
She was not lying so stop making a big deal over this.

Posted by: Kristen White | April 8, 2008, 3:13 pm 3:13 pm

Oh and another thing..if your running for Pres. and your a Senator, shouldnt you have the resources to be able to FACT CHECK your stories, before you let the words fly outta your mouth. If she cant even do simple fact checking on the things she talks about…what will happen when she’s in office? Is she going to rely on the media to do the grunt work for her?

Posted by: Michelle | April 8, 2008, 3:21 pm 3:21 pm

I can relate to this as i have a situation simular and cannot get into a clinic to have it taken care of. The public health dept. will not take the necessary tests for my situation, and yet, when i visit my specialists on a workmans comp injury they are absolutely mortified that my public health doctors wont check into the numerous lumps on my thyroid. I owe the clinic 129.00 from a past bill. But…a year and a half ago i paid over 1,600.00 in past medical expenses occured from my children during my claim for disability. I paid those right up front when i was able. They had “forgotten” this one bill, and now that I an on disability and have not the money to pay that 129.00, they refuse me. This is not right. I am a widow, 10 months ago I had 6 sscrews put into my back. Its not like I can work an extra shift to make this money.I have medical coverage through my disability now, so it isnt like i would be incurring any more to this bill. It just isnt right.

Posted by: jody | April 8, 2008, 3:28 pm 3:28 pm

The smartest woman in the world should have enough sense to investigate, verify, substantiate and confirm data before before moving forward with a story like this. As for Ms Bechtell; (1) don’t get pregant if you can’t afford it, (2) any poor person, even illegals, can get FREE medical care anywhere in the country. What do you think hard working Americans are for; do you believe they are just supposed to work hard all their lives to keep the economy going, save and invest their money for retirement and maybe enjoy a few years at the end of their lives…greety bastards, don’t they know they live in America? This is the land of the FREE and handouts for anyone in the world that is willing to TAKE rather than contribute.

Posted by: Noexcuses | April 8, 2008, 3:28 pm 3:28 pm

Thanks for setting the record and story straight for us Jake! With almost every other word coming out of Hillary’s mouth either being a lie or attack one never knows whats up with her! As usual, a grain of truth can be found in her daily exaggerations! Clearly a desperate woman in a failing campaign who will stop at nothing! Good report!

Posted by: Jim Kiricov | April 8, 2008, 3:30 pm 3:30 pm

You people all ask what experience does the candidates have? Lets look at the past Presidents?
Jimmy Carter – Ga Gov – No Federal experience
Ronald Reagan – Ca Gov – No Federal experience
George Bush Sr. – Foreign policy / CIA
Bill Clinton – Ark Gov – No Federal experience
George W. Bush – One Term TX Gov – No Federal experience.
Get the point people? I don’t care if Obama only has 3 yrs experience. These commercials about waking up and 3am calls are joke. Hillary what was your foreign policy experience? Wall-Mart NAFTA board of governors? What was your husbands experience?

Posted by: M | April 8, 2008, 3:37 pm 3:37 pm

What I find infuriating about all of this is that ALL of the candidates have lied and overstated events that have occured, but it is the Obama supporters who refuse to believe that he has lied or mis-represented the facts. I mean lets get real, the man lived his life, made many statements regarding his history and much of it was fabricated, or should I say he simply overstated the facts. Did anyone ask him to verify his own story??? You will NEVER get the complete truth from a politician, so get over yourselves and vote for the person that has the best platform. If we waited until we had an Honest Abe again, we would not have a President for many years.

Posted by: Karen | April 8, 2008, 3:42 pm 3:42 pm

Every emergency department in the country must evaluate and stabilize an emergent patient, regardless of their citizenship, ability to pay, credit score, past due bills, or any factor. (look up EMTALA) That is NOT to say that if you show up with a sprained ankle or a cold that you will necessarily be treated…those are not emergent conditions and with home care you will do just fine.
Ms Clinton’s account of the facts in this case is an excellent example of “truthiness” – rather than actual facts, its a gut reaction, the emotion that drives the discourse. If anything, this shading of facts is a real turn off. I don’t want a POTUS to be carefully packaging facts to get me to feel a certain way.

Posted by: Cliff | April 8, 2008, 3:52 pm 3:52 pm

Angela,
Hillary did try to pass Universal Health Care and she did fail. She is however the only one in this country to make a serious attempt. There is no guarantee that things will change with health insurance regardless of who wins the election. I do know that Hillary is a fighter and she will NOT give up. The feeling I have with Obama is that he will roll over when faced with confrontation. As for those who don’t “need” health insurance that argument doesn’t fly. There are those who may claim not to “need” car insurance but for the sake of everyone else they must have it. I don’t want to pay for those who aren’t willing to carry health insurance just as I don’t want to pay for those who won’t carry car insurance.

Posted by: Firefighter | April 8, 2008, 4:25 pm 4:25 pm

Firefighter:
No. Hillary hasn’t completely achieved this goal yet B U T
what she DID accomplish was to get health care for over 6,000,000 children…and that was a strong beginning.
Which is why I say:
GIVE’EM HELL, HILLARY!!!!

Posted by: questioner | April 8, 2008, 4:54 pm 4:54 pm

Thanks for reporting on this and clearing it up in a way that makes sense. I am a physician, and it seemed obvious that what was said by Senator Clinton could not be true, and that what the press reported on after they “investigated” was also not the full or accurate story. This explanation doesn’t make it less tragic, but does let us know that the system works the way it is supposed to at the current time…and by that I just mean to reinforce that it is against federal law for any hospital to deny emergency care to any person at any time. That would have been even more tragic.

Posted by: Audrey | April 8, 2008, 4:56 pm 4:56 pm

This story ALWAYS had some truth to it. The hospital never claimed otherwise. The reason it asked the Clintons to stop using it was the problem parts it still has.

Posted by: kravitz | April 8, 2008, 5:10 pm 5:10 pm

Lazy journalism!

Posted by: russell | April 8, 2008, 5:24 pm 5:24 pm

Forget about the heathcare system for a moment. What’s more interesting is that Clinton believed the officer and used that story in her speech. She didn’t even verify it. She had no qualms about telling an anectodal story in her speech. She wasn’t an anonymous poster at a forum or blog. She said it in a speech. Politicians distort the truth when they’re elected, but they try to present themselves as cleanly as possible before being elected. If that’s how she is now, what is she going to be like if elected?

Posted by: Imus | April 8, 2008, 6:17 pm 6:17 pm

This is a tragic story. What surprised me is that Hillary Clinton, who presents herself as one of the leading experts in the US on health care, did not see some of the inconsistencies in this story. Did she not know that it would be illegal for the hospital not to see this patient as reported above. This makes me question not only her truthfulness but her competence as well.

Posted by: Steve | April 8, 2008, 8:07 pm 8:07 pm

Remember Obama’s story about the captain in Afghanistan? That wasn’t vetted and only ABC got the name of the captain and claimed that the story checked out. Except nobody else was able to. We know ABC is one of the most pro-Obama networks around (Jake Tapper in particular). Why doesn’t that surprise me: the media goes into conniptions about Clinton’s anecdotes and gives Obami a free pass. The point is, the anecdote highlights the need for universal health insurance. For whatever reason, the woman who died believed she needed $100 to see a doc and that was the fundamental problem – it is irrelevant whether she owed the clinic money. And to all the bloggers questioning Clinton’s motive and statements, I hope that you will never be in the same situation as that most unfortunate mother.

Posted by: alee25 | April 8, 2008, 9:24 pm 9:24 pm

THE FIRST ENTIRE WEEKEND THE STORY BROKE, NOBODY MENTIONED A SHERIFF HAD TOLD HILLARY THE STORY. IT WAS, HILLARY IS ATA IT AGAIN!!!
THE OMISSION WAS DELIBERATE AND JAKE TAPPER KNEW EXACTLY WHAT HE WAS DOING.
PEOPLE WHO ACCUSE HILLARY OF NOT REPORTING THE TRUTH FAIL TO REPORT THE TRUTH THEMSELVES
THAT WAS DELIBERATE,MR JAKE TAPPER. I THINK YOU FEEL WHAT CHRIS MATHEWS FEELS RUNNING UP HIS LEG… SICKENING

Posted by: TJ | April 8, 2008, 10:00 pm 10:00 pm

Im sorry, But this is my BEST FRIENDS FAMILY we are talking about here;; If you dont mind, Stop “gossiping” it isnt the truth. This reminds me of some high school rumor that everyone seems to think is the “truth” OH MY GOD. this is someones family you are talking about here, LEAVE IT BE unless you know the truth.

Posted by: Christa | April 8, 2008, 10:34 pm 10:34 pm

People don’t seem to focus on the one true main point, that this woman would be alive if everyone had health care all the time. She wouldn’t have been in debt and would have gotten the care she needed immediately. The details are really pretty darn irrelevant and are just distracting from the real problem. Every American needs good, free health care like most of the civilized countries of the world.

Posted by: Judy | April 8, 2008, 10:46 pm 10:46 pm

Christa, who states you were her friend, please help me get the story straight. Feel free to email me at bigkahunareports@hotmail.com and keep up with the story at http://www.noquarterusa.net.
i’m not done with this story until its told fully.

Posted by: BigKahuna | April 9, 2008, 12:07 am 12:07 am

And folks, it is shameful that the entirety of this thread is filled with partisan bickering over candidates. THE STORY IS ABOUT TRINA and TRAY. Have some respect. I don’t care if Clinton says she’s been to Mars.
I care if the memory of Trina Bachtel and Tray Hutton are being ignored so that you can fight over your candidates or your politics.
Have you no shame?

Posted by: BigKahuna | April 9, 2008, 12:22 am 12:22 am

So many people miss the point. The reason that healthcare is in such a bad state is that unscrupulous lawyers are suing doctors for malpractice.
I am not an advocate of limiting the payment that a legitimately injured patient can receive, but if the amount that a lawyer can make for pursuing a claim was a fixed feee, regardless of the payout, it would stop many of the lawsuits in their tracks.
Does anyone believe that Hillary a liar (oops, lawyer) by trade would limit the payout of fellow liars (oops, lawyers)?
Doctors are paying out hundreds of thousands of dollars (per doctor) on insurance premiums each year
How much would you charge, if in order to make one dollar, you had to generate more than $300,000 to cover office expenses and malpractice insurance?
Hillary’s system will bankrupt the country, because she is only trying to address syptoms of the disease while ignoring the root cause.
When Hillary originally proposed this system, she (and others) pointed to the Canadian (bankrupt) model for nationalised healthcare as a shining example.
Those who don’t know Hillary, vote for Hillary.

Posted by: Ron | April 9, 2008, 12:55 am 12:55 am

So tragic and pathetic death of a 7 month pregnant pizza shop worker just because of not able to pay only $100 bill or lack of health insurance.Its so inhumanly act.

Posted by: Kaushik | April 9, 2008, 3:41 am 3:41 am

At what point did Obama address Sen. Clinton’s story about the young woman? He hasn’t. So how is this a knock against Sen. Obama?
Everytime Hilary “misspeaks” is it somehow Obama’s fault? Some people are just born stupid.
Some of you, both Obama and Clinton supporters, treat the election like its supporting your favorite sports team: All or nothing. Grow up and vote in the best interests of your children, morons.
Get rid of Bush policies. Support so-called radicals like Ron Paul who want to get rid of the Fed, income taxes and preemptive wars. Throw your support behind whichever candidate becomes the nominee and let’s get this country back to being the best in the world.

Posted by: J Smith | April 9, 2008, 3:50 am 3:50 am

To the poster who stated: “Everyone in this country should have FREE medical insurance.”
Young lady, there is no such thing as FREE – it always has to be paid for by the taxpayers – the only money the government has is yours and mine and when they haven’t got enough they simply print some more. And they never, ever have enough.
As for the story itself and HRC – before she ever repeated one word of what Holman told her she should have had someone in her campaign fully, and I fully, vet the story. She got it wrong and then repeated the same error. The MSM has attempted to justify the story as “partially” correct – that isn’t going to cut it. The media and the Clinton campaign both lied and now they are attempting to justify their error with the rationale that “at least part of the story is true.”
There appears to be no honest and impartial media in existence in this day and age. And that includes the weather people.

Posted by: dharper | April 9, 2008, 4:15 pm 4:15 pm

I had my own experience, similar to that. Jake is correct, the facts around the story do no erase the struggles of millions who are uninsured.
I don’t want to live in a country where people have to hold bake sales to get cancer surgery!!!

Posted by: Catriley | April 10, 2008, 5:14 pm 5:14 pm

Leave a Reply

Do you have more information about this topic? If so, please click here to contact the editors of ABC News.