McCain Adviser Brushes Off Rove’s Criticism
ABC News’ Teddy Davis and Tahman Bradley Report: Top McCain adviser Charlie Black labeled the presumptive Republican nominee "a populist" on Thursday while brushing off former Bush adviser Karl Rove’s criticism that the Arizona senator is unduly demonizing American companies.
"Sen. McCain has frequently received some criticism for taking on big industries," Black told NPR’s "All Things Considered." "John McCain is a populist. He believes in free markets; he believes in limited government and having the free enterprise system produce the jobs and the prosperity that he seeks, but he does think, as did Teddy Roosevelt, that you do need government there with some oversight and some regulation to avoid excess."
In an op-ed he penned for Thursday’s Wall Street Journal, Rove excoriated McCain for joining Obama in showing a "disturbing animus toward free markets and success."
"It is uncalled for and self-defeating for presidential candidates to demonize American companies," wrote Rove, who has informally advised McCain’s 2008 campaign. "It’s understandable that Mr. Obama, the most liberal member of the Senate, would endorse reckless policies that are the DNA of the party he leads, but Mr. McCain, a self-described Reagan Republican, should know better."
McCain has certainly stepped up his populist rhetoric lately.
This past Thursday, he ripped the oil companies for what he called their "obscene profits" and "failure to invest in alternate energy."
McCain’s economic record, however, does not match his populist rhetoric.
The Arizona senator has not joined Obama in supporting a windfall profits tax on energy, saying on Tuesday that it would "increase our dependence on foreign oil."
McCain has also offered a business-friendly set of tax cuts.
The presumptive Republican nominee is calling for a reduction in the corporate tax rate to 25 percent from 35 percent, tax breaks for corporate investment, and a repeal of the alternative minimum tax. The McCain camp says its plan would help create jobs by lowering taxes on businesses, including those small businesses that pay taxes at the personal income tax rate.
Even the most progressive component of McCain’s tax cut proposals — his call for doubling the value of exemptions for dependents to $7,000 from $3,500 — would provide more tax relief to higher-income individuals than to lower-income individuals because it was structured as an exemption from the progressive tax structure rather than as a flat refundable tax credit.

Email
Sen. DeMint: GOP Race Could Go Until Convention
Obama Avoids Questions on Contraception Rule
McCain is NO populist. He is really a Bushie.
Posted by: Sandy | June 19, 2008, 7:15 pm 7:15 pm
Just wait untill he says he is a Democrate, and Obama is a Republican.
Posted by: Thinking | June 19, 2008, 7:19 pm 7:19 pm
When I think of McCain I see two flip flops tapping each other. Can anyone count how many times he has changed his positions on issuses or how many gaffes he has made? The GOP should have thrown it’s support behind Mitt Romney, he would have been a better match against Obama.
Posted by: Oretega M | June 19, 2008, 7:25 pm 7:25 pm
What do you expect from someone who said he is a liberal Republican before correcting himself? This happened in a town hall meeting this year. In his head, he’s a liberal Republican and to the outside world he portrays himself as a Conservative Republican. What a joke!!!!
Posted by: Carlos Mencia | June 19, 2008, 7:31 pm 7:31 pm
McCain is quickly proving that he’s just George Bush with a better story and a less annoying laugh.
Posted by: Carborundum | June 19, 2008, 7:48 pm 7:48 pm
I will vote for a republican and populist rather than a socialist, marxist, communist, racist that Obama is. Obama certainly is not a moderate democrat. Mostly, he is just a liar.
Posted by: Mary | June 19, 2008, 7:52 pm 7:52 pm
“John McCain is a populist. He believes in free markets; he believes in limited government”….pallleeeaaasssee
McCain believes in whatever his audience wants, plain and simple. The man’s a sandal or I think republicans call him a flip-flop/.
Posted by: JR | June 19, 2008, 7:53 pm 7:53 pm
If McCain had stuck to his moderate roots, catered to the middle-of-the-road voter by promising a moderate approach to the future in policy, appointments and ideology, he’d probably win. I don’t know why he thought he had to appeal to the conservative right (I mean, who ELSE are the right-wing-nuts going to vote for?) when the entire country is looking for a shift away from Bush’s ultraconservative policies.
But he didn’t, he won’t and in that, he lost most of the middle-of-the-road voters (like me) who, while not thrilled about Obama’s leftist ideology, know it’s definitely NOT going to be the same as Bush’s BS, which seems to be what McCain, in most part, is pushing.
Kinda sad. I was in favor of McCain in 2000.
Posted by: Fatesrider | June 19, 2008, 7:53 pm 7:53 pm
Oretega has got it right…..
McCain has flipped on:
Torture
Bush tax cuts for the rich
Evangelical right wing
Drilling off the coasts and ANWR
Windfall profits tax
McCain says whatever his audience wants to here.
Posted by: JR | June 19, 2008, 7:55 pm 7:55 pm
Sure he’s a populist.
In political terms that means he says what he thinks peple want to hear.
That’s a waffler.
That’s a hypocrite.
That’s an unprincipled liar.
But it’s not Presidential.
And neither is McCain.
Posted by: Tannim | June 19, 2008, 7:58 pm 7:58 pm
Republicans have flip flopped so many times they don’t know what they are.
“I’m a fiscal conservative but spend billions on an unnecessary war.”
“I love God, but screw poor minority kids from CHIP.”
“I believe in freedom, but let’s let corporations dig into all your private records and tell you how to live your life.”
“I’m pro-military, but don’t give soldiers decent hospitals and health care.”
McCain is like all of them, talking three ways out of his mouth and laughing all the way to the bank.
Posted by: Martinez | June 19, 2008, 8:01 pm 8:01 pm
Mary, there will probably hundreds of others who feel as you and vote for McCain, but I suspect that we will have Barak Obama as our next president, and I wish him well. Following what Bush has done to us, I fear that he’ll have the toughest job of any American president in history.
Posted by: Javalation | June 19, 2008, 8:02 pm 8:02 pm
WHAT’S THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN OBAMA & McCain?
McCain is a man.
Obama is a puppet.
Posted by: Soetoro No! | June 19, 2008, 8:21 pm 8:21 pm
McCain a POPULIST? It doesn’t get any stranger than that statement. Unless, of course, the new definition of “populist” is “someone who thinks he’ll become popular by saying what people want to hear”.
Posted by: Phyllis | June 19, 2008, 8:26 pm 8:26 pm
I like McCain because I can trust him more than Obama to keep this country safe. Obama is lying about his relationship with his pastor and Rezno. He also did not keep his promise about public funding and NAFTA. He is just another politician that saying and doing anything to win the election. Obama is another Bush that doesn’t have any experience to handle this country.
Posted by: stephanie | June 19, 2008, 8:29 pm 8:29 pm
What’s wrong with populist? Do you want a phony who eats his words to fit his political agendas or propagandas? BhO has fooled enough people in the primaries, to earn himself a spot in the typical dems presidential nominee club, or the losers club.
Posted by: fact check | June 19, 2008, 8:32 pm 8:32 pm
Mr. Black has certainly changed the definition of populist. I don’t think his version will ever make it to Websters. What in the world does Rove mean by “disturbing animus?” Whatever it is probably best describes the both of them.
Posted by: kat | June 19, 2008, 8:41 pm 8:41 pm
Isn’t Obama a communist? He’s on more T-shirts now than Mao.
Posted by: anti-red | June 19, 2008, 8:58 pm 8:58 pm
McCain = BUSH all over again..Please god say it cant be???
Posted by: louiedog | June 19, 2008, 8:58 pm 8:58 pm
One thing that is admirable about McCain was his friendship with the late Mo Udall who died of complications of Parkinson’s disease. Mo had a number of witticisms which were both self deprecating as well as funny and probably borrowed from other politicians. One of the best was the old one about a politician giving a speech and then concluding “Those are the principles I stand for and if you don’t like them I’ll change them for you.” McCain has learned this well. Some may call it flip flopping while others call it being an astute politician. By the way, the idea of a progressive income tax has been endorsed by main line Protestant churches and the Catholic church for a long time and goes along with the principle that from those to whom much is given much is expected. Government serves the common good and that includes the good of the common and promotion of the general welfare means everyone, not just the folks at the Pentagon or GM or GE. McCain is not a Populist and Charley Black as the ultimate K Street fixer wouldn’t know a real populist is he ever met one. The GOP has never stood for Grand Old Populism and the Grand Old Party now has a three fold identity crisis as the party of Greed Over People (cut taxes for the rich and the hell with everyone else); God’s Only Party (see Dobson,Hagee, Robertson and the late Dr. Falwell) or the more traditonal monied folks from Wall Street with two last names ( Cabot Lodge, etc) , at least 5 generations at Ivy Schools commonly known as Country Club Republicans but referred to as Gold, Oil and Platinum these days with particular emphasis on oil in the Bush Cheney administration.
Posted by: bhciapol | June 19, 2008, 8:59 pm 8:59 pm
McCain was a populist in 2000, that’s why I liked him. He was a moderate, sensible, and likable candidate. I’m not sure what happened to him in the last 8 years, but he’s changed so much.
McCain 08 is no populist.
Posted by: Shain from NH | June 19, 2008, 9:06 pm 9:06 pm
Hum.. creating new jobs by lowering taxes on business. isn’t this the line that we’ve been getting for 8 years. Funny how taxes are not the solution. Taxes are not the reason our economy is being outsourced. Poor trade agreements are. And the lack of a pres with a backbone to standup for america. The GOP has messed us up good. It’s time for change. We need a forward thinking person. Have you noticed how all of McCain’s ideas seem straight out of 1970?! He’s talking coal mining and nuclear and war when we need clean energy and peace. Guess I shouldn’t expect him to think too far forward when he can’t even use a computer (his words not mine — look it up). I’m so shocked by the GOP.. all I can do when I read about this guy is think.. is this guy for real?! What a lame candidate.
Posted by: mrXgop | June 19, 2008, 9:06 pm 9:06 pm
I would have voted for Obama only if he is a man of his words. Unfortunately, he is not. He has already flip flopped on many important issues. So did McCain but not even close to Obama’s short political career. At least when McCain change course, he is not flipping for his own personal advantage but it is what he believes is best for his country. I call that leadership. I have already done my homework. I have already decided. My family and I are voting for McCain.
Posted by: al4mcattack | June 19, 2008, 9:10 pm 9:10 pm
So George W McCain is now a “populist”.
I already forgot what his campaign said he was LAST week or the week before.
This is getting confusing…gives me a headache.
Posted by: wilderrr | June 19, 2008, 9:10 pm 9:10 pm
This is Karl Rove and the RNC playing good cop / bad cop on the American People. Trying anything to see what sticks. Truly a candidate from the zillionaires comes come out and calls himself a populists? I guess McBush does not know who is pulling the strings.. Good try Karl, ; although you did it before with Bush 43: The Unifier… I still remember that interview you gave once Karl, calling Bush 43 a person of great intellect. (lol)
Posted by: enn | June 19, 2008, 9:29 pm 9:29 pm
John McCain is not a populist, the only people he cares for are the same people that Bush cares for.
Posted by: peoples_prez | June 19, 2008, 9:31 pm 9:31 pm
Let’s see, Republican conception of reality:
John McCain a populist.
Barack Obama is an elitist.
The Iraq War is the front line in the war on terror.
We’ve made great progress under GW Bush’s economic policies.
Waterboarding isn’t torture.
John McCain is the change candidate.
Anyone else see a disturbing pattern here? Are the Republicans really from some parallel universe of polar opposites?
Posted by: Michael | June 19, 2008, 9:31 pm 9:31 pm
The last paraghaph of this article is misleading. How would that benefit the rich. What is the difference do you think $3500 means to the poor and the rich???
Don’t be wonder why jobs are going overseas because our corporate tax is the 2nd highest in the world, not to mention union demands so much. Don’t be wondering why your job in a small business lose hours, or wages or even fired because obama wants to tax businesses so much!!
These people are in businesses for profits. If there’s no profit, they will go away or find ways to keep the profit. How is that so hard for liberal to understand.
Whoever wrote this article please don’t write something that’s not true. It’s misleading. You can state it as your opinion but don’t make it sounds like a fact because it’s not!!!
Posted by: hannah | June 19, 2008, 9:34 pm 9:34 pm
If McCain is a Populist, then Obama is so far to the left he’s out of view.
Posted by: Ryan O | June 19, 2008, 9:35 pm 9:35 pm
McWar will say ANYTHING to be president – he doesn’t care what he’s for or against. He’s CERTAINLY not a Republican – and neither is BUSH. That lot wouldn’t know Republican if it bit them on the butt with chromium teeth! I’m still hoping that someone will pick up the flag Ron Paul carried for so long. I want to ACTUALLY return to a small government with no FBI and CIA minding my business. You’re so afraid of terrorism – go live in Iran where there IS no terrorism. Leave me in America with my Freedom – the Freedom our fathers fought to protect and our sons are fighting to destroy.
Posted by: Louis Nardozi | June 19, 2008, 10:11 pm 10:11 pm
Obama is a flip flopper.
Posted by: mary | June 19, 2008, 10:13 pm 10:13 pm
Some people are really out of touch. What difference does $3500 make between a poor and a rich? $3500? I spend an average of $10 on gas everyday. That money will put gas in my tank for a whole year. Some people may have plentiful but $3500 is still a lot of money.
Posted by: eyes like summer sun | June 19, 2008, 10:33 pm 10:33 pm
C’mon, hippies, take it easy – you’re the ones who are supposed to be laid back. Of course John McCain is a populist – isn’t everyone married to a millionaire beer baroness?
The important thing to notice is that they don’t even try and label him as conservative.
Posted by: 1percenter | June 19, 2008, 10:44 pm 10:44 pm
That’s a waffler.
That’s a hypocrite.
That’s an unprincipled liar.
That’s Obama.
Posted by: obamasbeenlyin | June 19, 2008, 11:02 pm 11:02 pm
This 2005 interview with Tim Russert on Meet the Press made it very clear.
*********************************
RUSSERT: The fact is you are different than George Bush.
SEN. McCAIN: No. No. The fact is that I have agreed with President Bush far more than I have disagreed. And on the transcendent issues, the most important issues of our day, I’ve been totally in agreement and support of President Bush.
STRAIGHT TALK EXPRESS RIGHT?
Posted by: McCain is McSame | June 20, 2008, 12:31 am 12:31 am
It is becoming clearer and clearer that McCain can’t win. I rarely blog because there isn’t a single person that blogs that is undecided 99% of the time. The Hillary or death crowd that think they can give the appearance of widespread anger is always interesting to see. (Go PUMA) The Republicans blogging to push people’s buttons. I doubt there was a single person whose opinion was changed today by a blogger. Yet it continues as though it will sway at least one person one way or another. Elections won’t be decided by arguments made in blogs. However, I accept that it may be cathartic for some.
Reality check Point1 – Obama’s supporters will be at the polls.
Reality check Point2- Obama will vastly outspend McCain because Obama’s supporters are self organizing and will sacrafice to ensure he has all the resources he needs to campaign in 50 states. McCain has several hundred thousand unique donors. Obama has already passed 2 million (more on that when the campaign reports are released June 20)
Reality check Point3-Republicans don’t really care whether or not McCain wins. They may not want Obama to win but fewer than 25% of Republicans are reporting they are glad McCain is their nominee. That doesn’t translate into the grassroots activism required to effectively battle Obama. You can’t build those kinds of networks in 5 months. Ironically, the most fired up McCain supporters are disgruntled Hillary supporters. They will vote for McCain and may even give $20 but they won’t actively campaign for McCain unless it is obviousl Hillary related. That undercuts their ability to sway others.
Good luck guys and gals and HELLO PRESIDENT OBAMA!
Posted by: Elliot | June 20, 2008, 12:38 am 12:38 am
What’s going on here?
How much does John McCain know about his campaign manager’s lobbying history and potential current business interests inside Ukraine — and when did he know it?
The stakes of the answer to that question are increasing, due both to the continuing controversy over the role of lobbyists in McCain’s second presidential run, as well as the press inquiry into the connections between McCain campaign manager Rick Davis and the global business and political interests in Ukraine, a country represented by the lobbying firm that bears his name — Davis-Manafort.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2008/06/20/new-questions-over-mccain_n_108204.html
Posted by: Jim | June 20, 2008, 4:27 am 4:27 am
That’s a waffler.
That’s a hypocrite.
That’s an unprincipled liar.
That’s McCain.
Just check his record!
Posted by: Jack | June 20, 2008, 4:28 am 4:28 am
Actually, McCain has a long history of being a moderate, irregardless of what the Obamabots say.
Posted by: amazed | June 20, 2008, 7:25 am 7:25 am
So while he’s short changing the “CHIP” program in this country, his wife is dumping $$$ in Vietnam to help foreign kids. Maybe she has an investment or two over there.
Posted by: DAVID NH | June 20, 2008, 7:26 am 7:26 am
mc-more-war quotes:
“There’s not a history of clashes that are violent between Sunnis and Shiahs. So I think they can probably get along.” [MSNBC, 4/23/03]
“Because I believe that the success will be fairly easy,” [CNN, 9/24/02]
“We’re not going to get into house-to-house fighting in Baghdad.” [CNN, 9/29/02]
“But the point is that, one, we will win this conflict. We will win it easily.” [MSNBC, 1/22/03]
“But I believe that the Iraqi people will greet us as liberators.” [NBC, 3/20/03]
“It’s clear that the end is very much in sight.” [ABC, 4/9/03]
“This is a mission accomplished.” [This Week, ABC, 12/14/03]
“I’m confident we’re on the right course.” [ABC News, 3/7/04]
Can you estimate when we can bring our troops home? (Matt Lauer) “No, but that’s not really important.” [ABC 6/12/08]
Posted by: pt | June 20, 2008, 8:20 am 8:20 am
@ pt: That is McCain’s experience talking.
Posted by: X marks the spot | June 20, 2008, 9:11 am 9:11 am
Newsflash
BOTH candidates have flip-flopped… that’s what politician do.
The difference is that Obama’s whole run was based on him NOT being that sort of politician.
But who need ideals when you have 500 million dollars?
Should have been Hilliary, but I’d vote McCain or Libertarian before I’d vote Obama.
Read 1984… and then decide if the government really know’s what’s best for you? (socialism)
Posted by: MT | June 20, 2008, 6:56 pm 6:56 pm
If you are confused about the $3,500 deduction being more valuable to high income people than low income, it works like this: A low income family with a 10% marginal tax rate would see $350 of tax savings from a $3,500 additional dependent deduction, a high income family at a 30% marginal tax rate would see a $1,050 tax savings. As the article states, it is the difference between tax credits and tax deductions.
Posted by: Michael H | June 21, 2008, 8:46 pm 8:46 pm