Elizabeth Edwards’ ‘Anguish’ in Wake of Husband’s Affair
ABC News’ Nitya Venkataraman Reports: Faced with the betrayal of her husband, former Democratic presidential candidate John Edwards, those close to Elizabeth Edwards say she experienced "excruciating anguish" in her decision to stand behind him through his 2008 campaign but that ultimately her terminal illness forced her to "move forward" for the sake of her family.
"No one should assume it was easy," says Hargrave McElroy, Elizabeth Edwards’ best friend, in PEOPLE magazine’s latest issue hitting newsstands Friday.
Once news of the affair went public, the PEOPLE magazine cover story says Elizabeth Edwards encouraged her husband to come clean.
On August 8, John Edwards taped an exclusive interview with Nightline admitting he’d repeatedly lied about an extramarital affair with Rielle Hunter, a film maker once employed by his presidential campaign, and denied involvement in paying her hush money or fathering her child. In the interview, Edwards described his wife as ‘furious’ upon learning of the affair.
PEOPLE reports Edwards’ admission to his wife of the 2006 affair with Hunter as one that came in installments. "He told the truth slowly," said a source close to the couple who dated his confession as after the official launch of Edwards’ 2008 presidential campaign in late December 2006. In March 2007, Mrs. Edwards told reporters she had learned her breast cancer had returned and was incurable.
"There was anguish — excruciating anguish — for her in dealing with this. She was angry and furious and everything, but at one point she had to make a choice: Do I kick him out or do we have a 30-year marriage that can be rebuilt?" McElroy said, in the PEOPLE magazine cover story that also featured an interview with Mrs. Edwards younger brother, Jay Anania.
Anania said living with incurable cancer and "the uncertainty of her own mortality" gave special circumstance to Mrs. Edwards decision to forgive her husband for the sake of her three children Cate, 26, Emma Claire, 10, and Jack, 8.
In the PEOPLE exclusive, McElroy says, "She couldn’t say, ‘Well, maybe we’ll work through this for years, or maybe we should separate for two years. [The cancer] forced her to choose whether to move forward."
Hitting the campaign trail for her husband "was like returning to normalcy" McElroy said, though the challenge became more difficult than anticipated when tabloids began reporting the affair in 2007. McElroy says after that Mrs. Edwards did "strikingly less campaigning" than she did during the 2004 presidential election.
Her friends say Mrs. Edwards had hoped for some release following her husband’s interview with Nightline. "Part of the burden for Elizabeth had been the lie," McElroy says in the PEOPLE magazine exclusive. "She anticipated the great relief the truth brings."
That release for Mrs. Edwards is yet to come. The blow to her husband’s image has been significant. One Democratic strategist told PEOPLE "he’s finished, it’s too distasteful."
Friends tell PEOPLE magazine Edwards is working hard to regain his wife’s trust, that they "are not living separate lives. They are together in that house, as before." They say his remorse "is real" and that "he is in pain." The magazine describes others in the Edwards’ social circle as "outraged."
"The kids are, to a certain extent, oblivious," Elizabeth’s brother tells PEOPLE magazine, "but children are very wise and know things." So far, the magazine says, the Edwardses haven’t sat down with their younger children to discuss these events.
Email
Sen. DeMint: GOP Race Could Go Until Convention
Obama Avoids Questions on Contraception Rule
John Edwards could of been the leader of the country. Now he is going to be a homeless unemployed bum
Posted by: ragler | August 13, 2008, 3:37 pm 3:37 pm
Hey Worse,
Obama was disrespectful to his own Grandma, and repudiated his pastor of twenty years. It all comes with the territory, a bunch of arrogant men. Isn’t it time for a change?
Posted by: WestCoastMessenger | August 13, 2008, 3:48 pm 3:48 pm
John Edwards is going to live with what he did for the rest of his life. When his wife dies he will look back and see what he did to her and how much he hurt her. It is heartbreaking.
Posted by: JE | August 13, 2008, 4:25 pm 4:25 pm
Paul, people on both sides of the aisle care, that’s who cares. He could have been the candidate! That was the intention for running, and his family headed out full-bore with this secret. Our society is not to the place where this is fully condoned, though we are forgetful (witness Bill Clinton). Democrats would have been sunk in the general election, even had he been VP. Republicans, ones who don’t like to see the downfall of Dems just because of who they are, care because it’s another one biting the dust who could have been an example of trustworthiness and charatyer in our gov’t.
Posted by: Tracy Lynn | August 13, 2008, 4:30 pm 4:30 pm
We donated our hard-earned money for Edwards to spend on mistresses (under the cover of so called “political videos”). He should give the political donations back to his betrayed supporters (eventually donating extra to groups that support poor women battling cancer or husband infidelity).
Posted by: DD | August 13, 2008, 4:36 pm 4:36 pm
Actually, let’s face it; John Edwards is a HOT BABE. I was surprised he hadn’t had an affair. Of course, he is a good man and held out a long time. He lost his son, thought he would lose his wife, very vulnerable stage in his life. Then add the fact that he has obviously been quite wholesome and in walks the female player ready to go fishin’. Women all over must have been throwing themselves at him. Sorry we have the hottest guys in politics on our side, the downfall is megaloads of temptation coming their way. However, Al Gore was a real hottie in his day (still is to me) and he has managed to remain “decent.” But then Al is a total type A. The media’s role, is something to be suspicious about, but Edwards was weak, not evil. He still stood for the people who needed someone to stand up for them in our society; that makes him AWESOME to many of us including Elizabeth who continued to promote him as a servant of the PEOPLE, that says a lot…..
Posted by: irma | August 13, 2008, 4:57 pm 4:57 pm
It’s funny how republicans don’t seem to think there was anything wrong with McCain cheating. In fact they seem to be making excuses. Go figure.
Posted by: erin | August 13, 2008, 5:08 pm 5:08 pm
The McCain story is old news. It has been reported, disected and debated for 25 years. Edwards on the other hand lied thru his teeth all the while asking us to believe him and nominate him to be president. I hope this was worth it to him. Now the feds are supposedly interested in why his campaign finance chief feels the need to support this woman with his “own” money and whether or not it came from campaign donations. I think this story and his lies are going to be around for a while. Poor Elisabeth this is how she has to live out her last days.
Posted by: maryintampa | August 13, 2008, 5:11 pm 5:11 pm
Sherry, we don’t often elect leaders battling cancer. Her prospects for survival don’t look good. It’s one thing to sympathize with her, but elect her as VP?
Posted by: Tracy Lynn | August 13, 2008, 5:26 pm 5:26 pm
This scandal needs to be put to rest. Whoever has any compassion for Elisabeth Edwards? Let it go! Can you imagine what it is doing to her. Why? Should Elisabeth keep on being crucified! For the media to have something to write about! How cheap!
Posted by: mary | August 13, 2008, 5:26 pm 5:26 pm
I just wanted to comment on the Obama attackers. McCain is a big time liar or flopper. He seems to change his stands on the issues depending on which conservative group denouces his tax plan, energy plan, etc.
As far as Edwards he should establish a Politicians Reform group with donations from Spitzer, Craig, Vitter and probably the white hair dude.
Posted by: O Yah | August 13, 2008, 6:21 pm 6:21 pm
John is not a loser, just a fallible human-being like us all. Please, if there is a perfect being gracing this blog, PLEASE let me know. I will vote for you.
Posted by: hewhoiswithoutsincast... | August 13, 2008, 7:08 pm 7:08 pm
McCain’s story is old, very old news – Clinton’s story is fairly old news. The Edwards story is new news – thanks to the Mainstream Media who buried it for a year. I thought Edwards was pro-abortion. Guess it didn’t work this time!
Posted by: Sinners Lie | August 13, 2008, 7:30 pm 7:30 pm
To bad he continues to lie to her.
Posted by: Chris | August 13, 2008, 7:44 pm 7:44 pm
does anyone see a pattern here with MEN. They want total control of the world and take advantage of all women.
Posted by: a.orleans | August 13, 2008, 7:56 pm 7:56 pm
WELL THIS IS NOT SURPRISING AT ALL. THE ETHICS OF OUR GOVERNMENT OFFICALS, SPORTS PLAYERS AND CELEBRITIES ARE HORRIBLE. AND THEY WONDER WHY THE REST OF THE COUNTRY IS IN BAD SHAPE–DAH, THINK ABOUT IT YOU POLITIANS, PLAYERS AND ACTORS. WHAT HEROS YOU ARE NOT!!!!!!!!
Posted by: Dianne | August 13, 2008, 8:01 pm 8:01 pm
I think McCain’s past is a consideration, just as Obama’s past and his relationships are a consideration in determining who would be a better president. Everything should be taken as a whole. From what I know, McCain has been with his current wife for 30 years, so that speaks highly of him in the here and now. Democrats had better be careful about trying to bring up McCains’ affair from 30 years ago, just look at Edwards (and what he said about narcissism and ego) and don’t be surprised if something should come out about Obama.
Posted by: Susan | August 13, 2008, 8:22 pm 8:22 pm
My prayers adn thoughts are with Elizabeth and the children, may Elizabeth find the comfort, strength and love to move beyond this betrayal, and have many blue skies days ahead for her. She has enough on her plate with the illness and should not have to deal with the antics of her husband and Reille Hunter, Elizabeth Edwards has always been a very classy lady and her determination and resilence during this time has been as classy as she has ever been. Elizabeth you are an admired and stron woman, my prayers are definitely with you!
Posted by: AALFLYATT | August 13, 2008, 8:48 pm 8:48 pm
I hope Elizabeth knows that she and her children are in our prayers, and I hope somehow she will have the physical and emotional strength to show whatshisface the door.
He told her in “installments” — exactly like he thinks he’s going to be able to do with the public. The first installment is just the tip of a very polluted iceberg.
Posted by: Chris from Austin | August 13, 2008, 9:08 pm 9:08 pm
I agree that in public Elizabeth Edwards comes across as a classy lady. After learning of her husbands cheap affair, I can understand Elizabeth holding on to her marriage and family. Afterall, that is all she has when her life is getting short.
I don’t agree that Elizabeth should have continued her support for her husband’s campaign. She should have put a stop to the campaign and not allowed the lie to be continued on to the American people. People who gave money, time, and sacrificed careers for Edwards. Elizabeth also spoke badly about Hillary during the campaign while hiding her own deceit and her husband’s lies. I wish Elizabeth well and a happy time with her children.
Posted by: Mrs. Phoenix | August 13, 2008, 9:19 pm 9:19 pm
GIVE JOHN EDWARDS A BREAK.
HE IS A GOOD MAN.
HE MADE A MISTAKE.
HE IS HUMAN JUST LIKE THE REST OF US.
LET HIM OR HER WHO IS WITHOUT SIN CAST THE FIRST STONE.
Posted by: CHARLES | August 13, 2008, 9:49 pm 9:49 pm
Get real people. Elizabeth Edwards aided and abetted the lie John Edwards tried to pawn on his party and supporters. Had he been nominated it would have been a disaster and Ms. Edwards is no idiot her medical condition n.w.s.
If the fire’s too hot they shouldn’t have gotten into the kitchen.
That’s politics.
Posted by: Fred Durham | August 13, 2008, 9:55 pm 9:55 pm
hahahaaaa how does Hillary and McCain place this country first.
Posted by: ll | August 13, 2008, 10:05 pm 10:05 pm
My heart feels for Mrs. Edwards. What a strong woman and mother. Mrs. Edwards, you have all of our support. Do what you feel it best for you and your children.
Posted by: cookie | August 13, 2008, 10:26 pm 10:26 pm
I don’t believe American voters condone this kind of thing from our politicians but we’ve learned to tolerate it. Why? Because if we didn’t who would be left in Washington? That is the disappointment that everyone lives with everyday.
Posted by: rigatoni28 | August 13, 2008, 10:41 pm 10:41 pm
The McCain stuff has been discussed for 25 years. Nothing new.
Edwards…follow the money. If money from his campaign has been diverted as hush monet someone will go to jail.
This story is just beginning. Follow the money.
Posted by: Shawn | August 13, 2008, 10:47 pm 10:47 pm
He’ll receive what he deserves – no doubt the universe will see to that. In the meantime, I hope he spends the rest of his life trying to make up for the betrayal to his wife.
Posted by: Susan | August 13, 2008, 10:54 pm 10:54 pm
John McCain and Edward affairs are not equal in my mind and I may be wrong. But, John McCain was a POW for 5 ½ years with fractures in his right leg and both arms. He received minimal care and was kept in wretched conditions based on US report. I cannot think about all the other daily things (tortures, solitary, sexual and brutality) that they did to him while in prison. Even Nelson Mandela cheated and left his wife after he was released from prison. Nelson Mandela was no longer the person his wife once knew. McCain admitted that being a prisoner of war had changed him and he was not the same man that his wife knew. I would like to see any of us coming out of that type of situation the same. How can he and other POW preserve their sanity? They should be respected and it is understandable that each POW can out a different person than their family once knew them to be. Our soldiers have a lot of trouble after coming home from war, yet alone POW for 51/2 years. Maybe Edwards was under too much pressure with his wife illness and needed outlets to handle it.
Posted by: cookie | August 13, 2008, 11:02 pm 11:02 pm
Edwards is a cad just like McCain and Bill Clinton.
Posted by: Liz | August 13, 2008, 11:35 pm 11:35 pm
Doesn’t stress exacerbate or bring on cancer? John Edwards will be responsible for his wife’s demise, whether it be sooner, or blessedly, later. He is beyond scum. Why do these guys always cheat with whores who cannot hold a candle to their accomplished, smart, intelligent and loyal wives? Hopefully, he’ll suffer with this guilty forever.
I’m so disgusted. And to think my husband and I were going to vote for this jerk. He has done an amazing amount of damage to the party.
Posted by: Joan | August 14, 2008, 12:03 am 12:03 am
OK, this really isn’t a Dem/Rep thing. It has been mentioned here that what McCain did is the same, but for the passage of time. I guess that’s an anti-McCain stance. If you’re pro-Clinton, as in both of them speaking in prime spots at the convention, why can’t Edwards speak too? His crime and Bill’s only differ in the passage of time. Of course they all differ in the circumstances and the personalities involved, and who might have caused and felt the most hurt, but it’s all cheating and adultery in the final analysis.
Posted by: Tracy Lynn | August 14, 2008, 12:48 am 12:48 am
Don’t feel sorry from him. There’s plenty of ambulances left to chase.
Posted by: mikewolf9 | August 14, 2008, 1:15 am 1:15 am
Thank goodness this phoney’s lies were exposed before he could become POTUS and be subjected to blackmail. What a man who would put the potential security of our entire nation at risk! Since he had already bold-faced lied repeatedly to the American people, who knows what deals might have been made to keep this from being exposed to the general public if he had been elected Pesident. Truley,trulely scary.
Posted by: givingthanks | August 14, 2008, 2:03 am 2:03 am
When you see how flawed our would-be leaders are, we need to remember that it is at our own peril to give more and more of our freedoms away to politicians and the people they bring with them into our government. Let’s all wake up—let’s continue to push for smaller and less powerful government and start taking our own destinies into our own hands. Just think how much more power we would have if it were not for high taxes and the the endless numbers of rules and regulations that government and its bureaucrats heap upon us. Shed the repression!!
Posted by: annewoodward | August 14, 2008, 3:14 am 3:14 am
WestCoast Messenger: And Obama was disrespectful to his grandmother how ? If you’d done your research, you would have seen that this anecdote about his grandmother’s fear of the black man on the street was included in his book that was published ten years ago. And if you’d done your research you would have read that his grandmother read the manuscript beforehand and approved of what Obama said. I am so tired of readers not doing research.
As for Edwards, well, since he came down hard on Bill Clinton for the Lewinsky affair, he should expect others to seek the truth as to whether he fathered the child.
He has used the death of his son and his wife’s cancer to gain sympathy and votes. He has presented himself as the paragon of morality. He and his wife are addicted to the spotlight and are a sham.
Watch for the Feds to indict him on the hush money.
Posted by: southamco | August 14, 2008, 5:33 am 5:33 am
why you against the man. Edward is a good man. He done a terrible mistake which may stick with for life but he human, he is a good man. This woman is opportunist, she is Jezebell. She knew what she was doing and why she did it.
MEN BE ON QUARD AGAINSST THESE KINDS OF WOMEN. She carless about the hurt she caused
Posted by: krist | August 14, 2008, 6:30 am 6:30 am
This family has seen enogh suffering in terms of destroyed public image. The best we can do for the cancer striken woman is to put this story behind us and pray for all of them
Posted by: Richard Komi | August 14, 2008, 8:44 am 8:44 am
If I were her I’d take a gun and shot the SOB! Why not? She is going to pass anyway and then the attention would be directed at his funeral!
This is not a good example for the children to see their father get by with this!!! How will they ever trust anyone?
Posted by: Red | August 14, 2008, 9:24 am 9:24 am
Look how Edwards made his money. Anyone surprised he sold his soul?
Posted by: geevill | August 14, 2008, 9:43 am 9:43 am
Edwards is a one-term Senator. See what happens wehen you don’t know that much about someone. We know even less about Obama.
Posted by: geevill | August 14, 2008, 9:48 am 9:48 am
my prayers go out to the edwards family. as i read through all of the comments listed here…none of us have a clue how devastated this family really is. i wish elizabeth & thier children peace in the midst of this storm. when life hangs in the balance, nothing else is more important than gods love, presence & peace. many blessings.
Posted by: LV | August 14, 2008, 11:39 am 11:39 am
John Edwards should fall on this knees and pray for forgivness. Elizabeth is going through emotional aas well as physical issues with cancer. She doesn’t need this. I believe John is repentful, but only because he got caught, just like Clinton. He needs to get counceling and look within.
Posted by: Christian | August 14, 2008, 11:49 am 11:49 am
It is so amusing to read some of the comments and believe that rational people are writing them. No matter how long ago Johns McCain sinned, even though he was not running for any elected office that sin is sin; no party or affiliation immunes us and if your are not mathematicallly challenged you will know that he was not such a “young” man. John Edward is caught up in the power syndrome and felt just as others that rise to prominence that he is not infallible. Now about you and me let us be a little reluctant to load up our bags with stones.
Posted by: BEVO | August 14, 2008, 11:55 am 11:55 am
Either Irma is actually John Edwards (Hot babe????) or she has been drinking the koolaid toooooo long.
A person’s looks go far beyond the physical features. John Edwards is the MOST insincere human I have ever had the displeasure to look upon. He could look like Adonis – and his actions (always saying just the right thing and not meaning it, sleezy behavior) would negate that. I wouldn’t trust him alone with my pets – let alone want him for president.
Posted by: CharlotteNC | August 14, 2008, 12:21 pm 12:21 pm
Actually the same media source that was correct about Edwards has written stories regarding Obama and his activities in Chicago involving gay/bisexual men. The MSM has ignored those stories too.
Posted by: geevill | August 14, 2008, 12:38 pm 12:38 pm
I can forgive Elizabeth for being weak. Cancer will do that to you. However, I can’t forgive her for being dishonest. If she knew John was lying to the press, then she knew what that meant if he received the nomination. She should have forced John to tell the truth or she should have told the truth herself. She did plenty of interviews in her own right. If you are going to lead people, you cannot hide behind the “I am just a regular person” line of argument. If you want to be a regular person, then get paid like a regular person, get jerked around and manipulated like a regular person, and get ignored like a regular person. If you want to lead, then lead by example. John and Elizabeth want to make this seem like a momentary weakness on John’s part, but this appears to be something far more sinister. John Edwards put way too much time and effort into his affair with Hunter. This is not a smudge on his character. This is a great big crack right down the middle of who he is and claims to be. John didn’t just cheat. He cheated on his deathly ill wife. He was a mature man, not a crazy mixed up kid. He lied when he got caught. He tried to minimize the damage and get out of trouble instead of admitting fully what he did and trying to make it right. This event is not “happening” to the Edwards. John Edwards is making this happen. Sadly, Elizabeth can’t find the strength to stand up for herself and her kids.
Posted by: Sean O'Brien | August 14, 2008, 12:40 pm 12:40 pm
Hey it’s hard when you use the viagra and extasy. First he fights the drug companies , now he will be a spokesman whoop whoop drug test what’s there buddy
Posted by: vacantmorals | August 14, 2008, 1:20 pm 1:20 pm
I doubt that we will ever know the complete truth about what happened, nor should we, I think. But I know enough to say that I am completely heartsick. Not that Edwards is a cheating fool who did that to his wife, sick or not. Nor that Elizabeth has chosen to stay with him. That is her decision to make. I am heartsick because I wanted so badly to see Edwards as President.
That he would think that no one would find out about an affair in this age of blogs and mass media is simply pathetic. Is he not living in 2008?
I wish that, rather than doing “strikingly less” campaigning than in 2004 when the National Enquirer started making noise, Elizabeth would have stepped forward and told the truth. Or, earlier than that, stopped the campaign before it started.
I don’t even know what to think about this anymore.
Posted by: IdealSkeptic | August 14, 2008, 1:30 pm 1:30 pm
Dear Mrs. Edwards,
Your ‘so called faithful husband’ John has been officially caught with his pants down this time — maybe more affairs with other ladies will surface later In politics ( as with Bill Clinton ) — Its not a sin to tell a lie — just to get caught in one.. So,you owe him ( John Edwards ) nothing ! He has done You a big favor -and look at it in that light, which you will come to realize later on ! Go on with Your life now and always remember — you have Friends who care !
Posted by: Huber Hanes | August 14, 2008, 1:47 pm 1:47 pm
COWARDS!
American citizens need courageous media we can report to when a huge controversy comes up, but if they are too scared to stick their necks out, look at the fallout that can occur. Because of them- we could have had a v.p. Edwards and poss. eventually a president Edwards! Because of their cowardice- a lot of people wasted their time supporting him, a baby was born that shouldn’t have been, money was taken from the American voters to support his campaign, and Elizabeth Edwards’ pain was stretched to an unfathomable limit…and Reille’s ego got to go on a long joy ride.
Courage prevents these things. Come on U.S.A. Let’s hear it for the truth tellers! Let’s hear it for the Charlotte Observer!
Posted by: M | August 14, 2008, 1:54 pm 1:54 pm
So many of our most revered male leaders, men gifted with charisma and the ability to energize the masses, have all had affairs. I often wonder why that is. Seems like it would lessen the odds of sex scandals if more women were elected to office, they are usually too busy balancing career and family to have affairs.
Posted by: Mary | August 14, 2008, 2:32 pm 2:32 pm
Mc Cain an Edwards situations are very similar, and say a lot about the caracter of the person. Thanks God Edwards is out of the race! But mac Cain is hanging there and doesn’t matter if the cheating was 30 years ago, his first wive still is suffering and remember how she was left out because she wasn’t pretty enough any more! Bit Mac CAin doesn’t like when people make coments about his paealitic arm or the shoulder and posture problems!! haha He still wants to be a Dandy Married to a Barbie!!
Posted by: Judy | August 14, 2008, 2:41 pm 2:41 pm
We need Hillary in the White House, she is a stong leader and a phenomenal person, and most male politicians in America are affraid of powerful female personalities. So much that that they don’t like her because her husband infidelities.
Differnt standards, with Elizabeth is poor Elizabeth but with Hillary is she doesn’t know how to control Bill, is her fault!!!
America and the anericans are fouls!!
Posted by: AJ | August 14, 2008, 2:46 pm 2:46 pm
I think Elizabeth should come out and support Hillary since her disgraced husband endorsed BO. It might make a difference at the convention. She has the right to make her own pick regardless of John’s now dubious endorsement at the final stages of the primaries. Does it matter? Probably not but it does make the “smell” test where John’s endorsement does not. I think so. It would lead alot of people to question the endorsements that John and others made on behalf of BO. Perhaps I am making the same comment that others are making. I didn’t have time to wander through the minefield of this discussion. So Elizabeth could still make a difference to democrates. What would you do in her condition and with her legacy now in ruins. What do her children think in the future that daddy’s endorsement of BO was the only voice in the family and he was sleeping around behind mommy? What kind of message to children and young women is that?
Posted by: Dave | August 14, 2008, 3:00 pm 3:00 pm
I think Elizabeth based her forgiveness of her husband and her subsequent support of him in his Presidential campaign (which had begun in Dec 2006, just BEFORE her confessed to her in Dec 2006 or so) on his confessions.
If he had been honest in his confessions, I think a wife is entitled to forgive her husband and even support him in a campaign, knowing he is a reformed man who has confessed an “error”.
The public would have forgiven him too.
But the POINT is, the Public would never have found out about the affair nor would the Enquirer have taken up the story, IF Edwards had strickly folowed through with his confession and remained faithful from there on in.
So Elizabeth BELIEVEd this was the case. Any wife would give her man a chance.
BUT Edwards DID not remain true. He began to take up the affair once more in 2007, AFTER his confession to Elizabeth. And ELizabeth was in the dark as to this and would still be today IF she still believed her husband (when he came clean so-called on Nightline recently) as he would have the public believe him today.
It is the growing knowledge that Edwards remained in the affair and continued to cheat on his wife through 2007 and even fathered a child, that is his undoing. And Elizabeth is facing this for the first time just as the Public is.
SO my POINT is, Elizabeth did not know in 2006 what we know and suspect we know about Edwards today.
She only thought her husband ahd a “small affair” that her was terminatiing.
What is swirling around Edwards now is not this MINOR affair but the allegations of the Enquirere, which reveals an Edwards cheating and fathering a child and lying to the public in 2007 and 2008, after the story broke from the Enquirere in Oct 2007.
Had Edwards reamined true after his confession in 2006, there would be NO Enquirere story today and Elizabeth would be respected as pulling in her husband from an indiscretion and saving her marriage and preserving a Presidential candiate.
SO I disagree with people who write in and charge Elizabeth with a cover up.
She forgave a “small affair” and had no ideaa the affair was so big.
SHe never coverred for her husband in this BIG indiscretion.
She is a victim of Edwards.
He has hurt her by betraying her twice.
And now she is being reviled by some in the Public.
Peole have to analyse this matter more thoroughly in order to get a better picture of Elizabeht.
She was NOT involved in a cover up.
But Edwards was!
And he hid behind a wife who supported him after his affair, by lying to her that the affair was over.
She beleived him. She did not condone or support or agree to cover up a “continuing” affair into 2007 and 2008.
Had Edwards NOT returned to tha affair but ended it in 2006, there would have been no story.
No one is crucified for an indiscretion if they admit it and stop it!
Edwards is crucified becasue of lies, cover ups, and deception that still seems to be going on.
I am sure Elizabeth is shcoked by this. Even today edwards is clinging to the 2006 version of his “small affair” but the Enquirer is not interested in that, they are talking of an ON GOING affair into 2007 and 2008 with a love child resulting.
And this must be news for Elizabeth.
She never covered that up and we act as if she is covering this affair up, that she knew.
She knew in 2006 of a sjmall affair that her husband promised was over. Who would not forgive and move on?
Posted by: Ev | August 14, 2008, 3:05 pm 3:05 pm
I would like to believe he is remorseful. However, I believe he is just remorseful he got caught and he is exposed. He probably promised his wife he would have no more contact with her, yet he did.
Posted by: Fran | August 14, 2008, 4:42 pm 4:42 pm
Honor Elizabeth by allowing John Edwards to work his butt off for the public good. John Edwards affair is a human weakness – sadly he is in the majority. John McCain had several affairs while married and got involved with Cindy while still married to his first wife. You can’t help who you fall in love with and many of us have been hurt by infidelity. Mr. Edwards is intelligent and offering his services to the public. Let him serve the public and produce effective results that he is capable of, experienced, and educated for. Elizabeth even confirms this man can do the country a lot of good. George Bush is a former alcoholic,drug user and not too smart. Edwards has much to offer. Make him prove his value.
Posted by: Belle | August 14, 2008, 5:00 pm 5:00 pm
Honor Elizabeth by allowing John Edwards to work his butt off for the public good. John Edwards affair is a human weakness – sadly he is in the majority. John McCain had several affairs while married and got involved with Cindy while still married to his first wife. You can’t help who you fall in love with and many of us have been hurt by infidelity. Mr. Edwards is intelligent and offering his services to the public. Let him serve the public and produce effective results that he is capable of, experienced, and educated for. Elizabeth even confirms this man can do the country a lot of good. George Bush is a former alcoholic,drug user and not too smart. Edwards has much to offer. Make him prove his value.
Posted by: Belle | August 14, 2008, 5:04 pm 5:04 pm
Rielle(not her real name)is 44 years old and just had a baby. I guess white trash skanks really can breed like cockroaches.
Posted by: mom | August 14, 2008, 5:33 pm 5:33 pm
John Edwards talked about Dad’s mill,
While sleeping with a chick off the pill,
He lied and fibbed to the MS press,
And, awoke early to preen and dress.
His wife, Elizabeth, knew the lie in 2006,
But supported John in Iowa while sick,
They stole Hillary’s honest votes daily,
And laughed on cue, and hiding Rielle.
Now John’s betrayal is common news,
And Fred Baron has money to lose,
Rielle, now nursing, has jetted away,
Even ABC and CNN have joined the fray!
John’s affair has hurt his poor kids,
More than Clinton’s cigars ever did,
A sordid tale that some call a crock,
The only winner, a loser named Barack!
Posted by: Rose | August 14, 2008, 6:06 pm 6:06 pm
Rose – that sums it up rather nicely – very well written!
Posted by: Melissa S | August 14, 2008, 6:44 pm 6:44 pm
Belle – The difference is that John McCain didn’t lie to the press about the fact that he was still technically married to his first wife when he began seeing Cindy – he, Cindy and McCain’s ex-wife have given many interviews about the situation, it’s not the same as the Edwards affair. Edwards’ career is not over – voters tend to be very forgiving when it comes to things like infidelity, even alcohol use, it’s liars that voters generally don’t approve of.
Posted by: Just Me | August 14, 2008, 7:10 pm 7:10 pm
Mrs. Edwards should never have encouraged her husband in running for office of the President, for she knew he was scum. I regret she is being treated this way by her husband, he is a low-life and very whiney and most people don’t like him anyway even before this came out. This is also hard for her children to deal with but if they love and respect their mother, they should encourage her to put him out. The children should never ever expect their mother to live with a whore-monger just for them. The children need a decent role model, and Edwards is NOT it.
Posted by: DeHart-Starr | August 14, 2008, 7:23 pm 7:23 pm
I am sure that this press spotlight and all of the cruel remarks (such as some posted here) have done nothing whatever to lessen the anguish. I think it must be the weak, insecure and impotent people who enjoy bashing those suffering from terminal illness.
Posted by: Jordan | August 14, 2008, 7:36 pm 7:36 pm
Why are there so many judemental self righteous people in our society? The name calling is sick. I am not sure which is worst, those who “report” tabloid sentational “news” or the voyeuristic demands of many in our society that seems to create the market for this junk.
I don’t care if the person is a Democrat or a Republican everyone of us that lack the ability to WALK on WATER should focus on self. To all of those self proclaimed Christians, I wonder how gloating at someone else’s demise fits into the teaching of Christ?
Posted by: David | August 14, 2008, 7:58 pm 7:58 pm
WHY in the world would any rational person try to compare McCain’s cheating past to that of Edwards???
Yeah….I would hope that most ADULTS would correct a child if he/she said, “but so and so did it too”. My mom would say, “if your friends jumped off of a bridge would you follow them?” Right after popping me in the mouth.
GROW-UP people.
(However, there would be NO REASON to even go there with any form of comparisons if there weren’t so MANY conservative HYPOCRITES!!)
What sane person would sit on Fox “news” and try to use cheating on a sick wife is worst that a healthy one? The faux compasion for Edward’s illness is clear or else they would give her and even Mrs. Craig and Mrs. Hagee space to come to terms with the transgressions against their vows. (It seems as if the institution of marriage is being DESTROYED from within but some would blame same sex unions.)
So, before some of you are so quick to kick Edwards under the bus and try use his personal life against him like the Bill Clinton witch hunt….Do yourself a favor and APPLY the SAME STANDARDS to people like McCain, Craig, Bush, Newt and all of those snake in the grass Republicans. (They ARE CONSISTENT when it comes to DOUBLE STANDARDS.)
(Maybe the best thing is to let he who has not sinned throw the first stone)
(
Posted by: David | August 14, 2008, 8:44 pm 8:44 pm
John Edwards and Obama are both selfish selfcentered and it’s all about themselves. Say or do whatever they think will get them the votes. Both are unfit to Lead this Nation or be Senators.
Posted by: GotABrainfromOhio | August 14, 2008, 9:37 pm 9:37 pm
Andrew Young of the John Edwards story: The arrests for worthless checks, DWI, burglary, criminal mischief, the federal tax lien
webofdeception.com
Posted by: Robert Lewis | August 14, 2008, 9:51 pm 9:51 pm
I do feel very sad for Elizabeth, especially after the health-related issues she has had, but….let’s not forget that she knew about the lie while he was campaigning. So, she’s not totally innocent herself.
My guess is that when John went for the secretive meeting with his ex-mistress several months ago and this became public she realized John had not ended the affair as she thought. That’s what prompted the truth to be shared with the American public
Women such as Hillary Clinton, Mrs. Spitzer, and Elizabeth Edwards must want to maintain their life style and position in the elite world and accept their husbands’ infidelity and stay with them. If Hillary divorced Bill, she knew she would have ruined her chance to run for President. It’s too bad the examples being set for their children.
Posted by: Marci | August 14, 2008, 11:11 pm 11:11 pm
Edwards isn’t the nominee. Obama is. And Obama did NOT cheat on his wife. But John McCain ‘MARRIED HIS MISTRESS!’.
I do not want a Married Mistress for my first Lady. That is DISTASTEFUL and DISRESPECTFUL of the position of the ‘FIRST LADY’!
Posted by: lovinggrandma53 | August 14, 2008, 11:33 pm 11:33 pm
Hillary is also a nominee….not so fast Barack….We Hillary gals have got a big surpise for you in Denver.
Posted by: Mark | August 15, 2008, 12:05 am 12:05 am
I am with you loving Grandma. Both Edwards and Mccain are disgusting behavior. I found McCain’s life has all the elements of Edwards, infidelity, hurt, and money. I found even more disgusting Mcain’s applying for a marriage license before he had a final divorce. At least he or Cindy one are paying the first wife medical expenses for life. I am sure the southern Baptists must be real proud of both of them.
Posted by: aw | August 15, 2008, 12:47 am 12:47 am
I can’t believe all the Edwards apologists here… “He is not evil, he is weak” … what is more evil than to cheat and inseminate another woman after your wife learns she has incurable cancer? That behaviour is egocentric, heartless and evil…
What of the evil done to the body politic? Through his selfish deception and lying (supported by the m.s. media, the entire democrat primary was skewed …
He is a hypocrite and thief on so many levels … we are lucky that he imploded before he came close to having a shot at becoming POTUS…
Posted by: Reality | August 15, 2008, 12:48 am 12:48 am
Oh,and by the way, what else remained for Mrs. Edwards to do? It is not very practical, to enter divorce proceedings and to sue for child custody knowing that your days are limited. The best any mother can do under the circumstances is hope to protect her children by trying to get her husband back on track… Saying that, how such an approach can extend to standing by, listening to, and supporting all his hypocritical B.S. is beyond me.
It will be easy toninte to say a prayer for her and her children, but a little more difficult to say one for her dumb-horse’s-ass husband.
Posted by: Reality | August 15, 2008, 12:54 am 12:54 am
All married people, men and women, should take a lesson from this. Cheating is never alright. What doesn’t come out in the wash will come out in the rinse. I’ll betcha a million dollars against a glazed donut John Edwards wishes he had it to do all over again. I’m certain he would make a different choice.
Posted by: Hardlabour | August 15, 2008, 1:46 am 1:46 am
I see ABC has decided to not report the latest news that Edwards paid his mistress with campaign funds. The story is everywhere but ABC. And the NY Times denies they knew about Edwards’ mistress and that is why they never reported on it. America’s media is corrupt.
Posted by: Bill | August 15, 2008, 6:56 am 6:56 am
It’s hilarious how all you people are so titillated by having this new opportunity to gossip. It’s no different from thy way we used to gossip about our friends and neighbours, only safer – none of us are going to face the fury of the Edwardses because we gossiped on this blog.
Funny.
Posted by: bemused | August 17, 2008, 7:43 am 7:43 am
I would hardly call the comments posted as gossip. The news is out Bemused. The nation has a right to have an opinion about a man that asked for our trust and could have been our president. The reason those in power no longer feel obligated to live a better life is because they are counting on us to instantly forgive them and just let them back into the fold. We no longer hold those looking to lead our great country the highest standard possible for any human being. I could care less how the Edwards family works this out. What I care about is that they both lied for a variety of reasons none that satisfy me as a voter. They threw all of us under the bus.
Posted by: Kristin | August 17, 2008, 8:20 pm 8:20 pm
I think that John Edwards should make an immediate appointment with Gary Hart to learn that once he “dared” the media to follow him around, it was Katy, bar the door. I can’t believe, though, that Elizabeth Edwards is staying with that smarmy can of worms she is married to.
Posted by: Ruth Karraker | August 18, 2008, 9:39 pm 9:39 pm
He is a glib, smooth, disgusting liar!
Thank God this came out.
I pray for Elizabeth to have the strength to deal with this (in a better way). I also pray for her to see the light…the real truth about the complete lack of a moral compass of her husband.
This guy is the lowest of the low.
Elizabeth needs to dump him, as quickly as possible & make the best financial deal she can make for herself and her kids. She also needs to protect her kids from this completely amoral, selfish and dangerously narcissistic creep!
Watching this guy makes my stomach turn.
Disgusting!!
Posted by: Yvette | August 19, 2008, 6:53 pm 6:53 pm
Actually, let’s face it; John Edwards is a HOT BABE. I was surprised he hadn’t had an affair.
Yes, he was the real example of “The Candidate,” the movie with Robert Redford.
I look at it this way: philandering has been around for centuries. Rich men have always had the option of fooling around, and numerous mistresses have made their mark on society because of it. In addition, their wives have put up with it because the marriage gave them many things beyond companionship and love. Financial security and social standing are but two of the things people get from a marriage. In this case they BOTH stayed in a union that had obviously gone awry at some point.
My heart goes out to Elizabeth. She’s an educated woman, and quite frankly I think she could have her own financial securit, social standing if she were to leave.
Posted by: callie | August 19, 2008, 9:11 pm 9:11 pm
What does John see in Rielle? She is obviously white trash. Love those tacky head bands! She also seems like a wacko with all the New Age hippy stuff. Was she really worth throwing away his entire political career? Has she never heard of the Pill? Mrs. Edwards is much better looking. She also easily outclasses the hippy skank by a mile!
Posted by: Allison | August 23, 2008, 9:10 pm 9:10 pm
How much more can one woman take? Mrs. Edwards is a beautiful mother, wife and pearson. As a mother myself, dealing with the death of my son…I couldn’t even begin to carry her cross, it’s too much to bear.
Posted by: Rhonda Warren | August 24, 2008, 12:31 am 12:31 am
Elizabeth my heart is broken for you and John.I am so suprized at what he has done.I loved you both and supported you 100% I thought he was a good christine and family man. I still love you
Posted by: margaret bleggi | August 27, 2008, 7:40 pm 7:40 pm
Unlike Elizabeth, I don’t think it was a good idea for Edwards to come out with the truth. He was no longer running for president. He should have stayed clear away of this woman. He should not have gave them this story by meeting with her then or at any time. It was enough that his wife knew. Opening this to the public only made it ugly. I don’t think this will make Elizabeths last days comfortable. It would have been easier for her if it was never proven to be true in the public. I am sure that she doesn’t want anyone to feel sorry for her. I doubt that she thought people would be so unforgiving of her husband. Why he ever thought that he could run for president after doing this is unbelievable.
Posted by: Debra | August 29, 2008, 3:00 pm 3:00 pm
I’m just so sorry. A true Greek-type tragedy for a good family and for the country, too. I wish the best for John and Elizabeth Edwards and their children, that for the rest of their lives they may feel love from the world around them, to help them in their repentance and healing. May God be with them.
Posted by: Laurel | September 7, 2008, 1:01 am 1:01 am
Gotta hand it to him…the broad is hot…ol lady ain’t. She did pop out kids like a rat and that’s the point, she thought she mothered them…but this jerk treated her like a common rat instead of the mother of his children. He needs to rot his pretty hair off.
Posted by: Bubba | September 9, 2008, 11:29 pm 11:29 pm
All this is well and good but that does not excuse her from not stopping her husband from entering the presidential race and actively campaigning for him.
What would have happened if he had gotten the nomination and the information about his affair had come out? McCain would have easily won the election in November.
May be her ambition to become a first lady outweighed her obligation to her party and the nation!
Posted by: jazzman | October 5, 2008, 12:06 am 12:06 am
He’s be hurting if I was married to him. I’d kick in the b____s and then kick him to the curb.
Posted by: TERI | February 3, 2009, 12:45 pm 12:45 pm
Apparently, the Daily News got an advance copy of Elizabeth Edwards’ book. I’d do more than vomit.
Posted by: Cancer survivor | April 30, 2009, 6:15 am 6:15 am
Oh good lord – who agreed to publish this and “gift” someone like Elizabeth Edwards with MORE money on top of it all? Goodness. Makes me vomit just thinking about her writing these words, editing them, having John, the love of her life edit them for her, passing them along to her grown daughter to peruse. Yikes, hon. You are ever the opportunist – you knew about it all – and kept it secreted from the public while promoting your husband DURING A PRESIDENTIAL CAMPAIGN as the second coming? What does that make you, Mrs. Edwards? Pretty darned and totally pathetic. The antithesis of pathetic if you ask me. Your husband went back and back and back and back to Ms. Hunter for reasons that you have refused to own. Don’t bore us or demean Ms. Hunter any further by fictionalizing this sexual relationship between consenting adults any further. Get some help Elizabeth and apologize to your children for penning this. Really. Yuck.
Posted by: Lori | April 30, 2009, 3:30 pm 3:30 pm
To those who make bad comments about Elizabeth; YOU OBVIOUSLY HAVE NOT BEEN MARRIED TO A CHEATING, LYING MAN! You have no idea the pain they cause and how much you want to speak out about the pain when everyone looks down on you for your husbands infidelity. HOW DARE YOU!!!! I know first hand because when I found out about my husbands affair I didn’t want to get out of the shower but to instead stay in that water and use a bottle of the scum remover until it was gone!!!! It not just the infidelity it is about who you are as a person, yes, but you still try to make the best of a bad relationship. NO MATTER WHO YOU ARE!!! Women are expected to stand by their men, but men are expected to stab the wife in the back when they have an affair and leave them with nothing!!! WHO CAME UP WITH THIS DOUBLE STANDARD??? So, she is the bad person for speaking out? What the H___L is wrong with society that they can’t have a little respect for a woman who tried to keep her marriage afloat and tried to move on when in reality SHE SHOULD HAVE KICKED HIM TO THE CURB AND TOOK HIS CHANCES AWAY FROM HIM!!! She earned my respect!!! My twins weren’t even 1yr old when I found out! I am a happier person for leaving him and better off!!! As she will see she is too!!!
Posted by: NoneofURBus | May 1, 2009, 7:57 am 7:57 am
I do not condone cheating …. I actually caught my ex in bed with another woman.
People do make mistakes and it’s between their significate other and them.
I don’t feel we need to hear about it, unless in Bill Clinton’s case … he actually lied before the Grand Jury. Then it’s a crime ….
Posted by: Deb | May 1, 2009, 11:27 am 11:27 am
My own charming, intelligent and seemingly loving husband is a lot like John Edwards. I’ve come to realize that both his job and me are a “cover” for him. We help him project a public image of trustworthiness and caring, but really he lacks empathy and acts in very cruel and manipulative ways. I just found out he was having an affair…with a woman who he had so completely lied to that she did not know he was married. He has spun an extraordinary web of lies. The truth is still coming out in “installments”. Just like Elizabeth, I participated in his charade and kept his secret because I did not know how extensive the lies and cheating were. I still don’t really know.
My perspective is that Edwards is a similar kind of person. The charm is a veneer and below it is deeply selfish person without empathy. At least Elizabeth knows his true character now and won’t (hopefully) be fooled into thinking it was a one time mistake or that he has changed. If she chooses to stay with him, and given her health it would be reasonable to do so, she won’t be surprised now by any new revelations or other things he’ll do. I feel so badly for her…and I think John Edwards is scum. Charming, articulate, handsome scum.
Posted by: Editor's Wife | May 4, 2009, 1:07 am 1:07 am
I’ve been through many episodes of radiation, chemo, and heart failure (after the last chemo) since 1994.
My husband still enjoys his stellar good-guy, family-man, businessman reputation after his unbelievable long-term betrayal with scores of prostitutes on his “gambling” trips, and having dated a prostitute in our community for a year and a half WHILE WE WERE IN COUNSELING after he moved out for a “separation” (and while dating me on Saturdays only) for a year and a half. It wasn’t until April 2007 when I found the mistress’ phone bill in his car — and subsequently names of hookers on Windsor and LV hotel notepaper — that I realized how all those years, especially the ones in counseling, had been a deception of gargantuan proportions. We’re still together for various reasons, but I do resent that people have the impression that I was at the most fault because HE was the one who made the decision to move out even though I begged him to stay and try to work things out. I still feel foolish and have many mixed feelings. I threatened divorce after I found out everything, but he begged me to stay. I feel it was for his reputation and also the fact that he didn’t want to split our assets. I am still angry, even though he seems to be trying hard to make amends. But his stellar reputation is still intact. At least John Edwards got his comeuppance with the exposure of his secret life.
Posted by: mpg | May 7, 2009, 9:30 am 9:30 am
Only Elizabeth and John know whether staying with each other is / was the best decision. If she decides to go on her own, rediscover her identity, and empower herself,
Posted by: Kat | May 7, 2009, 8:49 pm 8:49 pm