Aug 11, 2008 7:12pm

Thar’s Gold in Them Thar Memos

The Atlantic has provided a link to Josh Green’s fantastic story as well as to original copies of even more interesting/prescient/bizarre memos by the campaign team.

Some must-reads: In October 2006, one month before Sen. Hillary Clinton, D-NY, was re-elected to the Senate (and when she was supposedly not contemplating a presidential run), Mark Penn prepares a memo prepares a memo called "The Plan," where he declares that "HRC is the power candidate" and assesses potential rivals:

"Kerry significantly damaged. Even though he has money in the bank, many will ask him not to run. Gore waiting to swoop in later, when we hope it will look like too late."

In December 2006, Penn writes that former British Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher should be Clinton’s role model. Voters view their president as the "father" of the country, he wrote, "they do not want someone who would be the first mama. ..A word about being human. Bill Gates once asked me, ‘Could you make me more human?’ I said, ‘Being human is overrated.’"

Here’s the March 2007 Penn memo that says of Obama: "I cannot imagine America electing a president during a time of war who is not at his center fundamentally American in his thinking and in his values." Classy.

Thar’s gold in them thar memos. Including a letter from the managing editor of the Washington Post in February 2008 complaining that a member of the Clinton communications team was falsely telling other reporters that a Postie had been fired by the New York Times.

- jpt

User Comments

Campaign is nothing to say about how a person can govern — Just look at Bush. He ran the most successful campaign, raised the most money until Obama surpassed it. Obama is still an empty suit — he and his strategists happened to be smart enough to find a good campaign strategy. I am not impressed by his own qualification, and I know there are many people felt the same way. I will still vote for Hillary if there is a chance. But for this election year, I will sit out.

Posted by: Amy | August 11, 2008, 7:25 pm 7:25 pm

Amy
I would disagree…
go ahead look at Bush…
a slimey political campaign means a slimey political administration.

Posted by: dl | August 11, 2008, 7:32 pm 7:32 pm

I agree with you 100% Amy. I have chosen to vote for McCain. The first time in my life that my vote will go to a Republican and teh same goes for my family. As African Americans we always stuck with democrats but now we have realized that they no longer reflect our values. Also sick of being embarrassed by them Bill Clinton, Edwards, Gary Condit . Hillary was the last vestige of hope for me in the DNC. Now I have jumped ship.

Posted by: Samantha | August 11, 2008, 7:35 pm 7:35 pm

Why criticize Penn for his memo about Obama? It is only not “classy” if he was wrong. Obama has since shown his questionable American values with his association with Wright and his racist, unpatriotic church, and with the flag stomping Ayers. All of this is FACT, not smears. You can’t run away from your past.

Posted by: decentAmerican | August 11, 2008, 7:36 pm 7:36 pm

Obama is just the same as any other politician.

Posted by: Amy | August 11, 2008, 7:39 pm 7:39 pm

I guess there’s gold in them memos if you’re out to spread Democratic ill will mighty close to the Denver convention. Dang!

Posted by: kat | August 11, 2008, 7:41 pm 7:41 pm

Amy,
Obama is an intelligent man who loves his country. He seems to be less affected by dogma than genuine thought. He has demonstrated an unshakeable quality when things have blown up in his face.
He is a man who believes in justice, for example in the case of Lilly Ledbetter. And he is a man who believes in universal health insurance; as Jesus said, heal the sick.
But his best quality is that he is a grown up. Grown ups understand the idea that some priorities override others: For example, the need to make the massive investment in and infrastructure, education and a changing to a renewable energy economy was and is inconsistent with going to war in Iraq.
As for McCain, his hot-head, bomb, bomb, bomb, bomb Iran style proves that you can be 70 years old and still be juvenile.

Posted by: John's conscience | August 11, 2008, 7:46 pm 7:46 pm

Did anybody ever report on Obama played dirty politics in Chicago with his REZKO connection

Posted by: scfar | August 11, 2008, 7:49 pm 7:49 pm

John’s conscience:
Your Obama judgments are only claims that can not be substantiated with facts. I am not convinced.
Obama is just the same as any other politician. His actions do not match his glorious words.
Obama-Wright stuff is as bad as Edwards’ recent scandal. A person who claims to the unifying force, yet he has listened to poisonous and divisive preaching for 20 years and did nothing (and even felt very comfortable). There was a reporter wrote about how he himself witness Obama sitting in the pew nodding with Wright when he said those ugly words. The MSM media ignored that report, just the same they did with the Edwards’ scandal.
Wait until the GOP uses the Obama-Wright as the center piece in their ads. I know many Obama supporters will cry smear campaign. But for many people, that is a legitimate issue, and it is a fact.

Posted by: amy | August 11, 2008, 8:06 pm 8:06 pm

Whoa nelly! Looking to McCain for ethics? The man who left his ill wife to chase an heiress and married her 6 weeks after their divorce? At least Obama is still married to his wife, and didn’t marry her for the money.

Posted by: Still A Democrat | August 11, 2008, 8:13 pm 8:13 pm

I would like to see the internal documents and emails of the Obama campaign, including regarding the following:
1. strategies with respect to how to appeal to people of particular demographics, including older white women
2. their aggressive marketing techniques, and how to manipulate this marketing to achieve their ends
3. how to deal with the “Rezko” problem after Obama said Rezko was not the man he knew; and how to deal with Ayers and Pfleger
4. what they said about Hillary Clinton
Atlantic, where is this information?

Posted by: Former Democrat | August 11, 2008, 8:19 pm 8:19 pm

Did Obama want to play the race card again with McCain as he did Hillary

Posted by: scfar | August 11, 2008, 8:23 pm 8:23 pm

SEXISM is praciced by both men and women in this country…

Posted by: bigwon | August 11, 2008, 8:26 pm 8:26 pm

Also what the campaign said about how Obama supporters should conduct themselves at caucuses

Posted by: Leslie | August 11, 2008, 8:27 pm 8:27 pm

“The Penn memo that says of Obama: “I cannot imagine America electing a president during a time of war who is not at his center fundamentally American in his thinking and in his values.”
Jake Tapper’s reply: “Classy.”
“Classy” must be a new synonym for “The truth”…

Posted by: pydnuor | August 11, 2008, 8:28 pm 8:28 pm

Penn is DEAD ON. I can’t imagine electing a man who is the complete antithesis of American values. I don’t want him near the WH, and the thought alone makes me break out in hives.
McCAIN ’08/HILLARY ’12
I don’t want any President of mine having associations with terriorist, anti American friends or mentors.

Posted by: Deb | August 11, 2008, 8:32 pm 8:32 pm

This just shows that all politicians SUCK…Edwards said it right they are egotistical and narcissistic to the extreme….no doubt some are worse than others…but for sure Obama just like Edwards was a media creation…there is no there there.
With Hillary and McCain there is something to latch onto with history Obama has obviously done nothing in 20 years because you cannot get any records on him for those years….which is interesting in its self.
Perhaps the absent media could give us Americans some BACKGROUND on Obama instead of all the fluff crap they have tried to spoonfeed us for a year now…people can say anything they want about the man because the media is not doing it’s job and giving information about him.

Posted by: Jaded | August 11, 2008, 8:37 pm 8:37 pm

Still a Democrat….yeah that Michelle Obama is married to is one happy American…NOT. At least Cindy loves her country and travels the world doing philanthropic work on behalf of ill children. Her two sons are serving this country and following a family tradition to service. The Obamas just give lip service…and WHAT, PRAY TELL HAVE THEY DONE FOR ANYONE BUT THEMSELVES, WHILE BASHING THEIR COUNTRY.
Like Obama told the 7 year old girl the other day when asked why he wants to be President….he doesn’t like what America has become?

Posted by: Deb | August 11, 2008, 8:42 pm 8:42 pm

Jaded….I’ll give you Obama’s background…143 days in the Senate before deciding to run for the most important office in our country. Before that…”community organizer” who got some asbestos removed from a building in his neighborhood.

Posted by: Deb | August 11, 2008, 8:45 pm 8:45 pm

Make no mistake, McCain is running for Bush’s 3rd term. The same team that slimmed him in 2000 is running his campaign.
I’m voting for Obama because I only want three things from him:
1. Stop the Bush Crime family from stealing treasury $
2. Slow the rise of the national debt
3. A president, when given the choice, would pick peace over war.

Posted by: JDS | August 11, 2008, 8:46 pm 8:46 pm

So two little posters under the illusion that Obama wouldn’t go to war or is a peaceful man….no he is an idiot who threatened to take military action in a nuclear armed Pakistan…he wants to sound “tough” too.
He is an idiot.

Posted by: Jaded | August 11, 2008, 8:48 pm 8:48 pm

I don’t understand how one could expect Obama to decrease the national debt. He has made no affirmative commitment to balance the federal budget, obviously has no experience with fiscal responsibility, and has suggested a whole bunch of costly programs.

Posted by: Mo | August 11, 2008, 8:52 pm 8:52 pm

Obama came he divided and now wants to conquer.
Obama wants america to serve him. Not Him serve America.
Looks around how he parades himself around It is all about him. It is nothing about What he has done for this country and would like a chance to do more.
He has done nothing, but run for office after office and give speeches, and market himself.
He changes his mind so much because he does not know what he is doing. That and he is trying to make everyone think he is doing Things just for them. When his only goal is himself.
He threw his family under the bus, all his best friends of life, you know he will through you under the bus.
He said he came to Unite, he did yes he did. He United the Black Community.
His Plan is coming together.

Posted by: seah | August 11, 2008, 8:56 pm 8:56 pm

“Whoa nelly! Looking to McCain for ethics? The man who left his ill wife to chase an heiress and married her 6 weeks after their divorce” StillADem, is that the new politics of “UNITY”? ah, no, the politics of Hypocrites.

Posted by: Jeff | August 11, 2008, 9:28 pm 9:28 pm

rodney…don’t worry so much about party, worry about COUNTRY FIRST. McCain has a history and I just read his speech in Penn. today and he again, spoke of the need for bipartisanship. Both parties need to be for COUNTRY FIRST!
HILLARY SUPPORTER FOR McCAIN!

Posted by: Deb | August 11, 2008, 9:43 pm 9:43 pm

* McCain has a history or working across isles.

Posted by: Deb | August 11, 2008, 9:44 pm 9:44 pm

Why are we still talking about Hillary at this stage of the game? Obama, like it or not, is the nominee! Is it really necessary to continue down this road of constant Hillary-bashing? Obama is (and always was) a media creation – a pop star candidate, nothing more! But the MSM still isn’t happy that their guy won the primary – NO! They need to totally destroy his competition. What are they afraid of, that they’ll have to take roll all at the convention?
P U M A!

Posted by: Jan | August 11, 2008, 9:52 pm 9:52 pm

rodney….it’s Pelosi and the Dems who put us in this foreign oil dilema…McCain and 67% of Americans favor drilling HERE. I’m OK with that. As for this war..no one wants it, but we’re in it, and I trust McCain to handle getting us out, better than BO as I trust McCain more in all foreign defense. I can’t explain it, I just will sleep easier with McCain at the helm and NOT OBAMA. Our enemies would relish an Obama Presidency.

Posted by: Deb | August 11, 2008, 10:03 pm 10:03 pm

Angie….you better come to grips that Hillary supporters are not all going to fall in line for Obama. Months after this election is over, when books are written and analysis is done, we WILL find out that OBAMA lost due to those PUMAS you so love to degrade.

Posted by: Deb | August 11, 2008, 10:09 pm 10:09 pm

SAMANTHA WROTE:
I have chosen to vote for McCain. The first time in my life that my vote will go to a Republican and teh same goes for my family.
———
So Samantha, you’re going to vote for McCain which means you’re going to vote for EVERYTHING Hillary Clinton stands for. Like it or not, she and Obama’s platforms are virtually identical. I think their only difference is a few inches in their health care plan. Then again, McCain doesn’t HAVE A HEALTH CARE PLAN — something you obviously you obviously don’t care about since you’re throwing him your vote.
Oh, and fyi, McCain clips his speeches from wikipedia.

Posted by: Kate | August 11, 2008, 10:10 pm 10:10 pm

SAMANTHA WROTE:
I have chosen to vote for McCain. The first time in my life that my vote will go to a Republican and teh same goes for my family.
———
So Samantha, you’re going to vote for McCain which means you’re going to vote for EVERYTHING Hillary Clinton stands AGAINST. Like it or not, she and Obama’s platforms are virtually identical. I think their only difference is a few inches in their health care plan. Then again, McCain doesn’t HAVE A HEALTH CARE PLAN — something you obviously you obviously don’t care about since you’re throwing him your vote.
Oh, and fyi, McCain clips his speeches from wikipedia.

Posted by: Kate | August 11, 2008, 10:11 pm 10:11 pm

rodney…we have to let the world know we have our own, we’re doing something about it and they don’t have us by our short hairs.

Posted by: Deb | August 11, 2008, 10:17 pm 10:17 pm

Angie, you need to deal with the analysis when this election is over in Nov. Obama loses because of Hillary supporters who just won’t vote for him (and the Independents too).
It’s not just the Hollywood elite who determine the outcome of this election. Hard working, middle AMERICANS (operative word AMERICANS).
Boomers will trump the American Idol vote.

Posted by: Deb | August 11, 2008, 10:21 pm 10:21 pm

Penn is the man. Write a bunch of drivel about terrorism, uneducated Americans will believe it hook-line-sinker, they’ll vote for McCain who’ll further tank the economy, McCain will be too tired to serve two terms (quack quack), and then bring back Hillary and her slimy husband.
American Values.

Posted by: Kate | August 11, 2008, 10:22 pm 10:22 pm

Hey Kate…sounds good, from your mouth to God’s ears.

Posted by: Deb | August 11, 2008, 10:25 pm 10:25 pm

Seah,
You know one thing Obama did? He got 200,000 Europeans (our allies, remember?) to show up to a pro-America rally.
POP QUIZ:
Was John McCain unhappy that:
A. Barack Obama gave a speech to our allies asking telling them were are all in this together.
B. A crowd of 200,000 Europeans were supporting the United States and waving the U.S. flag.
C. That John McCain couldn’t get ONE European to listen to him if he offered to pay them.

Posted by: John's conscience | August 11, 2008, 10:32 pm 10:32 pm

At some point, you have to get past party loyalty. For Democrats, that’s hard; I know, because the party demands an almost zealot-like allegience. But I’m so over the Democratic party it’s not even funny. I’m sorry!!! I never thought I’d be saying that. And don’t think for a minute that it has come without a LOT of soul searching. But the DNC has sold out, and it’s no longer the party I once knew. Being so involved in the party, I now feel like a tiny ship in the middle of the ocean.
I love this country, but I hardly recognize the Democratic party anymore. I still think Hillary had the best chance of winning the presidency, and she was tossed out like so much garbage by the party’s leadership, with the help of a complicit media. Those of us who supported her do not feel welcome anymore, and you’re all telling us to get over it. I’m sorry, but we’ll probably never get over it.

Posted by: Jan | August 11, 2008, 10:32 pm 10:32 pm

Comparing Obama’s experience to other high rated Presidents
Barack Obama
Federal Years = 4 State Experience – 6 Total = 10 Rating =
Abraham Lincoln
Federal Years = 2 State Experience – 8 Total = 10 Rating = 2
Theodore Roosevelt
Federal Years = 2 State Experience – 4
Total = 8 Rating = 5
Ronald Regan
Federal Years = 0 State Experience – 8
Total = 8 Rating = 8
Dwight D. Eisenhower
Federal Years = 0 State Experience – 0
Total = 0 Rating = 9
Franklin Roosevelt
Federal Years = 6 State Experience – 6
Total = 12 Rating = 3

Posted by: Jim | August 11, 2008, 10:34 pm 10:34 pm

Jan…YOU SPEAK FOR MILLIONS OF US.

Posted by: Deb | August 11, 2008, 10:39 pm 10:39 pm

John’s conscience…you know how Obama got 200,000 Germans out for his speech? He got Rheannon (a platinum selling German rock group) and a reggae star to come out for a free concert in the park. You can go to the rock group’s web site (hope I spelled it right)….and see where they posted Obama campaign asked (payed?) them to play before his speech. You think and unknown Senator for the states really could get that kind of turnout without a lure? BUT OF COURSE, THE MEDIA NEVER COVERED THIS.

Posted by: Deb | August 11, 2008, 10:44 pm 10:44 pm

*ageist, sorry

Posted by: Deb | August 11, 2008, 10:49 pm 10:49 pm

rodney….please give me the link to your fact regarding 95% of the Hillary supporters voting BO. All the polls say 1/3 of her supporters ARE SO NOT ON BOARD (and I’m guessing hundreds of thousands are lying and saying they will). Voter remorse and privacy in the booth do strange things.

Posted by: Deb | August 11, 2008, 10:56 pm 10:56 pm

“And all we could do is watch Obama “limp” across the finish line, hardly winning a single state in the last weeks,”
Amazing how being vetted took him down..

Posted by: Al Johnson | August 11, 2008, 11:37 pm 11:37 pm

Jan, Obama lost 9 out of the last 14, and his victories were weak to be sure. I think this country is to be commended for wanting a black President, especially the Dem party pushing for that….they just have the wrong black candidate. Hillary was the most qaulified and the polls continually showed her winning against McCain. My mother in law (a die hard Rep) DID NOT want Hillary to win, as she knew she was the strongest candidate. The Dems brought this on themselves, and I’m afraid they’ll never learn they only win when they nominate a centrist (i.e, Bill).
McCAIN ’08/HILLARY ’12

Posted by: Deb | August 11, 2008, 11:39 pm 11:39 pm

“Me, I’m voting intelligence and public/community service.”
Good. Check for it in the debates.

Posted by: Al Johnson | August 11, 2008, 11:44 pm 11:44 pm

It’s so great that the 18-30 year old demographic (aka, the non-voting demographic) of America has been inspired by BHO’s message of change and positivity…. Now all he has to do is actually get them to VOTE! Good luck with that! Too bad that’s the core of his support. HAHAHAHAHA

Posted by: BO Hoo | August 11, 2008, 11:47 pm 11:47 pm

Someone please remind John McCain that all of our soldiers are fighting in Iraq…. Remember the surge ? The one that Obama said would make us vulnerable. I’ve got some news for you Johnnie boy. Don’t irritate Putin right now because you are not President and we like living in our country and speaking English. Take a break and go to your ranch for some barbecue.

Posted by: Ron | August 12, 2008, 12:11 am 12:11 am

Truth be known….conservatives have
FAR less animosity toward Obama than
Hillary Dems do. It’s a given that
the “big tent” party is really an
exclusive little club…in your power
circle. Once again, the Clintons are
the straw that stirs the drink. Obama
will be left dehydrated and prostrate.

Posted by: Trajan | August 12, 2008, 12:59 am 12:59 am

Why am I not surprised when the McCain supporters see nothing wrong with the Clintons’ tactics? After all, John and Hillary are old drinking buddies, and agree on just about everything.
Senator Obama has twice the legislative experience as Senator Clinton — but, of course most of that was in a State Legislature, and we all know that anything other than Washington DC experience doesn’t count, right? What was that party that wanted to put more power back into the hands of the states? Repub-something. Haven’t seen them around recently.
“Campaign is nothing to say about how a person can govern — Just look at Bush. He ran the most successful campaign, raised the most money until Obama surpassed it.”
Actually, Amy, how you run a campaign says a LOT about you govern. Easiest example: the current POTUS was kept in one of the most comprehensive campaign bubbles of all time. All the real work went on around him while he smiled and capered without a care in the world. With few exceptions, that’s been the case in the West Wing since. Results? I recommend Richard Clarke’s “Against All Enemies.”
Obama is about as far from being an empty suit as McCain is from being a noble war hero. I will gladly stipulate that the Clintons’ campaign was badly planned and poorly executed through no (or very little) fault of the candidates, but it is over. Vote for McCain if you must, but vote. Democracy is not a spectator sport.

Posted by: MikeC | August 12, 2008, 5:40 am 5:40 am

Jan and Deb
I agree with both of your comments 100%.

Posted by: TO | August 12, 2008, 8:14 am 8:14 am

Sure it’s low but these memos are only coming out now to derail a roll call vote at the convention. The Obama campaign and the DNC want to disenfranchise 18 million + voters who did not vote for Obama in the primaries to cast the image of ‘unity’. These people deserve to be counted and to silence them for the sake of image is undemocratic at the very least and shows the true dysfunction of this party’s leadership.

Posted by: MPCT | August 12, 2008, 8:27 am 8:27 am

EVERY ONE OF THE 18 MILLION VOTERS WHO ARE NOT ALLOWED THEIR VOTE AT THE CONVENTION SHOULD GO VOTE MCCAIN. MCCAIN IS REALLY A PRETTY GOOD PERSON. I WILL NOT ACCEPT ANY MORE ABUSE FROM OBAMA AND THE DNC. IF YOU VOTED FOR HILLARY AND GO VOTE FOR OBAMA THEN YOU ACCEPT THE ABUSE. THEY WILL THUS CONTINUE TO ABUSE YOU AS LONG AS YOU ACCEPT THE ABUSE. THE ABUSE WILL ONLY END WHEN YOU STAND UP AND SAY.
NO MORE ABUSE. I WILL NOT ACCEPT ANY ABUSE FROM OBAMA AND THE DNC.

Posted by: DemocratNoMore2 | August 12, 2008, 8:43 am 8:43 am

Those of us who supported her do not feel welcome anymore, and you’re all telling us to get over it. I’m sorry, but we’ll probably never get over it.
Posted by: Jan | Aug 11, 2008 10:32:57 PM
**********************************
It might help if Obama stood up and publicly apologized to all the Hillary voters for abusing us. he apologized to the florida and michigan voters for abusing them. He apologized to all Americans for his associations with Black Liberation Theology and admitted he has problems with his citizenship. That he might not be eligable to be POTUS.
And he promised to be less corrupt in the future. He apologized to Hillary and Bill for pulling the Race Card and he promised to try to be less a racist himself.

Posted by: DemocratNoMore2 | August 12, 2008, 8:55 am 8:55 am

Poor Hillary. Are you kidding me there has never been a bigger collapse then Hillary had. She was the front runner from the start and she blew it. Not her staff HER!! She is the most pandering politician (well excluding her husband) ever. How about a gas tax holiday Hillary I could use 30 cents.
Quit the whining and move on are you kidding me. Your precious Hillary was handed the nomination and was beaten by herself and by Obama.
Vote for whoever you want but how much of a moron do you have to be to say it was stolen from her, do you live in the real world like the rest of us.
And all of you must really follow all of this to vote for McBush because all of the issues that your precious Hillary believes are things McBush has always been against. So go right ahead and vote McBush just stop making it seem like there is any reason other then you are bitter that Hillary blew it so bad.

Posted by: Joe | August 12, 2008, 10:54 am 10:54 am

Deb,
That was 200,000 Europeans who came out to listen to an American politician ask Europe to stand by us as allies.
Did you notice how many of them were waving the American flag? How many flag waving Europeans have gone to listen to John McCain?
Now that Putin has demonstrated his willingness to threaten all of the former Soviet states (and by extension, Europe) by rolling his tanks over Georgia, where is America?
Oh, I forgot, George Bush and John McCain blundered into a war in Iraq without any strategy whatsoever, or national interest, or plan to get out again.
Putin is laughing at how these men have compromised American interests and power.

Posted by: John's conscience | August 12, 2008, 11:50 am 11:50 am

Reading the Clinton campaign memos is depressing to me because of how negative Bill Clinton was (is?). He constantly wanted to hit negatively on Obama no matter the consequence to Hillary’s image or to the Democrats’ chances of winning the general election.

Posted by: Beth in VA | August 12, 2008, 12:08 pm 12:08 pm

Beth said: “Reading the Clinton campaign memos is depressing to me because of how negative Bill Clinton was (is?).” (snipped)
I have to ask what memos are you reading? Bill wasn’t trying to be negative. The memos themselves are anti-climatic. Josh Green’s article and ahem “creative” interpretations don’t have much in common with the actual memos.

Posted by: jen | August 13, 2008, 5:30 am 5:30 am

Leave a Reply

Do you have more information about this topic? If so, please click here to contact the editors of ABC News.