Obama’s Grandmother Eulogized in Honolulu
At the National Memorial Cemetery of the Pacific at Punchbowl, in Honolulu Friday, at a memorial service for friends and co-workers, President-elect Obama’s grandmother Madelyn Dunham — who died the Sunday night before her grandson was elected president — was eulogized as a strong woman.
There will be a private memorial for family members later this year.
Obama and his half-sister Maya Soetoro-Ng sent a letter read by Al Landon, chief executive officer of the Bank of Hawaii, where Dunham had worked. Using the Hawaiian word for grandmother — "Tutu" — Obama and Soetoro-Ng wrote, "When Tutu found out that she had little time remaining, she insisted that we dispense with excessive solemnity or sorrow. She was not afraid of any storm and withstood many in her 86 years. We feel fortunate to have had so much time with our Tutu. She spent more time raising us than did most grandmothers and we benefited from her closeness; we are stronger and wiser because of her."
She "taught us to be mindful and moderate, to be patient when calm was warranted and to act when action was necessary," Landon read. "She liked playing bridge, a good mystery novel, jigsaw puzzles and an annual cruise.
"She was fiercely loyal and protective of those whom she loved and had little patience for foolishness," said the letter. "She motivated us to work harder and to take pride in our work, irrespective of salary or prestige."
You can read more about her at the Honolulu Advertiser HERE.
Master of ceremonies Emme Tomimbang said of President-elect Obama, "It broke his heart not to be here. Even though Barack and Maya couldn’t be here physically, they were here in spirit. In fact, they both helped put this together."
Dunham was cremated, but it’s not yet clear what will become of her ashes. After his mother’s death in 1995, President-elect Obama scattered her ashes from an Oahu shoreline.
- jpt
Email
Sen. DeMint: GOP Race Could Go Until Convention
Obama Avoids Questions on Contraception Rule
Am I just weird, there isn’t anything that could have kept me from my mother’s or grandmother’s funeral services.
Posted by: samhiguchi | November 15, 2008, 9:54 am 9:54 am
Nothing that I know of has been said about whether Mrs. Dunham shared her grandson’s political views. While I realize she’s been in ill health during his presidential run, it seems to me that unless she was literally incapable of standing, the Democrats wouldn’t have been able to resist having a World War II-era white woman from the Midwest shilling for her grandson. That makes me think that she didn’t endorse his politics.
Posted by: bcwhite750 | November 15, 2008, 10:10 am 10:10 am
You’re not the president-elect of the United States, though. I think it’s unfortunate but understandable that he wasn’t able to attend. More importantly, he DID visit her before she died.
Posted by: Laura | November 15, 2008, 10:10 am 10:10 am
That just tells me that President elect Obama is such a private person that he would go to great length to keep it within the family at the same time try to satisfy friends and other good wishers wanting to express their condolences.
Posted by: Ms. G | November 15, 2008, 10:10 am 10:10 am
samhiguchi-
It was a memorial service. Not a funeral.
Posted by: cincyr | November 15, 2008, 10:10 am 10:10 am
…except perhaps preparing to take office as the 44th President of the United States in a time of Global crisis and financial peril.
Posted by: Silvercrown | November 15, 2008, 10:11 am 10:11 am
I would expect that she did share his political views. She raised him, after all. To expect an 86-year-old woman in ill health to be on the campaign trail is very unrealistic. Obama would never have expected something like that of her. We shouldn’t either.
Posted by: Laura | November 15, 2008, 10:12 am 10:12 am
AMEN….IT’S NOT LIKE OBAMA DOESN’T HAVE ACCESS TO A PLANE!!!
Posted by: Kris in AL | November 15, 2008, 10:12 am 10:12 am
What Jake doesn’t mention is that this was organized by the Bank of Hawaii, her former employer, along with some of her friends.
Obama and the family are holding their own private ceremony later.
Posted by: Bud | November 15, 2008, 10:13 am 10:13 am
It does seem strange that neither Obama nor his half-sister, Maya, would attend this memorial service.
One wonders why, if their hearts were breaking, they would not take the time to be at a service they are said to have helped put together.
Posted by: R Lamb | November 15, 2008, 10:18 am 10:18 am
bcwhite750, you did see the commercial she made for Obama, right? That would signal that she endorsed him and his policies.
But I guess it’s not good enough. Obama should have dragged his 86 year-old cancer-ridden grandmom across the country to campaign for him, right? And then you would have said how ruthless he is to put his political ambitions ahead of his grandmother’s care.
Folks like you are increasingly desperate to trash Obama. Guess what? He’s president.
Posted by: Yvonne | November 15, 2008, 10:21 am 10:21 am
FYI Obama’s grandmother did appear in a campaign commercial during the primaries. A screen shot from this commercial was widely used by the media in the announcements of her passing.
Posted by: Bud | November 15, 2008, 10:22 am 10:22 am
This is a great tribute for the friends and coworkers to put together. Memorial Services are often held many months after cremation. Often friends host a tribute event and families have a private ceremony at another time. Don’t assume this is the only memorial there will be. I can understand the family attempting to have a private service later under the circumstances. If Obama would have physically attended the event would have turned into a media and secret service circus.
Posted by: Sara | November 15, 2008, 10:24 am 10:24 am
Y’all (is that right) are just trying to find something not to like. He dropped the campaign to go see her while she was alive.
Once she’s dead it doesn’t matter much except that her remains are taken care of in a manner respectful of her wishes.
Posted by: Mr. Coffee | November 15, 2008, 10:26 am 10:26 am
For those who have trouble with hyperlinks, from the Hawaii Advertiser:
“People who knew Madelyn Dunham said she was a private person who wouldn’t have liked the attention that yesterday’s memorial brought to her, but would have appreciated the gestures and words of her friends.”
And as I mentioned below, it was organized by the Bank, not the family – who are planning their private ceremony separately.
Obama’s sister is the only relative living in Hawaii. From what I’ve seen in the media, her brothers and all other relatives all live on the mainland.
Some of you people need to get a new hobby aside from Obama bashing.
Posted by: Bud | November 15, 2008, 10:29 am 10:29 am
Stop speculating on what would have been, people. There are many reasons why someone unable to attend to a memorial service even for a grandmother. This is not a funeral service. Give the family a break. Are you an insider? NO!! Just cease this pessimism and go on with your lives.
Posted by: Ms. G | November 15, 2008, 10:29 am 10:29 am
A memorial service you imbeciles….various groups of associates can put together several memorial services for one person (co-workers, friends, club members). These dumb haters should just catch fire…give it up.
Posted by: Lynne | November 15, 2008, 10:30 am 10:30 am
yvonne:
Get a grip. I didn’t “trash” Obama in any way. I simply pointed out that I hadn’t seen Mrs. Dunham on the campaign trail. And no, I didn’t see the commercial. Thank you for informing me. My comment was completely neutral as to any political commentary. I was simply curious as to whether she endorsed his politics.
Posted by: bcwhite | November 15, 2008, 10:31 am 10:31 am
RIP.
Posted by: Bea | November 15, 2008, 10:35 am 10:35 am
bcwhite: your comment was not neutral. You interpreted Obama’s grandmother’s absence from the campaign trail in the worst possible light–her non-support of his candidacy.
Posted by: Yvonne | November 15, 2008, 10:41 am 10:41 am
Please, Please Republican vampires…continue to spew your vitriol and crazy suspicions about Obama. Your stupidity enabled his victory just ten days ago, we need your help to get him re-elected in four years.
You guys are pathetic.
Posted by: Don | November 15, 2008, 10:41 am 10:41 am
RIP and God Bless!
Posted by: Bea | November 15, 2008, 10:41 am 10:41 am
Maybe she really died when he was in hawaii?
Posted by: bobo | November 15, 2008, 10:43 am 10:43 am
A great memorial for a great woman who should make every man and woman proud of her exemplary life. May her soul rest in peace and may her grandson accomplish his promise of change, peace and prosperity and unity of the world and the United States of America.
Posted by: gjkotw01 | November 15, 2008, 10:46 am 10:46 am
BUD….you need to just get used to it. Expect the Obama bashing to continue for at least 4 more years!
Posted by: nobud | November 15, 2008, 10:50 am 10:50 am
I guess we’ll expect another Obama landslide in four more years and that sounds pretty darn good to me.
There is no Republican party left…its a country club of angry, Southern hunters…trust me.
Posted by: Don | November 15, 2008, 10:52 am 10:52 am
Folks like you are increasingly desperate to trash Obama. Guess what? He’s president.
Posted by: Yvonne | Nov 15, 2008 10:21:21 AM
You are SO right Yvonne. OUR President-Elect could wish some of these folks a very good morning and they would probably reply as follows;
“Ya see! I tole ya he was a liar! Its only 65 degrees, a bit cloudy, and by the way, its 11:58 am. Unless something changes in 2 minutes, he broke his promise because I had a terrible morning…”
Let’s face it! There is nothing that we sane,rational and INTELLIGENT people can do. Nor, is there anything that Mr. Obama can say or will do that will be pleasing to them.
Posted by: FS | November 15, 2008, 10:57 am 10:57 am
OBAMA WENT TO SEE HIS GRANDMOTHER ONCE IN 18 YRS WHEN IT BECAME CLEAR SHE WAS DYING.
HE NEVER TOOK HIS WIFE WITH HIM ON THIS TRIP. THE CHILDREN NEVER SAW THEIR GRANDMOTHER FOR THE LAST TIME.. A FAMILY GOOD FOR HOLLYWOOD.
NOW OBAMA EULOGIZES HER FROM A DISTANCE. THE WOMAN WHO MADE HIM.
OBAMA IS A HOLLYWOOD CREATION
“CHANGE” YOU CAN BELIEVE IN.
OBAMA IS A SHAM.
Posted by: TJ, | November 15, 2008, 10:59 am 10:59 am
Rest in peace knowing that you have raised and shaped one of the finest men in America. Thank you Tutu.
Posted by: SB | November 15, 2008, 11:00 am 11:00 am
Good God people, there’s no point in judging this woman’s grandchildren because they didn’t go to a memorial service from her workplace!
Not every occasion about you and your beliefs and your need to negatively judge our new president.
Rest in peace, Madelyn.
Posted by: Les YeeBee | November 15, 2008, 11:02 am 11:02 am
I MEANT TO SAY 18 MONTHS, OF COURSE.. WHICH IS WAY TOO LONG FOR SOMEONE WHO RAISED YOU AND WORKED IN A BANK, PINCHING PENNIES TO SEND OBAMA TO PRIVATE SCHOOL AND LAW SCHOOL..
WELL, ALL HE’S DONE IS RUN FOR PRESIDENT.
Posted by: TJ, | November 15, 2008, 11:02 am 11:02 am
I don’t mean any disrespect, but isn’t it odd that he didn’t go to the memorial service?
Posted by: Sarah | November 15, 2008, 11:05 am 11:05 am
you need to just get used to it. Expect the Obama bashing to continue for at least 4 more years!
Posted by: nobud | Nov 15, 2008 10:50:02 AM
*********************************************
That is right. The people who care the very most about this country will step up to the plate, get involved, contribute what they can and try to help a new administration get this country out of the ditch it is in.
It will be amazing to have a President who surrounds himself with people who will be directed by Obama that they are there to actually serve the public interest. That will be a huge difference for us.
It is up to us to remind them what the public interest is.
There are others who will sit around their hands for the next four years complaining. Evidently that is all they have to contribute.
Posted by: Truth Matters | November 15, 2008, 11:08 am 11:08 am
My grandmother, who died at age 94, lived with my parents and me from the time I was 3 years old, and she cared for me while my mom & dad worked long hours to keep us afloat during the Great Depression and WW2. I was 14 when she died. I shall always revere her for her kindness, her wisdom, her industry and her love. When my first child was born, my first thought was, “I must show him to Grandma!” My second thought was, “Idiot, she’s been dead for 12 years!” My third thought was, “She can see him anyway!” Obama took crucial time away from his campaign in its final days to visit with his beloved grandmother while she was alive, knowing that she probably wouldn’t live to see him elected. A funeral, or a memorial doesn’t matter to the deceased; they’re ceremonies held to benefit the decedent’s friends and families. If Obama had attended this memorial service it would have become a media/Secret Service circus in which he’d have been the center of attention, not his beloved Tutu.
Posted by: nanameow | November 15, 2008, 11:09 am 11:09 am
Am I just weird, there isn’t anything that could have kept me from my mother’s or grandmother’s funeral services.
Posted by: samhiguchi
*********************************************
There are many people who wouldn’t miss somebodys funeral. On the other hand, Obama chose to go to Hawaii and see her while she was still alive.
Posted by: Truth Matters | November 15, 2008, 11:10 am 11:10 am
Wow, you people are amazing. You will take any opportunity to use against this man. So your saying he should follow the protocol that YOU deem fit for memorializing a woman that HE loved and adored; a woman that YOU did not know or love? Or could give a cares less that she existed. SO what is next he will hug his daughter wrong, kiss his wife too long in public, or scratch his nose? Unbelievable!! I suggest that you GROW UP, get a life and figure out what you can do to help HEAL this country starting in your neighborhoods, communities etc. We have got to find ways to unite, find a common ground and move forward. Statements like those listed before my post only bring about division. We are ONE NATION. We may not have to agree on everything, but certainly we can find a compromise that works for us all. Our children are watching and listening. Do we really want them to carry the torch of division with them into their futures? In 20 or 30 years do we want them dealing with the same STUPID issues such as how a man or woman memorializes their loved one? Is this really a topic that is going to affect our future security or financial status? I do not think so. So can we just find a way to AGREE TO DISAGREE on something that only affects President-elect Obama an not WE THE PEOPLE? Let’s just respect his right to remember her in his own way just as each of us do in regards to our loved ones. And in the future let’s not make everything he does about us. He is still and individual with the right to PRIVACY. Everything he does is not about us, he still has a family that we have no say over. He is the head of his household. Thank you.Peace and Love to everyone and may GOD BLESS AMERICA.
Posted by: JLO | November 15, 2008, 11:12 am 11:12 am
TO ALL CONTRIBUTORS:
THIS IS A MEMORIAL for someone’s death.
PLEASE PAY RESPECT AND DO NOT MAKE IT
POLITICAL. IT IS A TOTAL DISGRACE TO
TALK ABOUT HER POLITICAL VIEWS AT THIS TIME. PAY RESPECT
FROM A WHITE MAN FROM GEORGIA.
Posted by: doubsack | November 15, 2008, 11:13 am 11:13 am
Hi Obama haters and sore losers. When are you going to give him a break. Move on and accept reality.
THE ELECTION IS OVER. OBAMA WINS AND YOUR GUY LOST. OBAMA IS NOW YOUR NEXT PRESIDENT WHETHER YOU LIKE OR NOT.
Posted by: Junior111 | November 15, 2008, 11:14 am 11:14 am
It is astounding to me that anyone would use this to suggest this lady’s grandchildren didn’t care enough about her.
I don’t think it is strange at all for geographically faraway relatives not to attend a workplace memorial.
And you know, even if you do think it’s odd, why post about it here? What’s the point other than trying to put down her grandchildren and suggest they didn’t care about her?
And even if you think that, isn’t it possible to not say it, here, in a story eulogizing Mrs Dunham.
Sorry, I don’t get it.
Posted by: Amazin' | November 15, 2008, 11:14 am 11:14 am
it could have been worst he could have faxed his eulogy.
Posted by: Oh NO | November 15, 2008, 11:14 am 11:14 am
I don’t mean any disrespect, but isn’t it odd that he didn’t go to the memorial service?
———————————
If you listen to the clip of the service, it states the family will hold a private service for her at a later date.
Funerals are for the living and the security that would be involved to have the President-Elect at this service would be a distraction honoring her. If you have ever been to the “Punchbowl” cemetary – It has to be near impossible to secure that place and would grossly inconveinece visitors not there for the service, but to honor others who have fallen.
Posted by: Paige | November 15, 2008, 11:14 am 11:14 am
TJ,
You cannot judge someone until you walk everyday in his/her shoes. So stop this vitriolic comments and go on with your life.
Posted by: Ms. G | November 15, 2008, 11:17 am 11:17 am
Loving the fake outrage!
The Obama’s spent their summer vacation in Hawaii, (in spite of the loony pundits that claimed it was too exotic) and that they should have gone someplace more common.
They spent as much time as they could with their ill and house bound grandmother and great grandmother.
In her final few days, Obama took critical time off the campaign trai to see his beloved grandmother one last time.
So if it was up to Toot, what do you think she would have chosen. Skip the visits while she was alive, and then go have a media feeding frenzy circus after she died?
Some of you people should really look hard in the mirror and see if anything comes across as warped.
Posted by: Truth Matters | November 15, 2008, 11:17 am 11:17 am
When I look at a picture of “toot” and her grandson whom she was hugging as if he was a golden apple who had fell off the tree, I can only think of my own affection for my own sons. They are so very precious to me. I say well done toot, and he knows what she would want him to do, and I know he is doing it. He has no choice, her love drives him and her memory sustains him. I salute you toot, well done, well done, well done, RIP, well done!!
Posted by: SD | November 15, 2008, 11:21 am 11:21 am
Some of you folks are just plane FREAKS!! Rush Sean and Laura have warped your heads!!!
But keep barking and you’ll help re-elect Obama in 2012. Wow, now that I think about it, bitch some more and maybe there will be 80 Democrats in the Senate too!!
Posted by: toddo | November 15, 2008, 11:21 am 11:21 am
God bless Madelyn Dunham and the people who loved her. Thanks for the information, Mr. Tapper. It sounds like it was a lovely and fitting service.
Posted by: moderate | November 15, 2008, 11:32 am 11:32 am
first of all ya’ll country ##### should not assume to know anything really about these people in public’ private lives.
second-you don’t know anything about the type of culture they are a part of.
just because you didn’t see obama screaming and crying “Oh, my god, my granmamma dead, what am i going to do?”
as you have seen in some of these black movies.
you presume to say he does not care,
you would have done anything if your grandmother had died, and on and on.
why don’t you just say what you know is appropriate to say, and leave all of the speculation out.
Mr. Obama-”sorry to hear about your grandmothers passing, i believe she must have been a good woman. I am sure she is proud of you”
Posted by: W | November 15, 2008, 11:34 am 11:34 am
All you folks criticizing others for “bashing” and “slamming” and “hating on” Obama on here, I feel sure that none of you have ever said one derogatory thing, ever, about George W. Bush over the last eight years, right?
Posted by: bcwhite | November 15, 2008, 11:35 am 11:35 am
Truth Matters, is Obama bashing any different than Bush bashing. Cause I am very sick of Bush bashing. I’ll let you know when Obama bashing reaches the level of Bush bashing. Right now Obama bashing is a -1 on the bashing scale. At least Obama will get a honey moon. Bush never had a honeymoon. He was the Great Pretender. So stop whining about a few complaints about Obama. After all, your candidate won.
Posted by: Sandy | November 15, 2008, 11:37 am 11:37 am
Me Kealoha Pau’ole Tutu, a hui hou aku no…
May you rest in peace…may God Bless and
watch over your beautiful ohana always.
Posted by: Kau'ionalani | November 15, 2008, 11:38 am 11:38 am
Maybe he should have been at the memorial services — I am sure he had agood reason for not being there — but don’t doubt the pain he felt or even imply the contrary because those who do cannot imagine or have never experienced ‘hurt’ which comes with the lost of someone dear to your life.
Posted by: true | November 15, 2008, 11:39 am 11:39 am
samhiguchi: It was a memorial service – not a funeral. Stop being so narrowminded.
I can understand him not attending the memorial. The man was just elected president. If he went to that service it would have been a media circus and had secret service men all over the place. It wouldn’t have been very pleasant for Toot’s friends and co-workers now would it? If I were Obama I wouldn’t want my grandmother’s service made into a media circus either. Doing it later and in private allows both Obama and his family a little privacy and respect to mourn their family in peace and private.
Stop being so mean and nasty.
Posted by: Marlene | November 15, 2008, 11:40 am 11:40 am
Just more obama secrets. His gm was a very private person, yet she liked to play bridge and a yearly cruise…hum. Doesn’t sound like a reculse to me. Only one picture of obama and his gm ever..was this just a visit to Hawaii when he was young? The wonderful obama family when they visited her for their summer vacation: it was reported that they only spent 2 hours with her. If this lady was so “special” to him why didn’t he plan the service at Punchbowl and not the bank? Did he really go to see her for the last time or was that a make sure nothing comes out trip. Just a lot of buried secrets……….
Posted by: Moline | November 15, 2008, 11:42 am 11:42 am
bcwhite,
this is for you:
in 2000 it became clear george bush was not the best choice for POTUS,but the supreme court gave it to him anyway
MY COMMENT: “Oh, that is nice, i would rather have a beer with him anyway.
After 9/11-the usa had the goodwill of all the world, mr. bush said “no thanks’
we’ll do this”
MY COMMENTS: “Well,we are a superpower, and he is the decider. let him do his thing.
I could go on and on, but you know the story as well as i do.
even the people who were supporters of bush and lying trying to say something good about him, ran out of things to say.
but i will say this one last thing about him, and it is not bashing him.
Our President George W. Bush, has about 65days left in office.
GOOD.
i will go even further than that and sing him a song.
NANANANA, NANANANA, HEY, HEY, HEY,
GOOD-BYE!
Posted by: W | November 15, 2008, 11:43 am 11:43 am
As I read this, I see an interesting divide. Traditionally, attendance at a funeral is considered an absolute must for those who knew the deceased. In fact, for many people it is more important than the ‘living visit’ that Obama made. This tradition is very very strongly embedded in our culture. Yet, for those people who are somewhat critical (questioning) in their nature, they see the rationality of challenging this tradition by suggesting that perhaps the living visit is more important than the funeral.
We are at an interesting moment in history where we are disposing of ceremony and pomp, at times this is being replaced by rational and well thought out logic, at other times it is being replaced by commercialism.
I wonder what this holds for the future.
Posted by: Bob | November 15, 2008, 11:43 am 11:43 am
Maybe Obama sent her an email…
Posted by: Dynahog | November 15, 2008, 11:50 am 11:50 am
and if you had found out he had sent her an email,
you would have found some reason to complain about that.
Posted by: W | November 15, 2008, 11:51 am 11:51 am
I honestly hope Obama is successful. Am I optimistic about that? No, but as an American, I hope he can make this a better place to live. However, I see a lot of parallels between him and Jimmy Carter. Obama, like Carter, and unlike Bill Clinton, is a true leftist idealogue. However, when Carter tried to push his leftist policies in Washington, what he found was that not too many others, even within his own party, were on board with such radical reforms. And not being that well-connected in Washington (like Obama), and being very principled (like Obama)and not very skilled at consensus-building (an area in which Obama is unproven), his presidency is generally considered a failure. When Carter took office in 1977, the country was tanking, and four years later, it was in even worse shape. If we have an international crisis parallel to the Iran hostage crisis, we’ll see if Obama handles it any better. Again, I hope his presidency is not Carter II, but I’m not optimistic.
Posted by: bcwhite | November 15, 2008, 11:52 am 11:52 am
He didn’t go because there is no political advantage in doing so now. He played that card prior to the election.
Posted by: HH | November 15, 2008, 12:00 pm 12:00 pm
HH,
at least you are honest,
so that is the way you would have done it if you were in obama’ shoes,
thanks, we’ve got your number.
Posted by: W | November 15, 2008, 12:05 pm 12:05 pm
the common sense police.
Posted by: W | November 15, 2008, 12:06 pm 12:06 pm
RIP
Posted by: nn | November 15, 2008, 12:08 pm 12:08 pm
Obamamites try to spin this all you want! The truth is he never took Michelle or his granddaughters to see Tutu. There are no pictures of them together. Tutu never came to Chicago. Obama did not like Grandmother. Maybe someday the journalists will start telling the truth so you understand.
At the nursing home a 92 year old man told me that this will go down in the History books as the media destroying the nation. So blinded by this man they couldn’t be true journalists. That will be there punishment for years to come. I am going to now sit back and enjoy watching them destroy themselves. What fools they are.
Posted by: Fae | November 15, 2008, 12:11 pm 12:11 pm
A close friend of mine and my husband’s died last year. This man was public figure, well-loved by a lot of people. We attended three services for him and missed about 25 others… does this mean we didn’t care? In spite of being on his hopsicing team and making repeated trips to the other side of the country to be with him? Come on folks– she was the grandmother of the now-president-elect… there will be multiple services for her and the family one hasn’t happened yet.
Anyone want to talk about global warming? Or the economy? or peak oil? or health care?
If YOU want to honor her memory and her life (instead of complaining about how lousy others are doing at it) back up her beloved grandson in helping us change this country for the better.
Posted by: madame M | November 15, 2008, 12:14 pm 12:14 pm
There were several news reports that members of the Westboro church (the hate group that pickets funerals of American soldiers) planned to picket Mrs. Dunham’s funeral. Rather than exposing grieving relatives & friends to the indignity of a confrontation between hatemongers and his Secret Service detail, Mr. Obama probably decided not to have a funeral at all.
Posted by: Sneezy | November 15, 2008, 12:17 pm 12:17 pm
Actions speak louder than fine words. If he really loved her, he would have been there.
Posted by: jan | November 15, 2008, 12:17 pm 12:17 pm
Enough hacking on Obama. I lost my dad and mother in 2004 – within 3 months of each other. Many friends and family were upset that I did not “look” too broken up over the loss of my parents and that I could still smile. Well, truth be told, I had a great relationship with my parents. They were absolutely great to me and I am forever thankful to God Almighty for them. We were always close. In my community it is customary to have a cermony after about 40 days. We had nothing of the sort – felt like it’s a waste of money. We pray that the Almighty God forgive them and accept their humble efforts. We pray – privately for them every day. I know people who don’t care for their parents one lick, but they show up at the funeral and memorials all sobbing and carrying on as if they lost their only best friend.
Pres. Elect Barack H. Obama does not need to be there to show “people” that he cares. God is the only one that matters and He knows what in the Pres. Elect Obama’s heart. That’s all that matters. Leave the President Elect alone.
Thank you,
M. Z. Rahaman
Posted by: Buddy | November 15, 2008, 12:17 pm 12:17 pm
TJ,YOU HIT THE NAIL ON THE HEAD!
Posted by: vinnie | November 15, 2008, 12:18 pm 12:18 pm
What person wrote that they have only one picture of Obama with his grandmother. There are several. Besides, how many pictures do you have with your grandmother?
And a cruise once a year and playing bridge does not make for some wild social life. Don’t forget the woman was older and frail. When we speak of someone’s life we like to remember them when they were at their best, not the worst. There are people who haven’t spoken to their grandparents in 15 years and will show up for a funeral. What good is that?
Posted by: Missy | November 15, 2008, 12:20 pm 12:20 pm
I see so many people stating obvious lies. There are pictures of Obama with grandma, Obama playing on the beach with grandpa, etc. There is a great picture of her embracing him. And we didn’t know she was dying of cancer, but she worked up enough strength to appear briefly in a campaign commercial.
What’s up with the haters out there. I loved my grandmother and didn’t make it to her funeral. Remember Obama went to Hawaii for a while (with the kids) and Michelle, during the campaign too. He announced he was running after a trip to Hawaii.
Posted by: Missy | November 15, 2008, 12:26 pm 12:26 pm
It wasn’t like he could not go to Hawaii for financial reasons. Since he has all the money he needs, surely he could have attended his grandmother’s funeral. I think it is like everything else about him, he is all talk and simply does nothing. I agree with the person that said the media elected Obama.
Posted by: Janice | November 15, 2008, 12:30 pm 12:30 pm
Actions speak louder than fine words. If he really loved her, he would have been there.
_______________________________
Yes they do! Obama left the campaign trail two weeks priot to election day in an unprecedented move to spend time with his grandmother while she was ALIVE. He did really love her and he was there when it was most important.
For all of you throwing so much judgment around – can you even meet your own standards? I highly doubt it.
Posted by: Paige | November 15, 2008, 12:30 pm 12:30 pm
Some of you are unreal. Also the Obama family went to Hawaii in August and spent several days with Tutu. How soon we forget facts and spout rumors. He went there during a critical time of his campaign to see her alive, when it really counts. How many of you can say you visited with your loved ones before they died. Funerals and memorials are for the living. If you really care about your loved ones, go visit them now instead of at the funeral home.
Posted by: maggiemay | November 15, 2008, 12:32 pm 12:32 pm
jan,
“There will be a private memorial for family members later this year”
At least read the blog before you comment.
This was a “memorial service for friends and co-workers”
Posted by: Vanessa | November 15, 2008, 12:32 pm 12:32 pm
My sympathy to the Obama family.
No one should second guess how someone feels. We lost my husband very unexpected last year. Our daughter came to the funeral home for the viewing but would not come inside. She attended the church service however would not attend his burial at Arlington National Cemetery and refuses to ever go there. This does not mean she did not love her father as they were so very close. Everyone has to do what is right for them — not what others expect or demand of them.
My husband passed several hours after taking me to the airport for a business trip. The day before he asked me not to go as he said for every day we are apart we can never get back. Folks, believe me when I say that it is so much more important to be there for someone when they are still with us then to attend all the ceremonies and traditions afterwards. And be there for the family and friends who has lost their loved one…today, tomorrow..and next year.
Posted by: Dianne | November 15, 2008, 12:33 pm 12:33 pm
Shouldn’t Obama be at Hawaii attending his grandmother’s funeral service. After all Obama milked his grandmother connections for all he can politically, it is a bit strange he is not there in Hawaai and once again the media does not question him on it.
Posted by: Gregh | November 15, 2008, 12:36 pm 12:36 pm
JLO…Thanks for your comment,well said, may God bless you.
Posted by: nanamax | November 15, 2008, 12:39 pm 12:39 pm
“He didn’t attend because she was no longer useful to him.”
Before any of you Bots rush to attack MY opinion, let me just say that YOUR opinions of what Obama meant to say or meant to do have no more validity than MY opinion.
Like someone mentioned, none of us have walked a mile in his shoes – and trust me, I would not want to walk in the The Tainted One’s shoes. I do not think I could handle lying as much as he does with such aplomb.
So, Bots, cease and desist with your constant trashing of people who dare to offer anything critical of Himself, The Tainted One. We haven’t drunk the kool-aid and can see clearly.
Himself, The Tainted One, does not care about anyone but himself. Just ask his Auntie and Brother.
Posted by: leelee.again | November 15, 2008, 12:42 pm 12:42 pm
Dianne- Your post at 12:33pm really got to me. I’ll try to remember to enjoy my family and friends each day that I still have them. Thanks for the insights.
Posted by: Richard | November 15, 2008, 12:42 pm 12:42 pm
Hey haters,
Obama is going to Hawaii on vacation before he is inaugurated, so wouldn’t ya think that is when he and his sister will have a PRIVATE memorial service?
Posted by: Jwench | November 15, 2008, 12:43 pm 12:43 pm
I have tried to speak to the negative comments on here.
but after reading more and more. you people writing negative comments about this are unreal. i want to refuse to believe you are in your life the people you portray on these blogs. i fear for my country, to have so many hateful and ignorant people out there. the bible speak of people who have had their sense of right and wrong, seared with a hot iron. I guess some of you are part of those people.
i am leaving now.
guess where i am going, (no kidding)
to a memorial service for a friends dad.
he died earlier this week,
there was a memorial service for him yesterday morning, and yesterday afternoon. and one today.
and tonight another friends love one died in india, there is a memorial service for that person here in the states, and i am going to that too.
did not know the person, i know the family member and guess what, that person has a good job, going on a winter vacation, did not go back to india for services.
Posted by: W | November 15, 2008, 12:43 pm 12:43 pm
Dianne- one more thing. Grief is the price we pay for love, and each of us grieves in our own way.
Posted by: Richard | November 15, 2008, 12:44 pm 12:44 pm
Obviously most of you who are being critical can’t wrap your brains around the concept of two services. One for friends an co workers another for family…This is not uncommon here in Hawaii and I imagine anywhere else in the world where the person who died or a family member is famous.
The Obama family was here in August and has been here almost annually over the years considering the the distance between Chicago, D.C. and Honolulu.
Give the family a break. I wouldn’t be surprised if some of Tutu Dunham’s ashes
were spread out over the Pacific just like the President elect and his sister Maya did with their mother’s ashes come December.
Posted by: hilodave | November 15, 2008, 12:46 pm 12:46 pm
I’ll say it again. Actions speak louder than words. If he loved her, he would have been there. Anything else is nothing more than an excuse.
Posted by: jan | November 15, 2008, 12:48 pm 12:48 pm
weather like it or not, this is what happend when somebody become public figure, people watch every movement he makes. weather people agree or not. they will judge. He has to have a strong personality to face reality.
Posted by: nn | November 15, 2008, 12:52 pm 12:52 pm
Well we now know he is to big of a person to go to his grandmothers funeral. What a guy.
Posted by: zgomer | November 15, 2008, 12:53 pm 12:53 pm
I’ll say it again. Actions speak louder than words. If he loved her, he would have been there. Anything else is nothing more than an excuse.
Posted by: jan | Nov 15, 2008 12:48:30 PM
Why would you want him to subject his family and his sister to a circus? It is a PRIVATE matter and when the time is right they will have their own service for her.
Posted by: Jwench | November 15, 2008, 12:54 pm 12:54 pm
How come none of the Obamabots and the liberal loonies cannot explain why Obama did not attend the funeral service of her grandmother when most Americans would and considering Obama is filthy rich and would have no problems getting a flight there. He did use her politically and he did not go to Hawaii for her service, the media as usual does not care question Obama about it.
Posted by: Gregh | November 15, 2008, 12:54 pm 12:54 pm
CAN YOU READ??
What does this say?
“There will be a private memorial for family members later this year.”
He planned a vacation before his inauguration and I am sure that is when the family will have their memorial service.
Posted by: Jwench | November 15, 2008, 12:57 pm 12:57 pm
Most likely, it was the truth.
Posted by: leelee.again | November 15, 2008, 1:00 pm 1:00 pm
zgomer: I’m with you, Obama is going to be one of the greatest Presidents.
Posted by: bob | November 15, 2008, 1:01 pm 1:01 pm
Gregh: Maybe because this isn’t the funeral service. Wake up and read the story!
Posted by: bob | November 15, 2008, 1:02 pm 1:02 pm
SECOND PARAGRAPH! READ IT! WHAT DOES IT SAY?????????
You people are annoying.
Posted by: Jwench | November 15, 2008, 1:05 pm 1:05 pm
I question the timing.
Posted by: Concerned in OH
*******************
Why and about what?
Posted by: spacerook1 | November 15, 2008, 1:07 pm 1:07 pm
bob, So the election is over and why did’nt Obama attend his grandmother’s funeral service. This is the women who basically raised him and he used her politically,wake up! Considering Obama is wealthy and could have gone to Hawaii, he didn’t and thats many here question his character,.
Posted by: Greg h | November 15, 2008, 1:07 pm 1:07 pm
Gregh: There will be a private memorial for family members later this year. This is copied straight from the story. Now, get over being jealous that the Democrats won over the dead Republican Party.
Posted by: bob | November 15, 2008, 1:07 pm 1:07 pm
bob, So the election is over and why did’nt Obama attend his grandmother’s funeral service. This is the women who basically raised him and he used her politically,wake up! Considering Obama is wealthy and could have gone to Hawaii, he didn’t and thats many here question his character,.
Posted by: Greg h | Nov 15, 2008 1:07:42 PM
Can you read? Read the second paragraph!!!!!!!!!
“At the National Memorial Cemetery of the Pacific at Punchbowl, in Honolulu Friday, at a memorial service for friends and co-workers, President-elect Obama’s grandmother Madelyn Dunham — who died the Sunday night before her grandson was elected president — was eulogized as a strong woman.
There will be a private memorial for family members later this year.”
SEE THERE WILL BE A PRIVATE MEMORIAL SERVICE FOR FAMILY MEMBERS!
Posted by: Jwench | November 15, 2008, 1:12 pm 1:12 pm
Bob, The topic is the funeral service and not the memorial service, Obama did not attend it. Can you understand wthe point or a you are a typical obama supporters finding it to read and deal with the facts.
Posted by: Greg h | November 15, 2008, 1:13 pm 1:13 pm
Still lying I see.”
Can you see into the future? Is that how you know it’s a “lie”?
Posted by: Concerned in OH | Nov 15, 2008 1:10:23 PM
You wouldn’t know what the TRUTH was if it hit you in the face. Just about everything you post is not factual. That’s how I know it’s a lie.
Posted by: Jwench | November 15, 2008, 1:14 pm 1:14 pm
Gregh: “There will be a private memorial for family members later this year.” This is copied straight from the story. Now, get over being jealous that the Democrats won over the dead Republican Party.
Posted by: bob | Nov 15, 2008 1:07:44 PM…………….Right on bob, Do you think we should have a memorial service for the Republicans too? I’d like to be in charge of scattering their ashes over in Iraq, but I’m scared it will pollute the groud.
Posted by: bosco | November 15, 2008, 1:16 pm 1:16 pm
Bob, The topic is the funeral service and not the memorial service, Obama did not attend it. Can you understand wthe point or a you are a typical obama supporters finding it to read and deal with the facts.
Posted by: Greg h | Nov 15, 2008 1:13:50 PM
They are both memorial services. Where do you even see the word Funeral? When poeple are cremated it is usually a memorial service. You and Concerned and the rest of the haters are the ones that need to learn how to read.
Posted by: Jwench | November 15, 2008, 1:18 pm 1:18 pm
I’ll say it again. Actions speak louder than words. If he loved her, he would have been there. Anything else is nothing more than an excuse.
Posted by: jan | Nov 15, 2008 12:48:30 PM
Why would you want him to subject his family and his sister to a circus? It is a PRIVATE matter and when the time is right they will have their own service for her.
Posted by: Jwench | Nov 15, 2008 12:54:23 PM
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Evrything else has been a circus, why not another one. It would be a good photo-op to show just how caring he is…barf
Posted by: Moline | November 15, 2008, 1:19 pm 1:19 pm
Jwench,
Did Obama attend the funeral service, the topic is the funeral service and not the memorial service. Why did’nt he go to Hawaii for it, he is wealthy and the elections were over. Why is the media as usual covering up for Obama and did not question his character.
Posted by: Gregh | November 15, 2008, 1:19 pm 1:19 pm
Jennifer Hudson did not attend all of the services for her family and had a private service because they did not want the media circus that follows these things. For a woman who was private and did not want it, it was very respectful not to turn it into more of a media circus than it was. Who besides the grandmother of the President-elect would have her services taped and played on the news? How do you think she might have felt about that? My brother was killed and was cremated. There was a memorial service for him in Oregon where he lived and one in his hometown in Indiana, several weeks later. I loved my brother but none of our family went to the one in Oregon.
Posted by: maggiemay | November 15, 2008, 1:28 pm 1:28 pm
Greg H; Exactly how many cremations have you attended?
Posted by: bob | November 15, 2008, 1:33 pm 1:33 pm
Getting off the campaign trail to see his grandmother before she died had both political pluses and minuses. But to his grandmother, I am sure it mattered enormously, seeing him. I have a feeling this woman wouldn’t have cared if he showed up at the funeral.
Posted by: Bob Long | November 15, 2008, 1:39 pm 1:39 pm
Obama did not attend the funeral service because it HASN’T BEEN HELD YET. It’s to be held next month.
Posted by: Midwest Lady | November 15, 2008, 1:41 pm 1:41 pm
None of the grandchildren attended. The family want to have their own service. It is nice that the community did a service. The community did a service on their own without the family’s involvement. The family chose to have a family service with no reporters and no tall tales of the posters on these message boards.
Your just blowing off steam because you Republicans lost. It has nothing to do with what is right. Get over it.
Posted by: mere | November 15, 2008, 1:42 pm 1:42 pm
Great moment !
This woman make man to be, the best american boy.
Thank you Madelyn !
Posted by: Allain Jules from Paris | November 15, 2008, 1:49 pm 1:49 pm
People with no lives picking over the dead like vultures.
Every one of us mourns, eulogizes, and attends funeral services as we need to comfort and pay respect to deceased,self and family.
Take a peak in your own closet and judge thyself.
Posted by: watching | November 15, 2008, 2:10 pm 2:10 pm
The loss of Obama’s grandmother is a personal and private matter. It’s clearly not up to the public to judge his actions. Criticism is what it is.
Posted by: Yankee | November 15, 2008, 2:41 pm 2:41 pm
Yankee:
You’re trying to make us laugh, right? Whether good or bad, right or wrong, public figures, including politicians and celebrities, HAVE NO PRIVATE LIVES. The media makes sure of that. And not that I necessarily agree with the way the media pries into areas of their lives that would be considered “personal” if they were not public figures, at the same time no one ever held a gun to their heads and said, “run for public office or else,” or “become a movie star or else.” No, they know or should know full well what they are getting into. Only a fool would aspire to become a national political figure and at the same time expect to have anything approaching an area of his or her life that is “private” and off-limits to public scrutiny.
Posted by: bcwhite | November 15, 2008, 2:56 pm 2:56 pm
I find it completely disgusting and very telling of who Obama is that he is not attending the funeral or memorial or whatever. I would not want to be the soul of the grandmother who raised him. This is all she gets for her love of him. A letter!
Posted by: David Johns | November 15, 2008, 3:10 pm 3:10 pm
David: Why don’t you read some of the posts? The funeral has NOT HAPPENED YET! They will attend that next month. Memorials can be held by anyone at anytime. Family is not always able to attend.
Posted by: Midwest Lady | November 15, 2008, 3:16 pm 3:16 pm
Okay, I see more people on here who can’t follow links or read properly.
This was NOT a family arranged memorial service. None of Madelyn Dunham’s brothers attended this service either. The Bank of Hawaii, Madelyn Dunham’s former employer, organized this with some of her friends. If you read the article Jake links to you’ll see the full story.
Obama and his family have planned private service, as per Madelyn Dunham’s wishes.
Posted by: Bud | November 15, 2008, 3:28 pm 3:28 pm
I think what some people are grappling with is the fact that the only thing the family is doing is having a memorial sevice a month and a half after her death. That seems odd to people. Whether someone is buried or cremated, I think people expect the family to plan a funeral/memorial service within a week of the person dying, even if they hold additional memorial services later on, as well. It just rubs some people wrong that his family is waiting until their annual Hawaiian Christmas vacation to hold a funeral/memorial at all.
I think it’s nice that the workers in the bank did something timely, or else it would seem strange to some people that nothing was being done within a week or so since she passed. Since his half sister Maya lives in Hawaii, it does seem a little odd that she wouldn’t organize some kind of services there for her grandmother’s friends and associates herself within a week of her death. I also find it odd that she sent a letter instead of attending the service when she lives there.
You have to be cognizant that a majority of Americans are coming from the traditional model of a funeral/wake service (whether cremated or not) that happens in a timely manner to the death and is put on by the family (even if not all family can be at that one)…not just for the family that can get there but for all the deceased’s friends. I don’t know why Barack and his half sister havge chosen not to do this, but it may just be culturally different for them. I don’t know a lot about their family’s beliefs and traditions. For example I know the Obamas do not exchange Christmas gifts with their kids, but don’t know the reason behind that.
Posted by: Lara | November 15, 2008, 3:58 pm 3:58 pm
God Bless Madelein Durham who cared about her community and this is what he passed along to her grandchildren, to care about their own community.
It is so nice to see now how the community remembers her.
She gaves us the most wonderful gift of all, having the excellent President that the USA deserves. Thank you Madeleine!
Posted by: Mary | November 15, 2008, 4:03 pm 4:03 pm
I though the election was over? THE PEOPLE HAVE SPOKEN. Why are people here disrespecting this woman and her family. If you are not a friend or family member please keep your opinions to your self. The election is over and it just seems to me that Americans are more partisan than any thing else. Are we now the United States of Democrats and the United States of Republicans? Instead of the UNITED STATES OF AMERICA. Why are we questioning our democracy? God bless Tutu and may her wishes be respected by ALL,though most of us here do not know her wishes because we were not apart of her life and have no right to be commenting.I think we should leave it to her family as this is a private matter. Thank you JLO for your post
Posted by: abraham | November 15, 2008, 4:03 pm 4:03 pm
Jwench,
Did Obama attend the funeral service, the topic is the funeral service and not the memorial service. Why did’nt he go to Hawaii for it, he is wealthy and the elections were over. Why is the media as usual covering up for Obama and did not question his character.
Posted by: Gregh | Nov 15, 2008 1:19:20 PM
Once again, the word FUNERAL does not appear in the article.
Posted by: Jwench | November 15, 2008, 4:34 pm 4:34 pm
I’ve finally figured out the origin of anti-Obama vituperation.
The post clearly says that the family will be having a private ceremony later this year. That’s a personal decision that they’re entitled to make, not a public policy question that’s open to debate.
Time to move on to the next round of paranoid conspiracy theories and baseless, mean-spirited conjecture. The next time, though, try reading the post carefully before you start in.
Posted by: Brooklyn Democrat | November 15, 2008, 4:42 pm 4:42 pm
Obama didn’t attend the service because the election is over.
With the election over no reason to win sympathy votes.
He was sure to talk her up right before the election to win sympathy votes.
You would think he could attend the service then.
But the difference is the election is over.
Posted by: Jeff | November 15, 2008, 4:50 pm 4:50 pm
He didn’t even take his daughters to see her when she was alive. Weird.
Posted by: Tina | November 15, 2008, 5:12 pm 5:12 pm
I can tell how much Obama cared about his grandmother – zero!
I went to my grandmother’s funeral in the middle of the Kentucky winterstorm. Obama is too sorry to fly to hawaii and say goodby to his grandmother. Rev. Wright was right, Obama is just a typical politician, that used his granny for votes.
Posted by: Salleyjane | November 15, 2008, 6:21 pm 6:21 pm
There sure are a lot of Obama haters here! The same people who said that his gradmother wasn’t really sick and he was just going to Hawaii to cover up his fake birth certificate are now taking another low road.
Newsflash: Obama is president and all of the hating in the world won’t change that!
Posted by: Yvonne | November 15, 2008, 6:31 pm 6:31 pm
Don’t forget about seance. He might still be communicating with her.
Posted by: Obama-Yah-Wright | November 15, 2008, 6:39 pm 6:39 pm
I have just read the article of where assasination threats are at an all time high for our President-Elect. Surprisingly, (to me anyway), upon my finishing the story my face is wet with tears (I’m not exagerating either.) It is one thing to disagree with the policies/directions of which an elected leader follows…that is the wonderful thing about our country. Yet, what is even more wonderous of our nation, is that should we disagree we are able to vote them out.
Many of the negative posts here on ABCNews have nothing to do with a disagreement in Mr. Obama’s policy/direction. They are postings which continue to promote the dispicable rhetoric spewed by the Republicans, and the McCain/Palin campaign–especially Governor Palin. Trust me! They knew what they were doing. Clearly they consider the electorate stupid. Are they on to something?
You don’t have to “say” racism/sexism or whatever, in order to effectively communicate/execute the desire.
They have successfully tapped into the baseness of many of you. Again, …they knew what they were doing. Had something happened to Mr. Obama I’m sure they would have sent the obligatory wreaths, condolences, and condemnations…BUT, “hey! YIPEE!!! We won!…tee hee!!!”
What many of you continue to post are allegations that have been certifiably debunked…yet, there are those of you who refuse to make an effort and research/learn for yourself. So, they continue. I just loved the one where the poster said the end of the world will happen when someone of color becomes a leader. This (according to him) is in the bible. However, he neglects to cite the verse and chapter. I tell you, I am just dumb-founded by the absolute stupidity that is amongst some of you. I would have lost a good sum of money betting that such dumbness did not exist in our country in this day and age. Apparently, it does and I find this very, very troubling and unfortunate.
Many of you are content to find comfort in the “sound-bite” that was fed to you. You have no desire to question or verify truthfulness. Imagine guys if we took as gospel the old adage regarding masturbation–”you’ll go blind if you…”
I challenge you to re-read many of these and your postings and then ask yourself; “What is factual here and what is my source?” Many of you might be surprised…
In closing…. congrats to Rush, Sean, John, and espeacially my “Talking Tina,” Sarah! Job well done!!!!
Posted by: FS | November 15, 2008, 6:44 pm 6:44 pm
President Elect Obama took his daughters to see his Grandmother in May 2008.
If you guys are going to go after Obama at least try to find someting to gripe about that is a fact.
Posted by: Grissom | November 15, 2008, 8:15 pm 8:15 pm
With most comments on this site and other’s it scares me that soooooooooooo many loyal american’s are so clueless and limited and ACTUALLY PROUD OF IT! I am so proud that the rest of this nation decided that “YES WE CAN” AND “YES WE DID!”
Real americans extend a heart and spirit of condolence when dealing with matters like this.
Posted by: mrmuffin | November 15, 2008, 9:09 pm 9:09 pm
RIP TUTU, YOUR GRANDSON WILL SAVE THE WORLD, HE HAS BROUGHT CHANGE TO AMERICA
Posted by: gekonge bwosano | November 15, 2008, 10:11 pm 10:11 pm
To leelee.again / Nov 15, 2008 9:54:46 AM: WELL SAID!
Posted by: Diana in California | November 15, 2008, 10:17 pm 10:17 pm
It is very sad that some of you are WITHOUT RESPECT FOR THE DEADS. When you Die, remember the words you are saying now….Pray no one treats you just as bad.
God bless this woman, and the family.
Posted by: God Bless | November 15, 2008, 10:20 pm 10:20 pm
He took his kids to see grandma 6-months ago. How close they must have been.
Posted by: ken | November 15, 2008, 10:23 pm 10:23 pm
I feel that Obama did the right thing by not going this his grandmother’s service. It would have been a media frenzy. He went to see her right before she left, and that was all she needed to be ok with moving on. To each’s own, not everybody will do everything the same way.
Posted by: Love for TuTu | November 15, 2008, 10:27 pm 10:27 pm
Obama could take two days off to see his ill-grandma before election. Now. he is the President-elect,he can not come for her funeral. American should think about this It is so weird !
Posted by: Hoang Dai Doan | November 15, 2008, 10:33 pm 10:33 pm
Jake,
Mahalo nui loa for including Madelyn Dunham’s memorial service! I enjoyed hearing stories about Toot and the Hawaiian singer was great.
Posted by: Julie | November 15, 2008, 11:31 pm 11:31 pm
Aloha Oe – Tutu Dunham – Rest in Peace – To all those who have made comments about the non-attendance of President-elect Obama at his Tutu’s “memorial service” – how disappointing it is to hear the judgement, the comments you all have made, you see; you have the right of freedom of speech to say “if it was you” you would be in attendance, but remember it’s not about “you” – rather than recognizing the fact that the President elect and his family has lost his loved one, you criticize him during this time of grief – if he went home to Hawaii and attended the memorial service, he would have gotten criticized for not being there for his country…either way there are those who will judge him…how inconsiderate can we be – *the family will have a private “funeral” ceremony for her family to say their final farewells…Presdient Elect – said his goodbyes when she was alive…think about it- in Hawaii we celebrate life and enjoy each other while we are still yet living…the funeral is for those who are left behind…not for those who have passed on…so I pray that you spend time with your loved ones while they are yet still living and let the President-elect and his family have their privacy to mourn in their own way. God be with you and bless you. Aloha Oe – Malama Pono
Posted by: Kihalani Payton | November 15, 2008, 11:32 pm 11:32 pm
As a 62 year old African American, it is time that we stop all of this racial hatred against each other. Let Obama and his family along. He is entitled to his privacy. You do not want anyone digging into your business; therefore, stay out of his. He has a right to remember his grandmother the way that he wants to. We have enough problems in this world already. What about the children that are being sexually, physically and emotionally abused. What about the elderly that are being treated the same way. I have a mother that is in a nursing home who has gone through a lot. What about the people that are losing their jobs, homes, etc. Just think about this. It could be you walking in their shoes. We need to learn how to respect each other. Encourage the young people to try and do better in life. You don’t seem to be that concerned as to how President Bush has nearly destroyed this country. To my understanding when President Clinton left office, we had a surplus. Now everything is going down the drain. Unite together and strive for a better world instead of one filled a lot of jealousy and hatred. No one is perfect. We all have flaws. Be thankful for each day that you live and live it to the fullest in a positive way. Peace and Love
Posted by: Katherine Chavis | November 15, 2008, 11:34 pm 11:34 pm
Wow people are very critical about Obama not being at the memorial. We have not walked in his shoes nor what the family plans are—He didn’t want to draw attention to her journey-Some of you are just missing the point and really show a lack of respect. Frankly you scare me!
Posted by: Sophia Beck | November 15, 2008, 11:41 pm 11:41 pm
It is amazing the amount of people who can’t read. It says right in the article the family is going to have a PRIVATE memorial. Obama is taking a vacation before he gets inaugurated. She was cremated and I am sure that they will do as requested with her ashes.
It is not for anyone to be judgmental of Obama or his family. It is not up to you as to how they handle this. I am sure he talked with his Grandmother when he was up there on how she wanted it handled.
Please keep your ugliness to yourselves. God doesn’t like ugly.
Posted by: Jwench | November 16, 2008, 5:03 am 5:03 am
It is funny to hear calls of compassion and understanding from Obama supporters considering they are one of the most hate filled, partisan groups in American politics. It is clear that Obama is a cold politician and ruthlessly ambitious and says a lot about his character.
Posted by: Greg h | November 16, 2008, 6:53 am 6:53 am
It is funny to hear calls of compassion and understanding from Obama supporters considering they are one of the most hate filled, partisan groups in American politics. It is clear that Obama is a cold politician and ruthlessly ambitious and says a lot about his character.
Posted by: Greg h | Nov 16, 2008 6:53:06 AM
Greg, come off it. You are no saint went it comes to bashing Obama and other people.
Posted by: Jwench | November 16, 2008, 9:11 am 9:11 am
No need for anyone to show compassion or understanding to Obama or his supporters – or even his grandmother. But there is some need for discretion.
Get some perspective, and let something besides you (and your desire to express your opinion) come first, every now and then.
Why not give this lady some respect by zipping it – just this once? How hard is that?
Posted by: Les YeeBee | November 16, 2008, 9:38 am 9:38 am
Why not give this lady some respect by zipping it – just this once? How hard is that?
Posted by: Les YeeBee | Nov 16, 2008 9:38:54 AM
How right you are.
Posted by: Jwench | November 16, 2008, 9:47 am 9:47 am
The man is creepy!
Posted by: otay44 | November 16, 2008, 10:30 am 10:30 am
The People of Illinois send their Gratitude & Respect. Aloha
Posted by: Joe | November 16, 2008, 10:30 am 10:30 am
Is that “toot” under the bus with the Auntie, and brother, Ayers, Wright, and others.
Climbing the ladder of success in the Obama mindset, apparently, is crushing and ignoring old friends and family.
Naricissistic Personality disorder persons have no empathy. It is after all, “ALL ABOUT HIM”
God Bless Toot’s soul.
Posted by: woman citizen | November 16, 2008, 10:57 am 10:57 am
Kihalani Payton,
Remember the scene in the movie “Nowhere in Africa”
where the old woman is put outside to die, so the animals could discard the body quickly?
I guess the child Barrack saw that method as a small child, and is more a part of that mindset than average compassionate American’s are.
If a public servant doesn’t want to belong to the scrutiny of the public, don’t apply for the job.
We just gave Obama power over the free World, of course we are stunned to see no compassion, in that man.
The man is creepy.
Posted by: woman citizen | November 16, 2008, 11:07 am 11:07 am
As a 62 year old African American, it is time that we stop all of this racial hatred against each other. Let Obama and his family along. He is entitled to his privacy. You do not want anyone digging into your business; therefore, stay out of his.
Posted by: Katherine Chavis | Nov 15, 2008 11:34:02 PM
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Hatred is ok as long as it is who you are hating; everyone seems to hate George Bush, NOW it’s obama. Take your turn. Oh, now we must leave him and his family alone, obama is entitled to his privacy…well, this guy belongs to the USA now and America has a right to know about him. obama has had more privacy and less vetting than any other president in history, and you say leave him alone…remember George Bush. Maybe
with him now under the microscope we will get some answers.
Posted by: Moline | November 16, 2008, 12:41 pm 12:41 pm
“Toot” was a registered voter! Why wasn’t more said about the right to vote! Unlike ohb’s paternal relatives who have never been registered voters in an American election! Is there a double standard? WHAT ABOUT THE FACT THAT A WHITE WOMAN GOT TO CAST HER VOTE FOR HER AFRICAN-AMERICAN GRANDSON BEFORE HER DEATH?? NOW THAT’S SOME HISTORY TO WRITE ABOUT!
Posted by: denisea | November 16, 2008, 1:43 pm 1:43 pm
When Biden’s mother in law died. He attended her funeral quietly. Obama could have done the same. Obama made a big issue
that he was going to visit his dying grandmother. Michelle and his daughters didn’t go see her. Michelle stayed to campaign. Now Obama nor his wife and daughters attend the funeral. I think it is very disrespectful.
Posted by: Carmen | November 16, 2008, 4:35 pm 4:35 pm
However a person grieves their personal loss…is none of our business…they should not have to explain…it is their loss…not ours…
If it was my loss…I definitely would not be explaining anything to the likes of those critics on this blog….
He knows…his Tutu knows…and his family knows…that is all that is important! We don’t have to know…none of our business….Get over it ….move on there is sooo much more that needs our attention…that is our business…not this…Leave them alone!
Posted by: Wahineali'i | November 16, 2008, 5:51 pm 5:51 pm
Maybe out of consideration FOR his Grandmother, Obama did not attend this service as it would have been a media circus–and choses to go to the PRIVATE FAMILY memorial instead and pay his respects in a manner fitting to him AND his Grandmother….
Posted by: Pat | November 16, 2008, 9:15 pm 9:15 pm
Nameless ones can always do cowardly stuff like jump to conclusion about things they know absolutely nothing! The President-elect does not owe any of you an explanation on his Tutu’s funeral. It is more than disrespectful to say such uncharitable things about a grieving family or its members. So you go “why won’t he attend his grandmas funeral?” If he had gone, then “why is he neglecting the national financial crisis?” What do you care? What part of the funeral is so painful to you now that he did not attend the public event? Anyone with good home training does not misbehave this badly in public. Shame on you. Youy know who you are, all of you
Posted by: olu | November 16, 2008, 9:45 pm 9:45 pm
What difference does it make if Obama went to his Grandmother’s funeral or not? That’s his choice. Or he may have been well-advised not to go. Or maybe he just didn’t feel like it. What, does the American public expect politicians to stuff their feelings? Or does everything a politician does have to be explained to the public? I got news for America, it is not a crime to hate your own family-nothing to do with Obama of course. But get real America, don’t some people have a right to feel hate towards their own families? Do you know how rotten some families are to their kids? Of course I know virtually nothing about Obama’s family and I am not talking about that. (He looks like he came from at least 100 times the family I came from.) But say that someone hated their parents or grandparents or anyone else so much that they did not want to go to their funeral. Is there something wrong with that? Remember that when some parents and grandparents were young, said some things said some things, etc. that may not have been very nice. And maybe there are a lot of pissed off kids who grew up and grew smart out there, kids all grown up who not only are not going to mom and dad’s funeral or grammy and grampy’s, but those very kids may also be wishing that they go to hell too. Put another shrimp on the barbie for them so to speak and smile and say, Could you turn up the heat a bit on those cinders, ah yes, now we on earth are feeling just a little bit better. I’m talking about American families in general. How we feel as Americans about our families. Just about every kid I knew growing up came from a family of jerks. Including my own family. Now I’m not saying this is true or not true for you nice readers out there. I’m just saying that though it may not have made Ripley’s Believe It or Not, there are people who have been very unhappy with their families in the past. People who have been mistreated by their families-and even their friends. And making, nice nice about the subject is not going to solve it. And trying to get people to stuff their feelings is not going to work either. Because that’s what they’ve been duped into doing their whole lives. Tricked into not being emotionally honest with themselves. Let’s face it in the past there have been a lot of jerks who happened to parents out there. And they have left a lot of pissed off people in their wake. And eventually those p/o’d people wake up and they realize that they are not happy about what has happened in their lives. And though there is no refund line in life like there is at Wal-Mart. Americans try to deal with their feelings. Like skipping out on doing the things they were supposed to do just to get a little closer to emotional honesty. Even though what I have said may have nothing to do with Obama, our new president’s example may be a call to action for all Americans to be honest with themselves and to have courage to do what they believe is right for themselves in their hearts. Even if it means saying No We Can’t to grandmother’s funeral. Or saying Yes We Can to kindly bless and pray for America’s unrelated enemies.
Posted by: Jerry Rosen | November 16, 2008, 10:22 pm 10:22 pm
Strange that the Republicans and others who consider “He’s Creep” don’t mention that the Westboro Baptist Chruch was planning on protesting at the President-Elect’s Grandmother’s memorial.
If President-Elect Obama did showed up his family it would give those fundies extermist access to the media that will promote their hatred of everything not phelps.
Secondly are you sure that President-Elect Obama and his family weren’t there. After all President-Elect Obama and his family has access to Air Force one. They could flight out to attend the mememorial and fligh back the same day. Didn’t see anything about him in the news on Friday or Saturday.
Third since their grandmother was cremated Obama and his sister might have a quiet family funeral with her ashs while everyone is looking at the memorial in Hawaii. That way then can morn with each other without making a public display of themselves and the grief.
Posted by: Informed Citizen | November 17, 2008, 12:16 am 12:16 am
How do we know that a private ceremony outside of the public eye was not already held? May be the President-elect wanted a private moment to grieve for his Toot where he wouldn’t appear weak if he shed o few tears or even wept. Creepy is killing small animals when you are a kid–one of the hallmarks of a sociopath. Guess who did this?
Posted by: Dee | November 17, 2008, 1:39 pm 1:39 pm
Just another selfish act on Obama’s part.
Not to show your respects for the woman who sacrificed so much for him is atrocious.
Just like everyone else in his life, no one has any meaning to him. There were all stepping stones and that’s how he treated them.
He used her in his ads to pretend he was “heartland America” and then tossed her aside.
If this man can throw all these people out of his life, who are we to him? He doesn’t even know us.
He was too busy playing President to show the respect she deserved.
Another reason..he’s not MY President.
Posted by: TriciaNC | November 18, 2008, 9:50 am 9:50 am
After becoming president elect, Obama’s grandmother’s funeral was taken over and the small intimate ceremony was turned into another political circus. Obama and his family did not approve of this becoming another political stunt, and so instead are holding their own private ceremony. Many of the people asked to speak at the original ceremony backed out for the same reason. Their decision not to attend is not one of disrespect, rather it is quite the opposite.
Posted by: catalina44 | November 18, 2008, 11:04 am 11:04 am
Cremation is the process of reducing human remains to basic elements in the form of bone fragments through flame, heat, and vaporization.[1] Contrary to popular belief, the cremated remains are not “ashes” in the usual sense, but rather dried bone fragments that have been pulverized in a device called an electric cremated remains processor. [2]
Cremation may serve as a funeral or postfuneral rite that is an alternative to the interment of an intact body in a casket. Cremated remains, which are not a health risk, may be buried or immured in memorial sites or cemeteries, or they may be legally retained by relatives or dispersed in a variety of ways and locations.
The president elect is big enough to conduct his family business the way he wants,but what about his two little daughters?
My family did the same to me when I was young, and I am 50 now. There is still no closure for me after my TUTU passed.
Posted by: Mike | November 19, 2008, 9:30 pm 9:30 pm
holy… you find time to go to honor your grandmother before burial..
i mean let’s face it … if his book is telling the truth, she raised him. She is truly his mom.
There is not a thing in this world that would keep me from a loved one’s funeral.. i would walk to get there if i had too..
wow.. i think less of him.. i can’t help it.
Posted by: Not a Socialist | November 20, 2008, 5:42 pm 5:42 pm
To: Informed Citizen…
i guess there are nut jobs on both sides if what you are saying is true.. i will look into your allegations myself…i trust no one at this point.
but remember we do have the real facts and proof of radical lefties that actually did protest the burials of military men and women who lost their lives in the current war on terror..
Absolutely unforgivable.. what they did to the families of the fallen.. unforgivable at that moment of grief and pain.
Posted by: Not a Socialist | November 20, 2008, 5:48 pm 5:48 pm