Army Suicides Remain High in February
ABC News’ Luis Martinez reports: The Army has had another bad month for suicides within its ranks with 18 suspected suicides during the month of February. That is a decrease from January’s record-high of 24 suspected suicides, but one Army official said Wednesday the number still remains high and "very disturbing." The Army’s in the midst of a month-long training stand-down to help soldiers identify suicidal behavior among their colleagues. That stand-down was prompted by last year’s record number of 143 suspected suicides in the ranks, 138 of those have been confirmed as suicides and five remain under investigation as possible suicides. Still, last year’s 143 possible suicides were substantially higher than the 115 suicides that occurred in 2007, and the fourth straight year that suicides had increased Army-wide.
Army Vice Chief of Staff Gen. Peter Chiarelli and top Army mental health officers released the February numbers during a bloggers conference call this morning. Last month’s high numbers prompted the Army to begin releasing monthly suicide statistics. Chiarelli said trying to reduce the suicide numbers within the ranks, "is one of the hardest problems" he’s seen in his 36 year military career and such a complex challenge, "that there is no single solution…suicide is a multi-dimensional problem that requires a multi-disciplinary approach to tackle it." He also said that the increase cannot be easily explained by conventional wisdom. For example, Chiarelli said he believed that if soldiers had adequate access to mental health providers the numbers would go down. But, he said a review of the numbers showed that 50 percent of those who committed suicide last year had sought out some form of mental health care or counseling and still went ahead to commit suicide. Chiarelli also explained how on first blush it might appear that soldiers with multiple combat deployments might have the highest suicide numbers, but the opposite seems true. He said suicide numbers are lower among multiple deployers and that they seem to develop a resiliency to the stressful situations they encounter. Furthermore, last year’s suicide numbers were split almost evenly into thirds among those who had deployed to combat, those who had come home from combat and those who’d never shipped out overseas. Stressing how this is "not business as usual and we must move quickly," Chiarelli noted success in helping to remove the stigma of seeking counseling, but said more progress had been made at the officer level than among junior enlisted and junior non-commissioned officers. "That’s an issue we have to work hard," said the general. At one point Chiarelli suggested the issue of unemployment might be a suicide risk factor among National Guardsmen and Army Reservists. He said he had participated in a conference call yesterday that detailed 15 suicide cases and noted that among the cases involving National Guardsmen and Army Reservists, a common theme was the issue of unemployment among the civilian soldiers who had taken their lives. He cautioned later that this was a very small sampling and the difficulties in trying to determine a trend from such a small group. Other officials also added that the issues that lead to suicide are hard to narrow down to one particular reason. For example, stress over personal relationships is often cited as a major factor, but it might be compounded by other issues like financial distress which again point to the importance of tackling suicides in a multi-disciplinary way.
Email
Rick Santorum Sweeps 3 States
Pentagon to Open Additional Jobs to Women
Very tragic. Now they say over 200,000 troops may have some sort of brain damage from all this.
Posted by: Huh | March 5, 2009, 2:32 pm 2:32 pm
Thanks a whole Bunch BUSH/CHENEY!
Posted by: Angie in PA | March 5, 2009, 2:41 pm 2:41 pm
Yes, I believe there has been research in using XTC/MDMA to help such suicidal people talk about their experience and integrate it.
This also gives a (not so new) dimension to ‘winning the war on drugs’.
Posted by: Werner Van Belle | March 5, 2009, 3:49 pm 3:49 pm
I found it very interesting that it does not mention a link between deployments and suicide. As a soldier on his 4th deployment the reason we have financial hardship and relationship problems is that we are deployed to often. If they were to look at the 15 soldiers in the guard that had “unemployment” issues related to there suicide, I bet deployments were a cause of the unemployment in the majority of them. If you lay a graph of increased optempo deployments over a graph of suicides, it is almost a mirror image. They are approaching this problem all wrong.
Posted by: SGT evac | March 5, 2009, 4:16 pm 4:16 pm
SGT..I agree. Which is why more attention needs to be placed on assisting Veterans in finding employment when they return to the states. I have been raising money for IAVA and hope it helps in some small way, so Vets feel that they are not alone!!!!! And they have some sort of hope when they come home.
Posted by: Holly Mintz | March 5, 2009, 5:14 pm 5:14 pm
These poor soldiers finally realized what has been done so that Bush could get Iraqi oil and finish what his old man started even tho Iraq was not involved in 9/11. For shame on those rich you no what. The more The Bushes have the more they want no amount is enough. The most greedy people I know. and it is costing lives in more than one way.
Posted by: Rose Szymanski | March 5, 2009, 5:20 pm 5:20 pm
Are you all interested in the VA scandal?
Posted by: Chauncey robinson | March 5, 2009, 10:30 pm 10:30 pm
My thought is that soldiers consider suicide because of the endless deployments in wars that the American public doesn’t want. And knowing that when they do get to come home, they must face financial insecurity, homes foreclosed upon, and spouses and family that have moved on. It would be difficult to find something to live for, in my book. Yes, we certainly take care of our soldiers well, don’t we? And God help them if they need any kind of medical or psychological care when they return.
Posted by: DaveM | March 6, 2009, 5:05 pm 5:05 pm
What an idiotic statement above…saying people are killing themselves over the Bush administration’s policies.
Now you know why we don’t want our war dead’s coffins filmed and photographed for public consumption.
Posted by: RR GOP | March 6, 2009, 8:33 pm 8:33 pm
RR GOP WHY SHOULD THEY BE HIDDEN? COULD IT BE BECAUSE THEY DIED FOR THE WRONG CAUSE?
Posted by: Rose Szymanski | March 11, 2009, 11:51 am 11:51 am
The pertinent question is not if the current number is higher than the previous year, or even the specific rate. Rather, I would question how this rate compares to the rate for a similar demographic group in the civilian population. It may be that there are twice as many next year as there were last year, but if that rate were foudn to be half the rate for the civilian population, it does not demonstrate that current military management or strategy is causing a problem. In addition to rte comparison to the civilian population, how about trend comparison to the civilian poulation.
Of course the best outcome would be for the rate of both civilian and military populations to be zero, but that’s not reality. We should push toward that goal, but be realistic in our expectations and focus on the where the real problem is. Without the other metrics, we cannot say the problem is in THIS sub-population.
Posted by: steve | March 12, 2009, 6:58 pm 6:58 pm
Thanks for not bringing the troops home like you said you would… O’bomba! Oh right, I forgot, you didn’t specify that they would be coming home in bodybags, in peices, and given nothing but pittance “thanks on behalf of a greatful nation.” So greatful, that they can’t even GET healthcare should they have the good fortune of surviving multiple tours in your fetish for perpetual war. Bush, Obama, one good war criminal deserves another! Pastor Wright, was Right!!! Especially for what we are doing to our soldiers, their family’s, and families all across the middle east!!!
Posted by: hmn... | March 13, 2009, 6:26 pm 6:26 pm