Rove: Bush Administration ‘Fulfilled’ It’s Katrina Responsibilities
Former President Bush’s chief political strategist Karl Rove today defended the Bush administration’s handling of Hurricane Katrina, blaming former Democratic Louisiana governor Kathleen Blanco and local officials for not having an adequate evacuation plan.
Rove made the comments after appearing as a guest on the "This Week" roundtable during a taped "Green Room" segment discussion with Democratic pollster Stan Greenberg and The Nation magazine editor Katrina vanden Heuvel.
"The government official who was responsible for managing Katrina under the Stafford Act was the governor of Louisiana and she lost office in large measure due to the poor quality of her performance," Rove said.
"I think many thought that Katrina was the bookend to Iraq," vanden Heuvel told Rove. "That’s when millions of Americans, left or right, woke up to the incompetence of an administration that had worked hard to diminish government as a force for good."
"With all due respect, the federal government’s responsibilities were met under Katrina which were to provide the immediate assistance, to pluck people off of the roofs," Rove said.
"The people in charge of calling the evacuations are the state and local officials who didn’t." "The voters have made their judgment," Greenberg told Rove.
"Ignoring what the law requires and ignoring what the reality of the situation is may be fine," Rove argued, "But policy-makers set the laws in a certain way and then the policy-describers — the scribblers, observers and commentators — ignored what the law did and ascribed the problems of the locals to the federal government."
Watch it here:
–George Stephanopoulos
Email
Sen. DeMint: GOP Race Could Go Until Convention
Obama Avoids Questions on Contraception Rule
Good ole’ Turd Blossom. He should be President. Of Iran.
Posted by: Steve From NH | March 1, 2009, 4:48 pm 4:48 pm
The fat weasel should be behind bars, instead of being given credibility for chasing its tail.
Posted by: kat the real one | March 1, 2009, 4:58 pm 4:58 pm
Why would you want to deflate your and your show’s credibility by having Rove on it? I DVR’d today and just watched it….after Rove’s partisan comments at the start, I just fast-forwarded every time he spoke. That’s not the way I want to watch your show.
Posted by: Lois Chepenik | March 1, 2009, 5:09 pm 5:09 pm
Why is this man STILL making a living spreading B.S. He should be in jail. God knows he has enough of our tax money from the time he was GW’s butt buddy.
Posted by: Clint | March 1, 2009, 5:22 pm 5:22 pm
Been in the 9th ward lately numskull?
Posted by: Omentum | March 1, 2009, 5:35 pm 5:35 pm
Youn should know that it is something or someones fault never the person who really made one of the biggest blunders of his time in office…..
Posted by: NHvoter | March 1, 2009, 5:40 pm 5:40 pm
Plucking people from the roof? Is he serious? We reacted like a third world country in a time of crisis. And let’s not forget Bush’s good friend “Brownie” who did a remarkable job of accomplishing nothing.
There are still entire areas of New Orleans that are not back together and people still living in Fema trailers. This is not acceptable. We should put Rove in a Fema trailer and see how he likes it.
Posted by: andrea | March 1, 2009, 5:41 pm 5:41 pm
Rove is precisely correct: First-responder responsiblity for natural disasters like Katrina lies with local officials. Nagin and Blanco failed utterly: Remember those pictures of 250+ schoolbuses sitting idle in a New Orleans that Nagin could have mobilized, but didn’t? The responsibility for mobilizing the National Guard and asking for Federal assistance was Blanco’s: the Feds can’t just march in, and if they had, Bush-haters would have screamed “Gestapo!” — anything to fit the narrative that Bush is wrong on absolutely every issue. Bush in fact alerted southern-state governors to be ready for what was coming. Blanco failed. And don’t forget that when informed about her responsibilities re: the National Guard, she tried to cover up by lying that she had called for them, when she had done no such thing.
Lois Chepenik: Good strategy: “I won’t listen to anything that Rove says, and then I will declare everything he says to be wrong.”
Posted by: PD | March 1, 2009, 5:44 pm 5:44 pm
Why is Butter Ball not in Jail hey Butter ball Instead of appearing On faux news Spewing your Lies GO TO COURT BUTTERBALL
Posted by: Angie in PA | March 1, 2009, 5:45 pm 5:45 pm
It is the US Government’s job and obligation to monitor a deadly situation and come to the immediate rescue of people whose lives are in danger when a local government fails. Bush did not respond because a large Democratic base was involved with a DEmocratic Governor. If a Republican base and GOvernor had been at risk the US government response would have been immediate. Our previous Government’s political alliances were much more important than people’s lives and they should have been severely prosecuted for ineptness and apathy to people’s suffering. Johnny El.
Posted by: Johnny El | March 1, 2009, 5:57 pm 5:57 pm
Some of you are so childish….I WONT LISTEN TO THE ROVE LIAR CRIMINAL BUT WHAT HE SAYS IS WRONG!!!
You base your opinions on what you WANT to be the truth, not on what it actually is. The Bush administration had some blame, but he is totally correct when he says that the local governments had primary responsiblility. Give credit where it is due, but blame as well.
Posted by: Someone | March 1, 2009, 6:01 pm 6:01 pm
There is a distinct role that the state and federal governments play.Gov.Blanco and Ray Nagin did not ask for help until it was obvious that they were in over their heads.the government responded in an appropriate manner once it was clear that the governor did not execute her plans appropriately.As a distinct difference,last year prior to hurricane Gustav,Gov.Bobby Jindal executed a well organized plan,and as a result, the rest of the country was not aware of the extent of the damage that was caused because residents evacuated where it was appropriate and help was supplied where it was needed.The comparison between the way Gov.Blanco and Jindal handled the hurricanes was like night and day.
Posted by: kim | March 1, 2009, 6:11 pm 6:11 pm
Wasn’t sure who George W was critizing when he said the American people don’t want to hear about Katrina.
I think he thought he would put down Greenberg but good for Greenberg he reminded George that it was the LA gov. who highlighted how poor the Federal Govt.is by the response to Katrina.
Again forcing Rove to defend the Bush administration
The Republicans are a mess.
Posted by: chicago6611 | March 1, 2009, 6:14 pm 6:14 pm
Kim,
It was Jindal who just this week admonished the FEDERAL govt. for Katrina disaster. He didn’t say the disaster was the fault of the state govt.
Republicans need to get their stories straight. One contradiction after another.
Rove, “state govt failed, Jindal ,No Federal Govt. failed.
LOL
Posted by: chicago6611 | March 1, 2009, 6:19 pm 6:19 pm
Please, no more of people like Rove and Greenberg. You lost control when they turned the show into a cable shouting match. If you want people like me to continue watching your Sunday morning show then take it back to its civil discussion of policies and ideas not shouts and rude interruptions.
Posted by: don viejo | March 1, 2009, 6:42 pm 6:42 pm
As a Republican, it is indeed sad to see the transformation of a clever political tactician into an apologist for his incompetent boss (Bush): indeed Rowe’s comments can be classified as political dementia: He was (past tense) clever enough not to wade (pun intended) into the ” Brownie you are doing a great job” morass of Katrina FEMA support etc etc etc.
Posted by: Bob | March 1, 2009, 6:58 pm 6:58 pm
Rove really does not care about his own reputation or reality, does he?
http://www.political-buzz.com/
Posted by: matt | March 1, 2009, 7:10 pm 7:10 pm
Karl. Did you clear this information with Rush? He supports Jindal big time…even liked his speech where he blamed the federal government bureaucrats.
Don’t you know he is the face of the GOP while you are just the a..h…. of the GOP?
Posted by: doug | March 1, 2009, 7:13 pm 7:13 pm
Why don’t Republicans just move to Alaska and leave the rest of us alone?
Posted by: Steve | March 1, 2009, 7:15 pm 7:15 pm
this week is the one “talking head” show i regularly watch, online or on tv. please don’t debase it with a scheming criminal like rove again. i really did have to turn off the show half way through the round table, one of the features i most enjoy.
i can listen to will, i can listen to pat buchanon, i can listen to cantor. i am not afraid of contrary ideas, but i want ideas, not attempted thought manipulations.
Posted by: jack | March 1, 2009, 7:17 pm 7:17 pm
Mr. Rove should be in federal prison for “contempt of Congress” for flaunting the subpeona given him for the political firing of US Attorneys and not giving commentaries on national television!! Sorry George…..I hope it’s the last time you have this S.O.B. on your show after what he did to former Alabama Governor Don Sielgelman!!
Posted by: Rich | March 1, 2009, 7:50 pm 7:50 pm
There is plenty of blame to go around. The FEMA director was inept when Katrina hit. But Mayor Nagin did nothing to get his people out of harm’s way. Blanco did not act quickly enough either.
I was formerly from Lake Charles and had to go rescue my mother after she had been evacuated. The hurricane devastated Lake Charles, but it was the broken levee in New Orleans that did the damage there.
Federal money had been poured into New Orleans for years to politicians there to fortify the levee and replace the aging pumps. However, corrupt politicians in New Orleans used those funds for some thing… for frivolous things.
The FEMA temporary homes, which we passed while driving down there to help my mother get back into her damaged Lake Charles residence were just seen sitting weeks later in large empty lots.. going no where. That was another government rip-off. Somebody got rich by selling all those FEMA trailers to our government. They sat there empty and just broke down. No foundation or structure to support them.
Three and a half years is long enough for the National Guard to patrol or do what ever they do. The corruption there is just so great, it’s sad. And I have relatives in Metarie and in Lake Charles. My mother suffered a heart attack from the stress of the evacuation and her health went really downhill after that. She died a year ago. For her, the evacuation was the beginning of the end.
Posted by: Fran | March 1, 2009, 8:01 pm 8:01 pm
I agree with all who’ve posted before me about “This Week” with George Stephanopoulos…sinking to the level of others by allowing Karl Rove to appear on this show means that I’d be better off (and MORE INFORMED about what’s important to middle America) if I tune in to “American Idol” or “Dancing with Idiots” or “fill-in-the-blank”…I may not watch this show in the future. It’s up to you.
Posted by: Gary | March 1, 2009, 8:14 pm 8:14 pm
Karl Rove is a soft, gooey, doughy, pathetic little weenie. He is adorable, and loads of fun to laugh at.
Posted by: euro.guy | March 1, 2009, 8:21 pm 8:21 pm
I, like many, disagree with much that Karl Rove has to say, but I would have to agree that Governor Blanco is squarely to blame for not having an evacuation plan in place and implementing it well in advance of the oncoming storm. Her reaction to Katrina was pathetic to say the very least. Hurricanes are not tornadoes. They follow a relatively predictable path over a matter of days. Add that to the fact that Louisiana and the city of New Orleans were well aware that the levies were not sufficient to withstand the pressure of a major storm. Knowing that, they were responsible in a major way for what happened to the 9th ward. Buses which could have been used to evacuate the hundreds of people in the path of that storm were left to drown in its aftermath! From where I sit, Kathleen Blanco and Mayor Ray Nagin are certainly to be held accountable for the disaster. Texas has been hit as has Florida with major storms, and in both cases, the governors of those states have been on TV and radio with a course of action to be taken by the citizens of their states. The disaster that is Katrina should not have happened as it did. Local officials are squarely to blame.
Posted by: momzworld | March 1, 2009, 8:24 pm 8:24 pm
Brownie did a heck uv’a job – a true qualified professional just like all the Bush appointees (look how well they rebuilt Iraq!).
Posted by: jhw539 | March 1, 2009, 8:24 pm 8:24 pm
The local and state government screwed up; HOWEVER, I live in Michigan and paid taxes that helped fund FEMA. Their response was at best pathetic and I am thankful everyday that I never need help from the Bush White House. The voters in New Orleans will take care of the local issues. The rest of us have can only vote out the losers in the Federal Gov.
Posted by: Scott_Michigan | March 1, 2009, 8:24 pm 8:24 pm
This is the second time Rove has undersestimated a Katrina.
First the hurricane, then Vanden Huesel.
Katrina Vanden Huesel stared into Rove’s eyes today and put him in his place. She knocked him down harder than hurricane Katrina did New Orleans.
Please ABC…, let’s see more Katrina.
Posted by: Wayne | March 1, 2009, 8:25 pm 8:25 pm
From reading some of these comments – I have a better understanding of WHY Obama was elected. One word of advice – if you don’t truly know the facts – look them us!
Posted by: MadinIllinois | March 1, 2009, 8:28 pm 8:28 pm
For all of you who thought it was wrong of ABC to have Rove on…, I totally disagree.
It’s time someone like him should be held accountable for his crimes. As long as they have guests like Katrina Vanden Huesel, he will be exposed as the fraud he is.
Today was a marvelous day!
(I love You Katrina Van Huesel)
Posted by: Wayne | March 1, 2009, 8:34 pm 8:34 pm
Without Katrina Vanden Huesel, I would never have made it to the end of the show. I CANNOT believe that he was so graciously accepted by your other esteemed guests. What he did, out of personal ambition, to this country is beyond anything one might have dreamed possible. The only thing more startling is that George S. and George W. actually accepted him to partner in furthering the debate on what to do with the mess he does not even accept responsbility for creating. I will not watch This Week again when he is welcomed by your organization. He is not welcomed into my home – he is toxic.
Posted by: JJoyhart | March 1, 2009, 8:58 pm 8:58 pm
Republicans are much like practicing alcoholics…it’s always someone else’s fault, never their own!!!
Posted by: karen | March 1, 2009, 9:00 pm 9:00 pm
Wow, the GOP should fly Rove’s remark on a banner over some public building in Louisiana. It would set things straight like: “Mission Accomplished” did. The Republican jokeathon keeps giving. With friends like the GOP elite, Louisiana doesn’t/didn’t need any enemies. Rove you are laughable. You know Rove, you kind of look like Rush. I bet you’re related. Both of you are stupid.
Posted by: Demsrgreat | March 1, 2009, 9:04 pm 9:04 pm
Yes, Katrina was fantastic–stayed on topic. “Oh, call me Karl.” What a bunch of garbage. Thank God she didn’t bite on that one. In no time, Rovie would be telling everyone that they are fast friends–the liar he is.
Posted by: Demsrgreat | March 1, 2009, 9:07 pm 9:07 pm
george,
while i don’t agree at all with Rove, i think it was a wonderful show b/c of Katrina and greenberg who were able to counter his arguments. For me, it was one of the best panels u’ve had, and all things considered, a very civil debate
Posted by: tw | March 1, 2009, 9:08 pm 9:08 pm
Is Rove mad? He uses the “letter of the law” in a situation where even the right words may have helped. The law got Bush elected. You can’t tell me the law is written to cover all circumstances. Not every event may fit within the particularly narrow categories that these lawyers place them. For Rove to say Bush did all that was required under the law is a cop out and didn’t help the people of Katrina. That sounds like passing the buck to me. Washing your hands of a situation under Bush’s interpretation of the law does not make him a good leader. A good leader would have found a way to help regardless. You can’t tell me there isn’t some loopholes they can sneak through. They’re experts at finding them.
Posted by: Dan Kolich | March 1, 2009, 9:10 pm 9:10 pm
Karl Rove that bastard should be in jail. He is a lying, manipulating, canalizing, arrogant person who should be prosecuted to the fullest extend of the law. I wish somebody has enough courage to get him and put him behind bar.
Posted by: Tony | March 1, 2009, 9:15 pm 9:15 pm
The main responsibility for Katrina was with the Mayor and Governor. The feds probably should have moved quicker when it was obvious that the one’s responsible weren’t getting the job done, but it is ridiculous to lay all, or even the majority of the blame on Bush. People seem to forget this, but we are supposed to be the United States of America, not the Federal Government of America. We’re also supposed to take responsibility for our own well being, not lay down and wait for Uncle Sam to take care of us. We all knew about the storm well in advance and it was common knowledge that the levees and pumps were not maintained properly – can you say evacuate? The biggest problem with Katrina was the existence of a large population that was totally dependent upon the government for all of their needs and don’t have a clue on how to take care of themselves – a situation that will only get worse with the current administration.
Posted by: coufplayer | March 1, 2009, 9:17 pm 9:17 pm
Nonsense coufplayer. The problem was with the levies. Louisiana had studies on their strengths. It was determined long before Katrina that they weren’t strong or high enough. THAT RESPONSIBILITY FALLS TO THE ARMY CORPS. OF ENGINEERS. THEY FALL UNDER THE FEDERAL SYSTEM. THEIR WAS A REQUEST FOR FUNDING TO RAISE THE LEVIES, BUT BUSH AND REPUB CONGRESS DENIED IT DUE TO THEIR HELL BENT MISSION TO DESTROY IRAQ. There simply wasn’t any money available to help the unimportant Americans in the South. Being poor, they were at the mercy of the so-called compassionate conservatives. I blow a big raspberry out on that one.
Posted by: Demsrgreat | March 1, 2009, 9:32 pm 9:32 pm
No, it was the Army Corps of Engineers responsibility to make the levies stronger and higher. They asked for the funds, but Bush and his Congress were too busy spending money to destroy Iraq. Shore up the levies, all would have been saved–for a fraction of the cost before the disaster.
Posted by: Demsrgreat | March 1, 2009, 9:40 pm 9:40 pm
Karl Rove is a disgusting pig of a man. It makes me sick to even look at his squishy stupid face. If I didn’t know better I’d say he may in fact be a sociopath as he shows no empathy to anything not white, republican or rich. I’m going to go throw up now. ick.
Posted by: Valerie | March 1, 2009, 9:42 pm 9:42 pm
I totally agree with Karen. Republicans are such hypocites. For a party that continuously spouts off about responsibility and accountability I find it odd that they are never ever responsible or accountable for anything. It is always someone else who is to blame for whatever the problem might be.
Posted by: I've had it | March 1, 2009, 9:46 pm 9:46 pm
Go to hell, Rove!
Posted by: Lewis | March 1, 2009, 9:48 pm 9:48 pm
Demsgreat: You are so wrong. Plenty of federal money had been sent to New Orleans to repair the levees and them money was used for other purposes by the corrupt politicians years before Katrina hit. What part of this don’t you understand? Over the first five years of President Bush’s administration, Louisiana had received far more money for Corps civil works projects than any other state prior to Katrina. The politicians used those monies for pet projects and not to rebuild or strengthen the levees.
And how insane if this. New Orleans was built below sea level. It will always be a flood waiting to happen. How would you like to live in a sunken bowl essentially surrounded by a large lake and the Gulf of Mexico, protected only be a levee of dirt and essentially giant sump pumps who can have power failures.
Posted by: Fran | March 1, 2009, 9:56 pm 9:56 pm
George,
We love your show, dvr it every week so we won’t miss it, but WHY – other than trying to gin up ratings – have you invited Karl Rove to appear on your show? After so many years of serious and credible guests why diminish your show’s reputation by having Rove as part of the venerable and much admired Round Table? Not only has his political philosophy of divide, conquer, and ignore constitutional governance been discredited, but he was a large part of one of the most destructive and incompetent presidential administrations in American history
I can only hope that the displeasure he evinced during his sparring with your other guests today, and who, by the way, finally said what so many of us have been screaming at our television sets for the last eight years, results in HIS decision to stay off the “This Week” set in the future.
Posted by: Alison Keleher | March 1, 2009, 10:07 pm 10:07 pm
Well Fran, Mike Foster was governor leading up to Katrina. So, that means he was a part of the Republican power at the time. In conclusion, as a Republican, he failed to meet his fiduciary obligations. Sounds like a typical Republican–corruption no doubt. If you come back that he was a Democrat before turning Republican, don’t forget that in the South, Democrat=Dixiecrat=Republican.
Posted by: Demsrgreat | March 1, 2009, 10:19 pm 10:19 pm
“the federal government’s responsibilities were met under Katrina” says Rove
Apparently it was the Bush administration’s responsibility to insure the removal of all poor blacks from New Orleans, so I guess your right pig face, mission accomplished..
Posted by: JR | March 1, 2009, 10:25 pm 10:25 pm
There he is again, bullying away in his dominating orange tie. Like was said above: I don’t watch TV anymore because the shows are not about conversation or discussion but political manipulation and people talking and shouting over others. Who needs added tension from the media in their life! Can we return to at least one plain old news program, just reporting it not trying to make it?
Posted by: Spence | March 1, 2009, 10:50 pm 10:50 pm
I am from Louisiana not New Orleans but less that 100 miles west of the City. That is our “New York” our “Oklahoma City”. Karl Rove needs to be put away. I feel that the ninth ward needs to be destroyed and for those who chose to live there build high rises. Our Governor Blanco was just as lost as was everyone in this state. I feel she did the best she could with what was put in front of her.
One comment the up and rising repulican our Governor showed the country what he is when he spoke Tuesday night.
In response to Lewis who stated that the monies were used for “pet projects” I’d like to know which projects they were?
If Bush would have wanted this job instead of being groomed for the position without wanting it he maybe could have done better. He was surronded by Rove and Chaney. What a loss!
Posted by: Karen Conine | March 1, 2009, 10:57 pm 10:57 pm
Karl Rove should be in jail for his crimes not appearing on TV. Why anyone would believe a word this man says is beyond me. The Bush administration showed themselves to be incompetent and corrupt at everything they did. Just yesterday I was just reading that the New Orleans FEMA Office has not distributed the funds properly and in most cases not at all to help the area. President Obama has sent someone to New Orleans to look into this matter. FEMA is just one of the incompetent departments that Bush had no clue about.
Posted by: Vicki | March 1, 2009, 11:07 pm 11:07 pm
It is amazing that the ignorant statements of hatred by many commentators here is superseded by their lack of information. Rove was absolutely correct in stating the law and its application during Katrina. It is such a relief to have someone intelligent to join Mr. Will in the round-table discussion.
Posted by: David | March 1, 2009, 11:13 pm 11:13 pm
Thats alright Mr. Liar Rove, you arrogrant Worthless Criminal, we’ve got your Number, and in time, we’ll have you every way but sideways ! The Patriot Hour Web Site has it in For you ! Your a Criminal and you’ll be held accountable, maybe not in in a Federal Court, but somebodys court, and it’ll be a court you wish you were never in – MINE !
Posted by: JetRanger | March 1, 2009, 11:48 pm 11:48 pm
Ya, put a bunch of young weak female reporters in a room to ask him serious questions, did ya see them back down, and everything became all laughs and giggles, they aren’t going to call this guy out on the carpet,, their too afraid, why, they’ve been programmed to show respect to these criminals, I wouldn’t have, I’d called the worthless scum what he is- a Bastard to his face !! Why would I Suck up to someone this Low !
Posted by: JETRANGER | March 1, 2009, 11:59 pm 11:59 pm
Privileged-character Rove should be talking, but not on This Week. A couple of congressional committees eagerly await the benefit of his recollections and insights about timely and important matters — under oath, in front of cameras and witnesses.
No surprise, then, Rove is johnny on the spot when ABC calls but a nose-thumbing no show when Congress summons him.
A segment about that would’ve been ever so much more useful and informative than giving Rove a national audience for more self-serving spin.
Posted by: S.W. Anderson | March 2, 2009, 12:03 am 12:03 am
George Bush made me live in a city that’s below sea level..Why didn’t he personally hold my hand and remove me from New Orleans while I was looting the day before the levees broke..
People had no problem getting downtown to loot the entire city after the storm hit..But then when the levees did finally brake the next day, after everyone thought New Orleans had dodged a major bullet, it is somehow George Bush’s fault…People never take responsibility for their own actions, all those idiots had 3 days warning to get out of town..I guess that wasn’t enough time in advance..Pathetic.
Posted by: Tim | March 2, 2009, 12:04 am 12:04 am
Seriously? Our country is screwed, judging by the totally ignorant statements and “there should only be a democratic party” comments on this blog.
Really? No opposing views on the news? Yeah, that’s great. Rove should be in prison? What crime has he committed? No, not what crime in your petty mind, but what actual CRIME has he committed?
Basic heirchy of a disaster: Local government (city, county) to State to federal. When Iowa flooded in 2008, the LOCAL government moved to sandbag, put out warnings, etc, the STATE government mobilized the national guard, and THEN after that, they called the feds when it was deemed necessary. Katrina was no different; the problem was, the state and local government failed. Period.
Partisan hatred will get you no where, and that’s all that I see on this blog. The attitude of democrats in the white house, congress, and everywhere else is that republican and conservative views do not matter because they didn’t win the election and don’t hold a majority; I hate to break it to you, but 50% of the US hold conservative or republican views – to say our views don’t matter is to disenfranchise half of the country.
Posted by: You've got to be kidding me... | March 2, 2009, 12:28 am 12:28 am
Rove refers to the law, specifically the Stafford Act, claiming the President’s
hands are tied unless a Governor requests aid. But the Act specifically and
explicitly contradicts that claim. The following is an excerpt from that law,
which my emphasis added:
Sec. 402. General Federal Assistance (42 U.S.C. 5170a)
In any major disaster, the President may -
…
(5) provide accelerated Federal assistance and Federal support where necessary to save lives,
prevent human suffering, or mitigate severe damage, which may be provided IN THE ABSENCE
OF A SPECIFIC REQUEST and in which case the President
(A) SHALL, to the fullest extent practical, PROMPTLY NOTIFY AND COORDINATE with officials
in a State in which such assistance or support is provided; and
(B) SHALL NOT, in notifying and coordinating with a State under subparagraph (A),
DELAY OR IMPEDE THE RAPID DEPLOYMENT, USE, AND DISTRIBUTION OF CRITICAL
RESOURCES TO VICTIMS OF A MAJOR DISASTER.
Bush had full legal authority and full moral imperative to act even if
Governor Blanco actively opposed his involvement. Using her delays in
filling out forms as an excuse for Bush to avoid his responsibilities is
morally and intellectually repugnant.
Why are the media still letting this bunch of crooks make such blatant
lies without calling them out on it? This isn’t rocket science, and
there’s nothing arcane to decipher–just read some black and white text.
Posted by: James | March 2, 2009, 12:30 am 12:30 am
As a Republican Moderate that voted for Obama, I continue to be amazed at the arrogance and narrowness of the Conservative Republicans views- while they preach patriotism and care for our country and it’s citizens , they have bombarded us daily with hate and such nastiness that I find incredulous. To what end this rhetoric is suppose to lead, I am unclear;but this group, lead by Rove & Co.,destroyed this country;never have our “leaders” taken us down a path that served so few and failed so many. To stand and do anything but apologize is mind numbing and they are gearing right now to ensure Pres. Obama fails- they will start by creating one crisis after another; sucking all of the time and energy out of the new administration; they will create these stall tactics while saying they are looking out for the American people and the children’s future;don’t fall for it! Next, they are definitely going to attack every day , anything and every thing with 2010 elections in mind, to try to take away some support for a run at 2012 Pres. elections. Don’t fall for it;they do not have anyones interest in mind other than own “narrow” (think racist,elitist,snobbish,superior)point of view. Life in America under the Republicans is like being “on the plantation”. Trickle down my ass!!
Posted by: John | March 2, 2009, 12:38 am 12:38 am
Bush sat on his hands for three days while America watched New Orleans drown on 24-hour cable news.
BUSH SAT ON HIS HANDS.
NOT MY JOB.
NOT MY PEOPLE.
Republican ‘leadership’ at its best.
Posted by: R Mutt | March 2, 2009, 12:53 am 12:53 am
Not only is Rove out of touch but….anybody here that supports Rove and the republican party the same party that has screwed up and ruined our great nation is either a paid blogger, delusional or stupid. Why should Rove and the republicans get rewarded for screwing up America from Iraq to this financial mess? Isn’t that like rewarding CEOs with huge bonuses even when they screw up the company. Sure let’s reward the people that screwed things up. Who’s stupid enought to do that? A fool, idiot, moron, masochist, lobbyist? I could add more but you get the picture.
Posted by: GOP = Destruction Of America | March 2, 2009, 1:09 am 1:09 am
How can it be that we are a nation which operates under the rule of law, yet Karl Rove is still not behind bars??
Posted by: hopesprings52 | March 2, 2009, 1:41 am 1:41 am
Ok, I goofed and cited a clause added post-Katrina that apparently was added to make the intent of the law less ambiguous.
Nonethess, my original point stands–the law (even pre-Katrina) authorizes the President to take actions even if the Governor has not acted. (Think about it–what if the Governor and successors are all dead as part of a disaster? Would any sane person argue the Feds could not help until a new Governor was elected?)
Unfortunately, that makes the citations a bit lengthy to post in this format–just go read the act for yourself, in particular noting that the President *may* declare disasters based on a Governor’s request, but implicitly may also declare them without a request, and that federal assistance is predicated on a state having initiated emergency action, not explicitly on having made a request for help. Unless of course you’re looking for reasons NOT to rescue drowning people.
Moreover, Rove’s entire defense completely ignores the point that the real time for action was BEFORE Katrina, when scientists were screaming from the rooftops that better levies were needed. But scientists, and in general people who deal with facts, were of course never given the time of day by Bush. So we’ve had to live through a miserable laundry list of screwed up federal actions and inactions since “no one could have predicted” the disasters and realities screamed from the rooftops by hundreds of experts for years or even decades.
Posted by: James | March 2, 2009, 2:03 am 2:03 am
I love the dysfunctional American family, especially the adults who seem to forget that our children are watching what we adults think, say, and do. BTW “GOP = Destruction Of America”: 40-50% of the country supports the Republican party, and that percentage will increase if President Obama’s rescue and recovery plans fail to deliver, so drop the name calling. Considering the fact that the last democratic President didn’t even know the definition of the word “IS”, there’s plenty of stupid in both major parties…plenty.
Posted by: Robbi | March 2, 2009, 2:14 am 2:14 am
Like him or not, and I don’t particularly, but he’s SPOT on with regards to who’s fault the lack of response was before (and I’d argue DECADES before), during and after Katrina.
AT what level of Government did the authorization for the rezoning of swamp lands into residential use occur, and the subsequent approvals of the construction of homes WELL below sea level?
Oh yeah, and then the collection and expenditure of all of the property taxes that were collected on those properties on everything EXCEPT emergency response planning?
No, the FEDERAL Government is the LAST in the long line of failures in Katrina… the beginning of that line of incompetence STARTS with the city council and the mayor, continues through parish elders, then to the Governor, then the state’s elected representatives in Congress, and only THEN does it land on the President’s desk.
New Orleans was a DISASTER waiting to happen, and it did. If you want to place blame, go back to the initial approval of a residential building permit in swampland, and the GREED that accompanied that decision.
Posted by: Fiercely_Independent | March 2, 2009, 2:21 am 2:21 am
My daughter visited New Orleans and said this is stupid the land is below the water. People said don’t worry, we have pumps. Everybody knows with storms you lose power and pumps fail. I would never live there, nature always wins. Those people expected to be taken care of by the government instead of taking care of themselves. One young boy took a bus and drove people out, he is the only one to show initiative.
Posted by: American Mom | March 2, 2009, 2:43 am 2:43 am
New Orleans got wet. Okay very wet. The hurricane actually hit Mississippi. Greensburg KS got 95 % wiped out two years ago. Guess which town has rebuilt with the least amount of federal aid and improved their community at the same time. The people of Greensburg did in two years what the people of NO have failed to do in four years with far less money.
So why do you nimrods blame Bush???
Posted by: Calvin | March 2, 2009, 6:37 am 6:37 am
Dan Bartlett has appeared as a CBS news political constultant several times in the last several months. Sheepish and lip-biting, trying to move to the center a bit, his attempts to analyze as if he could imagine objectivity comes across, like Rove, with such inauthenticity. Many are wondering as to the networks motives. Dah?? Lee Atwater, Ed Rollins, and Karl Rove are excellent examples of brand loyalty distillers for the GOP. The Democrats need to understand that winning “is” everything. That breaking the law is what you do to get done what needs to be done in the mere 4 years you enjoy in office. You know, the cut bait or go fishing b.s. Real winners just “do it.” Drill baby Drill. What still remains a mystery though is how the GOP ever became organized enough (while vying for most holy or who hates more, me, no me i.e. hate radio) to put together a voting block. In other words, how bizarre for narcissism to find a common theme without self-destruction. Therefore the current “socialism” rallying cry from GOP Kool Aid manufactures, getting that limbic system tuned for the senate elections. Rove now has his work cut out for him and that’s why he’s on ABC. Rove has his and the GOP’s legacy to recreate. The charge of incompetence is a huge image problem which Rove is deflecting via obvious spin to hold the line on “wink-wink” racism and godless, poor people. It feeds right into Freddi and Fanny Mae and how liberals forced banks to finance houses which irresponsible (if your a republican, you can fill in the blanks more effectively) people couldn’t afford which has now ruined the GOP Christian way of life. George S.’s program is counting the feedback numbers, in a sense, selling products for ABC sponsors. Rove and Rush seem both destined for angioplasty, a walker, and a Frontline one hour fairwell. This is all formula.
Posted by: Lee Atwater redo | March 2, 2009, 6:54 am 6:54 am
George – You finally had a program other than “I love Obama” and old black head couldn’t stand it. You need to report the news, not make it, and you do. You are so in love with Obama that you would probably lay down your life for him. You are pathetic as is your program. I was with a group of 600 people Sat. night and not in Washington and the discussion was how ABC had lost all touch with reality and people actually hate you and Charles Gibson for what you did in this last campaign. You did not post fairly, accurately and Geroge Will and the rest only what to hear what they want to hear. They can’t stand the truth. Now, I am pretty sure this will not get posted becasse you would not want anyone to know what you, Carvill (the idiot), Begala (worse) and you do all the time to keep Obama in the limelight. Would it be possible foryou to write another book “How I love Obama” and the lies you told to get himebn elected. After all you wrote a book on Clinton.
Posted by: Jane | March 2, 2009, 7:47 am 7:47 am
See, I told you it would not get posted.
Posted by: Jane | March 2, 2009, 7:49 am 7:49 am
Why do we listen to Rove and give him air time? He is the biggest liar in history. Why not prosecute him? I cannot understand the Republican party (which I have been a member for 20 years) selects him or Russ Limbaugh to be a spokesperson? Is that all we can come up with? I listened to Rush on t.v. at the cpac meeting and I was appaled at the venom he spews against our new president. What happened to giving him at least 100 days before we crucify him. He is so disrespectful of someone who was elected by the people. If he is the future of our party…my resignation is in the mail.
Posted by: talmag | March 2, 2009, 9:31 am 9:31 am
I thought it was very interesting to see the extreme right and the extreme left sitting across from each other on This Week. Katrina Van Huevel made a good point about government being starved ever since Reagan with the need now for govt to reinvest in America. Rove was delegitimized at the end of the Bush period and is just another in a line of Bush apologists and still towing the Republican line of more tax cuts and less spending – even in a time of severe recession and possibly a depression looming. How many jobs were ever created by tax cuts?
Posted by: Bob | March 2, 2009, 9:34 am 9:34 am
I never cease to be amazed by the blindness of partisanship. Those who don’t remember history are doomed to repeat it. NOL is still on the coast of the Gulf of Mexico which is prone to hurricanes. You can’t even bury caskets under ground because of the water table and yet NOL zoning still allows building homes below sea level. And yet hundreds of thousands of people live in these homes and further have made no preparaton themselves for evacuation or self-rescue when the inevitable hurricane comes and floods them. The images of the throngs sitting on their butts outside the convention center complaining that no one was taking care of them punctuates where the blame should lie. If you live below sea level in a hurricane area, listen to the news and get out when you have several days notice. If you don’t get out, do a little preparation to take care of yourself. These people are largely the same ones that don’t take personal responsibility even when the storms aren’t blowing.
Posted by: Mike | March 2, 2009, 9:38 am 9:38 am
The truth of the matter is that people died as a result of this tradegy and it is a more a reflection of us as a society than of a particular party. When will we wake-up and realize that the thirst for power and personal gain has infected our country to the point where we no longer have the capacity for compassion? You want to know who is to blame? Anyone who knows that they could’ve done more to reduce the suffering and didn’t and that includes me. Now, what are we going to do about it?
Posted by: Todd Bryant | March 2, 2009, 10:06 am 10:06 am
George, all partisanship aside, why do you continue to put Rove on your show?
Aren’t there Republicans with a better performance track record, more intellectual heft and certainly greater demonstrated integrity, to schedule instead?
Certainly there are. But you persist.
Do respond to this question. You have a responsibility to your viewers to do so.
Posted by: Ann Revere | March 2, 2009, 10:13 am 10:13 am
No more rove! He needs to be in prison. He can appear on your show but not before congress. If he continues to appear we will continue not watching.
Posted by: Jerry | March 2, 2009, 10:20 am 10:20 am
I don’t always agree with Katrina, but yesterday, she was absolutely stellar. I could tell that Rove was out of his element and was getting angry. She matched him point for point and totally delegitimatized his tired and prefunctory arguments. Bravo, well done.
Posted by: Laura Brown | March 2, 2009, 10:56 am 10:56 am
I just hate typing this because I think he is dispicable… but Karl Rove is right. A lot of the Katrina issues were totally mishandled at the state and local levels. The Bush administration share in this blame but should not shoulder the burden (unless you feel: “The buck stops here” attitude is appropriate. For some reason, people felt that they did not have to properly inform the President of what was really happening down there. Katrina is such a disgracefor our country.
Posted by: FS | March 2, 2009, 11:07 am 11:07 am
who cares what this bloated cheap carnival huckster says.
He’s a sad reminder of the past.
Welcome to the Age of Reality and Reason.
Posted by: quequeg | March 2, 2009, 11:14 am 11:14 am
Stop giving this man air time. He should be in prison.
Posted by: Nancy Ronan | March 2, 2009, 12:11 pm 12:11 pm
As usual, he chooses his words such that what he says can be argued to be correct, even as he ignores reality and deflects responsibility for the things they could have done and did not do. And of course, he ignores the simple reality that people died in New Orleans while journalists were on the ground to watch it unfold — all the while wondering where the help was. Sure, the feds plucked some people from rooftops (this is when Brownie was doin’ a heck of a job) but we expect them to do more than the minimum required under the law when Americans are in trouble. He may have found a way to explain this situation away and forgive himself, but most Americans have not forgiven nor forgotten.
Posted by: Tom | March 2, 2009, 12:15 pm 12:15 pm
The sad part is there are people who actually listen to this baby-headed jerk. Rove has zero credibility. After master-minding some of the worst aspects the the failure we call the Bush administration, he lied about it all. He should be in jail, not giving his toxic opinions on TV. It is sad that legitimate news sources give him a platform. Leave him to Fox…
Posted by: DaveM | March 2, 2009, 12:18 pm 12:18 pm
Rove lies. He lies often and with authority. What he says is not true, and thus to argue against it is to play to his strength, i.e., his willingness to lie without reservation or moral compunction.
Posted by: Jeebs | March 2, 2009, 12:22 pm 12:22 pm
I watch This Week every week, but this week I switched it off. I am a registered independent and I usually enjoy the diversity of the panel. However, Rove is a traitor who helped to oust a CIA operative and has no credibility to speak to anyone on anything, anytime, anywhere!!
Posted by: Ron | March 2, 2009, 12:37 pm 12:37 pm
If you’re going to invite criminals to your guest panel, at least show the viewers the courtesy of questioning them of their criminal activity while they are there first; and be sure to get a real answer. Then, please, by all means move on to the other panel questions.
Posted by: steve | March 2, 2009, 1:25 pm 1:25 pm
Why stop with Rove it’s time to put all the losers where they belong, behind bars, along with the rest of the Republicans they’re nothing but bums the only good Repulican is a Republican behind bars
Posted by: Eddie | March 2, 2009, 1:30 pm 1:30 pm
I have watched This Week for years and been impressed at the quality objective reporting. I have listened carefully to those representing opinion I do not support – that is a dialogue. But I was shocked, sickened, and angry that Carl Rove was on your show yesterday. He should be indicted, along w/ alot of others. A disgusting human being. Why do you think Carl Rove is time worthy, let alone speak? I’m so disgusted.
Posted by: Cyd | March 2, 2009, 1:42 pm 1:42 pm
How could you have that fat, lying SOB
on your show? I couldn,t believe my eyes when he was introduced. Why aren,t he and bush both in jail?
Posted by: pat | March 2, 2009, 2:09 pm 2:09 pm
Hey George, unlike some people on here who say that having Mr. Rove on was a waste of Air Time, however I find it amusing that he is still showing his face in public considering how the public in general feels about him and the Republican party at the moment!
Republicans can yell all they want but in order to get their message across someone has to be listening!
Republicans ya know you had the ball in your court, and you F…ked it up! The party of Fiscal Responsibility and less Government, and Spending went out the window, it was nothing but one great big party for 8 yrs out of 16 yrs, one great big spending spree! The problem is you spent it on absolutely nothing, at least nothing that helped this country move forward. Now we have bailouts coming out of our a$$es and why? You can blame it on the last Dem. President in the 1990’s, but might I remind you that you the Repubs were in the majority back then!
Now if this was say a year to a year and a half down the road with the new administration I could understand the rhetoric if there is not a slight change in the economy. But as always you yell about nothing, the usual Republican shallow attitude! Like our new president you are just showing you as well don’t have substance, just a lot of hot air!
As far as Katrina is concerned there is a lot of blame to go around, from the local to state and federal gov.
As far as people listening to Rush Limbaugh well it just says a lot about you!
Posted by: Politicians are Idiots | March 2, 2009, 2:24 pm 2:24 pm
Why would anyone take Turdblossom seriously? Geez……..what an appropriate nick-name………He even looks the part.
Posted by: Sammy | March 2, 2009, 2:36 pm 2:36 pm
That’s right this country does still have alot of Republicans in it, and will continue to do. We are not going anywhere. The funny thing is you libs have nothing of any importance to say. All you do is call people names and spew your nasty hatred. Grow up and get your heads out of your rear ends. If you guys don’t like it you need to move out of the country and join all the stupid Hollywood people that were SUPPOSEDLY leaving when George W was re elected.
Posted by: m | March 2, 2009, 2:52 pm 2:52 pm
Rove is right, 48 hours before Katrina hit, Pres. Bush had urged residents of New Orleans to evacuate and placed FEMA in positions to respond. Unfortunately, it was an incredibly destructive storm and thousands were impacted – however; it was the decisions made by the Governor of Lousiana at the time which prevented many people from leaving and compounded the proccess of allowing emergency aid from being rapidly distributed.
Posted by: South_Texan | March 2, 2009, 2:53 pm 2:53 pm
NO! I am DONE with Mr. Bush and his former lackeys trying to ‘spin’ their own version of the truth with regard to Katrina and my government’s mess afterward. I lived in New Orleans. I was exiled from New Orleans. I still live in New Orleans.
Go ahead, mention the Coast Guard one more time you fat @#$!. For your information, it is the Coast Guard’s mission to respond and act without a directive from ‘on-high’. Search and Rescue is their J-O-B, and they excel at it, just as they responded and excelled here in New Orleans in August 2005. I will never be able to fully express my gratitude to the men and women of the United States Coast Guard.
Now, If the rest of our government ‘mucky-mucks’ had pulled their heads out of their @$%#$ to do the same kind of J-O-B, instead of worrying about fashion, ‘tsk-tsking’ as they flew over my stricken city in their gazillion dollar airplane, my life today, along with thousands of others, might resemble something close to normal. That it does not, 3 and a half YEARS later, will be studied by sociologists and historians well into the next century.
For whatever it is worth, it is comforting to know that the truth is not anything that comes from Karl Rove, or any other of Bush’s lackeys, but DO NOT INSULT ME, SIR, nor any of the fine members of the Coast Guard. I am rebuilding my own life, no thanks to you and yours. It may take me longer, and I may, in fact, never fully recover, but it will be no thanks to you or your kind. It sickens me that I have to listen to your blubber at this late date. Go to &%@$.
Posted by: Mike Furguson | March 2, 2009, 3:00 pm 3:00 pm
…and they are so poor and so black..
Wolf Blitzer
… and totally enslaved by the government’s welfare system, with lots more just like them to come….
me
Posted by: coufplayer | March 2, 2009, 3:14 pm 3:14 pm
How funny, m, I listend to parts to the Republican meeting with Rush and Couleter speaking and all I heard was name-calling and spewing nasty hatred. So, it’s OK when a Republican does it? Seems to me as if the GOP has the patent on toxic politics with a trademark on character assasination. Maybe it is just that the Republicans can dish it out but they can’t take it.
Posted by: DaveM | March 2, 2009, 3:18 pm 3:18 pm
What was Karl Rove doing on TV on Sunday when he couldn’t be bothered to appear before Congress?
Why give him the credibility???
Posted by: hofkurz | March 2, 2009, 3:22 pm 3:22 pm
Folks, for the record, I am white, and owned my own successful business here in New Orleans. My home was trashed by looters, and my business went under because its market was scattered across the country. Welfare never entered the picture for me, or for many thousands of others. Put that and the race bait away, folks. Katrina and its aftereffects affected everybody, regardless of race or socio-economic statues.
Posted by: Mike Furguson | March 2, 2009, 3:31 pm 3:31 pm
The Democratic Party has been able to persuade reasonable intelligent people (with a little help from some cool-aide) to feel so guilty about success that it’s actual laughable. The far right politicians who are all living the high life in Washington actual have you guiltable liberal’s convenience that it’s okay to be non-productive and depend on the government. Believe me in due time you will all come to your senses, once you understand “it’s do as I say and not as I do.”
Posted by: Christine Dean | March 2, 2009, 3:45 pm 3:45 pm
PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE – Do not have Karl Rove back on your show. I watch ‘This Week’ every Sunday and he ruins the show for me. He was rude, talking over everyone and shouting to be heard when we don’t want to hear anymore from him. Eight years was enough!
Posted by: C E Wells | March 2, 2009, 3:47 pm 3:47 pm
Rove’s face makes me sick. Please go away with your master!
Posted by: leighg1 | March 2, 2009, 3:54 pm 3:54 pm
Isn’t there a jail cell waiting on him somewhere.
Posted by: Tonya | March 2, 2009, 4:04 pm 4:04 pm
The race bait was Wolf’s not mine – of course, nobody called him on it – if a conservative had said it, Jessie Jackson would still be hollering. Mike, I assume that you didn’t just sit down in the flood waters and wait for the gov’t to rescue you, right? That’s what I’m talking about. Decades of welfare have created a totally dependent and helpless under class of all colors. Katrina was a tragedy and thousands of good honest people suffered greatly – I get that. In fact, my step mother’s sister and husband lost everything and lived with my parents for over a year before getting their lives back together. What I’m tired of is the blame game and the denial by the local and state officials to accept their part of the responsibility. Bush’s bunch didn’t move quick enough, but their was plenty of blame to go around, including mother nature which is still beyond our control.
Posted by: coufplayer | March 2, 2009, 4:14 pm 4:14 pm
coufplayer, Thanks much! I wish your relatives the best. Had some friends who used to live here drive to New Orleans this past weekend. They settled where Katrina took them, in Memphis, and this was the first time they were able to even come back. I know, and miss, so many. Thanks again.
Posted by: Mike Furguson | March 2, 2009, 4:19 pm 4:19 pm
Mr. Credible is trying to convince us of what? If you believe that, I’ve got some WMD in Iraq to sell ya.
Posted by: DaveM | March 2, 2009, 4:40 pm 4:40 pm
Why is the voice of the Bush administration still getting air time? We had to endure eight years of those insular, head-in-the-sand, it’s-my-way-or-you’re-not-American conceited, self-absorbed, divisive tax-and-spenders. Do you not realize we are sick of them? Sick of Rove? Enough. We have suffered far too much for far too long because of Rove. Do not have him back on the show. I will not watch again if he is invited back.
Posted by: gudnuff | March 2, 2009, 4:48 pm 4:48 pm
i was shocked to see Rove as a credible commentator on “This Week.” I will not watch this program anymore if he is given a forum for his discredited, self-serving opinions.
Posted by: alchudley | March 2, 2009, 5:18 pm 5:18 pm
What’s wrong with this picture? Karl Rove being interviewed on a ABC when he should be in jail for failing to appear before Congress after being subpoenaed. And we claim to be a law-abiding nation?
Again, what’s wrong with this picture?
Posted by: karen | March 2, 2009, 6:09 pm 6:09 pm
America! Why is this man who has thumbed his nose at our laws and Congress itself been given any credibility; he has none! America when will “we the people” put these criminals in prison!?
Posted by: john copeland | March 2, 2009, 6:14 pm 6:14 pm
The Borgen Project has some good info on the cost of addressing global poverty.
$30 billion: Annual shortfall to end world hunger.
$550 billion: U.S. Defense budget
Posted by: Abel Tsegga | March 2, 2009, 7:31 pm 7:31 pm
I can’t believe it!! I sat throught the entire show waiting for that magical question. Why are you not in front of congress answering your subpenas? Then I realized that Carl Rove was using the Jedi mind trick, it had to be. I’d thought Katrina was stronger then that, but there was too much Bull$%#@*! spewing from his mouth I have to give her a pass….This time
Posted by: Vincent Reed | March 2, 2009, 7:48 pm 7:48 pm
As a long time viewer of This Week I join many other posters in asking that you do not invite the likes of Carl Rove to join discussions on the round table. I enjoy civil debate of different views, which is generally the hallmark of This Week. Sunday’s broadcast was a great disappointment since Mr. Rove’s presence turned the discussion into a cable-worthy shouting match. I look forward to being educated, not harangued by a boorish political operative. If repeated, this “new” aggressive confrontational approach is sure to drive away your viewers.
Posted by: Nicholas | March 2, 2009, 8:38 pm 8:38 pm
I went to Louisiana on November 5th, 2005…2 and a half months after Katrina. I didn’t see Karl Rove there. In fact, I didn’t see many government workers there. What I saw were a lot of people who still needed help, and a lot of non-government volunteers (like myself) who were there doing the work. Regardless of who’s responsibility it was, are you telling me that the government – more specifically, the president – doesn’t have a moral obligation to get on a plane and check things out themselves to see what needs to be done? I pretty sure they see the same news coverage in D.C. that I got on my local news in Phoenix, AZ. And the pictures alone were enough to tell me I needed to get involved. The comments from Rove are the biggest pile of passing the buck crap I’ve ever heard. And, shameful. Has no one learned that sticking one’s head in the sand doesn’t actually make the problem go away??
Posted by: andrea hill | March 2, 2009, 8:49 pm 8:49 pm
dave m-what I am saying is for everyone to grow up. All this stuff is crap. So no I am not crying that is not fair because both sides do it. All the hatred has to stop. It is suppose to be okay that we have different opinions, thats what makes the freakin world go around. Imagine if we are all a bunch a mindless democrats that want the touchy feely stuff, that taxes Americans to death. I work hard for my money and I be damned if I am going to be taxed to death to pay for people that don’t want to get off their butts and get a freakin job. By the way, George Bush isn’t President anymore, move on.
Posted by: m | March 2, 2009, 9:00 pm 9:00 pm
Please do not give Karl Rove any more
chances to speak. He has been the architect of many harmful policies.
Posted by: Jean | March 3, 2009, 12:33 am 12:33 am
Karl Rove is evil — CNN and moveon.org told me so, must be true.
Posted by: coufplayer | March 3, 2009, 8:01 am 8:01 am
Mr. Rove’s credibility dial is set firmly on empty, used up in creating the lies and subterfuge for the Bush administration. He truly should be in jail at this point. It is pathetic that the Republicans consider him a spokesperson for their party. What are they thinking?
Posted by: DaveM | March 3, 2009, 10:23 am 10:23 am
Rove has read the novel 1984. Perhaps we all should take it out again and read it over. Sometimes seems to be his handbook.
“He who controls the past, controls the future…”-from the novel 1984, by George Orwell
Posted by: MD | March 3, 2009, 11:39 am 11:39 am
George, I agree with most of the positions taken above, including the ones that spread the blame to all the players. However, I missed Rove’s input entirely because we changed the channel to something else … the first time EVER that we’ve turned off your program. The man is very intelligent, but he did a great deal of harm to the United States, and I won’t listen to what he has to say any more.
Posted by: Hal | March 3, 2009, 4:31 pm 4:31 pm
Rove will always be a con-man. He makes his living telling lies. This is what he does. Unbelievable for “This Week” to validate a con-man’s performance.
Posted by: CenterOne | March 3, 2009, 4:52 pm 4:52 pm
George,
I just wanted to say thank you for having Karl Rove on this week. It was great to finally have someone on not spewing all the mindless liberal talking points. Karl was on point and was using logic and facts to back up his arguments – which is so much better than the liberal arguments based on emotions and anger. He “B” slapped that nasty Katrina woman and that other liberal weenie. The face on that Katrina woman was PRICELESS when he smacked her down with facts! As always, George Will was great as well! Hope to see Karl on more often!
Posted by: Dan In SC | March 3, 2009, 6:12 pm 6:12 pm
I don’t really understand why ABC is asking Karl Rove anything except why he keeps thumbing his nose at congress and ignoring the fact that he has had more than one request for him to testify about what was going on in the Bush Administration. That should be the ONLY question he is being asked at this point and he certainly should not be being treated like a celebrity pundit.
Posted by: Livvy | March 3, 2009, 7:13 pm 7:13 pm
I can’t believe “This Week” had Karl Rove on. This guy is a crook and the subject of several subpoenas. He was involved in the outing of a CIA agent, Valerie Plame. In addition, he has been wrong on just about everything. I remember that he predicted a Republican win in the 2006 elections. He keeps the spirit of Lee Atwater alive at the expense of all Americans.
I lost a lot of respect for the program after seeing Rove tell lies and rewrite the most basic facts of the last eight years of history. Isn’t it bad enough to have the nay saying ideologue George Will on the program?
Posted by: Dave Southern | March 3, 2009, 10:51 pm 10:51 pm
Rove is a G.D. Liar
How past Presidents have responded to hurricanes:
President: Nixon
Danger: Category 5 Hurricane Camille (August 1969)
Area: About the same area as that affected by Katrina
Response: Nixon prepared the National Guard in advance, ordering rescue ships from Tampa, FL and Houston, TX to stand waiting along with over a thousand regular military, 24+ helicopters to assist the Coast Guard and National Guard about as soon as the hurricane passed.
President: George H. Bush (the first)
Danger: Category 5 Hurricane Andrew (August 92)
Area: Florida
Response: In the middle of a re-election campaign,
Bush ceased campaigning the day before the hurricane, went to Washington, and assembled one of the largest military forces ever mustered on U.S. soil. Seven thousand National Guard and 22,000 regular military were sent in with the necessary equipment shortly after the hurricane passed through.
President: Clinton
Danger: Category 3 Hurricane Floyd (September 1999)
Area: Virginia and Carolinas
Response: Meeting with China’s president Jiang in New Zealand, Clinton immediately declared the hurricane-affected areas as federal disasters, allowing the military and National Guard to move in and help. Clinton flew home immediately, one day BEFORE the hurricane hit, to help coordinate the rescue.
President: George W. Bush (the second)
Danger: Category 5 Hurricane Katrina (August 2005)
Area: Gulf Coast
Response: Bush was on vacation, riding his bike for two hours on the day before the hurricane lands. On the day Katrina landed, Bush attended a birthday party for John McCain. The levees began to crack. While emergency 1.5-ton sandbags were ready to be placed to steady the levee and absorb water, there were insufficient numbers of helicopters and pilots to set them before the levees break.
Nagin, the mayor of NO, pleaded for federal-level assistance and got none. Bush went to San Diego to play guitar with a country singer and end his vacation early — but not until the next day, because he had tickets to a San Diego Padres game.
National Guard troops are down about 8,000 members because they are in Iraq with much of the needed rescue equipment.
Posted by: Frank | March 4, 2009, 12:07 am 12:07 am
This Rove bastard is a serious threat to our nation. He is a God Damned Lying sack of feces that should be tried and executed. I would pay thousands for the honor of executing him, after a guilty verdict by way of a fair trial, of course. Rove is an enemy of all good Americans.
Posted by: Frank | March 4, 2009, 12:13 am 12:13 am
Kathleen Blanco and Mayor Ray Nagin are to blame because they did nothing to over-rule George Bush and bring the National Guard home. If they would have killed Bush, many more people might have survived Katrian. Kathleen Blanco should have taken what Guard troops she had left and taken Bush hostage so she could have brought the troops and resorces home. Killing Bush, Cheney, and Rove would have been the best course of action. It would have saved thousands of innocent people’s lives. Our entire nation would have been better off without these scumbals, no question about it.
We still have worthless representatives that make noise about holding Rove accountable for his crimes, but they lie just like Rove. Nothing will ever be done to him for what he has done to this country. Damned traitor.
Posted by: Pam Jacobs | March 4, 2009, 12:30 am 12:30 am
The party needs to get rid of Karl, Rush, all of the guard, before our party sinks with the economy…
Posted by: Richard | March 4, 2009, 1:28 am 1:28 am
Why anyone would even ask his opinion on anything makes me shake my head. He has no credability and his opinions make no impacat on me or anyone who has seen what he has done in the Bush administration. Unfortunately, no one is brave enough to prosecute him.
Posted by: talmag | March 4, 2009, 9:30 am 9:30 am
I am a progressive, a little to the left of middle and support Barrack Obama tremendously, with some reservation.
As much as I enjoyed seeing Katrina and her allie tie into Karl Rove, it made me sick to see your program give Rove a voice. This man is a mean, sick criminal mouth piece and manipulator for Fox news and the extreme right. He has totally disregarded at least three subpoenas from Congress and gotten away with it. He is basicly a fugitive of the law. He has sent Don Seigleman, an innocent good man to prison. He has ruined the carrier of Valerie Plame and probably gotten several covert agents in her organization killed. He has taken away the right of millions of voters by way of caging AND he has blatently been caught lieing about political issues, several times publicly.
PLEASE, Do not give this man audience and voice again on your forum, it is obscene slander to the respect I have given your program thus far.
Sincerely,
Lyn Myers
Posted by: Lyn Myers | March 4, 2009, 11:04 am 11:04 am
Yeah… sure… Rove’s a good Christian… NOT. He and the republicans could CARE LESS about people, and instead worship the almighty dollar! Yet the Money loving republicans have somehow conned the Christians that Christ cares about money too. If you think for a minute that adminstration gave one thought to the human part of the Katrina tragedy, then you too have been completely brainwashed.
Posted by: Troy Street | March 4, 2009, 12:21 pm 12:21 pm
The governor of the LA and the mayor of N.O. are incompetent. To cover their ineptitude, they blamed Bush.
It’s always someone elses fault with the democrats…..
Posted by: ReallyMeanIt | March 4, 2009, 12:28 pm 12:28 pm
“I would pay thousands for the honor of executing him, after a guilty verdict by way of a fair trial”.
Posted by: Frank
———————–
Very nazi of you.
Posted by: ReallyMeanIt | March 4, 2009, 12:34 pm 12:34 pm
It’s impressive to see how Rove, uh, operates…The guy’s successful for a reason…He’s the personification of an “evil genius”…Rove’s the Hannibal Lecter of politics…When you see him go back and forth with Van Huefel, you can imagine him saying: “..Fly back home now little Starling. fly, fly, fly..”
Posted by: TruthHurts | March 4, 2009, 10:03 pm 10:03 pm
If you were as disgusted to see Rove on TW as I was, watch out…David Gregory might have him on Meet The Press.
And as far as his comments on Katrina, Rove is correct if one follows the letter of the law. But is that what we want from the federal government in a crisis? Scott McClellan said it best in his book What Happened…the federal government is the fail safe to compensate for breakdowns at lower levels. Standing on the letter of the law in this case is ridiculous, and is a testament to Rove as a person.
Posted by: Steve Horton | March 4, 2009, 11:17 pm 11:17 pm
As a foreign student here in USA, I am still appalled at the incompetence of the local LA officials. That must be the Mayor and Governor. They are the ones who were supposed to know the characteristics of ‘their’ people and City. Their brilliant inputs (which obviously lacking),and persistent demand to the Federal Gov. to save their people could have made a big difference. Living in a ‘developing’ country seems to give me better understanding of this then most of you.
Posted by: Dan | March 5, 2009, 3:15 am 3:15 am
OT comment — if you’re going to put it in big letter, it better be right. Your headline reads “Rove: Bush Administration ‘Fulfilled’ It’s Katrina Responsibilities”.
“It’s” is the abridgment of “it is”. It is not the possessive for of it. Used in this context, there should be no apostrophe.
Posted by: Linda | March 5, 2009, 8:23 am 8:23 am
If it isn’t written in the communist manifesto .The liberals have no interest in it. They are using the constitution as butt wipe. They will fertilize their gardens with the blood of conservatives just like Stalin,Mao,Castro. That is what they want and the stupid will follow.Truth is not relevant to The left. The leftist leaders caused the Katrina problem by not following the law. Yet the stupid blame Bush instead of the right full criminals they are.
Posted by: Jeff | March 5, 2009, 9:36 pm 9:36 pm
Posted by: Steve
Why don’t Republicans just move to Alaska and leave the rest of us alone?
Hey Steve,
IF ALL THE REPUBLICAN’S MOVED TO ALASKA THEN WHO WOULD PAY FOR ALL THE “PORK” THAT JUST GOT PASSED IN THAT SO CALLED “STIMULUS” BILL?
YOU PEOPLE SAY “ALL” REPUBLICANS ARE RICH = RIGHT?
My Dad came to this country with nothing and worked his A$$ off to give us a roof over our heads. He didn’t believe it was the roll of the GOV’T to provide for his family, it was his. Take money for the GOV’T meant he failed as a father and husband. My Dad has passed and I’m so thankful for all the lesson’s he has taught my siblings and me.
May God Bless this country even when this Country doesn’t bless God.
Posted by: Roman | March 6, 2009, 7:44 am 7:44 am
OT comment — if you’re going to put it in big letter, it better be right. Your headline reads “Rove: Bush Administration ‘Fulfilled’ It’s Katrina Responsibilities”.
“It’s” is the abridgment of “it is”. It is not the possessive for of it. Used in this context, there should be no apostrophe.
Posted by: Linda
****************************
And there should be a comma before ‘its’
Posted by: spacerook1 | March 7, 2009, 11:18 pm 11:18 pm
What i don’t understand is why ANYONE would waste airtime or even air on this guy.
Cheny, Rove, Rummy….they should all be given a VERY long vacation, paid in advance by the RNC & the companies that profited from there collective raping of this country.
Posted by: Darryl the Contractor | March 8, 2009, 8:36 pm 8:36 pm
DID THE BUSH ADMINASTRATION ACTUALY GIVE AWAY 350. BILLION DOLLARS TO A GROUP OF BANK’S JUST BEFORE LEAVING OFFICE ? I SEEM TO REMEMBER HEARING ON TV.THAT SOME OF THE BANKS DIDN’T EVEN ASK FOR THE MONEY AND SEEMED TO BE UNCLEAR AS TO WHAT THEY WERE EXPECTED TO DO WITH THE MONEY.
Posted by: Richard Black | March 9, 2009, 2:26 pm 2:26 pm
Carisoprodol.
Carisoprodol.
Posted by: Pharmacy online carisoprodol description price. | August 26, 2009, 5:18 am 5:18 am
Percocet.
Percocet no prescription. Percocet. How long does percocet stay in your system.
Posted by: Percocet. | August 26, 2009, 7:01 pm 7:01 pm
Zoloft.
Zoloft. Supplements and zoloft. Zoloft side effects.
Posted by: Generic zoloft. | September 18, 2009, 8:55 am 8:55 am