By Caitlin Taylor

Jul 30, 2009 1:19pm

Clyburn: ‘Absolutely No Idea’ if Concessions to Blue Dogs Will Survive; ‘That Just Ain’t the Way the World Works’

ABC News’ Rick Klein reports: Democratic leaders in Congress are increasingly optimistic that breakthroughs in negotiations with conservatives inside their caucus will allow health care reform to get back on track before the August recess.  But having a bill pass the relevant committees is quite a bit different than finding a final product that both liberals and conservatives can support. On ABCNews.com’s “Top Line” today, House Majority Whip James Clyburn predicted that the House Energy and Commerce Committee will be able to pass a bill before the House begins its five-week recess at the end of this week.   Yet he said he could not guarantee that the concessions negotiated into that bill by conservative “Blue Dog” Democrats would survive in a final product. “We have absolutely no idea,” Clyburn, D-S.C., told me and ABC’s Jonathan Karl. “Remember this bill has to be squared with the product of two other committees. The Ways and Means Committee finished their markup a couple of weeks ago. Then the Education and Labor Committee has finished its markup. We have three different tracks running in the House. Now, when the Energy and Commerce Committee finishes, we’ll try to meld these three documents into one, and what that final document will be is certainly not going to be exactly what comes out of the Energy Commerce. People understand that.” As the chief vote-counter in the House, Clyburn has to balance a wide range of viewpoints inside the Democratic caucus — including Blue Dogs who have worked to hold down the cost and minimize the impact on businesses, and liberals who are insisting on a robust “public option” to compete with private insurers. “I don’t think that anyone can guarantee what the final document is going to be,” Clyburn continued. “The fact of the matter is when you’re doing legislation, you’ve got to take into account the districts that are being represented by Blue Dogs. But look: The Blue Dogs — we have some Congressional Black Caucus members, some Hispanic members, and their concerns have to be dealt with, too.” “So this whole thing about the one group getting all of what it wants to the expense of the other group — that’s not the way things work,” Clyburn said. “Things work with us trying to find common ground, trying to find a happy medium. And that’s what we’re trying to do here. So if you think any kind of deal will be exactly like you wanted it when it gets lined up with the other two committees — that just ain’t the way the world works.” Still, Clyburn sounded an optimistic note about the prospects of keeping the process moving. He said he believes the slide in support for President Obama’s health care plans will begin to move in the other direction when and if Democrats rally around a single product.  “I think the numbers go up when you get a bill,” Clyburn said. “The problem is when you’ve got three different committees doing three different things in the House. You’ve got the Senate with two different committees, doing two different things – that’s five things out there. People are confused. They don’t [know] exactly what the deal is. If you get these three committees working in concert with each other, we go out there next month with this bill coming out of all three committees, we’ve then got one bill to go out to the public that says, ‘This is what the Democrats are offering you. We’re offering you a change from your current situation.’ ” Clyburn, the highest-ranking African-American in Congress, also said he’s looking forward to this evening’s beer diplomacy at the White House.  “I came to the Congress after spending 18 years in South Carolina dealing with these kinds of issues on a day-to-day basis,” he said. “And I can tell you when people get together and stop talking past each other [and] start listening to each other, I think you get a much better result. So I think the president was right to have this little session today, because maybe the rest of us can look in on that little table that they’ll be sitting at and get a much better feel for how we ought to be treating each other as we go forward.” Click HERE to see the full interview with Rep. James Clyburn. Also today, we chatted with Paul Brathwaite, a Democratic strategist with the Podesta Group, about the Democrats’ troubles in passing a health care bill.  He also helped us preview tonight’s meeting at the White House — the Audacity of Hops. Click HERE to see the interview with Paul Brathwaite.

User Comments

Now that’s what I’m talking about. Vote public health care straight up or down. 2010 elections are coming. We have plenty of time to find real democrats and another 18 republican senators to throw out of office. I say let them yellow dogs take their chances with the republicans!

Posted by: rightbehind | July 30, 2009, 4:02 pm 4:02 pm

Insurance and pharmaceutical lobbies are fighting this tooth and nail, and using every dirty tactic they can to protect their obscene profits and bonuses, including enlisting the aid of their bought and paid for legislators in Washington. They are the reason we need health care reform in the first place, because they are now fully in control of the health care industry, and they run it with corporate profit as their only guiding principle. American businesses, health providers, individuals and government entities all come up on the short end, and that is no concern to them. A national government-run plan is the only solution with the power to rein them in and hold them accountable for their irresponsible greed. They are a huge part of the reason businesses are moving good jobs out of this country and converting to part-time work forces, to avoid the crushing, unrealistic burden of today’s cost of insuring employees in the US. Insurance corporations today are the devil, a legalized racket. And blue dogs, don’t think we aren’t watching. Without you GOP counterparts to hide behind and blame, you are now exposing yourselves as part of the reason nothing substantial ever gets done in Washington to effectively address this perennial top issue, and we will vote you out next election, no matter how much insurance lobby money you have backing you up.

Posted by: iamwomaninMI | July 30, 2009, 7:27 pm 7:27 pm

Highly doubtful the yellow dogs will survive when the 2010 elections come. We have plenty of time to find real democrats to replace them. Vote public health care straight up or down.

Posted by: rightbehind | July 30, 2009, 10:18 pm 10:18 pm

This is all so much theater. The real health care reform bill has already been written, it is H.R. 676,
Time to scrap this entire process, and just pass the bill the people want, HR 676

Posted by: Flash Override | July 31, 2009, 9:44 am 9:44 am

Rick Klein reports the following without a scintilla of evidence:
“Blue Dogs who have worked to hold down the cost ”
Throughout the process, the Blue Chip Democrats have done nothing but drive up the final cost of what is euphemistically called “reform”.
They took the already watered-down “public option” and allowed subsidies to go to private insurance companies instead of just to people enrolling in a public plan.
They limited the size of the group that would be eligible for the public option, thus reducing its negotiating power.
They eliminated the plan to use the Medicare schedule.
Then they eliminated the public option altogether, inserting a plan for small, unproven “co-ops”.
Every one of these proposals will drive up the costs of the plan.

Posted by: Flash Override | July 31, 2009, 9:52 am 9:52 am

Flash – I have news for you. Where are you going to get your medical care after your HR 676 passes? There are going to be alot of medical providers closing their facilities, why do you think that not all providers choose to take Medicare. Think it could have anything to do with the fact that the Medicare payment doesn’t equal the cost of the service provided and that may be one of the reasons they charge those not on Medicare more to make up the difference. Get your head back in the sunshine and think.

Posted by: sandcrab1612 | July 31, 2009, 2:50 pm 2:50 pm

THE WORD ON THE STREET* * * * * * * * * *
We seem to live in an age where the citizenry has to defend itself against government encroachment rather than having a representative government. There is a lot of unrest as people increasingly find themselves at odds with a government that doesn’t listen to the people. Disillusionment with local government as it raises property evaluations while real values decrease and other issues such as involuntary annexation. Disillusionment with a state government that increases taxes as many are jobless and others with reduced income and with higher expenses. Disillusionment with a federal government that blindly passes monstrous bills without regard to impact, the deficit, the debt or even the mechanism of implementation (bills that are often unread and certainly not understood by the congress). Disillusionment with a government where elected officials see themselves as an elite ruling class which knows more than those who blindly elected them. Disillusionment with a government that acts without regard to public input, even though in this computer age each official could receive input from his constituents via polling. Democrats are proclaiming a victory (over republicans, or over the constitution?) in getting a favorable vote on an activist judge. Those of us that are independent voters really feel disenfranchised as we are only courted for our swing vote, but we are looking forward to midterm elections with renewed excitement! Our rallying cry may be . . . “REMEMBER JOHN CONYERS (DUH)!

Posted by: Ed Taylor | August 5, 2009, 5:47 pm 5:47 pm

Leave a Reply

Do you have more information about this topic? If so, please click here to contact the editors of ABC News.