Obama and the Health Care Hurdles
When President Obama lays it on the line tonight with a primetime news conference pushing health care reform, part of his message may be to invoke, as politicians do, the will of the people. We got a preview yesterday; in a Rose Garden appearance, the president said, “the American people understand that the status quo is unacceptable.”
Were it that simple.
While he rightly brings up the public’s concerns about health care, the president’s challenge is that those concerns cut two ways. On the one hand, yes, most are supportive of reform in principle, given broad dissatisfaction with the current system overall and worry about future costs. But on the other, most people also are satisfied with their current care, coverage and even costs – and worried that reform could in fact worsen these.
We explored these dynamics in detail in our health care poll last month. They're in many ways the same as those that confronted President Clinton in his quest for reform 16 years ago. Barack Obama’s hoping that the politics and the economics have changed, and that may be; nonetheless public opinion by and large is where it's always been: Interested in reform, but skeptical about its impact.
Roughly eight in 10 in our June poll expressed concern that reform could reduce their quality, coverage and choice of care, and increase their costs, government bureaucracy and the deficit, with anywhere from 51 to 62 percent “very” concerned about these outcomes. Fifty-eight percent expressed doubt that people would be free to keep the coverage they have now without any changes – contrary to Obama’s repeated assurances on this point.
As an example of the compunctions, while 62 percent supported a government option, that fell to 37 percent if it put many private insurers out of business. And the public split essentially evenly on a personal mandate, but with great variation depending on the particulars.
Again, support for reform is there; when we rolled up the main pieces of the House plan in our new poll this week, 54 percent favored it. But “strong” support and “strong” opposition were even (a third each), and this was without the pushback language that so reliably resonates.
Note, moreover, the direction of Obama’s approval rating for handling health care as he’s pushed the issue forward: In April, 57 percent approved, 29 percent disapproved. In June, 53-39 percent. And today, 49-44 percent. On health care, it seems, the hurrieder he goes, the behinder he gets.
At the end of the day, two forces for change operate in public sentiment. Discontent with current conditions is the strong force; when it exists, change is demanded. (The economy is an example.) The weak force is apprehension about the future. It creates interest in change, but not demand.
Health care reform is somewhere between the two. Most people are unhappy with the current system and would like to see it improved. But eight in 10 rate their own quality of care and coverage positively, and 55 percent are even satisfied with their current costs. Those realities – and the concerns about the possible consequences of reform – are the hurdles in public opinion that Obama, like Clinton before him, has yet to clear.
Email
Santorum: Money Will Not Defeat Obama, Ideas Will
Rick Santorum's Full Speech at CPAC 2012
This ridiculous plan will be the final nail in the financial coffin for the U.S. 90% of Americans will be adversly effected to provide coverage for the 7% that do not have it. Passage of this bill will nearly complete Barack Obama’s dream of a Socialist America.
Overthrowing or changing our form of government without regard to the constitution is an act of treason, America you had better wake up!
Posted by: Robert Weathers | July 22, 2009, 10:25 am 10:25 am
I couldn’t agreee more with Robert Weathers. What I see around me is a lack of understanding on the part of the general public that the U.S. could be rapidly abondoning its democratic ways. There are polls that show that the vast majority of Americans, for various reasons, do not want this socialized health plan forced down their throats by a few left of center Washington politicians. That is exactly where we are heading if this keeps up.
My hope is that this plan receives the scrutiny that is necessary when making such huge changes; scrutiny that will reveal its true costs and shortcomings. What is needed is that enough Americans, through their representatives, voice thier concerns and feelings in order to stop the wool from being pulled over our eyes. This is too large NOT to do it properly and get it done right! This must be done in accordance with the US Constitution!
Posted by: Thomas Tousley | July 22, 2009, 11:02 am 11:02 am
Bottom line is that Americans don;’t favor the status quo that Republicans seem to be so happy with.
Posted by: matt | July 22, 2009, 12:02 pm 12:02 pm
Bottom line is that Americans don;’t favor the status quo that Republicans seem to be so happy with.
————————————–
Matt,
Instead of over-hyping your site, maybe you should actually wake up and check on a few FACTS!
Check out the gallup poll. Americans want healthcare REFORM Not the BS of HR3200!!!!
Posted by: Mike_C | July 22, 2009, 12:22 pm 12:22 pm
Why have a congress, they pass bills without reading, and this healthcare bill is another example…we the people need to clean house, which includes all the bureaucrats in DC.
Why don’t you deal with the real issues that are causing our healthcare problems…like illegal immigration, Medicaid fraud, and other government waste? Will YOU and your family opt out on the healthcare plan you presently have to join the public option health plan that Congress wrote for the rest of us?” 15 to 20 MILLION of those people are ILLEGAL ALIENS that you propose to include in your plan”? No one is talking about that and if more people were informed about this they would be outraged. That is a HUGE amount of money we would save if we did not cover the illegals.
If the proposed healthcare plan passes, and the government tells the doctor how to treat patients and who they are to treat, who do I direct my malpractice suit to. Do I sue the doctor, the government, both, or sue the doctor and then the doctor sues the government for preventing him or her from treating the patient??????? If so, how does one declare Chapter 13 Bankruptcy for the country in 2012?
Posted by: mary mook | July 22, 2009, 12:31 pm 12:31 pm
The Obama Administration must stop ignoring the libel and slander from the right if it wants to get ANYTHING done; especially health care reform. Take them to court for every false statement for the good of the nation.
Posted by: Cloteasboy | July 22, 2009, 12:48 pm 12:48 pm
If it were’nt for bluedog Democrats and Republicans we would have a healthcare bill that would outlaw health saving accounts, outlaw new private policies ,gives healthcare to illegals, would result in rationing and long waits, low priority for seniors, and worst of all, a government bureaucrat would get between you and your doctor. This healthcare bill takes away our freedom to choose. We need lower costs but we still have the world’s best healthcare. Government healthcare means Higher costs and Lower quality.
Posted by: Jennifer | July 22, 2009, 2:35 pm 2:35 pm
America better wake up fast. If you think it’s bad now wait until you have to wait months for heart or cancer surgery. Worse yet the goverment tells you the you can’t have that surgery! Pretty scary!!!!
Ginney
Posted by: Ginney | July 22, 2009, 3:16 pm 3:16 pm
I can remember when a hamburger, an order of fries and a large coke were only 50 cents and that was only 40 years ago. Today it is about $8-9. So the dollar is only worth about a nickel and you must have twenty times the money you had then to enjoy the same buying power today. The time has come for our Washington leaders to face the facts and get a healthcare plan that Americans, throughout their lives, can afford.
Today a millionaire, who hasn’t provided his family insurance, can wake up in the hospital in a catastrophic medical condition, facing bankruptcy. For decades healthcare costs compared to income have risen faster than any other sector within our economy. This is simply because of the mentality of the people who control the industry. They live only for profits and the bottom line very simply with an attitude of life being expendable if a person cannot afford to pay.
The American Dream is not just to own a home. The Dream must be about being about to enjoy a healthy and quality kind of life. Insurance companies and pharmaceuticals are two of the most powerful lobbies that manipulate our leaders in Washington. Obama is attempting to do what politicians have only talked about, for decades, a quality, fair and affordable healthcare system for all. It will basically create tremendous pressure on insurance companies forcing them to become more competitive and stop them from ripping people off.
Insurance companies are muck like Vegas. The statistical odds are skewed to always favor the house. I honestly believe whoever came up with the concept of insurance was preparing to rob himself, upon becoming insured. Then his case became the sales model to begin pushing the concept of insurance and financially rob his neighbors.
Obama is simply facing the facts and trying to emancipate the working man from being slaves to the greedy and powerful corporations. He must create drastic change that forces certain American industries into a system of honesty and reality. Furthermore, he is under enormous pressure to perfect something Americans will accept and trust, before the mess left by republicans, who promoted their concept of capitalism being simply free enterprise without regulation, totally implodes the world economy into absolute chaos.
Only the foolish fail to recognize how near we are to an economic abyss. This healthcare program facilitates a tremendous injection into the money supply to sustain the economy while rectifying a major defect within the quality of life of Americans. This money is not going into the pockets of bankers or corporate mobsters. It is going directly into services for the people.
United We Stand, Divided We Fall…
Posted by: Ed C in OK | July 22, 2009, 8:31 pm 8:31 pm
Ginny, don’t see that the plan will eliminate competition, not enhance it? The government option is non-profit and financed by the taxpayer. The insurance company’s must make a profit or go out of business. So what the democrats call competition is actually the total elimination of competition.
Posted by: rolliss | July 26, 2009, 10:30 am 10:30 am
Ginny, don’t see that the plan will eliminate competition, not enhance it? The government option is non-profit and financed by the taxpayer. The insurance company’s must make a profit or go out of business. So what the democrats call competition is actually the total elimination of competition.
Posted by: rolliss | July 26, 2009, 10:30 am 10:30 am
This 1017 pages of healthcare reform bills have both good and bad. BUT the jokers in Congress and Senate should at least read and understand it before rubber stamping it. Would the jokers that wrote this bill use this healthcare plan for themselves, of course not? If they won’t, why should they shove it down the American citizen’s throat? Did you know that part of the bill is for the tax payers to fund abortion? Our citizens should read what Betsy McCaughey, former Lieutenant governor of New York, shared with Bloomberg about Obama’s healthcare reform plan. This bill is not about healthcare, it is about population control by the government. Our healthcare is the best in the world. It is about health insurance, not healthcare. It is about the government controlling your life expectance. It is about the government doesn’t want to invest in your life and invest into some illegal alien’s live. Why should the taxpayers pay for the illegal aliens. These illegal aliens never pay into our tax system. They should ALL be sent back where they come from. What kind of country are we, asking our sick seniors to consider terminating their lives. Someday, it will be yours. For those who support Mr. Obama and the Democrat’s healthcare plan, you got what you deserved. The Democratic Party should rename themselves to the Socialist Party of America. Because that’s the agenda.
Posted by: Ken | July 29, 2009, 6:20 pm 6:20 pm
i wish you people at a.b.c. wasnt so bias toward obama.you was a good honest news source in the old days, when you did things honest.what you are doing now does no one any good not even you in the end,
Posted by: harvey nichols | August 1, 2009, 3:24 pm 3:24 pm
Obama’s healthcare reform…..is not reform!….he doesnt know the meaning of the word.. If he wants reform…go after negociating with the drug company’s…and lower the hospital costs….Now THATS reform! we do not want government controled healthcare! the ones who have it, come here to the usa to get it, why do they do that? because we already have the best in the world…and Obama wants to change it..
why? he says we will all have a choice…we can keep our present health care? He is dreaming! any company who provides health care..will change to the cheapist way to go to save money…cant blame them for that…they will go with the government..where does that leave me?…in a gov. program that I dont want!…you hear all the horror stories in other countries who have it, and they are true!..he wants to force it on us! It is not right…we are supposed to be a free country…with choices..we will have no choice in this situation…why dont the powers that be, know this? would Obama put his kids in a government health care…make them wait in a waiting room for hours to see a doctor? or weeks and/or months to get an appointment? I dont think so! if it is okay for me, then it is okay for his family too!…not gonna happen…we all know that…i for one will not be voting for any , i mean ANY INCUMBANT!….they are all sheep. following the bad wolf…time for them to go….they dont have the guts to think for themselves,….how can we have them representing us?…i have tried to write to all of my representatives…no actknowledgement at all…I am a native daughter of california..anf I hate what is happening in this state, as well as this country..i say STOP trying to change it..try implementing REAL REFORM.. and stop the government from running our lives..when we should be running the government…by the people , for the people…stop it Obama!
you have lied during your speaches…those of us out here who listens, knows what you said before, you cant say something different and not get noticed…where are your campayne promises? stop the socialist activities, or you WILL be a 1 term president…i just hope to god that this is not something that cannot be un-done!
you scare me Obama…and I dont like the feeling..
Posted by: Donna Guaraglia | August 6, 2009, 10:03 pm 10:03 pm
Americans are having a chance to do what most of congress including our great leader have not- read the bills. We do not like what we are seeing. Heaven help any seniors under Obama Healthcare!
Most of us are able to balance our household expenses. If your checkbook is low, the last thing you want to do is take on more bills and go on a spending spree. This is what our great leader suggests.
Asking folks to report “fishy” opposition to our great leaders healthcare is imoral, illegal and definately unethical. No matter how they try to smooth this over, this is an attempt to frighten people away from free speech. This will not happen. Most mainstream media is not even reporting this. It is no wonder they have lost their credibiliy.
As for the so called “mobs”, unlike the community organizers like ACORN and SEIU, the American people don’t need to be organized by anyone. We instictively know when our rights are being trampled on and respond with passion and integrity. The beauty is that we did not learn to Community organize from our great Leader, we are patriots who have been organizing for freedom long before the socialist have tried to hijack America.
Posted by: rosale | August 6, 2009, 10:55 pm 10:55 pm
From April through July companies like Highmark, who manage individual Insurance companies, sent out memos to their employees. They informed their employees in those memos that they should protest the Medical Health Insurance Reform. They were encourage to sign up for protests. gee, imagine that. The Insurance companies are the ones protesting the Medical Health insurance Reform. Imagine that.
Posted by: Angie | August 7, 2009, 5:13 pm 5:13 pm
I guess Highmark and other corporations who manage the insurance companies are scared. Maybe if their lowered their insurance rates there would be no need for reform. But since when has any corporation ever did anything from the kindness of their heart, or just because it was the right thing to do?
The answer to that is NEVER!
Posted by: Angie | August 7, 2009, 5:25 pm 5:25 pm
Angie, are all people who send out memos advocating for the way they want things bad? Because then I could call Obama and the Dems bad for sending out memos to “hit back twice as hard” against people showing up at town hall meeting protesting ObamaCare.
Of course, Highmark and other insurance companies are scared. They have every reason to be. ObamaCare is trying to put them out of business. And every employee of every insurance company should be scared, too. Because when the company goes out of business they will lose their jobs.
Posted by: Don | August 7, 2009, 9:13 pm 9:13 pm
How can a poll speak for millions The only way to know is to have a vote on it
Posted by: Steve | August 8, 2009, 12:28 am 12:28 am
I am very disappointed in Washington. I teach civics to 7th and 8th graders. Our freedom and responsibility as Americans is in flux. It is difficult to know how to present the actions of the Senate and House of Representatives to my students. Voting for things without reading them! Cramming things through to vote before LISTENING to “WE THE PEOPLE.” The Healthcare bill should be the WAKEUP CALL to all Americans. SLAM ON THE BRAKES!!!! WE THE PEOPLE are suppose to make our values and expectations known to our leaders. They are suppose to be the MEGAPHONE for the PEOPLE. The legislative branch is to serve the PEOPLE. I don’t call for violence — I call for standing up and sharing honestly, getting out and voting, working in each community AS A COMMUNITY. The politicians have kidnapped our voice and our choice! WE THE PEOPLE MUST TAKE IT BACK!!!!!!
Posted by: VICKI | August 8, 2009, 1:49 am 1:49 am
Folks at my townhall were certainly not from any insurance company. They were my neighbors and residents of my town. They had questions, as they should. The most worrysome thing about Obamas healthcare is WHO is actually helping to put it together. SEIU, a deceitful organization who attacked a protestor at a meeting (which Obama has responsibility for sending), or how about his great policy advisor Emmanuel and his “complete Lives System”. I made sure everyone in my area know exactly what it is and how it could be implimented under socialized medicine. The argument that this is not a power grab for single payer is not realistic. We have actually LISTENED to Obamas own words to know that is not the case. Obama can send as many thugs as he wishes. like those who stood outside of voting areas trying to threaten people into voting for him. This type of behavior is definately a “leftist” activity. I know. I AM a democrat.
The American people are NOT intimidated and WILL vote those people out who would support a plan that would further our debt and put people on a scale for rationed care. 2010 is coming up fast with 2012 just around the corner.
Posted by: jack | August 8, 2009, 10:34 am 10:34 am
I’m willing to bet that all the people ranting against health care reform are those who have adequate coverage. How would they feel if they were faced with cancer and no coverage.
All this panic – fueled by idiotic comments such as those made by Sarah Palin – over end of life issues needs to stop. You are going to die. Don’t you want to do it your way.
Posted by: Karen | August 10, 2009, 8:05 am 8:05 am