Death Panels and the Politics of Death
Mike Huckabee tossed a hand grenade into the debate over who's politicizing Ted Kennedy's death Thursday morning when he told his radio audience that under Obamacare, Kennedy would be told to "go home to take pain pills and die."
Which Democrat will toss it back first?
Will any Republicans jump on it by challenging Huckabee head-on?
One thing's for sure: by joining the debate in this time in this way, Huckabee is showing how determined he is not to be outmaneuvered by Sarah Palin in the early 2012 bidding for the GOP's conservative base
How will Mitt Romney respond?
-George Stephanopoulos
Email
Rick Santorum Encircled in Prayer
Boehner Slams Obama on Contraception Controversy
No he would not have. kennedy would not have had the same health care as the plebes. he would have kept his enhanced health care and would have had any posiible treatment he so desired.
Posted by: Karen | August 28, 2009, 6:41 pm 6:41 pm
Huckabee is correct, George.
Posted by: Joe C Beck | August 28, 2009, 6:43 pm 6:43 pm
The point of the comment was that if Kennedy had to deal with the garbage being forced upon the country he would not have been worth treating. Palin/Huckabee 2012!
Posted by: Lon | August 28, 2009, 6:47 pm 6:47 pm
Huckabee is completely correct and anyone who reads the bill can see that if they read it with a open mind. But as we all know ABC will never say or do anything that might make Obama look bad.
Good luck to America we will need it over the next couple of years.
Posted by: Robert | August 28, 2009, 6:48 pm 6:48 pm
I agree with Joe Beck. Huckabee is correct. Rather than wonder which Democrat will toss it back first, why not refute Huckabee’s statement with evidence from the bill. Because it is not there. If I was a senior citizen right now, I’d be scared to death. Huh?….Oh…excuse me I’d be scared to “end of life”!!!
Posted by: Pete Rieck | August 28, 2009, 6:48 pm 6:48 pm
Kenedy has never had to follow the same rules as the rest of us. Under Obama care he would still be one of the privaleged. Look at Mas considering changing the law again, talk about a flip flop. If there is a Repub in the governors seat we want it one way, opps, now there is a Dem in so we want it the othyer way, but stay tuned.
I agree that our health care could use a tune up but along with it has to go tort reform.
I am on medicare and I HAVE to have medicare. There is no longer any insurance company that will give anyone over 65 medical insurance. They have all been driven out of the market. Yes I can get medicare suplimental but I am stuck with medicare as my primary.
Do the rest of you want that all through life?
Anyway, to stay on topic, Huckabe is correct in that someone else, in Kenidys position would have had to take pain pills and go home and die.
Posted by: Dan in CA | August 28, 2009, 6:48 pm 6:48 pm
He sure didn’t rush off to Canada or the UK for superior treatment.
Posted by: George | August 28, 2009, 6:51 pm 6:51 pm
kennedy was a member of the ruling elite. they dont have to follow the rules they make for us. we should be happy to be ruled by people so wise.
Posted by: gregg | August 28, 2009, 6:53 pm 6:53 pm
George, do you sit up all night making crap like this up from your White House office, or do you use the stall next to Obama and hold hands, and combine both your half-wit brain powers…how sweet!!!!
get a life and start reporting objectively…..
Posted by: john | August 28, 2009, 6:53 pm 6:53 pm
How many Democrats “Challenged” Nancy Pelosi “Head-on” when she called Jane and Joe American conservative “manufactured” AstroTurf, and accused them of being Nazi’s? How wonderful it must be George to view the world in your Democrat tinted spectacles while pretending to be an objective “Journalist”.
Posted by: Harry | August 28, 2009, 6:53 pm 6:53 pm
Without Obamacare, as a 62-year-old retired teacher and former breast cancer patient who is currently uninsurable, I will not have pain medication if my cancer returns. My current income puts me slightly above the current cut-off for public funding, but I cannot afford my state’s “high risk” insurance since the economic downturn. Frankly, pain meds and go home to die sounds good, compared to no pain meds and go home to die. I have had my life; the limited money for public healthcare should support children and young families. Many of my age cohorts are of the same mind. But please, some end-of-life compassion for pain. Death is not the enemy; fear of death should not drive public decisions. Relief of pain is an appropriate goal for end-of-life decisions.
Posted by: willetta thomson | August 28, 2009, 6:54 pm 6:54 pm
The liberals will never impose on themselves the same crappy care they plan for us. As for Teddy, he could have paid for his care himself, but instead he billed us for it!
Posted by: Dennis | August 28, 2009, 6:56 pm 6:56 pm
Would Kennedy have access to the top brain surgeon in the country if he wasn’t wealthy and powerful? No. If was just your average 76 year old and there was only a public option I don’t think he’d cut in line in front of younger and healthier people.
Under a government plan there will be no incentive to keep hold people alive. Because they want to ration health care for the masses.
Posted by: James | August 28, 2009, 6:58 pm 6:58 pm
Isn’t it strange how so many right wing self-proclaimed Christians are such bald-faced liars?
Posted by: Don Williams | August 28, 2009, 7:00 pm 7:00 pm
Not only does Mike Hucekberry look like Gomer Pyle, but he thinks like him.
Posted by: Willy | August 28, 2009, 7:02 pm 7:02 pm
“No he would not have. kennedy would not have had the same health care as the plebes. he would have kept his enhanced health care and would have had any posiible treatment he so desired.”
Karen | Aug 28, 2009 6:41:36 PM
Just like the rich anywhere in the world. What’s your point?
Posted by: jhw539 | August 28, 2009, 7:02 pm 7:02 pm
Worst. Radical Leftist. President. Ever.
And if you disagree with him you get called a “racist”.
May our country survive these four long years…
Posted by: Randal | August 28, 2009, 7:03 pm 7:03 pm
Your baiting Mitt Romney. He doesn’t have to respond. No one does.
Posted by: Kent L Curtis | August 28, 2009, 7:04 pm 7:04 pm
George, you are not in the White House anymore, you are a journalist now. Stop talking like a Democratic pundit, it is embarrassing ABC News, and obviously killing their ratings.
Posted by: Realist | August 28, 2009, 7:05 pm 7:05 pm
It’s kinda strange to see Republicans making up lies about “Obamacare”. In the past 8 years that they had a Republican in the WHite House — and controlled Congress from 1995 to 2006 — they let 45 million American citizens go without healthcare. THEIR Healthcare policy was to steal $3 TRILLION out of our Medicare Trust Fund and gave it to the richest 2 percent of the population.
Posted by: Don Williams | August 28, 2009, 7:07 pm 7:07 pm
“Under a government plan there will be no incentive to keep old people alive. Because they want to ration health care for the masses.”
James | Aug 28, 2009 6:58:39 PM
AMERICAN OLD PEOPLE CURRENTLY RECEIVE GOVERNMENT HEALTH CARE RIGHT VIA A PUBLIC INSURANCE OPTION RIGHT NOW. Read that again. Think!
The current public option proposal is to create a government run insurance option and make it open to the public at their option. It is not to open up the fully “socialist” Medicare program to the masses.
Posted by: jhw539 | August 28, 2009, 7:08 pm 7:08 pm
Wow, talk about lifting something wildly out of context. Did you even hear the same commmentary I did?
Huckabee merely pointed out that Kennedy gave us a perfect example of why seniors’ lives are not worth less than young people’s; that even at 77, he was fighting for something he believed in, so he considered every minute precious and was willing to take heroic measures to live every extra day rather than just take a pain pill and go home to die. He said any health care bill should recognize that and give all Americans the same choice that Senators enjoy. He was actually being respectful to the recently departed while promoting the idea that everyone deserves the best health care. What part of that do you disagree with, George?
Posted by: Pat | August 28, 2009, 7:17 pm 7:17 pm
Oh no, Mr. Huckabee, Ted Kennedy would have the best his money could buy for his healthcare..Only the little folk would suffer under Obamacare..The elite would suffer not.
Posted by: MJ | August 28, 2009, 7:21 pm 7:21 pm
My memory fails me….who was the first Democrat to come out and challenge Ted Kennedy when he whipped Bork into bowing out of a Supreme Court nomination with his, (Teds),ridiculous and racist assertions?
Posted by: Fred | August 28, 2009, 7:22 pm 7:22 pm
Don!!! Talk about lies!!! I have never read so many lies in so few words in my life!!!
Posted by: Bruce | August 28, 2009, 7:23 pm 7:23 pm
George, reading the comments here, it seems you are unfamiliar with your own blog readers. most of us agree that under obamacare $100k+ surgery-care for a 76 year-old-man would probably NOT be approved. And it would seem that under that rubric rich Kennedy’s would not be able to purchase this care for their dear lion, either.
Posted by: kelli | August 28, 2009, 7:26 pm 7:26 pm
Shame on Republicans for trying to use Kennedy’s death in their LIES on health care reform.
Posted by: Sandy | August 28, 2009, 7:28 pm 7:28 pm
Don, Don, Don. First of all, there’s a difference between being uninsured and not having health care. Learn this, and you’ll be better off.
Secondly, you’d be shocked to learn that the top 1% of EARNERS pay 39% of all federal income tax, the top 25% pay 86% of all income tax, and the top 50% pay 97% of all income tax. You need to accept that those that EARN more money than you also pay much more than you do.
Finally, those above figures come directly from the IRS. Your two figures come from….where?
Posted by: Bob | August 28, 2009, 7:30 pm 7:30 pm
Agreed w/ MJ – Kennedy would still have recieved first rate care as a Senator, it is simply the rest of us who would be judged too old to be worth the treatment.
Posted by: MB | August 28, 2009, 7:31 pm 7:31 pm
How do you know that Mr. Kennedy didn’t do exactly that? Take pain pills and go home to die?
Posted by: Linda | August 28, 2009, 7:36 pm 7:36 pm
I see a couple of Obama’s staffers found the time to post a comment trying to insult Huckabee or suggest that everybody who opposes Obama is part of a Republican conspiracy- even a mild attempt to defend Obama’s policies just sounds silly these days. George’s blog entry is so wildly out of touch with reality that there is no point of reference to begin debating it- maybe he should lobby for government run career insurance…
Posted by: Frank | August 28, 2009, 7:39 pm 7:39 pm
It is called, being sent to pasture, and yes it happens in the UK and will happen here.
Posted by: CV | August 28, 2009, 7:39 pm 7:39 pm
wiletta thompson:
I wish you the best – you’re 62 and have alot of life ahead of you! your life is valuable until He decides to call you home. keep on truckin, honey!
Posted by: sue | August 28, 2009, 7:48 pm 7:48 pm
Gee George, What’s going to happen to “your” healthcare coverage?
Posted by: 86ahb | August 28, 2009, 7:50 pm 7:50 pm
Under Obamacare, America won’t even have good enough health care to meet the standards of the self-appointed “elite.” Currently, America is the place where OTHER foreign leaders come for world-class medical treatment; under Obamacare, OUR “leaders” will be going abroad for world-class medical treatment.
Posted by: Joe | August 28, 2009, 7:54 pm 7:54 pm
The fact of the matter is, people who think they know what’s best for us, never, ever consider taking what they are dishing out to the rest of us. Kennedy would never have subjected himself to universal health care. He would be sitting in the emergency room, still as a doorpost.
Posted by: BB | August 28, 2009, 8:01 pm 8:01 pm
“Frankly, pain meds and go home to die sounds good”
What an apt and concise summary of government-run ObamaCare. Especially since that is Dr. Obama’s exact stated position for those who need pacemakers.
I expect he’ll be contacting you any day now for permission to use your “just go away and die, you over-50s and disabled” endorsement in an ad! Stay by your phone!!
Posted by: Karen Schell | August 28, 2009, 8:06 pm 8:06 pm
It is an unfortunate and unintended consequence of the First Amendment that people, including Mike Huckabee, can just straight out lie with impunity. The shameless Republican Right knows that if you tell the lie enough times and say it loud enough, many gullible fools will believe it.
Posted by: Dick | August 28, 2009, 8:08 pm 8:08 pm
If so many people want government health care, why don’t they emigrate to Canada or England?
Posted by: BB | August 28, 2009, 8:08 pm 8:08 pm
After 50 years of the Great Society, dozens of opportunities by liberal congress, liberal presidents and both, THE POOR KEEP GETTING POORER. If you had a score card you would say, “The liberal game was over decades ago” But if you want to support a failed system and get poorer every year, go for it.
Posted by: Pappy | August 28, 2009, 8:13 pm 8:13 pm
…crickets chirping…
Posted by: BB | August 28, 2009, 8:19 pm 8:19 pm
Cuba. That’s where it at.
Posted by: snake | August 28, 2009, 8:21 pm 8:21 pm
Sorry Mr.Huckabee,
I meant to give you the thumbs up, your right on the mark and thanks for telling the sheep all about it. Let’s hope they will stop following the scap goat before the slaughter history always warns us about,
Russia,
China,
S.Africa,
Cuba,
South of The Boarder,
death seems to be the way of the dictators, count the cost for those governments aboved mentioned, is this our new America? No not quit, no not yet and no not today ….right Americans? That is a very easy question.
Sincerly
TIMERUNNER
Posted by: TIMERUNNER | August 28, 2009, 8:23 pm 8:23 pm
Hey, Clinton Boy–call it a “hand grenade” if you like, but Huckabee got it right, and the vast majority of Americans will agree with him, immediately and innately.
Posted by: Kevin Stafford | August 28, 2009, 8:27 pm 8:27 pm
He is right George. No wonder FOX is number one. He is already dead under this BILL of Odummy care. If he was regular citizen not a politician. they have theres we have ours
NBC id doomed who would be next CBS then ABC
Posted by: Bill | August 28, 2009, 8:33 pm 8:33 pm
It’s over for the socialists before they even had a chance. Even with ABC’s obsequious behavior to the socialists. We are a country based on freedom and liberty and personal responsibility. Thank God for Obama and Obamacare, it will seal Republican victory for at least another generation. See you socialists in 2010! I suppose ABC will try to pander to the Republicans in power, but we have long memories
Posted by: dude | August 28, 2009, 8:35 pm 8:35 pm
Well, that’s strange. He was going to die anyway. So….. Dying at home while being made as comfortable as possible is bad because? Why have we become such a nation of sensationalist imbeciles? When did things slide into such a sad state of affairs? Wake up people. Turn off the complacency box and think!!!
Posted by: Buck Cherrie | August 28, 2009, 8:36 pm 8:36 pm
It would be true except that he is under the Federal plan which is EXEMPT from Obamacare. Yep. Civil servants an federal ELECTED OFFICIALS KEEP THEIR PRIVATE INSURANCE. FYI – HR3200 mandates that companies pay 72 percent of employees premiums. The feds only pay 50 percent AND have fantastic rates due to the huge pool. Now if the gov’t wanted to make the same plans and rates they have to small businesses, that would be progress.
Posted by: 9trillionreasons | August 28, 2009, 8:37 pm 8:37 pm
How do you know that Mr. Kennedy didn’t do exactly that? Take pain pills and go home to die?
Posted by: Linda | Aug 28, 2009 7:36:17 PM
Ahhh, because it was widely reported that Sen. Kennedy underwent surgery to remove lesions in his brain shortly after his diagnosis, then underwent chemotherapy…
Under the national health services such as in Canada or the UK, a 76-year old with that diagnosis would likely have been put on waiting lists and gotten treatments in 8 months to a year. Unless of course, they “knew somebody” or had “connections” that could get them bumped up on the list. Common people would have to go home and wait and see their conditions deteriorate. No, it’s not death panels you have to fear, but bureaucratic paper-pushers, mid-level flunkies and post office type unfireable government employees-for-life who will be running the “public option”.
Posted by: H Sandy | August 28, 2009, 8:42 pm 8:42 pm
George, I do not agree with you but appreciate that you have the courage to make your statement and allow such an overwhelming number of opposing views to post. It is hard not to like a man with guts.
Posted by: Richard | August 28, 2009, 8:51 pm 8:51 pm
Karen:
Do you even have a clue as to what you read? It is understood that Kennedy ins’t included in the health care debacle that is designed for “the rest of us” and not for the elitists. The author is merely pointing that difference out.
Posted by: 1GregM | August 28, 2009, 8:53 pm 8:53 pm
I’m no fan of ObamaCare, not at all. Nor was I much of a fan of the late Senator. And Mr. Huckabee may have a point, or maybe not.
Regardless, politicizing the recent death of Senator Kennedy is no less disgusting when a Republican does it than when the Democrats do it. Shame on you, Mr. Huckabee.
Posted by: Ron Moses | August 28, 2009, 8:55 pm 8:55 pm
How is that any different than now? Ever hear of hospice? That is the gold standard for dying cancer patients. My father died from cancer, there isn’t anything else you can do with a terminal disease. Keep them alive longer to suffer longer? No one is exempt from death when it comes.
Posted by: Susan | August 28, 2009, 8:57 pm 8:57 pm
How is that any different than now? Ever hear of hospice? That is the gold standard for dying cancer patients. My father died from cancer, there isn’t anything else you can do with a terminal disease. Keep them alive longer to suffer longer? No one is exempt from death when it comes.
Posted by: Susan | August 28, 2009, 8:57 pm 8:57 pm
George,
It was President Obama who told a citizen that instead of the surgery to extend her life grandma could take pain pills instead. Facts are stubborn things!
Posted by: Greg | August 28, 2009, 8:58 pm 8:58 pm
So…What do think Teddy is doing in hell right now?
Posted by: Mike | August 28, 2009, 9:00 pm 9:00 pm
Just one more reason Jake Tapper should take over This Week.
Posted by: Dave | August 28, 2009, 9:01 pm 9:01 pm
Uncle Teddy had the best health care available while plotting to put the average citizen in a pinch when he/her got sick. Instead of listing keft wing achievements list the things he was against. Here’s a start;
M1 battle tank
F15 fighter
F16 fighter
Stealth technology
A 10 aircraft
B 1 bomber
He had the blood of millions on his hands because of the Cambodian killing fields after the Vietnam war.
Posted by: Rick O'Shea | August 28, 2009, 9:03 pm 9:03 pm
Isn’t that what it did anyway, with it’s SPECIAL government payed for PRIVATE heath care it had?
Posted by: WhoCaresFU | August 28, 2009, 9:05 pm 9:05 pm
The problem with Obamacare is that it is not laser-focused to fix the real problems and leave things that are not problems alone. Fix these:
* tort reform – make it so no one gets a windfall. A doctor found guilty pays the full penalty, but at a certain point the proceeds go into a state’s general fund. The lawyers get fair compensation, but no more than that. Any excess goes toward improving state-wide health care. You end the motive for frivolous lawsuits; doctors rest easier; and bad doctors still get penalized. I don’t see a downside to this.
* a safety net just for those who can’t be helped by private insurance. Not something competitive with private insurance; a “when all else fails” safety net.
* Relief of pain is should be a primary goal of any health care reform.
* A focus on NOT SPENDING the taxpayer’s money unless there is no alternative should be the polestar. Not “let’s soak the rich and do whatever the hell we want.”
* A law that says that if a politician meets or beats his or her cost estimate accurately s/he gets a $50,000 tax-free bonus; If s/he gets it underestimates it, s/he pays $50,000.
* An end to any preferential treatment of lawmakers or government workers. Everyone is on the same system – period. Any violation by a government employee results in a loss of health care insurance for a 5 years.
I bet lots of folks would get behind something like this.
Posted by: harryshell | August 28, 2009, 9:10 pm 9:10 pm
To those who believe Huckabee: what evidence do you have that the government would ever tell someone terminally ill to take pain pills and just die? There already is a government, public health plan that covers millions: it’s called Medicare and it’s existed for decades. How many of you have friends or relatives with Medicare calling you to say, “the government is trying to kill me?” The Obama administration is just proposing to extend public coverage to a larger segment of the population. Public coverage (i.e. Medicare) is neither radical nor new.
Posted by: Steve Rames | August 28, 2009, 9:11 pm 9:11 pm
As long as Palin is the nominee, I will be a happy liberal.
Posted by: samir2 | August 28, 2009, 9:13 pm 9:13 pm
Can George be anymore of a political over-thinker? Democrats are trying to use the corpse before its even cold to advance their own cause. Huckabee says what many of us are already thinking and somehow it’s “too soon” and “bad taste”. You know what this is? This is Stephanopoulos the Zebra who is unable to change his stripes. He’s not reporting or editorializing, he’s still just spinning for the libs. Using another rule out of that Alinsky / Clinton playbook. Its okay for libs to exploit Kennedy’s death but if a Conservative responds then its the Conservative who is the villain. The rules are so one-sided in all of these games liberals play. George, you need to legitimize yourself and get some credibility.
Posted by: James | August 28, 2009, 9:19 pm 9:19 pm
Taking pills would have been same outcome but 250k less money.
Posted by: Steve D | August 28, 2009, 9:21 pm 9:21 pm
Wiletta, I don’t know where you get your information. Go on Hospice website. “Hospices also care for people who don’t have insurance and can’t afford to pay for the services.” Hospice care includes pain meds and nurses. You will be taken care of if your cancer returns and you want to go home and die which will be part of Obamacare for everyone. Except politicians. They’re special.
Posted by: Monni | August 28, 2009, 9:24 pm 9:24 pm
George, Mitt Romney can’t comment. See RomneyCare, it’s essentially the same program Obama is proposing.
Posted by: Josh Leguern | August 28, 2009, 9:24 pm 9:24 pm
When I turned 65, I had to take Medicare (part A) even though I told them I didn’t want it. They told me I had no choice and I have a Medicare card but thankfully my husband still works and we can keep his insurance as primary provider. There are many doctors in Atlanta who are opting out of Medicare for seniors because of the pitiful payments they receive right now for the elderly. When Obama robs Medcare of 560 billion dollars there probably won’t be any healthcare for seniors. Maybe some of you don’t have anything to live for but I have a 26 year old son who hasn’t married yet and five beautiful grandchildren who need a grandmother from my other three children.
Posted by: Fran | August 28, 2009, 9:25 pm 9:25 pm
George I salute you as a brave man willing to defend a minority viewpoint. However I am so elated than even on ABC the All Barack Channel that the overwhelming responses are that Huckabee is correct. Obama would even have felt hip surgery for someone with cancer could be considered wasteful. He said so himself about his own family member. We will return conservative rule for a couple of generations if even in the enemy camp of ABC there are more supporters of Huckabee than opponents. I can’t wait for 2010. It will make the Clinton backlash look small in comparison. Long live liberty and freedom and personal responsibility.
Posted by: Dude | August 28, 2009, 9:28 pm 9:28 pm
I’m in the medical field and under obamacare I will f obama. How??? I will retire and just walk away and I will never serve one of his supporters ever again. And without any income, I will never pay federal income taxes again.
Posted by: jeff spence the fifth | August 28, 2009, 9:29 pm 9:29 pm
Tossed a hand grenade? The hand grenade was tossed when the radicals in congress and the Obama administration inserted themselves into the private conversation between patients and their doctors.
Posted by: Dave | August 28, 2009, 9:31 pm 9:31 pm
What is really sad about this is with all the “you are all racists if you are against Obama” talk from the governor of New York and now representative Watson, that Obama who was supposed to heal the racial divide, and probably wants to do so, will have presided over the worst racial schism since the l960′s. All this race baiting from African Americans is actually encouraging more antipathy to blacks. It is the classic example of making something a self fulfilling prophecy. I am sad to see it, but at least some good will come out of it. Republican rule for a couple of decades. Obama better hope a lot of supreme court justices die real soon. He won’t be relected. He has out Jimmied Jimmy Carter, and it took Carter almost 4 years to lose his second term. Obama has lost his second term in the first 100 days.
Posted by: Dude | August 28, 2009, 9:32 pm 9:32 pm
Huckabee is right! GO HUCK!!! Boo CORRUPT LIBERALS!!!!! We’re sick to death of your LIES!!!!!!
Posted by: Jill | August 28, 2009, 9:32 pm 9:32 pm
DAN IN LA
In 1965, the private sector wouldn’t insure anyone over 55. That’s the reason Congress enacted Medicare.
Posted by: ehevans | August 28, 2009, 9:36 pm 9:36 pm
Huckabee is making a very lame attempt to score political points out of Kennedy’s illness and death. Classy guy.
Posted by: Tom | August 28, 2009, 9:36 pm 9:36 pm
Medicare did that to my dad when he passed on… this is their only solution. Dollars and cents are what count, human life does not
Posted by: BillCrates | August 28, 2009, 9:43 pm 9:43 pm
It’s astounding how ignorant people are. Fueled with love of God and hate for anyone who disagrees with them. Never heard ‘don’t speak ill of the dead?’ Nothing in the proposed legislation would hurt any of us but it will help many. Turn off Fox and start reading (if you can) and get some real education. Huckabee is no Christian. He should beg for God’s forgiveness for the horrible words he spoke yesterday in order to give himself some potential political boost.
Posted by: Linda | August 28, 2009, 9:50 pm 9:50 pm
A more accurate statement would be, “If Kennedy resided in Canada or the UK he would have been sent home with painkiller in his pocket and advice on how to tough it out till the end comes.”
Posted by: Susan | August 28, 2009, 9:50 pm 9:50 pm
“Realist spews|– they let 45 million American citizens go without healthcare.”
Here we go with more lib lies used to smear Republicans. “45 million American citizens”? Repeated from Obama to the lowliest drones. But according to the U.S. Census Bureau (before it was taken over by Obama), the 45 million includes more than 10 million illegal aliens. Who are not “American citizens.” The actual number is estimated to be 8 to 14 million poor who do not have health care insurance. And none of them go without “healthcare.” Laws require hospitals to treat everyone, regardless whether they can pay. The big issue is “insurance.” Not “healthcare.” Realist my a$$.
Posted by: Real Realist | August 28, 2009, 9:51 pm 9:51 pm
Actually, I think Karen has it right. The political elite would not have to abide by any rules or policies established by Obamacare. Until they accept the same treatment as their constituents, this is not an American health plan.
Posted by: commonsense247 | August 28, 2009, 9:51 pm 9:51 pm
Kennedy died because he had brain cancer. Not because he did not have the right insurance But at some point there is just nothing more the Dr’s can do. So like anyone else he is told to go home and sign up for hospice. Just in case you have not had to deal with hospice they are there for pain managment. Till it is your time to go. And at some point we all have to go. That is how it has aways been. This has nothing to do with Obama as far as I can tell.
Posted by: Bonnie | August 28, 2009, 9:51 pm 9:51 pm
Huckabee’s timing is a bit off, but truth is truth.
Posted by: MaryS | August 28, 2009, 9:52 pm 9:52 pm
Willette, your situation is sad, however, to give upup on your life doesn’t mean others should be forced to also via the government. As far as pain pills not being given to you for cancer is perposterous on the surface. If insurance won’t cover it there are other outlets such as the drug companies. Haven’t you seen the Montel Williams commercial about handing out free prescriptions to people in need?
Posted by: Kris Rigby | August 28, 2009, 9:54 pm 9:54 pm
Americas finest is at it again! Clueless and paranoid!
Posted by: ChrisB | August 28, 2009, 10:05 pm 10:05 pm
Huckabee is right on. I just think it’s ironic that the Dems want to rename a health care bill after a man who didn’t even have the decency to call an ambulance for a woman he drove off a bridge.
Posted by: J.O'Toole | August 28, 2009, 10:07 pm 10:07 pm
Why is this man being laid to rest in Arlington Cemetary?? I know the Kennedy’s could afford that plot still for sale in the tidal channel in Chappaquiddick. Shouldn’t he be resting in hell there???? Sorry I was from Massachuesettes and I hated the Kennedy’s from the time my mother never thought about aborting me till I left to the military at the age of 18. (Under the best President ever to run this country. Ronald Reagan)
Posted by: Brian K | August 28, 2009, 10:08 pm 10:08 pm
I think they should rename the health care bill to Kennedy-Kopechne. Then point out how Kennedy acted like a death panel of one.
Posted by: Jim | August 28, 2009, 10:12 pm 10:12 pm
We should all read the bills, then discuss this issue intelligently with informed opinions. Especially the legislators and the media.
There is a man by the name of Peter Fleckstein who is reading HR3200 and has been posting on Twitter his findings. This is from his postings:
Pg 16: SEC. 102. PROTECTING THE CHOICE TO KEEP CURRENT COVERAGE. lines 3-26 of the HC Bill – OUTLAWS PRIVATE INSURANCE by forbidding enrollment after HR 3022 is passed into law.
Pg 21-22: SEC. 113. INSURANCE RATING RULES of the HC Bill MANDATES the Government will audit books of ALL EMPLOYERS that self insure!!
Pg 29: SEC. 122. ESSENTIAL BENEFITS PACKAGE DEFINED: lines 4-16 in the HC bill – YOUR HEALTHCARE IS RATIONED!!!
Pg 30: SEC. 123. HEALTH BENEFITS ADVISORY COMMITTEE of HC bill – THERE WILL BE A GOVERNMENT COMMITTEE that decides what treatments/benefits you get.
Pg 42: SEC. 142. DUTIES AND AUTHORITY OF COMMISSIONER of HC Bill – The Health Choices Commissioner will choose your HC Benefits for you. You have no choice!
PG 50-51: SEC. 152. PROHIBITING DISCRIMINATION IN HEALTH CARE in HC bill – HC will be provided to ALL non US citizens, ILLEGAL or otherwise.
Pg 58: SEC. 163. ADMINISTRATIVE SIMPLIFICATION HC Bill – Government will have real-time access to individual’s finances and a National ID Healthcard will be issued!
Pg 59: SEC. 163. ADMINISTRATIVE SIMPLIFICATIONHC Bill lines 21-24 Government will have DIRECT access to your BANK ACCOUNTS for electronic funds transfer. This means the government can go in and take your money right out of your bank account….
Posted by: Mike | August 28, 2009, 10:15 pm 10:15 pm
I feel the media is missing the story and that Huckabee didn’t “throw a grenade.” He is calling for the story that I can’t write but want to see. I believe there should be a front page NYT piece outlining every moment of Sen T Kennedy’s treatment from diagnosis to death. Who did he see? Public or private? How many opinions? What tests? What drugs? What type of surgery? What were his wait times? This is at the very heart of the debate. Full disclosure bc the care what Ted personally had is that in which he really believed.
Posted by: gorilla | August 28, 2009, 10:16 pm 10:16 pm
This posting goes out to Harry. Harry, do you believe we should re-write the system for less than .001 percent of the population. You are an exception to the general rule. We have an excellent heathcare system. I do believe that an insurance credit would help you my friend. It would be a Republican plan that includes that. VOTE REPUBLICAN in 2010, and maybe they can help you out.
Posted by: OMG Are You Kidding Me | August 28, 2009, 10:18 pm 10:18 pm
George as a pretend journalist you should pretend to be unbiased, which might mean refraining from passing judgement on things people say by referring to them as “hand grenades.” One man’s hand grenade is another man’s truth. Simply say: he said X and leave it at that.
Posted by: Bob | August 28, 2009, 10:23 pm 10:23 pm
Governor Huckabee’s statement is so true. Under Obamacare, Kennedy would not have been a priority. Obamacare will result in rationed health care for all American’s. Look at England and Canada, they have to wait for treatment. Socialized medicine does not work in other countries, why on earth would we think it would work here.
Huckabee for President 2012!
Posted by: L | August 28, 2009, 10:25 pm 10:25 pm
George,this Health Care Plan is similar to the add, where a child is playing wth a very nice car . All of a sudden, the salesman snatched it from him, an in returned gave him a pathetic piece of an imprint cardboard car. The awestruck child said,”But this is a piece of Junk”… Please is allright to help the poor an the uninsured, but the rest of it, live it alone, until this Administration have an idea of what they are doing..
Posted by: Let's Sanity Prevail | August 28, 2009, 10:25 pm 10:25 pm
You go Mike! You are the only politician that ever speaks the truth. Please run for President in 2012. Our weary nation needs your common sense and values!
Posted by: jill | August 28, 2009, 10:26 pm 10:26 pm
Obama’s own words, “At least we can let doctors know — and your mom know — that you know what, maybe this isn’t going to help. Maybe you’re better off, uhh, not having the surgery, but, uhh, taking the painkiller.”
His own words. Save money — take a pill. You’re old, you’re going to die soon anyway.
So, where are the lies all of you libs keep saying the Republicans are spreading? That was your messiah’s own words.
Posted by: I_Dislike_All_Politicians | August 28, 2009, 10:27 pm 10:27 pm
It is interesting that the Congress and Senate and White House will not sign up for the government run health care. That pretty much settles it for me.
Really though, my main concern is that we are 11.8 Trillion in debt and should be bankrupt. Adding another couple of trillion for government run health care is irresponsible.
In the short term I think we should provide assistance for those that need help and look for a longer term solution after we know how to reduce the deficit.
Posted by: Bulldog | August 28, 2009, 10:27 pm 10:27 pm
do you fools even understand what the “public option” means?? it’s an insurance plan, that’s it. it’s not managed care provided by the govt. it’s an insurance plan. it would pay money to doctors and pool risk across lots of people. the doctors and treatment wouldn’t change at all. somehow this got twisted into being govt provided health care. it is not. stop spreading lies. public option is for INSURANCE. not health care. so what huckabee said, aside from being completely asinine, is just dead wrong. of course the facts never bother talking windbags like him and palin and steele and the rest of the republicans. wake up america, you are getting shafted by the insurance companies and you’re too dumb to realize it.
Posted by: Dr. Spock | August 28, 2009, 10:27 pm 10:27 pm
Can’t you people see that the America we love is being changed forever. Supreme leader Obama is slowly implementing elements of communism into the government. One day we are going to wake up and realize that the land of the free and the home of the brave – no longer exists.
Posted by: fd | August 28, 2009, 10:30 pm 10:30 pm
Huckabee is a moron.
Posted by: John | August 28, 2009, 10:30 pm 10:30 pm
I am overwhelmed by the childish and thoughtless comments that are left here. To comment in the negative, in an intelligent and well-formed way, is fine. But to use this as a forum to spout nonsense and lies is simply not productive.
Whether you agreed with the Senator’s politics or not, there were many who loved him and are mourning his loss – from both sides of the aisle. And anyone spouting a “good riddance” sentiment is not only a bad “Christian”, but a miserable human being.
If any of you received a student loan, meals on wheels, benefited from the civil rights bill, was a woman who played sports in school or receive and appreciate Medicaid, you have the Senator from the great state of Massachusetts to thank for it.
If you feel so negatively about Kennedy, perhaps you should return any benefits you reaped from him working tirelessly on your behalf.
As for American health care being the best, that’s laughable. We rate 37th in the world, after Costa Rica and before Slovenia. That’s definitely not something to be proud of.
Posted by: B | August 28, 2009, 10:31 pm 10:31 pm
What happens when You do not opt for the Gov’t care… but, because it is cheaper, your company that you work for, decides that this is the option they will go with, You are now Stuck with it??? HMMMMMM??? I do not like being stuck with something.
Posted by: jane | August 28, 2009, 10:34 pm 10:34 pm
No, Kennedy would not have been sent home to die with pain pills. He was a senator, he would and did get anything he wanted. The elected bumbles have made themselves exempt from this trash bill. Hmmmm…..Wonder why. Could it be that the masses will recieve inferior care and they know it? I think so. The republicans wanted a vote to include themselves and their congressional peers in the plan should it pass. The vote was no of course with only one republican voting no, adding that he wouldnt vote for his dog to have that kind of healthcare. Wake up people. You cannot get more for less especially when the government is running the show. They cant even run a CARS program correctly let alone your healthcare.
Posted by: P N TN | August 28, 2009, 10:36 pm 10:36 pm
I am not an Obama supporter. I consider myself more Republican than Democrat. I’m a moderate.
OK that said…how many of us have said I don’t want to end up in a nursing home…with all the family’s money wasted instead of passing on to the kids.
As to TED, he did die at home. Life is finite. You are going to be faced with some end of life decisions. If you had to the pay the bill, and knowing you were going to die, would you pay for the extra care. So why is it that if someone else is paying the bill…Medicare or private insurance they should pay the extra bill, knowing full well you are on the last days.
Posted by: Tom Hagen | August 28, 2009, 10:50 pm 10:50 pm
The difference in the Democrats politicizing Kennedy’s death and Huckabee is that Huckabee is not an elected official. He is only a citizen voicing his opinion. He is no different than you, George. His thoughts mean nothing in the real world. Teddy Care is Democratic elected officials politicizing.
Posted by: DHD | August 28, 2009, 10:52 pm 10:52 pm
“Which Democrat will toss it back first?”
How about “which Democrat will toss back PROOF that Huckabee’s wrong?”
Posted by: samantha | August 28, 2009, 11:05 pm 11:05 pm
Just how bad does it have to get before people wake up to the fact that we need health care reform. People can’t afford to retire because they can’t afford health insurance on their own. No one is going to let people die because we have a public health care option. Don’t believe such scare tactics. This issue is too important. We need to get it done for the good of the country. We can’t afford not to do it.
Posted by: Jane | August 28, 2009, 11:07 pm 11:07 pm
Seriously, anyone who disputes what Mike Huckabee is saying about the health care bill is A. ignorant, or B. works for Obama. Huckabee speaks the truth, read the health care bill, it can be found online.
Huckabee really should be president. I hope he runs for office in 2012. He would def. have my vote.
Posted by: terrance | August 28, 2009, 11:08 pm 11:08 pm
Leave Mr. Kennedy alone. He was a fine man, excellent swimmer and propped up the Irish Whiskey industry around the greater Boston area for decades. I remember him and Uncle Chuck,errr.. Mr. Todd doing the squeeze dance one night with Nancy doing shooters. Mikey is wrong, Teddy was taking pills way before he was eligible for Medicare, oh wait, that was his brother. Nevermind.
Posted by: Bob Pike | August 28, 2009, 11:12 pm 11:12 pm
Huckabee has it right……ABC has it all wrong….so much for objective news reporting & they wonder why few Americans even listen to ABC
Posted by: SilverFoxOK | August 28, 2009, 11:19 pm 11:19 pm
Ditto what Pat said:
“Huckabee merely pointed out that Kennedy gave us a perfect example of why seniors’ lives are not worth less than young people’s; that even at 77, he was fighting for something he believed in, so he considered every minute precious and was willing to take heroic measures to live every extra day rather than just take a pain pill and go home to die. He said any health care bill should recognize that and give all Americans the same choice that Senators enjoy. He was actually being respectful to the recently departed while promoting the idea that everyone deserves the best health care. What part of that do you disagree with, George?”
Of course, George took Huckabee’s comment out of context. If some of you posters would read the comments BEFORE you took what George said as the gospel and condemed Huckabee, you would already know this. And, if you read the comments, you might learn something – that most of the hype being put out by the Obama machine is just that – HYPE.
You will NOT be able to “keep your insurance”
You will NOT be able to “keep your doctor”
There WILL be rationing, just like in England.
Medicare funding WILL be cut to pay for this, at the expense of the elderly.
The public option IS still on the agenda. “Co-Ops” is just another way to get to the objective of the “public option”, so don’t fall for it.
Abortion IS going to be paid for, under all the various plans.
Instead of just accepting what the Dems tell you is in the plan, read the bills yourselves. There are copies of the bills on The Dems in the House and the Senate DO NOT know what is actually in the bills because they did NOT write them. The bills were written by people outside of Congress, just as were the Stimulus and the Cap & Trade (written by the Apollo Alliance)bills.
Posted by: Jasmine | August 28, 2009, 11:21 pm 11:21 pm
George, don’t pretend to be a journalist. You’re a pundit.
Posted by: Creck | August 28, 2009, 11:32 pm 11:32 pm
The right to fight for control of one’s life is God given. Not even Barack Obama or his leftist and fascist government should be able to take it away; not from Kennedy, not from you or me!!
Yes, under BHO’s plan, an older person like Kennedy would be asked to save THE COLLECTIVE a bunch of money by taking a pill, crawling away and dying quietly and quickly. Perhaps worse, the government would destroy the profit motive that fosters inovation and new discoveries. So all of the drug and medical technology companies, private universities, researchers and other providers who HAVE made our care the BEST IN THE WORLD, would have little funding to take financial risks to find the next amazing cure or diagnostic advancement or treatment. The cure for what ailed Kennedy will never be found under Obama/Kennedy care.
Posted by: Cheese | August 28, 2009, 11:34 pm 11:34 pm
We all need to step back and take a deep breath. Let’s, just for a big change, discuss health care reform like adults. We have been acting like 4 year olds having a temper tantrum. Grow up and start reasoning this issue carefully, objectively- that would preclude name calling, insults, black/white reasoning- think for yourselves folks!
Huckabee knows exactly what he is doing when he throws out an incendiary statement- it works! We are like trained seals barking in response to ANYTHING no matter how outrageous!
Let’s start deliberating these important issues like intelligent, adult people.
Posted by: Nancy Kukay | August 28, 2009, 11:35 pm 11:35 pm
Tom, you said: “I am not an Obama supporter. I consider myself more Republican than Democrat. I’m a moderate.
OK that said…how many of us have said I don’t want to end up in a nursing home…with all the family’s money wasted instead of passing on to the kids.
As to TED, he did die at home. Life is finite. You are going to be faced with some end of life decisions. If you had to the pay the bill, and knowing you were going to die, would you pay for the extra care. So why is it that if someone else is paying the bill…Medicare or private insurance they should pay the extra bill, knowing full well you are on the last days.”
I think the point is this – we should be allowed to make that decision ourselves and not have it made by the government.
And as far as I know, none of us is God and so we don’t know “full well” when we are “on the last days”. My father-in-law was diagnosed with liver cancer and the doctors gave him 6 months to live. But he proved them wrong and lived on for 18 months after that prognosis was given. Just long enough to enjoy some quality time with his grandchildren before he died. By then he had been able to watch their first ball games, hear about their first day of school, and leave them with some wonderful memories of their grandfather that they would not have had otherwise.
Posted by: Jasmine | August 28, 2009, 11:35 pm 11:35 pm
willetta thomson
You know how full your post is…if you where a teacher you would have a pension..Plus now take into fact that you had breast cancer and after you did nothing to prepare for it…Why should I have to take from my family to help you when you didn’t even help your self. You could go to any church or many Charities that would help you..but no you want the Government to save you…and take from others…Government money is not free it has to come from someone…
Posted by: chadp71 | August 28, 2009, 11:36 pm 11:36 pm
The truth hurts doesn’t it?
Posted by: Dom Pfefferkorn | August 28, 2009, 11:43 pm 11:43 pm
Huckabee is right on target. I am tired of hearing about the Lion of the Senate. But, you know, I agree with the title the lib’s gave him. In the jungle the Lion is at the top of the food chain and that is exactly where the Kennedy’s think they are. They think they are above everyone else and above the law too.
JFK, RFK, and the Lying Lion had multiple affairs and the lib’s still loved them. The Lying Lion started the whole politicization of justice confirmations when he lead the charge against Robert Bork. Until then the Senate only examined a justice nominee’s ability and background.
I don’t mean to speak ill of the dead but for once the lib’s need to stop putting these Elite’s on a ____ pedestal.
God Bless America…..please?
Posted by: Stan | August 28, 2009, 11:43 pm 11:43 pm
Nancy, you said “Let’s start deliberating these important issues like intelligent, adult people.”
Tell that to your Congressmen and Senators. They don’t want debate. They fully expected us to sit back and let them ram this through without any debate at all.
And if you would just go out and look around on the internet (while you still can) you will find out that there ARE a lot of people “deliberating these important issues like intelligent, adult people.”
Just be glad that we still have access to the internet. That may not be true if Senate bill S.773 gets passed:
=== Bill would give president emergency control of Internet
Internet companies and civil liberties groups were alarmed this spring when a U.S. Senate bill proposed handing the White House the power to disconnect private-sector computers from the Internet.
They’re not much happier about a revised version that aides to Sen. Jay Rockefeller, a West Virginia Democrat, have spent months drafting behind closed doors. CNET News has obtained a copy of the 55-page draft of S.773 (excerpt), which still appears to permit the president to seize temporary control of private-sector networks during a so-called cybersecurity emergency.
The new version would allow the president to “declare a cybersecurity emergency” relating to “non-governmental” computer networks and do what’s necessary to respond to the threat. ===
Posted by: jasmine | August 28, 2009, 11:53 pm 11:53 pm
Huckabee was right. Kennedy was lucky he didn’t have to live by Obamacare rationing for seniors.
Posted by: Juju | August 28, 2009, 11:55 pm 11:55 pm
IF Huckabee runs, please pick Sarah Palin or Anne Coulter. You are guaranteed to lose. Please, please run those folks. If folks like Huckabee had his way, we’d live in a Christian dictatorship. I don’t want people who believe in a made up book with some farcical guy in the sky… Christians are anti-science, anti-reason and anti-freedom. They want to control everyone and everything. I will fight you to the death, you fanatics. You stupid birthers, racists, die!
Posted by: Run, Mike, Run! | August 28, 2009, 11:59 pm 11:59 pm
Mike my man is right on here. The whole death panel thing, that Sarah brought forward has derailed Obamacare. Read the elderly attack Obamacare at….http://cooperscopy.blogspot.com/
Posted by: Ron Victor | August 29, 2009, 12:06 am 12:06 am
Don Williams does not know what he’s talking about if he thinks that Medicare would be acceptable government health care.
Try calling doctors. Tell them that you’re on Medicare and need a new doctor. See if the doc is accepting new patients. Keep calling until you find one.
You’ll be on the phone a very long time.
HR 3200 ends Medicare Advantage and cuts reimbursements to “save” the money to pay for everybody else – so it will only get WORSE. Fewer doctors and hositals will accept Medicare patients, who will have to pay more out of pocket for their health care.
Posted by: huh? | August 29, 2009, 12:07 am 12:07 am
You lefties can’t read the writing on the wall. You have no argument here and all you can do is call Mike Huckabee names. (Like Christians are such bald-faced liars?) (Not only does Mike Hucekberry look like Gomer Pyle, but he thinks like him.) How about some back and forth. Why don’t you tell us how great Obamacare is going to be. I know one thing the house dems won’t accept the same Obamacare they want for the rest of us. Tell me how I’m better off with Obamacare.
Posted by: geno | August 29, 2009, 12:10 am 12:10 am
Let me comment on this from a factual rather than a political perspective. What Huckabee said was partially correct. For the AVERAGE person under the Obamacare program, the treatment for a person diagnosed with a high grade glioblastoma would be – go home take a few pills and die. Of course we know that’s not the kind of care that Kennedy received. For the ELITISTS, they will receive nothing short of the best as did Senator Kennedy – multiple consultations with doctors around the country, the highest surgical care and cutting edge technology at Duke University, privileged access to nearly every institution across the country, etc. These leftist ideaologues are trying to dismantle this great nation of ours and turn it into a “bannana republic” with third world health care. The American people reject this socialist philosophy and are voicing their objections at town hall meetings across the country. It’s time that we take our country back from these “King George”, Harvard educated, Chicago gangsters. My message to all of these silver-spoon cry-babies is eat dirt. We’re mad as hell and aren’t gonna’ take it any more. Revolution if we must.
Posted by: Mike Jefferson | August 29, 2009, 12:12 am 12:12 am
If (and that is a big word) they wanted to fix healthcare they would be looking at what caused costs to skyrocket in the first place.
The unintended consequences of the bill requiring healthcare to ANYONE who visits an emergency room.
Who pays for this service? Every person who pays for their own service and everyone who pays for their own insurance and every tax payer.
These patients are a loss for the hospital and that loss has to be made up somewhere. Service rates increase for everyone else. The government (you and me) reimburse some of the losses.
Why not pre-screen emergency room visitors to see if it is truly an emergency and if it is, then treat them. If it is not then send them to the local Health Department the next day. Stop these morons from going to the emergency room with a sore toe!!!! And if they are illegal aliens then deport their butts or, at best, give them the aspirin that Obama talks about and send them home.
ANYTHING THE GOVERNMENT GIVES AWAY HAS TO BE TAKEN FROM SOMEONE ELSE FIRST!!!!!
Posted by: stan | August 29, 2009, 12:17 am 12:17 am
Of course, Kennedy would died much sooner. Otherwise why would Senators and House Representatives not want to be on this crappy Health Care Reform they are trying to ram down our throats. If its not as good as what they have then we shouldn’t be forced into it after all they work for us not the other way around.
Posted by: Alan | August 29, 2009, 12:18 am 12:18 am
Now, this is just a down right disgrace to even read this crap. Per ABC News; Mike Huckabee tossed a hand grenade into the debate over who’s politicizing Ted Kennedy’s death Thursday morning when he told his radio audience that under Obamacare, Kennedy would be told to “go home to take pain pills and die.”
Just disgraces to even say such crap. “WELL” Ted is dead, Huckabee. This wonderful Senator and his family have been fighting for the rights of the poor for decades. He refused to allow death knocking on his doors to even stop his cause, championing for the people he always believe in so dearly. To get a message across even to slander an honorable man like this is not the way for gentlemen of the Senate to be conducting themselves. I would have expected the thugs and street scum to make a statement like that, personally attacking a dying man. Huckabee needs to extend an olive branch to the Kennedy family and chose his words and the situation of a person. A little more wisely in the future, before making opened statements
Posted by: Pedro Dixon | August 29, 2009, 12:18 am 12:18 am
I do agree that some form of rationing should take place with the elderly. That being said, I am 66.
I do not believe that organ transplants should be given to elderly unless they are in excellent health. I had an aunt at the age of 93 who was found to have had breast cancer and was operated on. I feel that this is wrong. I heard Chris Dodd speak of heart surgery on his father at the age of 90 something and how it gave him 18 more years of life. I think that is wrong.
I also feel that we have to set a threshhold for infant size. If an infant is born at 1 pound, they have no developed organs that function and they most likely will be burdens on the state because their parents might not have the resources to care for them. There is one set of quads on tv who are all both deaf and blind. That has got to use a lot of resources.
I have a Medicare Advantage policy. The premiums are $96 (Med. B) plus $40 for the advantage plan. I had an MRI and my insurance was billed $8,000. I paid a $100 copay. You can see that my premiums of $1632 for the year didn’t come close to this one test. We cannot continue on at this pace.
Medicare is to become insolvent in 8 years. It is not a good plan for the rest of the country. If people think the gov is going to pay all their premiums and charge no co-pays, they are drinking something funny. It just can’t work.
Posted by: optimist | August 29, 2009, 12:26 am 12:26 am
We have a major problem in the US. We do not have enough doctors.
I went to the ER a month or so ago. I had a killer earache and tried everything to relieve the pain. I called my doctor and got an appointment ten days later. The receptionist told me to go to the ER if it got worse. I decided that I couldn’t take the pain for ten days so I went to the ER.
I sat in the waiting room for 5 hours. During that time 30 people came in, registered at the window and answered the same two questions: Do you have insurance (all but myself answered NO) and do you have a job (again I was the only one who did). I watched them leave one by one and after I was treated, I was the ONLY ONE to be asked to pay my $50 copay.
I noticed as I sat in the waiting room that I was the ONLY one who did not have a fancy cell phone. They were all sitting there and some had more than one in the family, each on their phones talking, texting, playing games. That kind of usage costs $70 or more per month but they COULDN”T PAY ANYTHING TO THE HOSPITAL.
If you can afford a fancy cell phone, you can afford to pay your medical bills.
Posted by: optimist | August 29, 2009, 12:31 am 12:31 am
The indignation by the All Barack Channel to criticism of the messiah is quite predictable at this point. Hey Stefanopolis, are you still weeping with joy over Barry’s victory? Boo Hoo.
Posted by: I Love You | August 29, 2009, 12:36 am 12:36 am
Kennedy SHOULD have gone to Canada, Cuba or Great Britain for his Cancer treatment. obviously he would have far superior care to what we have here…
WHY?!? Why didn’t he follow the millions of now healthy Americans and go to those superior places… OH TEDDY! WHY?!?
Posted by: JThomas | August 29, 2009, 12:40 am 12:40 am
Anyone who says that the government option is “just an option” is either really deluded or flat out lying. It’s the back-door way to ending private insurance…even if it takes a decade or two.
George, you’re performing below your pay grade. Be a journalist, not a liberal operative.
Posted by: Creck | August 29, 2009, 12:43 am 12:43 am
Obama was the one who said that people who have lived the better part of their life should consider just taking a pain pill instead of using up healthcare resources – so why is it only a bomb to the media now that Huckabee has pointed it out? Where were you guys when Obama said it?
Posted by: QuoVadisAnima | August 29, 2009, 12:46 am 12:46 am
Don Williams is a shill for the Left — he’ll say anything in his attempts to cover the truth. People are paying attention now Don — your same old lying schtick doesn’t fly anymore.
Posted by: William | August 29, 2009, 12:50 am 12:50 am
If he can get away with murder, he can have whatever healthcare daddy’s bootlegging money will buy him.
Posted by: Truman | August 29, 2009, 12:55 am 12:55 am
I think it’s awesome that Huckster, Palin and Glenn Beck are in a competition to out-crazy one another. And they know that this is APPEALING to the “base”! What kind of a Party do you have Republicans??
Posted by: Rich | August 29, 2009, 12:57 am 12:57 am
HAHAHAHA. Another stellar journalistic impartial point of view. I dont know whether to laugh or cry at the lack of debate from the left. Its either platitudes and bumper stickers or name calling and the race card. Get some facts to back your attacks up and then we might take you seriously.
Posted by: Matt | August 29, 2009, 12:58 am 12:58 am
George. If you are a journalist, be one here and now. Cover both sides…Quit asking who will toss out what. Get the story. Quit being a liberal princess and go tell both sides of this story. Read the bill. George, be someone that generations of journalists will remember. Save journalism.
Posted by: D.Ann Shiffler | August 29, 2009, 12:58 am 12:58 am
Keep it classy, Mr. Huckabee.
Posted by: sinew | August 29, 2009, 1:14 am 1:14 am
ObamaCare = TeddyCare = Chappiquidi-care.
I wonder how long it will take for this post to be removed. Don’t worry, the term is out there now, and it can’t be stopped.
Posted by: WhyWillItBe | August 29, 2009, 1:14 am 1:14 am
Why would anyone “challenge Huckabee head-on” for saying something that is obviously a fact?
George- You know damn well that under socialized medicine a 77 year old man isn’t going to get the same treatment Kennedy got.
Oh wait, I forgot under socialism the rich and the elite still get good care it’s the other 95% that get the mediocre care.
Posted by: Brad | August 29, 2009, 1:18 am 1:18 am
Willeta, old at 62! Get up and get moving girl. Huck is so right! If you read and do the research it’s all laid out. Check out Dr. Zeke Emanual’s (Obama health czar)recent writings about the value of human life at different ages. We need to get serious and ask ourselves “do we really want the government to decide and tell us our value and when we should let go”. That doesn’twork for me, cause I belong to God not the government. Regarding money we will only be short on resources if we allow Obama to create a socialized state where too many people sit and hold out their hands for entitlements. Ronald Reagan had it right when Jimmy Carter was trying to convince us that the U.S.A. had seen it’s best days and he said “hell no”. Rise up America and fight back!
Posted by: Sheldon | August 29, 2009, 1:39 am 1:39 am
Yes because all we need is a poem and all the independent voters will flock to you guys….hahahaha. For the love of god can anybody on your side quote anything from HR 3200 to try to further the debate? I mean Obama HAS NOT put out any piece of legislation or “plan”. All he has are speeches and bumberstickers on whatever he has in his head, of which runs completely contradictory to HR 3200. Which again I invite any democrat to point out any passage in HR 3200 that makes Obama’s point.
Posted by: Matt | August 29, 2009, 1:48 am 1:48 am
Roses are red,
Violets are blue,
Socialism is great,
Just don’t get the flu.
Posted by: Krugman in Purgatory | August 29, 2009, 1:57 am 1:57 am
First hand played for politicizing this was renaming Obamacare to Kenedycare by Democrats.
Since this was done, it is only fair to point this out.
Politicizing his death is wrong, I wish the Democrats had left this alone.
Posted by: Dialla | August 29, 2009, 1:59 am 1:59 am
Let me guess George is now bringing lovers together on George’s bottom line :-D
I do love the poems :-D
Go Obama and Health care!
Posted by: Davis | August 29, 2009, 2:09 am 2:09 am
I agree with some previous posts….Never for one second believe that a Kennedy or an Obama would be sent home with some pain meds to die like the rest of us! The liberal mind-set has always embraced an arrogant elitist philosophy that requires the masses to conform to their policies. The only exceptions are the ones they make for themselves and the “select” groups they choose. Socialism will always fail because sooner or later you will run out of other people’s money! Does that sound familiar with what is going on right now in America? Even long time Democrats must realize you can’t keep spending other people’s money by the TRILLIONS and not adversely affect the economy! You have to be a political/economic moron to believe otherwise. There are only two ways Obama can pay for all these ridicuously expensive handout programs….raising taxes on the working class and above and government sponsored inflation. Wheee! That is the perfect recipe to ruin the economy.
Posted by: Dino Brava | August 29, 2009, 2:13 am 2:13 am
LET ME GET THIS STRAIGHT…. Huckabee is making a declarative statement about a hypothetical situation based on legislation that hasn’t even been voted on, much less passed? And that passes for serious commentary amongst Republicans?
If Buckley were alive today, he’d die of embarrassment.
Posted by: Henry Porter | August 29, 2009, 2:24 am 2:24 am
George who? If he ain’t on Fox, he ain’t worth watching!
Posted by: RDH | August 29, 2009, 2:28 am 2:28 am
Mike Huckabee’s hand grenade or Democrat Love Poems LOL
I vote the Love Poems
Posted by: John | August 29, 2009, 2:32 am 2:32 am
Hey, Betty.
GET THIS STRAIGHT…. Obama is making declarative statements about legislation that he hasn’t written or read! And that Main Stream Media refuses to make serious commentary on what is being perpetrated against our country!
Posted by: RDH | August 29, 2009, 2:33 am 2:33 am
notice how democrats copy others, while republicans write their own…
Posted by: Joe Klein | August 29, 2009, 2:36 am 2:36 am
George:
You are such a disappointment!!!
Posted by: Liz | August 29, 2009, 2:42 am 2:42 am
LET ME GET THIS STRAIGHT….Obama was upset that G.W. Bush spent billions.. so his solution is to spend trillions! In addition, Obama decides to take over industry and healthcare, apologize to every country while displaying his vast ignorance on foreign policy, emasculate the CIA, and subsidize a “green revolution” while China and India laugh all the way to the bank. Yup. That is pretty straight up socialism. Look it up. Socialism is when the government owns or controls the major means of production, transportation, and communication. (As opposed to all means of production in a communism system) Didn’t I just read today that Obama wants total control of the internet “in case of an emergency”? Jeez! This is too easy.
Posted by: Dino Brava | August 29, 2009, 2:46 am 2:46 am
Harry, I don’t know any sixty-two year olds who are ready to give up and die and let the younger generation have all the free medical treatment. I’m just a few years younger than you, and believe me, I’m eagerly looking forward to the next twenty or thirty years and hope to have them. I’ve got a lot to do and a lot to contribute. My eighty-five year old mother is hoping to reach a hundred at least, as far as I can tell. She surely isn’t ready to hang up the towel yet, although she is not nearly as vital and active as she was twenty years ago. She’s still got a mind and thoughts to contribute. Your attitude stinks. Sorry for you. I think I’ll say a little prayer that you get your rear in gear, as my old teacher used to say, and make something of the rest of your life. You might actually end up having to live it, you know.
Posted by: Anna | August 29, 2009, 2:47 am 2:47 am
What is so wrong with your healthcare that you want to change it so badly. “Its bold face lies” not bald face lies. That just shows that education should be first. Anyways, why is it that the same americans complaining about this, probably all have cell phones, and cable, and 2 cars, and eat out every other night. Listen, my only point is, is that it YOUR responsibility to map out your own future. If healthcare isnt YOUR priority, then why should your healthcare be MY priority. If you didnt plan for it, then its noone elses fault but your own.Look, most of these people who want it, already get the government option. Its called Welfare, or medicaid. Im glad its there for people in need, but, its not for everyone. If I need help, the last place ill ever look is to the govt. When I grew up, people were ashamed to be givin things from the govt. Now its just a rite of passage.
Posted by: michael | August 29, 2009, 3:12 am 3:12 am
Roses are red
Violets are blue
Obama thinks we have 57 states
OMG! He is now in charge of our economy!
We are screwed.
Posted by: Dino Brava | August 29, 2009, 3:17 am 3:17 am
WTB any democrat with a citation from House bill HR 3200 that will back up any of Obama’s claims. Anyone out there?
Bueler…Bueler?
Posted by: Matt | August 29, 2009, 3:30 am 3:30 am
Ted Kennedy did die in his house. I would bet my last dollar he had a prescription for pain pills.
If your health care is provided by your employer and you get to sick to work should you too be allowed to die homeless on the street?
Posted by: Freddy Mercury | August 29, 2009, 3:40 am 3:40 am
America is great because people “plan”, “think”, “act”, for themselves. We’ve made it 224 years without a nanny state and community organizer in chief telling us what to do all the time. I know that the socialists in the Democrat party mean well, but so did Joe Stalin and Comrade Mao and their social welfare plans effectuated the death of millions of people.
Posted by: Rep. Diane Watson *hearts* Fideladephia | August 29, 2009, 4:23 am 4:23 am
Georgie my boy, we both know that when the blue dog democrats (aka Pelosi Puppies) sign off on ObamaCares things are going to get ugly. Let’s be a good journalist and write something positive and uplifting for the esprit de corp in the meanwhile, capiche?
Posted by: Arlened right, Arlened Left, Arlened Spectered all over the damn place | August 29, 2009, 4:54 am 4:54 am
I agree with Huckabee; which is strange because he is not a metrosexual and did not attend Harvard.
Posted by: David Frum Canada, eh? | August 29, 2009, 4:59 am 4:59 am
George is wrong. The current bill exempts Congress. It applies only to us. They will still get state of the art treatment under any condition.
Posted by: Mike | August 29, 2009, 4:59 am 4:59 am
Obama is a liar and so are his hair dyed lap doggies.
Posted by: Pinochet & Pinocchio | August 29, 2009, 5:04 am 5:04 am
“my muslim faith”…. “you mean your Christian faith”.
Good thing Georgie has always got Obama’s back on this stuff. The One needs all the help he can get these days.
Posted by: Doug | August 29, 2009, 5:12 am 5:12 am
When a man of Senator Kennedy’s advanced age combined with chronic alcohol and obesity issues was diagnosed with a form of cancer which normally takes even the healthy within a year, Senator Kennedy did not limit himself to the avenues of his congressionally provide care – abundant as it is. Instead, he assembled a team of more than a dozen doctors, neurosurgeons flown in from around the country, and proceeded with a tremendously expensive form of surgery to extend his precious life by less than 9 months.
There were no reflections on end of life planning – obviously the wealthy are not a burden to their families, or a push to simply forgo surgery at this late stage as Mr. Obama has stated “Maybe you’re better off not having the surgery, but taking painkillers.” No, instead the champion of mandated, government run health coverage used all his immense wealth and privilege to obtain the best health care he could possibly have. The only thing is, he and Mr. Obama want to take that away for the rest of us. If his superior government medical coverage was not enough to satiate his desire for the best medical care, do you think “Medicare for all” will be good enough for those of us who are not majestic and wealthy?
Posted by: cottonmouth | August 29, 2009, 5:51 am 5:51 am
So George, you honestly believe the “publc option” would spend $400,000 worth of treatment on 77 year olds? Did you ever hear of the VA Health Care System? You used to tell us how bad it was under Bush. You and you ilk in the “State Run Media” seem to forget it even exists anymore.
Posted by: Tomas | August 29, 2009, 6:08 am 6:08 am
No he wouldn’t go home, take pain pills and die. The Kennedy’s have enough money to buy treatment wherever they want. THAT’S the point. It’s about access to the best care REGARDLESS of your situation.
Posted by: Nick Reynolds | August 29, 2009, 6:43 am 6:43 am
Mike Huckabee was making a point – and a good one – (of course, Kennedy would have the private insurance, as all public employees will continue to enjoy) it may have had more to do with his age/illness and how the current bill is written, than anything else. That said, Kennedy’s death had already been politicized by his own party – they tagged his name to Health Care Reform as soon as he stopped breathing – As a Massachusetts resident, the manner in which Ted Kennedy has been treated by his own party (tagging his name to health care reform, (political), Harry Reid calling Patrick and pushing him to change the State Laws to appoint a Successor, and the junk on Huffington Post (news organization (loosely stated) of the White House): “choose a Kennedy successor,” it is disgusting – they should have had the decency to wait a week. Kennedy political ideology aside – his service to his constituents in time of need, was impeccable. As to Huckabee and 2012 – in 2008, there were only two viable candidates Mike Huckabee and Hillary Clinton – Huckabee was my first choice, based on his performance as a 2-1/2 term Govenor, Clinton my second (after it became apparent that McCain was given the nod), because she had a stronger record (I did the research) on defense than anyone else in the field and her vision of fixing health care, was sane) Huckabee does, indeed, appear to be positioning himself for a run in 2012, and again, he would be my choice, he’s a fiscal conservative, who can reach across the aisle to get things done without comprising his principles – in 10 years he dragged the State of Arkansas in the 20th century, vis a vis, communications, education and tax cuts, and get this, he didn’t change the state into a theocracy!
Posted by: Tina | August 29, 2009, 6:57 am 6:57 am
Did anyone notice that a reporter named Cami Mc Cormick was seriously injured while reporting on our latest war. Kennedy went home to die, had the money to take care of it when he chose to do so (ironic that Obama was in town, and convenient as well since everyone is forgetting about the health care battle)and this poor woman is in a hospital somewhere in the middle east and no one gives her one minutes notice? Kennedy was a womanizer, drunk, liar, law evading rich kid who didn’t have a clue as to how the average human being lived! Anyone with money and power could accomplish what he accomplished which was evading truth! And Obama, the king, has fallen in step with the Kennedy clan! OUR country is in big trouble! Everyone knows it! Only the brave are willing to voice it!
Posted by: Rredds | August 29, 2009, 7:04 am 7:04 am
“’Its bold face lies’ not bald face lies. That just shows that education should be first.”
Pssst, it’s “it’s, not “its.”
“It’s,” with an apostrophe, is the contraction of “it is.”
“Its,” without an apostrophe, is the possessive form.
Anyway, William Safire once wrote in The New York Times: “In current use, then, baldfaced lie is the most popular because it sounds most resounding; barefaced lie continues to run strong with no connotation of any pursuit of the hirsute; and boldfaced lie sounds like a printer’s error. In every case, kill the hyphen.”
Posted by: Pitt Knicker | August 29, 2009, 7:27 am 7:27 am
Dear Willetta…Where is your family, your church, etc.? It is not the governments job to decide who gets anything or to provide anything!
Posted by: Avenger | August 29, 2009, 7:29 am 7:29 am
George – Huckabee is right! Obamam stated that for someone diagnosed with incurable cancer, they should not be treated but given a pain pill. Teddy was treated as aggressively as possible – by products made by those greedy drug companies who risked a billion dollars 9rather than just putting it in the bank) for the rare individual who might need this drug. If obama care went thru, all the heros who work to bring these drugs to market will be without jobs, the patients without the drug, but the government will hold on to the money so that they can spread the wealth to people whose votes they need. George, be like Reagan, Medved, Horowitz, Savage, Thomas, Bennett, and others…join us – come over to the other side….at least we are intellectually more honest….
Posted by: orange high | August 29, 2009, 7:33 am 7:33 am
If Huck was trying to make a point to clam irrational fears caused by lies about reforming healthcare – he screwed the pooch….if he was trying to compete with Palin for the wing-nut vote, he’s doin’ a heck of a job!
Republicans keep this up, Democrats will have a solid majority for the next 20 years!
Posted by: career fed | August 29, 2009, 7:37 am 7:37 am
Doug posted “‘my muslim faith’…. ‘you mean your Christian faith’.”
Sheesh, people STILL trot this out on a regular basis. Let’s go back to the original transcript:
OBAMA: Listen, you and I both know that the minute that Governor Palin was forced to talk about her daughter, I immediately said that’s off limits. And -
Stephanopoulos: And John McCain said the same thing about questioning your faith.
OBAMA: And what was the first thing the McCain campaign went out and did? They said, look, these liberal blogs that support Obama are out there attacking Governor Palin. Let’s not play games. What I was suggesting – you’re absolutely right that John McCain has not talked about my Muslim faith…
==============
Obama was NOT saying he was Muslim.
Example: let’s suppose that everybody on this blog, except for me, started saying that you, Doug, are a dodo bird. You could then rightly say “Rudy has not talked about my being a dodo bird.” You wouldn’t be calling yourself a dodo bird, would you Doug?
Posted by: Rudy | August 29, 2009, 7:50 am 7:50 am
Not very classy, Huck. You could have at least given Sen. Kennedy’s family time to grieve before you made it a political tool. Thought you were a Christian, dude?
Posted by: Rebecca | August 29, 2009, 7:56 am 7:56 am
At this time, this was a very inappropriate statement to make. It’s also JUST as inappropriate USING Senator Kennedy to as a political talking point in the healthcare reform debate. Let his family grieve, people.
Posted by: Rick from Atlanta | August 29, 2009, 8:06 am 8:06 am
The Last of The Kennedy Dynasty
As soon as his cancer was detected, I noticed the immediate attempt at the “canonization” of old Teddy Kennedy by the mainstream media. They are saying what a “great American” he is. I say, let’s get a couple things clear & not twist the facts to change the real history.
1. He was caught cheating at Harvard when he attended it. He was expelled twice, once for cheating on a test, and once for paying a classmate to cheat for him.
2. While expelled, Kennedy enlisted in the Army, but mistakenly signed up for four years instead of two. Oops! The man can’t count to four! His father, Joseph P. Kennedy, former U.S. Ambassador to England (a step up from bootlegging liquor into the US from Canada during prohibition), pulled the necessary strings to have his enlistment shortened to two years, and to ensure that he served in Europe, not Korea , where a war was raging. No preferential treatment for him! (like he charged that President Bush received).
3. Kennedy was assigned to Paris , never advanced beyond the rank of Private, and returned to Harvard upon being discharged. Imagine a person of his “education” NEVER advancing past the rank of Private!
4. While attending law school at the University of Virginia , he was cited for reckless driving four times, including once when he was clocked driving 90 miles per hour in a residential neighborhood with his headlights off after dark. Yet his Virginia driver’s license was never revoked. Coincidentally, he passed the bar exam in 1959. Amazing!
5. In 1964, he was seriously injured in a plane crash, and hospitalized for several months. Test results done by the hospital at the time he was admitted had shown he was legally intoxicated. The results of those tests remained a “state secret” until in the 1980′s when the report was unsealed.. Didn’t hear about that from the unbiased media, did we?
6. On July 19, 1969, Kennedy attended a party on Chappaquiddick Island in Massachusetts .. At about 11:00 PM, he borrowed his chauffeur’s keys to his Oldsmobile limousine, and offered to give a ride home to Mary Jo Kopechne, a campaign worker. Leaving the island via an unlit bridge with no guard rail, Kennedy steered the car off the bridge, flipped, and into Poucha Pond.
7. He swam to shore and walked back to the party, passing several houses and a fire station. Two friends then returned with him to the scene of the accident. According to their later testimony, they told him what he already knew – that he was required by law to immediately report the accident to the authorities. Instead Kennedy made his way to his hotel, called his lawyer, and went to sleep. Kennedy called the police the next morning and by then the wreck had already been discovered. Before dying, Kopechne had scratched at the upholstered floor above her head in the upside-down car.
The Kennedy family began “calling in favors”, ensuring that any inquiry would be contained. Her corpse was whisked out-of-state to her family before an autopsy could be conducted. Further details are uncertain, but after the accident Kennedy says he repeatedly dove under the water trying to rescue Kopechne and he didn’t call police because he was in a state of shock. It is widely assumed Kennedy was drunk, and he held off calling police in hopes that his family could fix the problem overnight. Since the accident, Kennedy’s “political enemies” have referred to him as the distinguished Senator from Chappaquiddick. He pled guilty to leaving the scene of an accident, and was given a SUSPENDED SENTENCE OF TWO MONTHS. Kopechne’s family received a small payout from the Kennedy’s insurance policy, and never sued. There was later an effort to have her body exhumed and autopsied, but her family successfully fought against this in court, and Kennedy’s family paid their attorney’s bills… a “token of friendship”?
8. Kennedy has held his Senate seat for more than forty years, but considering his longevity, his accomplishments seem scant. He authored or argued for legislation that ensured a variety of civil rights, increased the minimum wage in 1981, made access to health care easier for the indigent, and funded Meals on Wheels for fixed-income seniors and is widely held as the “standard-bearer for liberalism”. In his very first Senate roll, he was the floor manager for the bill that turned U.S. immigration policy upside down and opened the floodgate for immigrants from third world countries.
9. Since that time, he has been the prime instigator and author of every expansion of an increase in immigration, up to and including the latest attempt to grant amnesty to illegal aliens. Not to mention the pious grilling he gave the last two Supreme Court nominees, as if he was the standard bearer for the nation in matters of “what’s right”. What a pompous ____!
10. He is known around Washington as a public drunk, loud, boisterous and very disrespectful to ladies. JERK is a better description than “great American”. “A blonde in every pond” is his motto.
Let’s not allow the spin doctors make this jerk a hero — how quickly the American public forgets what his real legacy is. Let’s keep this going for truth, justice and the American way
Posted by: clarke | August 29, 2009, 8:07 am 8:07 am
I’m sorry, but this is BS, people. From some of the sick comments, it’s no wonder our country is on the verge of disaster.
Posted by: Rick from Atlanta | August 29, 2009, 8:11 am 8:11 am
Yep, Mike is right.
Prove his statement wrong.
Posted by: Delta | August 29, 2009, 8:15 am 8:15 am
Kennedy selfishly stayed in office until he died, doing no work, receiving a paycheck, and getting his health care for free. I would like to know how much debt my children will have to pay back because of the enormous medical expenses incurred in the last year of his life.
Posted by: EdwardATeller | August 29, 2009, 8:15 am 8:15 am
“Obamam stated that for someone diagnosed with incurable cancer, they should not be treated but given a pain pill.”
I don’t know about “Obamam” but Obama didn’t say that. To see what he actually said, go to Politifact and search for Lungren. Republican Rep. Dan Lungren twisted that quote also.
Posted by: WWW | August 29, 2009, 8:16 am 8:16 am
Obama would not let his brother Ted go without healthcare.
Posted by: John | August 29, 2009, 8:19 am 8:19 am
With his lack of work ethic, lack of morals, and lack of intelligence, he would have been a 76 year old wino, living under an interstate.
The Kennedy name and Daddy’s money was all he had….and needed.
Posted by: John | August 29, 2009, 8:38 am 8:38 am
George: You can try to demonize Huckabee all you want. Hands down, he is the most respectable person in televesion and politics these days. No one comes even close to matching those qualities that he possesses.
Posted by: AG1 | August 29, 2009, 8:48 am 8:48 am
Do a search with the following tags: “Ezekiel Rahm McCaughey WSJ “. You will find that a certain MD who is one of the MAJOR consultants to the Pres on health care has been critical of US doctors who provide services to the patient based solely on the Hippocratic Oath-with no concern for the “broader society”. Yes, Virginia, Rahm has questioned whether a patient with dementia should receive dialysis! And brain cancer often leads to dementia so it is NO LONG STRETCH for Huckabee to take the position he did.
Posted by: jimbojinx | August 29, 2009, 8:51 am 8:51 am
Wow! Republicans come across as mean in their postings and ruthless I might add.
They will say anything to destroy a great Senator and health care.
Mike Huckvee and Sarah Palin will be fighting for these same Republican posters here in 2012? They can have them. We will go after the Independent Voters and expand on the Obamacans.
Posted by: Thoughtful | August 29, 2009, 8:54 am 8:54 am
Did you see John Kerry with his cane? Do you think he would have hip surgery at his age under Obamacare? Well, YES he would b/c you and I the taxpayer have afforded him a Cadillac plan which he will keep, but you and I will have a “public option” where I will have the same treatment as a homeless bum.Also noticed how even Ted Kennedys family couldn’t help themselves with the cause during their speeches at the wake-what opportunists they are-pitiful.
Posted by: Mikejpss | August 29, 2009, 8:55 am 8:55 am
Don’t be so hard on Stephanopoulos….he is just repeating what he has been told to say by the higher ups…..It is sad to see that after giving Obama a free hour long infomercial on his healthcare plan,ABC now refuses to allow paid airtime for information which opposes Obamacare…..it is really disgraceful what our media has become….Americans deserve better than this.
Posted by: Carl | August 29, 2009, 8:56 am 8:56 am
George! Do you honestly think that he has to better Sara Palin? Cannot be outdone? Unless Huckabee said it directly, that is rhetoric. Substantiate that claim, please.
Posted by: Monte R | August 29, 2009, 9:02 am 9:02 am
I wonder if anyone ABC reads these posts and realizes the majority of the people disagree with the direction that America’s headed. Quit carrying the water for this Administration
Posted by: Jim | August 29, 2009, 9:04 am 9:04 am
If you stop and think about it the American people paid for Kennedy’s health care. But yet under Obamacare we would not have the same privledge and we would still be paying for it.
It’s wonderful (sarcastic) being a second class citizen under the new administration.
Posted by: Judi | August 29, 2009, 9:05 am 9:05 am
Huckabee is a wolf in sheep clothing.
Posted by: Matt | August 29, 2009, 9:10 am 9:10 am
JAMES (ref. bold face liars) where are the lies? show us where we have all gone wrong. maybe you’ve read legislation that says something different? maybe you have the inside track?
substance — that’s what this conversation needs, not name calling.
Posted by: Bryan | August 29, 2009, 9:24 am 9:24 am
Huckabee is wrong, wrong and wrong. Kennedy would not have the same health coverage as the rest of us. He would have the privileged health care coverage that members of Congress would have. I assure you he not be in the public option.
Posted by: Norman P. Weiss | August 29, 2009, 9:25 am 9:25 am
George, Obama told Jane Sturm at the ABC White House special that maybe her 100 year old mother would be better off with the pain pill rather than the surgery. He said we can’t bring “subjective decision” making in the process, so would Kennedy really have done much better?
Posted by: Peter | August 29, 2009, 9:35 am 9:35 am
“It’s kinda strange to see Republicans making up lies about “Obamacare”. In the past 8 years that they had a Republican in the WHite House — and controlled Congress from 1995 to 2006 — they let 45 million American citizens go without healthcare. THEIR Healthcare policy was to steal $3 TRILLION out of our Medicare Trust Fund and gave it to the richest 2 percent of the population.”
I can visualize Don Williams as a 60 year old unempolyed dropout sitting on his front porch waiting for his welfare check and food stamps, crying about achievers having all th “luck.”
Posted by: Johnny | August 29, 2009, 9:40 am 9:40 am
“I wonder if anyone ABC reads these posts and realizes the majority of the people disagree with the direction that America’s headed.”
According to the latest ABC/Washington Post poll, 55% think the country is headed in the wrong direction. That figure has gotten worse since April, when it was 48%, but it is still much better than when Obama first took office. In January, 78% thought we were headed in the wrong direction.
Posted by: Numeros | August 29, 2009, 9:41 am 9:41 am
Mike Huckabee tossed a hand grenade into the debate over who’s politicizing Ted Kennedy’s death Thursday morning when he told his radio audience that under Obamacare, Kennedy would be told to “go home to take pain pills and die.” Huckabee is absolute right
Posted by: WISDOM | August 29, 2009, 9:57 am 9:57 am
“Obama told Jane Sturm at the ABC White House special that maybe her 100 year old mother would be better off with the pain pill rather than the surgery.”
He did not say that. Here is part of that exchange. Also note the words I have EMPHASIZED.
“And all we’re suggesting — and we’re not going to solve every difficult problem in terms of end-of-life care. A lot of that is going to have to be, we as a culture and as a society starting to make better decisions within our own families and for ourselves. But what we can do is make sure that at least SOME OF THE WASTE that exists in the system THAT’S NOT MAKING ANYBODY’S MOM BETTER, that is loading up on additional tests or additional drugs that the evidence shows is not necessarily going to improve care, that at least we can let doctors know and your mom know that, you know what? Maybe this isn’t going to help. Maybe you’re better off not having the surgery, but taking the painkiller. And those kinds of decisions between doctors and patients, and MAKING SURE THAT OUR INCENTIVES ARE NOT PREVENTING THOSE GOOD DECISIONS, and that — that doctors and hospitals all are aligned for patient care, that’s something we can achieve.”
For more of the exchange, go to Politifact and search for Lungren. Republican Rep. Dan Lungren twisted that quote also.
Posted by: WWW | August 29, 2009, 9:59 am 9:59 am
Nobody should even acknowledge that ignorant comment. It has been proven over and over again that, that’s not the wording or meaning of that part of the bill, that it is about living wills and was included by the Republicans that now attempt to skew it into something else. I used to find Mr. Huckabee amusing and likable even though I didn’t agree with him. He now is liar and in his heart he knows that if he really is a Reverend!
Posted by: Try the truth | August 29, 2009, 10:00 am 10:00 am
It is amazing to me that ‘focus-on-the-fetus’ GOP birthers like Mike Huckabee can continue to put out their completely outrageous fictions about supposed Democratic advocacy of “death panels.”
Republicans who are lackeys for big insurance corporations do their own version of death panels already, every day. Everyone who gets in the way of the corporate bottom line profits gets left to die by company bean counters pulling the plug on existing, good-standing insurance clients when problems arise.
Therefore, the GOP’s tender concern over seniors’ end of life freedom of choice is really touching in view of the very hypocrisy involved in the GOP’s fabrications. .
Never mind the specter of Democratic “Auschwitz-care”.GOPers have killed more people already than any death panel with their party having spent the last 50 years denying our whole nation a universal, accessible and adequate health care system.
Now, on top of that, we here in CA just pulled the budgetary plug on half of our state’s population ( the poor, elderly, sick, unemployed, etc) by eliminating the safety net completely, so that nobody here in CA will need even worry about living long enough to face some future death panel.
Those few of us who do survive this state-budget- holocaust will be accorded the privilege of demonstrating to the world what it means for California to “live within its means.”
Posted by: JL | August 29, 2009, 10:08 am 10:08 am
Anyone who believes Sarah Palin and her “death panels” is a complete moron. Period.
Posted by: SearamblerOne | August 29, 2009, 10:12 am 10:12 am
Under “Obamacare” – or at least under any of the four bills currently under consideration in Congress – Senator Kennedy would be entitled to keep his coverage under the Federal employees health insurance program. Any one of the many available plans in this program would have paid for complete and comprehensive medical care; they really differ only in cost and deductibles.
Posted by: ACB-3 | August 29, 2009, 10:14 am 10:14 am
Yes, “death” panels will follow all of us under the House plan, perhaps not stated as such, but as the logical result of government mandates of rationing health care dollars.
Every American should have what Senator Kennedy had: the political freedom to pursue his own medical care. Sure, he had means, and others don’t. That is not the issue. Freedom to pursue care is the issue, a freedom than the government plan makes impossible.
It is time to repeal Medicare, Medicaid, and all forms of government control and funding of medical care, not expand it into an immoral monster under which everyone suffers equally. The American people deserve political freedom, which means a government designed to protect the rights of the individual to pursue his own care on his own terms by paying for it or by asking for private, voluntary charity.
Mark A. Hurt, MD
Physician, Patriot
Posted by: Mark A. Hurt, MD | August 29, 2009, 10:20 am 10:20 am
All this hype about death panels is such an embarassment in that the entire world can see just how easily frightened many (not all) US citizens can become. This is the same motis operandi that landed us in Iraq and Afghanistan. It is the same FEAR TACTIC that the right-wing used to keep the most dismal president we have EVER had in office for a second term. America hangs its head in shame.
Posted by: Rick in SB | August 29, 2009, 10:30 am 10:30 am
In Canada with the Socialized Health Care that faiiled as they now admit, you would accept that your wait for a MRI or Cat Scan would be months. This means many die BEFORE they even know what is wrong with them. Obamanomics, would give the same caring treatment to Americans.
There are 15% of Americans with out Health Care, how many are illegal alians and how many are on welfare and do not work nor have they ever been productive ? We should care for the ill, infirmed and elderly, BUT having workedd in a County Hospital for many years and seeing healthy, over fed and lazy people with no real medical problems live off of those of us who work and do not have ours hands out, you question thhe SYSTEM.
If we re-move all illegals, all able bodied who are on welfare from that 15% our numberd would change.The Democrates only bring the very ill, very disabled and the very pathic before the camara for you to see.
ABE LINCO
LN SA
ID IT BEST ” You do not give to the poor from the wealthy, it removes the incentive for those who are providers and gives no incentive to those who are not.” Inother words, let the government set up care centers for the under privledged, let them set up hospitals for the welfare, or contract with a health care provider for these services, that would take the burden off of the cities that now pay horrible Hospital Taxes, set up schools for the illegals, that would remove some of the over burdening school taxes. I
f the Government wants to help, set up programs for the targeted people, BUT do not expect ALL AMERI
CANS to be treatede like those that won’t or refuse to accept responsibility. Stop the Rx over charging, Stop the Insurance Companies from setting rates so high, many ways to over come this problem, but making, forcing Americans to all fall into one catagory isSOCIALISM, and that is UN-AMERICAN !
Posted by: carole999 | August 29, 2009, 10:31 am 10:31 am
Our ” leaders” and I use the term loosly, should ALL be limited to two terms. That would stop the good ole boy system. All Public Servants elected should have what ever Health Insurance they can afford. And we all know most can afford the BEST.
No more private planes to fly back and forth to California Nancy, and no more paid for fun trips Mr. President. It is time for these people to realize they are SUPPOSED TO WORK FOR “US”.
When you go to the polls next time, look at hoew your representitives have spent your money, you may decide it is time for a change, but next time be sure what that change is. Obamanomics has not worked from the first week, and it progresses to fall down hill. He is offering you loss of freedoms, choices nad SOCIALISM………….that is not what America is about.
America offer OPPOR
TuN
ITY not a free lunch, not sit down and stick out your hand and the government will take care of you, if you want that go to a Socialist or Communitst Country. If you want Freedom of speech, which Nancy and Obama are certainly against if ANYTHING is said negitively about them, and they are now trying to reduce that freedom on all talk show host……wonder why ?
Be very atune to WHO you put into office….and be very careful what you allow the OBMA GROUP
to do.SPEAK UP AMERICANS.NOW BEFORE
IT IS TO LATE !
Posted by: carole999 | August 29, 2009, 10:40 am 10:40 am
So, we have a U.S. Senator and a Vice-President using profanity at Sen. Kennedy’s funeral, and the media is focusing on Mike Huckabee’s statements? Hmmm, this could be a good thing!
Posted by: Maxine | August 29, 2009, 10:54 am 10:54 am
What a clown – May Ted Kennedy rest in peace…….What ordinary Americans should be afraid of is the insurance companies telling them they can’t get the treatment they need because it’s too expensive. There’s the true death panel!!!
Posted by: deevulge | August 29, 2009, 10:58 am 10:58 am
Conservative politicians oppose death panels unless it’s the insurance companies that have them. Conservatives oppose abortion but love war. Conservatives like to preach to everyone while they worship their guns. Conservatives spew hate every chance they get, lie constantly, and go to bed with the big companies that line their pockets. They have no compassion for their fellow human being, no concern over the environment nor do they care about this country. They’re hypocrites-they go to church every Sunday while they lie and hate Mon-Sat. They have blinded many Americans into believing in all their lies. They are the true anti-Christ! They ONLY love MONEY – Shame on them.
Posted by: deevulge | August 29, 2009, 11:11 am 11:11 am
Huckabee said, under Obamacare not by means of his own wealth or the senate healthplan. Mike meant if Teddy was a mere mortal instead of the ruling elite! Plus Mike wasn’t playing politics, just the facts! Remember George is really on the other side, he is just feeding the flames.
Posted by: Ed Taylor | August 29, 2009, 11:18 am 11:18 am
Go home, take pain medication and die is probably what Kennedy heard at some point. When there is no hope for a cure, what better way to spend your last days that without pain and surrounded by your loved ones in your own home? Many people would certainly prefer that to being in a hospital bed, surrounded by all sorts of tubes and machines, when the outcome will ultimately be the same.
Posted by: Marie H | August 29, 2009, 11:19 am 11:19 am
Politics can be a very reprehensible and demeaning art form. In my opinion, American politics has gotten itself mired in a very smelly, very stagnant, and very dangerous swamp. This government, we as American citizens, and the world deserve much better from our politicians and from ourselves than what we have been subject to over the past 8 years and this past presidential campaign. We deserved better than the pitiful and ridiculous attempt to link candidate Obama with terrorists or the “he’s really a Muslim” smear tactics. We deserved better than “I can see Russia from where I live” or Joe The Plumber becoming a national celebrity. We deserve better than what we’re being subjected to now in the “health care debate” and the hysteria generated over non-existant “Death Panels.” Anybody remember the one tv political ad that effectively killed Barry Goldwater’s chances of becoming president – the atom bomb spot that only ran once but had such an enormous impact upon the voting public? Both Barry Goldwater and we deserved better than that. The atom bomb spot and the “Death Panels” were brilliantly conceived to generate unthinking hysteria in people’s minds, and both worked very well. But we, as a nation, deserved better than that.
We deserve a truly partisian-free, completely factual, and respectful debate that brings us together instead of driving us apart. We deserve a government guided by politicians who truly wish the best for all of us, “the people,” instead of what power they can generate for themselves. We deserve to have the best health care in the world instead of being ranked #37. The nation of San Marino has the 3rd best health care ranking in the world. Look it up. San Marino is not a readily-recognized name; however, according to the internet, it is the oldest sovereign state in the world. And it ranks #3 in health care. We deserve to have a better health care ranking than San Marino.
We deserve better.
Posted by: A senior citizen | August 29, 2009, 11:22 am 11:22 am
Anyone that wants to know where most of the cost of medicare is going should volunteer their time at the local nursing home. See for yourself. I know, I worked in the nursing home business for years. The largest cost in a persons lifetime is in their last 6 months of life. Healthcare workers have to provide any care available even when the person is dying, especially when there is no advanced directives. The hospital bills are enormous. Everyone who works is having to pay into Medicare, if we as a society want to cover any and all care possible then expect all workers to have that medicare tax be increased, substantially, because medicare is going insolvent soon. This is the same with a public option insurance plan. Private plans ration care.
Posted by: Pete | August 29, 2009, 11:25 am 11:25 am
Huckabee–More pandering to the lies from the right wing extremists who are loud enough to convince people they actually constitute some kind of majority. (Hope someone saves a copy of that to use against him when he’s up for re-election.)
People are frightened and angry because they have been LIED TO by news outlets such as Fox and Rush, who exploit and encourage fears (racism, xenophobia, classism, etc.) for the sake of ratings and power. Time to bring back the Fairness Doctrine! (The Repubs got rid of that, and rt. wing hate radio surfaced soon thereafter…coincidence?)
Something like 75% or more of the people who believe the myths out there get their info from Fox. Shameful. Time to hold journalism accountable.
Posted by: Deb | August 29, 2009, 11:25 am 11:25 am
I’m reading the bills (both of them) and though it’s a long slog, I’m not seeing anything about not being able to keep your own insurance, nor have I found anything about denial of services (or reduction to just “taking pills and waiting til the end”). Please annotate which section, page and version of the bills you are refering to. With regard to the end of life counseling: Aren’t those the same topics that we, as supposedly responsible adults, are supposed to talk to our doctors about anyways? But we don’t. Why? Because we are too scared to admit we will all die. Currently the doctors aren’t encouraged (paid) to bring up the subject and patients are too scared to bring it up, So doctors do all they can to keep you alive after any emergency (even if your wish was to just die), to prevent your family from suing them because they didn’t do “everything to save my granny!” As far as the reporting back part of the bill, “Yes we talked about this, this, and this.” That’s all that has to be reported back. We have minimums on car insurance coverage (there are minimums they have to cover), so why is there this big uproar over telling doctors “yes, we’ll pay you for these discussions as long as you cover this, this and this at a minimum.” ? The idiots who are saying this is only one step from wheeling 60 year olds into crematoriums to pick out their urn that they’ll get when they retire are just playing on emotions (fear in this case). They complained when Oregon passed its death with dignity act. Guess what, there hasn’t been a wave after wave of grannies and grampies being run into suicide booths by greedy doctors and family members. Really, all it’s done is to make death more open to discussion and made people understand that palliative care would be make the end less scary and life more manageable. Sometimes all they want to know is that they have some control left. When they know that, they may just choose to “exercise it” by choosing palliative care.With regard to Obama’s remark that seems to have started this firestorm, I concur with him. My grandfather has stage 4 lung cancer, emphysema, and COPD. What possible treatment could he go through that wouldn’t be as damaging as the disease? There comes a point in which trying to cure someone is futile and just becomes damaging and selfish.
Posted by: rayhagermann | August 29, 2009, 11:33 am 11:33 am
Kennedy would not have been needled under the proposed plan. The plan and the “advisers” contracted by the government would have stamped his health care needs as “necessary” so that he could continue his productive contribution to the political agenda. Anyone else that could not meet the litmus test of a “Return on Investment” would get denied care. Government involvement and the big cost associated with it is an echo from the past when health care became rationed to bring the cost under control. Are we really that euphoric with the panacea of universal health care where all people get quality equal treatment? There are way to many people that are short sighted to the fact that this plan sets the foundation to a return of an era where undesirables are denied care or even recommended for euthanasia. Anyone that knows their world history regarding nationalized health care either advocates atrocities of the past or are victims of the Pied-Pipers.
Posted by: TX_MBell | August 29, 2009, 11:36 am 11:36 am
We already have “death panels” ….. they’re called private insurance companies that decide who they will insure and deny services to those with “pre-existing conditions.” You idiots complain about have the government come between you and your doctor, but have no problem with for-profit companies coming between you and your doctor. I trust my government more than I trust an insurance company CEO.
Posted by: Guido | August 29, 2009, 11:40 am 11:40 am
Are all Republicans just plane ignorant? In our existing healthcare system, you die if you don’t have the money. Today you die when insurance companies turn you down and ignore your doctor’s requested treatment. INSURANCE COMPANIES KILL EVERY SINGLE DAY TODAY.
Republicans continue to sponsor these insurance companies that prectice murder. We get rationed healthcare today. The public option is to get rid of this practice. Republicans need to stop being so incredibly gullible and naive. (By the way, the world is really not flat.)
Posted by: Tim | August 29, 2009, 11:54 am 11:54 am
I don’t trust the Government to
handle my health care or any
part of my personal life. In
the health care plan, they are
not specific on anything. If you
ask about the end of life provision
they completely deny any death
panel, however, everybody seems
to know that it will be in the
bill. George, perhaps you should
get the truth about what you
are promoting. This bill will be
disaster. The elderly will suffer
beyond anyone’s expectations.
Posted by: marcie 12 | August 29, 2009, 11:56 am 11:56 am
The elderly will suffer beyond
anyone’s expectations if health
care passes. Perhaps you should
really read the bill, George.
It would be more than what Congress
has done. It will be disaster.
Posted by: marcie 12 | August 29, 2009, 11:59 am 11:59 am
It is very regretable that ABC speaks in
favor of this Administration, in partic-ular for President Obama. Time to
become objective and evaluate the danger
he is to the freedoms of our country.
Posted by: Ken | August 29, 2009, 12:09 pm 12:09 pm
Ted Kennedy traveled the road paid with good intentions and has arrived gloriously at its destination. May he RIP.
Posted by: HughAkston | August 29, 2009, 12:20 pm 12:20 pm
The legislation should be to address health care “Equal Rights”. There have been successful government grant programs for States. Programs for children and the needy. Companies that deny care should be taken to task through legislation. Legislation is the job of the congress. There should never be a “Government, Inc.” If the government can’t regulate the health insurance companies then the companies will be pulling the stings in any government program.
Posted by: TX_MBell | August 29, 2009, 12:21 pm 12:21 pm
Union payoff should get stripped from ObamaCare: Detroit News
$10B aimed at union retirees
Greg Mourad of the National Right to Work Committee called it “a shameless case of political payback,” saying Democrats and President Barack Obama are trying “to force the rest of us to pay billions to cover those unions’ health care.”
Posted by: michael | August 29, 2009, 12:27 pm 12:27 pm
I can’t decide what to do about Mitt Romney. He did start a state run health plan in Mass which was 1.5 billion short last year and his solution is to cut payments to (already overcrowed, overworked) hospitals. They also increased taxes on some things. He didn’t do anything about getting non-profit insurance companies or getting any tort reform. The answer always seems to be to raise taxes on somebody and cut doctor’s payments. The insurance companies and lawyers don’t have any skin in the game. Why don’t politicians refuse to take all those huge political contributions insurance co make to them? That money could be better used to treat uninsured. There is waste alright- but not where the pols choose to see it. I don’t think I trust Mitt Romney.
Posted by: teri | August 29, 2009, 12:32 pm 12:32 pm
“If you ask about the end of life provision they completely deny any death panel, however, everybody seems
to know that it will be in the bill.”
Who is “everybody?”
Posted by: Shomida Panels | August 29, 2009, 12:38 pm 12:38 pm
George you really annoy me. For a bright guy and a political commentator of your stature, you should be busy correcting all the misinformation that is being publicized. You know that there are no “death panels” being proposed. What is being proposed is the opportunity for people to discuss with their doctors their options for end of life care and their quality of life, to encourage discussion about these issues. I don’t know what Bill Clinton saw in you. You are a disappointment to your profession. You represent yellow journalism at it’s worst. You should be working for Fox News, or the National Enquirer.
Posted by: Deb | August 29, 2009, 12:48 pm 12:48 pm
Quote from President Obama’s Health Care Reform Advisor,
Dr. Ezekiel Emmanuel:
“[S]ervices provided to individuals who are irreversibly prevented from being or becoming participating citizens [in the body politic] are not basic and should not be guaranteed.”
Translation: if you can’t vote, you don’t deserve to live. Which, for advocates of the disabled, ought to give just a little pause. All those developmentally disabled adults dependent on charity and/or Uncle Sam for their bed and board? ‘Drop dead’. Anybody who’s had enough of a stroke that they can’t clearly articulate their wishes? ‘Drop Dead’ Dementia? Drop Dead. Mental illness? ‘Drop Dead’.
Which is especially cruel, because every one of those groups I just named really does need a little extra help from government(nothing special) and support for living, and we as a nation have supported them better than anyone else. But not any more, if the President and his ‘political utility’ squads have their way.
So when President Obama claims there will be no “death panels” in his health care reform plans, why then does he have Dr. Death as one of his health care reform advisers? Moreover, why is he reducing the Medicare budget by 500 billion when a 30% increase in enrollment is about to occur when the “baby boomer” generation turn 65? Where there is smoke there is fire. That is why so many people are rightly concerned about the government becoming a prime decision maker in how the health care dollar is spent.
At least in the private health care system health care providers are rewarded for keeping people alive and well as long as possible. Whereas in a government run system the incentive is to cut costs by denying care for your most costly clients (the elderly and disabled). Then all the money can go into the pockets of governments’ true clients, bigger and bigger bureaucracies and govt. union workers.
Posted by: Terry | August 29, 2009, 1:13 pm 1:13 pm
Because of pre-existing condition which does not require medication and for which I have never spent a minute in a hospital, I am uninsurable by any but the state assigned risk pool. Unfortunately the premium cost is more than the I clear. I am counting the minutes until I qualify for Medicare. If I have an accident or get ill, I am out of luck unless I spend hours in an emergency room running up a bill it will take me the rest of my life to pay. On the other hand my parents have had cancer, asthma, cataract, and other treatments in the thirty years they have been on Medicare with no worries. Funny as more and more people lose their jobs, they suddenly see how precarious health care is. Most of the 59+ year old engineers and IT people who are being replaced find out that there is no private healthcare market if you are over 25 and have ever had a cold! The people who do not want a strong national health plan are those who feel their job is secure, and there fore their healthcare is solid. I am amazed at Medicare patients who don’t want a government plan as they present their Medicare cards and gladly accept treatment….
Posted by: chidem | August 29, 2009, 1:21 pm 1:21 pm
More GOP politics of fear…….
Every factcheck organization out there has decried the death panels as nonsense, a fabrication, smear and fear tactic. But the GOP still calling the sky red….lives in their own cuckoo reality.
Stop “ditto”ing and think for yourselves.
Posted by: John | August 29, 2009, 1:39 pm 1:39 pm
chidem, The reason Medicare members are against health care reform is due to the fact it mandates a 500 billion dollar cut in funding. The argument that the cuts will not impact services is not believable. Even some Democrats are admitting that Medicare recipients will have to make “sacrifices” in order to help pay for the coverage of the 47 million more people.
Than there is Dr. Ezekiel Emmanuel, one of President Obama’s top health care providers who has stated:
“[S]ervices provided to individuals who are irreversibly prevented from being or becoming participating citizens [in the body politic] are not basic and should not be guaranteed.”
So when there is talk about “death panels” Medicare recipients know that the only way the government can cover an additional 47 million people is to cut care for them based on the criteria of President Obama’s “Dr. Death” who already has been appointed to serve on a Comparative Effectiveness Panel aka “Death Panel”.
Posted by: henry | August 29, 2009, 1:45 pm 1:45 pm
Most of you dont even have an idea what the public option is. medicare is a gov. program, is it killing the seniors right now? of course not. if you are against health care for all Americans, you must be an idiot.
Posted by: JKO | August 29, 2009, 1:49 pm 1:49 pm
I think Huckabee’s statement was inappropriate judging from the fact that what he is inferring is not even reflected in the health care bill. If anyone should know better it is people like Huckabee.
I am a Christian and unapologetically evangelical but I think we have make a mockery of what we believe by the way we have responded to this bill. We have acted more ignorant than I could ever have imagined.
We talk with both sides of our mouth on the debate of life and death. When was it ever not okay to embrace death if we have to? I thought we were taught that we have a better home in heaven. When did it become evil to recieve counseling so I can make a choice between the quality and the quantity of life for myself and my loved ones? Is Huckabee along with others on his side saying that we are not intellect enough to decide what we can do with the choices we are being presented?
If Christians can take politics out of this debate and report only the truth to people then we can begin to gain the respect we so deserve. As impossible as it sounds, we can disagree and still remain faithful to who we are as believers.
Posted by: Abi | August 29, 2009, 2:06 pm 2:06 pm
My $500 deductible Blue Shield health plan went from $150/month 6 years ago, to $820(!) a month this year. You conservatives really are a bunch of idiots. You have no problem with private insurance companies ripping off the public for PROFIT, while 20-30 MILLION Americans are shut out of health insurance because they can’t afford it, and the rest of us pay through the roof to buy it because we are lucky enough to afford it?
Posted by: Eric | August 29, 2009, 2:09 pm 2:09 pm
Abi, The best way “to take politics out of the debate” is to take politicians out of health care reform and make sure they don’t get a hold of more of the health care dollar. Politicians in control of more of the health care dollar means that decisions on who gets what health care will be made by politician and government bureaucrats, not the people. Think about it, politicians will be looking at who voted for them and how much money was contributed to their campaign and base decisions on who get what health care accordingly. So, I agree with you, if you want to “take politics out of the debate” make sure some sleazy and corrupt politician and/or bureaucrat does not have control over who the health care dollar is spent on. Thank you.
Posted by: Jim | August 29, 2009, 2:15 pm 2:15 pm
George, Pelosi started this well before Huckabee weighed in. She started the let’s vote this for the gipper. Then Byrd said let’s name the bill after Kennedy. The fact is that he democrats are the ones that are trying to use kennedy’s death as the ploy. The fcat remains that the president consistantly claims things are not in the bill that are in the bill. And dems keep getting upset that average ameicans have the audacity not to listen to their lies, but actually ask questions. Don’t those simple minded folks know that obama is the wisest man in the land and you are suppose to sit and listen and not challenge him. The liberal media like George understand that. Yes, sir, you are absoluetly right, yes, we will distort the reasl image for you to prove you are right. And that black man who was beat up by your lackies, well, if he votes conservatives and complains, he can’t really be black, can he?
Posted by: Bruce | August 29, 2009, 2:20 pm 2:20 pm
As someone who has not managed to get a copy of the heath bill let alone time to read it carefully, I’m wondering if
the people who are commenting have gotten a copy, where they got it, and
would they mind quoting a few passages so I can get a better handle on it. Just quoting pundits from one side or the other doesn’t really help my understanding. I do know this – the government is already running a health care plan (Medicare) whether you like ir or not (and many do). And if so many of you are for keeping the government out of your doctor’s office, where were you for the pro-choice debates and the
Terry Schiavo circus?
Posted by: Louise | August 29, 2009, 2:22 pm 2:22 pm
Eric, The reason health care premiums are so high is all due to government regulations and mandates on the private insurance industry. Take the government mandates out of the picture and Insurance costs would dramatically go down. The government now forbids private insurance from tailoring plans to the needs and pocket books of individuals. There are over 1000 government mandates now that most people don’t want or need but have to pay for because they are being mandated for by government.
Another reason for the high cost of health insurance is due to the fact government does not allow insurance companies to market their insurance across State lines. If this restriction was lifted health insurance costs would go down even further.
Not to mention TORT reform. Make sense?
Posted by: Gary | August 29, 2009, 2:31 pm 2:31 pm
I READ SEVERAL GOOD LEGIT BOOKS BEFORE THE ELECTION ABOUT OBAMA . SOMETHING THAT EVERYBODY SHOULD HAVE DONE…YOU WOULD NOT HAVE BEEN SURPRISED OVER WHAT HE HAS BEEN DOING OR IS GOING TO DO….IT WAS ALL THERE IN THE BOOK “THE OBAMANATION”……WE ARE ALL RESPONSIBLE FOR OUR DECISIONS AND ACTIONS OR LACK THEREOF…..
Posted by: MARGIE G. | August 29, 2009, 2:32 pm 2:32 pm
AND IF KENNEDY HAD BEEN ONE OF US WE WOULD STILL BE IN JAIL FOR LEAVING THE SCENE OF A CRIME AND NEGLIGENT HOMICIDE FOR NOT HELPING MARY JO OUT OF OUR CAR…..
Posted by: MARGIE G. | August 29, 2009, 2:35 pm 2:35 pm
Those who object to “socialized medicine” and oppose “government control” over health issues, okay–then please, if (1) you are a veteran do NOT go to the VA Hospitals, see VA doctors, receive VA government subsidized medicines; (2) retired, do not apply for or receive social security benefits or medicare or medicaid; (3) are a student, do not go to public high schools, public libraries, public swimming pools; (4) a homeowner, do not call the public fire department or police–for all of these are socialist programs run by the USA government. The “death panels” sit on the boards of the insurance companies and decide if you can have an operation or if they will cancel your policies. Vote Palin/Huckabee and get rid of all government services (listed above) and end all federal subsidies to road, bridge, dam construction, let the interstate go back to being a field of weeds, end the military service, shut down all jails and prisons, end EPA and clean environment laws–and you will have a nonsocialized government. Those who say “keep the government’s hands off my medicare” need to know that medicare is a government program and they would be better off committing suicide than accepting socialized medicine–that is what Palin/Huckabee want–no socialism in the USA.
Posted by: Dr Arthur Frederick Ide | August 29, 2009, 2:38 pm 2:38 pm
I have been a nurse for over 20 yrs without health insurance.The comment Mr Huckabee made I will first respond by the question”what do you think Hospice actually does?’Hospice is “pallative care.”This means patients are sent home or in a hospital setting and given pain patches ,Patient controlled morphine IV’s,as well as strong pain medication.The combination of these meds would drop a horse.These people are “no codes”.So what do you think we have now?I have severe sleep apnea and genetic lymphedema with no insurance.I have no breathing machine and have waited months for help.16,000 americans die every year waiting for disability approval alone.How dare anyone twist and turn helping into a “death squad”etc.
Posted by: sue | August 29, 2009, 2:45 pm 2:45 pm
Huckabee must have misplaced whatever small amount of sanity he appeared to have.
Posted by: Jon | August 29, 2009, 2:47 pm 2:47 pm
Of course Ted Kennedy had better health care than other people. He was fabulously wealthy, and the wealthy can always command more resources than others. But in other developed countries people under 65 are guaranteed at least a decent standard of health care. In America today, the only people who have that are seniors, and why they begrudge decent health care for others is hard for me to understand.
Posted by: Oozy | August 29, 2009, 3:06 pm 3:06 pm
Dr Arthur Frederick Ide , In a private health care system you always have a choice to change plans or appeal a decision or sue for that matter. In a government run system, there are no choices, you can’t change plans, some impersonal bureaucrat bases who gets what health care if any based on “Dr. Death’s” Comparative “Political” Worth criteria with no appeals and you can’t sue the government, they have all the power. Think about it.
Posted by: Terry | August 29, 2009, 3:08 pm 3:08 pm
Dr Arthur Frederick Ide, The track record of government run health care is very bad so why would anyone in their right mind want to impose such a proven bad system on the whole US? At least in the private sector you can still sue if you get a bad deal. In a government run system you have no recourse no matter how bad the health care is.
The bottom line is that with out any profit (as in a private run system), corruption and fraud will dominate just like it is now in the government run programs like Medicare and Medicaid. At least with profit a motive, people will try and do a good job to please their patients and get their business. With government being the only game in town, people will try and game the system and political favoritism will rule the day. In a government run system the goal will not be to try and do a good job so people with be happy with your service, the goal will be to try and bribe the powers to be in government and commit as much fraud as possible. Third world America here we come if HR 3200 is approved as we have seen on the Indian Reservations where government runhealth care is a big failure.
Moreover, if a Public Option is approved, the private health care system (that the vast majority of people are very happy with) will eventually cease to exist. Once the people find out that Congress is more interested in promoting a government run system (with a proven track record of incompetence, fraud and waste) and intent on destroying the private system that meets the needs of the vast majority of its patients, THEY WILL BE VOTED OUT OF OFFICE.
Posted by: Winston | August 29, 2009, 3:14 pm 3:14 pm
Listening to the republicans and their contrived garbage one would think that they didn’t leave America with the worst recession in history. The stench of republican failure hangs still. When Clinton left office, we were 18 billion dollars a year from a balanced budget. When Bush left office, we were 900 billion from a balanced budget. To hear these scum balls blame the dems and Obama for their horrible self-serving fiscal policies is sickening. Health care reform now! Republicans serve only themselves.
Posted by: mikey | August 29, 2009, 3:14 pm 3:14 pm
hello
Posted by: j p romansic | August 29, 2009, 3:21 pm 3:21 pm
Even our beyond IDIOT politicians are not going to put a term like “DEATH PANEL” in a bill, but when the bill is put in action and BOTTOM LINE decisions are made, the elderly will receive EXACTLY what Mr. Huckabee and Mrs. Palin said. The problem as i see it, with private you have a few avenues if you’re not satisfied, NOT MANY, but a few, but if all you have is the government, when they say no more treatment, because its no longer COST EFFECTIVE, you do like the OLD CHIEF in the movies, you see the poor old frail Indian walking off into the DESERT to die !!!!!!!!! But the people are right, senators WON’T have to face those problems !!!!!!! We need TERM LIMITS, one term and you’re gone ……….!!!
Posted by: wildbill69 | August 29, 2009, 3:21 pm 3:21 pm
huck is a joke-rich folks are always gonna get better care-we the average joe have death panels right now-that would be the insurance companies the dug companies and the medical profession in general-its like no money no treatment-at least with the stuff obama is pushin we would have at least basic stuff-which we dont have now-
Posted by: j p romansic | August 29, 2009, 3:25 pm 3:25 pm
THIS MESS STARTED WITH CLINTON’S NAFTA BILL AND HAS JUST GOTTEN WORSE….WE ARE ALL TO BLAME FOR NOT HOLDING OUR ELECTED OFFICIALS RESPONSIBLE FOR THEIR VOTES AND ACTIONS
Posted by: MARGIE G. | August 29, 2009, 3:28 pm 3:28 pm
I’m 64, white and have no health care. I couldn’t afford to keep it when I had to quit work to care for an ailing father and a disabled father.My husband and I live on Social Security and I can’t wait till I can qualify for Medicare; a program we have because of Ted Kennedy and other Democrats.I know how it feels to live in fear that you will become ill and loose every thing because of medical bills. My daughter works to pay the thousand dollars a month to keep her family’s insurance and still has over $100,000 in medical bills for her daughters recent illness and that is after insurance paid what they would. We need health care reform, like Obama and Ted Kennedy envisioned.
Posted by: sandra french | August 29, 2009, 3:31 pm 3:31 pm
Even if Senator Kennedy was denied care under the Obama healthplan, all he has to do is pay for the radiation treatments and chemotherapy out of pocket because he has lots of money.
Posted by: fann | August 29, 2009, 3:35 pm 3:35 pm
j p romansic, You are pretty naive to think government will provide you with the “basic” stuff. Remember what President Obama said about that needed surgery for Grand ma? Quote: “Maybe she would be better off just taken a pill instead of getting that surgery.” that would make her life better. Than there is the Indian Reservations where basic services are not being provided by government run health care.
Keep in mind, once the government has control over the health care dollar the bulk of the money will go into the pockets of governments main clients, government union workers, the politicians and the bureaucrats. Whatever crumbs are left over will go to the people and it won’t include any “basic care” you can count on it.
Posted by: Jim | August 29, 2009, 3:36 pm 3:36 pm
George hasn’t changed. He has always been a fool. That is all the major networks will hire. A fool is the only person that will spew the garbage of the major networks. That ie why we don’t tune in.
Posted by: Ginny Rosebush | August 29, 2009, 3:42 pm 3:42 pm
wow, if half of this is true, we elderly should be very concerned, for me it smells of genocide aginst the old folks. an any body else with disabilities. think of the money to be saved. sounds a lot like nazi germany. everything for the state. wow. im 62 an im worried
Posted by: mike | August 29, 2009, 3:50 pm 3:50 pm
So, rayhagermann, you are reading the bills and “not seeing anything about not being able to keep your own insurance”. Then you must not be reading HR3200:
Start with this statement from Page 19, lines 1-5:
=== IN GENERAL.—Individual health insurance coverage that is not grandfathered health insurance coverage under subsection (a) may only be offered on or after the first day of Y1 as an Exchange-participating health benefits plan.===
We can establish thus far that, as of January 1, 2013, all health insurance plans must be either a) an “Exchange-participating” benefits plan, or b) a grandfathered plan.
An “Exchange-participating” benefits plan is, essentially, any plan that is “qualified” under HR 3200, according to qualification rules that will be determined and implemented by the government.
So, what is a “grandfathered” plan? From the rhetoric coming from Obama, one would assume that all currently existing plans would be “grandfathered”. Not so.
According to Page 16, lines 3-26, Section 102,
=== PROTECTING THE CHOICE TO KEEP CURRENT COVERAGE:
GRANDFATHERED HEALTH INSURANCE COVERAGE DEFINED.—Subject to the succeeding provisions of this section, for purposes of establishing acceptable coverage under this division, the term ‘‘grandfathered health insurance coverage’’ means individual health insurance coverage that is offered and in force and effect before the first day of Y1 if the following conditions are met:
(1) LIMITATION ON NEW ENROLLMENT.—
(A) IN GENERAL.—Except as provided in this paragraph, the individual health insurance issuer offering such coverage does not enroll any individual in such coverage if the first effective date of coverage is on or after the first day of Y1.
(B) DEPENDENT COVERAGE PERMITTED.—Subparagraph (A) shall not affect the subsequent enrollment of a dependent of an individual who is covered as of such first day.
(2) LIMITATION ON CHANGES IN TERMS OR CONDITIONS.—Subject to paragraph (3) and except as required by law, the issuer does not change any of its terms or conditions, including benefits and cost-sharing, from those in effect as of the day before the first day of Y1.===
See that? Not all pre-existing plans will be considered as “grandfathered”; but rather only those that meet two very important conditions. To be considered “grandfathered”, a plan must:
1.Exist prior to January 1, 2013,
2.Not enroll any new members on or after January 1, 2013 (except for adding dependents to existing plans, and
3.Not change any of its terms or conditions on or after January 1, 2013
Now, how tenable are those requirements? Not very.
Are you insured through your employer? Do you think that your company will hire any new employees on or after January 1, 2013? Do you think that your employer will want to add those new employees to the company insurance plan? Do you think that your company might want to negotiate new or better coverage, or changes to deductibles, or make any other routine changes to your plan?
Of course. And if so, your insurance plan will no longer be grandfathered. Once it is no longer grandfathered, it will be subject to government control and subject to the requirements and qualifications for “Exchange-participating” plans.
Posted by: jasmine | August 29, 2009, 3:52 pm 3:52 pm
sandra french, You must live in dream land if you think government will answer all your prayers when it comes to health care or anything else for that matter. Medicare and Medicaid are going bankrupt. Health Care on the Indian Reservations is a failure. The deficit has risen to over 9 TRILLION dollars under President Obama, more than all the other Presidents combined.
The bottom line is when government gets control over the health care dollar, like rats on a sinking ship, they will save themselves first, and let everyone else drown. As the ship sinks, more and more cuts will be made in health care and other critical services in order to save as many union worker jobs as possible.
That is what is happening right now in California. Instead of laying off CA union workers, the Democratic controlled legislature is making cuts in critical services that would never happen in the private sector. In the private sector, the critical services are maintained and administrative staff and non essential personal are cut so critical services can still be maintained. The opposite occurs in government.
Think about it. The government is already broke so they will use the people’s money to save themselves first. The people, us, will be last in line. Bottom line, don’t tie your hopes to a sinking ship that is already bankrupt.
Posted by: jason | August 29, 2009, 3:55 pm 3:55 pm
Don, You and I voted for this guy, you have blinders on I do not. I am no longer a dem nor a rep, I am an AMERICAN. BEWARE WASHINGTON, WE THE PEOPLE ARE FIGHTING BACK.
Posted by: Robert | August 29, 2009, 4:09 pm 4:09 pm
And ray, you also said this:
“Currently the doctors aren’t encouraged (paid) to bring up the subject and patients are too scared to bring it up”.
So, ray, are you saying that you routinely accompany people when they visit their doctors?
NO?
Then how would YOU know what they do or say? You don’t.
You are just regurgitating the Dem talking points. I imagine you go about and talk about how doctors run tests and don’t bother to send the results on to the next doctor. (are you psychic?)
And also how pediatricians refer to the reimbursement tables to see how much they will make from prescribing antibiotics as opposed to removing a child’s tonsils. BTW – Obama said that, but he forgot about the fact that pediatricians don’t remove tonsils, SURGEONS DO. Was he saying that doctors are in cahoots with surgeons and get kickbacks?
And this is to that earlier poster who referred to the WHO study that said the U.S. ranked 37th in health care among industrialized nations. You forgot to mention WHY we were ranked so low:
=== The WHO judged a country’s quality of health on life expectancy.
But that’s a lousy measure of a health-care system. Many things that cause premature death have nothing do with medical care. We have far more fatal transportation accidents than other countries. That’s not a health-care problem.
Similarly, our homicide rate is 10 times higher than in the U.K., eight times higher than in France, and five times greater than in Canada.
When you adjust for these “fatal injury” rates, U.S. life expectancy is actually higher than in nearly every other industrialized nation.
=== Diet and lack of exercise also bring down average life expectancy.
=== Another reason the U.S. didn’t score high in the WHO rankings is that we are less socialistic than other nations.
What has that got to do with the quality of health care? For the authors of the study, it’s crucial. The WHO judged countries not on the absolute quality of health care, but on how “fairly” health care of any quality is “distributed.” The problem here is obvious. By that criterion, a country with high-quality care overall but “unequal distribution” would rank below a country with lower quality care but equal distribution.
Posted by: jasmine | August 29, 2009, 4:09 pm 4:09 pm
if this country can survive 8 years republican rule,turning a Clinton surplus into a massive debt,we will again lead the world with leadership like our president now has.
Posted by: glen | August 29, 2009, 4:10 pm 4:10 pm
Will the media please do a documentary series on the truth of what is and will be proposed for the health care bill? The criticism of the bill is inappropriately lambasted as political fear mongering or the tirade of morons. Many people fear the repeat of Germany’s history regarding the cost of over extended health care and the resulting deaths of people no longer considered life worthy. Rather than demeaning people who have real concerns why not present the facts and how this health care agenda could never lead us to government sponsored brutality and feared persecution. The current health care system abandons people to die by not covering the cost of care they need. We don’t need a system that leads to the government doing the same and sanctioning who is worthy to live or die.
Posted by: TX_MBell | August 29, 2009, 4:13 pm 4:13 pm
This story is not about republicants and demodonts. You people better wake up and smell the coffee. This is about revolution and socialism. Look who Obama has appointed to give him and the country guidance. This issue of health care is nothing more than a ruse. The socialist are trying to make sure you take your eye off the prize and thats cap and trade. This Oligarchy that is in power right now is bad for America, and Americans are finally waking up. The only people who are saying positive things about this admin is Chavez and Castro. I say vote all these idiots out of office and start fresh. Set term limits for each of these offices. The only thing I want to know and this question has been asked of famous people before. Who in the heck is paying for Ted Kennedy’s funeral and all the traffic cops. I hope its not me.
Posted by: Greg McWhorter | August 29, 2009, 4:23 pm 4:23 pm
glen, What leadership?
9 TRILLION dollar deficit, more than all other Presidents combined.
9.8 % unemployment (some say 16%)
StimulusmMoney being wasted on pork barrel projects and into the pockets of corrupt organizations like ACORN. Where’s the stimulus money going into? Not job creation that’s for sure.
Iran and North Korea thumbing their nose at us and going ahead with their nukes.
Scotland and the UK releasing the Lockerbie bomber against our protests.
American troops still in Iraq and Afghanistan turning into a possible defeat for the US.
etc etc etc
Bottom line is blaming Bush won’t work any more.
Posted by: Nelson | August 29, 2009, 4:24 pm 4:24 pm
All of you people agreeing with Huckabee are just plain nutty. There is no final bill yet, so NO ONE can say with any certainty what will be in a final bill; if there is a final bill. You people are in full fear mode. And like all humans in fear mode, your ability to reason has been put on the back shelf.
Posted by: Beowolfe | August 29, 2009, 4:40 pm 4:40 pm
Fred, I’m afraid you’re comparing apples and oranges. Kennedy’s opinion on Bork was just that, an opinion and it couldn’t be checked one way or the other. He ‘felt’ that Bork should not be on the court and he acted accordingly. In the case of health insurance reform and Kennedy, there is nothing in either of the bills that is being floated around that would have caused Kennedy even if he had been covered under any of them to be told to go home take a pill and die. There is nothing in either of the bills that would place seniors in any more jeopardy of having a procedure rejected than they are in under the current system. I’d wager tht NONE of you agreeing with Huckabee have read any of the bills circulating through congress. Like all mentally lazy people (and yes, Americans have generally become mentally lazy) you are relying on someone else having read them and to tell you the truth. They are not telling you the truth. They are lying to you for their own purposes. If you look at all of the health insurance reform efforts in our history, you will find the same patter. But, you’d have to not be mentally lazy to know that.
Posted by: Beowolfe | August 29, 2009, 4:46 pm 4:46 pm
Greg McWhorter said: “The socialist are trying to make sure you take your eye off the prize and thats cap and trade.”
Besides Cap & Trade, there’s THIS:
=== Bill would give president emergency control of Internet
Internet companies and civil liberties groups were alarmed this spring when a U.S. Senate bill proposed handing the White House the power to disconnect private-sector computers from the Internet.
They’re not much happier about a revised version that aides to Sen. Jay Rockefeller, a West Virginia Democrat, have spent months drafting behind closed doors. CNET News has obtained a copy of the 55-page draft of S.773 (excerpt), which still appears to permit the president to seize temporary control of private-sector networks during a so-called cybersecurity emergency.
The new version would allow the president to “declare a cybersecurity emergency” relating to “non-governmental” computer networks and do what’s necessary to respond to the threat. ===
If this should be passed and something, ANYTHING, happens that they can call a “cybersecurity emergency”, then they will not hesitate to take all non-government servers off of the internet.
Let’s recap what they have done, or tried to do, so far, since Obama was elected:
- Set up flag.gov (for people to turn in their neighbors, friends, famile, etc.)
- removed restrictions on gov websites downloading cookies on our computers.
- hired independent companies to download tracking cookies on our computers.
- submitted a bill to give the President control of the internet in “emergencies”
- laid the groundwork and started the process of setting up a “civilian security force” as large and as well-funded as the military
- systematically undermined the capabilities of the CIA
They have been very busy, haven’t they?
What have I overlooked? Or what do we not know about?
Read about the Cloward-Piven Strategy of Orchestrated Crisis:
=== The strategy of forcing political change through orchestrated crisis. The “Cloward-Piven Strategy” seeks to hasten the fall of capitalism by overloading the government bureaucracy with a flood of impossible demands, thus pushing society into crisis and economic collapse. ===
(BTW – I think I graduated high school in 1972 with someone by the name of Greg McWhorter. Probably your dad? LOL)
Posted by: jasmine | August 29, 2009, 4:49 pm 4:49 pm
The only reason Obama is pushing this health care is because the Democrats control everything. You want to make health care affordable? Make the illegals pay taxes and stop treating them in the emergency rooms for free. And DON’T give them social security like you plan. They didn’t pay for it. WE DID.
Posted by: Barbara | August 29, 2009, 4:52 pm 4:52 pm
Kennedy and Obama’s Granny both would be allowed to pass …with comfort care, not to lay in pain.
Posted by: David M | August 29, 2009, 4:58 pm 4:58 pm
Greg asked “Who in the heck is paying for Ted Kennedy’s funeral and all the traffic cops. I hope its not me.”
Well, you (and me and everybody else) ARE probably footing the bill for some of it – the police, the military flight to carry his body from Boston to D.C., etc.
BTW (and speaking of C&T), has anyone come up with the “carbon footprint” from driving and flying Kennedy’s body, his huge family and all those “dignitaries” all over the East Coast these last two days?
Bet its astronomical!
And I saw that they used SUV’s, too!
For shame
(Or maybe it was that my DAUGHTER went to school with a Greg McWhorter, or was it that my son played bball w him? All of this within the last 10 years. LOL. I forget.)
Posted by: jsamine | August 29, 2009, 5:01 pm 5:01 pm
Huckabee is 100% correct. If Kennedy had been treated under the ObamaCare plan at his age, he would not have gotten the excellent treatment that he did. He would not longer be considered “productive” enough to recieve life saving treatment simply because of his age. This according to Dr. Ezekiel Emanuel who is health policy advisor to President Obama and brother of Obama’s right hand man and chief of staff, Rham Emauel so his opinons hold a lot of weight with the current administration. Dr. E. Emauel is not a medical doctor. His views on rationing of healthcare due to age and condition are simply frightening.
Emanuel thinks we need to ration basic, guaranteed care to only those who can fully participate in society. His view leaves out the very young, the disabled and most of all our seniors. If you have ahy doubts about how his views have helped to shape the current ObamaCare bill, simply read the bill for yourself. As Albert Einstein said: “We believe that an informed citizenry will act for life and not for death.”
Posted by: Pam | August 29, 2009, 5:05 pm 5:05 pm
Healthcare for the masses? Yes, lets drop the seniors who fought for and built the country and use the money to buy the votes of the masses who are to stupid to understand what’s being done
to our country.
Posted by: davetoo | August 29, 2009, 5:12 pm 5:12 pm
Mr. Bush and GOP congressmen and senators repeated many times that Medicare will go bankrupt in a few years. Nothing had changed for the better, and if we don’t slow down Medicare growth its bankruptcy gets closer every day. Shouting down any attempt to restrict this mushrooming program as “rationing” and “pulling plug on grandma” doesn’t change this. What will the old folks who now yell “don’t touch my Medicare” do in 10 or 15 years when the Chinese will not lend us any more money to keep them covered?
Posted by: Richie | August 29, 2009, 5:13 pm 5:13 pm
I see that fear of death makes people irrational. Kennedy had a death sentence with his brain cancer, and no medical technology anywhere would have helped him. If you’re going to compare to his situation under “Obamacare” then exactly what is the *alternative* that you think Obamacare eliminates? A few extra months on a heart-and-lung machine while you’re in a coma? Or how about a few extra surgeries that won’t affect the outcome at all? If you’re afraid of death, go deal with the fear instead of spending the rest of society’s money to have another week of life in a coma. I’ve never understood Christians’ fear of death when they should be delighted to go meet Jesus in person once they are done on this earth.
Fear clearly lowers IQ by 50%.
Posted by: Seer | August 29, 2009, 5:14 pm 5:14 pm
many here are missing the point. ted was a man of principle …by that i mean, his political beliefs are from the heart, and his principals are what he was made of. and yeah, i know, lots of people are whining about the new med bill. maybe you have good jobs, and excellent insurances plans – bully for you! but what about the millions and millions who have no insurance? should they continue to be kicked to the curb? truly great civilizations are judged by how they treat the least of their citizens: you know, the elderly, the hungry and the sick. even the struggling middle class will benefit by lower prices and affordable prescriptions. what is so bad about that?
Posted by: eric | August 29, 2009, 5:14 pm 5:14 pm
“Specter: Town Hall Meetings Are ‘Not Really Representative Of America’ ”
I say, What could be more representitive of America, sitting down and giving in to something you do not beleive in?
America was born on citizen disapproval of government, where is Specter comming from? Another planet? Or, is he just following the socialist party line!
Posted by: David from Massachusetts | August 29, 2009, 5:19 pm 5:19 pm
In response to kennedy and Ma. changing the law in filling his seat in the senate…..
KENNEDY WAS THE DRIVING FORCE TO CHANGE IT IN THE FIRST PLACE IN ORDER TO KEEP ROMNEY FROM FILLING IT IN THE EVENT KERRY GOT ELECTED PRESIDENT…..NOW THE DEMONcRATS (and kennedy, before his death) WANT TO CHANGE IT BACK TO WHAT IT WAS ORIGIONALLY….Talk about slimy politicians…..Look to Deval Patric getting the call…..he be bro’s wid da prez, ya know’s.
Posted by: David from Massachusetts | August 29, 2009, 5:24 pm 5:24 pm
Someday, someone will have the ##### to say that we should NOT be spending a trillion dollars on futile care for seniors in the their last few months of life. No one says they are worth less but heroic measures to keep people alive who the Lord is calling home is stupid and helping to bankrupt this country.
Posted by: Tim H | August 29, 2009, 5:26 pm 5:26 pm
People must be living in a dream land if they think government will answer all their prayers when it comes to health care or anything else for that matter. Medicare and Medicaid are going bankrupt. Health Care on the Indian Reservations is a failure. The deficit has risen to over 9 TRILLION dollars under President Obama, more than all the other Presidents combined.
The bottom line is when government gets control over the health care dollar, like rats on a sinking ship, they will save themselves first, and let everyone else drown. As the ship sinks, more and more cuts will be made in health care and other critical services in order to save as many union worker jobs as possible.
That is what is happening right now in California. Instead of laying off CA union workers, the Democratic controlled legislature is making cuts in critical services that would never happen in the private sector. In the private sector, administrative staff and non essential personal are cut so critical services can still be maintained. The opposite occurs in government.
Think about it. The government is already broke so they will use the people’s money to save themselves first. The people, us, will be last in line (unless your of political “worth” that is). Bottom line, don’t tie your hopes to a sinking ship that is about to go bankrupt.
Posted by: jason | August 29, 2009, 5:28 pm 5:28 pm
For all you folks who like to say that the Republicans “just say no” and haven’t offered any positive ideas of their own, have you heard about HR3218?
This is probably the first time you’ve ever heard of it because the msm (ABC, CBS, NBC, CNN, etc) won’t report on it.
== HR 3218 would greatly expand the availability of insurance, create market incentives like refundable tax credits to help lower and middle-income workers afford coverage if their employers don’t provide it, and create a high-risk pool so that people with pre-existing conditions could get affordable coverage. ==
Why don’t you check into it and if you like it, ask your Congressman to co-sponsor it?
Posted by: jasmine | August 29, 2009, 5:30 pm 5:30 pm
You guys need to go back to the basics…
the basics are the path to the future..
start with 8 years ago..
before Obama…
Posted by: healthcareweneed | August 29, 2009, 5:59 pm 5:59 pm
While I am not a Democrat nor a supporter of President Obama, the reports of “Death Squads” directed at the nation’s Senior Citizens are no more true that our President’s statement that surgeons such as myself amputate people’s legs to earn $50,000.
People don’t sign a medical consent to amputate their leg unless life threatening gangrene is present. A doc’s payment from Medicare for such an operation is about $800.
Both the polictical left and right are playing loose with the facts.
God bless us all.
Mark Sanders MD
Posted by: Mark Sanders MD | August 29, 2009, 6:13 pm 6:13 pm
Number one, to listen to anything Huckabee says is ridiculous. He truly believes there is no such thing as evolution or global warming. He is a religious whackjob.
Number two, the health care proposal that Kennedy championed his entire career was for EVERYBODY to have the same health care he has always had. Lets make something VERY clear, FOR PROFIT insurance companies make the choice as to what treatments are done. The current proposal does not stop anybody from purchasing their own insurance (either on their own, or through their employer). It also does not stop wealthy people from paying out of pocket for any treatment they choose.
Posted by: John | August 29, 2009, 6:19 pm 6:19 pm
Everytime the republicans MENTION a death panel I get angry!
I get angry every day when I PAY for “REPUBLICAN” politican health care!!
Every politican today is getting health care from the taxes of the American taxpayer!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Posted by: healthcareweneed | August 29, 2009, 6:27 pm 6:27 pm
Instead of believing all the wacko right wing lies, go to factcheck and see that this BS about being sent home to die is not true. You idiots are being led around by the ring in your nose. Also Congress has the same medical insurance as other federal employees. If anyone wants added coverage they may obtain it on their own
Go to Factcheck and verify and stop the lies.
Posted by: Rich | August 29, 2009, 6:34 pm 6:34 pm
That’s what my mom was basically told–and that’s under the care we currently have.
Posted by: Fluffy Singler | August 29, 2009, 6:37 pm 6:37 pm
All you folks who believe in global warming, the joke is on YOU. People like Al Gore are getting rich of of the global warming hysteria that THEY created.
Posted by: jasmine | August 29, 2009, 6:38 pm 6:38 pm
I am amazed at the conservative fortune tellers who can see into the future how legislation will turn out without even reading the facts about specific legislation. It seems to be easier on the mental facilities to just listen to the lies of the Right and not have to evaluate information. For almost all those posting negative comments they are likely to have been affected by at least one of Ted’s 550 bills he authored. Those of you against the health care bills should read them first and understand there is no final bill. Try to be a responsible American and THINK. Read. get facts. Use logical thinking concepts
(that may be difficult for most of you.).
Posted by: Leslie Gaskins | August 29, 2009, 6:43 pm 6:43 pm
I do believe that jasmine has bought into every right wing distortion out there.
Posted by: Rudy | August 29, 2009, 6:48 pm 6:48 pm
I think all you folks who are so hot to get Obamacare enacted need to answer ONE question….
If its so great, then why do ALL versions of the bill in the House and in the Senate exempt the members of Congress, Federal Employees and members of certain unions (SEIU) from the plan?
Why?
Its a simple question. Ask your Congressman and Senators that question. See if they will give you a straight answer.
I’ll bet they won’t.
Posted by: jasmine | August 29, 2009, 6:51 pm 6:51 pm
May we focus on the things on which we agree, rather than those where we disagree? Do we agree that pre-existing conditions should not be a reason for denying health care? Do we agree that insurance should survive when you become sick, and need it? Do we agree that health care costs are going up, fast, and we need to look at ways to contain them? Then let us do these things on which we agree. Shrieking about these imaginary “death panels” is just a scare tactic put forward by the insurance companies who want to protect their profits, not you–it’s not in the bill, any of the bills currently being considered, and no rational politician will ever consider them. Suggesting that they are the logical outcome of a responsible discussion with your doctor about what to do in the event you are not able to give directions is false–I have had exactly that discussion, and committed my wishes to paper, duly notarized by my lawyer. I understand the fear of death. Truly. As a result of adverse prescription drug reactions, I could have died on three occasions. I want my doctor to know what to do. It’s irresponsible not to give those instructions. Fearing death is a part of who we are. Making responsible provisions for something we know is inevitable is a part of being adults.
And to those of you who have posted unfavorable comments regarding the late Senator–All of us will eventually die. I’m sorry, but it’s true. I hope your family won’t have to read that kind of nonsense while your funeral is in progress.
And to Mr. Huckabee–you were trained as a pastor. If your actual intent was to hold Mr. Kennedy up as a positive example of somebody who used his last year effectively, are you sure you would have wanted to draw the conclusion that his life work was in error in the presence of one of your parishoners at exactly this time?
With regard to those who have objected to Democrats who have suggested naming the bill after Mr. Kennedy, or who want to win one last victory for this lion of the Senate–actually, it’s not a two-way street. When a soldier is killed, or a teammate is injured, it is socially acceptable to fight for one last victory on his behalf. It’s not even unusual. I can think of many memorials to the fallen that are attempts to do good. Perhaps you’ve been to a hospital, or a church, or have volunteered time or money to a foundation named for someone who is dead. Many families ask for donations to a charity in lieu of flowers at a funeral. Taking care of the sick–that sounds like the kind of memorial that ennobles the America I love.
Posted by: Gerry | August 29, 2009, 7:04 pm 7:04 pm
Huckabee surely knows we already have death panels . They are called private insurance companies . They decide to let people die every day all across this country by denying care for a variety of excuses but ultimately to avoid paying claims .
Posted by: otiebug | August 29, 2009, 7:15 pm 7:15 pm
You know what??
YOU don’t hold a candle to me..
I PAY for your republican health care and you deny mine???
Posted by: healthcareweneed | August 29, 2009, 7:17 pm 7:17 pm
and this is any different than the for-profit “death panels” that exist in the form of insurance companies? New York State forbids insurers from excluding individuals for pre-existing conditions. Oh, forgive me; New York is a LIBERAL state. Wake up, people……any proposal is better than the system we have now.
Posted by: paul | August 29, 2009, 7:17 pm 7:17 pm
Obama will fail as a president simply because everybody’s opinion of him is low. He talks well, but he does not back it up. He will ruin this country. Gods have mercy.
Posted by: Optimus Prime | August 29, 2009, 7:22 pm 7:22 pm
It is shocking how much the “age of information” has turned into the “age of disinformation”. The “power brokers” on both sides are so afraid of an honest debate on the issues that no-one knows what is true anymore. Everybody seems so intent on stating that their opponents are evil incarnate that it has become impossible to have a discussion between two people who disagree. Democracy isn’t about the imposition of the will of the majority its about people who disagree being able to reach compromise.
Posted by: David | August 29, 2009, 7:30 pm 7:30 pm
“Obama will fail as a president simply because everybody’s opinion of him is low.”
Everybody? I don’t think his job approval ratings or his favorability ratings are approaching 0% quite yet – not even at Rasmussen or Fox.
Posted by: Numeros | August 29, 2009, 7:32 pm 7:32 pm
Becareful what you ask for. I DO NOT want the government involved in my healthcare decisions PERIOD! Obamacare is nothing more than socialized medicine and I DO NOT WANT IT!!!!!!!!!
Posted by: Bill | August 29, 2009, 7:36 pm 7:36 pm
There are no end to the pundits and peanut gallery participants that will say that “Obamacare” is fascism, racism. The problem with this mindset is that none of these people have had a close relative with a major illness, and uninsured. None of these people have had pre-existing conditions and got turned down for health insurance. Walk a mile in the shoes of the uninsured and come back to the table for a chat. UK and Canada have great health care systems, the doctors are paid better, and hospitals aren’t charging thousands of dollars for medicine that costs pennies to make. America! Wake up! Isn’t it plain to see that the insurance companies are using scare tactics to manipulate the masses? We can’t be so stupid as to think they(insurance companies) care about us. They care about their bottom line. Yes it is Obamacare. Because Obama Cares. He is from an area (Chicago,the Midwest) that there are MANY, MANY people without health insurance. Many work, but either their employer can’t afford the premiums or they can’t. But the conservatives don’t want this. Isn’t the GOP the party of the Religious Right? Let me ask you. What would Jesus do? He would care for ALL, rich or poor, black or white, Jews or Gentiles. People stop complaining. If you exerted as much energy into finding a solution instead of complaining, we would have a viable health plan.
Posted by: Mike Howard | August 29, 2009, 7:38 pm 7:38 pm
i have never seen more know-it-all drama queens and kings as have come out during this health care debate. but i wonder- do any of you people really believe that your current health care insurance carriers have an unlimited amount of money that they are willing to pay for all the people they cover?? if so,who do you have insurance with? i find it amazing that people are so ready to accuse “obamacare” of all these misdeeds that they assume it will be guilty of, when their current insurance providers are in fact, already doing these things. can anyone genuinely and factually show that the for-profit insurance industry is not ,nor has it ever, been guilty of denying necessary care, capping payout, dropping coverage after large payouts or denying coverage after somehow tying an illness to some pre-existing condition that they claim they were not made aware of? can anyone deny that premiums have increased many times faster than inflatiton, while out-of-pocket expenses have increased every year? no matter how you feel about the govt proposals, has everyone developed amnesia concerning the the practices of the existing health ins. companies? im just saying..
Posted by: debi | August 29, 2009, 7:45 pm 7:45 pm
I find it so amuzing that both houses talk at length about healh care but in 60 years of legislation, the health care lobbyists have managed to pump billions of dollars into congress to ensure that health care laws will be written by the health care industry. I also find it amuzing that the GOP believe all the lies about free health care in other country,s that if they could read and understand that every person in the U,S pays $7000.00 more per person than any other industralized country in the world. I believe that we are rated somewhere around 37th in the world.
If the GOP believes that these other country,s don’t want national health care or if it is so bad than why do they still have it??????
REMEMBER HEALH CARE FOR EVERYONE IS NOT A LUXERY AFFORDED BY THE RICH ONLY!
BUT EVERY MAN,WOMAN, AND CHILD SHOULD HAVE EXCESS TO FREE HEALTH CARE SUPPLIED BY THE RICHEST NATION IN THE WORLD.
Posted by: Denny | August 29, 2009, 7:49 pm 7:49 pm
And the lies continue.
Posted by: Gretchen | August 29, 2009, 7:53 pm 7:53 pm
gripe, complain. geeeee ,obama is the worst president ever… how so? you constantly critical, hateful complainers were saying he was the “worst president ever”,since his first day in office. you were on him before he had signed his john hancock on the first piece of legislation.THAT is why you suck. not because your criticisms are perceived as racist,though god knows, you HAVE been guilty of many incidences of hateful, mean-spirited, childish, tacky racial acts. SO YOU DONT WANT A LIBERAL PRES.this is a democracy. you dont have to turn on your own citizens and your own govt.you only hurt yourselves. its like the republican who went to a town hall meeting to disrupt it recently. he was injured in the process and had to be taken to the hospital. once at the hospital, he started whining because he had no health insurance…
Posted by: debi | August 29, 2009, 8:07 pm 8:07 pm
Obviously many people posting here have not even taken the time to read HR 3200 or to listen to the comments made by Obama, Reid, Pelosi, Hoyer and many more including the late Ted Kennedy. HR 3200 does not specifically call for nationalized health care however, it calls for a government option to compete with private insurance, mandates that employers offer the public option, raises the income requirement to 133 and one third percent of the poverty level and calls for congressional approval of all non public option plans. If your current plan doesn’t meet government specs it will be disallowed and you will have to go on the public plan. That is the first step towards socialized medicine in America for all and I don’t care what you claim socialized medicine means rationed care. Obama supports single payer health care, so does Pelosi, Reid, Hoyer, Frank, Dodd and just about every other liberal you can name in Washington. Frank openly admitted that a public (read government) option was necessary because it was the first step towards nationalized health care. If the government wants real health care reform it needs to start with Tort Reform and the removal of state boundaries for purchasing health care insurance, removal of pre-existing conditions and life time limits and the ability of insurance companies to cancel clients for health related issues, after all that is why they collect premiums. What we don’t need is another poorly managed social program that provides too little in the way of services and too much in the way of tax obligations. The government is not the answer they are the problem.
Posted by: Jim Davidson | August 29, 2009, 8:10 pm 8:10 pm
What is Mike Huckabee’s record of truthfulness? Politifact has analyzed 25 of his past statements. Here’s the score:
7 True statements
2 Mostly true statements
6 Half-truths
5 Barely true statements
3 False statements
2 Pants on fire lies
Posted by: Numeros | August 29, 2009, 8:23 pm 8:23 pm
Democrats MUST know that Obamacare will ruin this country.
Posted by: Don | August 29, 2009, 8:27 pm 8:27 pm
Ted Kennedy, from an extremely wealthy family, would STILL have been able to afford the best care possible under ANY any type of insurance scheme, as would the rich everywhere else in the world.
Under the current system of health care, all but the most RICH have to fight tooth and nail to receive extremely expensive treatment. Once again the Republicans would like to forget reality and are blasting Obama with all the failings of our current system … without proposing any true overhaul of the current system.
Point is, while the Republics accuse the Democrats of politicizing Kennedy’s death, they turn around and do the same.
This remark reminds me of the same Republican scare-mongering lies which led to the accusation that Stephen Hawking, a handicapped British citizen, would have died under British socialized health care. Despite Hawking denouncing the statement as an outright lie, Republicans just keep using these scare-mongering techniques over and over again.
Posted by: HealthLawyer | August 29, 2009, 8:28 pm 8:28 pm
I have a friend whose former boyfriend’s father was sent home from the hospital with terminal prostate cancer. And that’s not under Obama-care, that’s as things stand now.
Posted by: Robert Evans | August 29, 2009, 8:44 pm 8:44 pm
To add: He was sent home after receiving a blood transfusion after having passed out from blood loss. “condition unknown”, she said.
Posted by: Robert Evans | August 29, 2009, 8:47 pm 8:47 pm
So why should the rest of us pay for treatment which likely costs greater than $150,000 for an incurable disease only to buy an additional 6 months?
Part of the reason were breaking the bank with healthcare is the unreasonable expectations people have and their refusal to realize that sometimes, spending a lot of money (particularly money that nobody really has) garners only a minimal benefit and really isn’t worth doing. All these folk complaining about rationing are free to pay for their expensive unproven or experimental therapies out of pocket.
Posted by: Matt | August 29, 2009, 8:56 pm 8:56 pm
Mike Howard writes that UK and Canada have great health care systems and that doctors there get paid more. Obviously he has never participated in either health care system and doesn’t take the time to research his facts. Anethetists in UK make about the same as rubbage collector. I have an engineer who works with me who took early retirement from the Royal Navy to bring his U.S. citizen wife home for health care because she was diagnosed iwth colon cancer and was looking at an 8 month wait to have surgery. In 8 months you can die with colon cancer. The dealth rate for cancer in both the UK and Canada is significantly higher than in the US. I too have pre-existing conditions and have never been denied insurance, I have been made to wait six months to a year before those coditions were covered but never denied. I have excellent insurance that I pay a reasonable amount of money for and they have never denied any services unless the hospital misfiled the claim and then it was paid after the hospital corrected their mistake. Bottom line is the government has no business in business. Congress has no constitutional authority to pass socialized programs in the first place anymore than Obama has the constitutional authority to fire the CEO of GM and take over the company. That is the major problem in this country, the abuse of power by the federal government and this administration is turning that abuse into an art form.
Posted by: Jim Davidson | August 29, 2009, 9:01 pm 9:01 pm
I cannot believe the uninformed comment on this page. If you wish to comment on Health care in the US you should at least take the time to try understand it! Currently for any but the super rich over 65 health care is paid for by the US government via a single payer GOVERNMENT insurance system called MEDICARE. So if TK hadn’t been a senator he would have been getting Medicare. Why was MEDICARE set up? Because in the 60′s!! people could not afford the rates medical insurers charged – why is this? Because they don’t want to insure old people they make no money. So if you don’t want the system for the over 65′s to change because the US system is so great it is MEDICARE the US Government system you are fighting for.
Posted by: PC | August 29, 2009, 9:02 pm 9:02 pm
So many people commenting on what “obamacare” means when I would bet my last dollar only 1/100 of 1% have actually read any of it at all. You don’t want government to mess with health care!!! Newsflash: they already are with Medicare and Medicaid. Have you read the statistics on how many seniors are very happy with Medicare? Over 72%. You don’t want government telling doctors how to practice but insurance companies are already doing this. I am a nurse practitioner and I HAVE read the bill and I DO know how bad the health care industry already is. The government does a lot wrong but they do a lot right as well and people always want them there when it fits THEIR agenda. THere is way too much false info being spread about what will transpire if Obama’s health care reform passes. Actually that is a mild term as a lot are outright LIES. If the ‘other side’ is so sure they are in the right then why do they have to resort to lies about what is being considered? Sure there are a lot of things about the bill that need to be tweaked but that is to be expected isn’t it? Contrary to what a lot of Repubicans say we do NOT have the best health care in the world. I think-according to WHO-that we are somewhere around 14th in the world. Too many people are being misled and it is time to wake up and listen to the truth.
Posted by: nancy | August 29, 2009, 9:02 pm 9:02 pm
Secondly. If it is wrong for the government to deny you care and condemn you to die because of your age to have ‘DeathPanels’ as the right wing put it. Then surely it is also wrong for an INSURANCE COMPANY to condemn an insured person to die because a treatment is ‘experimental’ despite the fact that the treatment (such as a transplant) has been routine for 30 years – these are also ‘Death Panels’. Many doctors who have worked processing claims in the insurance industry have testified that they denied claims as ‘experimental’ purely to save money for the insurance company because that is what was required to meet the companies quota of money saved. WHERE IS THE OUTRAGE ABOUT INSURANCE COMPANIES DEATH PANELS??? IT IS WRONG PERIOD BUT THAT IS THE CURRENT SYSTEM SO SURELY THE OUTRAGE SHOULD BE DIRECTED AT THOSE FORMING THEM NOW!!
Posted by: PC | August 29, 2009, 9:11 pm 9:11 pm
Here is some truth for everyone. In our current health/insurance system, you get the best if you are rich. However, for everyone else it is rationed. The health insurance company you are with will decide what treat you will get. If you can’t afford health care because you are poor or had a crisis that severely limits your income, or have a prior condition that prevents you, then you don’t have anything but emergency care and sent home. You will never receive screen to see if you have a heart condition or if cancer has started. But by rationing this way, the rich will never have to wait in line and always get the best doctors. It is called Survival of the Richest.
Posted by: MikeMo | August 29, 2009, 9:13 pm 9:13 pm
The Right-Wing Radical Republican Party of Sarah Palin and now Mike Huckabee are the political party with an agenda of stupidity, fear, hate and an obsession with death. They are cowards and bullies. They have no decency and no honor. If they are truly the party of faith and family values, maybe they should read the Ten Commandments and The Golden Rule before they ever open their mouth or appear on Twitter and Facebook again.
Posted by: William S Adams | August 29, 2009, 9:14 pm 9:14 pm
I am surprise that Huckabee would make such a crass social and political remark.
It is sad how some will twist the truth for the sake of politics. There is nothing wrong about or having Hospice care.
Posted by: threeriverscrossing | August 29, 2009, 9:19 pm 9:19 pm
Here is another reality check. Most companies that provide health care pay for only part of the cost. For the employee, that means they can go with the company plan and pay for part of the cost or go with another health care provider and pay for the entire cost. That means most people don’t really have a choice in what plan they want. Second, the money that companies pay for health insurance is really the cost of hiring an employee. But you won’t see these companies dropping health insurance and putting that money into the employee paycheck. The employee will be lucky to get 50% of that money coming back to them. The company will keep the rest.
Posted by: MikeMo | August 29, 2009, 9:22 pm 9:22 pm
To Matt and Jim above – if you are so indisputably right why do you have to lie like Huckerbee and Palin?
Fact.MEDICARE is a Government Insurance program paid directly from ALL our taxes ditto MEDICAID. That pays for over 50% of the current medical costs in the US. So if you like you say the current system is so great you support one with a huge amount of government involvement already.
Fact. There are countless examples of insurers denying care because of claims that treatment is experimental or the practice of recision where policies are canceled because the persons treatment is going to be too expensive. If you don’t believe that your simply refusing to listen or read the thousands of people who have had this happen.
Posted by: PC | August 29, 2009, 9:33 pm 9:33 pm
Under the Obama plan you have the right to chose your current health care provider. The elitist republicans are trying to keep the billionaire insurance CEOs fat and rich. These companies PROFIT from denying coverage, that’s who the republicans are going to bat for.
Posted by: Jaik | August 29, 2009, 9:34 pm 9:34 pm
Matt!! Don’t LIE about treatment in the country I grew up in for over 25 years. The UK does not KILL people when they get to a certain age and people do not get denied CRITICAL LIFE OR DEATH care. Us Brits have not reached the barbaric state where we deny people life or death care for any reason and certainly not for excessive cost unlike the insurance industry in this country.
We get upset when you tell lies about a subject we know far more about (OUR healthcare system) stick to truth about your own!
Posted by: PC | August 29, 2009, 9:43 pm 9:43 pm
I’m getting sick of people believing the lies that Republicans and the Health Care Industry feed them. THERE IS NO DEATH PANEL. Republicans just keep spreading lies cause they have no positive ideas. Kennedy was in support of Obama and the health care reform so Huckabee using his name to support the Republicans is just disgusting. That’s pretty low.
Posted by: Mike | August 29, 2009, 9:44 pm 9:44 pm
I think you all have it wrong. The so called end of life business concerns a person’s will to be allowed to die or to be placed on life support to keep them artificially alive. Personally I would prefer to be allowed to die rather than be on life support.
Posted by: Don | August 29, 2009, 9:46 pm 9:46 pm
The Obama health care bill will pull the plug on grand ma and withold health care for republicians. Are people really that stupid ? And the most frighting thing is, these people vote. These are really happy people, but then you have to consider that ignorance is bliss.
Posted by: William H. Cunningham Sr. | August 29, 2009, 9:47 pm 9:47 pm
I’m an old man with a history of heart disease. Obamacare would give me just enough options to give up and die.I don’t want my insurance to be changed.
Posted by: Jay | August 29, 2009, 9:50 pm 9:50 pm
With all the years the Republicans controlled Washington recently, and noting the current state of the Union, I am having trouble buying into their born-again fudicial stewardship persona.
The Republicans may have some very valid
points concerning health care, but I am not sure when to believe them. There’s a
creditability issue. And this is not about Ted Kennedy, it’s about healthcare
reform people.
Posted by: WilliG from TX | August 29, 2009, 9:55 pm 9:55 pm
Jasmine, I’m not coverable under alot programs anyways. So, though I dislike it, I’m pretty stuck with the VA health care. I’ll respond to most of your rants, because, no matter what anyone says, you aren’t going to listen. 1) With most people who have insurance “satisfied” (and presumably staying on their plans), they wouldn’t have to change (takes care of their “grandfathering”). 2) If the HMO’s, PPO’s and whatnot can’t lower their costs and fees and provide a quallity service, they deserve to die.
Isn’t that the “true American way?”
With regard to doctors visits and what they talk about, just listen to the doctors themselves and the surveys of patients themselves. Even better go talk to the veterans at the VA centers and the doctors who treat them. The doctors are told go with what the patient wants to talk about as far as medical treatment. Under current rules they aren’t paid to talk about it, they are paid by the procedure done. Don’t believe me? Check the analyses. I’m not going to say NO doctors talk about end of life care, but it’s sporadic, mish mashed and cobbled at best.
I don’t care about the profits of the HMO’s, PPO’s, and what not, when my grandfather couldn’t afford any of them though he worked his whole life (as have I) and is now dying because he couldn’t afford the doctors visits that would have found the illness in it’s early stages. So my own opinion is that the families of all HMO, PPO etc workers can die horrible and long drawn out deaths. Why should healthcare be only for those who can pay $200 a month for even basic coverage? I’m not claiming to be a nice person. I’m not even going to pretend to be non biased. BUt if your precious Republicans/Conservatives have better ideas, then they should prove it. Until then they can rely on one veteran to continually work AGAINST them. Want to show you care about the “great citizens of America”? PROVE IT and don’t pay lip service to it
Posted by: rayhagermann | August 29, 2009, 9:57 pm 9:57 pm
kennedy had better insurance mutch better than medicare. when the doctor say’s that’s all that they can do you will either die in the hospital or on the way home when they take the tube’s from your arm. a friend died waiting for a ride home after he had been informed of all they can do.guess the insurance wasn’t there the doctor’s are the death panal allready and always will be because of money.
Posted by: ray | August 29, 2009, 9:57 pm 9:57 pm
At this point, my grandfather literally is just palliative care and waiting to die.
Posted by: rayhagermann | August 29, 2009, 9:58 pm 9:58 pm
This is to that earlier poster who referred to the WHO study that said the U.S. ranked 37th in health care among industrialized nations. You forgot to mention WHY we were ranked so low:
=== The WHO judged a country’s quality of health on life expectancy.
But that’s a lousy measure of a health-care system. Many things that cause premature death have nothing do with medical care. We have far more fatal transportation accidents than other countries. That’s not a health-care problem.
Similarly, our homicide rate is 10 times higher than in the U.K., eight times higher than in France, and five times greater than in Canada.
When you adjust for these “fatal injury” rates, U.S. life expectancy is actually higher than in nearly every other industrialized nation.
=== Diet and lack of exercise also bring down average life expectancy.
=== Another reason the U.S. didn’t score high in the WHO rankings is that we are less socialistic than other nations.
What has that got to do with the quality of health care? For the authors of the study, it’s crucial. The WHO judged countries not on the absolute quality of health care, but on how “fairly” health care of any quality is “distributed.” The problem here is obvious. By that criterion, a country with high-quality care overall but “unequal distribution” would rank below a country with lower quality care but equal distribution.
Posted by: DoNotWantSocializedHealthCare | August 29, 2009, 10:16 pm 10:16 pm
My roommates father has Stage 4 Esophageal cancer (which has metastisized into his bones). He was in the hospital for 3 weeks in the cancer wing of a hospital, taken care of by one of the best oncologists in the
state, talk to his healthcare organization personally and explained that a patient with a raging infection, fever and low blood pressure should be in the hospital. The HMO told this doctor, that someone with 15 years of medical training and 30 years of real experience, that he didn’t know what he was talking about and that his patient would be just fine at not in the hospital. So this mans family now owes the medical company 13 days of intensive care. Wow, sounds like we don’t need to wait for “Obamacare” for a “death panel” do we? Some mindless drone made a life and death decision for someone that is merely a number. Such a great system we have, no?
Posted by: rayhagermann | August 29, 2009, 10:21 pm 10:21 pm
Wow!,the marching morons wasted no time in regurgitating their spoon-fed non-facts!
Huck and Ted Kennedy work for the federal gov’t,their state-run health program is excellent,…if only there was a way for the rest of us to share in that?
“Read the bill w an open mind”? as in “disregard what it says,because everyone from the AARP to the Society to Preserve Medicare,to fact-check .org,and anybody else not being paid by the poor insurance companies and Big Pharma has read it and verified there’s nothing in it to ration medicine”.
Wake up,the reason there are few if any private health care options for seniors is not that Medicare “drove them out”,those are the first people to be excluded or rescinded coverage from private policies,they’d rather insure the least likely to file claims..gee that’s an awful lot like rationing
Posted by: Marc | August 29, 2009, 10:27 pm 10:27 pm
So, rayhangerman, you are “pretty stuck with the VA health care”, are you?
If the VA health care is so terrible, why would you want the government to run the health care system for the entire population?
And you also said “if your precious Republicans/Conservatives have better ideas, then they should prove it.”
I referred earlier to HR 3218 (you can read it yourself. It’s in plain language, and only 24 pages long.
If you go to that website, you can look up ALL of the Health Care reform bills submitted to Congress and track them. You will find that many of them never make it out of committee.
HR3218 would greatly expand the availability of insurance, create market incentives like refundable tax credits to help lower and middle-income workers afford coverage if their employers don’t provide it, and create a high-risk pool so that people with pre-existing conditions could get affordable coverage.
HR 3218 involves neither more deficit spending or government control.
Just because the mainstream media does not report on options offered by Republicans, doesn’t mean there haven’t been any offered. And just because the Democrats claim that the Republicans refuse to work with them, doesn’t mean that they have refused to either.
As for your accusation of me “ranting”, here is the definition of a “rant”:
•A rant or harangue is a speech or text that does not present a well-researched and calm argument; rather, it is typically an attack on an idea, a person or an institution, and very often lacks proven claims. Such attacks are usually personal attacks.
I don’t believe that any of my posts have been any of those things.
There have been several rants posted here, but none of them were posted by me.
Posted by: jasmine | August 29, 2009, 10:39 pm 10:39 pm
Everyone who is for this health care I challenge you to open it and read it for yourself and stop listening to the news. You can find it on US congress website( HR3200). It is a very scary bill and you can cleary see where the power and control will lie. I urge you to know what your fighting for and against. This one we can do without. There are answers to reform but this IS NOT IT.
Posted by: Jenn | August 29, 2009, 10:50 pm 10:50 pm
kenedy had a brain tumor that gave him a year to live ..infact that particular brain tumor has a definate death sentence ..wheater you get superior care or no care …the live expectancy would have been 12 month kennedy lived 14 month …you dont know what you are talking about but many american mothers die from very treatable breast cancer because they havent got health care ….what decent society has its mothers and woman without even basic health care so a bunch of fat old cats can line their pockets …a society of animals thats who
Posted by: maria | August 29, 2009, 10:53 pm 10:53 pm
Could someone please show me where in one of the FOUR bills currently under consideration that it says or implies that someone suffering from terminal brain cancer would be given pain meds and told to go home and die?
Could it possibly be that Huckabee’s comment is another right wing lie, comparable to Palin’s Death Panels lie?
What’s truly astonishing is the number of people who STILL believe the garbage that issues from her mouth and from the mouths of other right wing whackazoids. Polls indicate that there a lot of intentionally ignorant people in our nation.
Huckabee-Palin in 2012? God help us!
Posted by: Dude | August 29, 2009, 11:00 pm 11:00 pm
we don’t need to wonder about what kind of health care the Democrats would give us versus the Republicans. There are already examples out there for us to examine: Medicare (liberal) and Medicare Advantage (Republican). Seniors love the former because it’s fair, it’s understandable and it works. They hate the latter because it wastes money, puts huge profits ahead of actual care and is written in such a way that no one can understand it.
These are facts, already out there, not opinions.
Posted by: John | August 29, 2009, 11:01 pm 11:01 pm
Oh for…*argh* I’m not a proponent of Obama’s plan and I’m not against it. Yet. You know why? Because he doesn’t have a plan yet. There IS no Obamacare. The President has put together a wish list for health care modification, which via the democratic process (yes, there is still democracy in this hideous socialist state!) is being vetted by Republicans and Democrats alike. A final version has not been released yet. They’re not even close. So to make any statement about who Obama is going to ‘kill with his death panels’ is ridiculously premature. I have to wonder…has anyone here actually been following the White House website for updates on the health care program as different issues are being addressed and wording is being altered? And for those of you who have objections to the way things seem to be going (objections based on legitimate info, not on some late-night pundit or gossip with your neighbor), how often do you call your senators and representatives? How many letters do you write? How many rallies have you attended? How many editorials have you submitted to newspapers? Or do you just whine to your neighbors about how that commie pinko loser is ruining your country? Also, it’s pretty easy to point at some imagined straw-man horror when you yourself have not dealt with ruin under our *current* health care system. Have not had to declare bankruptcy after one surgery, or choose between meds for you and meds for your kids. Have not delayed treatment because of money issues and then found out you had terminal cancer. Sure an ER has to take you…but try to buy a car or house after when your credit is ruined. If you have a better idea for health care, if you really know how to fix the stuff that’s ruined my life and the lives of my family members and friends, let’s hear it. Seriously, us crazy libs are all ears.
Posted by: Nic | August 29, 2009, 11:30 pm 11:30 pm
The medical community is already treating patients with the “go home and die” approach. If you’re low-income you might as well crawl under a rock and die for all they care. Greedy pigs, go spend some more money on the space program or something, maybe develop more surveillance equipment and fund more “big brother is watching” type activities. Or load up the CEO’s with a few more bonuses. Wastrels!
Posted by: S.Y.L. | August 29, 2009, 11:42 pm 11:42 pm
I cannot believe that there are so many ignorant people taking time out of their stupid lives to post such junk online.
At least READ the Health Care Program being offered. Try that instead of just running around yelling, showing guns, aimlessly showing the rest of us that you have fallen by the wayside as a result of the poor education given to the masses in America. Thanks to the GOP.
It’s time for real Americans to show (as they did when we voted Obama in) that we believe in what is being offered and Kennedy agreed with it also.
God Bless Teddy’s soul.
Posted by: Ramcc | August 29, 2009, 11:52 pm 11:52 pm
I have read the House Bill. It very clearly spells out the end of everyones current coverage. You “can keep it” as long as several near impossible conditions are met by both the insurance company and the insured. It is in the “Grand Father” section at the begining of the bill. If all conditions are met, you have a five year grace period to keep your current coverage, at which time you have no choice but to change to coverage within the government controlled “Health Exchange”.
There is very, very much within this bill that is just plain bad. The bottom line is cost control. It will give government control over your healthcare options. It will ration the care you will be allowed to recieve.
Posted by: Keith | August 29, 2009, 11:55 pm 11:55 pm
Keith, I’m glad you read the bill in its current form! I’m glad people are taking time to get educated on the details. I hope that if you have objections based on reason, as it seems you do, that you’re contacting your representatives and expressing your views. That’s the power we have in a democracy. If enough of us stand up and say, “I feel strongly about X”, our representatives (employed by our votes) will see the wind changing and vote accordingly in order to keep their jobs. I’m a social liberal and fiscal conservative, and I’d love to see health care reformed in a way that would benefit all Americans, right, left, and in the middle without impoverishing us in the process. The only way to do that is to be informed and communicate with those in power about what we need and what is waste.
Posted by: Nic | August 30, 2009, 12:06 am 12:06 am
republicans are the worst poor lossers in history , jajajajaja
Posted by: yohan | August 30, 2009, 12:17 am 12:17 am
Death Panel? Bunch of right wing nuts, next thing you know Palin with fight to have DNR removed.
Posted by: heather | August 30, 2009, 12:22 am 12:22 am
No, George. The first move to politicize Kennedy’s death was Nancy Pelosi’s call, made shortly after he died, to pass Obama’s health care plan immediately because Ted Kennedy would have wanted it.
Posted by: AvidReader | August 30, 2009, 12:32 am 12:32 am
well, if the object is to save gov’t money and make it stretch, then the higher the income of seniors, the more they should pay, but not just for the premiums. also for copays. the ones who learn good healthy living and avoid/ prevent diseases, should not have to pay the same as those who ignore health issues and use the system too much after practicing an unhealthy lifestyle. People who take good care of themselves, don’t need medical half as much as those who don’t bother.
Posted by: D | August 30, 2009, 12:37 am 12:37 am
George, I have never read so many ill informed opinions. It’s scary that so many people don’t know how much legislation Sen. Kennedy was abled to get into law for the disabled, working class, for all that needed help. His purpose was to get laws passed that helped the people without connections. Yes he came from a wealthy family who taught all of the their children to serve their country and the public that has no voice. READ! READ! and inform yourselves. We are the only civilized country without health care for all. US health care is run by insurance companies and Wall Street for profits. They will not let go of their grip of huge profits easily…Health care FOR all citizens is the MORAL imperative of our country. Educate yourselves on history.
Posted by: Cindy | August 30, 2009, 1:23 am 1:23 am
I’m 62, my husband 61 and I can tell you what healthcare we have had to date: zilch…….Due to pre-existing conditions and premiums that are too high. The Republicans don’t give a damn about us. I have already experienced health care rationing the American free market way. I’ll take my chances with the Democrats anyday.
Posted by: Grace | August 30, 2009, 1:40 am 1:40 am
Hello, Grace. I have so much sympathy for you, and I hope you and your husband remain healthy enough to sustain yourselves and enjoy your retirement years. My parents are in their mid-sixties and are both strong supporters of the most radical health reform we can manage to pass. Although they both worked all their lives in jobs that helped the poor and disadvantaged, they both have serious conditions (cancer in one case, congenital heart defect in the other) that could wipe them out if anything untoward happened. Both of them are models of a healthy lifestyle, exercising and eating according to carefully controlled plans, not smoking or drinking or driving carelessly–yet they’re aware that what awaits them is nothing less than disaster. Though college-educated, they’re lower-middle-class because they’ve chosen to work for nonprofits, so they’re going to be wiped out by long hospital stays and costly ongoing treatments. They are willing to take a chance with change, since what’s waiting for them won’t last through their retirement. I think my duty as a good daughter is in supporting what they desire–the sort of reform that could make their lives easier.
Posted by: Nic | August 30, 2009, 2:11 am 2:11 am
It’s true. The Older you are, the harder it is to get good quality care. Older Patients are neglected. Family advocates are made to feel like stupid jerks. It’s totally imoral to refuse an 89 year old lady IV antibiotics. But folks, it’s happenning now. Fact is, it just happened last week. They just wanted to send her to a nursing home – no meds. Didn’t care they were sentencing her to die with out even trying to help her. It was all $$$$$. The excuse to the family? Well she’s lived a long life.
Posted by: BeenThereAmThere | August 30, 2009, 2:17 am 2:17 am
Glad to see the crazies are out in full force.
The reality of it is that most people at 77 depend on medicare. And if they they have private insurance nothing changes.
Gotta love Huckabee though. He is making is clear he will not be out crazied.
Posted by: Protactinium | August 30, 2009, 2:24 am 2:24 am
How much is a life worth???
Americans are fighting a war to protect us; but we have a war here which is killing more people then the war in A. It is a war between the Insurances companies, Republicans and the rich. It is killing hard working, average Americans, who aren’t even able to defend themselves. The solder has a gun and ammunition . We have elected representatives who are owned by the insurances GIANTS and want more. GREEDY! What is a good name worth??? Life here is so short. Make a difference HELP US, WE ARE WORTH MORE THEN MONEY
Posted by: yvonne | August 30, 2009, 2:25 am 2:25 am
Old People Are Precious; they have lived, survived, and offer so much wisdom to us.
FOR THE INSURANCE GIANTS AND REPUBLICANS TO LIE I MEAN OUTRIGHT LIE TO THEM AND TERRIFY THEM IS SHAMEFUL. they lie so well, with a straight face and gleaming eyes knowing how it will cause our retired special, gentle, honest, faithful, seniors to fear. HOW CAN YOU BE SO CRUEL Republicans. Quit hurting our seniors. You know the public option will be a blessing to all people. You know the only reason you don’t want it to pass is because you don’t want to give credit to a BLACK MAN. If God came down and slapped you on the face, would scream and say NO, NO, NO,. You can’t imagine helping a man who reminds you as a child, a slave in your house.
It is not about OBamah, it is about millions of Americans; hundreds dying daily for lack of health care.
Posted by: yvonne | August 30, 2009, 2:39 am 2:39 am
REALLY EVERYONE,
WHO IS THIS HUCKOBEEEE. He is a lie personified. He acts like a snake sweet and always slithering. He dosn’t Care about anyone, but himself and MONEY. He judges people and has a tree in his own eye. Who really cares what he thinks. He is just a man when it is all said and done. Whenever you find people who have nothing good to say about a person better start looking at that person. I am scared of you!
Huckebee is just a fat man living off the emotions which his lies express.
Posted by: yvonne | August 30, 2009, 2:47 am 2:47 am
It’s Not the Republicans refusing the “Old People” care. It’s the Public Option Medicare! The Doctors and Hospitials who are BTW under pressure to make a profit. Medicare and Medicade don’t pay enough to cover costs. And ObamaCare is cutting the reimbursement down more from these 2 Public options plans. That will lead to Rationing.
Posted by: BeenThereAmThere | August 30, 2009, 2:50 am 2:50 am
All you right wing confessing Christians shame on you I wonder how many people who are astounded by your LIES have turned away from becoming Christians because of what you represent Shame on you God will have a GREAT REWARD FOR YOU WHEN YOUR TIME COMES. AND YOU KNOW IT IS COMING LOOK AT YOUR AGES THERE IS NOT ENOUGH MONEY IN THE WORLD TO GIVE UP YOUR SOUL FOR, BUT I BEYA DON’T EVEN CARE!
Posted by: yvonne | August 30, 2009, 2:54 am 2:54 am
Ted not only spent oodles of cash on a team of specialists to prolong his life he opted to undergo expensive experimental treatments. He may have ultimately died in his home taking pain pills but that didn’t happen until he had exhausted every option available to him. Once agian the Democrats who posted he died in his home aren’t being honest just like the politicians who advocate Obama Deathcare. If it is so wonderful, why can’t Obama supporters honstly describe what will happen under nationalized healthcare? We all know the answer to that question. At least the media asks tough questions about Obama’s policies and handout programs….HAHAHAHA!!!!!! Ya gotta love being lied to by the government AND the media.
Posted by: Dino Brava | August 30, 2009, 2:55 am 2:55 am
Well, at least with ObamaCare Old Huckabee will get the psychological help he so desperately needs.
Posted by: Homey | August 30, 2009, 3:02 am 3:02 am
Dino Brava, would you mind pointing out the passages from section 1233 of the house bill that ‘truthful’ conservatives like Palin, McCaughey, Gingrich, Limbaugh, Beck, et al, interpret to mean death panels and mandatory euthanasia counseling?
Posted by: Shomida Panels | August 30, 2009, 3:16 am 3:16 am
Someone give Obama a pill please. He is such a pain in the arse.
Posted by: fromohio | August 30, 2009, 3:19 am 3:19 am
You can always tell the people that have been faithfully listening to Fox News. They are the ones going around yelling and screaming in everyone’s faces. To all the little sheep who listen and fall for Glen Beck and the rest of the fear and hate mongers’s crap…….take those blinders off….HA! HA! WHAT SUCKERS!!!!!
Posted by: Spann | August 30, 2009, 3:31 am 3:31 am
Last time I checked, the Federal government already pays for nearly 60% of health care in this country NOW. And you know what, the insurance companies are the ones telling old people to go home and die NOW because they can get more money from someone else with those beds. But we don’t want to talk about that because big insurance LOVES the GOP.
Posted by: Frank | August 30, 2009, 3:40 am 3:40 am
It is a shame that a Senator, Congressperson, or State Representative and all other appointed officals get benefits for life even if they only serve one term. Would be nice if I could still have the benefits program from a employment I had before I was critically injured on a Federal Job Corp in San Marocs Texas. But instead I am stuck with Medicare and Medicaid. I am offically considered fully disabled and live on Social Security, Food Stamps and donations. I still can not afford my medications or to go to the Dr when I need. I just wish I could have had the same medical care all these elected and appointed officals get because I would be in better shape and possibly even get successful employment but this country is set up for the elite and the rich. These are the people who allowed the biggest bank robbery in histroy by allowing the CEO’s of our countries banks to rob them blind and here we are paying the bill while those same CEO’s sit back with their “Golden Parachutes” retirement deals which we also get to pay for. Just think what going to happen when people who allowed this to happen start running Health Care. This scares the hell out of me because it is always the little people they step on and steal from. Don’t believe me, ask someone who has lost their home to foreclosure.
Posted by: Anne Cooper | August 30, 2009, 6:29 am 6:29 am
Hay people,The healthcare system we have know is a joke.It’s all about money.Not healing,Both my parents dsied from cancer.My mother Had ciemo tharipy,
And sergeury,The cost blew my mind.And this was 30 years ago.I couldnt nor wouldnt want to have to pay what it would cost today.My father got lung cancer,and it spread every to his leanex and pancreus.If he would have had adiquit,health care,Physicals ect.He could have cought his earlly and mabbie.fought it.But as it is know.insurance companies and hospitals.Manage our care,Insurance companies love taking your premiums,And tthen,when you get sick limmit your care,Because they want to make a proffit.And cost its rediculuse.The system we need is a government system.Most people in this country work for minimum wage.And you can not depend on your employer either,I can tell you your employers insurance costs go up when you use your insurance,And they will get ridd of you.People in health care aspecially insurance companies want everyone insured,sure but they want to be able to get you out of the system when you need to use the insurance you payed for,Pre-existing conditions = get sick stay sick.at
least,Oboma is trying to make them give you what you payed for.And for lower payed workers or the ones to sick to work would have health care.We need a government option,Us millitary,Has government bassed health care.And i can tell you.She got excelent care.And she servived a long time.she got what she needed without the wast.and it was free.A lot of illnesses can be cured if cout earlly,CHECKUPS an ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure.
Posted by: Billy Jackson | August 30, 2009, 6:54 am 6:54 am
I’ve heard enough of this stuff.
It is time for congress to get of its duff and vote. Everybody knows where he or she stands. All the talk just keeps anyone from having to be accountable.
I have Medicare, so I know government health insurance is good. Those who have government coverage akin to a public option plan (including congress) wouldn’t give it up for private plans with rescission, prices doubling every ten years, pre-existing illness exclusions, huge deductibles and low caps on coverage.
Health care and insurance costs doubling every ten to twelve years will destroy Medicare.
But all this discussion is worthless now. Let each congress person stand where he or she decides to stand. Congress, quit talking and vote!
Posted by: JAB | August 30, 2009, 7:18 am 7:18 am
The fact that Americas health care system is broken is a no brainer, but you know what? I didn’t see anyone else besides Hillary Clinton back when her husband was in office, do anything about it, says allot about our “caring” “committed” public servants. It’s the “don’t fix what’s broken” mentality that’s led us to the current situation we’re in, and I don’t mean just the health care system. Every time someone comes up with a fix that might jeopardize someone elses special interest pocketbook, they scream foul and throw everything but the kitchen sink to derail it, at least until they can come up with something that on the surface looks different, but is essentially the same thing. What the hell does Kennedy have to do with this? Despite his money and clout, in the end, he was just as mortal as the rest of us, broken health care system or not.
Quit clouding the issue and FIX SOMETHING instead of trying to tear it down.
Posted by: Jax | August 30, 2009, 7:37 am 7:37 am
The economy is bad, our healthcare system IS horrible.. how the hell is it Obama’s fault? George W. had 8 years to make this mess and after only 8 months supposedly Barack is to blame for everything.
My grandmother, an 89-year-old Floridian hoping to live another dozen years like her mother, has had insurance companies swindle her out of 25 grand in additional “insurance” just because medicare and medicaid weren’t enough.
If you want to talk about deadly heathcare talk to her about how her cancer test had to be postponed a month ago because our wonderful, top-of-the-line system simply ran out of the radioactive material needed for that and the newly diagnosed breast cancer patient who was in the waiting room at the time.
And then there have been several incidents where doctors have tried to force another patient’s pills on my grandmother and had she not be vigilant enough to notice and insistent enough to refuse, a few of them would have undoubtedly killed her.
She is a republican and always has been. I wish you idiots would all get your heads out of your asses and put your misplaced fears and barely disguised racism aside and have real conversations making honest points.
Hell, track my grandma down and interview her or other actual grandparents already dealing with our crap system instead of whining because you are afraid of change. It is coming whether you like it or not so why not get your facts straight and help shape this change into something where we can all benefit.
Posted by: jessica | August 30, 2009, 7:50 am 7:50 am
Please the rules don’t apply to people in power. If ignorant average joes can’t see behind Obama’s purposed health care plan. They deserve the the health care plan. I can understand going after these insurance companies. But, lets not forget these Dr.s who beef up there bill for them.
Had a physical last yr if I paid out of pocket it was $100.00. Once they realized the insurance covered it 100% the bill was $270.00. How does that happen. And let the goverment decide if your life is worth the all mighty dollar.
I’d prefer to play russian roulette. The odds would be better that I could walk away breathing.
What do you call a democrat witha brain? You call him a republican.
Posted by: BRANDI | August 30, 2009, 7:52 am 7:52 am
Having lived in Arkansas under the Govenership of Huckabee, I pray to any god that will listen, that man never gets anywhere near the white house. We made him Lt. Govenor thinking it would shut him up and we wouldn’t have to see him in every election. He was a joke, that got played on us when Jim Guy went to jail and Huckabee took over.
The public should talk to people in Arkansas about Huckabee before they jump on his band wagon. The only death panel I see here is the one that by claiming there will be death panels will bring about my death and the deaths of thousands of others by not letting us have affordable health insurance. No one thinks about that though do they.
Posted by: Becca | August 30, 2009, 7:58 am 7:58 am
Would someone tell me where to look up what Huck is talking about being told to take some pills and die. I can’t find it.
Where? I am on medicare disability because my private long term insurance I bought requires you to use it as the primary. I was very well paid and got 2/3 of my base salary because i paid for an optional coverage. So my insurance was secondary. Then after two years my pension and insurance was canceled as there was a loop hole and many types of injury and illnesses are limited (very fine print).
We have tort reform here in Texas and though my disability was caused by MRSA infection and was clearly malpractice no one will sue as there is a cap of $125,000 lifetime and it can cost that much to sue. FYI malpractice insurance rates did not go down either.
I thought I had everything covered…
Lookout for yourself. This is happening to more and more people.
I paid 20% of my bills and a million goes fast. I make $1000 a month but the SS medical is not too bad at all. Part of it is privatized and no one gives a damn about the patients. I have even been asked to lie about the services I never got but medicare paid for. Crooked.
Be well and don’t vote politics, vote for yourself.
Posted by: Patrick Crothers | August 30, 2009, 8:37 am 8:37 am
I challenge any conservative to come up with an actual line from the health care bill that does any of the crazy things that they are making up. It has to be documented, not something they made up. Obamacare would lower healthcare costs for Americans. That is something that conservatives just don’t want to admit.
Posted by: Joe | August 30, 2009, 8:39 am 8:39 am
Never have I seen such right wing bull. Talking wihtout facts is a right wing devotion. The US is 37th in the world in health care. We are only number 1 in cost of heath care. Not one Republican member of congress want’s to do away with our present single payer government programs like Medicare or the VA.
Posted by: Larry | August 30, 2009, 8:49 am 8:49 am
Four years ago I was diagnosed with breast cancer. I was able to go from my small town to the University of Pennsylvania for treatment. As a teacher with good health insurance I was able to leave my small town for expert advice. My insurance covered everything. Most people with insurance are able to seek out good doctors. Health insurance for all is something every society owes its participants. Let’s get with it! Senator Kennedy may have been very wealthy, but I know others who, though not wealthy, have been able to seek help at the hospitals of their choice. This can only be something all of us should have acess to if we all have health care.
Posted by: Ruth Sklar | August 30, 2009, 9:13 am 9:13 am
Death panels? Right now, folks are dying and not receiving proper treatment, because of the lack of coverage. Prescriptions aren’t affordable for our medicare recipients that are barely makind it. If they need to go back to the hospital they have to pay again, these are the medical advangtages plans, these plans are full of restrictions already. My daughter was under my group ins. at the age of nineteen she was drop, reason??? she wasn’t a full time student, reason??? she has a condition. No individual coverage will touch her, reason??? she has a pre-existing condition. My group ins. or any other works the same way, the funny part of the story???? I work directly for one medical ins. one of the major ones, we are the workers taking the calls, we are the ones listening to our members or prospects, , guess what Huckabee, we want change!!!! and we want it now. The true is we wouldn’t be having theses debates is our greatest institutions will provide coverages at affordable prices and will cover pre-existing conditions.
Posted by: Mel | August 30, 2009, 9:17 am 9:17 am
Good Lord, the ignorance in these comments of knowledge and literal understanding of the content of Kennedy’s hoped-for healthcare reform is appalling. I now understand what the “dumbing down” of America means. Have you commentors no shame? Obviously, you are so blinded by ideology you are not willing to seek the truth, but are willing to be led by even the least among you. May God have mercy on your souls, and I am sure He will take into consideration your vulnerability to the fear mongering hoisted upon you by your leaders. As for your leaders, I am not so sure about His mercy. I fervently believe that He sees the utter selfishness and intolerance exhibited by yourselves and your leaders, and I hope for your sakes He will forgive you.
Posted by: KV | August 30, 2009, 9:19 am 9:19 am
as the bubonic plague surfaced the renaissance was marked by the 1st public hospital in florence. The renaissance, its art created by children like leonardo and michaelangelo gave impetus to our prosperous world as we know it without it we would be in the dark ages, no wonder we are reverting to the dark ages now with the fantastic and arcane views of backward christians and muslims. Public option is on the right track to spur a renaissance with a mix of art and design. Now refute that backward persons who think healthcare is socialism. Public healthcare is a renaissance option not socialist. And what the conservative dumbells are opposed to is good they are the ones that are backward and live a life of make believe and hypothecise things that sound good to their brainwashed and shallow ears yet they have no deapth of humanistic, poetic or itelligent thought.
Posted by: paul | August 30, 2009, 9:40 am 9:40 am
if you do not have public option what happens to all when a epidemic surfaces by attack or naturally. You are disposed to spend all that money on the army but the people are the army without which you will have nothing. the poor are the ones that buy all the stuff the rich get money from. So the poor are the army who you the conservatives pine do not deserve healthcare. That is really stupid. It is the rich who are tight with money that is why they are rich, while the poot spend everything and get nothing not even get stiched up after cutting ther hand washing dishes for the rich and if they do get fixed a stupid stich costs thousands. A stich is the most stupid procedure it is exactly the same as mending a sock yet they charge you so much what stupid stuff the medical community passes off on the masses. Medicine is not that brilliant really and being a student is a privelage. The guys who should make all the money should be the labourers not doctors who are not that good anyway. I used to teach dentists prosthetics and I can tell you they are inept at it it’s just they make themselves sound smart, what a joke the whole medical field is. Its just like carpentry and nothing more, its just that htey put a aura around themselves as godly witha devine right to obfuscate and charge a lot. Second the govt already subsidises their education that means we the taxpayers do it already and then they rip us off.
Posted by: paul | August 30, 2009, 9:52 am 9:52 am
last thing if you make healthcare availabe for everyone you will have a nicer society with less murders and crime eventually. It will be a nicer world for the rich as well. Dont you want to live in a utopia. Voltaire and the age of enlightement paved the way with their utopian ideas for the revolutions of democracy and nicer societies and we are reaping the benefits of that. Univeral healthcare belongs to these visionaries and whoever attacks these principles is a backward boor who must take halucinagenic drugs to believe the vapid republican theories of what will happen if this or that. These theories are stupid and unrealistic. These people are going against their own good, Because a nicer world will benefit them realistically , while their own contradictory mind bending thinking is to their own detriment. Go to canada and see how peaceful, clean, and nice it is there. It is a example of the lies perpetrated by republicans on the american public. There are no slums in canada but US is full of them.
After enslaving the blacks and destroying the indians the US should be obliged to help these underprivelaged, it is the least they can do as well as help themselves. It is that simple. And what the repuplicans propose is so complicatedand convoluted that it just boggles the mind the arcane thinking. Can you imagine Picasso opposed to public healthcare. And artists like him create out prsperity not so much scientists, or bankers and you must realise that. Artists are the poorest group yet they are responsible for the wealt created culturally and systematically in society. without artists we are living in the dark ages with no light at the end of the tunnel. Roosevelt employed artists to success to draw the republic out of the dark age, charlamagne did the same in europe institutin g the Goeblin tapestry shops, italy did the same with industrial design after world war 2 to make its post war economy one of the richest. This is the right path not the religious and conservative vapid mindless uninspired nothing of a philosopy. And I challenge anyone to refute that please.
Posted by: paul | August 30, 2009, 10:08 am 10:08 am
i have really admired the americans for voting for change and i think everyone should have known what that change means. As we germans know public and private insurances being offered at the same time (and my family and myself having kind of public option) i really can assure you that you will get any treatment you need under a public option, too. So please do trust your President and do not get confused by the rebublicans who try to ruin President Obama’s presidency your country. Please support your President, so that we can look up to the American people the same way we did on election night 2008!
Posted by: uli | August 30, 2009, 12:15 pm 12:15 pm
With the revelation of the Veteran Administration’s “Death Book”, is there any doubt that the elderly and chronicaly ill would be told to “take a pill”? Those were the words of President Obama, responding to the story of a Great Grandmother who recieved a Pacemaker at the age of 100. She is now 105 and doing well, fortunately ObamaCare was not in effect at the time.
Posted by: we_are_not_amused | August 30, 2009, 12:33 pm 12:33 pm
The Department of Veterans Affairs has “a manual out there telling our veterans stuff like, ‘Are you really of value to your community?’ You know, encouraging them to commit suicide.” -
Michael Steele, August 25th in a Fox News interview
Politifact has rated Steele’s claim a “Pants On Fire” lie. Go to the Politifact web site to read the complete analysis.
Posted by: WWW | August 30, 2009, 1:25 pm 1:25 pm
I’ve never heard such bald faced lies as Republicans are making about health reform, including distortions and lies here. There is nothing in health reform about denying care to anyone, this is solely a Republican scare tactic.
I lived and worked in the US for seven years and I’d take the Canadian system anytime over the low quality, barbaric system I found in my time in the US. Not only does the US need a public option, it would be far preferable to have a single payer system as Anthony Weiner has proposed.
Americans should not let Republican distortions, lies, and baseless fear mongring prevent the American people have an improvement in the low quality health care system, heavily rationed by insurance companies, that they have now.
The United Nations rates the US health care system 50th in the world, just behind Cuba. This is in line with what I was forced to endure during my time in the US. Give me the higher quality Canadian Health Care system anytime.
Posted by: John Murphy | August 30, 2009, 2:09 pm 2:09 pm
To the totally misinformed idiots who claim there is no treatment for seniors in Canada, I had surgery two months ago at age 60, my mother had bypass surgery at age 72 and cataract surgery at age 77. Furthermore, 1200 of the hip replacements done in Canada last year were done on people 85 or older. Either you know nothing about Canadian health care or you intentionally construct self serving lies. Canadian health care is far better for the average person than American health care is right now and has been all along.
Posted by: John Muphy | August 30, 2009, 2:33 pm 2:33 pm
Mike Huckabee and the rest of the Fox “wanabees” will do anything and say anything to get in the running. “Death Panel” is another of the coined phrases that simply has no meaning in reality. Palin used the term and they are perpetuating the lie. For all you Foxheads – wake up – it is time to start using your own head and stop being brainwashed by these extreme nutcases whose goal is to make MONEY. They are NOT true conservatives – they are extremists. They are kin to the neo-nazi’s who want to strip people of their rights by teaching them to hate. That is exactly what they are doing. Does anyone in their audience actually think or reason or do you all just mindlessly goose step to furer Limbaugh, Huckabee, Hanity and the rest? It is pathetic. You have been taught to HATE without reason – to assume that any other news source is misleading you and to label other Americans with a different viewpoint the dreaded “liberal”. Isn’t that exactly how the Nazi’s got in power – by teaching hate, convincing people that, like liberal Americans and illegal alliens, that Jews and Gays and others were the source of all their problems? The Nazi’s also had control over the press (On Fox they have convinced many that their “press” is the only “real news source”. Also have you noticed that in many markets – they are the ONLY commentating station on the radio. That is true over most of the south. You don’t hear any opposing opinions on a daily basis. FOX is it. Wake up…change chanels…read things besides books by Mike Levin and learn to reason on your own. Reason would take you into an entirly new realm.
Posted by: mertsgm | August 30, 2009, 6:50 pm 6:50 pm
The little people that so many claim to be concerned for are already screwed by the current American health care system. If you are poor or middle class, you are at risk. Don’t claim that the status quo is cheaper or better to the uninsured, under-insured and fully insured average American that can lose their coverage… if they actually get sick. We are all already paying for those forced to go to emergency rooms for care that amounts to, too little, too late, and too expensive. People are dying and corporations are getting richer. Those who support that should be shamed publicly, often, and relentlessly. Any representative of mine that does not support real reform will not get my vote. On the behalf of the intelligent portion of the electorate, I will not forget. We are likely going to be the last industrialize capitalist democracy to care enough about their citzens to actually require we are protected from captitalism that is detrimental to our health. Very say indeed. Embarrassing actually. For those that think it is preferable to keep it the same, beef up the corporate coffers, I can only wish ill on those you care for the most. Then there is a slight possibilty you might find your humanity and maybe even recongnize the reality. Hopefully not too late for the rest of us to be saved from your ignorance and selfishness.
Posted by: Scott O'Donnell | August 30, 2009, 7:10 pm 7:10 pm
Sorry George,
It’s sad to see you riding the OBAMA bandwagon. Are you willing to do the public option or co-op? Incidently ,no matter what they call it from here on out is not going to stick.I hope they do call it Ted Kennedy Health Bill,now that’s under the bridge.
Posted by: Dale | August 30, 2009, 11:11 pm 11:11 pm
Huckabee is nothing but Palin with an affable smile and some polish. They’re both right wing nutjobs who have no regard for the truth or for propriety, and if I was an evangelical I would be embarrassed to think they spoke for me.
BTW after reading the comments of all these raving right wing lunatics on this blog I think I’m beginning to understand why Stepanopoulos is pulling his punches and is turning into a bland corporatist on MTP and elsewhere.
Posted by: sambam | August 31, 2009, 1:52 am 1:52 am
Actually, if Kennedy had been an ordinary citizen, and not from the wealthy and powerful, that would be a true statement.
Kennedy would have been given pain relief, and told to prepare for death.
Under Obama’s plan, it would likely have been worse. He would have not even been told what was wrong with him, he wouldn’t have been given pain pills, and he would not have been given another appointment.
Posted by: Rick McDaniel | August 31, 2009, 10:24 am 10:24 am
“Under Obama’s plan, it would likely have been worse. He would have not even been told what was wrong with him, he wouldn’t have been given pain pills, and he would not have been given another appointment.”
That’s a new one. From what sections of which bills are you getting all of that?
Posted by: Shomida Panels | August 31, 2009, 11:43 am 11:43 am
I ask all to get a copy of the September AARP Bulletin. In it, it debunks all the mis-information on the health care reform. No death panels, no taking money out of medicate to pay for the health bill, no socialized medicine, private insurance will not be outlawed and it places the blame on just who is lying to whom. They are not in anyone’s pocket and are having to do this because of the fear that has been perpetrated on the public and the fear that the elderly are now experiencing. People need to get their facts from other sources than talk show hosts and guests on shows. FactCheck.Org is a good source and now this. Unfortunately, much damage has been done but we need to get things straight. Read this article it is very helpful for all.
Posted by: talmag | August 31, 2009, 1:23 pm 1:23 pm
As I said in my comment feed, read the latest AARP Bulletin. It debunks all the mis-information out there by talk show hosts etc. It will help especially the elderly who have been traumatized by these lies. No one will take anything out of Medicade or Medicare to pay for the plan. I recommend Mr. Huckabee read this as it will straighten him out.
Posted by: talmag | August 31, 2009, 1:36 pm 1:36 pm
Mr. Huckerbee…read the AARP Bulletin and get things straight.
Posted by: talmag | August 31, 2009, 2:51 pm 2:51 pm
Huckabee sure does not represent a good Christian man. He is the devil in a three piece suit. He and Palin are good friends and he wants to be VP on Palin’s ticket. Both are sick. They don’t care about Americans and their well being of good healthcare. No these good Christians are liars and slanders but they are for family values. How can you care about families when people can’t get health care.They don’t care-only about their family forget everybody else. I think Jesus care more about people than trying to upstage Obama.
Posted by: lowes4321 | September 1, 2009, 9:15 am 9:15 am
Did Pat just say the little people suffer under Obama’s plan? Really??? The little people are the ones who will get the help they don’t have. It’d be nice if some of you people would realize you’re just not that bright and maybe you have no idea what you’re talking about.
We are the only advanced country that is set up where profit can be made from people’s healthcare. These companies are making boatloads of cash, sometimes by screwing people over. They aren’t in competition, they are in bed together because non-related companies make more money by keeping all prices high than driving costs down, an unfortunate truth based on greed that defies the intended good nature of our free market. This, by the way, wouldn’t happen if there was a non-profit government option because the big boys would then have a reason to drive costs down instead of keeping them artificially inflated for the sake of profits. That means lower costs for your business which is more money in your pocket.
700,000 Americans are bankrupted by medical costs each year, that doesn’t happen in other countries, but Obama is screwing the little guy right? I don’t care if you like him or not but at least know what the heck you are talking about before spouting off.
Forget healthcare, spend the money on education so all you mindless parrots can actually grasp what you’re parroting.
Posted by: Tice | September 1, 2009, 12:40 pm 12:40 pm
Huckabee is no better than the rest of these wanna be conservitives. Get rid of it all. Stop spending borrowed money. Audit the FED……Ron Paul in 2012 or your and idiot.
Posted by: Nick | September 2, 2009, 10:31 am 10:31 am