Obama: Immigration Reform to Start Moving By the End of the Year
From ABC News' Sunlen Miller: President Obama said today at a presser in Guadalajara, Mexico, that because he has so much on his legislative plate, and it’s important to “sequence these big initiatives in way a there they don’t all just crash at the same time,” that immigration reform will have to wait next year, yet movement will start rolling in the fall session of Congress this year. Ticking though the still-outstanding legislation yet to get passed this year – health care, energy and, financial regulatory reform – Obama said immigration will be addressed, but not just yet. “Am I going to be able to snap my fingers and get this done? No. This is going to be difficult," said the president. "It's going to require bipartisan cooperation. There are going to be demagogues out there who try to suggest that any form of pathway for legalization for those who are already in the United States is unacceptable. And those are fights that I'd have to have if my poll numbers are at 70 or if my poll numbers are at 40. That's just the nature of the U.S. immigration debate.” Mr. Obama laid out a broad goal for working immigration reform through Congress, saying for the first time he anticipates that before the end of the year draft legislation will be moving forward. “What we've been able to do is to begin meeting with both Democrats and Republicans from the House and the Senate," he said. "Secretary Napolitano is coordinating these discussions, and I would anticipate that before the year is out we will have draft legislation along with sponsors potentially in the House and the Senate who are ready to move this forward, and when we come back next year, that we should be in a position to start acting.” Obama admitted as he has in the past, that the system as it stands right now is broken, and that fairness is what ultimately the American people want. “We can create a system in which you have strong border security, we have an orderly process for people to come in, but we're also giving an opportunity for those who are already in the United States to be able to achieve a pathway to citizenship so that they don't have to live in the shadows.” Obama returns back to the US this evening after a quick 24 hour trip to Guadalajara where he sat down for a series of bilateral and trilateral meetings with his counterparts of Mexico and Canada. -Sunlen Miller
Email
Rick Santorum Sweeps 3 States
Pentagon to Open Additional Jobs to Women
The time for Talk is over.
We need to get those millions of undocumented Democrats naturalized and registered to vote by fall 2010!
Posted by: Community Agitator | August 10, 2009, 4:50 pm 4:50 pm
Another “Jam it through bill” say, do you think the administration will read this one?
Posted by: ZK | August 10, 2009, 6:09 pm 6:09 pm
I hope this time immigration can be tackled in a reasonable way, one that puts the human and civil rights of current American citizens first and foremost. Beyond that, whatever else this country is able to afford to it’s neighbors can be provided.
National security demands that immigration not be “reformed” so much as systematized. If our economy needs the labor, good grief, double or triple the openings for LEGAL immigrants. Why is this so complicated. Let screened, selected workers come in with legal status, and work and live openly. Know who they are, and what they’re doing. Monitor and provide renewals for their presence in this country — within a strict LEGAL framework. Give them that basic dignity, and grievance (and all that goes with it) will be lessened.
Every other country on the planet, including Mexico, has a strictly monitored immigrant program that serves their needs. Why this is so beyond the grasp of the country that was first to get to the moon I have no idea.
Posted by: mj | August 10, 2009, 6:38 pm 6:38 pm
I hope this time immigration can be tackled in a reasonable way, one that puts the human and civil rights of current American citizens first and foremost. Beyond that, whatever else this country is able to afford to it’s neighbors can be provided.
National security demands that immigration not be “reformed” so much as systematized. If our economy needs the labor, good grief, double or triple the openings for LEGAL immigrants. Why is this so complicated. Let screened, selected workers come in with legal status, and work and live openly. Know who they are, and what they’re doing. Monitor and provide renewals for their presence in this country — within a strict LEGAL framework. Give them that basic dignity, and grievance (and all that goes with it) will be lessened.
Every other country on the planet, including Mexico, has a strictly monitored immigrant program that serves their needs. Why this is so beyond the grasp of the country that was first to get to the moon I have no idea.
Posted by: mj | August 10, 2009, 6:38 pm 6:38 pm
This will be the final coffin of the USA, at least as we knew it. Unless I’m drastically mistaken Obama will go for an amnesty bill even worse than the previous bills and attempts. He will not listen to his initial core constituency but instead look to the “new voters” possible under a general amnesty and open borders. Obama, and his ilk, also like ideas of poor, uneducated people who hail from often corrupt and violent nations to move to the USA. They will vote how told, they won’t complain about corrupt politicians, and they accept police/military abuse because it will still be better than most countries they currently live in.
Posted by: Ed | August 10, 2009, 6:49 pm 6:49 pm
Oh boy. Think how many race cards can get played during THAT debate.
Posted by: Foghorn Leghorn | August 10, 2009, 7:17 pm 7:17 pm
Can’t wait too long—potential voters.
Obama needs someone to replace all the voters that he punked in 2008.
They won’t get fooled again.
Posted by: nick | August 10, 2009, 7:52 pm 7:52 pm
Immigration reform? Do they mean they’ll start inforcing the law for a change?
Posted by: LongT | August 10, 2009, 8:25 pm 8:25 pm
2010 is gonna be fun with all these xenophobic right wingers.
If the Hispanic vote hits 10%, the GOP could be done.
Posted by: Ryan C | August 10, 2009, 8:41 pm 8:41 pm
Most of the population of the US population has immigrants at its roots. But there was a time when the country was so sparsely populated that land was given away. In a time of deterioration in the environment and energy shortage and declining incomes for many Americans our ideal population is probably a stable one. This would require very little immigration (perhaps 200,000) a year. Fairness does not involve keeping potential immigrants that obey the rules out and letting the criminal immigrants stay.
With high unemployment of people with all most all skills (or lack thereof) and the huge glut of immigration over the past few years. There should be very little immigration for a decade.
Posted by: merchantilist | August 10, 2009, 10:25 pm 10:25 pm
We have had a huge wave of immigration over the last 4 decades. It is rightly characterized as a cheap labor anti environment policy. Among the big casualties of the onslaught have been less educated African Americans. Population growth increases the labor pool and pushes down wages. More people require more energy, more food and more water – all of which places strains on the environment. Immigration is responsible for essentially all U.S. population growth over the last four decades. A stable population it is estimated require immigration to fall to a level of around 200,000 a year. All of the Visa program land a typical mix of workers – just average skills. There are not tens of thousands or hundreds of thousands among the cohorts of legal immigrants- just the usual mix. Illegal immigrants tend to have very low levels of education and by breaking the law on entry reveal a propensity toward lawlessness.
Posted by: merchantilist | August 10, 2009, 10:42 pm 10:42 pm
This will be the final coffin of the USA, at least as we knew it. Unless I’m drastically mistaken Obama will go for an amnesty bill even worse than the previous bills and attempts. He will not listen to his initial core constituency but instead look to the “new voters” possible under a general amnesty and open borders. Obama, and his ilk, also like ideas of poor, uneducated people who hail from often corrupt and violent nations to move to the USA. They will vote how told, they won’t complain about corrupt politicians, and they accept police/military abuse because it will still be better than most countries they currently live in.
—————————————-
I agree totally. My two posts were censored so since yours got through the mind police, I decided to just sign on.
Thanks.
Posted by: Sunnyr | August 11, 2009, 2:42 am 2:42 am
Can’t wait too long—potential voters.
Obama needs someone to replace all the voters that he punked in 2008.
They won’t get fooled again.
—————————————–
BRAVO! My sentiments exactly!
Posted by: Sunnyr | August 11, 2009, 2:43 am 2:43 am
Why do we want to increase the population?
A larger population means there is need for more energy, more roads, more water and more food. If the population triples, we may have more military and political clout in the world. If that rising population makes the population poorer, the increase in global power will be attenuated. Deciding on an appropriate path for population growth should be the starting point in discussion of immigration. Immigration should not be discussed in isolation but as a tool to promote the domestic good (welfare).
Posted by: merchantilist | August 11, 2009, 4:16 am 4:16 am
Immigration is a card that Western countries are playing in the global chessboard. China gives money and material facilities to developing countries to get their resources. We give them ALSO the opportunity to send some people to our countries. Africans see Rome, Paris, London or New York as a sort of second fatherlands. They don’t see Beijing or Shanghai in the same way… TILL NOW! This is an important advantage of the West in the race for African resources. The same is for South America. Many Latinos see Usa as their second fatherland. Racism and closed borders would just spoil this advantage of the West and help China to grow even more in the global trade. Think about it!
Posted by: Paolo Zeriali, Italy | August 11, 2009, 5:03 am 5:03 am
Does this joker ever do any type of cost anyalsis? I am sure that it will be just a matter of days before he states that the immigration reform is necessary to fix the economy. I guess the argument that they only perform jobs americans will not take. Unemployment at 10%, so will they be saying that these 10% of americans don’t want to work.
Posted by: ubu1991 | August 11, 2009, 8:12 am 8:12 am
“Racism and closed borders…”
Its not about racism, not sure where your getting this at. We also don’t have closed borders. What we do have is immigration laws. My wife went through the entire naturalization process. Why should she even have to do that and follow the law if we are just going to let people come in illegally and just give them citizenship anyway? Why not just eliminate immigration laws which are designed to prevent infectious diseases, wanted criminals, and just about any other type of social issue from entering the country?
I forget the year, but Cuba emptied its prisons of some of the most dangerous criminals (not political prisoners, rapists, murders, etc) and put them on boats to the US, most of them made it here. Should they be allowed to immigrate or sent back to Cuba?
We need laws, we need them enforced.
Posted by: KR | August 11, 2009, 9:09 am 9:09 am
“”The law must be compatible with how people actually arrange their lives.”
Truth, it goes well beyond just changing the law. Our current laws are sufficient, the problem is in the capacity of the government to enforce the laws. First, why do these laws exist? Do you think its proper for the government to screen immigrants for things such as infectious diseases, criminal background, and so forth? Those are designed to protect US citizens. So I disagree and also agree with the author. I disagree that because we deem the law too hard to enforce, we change to law so we don’t have to enforce it. That’s a bit of flawed logic. While there are examples of laws that need to be changed, we need the capacity to process and handle immigrants at our southern border. Simply relaxing the law is not to the benefit of US citizens and that is the responsibility of the government to ensure.
So while some laws need to be changed, the intent to protect US citizens should be preserved.
Examples such as Dengue and Cholera are still problematic in Latin America and the Caribean. We still need the capability to screen immigrants to protect US citizens.
I’m not willing to sacrifice our protection for easy immigration. I’d rather demand our government do its job and protect our citizens.
Posted by: KR | August 11, 2009, 10:42 am 10:42 am
If Barry thinks We the People are loud now, wait until the starts with amnesty. Bush tried it and now that Barry is losing popularity, people arern’t charmed by him any longer and are asking questions – loudly! The immigration ‘reform’ bill should be easy and short: Enforce the laws already on the books, period! If they’re here illegally, deport them immediately. Use e-Verify for all jobs and heavily fine employers that employ illegals. Cut off all social services for them and change Amendment 14 that allows illegals born in the US to immediately be US citizens and able to collect welfare until they’re 18. Amendment 14 was passed for slaves and it’s being used to our disadvantage. No amnesty; enforce laws and stop the political bs. We’re awake now and you work for us, Barry!
Posted by: Mary | August 11, 2009, 11:48 am 11:48 am
Immigration “reform” has to wait until we guarantee health care for every illegal alien in the coutnry first.
That will no doubt discourage further illegal immigration.
Posted by: drjohn | August 11, 2009, 12:00 pm 12:00 pm
President Obama said today at a presser in Guadalajara, Mexico, that because he has so much on his legislative plate, and it’s important to “sequence these big initiatives in way a there they don’t all just crash at the same time,” that immigration reform will have to wait next year, yet movement will start rolling in the fall session of Congress this year.
Immigration reform should have been passed FIRST! If you are here illegally then you will deported back to your OWN country and have to enter our country legally just like everyone else.
This will save the state of California $10 billion annually alone (this number was factored AFTER figuring in the close to $2 billion they put into the state-huge discrepancy on what the state forks out for illegals versus what they put into it).
Posted by: KMDay | August 11, 2009, 1:20 pm 1:20 pm
The time for Talk is over.
We need to get those millions of undocumented Democrats naturalized and registered to vote by fall 2010!
Posted by: Community Agitator | Aug 10, 2009 4:50:06 PM
========================================
Ha ha….they already vote!
Posted by: KMDay | August 11, 2009, 1:20 pm 1:20 pm
Oh boy. Think how many race cards can get played during THAT debate.
Posted by: Foghorn Leghorn | Aug 10, 2009 7:17:29 PM
========================================Oh they have already been flying.
“If you are against illegal aliens getting a fair shake, you are racist”.
trust me, I am here in Houston and that card is thrown around like no ones business.
funny, you are here illegally and breaking our laws. If we break our laws we are arrested but if you do, we are suppose to look the other way and say nothing while we are footing the bill to take care ofyou and your family?
Right-i think not!
Posted by: KMDay | August 11, 2009, 1:23 pm 1:23 pm
Oh boy. Think how many race cards can get played during THAT debate.
Posted by: Foghorn Leghorn | Aug 10, 2009 7:17:29 PM
========================================Oh they have already been flying.
“If you are against illegal aliens getting a fair shake, you are racist”.
trust me, I am here in Houston and that card is thrown around like no ones business.
funny, you are here illegally and breaking our laws. If we break our laws we are arrested but if you do, we are suppose to look the other way and say nothing while we are footing the bill to take care ofyou and your family?
Right-i think not!
Posted by: KMDay | August 11, 2009, 1:23 pm 1:23 pm
No Amnesty for illegals, If democrats pass this reform they will lose another block in thier pary, The loss will be far more staggering in thier voter base then giving illegals amnesty.
Posted by: domino | August 11, 2009, 2:27 pm 2:27 pm
Amnesty will be a big boost to the fact that within 20 years the voting majority in the US will be Muslims. GOD BLESS you all. I’m 69, and probably won’t see the outcome, but feel sorry for the younger generation.
Posted by: USN,Ret in PA | August 11, 2009, 2:44 pm 2:44 pm
“Amnesty will be a big boost to the fact that within 20 years the voting majority in the US will be Muslims. GOD BLESS you all. I’m 69, and probably won’t see the outcome, but feel sorry for the younger generation.”
Huh? Muslims account for about 2% of the electorate.
Posted by: Ryan C | August 11, 2009, 2:51 pm 2:51 pm
So much for reform in Mexico. Immigration is also destroying the environment, but liberals will never admit to it. And Big Business has no better friend than liberals when it comes to cheap labor and exploitation.
Posted by: Pedro | August 11, 2009, 4:01 pm 4:01 pm
As I read the comments here I realize once again how ignorant we, Americans, are. Recently we rejoiced over the release of our own journalists from North Korea. They had entered that country illegally. We sought clemency so they did not have to serve the twelve-year sentence.
Several years ago a US marine committed a crime in Mombasa, Kenya (murder) again we cried for mercy for him. Yet here we are: the one people in the world who should be the most compassionate; we sue our political muscle to get from other nations what we are not even willing to give to others. We have so many immigrants who entered illegally, many who just want to leave and go home yet we hold them for years.
We should not expect what we are not willing to give to others. Yes, there are laws. Let’s abide by them but in the meantime what do you do with people who have been in the country for thirty years? Twenty years? Who have US-born children? Who have paid taxes for years and the reason they are out of status is our immigration system?
Politics or otherwise, I say this in all sincerity, my God will resolve this if we do not do it according to His will.
God bless America
Posted by: Zinzi | August 11, 2009, 4:26 pm 4:26 pm
Let’s take every single immigrant that came to US and ship to China and see what would be the result of it, after few generations… I am sure a very successful contry indeed. Let’s close the United States Border up and chase immigrants and see what the resut of this contry would come up!!! United States it was made from and with Immigrants…
Posted by: Julian Vieira | August 11, 2009, 4:28 pm 4:28 pm
Obama, Reid and Pelosi seem to say “fire and American hire an illegal”. Business and farmers want cheap labor (including nannies, gardeners and ground keepers for the county clubs) the extreme left wants open boarders and votes. Limit less immigration does not work well when the governments has large welfare, education, health care programs. Massive illegal immigration is not working well for the environment in California.
Posted by: merchantilist | August 11, 2009, 6:02 pm 6:02 pm
Some say the existing immigration law is too difficult to enforce. This is not true. A little work place enforcement would go a long way. The mayors of big cities like Los Angeles and New York have become advocates of violation of immigration law. They indicate that any attempt to assist in enforcement of immigration law will make people unwilling to report other crimes. This same incredible argument might be made about shop lifting, tax evasion drug sales etc. So with hold some federal aid (for say law enforcement) to these rogue cities. Do away with citizenship for children born to anyone in the county that is not a citizens or a legal permanent resident. These three measures and a little border enforcement and the problem will be 80-90% improved.
Posted by: merchantilist | August 11, 2009, 6:15 pm 6:15 pm
Some say the existing immigration law is too difficult to enforce. This is not true. A little work place enforcement would go a long way. The mayors of big cities like Los Angeles and New York have become advocates of violation of immigration law. They indicate that any attempt to assist in enforcement of immigration law will make people unwilling to report other crimes. This same incredible argument might be made about shop lifting, tax evasion drug sales etc. So with hold some federal aid (for say law enforcement) to these rogue cities. Do away with citizenship for children born to anyone in the county that is not a citizens or a legal permanent resident. These three measures and a little border enforcement and the problem will be 80-90% improved.
Posted by: merchantilist | August 11, 2009, 6:15 pm 6:15 pm
I myself in 1965 emmigrated to the USA. In five years I obtained a citizenship under the condition, that I spoke, understood and knew how to write in English. I found work (which was not very complicated in 1965) in two weeks. Received no money, financial support from the US. The years to follow were productive, possibilities were there and we progressively went on living. My opinion is that if any country let an emmigrant in (and they should), the emmigration group should fully understand and agree that they will have to follow the rule and an order of that particular country starting with the fluent knowledge of in this case English and knowing the history of USA as was required when we obtained the citizenship. The total disorder in the basic requirements is another addition to the chaos existing now.
Posted by: Jana | August 12, 2009, 8:19 am 8:19 am
Sorry immigration.
Posted by: Jana | August 12, 2009, 8:27 am 8:27 am
Path to green card takes 8-10 years for a Indian/Chinese in EB3 category.. and then Citizenship.. During the period of 8-10 years, he or she is stuck with same company at less competitive environment at lower wages. Definitely need to speed up this process..
Posted by: Ramya | August 12, 2009, 11:01 am 11:01 am
Let them all stay but don’t give citizenship, rather a right to work and come and go across the border as they wish. Their children will be citizens (if born in the US), but that’s already happening. Make them all pay a $$ fine, back taxes (if applicable) and let’s get them into the tax base. Also, rather than wait for the border to be secured, set a date (if Jann 1, 2008) that they would have to prove their presence in the US – that will stop the flood coming in to qualify for the program. Also, must learn English and not have any felony records ….
Posted by: James | August 12, 2009, 1:20 pm 1:20 pm
god bless america.
america is for everybody white black chinese asians we are all immigrant here.
this immigration problem realy need to be solved and as soon as possible believe me it is so hard and defficult to live illigale in usa.
unfortunately alot of americans are against amnesty.
to any kind of human relief for those people that came to us to make a living like any american citizen who came here from europe or any other places which alot of them came here with sailing the sea stop this racism lets be more human and let the world love america not hate us.
god bless
Posted by: george | August 29, 2009, 12:11 pm 12:11 pm
Amnesty for all illegals immigrants!
We the people of US were once immigrants too…came from England!!!
Posted by: John | September 3, 2009, 2:45 pm 2:45 pm
immigration reform is good.america belongs to indians first of all.i think americans should put their hands to history books and learn about their own history.they dont have any idea about their own country.and “YES”…AMERICA R IMMIGRANTS AND THEY DESERVE TO BE AMERICAN CITIZENSHIP.WHY?BECAUSE IMMIGRANTS R THE FOUNDATION OF THIS NATION.THAT’S IT.
Posted by: adrian | September 3, 2009, 10:00 pm 10:00 pm
Immigrants do deserve the right to be legalized as long as they follow the path required for getting citizenship and prove that they can be an asset to this nation. This is a country whose economy is to a considerable extent supported by the work of millions of people being exploited by the greedy and unscrupulous. Think of all the natives that were assassinated by the invading immigrants who decided to make this land their own, the ancestors of those who now oppose immigration reform. Guess what, it’s payback time!
Posted by: Mark | September 23, 2009, 7:50 pm 7:50 pm
I totally agree to this immigration reform for a couple of reasons in priority. In 2001, i immigrated from Former Albania,not knowing any of the language or culture of the US. As time went by i enrolled in a public school and eventually learned the language and culture throughout the years. in 2005 i recieved by citizenship along with my father,mother, and brother. But on account having my beloved Uncle without citizenship. As the years went by Homeland Security gave him deportation twice and he paid his lawyer for another appeal. Despite losing close to 40,000 dollars in the process of paying his lawyers to one day gain his right to citizenship, he has been working for 9 years current, a nice man, no wife, never arressted, paying all of his taxes trying to make ends meet. Currently he his still waiting on his third appeal, and has hope that these couple of months Obama will take on the Immigration Reform. What type of a democracy is this? what sympathy or recognition does homeland security have? These people are tearing apart families, ruining lives, and most of all deporting them. Im not stating that every immigrant should gain citizenship, but those who are not harming anyone, nor causing any trouble, paying their taxes and working their of should be eligible for citizenship. Im only 15 and i wouldnt want by loving Uncle to be deported. PLEASE HELP US OBAMA! HELP THOSE FAMILIES IN NEED AND THOSE WHO ARE WORKING IN EVERYDAY STRUGGLE TO SURVIVE!
GOD BLESS!
Posted by: Angelo | January 24, 2010, 9:17 pm 9:17 pm
the only people who can morally expel others from this country are the natives americans – the indians. we all came here by sea, air, or trekked through the desert.
Posted by: davj | February 16, 2010, 10:29 pm 10:29 pm