Aug 19, 2009 7:51am

Will the WH Use Hillary on Health Care?

No one's talking about what exactly went on in yesterday's Oval Office meetings with the Clintons, but Administration officials are thinking about how to use the former First Couple on the subject they know so much about: health care.

In the wake of President Clinton's passionate pitch to the "Netroots" convention last week, officials are debating whether to deploy Hillary too. No one may have more credibility than her in convincing Democrats that failure to compromise for the sake of getting something done has real consequences. But will weighing in detract from her current responsibilities as Secretary of State?

Watch my two-way this morning on GMA with Diane.

- George Stephanopoulos

User Comments

Wouldn’t that only bring up images of her failure last decade on the same issue?

Posted by: matt | August 19, 2009, 8:20 am 8:20 am

They need Hillary and anyone to get this passed.What are we thinking? This is no different than medicare and many folks need it( I am in Michigan).The money politics of PAC is a sham and should be made illegal.It is OK to spend money in Iraq but not in the US. Makes me ill and I don’t fear those who are not for this.Wait till you have no insurance.

Posted by: michaeljmazzoni | August 19, 2009, 8:40 am 8:40 am

Bring it on!!

Posted by: rightbehind | August 19, 2009, 9:07 am 9:07 am

The issues of health care weren’t as dire as they are today…the couple’s voices will be heard with more ears this time around and those who are unsure, perhaps their persuasion will allow to come to fruition…also, remember that Hilary was instrumental in putting forth to the houses a bill requiring that insurance companies allow mothers after giving birth to stay within the hospital for at least two days…they were kicking them out of the hospital 24 hours and under…mothers have a risk of bleeding to death within those first 48 hours…

Posted by: phantomniter | August 19, 2009, 9:21 am 9:21 am

This is not Hillary Clinton’s health-care plan, but a huge subsidy of insurance companies as promised to them by Barack Obama during the primaries.
When Michael Moore made “Sicko” he cut out my country Norway because it was to good to be true. This is our solution:
1. Insurance is not health-care. To buy insurance is not the same as to buy a doctor.
2. Give universal health-care for free to all. Old, very sick, rich and poor. You need to include the rich, if not they will not pay for it.
Of the 8 Dems in that first TV-debate wanting to be president, only one of them did not have a plan for universal health-care. Already then he was in the pocket of the insurance companies who deeply feared Clinton-2. Big whigs on Capitol Hill who burns for reform after having failed for 30 years gave Obama money, personnel and Superdelegate votes.
When it was over, and Americans once again was thoroughly screwed, they tried unsuccessfully to have Clinton their hostage as Secretary of Health-Care. She was smart enough to stay out of it then, and she should still stay out of it.
I just think it’s sad: You voted for the one candidate who guaranteed will not deliver universal health-care in the next 4 years.

Posted by: Sylvia Johnsen | August 19, 2009, 9:49 am 9:49 am

Mr. Obama and the Democrats forgot the one critical key factor on this issue: control the message from day one. On that, they have failed miserably and the Republicans, always looking for weakness, seized the message for their patrons in the insurance industry. Generating fear, the favorite Republican method of manipulation, spread like a virus among un-informed Americans who count on the news media to spoon-feed them their opinions. All, in all, the Republicans and the insurance companies win, the Democrats are clueless, and the American people will lose as we endure diminished quality in health care.

Posted by: DaveM | August 19, 2009, 9:53 am 9:53 am

Whoever! Just get the job done! If people are so shallow that another personality/sex/race has to convince them of the same thing, so be it.

Posted by: Gerald | August 19, 2009, 10:15 am 10:15 am

lmao let Hillary push health care…if it passes she takes credit, and runs against Obama in 2012 and kicks his butt

Posted by: stardate: 2731.1 | August 19, 2009, 10:34 am 10:34 am

The WH and Democrats just don’t seem to get it. The people are rejecting a big government take-over of their healthcare. At least with a private insurance company, you can sue for breach of contract, bad faith, etc. If the government controls what kind of care you get, you have no recourse to challenge them if the care you get is substandard. You won’t be able to sue the government. They will control what kind of care and how much care you will get.
And they say there won’t be rationing? Really? There won’t be enough doses of the H1N1 vaccine this year. There’s going to be rationing even now – healthcare workers and pregnant women will come first. That’s only right.
It’s naieve to assume that rationing will never occur. It will, and the people who are judged by the government to be the least productive will get the least care. Those people include retired people and infants.
The Democrats can now honestly be called the Socialist Party. They want big government to control every aspect of our lives – not because they care about people, but because they want to solidify their power. The more they give away “free,” the more votes they’ll get.
The American people realize that nothing is ever free. “Free” healthcare is going to be very expensive for all of us. Taxes will go up, quality will go down.
Obama and his Socialist cabal can try to dress up this pig any way they want. In the end, it’s still a pig, and the majoritity of the American people know it.

Posted by: Janet | August 19, 2009, 10:35 am 10:35 am

Real smart – take another polarizing figure who tried to remove our health care rights from us before…
We don’t want Government Health Care. Not now. Not ever.

Posted by: Jon | August 19, 2009, 10:41 am 10:41 am

How can the Republicans be the ones derailing anything ? Didnt we just hear about a billion different talking heads tell us the GOP was done or at least severely and nearly irreversibly neutered by the last election (go back and check out the commentaries and narratives from earlier this year).
I guess Steele is a genius as he seems to have resurrected the party that was completely written off as powerless, irrelevant and on life support 6 months ago….or do the Dems just suck that bad at actually governing ?

Posted by: undecided2012 | August 19, 2009, 10:44 am 10:44 am

I still don’t understand why the woman didn’t win. I think everyone realizes it now that it was a big mistake electing Obama. Was it a socially progressive move on the part of Americans? Yes. But was it a good time to vote in an overly-idealistic, both sides of the aisle, generalist who lacked the political experience and personal assertiveness/conviction to see things through? No. Hillary has the gumption and leadership that this country direly needs.

Posted by: Emily | August 19, 2009, 10:45 am 10:45 am

Dave M: “Generating fear, the favorite Republican method of manipulation, spread like a virus among un-informed Americans who count on the news media to spoon-feed them their opinions.”
Huh? Are you serious? The mainstream media has been promoting Obamacare from the start. If Americans are so “un-informed,” and allow the media to “spoon feed them their opintions,” they would be solidly in favor of Obamacare, not solidly against it.

Posted by: Janet | August 19, 2009, 10:45 am 10:45 am

Stop whining, Democrats, and just use reconciliation to push this thing through? What are you waiting for? Why are you vacillating?
Is it because you know you’ll get your buttts kicked at the ballot box in 2010 and 2012?
Obama has a choice – compromise with the Republicans and enact meaningful healthcare reform that does not include a public option, or use reconciliation to push through Obamacare and face a bloodbath in 2012. (And then the Republicans will dismantle nearly everything he passes).
Seems to me that this is a win-win situation for the Republicans. Not too shabby for a party that was supposed to be dead.

Posted by: O.B.A.M.A. | August 19, 2009, 10:54 am 10:54 am

O.B.A.M.A. is right. The dems are screwed now and they have NO ONE to blame for it but themselves. The public gave them EVERYTHING (WH and BOTH arms of Congress) and they still can’t get anything done. Also, I’m tired of hearing the lib media clowns talking about filibusters. The dems now own a filibuster proof majority. NO EXCUSES!!! Enjoy the next 3 years kooks. You won’t see power for 12-16 years after that.

Posted by: Ryan | August 19, 2009, 11:15 am 11:15 am

YES get BOTH Clintons involved. Let Biden pick up the slack for Hilary on foreign affairs right now. She can take over again when this gets PASSED. Need a PUBLIC option. Clintons can get it done…. Let them!

Posted by: SLICK | August 19, 2009, 11:36 am 11:36 am

Oh and start distributing SICKO for free to some people. Love or Hate Michael Moore. That movie was an eye opener.

Posted by: SLICK | August 19, 2009, 11:38 am 11:38 am

I still think to this day that it should have been President Hillary Rodham Clinton.

Posted by: Lenny | August 19, 2009, 12:01 pm 12:01 pm

Yes, adding Secretary Clinton, who had no success selling it to the public as either the first lady or a Senator, to this issue, which has nothing to do with her public office, had will really help – NOT!

Posted by: Publius | August 19, 2009, 12:17 pm 12:17 pm

It’s time to stop whining and come up with a plan. Look at the past, what has made America great? It was a free market and entrepreneurism . What has hampered that approach, the government with excessive taxes and over regulation.
The solution is the private sector. How about a new breed of doctors who are no so greedy that the want to get rich the first year. How about tax breaks to encourage such Americanism?
How about the government encouraging entrepreneurs to found new insurance companies that pay dividends if profits soar? How about no, or reduced taxes to encourage such endeavors.
The government has a poor track record with anything it controls and the government has yet to learn that a business cannot be taxed, it just passes it on.
If anyone believes in the free spirit of the American dream as opposed to an ever growing government and taxes pass this seed of an approach along to your representatives.

Posted by: Ed Taylor | August 19, 2009, 12:22 pm 12:22 pm

The reason that the Republican Party isn’t dying is because a large portion of Americans, mostly the rednecks (whether southerners or northerners — but mostly southerners), are stupid and uneducated and easily led around by tyrants through fear and lies. (I’m a southerner, but I got an education, so I know better.) Republicans/conservatives consist of two types of people: slick, rich tyrants and stupid peasant folk who don’t know good from bad unless the tyrants tell them what’s good and what’s bad (which is usually the opposite of the truth). Just like during witch hunts and mob lynchings, mobs of stupid people are easy to manipulate in the right hands. They don’t understand reasoning; they only understand FEAR and ANGER. Maybe the reason that Europeans and the Japanese don’t have so much trouble with far right conservatives (I’ve heard that their conservatives are more like our moderates) is because the overwhelming majority of them go to university (college) where they grow a brain through something called *critical thinking*.

Posted by: knowerseeker | August 19, 2009, 1:00 pm 1:00 pm

On the flip-side of that coin, the Democrats are failing to get through to people with the truth. I don’t know if it’s divisions within the party or just simply a lack of “testicular fortitude”, but nobody, not even Obama, is manning-up to tell Americans that Republican politicians are nothing but liars and fear mongers who care about *nothing* but the bigwigs, including insurance companies. Every lie that the Republicans come up with needs to be directly refuted by the lips of The President and every Democrat in Congress as *One Voice*. If they can’t do that, then the Democrat Party, freedom, rights, and all that other American jazz is done for.

Posted by: knowerseeker | August 19, 2009, 1:11 pm 1:11 pm

@DaveM. You’re right. But they made other errors.
1) Selecting Sebelius as HHS. Have you heard her talk about reform? She comes across as either unsure how to answer a direct question or calculating.
2) Insisting on Republican support. As Bush said, you’re either with us or against us.
3) Giving Congress rope on what you consider health care reform. Lofty goals are simply not enough.
4) Putting an energy bill before the healthcare bill. Obama underestimated how anxious all Americans are with all this spending and debt. An energy could have EASILY waited until next year.
5) Putting up with crap from the Dems. He should remind them that Americans voted for them for a reason and this is it.
In short, he gave the Democrats everything they wanted and now they are stabbing him in the back. Lesson learned, you get one thing and one thing only until you give me something in return. He needs to start playing hard ball with his own party.

Posted by: Cassy | August 19, 2009, 1:24 pm 1:24 pm

President Obama is a smart and talented man but I agree with many others that it should have been Hillary Clinton elected as President.
Oh well – thank GOD it wasn’t crazy/cranky old man McCain and the know nothing whack job known as Sarah!

Posted by: ch | August 19, 2009, 1:32 pm 1:32 pm

“(I’m a southerner, but I got an education, so I know better.)”
You may be a southerner but you sound like you received your degree in applied socialism.
I am a southerner, and moved out of the democrat party due to its obsession with killing pre-born children. Since my move to independent the democrat part has moved considerably closer to socialism. A party of mama’s boys that want their socialistic government to provide all their needs.
That being said, the republican party unless it gets a renewal is just about a dime behind the democrats.

Posted by: Ed Taylor | August 19, 2009, 1:36 pm 1:36 pm

Really? A one minute pre-roll? Great story but come on!

Posted by: newsmannyc | August 19, 2009, 1:36 pm 1:36 pm

Ed Taylor… Actually, no, an unbridled free market and pure capitalism didn’t make this country great… but it did lead to child labor, excessively long shifts and underpayment of workers (before the unions), dangerous working conditions… and more recently, jobs sent overseas. Capitalism, in a nutshell, is people chasing after riches and hiring other people to help them get rich. Job creation is a *byproduct* of capitalism, but not its goal. If you don’t control capitalism, what you get is some people with jobs and other people without… and those with jobs would just as soon die. That’s why we don’t have uncontrolled capitalism in this country anymore. Despite that, the problems we’re (still) having now are because we don’t control it enough. The Republicans are screaming “Socialism! Socialism! Evil! Evil!”, when actually, democratic socialism is a *good* thing (look it up) — it’s just simply putting a bridle on capitalism. Capitalism is like a hungry beast (hungry with greed); it can be put to good use like a mighty horse pulling the plow of job creation and economy building… but if you don’t control it, it’ll turn around and eat you! We need to better control capitalism in this country, including what the insurance companies are doing to us, before its too late.

Posted by: knowerseeker | August 19, 2009, 1:37 pm 1:37 pm

Great idea! It’s clear that universal health care is an issue that the Clintons feel strongly about. They will bring a renewed sense of purpose and urgency to the health care debate.

Posted by: Kaye Martin | August 19, 2009, 1:43 pm 1:43 pm

Sen. Jim Webb is going to visit Ed Taylor soon to have a discussion about “mama’s boys.” Hope Ed has good insurance…

Posted by: robert | August 19, 2009, 1:49 pm 1:49 pm

If Hillary can focus this fight on giving PEOPLE (not Insurance Companies)what they need, then bring her into the fight… we need someone with clout who is not afraid to throw a few punches at the Insurance Companies and the Pharmaceutical Industry, on behalf of the Electorate.

Posted by: plynch | August 19, 2009, 1:50 pm 1:50 pm

Yeah, I don’t think so. If the Dems wanted truly universal healthcare, they would have backed Hillary Clinton as our nominee, she’d be President right now and we’d have true healthCARE reform as opposed to healthINSURANCE reform Obama is failing to sell to the American public. She needs to stay put where she is, keep her mouth shut on this topic and let them sink or swim on their own. They wanted a rookie in the White House and that’s what we got. Let the rookie sell his own deficient plan himself.

Posted by: UhIdontthinkso | August 19, 2009, 1:51 pm 1:51 pm

BRING out HILLARY…. Duh!
I have been wondering when the Administration was going do this. Many of rural Americans… and lets face it, people who are scared of Obama”s skin color and all the prejudice that goes along with that, but need health care reform are effected by the lunatics yelling “Death Panel…” and the rest of the Garbage… and would be more amenable to the changes that are needed… if Madam Secretary Hillary Clinton gets out there and gives them hell…
I say do it… I know here jobs as Secretary of State is important… but Health Reform with a Public Option is one of the most important issues for America right now… and I am sure she would love to “gitter done”… Yes indeedy…

Posted by: Wil | August 19, 2009, 1:57 pm 1:57 pm

Of course Hillary is the one…in health care and in leadership on it. The inner-circle White House boys club is sweating bullets on this one, because the curtain has been pulled open and is now revealing a very inexperienced and tragic bunch of power-hungry thugs that don’t know how to run a government except through under-the-table manuevers that have already been spent and are now ineffective. These elitist frat-boys are being slammed every way possible by the real Washinton insiders and power-brokers and don’t stand a chance of making their agenda work. But the push is on regarding the payoff to the supporters and Obama will have to deliver because that was why he was put in there in the first place, to deliver the payoffs to the drug companies, pharma,industry and so forth. The fix is in and he has to deliver. What more can we say…we have been punked!

Posted by: swoosie | August 19, 2009, 2:13 pm 2:13 pm

Like this administration isn’t failing right now in their efforts?

Posted by: sue | August 19, 2009, 2:31 pm 2:31 pm

I think it is a good idea. Both Clintons and Biden would be good. People with white hair. We need to get the seniors on board.

Posted by: Lopez | August 19, 2009, 2:36 pm 2:36 pm

I thought the Obama White House didn’t want to make the same mistakes that the Clintons did back in ’93 with their attempt at reforming the health care system? What a big mistake this will be if that happens. Bill already said that he thinks Obama should pass anything just to pass something! What a waste of time that would be!!! What Pres. Obama needs to do is stop relying on bipartisanship….Republicans aren’t gonna vote for health care reform no matter what is in it or who tries to push it~!

Posted by: LucieLee | August 19, 2009, 2:42 pm 2:42 pm

Thanks for reviewing the talking points Stardate! We haven’t heard them before.

Posted by: reason | August 19, 2009, 2:43 pm 2:43 pm

Have we forgotten, the Clitons failed at Health Care Reform, so why is George S. trying to make them the people that will save health care for Obama. Am surer President Obama and former President Clinto discussed the Health Care isuue at their meeting, but if the Clintons get too involved in this other than what what President Clinton did at the Net root Conferenc, the media will be giving the Clintons credit for the Health Care. Reform passing and not President Obama. So President Obama has to be very careful with regards to how he uses them, if he does.

Posted by: JP Cross | August 19, 2009, 2:53 pm 2:53 pm

“The reason that the Republican Party isn’t dying is because a large portion of Americans, mostly the rednecks (whether southerners or northerners — but mostly southerners), are stupid and uneducated and easily led around by tyrants through fear and lies.” And the reason that the Democratic party is around is that appeals to the worst in people through its basic tenets: 1) Let government nullify the consequences of your mistakes, the personal responsibility for your mistakes, and all reason and incentive for you to not repeat mistakes. 2) Find someone else to pay for anything not whitewashed by Tenet 1.

Posted by: Publius | August 19, 2009, 2:57 pm 2:57 pm

It should have been Hillary! and Howard Dean should have been selected as HHS. I always new I was right when I wrote in Hillary’s name on Nov 4
Repubs swung the pendulum way to the right….Obama’s Waffling is only pulling it back center right. We need someone who would have been a bold leader not a compromising hack whose clear set policies who will swing the political pendulum back to the middle (Hillary in the primaries from day one told you exactly what she was going to do and how she was going to do it…not just hyping buzz words and slogans…change…yes we can)

Posted by: Max | August 19, 2009, 3:03 pm 3:03 pm

Bill Only!!!!

Posted by: Calle | August 19, 2009, 3:05 pm 3:05 pm

Please go and research the word Socialism, and then post! The government is not taking over the healthcare industry! competition is not a take over. Private insurance companies have created this problem!.Now they must be held accountable! If there profit margains are effected hmm. I personally don’t care! let them sweat let them lie awake at night worrying will they exist tommorrow. I am fully aware what this means. However nothing will reverse the Iraq war expenditure on this country any time soon. If I am going to be broke ( as some refer) then let it be for something I believe in. Future generations guaranteed affordable healthcare!

Posted by: charity | August 19, 2009, 3:56 pm 3:56 pm

To clarify the argument insurance reform is not the same as healthcare reform. True in theory, but try getting adequate healthcare without it. Here lies the problem. I am so tired of the Dems either you are going to jump in the fire or not! Christ. There is no safety net co-ops want work! It must be hell to have gotten that far out to sea, and start to drown.Becuase you underestimated the strength of the current. However it was that same current that brought you to shore. Interesting….nothing will stop Obama from being called a Socialist. Just on with it already! or admit the suppose bill needs to be redrafted. It better have a public option!

Posted by: hope | August 19, 2009, 4:08 pm 4:08 pm

I don’t think they should use Hilary… The GOP would only bring up how easy it was to pay her to shut up about universal health care more than a decade ago. She supported it then, but only up to a certain price. Somewhere near $1m I believe. Besides, she’s easily flustered and has been looking slightly silly in the media lately… I just don’t think it would help us more than it would hurt us.

Posted by: Julia | August 19, 2009, 4:43 pm 4:43 pm

Love your post, Emily! I agree.
Plus – have both Clintons go, they would rock it. And why wasn’t Bill selected as H&HS secretary, I would have done that, man! We’d be in a different place if these things were done (a good place).

Posted by: PNK | August 19, 2009, 5:07 pm 5:07 pm

Ask any small business owner these days about health care costs & they will tell you the high cost of coverage is killing their business! This is not about ideological or political terms like socialism, it is about practical things like economy, fair prices, fair
coverage for all! I was recently charged $66,000 for a 48 hr hospital to repair my broken arm after falling 10 ft through the roof of our home! Allstate Insurance rejected our homeowner’s policy claim saying liability only pays when there was negligence. I’m in two casts now & stuck paying the bill in full myself too because my employer doesn’t cover me either. That’s two yrs salary for me. I am for Obama’s health care reform
now more than ever! Can you blame me?

Posted by: tom g | August 19, 2009, 5:18 pm 5:18 pm

Everyone is forgetting that if the Democrats fail to pass healthcare reform this year, the party is basically irrelevant with their own base. They will pass something, but no one knows what it will be. In addition, Obama has learned that he really cannot trust anyone, even within his own party. His domestic policy advisors are mediocre at best (unlike his foreign policy team, which in my opinion, deserves an “A”. Obama has to get rid of Axelrod ASAP. Alexrod is a campaign strategist. He knows nothing about inside the Beltway politics. Same goes for Gibbs. He’s not tough enough nor knowledgeable enough to be the Press Secretary. Just because these people were great campaign staff doesn’t mean they translate to hardcore politics in Washington. Which brings me to Obama. He has to play hardball while Democrats have the majority. Just lay it on the line and be President. Tell them if they don’t produce reform, they’ll definitely lose their majority, so it’s up to them. Obama has 4 years. Some of these congressmen and senators don’t. It’s that simple.

Posted by: Laura Brown | August 19, 2009, 5:31 pm 5:31 pm

How about that Barney Frank!
He doesn’t like constituents who don’t accept his ruling class position.

Posted by: Ed Taylor | August 19, 2009, 5:42 pm 5:42 pm

howard dean would have been ideal to use for this heatlh care debate thats going on around the country he’s shown in the past not to be afraid to lock horns with the gop base and could have done a more effective job getting the public behind this kind of debate. he should have been considered for a cabient position.

Posted by: beforreal | August 19, 2009, 5:47 pm 5:47 pm

I hope the Obama team regroups and educates the public on health care. So far they have blown the message and let the discussion generate into a classic ideological war. With the advantages Obama had this time, Hillary could have got the job done on health care reform.
The public must be shown graphically just how broken this health care system is, and what will happen to our country if it’s not fixed now.

Posted by: hopesprings52 | August 19, 2009, 6:31 pm 6:31 pm

WHO EVER PASSES THIS STUPID OBAMA HEALTH CARE BILL OBAMA AND HILLARY CLINTON ADMINISTRATION DEMOCRATS NEEDS A LIFE TIME IN PRISON NOT IN THE WHITE HOUSE THIS VIOLATS ALL THE RIGHTS OF THE AMERICAN PEOPLE THIS IS TOTLE AGANIEST THE CONSTITUTION RIGHTS OFTHE AMERICAN PEOPLE SAY HELL NO TO THIS STUPID OBAMA HEALTH CARE BILL KILL THIS STUPID BILL IMPWEACH OBAMA AND ALL OF HIS THUGS OBAMA AND HIS THUGS SOLD OUT THE AMERICAN PEOPLE

Posted by: RAMBOW99 | August 19, 2009, 7:08 pm 7:08 pm

hopesprings52….i hope obama regroups like bill clinton and realize most of the country is not aligned with left wing liberals. i hope he realizes that his election victory was the result of a perfect storm rather than what he was hocking. most americans dont want this bill or the public option and they are not rednecks because they do not want to pay for someone elses health care. this administration is imploding. what s next…illegal immigration and how i should give one of of my bedrooms away?

Posted by: catman | August 19, 2009, 7:12 pm 7:12 pm

THESE 2 BILL HILLARY CLINTON BELONG BEHINDS BARRS NOT IN THE WHITE HOUSE OR YOU CAN SAY PRISON FOR LIFE

Posted by: RAMBOW99 | August 19, 2009, 7:13 pm 7:13 pm

We need a ruthless president not this vacillator.

Posted by: Butchie Barretto | August 19, 2009, 7:41 pm 7:41 pm

I think they should everyone and anyone they can in the Democratic party — obviously, the GOP will only stall, or cause too many concessions — they should go it alone!!
As far as death panels, that is what is happening now — people are not getting services they need because insurance companies making up the rules as they go along and as long as the CEO’s get their pay in the directors get their insurance and pensions they do not care.

Posted by: paulet | August 19, 2009, 7:42 pm 7:42 pm

i have no problem with government control. Why does everyone think the government is useless. I’d rather have the US government in charge of things than the state of Texas. We have a terrible track record on all social issues. Aslo, why are people so afraid of taxes. I’m poor now, but when I wasn’t, I never complained about paying taxes. It’s my honor and duty to pay my share in return for Fema, Center of Disease Control, national highway system, grant to students, states, anything we hold dear. When did the USA turn into a bunch of greedy idiots. The things said and signs waved at these town hall meetings are not how moral, caring citizens act.

Posted by: Terri Kaufman | August 19, 2009, 7:48 pm 7:48 pm

Winning political debates with personalities went out years ago. It’s never been a matter of who is speaking so much as what they are saying. Democrats boned the message, lost the audience, and did so because they relied on crony PR people who’s tactics couldn’t land a cow pie near a the ground. And yet, I’m unemployed–go figure.

Posted by: Dennis | August 19, 2009, 7:50 pm 7:50 pm

Gibbs denies that White Hose Dems will go it alone on Health care…Hmmm lets dsee what else has been denied by Gibbs, O.K.?
Gibbs Denies the Bow to King Abdallah
White House Denies Collecting Names of Opponents of Health Legislation
“Tech-Savvy” White House Denies, Then Apologizes For, Unsolicited Emails
White House Lies About Health Care Cost Despite CBO Reports
Robert Gibbs LIES About Obama’s Blurb on Ayers’ Bo

Posted by: pauldia | August 19, 2009, 7:50 pm 7:50 pm

Will the WH Use Hillary on Health Care?>>> What as a test dummy. :-)
Now they want a bipartisan effort? I am sorry I heard Reid say WE WILL do it.
Maybe he called some of the senators that have not been bought off yet.

Posted by: ChicagoBob | August 19, 2009, 8:27 pm 8:27 pm

My husband and I always joke when we see George S. and his supposedly impartial views.
Former Democrats, we’ll stay with a NO PARTY designation.
Endless “assistance” means people who are majoring in helplessness. We could have enjoyed it – we both chose not to.
Why?
NO to illegals and NO to “liberal” viewpoints.

Posted by: NoParty100 | August 19, 2009, 9:02 pm 9:02 pm

The government(s) Medicare and state Medicaid programs NEED private insurance companies – they deliver the lion’s share of services!!!!!!
Obama must have the IQ of a mouse.

Posted by: NoParty100 | August 19, 2009, 9:05 pm 9:05 pm

Nancy Pelosi is trying to get cheap labor for her Napa Valley vineyard multi-national company owners – her cronies. She will give the illegals free healthcare – don’t say illegals aren’t covered. They are currently covered, for emergency and births. Why would that change? The anti-illegal immigration groups are studying these issues and say there will be more corruption and fraud.
We already have illegals getting coverage without income level checks – you didn’t know that? Wage screens are used to check American’s income – but not illegals, since they don’t have a social security number!
What idiots we have in the government.

Posted by: NoParty100 | August 19, 2009, 9:14 pm 9:14 pm

They should Use Hillary so long as it includes a strong public option.

Posted by: rightbehind | August 19, 2009, 9:53 pm 9:53 pm

I’m against the health care bill because I do not trust the government to run anything correctly. I am however open minded but so far nobody has convinced me it is good policy.

Posted by: hkdakota | August 20, 2009, 7:35 am 7:35 am

I have gone from saddened to disappointed to alarmed at the lack of committed leadership so sorely needed to enact the agenda the people of this nation voted for. As a lifelong Democrat, I must also rebuke my party for putting campaign connections above public good. We don’t need Hillary to fix health care.
Calling to mind her positions during the endless campaign, we don’t need to be burdened with the mandatory insurance she would impose on already cash-strapped Americans, 1 of 10 of which need a job (remember,Hillarycare 1990??) “Hillarycare” flopped miserably then, and it is not the answer now. Sylvia Johnsen hit the right nail on the head, pointing out that “buying health INSURANCE is not the same as buying medical care.” Why does this discussion always begin and end with Insurance, insurance, insurance? The only real “coverage” insurers will make good on is the handsome sums paid out to lawmakers to sell out their constituents once again. I guess lawmakers really do not comprehend what a few hundred dollars each month would do to already cash-strapped families with ordinary jobs. I am disgusted with Obama’s vacillating leadership, unimpressed with Sibelius, and aghast with a Congress that can’t seem to recognize Santa on it doorstep. Most certainly they will lose their majority in 2010, and deservedly so. Too bad. My party has always had the ideas, but can’t seem to govern, whereas Republicans can pick upo a losing hand and take home the bank every time. Too bad for our country. How can we change this? Maybe for starters, we copuld toss “bi-partisanship” (whatever that is)into the rhetorical bilgewater where it belongs and try this- Health Care- NOT insurance subsidies. Are you for “We the People,” or against us? Do you even hear us? President Obama, we really trusted you. Passing anything at all just to say you did it is not the mandate we gave you. Give us the real health care you promised . Other Americans are routinely tossed aside when their jobs are obsolete, downsized, or outsourced. Maybe Insurance Companies need some downsizing too. After all, its the American way.
Marianne Menter

Posted by: Marianne Menter | August 20, 2009, 7:57 am 7:57 am

Why don’t everyone on this site grow up.
Most of the Representives haven’t read the bill they nit pick on what the they ffind and don’t even read it.
There has to be a start and we know it will have some flaws, but they then can correct them.
If we don’t have a plan to control the cost and clean up the mess we are not going to see any improvement.

Posted by: Lillie | August 20, 2009, 10:02 am 10:02 am

Just looking at that phony, phony smile of Hillary’s makes me want to gag. That woman is evil.

Posted by: Anna | August 20, 2009, 11:06 am 11:06 am

Obama is becoming a sad case – he doesn’t do anything – he does look good – his speeches are becoming less dynamic and more like every other politician -
Obama’s promise for change failed 100% in fact Washington is worst since he took office.
The Clintons should just go away – But Obama will drag her back into the health care debate and if she fails, she will have a hard time running against him – If she gets it through and it works Obama will take the credit.
Notice Obama is not involved, that is he talks around it, but personal involvement is not there. He turned everything over to the two biggest losers in Congress reid and pelosi who quickly shut the door on the republicans?
We got who voted for a person who has never done anything but talk and that he does very well. The American people are finding this out – we all were so hoping he would be the change our country so badly needed.
Obama will make history being the first black man elected President – but what will they say about him? That he turned over the country to pelosi and she hurt him, no the will not work – he just wanted the job not do the job.
Boy are we all in for it.

Posted by: A Citizen | August 20, 2009, 11:18 am 11:18 am

Obama says we can keep our current insurance if we are satisfied with it. However the bill seem to include a plan to ensure that said insurance company is destined for phase out due to inability to attract new client in a free market. Read it for yourself:
SEC. 102. PROTECTING THE CHOICE TO KEEP CURRENTCOVERAGE.
(a) GRANDFATHERED HEALTH INSURANCE COVERAGE DEFINED.—Subject to the succeeding provisions of this section, for purposes of establishing acceptable
coverage under this division, the term ‘‘grandfathered health insurance coverage’’ means individual health insurance coverage that is offered and in force and effect before the first day of Y1 if the following conditions are met:
(1) LIMITATION ON NEW ENROLLMENT.—
(A) IN GENERAL.—Except as provided in this paragraph, the individual health insurance issuer offering such coverage does not enroll any individual in such coverage if the first effective date of coverage is on or after the first day of Y1.

Posted by: Ed Taylor | August 20, 2009, 11:48 am 11:48 am

What would the Clintons be used for?????
As the example of how NOT to succeed?
I find this not just amusing…..but a raucous joke, actually.

Posted by: Rick McDaniel | August 20, 2009, 11:53 am 11:53 am

Hilliary would help in any situation.She is Class! Now there is also 30+ religious organization that say it immoral not to take care of those who are less fortunate. I think a lot of people will have to switch churches if they disagree with their church. The churches against the plan are attended by those that must wear white hoods to attend! Where do you fit in?

Posted by: Ken | August 20, 2009, 12:56 pm 12:56 pm

That’s fantastic news. It worked so well last time.

Posted by: Joe Eckhardt | August 20, 2009, 1:14 pm 1:14 pm

It ought to be obvious by now. Hatred is a much more potent motive for political movements than love. Most of us may want significant health-care reform but not enough to get out and demonstrate for it. During the campaign, Obama’s support was fueled by a justifiable hatred of Bush, but Bush, Cheney, and Rove are gone. Obama might do better if he “put a face on” the opposition and began bad-mouthing the health insurance industry instead of being always rational and conciliatory. What his program needs is an enemy. The irony is that we’re going to get reform (WITH a gov’t-sponsored alternative) sooner or later because the present system is unsustainable, only we’ll have to wait until more lives are lost and more dollars thrown away before it becomes self evident.

Posted by: Robert Maxwell | August 20, 2009, 2:23 pm 2:23 pm

Is it my imagination or are we in a political war over this. Are the republicans against for viable reasons or do they just want to undermine anything Obama wants to change? I can’t help but think we not only need a complete health care reform but lets examine the reasons health care is so expensive. Frivolous lawsuits, OUTRAGIOUS cost of care. Medications that’s as expensive as a monthly car payment. The rising cost of living is enough to drown the average paid worker not to mention if you only make minimum wage. Yes lets bring Hillary and Bill into the program, lets all get into the program and get this done. I don’t care if it is a government run program! We need something to compete with the price and bring the cost down for us all.

Posted by: Anna | August 20, 2009, 4:04 pm 4:04 pm

Yep, the Dems screwed up when they threw Hillary under the bus and pumped up Obama.

Posted by: Moderate | August 20, 2009, 6:23 pm 6:23 pm

Despite both Clintons being labeled racist and other slanderous things by the Obama campaign during the primaries the Obama folks now want the Clintons to come to their aid after Obama has gotten the 3am telephone call (a metaphor Mrs Clinton used to describe troubling situations). As Sylvia Johnsen, from Norway (9:49am posting), said: “Of the 8 Dems in that first TV-debate wanting to be president, only one of them did not have a plan for universal health-care. Already then he was in the pocket of the insurance companies who deeply feared Clinton-2. Big whigs on Capitol Hill who burns for reform after having failed for 30 years gave Obama money, personnel and Superdelegate votes.” I agree, Sylvia. Instead of calling upon the Clintons to help salvage this healt-care reform bill, why doesn’t he (Obama) call on Donna Brazile, Barbara Boxer, Chris Dodd, Teddy Kennedy, Dianne Feinstein, Patrick Leahy, Bill Richardson, Jim Clyburn, Maxine Waters and the rest of those super delegates who gave Obama Michigan, Florida and the election.

Posted by: Percy | August 20, 2009, 8:09 pm 8:09 pm

Hillary had a much better plan last year but you and your media cohorts were too busy with stars in your eyes over Mr. Obama, who is too arrogant and proud to make use of her plans. Then again, his goal is altogether different — it’s just a giveaway to insurance and health care companies — this is not something that will help the people who need it.
Let’s leave SoS Clinton out of it. The Clintons do not need to rescue his fat from the fire. Obama spent close to a billion dollars to get this job. He got what he wanted. Let him show his “ready on day one” like he promised.

Posted by: Annagain | August 21, 2009, 11:25 pm 11:25 pm

Remember Clinton’s doublespeak and spin about making abortion “safe but rare”. The pro-abortion voter knew he would reliably support abortion. The people who belong to an anti-abortion religion also knew he was pro-abortion, but they supported him for reasons of their own (known to God). They may agree with abortion but they aren’t prepared to admit that they’ve abandoned the religion of their forefathers and placed politics ahead of God.
Now we have Obama following the same pattern, just listen to what he says about healthcare and abortion while remembering that he made a promise to Planned Parenthood. Obamacare will not exclude abortion!

Posted by: Ed Taylor | August 26, 2009, 3:41 pm 3:41 pm

Leave a Reply

Do you have more information about this topic? If so, please click here to contact the editors of ABC News.