BREAKING: Rep. Charles Boustany of LA to Deliver GOP Response on Health Care
GOP Sources tell me Rep Charles Boustany, a third term congressman and a cardio-thoradic surgeon, will deliver the Republican response to President Barack Obama’s health care speech tomorrow night.
Like Bobby Jindal (whose response to Obama’s State of the Union speech landed with a thud in January) Boustany is a health care expert from Louisiana.
But GOP sources say he'll avoid Gov. Jindal's fate: “Boustany is a common-sense conservative who can communicate our vision for health care reform, and how we want to work with the President to do what the American people want: lower health care costs. He’s also led the effort on behalf of House Republicans to reach out to the other side of the aisle to find real bipartisan reform. We’re pleased with this David-Goliath matchup tomorrow night.”
Cokie Roberts, who knows a thing or two about Louisiana politics, points out that Boustany has a Kennedy connection. He's related to Vicki Kennedy (whose father was a Louisiana politician and judge) and Boustany's wife is related to former LA governor Edwin Edwards.

Email
Rick Santorum Sweeps 3 States
Pentagon to Open Additional Jobs to Women
I hope it is followed by the Republicans submitting their vision as a bill for CBO analysis.
If not, take his words as worth what you paid for them. You may want to consider the source too (the party of the birthers, Saddam’s slam-dunk weapons of mass destruction, Mission Accomplished, death panels, and most recently Chicken Little cries over Obama’s indoctrination speech to school kids).
Posted by: jhw539 | September 8, 2009, 11:10 am 11:10 am
Wow ….will the networks actually air another point of view ?? Most of them are still slobbering over Obama with MSNBC and ABC now being the sister Obama networks. Also if you actually read any of the bills you would see that there would be rationing, there would be panels of Community Organizers that would review your health care requests for surgery etc …and the bills do insure ALL ILLEGALS. You wont get to keep your own insurance because your employer will most likely dump you on to a government plan. It will incrrease the deficit tremendously. But many of you would rather shoot the messenger and blindly follow Obama over the cliff. The rest of us left the Democratic party when these radicals hijacked it this past year. You will too – in time ..
Posted by: jimbo | September 8, 2009, 11:21 am 11:21 am
“Wow ….will the networks actually air another point of view ?”
jimbo | Sep 8, 2009 11:21:35 AM
You mean just like they aired the Republican response to Obama’s last speech to a joint session of Congress? Or the way they keep repeating absurd lies about the actual bills in the interest of being balanced, rather than worrying about repeating lies?
Posted by: jhw539 | September 8, 2009, 11:24 am 11:24 am
Similarly, let’s consider the sources who brought us those wonderful messages like “General Betray Us,” 9/11 Truthers, unemployment won’t go over 8% if we pass the stimulus package, the $9 trillion federal deficit projections, the $1 trillion extra costs on healthcare, we want other people to pay more taxes while our cabinet officials get caught not paying their own, etc.
Posted by: bkm | September 8, 2009, 11:33 am 11:33 am
Thanks “Jimbo” for your professional analysis. Now let’s do the opposite of what the GOP idelogues suggest (if they suggest “solutions” at all).
Posted by: Ethan | September 8, 2009, 11:35 am 11:35 am
Any GOP saying they want to work with the President — Days late, millions of special interest dollars short.
This is the GOP’s attempt to delay this further in order that it falls into 2010 at which time they have no interest whatsoever to further healthcare issue along. It doesn’t take much to see through them for the fakes they are.
The only thing the GOP is supportive of — IS WAR. Spending the billions to battle in foreign countries the way which too in Iraq was fake. For them to say now they believe in the Afghan war — hello — they dropped that ball years ago and followed their Liar Leaders into Iraq for non-existent WMD’s and left NATO to deal with Afghan. Now the GOP want to return like they are the do-gooders. Fake, lying, two-faced, racist GOPer’s who will remain the ‘Party of NO’ and never vote in support of Obama.
Posted by: Diane | September 8, 2009, 11:40 am 11:40 am
I can understand people disagreeing with each other, by why inject race into this issue as one blogger just did? It serves no purpose and has no relevance to the discussion at hand. It’s just a “fall back” position that some people take when they have nothing left to say.
Posted by: bkm | September 8, 2009, 12:44 pm 12:44 pm
Charles Boustany??????Are you kidding me? There was no one else to select by the GOP?!
Posted by: bayoubell | September 8, 2009, 1:13 pm 1:13 pm
So the GOP couldnt give us a healthcare version earlier and talk about and explain it in a decent manner so they are going to air their side to try to debunk our current president’s plan. They are just plain ole “sorry” and some of them are racist!!!!! Yes BKM….some of the presidents oppositions are RACIST
Posted by: us citizen | September 8, 2009, 2:38 pm 2:38 pm
Why don’t they just make Charley Rangel, Geithner and Daschle and other Dem’s who are tax cheats pay their taxes and get rid of all of the czars? This will pay for health care for quite a few.
Posted by: susie | September 8, 2009, 3:32 pm 3:32 pm
I hope he’s as effective as that super orator, Bobby Jindle!
Posted by: DaveM | September 8, 2009, 4:54 pm 4:54 pm
He needs to illustrate to the people of this country what the Baucus bill includes, and make people aware of its contents, right now!
Let the people rise up and put a stop to this un-American proposal!
Posted by: Rick McDaniel | September 8, 2009, 5:34 pm 5:34 pm
if you want to leave racism out of this then PLEASE leave out the socialism, marxism, communism, birther conspiracies and indoctrination attacks…..fair is fair!
Posted by: amber | September 8, 2009, 6:23 pm 6:23 pm
Gov Jindal’s speech landed with a thud? Who knew! I guess however George and the media interpret things is how they go. Gov Jindal=thud. Obama=Soaring and inspirational. Who couldn’t foresee that? Especially from George “Democrat Toy Poodle” Stephanopoulos
Posted by: Keegan | September 8, 2009, 7:58 pm 7:58 pm
Honestly I can only imagine what the GOP response is gonna be… I can almost probably recite the whole entire thing right in my head. What they say will be SO predictable, because at this point everything that’s come out of their mouths has been the same old thing… lies, lies, lies yeah!!!!
Posted by: ltl lulu | September 8, 2009, 9:23 pm 9:23 pm
delay delay stall delay
delay delay stall delay
delay delay stall delay
delay delay stall delay
Posted by: LK in OP | September 8, 2009, 9:24 pm 9:24 pm
Thats whats admirable about the gop. They all take a turn when it comes to lying.
Posted by: gop liars | September 8, 2009, 10:06 pm 10:06 pm
Boustany is supposed to let us know how much the Republicans want to work with the President on this issue.
Where was he when DeMint was talking about Republican resistance making this the President’s Waterloo?
The not so “loyal opposition” needs to decide—do we work with and gain consensus or do we simply oppose everything even when we get concessions and let the Democrats go it alone?
Posted by: George | September 9, 2009, 12:29 am 12:29 am
bkm- ….”I can understand people disagreeing with each other, by why inject race into this issue as one blogger just did?…”
—————————————-
I agreed with you 100% until I went to a town hall meeting on health care and finally realized what is going on. The irrational hate spewed by some of these people could not come just from disagreeing on health care reform. When I heard the N word used several times in people’s private conversations as I stood in line and walked in the building – I knew that IS the underlying issue. I live in the South – and, after that experience, I believe firmly that racism is there, right under the surface in much of what is happening. Not by everyone but by a lot of those who are spreading the hate under the guise of “conservative” and Christian. It is very, very sad.
Posted by: Gretchenmom | September 9, 2009, 7:45 am 7:45 am
All four current versions of this bill make Washington smell even worse. Can’t we sit down and do something for the American people WITHOUT interjecting MORE Government control and without spending ANOTHER 900 billion of China’s money?
Posted by: No Common Sense in DC | September 9, 2009, 10:52 am 10:52 am
The not so “loyal opposition” needs to decide—do we work with and gain consensus or do we simply oppose everything even when we get concessions and let the Democrats go it alone?
I say they let the Democrats go it alone. It WILL be 1994 all over again. All of the liberals up for re-election will be replaced with centrists or conservatives.
Posted by: No Common Sense in DC | September 9, 2009, 10:56 am 10:56 am
How do you add a tremendous strain on the already gorged health care system without increasing (most likely decrease) the supply AND cut the cost? By Government intervention? How has that been working in the past? Geez!
This is the dumbest idea ever to come out of D.C. Well, second dumbest, right behind tarp!
Posted by: No Common Sense in DC | September 9, 2009, 11:00 am 11:00 am
The Republicans continue to look more insane every day. The “birther” is the best they could come up with to represent them. They are a party of no ideas and could care less about making anything better. They always prefer spending money on WAR. Tired old party full of tired old white men, one would think they would be running out of testerone. They only spout FEAR and cry Chicken Little.
Posted by: nanbar | September 9, 2009, 2:20 pm 2:20 pm
Wow….so Dems have absolutely nothing positive to say about Obama and “their” health care plan. The only thing I read on here is a bunch of name calling (“birthers”) by a bunch of whiny Liberals accusing Republicans of being underhanded, lying and un-supportive…are you serious?
I find it very funny that Democrats are Liberals are claiming these things, because this is EXACTLY what DEMS and LIBS have been doing for decades. Funny…it sucks when it’s being done right back at ya.
I actually hate both parties, but find the hypocrisy of Liberals and Democrats to be laughable. At the very least, GOP-ers are up front about their intentions and platforms. Dems use terms like “Hope” and “Change” to disguise any actual policy stances.
And to “nanbar”….”They only spout FEAR and cry Chicken Little”….wow, one would think you were talking about Al Gore and his environmental campaign, or maybe it’s Obama and his “the economy is ending” speaches, or maybe it’s Clinton’s “it takes a village” mantra. Kinda funny how things turn on ya…..too funny.
Posted by: TSL | September 9, 2009, 2:31 pm 2:31 pm
No Common Sense, In response to your posts – One thing I have learned is that health care if left the way it is, will bankrupt this country in not too long a time. All administrations have known that is an absolute fact for years. Obama has the courage to take on what no other administration has. He is not only fighting the far right nut cases but also the insurance company lobby, the drug company lobby and the far left in his own party. I am confident that there will be a compromise and many, many people will still be unhappy in all those factions. But, like it or not – reforming health care is the right thing to do. The question, of course, is how. It would be so helpful if people would start from the premise (because it is fact) that left the way it is, will bankrupt us. We have to lower the costs and from everything I have heard and read from reliable media, my own senator, and our representatvies here is that the whole purpose is to lower costs. There are a lot of ways that can be done. But to do nothing is simple irresponsible. I would hope you can put your hate aside long enough to watch and evaluate the facts not the rumors and untruths that have been circulated for months.
Posted by: Gretchenmom | September 9, 2009, 4:15 pm 4:15 pm
TSL- “I actually hate both parties, but find the hypocrisy of Liberals and Democrats to be laughable. At the very least, GOP-ers are up front about their intentions and platforms.”—————————————-
I find your comments laughable because we just survived 8 years of the most secretive administration in history. And this is from someone who made the mistake of voting for them. The only thing “upfront” about the new, “Fox conservatives” which have destroyed the GOP is the fact that they don’t hide their hate and fear. So, the Republican party is pedaling hate, fear and discord. They have turned their backs on the more rational Republicans (the moderates and liberals in their own party). They are sucking up to the goose stepping, gun carrying, far right fascists who have disguised themselves as “conservatives and Christians” – Don’t believe it – their idea of freedom is to make us all a goose stepping nation of people who act and think just like they do. And, unfortunately, those are the people who swing the club right now in the GOP. And,least you label me with the dreaded liberal label that Fox has recoined- this comment comes from a life long, registered, money donating, ex-member of the Republican party.
Posted by: Gretchenmom | September 9, 2009, 4:28 pm 4:28 pm
Oh god, he’ll deliver the Republican response to the bill? Is he going to end up saying it’s going to indoctrinate our children? That it’s full of socialisitic ideas? That no one should be allowed to hear it without reading it first? etc. etc.
Posted by: keredte | September 9, 2009, 5:20 pm 5:20 pm
How will we pay for this? Not even Obama knows! Where will all the new doctor’s come from? No one knows! Why will this government program work when hundreds of others haven’t? No one has answered that one either! Why do we need a government option? Power grab? Not even Obama knows what’s in the proposed bills but we have to close our eyes and say “Yes we can”? I don’t think so!
Posted by: FASTZX6R | September 9, 2009, 5:25 pm 5:25 pm
Gretchen:
I have no hate, other than the loathing of this bill. There are so many things that could be done that arn’t even mentioned.
Additionally, I see a few billion going down the drain in more useless committes and fat paychecks to Government overseers. It has always happened and the only way to keep it from happening again it to keep government out of it.
My nephew studying high school Government could and HAS come up with a better plan than this do-nothing congress has accomplished.
Our law makers approched this problem as the did the economy and every other problem – simply throw money at the issue and hope it goes away.
We are in desperate need of real Americans, real leaders. Unfortunatly what we have is 500 empty suits in Washington trying to figure an angle to get rich off of tax payers.
Posted by: No Common Sense in DC | September 9, 2009, 5:26 pm 5:26 pm
P.S. Gretchen:
The one who has turned the back is Obama. I voted for him because he said he would bring the country together. He ran as a centrist. God, I wish Hillary had won! This president has no experience and will put us so far in debt that we can NEVER recover.
We need a little more than “hope and change” We need a real leader. Obama ain’t it.
Posted by: No Common Sense in DC | September 9, 2009, 5:33 pm 5:33 pm
If the proposed Healthcare Reform Bills are so great, why can’t Obama pass them without any Republican support. The Dems control both the House and the Senate. So why are they blaming the Republicans? What are they waiting for? Sounds to me the Dems are scared. Why are they so scared? The Republicans at least have the balls to do things! The Republicans went to war for God sakes and the Dems can’t even pass a freakin Health Care Bill!! Give me a break! LOL
Posted by: FASTZX6R | September 9, 2009, 5:36 pm 5:36 pm
Typical leftist whining, Democrats have all of the votes they need to pass this bill and cannot do it because they are afraid of the voters.
The bigshots behind these Democrat politicians from Bear Stearns to GE, et al are going to demand heads on poles – Nancy Pelosi is toast for starters. Voters will take care of Dingy Harry in 2010.
Posted by: SirGareth | September 9, 2009, 6:37 pm 6:37 pm
No Common Sense -I agree with you that the health care should have been handled better. Obama was, I’m sure, trying to use open debate as a way to get ideas. How can you say after eight months that he is ineffective. I think he is extremely effective in tackling problems that should have been tackled a long time ago. That makes a politician unpopular. But all great presidents including Lincoln and Truman, were very unpopular while in office. I am anxious to hear what he says with an open mind. My problem is that when nut cases like Palin come out with downright lies, about a bill that is not even fully constructed, – and people jump on her statements knowing full well they are stupid – I have to wonder why. The idea is to lower costs on health care and I really don’t believe that Obama or any Senator will sign any bill that does not lower costs. Thanks for your reply.
Posted by: Gretchenmom | September 9, 2009, 7:02 pm 7:02 pm
P.S. – In response to your second part. Obama is a moderate. That is why the liberals are so angry at him and threaten not to vote for health care reform. Again, he has done nothing but respond to the problems already there. Where was the outrage when Bush charged a whole war? We are coming out of the recession, of that I am sure, but you can bet that noone will give Obama any credit for it. And, Hillary is in the right job.
Posted by: Gretchenmom | September 9, 2009, 7:06 pm 7:06 pm
FASTZX6R SAID – “If the proposed Healthcare Reform Bills are so great, why can’t Obama pass them without any Republican support. The Dems control both the House and the Senate.”——————-
Very simply, because despite what the far right says, Obama is a moderate. And the liberal wing of the Democratic Party are as hard headed as the GOP. They want a one payer system and are determined not to settle for anything else. So, in order to do the right thing – which is reform health care – he has to buck the extremists in both parties.
Posted by: Gretchenmom | September 9, 2009, 7:10 pm 7:10 pm
mr. congressman if you are not trying to help your fellow american shut your mouth and stand aside let those willing try.oh by the way how many dollars did you make last year?(thanks for saving lives}
Posted by: mewy | September 9, 2009, 9:22 pm 9:22 pm
Let’s see…a heart specialist M.D. & a republican & the only thing he agreed with the President on was the need to limit malpractice lawsuits. I can see why they chose him to speak.
Posted by: Judy Lilly | September 9, 2009, 9:25 pm 9:25 pm