Obama Ally: Joe Wilson Won Faceoff with President
For the third day in a row, President Obama came under fire from a Chicago Democrat who was the first Latino member of Congress to endorse him for president.
My colleagues, ABC News' Teddy Davis,and Elizabeth Gorman have more:
Rep. Luis Gutierrez, D-Ill., hammered President Obama on Wednesday for announcing over the weekend that he would not only block health care subsidies from flowing to undocumented workers, he would also block them from using their own money to purchase health coverage through the proposed health insurance exchange.
The exchange, as envisioned by the president, is a type of marketplace which will use group purchasing power to make insurance affordable for small businesses and uninsured individuals. Simply using the exchange to purchase a health plan does not entail receiving a taxpayer-funded subsidy.
Referring to Wilson's accusation that Obama lied during last week's speech to Congress, Gutierrez said: "The president didn't lie because I and others were part of a conversation that denied access (to government subsidies) to undocumented immigrants. But then he went one step further."
"Couldn't they call around?" he added, referring to the president's advisers. "No, they made a decision over the weekend. They said: Rep. Wilson? You're wrong but because you're wrong, we're going to go even further."
Gutierrez worries that Obama's decision to modify his health care plan in the face of conservative criticism will make it harder for undocumented workers to spend their own money to buy health insurance.
This, in turn, will make them more reliant on expensive emergency room care, the costs of which are eventually shifted to the government or to those with private insurance in the form of inflated prices.
Of the 12 million illegal immigrants currently in the United States, an estimated 5 million currently have health insurance and an estimated 7 million are uninsured.
Under President Obama's plan, health policies will still be sold to individuals outside of the exchange. But the whole idea behind the exchange is to create the kind of widespread risk sharing necessary for making insurance affordable.
As we reported earlier this week, Gutierrez first spoke out on this issue in Spanish on Monday during a panel discussion sponsored by the Congressional Hispanic Caucus Institute. On Tuesday, he continued his criticism in an interview he gave to the Los Angeles Times.
Wednesday's remarks were in English and were made on a conference call with reporters sponsored by America's Voice, a progressive group which advocates for comprehensive immigration reform.
Gutierrez is not committing at this point to vote against health-care reform when it reaches the floor of the House of Representatives.
Nevertheless, he finds it difficult to hide his disappointment in a president whom he worked to elect.
Referring to the Obama administration, Gutierrez added: "They said to us: 'we want to bring these people out of the shadows' and then we create public policy that pushes them further into the dark."
"Why does hatred always have to win? Why do the politics of bigotry always have to win" he added.
Email
Sen. DeMint: GOP Race Could Go Until Convention
Obama Avoids Questions on Contraception Rule
“Undocumented workers” — you mean illegal immigrants? The former sounds like somebody is here legally but just forgot to do the paperwork. I’m not conservative — I don’t like the “pro-life” propaganda lingo either, but journalists shouldn’t take the bait, even if they agree with the cause.
Posted by: Rusty | September 17, 2009, 6:19 am 6:19 am
Gutierrez has a point, although it was a wise political – if not policy – decision to take even the fabricated argument of free health care for illegal immigrants away from the fringe right. Not that they won;t still they to use it…
Posted by: matt | September 17, 2009, 7:45 am 7:45 am
I’d have to agree. Obama backed down yet again in his apparent never-ending desire to be liked by everyone, whether friend or foe, as long as they’re not a member of the liberal base of his own party.
I’ve pretty much given up on the democrats. They’ve pretty much proved the republican accusation of not being able to take a position and stick to it. Anyone know of a decent third party? I’m actively looking.
Posted by: jan | September 17, 2009, 8:01 am 8:01 am
Hasn’t this counrty seen enough of hate.. it’s sad to see and hear all of what’s going on with the Pres. and Wilson.. So many people have died and fought to bring all of us to this time in our lives. and there is still all this hate..
Posted by: tree | September 17, 2009, 8:11 am 8:11 am
it isn’t about hate. it is about taking care of our own and “undocumented workers” are here illegally. when does our role as mother hen end?
Posted by: pq | September 17, 2009, 8:24 am 8:24 am
So this is the nonsense that is being generated. Why block illegals from buying health insurance? It actually allows them to act more responsible and contribute to paying down our medical costs rather than using the ER and running up thousands of dollars in costs that they will never pay.
This is where xenophobia overcomes logic.
Posted by: tylerkad | September 17, 2009, 8:27 am 8:27 am
I think that even his supporters are now seeing how truly weak this president is.Wilson may have been inappropriate,but his comment set off a scramble to ensure that illegals would not be covered; a scramble that would have been unnecessary had there not been truth in hs original statement.The real lesson here is that nobody remembers the speech itself- it is all Wilson,Wilson and Wilson in the media.I thought that Mr. Obama was a master communicator-how could he be upstaged by a nobody from So. Carolina?Despite massive majorities in both houses this administration’s accomplishments (except spending money) are mighty thin.It is government by Brownian motion-everybody is in charge because nobody is in charge at the top.
Posted by: Nephron | September 17, 2009, 8:35 am 8:35 am
Sorry, I must have missed it. What exactly is the mechanism for ‘blocking’ illegal aliens from obtaining insurance via the taxpayer funded exchange? The Fed can’t block them from entering the country nor from buying insurance today. Police and ICE don’t bother deporting anyone anymore, companies don’t bother checking and verifying SSN’s before hiring. Any notion that they will be blocked is a…lie. Hence that boob Joe Wilson was entirely correct.
Posted by: Chris | September 17, 2009, 8:44 am 8:44 am
Inner city Blacks and others that suffer from competition from illegals would be better off if the illegals not only stay in the shadows but leave the country. There are nearly 15 million unemployed. We need less immigration and we do not need certainly do not need those whose very presence is criminal.
Posted by: merchantilist | September 17, 2009, 9:00 am 9:00 am
All of the Latino lawmakers, and indeed many Latinos in the media, have favored very lax treatment of illegal immigrants in many ways.
The citizens of this country, are fed up with their tax dollars providing benefits to non-citizens.
Those in the Latino community, who have shown heavy bias in the favor of illegal immigrants, may have to deal with backlash from the public, in the next election.
Posted by: Rick McDaniel | September 17, 2009, 9:17 am 9:17 am
tylerkad asked: So this is the nonsense that is being generated. Why block illegals from buying health insurance?
Obviously you do not understand what the concept of “insurance pools” is all about. This is the equivalent of allowing a bank robber to redeposit the money they stole into their own bank account at the bank they robbed. Under no circumstances should a person who committed a crime be allowed to profit or gain from his or her crime. No “illegal” (your word) should be allowed to enter into my insurance pool and have me subsidize any aspect of their life. And the fact that courts have been idiotic enough to force me to subsidize their K-12 education or emergency room treatment does not dimiss the insanity of their ruling.
Posted by: MNResident | September 17, 2009, 9:40 am 9:40 am
In my opinion there would be two ways to solve this problem, create a legal point of entry for aliens who come here to work while strictly monitoring and closing the rest of the border, give them temporary visas or force employers to verify them and then let them purchase their own insurance by creating a pool just for them so they have purchasing power. The long term solution would be to work with Mexico to clean up its act and create a stronger economy so they don’t have the need to come here in the first place. You don’t see Canadians flocking over the boarder looking for work and it is beyond time that Mexico and Mexicans started stepping up to the plate and began taking care of their own instead of acting like a banana republic rife with crime and corruption, it’s time for them to start focusing on education and innovative ways to solve their country’s problems.
Posted by: Ferrari5858 | September 17, 2009, 9:40 am 9:40 am
Obama is a lying? He has been lying throughtout his campaign about who is and what he is.
Posted by: Morris Berry | September 17, 2009, 9:40 am 9:40 am
Though this is a good point to discuss, it still boggles the mind how these morons spend so much (tax) money without batting an eye.
Posted by: James L. | September 17, 2009, 9:45 am 9:45 am
Illegals as every Informed American know, get Medical Care and the taxpayers are paying for it through Emergency Rooms visits….supported by the Law championed by
Reagan in the 1980′s, that NO Human-Being be denied “care” by the American Hospital system. OH WAIT….. Here’s the catch to that “half-arse, I did something for the American people” Law by Reagan is that the EMERGENCY ROOMS are only held to STABALIZE you, which means, I X-RAY AND wrap your BROKEN FOOT, GIVE YOU A TYLENOL-EXTRA STRENGTH, WRITE YOU A FOLLOW-UP/DISCHARGE PLAN THAT SAYS FOLLOW-UP WITH YOUR PRIVATE PHYSICIAN. WHAT PHYSICIAN! THIS IS WHY THEY WERE IN THE ER IN THE FIRST PLACE.
Posted by: sara | September 17, 2009, 9:47 am 9:47 am
To Chris. The only thing that I can possibly say and please do excuse if I sound a bit angry, but the fact of the matter is that YES maybe there are 15 million people unemployed but be sure that those people that are unemployed are NOT willing to do the jobs that these immigrants have. Many of them work as hard as they possibly can and get limited time to rest and even through such factors they wake up every morning to WORK. Understanding that every day they go out they are risking being deported. Risking the fact that they might be working with a racial boss and that possibly that boss might just revoke there pay checks and even through this many illegals still provide the necessities for their families.
Now do not get me wrong, I am not saying that all illegal immigrants are like this and I can agree with you in the fact that many are criminals and there are those that do not respect this country. With that I can say that yes i would like to see those that are considered to be criminals to be deported but I do believe that maybe when you comment on such a matter it would be a good idea to specify what you really mean, and also think before you write. you don’t want to offend anyone.
Posted by: Alyse | September 17, 2009, 9:48 am 9:48 am
I think Obama should stick to what he had promised during his election campaign. I believe that now he is starting to see things are going different from what he planned. He should review his policies and keep it without playing two-face. You can’t please everyone Mr. President . Illegal immigrants in this country are undoubtedly is a part of the soceity, they are very hardworking, not-so-demanding and not-so-choosy in jobs. To wrap it up, stick to what you have promised America while you are begging them for their votes.
Posted by: Powernap75 | September 17, 2009, 9:52 am 9:52 am
What in the world happened to GIVE ME, YOUR TIRED, YOUR POOR, YOUR HUNGRY.???Many of us have listened to the Political mumble jumble and none have heard the voice’s of the people. In defense to Joe Wilson come on folks he after all merely pointed out what we already knew POLITICIANS LIE!!! They have to convince us that thier way is the only way even if it is at the expense of the tired the poor and the hungry.
May God HAve Mercy.
Posted by: thetruthhurts | September 17, 2009, 9:58 am 9:58 am
Why do we have illegal immigrants? Because we have American employers who want cheap labor for the most part. If you use the laws against the employers for hiring illegals and strongly fine them (jail them if need be), we would not be having this conversation. They are the lawless ones. American business hiring them is the real core issue. Stop treating Illegals as if they are inhuman and all thugs. Most are just looking to work hard to help their families back home. They are human beings and should not be treated like garbage. You invite them here for cheap labor and then you accost them and treat them shamefully. Christian nation – your actions prove otherwise.
Posted by: eyeonyou | September 17, 2009, 10:52 am 10:52 am
it isn’t about hate. it is about taking care of our own and “undocumented workers” are here illegally. when does our role as mother hen end?
===============================
I don’t think it is aobut hate either – it is about selfishness and greed. Selfishness by the Americn people and greed by Corporate America. We have lost our moral compass and let us start by clean up American business and greed gone wild.
Posted by: eyeonyou | September 17, 2009, 10:57 am 10:57 am
I have to ask a question, with the LEGAL outsourcing of millions of jobs, why do we continue on our path of demonizing illegal aliens. We move our plants to mexico, china, india…
I would much rather see us stop that from happening and create jobs for all in our country and turn the illegals into tax payers and get our country back on the road to prosperity.
In the scheme of things, free trade agreements, tax incentives for outsourcing, and the lack of a managed tariff system is killing our economy, not illegal aliens
Now I am not a fan of illegals, but it seems to me we are keeping the focus here to keep people from discussing and addressing the real problems
Posted by: jeffers | September 17, 2009, 11:28 am 11:28 am
If Conservatives ruled the world, sick and injured illegals could starve or die by the sied of the road. they would be turned away from any medical care, be they man woman or child. A more heartless race does not exist than the so called Christian conservative.
Fewer illegals are coming all the time, but those who remain will remain. No matter how we spit on them and grind them under our heel, they have it even worse in Mexico. America the Beautiful!
Posted by: Phoenix Lady | September 17, 2009, 11:31 am 11:31 am
First I feel that Congress needs to back off Pres.Obama, he’s only been in office since January, he came into a mess that he now has to “fix”! Health Care is a Major issue in this country! My husband was diagnosed with Crohn’s Disease in 05′, the battle for my husband to receive Medicaid benefits for his ostomy supplies and remicade infucsion’s was absurd. The battle continued from 07′to 09′. The paper trail, driving expenses was a waste. Having a lawyer review my husband’s medical documents, he met the criteria of S.C. “working Disabled” program, of course he got denied & we had to appeal several times. I contacted Joe Wilson’s office numerous times to help my husband receive “emergency supplies” for his illness, I HAD NO LUCK! Representative Bill Herbkersman was our only help. As being a legal student, and very familiar with Social Security Disability Laws and Medicaid Program’s, (due to my huusbands illness)the headache and emotional stress it put on my family was uncalled for. I’ve had to write several research paper’s, my favortie topic was “Universal Health”! Every Legal American SHOULD be entitled to Health Care, however; IT SHOULD NOT BE FREE!! I grew up in Low-SES family, my parent’s still to this day live off the “system”, the fight for my husbands benefit’s, was not fair or right! We Do NOT live off the system, however; my husband does receive S.C. W.D., due to his “autoimmune disease”. He is entitled to that. My opinion to “Universal Health” is; Every American is entitled to receive which ever health plan, HMO,PPO, or a government funded program. However; if that person/family can’t afford a HMO or PPO health insurance, they should have the right to a government program. This program SHOULD NOT BE FREE!! Medicaid needs to revise their program’s; go off family size, income criteria, and monthly deduction’s (childcare expense, utilities, the same process & deductions that DSS does for Food Stamps eligiblity, ect.), then do the evaluation on how much the family can pay monthly for their health services to the government. In Canada, a family of 4 pays $125. a month. I have a family of 4 and can pay $125. a month for health coverage, I CAN NOT pay over $500. for health insurance for my family, inaddition, my husband has a “pre-exisiting” condition, NO health insurance company will cover him. That’s sad when he is required to have a “theropy maintainence” drug every 6 weeks @ the cost of $18,000. (which is done by I.V. only) and monthly medical supplies that cost $345.55 a month. We as American’s need to stop wanting things in life for “FREE”! If American’s can’t afford “real insurance”, such as Blue Cross, we should be able to receive a gov. state program, but PAY for it monthly! Yes, the benefits our limited, however; it’s not for “free”, & it’s not taking away from those who are retired. Another issue, American’s need to get over the fact that we have an “Inter-Racial” President, we voted for the man, let him do his job! He is part “white”. America is about “black & white’s” in this country, Obama did not ask to have parents from differnt races, WILL WE EVER GET PASTED THAT?? This is our country, that includes the blacks & white’s, we are all entitled to vote! My grandfather came from Hungary, but I was born here in America so what does that make me??? That goes for the blacks, their grandparents/greatgrand may have came from Aferica, but those who were born here in the U.S. have ALL rights! This country needs to get back on track & stop dividing this country, we should all be treated equally! The illegal’s, that’s a different topic. As being a resident of S.C., I feel Joe Wilson should apologize to the House. He represents this state, I’m very ashamed of his action’s. The allegations of Joe Wilson being “prejudice”, the word is not used only for “race” it’s also used for “unfavorable idea, an opinion held in disregard of facts that contradict it; bias”, I most definitely feel Wilson is “prejudice” for the Health Care Bill. I feel he rather focus on the wealth than those who are “low class/middle class” that are in need of Health Care. Again, it should not be FREE, we should pay some monthly payments into the program.
Posted by: Heather Sederbaum | September 17, 2009, 11:37 am 11:37 am
I am 4th generation, mexican descent and grew up in Texas. We have this bias against undocumented workers at times and I admit I have been prejudiced about them from time to time. Sometimes I side with more conservative views.
However – in this case. OH MY GOD who was smoking the green hawaiin herb up in the White House? Really? You do realize undocumented workers still have to PAY TAXES, and higher TAXES as it is.
They are blamed for creating a mess in our health care because of emergency room visits but given the opportunity to PAY for health care and be responsible they are flat out denied before given the opportunity?! I mean REALLY Obama? Is this some sort of Hawaiin thing to have no common sense?
Posted by: Jorge Lopez | September 17, 2009, 11:40 am 11:40 am
Should he called Wilson out to a fight, stop the maddness……
Posted by: emmett | September 17, 2009, 11:55 am 11:55 am
Alyse – how about these fine upstanding want to work hard immigrants work hard in the home country and make it a better place to work and live ? If they are the better workers than the American’s who “wont” do these jobs, shouldn’t they be quite capable of getting their home country on the right track ? just sayin’ !
Posted by: halfmn | September 17, 2009, 11:57 am 11:57 am
Anything the President does someone is upset. Where are the articles from people who are satified with the President. Oh I forgot negative responds sell…………
Posted by: emmett | September 17, 2009, 11:57 am 11:57 am
What don’t you understand about ILLEGAL???
Posted by: lovingpolitics | September 17, 2009, 11:59 am 11:59 am
Obama Ally: Joe Wilson Won Faceoff with President…….Rep. Luis Gutierrez, D-Ill. Please grow up……
Posted by: emmett | September 17, 2009, 11:59 am 11:59 am
Illegal immigrants should be REQUIRED to buy their own insurance, not barred from it. It would be far better for us as a country to force them into paying for their own preventive care than to have them clogging up our ERs receiving worse care at ten times the cost.
Posted by: mallory | September 17, 2009, 12:07 pm 12:07 pm
I find a lot of the comments above to be extremely naive politically. People have said that the president is weak or that he is giving in to pressure and changing his policies. But the people who have said those things are thinking, like little children, that everything is simple and straight-forward. The fact is that many democrats in congress are “fakers” who have extremely conservative views, but who campaigned as democrats because it was trendy to do so during the last election. The point is that THERE IS NO WAY obama could pass this health care legislation AT ALL unless he compromises with many political points of view. He isn’t blocking immigrants because of Joe Wilson. He’s blocking them because many (conservo-)democrats will NOT vote for the bill otherwise.
All law-making is compromise. And Obama is proving to be an excellent president–just look at all the work he is doing for the country! It’s amazing. No president in history has worked harder or been more effective. Obama has accomplished more for the american people in the first 200 days of his presidency than the past 8 presidential terms combined.
Of course, not every action is 100% progressive or perfect. It is a political requirement to compromise with people who end up polluting the legislation, but that is the only way anything can be accomplished.
Posted by: rich | September 17, 2009, 12:18 pm 12:18 pm
Who cares about ARCON…..
Posted by: Big E | September 17, 2009, 12:20 pm 12:20 pm
FOX news ACORN has you covered….LOL
Posted by: Big E | September 17, 2009, 12:22 pm 12:22 pm
why not let them buy health insurance and have them share in the cost since they are going to be here anyways? They will just go the the ER and get treatment if they don’t have insurance so why not have them paying premiums and helping to share the cost? Makes no sense Not letting them get insurance will not stop them from coming.
Posted by: Bill | September 17, 2009, 12:27 pm 12:27 pm
Illegals don’t want to pay taxes, many don’t even have auto insurance even though all drivers are “required” so using common sense, why would anyone believe illegals would purchase health insurance when they can walk into any ER and get free treatment? free vs not free, it’s a no brainer. If illegals wanted to be responsible members of society they would be LEGAL and pay taxes for all these programs like the rest of us do.
Posted by: Elmo | September 17, 2009, 12:32 pm 12:32 pm
If a person is here illegally and is being paid then he’s being paid illegally and shouldn’t be allowed to buy anything at all. They are ILLEGAL. I don’t understand why there’s even a debate about this. Change the laws if you want to but as of now they shouldn’t be allowed anything.
Posted by: George | September 17, 2009, 12:36 pm 12:36 pm
Phoenix Lady: That’s too bad, Mexico is their domain and they should stay there. Us citizens don’t invade Mexico so why shouldn’t we deny them anything for sneaking illegally here. We should only take care of our citizens.
Posted by: Mariann Pepitone | September 17, 2009, 12:37 pm 12:37 pm
The con which wilson stands for is confederate. If wilson had his way Georgia would secede from the Union and No one would pay any taxes and they would have no schools,roads and government at all. Than all Georgians could be as illiterate as wilson is.
Posted by: con me not | September 17, 2009, 12:39 pm 12:39 pm
Illegal immigration is becoming an industry and a crime syndicate into itself with the smuggling that goes on and the more it becomes profitable for the smugglers the harder it will be to eradicate. The US should really start coming down on the employers who hire them and start coming up with a cohesive plan to allow them to enter to work legally. It would be to our benefit to have them on record somehow so we know who is coming in, where they are and where they entered. For our safety and for their safety we should change our immigration and border security policies. There has to be some logical middle ground to this problem.
Posted by: Ferrari5858 | September 17, 2009, 12:40 pm 12:40 pm
Listen up: If 12 million people in uniforms with guns crossed our border and began to avail themselves of our systems, our communities and our employment opportunities, we would consider that war had been declared on our country. The fact is, 12 million is a very conservative number for the the estimate. And just because they didn’t have guns and uniforms doesn’t mean we weren’t invaded. Undocumented, illegal aliens should be required to register immediately and pay a fine for being here illegally. Post haste. Where else in the world would such a flagrant abuse be tolerated?
So the fact is, Guitterez is wrong. He and others politicians turn a deliberately blind eye to this continuing abuse. It robs American workers of jobs, forces us to compete for the very benefits our hard earned deductions paid for. It’s a travesty and I think people in our government who continue to do nothing about it should go to prison. What is the law if rich a-holes have the audacity to flaunt it to save a few bucks? Their dream of destroying the American middle class is rolling right along. I don’t blame the patriots and the militias one bit for being up in arms about this. If 12 million+ Americans crossed Mexico’s border and began to take up residence, there would be a war for sure.
Posted by: K. Kojei | September 17, 2009, 12:40 pm 12:40 pm
MNresidents says **Obviously you do not understand what the concept of “insurance pools” is all about. This is the equivalent of allowing a bank robber to redeposit the money they stole into their own bank account at the bank they robbed*** It’s obviously you that doesn’t understand the “pool” it is NOTHING like a bank robber robbing banks JEZZZZZZZZZZ. Don’t you get it you are already helping them by subsidizing their ER visits? Let them in the pool so they are sharing the cost. Of course you think its better for you to pay/us it LOL. Most Illegals are young healthy adults that need very little Health care. they would be a welcome members by any insurance company for that reason alone and would add millions to the “Pool” that we all use.
Posted by: Bill | September 17, 2009, 12:48 pm 12:48 pm
If they are not legal they should not get care. If the hospital chooses to take care of them, the hospital should pay for it. If the hospital raise their bills they should loose business. They should be made to post their rates like other companies must do.
Posted by: Joe Eckhardt | September 17, 2009, 12:49 pm 12:49 pm
What is it about “illegal” do they not understand? People that sneak across our borders have NO rights. Of the millions of ILLEGALS who have health insurance here, how many of them are on medicaid????
Posted by: bo | September 17, 2009, 12:50 pm 12:50 pm
Documented undocumented legal illegal …watc hte wording folks..because thats how they will push throug ha bill to cover them. Dont forget that Obama received the most from insurance companies while he wasa Senator. Michelle has ties to the hopitals and insurance companies. Soros and his pals doo too. There are reasons for this mad rush to push the bill through and dont think its concern about all of us… This legislation is huge and will have an impact on everyone – except our illustrious Congress and Mr Obama – why are we RUSHING it ??? Take time and do it right
Posted by: jimbo | September 17, 2009, 12:52 pm 12:52 pm
Jorge…as a fellow T4exan….you have got to be kidding! If they wanted to be “responsible”, they wouldn’t be here illegally, collecting food stamps, housing subsidies, etc. They have NO rights except to board the bus back to where they came from. I welcome immigration, as long as it is done legally. Most fellow hispanics feel the same way.
Posted by: bo | September 17, 2009, 12:53 pm 12:53 pm
Case in point….recently a mexican woman sneaking across the border with her teenage son, called 911 because they ran out of food and water. Ground crews and search helicopters were dispatched and they were found. She is in jail waithing extradition…she had recently been sent back to Mexico, and here she was sneaking over again. Her son was sent to relatives in Mexico. This cost taxpayers hundreds of thousands of dollars.
Posted by: bo | September 17, 2009, 12:55 pm 12:55 pm
You come to my front door and knock, I’ll greet you and invite you in….you sneak into my home by the back window, you’ll be met by force. Same principal….send em’ all packing and let them come across legally.
Posted by: americafirst | September 17, 2009, 12:59 pm 12:59 pm
Okay, is the House going to go back and sanction the Democrats that Booed President Bush? No I don’t think so. Are the Democrats going to vote, yet again, to change the way a vacancy is filled in Mass? Absolutely. Does Rep. Joe Wilson need to bow down and kiss the President’s ring? What do you think?
Posted by: dandydonmc | September 17, 2009, 12:59 pm 12:59 pm
I like what you said PhoenixLady! If there here, there not going back. The Mexican (legal) employees that work for my company are afraid to go home just to visit. The drug cartel violence in that country is horrible. They police are crooked as a dogs hind leg and the last time one of our guys went home he was pulled over by the police and they took all his cash and then let them go. This has has happened to them twice. They felt lucky for their life. If they are here to stay, we need to make them go thru the legal process, pay their dues, learn ENGLISH and pay taxes. After that there is no reason they shouldn’t be able to buy insurance. I don’t agree that they should be able to buy insurance if they are illegal though. I think they would be more egar to become legal if they could get health care. Most of them want to become legal! The main problem is the companies that are allowing them to work here illegally, and ICE needs to step up on these companies and start fineing them like the law says!
Posted by: Joker1956 | September 17, 2009, 1:12 pm 1:12 pm
You’re illegal means you are undocumented means you are not here and will be treated as such. How does Mexico treats illegal aliens in Mexico. Exactly the same.
Posted by: Sally | September 17, 2009, 1:21 pm 1:21 pm
I agree that President Obama should have called Wilson out to fight. Not only would it have stopped the madness, but it would have shown character. That in turn would have push the health care bill a little bit further in the right direction. I think the President is doing good, but could use a little more focus.
Posted by: ruth | September 17, 2009, 1:25 pm 1:25 pm
I wonder if we are better or worse off financially allowing illegal immigrants into insurance pools, assuming they pay their own way? I don’t want them here, but if they are here, do we really want to deny them access to decent medical care?
As I understand it, the concept at work in health insurance is that the bigger the pool covered people, the more the risks are spread and the cheaper it can be for everyone? Or would illegals be an added burden because they need more medical services than others? I don’t know the answer, but if their participation would make it cheaper for the rest of us, it seem like a reasonable arugment for allowing them into the pool. Even if a few taxpayer dollars benefit them by subsidizing the operation of these healthcare insurance cooperatives, it might be a net plus — or not. A factual analysis would be useful.
Posted by: savage64 | September 17, 2009, 1:25 pm 1:25 pm
President Obama is doing a great job. He is working on the tough issues no one had the courage to deal with in the past, except Pres. Clinton. He inherited a massive debt. He is not even a year into his Presidency. Give him a break.
Posted by: Brandon | September 17, 2009, 1:26 pm 1:26 pm
alyse wrote a nice email about how hard illegals work and how our unemployed wouldnt do what the illegals do. i agree from the standpoint that they work very hard. i disagree that americans wouldnt do those jobs, if the illegals were gone the wages for those jobs would rise and americans would fill tyhose jobs. if we got tougher with handouts americans would fill those jobs at a higher wage than the illglas were getting. we could have full employment for americans and fewer illegals to tax the system.
Posted by: catman | September 17, 2009, 1:36 pm 1:36 pm
OK,….here is a suggestion–ALLOW immigrants coverage, document where they are from and then BILL THEIR HOME COUNTRY—subract it from whatever subsidy our govt/country already gives them–subtract the care of THEIR citizens that way, those in need of medical care GET medical care and it is then paid for–THAT COULD WORK BEST FOR ALL CONCERNED !!!
Posted by: Buttons44 | September 17, 2009, 1:42 pm 1:42 pm
Why is it hate to want to limit our public health care system to citizens and people who are here legally?
If you want to have access to our new system, then be in this country legally – it’s that simple!
Posted by: Vick | September 17, 2009, 1:50 pm 1:50 pm
Wilson did win in the sense that the only thing people now remember about the speech is ‘You Lie’. Not great PR for the President and now his ‘allies’ keep shouting racism when what they really need to do is prove the policy should be passed on merit. Name calling just says weakness.
Posted by: bct | September 17, 2009, 1:52 pm 1:52 pm
What this fuss about race again?? The United States of America will continue to be racists until 1) school districts are abolished fostering race segration.
Posted by: maryjo | September 17, 2009, 1:56 pm 1:56 pm
I support the President. I don’t support the losers who take every opportunity to try and put Obama in a bad light. They are only showing their ignorace. The last President couldn’t find his *** with both hands and the folks who voted for him are just looking for a way to get out of the hole they dug for themselves. Crow for all of them…
Posted by: MRTexas | September 17, 2009, 1:59 pm 1:59 pm
Isn’t this great. President Obama lies about his intentions to extend healthcare to illegals, gets called out on it (totally inappropriately but so publically) and then has to live up a statement he had preferred we all would have just forgoten. Politics is tricky business indeed.
Posted by: Buck7756 | September 17, 2009, 2:03 pm 2:03 pm
Openly advocating Federal benefits for illegal immigrants is political suicide. Obama knows this. Poll after poll shows that American’s are angry about the uncontrolled nature of illegal immigration and they blame the Federal government. And making Joe into a story right now is a big, big mistake.
Pelosi should have taken her cue from the President and let it die. But now Jimmy Carter has joined Dowd in throwing the race card on the table. The timing could not have been worse for Democrats. The Joe story and Acorn have virtually sucked the air out of the room and the poll numbers for Obama are falling yet again.
One has to wonder whether liberals have lost their minds? Why don’t they just charter buses and start shipping the independents over to the RNC?
Posted by: jche | September 17, 2009, 2:09 pm 2:09 pm
What was all the fuss about, politicians are profesional liars – and they call each other “liar” all the time. Usually it is done with a little more subtlety.
Posted by: Ed Butt | September 17, 2009, 2:39 pm 2:39 pm
The President is not being a bigot. This is not a racial issue. This is a legal issue. The illegals need to become legal or go back to their countries. Why come to the Unite States from any country and not become legal. I am in the medical field and I am tired of the uninsured illegals getting free care when I pay through the nose for my children to get care. This is not racial this ignorance and arrogance on the parts of the illegals and the government.
Posted by: Patricia McFadyen | September 17, 2009, 2:48 pm 2:48 pm
Undocumented works are the new scapegoat.
The US will pay much more for health care because the illegal worker will have to go to the emergency room for help.
The best plan would be single payer.
But that’s been killed already and soon the public option will follow.
Private insurance companies will maintain their stranglehold on the American People.
Posted by: RRuin | September 17, 2009, 2:51 pm 2:51 pm
Now, I’ am going to say this as clear as I can. Obama, did not tell, or order any changes to the Bill, he did not lie, he did tell the truth.
Now the Bill can be changed and if it’s changed, it will be done by Senators, or Representatives, not Obama.
Last, yes Obama can ask for changes, but he has not and not ask for that change, why would he if it correct as he said and it was correct what he said.
So, Mr. Rep. Luis Gutierrez, D-Ill., get a grip and your issue is with your fellow Representatives, stop making up crap.
Posted by: Bruce | September 17, 2009, 3:00 pm 3:00 pm
Am I incorrect in saying that the wording of the bill in question was changed by the (worthless) Gang of 6? I do hope I am incorrect- otherwise there’s a whole lot of folks from above that have no idea what’s going on.
Posted by: hoser | September 17, 2009, 3:03 pm 3:03 pm
I’d hardly say he said ‘Joe Wilson won’.
What a ridiculous headline.
Posted by: Get it Right | September 17, 2009, 3:14 pm 3:14 pm
Many people here are missing a point I would like to bring up…Where it may likely be true that Illegal Aliens will be denied access to the Healthcare Refrom….What happens should the democrats in charge simply grant amnesty to all illegal aliens currently in the US? Won’t they then have the access? Sounds to me like Obama is setting up a slick “out” for himself and his party.
Posted by: Chris | September 17, 2009, 3:21 pm 3:21 pm
WOW! Is this a misleading headline.
Posted by: KdNicewanger | September 17, 2009, 3:26 pm 3:26 pm
Not all that misleading if you consider Joe Wilson’s primary objection is that he doesn’t want Illegal Aliens covered under the Healthcare Bill. By pushing Obama in a corner regarding the issue…In the end, he has gotten what he really wanted with Obama insisting publicly illegals will not be covered.
Posted by: Chris | September 17, 2009, 3:29 pm 3:29 pm
This is a no win situation so might as well be strong and go forward: If you allow illegals to buy insurance you are also admitting it is OK for them to be here undocumented and therefore you are “weak” on them to the right. If you deny them buying insurance you force them into the emergency rooms and/or they suffer with no care and you are “heartless” to the left. Where does the President have to come down here? I say support those who brought you and let them buy insurance if they can pay for it. After all, they do pay taxes and if they have a job they probably have a ssn even if it is not theirs so they are putting tax money back into the system. BE STRONG! Fight for a public option because we could and are doing worst without socialized medicine.
Posted by: TEHelms | September 17, 2009, 3:33 pm 3:33 pm
Denying the ability of illegal immigrants to purchase their own affordable insurance, with their own money, to positively, absolutely, make sure they can’t get health care until it’s the most expensive ER and hospital care we will pay for out of our own pockets, is truly cutting off our xenophobic noses to spite our faces.
Should everyone’s citizenship be checked when we all try to shop at WalMart too?
Or do people imagine in this new world of making sure we absolutely deny all the necessities of any illegal could possibly want to purchase, only brown people will be subjected to citizenship checks?
Posted by: melodramy | September 17, 2009, 3:35 pm 3:35 pm
What are they out of their minds. I doubt very much if the Obama administration plan to include illegal aliens in the health plan. Without a social security card they can’t even get medicare or medicaid. So how in the world would anyone in their wildest dreams imagine aliens will get covered if they can’t even produce a social security card nor driver’s license. What baloney!
Posted by: Allen | September 17, 2009, 3:44 pm 3:44 pm
There is NO language in the Bill that will prevent the enforcement of the “No Healthcare for Illegals”. Just because he says no to them there must “enforcement” language. Therefore, Rep. Wilson is correct when he said “You Lie”. Don’t beleve me, look it up yourself, we did.
Posted by: Gunrunner | September 17, 2009, 3:48 pm 3:48 pm
If for one second we are capable of thinking logically about this and not caving to emotion and xenophobia then it is clearly a good idea for undocumnted workers to be able to buy insurance.
These people are here, no two ways about it, and we as a nation will NOT be able to ebb the flow of workers, nor will we deport 12 million people, breaking up millions of families with ligit citizen children in the process.
If undocumented workers are not insured they will continue using the emergency room for primary-care. This is how a $100 broken finger turns into $100,000 life-or-death ER operation. The ER is bound by law to attend to life-threatening conditions and the taxpayer will cover the bill one way or the other.
P.S. The minimum wage in the US is about 15 times that of Mexico (which is itself far higher then anywhere else in Latin America). What if I told you that right now, today, you could make $100 dollars an hour flipping burgers or picking blueberries in Canada, would you go? Would you care that it was illegal, if your family didn’t have food and your house was being forclosed?
Posted by: john | September 17, 2009, 3:52 pm 3:52 pm
Isn’t it quite obvious that the right wants our president to fail regardless of how ‘good’ his health plan is. As I read all the horrible things said and see all those horrible posteres being carried I find it quite frightening to even think of what some nut might do with the freedom to carry a weapon to any rally and suddenly ‘go off’. Am I the only one who thinks down those lines?
Posted by: Chuck Parton | September 17, 2009, 3:55 pm 3:55 pm
My son is self employed, has way too much responibilies. Unable to pay taxes..but he was born here! Our families go way back in history..and built this country. Fathers and Grandfathers have gone to war for this country…..
MY son was turned away from social services because he was unable to prove an income. and yet he had his birth certificate..
How come he does not get the same privilages as an illegal person.
Posted by: matt Wood | September 17, 2009, 3:57 pm 3:57 pm
I had a man working on my swimming pool yesterday. His English wasn’t very good, but he was upside down in a muddy hole working harder than anyone I’d ever seen work. I get so mad when I hear people talk about how hard they work, this man didn’t stop until he was finished. I hadn’t been able to find anyone willing to do this job. If he’d gotten injured while working, I’d have wanted him to be able to go to a doctor just like everyone else does.
Posted by: Kathy | September 17, 2009, 4:00 pm 4:00 pm
I don’t hear anyone (republican or democrat)saying we won’t take any of the illegal immigrants MONEY.
Posted by: toomuch | September 17, 2009, 4:02 pm 4:02 pm
We need to stop illegal aliens, space invaders, people with red hair and all undesirable “others” from getting decent health care. What, are we our brother’s keeper for heavens sake.
Those awful French may believe in liberté, égalité, and fraternité, but we only believe in personal liberté!
Posted by: Edward Murray | September 17, 2009, 4:11 pm 4:11 pm
Unless you are a private hospital or a doctor’s office that does not take government money(medicare & medicaid) you are required to take anyone that comes in that emergency room door. So I don’t know what all the fuss is about. Hospitals could not make it without government money and as long as the government gives money to these hospitals they will have to take illegals. A Doctor takes an oath when they become doctors to treat EVERYONE. So until these hospitals or Doctors offices refuse the government money there will always be a place for illegals to go. I use to be employed at a private hospital in the emergency room and people were denied care because they had no insurance. They were sent to the hospital 3 miles away that was a teaching hospital and treated. I don’t know if there are any private hospitals anymore, they can’t afford to be private.
Posted by: ? mark | September 17, 2009, 4:13 pm 4:13 pm
If Conservatives ruled the world, sick and injured illegals could starve or die by the sied of the road. they would be turned away from any medical care, be they man woman or child. A more heartless race does not exist than the so called Christian conservative.
Fewer illegals are coming all the time, but those who remain will remain. No matter how we spit on them and grind them under our heel, they have it even worse in Mexico. America the Beautiful!
———————————
They shouldn’t be here in the first place. Couldn’t care less…
Posted by: safdasdf | September 17, 2009, 4:15 pm 4:15 pm
“Undocumented”, “illegal”, who cares!? They are NOT US Citizens! UNTIL they become a citizen of these united states of america, they should not have ANY rights or priveleges! period! they come over here for poverty wages because of some sorry a** employer to take back to whatever country they came from because even at those wage levels it is better than the sorrier place they are from! They then want to milk us for rights and priveleges WE as AMERICANS have because we ARE americans! make them legal, make them pay taxes on the labor they provide or send them back home empty handed! how many of the “millions” of uninsured are being counted from these numbers!? Democrats specifically and the average american in general are so ignorant of the liberal agenda being shoved down their throats! It is almost humoristic to see these clowns go down in “flames” because of their ignorance! LMAO!
Posted by: chuck | September 17, 2009, 4:16 pm 4:16 pm
jeffers wrote:”I would much rather see us stop that from happening and create jobs for all in our country and turn the illegals into tax payers and get our country back on the road to prosperity.”
———
Problem is, jeffers, that even working their tails off, illegal aliens are among the working poor. They’d stay that way because they’re unskilled, uneducated, and there are simply so many of them with much the same lack of skills that they depress wages. That wouldn’t change even were they legalized. If legalized, they’d instead be eligible for the Earned Income Tax Credit as well as means-tested programs they can’t now get. They could also sponsor their equally poor relatives to come here whom we’d end up subsidizing in turn.
Posted by: Ali | September 17, 2009, 4:18 pm 4:18 pm
Alyse: I have nothing against illegal immigrants. If fact, I don’t blame them one bit for trying to better their families by coming here. However, I take exception to your statement that they do jobs that no one here wants to do. That is false. They may be filling some jobs that Americans don’t want to do in some pockets of the country, but they are also taking many other jobs that many Americans would take. Go into almost any restaurant kitchen in America and you will find them doing the jobs of busboys, dishwashers, and cooks. Jobs that many American teenagers used to fill and are no longer given the chance because they can pay these people below minimum in cash, make them work as many hours as they want without overtime pay and the owners don’t have to bother paying FICA, SUTA, and FUTA. (Although, some have been know to take it out of their pay and not actually forward to the government.) It’s fine by me if they want to buy insurance, but it shouldn’t be with a government subsidy of any kind.
Posted by: Catherine | September 17, 2009, 4:26 pm 4:26 pm
Hatred and bigotry? No …more like following the rules to experience the American dream not coming here and taking it because you think your entitled…its funny how the left always uses a sense of twisted logic and tries to demonize anyone that would dare to point it out…they are the blood suckers …why do we have an obligation to take care of people who belong to another nation…we are very generous with other people coming here they are taking advantage of our good nature its a privilege not a right …sit down and become an american first
Posted by: phillysmart | September 17, 2009, 4:27 pm 4:27 pm
Thank you
Mr Wilson
Posted by: phillysmart | September 17, 2009, 4:28 pm 4:28 pm
Amen, Heather!
Posted by: DrLuna | September 17, 2009, 4:28 pm 4:28 pm
Illegal aliens have the “Right” to leave. If they do not exercise that right, they and their anchor babies should be deported to a country that already speaks their language, Mexico!
I say Press “1″ to deport or “2″ to incarcerate; same goes for Palestinians, Poles, Chinese or whatever other SARS, H1-N1, terrorists or AIDS infected future Democratic Party voters our elected morons allow into this country through liberalism and lax borders.
Posted by: Anicholas | September 17, 2009, 4:32 pm 4:32 pm
What is that these folks don’t understan?
Illegal means illegal.
Why shoud the President support poviding America’s goods and services to illegals of any nationality?
Posted by: Robert Bostick | September 17, 2009, 4:42 pm 4:42 pm
Many are saying that denying illegal immigrants the opportunity to buy into a government run healthcare program denies them the ability to act responsibly.
Give it a rest already. They are in this country illegally. Their opportunity to act responsibly has come and gone.
Posted by: melrose | September 17, 2009, 4:52 pm 4:52 pm
Allowing illegal immigrants to buy insurance still amounts to the taxpayer eating the cost to treat them. I personally don’t want my tax dollars going toward this. Health care reform must be as cost effective as possible. Allowing illegal immigrants to purchase government insurance will increase the cost of reform. Realize that this bill will not pass if it is too liberal or too conservative therefore there must be some concessions on both sides in order for this to pass and it will pass but only by a hair thin margin. Let’s make it easier for illegal immigrants to become taxpaying US citizens FIRST then allow them the priviledge of purchasing gov’t insurance.
Posted by: donnell | September 17, 2009, 5:14 pm 5:14 pm
People forget that at one time in the past their parents, grandparents, great grandparents and so on, were immigrants. They were given a fair chance at improving their lives, and at the same time contributing to what is now the greatest nation on earth. So why not give today’s immigrants a fair chance? I recall that the true Americans are our Native American brothers and sisters, whose lands and dignity were taken away by the very immigrants at the time. Now their descendants today are upset at human beings who are trying to improve their quality of life as did their families of past generations. Now I ask. Is this another WHITE/RACIST objective? I don’t see anyone else pushing it.
Posted by: IzzyOr | September 17, 2009, 5:16 pm 5:16 pm
I agree with this guy. It impresses me as Obama is trying to show some bi-partisan spirit and they’ll just use it to call him weak and keep going at him.
I wish the President had removed ALL reference to illegals in it, and made some huge announcement telling the public that since the illegals already get free care (hospitals and local health departments) the republicans were making sure it cost the taxpayers more.
Posted by: Secondlook | September 17, 2009, 5:27 pm 5:27 pm
I say illegal immigrants go home!
Posted by: Wil Burns | September 17, 2009, 5:34 pm 5:34 pm
What’s the problem with giving illegals free medical treatment? I don’t have any problem with being humane… as long as we station deportation officers in the ERs to take the illegals off to jail and back to their countries once they’ve been patched up. That would be the “price” of obtaining our free medical care.
Posted by: knowerseeker | September 17, 2009, 5:35 pm 5:35 pm
Gutierrez is a traitor to the nations laws. He is supposedly a “lawmaker”. Folks, it is time to wake up to the fact that we have fifth columnists in the administration, who every single day work against the best interests of the American citizenry, and for foreign interests. That is what illegal aliens are afterall, foreign nationals, in the United States without premission, illegally in other words. La Raza, Gutierrez, Lulac, or any other group resisting Americans when it comes to their laws, are fifth colunmnist traitors. Their undermining the country. PERIOD!!
Posted by: Bobby | September 17, 2009, 5:43 pm 5:43 pm
The headline suggests that Rep. Gutierrez was endorsing Joe Wilson’s uncouth behavior when he really wasn’t. I can’t believe that Georgie would stoop so low as to sensationalize the sorry event. Shame on you!
Posted by: Tux | September 17, 2009, 5:53 pm 5:53 pm
i wish that the hatian people were treated as well as other people that enter this country illegally if you are any other race other than black you are welcome in america hatian people are the same as everyone else in this world they just want a better life for themselves as well as their children the hate in this world seems to be winning how sad everyone deserves a goog life the only difference between people is the shade of their skin in acts 17:26 we are all the same in the same of God.
Posted by: joyce | September 17, 2009, 6:00 pm 6:00 pm
Solution: If an undocumented imigrant chooses to get healthcare in any emergency room, they acknowledge that they will be stabilized and shipped back to their country of origin.
Posted by: Anthony | September 17, 2009, 6:22 pm 6:22 pm
This is just so messed up. Because Obama is making sure illegals do not benefit from health care reform, Joe Wilson wins??? What kind of twisted logic does it take to arrive at that conclusion??? Obama said that contrary to claims illegals would not benefit. Now he’s making double sure of it & some how the guy who called him a “liar” wins??? WOW!!!
Posted by: Chapman | September 17, 2009, 6:23 pm 6:23 pm
obama did the right thing. no way illegal aliens should be included in any type of exchange or public option. these people are disrespecting our laws and should all be deported – for our sake and for theirs. the employers treat them poorly and get away with paying them little to nothing. if we, as a country, care so much about human rights, why do we allow these employers to treat illegal aliens as they do? deport them and lock up the employers. it is somewhat hypocritical to fight for human rights around the world and allow such poor treatment within our own borders. go home and get in line.
Posted by: robin | September 17, 2009, 6:23 pm 6:23 pm
Once again the media gloms onto the silly and the irrelevant so they don’t have to do the hard work of decerning what is true and important.
Posted by: xargaw | September 17, 2009, 6:35 pm 6:35 pm
“Why does hatred always have to win? Why do the politics of bigotry always have to win” he added.
~~~~~~~~~~~
I knew we’d get to it. If you can’t win on the merits, call the opponents racists or bigots.
How about this, Mr. Gutierrez: Quit encouraging and supporting illegal immigrants, and help enforce our immigration laws! It has nothing to do with bigotry or racism. It has everything to do with the fact that we are a sovereign nation, and we have the right and the responsibility to control who is in our country. We can’t afford to continue adding more illegal immigrants to our schools and medical facilities. Why is that so difficult to understand????
Posted by: Anna | September 17, 2009, 6:42 pm 6:42 pm
ANYONE in this country who is ILLEGAL should not be allowed to stay. Go through the correct procedures and process to obtain you right to be an American. No they should not be allowed to buy in, it will make their ILLEGAL stay easier. Make them work for what they have as WE do
Posted by: Michelle | September 17, 2009, 6:44 pm 6:44 pm
Doesn’t anyone know the definition of ‘illegal’? Illegal immigrants are not here legally and shouldn’t have the rights of Americans–they need to become legal immigrants to receive those rights. Rep. Luis Gutierrez needs to realize that illegal immigrants aren’t entitled to everything that Americans have just because they live here–they are here illegally. If they had entered the country legally, then they would be entitled to the rights of the insurance that President Obama is proposing.
Posted by: kb | September 17, 2009, 7:02 pm 7:02 pm
To Jorge Lopez,
It may be true that some pay taxes, but in the construction industry they are paid under the table. They prefer $$$$ and the less spent on taxes, and other benefits, the better.
Posted by: Dan | September 17, 2009, 7:04 pm 7:04 pm
Heather Sederbaum; I am a conservative, you know, the people who hate babies and puppies and old widowed women. I feel your pain and I don’t mean that sarcastically. You seem like an honest American family and I understand your problem better than you could know. You are the reason that we are working to solve this problem and even though I am against the current health proposal and fight the president tooth and nail..I want American families that find themselves in just such a situation to find the help they need from OUR government.
Having said that…is it fair to have ILLEGAL ALIENS using resources that could be used to help our citizens who find themselves in a terrible situation?
We allow more immigrants (more than a million a year)than any country in the world!! Every one of them eligible for most everything we get as citizens.
This is not enough for the MORONS who think that America is just “being mean” for not sharing with the rest of the world. Show me just one (1) country that is more generous than the United States of America or shut your mouth and berate the real culprits of human rights abuse…one being the countries of Latin America!
Posted by: Big clown hunter | September 17, 2009, 7:17 pm 7:17 pm
Where the hell are 12 MILLION illegal immegrants hiding so well that they can’t be deported? That’s what I’d like to know!
Posted by: SteveA | September 17, 2009, 7:29 pm 7:29 pm
Short run or long run? Maybe it the short run it appears Wilson wins. But the GOP is just cementing the alienation of large groups of minorities for a long time. If you were African America, Hispanic, gay or Muslim, would you vote GOP? Except for a few stragglers, I doubt it. I suspect Wilson’s shout is just another nail in the GOP’s coffin so far as minorities and moderates are concerned. And that will take a long time to turn around.
Posted by: JAB | September 17, 2009, 7:29 pm 7:29 pm
Enough is Enough we can not be responsible for other countries residents. We should take care of our own so Obama has this public option right
Posted by: Sean | September 17, 2009, 8:17 pm 8:17 pm
If any person comes into our country illegally, then tries to take advantage of our system, they should be deported immediately and a bill for the costs incurred sent to the originating country. This includes health care at hospitals, food stamps, unemployment insurance, education, etc. Even bill them for the transportation home. Deduct these costs from any foreign aid received by that country, and if needed freeze their bank accounts too. These illegals are STEALING from citizens of the US.
Posted by: douglas Paulsen | September 17, 2009, 8:24 pm 8:24 pm
MNResident, insanity would be letting them die. That would be criminal and it would be on your head.
Posted by: Danny | September 17, 2009, 8:24 pm 8:24 pm
Obama lied during his speech, he is lying now, and he will lie tomorrow. Wilson is not a wrong for calling out a liar. Send the illegals home and make them immigrate lawfully.
Posted by: Seamus | September 17, 2009, 8:52 pm 8:52 pm
I’m OK with allowing illegals to purchase health insurance, as long as the I.N.S.is committed to doing there job and using that information to locate and deport those same illeagals.
Posted by: Mike Bergeron | September 17, 2009, 8:54 pm 8:54 pm
Go back to Mexico. Problem solved. Obama the Great Divider. Thank You ABC, CBS ect. for not vetting this clown. Thank You Joe Wilson, Obama is a liar..
Posted by: Tim Weaver | September 17, 2009, 9:13 pm 9:13 pm
Wait a minute, I thought Obama said he wasn’t lying and Wilson was. If so, then whey are they adding this?
It couldn’t be that Obama was lying all along, could it?
Posted by: burr | September 17, 2009, 9:15 pm 9:15 pm
So as long as we’re making it impossible for illegal aliens to purchase insurance with their own money, let’s also make it impossible for them to purchase groceries, clothing, cars, gas, and even toilet paper – with their own money. Geez!
The irony is that these folks are just responding to FREE MARKET FORCES – the true religion of the right.
Posted by: Chris | September 17, 2009, 10:03 pm 10:03 pm
oh according to WHO that he won?!
Not according to polls.. the majority of Americans think it was wrong wrong wrong.
Posted by: tommy rand | September 17, 2009, 10:30 pm 10:30 pm
What don’t some people understand about ILLEGAL ALIENS? Deport them ASAP!
Posted by: tom toth | September 17, 2009, 10:47 pm 10:47 pm
I read recently that Mexico is going to have Universal Healthcare or has it already in the works…why don’t they just go home (mexico)and live the life they want to there? better deal than running to the emergency room!
Posted by: Terry | September 17, 2009, 10:52 pm 10:52 pm
Doesn’t really matter anyway the president has made promise to make existing illegals and family US citizen’s. Is that not his next goal?
Gutierrez is the only real flare up regarding non-coverage for illegal aliens. Didn’t the Obama’s just party it up with J-Lo with little or no protest.
He brought in Sotmayor expediciously like most things fishy in this administration and in doing so began the groundwork. The illegal immugrant issue is nada!!
Posted by: modelle | September 17, 2009, 10:54 pm 10:54 pm
To Jorge… Illegals do NOT pay higher taxes. They come in with a fake (or stolen) social security number, fill out their tax forms, and claim 15 dependents. Any tax they pay is minimal, at best. Many, many more work for cash only, so pay no taxes at all. I live in Texas, and I’ve worked in payroll, so I know.
To Alyse… The claim that illegals only take the jobs American’s won’t do is a lie. They have driven down wages to the point that Americans can’t afford to take those jobs! After all, my kids don’t get a free education, free meals, free bus transportation, or free medical care. I have to pay enough taxes to cover both my kids’ expenses AND those of the illegals. So I can’t AFFORD to take a minimum wage job and still keep a roof over our heads.
Posted by: KathyH | September 17, 2009, 11:00 pm 11:00 pm
Obama lied, Joe cried!
“you LIE” and it all came apart.
Hmmm, maybe these weak kneed congressmen ought to try Joe’s method, it seems to work better than that Mr. Nice guy approach. I like the way the Brits do it, nice and in your face.
Posted by: Jimi | September 17, 2009, 11:06 pm 11:06 pm
Illegal immigration is merely a wedge issue. It merely serves the illusions of people’s misplaced sense of patriotism, and their mispplaced understanding of geopolitical economics. Like all demarcations within the culture of Man, borders are arbitrary, drawn by bloody ambition. So while we embody and personify our prejudices on poor people determined to survive, the powerful entities that truly deserve our scrutiny go unnoticed. Indeed, in America, ignorance, and all of its children-prejudice, hatred, fear, and narcissism, is the lash of our task masters!
Posted by: DofG | September 17, 2009, 11:07 pm 11:07 pm
The gall! This Illinois Democrat was elected by ‘citizens’ of this country. He was not elected by ‘undocumented’ persons (at least I hope this to be the case). These individuals will still be able to purchase private insurance outside of the exchanges. Sucks really, why should they be denied coverage, because then they just show up at the ER.
Posted by: Ivy | September 17, 2009, 11:16 pm 11:16 pm
I don’t understand the protection of the illegal immigrants. If they want to have health care, if they want to have health ins they should become legal. Yes, not having health ins and living off from the gov’t or the private sector who has to consume the costs of them going to the emergency room doesn’t help. What will help is ‘become legal’. Then they can have all the benefits of citizens and those who are here legally.
I know of a company that was raided for hiring many illegal immigrants. All the news could speak of was ‘the poor families of those immigrants.’ and all the fund raising for those families of illegal immigrants. Well, they got a social security number from somewhere! What about the nightmare of the person who actually OWNS that social security number?! Think of the tax implications for them. The mess they have to sort out. Let’s look a little more toward compassion for those who are deserving of it, those who are citizens and those who have ‘paid their dues’ and come here legally. What is the benefit to becoming legal if all that is offered to the legal immigrants and citizens is also offered up to the illegal immigrants. My husband is a LEGAL immigrant. We stood at the INS office and heard an officer ask a girl, ‘Are you here illegally?” To which she said, “yes”. He responded asking, “Do you have the $500?” She said, “Yes” at which time the officer turned to the newer officer and said, “Start the paperwork.” So it is not that difficult to become legal. Why should the rest of us suffer and pay more out of our checks for those who are 1) here illegally; 2) working for cash and not paying in for the benefits they seem to feel they should be receiving; 3) public assistance they are getting with no questions asked of being legal or illegally here. Let’s look at the fact that until they CHOOSE to do the legal thing, they are basically criminals. They cannot be rewarded with the same benefits we have. The push should be on legalizing them, not rewarding them for being illegal. Let’s look at this in the proper perspective.
Posted by: Linda | September 17, 2009, 11:23 pm 11:23 pm
thetruthhurts said:
“What in the world happened to GIVE ME, YOUR TIRED, YOUR POOR, YOUR HUNGRY.???”
Nothing happened to it. That concept is very much alive and well in this country. That’s why we still let in about one million LEGAL immigrants each year. But keep in mind that nowhere on the Statue of Liberty does it say “Give us your lawbreakers”.
Posted by: Marlowe | September 17, 2009, 11:27 pm 11:27 pm
The only thing Joe Wilson won was the admiration and loyalty of the type of vermin that poisons the well of America. Their bravado support both in money and example is not only predictable but also insignificant and easily dismissed by a majority of decent Americans. That President Carter touched a nerve for his brave statesmanship only serves to mildly nudge the conclusion obvious to the discerning American. If Mr. Wilson and his ilk believe that their indiscretions are supported or judged successful by their barometer; then so be it. It is better to have an ignorant opponent than one with actual substance. Many of us predict; Mr. Wilson will not win his next election, no matter how much racist money is thrown at him. His true colors and digusting pandering have painted a picture of him as the loser he will soon be.
Posted by: Anthony Look | September 17, 2009, 11:42 pm 11:42 pm
Giving “illegal aliens” any kind of rights except the right to gather at the border to be deported is a slap in the face to the millions of hard-working people that came here, and got their citizenship the legal way.
Send them back, then let them apply and come back legally. The problem is, a good portion of them are gang members, drug traffickers, fugitives from Mexican justice, who cannot get in legally.
AND WE DO NOT NEED OR WANT THEM IN THE USA!
Where are the “legal” immigrants?
And why are they being so silent?
I cannot figure it out…
There are way too many personal agendas are being fulfilled in our government.
Posted by: Terry Thompson | September 17, 2009, 11:44 pm 11:44 pm
Close your eyes. Imagine living in country where the currency is worth next to almost nothing. A country where Drug Lords kill and kidnap at will. A country where you can’t even call the cops, because more than likely, they work for the Drug Lords. A country where you are surrounded by poverty. A country where, if you have a low paying job, you’re very lucky.
But within sight is a country that is known as the land of opportunity. In this country, you can start with nothing and still make your dreams come true. It happens all the time. Around the world that’s what this country is known for.
Open your eyes. Now, tell me.
What would you do?
What would anyone do?
Posted by: atretrioeciii | September 18, 2009, 12:01 am 12:01 am
We need to recognize that we do not have the ability in this country to round up and ship all the illegal people in this country back to their country of origin. We need to immediately create legislation that will give undocumented people currently in this country a road to citizenship. While doing so, we need to enhance the patrol on our borders to prevent others from entering this country illegally. When they do find a way to illegally enter this country, we need to enforce the laws allready on the books to prosecute them and or deport them back to their country of origin.
Posted by: johnnyle | September 18, 2009, 12:20 am 12:20 am
I just don’t get it. It seems that most of the people posting understand the damage people like Gutierrez do to this country and its people, yet we seem to get nowhere with these politicians, whether they are Democrats or Republicans. Americans are not being listened to and we aren’t being represented in the slightest.
Posted by: Bobby | September 18, 2009, 1:03 am 1:03 am
I agree wholeheartedly with thetruthhurts and Heather Sederbaum. Illegal immigrants do the jobs at great peril that no other Americans will do. Illegal immigrants pay taxes. If no healthcare system exists for them, they will have to resort to emergency room care which we will eventually have to foot the bill for at a much higher cost than if they could pay into the healthcare pool that everyone is talking about. Why are the Republicans still controlling the debate when they are out of power?!?! I’m so sick of the ball-less-ness of the Democratic party! Someone grow a pair!
Posted by: rabo | September 18, 2009, 2:29 am 2:29 am
I will support for President any candidates who will promise to remove all of these illegal aliens pronto. They do not belong here. They are all criminals just by being here.
Posted by: mars4earth3 | September 18, 2009, 2:56 am 2:56 am
Another thing to ponder. The Swine Flu epidemic is not over and is possibly coming back worse this fall than it was this past spring. Do you really want to deny healthcare to 12 million people? Really???
Posted by: rabo | September 18, 2009, 3:03 am 3:03 am
The solution is to remove the illegal aliens now. Many Republicans are for the illegals being here because it is cheap labor for quick profits. Many Democrats see the illegals as future votes. The people of the USA are the victims of the illegals. Wages are depressed because of the illegals. California in the 1960s had the best school system in the USA. Now with it taking care of millions of illegals it has one of the worst school systems in the USA.
Posted by: mars4earth3 | September 18, 2009, 3:15 am 3:15 am
Bigotry? Come on . . . everybody gets treatment. Immediate health CARE and paying for somebody’s health INSURANCE are two very different things. Liberals need to stop lying about what conservatives are trying to say.
Posted by: EPU | September 18, 2009, 7:16 am 7:16 am
Why is it every time someone doesn’t agree
with the democrates is it bigotry or hatred?? Perhaps we just don’t agree with the policy!!!
Posted by: hkdakota | September 18, 2009, 7:25 am 7:25 am
Why is it that some of these Congressmen and women cannot get it through their thick heads that the ILLEGAL immigrants are just that..ILLEGAL! We as the taxpayers should NOT be footing ANY of the bill for them..THEY BROKE THE LAW…GO HOME!
Posted by: angus | September 18, 2009, 9:31 am 9:31 am
halfmn- MAYBE!!! (and this is just a wild guess) It is do to the fact that their home countries are corrupt and if anything treat them worse than America would ever. In many countries people have no say in government unless you have the money to speak, if you know what I mean. So before you comment about how they should go back and fix their own country learn how their own country is and think about whether you would ever go back to a country that thinks you are pretty much worth nothing and in fact actually controls you as a person. You take a minute to think that though and then get back at me!
With that understand that I am not saying that immigrants don’t have advantages here in America because they do but just because they are illegals does not mean that they can be treated like trash.
Posted by: Alyse | September 18, 2009, 9:32 am 9:32 am
Alright Mr. Elmo, so what about those illegals who get a paycheck and there are about two hundred dollars in tax reductions? Are you telling me that those two hundred dollars are not going to the government? Just a thought.
Posted by: Alyse | September 18, 2009, 9:37 am 9:37 am
The business owners, many of them who are white, are the ones that are employing people who are here illegally and perpetuating the problem. Why can’t people see this. Once again, instead of dealing with the root cause of the problem, people want to point fingers at the President. He wouldn’t have to deal with this healthcare debate about people here illegally, if business owners didn’t employ them.
Posted by: Davina | September 18, 2009, 9:43 am 9:43 am
MNResident said . .And the fact that courts have been idiotic enough to force me to subsidize their K-12 education or emergency room treatment does not dimiss the insanity of their ruling.I agree with you on this, but like I have told people before, if we are not going to send “them” back, do you want a bunch of stupid immigrants running around the USA? Why is it that prisoners have a guaranteed right to health care, but I as a taxpaying citizen do not? I am Native American and Proud! Our elders took care of everyone in our tribe and we were a better people for it.
Posted by: flying eagel | September 18, 2009, 10:08 am 10:08 am
Joe Wilson won because the President refused to waste time arguing with this guy? Joe Wilson won because the President keep his composure and appeared to be mature and undaunted? Joe Wilson acted like a bratty child. What a disgrace. On top of that, didn’t Joe Wilson fight to keep the confederate flag flying in SC? Yeah, Old Joe — the loser!!!!
Posted by: Mayleren | September 18, 2009, 10:40 am 10:40 am
as far as Illegal goes.why is it even an issue..they are Illegals..I can only assume that were i to visit Mexico or any country Illegally, that the best i could expect is a jail cell.I mean cmon,is it really our goal to provide food, water ,medical,education and funding to every nation in the world.Why is a country that has no resources nor any means to create jobs, food, health care and so on even a country.Its time for me to say enough.Get off the worlds issues and concentrate on my country my health my retirement.quit killing me for the sake of the world view.it doesn’t matter how much you spend on illegals health care.i’m legal and i’m being drained.threat them as they would treat me.imprisonment or maybe worse huh.
Posted by: Dave Meyer | September 18, 2009, 12:26 pm 12:26 pm
This guy just wants his cousins who are here illegally to be insured… Sorry dude, I don’t think so…
Posted by: Obamaall theway | September 18, 2009, 1:45 pm 1:45 pm
Obama may have backed down, but he’s gotta compromise to get this thing through! Change, little by little!
Posted by: cameron | September 18, 2009, 2:58 pm 2:58 pm
So if they are able to pass this crap (which I don’t think they will, but if they do) here is what all of the TAX PAYING Americans should do.
#1 as we all know they cannot constitutionally FORCE us to buy their stupid insurance. But we all know that as soon as something cheaper is out there our employers will drop what we have, and give us that crap.
#2 when we do not buy their insurance they will try to fine us somehow through the IRS so
#3 we do NOT buy their insurance, and we STOP filing tax returns and we put millions and millions in the ER just like the illegals will STILL BE ON OUR DIME to get their care.
Then #4 they will stop all of this stupid stuff and repeal it.
Posted by: Carmen | September 18, 2009, 4:22 pm 4:22 pm
H.R.2892 – border security fencing, infrastructure, and technology – For expenses for border security fencing, infrastructure, and technology, $732,000,000, to remain available until expended. ALSO U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement: salaries and expenses: For necessary expenses for enforcement of immigration and customs laws, detention and removals, and investigations; and purchase and lease of up to 3,790 (2,350 for replacement only) police-type vehicles; $5,311,493,000, of which not to exceed $7,500,000 shall be available until expended for conducting special operations under section 3131 of the Customs Enforcement Act of 1986 (19 U.S.C. 2081); IT GOES ON AND ON. The ridiculous amount of money appropriated and still there is no end to the problem
Posted by: d | September 18, 2009, 10:25 pm 10:25 pm
After illegals are treated in ERs they
should be deported. Of course this won’t happen because our government lets the rich who benefit from cheap labor ignore enforcing the laws by making large campaign contributions.
Posted by: vin suppicich | September 18, 2009, 10:35 pm 10:35 pm
How do illegals file their income tax return? Do they pay the taxes that support the hospitals and schools where they get free health care and a free education? Why do I have to pay for them to go to an American hospital when my child would NEVER get free health care. No, if I didn’t show an insurance card she would be turned away.
Obama IS a liar. Sadly Joe Wilson chose the wrong venue but he was being honest. I’m tired of paying for illegals and lazy welfare recipients. NOTE: lazy.
Posted by: jsherryd | September 19, 2009, 9:49 am 9:49 am
One other thought…where does it say “I’m entitled to everything I want because it’s my right” ? When was the thought I’m RESPONSIBLE for myself eliminated from society? Did it come with the government stepping in and teaching several generations to hold their hand out and wait for a socialistic government to ‘take care’ of them? This is Obama Law.
Posted by: jsherryd | September 19, 2009, 9:55 am 9:55 am
If they are here illigal they should only get enough treatment to get them back home. They are illigal and therefore should be sent home at once.
Posted by: Robert | September 19, 2009, 9:55 am 9:55 am
Latino politicians who favor illegals
demand that the law be followed when its
convenient…but not when it applies to
immigration. Do they not see the hypocrisy?
With no verification, how does Obama
expect illegals to be kept out of taxpayer subsidized health care? Does he
think we can’t see his real motive?
Posted by: Manny | September 19, 2009, 4:22 pm 4:22 pm
All illegal immigrants have to do is become legal. If they are not willing, then why should we include them? Illegal immigrants should not even be working here unless the company is breaking the law. The company should be fined and the immigrant should be given 60 days to decide if they want to become a citizen and then I have no problem with them getting anything anyone else has. Many of them are sending their money back to Mexico and not helping our economy. Becoming legal gives them the right to vote and become a part of society and not to have to hide in order not to be deported. If they are serious about living here, then they should become legal. It’s not a hard process. There are schools to teach them enough English to pass the test and if they want a voice in the society…this is the answer. I am not for amnesty for all. Truthfully, I feel Mexicans are very hard workers and I do not understand their refusal to become a citizen. Many are family oriented but there are others who are gang members,who rob, steal and bring in dope which is not good for neighborhoods. So many have caused problems for those poor people living near the borders and I feel sorry for them to see their land being destroyed and their homes being robbed. Unfortunately, these are the people we hear about more often rather than the ones who just want a better life. A better life happens when you become a citizen. More doors open up and the fear of being discovered goes away. It is your choice. Now as to Joe Wilson…if anyone lied it is he. He knew the bills he was referring to had been killed but he just wanted to make a point. It had been on t.v. and on Fact Check.Org that there was no health coverage for illegals immigrants. Where has he been…in a closet? Also, his apology was not personally to Obama and the things he continued to say on u-tube contradicted his apology. He did not deserve the coverage he received and to me he is the “joker”.
Posted by: talmag | September 19, 2009, 8:25 pm 8:25 pm
It’s finally come to light that the entire reason Obama wants to fix healthcare is to add another 12 to 15 million voters to the democratic party and guarantee another landslide victory in 2012. Create another crisis that can only be fixed by drastic means. A magician’s trick is misdirection. Keep everyone focused on healthcare and ignore the fact that he really wants to instantly legalize anyone who crosses the border. You know these nice innocent hard working folks won’t register Republican or Independent. No they will be so greatful to Obama and the Democrats for letting them in, giving them cheap loans, setting them up in houses and giving them free or nearly free healthcare they will be more than willing to vote them back into power. In the meantime what are we going to do with all the other unemployed Americans that have been here struggling throughout this administration. Do we protest on the streets of Washington? Do we dare without being called racists, Nazi’s and far right idiots? It amazes me what a short attention span the average Obama idolizer actually has.
Posted by: Michael | September 20, 2009, 2:33 pm 2:33 pm
It has nothing to do with hate. It’s that we are tired of paying for others while trying to support our own families. There are so many that are making a better living by living off the system than those of us who work and pay taxes. We are just sick and tired of it I know I am. There are to many here ILLEGALLY and getting free health care , food stamps, and housing so I think enough is enough. Go back home do it the legal way.
Posted by: Marley | September 20, 2009, 5:34 pm 5:34 pm
“it was a wise political – if not policy – decision to take even the fabricated argument of free health care for illegal immigrants away from the fringe right.”
Take the issue away by giving the right what they want? What about Obama’s support on the left — or do they suffer from low self-esteem?
If ‘surrender and claim victory’ works politically, it’s only because the left are such suckers for the race card. That may be why Clyburn, Hank Johnson, Modobot and Jimmy Carter played the ‘straight flush’ — to bamboozle the left into lying down for this anti-abortion anti-immigrant ‘reform bill.’
Posted by: whoframedrudy | September 21, 2009, 9:28 pm 9:28 pm
Obama is losing is base and needs to give amnesty to the illegals as soon as possible.
He will do it quickly before the next election mark my words.
Posted by: Colette | September 22, 2009, 9:28 pm 9:28 pm
Oh by the way Pheonix Lady. That is a good reason to buy health insurance prior to getting sick not after.
The values a family are taught are how important insurance is and as fundatmentally important as groceries.
Posted by: Colette | September 22, 2009, 9:30 pm 9:30 pm
Everyone forgets the issue regarding Wilson is not if illegals should get insurance paid for by moi but that the Presdient blantantly lied to the American People recklessly and purposefully regarding covering illegals in the bill.
If he were my child I would have his hide!
Posted by: Colette | September 22, 2009, 9:33 pm 9:33 pm