By Jennifer Parker

Nov 19, 2009 4:39pm

Reid Rules Out Reconciliation?

Senate majority leader Harry Reid today seemed to rule out a reconciliation vote on health care.

But will he find some wiggle room later if he needs it?

My colleague on Capitol Hill, ABC News' Z. Byron Wolf has the latest:

Democrats in the Senate had another celebratory press conference today — still two days before they’re likely to face the first procedural hurdle on Harry Reid’s health care bill.

And Republicans continued blasting reform efforts, targeting individual Democrats agonizing over this weekend’s likely cloture vote.

At the Democrats’ press conference, supporters, some wearing white doctor coats, applauded as Reid and other Democratic leaders entered a packed room.

“This Congress. This President are going to sign into a law a national health care law for all Americans,” declared Sen. Chris Dodd, D-CT.

“For the first time we’re going to enable the American people to take part in a buyers market when it comes to health insurance and not a seller’s market where the insurance industry decides what happens.”

“Never again will an American citizen be denied the kind of health coverage they deserve to have.”
“There was the New Deal. Then there was the Fair Deal. And this is the good deal for the American people,” said Sen. Tom Harkin.

And Reid, while he wouldn’t say if he has the 60 votes he will need to overcome those procedural hurdles, seemed to say he’ll avoid using the “reconciliation” process to bypass Republican and moderate Democratic opposition to pass a bill with only 50 votes.

“I’m not using reconciliation,” he told reporters.

The sound was pretty unequivocal and seemed different from months past when Reid would mention that he has reconciliation in his back pocket.

Reid spokesman said Reid has always been focused on getting a bill to pass through the Senate in normal order.

“For weeks if not months the only thing he has been working on is getting 60 votes,” Manley said.

Republicans are getting more pointed with their criticisms of the bill. Sen. Lamar Alexander said the bill would have the intended consequence of forcing Americans onto the public option.

“For millions of Americans this bill means employers drop your insurance and say congratulations you're in the public plan,” Alexander said.

And playing a much more visible role for Republicans is Sen. Mike Johanns, R-Neb. His state colleague, Democrat Ben Nelson, who supports restricting abortion rights, is one of three Democrats having the most trouble supporting the cloture vote this weekend.

“Some say the motion to proceed is just procedural,” said Johanns in an obvious rib at Nelson.

“This is the pro-life vote,” Johanns said of this first test this weekend.

User Comments

Reid hasn’t got the votes and he knows it.
Much of the ‘stimulus’ money is yet unspent.
As the Administration starts releasing it during the 2010 election cycle, we’ll see how many health care votes it will buy.

Posted by: Joe White | November 19, 2009, 4:54 pm 4:54 pm

“I’m not using reconciliation,” he told reporters.
If this effort fails, Reid needs to go. No Republican administrator has lacked the will to use reconciliation and it is perhaps the only check left on the flagrant abuse of the filibuster by the Republican minority in the Senate (on track for a *third* record year of filibustering – almost double the most launched by any Democratic minority, ever). I personally dislike her, but I almost wish Pelosi was in the Senate leader seat at this point.

Posted by: jhw539 | November 19, 2009, 5:03 pm 5:03 pm

Just wondering who the primary beneficiaries of this bill are going to be, if it passes? It certainly won’t be the citizens.
Just the special interest groups as usual.

Posted by: Rick McDaniel | November 19, 2009, 5:20 pm 5:20 pm

To get an idea of the difficulty Reid is encountering as the Senate ponders a health care bill, recall his comments when the (at the time) much anticipated Baucus bill made it out of committee a few weeks ago.
Reid’s response?
“That won’t work in my state”
lol

Posted by: Joe White | November 19, 2009, 5:44 pm 5:44 pm

Everyone wants to do away with the preexisting condition clause. Just don’t see the need of a 2000+ page bureaucratic nightmare overhaul of health care to do it.
How many pages was that stimulus bill?

Posted by: wow | November 19, 2009, 5:48 pm 5:48 pm

Sadly, Sen. Reid’s spine has the same degree of stiffness as a piece of old red licorice left too long in the microwave.

Posted by: B. Bear | November 19, 2009, 7:03 pm 7:03 pm

Reid needs to rule out re election.

Posted by: Charlie C | November 19, 2009, 7:26 pm 7:26 pm

wow wrote:
“Everyone wants to do away with the preexisting condition clause”
Not everyone.
Some of us understand that it’s a bad idea to let someone wait til they are sick before enrolling for health coverage.
Kinda like buying homeowner’s insurance the day after the house burns down.

Posted by: Joe White | November 19, 2009, 11:52 pm 11:52 pm

Wow, you are comparing a human life with a house. I can see where your priorities are. People with pre-existing conditions need insurance, because even the richest people can’t afford out of pocket hospital expenses. Think about that Charlie. My doctor thinks I MAY have Bipolar Disorder, but he is not completely sure about it. Guess what, now I can not get health insurance because the possiblity of me having Bipolar Disorder. Really amazing. It seems that Charlie, you may taking a real simplistic business approach to your rationalization of this reform bill. I guess that’s where we differ; I think of the human approach to this, and why all Americans should be able to receive quality affordable healthcare. This bill is not perfect, but it is a start, I think, a really good start. Enough is enough. Insurance companies have made enormous profits by denying coverage and allowing so many Americans to get sick and die. What if one of those people was your mother or your brother, or sister?

Posted by: Matt | November 21, 2009, 6:45 am 6:45 am

It passed the procedural vote to bring the bill to the floor, and guess what…
It will pass the senate then go to committee then pass in both houses..
and be signed by the President.
Even Judd Gregg, a republican, says this can’t be stopped; its a “done deal”.

Posted by: Doc Holiday | November 23, 2009, 2:11 am 2:11 am

This Congress will be remembered as the one that fiddled away our money promising things they cannot deliver to solve probems that do not exist. And then wondered what happened to our rich nation when it collapses. From the looks of our dept and the falling dollar, we won’t have to wait!

Posted by: Campbell | November 23, 2009, 7:08 pm 7:08 pm

Leave a Reply

Do you have more information about this topic? If so, please click here to contact the editors of ABC News.