By Kristina Wong

Jan 11, 2010 2:56pm

‘Top Line’ — Can Obama Sell a Cadillac Tax?

ABC News’ Rick Klein reports: President Obama today is meeting with labor leaders at the White House to discuss health care — specifically, to convince them of the need for them to compromise on their longstanding opposition to taxing high-end health care plans. Obama himself was opposed to a tax on so-called “Cadillac plans” as a candidate. He even cut an ad slamming Sen. John McCain for wanting to tax health benefits. But the president is now convinced that the best way to raise some of the revenues the bill needs is with a tax along the lines included in the Senate version of the health care bill. Now he wants his allies in Big Labor to go along, Time magazine’s Karen Tumulty told us on ABC’s “Top Line” today. “The message is going to be, ‘There’s a deal here — let’s make it.’ Ad what they’re probably going to do is move the threshold so that fewer and fewer of these policies would get taxed,” Tumulty said. While unions including the SEIU, the AFL-CIO, and AFSCME have been outspoken in their opposition to a “Cadillac tax” — something they say will wind up falling disproportionately on the middle class — few observers expect them to oppose Democrats’ health care reform efforts. “There is so much else in this bill that they want — starting with coverage of over 30 million Americans — that I think that if and when this bill passes, it is going to be marked as such a gigantic achievement,” Tumulty said. We also got her take on the scandal enveloping Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid, after a book reported him to have made racially insensitive comments about President Obama. “The fact is that Barak Obama also brought to the table some really extraordinary political talents, and so I think that there is really no history that would suggest that Harry Reid is a racist. There’s a lot of history that would suggest that he is not really good with words,” Tumulty said. Watch the full interview with Karen Tumulty HERE. We also checked with GOP strategist Justin Sayfie, the publisher of the influential Florida political blog SayfieNews.com, about the Senate race pitting Gov. Charlie Crist, R-Fla., in a Republican primary against Marco Rubio. Watch that segment of today’s “Top Line” HERE.  

User Comments

Well I am sure this will all part of the public information provided to us on Cspan. I have every reason to believe that candidate Obama was truthful when he said the health care debate would be public and we could watch it on Cspan. What time is it on?
Wasn’t he being truthful?

Posted by: jamescbuilder | January 11, 2010, 3:50 pm 3:50 pm

If the vote on the healthcare bill is delyed beyond the special Mass. senatorial election and Scott Brown is elected, the Democrats will not have 60 votes if needed for the HEALTHCARE bill. Do you want to HELP? Donate time or money http://www.brownforussenate.com/

Posted by: deanbob | January 11, 2010, 4:11 pm 4:11 pm

This tax on health care was one of the 2 major things I looked at when I voted for Obama, and it is a major thing. There are many of us middle class workers living paycheck to paycheck, waiting for the bottom to fall out, and now one of the few things that help keep our heads above water is being ripped from us. We can end up in debt to either the IRS. or the medical communitym depending on what we do. The CEO of our Fortune 500 company, who makes in 1 day, what I do in a year, just stepped on our benefits, and now the person I trusted to “CHANGE” things is making them worse with his Health care D-FORM program.

Posted by: Gary | January 11, 2010, 5:51 pm 5:51 pm

Whatever causes people to Begin Campaigning before they know what the actual bill is going to ‘look like?’ Classic “Fear of the unknown.” (That’s when your folks aren’t controlling anything.)
OBTW, the C-Span Commitment was predicated on the republican’ts “Productive Participation in-the-process.” Now since there WAS NONE……. all bets are off. Or didn’t you get the memo on that???

Posted by: bobj72 | January 11, 2010, 6:30 pm 6:30 pm

Yes he can!
If some people choose to have excessive health coverage, they should be ok paying for part of the overall health care costs. I don’t know why it is called a called a Cadillac tax. It should be called a surcharge on extravagant healthcare.

Posted by: slim | January 11, 2010, 7:25 pm 7:25 pm

bobj72 | Jan 11, 2010 6:30:24 PM….I heard no words to that effect, at any time.

Posted by: deanbob | January 11, 2010, 8:29 pm 8:29 pm

Leave a Reply

Do you have more information about this topic? If so, please click here to contact the editors of ABC News.