Alexander: Health Care Reform a ‘Political Kamikaze Mission’ for Democrats
Senate Republican Conference Chairman Lamar Alexander says pushing health care reform through Congress by a simple majority using the reconciliation process would be political suicide for Democrats and vowed to campaign for the repeal the bill if it passes. On “This Week”, Sen. Alexander to told Elizabeth Vargas, “It would be a political kamikaze mission for the Democratic Party if they jam this through after the American people have been saying.”
Alexander also said, if Democrats do pass a health care reform bill, “for the rest of the year, we're going to be involved in a campaign to repeal it.” He added that democrats would pay a political price for passing health care. “Every Democratic candidate in the country is going to be defined by this unpopular health care bill at a time when the real issues are jobs, terror and debt.”
Watch the video HERE:
Read full exchange HERE:
VARGAS: You had said in your opening remarks at the health care summit, you quoted Senator Byrd when you said — you called on the president to renounce using reconciliation to push the bill through the Senate with a simple majority vote, saying, quote, "It would be an outrage to run the health care bill through the Senate like a freight train with this process."
Why — why are you so opposed to this, given the fact that Republicans have used reconciliation more often than Democrats in the past?
ALEXANDER: Well, the outraged words were Senator Byrd's words, not mine.
VARGAS: True…
(CROSSTALK)
ALEXANDER: You're correct. The reconciliation procedure is a — where you use legislative (ph) procedure is a (ph) — where you use — legislative procedure 19 times it's been used. It's for the purpose of taxing and spending and — and reducing deficits.
But the difference here is that there's never been anything of this size and magnitude and complexity run through the Senate in this way. There are a lot of technical problems with it, which we could discuss. It would turn the Senate — it would really be the end of the United States Senate as a protector of minority rights, as a place where you have to get consensus, instead of just a partisan majority, and it would be a political kamikaze mission for the Democratic Party if they jam this through after the American people have been saying, look, we're trying to tell you in every way we know how, in elections, in surveys, in town hall meetings, we don't want this bill.
VARGAS: Why political kamikaze, though? We know that Americans don't support health care in general, but when you start drilling down into the specifics, a lot of people do support some of those specifics.
ALEXANDER: Oh, they do support some of the specifics, but you put it all together, they don't like it. They don't want their Medicare cut. They don't want their taxes increased. They don't want their premiums increased. I mean, millions of American will have their premiums increased. The governors are up in arms about the new cost on states, so people have decided — and — and there's a sense that Washington is taking over too much.
So I was thinking this morning of President George W. Bush, when he tried so hard to have private accounts for Social Security. He thought he was right. He pushed, he pushed, and he pushed. If he'd stopped about halfway through and shifted, he could have probably gotten a bipartisan agreement on Social Security. I think President Obama could learn from that.
He has a lot of us who would like to help him write a health care bill, but not this one.
VARGAS: When you say political kamikaze, are you saying that if the Democrats push this through, they will lose all their seats in November? I mean, what are we talking about here?
ALEXANDER: Well, here's what I think. I mean, the people are saying, "We don't want it," and the Democrats are saying, "We don't care. We're going to pass it anyway." And so for the next three months, Washington will be consumed with the Democrats trying to jam this through in a very messy procedure an unpopular health care bill.
And then for the rest of the year, we're going to be involved in a campaign to repeal it. And every Democratic candidate in the country is going to be defined by this unpopular health care bill at a time when the real issues are jobs, terror and debt.
Email
Santorum Wins Three States: What Does It Mean?
Rick Santorum Wins Minn., Mo. and Colo. Primaries
I would like to compliment Elizabeth Vargas for the most directed series of questions and cogent follow-ups I have heard civilly posed on This Week in many years. She would be a GREAT new host.
Posted by: USCitizen | February 28, 2010, 10:35 am 10:35 am
Oh Lamar you sound like Marie Antionette . If the peasants don’t have any bread let them eat cake. We all know what happened to her.
Posted by: bob samms | February 28, 2010, 11:01 am 11:01 am
If the public can’t have bread then let them eat cake. Lamar ‘Antionette’ Alexander. We all know what happened to her.
Posted by: bob samms | February 28, 2010, 11:05 am 11:05 am
“Every Democratic candidate in the country is going to be defined by this unpopular health care bill at a time when the real issues are jobs, terror and debt.”
Well, we know the Republicans certainly know a lot about debt and terror, and loss of jobs. But not in a good way…..
Posted by: SearamblerOne | February 28, 2010, 11:08 am 11:08 am
People that go into government shouldn’t be worried about re election but to do the right thing for it’s citizens. That is the problem with many of todays politicians they want to vote to keep themselves in office and not do the right thing. It’s really a joke. A few hundred toyotas autos are having problems and there is a congressional hearing immediatley. 30 million american citizens can’t go to a doctor and the republicans are fighting reform tooth and nail. Who do you think is out for your best interest.
Posted by: bob s | February 28, 2010, 11:12 am 11:12 am
Wrong! The democrats talks like Marie Antoinette. Nancy Pelosi wants democrats to commit the Johnstwon kool-aid drinks. And you know how that ends.
Posted by: myohmy | February 28, 2010, 11:17 am 11:17 am
My family and I don’t want this bill, don’t want the increased taxes and intend to vote against any Democrats that vote for it. That’s 5 Democrat votes NO in my house. That’s just at MY house. Most of my neighbors think exactly the same way. That’s 12 Democrats and 6 Republicans who also hate this bill. And we ALL vote. Every single election.
Posted by: KariB57 | February 28, 2010, 11:22 am 11:22 am
I just heard the Senator admit governing the USA is just too complicated for their simple, fascist little minds, didn’t I?
Posted by: MikeC | February 28, 2010, 11:26 am 11:26 am
Dems will now lose control of the House AND Senate in November. And on the chance that they do ram through a few parts of the Health Reform Debacle, those parts will be promptly repealed in January 2011. Way to go, Obama!
Posted by: Higgins | February 28, 2010, 11:27 am 11:27 am
WE do not need the Feds telling us what should be in our health care polices. There is no need to debate abortion, or other procedures.
Keep government out of deciding where I have to spend my money.
Posted by: scott jeffries | February 28, 2010, 11:28 am 11:28 am
For those of you who have health care you should understand you have a good chance of losing it. SO to think it’s not my problem so don’t change anything your just flat wrong. People that say they hate this bill are absolutley clueless. They are just taking their marching orders from the morons like Rush or Sean.
Posted by: bob s | February 28, 2010, 11:35 am 11:35 am
Yeah Higgins, Scott…it’s really stupid for our country to try and give us the same benefits every other citizen of every other civilized country in the world gets.
Americans Deserve, i guess, to keep getting the worst deal in the civilized, industralized world as far as health care, safety nets etc. All to support the much faded and faster fading dream of individual wealth at your country’s expense.
Posted by: MikeC | February 28, 2010, 11:35 am 11:35 am
Alexander says America can’t do big things. Are these the people you want running your country-a bunch of lying wimps that have given up on the country and have no backbone?
Posted by: jeff | February 28, 2010, 11:35 am 11:35 am
People in this country are so easily fooled. Do you know there is someone named Frank Luntz who’s job is to figure out words to use to sway the public thinking. He polls over and over again to see what will rile people up. It’s only based on political uses and have no policy merit at all. The republicans pay Luntz big bucks to fool you and your buying it.
Posted by: bob s | February 28, 2010, 11:40 am 11:40 am
Oh thank goodness. Nothing should threaten the american citizens standing as #1 as far as getting the worst deal in the civilized, industralized world for health care, education, safety nets etc etc.
They, dem and repub alike may be too stupid to govern, but they’re absolutely brilliant at turning any legislation beneficial to the lower and middle classes into such crap nobody can support it.
Posted by: MikeC | February 28, 2010, 11:40 am 11:40 am
Jobs went overseas because Bubba signed into NAFTA and WTO, Islamic terrorist grew under Bubba’s nose because he was too busy playing with Monica and Jennifer in the oval office. Now you blame Bush for the economy being bad? The GDP grew 70% from 2002 to 2006 until Pelosi and rest of democrat thugs ruined the economy in their 1st year. Now we our ACORN president who’s destroying the free marketing… do the math people, the healthcare reform is DOA (dead on arrival). The democrats don’t even know what they are passing it was proven when that republican senator dropped the 2000+ of this so-called health reform on Obama’s face, he admitted he had no time to read it…geeze louis even our teleprompting president couldn’t read the bill he is trying to pass….
Posted by: cherokee4x4 | February 28, 2010, 11:42 am 11:42 am
AMERICANS ARE IDIOTS! RIGHT NOW YOUR HEALTH CARE PREMIUMS ARE GOING UP BY OVER 30% – THE INSURANCE COMPANIES DO NOT CARE ABOUT YOU
THE DEMOCRATS ARE TRYING TO HELP STOP THE INSURANCE COMPANIES FROM RIPPING YOU OFF, AND YOU ARE AGAINST THAT – WHY?
THE DEMOCRATS ARE TRYING TO HELP YOU AMERICANS, AND YOU ARE ALL TO STUPID TO LSEE THAT!
- WITHOUT A BILL YOUR PREMIUMS WILL CONTINUE TO GO UP!
- WITHOUT A HEALTH CARE BILL YOUR HEALTH INSURANCE COMPANY CAN DROP YOU FOR ANY REASON.
- WITHOUT A BILL MANY BUSINESSES IN THIS COUNTRY WILL NOT BE ABLE TO AFFORD TO KEEP GIVING THIER EMPLOYEES HEALTH CARE INSURANCE – BECAUSE THE INSURANCE COMPANIES WILL HAVE JACKED UP THE RATES SO HIGH, THAT IT WILL BECOME UNAFFORDABLE TO MOST AMERICAN BUINESSES
- WITHOUT A BILL NO ONE WILL BE PROTECTED FROM BEING REFUSED HELATH INSURANCE BECAUSE OF A PRE-EXISTING CONDITION
- WITHOUT A BILL THE FEDERAL DEFICIT WILL CONTINUE TO GO UP, AND UP, UNTIL THE COUNTRY GOES BANKRUPT.
THE DEMOCRATS BILL WOULD HELP SOLVE ALL THESE PROBLEMS – BUT YOU AMERICANS ARE TOO STUPID TO SEE IT!!
KEEP LISTENING TO THE STUPID, REPUBLICANS WHO ARE WORKING FOR THE HEALTH INSURANCE COMPNIES, AND GETTING MONEY FROM THE INSURANCE COMPANIES TO STOP THIS HEALTH CARE BILL – JUST SO INSURANCE COMPANIES CAN KEEP CHARGING YOU WHATEVER PREMIUMS THEY WANT!!
THE REPUBLICANS ARE LIARS, THEY DO NOT CARE ABOUT THE AMERICAN PEOPLE, THEY ARE WORKING FOR THE INSURANCE COMPANIES!
AND YOU STUPID PEOLE ARE FALLING FOR THE REPUBLICAN’S GARBAGE — DUMB!
Posted by: SARAH | February 28, 2010, 11:45 am 11:45 am
Who are you people?haha HE IS RIGHT. I hear Libs give their opinions w/o logical reasons. WE CANNOT AFFORD THIS BILL. PEOPLE EXPERIENCE PAIN AND DIE. THERE WILL ALWAYS BE WINNERS AND LOSERS.
Posted by: HA! | February 28, 2010, 11:46 am 11:46 am
I am disappointed that Ms. Vargas did not point out to Pelosi that three of four American think the Dem. lawmakers should quit the current health care bill. This fact was mentioned by CNN reporter when questioning Pelosi a day earlier.
Posted by: austin | February 28, 2010, 11:52 am 11:52 am
What you leaving out of your comment cheroke is the fact that George Bush Sr administraion is responsible in drafting the legislation for NAFTA. Clinton is another traitor to the country signing that crap.
Posted by: bob s | February 28, 2010, 11:56 am 11:56 am
It will be so refreshing to get to Canada and give up the constant worry of which conglomerate is scalping me over what. Oh that dang socialism, it’s just plain evil, isn’t it? Or is it those conglomerates telling and selling me that it is? Hmm.
Posted by: DAB | February 28, 2010, 11:57 am 11:57 am
Being the crafty politician that he is, why would he telegraph his intentions to “brand” democrats with this bill. He should shut up, let them do it, then attack and win in November. No, he’s scared this bill will get so many votes that HE will be gone in November for having opposed it, and wants to stop it now.
Posted by: justanotheropinion123 | February 28, 2010, 12:07 pm 12:07 pm
The only suicide for Democrats would be to NOT pass this bill. They know that once people find out what it really does to secure health care for individuals that you won’t be able to vote them out. The health care industry has spent over 700 million to defeat this. I wonder where all this money went? hmmm.. The real meaning of this bill is: Is America just a cash cow for the rich or is it a country of citizens who are concerned for our quality of life. There are a lot of people against this bill the way it is but the polls show the majority are against it because it doesn’t go far enough. We are drowning in health care costs and the premiums to pay for it. If you don’t feel like your drowning, you will. Your going to land up being a part of a smaller and smaller pool of individuals paying higher and higher premiums as those who can’t afford them drop out. Wake up! It’s over! Something has to be done now or you will see what has happened to the housing sector happen to the health care sector.
Posted by: member of the club | February 28, 2010, 12:09 pm 12:09 pm
It seems to me that only republican don’t want this bill to pass. Thats because they are the one’s who benifit from the Insurance companies,doctors, and pharmisudical lobbyist. They don’t give a hoot about the spending or how it will be paid for, they only worry about losing those dollars that come to them for apposing healthcare for those that can’t afford it. None of them are willing to give up the perks of their healthcare provided to them thats being paid for by those same American people they say they are looking out for. If htey are serious about the cost, why haven’t that small proposal been apart of their argument. Having “FREE” healthcare is good for them, but its a “BAD” idea to provide it for those who can not afford it, Why? Is this the start of the CLASS system crumbling. “Live and let live,” only applies when I can live better, is that the way you see it?
Posted by: Sad | February 28, 2010, 12:15 pm 12:15 pm
Member of the club…well said. Very well said.
Posted by: justanotheropinion123 | February 28, 2010, 12:17 pm 12:17 pm
If anyone should not be calling someone else dumb, it is “all caps” SARAH. When “all caps” talks about the cost of health insurance going up 30%, we can bet she is misunderstanding Anthem in California. If California controls health insurance so that the healthy are driven away and only the sick remain, then, of course the cost of health care will go up. Unfortunately, lefties like “all caps” Sarah have no idea how economics works. Hence they think everything should be free and there should be no consequences of government actions. Talk about dumb.
Posted by: Rick Caird | February 28, 2010, 12:20 pm 12:20 pm
Elizabeth Vargas is not up to the standards of Jake Tapper or George whatisname. She gave Pelosi a tongue bath. I had to turn it off. Really limp and leaning left so far I was worried for her.
Posted by: Mike K | February 28, 2010, 12:22 pm 12:22 pm
I have to wonder about what is not being said on this Health Care deboggle….Is the common sense person expected to pay the price for people who make bad choices in their life. Carefully the dems have avoided the AID’s epidemic that is rampant in the free living segment of our society. With the “PUSH” to cover pre existing conditions, I want to know how much I will have to pay for segment of society who are so self indulgent they throw caution to the wind and end up with terminal ills. How much will it cost the tax payer for the drug addict? How much will it cost for the sex addicts? How much will these high risk patients cost the person who pays attention to health, weight, safe sex? How much will these “free spirits” cost the individual who takes the time to protect themselves from social ills?
Posted by: cjvwise1 | February 28, 2010, 12:27 pm 12:27 pm
So, who’s going to pay for Obama’s health bill? He’s got to raise taxes or borrow the money. So either pay now or let your kids and grand kids pay in the future. With the Chinese selling US gov’t bonds, Obama might not be able to borrow the money. Guess what’s left? He’s going to print more of that green stuff and cause inflation. Gee…shades of Carter. Now we all want more of that, right?
Posted by: David | February 28, 2010, 12:30 pm 12:30 pm
I have to wonder about what is not being said on this Health Care deboggle….Is the common sense person expected to pay the price for people who make bad choices in their life. Carefully the dems have avoided the AID’s epidemic that is rampant in the free living segment of our society. With the “PUSH” to cover pre existing conditions, I want to know how much I will have to pay for segment of society who are so self indulgent they throw caution to the wind and end up with terminal ills. How much will it cost the tax payer for the drug addict? How much will it cost for the sex addicts? How much will these high risk patients cost the person who pays attention to health, weight, safe sex? How much will these “free spirits” cost the individual who takes the time to protect themselves from social ills?
Posted by: cjvwise1 | February 28, 2010, 12:32 pm 12:32 pm
I voted for Obama, but one year later I believe one term limit is the only way to deal with the swamp in Washington. While American workers remain unemployed, Pelosi fills her “private” jet with the best “booze” in the world and vacations on the taxpayers dollar from Paris for Valentines to any other yuppy get-a-way in the world. The arrogance of our elected officials cannot “fix” the country for the average person.
Posted by: cjvwise1 | February 28, 2010, 12:37 pm 12:37 pm
The dems won’t do reconciliation….it’s political suicide…
Posted by: LongT | February 28, 2010, 12:39 pm 12:39 pm
The older you get, the more dealings you have with both insurance companies and government agencies. The more experience you have with both, the more likely you are to dislike dealing with government agencies over insurance companies.That’s not a consequence of ‘brainwashing’, it’s a consequence of experience. Maybe if Government spent more time fixing the agencies it currently has, instead of coddling them, citizens would reevaluate their dislike of these agencies as a whole and be more open to the introduction of new ones.
Also, pretending cost isn’t an issue is not a winner for Dems and their supporters. In every persons life, in everything they do, every decision they contemplate, cost is ALWAYS an issue. Pretending it’s just a talking point doesn’t make you look wise, it makes you look deluded. That’s not helpful.
Posted by: Chad | February 28, 2010, 12:50 pm 12:50 pm
Ha
You have the communist talking points down to a fine art dont ya?
Pelosi has just said what we already knew. She knows that if they pass this healthcare bill against the peoples wishes, they will lose in November so they know that this is suicide of their careers but they plan on doing it anyway to destroy whats left of our constitution
Go move to a communist country if you want it so bad!
Posted by: Holly | February 28, 2010, 12:51 pm 12:51 pm
I had minimal need for my Health Insurance when I was employed, household combined incomes in the over $240k, healthy and young.. my 401k went down 70%, sold-off another property and retired. With property taxes at $1,100/month and 4 prescription drugs that maxed-out in July into the “donut”..an additional $450.00/month on medications is a bit too much…I decided to buy generics and from the internet to save and 100% out of pocket. I’ve worked continuously for 38 years..the last 15 years building facilities like Merck, Schering-Plogh, Bristol-Myers, Amgen..etc.. I could “wing” the payments now..but I’m not sure I’ll be able to do it 10 years from now. The reason Health Reform is imperative. These “no” politicians are always going “against the grain”, contrarians.. I’d say: if these people are drowning away in a swift current – wait upstream and they’ll be there..expectedly.
Posted by: Emit Pallarca | February 28, 2010, 12:58 pm 12:58 pm
I would like to commend Vargas for being the first journalist to actually question her guest–Lamar Alexander–and then to even respond to his answers by asking follow up questions. What a novel idea! Perhaps others at ABC News should follow her suit? I know it’s a moot point and that another white guy will end up getting the This Week chair but I’d like to put a vote in for Vargas becoming host. I might even start watching the show again. She doesn’t seem to be as afraid of the right wing or left wing and isn’t consumed with the notion of “access.” What good is “access” if all you’re getting access to is a bunch of bunk?
As far as Alexander’s comments on health care reform. When you’re a millionaire who also makes $170,000 plus a year AND gets the best health care insurance MY tax dollars will pay for, it’s really easy to make blanket and false statements about health care reform. I’ve been polled and the questions are such that I said I was unhappy with the current bill in the Senate…not because I don’t want health care reform but because I don’t think the Senate bill goes far enough. What is so funny is that the Republicans have wanted to dismantle Medicare for years. They still want to get rid of it. And yet, they portray themselves as the protectors of Medicare. Please! Read their so-called health care bill folks. They want to replace your Medicare with vouchers. Essentially, they want to RATION healthcare. Eegads!!!! Do I smell Death Panels? These men are small minded corporate shills and they should be ashamed of themselves. I believe that what goes around comes around and I truly look forward to the day when Mr. Alexander and his Republican comrades find themselves either going bankrupt because of some illness their insurance won’t cover or simply unable to get insurance. That would be justice indeed.
Posted by: Miz | February 28, 2010, 1:04 pm 1:04 pm
Ah the American public, like turkeys voting for Thanksgiving.
Good news for me, in only 3 more months I get to move to a country that takes care of it’s citizenry on the health care front rated above America for cost, access to care and longevity of life.
Of course most other countries are ranked higher in all these areas, but we keep denying that to keep from changing anything. (by the way I’ve been to this country and gotten medical care before and it was great)
Lucky thing I can do this as my employer is taking away my health insurance and I cannot afford the laughably high cost of premiums on my own.
So I don’t have to worry about whether America joins every other first rate country on the health care front. I don’t have to worry about absurd premium increases or lack of coverage and that makes me very happy.
I wonder for those who say we can’t afford the program, when will it be possible to change? Another ten years from now? Or do we have to wait until all Americans do not have/ cannot afford health care and thus are all “losers” under the current system Ha? Will that be what it finally takes to motivate us?
Sounds like a good plan!
By the way I do think the Democratic party is doing a fantastic job of shooting themselves in the foot on this issue astounding really, Bob makes a good point about the parties ability to turn any legislation into crap.
Good luck folks you’ll need it!
Posted by: Wade | February 28, 2010, 1:05 pm 1:05 pm
Skip the insults. Look at facts. A majority of Americans have access to the world’s best health care – and the costs reflect that.
Do Americans go to other countries for expensive life-saving medical care? Why do many more people – from the Middle East, Europe and Canada – come to the US for it?
Yes, reforms are obviously needed. But, when there is an economic crisis, all spending needs to be carefully considered.
An incremental approach makes sense for economic and political reasons. It would be much easier to get broad political support for it in Washington and around the country.
This is the way Washington normally works. You pass something, then add to it, revise it, tweak it, whatever, as the need becomes clear.
It’s ok to condemn the insurance companies. But, Democrats and Republicans have just eliminated these companies’ anti-trust protection. That’s a good warning shot across the bow.
Or, look at this way. High quality health care in W. Europe is not free. It’s paid for with much higher income taxes, starting with lower incomes, higher gas taxes, VAT’s and other taxes.
We don’t have these kinds or levels of taxation. This is a primary reason why we don’t have universal health insurance coverage.
The fundamental question is how much more are Americans prepared to spend for that kind of coverage for everyone.
Posted by: vrytix | February 28, 2010, 1:08 pm 1:08 pm
Keep pushing liberals, Karl Rove couldn’t have drawn this up any better. The liberals are now telling 73% of the American Public who oppose this bill that they are just too dumb to understand and the 22% of koolaid drinking liberals are the only smart ones.
That’s a good slogan liberals, you can even put it on a bumper sticker.
“Vote for liberals because you are just to dumb for anything else”
Good luck in November you arrogant idiots.
Posted by: robtr | February 28, 2010, 1:11 pm 1:11 pm
Go Democrats, pass it. The people will vote you out and your bill will be repealed. We will reform the reform. This will be a good thing. Americans prefer a country that has a government, rather than the other way around.
Posted by: Meremortal | February 28, 2010, 1:26 pm 1:26 pm
I want a helath care bill. We’re supposed to be the greatest nation on the planet yet we have out of control healthcare that is destroying the middle and lower classes.
and yet the majority of other industrialized nations have much better healthcare then us, but we can;t do it.
Time ot buy some guns and start shooting the morons who are selling us down a river.
The only good republican is a dead one
Posted by: DP | February 28, 2010, 1:39 pm 1:39 pm
These politicians are so out of touch with real Americans. They get their healthcare for free while we pay thousands per year for terrible policies. Take away their free healthcare and see how fast they change their tune.
Posted by: Dave | February 28, 2010, 1:46 pm 1:46 pm
The nature of politics have always been to push self-interests whether it is at the Government or Corporate level. You buy/bait supporters in by throwing carrots. Simple truth keeps everything in perspective.
Job losses didn’t happen overnight, and, as such, jobs can’t be created overnight. Logically, no jobs mean no affordable health care as per the status quo. You would like to patch it now and not let generations to endure it. We can afford it, if we don’t build “fire crackers” just to drop on heads of people we don’t like else where in the globe.
Posted by: CommonGood | February 28, 2010, 1:50 pm 1:50 pm
PS… for that poster who has x number of family members who will not vote Dem because of this bill, there are 30 million people without health insurance and their respective families who will vote Dem because of this bill. So I dont think Dems are too worried about your vote. I dont think they were worried about your vote in the last presidential election either.
Posted by: Dave | February 28, 2010, 1:51 pm 1:51 pm
trillions of dollars of debt for this and it will be the end of the u.s. the best way to ensure health care for all is JOBS for all. the best economic minds say jobs will tank for the next five years. whose going to pay and it doesnt even come into effect for a number of years.were gonna pay for it now and trust chicago politicians to do the right thing with the money? how dumb can we be.
Posted by: catman | February 28, 2010, 2:19 pm 2:19 pm
“Every Democratic candidate in the country is going to be defined by this unpopular health care bill at a time when the real issues are jobs, terror and debt.” ——————-The bill that pasted the Senate is not the health care bill the public will get. That bill is going to be voted on as is by the House of Representatives, then modified by reconciliation, that’s what the final bill is going to be. Lying to people about the process, and what will be in the bill is killing Americans to advance the profits of “Big Insurance”. And for that the Republicans will never be forgiven. – ITWARZ
Posted by: ITWARZ | February 28, 2010, 2:20 pm 2:20 pm
One thing for sure is they don’t move they’re done. They add the public option their base will be there for them along with finacial support. Up till now they have turned their backs on their base
Posted by: rightbehind | February 28, 2010, 2:24 pm 2:24 pm
“Every Democratic candidate in the country is going to be defined by this unpopular health care bill at a time when the real issues are jobs, terror and debt.” ————— Wrong again! What Americans are going to remember is who sided with Big Insurance over them. Who stood by and watched as Americans suffered and died without health care, whining “let’s start over”. They are going to remember who on Friday blocked an extension of unemployment benefits to families thrown out of work by Republican mismanagement of the government under Bush. Then they are going to remember how the right and the “Conserva-Dems” sabotaged the original health care bill by loading it up with bribes and personal kickbacks for their vote. That’s what the American People are going to remember. – ITWARZ
Posted by: ITWARZ | February 28, 2010, 2:34 pm 2:34 pm
OPEN MEDICARE to EMPLOYERS this will save medicare, solve preexisting conditions and compete with insurance companies all at one stroke. It is a no brainer.
Posted by: hybridhealthcare | February 28, 2010, 2:46 pm 2:46 pm
Republican Double Speak – “Passing this massive health care bill by Reconciliation is subverting the Constitution”. – The Truth – Reconciliation is only going to be used to modify the Senate version of the bill that has already passed the Senate by 60 votes. The Democrats are going to have an up or down 51% majority vote to get rid of the pork the “Conserva-Dems” insisted on in exchange for their original support of the bill. They are also going to make some fixes that will better bring the bill in line with what the President’s outline is. – ITWARZ
Posted by: ITWARZ | February 28, 2010, 2:47 pm 2:47 pm
Republican Double Speak – “Democrats will rue the day they voted for this massive takeover of health care!” – The Truth – If this were true why in the world would they be doing everything in their power to stop Democrats from walking off this cliff? Republicans, to quote DMX, “Ya’ll been eaten long enough now, stop being greedy”. – ITWARZ
Posted by: ITWARZ | February 28, 2010, 2:54 pm 2:54 pm
It is amazing how the Democrats believe that those that work for a living owe those that refuse to work a living. They believe that people shouldn’t be responsible for their life choices and that the government should stand by them and dictate their every move, that somehow a bureaucrat in Washington should make life and death decisions on one’s healthcare, based on the cost to the government, not the health or wishes of the individual.
We once again see the Democrats view that instead of bringing people up and helping them succeed, we should punish those that have and bring everyone down to mediocrity. Socialism in all it flavors has failed miserably everywhere it has been imposed, and yet the Democrats and their self-indulged leadership attempts to lead every American over the cliff to a failed healthcare system, void of innovation, plagued by bureaucracy and destine to failure.
Hard work, sacrifice, individualism, responsibility all traits foreign to Democrats and their supporters, where collective failure, mediocrity, shared pain, and achievement measured in collective failure in the cold bureaucratic embrace of socialism and the lose of individual freedom and achievement.
Posted by: mgw | February 28, 2010, 3:00 pm 3:00 pm
I don’t understand why some people here think they’re actually going to benefit from this monstrous bill. You’ll end up in the emergency room anyway because there aren’t enough doctors. That’s what happened in MA.
Regulation cannot make costs go down. Only market competition does that. If the Dems force the insurance companies out of business with price controls, then the ONLY way that costs can go down is through rationing.
Government programs such as Medicare ALREADY deny more claims than the private sector and these denials will only become more frequent, not less.
Why do you think all those new government commissions, boards, and panels are in these bills? They’re not there to pass out candy.
Posted by: Syl | February 28, 2010, 3:03 pm 3:03 pm
The Republicans exist on self-delusion and lies. They will find out in November what America really thinks about them and their failed policies. Do they really think that the right wing crazies are enough to get them elected?
The People are too smart for that. They know Goper policies and ideology has failed and they don’t want any more of it.
Posted by: wernervonphooey | February 28, 2010, 3:07 pm 3:07 pm
IF the politicians are at such great risk if they vote for this bill, IT MUST MEAN THE VOTERS DON’T WANT IT!
Posted by: hawkey | February 28, 2010, 3:07 pm 3:07 pm
Count 2 “no democrat votes” in my household, 2 for my parents, 1 for my grandmother, and 2 for my brothers household.
Posted by: stevemb12 | February 28, 2010, 3:11 pm 3:11 pm
Republican Double Speak – “It is amazing how the Democrats believe that those that work for a living owe those that refuse to work a living.” – The Truth – Democrats would love to take away ANY ill gotten gains people who REFUSE to work have gotten. The RICH unfortunately have control of the Republican party and FOX News, making stripping the wealthy of what they looted from hard working Americans impossible in this political climate. – ITWARZ
Posted by: ITWARZ | February 28, 2010, 3:25 pm 3:25 pm
Its amazing how so many people who appose the health care reform, have all that facts twisted. If you all payed any attention, to the 6 hour debate, you would know that through the insurance exchange the Dems are trying to pass, you will have the the choice to purchase much more inexpensive health care insurance. Ah, and lets not forget who’s idea it was to put health care insurance exchange to the table, yes thats right it was a Republican idea. So the Dems go and put the exchange into place and the Reps. are still crying foul. Party of Just say “NO”
Posted by: mg | February 28, 2010, 3:32 pm 3:32 pm
I do not know about anyone else, but my husband and I cannot afford any more increases in our medical insurance. How-
ever, when they messed with credit cards, things just got worse, not better. Could that happen with insurance too? We DO NOT have ANY money
left even for food. Are they trying to
KILL us that are poor out here???? I am an independant, not republican or democrat, I just need to live.
Posted by: nameless | February 28, 2010, 3:35 pm 3:35 pm
OK Sarah, so lets say we all went for this legislation. Hmmmm, immediately MY Insurance Premiums go up. Immediately, if I lose my job, I have to PAY for insurance benefits even when I don’t have the money (saved up due to the economy and previous lost jobs) to pay for it. The safety net is not for the middle class. The safety net is for the Looter Class who’s only “work” experience is how to WORK the tax payer over for free money, food, etc. Of course as soon as this thing passes, instead of working on JOB creation in the Private sector – this Dem Govt will work to pass an IMMIGRATION bill that will allow people who are here illegally to become IMMEDIATE AMERICAN CITIZENS so they can IMMEDIATELY get on the subsidized insurance, so my premiums can go up again….and again…and what do I get for all this. I’m sick – and I may have to wait 2 or 3 months to see a Dr. WAY TO GO! Lets work on the COST of healthcare, instead of the INSURANCE cost. Lets put regs on the INSURANCE company and mandate things there instead of costing more and more on the middle class who are struggling. In fact, by week after next, if I don’t find a 2nd job…I’ll be looking at Bankruptcy and I make over 50K a year. Husband lost 4 jobs in 5 years. I still have a job and insurance…Where is my help???? Oh – I’m not AA and have 6 kids without a husband…so I get nothing, but to PAY for the looter class to get more and more. So – until there is a better plan on the table that doesn’t put me in the looter class, I’ll pass on this bill. I’ll wait for the next one that comes along…
Posted by: My_Prerogative | February 28, 2010, 3:46 pm 3:46 pm
And Sarah, How about reading about the Greek people now and how they are completely socialized and going completely broke, but yet they still expect the Govt to take care of them…. I don’t trust the folks in Washington DC – wouldn’t trust them taking care of my cat, let alone me and my child.
Posted by: My_Prerogative | February 28, 2010, 3:48 pm 3:48 pm
A lot of comments about 30 million people without health care, but little about 270 million with health care. I have it, I pay for it and I do not want to pay for someone who does not want it. A lot of those who do not have it are young and do not feel they have to have it, I felt that way and did not have it until I turned 40 and then reality set in. I would bet that many of those posting comments here do not realize that their costs will increase to support other, their taxes will increase to support others and the costs of health care will not go down with this proposed legislation. Obama care will make a bad situation worse.
Posted by: jim 234 | February 28, 2010, 3:49 pm 3:49 pm
The repub plan of no action will result in the death of the repub party. So yes, we may end up paying more for HC in the short term. But the long term prospects of no HC are even worse. Well, everybody get ready to pay for Emergency Room bills for the indigents. That’s right, our tax dollars will pay for all indigent care. You pay taxes, you pay for indigent care. Doesn’t matter what part of the country you are in.
Posted by: raggmopp | February 28, 2010, 4:13 pm 4:13 pm
I see a post from vrytix saying we have the best HC in the world. How do you figure? We have SOME of the best technology – yes. We do not have the best HC in the world. This country is so far down the list on mortality and the care of patients. The costs do not reflect the quality of care we Americans are provided. The costs reflect the greed and corruption of the repub politicians and INS companies.
Posted by: raggmopp | February 28, 2010, 4:20 pm 4:20 pm
Prior post probably didn’t agree with ABC’s political/financial/philosophical viewpoint. Bottom-line, neither my family, brother’s family, father/mother/grandmother appreciate the Dem.’s “ram it home” approach. Thus, no Dem votes from this family for years to come. My wife, who voted for BO, learned her lesson, when our standard of living dropped after the great one came to power. She will not vote Dem again.
Posted by: stevemb12 | February 28, 2010, 4:22 pm 4:22 pm
ALEXANDER: “The reconciliation procedure is a — where you use legislative (ph) procedure is a (ph) — where you use — legislative procedure 19 times it’s been used. It’s for the purpose of taxing and spending and — and reducing deficits.”
Even his own mouth could barely speak such lies! The reconciliation process is responsible for trillions in additional deficits – including for bills which don’t expire unless well into the 2010′s or later.
Posted by: The_Mick | February 28, 2010, 4:22 pm 4:22 pm
Go Dems., ram this home, and the voters will return you home. Don’t let the doorknob hit you on the way out. This includes you BO!
Posted by: stevemb12 | February 28, 2010, 4:30 pm 4:30 pm
Sarah, assuming you are an American, you have proven your point that some Americans are stupid and but sheep waiting for the Democrats to shear them. However, kudos for being able to memorize the Dem’s talking points despite your debilitated comprehension.
Posted by: John | February 28, 2010, 4:31 pm 4:31 pm
Europe is dying and you want to be more like Europe?
Get a clue, America. Your founding fathers were closer to the truth than any other government in history.
Stick to your constitution. Don’t drown in Obama-debt.
Posted by: Bill Clancy | February 28, 2010, 4:44 pm 4:44 pm
The comments to this article are amazing. One liberal equates the US government with America (is dissent against the government same as dissent against America?). Another liberal proclaims that if US were to increase welfare and become more like Western Europe, it would be competetive. A third liberal loudly proclaims that insurance companies don’t care about you – as if it means that politicians like Nancy Pelosi, Harry Reid and Barack Obama care about American people. Yes another liberal called it fascism when the politician stands against the increase of the government power – as if Mussolini was a libertarian.
And on and on it goes.
I have only one question – are all liberals that dumb?
P.S. Don’t forget to visit my blog:
Posted by: Hyphenated American | February 28, 2010, 4:55 pm 4:55 pm
I am tired of this being such a football, but even a broken Clock is right twice a day. Americans Do not want the mess the President is trying to make. (not covered here is the fact that the Mandates are very likely to be found Unconstitutional) Pelosi said today Ignore what the voters want , we know better.
Yes it will be Kamikaze Mission. That frightens me as I would rather not see both a Republican Dominated Congress and a Republican President.
Posted by: Rick | February 28, 2010, 5:19 pm 5:19 pm
Down with Capitalism, communism, and monarchism. “The socialism I believe in isn’t really politics. It is a way of living. It is humanity. I believe the only way to live and to be truly successful is by collective effort, with everyone working for each other, everyone helping each other, and everyone having a share of the rewards at the end of the day. That might be asking a lot, but it’s the way I see football and the way I see life.”
Shankly’s philosophy
Posted by: cony647 | February 28, 2010, 5:52 pm 5:52 pm
Bob S, Mike C.,
You two, and the other damned fools like you, are responsible for the problems we’re in right now. Understand this, chumps: WE, AS A NATION, CAN’T AFFORD THIS BILL AND DON’T WANT IT! You’re probably part of the 40+% who don’t pay taxes so you don’t give a damn who has to cough up for your entitlement, because it won’t be you.
If you like other countries’ health care so much, move there. You won’t be missed.
Posted by: mac | February 28, 2010, 5:56 pm 5:56 pm
I totally agree this will be the demise of the democratic party in November. To toatlly think they have lost it and don’t know where their reasoning is. I for one intend not to support any of my representatives that vote for it. I have seen enough waste. If both parties can’t compromise and come up with something that really helps healthcare and is not a show bill then I will think about it. Right now this new bill will only help a few and cost the rest of us who are working dearly. Including our employers.
Posted by: Steve | February 28, 2010, 6:15 pm 6:15 pm
National Flood Tax..National Health Tax
Lessons to be learned…
The FEMA NFIP was sold to “provide affordable flood insurance” to individuals in this country. NOTHING could be further from the truth.
My personal home “fell between the cracks” from the time FEMA forced my County to join and accept ALL the responsibility and there has been NO PROVISIONS available to fix the problem.
My 160K house is expected to pay $400/MONTH for Flood Insurance although I’ve never flooded since 1981!
A HUGE, UNFEELING GOVERNMENT MACHINE from which there is no escape.
THIS is what “THEY” want for “Healthcare”!
Posted by: Chris Petty | February 28, 2010, 6:28 pm 6:28 pm
Alexander’s wrong. A majority in Congress, and that’s the way our representative democracy works, will pass Obama’s health care reform legislation very soon. It will benefit millions of Americans, reduce costs for all.
Posted by: dudh | February 28, 2010, 6:33 pm 6:33 pm
The Obama plan has dropped the public option and goes with the Health Exchanges favored by Republicans. Many other amendments offered by Reps. are incorporated. It will be a bipartisan health care reform bill of ideas, though it will not be bipartisan by votes. The Republicans should be ashamed of themselves. Alexander says if health care reform passes (after the entire GOP votes against it) they will work to repeal it. That’s the best the GOP can do? Note Alexander does not say they will work to fix what they think is wrong with it. You take that hyper political position to November Alexander and let the voters speak on what they think of that attitude!!!
Posted by: hopesprings52 | February 28, 2010, 6:34 pm 6:34 pm
As the dems try to pass on these costs to our children, they will seal their epitapt.
Posted by: jonny | February 28, 2010, 6:45 pm 6:45 pm
Let them pass it, then in November, let the GOP repeal it.
Posted by: Rick McDaniel | February 28, 2010, 6:51 pm 6:51 pm
I read this and thought… “The French Revolution comes to mind…” I think this interview should be on the front page of every paper – so everyone will know what enemies of the people these Republicans are. For every stupid “Tea Party” (don’t get me started on this misnomer..) member, there are probably 10,000 people who NEED help. All these so-called Christian (“Hey, I give to charity.. blah blah”) people who are denying help to their fellow man. Karma’s a *itch, you know….
Posted by: paintpaintpaint | February 28, 2010, 7:19 pm 7:19 pm
Lamar, tipped the GOP’s hand alittle. The Dems already know they don’t have the votes in the House to pass the Senate version, they are 20-30 votes short now. Assuming they could give out enough bribes to get over that hurdle, recon would take months. The GOP has already stated that they will shut the Senate down by offering amendments to the recon bill endlessly, until will get to November. Then after the landslide GOP victory, the bill would be repealed anyway. The loons should start over, because if this by some miracle does pass, Obama would be a lame duck for the rest of his only term.
Posted by: Tony T | February 28, 2010, 7:40 pm 7:40 pm
Freedom-loving America will never accept this bill of slavery even if it passes. There is not near enough room in the prisons to contain all the people who would be arrested for failing to pay for their healthcare insurance, so it would be non-enforcable.
It is unconstitutional for government to force citizens to pay for an unwanted service or product, so it would most likely be overturned by the Supreme court anyway.
Why not write something that America wants, that is constitutional, and that has potential to actually work?
Posted by: Daniel Martinusen | February 28, 2010, 7:41 pm 7:41 pm
Like the American congress, the Japanese of WWII knew how to spin a political phrase. What we know as kamikaze missions in which the pilots attempted to fly their planes, often successful, into Allied Naval vessels, the Japanese pilots knew as “divine wind.” The Japanese emperor believed that this would save the country even though Japan had a dwindling supply of pilots and no airplane manufacturing to speak of. In the end, while the cost to American vessels was high, the outcome was the same. It is not a fair comparison to equate today’s congressional leadership with an attack on the world, but it is fair to say that individuals who approve this debt-ridden, liberty-stealing piece of legislation will have to face voters, or retire. Even the most liberal of polls now has almost 60% of Americans opposed to this bill. Why? Despite Obama’s efforts to hide creation of this bill, its contents are now public. Despite the current congressional leadership claims of ethics, bribes-for-votes produced the current outcome. And then, after one kamikaze pilot had crashed his plane in a Nebraska cornfield, poor Sen. Nelson had the rug pulled from under him as Obama promised to remove the $100 million bribe paid for Nelson’s vote. The current legislative activity is not change you can believe in. It is more of the same contempt for the American public that we have experienced in increasing amounts every year. It’s time we all stood up and said no.
Posted by: wantingbalance | February 28, 2010, 7:41 pm 7:41 pm
“only 3 more months I get to move to a country that takes care of it’s citizenry on the health care front rated above America for cost, access to care and longevity of life” Good luck, loon. Enjoy paying 50% of your wages for FREE healthcare. Make sure you book your doc appointments 6 months in advance and pray you don’t need medical attention fast.
Posted by: Tony T | February 28, 2010, 7:44 pm 7:44 pm
they figure the tax’s wont be noticed, and they can buy the votes of the non working
Posted by: madmax | February 28, 2010, 7:52 pm 7:52 pm
“The repub plan of no action will result in the death of the repub party.” Never ceases to amaze me how stupid the left is. Loon, the GOP won the governor’s race in NJ and VA, by landslides. And “Teddy’s seat” went to the GOP in one of the most backward liberal states in the union. Which party is in a death spiral??? You people do make me chuckle though. Kind of like Pelosi with the old “we haven’t counted the votes yet”, which is code for we aren’t even close.
Posted by: Tony T | February 28, 2010, 7:52 pm 7:52 pm
Dave, you are obviously to slow to understand the point of my post. While my family are just but a few votes-think what that means multiplied by millions.
Posted by: stevemb12 | February 28, 2010, 8:06 pm 8:06 pm
Republicans really care about people in America so much that they could care less if they have access to decent health care or not. Republicans are the ones who are clueless and spineless. They stand united with the republican leaders against helping anyone at all. Republicans are so good at saying people don’t want health care reform when the truth is we need it desperately.
Posted by: Vicki | February 28, 2010, 8:08 pm 8:08 pm
“Republicans are so good at saying people don’t want health care reform” Vickie, try watching C-Span or reading a paper. The GOP never said any of your Dem talking points. They have said the American people WANT healthcare reform, just not this bill. If you don’t believe that try Googling for the polls. 2700 pages that barely got thru either house, and only when bribes and kickbacks to get the final votes….is that a good bill to you??? WAKE UP!!!
Posted by: Tony T | February 28, 2010, 8:14 pm 8:14 pm
By threatening to use filibuster so very often, the GOPers have turned the noble idea of protection of minority rights into the dangerous idea of minority tyranny. While I am against doing away with filibuster altogether, I do believe we need to legislate to limit its use.
Posted by: teddymaniac | February 28, 2010, 8:16 pm 8:16 pm
There are some really simpleton type idiots commenting here. Fortunately President Obama and the Democrats will forge ahead to make sure that health insurance, health benefits, and health premiums are kept from going through the roof. Republicans really are dumb if they think without any steps taken we will still have access to good care.
Posted by: Vicki | February 28, 2010, 8:17 pm 8:17 pm
Simpleton here. ‘Obama and the Democrats will ~ make sure ~ health premiums are kept from going through the roof.’ How will Obama and the current congress assure that since they won’t be around after their maximum terms expire or retire and the full affect will not be experience until after 2014? This is no longer a health care bill. It is a crony and politician line their own pockets deal. They’ll have their prize long before the system crashes from the debt burden. Back room deals are for who?
Posted by: TX_MBell | February 28, 2010, 8:38 pm 8:38 pm
I agree with most of the people who have left comments here. My wife and I mostly vote Democrat… and we will NOT vote for local democrats–senate democrats–house democrats–or presidential democrats–if they ram through healthcare this way. we DON’T want this National Healthcare bill. And we VOTED for this president and our Democratic Senators. ARE YOU LISTENING, WASHINGTON? Vote for this bill, and we WILL NOT VOTE DEMOCRATIC FOR A LONG TIME. And we have very long memories!!!
Posted by: Brandon | February 28, 2010, 8:45 pm 8:45 pm
“Democrats will forge ahead to make sure that health insurance” OK, I am apparently simple. Educate me. How exactly will the Dems “forge ahead”? Recon is a dead end, the House MUST act first. The House doesn’t have the votes for the Senate bill. This is because of the abortion, union taxes and the kickbacks to certain states. None of those can be “fixed” under recon. So instead of preaching the typical loony talking points, tell me exactly what you think the Dems can do?? We all already know who the simpleton is….
Posted by: Tony T | February 28, 2010, 8:46 pm 8:46 pm
The democrats have really been to nice to the Republicans. Obama needs to call them for what they really are. Denial of healthcare nearly makes them eligible
for at least negligent Homicide. Wait when putting people in a pine box makes it pre-meditated when we know it’s going to happen. It is time to create a wall as we did for vietnam veterans of
each person a republican kills. Then we
should drop that republican from his role and have him and his staff be denied health care. Remeber all men are created equal just the republicans want
to start from scratch. Well why the ???
did they not do that months ago instead of sitting on their ????? doing nothing.
This is the firstr day of the fall of the republican party.
Posted by: ken | February 28, 2010, 8:50 pm 8:50 pm
I am now 58 years old, and Senator Larmar Alexander has been in the senate since 1979.. ISN’T IT TIME THIS “DO NOTHING” FOR HIS COUNTRY MAN RETIRE? HE IS ONE OF THE REASON WHY AMERICA HASN’T MOVED FORWARD FOR DECADES AND DECADES. VOTE HIM OUT TENNESSEEANS!
Posted by: sara | February 28, 2010, 9:00 pm 9:00 pm
Insurance will continue to rise. and guess what your companys answer will be.
lets get rid of our older employees because they cost us the most money.
Then when your getting close to retirement that company will hire
your replacement at half your cost.
You will wind up spending retirement money before it’s you time.
My normal cobra is more than what i GET FROM UNEMPLOYMENT.
Well now I know my republican neighbors will not come to my funeral because the
company they work for just dropped their insurance. Hope it goes up another 60% for you next year.
Well why not if I can’t have it and I’m a Vietnam veteran why should you have it if I don’t. This way only the Rich can afford insurance which is how it should be.
The republican party had 8 years to fix
this, but they made such a mess of everything.
I will never vote republican again
Posted by: ken | February 28, 2010, 9:10 pm 9:10 pm
A health care bill should A) have a public option thereby providing direct competition to corporate industry and B) be available to every single American citizen. Health care is not a matter of how much money you do or do not have. All civilized countries take care of their people, and health care should be no different. Insurance companies and drug companies are only interested in their bottom line, not the welfare of the people. We need the public option. Anything else is insufficient.
Posted by: Toby | February 28, 2010, 9:12 pm 9:12 pm
“We need the public option. Anything else is insufficient.” Public Option is dead and buried, let it go. We have the GOP and 2 Dem Senators to thank for that and of course the good people of Mass. Still trying to understand why adding one government run insurance company to dole out the lowest version of health care possible, is adding competition to the 1300 health car insurance companies we currently have? Anyone, Anyone? Bueller?
Posted by: Tony T | February 28, 2010, 9:17 pm 9:17 pm
Lamar is pilot in the cockpit of the kamikaze plane. Instead of using its clout to shape a health care bill which is more palatable to them, which they have been invited to do, the GOP is choosing to fly their kamikaze plane right into the U.S. Congress and our system of democracy. The art of democracy is using your clout to compromise and put more of your priorities on legislation. Voting NO at all costs, refusing to participate for political gain and rejecting compromise at all costs is a kamikaze attack on democracy. This bill will pass and do much good and not bring the horrors bemoaned by the GOP. In the end, the voters are smart enough to see which Party is merely intent on using power to amass more power and not on doing the peoples’ business. The arc of history is taking the present day solid bloc GOP molded by Bush, Cheney and DeLay right into the dustbin.
Posted by: hopesprings52 | February 28, 2010, 9:35 pm 9:35 pm
Hopefully this Health Care Bill debate is practice for an Energy Bill. If the Democrats can acquire the balls to push this bill through maybe they’ll actually learn how to get something done and can move on to the next item on the agenda. The best way to deal with Republicans is to do unto them as they would do unto you.
Posted by: Bob | February 28, 2010, 10:17 pm 10:17 pm
Good of Mr. Alexander to be so concerned for the Democrats. Here’s one for Mr. him, perhaps he remembers, he was there:
“The point is this: if you’ve got 51 votes, you win.” – Sen. Judd Gregg, 2005, defending the Republicans’ use of the budget reconciliation process.
Posted by: NovShmozKaPop | February 28, 2010, 10:37 pm 10:37 pm
My insurance premium through my employer went up 18% effective tomorrow for the next year. My co-pays are already higher than the basic cost of medical services; i.e. pharmacy, primary physician, chiropractic. So if I am relatively healthy, I still pay more. We need this legislation and just backing off and saying ‘no’ isn’t serving the American people. Congressmen and senators get their insurance premiums at no cost to them and their families, no co-pays, and we pay for their insurance, yet they can’t even support and encourage this legislation with fair debate with a common purpose for the people they ‘say’ they are serving. (By the way, they also don’t pay social security and serve one term to qualify for their full salaries for their retirement.) You can tell that most that are opposed seem to already have taken their eyes off the legislation and are now looking at the mid-term elections as the finish line.
Posted by: Rob Dent | February 28, 2010, 10:45 pm 10:45 pm
how we respond to foreign companies who have killed us.
Mitsubishi make everything from autos to forklifts for America. They also made the engines for the planes that killed us at Pearl Harbor. Did’nt even feel they had to change the name.
It’s time to ask these companies to leave America.
Posted by: ken | February 28, 2010, 10:45 pm 10:45 pm
From the repub party of no, to televised interviews of repubs saying “I hope the Pres fails” to the repub mantra of never passing a dem sponsored bill – what a great display of repub patriotism (vomit). They care so much about this country they will do anything so prevent the middle class from regaining lost ground. How about a little history – the repubs have not constitutionally declared war since the 19th century. The greatest wars this country has fought in during the 20th century, and were victorious, were dem presidents who sought and received the constitutional declaration of war. WWII saw massive amounts of money and debt, take into account the inflation and time differences and you will see that the HC bill pales in comparison. A repub pres reduced the military by the greatest margin in this country’s history (Eisenhower), plus he started sending American troops to Viet Nam and the USA fully supported the country from 1954 until our departure. The first American troops to die in Viet Nam occurred in 1957 in a non-declared war. The greed and corruption of the repubs began the Great Depression. The greed and corruption of the repubs lead to the Teapot Dome scandal. Watergate was a repub. A repub pres took a budget surplus and spent it all plus started all of this debt that everyone is talking about. The dems have not been angels either but their transgressions are minor in comparison. Neither party has acted n the best interests of this country but it is the dems who have provided this country its greatest moments of the 20th century. Neither party can be trusted but if you review the history, the dems have done better for this country than the repubs will ever do.
Posted by: raggmopp | February 28, 2010, 10:53 pm 10:53 pm
Proposed 28th Amendment to the United States Constitution:
“Congress shall make no law that applies to the citizens of the United States that does not apply equally to the Senators and/or Representatives; and, Congress shall make no law that applies to the Senators and/or Representatives that does not apply equally to the citizens of the United States “.
Members of Congress should pay for their healthcare and that of their families, same as most of us. They should also pay Social Security, which they currently have exempted themselves from. They should not get full pay at retirement for serving (I use the term ‘serving’ with due caution) only one term.
There should not be an elitist group of elected government employees. I believe they have corrupted enough of our values. Time to level the playing field.
Posted by: Rob Dent | February 28, 2010, 10:59 pm 10:59 pm
If the HC passes, there will be new taxes. No doubt. If the HC bill does not pass, they will be even more taxes as we will be paying for indigent HC. The emergency rooms will be inundated with common colds, ear infections, etc. that the patients will not pay for. Which means all of us who are paying taxes will see a greater increase in taxes because we will have to support the HC infrastructure. This tax increase will be mainly from the local and state level which means they will stick it to us even more than the feds. We are going to lose either way, take the lesser of two evils.
Posted by: raggmopp | February 28, 2010, 11:08 pm 11:08 pm
I’m baffled by my fellow Americans’ failure to appreciate the concept of individual rights: you live in a country where you’re not supposed to look to your government overlords to “do what’s best for you,” they’re supposed to LISTEN to you and do what you pay them to do, which for most people is fund a standing military and few reasonable initiatives, and then get out of my way. You’re not supposed to expect to get all of your basic needs from the government – which has to forcibly take it from others to give it to you – but to work hard and earn what you need and want.
When did Americans become so foolish as to cast aspersions on the character of companies who lawfully provide what you need at a market price, and yet want to hand over all power to politicians who have no incentive to give you what you think you’re paying for? Ever consider that health care insurance prices are high because our sue-happy culture makes the cost of medical care prohibitive? That you can’t take your business to another provider because the government forbids the sale of insurance across state lines? Think the market forces might drive those costs down if the insurance companies had to compete for your business? Who’s preventing that? Washington is.
And don’t give me this public-option-is-competition crap. The public option (dead or no, and I’m not convinced they won’t add it in somehow) is a monopoly in the making, because government doesn’t have to make a profit to stay in business (obviously: look at that national debt), and in a few years, they’ll undersell and regulate every private insurer out of business, and then – TA DA! – Single payer.
Ever looked at cancer survival rates in countries with single-payer systems? Hospital conditions? And where do they get their drugs? American pharmaceuticals provide many drugs that universal systems depend upon, because there’s private money for research. Good luck if you have to get all your research money from the government. If you have a disease that they don’t think is worth funding to find a cure, you are out of luck, I guess.
Anything a government can give you, they can take away. If you give politicians control of your health care because you think they’ll take care of you, keep in mind you’ve just dragged the rest of us in with you: our blood is on your hands.
Posted by: Animator Girl | February 28, 2010, 11:22 pm 11:22 pm
Bush/Cheney/Rove/DeLay didn’t hesitate for a moment in using every tactic and sleazeball maneuver to advance every stage of their monstrous agenda. That meant, for instance, leading us into a horrendous war in Iraq which was funded by open-ended supplemental expenditures. Dems were voted in by an overwhelming majority and should not be bullied by the GOP into hesitating for a nanosecond to use the power of the majority to extend health care to all, make sure those who have pre-existing illnesses are covered, folks cannot go bankrupt paying for their health care, and containing exploding costs for all. That’s what America is about and that is God’s work on earth. Don’t let any GOPer scare you into thinking otherwise.
Posted by: hopesprings52 | February 28, 2010, 11:39 pm 11:39 pm
Right, the Dems should do this to the citizenry for their own good.
Representative Government? HAH, the leaders will tell you what is good for you, and you will accept their dictates. That is how the Government should work, right Dems?
Maybe we should look into disarming the populace before we shove things they don’t want down their throats “for their own good”?
Or perhaps representatives should um,…. represent what their voters want; and not what they want to force on their voters? NAAH, that’s madness there. People love the boot of government on their necks, don’t they?
Posted by: Ertdfg | March 1, 2010, 3:09 am 3:09 am
“The emergency rooms will be inundated with common colds, ear infections, etc. that the patients will not pay for.” Hello?? Anybody in there? If you go to the hospital, YOU GET A BILL. If you don’t pay they sue you. Many of the people who do not have health care can afrord it but CHOOSE not to have it. Educate yourself, don’t just spout the Dems tired old lies.
Posted by: Tony T | March 1, 2010, 6:59 am 6:59 am
All these people need put down their patisan egos and start being more responsible. The democratic bill is just a one-sided attack on the insurance cos. without looking at the rest of the medical community who have the “It’s okay! It’s covered by insurance” mentality. There are the Republicans, whose great idea is to stop medical lawsuits. I’ve seen the doctors scare the hell out of my fearful 75 year old mother having her sign an agreement that no matter what happens, they are not responsible, to get a very necessary surgery. You have fat acceptance groups, and their followers saying the medical community should know what to do with them. They are living longer than at any time in history, because of all the drugs and advanced procedures the medical community can do. The common ground in this is stopping insurance cos. from denying coverage. They need to take that common ground, do the responsible thing, and build. That common ground can be a strong foundation, as long as they build from it instead of trying to make it too one-sided.
Posted by: parma hts gary | March 1, 2010, 7:04 am 7:04 am
After watching the talking heads this weekend from the left, it is obvious they have no plan and are no where near the votes required to jam this thru. If they did have the votes they would have done it already. Problem is they are too dumb to start over. In one week, they could pass the following single topic 5 page bills. End pre-existing conditions, sell insurance across state lines, re-importation of drugs, tort reform, kids under the age of 29 can stay on their parent’s health insurance and several other bills that directly affect most Americans. They would all pass by huge margins and they ARE ALL FREE!!! The problem for the Dems is, those don’t allow for special interest kickbacks and a push to socialism, higher taxes and slashes in Medicare.
Posted by: Tony T | March 1, 2010, 7:09 am 7:09 am
Yes, you are right. You go to ER and you will get a bill. If you don’t pay they sue. Correct, no problems here. But talking about indigents who have no means to pay because they have been unemployed, how do you get blood from a turnip? Still, we taxpayers end up footing the bill. Its not a dem lie, it is a fact. Somebody goes to the ER, gets a bill they don’t pay, the debt becomes a write off and goes to collection. Collections tries to collect maybe by garnishing wages (if there is income to garnish) but during this time the HC infrastructure gets reimbursed by our tax dollars to stay afloat. Just because the indigent is being sued doesn’t mean that the collection will be successful. Plus, how do you sue a homeless vet with no job? Hmmm, these neocons have an answer for everything – NOT!
Posted by: raggmopp | March 1, 2010, 9:32 am 9:32 am
Scrambler one I got news for you our system of government is by and for the people not dictators. We rise and fall on the backs of “we the people”. This is what representative government is all about.
Posted by: David Lamon | March 1, 2010, 9:57 am 9:57 am
Everybody read Mike C’s post and get the real facts.
Posted by: David Lamon | March 1, 2010, 9:59 am 9:59 am
Alexander Lamar lost his bid for presidential Republican nomination. He is trying to realign his power. U.S. Jim Buning has blocked job creations bill, therefore, don’t support anything for Kentucky Derby which funds Bunings state with those who attend, sponsor, and air. The state of Kentucky gains all tax proceeds from this one event. Therefore, don’t support the sponsors, any events, and don’t view the stations that broadcast this event. Completely block all funding that goes into this event to Buning’s state, which is Kentucky. He wants to play, let the games begin. He blocks, we block also. We keep all people in Kentucky from making anything at all. The American people are being held hostage by this Republican loser, so we in turn, will keep Kentuckians from making anything either. It’s up to you Buning — do you want your people in Kentucky to suffer from your irresponsbile behaviors as a out of control adult like teenager who is also Republican. Keep it up Buning, and your state will have a negative financial Tsunami from your actions. The blood is on Buning’s hands.
Posted by: Gig76 | March 1, 2010, 10:16 am 10:16 am
KariB57, how do you balance slightly higher taxes,only if you are in the upper incomes bracket, with all the bad stuff that will happen if we don’t pass this bill?
Without this health care bill passing, will your increased premiums every year bother you?
Without the bill passing, does the fact that if you (or anyone you love,)lose your job, you lose your insurance and if you have a pre-existing condition you will be priced out of the market, bother you?
Does the fact that 45,000 Americans die every year because they lacked insurance bother you at all?
You should really read Sarah’s comment and think about it.
Unless you are working for an insurance company in an upper level job or you own a lot of health insurance company stock, you will benefit greatly from this health care package as will our greater society.
Sarah, Very Well Said!
Posted by: Lydia | March 1, 2010, 11:09 am 11:09 am
it would be interesting to take a poll amongst health care personel defined by position, i.e. MD, nurse, etc. and find out what position they are most aligned with. It would also be interesting to break it down by non union and union, i.e., union MDs vs non union MDs.
Posted by: Downwithsocialism | March 1, 2010, 11:16 am 11:16 am
The main issues with the bill are:
1. Loss of autonomy. When government gets more into health care they will take away our choices. It will become more and more politicized. I do not want an idiot bureacrat in D.C. to decide what medical procedures I get.
2. Cost. The CBO states that premiums will go up. Has any government run program ever stayed within budget, run efficiently, been free of corruption or nepotism and special favors?
Posted by: Braden Lynch | March 1, 2010, 1:13 pm 1:13 pm
Yes it is. They will find that out, in November.
Posted by: Rick McDaniel | March 1, 2010, 1:31 pm 1:31 pm
Take off you Caps Lock and quit calling names. Do you think just one group are liars? If this is passed your premiums will continue to go up, it does not bend the curve in the out years and the cost is unsustainable past 2015 when all the upfornt money is spent, it is not the answer. All the printing at treasury is bankrupting the nation and this president has selective hearing; 57% do not want this bill and he has spent over a year swimming against the tide. We need health reform but not the total take over and dismantling of the best health care in the world. The voters do not want European health care, they come here when the need special healthcare not to Great Britain, Germany, France or Canada. This president was suppose to bring change and was heralded as the savior but is tuning in to the destroyer of Demo world. The focus for the past year should have been jobs, jobs, jobs. Do you hear us now?????
Posted by: Don | March 1, 2010, 1:36 pm 1:36 pm
It seems to me that political suicide has already taken place, we just have yet to see the bodies float by. Politicians have been indoctrinated with so many bad habits and elitist attitudes that they don’t have the character to break they are doomed.
Posted by: Ruler4You | March 1, 2010, 1:47 pm 1:47 pm
Well, we can see that Bob and Sarah have obama disease!
Let’s attack the first glaring issue of Constitutionality. Show us ALL where in the Constitution there is provision that allows government to dictate/mandate that the American people HAVE to purchase insurance (just a for-instance; many more unconstitutional issues are still out there). I’ll give you a clue — you won’t find it.
Second, show us ALL where government has SUCCESSFULLY (and I mean continuously successful and accountable) operated ANY program. I’ll give you a clue — you can’t name any. (and for all you bobbleheads, Medicare/Medicaid, SS, etc. are going BROKE)
Third, if the government should happen to get its way and take more control, with nearly all U.S. manufacturing jobs shipped to Mexico, China, India (service jobs pay little to nothing; illegals get first swipe) how long do you REALLY think government could financially sustain every handout? (and don’t forget, obama is now deeply using Fiat money so you might just as well get out the monopoly money and play with it) Government can’t and won’t sustain and would quickly cut off or ration goods and services to all the little serfs (meaning US).
If you don’t believe what I’m telling you, get yourself a history book and start reading because this stuff has been played out before and the end result is catastrophe! obama may be doing this to set himself up as dictator; why else would someone rush so quickly to destroy the greatest country–bar none! (and for those who disagree that the U.S. is great, then go live in one of those third world nations that we will soon become and come back and report how wonderful the room service is)!
Any questions?
Posted by: needfreshair | March 1, 2010, 2:10 pm 2:10 pm
It’s incredible that it’s come to this. The majority doesn’t have enough votes to push through their legislation an now has to work with the minority to find a bill that will pass.
This prospect is so unappealing that they are going to sidestep the “normal” political process and use some kind of technicality to get it done.
On the face of it, that sounds like something that would damage the trust of the people in the political process.
Posted by: USCitizen | March 1, 2010, 3:34 pm 3:34 pm
Personally, I agree with Warren Buffet in this matter. This Healthcare Bill doesn’t do enough to address the rising costs in Healthcare.
We need to include measures that will generate more competition and encourage lower health care expenditures.
Posted by: USCitizen | March 1, 2010, 3:37 pm 3:37 pm
the real moran is anyone who thinks you can add 50 million people on a new entitlement program and not raise the cost on people who work, or did work, and living on retirement income. plus insurance companys have a sound actuary (fidicary duty to their policyholders)reason to deny pre existing conditions. if you were in a small plan, you wouldn’t want them opening it up for the same rates you pay, to new people with pre existing conditions.
Posted by: tightwad | March 1, 2010, 4:13 pm 4:13 pm
Democrats are dumb. Clinton got elected 8 years for the economy and delivered. Economy goes to crap and people vote Democrat and they want to do Healthcare? They already commited suicide. Yes Healthcare is a part of the economy, but it is going to cost even more to change it that way. Healthcare is a long-term goal in good-times not a quick-fix in bad-times. Everyone with a brain know this was dumb. It must be Bush’s fault!
Posted by: Darlene, PA | March 1, 2010, 5:06 pm 5:06 pm
Your right W has been blamed for every thing form global warming to Noah’s flood. If Repubs are the party of NO the Demos are the party of BLAME.
Posted by: Don | March 1, 2010, 5:20 pm 5:20 pm
One thing is for sure. We will know who is right on November 8th.
Given Senator Alexander’s credentials; I’ll bet he is correct on this issue.
Posted by: Eagle68 | March 1, 2010, 5:25 pm 5:25 pm
If the Leftist Democrat leadership jams this outrageous Federal takeover of medical insurance and the concomitant huge bureacracy building and taxation, I will simply spend my time and money between now and November working full-time for a veto-proof majority to repeal the entire package. That will be a one-item Contract With America that any politician who signs onto (Rep, Dem, or other) will almost ensure their victory over any candidate who does not. Then Egobama can pound sand as the next Congress overrides any vetos and repeals the garbage Obama/Pelosi/Reid debacle.
Posted by: marcus neveutius | March 1, 2010, 5:57 pm 5:57 pm
It’s interesting to hear people paint Democrats as the standard bearers against the horrible, greedy insurance companies. The inconvenient truth, however, is that the Democrat party has negotiated a sweetheart deal with Big Insurance, that in trade for forcing millions of Americans to buy insurance they neither want nor can afford – Democrats will enshrine Big Insurance as Government Franchised Monopolies. Come on all you knee-jerks on the left – quit being so naive. The Democrats (and Republicans) by and large don’t give a rat’s ass about you or me.
Posted by: Cam | March 1, 2010, 7:12 pm 7:12 pm
For those of you who want everything the civilized industrialized world has—check and see how all that is working out in Greece, Italy,Spain, etc,etc. They have socialized medicine and the added “benefit” of thousands of windmills for energy. Problem is their finances are in the tank. We don’t need to go there but, Obama and Congress are trying their hardest to take us there.
Posted by: Dick | March 1, 2010, 9:15 pm 9:15 pm
This is soooooo funny, really, hilarious. Repubs couldn’t have asked for more from the Dems if they PAID for it: a Messianic President who believes he walks on water (perfect definition of a true Liberal); a majority Congress that can’t get their act together to pass their signature socialist bill when they had the 60 votes in the Senate; a toe-sucking,kowtowing, groveling media yelling praises to anything remotely resembling a Marxist idea: and, last but not least, the pointy-headed retards who continue to make excuses for this affirmative action flunkie are running out of excuses and may have to get a job when their government runs out of Obama Stash Money. Thanks Obama, you are the GREATEST! We Conservatives love you! And thank all those Student Union Lounge Lizards you call Czars, we couldn’t have done better pissing off the American Middle Class if we tried!!! Oh yeah, one more thing, you can keep your hope and change and we’ll just keep our guns and Bible and wait to see if you really think you can steal our country.
Posted by: montereyjack | March 1, 2010, 9:48 pm 9:48 pm
Warren Buffett says that we need this health care passed. When Buffett talks people should listen. The independent commission also said that the health care bill will actually bring down the debt. It’s time for a mojority vote. The GOP used it to give millionaires a tax cut. This country can’t afford to let health care go as it is now.
Posted by: pt | March 2, 2010, 8:31 am 8:31 am
Yea, let the Gov. run health care.
They did such a great job with:
Social Security, Vetrans Hospitals, Medicaid, Medicare, the USPS, OUR ECONOMY etc., etc.
Believe in this bill and YOU are the fool. Nothing is FREE people…
Posted by: Ray | March 2, 2010, 10:40 am 10:40 am
And what fool(s0 would believe that the Republicans are actually “warning the Democrats AWAY FROM a kamikaze mission. None of you think there is a liitle “reverse pscycology” being played out here? The Republicans, in the worst way wants health care reform to go away. Besides not caring about the uninsured or the rest of our premiums rising dramatically, they are “fighting for their special interests contributors”. If you cannot see this “strategy” you are just like them and do not care about anyone but yourself or you just do not look deep enough. What a hypocrite you are Lamar. Vote for “W”‘s tax cuts that cost us TWICE as much and then deny affordable health care for the rest of us.
Posted by: CND FOX | March 2, 2010, 12:05 pm 12:05 pm
Am I wrong or is there not a stipulation in the Democrat bill that no provision of the bill can ever be changed? I believe that I heard this on a news channel early in the debate.
Posted by: RustyG | March 2, 2010, 2:45 pm 2:45 pm