By Jonathan Blakely

Feb 8, 2010 12:54pm

HAMP Champ: What Ever Happened to That Obama Mortgage Modification Plan?

One year ago this month President Obama announced a plan to help alleviate the housing crisis. Part of that plan included incentives for banks and lenders to renegotiate mortgages with homeowners who were struggling to make payments.

"Under this plan, lenders who participate will be required to reduce those payments to no more than 31 percent of a borrower's income," the president said. "And this will enable as many as 3 to 4 million homeowners to modify the terms of their mortgages to avoid foreclosure."

Up to $75 billion could be spent on this program, called the Home Affordable Modification Program, or HAMP. Program — $50 billion of which could come from the Troubled Asset Relief Program funds. (The other $25 billion would come from the Housing and Economic Recovery Act of 2008, used to modify mortgages owned or guaranteed by Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac.)

As of December 30, $35.5 billion had been allocated to the program, the Special Inspector General for the TARP program, Neil Barofsky,reported to Congress last month, with $10 billion "allocated to encourage HAMP modification by protecting investors from potential home-price declines in their mortgage portfolio assets in regions where forestalling foreclosure may lead to significant losses."

But only $15.4 million had been disbursed.

Why so little?

Because far from the 3-4 million the president had said the HAMP program would help, only 66,465 Americans have received permanent mortgage modifications.

With a slow start to the program, the Obama administration announced in July 2009 that it would seek 500,000 trial loan modifications by November 1. As of the end of December there were 902,620 trial modifications, many of which were done through verbal agreements and with no guarantee they would become permanent.

In our interview yesterday with Treasury Secretary Tim Geithner, I asked him if a year ago, were I to tell him that a year later only 66,000 Americans had permanent mortgage modifications through the program, if he would have said at the time that the HAMP program was a success.

"I think it's very important to recognize this program is providing very, very substantial cash flow relief right now to more than three quarters of a million Americans," Geithner said. "We believe we're still on a path to be able to reach many, many more American households. And of course we're going to make sure that those temporary modifications translate into permanent modifications."

A lot of those temporary modifications were done verbally, I pointed out.

"We're absolutely committed to make sure that translates into what we said it would, which is for eligible Americans — they're getting permanent modifications that substantially lower their monthly payment…For the average household that translates into hundreds and hundreds of dollars every month for them."

-jpt

User Comments

I can’t get too upset about a program so obviously susceptible to abuse getting a slow start. It should go slow and cautiously assess the situation and establish how to proceed before really laying out our money. Just throwing money out the back of a truck isn’t the right way to do.

Posted by: jhw539 | February 8, 2010, 1:11 pm 1:11 pm

Another flop
Another waste of money
How many homes did Obama save in districts that do not exist?

Posted by: phillip | February 8, 2010, 1:20 pm 1:20 pm

I can’t get too upset about a program so obviously susceptible to abuse getting a slow start.
============
Doing things via verbal agreement hardly seems the perfect antidote to abuse.

Posted by: MayBee | February 8, 2010, 1:35 pm 1:35 pm

I can’t get too upset about a program so obviously susceptible to abuse getting a slow start. It should go slow and cautiously assess the situation and establish how to proceed before really laying out our money. Just throwing money out the back of a truck isn’t the right way to do.
Posted by: jhw539
____________________________
Totally agree! Is that really you? :)

Posted by: wow | February 8, 2010, 1:50 pm 1:50 pm

Doing things via verbal agreement hardly seems the perfect antidote to abuse.
MayBee | Feb 8, 2010 1:35:08 PM
When they’ve only dispersed about $20 per verbal agreement, yeah it’s pretty good actually. Gets the program started up while providing time to do the contracts properly.

Posted by: jhw539 | February 8, 2010, 1:50 pm 1:50 pm

When they’ve only dispersed about $20 per verbal agreement, yeah it’s pretty good actually. Gets the program started up while providing time to do the contracts properly.
===========
Fun with numbers!
Of course, people with verbal agreements are not getting only $20.
Making verbal contracts is the antithesis of doing contracts “properly”.

Posted by: MayBee | February 8, 2010, 1:56 pm 1:56 pm

Obama and his liberal cronies based the entire 2008 campaign on lies. They simply cannot be trusted. THIS CORRUPT ADMINISTRATION NEEDS TO CREATE JOBS, REDUCE SPENDING AND DEBT, PAY ATTENTION TO HOMELAND SECURITY, AMONG OTHER THINGS. WE DON’T WANT THEIR GOVERNMENT-RUN HCR. This administration has no problem governing “against” the will of the people of America. If they cram their HCR down our throats in 2010 – maybe we’ll cram it down theirs in November.

Posted by: WILL OBAMA EVER DO HIS JOB? | February 8, 2010, 2:25 pm 2:25 pm

Making verbal contracts is the antithesis of doing contracts “properly”.
MayBee | Feb 8, 2010 1:56:28 PM
Trial modifications by verbal agreement are fine. These are not long term commitments but stop gaps until long term can be implemented. As such, they make perfect sense – sort of like throwing water bottles out of a truck at a disaster sight before you can get the engineering corps in to trench and lay a new water main.

Posted by: jhw539 | February 8, 2010, 2:56 pm 2:56 pm

JHW!! I agree with what you said..whooowee! That’s a first!! You are right, there is TONS of shady stuff going on here..right in my neighborhood as a matter of fact. This program is being gamed BIG TIME! It’s not that the govt is always too dumb, it’s that they are always too big to respond to the quick witted fraudsters in time.

Posted by: cindy | February 8, 2010, 2:57 pm 2:57 pm

THIS CORRUPT ADMINISTRATION NEEDS TO CREATE JOBS, REDUCE SPENDING AND DEBT, PAY ATTENTION TO HOMELAND SECURITY, AMONG OTHER THINGS.
WILL OBAMA EVER DO HIS JOB? | Feb 8, 2010 2:25:27 PM
Why don’t you include invent teleporters, put a flying car in every driveway, achieve full peace in the Middle East, eat sunshine and ____ diamonds while you’re at it?

Posted by: jhw539 | February 8, 2010, 2:58 pm 2:58 pm

Don’t deal in Double Talk. By letter or e-mail only. You need the records of proof.

Posted by: Steve | February 8, 2010, 3:13 pm 3:13 pm

I think that credit worthy types could not only take advantage of these programs but coerce their lenders to renegotiate.. IMHO.. market conditions forced many lenders to make lesser deals.. and there was plenty of cheap government money to prop it all up.. in this instance, I think Obamanation took ample action to keep people in their homes..

Posted by: DontGet818OnMeNow | February 8, 2010, 3:15 pm 3:15 pm

Trial modifications by verbal agreement are fine.
=====
Good to know you think so.
Of course, you were arguing that the slow start is good because it protects against abuse.
Verbal agreements are not good protection against abuse. A slow start is not evidence that abuse is being safeguarded against.
Keeping people who legitimately need help from getting it is not efficient. It is also not protection against fraud.
This program may end up being great, but it’s slow start and lax contract system isn’t evidence of taxpayer protection.

Posted by: MayBee | February 8, 2010, 3:18 pm 3:18 pm

Swine flu Vaccine program part deux

Posted by: mjishernameo | February 8, 2010, 3:25 pm 3:25 pm

THIS CORRUPT ADMINISTRATION NEEDS TO CREATE JOBS, REDUCE SPENDING AND DEBT, PAY ATTENTION TO HOMELAND SECURITY, AMONG OTHER THINGS.
WILL OBAMA EVER DO HIS JOB? | Feb 8, 2010 2:25:27 PM
Why don’t you include invent teleporters, put a flying car in every driveway, achieve full peace in the Middle East, eat sunshine and ____ diamonds while you’re at it?
Posted by: jhw539 | Feb 8, 2010 2:58:07 PM
____________________________________
Noted . ..

Posted by: tierra | February 8, 2010, 3:41 pm 3:41 pm

Good question…..all I have read, is that no one seems to be getting it.
More rhetoric, without substance.

Posted by: Rick McDaniel | February 8, 2010, 5:09 pm 5:09 pm

I like the way Jake Tapper is exposing Tim Geithner for the rhetorical talking head he obviously is! ANyone who believes anything this guy says is foolish.

Posted by: LongT | February 8, 2010, 7:12 pm 7:12 pm

The paperwork involved……Some just get lazy and don’t complete the process..

Posted by: Parallax View | February 8, 2010, 7:45 pm 7:45 pm

Geithner is pure baloney, a rich kid who has no idea (nor cares) what people are going through with his stupid number-crunching fraudulent rotten ideas. He’s another example of our government going wrong and should be busted for trying to save his banking buddies from us, the “horrible people” he was hired to “serve”. Go to hell Geithner – I only wish you what I and others are going through: HELL, thanks to you you spoiled brat.

Posted by: C. Kaye | February 8, 2010, 10:05 pm 10:05 pm

I did not buy above my means but none the less fell prey to un-employment and financial problems. I entered the H A M P program and was told that it would require a three month trial period of a specified payment as a good faith gesture before a permanent adjustment would be put in place. I have submitted all requested paperwork multiple times and have not missed a beat.
At this point I have just submitted my sixth payment with no resolution from my lender JP Morgan Chase. I am now calling them twice a week to no avail. My wife and I have spoken to at least 15 different representatives, each one unable to answer the most basic of questions and unwilling to connect us anywhere up the chain to find out what is actually going on with our account, up to and including today’s representative who was unable to even locate our account. We have been in constant communication and when I ask if my last call was documented, no one seems to know. It seems as if Chase is doing everything in their power to assist us in losing our home rather than help us keep it. At first we thought that all of this was a result of pure incompetence but now believe these are intentional evasive tactics being used to cover a more sinister motive. What ever the case it needs to be investigated.

Posted by: Fed up | February 9, 2010, 12:06 am 12:06 am

I was a victim of the supposed trial modification with JP Morgan Chase. After doing just as they asked my home was foreclosed on anyway.I feel the crooked bastards wanted the house from the very outset and never intended on helping me get a lower payment.
I also think they need to be investigated

Posted by: fedup2 | February 9, 2010, 1:39 am 1:39 am

Everything Obama does is URGENT. Until it fails. One million homes were foreclosed on in the third quarter of 2009. Obama’s program has served 80K people to date.

Posted by: smartlillena | February 9, 2010, 6:46 am 6:46 am

How about if we promise to pay our taxes timely, would the administration go for that and call the tax collecting a success? Or, how about we promise to pay our current administration salaries and then don’t – would they accept that?

Posted by: Ken | February 9, 2010, 11:27 am 11:27 am

Just remembered something. Obama is use to getting awards for fine speeches without having to provide any real results, so action is not needed only good thoughts, enjoy your cardboard boxes and tents. This program falls under the above criteria so he’s due an award. I think Rowan and Martin’s “Flying Fickle Finger of Fate” award is appropriate.

Posted by: Ken | February 9, 2010, 11:34 am 11:34 am

THAT FAILED TELEPROMPTER MORTGAGE PLAN IS ON THE ASH HEAP WITH THE OTHER “BEGINNER IDIOT COMMUNITY ORGANIZER’S” EXPERIMENTS…………
WHAT WOULD A MAN WHO GOT A SWEETHEART REAL ESTATE DEAL FROM FELON TONY REZKO KNOW ABOUT HELPING HONEST HOMEOWNERS….
HIS OTHER FAILED POLICIES:
GITMO
TERROR TRIALS
8% UNEMPLOYMENT
BOTCHED HEALTHCARE REFORM
DOUBLED DEFICIT
DOUBLED WAR
THE MAN IS A VILLAGE IDIOT TAKING AMERICA DOWN PIECE BY PIECE

Posted by: CATHERINE | February 9, 2010, 12:47 pm 12:47 pm

Ha, 66,000 too many modifications if you ask me. Let the bad loans fail. Let those who can’t afford their homes go rent. Let the prices fall so people who want to buy can afford it.
Every time the government comes up with a new scheme to reward lying borrowers, I get mad until I realize it’s not going to work anyway. It just wastes our time, money, and attention.

Posted by: linda | February 9, 2010, 3:41 pm 3:41 pm

Hey Linda, not everyone who has a “bad loan” is a liar. Some of us lost our jobs, and some of us live in areas that have extreme depreciation in home values. These upside down homes have no equity and probably won’t for many years. So it’s more to it than “liars”. What about these GREEDY banks who made millions and never checked out the buyers credentials. They are the ones that ultimately screwed up this housing market.

Posted by: LG | February 9, 2010, 4:08 pm 4:08 pm

Hey Linda, not everyone who has a “bad loan” is a liar. Some of us lost our jobs, and some of us live in areas that have extreme depreciation in home values. These upside down homes have no equity and probably won’t for many years. So it’s more to it than “liars”. What about these GREEDY banks who made millions and never checked out the buyers credentials. They are the ones that ultimately screwed up this housing market.

Posted by: LG | February 9, 2010, 4:08 pm 4:08 pm

I thought HAMP was to help you through difficult situation, not create an impossible one?
fees, fees, and more fees
Hope Stops with AURORA LOAN SERVICES?
Read the comments…..they string you along as they take your payments:

Posted by: louise | February 9, 2010, 5:36 pm 5:36 pm

A few posters have failed to weigh in on this subject. Tierra? This administration should be asked about the car dealers still waiting on their cash-for-clunkers $$$.

Posted by: smartlillena | February 10, 2010, 6:37 am 6:37 am

I saved $590 a month with a modification due to lost hrs at work from the Bush Admin. Now I will buy shoes and put the shoemaker back to work, i’ll buy bread and put the baker back to work etc… etc. see how it works? And best of all I can keep my home, the lender still gets interest and everyone lives happily ever after except for the corperate thugs wont be getting big bonuses anymore :)

Posted by: Sharon G | February 10, 2010, 10:13 am 10:13 am

What amazes me is how many people blame the homeowners who are the real victims here. The whole financial/mortgage system is corrupt. This crosses party lines. These are the same people receiving the big bonuses that almost brought the country down single-handedly. What the problems with the HAMP program is just how corrupt it is. Pretending to the government that they didn’t receive documentation or that homeowners don’t qualify. Then, they lie to homeowners that they’ve lost papers, FannieMae is the culprit, while pocketing the funds paid by TARP and the homeowners during the “trial program.” When I asked what happened to the money I paid into the program, the response was, it’s not our program. When I pointed out that the checks were made out to them, they had several reasons, all of which are illegal. Contact your State Attorney General and the banking regulators for your state. Know your enemy, the financial community.

Posted by: Seminolewoman | February 21, 2010, 11:55 am 11:55 am

Dear Fed Up, I have some numbers that might help you and your wife. We have been in this boat with Chase for 17mth. We were hit by Ike and 7000. ded and loss of income and a cut to what is left, well it’s a long story. They made some promisses then changed their mind, and here we are. I do have some numbers to some real people, not call center people but real people in charge that might be able to help. Let me know and i will get them for you. Not all of us in this situation are losers and someone had posted, we are trying really hard to make it in an area that has been hit by 3 major Hurricanes.

Posted by: gina | February 23, 2010, 2:47 pm 2:47 pm

I get unemployment . I entered the H A M P program and was told that it would require a three month trial period of a specified payment as a good faith adjustment would be put in place. I have submitted all requested paperwork multiple times and have not missed any paper work.My Name is on the loan only.So What my wife get paid does not count. so it does not show I make enough for HAMP but over all I can make the payment that they set me up for the trial period .Whats going on?? If I can make the payment and proved it. Then Why denied? Now they say I owe Thousands and could go ito foreclosure. Just put me on the program. #### is not on your side. They got bailed out but chooses not to help there people. Its funny how someone can choose our future. I think we should all do something about because the Gov.is not.

Posted by: Mary | February 24, 2010, 7:13 pm 7:13 pm

We finally got approved for HAMP with the help of our attorney after 6 failed attempts and one year, trying it on our own with OCWEN. Two months after the approval, we received an unknown and unexplained $540.00 fee added to our monthly rate. Our attorney contacted them because she said that they cannot legally add any fees. After 16 calls back and forth to OCWEN, and their claim that their supervisor is sick at home (what a joke), our attorney gave up and said that she cannot do anything and we have to pay the extra fees eventhough it is illegal according to the document we signed. So now we are going through foreclosure anyway because OCWEN won. We are all a bunch of losers in this game.

Posted by: mimi | February 28, 2010, 11:41 pm 11:41 pm

I’ve been helping my brother-in-law (English is his second language) with his efforts to secure a loan modification through Saxon Mortgage Company since December 2008. He was approved in February 2009 for a loan mod of 5.6%, down from 8.25%. However, Saxon NEVER sent him the paperwork, then cancelled the modification when he failed to sign and return it. Saxon admitted its error, but inexplicably still required that we begin the application process all over again. So we did. The second attempt to get a loan mod was also cancelled when we failed to submit my brother-in-law’s Social Security Disabilty paperwork DESPITE my rrepeated calls to Saxon informing them that he is NOT ON SS Disability. No matter. Cancelled. I got him signed for the HAMP program at Saxon in early May. Here it is 11 months later, and he STILL is without a loan modification, although the HAMP “Trial Period” was supposed to last just 3 months. This is disgraceful. Just last Friday, Saxon requested more documents…though I was told last August that all of his paperwork was in order. We are chasing our tails with this company, but what else can we do — we’ve come this far; it’s no time to give up, so we’re just playing the game. Still, the incompetence and inefficiency on display here is mindboggling and exceedingly frustrating. I just hope my brother-in-law can hold on. He’s an excellent candidate for HAMP, is gainfully employed, and has a perfect payment record….

Posted by: William | March 1, 2010, 10:50 am 10:50 am

My husband and I were tricked into thinking we were getting a good mortgage when we bought our modest home in 2005. We were getting remarried and needed a home for our kids. We both put down our entire life savings as down payments. The adjustable mortgage was misrepresented to us and we were told of the worst case scenarios with a mortgage of this type..nothing even close to what has happened. We refinanced when we realized that we were in big trouble with negative amortization…by the time we did that, we had lost about $30,000 of our $60,000 we had put down and we reluctantly got stuck with a high interest rate which has left us so poor that we cannot afford to live a decent life. We work our fingers to the bone to do it. Then, we tried to get our loan modified by Chase which was a joke…they strung us along and we never got anywhere. We then tried to refinance…another joke…seems that they accept that people’s credit (ours is fairly good) should be perfect after all this…we do our best, but when your mortgage payment is all we bring in, something has to suffer. What kills me is that we always pay our bills and struggled to make every payment. That doesn’t count. We don’t qualify…no understanding on their part. I hate that they get away with this. I thought, stupidly, that they were going to have to help the people they hurt…especially since we were forced to bail them out. I guess I am naive! I want to know how I should fight this..go over their heads. I do believe Obama meant well, but no one is making sure Chase or any other mortgage institution is doing what they were supposed to do. Where do I turn next?

Posted by: Karin | March 1, 2010, 8:30 pm 8:30 pm

My husband was was layed off for 6 months . we fell three months behind in our payments and were in forclosure.Chase put us in a temporary mod. we have now been in our temp mod for 5 mos. we were just informed that our perm, mod was denied. Now my husband is back to work and we can afford our payments but we can’t afford to pay what we are behind. countless calls and always getting a different story. We do not know what is going on or if they will at any time place us back into forclosure. Our negotiator has only ever called us once and now we never hear from her. We have asked countless times for her number and we are told that they can not give it to us. I agree with fed up . I think they waited until we now don’t qualify for hamp and they set us up to fail. we want desperately to keep our home but we were misslead from the beginning ,that since we qualified for the temp mod that we would qualify for the perminant mod. Chase is nothing but a bunch of liars. Now we are told that we may or may not qualify for an inhouse modification but who’s to tell the rep on the line just says you may but it’s really up to the negotiator who did I mention never calls. SO we are stuck in limbo our nerves are shot and we don’t know if we get to keep our home . oh and to us it is a home not just a house!!!!!

Posted by: Brandy | March 17, 2010, 2:31 pm 2:31 pm

My husband and I bought our home in 2006, just before the values fell. We were fine with that though, our daughter was starting kindergarten, it was our first house and we’re in it for the long haul anyway. Mortgage process was awful to being with, at the very last minute (extension already filed) they came back with PMI that would have resulted in almost $4K a month for a $318K home. We had to quickly go with another mortgage broker and I think it took less than 5 days to have our HORRIBLE 80/20 subprimes in place. Payments were still high, but $3K a month with a promise that in 6 months, we would refinance. Needless to say, that didn’t happen. Housing market dropped and there was no way to save any money for a better loan with a downpayment. Anyway, tried modification with original mortgage company, that was ongoing for at least 6 months, but then they sold to another company and we were told we had to start all over. At that point though, the new company was already sending us notices of default and foreclosure dates were being set. We had no choice but to take out a 401K loan to pay the $10K to keep our home. Just after, submitted info to the new company for modification – went absolutely no where. Finally, this past Oct, got them to start the trial period. We are at a disadvantage though becuase, even though they also hold our second loan, we just miss the 31% front end and they will not add in the second that would give us relief. Got the letter 2 days ago that we don’t qualify. On 4/8, we’ll get the formal no and a notice from them that we owe $12K. My biggest problem is that I WANT to keep our home, we are NOT deadbeats trying to milk the system. One loan is at 9.25%, the other at 11%, my credit is trashed and to think all I want to do is pay a reasonable in the $2200 range for a monthly mortgage. We can afford it, but not the $3K. We have paid over $120K to them already in the past 4 years for our modest $318K home and now they are telling us we should do a pre-forclosure sale. How does that keep a roof over our head, our daughter in the school district we wanted her in for all of school AND us with our beloved (like children) pets? Renting is not an option for us becuase of 2 dogs, someone in the process has suggested we consider finding homes for them – JUST NOT FAIR. Meanwhile, we’ll do what we can with no relief and possibly lose our home anyway. I have had the same job for 11 years now, never collected any sort of any aid, neither has my husband, we are just hard working willing to pay people that will not get help here in the end I guess? Meanwhile, the government loses all the tax $$ they could have from us because we have almost $30K in interest deductions paid to these horrible people – guess I could be glad for the tax break, but would rather just have a reasonable payment for sure!

Posted by: JS | March 17, 2010, 5:51 pm 5:51 pm

Although I’m an Obama supporter this HAMP program is a joke. We’ve applied twice and Wachovia told us that “we need to make more money to qualify”…does this make any sense? Don’t get me wrong… I’d love to make more money, but after my former employer went out of business, my wife became disabled, and the economy tanked it’s not going to happen in time for next month’s mortgage payment. I’m making half what I did before, and I feel damn lucky to have a job. Wachovia’s solution was for us to ‘short sell’ the property… leaving us homeless and them owning our biggest asset (with $150 in equity). Seems like HAMP must stand for ‘Hand us back your Asset so we can Make a Profit’…?

Posted by: billkaufmann | May 15, 2010, 12:42 pm 12:42 pm

I think those cases should be investigated as soon as possible. Thanks for sharing this article.

Posted by: philippine call center | May 17, 2010, 11:14 pm 11:14 pm

Leave a Reply

Do you have more information about this topic? If so, please click here to contact the editors of ABC News.