Mitt Romney Gets Specific on Social Security Plans

Win McNamee/Getty Images
GOP presidential candidate Mitt Romney gave specifics this morning on how to shore up Social Security, a government program that continues to emerge as the No. 1 issue between him and his chief rival, Texas Gov. Rick Perry.
Speaking at a hotel near the Miami airport where two screens displayed the Romney campaign’s “Six Questions to Ask Rick Perry about Social Security” fact sheet, Romney told the crowd, “There are one of two ways you can make Social Security work forever.
“One of course is to raise the retirement age by a year or two,” said Romney. “The other is having slower growth in inflating the benefits of higher-income of Social Security recipients. Again, not current recipients but those in their 20′s, 30′s, 40′s and early 50′s.
“Those combined, represent the best course for us to be able to permanently solve our Social Security shortfall,” said Romney.
GOP frontrunner Perry’s campaign immediately attacked Romney’s remarks.
“Mitt Romney’s own book compared Social Security to a criminal enterprise,” the Perry campaign said in a statement. ”Now Mr. Romney is again sounding like a Democrat, distorting the truth and trying to scare senior citizens. As he has so many times in the past, Mr. Romney seems to forget he’s a Republican.
“Mr. Romney has been running for president full time for nearly five years, and has failed to issue a specific plan on Social Security,” the Perry statement continued. “Rick Perry and other conservatives are courageous enough to be honest about federal spending and entitlements, whether Mr. Romney and the liberals like it or not.”
Did Romney actually compare Social Security to a criminal enterprise in his book? Not quite.
In his book “No Apology” Romney provides an example of what might happen if an average citizen were to do what he says the government is doing with Social Security – effectively “defrauding” the American public by spending the surplus raised by Social Security taxes on the budget and not what they should be spending it on: retirement security.
The example given by Romney in his book is this: Two grandparents go to their bank and create a trust fund to provide for their grandchildren’s education. As the kids grow up, the bank is spending the money from the trust fund on something else. When the kids are ready to go college, there is no money in the trust fund.
“What would happen to the bankers responsible for misusing the money?” Romney writes. “They would go to jail.”
“But what has happened to the people responsible for the looming bankruptcy of Social Security?” he writes. “They keep returning to Congress every two years.”

Email
Best Commencement Speeches of 2012
Joe Biden Recalls Death of Wife, Daughter
When Perry’s own response to this is a distortion of what Romney actually said it shows me that Perry doesn’t have the answers. That to me sounds like a Democrate more then anything else. If he doesn’t have them now, he wont have them in a few short months when he is defending his wild remarks against the OBAMA machine. Not president material in my opinion. Sure everyone one laughs when you say something off the wall at a party when you are surrounded by your best friends, but that doen’t mean you should be president.
Posted by: serts | September 21, 2011, 3:43 pm 3:43 pm
the majority of Americans are tired of politicians. they want real solutions to their very real problems. Rick Perry is a politician. He became a millionaire while in office. Romney made his money in the private sector trying to solve complex business problems. The US government is the largest business problem in the world. We need some one who has the turn around skills of Romney to turn around the economy and get the government in order!
Posted by: misterrogers | September 21, 2011, 4:53 pm 4:53 pm
Typical Perry–Tear down the competition by saying they don’t have a plan or their plan is flawed and then offer nothing but a promise to “talk honestly about a plan” when you’re president. At least Romney has a workable plan–in fact he has 2. That’s 2 more than Perry has.
Posted by: Tyson | September 21, 2011, 5:08 pm 5:08 pm
Rick Perry’s team could at least quote from Mitt Romney’s book correctly. They try to say romney called social securty criminal. The politicians using the funds for social security in the wrong way were
were at fault not social security. Is that the only way Rick Perry can reply? How are you thinking to reform social security Rick Perry. I’d like to hear bout it. Just don’t attack Mitt with untruths.
Posted by: Bob Fullmer | September 21, 2011, 5:38 pm 5:38 pm
LOL… you are funny, if you think because Romney ran a business that he can run the U.S. You might as well throw Cain in there. Another one that has no clue about government. Romney is a liar and a voter fraud and Cain is JUST
Posted by: Lorrie | September 21, 2011, 5:39 pm 5:39 pm
Lorrie, you are placing yourself down on Slick Rick’s level when you make baseless accusations and outright fabrications.
Posted by: Clark | September 21, 2011, 6:20 pm 6:20 pm
Again Govenor Perry, Mitt Romney did not call Social Security a criminal act in his book. He called the way Congress was administering the funds for Social Security criminal. There is a big difference.
Posted by: Kay | September 21, 2011, 6:43 pm 6:43 pm
I don’t buy into Perry or Romney’s plans on SS. Romney says there are only two ways to fix SS. Romney says: You can increase the reitement age and/or slow growth in the benefits of higher income. What about forbidding Congress from dipping into SS and what about making policy/laws that stop corporations for outsourcing, H1-B immigrant visas, and placing huge tariffs on US companies that set up shop in foreign countries but registered here. If corporations are people too my friend as Mr. Romney claims then I would say corporations as good patriotic citizens should pay their fair share of taxes. If we create, build, buy, hire American then more will contribute to Social Security!
Posted by: Debbie | September 21, 2011, 8:13 pm 8:13 pm
Mitt Romney has detailed ideas about SS, the economy, job creation…and they are all in writing. My dad used to say “those who do get criticized.” Romney is a doer. I can imagine him lying awake at night thinking, “Why do we have to go through this campaign silliness, just let me get to work fixing the economy.”
Posted by: Kathryn | September 22, 2011, 12:49 am 12:49 am
Who cares if Mitt’s job creating plan is in writing if it doesn’t actually create jobs, which it doesn’t. All he’s proposing is more tax cuts for the rich and deregulation. Same old failed Republican policies. It doesn’t matter which GOP you vote for, they all have the same plan. The only one different is Ron Paul who would end the war which I like, but he’s crazy on every other issue.
Posted by: Sandy | September 22, 2011, 11:40 am 11:40 am