Search the Web and ABCNEWS.com  
Good Morning AmericaWorld News Tonight20/20PrimetimeWorld News Now
 
Print This Page
Email This Page
See Most Sent
  
 
Not Black-and-White
Most Americans Back Health Exception to ‘Partial-Birth’ Abortion Ban

Analysis
By Telis Demos

ABCNEWS.com

July 24— While most Americans favor banning the procedure known as partial-birth abortion in general, most also say the procedure should be legal if the woman's health is in danger — an exception that's absent from federal legislation working its way to George W. Bush.

Sampling, data collection and tabulation for this poll were done by TNS Intersearch.

Broadly, 62 percent in this ABCNEWS poll favor banning this form of late-term abortion. But when opponents are asked a follow-up — what if it would prevent a serious threat to the woman's health — the numbers reverse, and six in 10 say it should be legal.

A conference committee is merging measures approved by the House and Senate, both of which would allow the procedure only if necessary to save a woman's life. The House rejected an amendment that would have extended the exemption "to avert serious adverse consequences to her health." Bush has said he'll sign the legislation.

In this poll, just 20 percent of Americans say partial-birth abortion should be legal in all cases. But, when the follow-up is asked, an additional 41 percent say they'd make an exception when the mother's health is at risk - for a total of 61 percent who say it should be legal in that circumstance. One in three say it should be illegal nonetheless.

Uncommon Operation

Several other recent polls have found majority support for a law banning partial-birth abortion (including an ABCNEWS/Washington Post poll in January), but without asking about a health-of-the mother exception.

Support for that exception fits previous findings on the abortion issue. While views on abortion vary considerably depending on the circumstances, support for keeping it legal is broadest when the woman's life, or health, are at risk. Partial-birth abortion generates majority opposition in general, but as this poll shows, concern for the woman's health trumps that opposition for many Americans.

Partial-birth abortions are not common. Fewer than two percent of abortions are done after the fifth month, according to a 1999 report by the federal Centers for Disease Control; and a 2000 report by the Guttmacher Institute said that fewer than two-tenths of one percent of abortions are partial-birth abortions.


Views on Partial-Birth Abortion:
 In General:To Protect Woman's Health:
  Legal-Illegal Legal-Illegal
All 20-62 61-33
Women 18-68 58-37
Men 23-56 64-28
Democrats 27-50 73-20
Republicans 15-76 55-42
Independents 21-60 58-34
Protestant 20-64 60-35
White Evangelican Protestant 12-76 43-53
White Not Evangelical 28-51 76-20
Catholic 11-73 58-39
Other Religion 23-59 63-33
No Religion 31-47 64-23

Ideological, Gender Divide

There are strong religious, ideological and political components to these views. There's also a difference between the sexes: Perhaps surprisingly, women are somewhat more likely than men to say partial-birth abortion should be illegal regardless of the mother's health, 37 percent to 28 percent.

Support for a ban runs highest among evangelical white Protestants, among whom 53 percent say the procedure should be illegal regardless of the woman's health. (That compares to just 20 percent among white Protestants who are not evangelicals.) Still, even among evangelical white Protestants, 43 percent say partial-birth abortion should be legal, at least to protect the mother's health.

Among ideological terms groups, conservatives divide about evenly on the issue — 48 percent say partial-birth abortion should be legal when the woman's health is at risk, 46 percent say it should be illegal. Among moderates and liberals alike, by contrast, about seven in 10 say it should be legal.

In terms of political allegiance, Republicans say the procedure should be legal to protect the mother's health by 55-42 percent, and independents by 58-34 percent. It's a much more lopsided 73-20 percent among Democrats.

Methodology

This ABCNEWS poll was conducted by telephone July 16-20, among a random national sample of 1,027 adults. The results have a three-point error margin. Sampling, data collection and tabulation by TNS Intersearch of Horsham, Pa.

ABCNEWS polls can be found at ABCNEWS.com on the Internet at:Poll Vault.

 Search the Web and ABCNEWS.com  

FULL COVERAGE
Poll Vault: ABCNEWS Poll Archives
RELATED STORIES
Poll: Court Nominees Must Say Abortion View
Poll: Abortion Support Conditional