The season six finale of "The Bachelorette" ended with Martinez on bended knee proposing to Fedotowsky against a stunning Tahitian backdrop.
"I want to make you smile. I want to make sure you wake up every morning for the rest of your life knowing that you're so, so loved," he said, dropping to one knee. "Share your life with me. Be my wife. Will you marry me?"
She said "yes."
Fans across the country had been rooting for Fedotowsky to meet her prince.
Viewers had been told by host Chris Harrison to prepare for a finale "unlike anything we've seen before." And Fedotowsky did not fail to deliver.
At the outset of her final date with runner-up Chris Lambton, the bachelorette broke down and told him that she was "in love with somebody else." She said she didn't want to put him through the final date and the rose ceremony because it would be too painful to him.
"I have to let you go here and not wait till tomorrow. This wasn't an easy decision," she told her suitor. "I just didn't want to put you through tomorrow because I knew it was going to be so hard."
A visibly shaken Lambton took the rejection in stride.
"Thank you for being honest," he told her. "Good luck tomorrow. Go find out tomorrow if he loves you."
Moments later, Lambton said he saw a rainbow streaking through the Tahiti sky and took it as a message from his deceased mother.
"That's my mom telling me it's going to be OK," he said.
Previews for the final episode, with scenes of a tearful Fedotowsky and the final two suitors saying they may not be ready to propose, hinted that Fedotowsky could walk away without a ring.
Martinez had long been the front-runner. Fedotowsky clicked with the 26-year-old ex-baseball player from Tampa from the beginning, giving him the first impression rose.
"He dropped out of my dreams," Fedotowsky said.
On top of the romantic dinners and helicopter rides, the couple's most memorable dates were a sensual performance in the Broadway musical "The Lion King," where they were suspended in mid-air, and a daring 100-foot tightrope walk between two of Los Angeles' tallest buildings.
Watch an exclusive interview with Ali Fedotowsky tomorrow on "Good Morning America" at 7 a.m. ET.
It took longer for Fedotowsky's relationship with Lambton to pick up speed. It wasn't until the 33-year-old landscaper's hometown date in Cape Cod, Mass., where the Bachelorette met his family, that he opened up and the two deeply connected.
Lambton, a family man, moved back home from New York City to support his family when his mother was dying of a degenerative disease.
"He would make a great husband," Fedotowsky said.
America first fell in love with Fedotowsky on last season's "The Bachelor," when she left Jake Pavelka and quit the show to give priority to her career. The fan favorite was then chosen to return as "The Bachelorette," where 25 bachelors vied for her love.
"The Bachelorette's" sixth season was filled with its fair share of drama.